33 ms·
Elon Musk owns 9.2% of Twitter
- okokwhatever 5y agoGuys, Musk is simply buying the best marketing platform available for his companies (he's just ensuring a good position online) And, meanwhile, any competitor is gonna have to pay "to be there".
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ctvo 5y agoOne interesting thing is that unlike Paul Graham, who thought it was possible to launch a Twitter competitor in a month, Elon understands it’s not that easy to compete with or build a new Twitter. It’s not a particularly expensive company for its outsized influence in the world. Having said that, boy is Elon the wrong person to own a platform that should respect free speech and be neutral (understanding Twitter hasn’t had a perfect record on either front).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- oblio 5y agoStuff like Reddit or Twitter should be public services or at least non-profits. Edit: Why is this downvoted? How does it make any sense to have them as public, for profit, companies, when we all know what happens when their growth stops? How sleazy they all become? Heck, they're sleazy as-is. Who here likes where Reddit is headed, for example?
- _3u10 5y agoI thought twitter was a non-profit, I guess this is why musk is investing now that it isn’t.
- Jcowell 5y agoWhat does this mean or rather what does this look like? When I see these I never understand if it’s for or against governmental free speech. As I understand it , services under governmental control are under even more free speech restrictions than privateer services since they have a duty to crack down on whatever values a government is beholden to (anti-porn, anti-illegal activity, anti-Anonymization). What is the end goal here?
- oblio 5y agoOk, non profit then. Have some neutral org not chasing profits improve what it has instead of shoving dark design patterns and closing APIs in order to sell more ads.
- Jcowell 5y agoWhat is “neutral”? As I see it your target 3 different things here. To be honest interpolation is something that will be ripe for abuse by actors like 4Chan just because they can. I’m not seeing a way to ensure the banning of users while allowing interoperability that isn’t solved already by email. If the solution to this is to not allow the banning of users, then how does one combat things such as child porn, revenge porn, etc.
- oblio 5y agoI'm not for decentralized solutions since I don't think their UX can scale. Theoretically maybe they can, but in my eyes it's a P=NP hard problem right now. I'm also not for absolute free speech, so yes, users should be banable in case of abuse. The main thing I'm against is the fact we're taking for granted various methods of online communication (Twitter like broadcast, Reddit-like centralized forums, plus I'd actually put WhatsApp like instant messengers here). And they should just be dumb pipes. They shouldn't try to add a ton of smart features they sell to <<other companies>>. Because their incentives are out of alignment with their direct user needs. They will serve whoever pays them instead of whoever uses them. The classic enterprise software dilemma which in that case creates functionally horrible software. For online software it creates morally horrible software, instead.
- riffic 5y agointeroperable protocols are arguably more important. ActivityPub is a W3C specification at the Recommendation stage, which basically means it's ready for production. This would allow groups like, oh, house.gov to run their own platform and assign every congress person their own interoperable user account (AOC@HOUSE.GOV for example) and it works pretty much the same way email works.
- oblio 5y agoI'd really, really want to have that. The problem is, companies know these and they subtly sabotage these standardization efforts. Look at the web. Desktop UI toolkits have had solid components since the start. From the late 80s and early 90s. The web is maybe getting them universally in 2024. I mean, it's great that we have standards, but can you really afford to wait 30-40 years? I'll be frank with you, if you're a professional in our field, 30-40 years is your entire career. Many people in IT actually retire even earlier or move up to management and basically out of regular IT, after 5-10-15 years. And people can only care so much. Heck, many Open Source hackers move on after 5-10 years. Only a handful last 30 years. Faster moving standards are a sort of utopia, it seems.
- LewisVerstappen 5y ago> Elon the wrong person to own a platform that should respect free speech and be neutral (understanding Twitter hasn’t had a perfect record on either front). Does a "right person" exist?
- ctvo 5y agoOff the top of my head and solely? Mackenzie Scott (Bezos)? There are quite a few folks who could create structures for shared (vs. sole) ownership of Twitter as a public good.
- rayiner 5y agoWhat does Mackenzie Scott know about anything other than running Amazon? She’s a busybody who involves herself in stuff that’s none of her business. E.g. knee-jerk donating to anti-Asian front organizations like AAJC just because #stopaapihate was trending and they had “Asian” in the name: http://nwasianweekly.com/2020/08/mackenzie-scott-billionaire-ex-wife-of-jeff-bezos-donates-part-of-fortune-to-asian-charity/ http://nwasianweekly.com/2020/08/mackenzie-scott-billionaire... Musk is an infinitely better influence on something like Twitter.
- ctvo 5y agoTo spell it out clearly: Mackenzie Scott will leave running the platform to the people familiar with it. That's exactly why she's the best person to own Twitter and turn it into a public good vs. Elon, who also knows absolutely nothing about running Twitter, but will no doubt intervene.
- rayiner 5y agoTwitter is already a public company left to its own devices. But free speech wise, what Twitter needs is intervention. Scott is plainly in the same bubble as the existing Twitter employees and can’t provide that intervention.
- 5y ago
- Jyaif 5y agoEverybody knows that building a competitor is not the hard part. Elon could build and own 100% a competitor to Twitter for much less than the 3 billion he spent to get 9% of twitter. The problem is getting the competitor to have traction. For that you need to have the idea for a differentiator that will hook people, and unlike engineering talent you can't buy this!
- ShamelessC 5y agoWell yeah, you have to actually compete in a competition. Seems pedantic to me.
- kertoip_1 5y ago> The problem is getting the competitor to have traction The mere fact that the platform belongs to him can help a lot
- dagw 5y agoTruth Social launched with a real differentiating message compared to Twitter that appeals to a lot of people, had massive media coverage and is fronted by one of the most prolific and famous Twitter users in history. Yet by all accounts it has effectively zero traction.
- pjc50 5y agoAs I've said elsewhere, it has the PVP MMO problem: it needs a supply of victims. It's no fun shouting at each other in an echo chamber.
- ctvo 5y ago> Everybody knows that building a competitor is not the hard part. Everybody knows this? Truth Social needs to be told. The app can barely launch, and got a head start forking Mastadon as far as we know. They have hundreds of millions (a few billion?) in capitalization. Everyone knows people who haven’t actually tried tend to underestimate the difficulty in other’s work. To be clear, nowhere did I say the engineering is the hardest part.
- fallingknife 5y agoHe is specifically buying it because he wants it to respect free speech and it currently doesn't. He tweeted about this before buying. https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1507259709224632344 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1507259709224632344
- ctvo 5y agoStating his aspirations and actually following through is something else entirely. If we went by what he aspires, we’d be on our second human mission to Mars with fully autonomous vehicles. Elon has the emotional stability of my 13 year old cousin, and changes his mind as often.
- ramblerman 5y agoThat's quite a cynical take, and plainly incorrect. He is still actively pursuing those goals, they are just very difficult projects. Objectively he has done more for promoting space travel than most any other individual today. He has his flaws sure, but people generally admire his willingness to pursue bold aspirations with extreme tenacity.
- ctvo 5y agoNot really. I picked examples of his most successful aspirations. There's a graveyard of others that have died quietly: - Elon wants to take Tesla private and has the capitalization - Elon wants to rescue Thai children stuck in a cave - Elon will sell Tesla stock to end world hunger - Elon wants to fight Putin in a 1-on-1 to end the war in Ukraine - Elon thinks 98% of the US will be covered in Supercharging stations by 2015 - Elon wants to send 2 people into space by 2018 ... Elon has a long history of underestimating how difficult things are and gives up quietly or is proven immediately to be wrong. Edit: Forgot about this site https://www.elonmusk.today/ https://www.elonmusk.today/ which does a better job than my memory of documenting some of Elon's outrageous tweets. Add: - Elon wants to fund the repairs of any house in Flint that's water contaminated. - Elon wants to use bricks from the Boring Company to create low cost housing. - Elon is starting a candy company that will be amazing. - Elon wants to use SpaceX rockets to power aircrafts for quicker trips from New York to London in 29 minutes. - Elon received government approval (verbally) to build a tunnel for the hyperloop from New York City to Washington DC. ...
- ramblerman 5y ago> boy is Elon the wrong person to own a platform that should respect free speech and be neutral Given twitter has not respected free speech, and Elon has no track record (AFAIK) of thwarting free speech, what makes him so wrong?
- jsemrau 5y agoI just leave this here. https://www.businessinsider.com/free-speech-absolutist-elon-musk-censors-employees-critics-2022-3 https://www.businessinsider.com/free-speech-absolutist-elon-...
- acallan 5y agoDo you have any examples of Twitter arresting or imprisoning people for speech, or acquiescing to government censorship? Perhaps you are instead to moderating their private platform and enforcing community guidelines? I understand the latter can be annoying, but it is a mistake to conflate the two, as free speech is something very special and important and in the US is in fact codified into the Bill of Rights. TL;DR free speech is between you and the government, not between you and someone else or some other company.
- rmbyrro 5y agoThey claim to be a platform, not publishers, so they shouldn't be able to invoke publisher rights and be the judge of what can or cannot be published. Let the government do this mediation. Twitter should let people ask a judge to issue content take downs based on the law and just comply with it.
- acallan 5y agoThere is simply no meaningful legal distinction between the two in this context. See https://twitter.com/badsec230takes https://twitter.com/badsec230takes
- pjc50 5y ago"Twitter is _not allowed_ to remove porn, spam, doxxing, or death threats without a court order (of what jurisdiction?)" would immediately collapse into goatse chaos.
- noxer 5y agoHes very much pro free speech why would he be the wrong person? He doesn't have to become the CEO anything if he has enough influence trough his shares he can push twitter to be more open about how it make stuff trending and prevents other stuff from trending etc. There is no doubt hes not happy with the current way Twitter restricts speech which is heavily biased and so he wants to change that.
- RivieraKid 5y ago> Hes very much pro free speech Nope, he has a history of silencing or trying to silence opinions that he doesn't like.
- noxer 5y agoCan you name 3 such opinions that he does not like? Can you name 3 incidents where he tried to silence someones opinion?
- jsemrau 5y agoDeSo / Bitclout is a company that had rebuild Twitter on top of a blockchain and its just not that good. The whole Twitter UI paradigm is so 15 years ago.
- ckastner 5y agoThis implies that he sees value in Twitter. The interesting question is whether said value is based on one of his insights/visions that most others seem to lack, or whether he is outright deluding himself because of his Twitter addiction.
- vmception 5y agoOr because it’s just a trade that went above reporting thresholds
- vmception 5y agoNope total activist investment!
- LewisVerstappen 5y agoIt's an investment of a couple of billion dollars. He couldn't care less about the ROI on that. It's more likely to do with his issue around Twitter & free speech.
- bl0rg 5y ago*couldn't care less. Unless you mean that he could care less, implying that he cares somewhat. Perhaps even a great deal.
- LewisVerstappen 5y agoHa whoops. Fixed the typo. Thanks.
- da39a3ee 5y agoDo you mean "he literally couldn't care less"?
- 0xdeadb00f 5y agoOf course he sees value in Twitter. He may not like it, but he would be a moron to not see the value in it. Heck, half the reason he has so many fanboys is probably because of his twitter antics.
- sylware 5y agoElon, restore twitter support of noscript/basic (x)html browsers. Please?
- dbbk 5y agoYou know he doesn't work there right
- 0xdeadb00f 5y agoHe also has never voiced concern for JavaScript bloat, nor noscript
- sgt 5y agoNow, if Richard Stallman becomes a shareholder at Twitter, we might start to see some changes in that arena.
- 0xdeadb00f 5y agoNever gonna happen. Mostly because there's no freedom respecting, free-as-in-libre stock exchange that RMS would be okay with using. Not to mention I'm sure he doesn't like the idea of being a twitter shareholder.
- arrakis2021 5y ago
- kevingadd 5y agoThis is already allowed on twitter, along with lots of other "cancelled opinions" (despite any stated rules to the contrary - they do not take action against such posts). One of the freedoms you have in many parts of the internet is being able to express regressive opinions like that without being banned or having your posts deleted.
- hx833001 5y ago
- qayxc 5y ago> The science of basic human biology is now a “regressive opinion.” Stunning. Your lack of medical knowledge is just as stunning. Not only does intersex exist (yes, humans can indeed have both primary sexual organs, though it's rare), there's also a plethora of conditions that blur the line, from De la Chapelle-Syndrom to Swyer-Syndrom. There's chromosomal-, gonadal-, hormonal-, and anatomical variations that are part of "basic human biology" yet result in individuals that cannot easily be classified by vagina=woman and penis=man. Shocking, I know.
- HereIGoAgain 5y agoA small number of people are born without the ability to hear... That doesn't mean we should erase the ability to hear out of human biology books.
- da39a3ee 5y agoDespite the messiness of biology it is, has always been, and always will be a reasonable statement to say that "boys have a penis and girls have a vagina". That really shouldn't need saying. Of course, the meaning of the statement depends on the meaning you assign to "boy", "girl", as well as "penis" and "vagina". But in the semantic/communication environment in which we operate, the statement is reasonable because most people define those words such that the statement evaluates to usually-true. And usually-true is what we work with in biology and language; it's not computer science, it's messy, so approximate language is appropriate.
- influx 5y agoInteresting, given this tweet: https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1507259709224632344 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1507259709224632344
- kertoip_1 5y agoAlso this one: https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1507041396242407424 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1507041396242407424
- ckastner 5y ago> "Twitter algorithm should be open source" I can see the idealism behind this question, but imagine just how hard this could backfire in practice. People discovering to what extent algorithmic ranking manipulates them, and feeds the outrage machine. And that's what glues eyeballs and generates revenue, so changing the algorithm would work against revenue.
- rubyist5eva 5y agoWe shouldn’t be transparent because it would make people mad
- ckastner 5y agoJust to be clear, I'd love for this to happen. I absolutely despise the outrage machine that Twitter has come to be. I'm saying it's interesting for Elon, as a major shareholder, to argue in favor of this.
- colinmhayes 5y agoWe shouldn't be transparent because there would be insane SEO if we were. Social media needs to be a black box or the only thing you'd see if propaganda and ads.
- rubyist5eva 5y ago
- jbirer 5y agoSounds like laying the groundwork for stock manipulation. There is a subtle threat there, that he might dump those shares if people vote that Twitter is not a free speech place.
- lvl102 5y agoHe can buy enough to influence Twitter management. If he can accrue roughly 20%, I imagine he can easily influence their 30-something CEO. At the same time, Twitter will become another meme stock for the r/wsb crowd. Elon will exit at a healthy profit. TWTR has been an underperforming stock for such a long time, it’s ripe for something like this to completely remake the company.
- freddie_mercury 5y agoTwitter's CEO isn't 30-something. He is 45 years old.
- epmatsw 5y agoIs 37 really young enough to be worth mentioning?
- lvl102 5y agoThat’s very fair. Most people, regardless of age, would listen to Elon Musk especially in SV. I actually like Parag so it wasn’t meant as a knock on him.
- davidkuennen 5y agoTBH I have Twitter shares for some time now because I think they are fairly undervalued. You can think about Twitter what you want, but it's the only social network doing what it does and it's building a solid Ad-Business. There couldn't have been a better time to buy.
- adam_arthur 5y agoI've been pretty amazed at their inability to monetize. Their share price is roughly in line with what it was when they IPOed in 2014. I do think there's much further potential for monetization, but it's been a very shareholder hostile company historically
- lvl102 5y agoI think all of Wall Street sees that TWTR is sitting on a goldmine. They were just grossly mismanaged for decade plus.
- aemtox 5y agoSmart investment Elon..
- alfiedotwtf 5y agoIf his plans are to turn twitter into an untouchable free speech zone, then twitter's in a world of pain. We've seen from the past 4 or so years with QAnon, anti-vaxers, flat-earthers etc, that free speech to the wrong listener can be weaponised. If you make twitter censor-proof, all you'll get is a bigger trash fire. I was sad when I got kicked off Twitter, but it possibly ended up being the best thing for me. Damn twitter is a toxic place... and if Elon turns it into censor-proof cesspool, I give the platform 5 years tops before it becomes yet another social platform that nobody uses anymore.
- BurningPenguin 5y agoThose "opinions" are heavily inflated by bots and other fake accounts. I've observed this behaviour around 2012 on Youtube comments, where the usual tinfoil nutjobs kept running several accounts at once and artificially upvoted their fantasies and downvoted any criticism. It happened on multiple videos on very specific topics from respectable sources. Usually moon landing, 9/11 and so on. It's pretty much the same now on Twitter. It's just the scale that's different, and apparently also the professionalism behind it.
- alfiedotwtf 5y agoSure, but I think this also highlights something even worse - if Twitter becomes censorship free, how do you stop the bots? You can't by design!
- BurningPenguin 5y agoThat's the problem, yes. I fully agree with your point. Just wanted to add some observations. Every community needs some form of "censor", or as we called it back in the day: "moderator". Just to keep things civil. The only way to stop bots, or at least lessen their impact, would be to make verification via ID (passport, drivers license, etc) mandatory. But that opens up a whole other can of worms. Another thing i noticed is, that many people don't seem to know what "free speech" actually is. Maybe it's different in the US. I can only speak for the German version of it. It's to protect you from prosecution by the government. It is not a free ticket to attack others and it doesn't protect from criticism.
- Mulpze15 5y agoThen he probably is the biggest shareholder now. Based on public data Vanguard and Morgan Stanley were the biggest with about 8.5% each.
- ckastner 5y agoTWTR is up 24% pre-market. I don't think there's much that Musk can do to increase Twitter's revenue, but at least the market seems to believe that he can hype this one beyond reasonable valuations, too.
- sudden_dystopia 5y agoI don’t think he cares about revenue. I think he is trying to build a majority share and then take the company private. It is the very fact that twitter is a public company to begin with, that is pushing it to extremes. Social media companies should be banned from the stock market.
- chasd00 5y agoIf he takes it private then maybe he could just turn it off and walk away. That would be a huge contribution to society.
- arlcode 5y agoGiven the significance to some politicians I can imagine that they would intervene if it came to that. Musk has to take care to not overplay his hand.
- pyronik19 5y ago"It's a private company" has been the excuse for the abusive censorship. Are you saying if someone has right wing leanings on free speech that politicians will now change their tune and threaten it?
- arlcode 5y agoNot at all (under the assumption that a possible Twitter under Elon Musk would continue to adhere to local laws). But trying to shut down a platform which is considered (by some) "critical infrastructure" might find you in a position where regulations restrict what you can do. It's not a certainty but a possibility that this might happen (regardless of who is in power at the time.) Many politicians of different leanings use Twitter for communication.
- nemo44x 5y agoSmart move for a billionaire that wants to influence public opinion. The usual route is to buy a magazine or newspaper but in our new world, being a highly influential stock owner of a social media company is the way forward.
- pjc50 5y agoThe Berlusconi approach? (I'd suspect Musk of wanting to run for office, except I don't think he'd accept a lesser office than President which he's ineligible for. Maybe a state governor like Arnie?)
- geoah 5y agoI was wondering why that would be the case and a quick google basically comes up with this: > He was born in South Africa so he could never become President of the United States. Didn't know that was a requirement. TIL :D
- philistine 5y agoIf not for that detail, Arnold would have run against Obama.
- dmurray 5y agoYou might recall a certain movement asking for Obama's birth certificate to prove that he was born in the US, back when he ran for president. It's not completely clear that you need to be born in the US - several presidents and presidential candidates weren't - but it's pretty clear that foreigners who become naturalized US citizens later in life are not eligible to run for president.
- jen20 5y agoYes - I don’t believe there is a requirement to be born inside US territory (Ted Cruz was born in Canada and clearly desperately wants to be president!) - just to be a US citizen at birth.
- KaiserPro 5y ago
- evancoop 5y agoI'm waiting for some Musk tweet, the requisite outrage from an impassioned subset of the populace, a quick-witted Musk response, followed by the new title: "Elon Musk OWNS 9.2% of Twitter."
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Traster 5y agoWorth noting that the date of buying these shares is March 14th, and the date he started rather unsubtly tweeting about Twitter's approach to free speech is March 25th. So to be clear, anyone who thought that Musk's actions are the result of the twitter poll he ran has clearly been misled.
- refurb 5y agoAre you inferring that when someone tweets about a topic that’s the exact moment the thought first occurred to them?
- Traster 5y agoNo I'm saying that quote > The consequences of this poll will be important. Please vote carefully. Is pretty disingenuous when it turns out that he's launched the poll a week after he already decided to buy 10% of the stock. Do you seriously think Musk spent several billion dollars on twitter stock and then decided to check what people think?
- kreetx 5y agoPerhaps he's asking as to decide what to do in the company?
- Traster 5y agoI just don't think it's very likely that Elon Musk spend billions buying a stake in twitter before he knew what he wanted to do with the company, especially since his view on free speech is already well known and goes far beyond even vocal free speech advocates.
- Clubber 5y ago>his view on free speech is already well known and goes far beyond even vocal free speech advocates. I don't follow him that closely, how so?
- frankbreetz 5y agoThe Elon Market Hypothesis is alive and well https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2021-02-10/elon-musk-tweets-great-news-for-bitcoin-bad-news-for-econ-majors https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2021-02-10/elon-m...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gigatexal 5y ago
- refurb 5y ago
- briandear 5y ago
- netsharc 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- thinkingemote 5y agoPutin is on Twitter. Logically, should you have found another alternative on Feb 23rd 2022 and not some hypothetical time in the future? Or is this not about rationality?
- jasonvorhe 5y agoPutin himself isn't on Twitter. The Kremlin has an account that's managed by a team. That's not comparable to Trump's Twitter account who had his personal account and @POTUS.
- betwixthewires 5y agoPutin's position is unaccountable to voters, he isn't losing the Kremlin's twitter account through an election, for all intents and purposes it is his personal twitter account, worse actually because it comes with the machinery of government behind it.
- ramblerman 5y agoYou could just... not follow Trump, or block him.
- yummybear 5y agoDoes this mean Trump will be let back in again, because then I'm out.
- trompetenaccoun 5y agoYou are going to leave a platform if a certain person is allowed the right to speak there? Have you tried Weibo or VKontakte? Those seem like the sort of sites you'd enjoy then.
- HereIGoAgain 5y agoSeriously.. That kind of attitude is insane!
- thinkingemote 5y agoPutin is on Twitter and yet many people have not left the platform. Logically what should you do?
- ShamelessC 5y agoWait what? He is?
- lentil_soup 5y agohe's not, the poster above is trolling
- ShamelessC 5y agoThanks, flagged it.
- thinkingemote 5y agoNot trolling, but as another comment corrected, the dictator's official Kremlin account is up on twitter.
- 5y ago
- motohagiography 5y agoAppreciating how funny it is that a buying a platform for emitting 140 char messages was the way to get short narrative. It's a huge channel with a very poor and constrained platform under it, which I suspect is the opportunity. However, the only way to unlock it is with leadership who still want to grow for real, instead of keeping it leashed as a zero-sum political tool. If I were to speculate on what makes this a Musk super-play, Twitter seemed on the path to collapsing under the weight of all the fucks its managers and keepers have had to give, thus destroying the value of a historically unique channel. The best way to use that huge channel for real good and value is to open it up to users to build on and get out of the way. It's something he's almost uniquely capable of driving.
- grapescheesee 5y agoSure, but we should ask. How much could he own?
- dusing 5y agoWhy?
- 11thEarlOfMar 5y agoAgrawal: "Our role is not to be bound by the First Amendment, but our role is to serve a healthy public conversation and our moves are reflective of things that we believe lead to a healthier public conversation,” [1] Musk: "Sorry to be a free speech absolutist" [2] Investopedia: "Large shareholder blocs can therefore vote to fire a member of the board and replace them with somebody else for perceived mismanagement, ineffectual governance, or malfeasance." [3] The Board hires the CEO. [1] https://www.technologyreview.com/2020/11/18/1012066/emtech-stage-twitters-cto-on-misinformation/ https://www.technologyreview.com/2020/11/18/1012066/emtech-s... [2] https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1499976967105433600?lang=en https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1499976967105433600?lang... [3] https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/072815/how-do-corporations-shareholders-influence-its-board-directors.asp https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/072815/how-do-corpo...
- ahiknsr 5y agoHe is probably trying to take down the flight-tracking bot (https://www.protocol.com/elon-musk-flight-tracker https://www.protocol.com/elon-musk-flight-tracker). Funny how he talks about Free speech on twitter while actively trying to take down a twitter account.
- panick21_ 5y agoWhat? Why would he care about that?
- jwozn 5y agoI don't think he would try to take it down like OP, but he did offer the owner of the account $5K to take it down, citing security issues. See: https://www.protocol.com/elon-musk-flight-tracker https://www.protocol.com/elon-musk-flight-tracker.
- enraged_camel 5y agoI think the tracking bot goes quite a bit further than simply being free speech.
- jwozn 5y agoCan you elaborate? The bot is collecting and publishing public information.
- fleddr 5y agoYet clearly targeting a single aircraft with a single high profile user. The fact that the information is public is not a perfect defense, by combining public information, clearly associating it to an individual, and publishing this to a large audience, you can create a sizable threat.
- enraged_camel 5y agoYep, pretty much. I'm really disappointed in the way the HN crowd seems utterly unable to see beyond "it's free speech!" when it comes to situations like this.
- lastofthemojito 5y agoThe timing makes me wonder if Jack Dorsey knew this was happening yesterday? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30899950 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30899950 I'm not up on my billionaire gossip so I have no idea if Dorsey and Musk are friend or foe but I can certainly see where someone would regret building something powerful and then letting others (especially those with different views) control it.
- cloudwalking 5y agoSeems unlikely. They’re friends. https://twitter.com/jack/status/1507146276416098307 https://twitter.com/jack/status/1507146276416098307
- qiskit 5y agoIf Dorsey was worried about letting others control it, he wouldn't have gone public with twtr nearly 10 years ago. Crazy how in 10 years, twtr's market cap hasn't budged while tesla's has grown to over 1 trillion dollars. If only I knew back then what I know now...
- vineyardmike 5y ago> The timing makes me wonder if Jack Dorsey knew this was happening yesterday? He totally could have known, since the paperwork was filed a few weeks ago. Did he look into the paperwork? Maybe? - if I found a major biz, I'd keep my EDGAR alerts turned on.
- syshum 5y agoJack lost control of Twitter to activist employees, not the shareholders. I could be very wrong but the impression I got from watching several interviews with Jack (like his appearance on Joe Rogan) he seemed to have been very very torn by the desire to be a more free speech platform while still being in a constant battle with his Activist CA based employee's I think this battle is why he left.
- adolph 5y agoStarlink + Twitter = ??
- thoughtstheseus 5y agoI’m calling it now. Elon will push Twitter to allow users to determine their algorithmic feeds. A market for algos to compete with what content to serve you will be unstoppable. Everyone gets what they want.
- fallat 5y agoOptimal ad placement for each user.
- CWuestefeld 5y agoThat's a pretty wonderful thought. I hope/wish you're right.
- bpodgursky 5y agoFar more likely he wants to drastically curtail the moderation and account banning. He's basically a free-speech absolutist.
- memish 5y agoHe'd do both. He'd bring back free speech and open source the algo.
- the_doctah 5y agoI prefer that over the current "Arbiters of the definition of misinformation" censorship style they and every other social media platform has adopted.
- eric_cc 5y ago> a free-speech absolutist You don't need to be an absolutist to be pretty disgusted with Twitter censorship.
- bpodgursky 5y agoI agree entirely, I was just being clear about his perspective.
- Gareth321 5y agoGood. Hopefully he fires the CEO, Parag Agrawal, who infamously doesn't care about free speech. I know this is a business, but Twitter is a virtual town square now, and I expect these tech giants to at least pay lip service to the ideals which built modern Western societies.
- scaramanga 5y agoHopefully they let the townsfolk put the lord's heads on pikes :) Or will the lords only set foot in the town square with a praetorian guard to protect them?
- Traster 5y agoPeople seem to forget that the absolutist free speech approach is something we tried for about a decade and it hard absolutely terrible results. If Musk comes in and starts throwing around more of that it'll simply be a matter of letting Musk relearn the mistakes that industry already made (which to be fair, is something he's done in plenty of other industries - the failure of the solar roofs, the boring company etc)
- malwarebytess 5y agoSeemed fine to me. If you don't like what you see on the internet, walk away, turn off your device, uninstall the app, stop visiting that address.
- csee 5y agoUnfortunately the real world doesn't work like that. If misinformation about COVID persuades large numbers to avoid the vaccine, and the hospitals get clogged, that invariably impacts me. If misinformation persuades the population to elect a populist, that invariable impacts me. If climate change misinformation persuades the population to block the transition to renewables, that impacts me. If hate speech galvanizes the population against my ethnic group, which causes a 300% spike in hate crimes against that ethnic group, that impacts me.
- MangoCoffee 5y agothis blow up at /r/wallstreetbets/
- hsnewman 5y agoFunny, it looks like he uses a P.O. box in a grocery store (HEB).
- DrBoring 5y agoI find Elon Musk to be a fascinating person. I cannot pretend that I understand his motives for any of his actions, be it buying a 9.2% of Twitter, or tweeting something strange. No more than I can understand the motives of my next door neighbor who mows her lawn twice a week in the summer. I think the premises which many people hold about Musk are based on their own personal experiences, which are undoubtedly far different than those of Musk. Given that, I suspect the conclusion which they draw about him are likely incorrect. But, I too enjoy the pastime of trying to imagine what Musk is up to. So far I work from these premises: * He doesn't do anything unintentionally. * Most of his Twitter behavior is a ruse. * He likes to skirt the rules.
- gigaflop 5y agoSome things I like to ask myself when his name inevitably comes up: * Is he being stupid? * Is he promoting something? If so, for who's gain? * Is he lying? * Did he let the wrong thought out of his head and piss people off? Nobody in his position would be too thick-skulled to see that his biggest fans aren't the sharpest tools in the shed. Consider how he's treated his own employees, and ask if you think he's above poking and prodding his cult following to his own ends or entertainment.
- iepathos 5y agoOh look a social media platform with declining earnings and user base... buy stock just cause elon did? I think not.
- jnmandal 5y ago"If it happened there" AKA how the media would cover this happening in another country: > Powerful oligarch announces bid to gain control of influential media platform
- ChadNauseam 5y agoIt’s not my impression that the media calls every foreign billionaire an oligarch. i’ve never heard george soros described that way for example. oligarch has a connotation of being highly connected to the government, but the US government often seems actively hostile to Tesla
- Pxtl 5y ago> the US government often seems actively hostile to Tesla Literally every company he runs depends heavily on the government for funding. I'm not saying that as an attack - Tesla, SpaceX, and posibly Boring (too soon to tell) provide good products that should be supported by government. But with that context it's very hard to say that the US government is "hostile".
- id 5y agoGeorge Soros is not a foreign billionaire. He's a US citizen as has worked and lived in the US for most of his life.
- AbrahamParangi 5y agoThe more you know. I'd always heard that he was Hungarian, but not that he was Hungarian-American and lives in Katonah, New York. Pretty insane that he has a reputation on the right as a foreign meddler given those facts.
- ChadNauseam 5y agoHm. My dad is a US citizen, born in the US, but grew up in france before he came to live in the US and I think most people would consider him foreign. But I see your point.
- 5y ago
- kornhole 5y agoWhat could go wrong with the richest many in the world now owning an influencing stake in one of the main communication platforms in the world? He made his first billions on financial surveillance and then moved onto selling Iphones on wheels and satellite based surveillance technology. I will stay on HN and Mastodon.
- Heliosmaster 5y agoI'm not sure whether you're being sarcastic, seeing who owns HN...
- kornhole 5y agoGood point!
- awb 5y agoHN was designed to be independent of YC interests. And Paul G doesn’t seem to care to be involved in the moderation of HN. The rules were established at it’s inception and enforced by others. Musk seems far more reactionary to hot button issues. I don’t see him as a set & forget leader.
- Heliosmaster 5y agoI'm not arguing against anything you said, but op said something about > with the richest [...] owning an influencing stake Regardless of how HN was designed, and what Paul G cares or does not, I don't think this can truly change
- HWR_14 5y agoDoes Paul G own an influencing stake or does HN have some kind of legal rights to avoid his influence?
- mdoms 5y ago> HN was designed to be independent of YC interests. lol come on
- fleddr 5y agoThis study shows that 25% of Twitter users send 97% of all tweets: https://www.socialmediatoday.com/news/new-study-shows-that-25-of-twitter-users-produce-97-of-all-tweets/610146/ https://www.socialmediatoday.com/news/new-study-shows-that-2... And some 80% of that are retweets or replies, not original tweets. Most people do not use Twitter at all. When they do use it, it is mostly read-only. When it's not read-only, it's most retweeting stuff. You can't deny that Twitter has an outsized cultural influence, but the underlying reality is sobering. It's not a "speech" platform for the masses as no actual speech happens by the masses themselves. If the retweet button were to be removed, the platform would collapse. It's not surprising that the masses don't post. You can't express yourself on Twitter due to the character limit, so all you can do is witty superficial takes. Threading and replies are a disaster making a structured discussion impossible. These two things alone make the platform useless for most speech purposes. And let's not forget the sour atmosphere of extreme hostility, permanent outrage, bad faith discussions, smearing, doxxing, cancellations, the culture is terrible. Back on point, I think Twitter has a far bigger problem than a free speech problem. There is very little speech and it excessively rewards the most unreasonable speech.
- djrogers 5y ago> You can't express yourself on Twitter due to the character limit That's completely untrue - there are certain types of expression unsuited for twitter, but it's far from impossible to express oneself.
- madeofpalk 5y ago> This study shows that 25% of Twitter users send 97% of all tweets This is significantly higher than I expected, and I think Twitter would be proud of that.
- alophawen 5y agoAs also mentioned in the comment you reacted on, 80% of those 25% is retweets. You also need to consider how much of that is bots.
- andrew_ 5y agoI really, really hope this is a sign of big changes. Board takeover, C-Suite cleaned out, Coinbase company culture installed, open algorithms, open moderation, removal of company bias. That would be incredible.
- nly 5y agoI'm amazed there's so much fervor around this move, and guesswork with regard to Elons strategy. This guy throws billions of $ around for the lulz. He probably doesn't have one.
- newbamboo 5y agoThere is a great amount of envy that drives many people’s opinions of Elon. Sorry, but that’s how it appears to normal people who don’t care or spend much time worrying about musk or trying to “take him down.” Pretty cringe tbh.
- michelb 5y agoOr he suspected deplatforming of his account by the SEC was in the cards and this is a powermove.
- deephdave 5y agoHow Twitter Gamifies Communication by C. Thi Nguyen https://philpapers.org/go.pl?id=NGUHTG&aid=NGUHTGv1 https://philpapers.org/go.pl?id=NGUHTG&aid=NGUHTGv1
- mercy_dude 5y agoThis again goes to show what a kleptocratic symbol American media platforms have become, and serves as an argument against those who think private entities such as Twitter and Facebook should be outside the scope of first amendment and amended of section 230. Billionaires like Jeff Bezos, Elon Mask, Bill Gates, Pierre Omidyar hold a large share of manny media platforms, it is hard to imagine how the same organizations can serve as a check against the powerful which is supposed to be their jobs.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mancerayder 5y agoTwitter has an important use case for journalists, politicians, governments, announcements, etc. There should be some way to preserve neutrality and not have one side find a "terms and conditions" clause to remove the opponent's viewpoint, cheered by the supporters of the opposite. It's silly politics, in the most abstract use of the word. It's like corporate politics. It does seem like most of the hostility are in the replies to things. The one-liner quips, the arrogance, the condescending sarcasm, and the sometimes outright name-calling. It's amazing to watch how your fellow adults behave when there's no one physically in front of them.
- awb 5y ago> not have one side find a "terms and conditions" clause Those are the rules of using the platform. Not sure why enforcing the rules would be considered a bad thing. If you don’t like it, advocate for changing the rules. Seems far more inappropriate if Twitter were to selectively apply their T&C out of deference to some and not others.
- wand3r 5y ago> Seems far more inappropriate if Twitter were to selectively apply their T&C out of deference to some and not others. I think this is basically every groups contention with Twitter.
- awb 5y agoAnd every groups convention with judges and legal decisions. Interpreting language is inherently really, really difficult. It can always get better, but never be perfect.
- loceng 5y agoTwitter doesn't even follow their own rules though. I don't know whether it's purposeful or just that their moderators aren't competent, lacking critical thinking, and lacking oversight; I have seen tweets that were cause of account suspensions that clearly didn't fit under the reason given for the suspension. If no one in the hierarchy at Twitter cares about integrity of actually even following the rules, or isn't capable of making sure they're applied properly, then there will continue to be problems.
- ck2 5y agoImagine what he spent on "x.com" getting back from his founding paypal in 2017 I'm convinced over the years he is some kind of weird "man who fell to earth" trying to fund something weird. (now I need to go watch that movie again, the cool original version with Bowie)
- ls612 5y agoWell he has built his own personal space program so that is evidence in favor of your hypothesis ;)
- conradfr 5y agoMaybe The Babylon Bee will finally get their account unsuspended.
- RivieraKid 5y agoI find this very concerning. Elon Musk is someone who should have less, not more political and media power.
- jl6 5y agoIs 9.2% enough to dictate that Twitter relaxes some of its speech rules?
- tim333 5y agoFor those who don't follow him Musk has been polling his followers on the future for twitter: >Free speech is essential to a functioning democracy. Do you believe Twitter rigorously adheres to this principle? https://mobile.twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1507259709224632344 https://mobile.twitter.com/elonmusk/status/15072597092246323... >Given that Twitter serves as the de facto public town square, failing to adhere to free speech principles fundamentally undermines democracy. What should be done? https://mobile.twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1507777261654605828 https://mobile.twitter.com/elonmusk/status/15077772616546058... >Twitter algorithm should be open source? https://mobile.twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1507041396242407424 https://mobile.twitter.com/elonmusk/status/15070413962424074...
- ryzvonusef 5y agohttps://twitter.com/GerritD/status/1511035113890410496 https://twitter.com/GerritD/status/1511035113890410496 >Despite Elon saying his stake in Twitter will be "passive," he will actually wield huge power at the company now. Elliot Management managed to get two seats on the board, change the company's business priorities, and arguably push Dorsey out as CEO with just 4% >Twitter doesn't have the dual share structure that gives founders ultimate control, like other tech companies of its generation do, so this is real power. Elon could end up not caring or being too distracted to actually change the company, but if he wants to he can
- timcavel 5y ago[dead]
- GoodJokes 5y ago
- injb 5y agoElon Musk always said that he owned basically nothing other than the stock in his own companies. So was this the real reason for his recent TSLA sell off? He told everyone he was doing it to pay taxes. Which I'm sure he did. But I wonder now if that was a clever and expensive ruse to throw people off the scent!
- stjohnswarts 5y agoThis should be good. I can't believe the elonites priced it up 30% though lol. I will get my popcorn and enjoy the show.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- stereoradonc 5y agoThe responses here have divided the entire community on the basis of political divide and biases. It appears more Twitter like than Twitter itself :-)
- eddof13 5y agoIf Elon gets them to become an actual free speech platform and drop all right wing censorship, he will be my hero, and I will become a Tesla SpaceX shill for the rest of my days
- MichaelMoser123 5y agoLots of people have high hopes about this development. However, the funny thing about all this is how the center of power is somehow moving to big tech - meaning that the rich guys with the big yachts are kind of in charge of The Show. Does that remind anyone of those Russian oligarchs? I mean, i mean that there's some kind of pattern here: the oligarchs get to run the show, then there is some sort of crisis, the oligarchs pick some side kick from the province to fill in the vacancy of frigging dictator, however the dictator eventually manages to kick out all of the oligarchs... Happened in Germany, happened in Russia, will you get something like this in the States too? (the problem seems to be that ollies have a problem because they lack legitimacy, they therefore tend to delegate power to some dictator, who they think can be controlled on their part, however eventually this turns out to be a miscalculation)
- Ajay-p 5y agoMaybe this will lead to twitter employees leaving. I think a total change of management is needed, and if employees don't like it, then they should quit. Twitter is harming society by silencing speech.