21 ms·
It’s Still Stupidly, Difficult to Buy a ‘Dumb’ TV
- cush 5y agoMy friend had a smart TV, and didn't use the smart features. It had a light on the front of the TV that pulsed on and off unless it was connected and set up. You couldn't even use it as a dumb TV unless you connected it to wifi...
- atVelocet 5y agoJust search for the professional line of monitors every major brand sells. Those are made for ads, conventions, etc and most of the time lack any smart features but have the same displays as their „smart“ counterparts. Only downside: You pay more (>$/€1000) to have less.
- sam_lowry_ 5y agoThe search term is "digital signage".
- momenti 5y agoDo you really pay for less? Digital signage displays often run 24/7 in temper proof cases with relatively poor ventilation and heat dissipation. Thus you might actually get a display that lasts longer (which, AFAIK, mostly comes down to higher quality capacitors and capacitors placed where they do not overheat, e.g. not directly next to high current transistors and resistors, which is common planned obsolesce practice in consumer TVs).
- bjelkeman-again 5y agoIn Europe/Sweden I have been purchasing dumb screens from Swedx.se [1]. Both dumb TVs and a video wall. They are clearly imported from China and not a big vendor, but I’d expect these type of companies selling digital signage to be available everywhere. [1] https://www.swedx.se/index.php?cPath=133&language=en https://www.swedx.se/index.php?cPath=133&language=en
- raffraffraff 5y agoI haven't had a TV for 18 years. I used large monitors for a while, then when I moved 10 years ago I bought an 42" LG "digital signage" panel. They're the flat screens you'd see used for advertising, product display or notification in hotels, stores etc. They still sell them. If I had to replace mine now, I'd probably get the 65UH5F-B, a 65" LED, 500 nits, 3840x2160, 60Hz, HDMI 3.0, DP, DVI, RS232, RJ45, IR.
- navjack27 5y agoGross, 500nits willingly? Why wouldn't you just go for the standard 1000nits where HDR content is mastered for usually or 100nits where SDR is mastered for?
- raffraffraff 5y agoThat's a hilarious opening question. I just watched an excellent Columbo episode from 1976 on a 10 year old LED screen, willingly, and I didn't even throw up.
- eric4smith 5y agoThe reason why no one wants to buy “dumb” TV sets is because no one wants one. Let’s face it, it’s not easy to connect a computer or get some set top box that is probably just as intrusive security-wise as a smart tv. Sometimes we here on HN don’t think about the normal requirements of civilians. And I’m saying this having bought a few TV sets recently. Both a dumb 1080p panel and 2 smart 4K tvs. And yes it was extremely hard to find the dumb set in the store here. Almost don’t even bother looking online - it’s the same problems. But in the end I’m using a Roku box which is no less intrusive than your typical smart set. So really we can’t win.
- k__ 5y agoI still use my >10 year old plasma TV. Works pretty well and I can switch out streaming sticks easily when they start to suck. All my friends have smart TVs and aren't very happy with them.
- revanx_ 5y agoI bought a 58 inch samsung tv in 2016 for around 250 euro. 1080p, barebone no smart features, two hdmi ports and two usb 2.0 ports. I wouldn't give it up even if someone payed me double today. It works as intended and that's all I care about. I use it daily. Yes, color vise it's a TN lcd panel so about as good as it can be expected but none of that matters because you simply get used to it. I haven't checked but I think you could probably still find something bare-bone today it's just that people want the greatest shit and don't want to settle for less. Maybe try something that isn't OLED or 4K and you might be surprised...
- deergomoo 5y agoAside from the fact that image quality and motion handling are the two most important factors in a TV for me—and therefore I would never settle for less unless I couldn’t afford it—the barebones offerings today are likely to be even worse. Even super cheap TVs are smart now, except they have even worse CPUs and even less effort is put into making the software anything close to good.
- LaserDiscMan 5y agoThey're not cheap or large, but broadcast monitors can be an option. Very expensive unless used though. Lots of lesser known manufacturers in the space, and some great deals can be found. The largest size most manufacturers will do is around 32 inches.
- IYasha 5y agoThe only "smart" thing I wanted in a TV is a SMB-capable media player. And nothing else, literally. I had to hack my tv to install CIFS module and a few dirty hacks to mount the NAS, but it was worth it. Because I hate to have an external computer (aka set-top-box) connected to computer inside tv to be able to connect to computer on a network to show some damn movies and photos.
- bXVsbGVy 5y agoASUS sells 43" monitors. https://www.asus.com/Displays-Desktops/Monitors/All-series/filter?Category=35-and-above https://www.asus.com/Displays-Desktops/Monitors/All-series/f...
- andrewclunn 5y agoI'd settle for a mechanism to update a "smart tv" to remove said "features" and prevent future updates. A rogue firmware update hack. Let's see them take users to court saying we're "not allowed to remove those advertisements... but not because we don't really own the device."
- amelius 5y agoWe should have a law that says that any product sold at a large scale should first be approved by a consumer organization. Let's stop producing junk that works against the consumer's interest.
- richardwhiuk 5y agoThat sounds eerily like censorship.
- amelius 5y agoI don't see the analogy. They can still publish the blueprints for the device, they just can't produce it at a mass scale. The market creates a natural power imbalance, and the market has shown that it can't act responsibly here. A better analogy is the power imbalance in the relation company-versus-employees, where you create a union to break the imbalance. Except now it is a "union" of consumers. Another analogy is democracy: let's not produce stuff that a few CEOs and shareholders want, but instead, let's produce stuff that the world wants. Also helps with resource/climate/environment problems.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> any product sold at a large scale should first be approved by a consumer organization You’ve created a government body gating market access. Surprise! Only the incumbents’ products get approved. Even if it doesn’t get corrupted, the wait times and specialist skills required to prepare the requisite documentation and answer questions properly will add a huge barrier to entry for new entrants.
- amelius 5y ago1. It only becomes active after (say) 10K-100K products are sold (threshold can depend on market/product type). 2. You can still go to court where a jury of consumers can look into the case. 3. Surprise, without government intervention the market doesn't function like it should (see this very article).
- dwighttk 5y agoMy TCL has not had any problems not being connected to the internet except it flashes a light on the front to helpfully remind me. I keep telling myself I’m going to take a sharpie to it but it doesn’t bother me that much.
- causi 5y agoSharpies don't stick too well to slick plastic. Black nail polish is much more effective. Black hot glue also looks nice.
- dwighttk 5y agoI want to tamp it down on the first pass. It is helpful to know if the tv is on or not. Maybe I can cover all but a small part or something.
- navjack27 5y agoYou can connect it to the network and have it download whatever latest updates might be there and if your router is an Asus you could install wrt Merlin and use skynet and diversion to pretty much block everything from Roku and the light never blinks and you could still use your phone as a remote for the TV.
- dwighttk 5y agoNice. That sounds like a fun weekend project one day.
- sgjohnson 5y agoI for one enjoy that my Smart TV is subsidized by all the morons who think that my data is worth anything. It's not connected to internet. It's connected to Apple TV box. Thanks for the discount.
- dancemethis 5y agoAnd then Apple getting a "monopoly" on your personal data and metadata is better, somehow...? Nevermind that this data is then shared between them. And anyone and anything else getting in through the doors in the back.
- sgjohnson 5y agoFeel free to replace “Apple TV” with whatver is your preferred input source, be it a Raspberry Pi or whatever. It doesn’t change the fact that the people doing the subsidizing aren’t getting the intended value from me.
- PeterWhittaker 5y agoApple does far less with your data than others, to the extent that there are things they cannot do that others can, e.g., in the line of recommendations: https://www.theinformation.com/articles/apples-privacy-rules-leave-its-engineers-in-the-dark https://www.theinformation.com/articles/apples-privacy-rules... Apple also does a pretty good job of securing devices against “back access”.
- hypertele-Xii 5y agoUntil your neighbor enables an open, unprotected wifi, your smart TV connects to it and auto-updates to start showing you ads.
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoA device automatically connecting to unprotected wifi is a major security issue waiting to happen.
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoI bought my previous TV right before they became "smart"; it had media playback features from a network, but no online services. Currently have an LG TV; while in theory it's a fairly dumb TV that has services like youtube and netflix built in, it's only dumb because it still allows you use it without agreeing to certain terms and conditions; they have split it up in a number of categories for things like 'smart' advertising (I paid too much for this thing for it to have advertising), speech controls, etc. At the moment it will still nag me to agree to something if I try to open up Amazon Prime, but it can still be skipped. Probably only a matter of time before it gets bricked if I don't agree to the T's and C's. Probably after three years so the warranty expires.
- danr4 5y agoMaybe a stupid question, but why isn't there a DD-WRT/OpenWRT-eqsue firmware for TVs?
- navjack27 5y agoMy guess would be that there is not enough unified Hardware
- butz 5y agoAre there any efforts to build alternative, open-source or just modified for privacy TV firmware? How hard is it actually to flash TV firmware with custom one? I understand, that there are too many TV models for unified solution, but at least some LG models were running modified version of webOS.
- evolve2k 5y agoAnyone have suggestions around the peak sweet spot for second hand tvs. Eg that moment just before smart TVs went big. Any suggestions for great second hand higher res models?
- panax 5y agoSceptre still makes dumb TVs, try checking those first.
- memcg 5y agoI paid $75 for a Samsung LN46A650 (46" LCD) in 2019 to replace a Philips HD CRT. Since, I have bought two more ($50 and $20). So, I use two and have one as a backup or parts. All from Craigslist. I also have picked up three LN46A550 ($20 total) on CL with minor problems.
- ramshorst 5y agoI would be interesting to see regulation that forces TV makers to allow users to physically remove the 'Smart' out of their devices. Like some beamer constructors do with HDMI mini computers.
- oneoff786 5y agoUse a computer and an hdmi cord as your media source and you can’t go wrong. I just wish the pi was powerful enough to cleanly stream high res content. It’s so close.
- rosndo 5y agoYeah, good luck with getting dolby vision and the likes to work. You’ll also have to deal with substantially degraded experience from streaming services unless you’re willing to deal with the inconvenience of pirating everything.
- superkuh 5y agoThese days it's the other way around. If you pirate everything it's all very easy, it's the guessing game and multiplying streaming services where you have to deal with inconvenience. It's all just a little bit of history repeating...
- doldols 5y agoI know all about this, my Plex server is rapidly approaching 200TB of content. Is it really convenient? Sure! As long as you ignore all the work that goes into setup and maintenance. I’d be deluding myself if I tried to pretend that this is anything but yet another part of a really expensive and time consuming home theater hobby. Even at it’s best DIY piracy is still miles away from just being able to open up Netflix and start watching. Of course you can pay for someone else to maintain the Plex server for you, which isn’t a horrible option.
- superkuh 5y agoI see this a lot. I've never understood my peers need for complex "plex server" (or related) setups. Why not just store the files on the hard drives of your normal computers? 200TB is why, I guess, but this is hardly typical nor does it require "plex". I do just fine with a handful of computers with ~30 TB between them and some network shares. No "maintainance" required.
- MrMan 5y agolefty twitter nimbys burned down our cities last summer, web3, and this too?
- rvr_ 5y agoIt's also becoming harder to buy dumb refrigerators above a certain size.
- mark_l_watson 5y agoI think it is common knowledge that much of the profit from Smart TVs comes from data collection. Last year I gave our beautiful Samsung Smart TV to a friend and bought a $199 dumb TV from Walmart, and just have an Apple TV box plugged into its HDMI port. I love this combination! My wife is not so happy with it, but went along with the change. Everything about watching TV now just seems easy, no ads, no crap. Love it.
- ortusdux 5y agoI'm on year 3 of not accepting the EULA on my 'smart' tv. It has never been connected to the internet. It is effectively a dumb tv that was slightly cheaper because it has dormant bloatware.
- AndyMcConachie 5y agoSame. I don't understand why more people simply don't connect the thing to the network.
- ezfe 5y agoI have a TCL Roku TV that was much cheaper than the competition, but the tradeoff is that it requires connecting to the internet to setup. If you unplug it from the internet, the little light at the bottom blinks FOREVER. The trick, though, is to connect it to the internet and then block it on your router. For some reason this doesn't trigger the light to blink.
- irobeth 5y agohow far are we from "the TV has a cellular modem so it can receive advertising updates without the need for a home network", though? isn't it like this for cars already?
- chrisjc 5y agoA great solution while it's an option... however think about where this can/might/is going. - Ethernet over HDMI - TVs with modems - Ambient/background networks like Amazon Sidewalk - Existing open networks
- andrew_ 5y agoSame here. 2018 Samsung has never been connected. I use an HDMI with Arc peripheral that I have complete control of to run everything that streams.
- robg 5y agoWorking in this space and seeing the potential for true smart displays tied to lifestyles, curious what folks would want to see in TVs as a better medium than phones. What features do you want? What pain points do you have that huge immersive displays could help with? Unfortunately the margins are so thin, need to be investigating new revenues streams or else the business fails under commoditization pressures. Agree that Adtech is not the answer.
- tapanjk 5y agoPerhaps I do not get it, but a big screen never appealed to me. I think of smart TVs as a big screen with a built-in computer, and a laptop as a computer which has a built-in screen. I always thought the laptop is a better bang for the buck. Perhaps I am missing the point because I do not live in the western world. I have observed my people who moved to the west are into large screen TVs, but I never understood the lure.
- astura 5y agoYou can watch TV with friends and family.
- augstein 5y agoI was in the same boat when I was younger. After upgrading to a (dumb) projector for movies and gaming (ex shooters), I can’t go back, since the immersion and amount of details I see on a big screen for me is just an order of magnitude better.
- JohnFen 5y agoI live in the western world, and I've never really seen the point either. But I know a few people who value a large TV, so I know they exist. It's just a matter of what floats your boat in the end. The state of the TV market is why I haven't purchased a new TV in a decade or so. And the way things are going, I probably never will. When the one I have dies, I'll likely not replace it.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- davidmurdoch 5y agoAnd now even if you do get a dumb tv and connect a new Chromecast (4k) to it you STILL get ads. You even get ads for services you already subscribe to, asking you to subscribe to a higher tier. And you also get the dark pattern of the down button on the remote navigating upwards the first time you press it... So it highlights the giant advertisement first. I'm close to building my own TV DIYPerks style.
- fuckcensorship 5y agoLast year, the NVIDIA Shield TV, a $200 device if you get the Pro version, received an update to Android TV that forced a new UI for the homescreen that injects ads from a variety of premium streaming services [1]. There is no easy way to disable it as far as I know other than installing a custom launcher such as FLauncher [2]. The cancers of modern day advertising cannot be understated. [1]: https://www.guru3d.com/news-story/nvidia-shield-tv-update-annoys-users-with-ads-and-bloatware.html https://www.guru3d.com/news-story/nvidia-shield-tv-update-an... [2]: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=me.efesser.flauncher https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=me.efesser.fla...
- davidmurdoch 5y agoGood to know! I was looking into getting one to replace my Chromecast. If I have to babysit a device's software I might as well just build the hardware myself, too! Even more pain in doing that, of course, but at least it's self inflicted.
- nerdjon 5y agoI cringe anytime I go to a friends place and their TV is connected to their network. I can't believe people have gotten to comfortable with the privacy implications of these devices being connected all the time. It wasn't that long ago that I think it was Samsung was caught with the mic always on or something? I don't remember. I hate how TV's have gone. I don't really consider myself an audiophile (or the picture quality equilvent) but I am willing to spend money on good sound and picture. Not spend a ton but cleanly middle ground on sound and high ground on picture quality. I have a 75" tv right now and eying an 85" when I upgrade this thing. I play a lot of video games, watch a lot of movies, so it is very worth it for me. I would happily pay a premium to not have all of this smart tv stuff thrown in that I will never use. There are display or other dumb TV's but from what I can tell they lack many of the bells and whistles that the top of the line TV's coming out today have. Which is what I care about. For example, getting rid of the Halo effect around lights. Something that could ruin a dark video game or movie. You could just say "don't connect it to wifi". Well the first obvious problem, I live in a city. There are a ton of unsecured Wifi networks nearby that it would be very easy for the TV to connect too. Even if not, if they entered an agreement with Xfinity and used their shared wifi network... I would wager they would be able to connect almost anywhere. Problem 2. I have had a number of times that randomly I would have signal issues with devices that had been working just fine. The only possible solution I could find was to update the firmware on the TV. Requiring me to connect it to the internet (I keep an ethernet cable nearby just for this use case) so it could update and likely send all of the data it was collecting anyways. I always connect an Apple TV to my tv for any streaming I want to do. That being said, If Apple actually truly put out a Smart TV that just ran TVos and didn't invade my privacy... I would likely buy it and have no hesitation on connecting it too the internet.
- matthewmcg 5y agoI strongly agree with the sentiment in the article, but the comma in the title seems misplaced. Edit: I think there's just a typo on the HN title. The original title showing on the website is "It's Still Stupidly, Ridiculously Difficult to Buy a 'Dumb' TV" which is perfectly grammatical.
- perihelions 5y agoThere's a vestigial comma because an automated script removed the word "ridiculously", which is (probably) on HN's list of blacklisted clickbait words.
- HonestOp001 5y agoQuick story. I purchased a Sony tv with android OS. In the store, the OS did everything I wanted. When set the system up at home, it worked just like in the store. Then five days later, an OS update forced ads onto the front page. The entire home page was changed from what I had purchased. Fortunately, I could reset the device back to the previous OS version and not let it anywhere near a wi fi. What I purchased and what I was having in my possession became antithetical to what I wanted with a software update.
- jauco 5y agoFriendly tip: new hdmi cables include ethernet. Make sure to use old ones to connect your media player
- chrisjc 5y agoOf course both the TV and media player need to be ethernet-over-HDMI enabled as well. And if you want to be able to take advantage of all the latest visual and audio advancements, you'll probably need to use one of the latest cables that comes with ethernet-over-HDMI. Is it possible to get one of the latest HDMI cables without ethernet? Are there ways to cut ethernet-over-HDMI off at the media device? I know that there might be things that can be done through the network or at the router (PiHole,etc), but I'm wondering specifically about this gaping hole through HDMI. (as I type this, I now remember that my router/Orbi can physically block individual devices) Of course the next big issue will be when the TVs come with their own internet connection. I recall this is already happening with some HiSense TVs that come with 5g. I guess at this point we'll be forced to open these things up and disconnect the antenna.
- znpy 5y agoThat should really be considered a security threat, imho.
- sliken 5y agoGenerally I recommend factory reset, then hook up to a roku or similar and just use it as a dumb display. If it fails in that configuration return the TV immediately.
- yehBu77 5y agoI solved this problem by selling my TV and learning guitar and piano during lockdown. I feel lazy and useless if I find myself in front of a TV. Personal laptop, headless desktop for local file backup and music server, WiFi gear, phone, and job laptop, are the extent of my tech at home. Feels great being decoupled from the consumer garbage churn. The made up frustration not finding what you want, the contrived reviews and story; all make for pretty banal and repetitive social life around you meat based tape recorders.
- LinuxBender 5y agoSomewhat off topic... Has anyone started developing alternative firmware/OS for these things much like the alternate OS for cell phones GrapheneOS for pixels and related alternatives? There are a few dumb TV's remaining but options are very limited. Is it even feasible to just replace the firmware and OS on these things? Is there a JTAG or similar interface over USB or ethernet? [Edit] Upon thinking about this a bit more, I am going to assume someone will figure out how to replace the firmware and OS on these. Probably a better question is, what can these devices be used for beyond watching television? How much graphics processing power do they have? Do they have any advanced instructions in their chipsets or any special purpose chips?
- phendrenad2 5y agoTaking the case off of your 65-inch TV and soldering to the JTAG points is less than ideal. A "softmod" would be awesome. Maybe a web browser buffer overflow, a la the Nintendo 3ds and wii?
- ahaferburg 5y agoI found this [1] for LG firmware but couldn't figure out much about what it actually is or does or how it works. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29338658 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29338658
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- marcodiego 5y agoIt will be a hard fight to fight. Soon TV's will come with built in 5G, you won't even need to setup its wifi. It will be a difficult to win battle.
- daveoc64 5y agoDo you honestly believe that? The TV manufacturers will subsidise a cellular connection to allow users to stream hours of 4K content in exchange for a few pennies of ad revenue? Smart TVs don't make any sense unless they are connected to a home network.
- marcodiego 5y agoThe 5G connection can be limited to phone-home functions.
- daveoc64 5y agoWhat would be the point? So they can track that you keep the TV tuned to HDMI 1 all day?
- marcodiego 5y agoAnd show ads.
- gverrilla 5y agonobody needs a "smart" tv, except for the industry trying to retain high margins.
- kkfx 5y agoThings changes: in the past the TV was a means of mass communication with both trash and valuable contents, nowadays that's only trash, at least in my current (France) and home (Italy) countries, so the fact all TV are "smart" (or, their buyer are considered dumb by the "smart" device OEM) it's just part of a Darwinian evolutionary process: a small help to push certain cohort of users out of TVs for the sake of humanity...
- mrandish 5y agoI haven't bought a new TV in a while since I use a video projector in my home theater. Last year I got a vacation place and bought a new higher-end Samsung TV. The place is semi-off-grid and only has connectivity through a 4G mobile hotspot (c'mon Elon hurry up with my Starlink!). However, the day I unboxed the TV there was no internet yet. I only got it out with the goal of testing the new receiver and 5.1 speakers that had just arrived. All I needed was to display the HDMI UI output of the receiver so I could select the proper speaker assignments and validate the speakers were working before mounting them. I could NOT figure out how to get this display to... you know, display! At least not without first providing it an internet connection and spending nearly half an hour configuring it. The first barrier was accepting the license agreement. But before displaying the license agreement the TV insisted on checking a server to see if there was a newer version of the license agreement. I couldn't figure out any way around this and it's just unacceptable.
- ahaferburg 5y agoAnd by unacceptable you mean that you returned the Samsung and purchased another TV. Right? That's what unacceptable means.
- phendrenad2 5y agoAre there any TVs that are rootable? If we can't have dumb TVs, we can at least install Cyanogenmod and hack them to work properly.
- squarefoot 5y agoThere are still some dumb TVs manufacturers like SWEDX in the EU and Sceptre in the US. I don't have any of their products so I can't tell about their quality. https://www.swedx.com/ https://www.swedx.com/ https://www.sceptre.com/ https://www.sceptre.com/ Also some Samsung models use Tizen as the OS, which hopefully could be more easier to jailbreak. Another option are signage displays, which usually (not always, though) are big dumb unconnected monitors. They're also a lot more robust (and pricey) than consumer TVs.
- howenterprisey 5y ago50-inch Sceptre here. Good stuff, would recommend. Mine shows some very, very faint shadows when the screen shows pure white, but could just be my setup.
- znpy 5y agoI bought an absolutely “fine” full he 42” to from Mediaworld, branded “Ok” for ~250€. It has no software, no updates, two hdmi inputs, an USB port and some minor inputs. I absolutely love it.
- meatsock 5y agoi have found that an external broadcast television tuner with a regular hdmi display works well for my needs. the mediasonic HW220STB includes a PVR function to record broadcasts but the firmware is a bit old. Contemporary Research 232-ATSC is an older but fully capable tuner with rs-232 and ethernet remote control and can be had for around $100. there's a newer model called "232-ATSC 4K" which retails for around $1k and offers 4K output - the older one only goes up to 1080. these are both ATSC tuners so they're fine for me in the US, but there is of course a different broadcast standard in non-US countries so this advice won't apply there.
- zzo38computer 5y agoI wound want with: no operating system, no HDMI, no internet, no transmit, no OSD (a simple segmented display or lights could indicate mode/input selection, if needed). Input can be composite, component, VGA, Digi-RGB, etc. I should put my own computer, which can be used to provide such functions as captions, volume, picture setting, etc. I should want a remote control that has numbers on it (which can be used with the computer to control the TV-oriented functions). Is there possibility to disassemble the TV set to get the display and then connect that to your own equipment, somehow, if you do not want all of the other functions? One comment in the linked article says: > A panel with a bunch of inputs should not need firmware updates. Personally, I’d go simpler: one input (HDMI or DisplayPort), no remote, automatically turns on and off depending on signal availability. Maybe with a knob for brightness. That could work, but I don't like HDMI; other than that it looks like a good idea. (My idea is Digi-RGB, which I had written the specification; I think is much better than HDMI)
- zerof1l 5y agoIf you're looking for a dumb display, check out Swedx signage displays. The cost is reasonable and you can get a large screen.
- Brian_K_White 5y agoWe pay money for a device and receive a device which does other people's bidding instead of our own. Yet the money we paid does not have this property. The money works 100% for the recipient and we retain no influence over it at all. We can't say what it get's spent on or poison it's performance so that it works for us instead of them somehow. We hand it over and it becomes 100% theirs and it works 100% normally, and does so forever, and with no strings. There is no amount of rationalizing or explaining or excusing that resolves that simple fact.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoSamsung (and other) smart TVs have begun the evolution towards the "brains" of the TV being a dongle. The key is probably to get that interface standardized so you can buy one of their smart TVs and plug in your own, dumb dongle for nerds and hackers.
- supersync 5y agoI’m dead serious I’d pay an $80 to $100 premium for a dumb TV I’d even consider replacing a couple Smart TVs are just terrible
- bonzini 5y agoBuy digital signage/conference room screens. https://www.viewsonic.com/us/products/shop/digital-displays.html https://www.viewsonic.com/us/products/shop/digital-displays....
- windowsworkstoo 5y agoDon’t know your exact specs or the premium you pay over consumer level but I buy/install commercial display panels and when I need a new TV or such, I just grab one of them. No extra stuff, fast input switching etc etc
- rbanffy 5y agoThe other day I was reading the HDMI spec. I realised, in almost full horror, it’s stupidly streaming pixels instead of image deltas. When every TV has memory enough for several full frame images, this is just crazy.
- bXVsbGVy 5y agoEncoding would add latency and it is not free. A single frame in 4k UHD 10-bits takes more than 10Mb (1/3 of the L3 cache on modern CPUS).
- IYasha 5y agoAnd you are already paying enough because of HDCP.
- IYasha 5y agoI've recently came to despise HDMI too. When I realized how many OFFICIAL standard revisions are there and how many fakes are on the market... With DisplayPort you have one cable serving you for a DECADE of HW revisions, supporting all framerates and resolutions. With HDMI you have to buy a new cable for each upgrade and when, for example, HDMI 2.0 says "Supports 4K" it only means 60Hz, and you have to buy a "8K" cable to connect a 4K gaming display. Not to mention varieties of "ethernet-enabled", "ARC-capable" and other bullshit out there on the market. And some rare proprietary HDMI cables too! Not to mention some 2.1 cables are actually optical...
- Blackstone4 5y agoMight be better off using a computer plugged into a screen + speaker combo to have the most control
- ajsnigrutin 5y agoEvery TV is "stupid" when it's not connected to the internet, and none of them can transmit your data when disconnected.
- Bancakes 5y agoMy provider gives me a EON set-top-box which is just a smartphone with a ethernet and HDMI port. It's always connected as it's internet-based TV. This is the sad state of reality.
- chii 5y agoIf it turns out that too many people are disconnecting their tv, the manufacturer would merely add in a sim card. They don't yet ATM because they don't need to - too many people are stupidly connecting their wifi.
- snvzz 5y ago>If it turns out that too many people are disconnecting their tv, the manufacturer would merely add in a sim card. Or silently use your neighbor's tv (of the same brand or cross-brand network pact) as access point. Not for streaming video, but just for the tracking. This is where we're headed.
- 3np 5y agoI also theorize that 5G will drive down the overhead enough to make that more prevalent.
- vortico 5y agoWouldn't the free market simply provide modifications with the cell networking removed for an extra $50 or so? The "discount" you get from buying a smart TV verses a dumb TV (which is a niche product so it would cost hundreds more) would still be positive after subtracting the cost of modification.
- OrderlyTiamat 5y ago> Wouldn't the free market simply provide modifications The free market doesn't seem so keen on modifications, see phones, laptops etc. All walled gardens where even repair is discouraged.
- jahnu 5y agoIs there a reason I’m not aware of that not connecting a smart to to a network isn’t enough? Do they auto-connect to open Wi-Fi for example?
- elxr 5y agoIt's enough for me. I have a 2022 4K TV that I just never connected to a network and everything works just fine.
- _moof 5y agoApparently some(? many? most?) of them refuse to work at all until they've been "set up" over the internet. Don't know for sure though; I'm clinging to my old dumb TV like a life raft.
- DoingIsLearning 5y agoAll the sony tvs that I have owned, I just connect HDMI inputs. The TV works as intended. If I use sony's remote and go to the home menu it is still waiting for a connection but it works just fine as a tv panel.
- qwertox 5y agoI don't understand it either, but it's also because I don't know how modern TVs (2015+) behave when not connected. But I wouldn't be surprised if Samsung and others would already be working on a solution where the TVs use your phone as a bridge to the internet. Or neighboring IoT devices (similar to Amazon Sidewalk).
- mtsr 5y agoJust a built in sim card with very cheap data rates works. Apparently this viewing data is worth quite a bit of money on the data markets.
- nmstoker 5y agoI guess it's not easily done but if people were to send blatantly messed up data back to the servers that were listening to the creepy TVs it would undermine that value and maybe the manufacturers would reconsider.
- lordnacho 5y agoWhat's frightening is that I can see on my PiHole the huge spike of requests that happens when one of my TVs comes on. Just the standard graph in the front page is enough to see exactly when the kids have turned it on. Most of the requests are rejected though, maybe someone can say whether that is enough to protect me from corporate surveillance.
- beckler 5y agoDude, no joke. My TCL Roku TV is the nosiest device on my whole network, second to maybe my work laptop. The difference though, is that TV is sitting in our bedroom mostly dormant, since my wife watches it maybe 1-4 times a week while she's getting ready for work.
- contravariant 5y agoBlocking the MAC address from making connections outright seems like a more sensible way to prevent surveillance. Assuming of course you are using it as a truly 'dumb' TV and not as a client for Netflix etc.
- mschuster91 5y ago> Blocking the MAC address from making connections outright seems like a more sensible way to prevent surveillance. That won't protect against DNS data exfiltration. Extremely low-bandwidth, but works in a lot of cases - people have even written proxy servers to get slow but working Internet on public hotspots that normally require login.
- ezfe 5y agoHow does that work if you block the internet at the router level?
- mschuster91 5y agoSimple: most router firewalls only block traffic that has source:<IP of device> and destination:<anything in the Internet>, but traffic from source:<IP of device> to destination:<IP of router, IP range of home network> will be allowed. That is enough for the device to emit a DNS query like "pbs.12345.metricservice.example.com" to notfiy some tracking service that the device with serial 12345 just switched to a channel labeled "PBS". The router will resolve that name record at the DNS server for metricservice.example.com, which gets the request and logs it away.
- Markoff 5y agoAren't those called nowadays "computer displays"? But I guess it can be problem with larger size, 43-55 are way more expensive than TVs, like 3-4X more than same size smart TV with same resolution. I mean if you worry about spying just don't connect smart TV to internet, but yeah, the interface will be usualyl slower than dumb TV. If you are frustrated by outdated software nothing stops you from plugging whatever Android stick into HDMI port, that's what I did with my dumb "smart" TCL with extremely locked Android without app store, without side loading (no it's not possible unless you wanna disassemble the TV and hardwire it) and with Youtube regularly crashing. But why would you want TV without speaker, that's what makes TV a TV, if you dont want even speaker then it can be hardly called a TV, that's like calling phone something which can't even make call. Btw. there are always projectors, where it should be better situation and you are also not limited by size.
- sjamaan 5y ago> But why would you want TV without speaker Many people hook up their TV (or media box) to their home audio system which often has much better sound quality. The built-in speakers of TVs are a bit pointless in that context.
- Markoff 5y agoSure, but they cost almost nothin and majority of people would have big problem with buying TV without speaker and it would cost more produce limited series without speaker than just produce all with speakers, nobody force you to use the built-in speaker, that's why there are ports to connect whatever you like. Me personally watch TV mostly through headphones, but I find TV without speaker idea absurd. What's next niche, TV without remote and infrared transmitter?
- 7steps2much 5y ago> But why would you want TV without speaker I mean, you can grab some dedicated speakers or a sound bar or something? In fact, some people do this instead of using the TV speakers anyways since it usually results in a better experience/higher audio quality.
- bojangleslover 5y agoI have a Panasonic 50" and I just never connected it to the internet. I do everything on my old MacBook plugged in via HDMI which I control via screen sharing on my current Mac.
- TheSpiceIsLife 5y agoEthernet over HDMI is a thing, so this might not work for all smart TVs.
- bojangleslover 5y agoWow I did not know that. That's wild.
- andix 5y agoTVs without a tuner are quite popular in Austria. You save around 30€ per month on payments to public TV stations, if your TV is just a monitor and has no tuner. You can get for example one of those (german, but you probably can read the specs anyway): https://nogis.at https://nogis.at or https://www.gisbefreit.at/ https://www.gisbefreit.at/ Most devices are not high end though.
- 404mm 5y agoVizio makes (or used to make) those as well. I have one of their 4k 70” without tuner (in the US). It does not suck any less. Disclaimer: I received it as a “equal replacement” by squaretrade for broken Sharp 70”
- pluc 5y agohttps://www.sceptre.com/TV/4K-UHD-TV-category1category73.html https://www.sceptre.com/TV/4K-UHD-TV-category1category73.htm...
- BrandoElFollito 5y ago> Most devices are not high end though. Do you mean that their quality is meh, or whether they lack functionality?
- andix 5y agoThe functionality is fine. You can turn them on and off. And you probably want to use a soundbar, because of bad speakers. But the panels are just not great. Like all the other TVs in that price range.
- woldenron 5y agoDo you perhaps know how does it work in Germany? I heard you have to pay the TV tax regardless if you have a TV or not.
- LeonidasXIV 5y agoYes, you have to pay the Rundfunkgebühr also if you don't have a TV but your computer has access to the Internet because public broadcasters also have a presence on the Internet.
- mrjin 5y agoSmart TVs were created for all kinds of agendas but none were actually for us the consumers. All those agendas require an OS which takes time to boot. Making it worse, some of those TVs' CPU are crap and thus every operation takes much longer than those dumb ones. Lots of vendors also start to ship new remotes that removed all the essential buttons, especially the video source button, and I have to press 5 or more times than before just to switch to a different source. So we are actually paying more(of course, lots extra hardware cost) for less. But it does not end there. Vendors put lots of Ads in them, some vendors even put boot-up Ads regardless it is connected to internet or not. The worst I guess was mentioned in a couple of day ago some rouge vendor even started to put customized Ads based programs we are watching on air. I guess my replacement for a TV would be a big monitor.
- ramraj07 5y agoIf you’re happy with a computer monitor as a tv good for you. I’m spoiled by super large screen 4K Qdot displays. If I really have to choose not to get a smart tv, the simple solution is actually to get a really good projector.
- robgibbons 5y agoEven projectors these days are becoming "smart". Though they tend to still be the exception currently, I suspect they will soon be tough to avoid.
- emerged 5y agoEventually we’re going to have Smart Drywall, so maybe we should enjoy our current relative freedom from ads.
- Kinrany 5y agoA friend of mine has a projector and projector screen-colored walls, it's great.
- TACD 5y agoThis is exactly what we did. Our ‘television’ was never hooked up to actually receive broadcast signal, we’ve always just used it as a big screen for the media/gaming PC set up in the lounge, and at some point I realised if I’m going to spend my evenings staring at Good Screen I might as well upgrade from this 40” 1080p TV with a dead pixel row. So I looked around and eventually bought a Philips 559M1 55” monitor instead. The price difference compared to an actual TV is a little tough to swallow (~£1,200 vs £?00), but the size, the resolution, and the overall picture / sound quality upgrade is very nice. The HDR leaves a lot to be desired but that’s probably inevitable when getting an LCD panel instead of OLED (which was not considered because of the likelihood of burn-in). Worth it? Eh… maybe. When compared against the available market for “TV-sized monitor” or upgrading from 1080p, absolutely. But if you’re coming over from an equivalent-sized OLED TV, you’ll be paying a hefty amount for a visual downgrade, just to escape the ‘smart’ features.
- peoplefromibiza 5y agoThat's why I'm not replacing my 10 years old panel, which is HD only (1080p) but has no connection abilities other than the ethernet port. When it'll be too old to work, I'll replace it with a projector.
- civilized 5y agoI use a projector. They're cheap and dumb.
- mvanbaak 5y agocheap ... depends. If you want good quality, brightnes and lifetime ... they are at the same price or more expensive then tv's (4k hdr projector is quickly over 4000 euro)
- civilized 5y agoI think you can get one with acceptable quality for $100. Your threshold of acceptability may be different!
- pomian 5y agoGoing to be the same solution with cars.
- Havoc 5y agoWhy doesn't one of the providers just add a software option for this? It'll get you a small but absolutely die-hard customer base for a couple lines code
- blenderdt 5y agoThere are a lot of stories that TVs still try to connect to open Wi-Fi networks while you didn't configure any. I wonder if those stories are really true. Because personally I never ever would configure internet on my TV. I just use HDMI as input. But this is also because I don't have cable TV. Imho dropping cable TV is one of the best ROIs you can make.
- littlecranky67 5y ago> I wonder if those stories are really true. Me too, I strongly suspect it is just a rumour or urban legend. I can't find any reliable sources that could name a vendor or model number of TVs that do this. And it is not like it would be hard to prove/verify for tech-journalists, yet there has been no credible report of it. I do, however, think that there are quite some TVs out there that will just refuse to work if you don't connect them/shut of the internet. But if you get one of those, just return it to the store.
- quickthrower2 5y agoDidn’t read it but a smart tv not connected to wifi with an hdmi port should do the trick?
- swayvil 5y agoProjector? I think they are typically dumb. Last I checked anyway. And have a few other advantages too.
- vmurthy 5y agoI learnt a lot from the previous discussion https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24666968 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24666968 Sigh. I am stuck on a 40" 1080p Dumb tv :(
- panax 5y agoAfter not having a TV for more than a decade I recently got a Sceptre 55'' 4k based on that thread https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24668015 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24668015 and it is all I would ask for in a TV. It is only a TV with no bullshit and was very reasonably priced. The one I have also has absolutely no wireless and I can guarantee that it is air gapped.
- endisneigh 5y agoDon’t connect to the wifi on it, plug in Ethernet with no working internet. Plug in android tv, root it and install ad free launcher of choice. Any updates you need do it via android tv. Done.
- xz18r 5y agoI recently bought a TV and faced exactly this. Basically, I use my TV for two things: a RPi with Kodi (LibreELEC) from which I do all my 'watching' and a Nintendo Switch. Both of those devices are connected via wifi. There is no reason whatsoever to have my TV do anything else than 'be a screen' and connect to my soundbar - yet it was nearly impossible to get a dumb tv anywhere where I live (Belgium) without paying ridiculous extra costs. Ended up buying a Samsung QLed (marketing bling) TV that I never connected to my network. Switching between input devices requires 6 buttons presses (!) because it keeps nagging to connect the TV to the internet.
- GoToRO 5y agoAlso on some Samsung tv: it needs to connect to download the Terms and Conditions, then it will prompt you to accept them and then it will work/remember last used input. The download happent overnight on very good net access, I guess because their servers are very busy.
- zasdffaa 5y agoA serious, non-trolling question to all. I've not had a TV for decades and for me that's a good thing. I've watched TVs in pubs (I'm in the uk) and round my mates' houses so it's not become some strange alien thing, and I'm still happy to be without it (that is, on balance; there are good things about broadcast TV and some bad, and the latter outweighs the former for me). In your opinion, is there actual overall value to still having a TV any more or is it just a habit? The number of ultra cheap space-filler productions (reality TV about police chases being one, but how many cookery programmes are there now?)seem to have diluted everything worth watching to almost zero. (I do watch DVDs on computer BTW)
- NikolaNovak 5y agoI think we need to distinguish a television as a hardware device, and what here we would call "cable channels". If you have a family, tv is not a necessity per se but a convenient norm. It allows more than one person to watch the Disney or Netflix show or movie, or even a DVD if your inclinations are toward vintage antiques ;-) I agree that I have not watched a cable channel in more than a decade.
- Brian_K_White 5y agoI watch youtube and play xbox on my tvs. I want the big screen sit back good surround sound. Laptops and phones are for airplanes and work.
- dudul 5y agoDidn't you just answer your own question? I dont have cable but I have a TV to watch movies, DVD or BR. More comfortable than watching on a computer. There is a difference between the TV set and broadcast television.
- Trasmatta 5y agoMany people use their TVs almost exclusively for video games (including me)
- scarface74 5y agoThis is the oldest trope on the Internet. I saw this years ago Slashdot. There has been this thing called “the internet” since the last time you owned a TV and these things called “streaming services”. Why is this the one area where being ignorant of something that has 90% penetration seen as a virtue?
- shaky-carrousel 5y ago> There are options, but guides on this front will usually shovel you toward computer monitors (too pricey at large sizes) I have the feeling that "smart" tvs are cheaper because (like the laptops with windows preinstalled) they are filled to the brim with adware and spyware.
- guidedlight 5y agoI'm 90% sure that all Sony TV's give you the option of a "Basic TV" when you go through the initial set up. Edit: Yep. Any Google TV based television will do this. https://9to5google.com/2021/02/24/google-tv-basic-tv-mode/ https://9to5google.com/2021/02/24/google-tv-basic-tv-mode/
- aceazzameen 5y agoLooks like newer TVs only. My Sony X900F doesn't have this option. It's about 3-4 years old now? But I also never updated Android on it (still on Oreo) and I declined all agreements (like Samba). I liked it, but hated how slow it was compared to my older dumb TV. Pressing a button and waiting for something to happen on the home screen was ridiculous. After 2 years, I went nuclear and disabled as many apps and background services as I could. Lo and behold, I suddenly had a snappy TV with only the 3 streaming services I need on it. This is what I continue to want. A TV that can do streaming without additional hardware, and without the insane level of tracking and ads that are so prevalent.
- helloworld11 5y agoI'm a bit hazy on this and how a smart TV interacts with the rest of the devices in a home, but for example, I have a 55 inch 4K Samsung TV in my living room, which I barely use. Occasionally I stream a movie on it, use it for music when friends visit and sometimes hook it to my laptop as a large monitor through HDMI but that's it. About 80% of the time it sits unused. With all that in mind, I don't see how all of its internal spying and tracking software is even important. How much information could it possibly collect if what it gets is nothing more than sporadic generic movie/music viewing? I don't see the problem with this particular technology if it's used lightly, unlike a smart phone, for example, which can pass enormous amounts of personal and location information on you even if you're not addicted to using it all day.
- phdelightful 5y agoI'm currently in the "smart TV but don't connect it to the internet" crowd. I think there are three broad criticisms. Violating your privacy in unsurprising ways that provide no value to you: obviously when and how you use it, possibly including screenshots and audio fragments to help HQ determine what you're watching Degrading your experience: basically just ads in places you don't want them that didn't exist when you bought it. Violating your privacy in "surprising" ways that provide no value to you, and circumventing your efforts to stop it: what other devices are present on your home network, where your home is, connecting to unsecured wifi (or soon mesh networks with your neighbor's TV) to do so. IMO these are the things to defend against. If they're not happening to you then that's great. It's also fine if they don't bother you. For example, if 3 is happening to me I'm not going to go to the trouble of figuring it out how to stop it, though it will change my future purchasing decisions.
- timwis 5y agoI’ve been trying to sell a dumb tv on Facebook all week, and people keep asking if it has Netflix built in :P
- FroshKiller 5y agoI sold an old 42" LCD on Craigslist this week. The person who bought it was getting it for her kid's apartment. She did not know much about televisions and had a lot of questions. One of the first questions she asked was, "Does it have apps for Netflix and stuff like that, or will I need a Roku or Fire stick?" If you only use one or two hardware inputs and one's not an OTT box, it's a lot easier to just use the TV's apps. People don't want to have to buy extra gadgets just to have another TV for their kids or in another room.
- nicolas_t 5y agoTypical recommendation I always give to anyone looking for a dumb tv, get a JVC videoprojector, it's dumb and you'll get the biggest price to size to quality ratio possible for watching movies (note: the actual price is far below msrp if you look). Buying a B-stock JVC DLA-X790R for 2,300 usd was one of the best purchase I've ever made. Amazing image quality, looks great on the 120 inch screen that drops from my ceiling in the living room and not a iota of smartness included. Only thing is that it does mean that watching movies during the day is not great without black out curtains. This creates intentionality behind our tv watching. Turning on the video projector, closing the black out curtains and opening the screen means that we don't start watching tv out of force of habit. There's a certain degree of conscious decision behind watching a movie or tv show and I think that's beneficial to us by reducing the amount of tv watching and forcing us to concentrate on higher quality content. It's a bit similar to using records to listen to music (I don't personally but I can see how it could enhance the experience compared to just turning on spotify) or to making loose leafed tea with proper teaware.
- csa 5y agoFor a tech periodical, this seems to be a stretch for content. Thirty seconds poking around the interwebs led me to this Samsung 65” 4K “digital signage” for $1125: https://www.samsung.com/us/business/displays/4k-uhd/qb-series/qbr-b-series-65--lh65qbrbbgcxgo/ https://www.samsung.com/us/business/displays/4k-uhd/qb-serie... 43, 50, 55, 75, and 85 also available. I assume that these are as good as or better than most people have in their homes (esp. with Vizio), but probably not as good as what home theater enthusiasts might want. Am I missing something?
- martyvis 5y agoThey don't operate as TVs - no tuners - they are displays for content that is downloaded or streamed.
- raffraffraff 5y agoYep, but if you want a tuner, you get a tuner. Most cable/satellite boxes handle everything for you. If you want a "dumb TV" digital signage is the way to go.
- SideburnsOfDoom 5y agoA TV tuner can be plugged in, if it's even needed - the same channels will be available via e.g. in the UK case, the Sky box (cable tv) or BBC app (running on Chromecast or similar).
- naoqj 5y agoYou are supposed to connect a dvb-t tuner to it, or maybe a chromecast if you want online content.
- devin 5y agoI don’t know the answer but wonder if “digital signage” means it is more often viewed at a distance, and thus has lower quality control around say, dead pixels. Just a guess, but it seems like that could be true.
- 5y ago
- bsenftner 5y agoSeriously, it is dumb to look for a "dumb TV", search for a "monitor" and you'll find what you need. I've got 9 large monitors from 25" to 50" - 6 on my computers and the other 3 on old computers, but displaying whatever - YouTube music playlists and Reddit EarthPorn. As a monitor, I've never paid much over $500 for one, as (stupid) people think they are no good; consumer electronics stores have such idiots as managers they'll have a 55" monitor on the floor for 6 weeks and mark it down to $400.