12 ms·
One can blame Airbnb, Zillow or whoever else, but the truth is that speculation in real estate and vacation towns have both been a thing for a very long time. I
by paxys 5y ago
One can blame Airbnb, Zillow or whoever else, but the truth is that speculation in real estate and vacation towns have both been a thing for a very long time. If the population rises and we refuse to build more houses, the existing ones will get more expensive no matter what. The solution is out there in front of us but everyone prefers to dance around it.
- KETpXDDzR 5y agoIn addition to the rising need for housing vs the number of new ones is leaving homes vacant. E.g., allegedly about 10% of San Francisco's housing stock is vacant. As with stocks, investors don't buy them anymore because of dividends, but only to hope they rise in value. https://hostagenews.com/report-10-of-san-franciscos-housing-stock-is-just-sitting-vacant-and-empty/ https://hostagenews.com/report-10-of-san-franciscos-housing-...
- jliptzin 5y agoThere's even lower hanging fruit than that. I have a 6 bedroom house, but local regulations state that I am not allowed to live with more than 2 people unrelated to me. Plenty of parking, tons of people looking for housing, but legally I am forced to keep 3 bedrooms empty.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gnopgnip 5y agoMany of these laws are a family plus two unrelated people. There have been broad changes in how a family is defined in this context.
- adflux 5y agoGood point, never thought about that. Here in the Netherlands, it used to be "common" to house other people than your direct family for some time, e.g. during harvest season.
- paxys 5y agoAgreed. Heck I know several people who prefer to keep their condos/houses empty rather than rent them out at market rate because of 100% tenant friendly city and state laws. Someone can move in and refuse to pay rent, refuse to leave, use your house as a drug den, destroy your property and lots more, and you can do nothing about it. At that point the city is just incentivizing homeowners to contribute to the housing crisis.
- Teknoman117 5y ago> Someone can move in and refuse to pay rent, refuse to leave, use your house as a drug den, destroy your property and lots more, and you can do nothing about it. This is one of those things that really just confuses me. It's like no one could agree on happy medium between "landlord can eject you whenever they want for whatever reason" and "no one can make you leave, ever, for any reason". And to whoever downvoted you, there are some places in the bay that are demanding 6 months rent up front in order to move in because they can't do much if you stop paying rent.
- TimPC 5y agoThese laws are hard to get actually correct. The major problem is court delays. There is a very high bar for kicking someone out before they get their day in court about whether it is fair to do so. This seems eminently reasonable but there is also a severe shortage of judicial services that result in court dates over a year out to resolve such issues. In that year of time, it's quite possible for a tenant with maybe $5K to their name to accumulate $500K in damages and debts. For many such tenants it is a cost they could never repay in their lifetimes which means even if the landlord gets the desired verdict they'll never see the capital they wanted. I agree there are places in the world that are so biased against landlords that they don't even try to get this problem correct but I think for many cases the problem isn't bad laws but rather the delays to being able to execute reasonable actions to limit damages. I'm not sure what a good solution is for many cases because I think it would take fairly extreme evidence to kick someone out without their day in court if they decided to fight it. I do agree with landlords it should be easier to kick someone out if they stop paying rent and that fact is adequately documented. I mean stop paying rent in the sense of an appropriate pattern not a single late payment.
- aksss 5y agoI wonder if you could find exemptions for refugees. Seem to be a lot of those lately. Not ignoring the sad irony of this, but if you want to put that space to use there may some allowable loopholes.
- pge 5y agoI am working through this right now with a house that I recently bought. No way around the restrictions, but we did find one loophole. Two related families (eg two families in which the respective fathers are brothers) can live in the same house, at least under the way the restrictions are written where I live. We are able to house two refugee families in the same house legally as a result, but it's a shame that it is not easier to do, and possible with two unrelated families.
- KptMarchewa 5y ago>local regulations state that I am not allowed to live with more than 2 people unrelated to me What? Where is that? It sounds insane and extreme overreach. How can somebody regulate with whom consenting adults choose to live?
- londons_explore 5y agoRegulations like this are common. Usually you need to get a special license, have home inspections annually, pay various fees, etc. if you want to do so.
- KptMarchewa 5y agoRegulations where you'd specify minimum floor size, or rooms per person make sense for me. It's about straight up saying you can't live with people without state sanctioning the relationship.
- londons_explore 5y agoIn my region, the rules are so incredibly precise. Things like washing up areas must have at least 3 bowels in. Toilets must have flush handles above a certain height and below another height. Radiators must have 6 heat settings... Etc. The entire aim seems to be to make running such a house not illegal, but very difficult and very expensive.
- HWR_14 5y agoPrecise laws are usually because enumerating every single bad alternative is an issue, so they just tell you what is permissible. Besides, such specificity is usually drawn from building code best practices, which advocate for standardization. Which means that manufacturers don't bother creating radiators with less than six heat settings.
- dave5104 5y agoOccupancy limits are somewhat common in many cities/towns. But probably only enforced via neighborly complaint, so you don't really hear about them. Just searching "occupancy limits city" popped up the limits for Boulder, CO: https://bouldercolorado.gov/occupancy-limits https://bouldercolorado.gov/occupancy-limits
- dopamean 5y agoIs this in the US? I've never heard of this before and am curious to learn more. It sounds like something that is nearly unenforceable.
- zo1 5y agoIt doesn't have to be enforceable. But as soon as you do this, any potential hiccup like having to evict tenants or go to court for anything minor, and the state/police find out about your little "unenforceable" violation.
- notch656a 5y agoPeople on AirBnB generally are not 'tenants' and kicking them out is as easy as trespassing them, optionally with a Sheriff if they refuse to leave. You're reading way to much into Sheriff Bill worrying about what's happening. The AirBnB side is typically a civil matter.
- LegitShady 5y agoThats because your neighbours probably won’t like you opening a rooming house in their residential neighborhood without some kind of consultation with them on the zoning and appropriateness of such a thing. I’ve seen houses where every room (including the living room) is occupied by a foreign student and the ‘landlord’ is running a slum rooming house. Thats what you’re not supposed to be able to do without getting approval. It impacts you negatively to avoid impacting your neighbours without consulting with them.
- tonyarkles 5y agoAs a curiosity, since you're probably better versed in this than I am, does the situation change if you yourself didn't live there? I'm pretty sure around here (300kperson city in Canada), the rules are different if one of the roommates is the owner or if it's a purely rental property... which seemed even more confusing!
- devoutsalsa 5y agoHouse Hacking, Extreme Edition: legally adopting your roommates.
- delusional 5y agoWhy do you have a 6 bedroom house if you only need 3 bedrooms? It sounds like you're annoyed that you can't turn a profit on your 3 bedrooms and the housing problem is really a tangential concern.
- danans 5y agoWhat a terrible policy. Do you mind sharing where this is?
- knodi123 5y ago> legally I am forced to keep 3 bedrooms empty. Not at all! Look into what it would take to lease them out to a self-storage facility. :-P
- MattSayar 5y agoBut what does enforcement look like?
- Peanuts99 5y agoAs someone not from America, this seems insane to me. Who's stopping you from renting not living with people you aren't related to and why the hell are they allowed to tell you what to do with your own bedrooms? Equally, is 6 bedrooms normal? Sounds like a lot of cleaning.
- RC_ITR 5y agoExactly. Formerly the 'unseen' behavior was seasonal renting brokered through agents or high-end advertising. This still kept locals out of the house, but 1) it was harder for normal people to become aware of the listings in the first place 2) One renter who comes every weekend for an entire season 'feels' more like a local. Now what we have is listings that are easily found via google and a much broader set of visitors whose faces change every week. Our limited brains interpret that as a much bigger shift than it may actually be.
- bitlax 5y agoWell, there are two solutions.
- moffkalast 5y agoTrue, we could lower the population back down by exiling real estate agents.
- JaimeThompson 5y agoA town close to me has lots of land to build new homes, few restrictions, fast fiber Internet and prices are still going up way faster than before which seems to indicate multiple things are causing this.
- tshaddox 5y ago> If the population rises and we refuse to build more houses Building more houses is generally good too, but it's a bit of a cop-out to blame the whole situation on that. Totally independent of supply concerns, I would argue that it's not great that in so many areas the value of homes seems to be almost entirely divorced from the fact that people need homes to live in. Imagine if a bunch of very wealthy people just decided to start collecting medicine, not to use as medicine, but to just collect and perhaps sell later at a higher price. Is that within their legal rights? Sure, it seems like it. Would producing more medicine be a good thing? Yeah, sure, more medicine is probably generally a good thing. But is it still really crappy that people's habits for collecting medicine are driving up the cost of medicine for people who want to take the darn medicine? Yeah, it's crappy.
- taurath 5y agoWe need to make primary residences extremely more advantageous tax-wise, and punish investment properties.
- darkerside 5y agoThis happens all the time every day. Those rich people are pharmacies like CVS and Walgreens. They buy the medicine, stock it in smaller doses at an elevated price. It's really not that different from investors buying a property and offering it for short term rental so that people can enjoy it in small doses.
- deepakhj 5y agoUS housing inventory is 860k which is at historic lows compared to 1.5m pre-pandemic. It's a housing supply issue. Salt Lake City and Missoula are up 45% YOY with inventories down 40-50%.
- gregable 5y agoYes, and this would really be awful in the short term, but in the medium term medicine companies would just spin up more production until the "very wealthy people" demand has been met and medicine becomes available again at some reasonable price. The fact that this is very likely prevents most of the speculation in the first place. The difference with real estate is that the owners get to determine production levels, via local zoning laws. Sure, there is some natural scarcity: Land cannot be created, but in most cases artificial scarcity is the issue.
- thelock85 5y agoThat speculation is being scaled/super-charged through technology, and making the proposed solution to build more harder, in part because an increase in corporate landlording dilutes the political power of regular homeowners. I'm really trying to think of reasons why a PE market maker that just bought a sub-division would want to build more and depress their future rents (unless the area has massive population growth).
- wpietri 5y agoAgreed, but there are big structural barriers. We generally want necessary goods to have stable or decreasing prices over time. But in America, we encourage home ownership as an investment. For many, their biggest investment. That creates a big constituency who want housing prices to go up. But we also want people, especially those just starting out, to have affordable housing. We can't have housing be both affordable and a good long-term investment. We need to pick. And given increasing prices and how 65% of Americans are howmeowners, I think we already did.
- hyperbovine 5y ago> The solution is out there in front of us but everyone prefers to dance around it. Could not agree more, just so we're all on the same page it is: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_population_planning https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_population_planning Oh, sorry, were you referring to something else? :-)
- c-linkage 5y agoChange the word "house" to "car" and I think the problem becomes not-so obvious. It's often bemoaned that personal cars are a waste of money and space: they sit idle most of the time, we have to build parking lots to accommodate them and that takes space. It would be so much better if we could just hire cars on demand! But this doesn't scale because the demand is not spread out during the day -- absent carpooling, you still need one car per person twice a day, meaning the supposed savings don't exist. The same could be said for housing. If I'm at work all day, then my house is sitting idle (it's not housing anyone) and it takes up space. Why not let someone live in my house while I'm at work? This also doesn't scale but for a different reason: we all work during the day (excluding night-shift workers) so at night we still need one house per person (ignoring families, stretching the metaphor a bit). Now add "vacation homes" into the mix, now you're looking at ~20% of housing (calculated from empirical analysis) in any vacation hot-spots being rental properties. This means that 20% of the existing housing that could be available for permanent residents is missing. Saying "just build more housing" is just not realistic. 20% more housing is a ludicrous amount of housing! Hotels, on the whole, are much more economical in space utilization because people who are going on vacation do not vacation to _visit a home_. They go to do things in the place they are visiting and are thus _not at home_.
- iso1631 5y ago> But this doesn't scale because the demand is not spread out during the day -- absent carpooling, you still need one car per person twice a day, meaning the supposed savings don't exist. Very rare for my neighbour to be using her car at the same time I use my car. Not every car driver commutes 5 days a week 9-5. I work from home, have done for years, my neighbour is retired. I guarantee in my village there will be at least 10 unused cars at any point during the year, probably nearer 50. There certainly aren't that many empty houses
- jacobr1 5y agoWe take two types of vacations: 1) foreign travel where we are constantly on the go visiting new places and 2) home rentals with extended family. For the second category usually it is the beach, but sometimes in the mountains or other area. We tend to get 10-15 members of our extended family and friends and the activities often include making food communally, playing games, moving between the house and walking distance activity like the shore, even napping. The house very much gets used and isn't just a place to sleep.
- rednerrus 5y agoWe lost four years of housing growth because of the recession.
- ar_lan 5y agoNIMBYs are a special breed of evil
- adam_arthur 5y agoNumber of housing units to households is the same as year 2000. 1.1:1 So the undersupply story is a myth. There has been a recent pull forward in demand that ate through all active listings though.
- deepakhj 5y agoUS housing inventory just hit historic lows of 860k. It was 1.5m pre-pandemic. https://twitter.com/LoganMohtashami/status/1503120536909803520?s=20&t=fH8PccF4zgryGXQ9Nc4Rqg https://twitter.com/LoganMohtashami/status/15031205369098035...
- adam_arthur 5y agoThis inventory metric is simply active listings. It has nothing to do with structural housing supply. It also doesn't include houses that are listed and sold within the same month If 1m people decided to sell tomorrow, suddenly inventory would be normal. At the end of the day what matters is how many housing units are there and how many households. To say there's a shortage is simply wrong, given that the ratio is well in line with historical norms. The number of active listings is low because a surge of demand due to low interest rates and then later FOMO ate through active inventory. If rates hit 5% within the month, you'll be surprised how quickly inventory returns to normal. Way too much statistics crimes when talking about housing
- deepakhj 5y agoOk, I'll revisit this thread when rates are 5% and inventory jumps back to 1.5m.
- adam_arthur 5y agoGreat! Should only be a few months. I use logic and accurate interpretation of the data in my assessment, all these counter arguments use statistic butchering and hopium. Yet people cling to the narrative for whatever reason. Bias is a hell of a drug. If inflation persists at 4-5% we will see 6% mortgages within the year. Many are blinded by the last decade of low inflation. If inflation suddenly dissipates, due to a shock etc, then housing prices can preserve at these levels.
- sudosysgen 5y agoPrices have increased tremendously even in cities with stagnant population. It's not just pure supply and demand - real estate has a tendency to occupy enough of income in a given area so that the lower paid cannot afford it.
- somewhereoutth 5y agoThe problem is that interest rates are too low. 5% interest rates would fix house prices (and other capital mis-allocation). The reason why lots of boomers are sitting on large amounts of housing equity is that they bought before the transition to low rates. The reverse will also hold - anyone buying now before the transition to higher rates will get clobbered (in terms of loan to equity - probably they'll be ok repayment wise so long as they have a fixed mortgage)
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 5y ago> One can blame Airbnb, but > speculation in ... vacation towns [has] been a thing for a very long time. > the existing [houses] will get more expensive no matter what. In vacation towns, the issue is that tourists are flooding out of hotels, and into livable dwellings. Our hotel vacancy rates are rising just as fast as our home prices. Perhaps the solution is tearing down hotels and building high-rise apartments in their stead, but it seems a bit wasteful compared to the alternative (regulating and taxing Airbnbs to nudge tourists back into the hotels designed for them).
- margalabargala 5y agoOn some level, this is hotels failing to compete. If I look up both airbnbs and hotels in a popular vacation town (randomly using Big Sky, MT, april 18-20, for this example) then I see hotels and airbnbs in similar locations, and at similar price points. However, there are airbnbs cheaper than the cheapest hotels, and they have a number of amenities that no hotels offer- notably, a washer/dryer in-unit, a full kitchen, and multiple actual rooms. Given the same nightly price, who would choose a minimal pared-down hotel room over an entire furnished condominium?
- MrMan 5y agowhere I live all they do is build houses. this idea that we arent building houses mystifies me.
- knodi123 5y ago> The solution is out there in front of us but everyone prefers to dance around it. Jesus, man, slow down. It's a little early to start suggesting cannibalism as a solution to the housing crisis.
- jfoster 5y agoThe problem is adversarial. If real estate were more affordable, what of those who have invested in it?
- tunap 5y ago"...the truth is that speculation in real estate and vacation towns have both been a thing for a very long time." Eh, in the US, it was limited by the Glass-Steagal protections enacted after the speculators ruined the world economy almost 100 years ago. We can thank the 'Modernisation Acts' of 1999/2000 and QE for the economic rollercoaster in the US(so goes the world?) for the last 20 years in housing, energy & metals. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glass_Steagal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glass_Steagal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gramm%E2%80%93Leach%E2%80%93Bliley_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gramm%E2%80%93Leach%E2%80%93Bl... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commodity_Futures_Modernization_Act_of_2000 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commodity_Futures_Modernizatio...
- karlkatzke 5y agoWhat’s funny is how much property values and rent have risen in the US in 2020 to 2022, when population growth has been flat due to Covid. (Population has increased 1 million in that time, from 331.5 million to 332.5 million.) obviously, newborns aren’t buying houses, but the excess deaths (not to mention early retirements requiring around the clock care) were entirely due to Covid and should have opened up a number of properties for first time homebuyers.
- qiskit 5y ago> If the population rises and we refuse to build more houses, the existing ones will get more expensive no matter what. Mix in low interest rates and you get a major property bubble. Population growth and low interest rates are the two major predictors of housing price increases.
- voidfunc 5y agoNobody is dancing around anything. We need to stop pretending its ignorance driving the housing bubble. The problem is real estate is treated as an investment and in many cases the most important investment for ordinary people. More housing works against their interests.
- esalman 5y agoIs the claim that not enough houses are being built or have been built backed up by data? Real estate investors don't seem to have much problem finding homes to turn into rentals.
- AlwaysRock 5y agoSure building more houses help but many houses sit empty. There are other problems.
- daniel-cussen 5y agoAnd commensurately there's a tight relationship between the percentage of income spent on rent (often cited as a third, it used to be less than half that), and the percentage of people on the street.