19 ms·
Tesla fired an employee after he posted driverless tech reviews on YouTube
- mlindner 5y agoI'm not sure why people are surprised why someone would be fired for making their employer look bad? If you publicly badmouth your employer you can get fired for it if they want to. This is not something abnormal.
- jazzyjackson 5y agoits not shittalk tho, its a bit closer to whistleblowing, seeing as the marketing paints a different picture you should keep your critics close, they are the only ones who care about you enough to tell the truth
- alphabetting 5y agoHis videos were amazing for following FSD. Most sources on Youtube seem very biased in talking up current capability. Pretty shitty to fire him and disable FSD on his car when he made it clear to higher ups he was operating the channel. I can't imagine he gets fired if he put up videos like some do with over the top headlines like FSD SAVED MY LIFE or other hype channels.
- dawnerd 5y agoHe was the guy that let the car drive into the pole. That completely goes against what everyone agrees to when joining FSD, and probably what employees agree to. Fact that he even posted and and tried to capitalize on it really shows... https://electrek.co/2022/02/04/tesla-full-self-driving-beta-crash-video/ https://electrek.co/2022/02/04/tesla-full-self-driving-beta-...
- jjulius 5y agoYou're not wrong, but as someone who is forced to share the road with FSD Teslas, I'm happy that he was willing to show what one is capable of doing without proper interference.
- zionic 5y agoWell we all share the air with aircraft. How would you feel about a pilot “demonstrating” controlled flight into terrain on autopilot? I assure you my Lear’s autopilot would do it.
- jjulius 5y agoWith nary a civilian or other airplane within impact distance, like in the video? Sure, let's do it!
- stjohnswarts 5y agoMost of us don't have Lears to test that hypothesis out.
- AniseAbyss 5y agoAviation is severely regulated. After decades of horrendous accidents... Self driving is new and it is painfully obvious the government hasn't figured out how to deal with it yet.
- juanani 5y ago
- HWR_14 5y agoWhen the risk of an airplane crashing into my car/my bike/me as a pedestrian is 1/1,000,000 as likely as a car collision, we can talk. Meanwhile, if you want to splat into the edge of a mountain, I really have no feelings about it. Or did you mean you would use your Lear's autopilot to try to do some extremely low level flying over a highway?
- 5y ago
- alphabetting 5y agoPosting unbiased full length videos of FSD was much more informative than self-censoring for Tesla, or "capitalizing" as you call it. The fact they removed his access to FSD makes it likely the few with access to FSD will feel the need to self-censor issues in the future.
- dawnerd 5y agoHe broke the terms of the FSD program. That should, for the safety of everyone on the road, lead to revocation. I'm part of FSD, I don't self-censor. It's terrible right now. I'm more worried about youtubers letting the car make mistakes just for the views. And honestly it's not safe for people to be trying to talk while paying attention to a car that constantly does dumb things.
- alphabetting 5y agoI just don't see how you could follow his channel and watch that video and come to conclusion he let that happen for youtube views.
- metadat 5y agoI've seen plenty of FSD Tesla abuse IRL with my own eyes. Infinitely more dangerous than what this guy did. Is there a way to report these truly egregiously dangerous license terms offenders to Tesla via license plate along with my dashcam footage?
- ggreer 5y agoA lot of people in this thread are mixing up the FSD option (that you buy for your car) with the invite-only FSD beta. Currently the non-beta FSD will drive itself on limited access roads (basically taking you from onramp to offramp, changing lanes, taking interchanges, etc), but it's basically cruise control on surface streets. The FSD beta will self-drive pretty much anywhere (even parking lots) but it has only rolled out to a few percent of Teslas. Both versions use cameras inside the car to monitor the driver's attention. If you blind the internal camera, the car will refuse to engage autopilot or FSD beta. If you're seeing "egregiously dangerous" behavior, you should call the police. The dash cam should be more than enough evidence to get the reckless driver charged.
- im3w1l 5y ago"Let it hit" is pretty deceptive wording. You can see in the video it was not an intentional decision on his part. He trusted the car in a low-risk situation, where the only repercusion was small cosmetic damage. Perfect to see what the car can and cannot do in a responsible way. To me it does not reflect the least bit poorly on him. I do find it weird that an employee ongoingly posts critical reviews though. I can understand why Tesla do not want that.
- hackernewds 5y agoSo much discussion here but no one has posted the referenced YouTube channel. Anyone have it? Not sure where to find it
- alphabetting 5y agohttps://www.youtube.com/c/AIAddict/videos https://www.youtube.com/c/AIAddict/videos
- im3w1l 5y agoThe video was embedded in the article he linked, but for maximum convinience the direct link is https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sbSDsbDQjSU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sbSDsbDQjSU and the time of the collision is 3:30.
- camjohnson26 5y agoThis was considered the first confirmed crash on FSD beta. Unfortunately his firing is going to encourage other beta testers to only show positive clips. We’ve already seen other testers try to hide near misses and failures. Here the testers suggest cutting out a clip where FSD beta lunges toward a bicyclist: https://mobile.twitter.com/omedyentral/status/1491146820097298433 https://mobile.twitter.com/omedyentral/status/14911468200972... That same tester (Galileo Russel) nearly had beta access revoked after posting an earlier video where the beta crowded a pedestrian. He issued a DMCA takedown to try to stop the spread of the clip. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28566376 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28566376 Whatever you think of the beta (I think it’s blatantly irresponsible), Tesla should not be pressuring the testers to only share the good clips. That will lead to overestimation of the system’s capabilities and deaths in the long run, like what we’ve already seen from autopilot.
- mlindner 5y ago
- Sebb767 5y agoNeither does posting clips of how great the system is. If they didn't want any publicity, they could simply put the system under NDA. The way it is right now, they want to have their cake and eat it too.
- mlindner 5y agoIt used to be under NDA and people attacked Tesla for doing it so Musk decided to release people from being under NDA. Not being under a legally enforceable NDA doesn't mean Tesla can't pick and choose to remove people from the program for literally any reason they like. IMO they should put everyone under NDAs. Damned if you do, damned if you don't here. People just want to attack things.
- AlexandrB 5y agoYes. It's too much to ask for a billionaire to spend some more time/money testing his shit before he unleashes it on the world. Poor him.
- hackernewds 5y agoThat video did not remotely seem like he intentionally crashed it like others are speculating. They even braked the car, which the TSLA didn't respect. Not to mention, it ran a rolling right turn on a red light. FSD is definitely not ready for mass market, although TSLA seems to be willing to make the bets necessary to make that happen, the only way it can.
- oh_sigh 5y agoWhat do you mean "let"? It looks like he took control within less than a second after it was clear the car was turning too much.
- itsoktocry 5y ago>He was the guy that let the car drive into the pole. He "let" it, did he? >That completely goes against what everyone agrees to when joining FSD, and probably what employees agree to. This makes no sense. >Fact that he even posted and and tried to capitalize on it really shows... Someone posting "reality" has an agenda, whereas all of the people posting nothing but (highly edited) successes of FSD have zero agenda.
- Animats 5y agoDisabling FSD in retaliation for a review is probably illegal, under the Consumer Review Fairness Act.[1][2][3] [1] https://www.congress.gov/114/bills/hr5111/BILLS-114hr5111enr.pdf https://www.congress.gov/114/bills/hr5111/BILLS-114hr5111enr... [2] https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/consumer-review-fairness-act-what-businesses-need-know https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/consumer-rev... [3] https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2019/06/ftc-announces-two-actions-enforcing-consumer-review-fairness-act https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2019/06/...
- theturtletalks 5y agoWhat's a law with no teeth? These sort of things never lead to charges and in the rare cases they do, it's a drop in the bucket for the company.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- superfrank 5y agoI have no horse in this race, but they only cut off access to the FSD Beta. He still has access to normal FSD. I'm not a lawyer, but since it's a closed, invite only program, my guess would be that makes things a little less black and white.
- alphabettsy 5y agoWhat is normal FSD because afaik that’s just regular Autopilot.
- jazzyjackson 5y agoSmart summon and auto-lane change according to: https://www.tesla.com/support/autopilot https://www.tesla.com/support/autopilot So yeah the money is 95% a kickstarter pre-order for features that may be delayed beyond the useful life of the car
- clouddrover 5y agoMusk busily promulgates lies about Tesla's "full self-driving" and gets rewarded. Bernal demonstrates the practical reality of it and gets penalized.
- _carbyau_ 5y agoHe who has the gold, makes the rules.
- adfgadfgaery 5y agoLet's not try to paint him as a hero. He continued working at Tesla despite knowing the fraud they were perpetrating. He endangered everyone around him by operating the "Full Self Driving" "Beta" on public roads despite knowing it didn't work. He's a conspirator, not a whistleblower.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- twblalock 5y agoPutting yourself in a situation in which the public might assume you are speaking on behalf of your employer is unwise, unless speaking for your employer is your actual job. And even if it is actually your job, it's just common sense that you shouldn't publish content that makes your employer look bad. It doesn't matter if you have "permission" or your managers are "aware of it." Permission can be revoked. Managers can change their minds or be overruled. This is just how the world works. Maybe it's not how things should work, but it's reality. This guy learned that lesson the hard way.
- rodgerd 5y ago> And even if it is actually your job, it's just common sense that you shouldn't publish content that makes your employer look bad. Given the output of the CEO of Tesla I feel like this would be a pretty amusing argument to make. "Do I make Tesla look worse than Elon does on a regular basis?"
- belval 5y agoIf Elon had a superior he would be fired over those tweets for sure, but the rules are different when you *own* the company.
- adfgadfgaery 5y agoThe company is public. It has no single owner. Musk is supposed to answer to the shareholders, but he's defrauded them on many occasions and the SEC doesn't seem to care.
- jazzyjackson 5y agosomething of a stockholm syndrome isnt it, they are free to leave but they make too much money, and actually ousting the chief meme officer, I assume would crash the stock, perhaps only temporarily
- tomrod 5y ago
- gnkLd 5y agoI thought Musk is constantly railing for free speech on Twitter (he inserts himself into any major event, trucker protests, Ukraine). Awaiting his commentary.
- jaimex2 5y agoThere's no takedown request on the videos. You just can't be an employee that violates your NDA by giving insider scoops.
- alphabetting 5y agoTesla was aware of the youtube channel and Tesla made a big deal about dropping NDAs on FSD last year.
- clouddrover 5y agoThere were no insider scoops. He demonstrated the product he purchased.
- filoleg 5y agoHe didn't purchase FSD Beta, because it isn't for sale. Current FSD is for sale, and you will receive FSD Beta update when it gets out of beta. The only way to currently get FSD Beta is get selected (after applying) into the beta tester group for it. If you want to record videos or reviews of yourself driving current FSD (that's for sale), you are more than welcome to, no one will stop you, and you aren't breaking any rules. FSD Beta is literally a beta tester program. And selective small-audience beta tests for all kinds of products typically carry extra restrictions in terms of what you can publicly reveal as a participant.
- clouddrover 5y agoTesla doesn't have a full self-driving product to sell. Tesla's been lying about it for nine years now: https://www.tesla.com/blog/all-tesla-cars-being-produced-now-have-full-self-driving-hardware https://www.tesla.com/blog/all-tesla-cars-being-produced-now... https://jalopnik.com/elon-musk-promises-full-self-driving-next-year-for-th-1848432496 https://jalopnik.com/elon-musk-promises-full-self-driving-ne... Bernal demonstrated the product he purchased.
- fjklap 5y ago"Following Bernal’s dismissal, Tesla also cut off his access to the FSD Beta system in the vehicle he personally owns, a 2021 Tesla Model 3, despite having no safety “strikes” in the software." This shows that you don't own a Tesla, it owns you. What was Musk saying again about the freezing of the bank accounts of the Canadian truckers?
- hackernewds 5y agoIf they _really_ despised him, imagine they could crash his car off a cliff as well? This is our self-driving future.
- mlindner 5y agoTesla has no remote ability to control the vehicle.
- macintux 5y agoI don't know how we'd ever know that's true; at the very least, the capability would seem to be inherent in the system.
- revnode 5y agoThey have remote root access to the vehicle. Even if they didn’t, they can push an update specific to your vehicle that then drives you off a cliff at a designated time.
- kappattack 5y agoSounds like he broke some kinda of NDA which he probably signed himself, resulting in removal from the beta program and being let go from his position. That kinda sucks, because it seems his content did have a positive spin to it and it doesnt seem like he meant to hurt anyone or the company. I don't see whats wrong with the action taken though. He probably agreed to these terms and then he broke them. Whether he was aware that he was going against his own agreement or not is out of the question. I don't like Tesla as a company or a car manufacturer (nothing personal, I just wouldnt buy their cars) and I agree that this response was probably to be expected by anyone who was aware of the terms surrounding their employment and the internal beta access that position grants them.
- mlindner 5y agoYes that's precisely what seems to have happened. A lot of people here have irrational hatred toward Musk and/or Tesla though.
- AniseAbyss 5y agoPerhaps. I also see the reverse: the man is practically worshipped as a god for nerds.
- mardifoufs 5y ago[dead]
- sofixa 5y agoAnd on one hand, his shit quality far right memes are pushing some people off his bandwagon, but I fear for the rest.
- benatkin 5y agoI have to share the road with people in the FSD beta program, and I never signed an NDA for the FSD beta program, so I think I should be able to hear people recount their driving experiences on public roads with me.
- kube-system 5y agoPublicly and knowingly making your employer look bad will get you fired just about anywhere.
- alphabettsy 5y agoThis, and I certainly have my issues with FSD and the way it’s marketed and sold.
- jazzyjackson 5y agoor perhaps his thinking is that his tesla stock will be worthless if FSD sees wide release before its ready; better to keep their feet to the public fire and push them to improve the product, doing it out of love, not malice
- kube-system 5y agoI didn’t say malicious, I said knowingly. i.e. someone misspeaking might be forgivable. This person knew what they were publishing. I don’t suspect they were malicious, they were just reckless and had no respect for their role in the workplace. I definitely don’t think that personal gain is a good excuse for undermining your coworkers.
- stjohnswarts 5y agoI'm sure he broke several contractual obligations by doing that. I mean I wish he could do stuff like that, but when you sign a contract you sign a contract.
- gzer0 5y agoA lot of comments here seem to miss how exactly Tesla FSD works. First, it is important to understand that there is FSD and then there is FSD beta. For our purposes, these two are distinct. - To be able to use FSD, you must purchase it for $12,000 USD. - To be able to use FSD beta you must have FSD AND either 1) have a high enough driver score after which Tesla might invite you to join the FSD Beta or 2) receive access to the FSD beta whilst you are an employee FSD Beta has extremely strict prerequisites. Some of these conditions include traveling 100 miles or more in a 30-day period, having a computed driver score that must be in the top percentiles of driver safety, and additionally, Tesla must actively be pursuing a fresh batch of FSD Beta invitees. In anycase, after the entire Otto / Uber lawsuit(s) + one of the engineers supposedly uploading source code files to their iCloud account, Tesla Autopilot really hardened the NDAs around the department. I don't think they were in the wrong.
- ecf 5y ago> driver score _shudders_
- randcraw 5y ago“AI Addict”. Cool. That sounds like a vlog I should enjoy. But I'd never have heard of him or the latest problems with Autopilot if the company hadn't overreacted and made him famous. Thanks for the heads up, Tesla!
- nunez 5y ago> When the company fired Bernal late last month, his written separation notice did not include the reason for his firing. It came after one of his videos depicted a drive in San Jose where his car knocked over bollards while FSD Beta was engaged. This is particularly troubling and concerning. I didn't know that the car was an employee car. Given the timeline presented here, it seemed that he was fired for showing a failure mode for FSD Beta that people absolutely needed to see. (I'm also in the program.)
- pipeline_peak 5y ago“The video shows a driverless Tesla being launched out of the mythical Boring tunnel before crashing into a telephone pole.”
- buro9 5y agoReviews in question: Incident: https://youtu.be/sbSDsbDQjSU?t=204 https://youtu.be/sbSDsbDQjSU?t=204 Review of it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zl9rM8D3k34 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zl9rM8D3k34
- josefresco 5y ago"free speech absolutist." What a joke. Typical narcissist behavior. Rules for thee but not for me.
- 0F 5y agoIt’s crazy how to truth can hide in plain site. This guys channel had raw footage of FSD driving through terrain deliberately chosen to be difficult and FSD absolutely shined. Just flicking through the channel it’s immediately apparent that FSD is the most advanced self driving system by a mile. But sometimes it made mistakes. And literally any time I have ever seen a video of FSD float to the top of a link aggregator site, it’s a video of one of the mistakes. If you didn’t deliberately look through the archives yourself, you might not ever know that FSD does anything besides make mistakes.
- jacquesm 5y agoThat's pretty logical: 99.9% of self driving is easy. That last .1% is very, very hard.
- jtwaleson 5y agoYou have a weird definition of easy :D But I agree with the 0.1%.
- tylermac1 5y agoThe reason the failure videos float to the top is because failure in self-driving can result in serious bodily harm for those that have little to no control of whether they’re participating in a review or test.
- MayeulC 5y agoMake that simply driving. Human do not necessarily make the same mistakes as computer vision and deep learning systems, but they make mistakes too.
- simion314 5y agoI seen many fanboy made videos where shit just works, sometimes the fanboys live stream and the mistakes can't be hidden. When we get full data transparency( where full here mean 100% and not the fake "full" from the Tesla dictionary) just want to know if Tesla's PR stats include the mistakes too when they calculate safety , what I mean is if each time a human had to intervene is counted as a crash , and how corners or roads where the user has no choice then take over are also counted. Is like F in FSD seems to be mathematically { F, the subset of everything where our shit worked(we intentionally exclude stuff and have our fanboys defend them as micro mistakes or blame the roads, or blame the driver or blame anyone else/ in our dictionary FSD and autopilot means whatever we want to mean and yes the naming is very clever to be super missleading because $$$ ) }
- tedivm 5y agoAmazing how much Musk advocates for free speech for himself (he's super salty over the SEC wanting his tweets to be reviewed, due to his breaking the law previously) but will do anything he can to stifle free speech for others.
- jimmygrapes 5y agoI really doubt he is the one who fired the person. He could however reinstate them, if there's valid reason to.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hayd 5y agofree speech is freedom from persecution from the government, not from your employer.
- Dma54rhs 5y agoFree speech doesn't mean no consequences.
- Jxl180 5y agoTesla has about 100,000 employees yet people seem to operate under the absurd assumption that Elon is in every meeting, in every scrum, and sits in a cubicle managing the HR department. This is most definitely the decision of legal and HR and there’s an excellent chance Elon Musk knows nothing about it. I can be fired at my 10k employee company after 20 years of service and the CEO will never know of my existence.
- nobodyandproud 5y agoPost a criticism on a website like Arstechnica, and you will be downvoted to oblivion. The lack of transparency across the board means it’s going to take many disasters and lives lost to fix any on-going issues.
- whoomp12342 5y agowelcome to the new age, the dark age of the internet where freedom of speech is not
- Jxl180 5y agoYou don’t have free speech when it comes to your employment. If I made videos representative of my company or its tools when I don’t have the authority to publicly represent my company, I’d be shit canned too. That’s normal policy at corporations. Only specific roles are usually allowed to speak on behalf of the company and its products.
- whoomp12342 5y agoheaven forbid someone says the truth. Gotta keep up perceptions.
- mctt 5y agoFrom his latest Video 19 hours ago. (Wed 16 Mar 2022 1836hrs GMT) Tesla FSD Beta San Jose Stress Test https://youtu.be/ByKE6RZjYes https://youtu.be/ByKE6RZjYes "Hey guys it's AI Addict. If you're new here welcome, if you're a veteran it's good to see you. Today I'm testing FSD Beta in downtown San Jose for another stress test review. Some of you may know I worked for Tesla helping develop FSD and I test operated their software. Big update there, I was fired from Tesla in February with my YouTube being cited as the reason. Why? Even though my uploads are from my personal vehicle off company time or property, with software I paid for. The morning of being fired I had zero improper use strikes in my vehicle. Shortly after being fired my system was suspended. This channel is meant to educate the public by showing honest reviews from experts with industry knowledge. I care about finding important safety bugs and I still want to help, — Luckily this is silicon valley where there is plenty of beta to go around so today I'm in a new tesla." Auto-generated caption extracted with formatting added by me.