41 ms·
Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment systems in Netherlands
- formvoltron 5y agoWhy would the Dutch allow this?
- TheRealPomax 5y agoI like how they're literally explaining that the actual cost for app payment processing caps out at 3%, and everything they charge on top is just pure profit margin. Nice one Apple.
- sylware 5y agoWhat's funny, asml is from over there, and without them, no apple anymore.
- jacquesm 5y agoThey're nuts. All they are doing is setting themselves up for another set of lawsuits. Seriously: Apple should focus on selling hardware and be happy to facilitate those payments that people - and application developers - voluntarily process through their system. All this stupid taxation of other peoples' businesses should stop, it is anti-competitive behavior that they themselves would never tolerate. Imagine if in the past Apple would have had to pay 30% of their gross to Microsoft in order to be allowed to run their software on Windows.
- short_sells_poo 5y agoThey are doing everything they think they can get away with. I agree that ethics and morale should factor into corporate decision making, but at this level I'd argue that corporate decision making is purely an optimization game between profits over various horizons. If they think this maximizes their payoff, they'll do it. I'm 100% certain that they realize that this may/will invite further lawsuits and have factored this into their calculations.
- thathndude 5y agoPrecisely. Let them reap what they plant.
- withinboredom 5y agoApples?
- Hokusai 5y agoOr not. Short term bonuses are key, achieving quarter goals is extremely important, that the company crashes and burns in 10 years may be someone else problem. Big corporations are giants with clay feet. From inside one can see the real humans behind the curtains. So, you could be right and its a long term strategy, but it's also possible that they are just thinking about their next bonus.
- short_sells_poo 5y agoThat's pretty much what I wrote. You are disagreeing with a strawman. > corporate decision making is purely an optimization game between profits over various horizons. If they think this maximizes their payoff, they'll do it. Keyword being "various horizons". Sometimes it's a long term strategy, often it will be just maximizing the next bonus..
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jsnell 5y agoIs it really nuts though? This should be a completely unsurprising move, given this is exactly what Play Store did in South Korea [0]. That's three months old, has anyone heard of a followup suggesting their solution is being treated non-compliant by the regulators? This solution also seems to be in line with what the US courts found in the Epic vs. Apple case. > Imagine if in the past Apple would have had to pay 30% of their gross to Microsoft in order to be allowed to run their software on Windows. Anyone making software for the Xbox has to pay Microsoft. Why is this different? [0] https://developers-kr.googleblog.com/2021/11/enabling-alternative-billing-in-korea-en.html https://developers-kr.googleblog.com/2021/11/enabling-altern... Edit: Good grief, people. I am not pro-App Store. But jacquesm is literally claiming that Apple is nuts and that their solution will never fly. But everything we've seen so far in analogous cases suggests it will.
- clusterfish 5y agoWhy? Because how much you have to pay is determined by how much the platform owner can get away with. There is no fundamental logic to it other than market power. Why don't you compare to better, open platforms instead - desktop apps, the web. Why does everything has to be as shitty as something else.
- jsnell 5y agoI'm not comparing to those other cases because the question being asked was "what if Microsoft had been charging a fee", so it seems rather relevant that Microsoft has been charging exactly that kind of a fee for a couple of decades. I hope we can agree that laws need to apply to everyone equally. For a long time, it's been fine for platform owners to charge e.g. licensing fees, for store owners to charge a fee, etc. Why is Apple different, such that they cannot charge such a fee while others can? If they're not substantially different, do we expect that going forward nobody can charge a fee?
- shkkmo 5y ago> I'm not comparing to those other cases because the question being asked was The question being asked was specifically about windows, and wasn't about Microsoft being "good", but rather about how Apple benefited from platforms being open. > If they're not substantially different, do we expect that going forward nobody can charge a fee? That seems reasonable.
- anm89 5y agoThey have armies of economists, lawyers, and accountants. Do you really think that they are naive and you simply understand the situation better than them or do you think it's possible that they've run the numbers?
- zepto 5y agoThe problem is that people can easily be induced to install software that negates the benefit of Apple’s hardware. Apple can’t deliver their hardware benefits without also controlling the operating system. It’s as simple as that.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y ago> Apple can’t deliver their hardware benefits without also controlling the operating system. Nobody is talking about loading something besides iOS on Apple mobile devices. The argument that "The OS is everything" failed over 20 years ago in US v Microsoft.
- zepto 5y agoThat’s irrelevant. It would be simple enough for Facebook for example to build a store into their own App, and build their own ‘platform’ within the Facebook app.
- Apocryphon 5y agoSo you mean how WeChat and Alibaba do it, and are allowed to do so by the App Store. Then why hasn't Meta done that? Perhaps they don't care to? Not that the Facebook app isn't already hugely overstuffed.
- fxtentacle 5y agoBecause Apple bent down for WeChat and Alibaba, but Apple won't do it for Facebook? I'm 100% sure that if Facebook could have an iOS app store, they would start one. It's worth all the work for the improved tracking alone, as app download ads are a big part of Facebook's mobile revenue.
- Apocryphon 5y agoThe GP is talking about Meta embedding its own app store within the Facebook app, not about Facebook creating its own iOS app store. An "internal" app store would still be subject to the same restrictions and security that the actual Apple App Store already has. I don't believe the mini-apps within WeChat or Alibaba's apps can flout those regulations, but it's China and those are big apps so who knows. From a technical perspective, I'm not sure how hosting littler apps within your own app, which is already on the Apple App Store and subject to its review process and rules, would allow you access to improved tracking. On the subject of a Meta third-party app store independent of Apple's control- yes, there is motivation there to do that, but I am dubious of how much of a threat that is to the end user because: 1. Apple still maintains control of iOS and can restrict invasive tracking from the OS level. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30199125 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30199125 2. I'm not actually convinced that Meta, Google, Amazon, et al are really capable of executing successful alternative app stores. They would need to make it a sufficiently seamless and friction-free experience, and offer enough incentives for users to overcome having to sign up for yet another service just to use the apps they already have access to. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30204012 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30204012
- RC_ITR 5y ago>Imagine if in the past Apple would have had to pay 30% of their gross to Microsoft in order to be allowed to run their software on Windows. Sure, instead Best Buy would record a 22% gross margin for selling the software on a CD [0] (I know it's not a perfect example since Best Buy sells a lot of things, but Software was 22% of sales in the linked period) [0]https://s2.q4cdn.com/785564492/files/doc_financials/2006/bby_ar06.pdf https://s2.q4cdn.com/785564492/files/doc_financials/2006/bby...
- gamblor956 5y agoSo you're argument is that an online digital store justifies a higher fee (30% vs 22%) even though it's significantly less expensive for Apple to run a digital store than it is for Best Buy to operate physical retail stores? If anything, that's just evidence that Apple is grossing abusing its market position.
- nappy 5y agoRight, but there are at least many competitors to Best Buy all competing for your business, driving down margins. Running physical stores is costly. If Apple allowed competing digital stores, I would expect margins would be less than 30%, and even less than 22%, and the value would end up in consumer and developer's pockets.
- tssva 5y agoGoogle allows competing stores but this isn't the case.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoIf Apple lists an app on the app store and it does not sell, how much money does Apple lose?
- RC_ITR 5y agoAs much as Best Buy did, since they required vendors to reimburse them for markdowns and unsold investory. We receive vendor allowances for various programs, primarily volume incentives and reimbursements for specific costs such as markdowns, margin protection, advertising and sales incentives. Vendor allowances provided as a reimbursement of specific, incremental and identifiable costs incurred to promote a vendor’s products are included as an expense reduction when the cost is incurred. All other vendor allowances, including vendor allowances received in excess of our cost to promote a vendor’s product, are initially deferred and recorded as a reduction of merchandise inventories.
- echelon 5y ago> Imagine if in the past Apple would have had to pay 30% of their gross to Microsoft in order to be allowed to run their software on Windows. iPod wouldn't have happened and Apple wouldn't exist today. Apple relied on the fact that most of its customers used Windows and that they got to transact for free on the platform. Heck, they didn't even need Microsoft's approval to offer iTunes downloads. Think about all of the small businesses and startups that are getting snuffed out today by Apple's aggressive over-harvesting. Some non-trivial percentage of Apple's $3T market cap owes itself to a system of feudalism and mafia-style tactics rather than innovation and product sales. Imagine of those dollars were instead represented just about anywhere else.
- sekathlon 5y agoNonsense. Most of those businesses only exist because of the App Store. Apple can ask whatever they want as users can buy whatever they want. There is no need for whining.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- huhtenberg 5y ago> They're nuts. They aren't nuts. It's a middle finger to the legislators.
- virgilp 5y ago> It's a middle finger to the legislators. I.e. they're nuts.
- rmbyrro 5y agoThey're not. Apple is essentially acting like a government, and they're certainly way more powerful than the Dutch government: - They have an income tax -- 30% (wait until they come up with a capital gains tax, and a property and inheritance tax as well) - Use monopoly of "force" by removing us if we "evade taxes" - Have their legislation branch to come up with their own set of "laws" - they call it "terms", but can't be "terms" if we have to swallow it without coming to terms with it - Their judiciary branch judge our actions with no recourse - Have their executive branch to put into practice what their judicial branch decides (usually in an automated fashion)
- virgilp 5y agoNetherlands has a strong voice in the EU; I'm betting that Apple doesn't want to cease all business in the EU. Heck, they bent to China.... they'll bend to EU, make no mistake. This is an mind-blowingly-risky move on Apple's part. They show malice here - if they are acting like a government, they invite governments to fight them. I.e. they're nuts.
- Apocryphon 5y agoAnd it's not even just the EU. The U.S., South Korea, Australia, India, Russia- a lot of countries and markets are taking notice. This is a global phenomenon. The sharks are circling.
- rmbyrro 5y agoI hope you're right, but I don't bet a satoshi on it.
- markus_zhang 5y agoThe point of making competitive mobile hardware is to make sure users stick to it so you can extract values from left and right.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- paulpan 5y agoI think Apple's stubbornness at keeping their commission ~30% underscores how critical that percentage is to their bottom line profitability - both present and future. "Services" is foundational to Tim Cook's vision to continue to grow the company and increase its revenue streams. Based on latest Q4 earnings, Services is one of the highest growth segment of Apple at 25% YoY (others being Mac at 25%, Other Products at 13%). As the clamor for M1-based Macs subsides, monetizing its existing 500M+ users is the only major revenue-growth area. But what happens if their commission rate is cut in half to 15%? Apple doesn't break out the specific App Store revenue amount or percentage but it must be quite significant. Hence they're willing to risk these continued lawsuits and regulatory backlash. The day that Services division no longer reports 20%+ YoY growth could well be one when Apple stock faces the reckoning like FB/Meta.
- gogopuppygogo 5y agoI honestly prefer to use Apple payments and Apple "Hide My Email" as I'm sure a non-trivial number of users do. If they could just refocus on making developers prioritize that flow for users over outside payment systems (e.g. create a flow requiring users to agree to disclose their private information to the app maker and third parties in order to use an outside payment system) then they'd keep most of their customers in the Apple ecosystem and keep the payment processing. The fact they are trying to keep a stranglehold on this revenue seems penny wise and dollar foolish. Clearly regulators are gunning for them and it's not long before they lose this and don't get to set the standard.
- AniseAbyss 5y agoIf Apple had confidence in the superiority of their service they would not be afraid of someone undercutting them.
- Dylan16807 5y ago> I honestly prefer to use Apple payments and Apple "Hide My Email" as I'm sure a non-trivial number of users do. If they could just refocus on making developers prioritize that flow for users over outside payment systems (e.g. create a flow requiring users to agree to disclose their private information to the app maker and third parties in order to use an outside payment system) then they'd keep most of their customers in the Apple ecosystem and keep the payment processing. It's pretty good stuff. But they seem to be admitting that the payment processing is only worth a 3% cut. And you wouldn't charge apps for the email hiding.
- softwarebeware 5y agoI think 30% is only unreasonable if apps in their ecosystem start to leave. Honestly, when the marketplace votes by staying on the platform at 30%, then it doesn't matter how ridiculous it seems to some of us, they're going to keep doing it.
- fxtentacle 5y agoThere's no place to leave to. Or if you mean developers abandoning support for iOS and Mac, then yes, that is precisely what we did.
- Razengan 5y agoHow many of your users left you?
- fxtentacle 5y agoNo idea. We released a new Windows version around the same time which introduced DXVA support and sales overall went up. So if Apple users left, they were overcompensated by additional Windows users.
- Razengan 5y agoSo your product didn’t matter that much in the Apple software market to begin with.
- threeseed 5y agoIt's 15% for developers making up to $1m a year. That's pretty reasonable compared to other distribution channels.
- jurassic 5y agoBy the same logic BestBuy, Verizon, and other hardware retailers should get a cut of Apple’s revenue.
- bdowling 5y ago> By the same logic BestBuy, Verizon, and other hardware retailers should get a cut of Apple’s revenue. Best Buy, Verizon, and other hardware retailers buy Apple products at a discount and sell them for retail price. So, in a way they do get a cut of the revenue that Apple would make when Apple sells products at Apple's retail stores.
- wccrawford 5y agoWhen Develop X sells IAP for their app, Apple demands a cut. Apple didn't ship that IAP or have anything to do with it. When Apple collects their cut from an app, they don't pass any portion of that on to Best Buy, who sold that device. Apple insists that Developer X wouldn't have made that profit without Apple's support, and they're due that cut. By that same logic, Best Buy is due a portion of that because they enabled Apple to make that money in the first place. It's bonkers, which is why everyone's mind rejects that Best Buy would be entitled to anything of the sort. But Apple has managed to sell that line somehow.
- dwaite 5y ago> When Develop X sells IAP for their app, Apple demands a cut. Apple didn't ship that IAP or have anything to do with it. Apple provides hosting for IAP content, if developers wish to use it > When Apple collects their cut from an app, they don't pass any portion of that on to Best Buy, who sold that device. So far I don't believe Best Buy has asked for such a thing. They do ask for fees on things like customer acquisition for cellular plans AFAIK. In the past they have gotten customer acquisition fees for other subscription services, such as ISPs. Apple's various stores are based directly on this same model (portion of revenue on directly sold products, money for customer acquisition on subscriptions). > Apple insists that Developer X wouldn't have made that profit without Apple's support, and they're due that cut. By that same logic, Best Buy is due a portion of that because they enabled Apple to make that money in the first place. Apple has looser restrictions for so-called reader apps (for consuming digital alternatives of physical goods), but generally their restriction is that a consumer-directed app be usable without requiring out-of-app purchasing, and that apps do not direct users to out-of-app purchasing options (either marketing their availability or linking to them). This is again analogous to what you would expect in a brick-and-mortar store. For example, subscription revenue games are way harder to negotiate for sale at a Best Buy than episodic content. There is no way you'd see such a storefront stock a game that sold for $.99 but required a $19.99/month subscription to play without the retailer getting a major acquisition payback. A better comparison would be to compare a wild fictitious example against another retailer, Whole Foods. It would be wild to imagine Amazon selling a high quality refrigerator that only allowed you to place perishable items from Whole Foods inside of it. Independent of whether Whole Foods was selling things at a reasonable rate and of reasonable quality, the expectation is that you would not need to purchase a different brand of refrigerator in order to get food from other markets. No matter what sort of concessions they made, such as offering to sell food at lower margin for local farmers and smaller suppliers, the mere existence of such a closed system would offend some people. But ironically, those people are just as likely to buy into in other closed systems without blinking an eye. Perhaps they have an EV which is only repairable by its manufacturer. Perhaps they have a game system which requires games to be sold in its store or be pressed onto its CDs, and requires hundreds or thousands of dollars for game developers to sign up to participate. Perhaps they have a smart thermostat or smoke detector which refuse to interoperate with any other vendor. The reality is that people are offended by the grocery example because they _understand_ the grocery example. Enough to feel that some company is pushing them through bizarre restrictions because of the revenue model they chose to pursue. And those restrictions impact them.
- blihp 5y agoWhen they eventually lose a major lawsuit, any 'record setting' settlement or judgement is likely to be a tiny fraction of the profits they were able to reap in over a decade of bad behavior. Name a single multinational company in the last 20 years where the consequences were more than a fraction of the profit they made from their bad behavior.
- somethoughts 5y agoI think Apple would actually have more of a case if they charged different rates for different types of apps based on technical reasons (i.e. Basics - web/touch/image/audio, video media, gaming/ARKit): 1.) web view/touch/audio streaming app - 10% 2.) accelerated web view/SDvideo app - 15% 3.) HDvideo H.264 app - 20% 4.) 3D Graphics/ARKit SDK app - 30% 3D and ARKit which are pushing the boundaries of the silicon probably do have associated R&D costs as well as silicon COGS costs that perhaps do need to be recouped in a manner similar to gaming console SW licensing agreements (i.e. Xbox, PS, Nintendo royalty payments). In the court of public opinion it would also minimize the effectiveness of "think of the solo iOS dev" type scenarios that the big guys such as Epic, etc. like to hide behind.
- Apocryphon 5y agoI wonder if that would run into net neutrality-type issues, but setting different rates is definitely a novel way of looking at things. Charging higher rates for publishers of larger app binaries would also make sense. Certainly tech giants such as Facebook and Uber who have bloated app sizes could pay the extra expense for the hosting and so forth.
- Gorbzel 5y ago> I wonder if that would run into net neutrality-type issues It absolutely would. Who is Apple or anyone on HN to tell one developer that their app is more important/costly/uses higher priority SDKs than another?
- Apocryphon 5y agoWell, maybe app binary sizes are an objective metric. Apple could even raise the existing cap and give Uber a bit more room to breathe, while charging them for the inevitable expansion of their app.
- somethoughts 5y agoI think the analogy would be more equivalent to AWS. There are different costs associated with using the various SDKs (i.e. Lightsail, EC2, S3, SageMaker). I'd also say the more it can be defined in terms of technical reasons the better. There are R&D costs to maintaining a cutting edge, industry leading 3D Graphics SDK for iOS that the primary users beneficiaries of said library (i.e. Epic, Xbox) should contribute to. This would require a bit of mindshift and context.
- readams 5y agoThey have provided a convenient breakdown for their invoices: 3% payment processing 27% monopoly rent
- sfe22 5y agoOther payments processors charge 30c + 3%, so it would be interesting to see how it would work here for smaller payments
- Dylan16807 5y ago5c + 5% is also standard for smaller payments.
- IncRnd 5y agoIt's pretty straightforward, assuming that you have the standard charge amount correct. (I don't know) Between the two approaches, the costs break even when 30c = .27*cost. Apple's 27% exceeds the 30c whenver the purchase costs less than $1.11. 27% of .99 is 26.73c. So, this is a strong case Apple has calculated the other processor's charges for all app sales of .99 or less. It seems they are trying to charge more than normal processors for all micro-transactions.
- threeseed 5y agoFor developers making up to $1m a year: 3% payment processing 12% cost of channel
- ROTMetro 5y agoYou just made Apple's point though. The Microsoft ecosystem of flexibility introduced so much variation that lots of people moved to Apple BECAUSE of it's enforced uniformity. Microsoft's ecosystem of flexibility allowed their system to be abused and exploited by bad actors more easily resulting in people MOVING to Apple to get away from this. If you want flexibility, develop for Android or Windows. You don't have a right to have access to people who moved to Apple for the express purpose of living in a managed ecosystem that just worked and simplified their lives. Everyone is talking about the developer's rights but no one is talking about end users, many of whom choose Apple for the very reason this is trying to negate, even if they couldn't articulate it as such.
- oaiey 5y agoThe industry could build platforms which are both safe and flexible. They just do not want it. Some for keeping their revenue other for sticking to backward compatibility
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- spideymans 5y agoYou’re not wrong, it what does this have to do with App Store commissions? I (an end user) would be quite happy to see iOS remain a restricted environment for developers, while also lowering App Store commissions, such that more business models will be competitive on iOS.
- Hokusai 5y ago> many of whom choose Apple for the very reason this is trying to negate I already use apps in iOs that bypass the store to transfer money, pay for train tickets, parking, etc. Many people in Sweden likes Swish and probably will be ok with being able to choose it for all their transactions. I could be wrong, but I don't think that there is data to support the opposite either.
- passivate 5y agoThere is absolutely nothing is preventing Apple from creating an easy to use 'checkout' process that pretty much every single e-commerce websites have. Developers can choose to integrate with Apple payments, pay pal, square or whoever. Its no different than Amazon. Users can check a payment processor as a default and never be bothered. In my opinion, this is simply Apple being a bully, for commercial reasons, not technical, or UX ones.
- alexashka 5y agoIs it nuts? Or is it just business as usual? There's a department and the head of that department's responsibility is to make the profit number go up. So, he/she is doing just that. It'd be nuts if that didn't happen, that would be nuts.
- Razengan 5y ago> Apple should focus on selling hardware and be happy to facilitate those payments that people - and application developers - voluntarily process through their system. Why don’t you apply that to the Xbox, PlayStation, etc.? > All this stupid taxation of other peoples' businesses Exactly. Stop trying to overthrow Apple from the ecosystem they built.
- scarface74 5y agoGame developers do just that on Microsoft’s consoles…
- aspenmayer 5y agoThe original app store on iOS was saurik’s Cydia. App Store wasn’t even on iPhone 2G at launch. Cydia is free and open source. Hopefully Jay can clarify the commission for paid apps on Cydia, but something tells me it isn’t 27%.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pbreit 5y ago27% versus 30% for cards?
- Hamuko 5y agoI hope that the Dutch demand a breakdown on that commission to see where it goes, if it's not just a number that they pulled out of their ass. Surely they wouldn't put hosting and approval processes there if free apps don't pay separately for those?
- jacquesm 5y agoIt will be smacked down hard is my prediction, because clearly Apple is trying to argue that they have an innate right to other parties' business income. It's the Mafia model: you have a partner in the business who wants a sizeable chunk of your gross without doing anything for it.
- myspy 5y agoBut when you use the store, you need to pay for using and maintaining the store, which is the other 27%. Why would you expect to upload apps in the store and let them be downloaded for free?
- Hamuko 5y agoNo developer can upload anything to the App Store for free. You need to pay $99/year for access.
- jacquesm 5y agoBecause that is the model that Apple has chosen for. If the downloads can be priced or can be free that is Apple's choice. Then they should raise the minimum price for distribution. Distribution is a one-time expense, and it does not entitle you to a 30% cut of services that use Apps as endpoints. It's a mob move, taxation because you are powerful enough to harm another business, not because you have contributed to the business.
- maccard 5y ago> Distribution is a one-time expense No, it's not. Distribution requires ongoing storage and bandwidth costs. > It's a mob move, taxation because you are powerful enough to harm another business, not because you have contributed to the business. This is just flaming. Apple absolutely have contributed to the business. They provide hosting, storage, versioning, a marketplace, storefront reviews, developer tools, various high-availability services (auth being one of them). We can argue all day how much that is worth, but it is definitely worth some number greater than 0, otherwise people would just ignore the platforms.
- Jyaif 5y ago> Each month, developers will have to send a report to Apple that lists their sales. Apple will then send out invoices for its commission, that must be paid within 45 days. LOL! Apple has no way of knowing how many sales actually occurred in the app, so they have to trust the developers to report the correct number. How the tables have turned :-)
- bryanrasmussen 5y agoProbably apps with low numbers of sales will be punished in rankings, with low numbers of sales it means your users don't really like you.
- grenoire 5y agoDoes that mean I can buy my app into the rankings by paying more in commission?
- bryanrasmussen 5y agoI mean maybe I am being cynical here, but it was implied that developers could just under-report their sales without negative effects, in order to fight that possibility I might suppose that Apple would increase positioning of apps in the Netherlands that reported high sales, under theory that they were 'better'.
- grenoire 5y agoApple is basically a local tax authority now. For the... Apple tax, y'know?
- neximo64 5y agoThey're signalling that other methods or payment are fine, but they're entitled to that commission of 30% (- processing fees i guess) If people thought the lawsuits were about the commission they're wrong, they were about forcing Apple's method of payment, but even after you get through that they still feel they are entitled to the commission. You might have your opinions about whether thats right or wrong, but Apple's approach was to look as both as 2 different things whereas everyone seemed to see them as the same. And thats what they took advantage of.
- jacquesm 5y agoThey are as much entitled to that commission as the Mafia is entitled to theirs. It's a ridiculous demand. It is a pretty American way of thinking that the courts order is about the payment system rather than because of the commission when clearly, if the commission weren't there companies would not be looking for alternative payment systems to begin with. It's ignoring the spirit of the ruling. Prediction: this won't end well for Apple and it will cost them plenty of goodwill in NL.
- martimarkov 5y agoThey kinda are entitled - you are build for their OS, using their APIs and SDKs, targeting their customers. All that needs to be funded somehow plus as I always say - nobody has forced engineers to build iOS apps. An example: what if US engineers dislike the privacy laws of the EU and start asking to get them removed because you know their app wants to track and stalk ppl without their knowledge. Maybe not the best example but I hope you get the point
- sofixa 5y ago> All that needs to be funded somehow plus as I always say You pay for that privilege, in the form of a yearly developer account, so that's a very poor excuse.
- simion314 5y ago>They kinda are entitled - you are build for their OS, using their APIs and SDKs, targeting their customers. The fix is super obvious, Apple selling shit in my country uses my country population and wealth, so 30% tax on each sell, NOT on profits, We could use the Apple Tax against Apple, if they don't like it they are not forced to sell the products in my country.
- lewisflude 5y agoSeems fair to me, 27% commission implies 3% for card handling fees, to level out to the same 30% developers would have to pay doing things the intended way. All this talk of using "alternative payment systems" just seems like a way to skirt around paying Apple commission.
- Hamuko 5y agoI thought that the justification for the 30% commission was the tightly integrated payment system, and not just the fact that you can install the app in the first place.
- lewisflude 5y agoThat's definitely one aspect of it, but I've always thought most of that fee is simply for the "privilege" of being a part of the Apple ecosystem, being mostly profit for Apple with a portion going towards the hosting, distribution of the App, search/discoverability aspect. I can definitely see why this fee and it's associated lock-in upsets many consumers and developers. It's clearly a divisive issue right now, and I am unsure we'll see any resolution to the overall narrative until the EU/US forces Apples hand.
- matheusmoreira 5y agoThere should be no Apple commission in the first place.
- lewisflude 5y agoI think the big sticking point is whether smartphones are a generic, standardised thing that requires some level of guarantees for the end consumer on accessing software of if each smartphone is one of many products in a broad category that all have different restrictions and limitations. Essentially the "you have a choice, just use Android" defence. I'm not saying which one is correct here, just that this seems to be the specific fork in the road between differing opinions.
- 5y ago
- klelatti 5y agoProblem for Apple is that if it charges less then it shows that it can run the store for less than 30% in total - and what is true in NL is true everywhere else - which is not helpful for them in antitrust actions. Burning goodwill and brand value while they do it though.
- thathndude 5y agoWe know they can run it for way less because they disclose numbers in their earnings, and the Epic litigation turned up emails from Phil talking about this issue and going down to like 10%. The issue is what’s the recourse and remedy? Go to Google/Android, which charges a comparable fee and tends to be less valuable? Folks are getting their money’s worth on Apple’s ecosystem. But they somehow feel like they should just be getting more, just because. But apple doesn’t have a monopoly. They just have a good product.
- baxtr 5y agoI have an app in the App Store and pay 15% commissions, since we are below 1 mn USD in sales. In exchange, I can roll-out my app in 175 countries and have not deal with local authorities re taxes etc. For me, that's a pretty good deal. I could never do this on my own. Any other provider would probably take the same cut for that kind of service.
- madeofpalk 5y ago> Any other provider would probably take the same cut for that kind of service. Too bad we'll never know because Apple prevents the competition on their platform!
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- baxtr 5y agoThat's an easy one. Let's look at the other big ecosystem Android. There we have a couple of alternate stores like Amazon's. They take 30% as well? I am not sure why it should be different with Apple. Maybe, just maybe, running a well-curated app store is just something that is expensive.
- disgruntledphd2 5y agoNah, it's because Apple and Google are a cartel with respect to app fees. Like, 30% is a crazy amount to take, at the scale they operate at.
- tsimionescu 5y ago> Maybe, just maybe, running a well-curated app store is just something that is expensive. Are you trying to claim that Apple and Google are each running a "well curated" app store?
- ambicapter 5y agoI'll bite, show me an example of a "well curated" app store to your standards.
- danuker 5y agoAs a consumer I do not want to enter an ecosystem where 30% of any software entering my device is leeched away into by an ever-increasing monopoly. As such, I use second-hand Android devices with Lineage OS, and get my software from F-Droid.
- homarp 5y agois your bank app on F-Droid?
- sofixa 5y agoIt probably isn't, but bank apps usually are free so it doesn't matter.
- YXNjaGVyZWdlbgo 5y agoMost bank apps don't work properly anymore on rooted phones or custom roms.
- gkbrk 5y agoSounds like a job for regulations if an essential service like banking can keep users out on such arbitrary terms. I think only one of the banking apps I use check for rooted phones, and it only uses that to warn the user once on app install and never again.
- YXNjaGVyZWdlbgo 5y agoIs it just a warning? Mine explicitly teels me that if anything happens to the bank account they won't be liable because I used the app on a rooted phone.
- viktorcode 5y agoRegulators can't force banks to provide service in an unsafe environment, which a rooted phone essentially is.
- NicoJuicy 5y agoOh well, they will claim you can use pwa's as recently announced in 2007. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Progressive_web_application https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Progressive_web_application No surprise here. They will literally block/slowdown progress every way they can.
- toolslive 5y agothey're probably just anchoring the rate for future negotiations.
- can16358p 5y agoDon't want to play devil's advocate here but if they didn't, many big players would be using their platforms to build their apps, reaching Apple's customers on Apple devices, giving the app for free and processing everything off-Apple land, basically using the whole platform for making millions without giving Apple literally anything ($99 dev fee is nothing compared to all the money being made). If I were a company who literally created a whole industry and many other companies were making millions off the platform I created, I'd of course take my cut, and a well-deserved big one. It's a for-profit company who enabled those apps/purchases* to be made in the first place, not a charity or a non-profit. (*: not talking about non-app related payments like real world items, obviously)
- qalmakka 5y agoFollowing your logic than all PC makers should be paying a fee to IBM for creating the PC? It doesn't make sense, it was never done this way in the past and it only goes on because sadly most politicians are borderline computer illiterate and are easily bamboozled by the complexity of the matter. Just look at when Sundar Pichai testified at the US Senate, most lawmakers have zero ideas on how the Internet works, and they don't really have the means to understand the similarities that exist between what Apple is doing and the "brick and mortar" world they are accustomed to. If you create an industry, a platform, you already have instruments to monetize on it. the Apple software platform is already tied to its own devices, from whose sales Apple has earned a vast amount of wealth over the years and profited thanks to their massive margins. What makes Apple different from Google in this regard is that the Play store has won due to consumer choice, while Apple has basically prohibited side loading and alternate stores in any possible way and shape. The Amazon Appstore has failed to gain marketshare because people simply didn't like it, and Google play was just superior, end of it, and if you want to use Google services in order to give your customers what they want you have to pay Google's fee, fair and square. On an Apple device there are no ways to sell people anything without paying Apple because Apple does not allow it. If Apple starts providing a shitty service with its Appstore, there is no way to circumvent it, you must choose either to quit the iOS market entirely or play along whatever rules they decide to adopt. This is basically extorting protection money, with a few extra steps on top of it.
- mrtksn 5y agoIf you paid attention to Epic v.s. Apple, that was also the conclusion of the US court.[0] When you use Apple tools to to make and publish software, Apple is entitled to a cut. The limitations Apple imposes on the payment processors are simply to make it easy to collect their cut and streamline the user experience. I think the only scenario where Apple is not entitled to a cut is when you use non-Apple toolchain to develop your apps and spread it through non-Apple distribution channels, i.e. Cydia. Currently that requires a jailbroken device but maybe if Apple is forced to allow side loading, the cut for distribution can be collected by other companies instead of Apple. [0] https://9to5mac.com/2021/09/14/apple-can-still-charge-its-app-store-30-fee-even-after-epic-ruling-analysts-say/ https://9to5mac.com/2021/09/14/apple-can-still-charge-its-ap... “Apple has the legal right to do business with anyone they want,” said Paul Gallant, managing director at Cowen & Co. “So Apple could change the terms of the App Store and say to developers, regardless of where you collect your revenue, you owe us 30%, and if developers refuse to pay it, Apple would be free to de-platform them.”
- GeekyBear 5y agoThere's an excellent overview of the US Federal court's 180 page decision on Youtube, but it's rather long. The diction is good, so it's still understandable when set to run at a faster speed. The first 15 minutes is a summary and the balance of the video is a more detailed look. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=43CMV8KIs3E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=43CMV8KIs3E TL;DW, the judge makes it clear that Apple can still charge a cut even if developers use someone else's payment system. She also hints strongly that Epic screwed up by not challenging the size of Apple's cut instead of challenging their right to take a cut.
- ls15 5y agoIf only they would allow sideloading. How cool would a F-Droid equivalent for iOS be? I can only hope that Apple or regulators will open up that walled garden a bit.
- schmorptron 5y agoDoesn't that still leave the problem with "using apple tools"? Currently, the only way I know of to compile apps that run on iPhones are xcode, on a macintosh. Even when using frameworks like flutter I'm pretty sure you still need to use an apple compiler to make the final build, right?
- foxfluff 5y agoHuh so they were fined 5M eur and pulled this trick. I think they deserve a follow-up fine that's at least two orders of magnitude greater.
- rvz 5y agoI don't see why Apple would back down from making their intellectual property to be used for free. But it is quite unsurprising and expected that they will find a way to collect the fees even if IAP was optional. [0] [1]. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29490666 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29490666 [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29914273 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29914273
- jacquesm 5y agoWhat intellectual property?
- rvz 5y agoSo using Apple's SDKs, App Store, devices and services etc isn't their intellectual property and it is all public domain and free to use? In case if you haven't read the comment: From [0] of page 112 (b) > The Court agrees with the general proposition that Apple is entitled to be paid for its intellectual property. The inquiry though does not end with the bald conclusion. Apple provides evidence that it invests enormous sums into developing new tools and features for iOS. I don't think anyone would agree to develop all of that for free at a loss, especially when it is used by billions of users and devices. They will still collect the fees either way and as predicted. [0] https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/17442392/812/epic-games https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/17442392/812/epic-games...
- jacquesm 5y agoDifferent court case.
- pritambaral 5y ago> So using Apple's SDKs, App Store, devices and services etc isn't their intellectual property and it is all public domain and free to use? Don't you have to pay $99/yr for that already?
- etchalon 5y ago
- amelius 5y ago> it is anti-competitive behavior that they themselves would never tolerate TSMC should force Apple to pay a 30% tax, and if they don't comply, kick them out of the FabStore.
- thathndude 5y agoBut developers do tolerate it, and that’s the problem. And they tolerate it because there’s immense value there.
- jacquesm 5y agoUntil there isn't and then they should be free to take their payment services elsewhere because a 30% cut to your payment provider makes no sense. The value is there but then again, Stripe and other PSPs provide much of that same value at a much better price point, and that's because there is competition in the realm of payment processing.
- jb1991 5y agoThere is definitely some value to the App Store and Apple's management of it and the payment service, listing, etc. But I would not say it is "immense" value, and 30% is a lot.
- sunderw 5y agoWell they tolerate it because there is no other choice. You can't say f** all the apple users. Would you have the same argument if Windows took a 30% cut of all transactions that happened on "their platform" ?
- interpol_p 5y agoIt's not the number of Apple users that matter. There are many more Android users world wide. It's the fact that Apple users spend more, and more often than users on other platforms.
- 5y ago
- hexo 5y agoExtortion practices.
- traveler01 5y agoI got an iPhone in August. Their I've never seen such a crappy and expensive AppStore before and I'm a longtime Android user. And this won't improve it, apps are very expensive for they do, phone is pretty much a closed up black box which apparently is easily hackable if you manage to find the security holes.
- philliphaydon 5y agoI don’t see any difference in prices between android and iOS. They are both expensive. But the quality of apps on android is definitely lower.
- viktorcode 5y agoGood thing iPhone holds resale value for longer than an Android phone, so you can just ditch it.
- xuki 5y agoApple ran out of people to sell iPhone to and they’re turning into a service company to keep the stock price flowing. Infinity growth is cancer.
- disgruntledphd2 5y agoSee also them exempting themselves from the cross-app tracking thing. Personally, I predict that they'll need to either give up on service revenue growth, or roll back on these changes. This will occur as the next big f2p games will find it much, much harder to monetise profitably without being able to measure/optimise at a user level. It'll be interesting to see what happens here.
- ksec 5y ago>Personally, I predict that they'll need to either give up on service revenue growth, or roll back on these changes. There is no need to give up on service revenue. Before 2016, my expectation of future Apple Services was growth from AppleCare and iCloud. Today, Apple put $10 per devices to services revenue for OS, Map and other Software. Apple could hike the price and move those to services. For example iPhone price hike but with 2 years AppleCare by default. Nearly 80% of App Store revenue are from Gaming. There is no reason why Apple cant separate Game into a different Store and continue to charge 30% off it. That would have protected 80% of App Store revenue alone. EPIC wouldn't be happy, but I am sure most people couldn't care less. Gaming are not the fabric of our modern society ( I am sure there will be people who disagree ). Then it is the Apps and Services. Which is not only just a revenue problem but a power play problem. Why does Apple get to dictate which business it is allowed on their platform when it holds 60%+ of usage in US / UK market. I have an app for my restaurant, but Apple refuse to host it. While QSR next door get to use Apps and customer are flying in. Under which law does Apple gets to discriminate small business? May be that is fine by US standards, I can assure you this wont fly in EUR. And where are business and developers going to complain? And how is Apple responding? If you watch every speech, interview or answer Tim Cook gave, it is obvious he ( representing Apple ) doesn't think they have a problem at all. And the biggest problem in the world is not understanding there is a problem. It is sad those who were on Steve Jobs side are all gone. Phil Schiller, Katie Cotton, Jony Ive, Scott Forstall, Bob Mansfield, Ron Johnson. And only Tim Cook and Eddy Cue left. There may be not of people with high intellect at Apple, but very little with intuition. “Intuition is a very powerful thing, more powerful than intellect, in my opinion,” - Steve Jobs
- pembrook 5y agoIt’s interesting to me that the OS market in two separate generations of tech has naturally shaken out to become a duopoly. Desktop computing for decades has been just Windows or MacOS (For 98.5% of people, yes I know Linux exists, but quit being cute). Mobile computing took only a few years to shake down to iOS and Android. Are OS markets inevitably always going to mature into duopoly? To me this is the core issue here. Since computing is now the basis of the modern economy, the 3 companies that are in the OS business across desktop and mobile (Microsoft, Apple, Google) are basically the wealthiest companies on earth due to their ability to extract rents from all of computing. I get that these companies built the market (although you could argue the tech was inevitable, so many teams were working on it in the early days) but once you become one of the winners and most valuable company on earth, extracting 30% rents starts to feel like a drag on future innovation. It’s also interesting to me that Jobs originally courted John Scully from Pepsi to run Apple way back in the 80s—-what a bizarre choice. Did he know the market would inevitably always be a duopoly like the Cola market, already back then?
- Isinlor 5y agoEU is specifically drafting legislation for gatekeepers in Digital Markets Law. TL;DR Apple and Google will have to allow to install third-party app stores trough their stores. This type of private taxes will become impossible to enforce. https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/en/TXT/?qid=16081168 https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/en/TXT/?qid=16081168... Gatekeepers like Apple will have specific obligation according to Article 5: (b) allow business users to offer the same products or services to end users through third party online intermediation services at prices or conditions that are different from those offered through the online intermediation services of the gatekeeper; (c) allow business users to promote offers to end users acquired via the core platform service, and to conclude contracts with these end users regardless of whether for that purpose they use the core platform services of the gatekeeper or not, and allow end users to access and use, through the core platform services of the gatekeeper, content, subscriptions, features or other items by using the software application of a business user, where these items have been acquired by the end users from the relevant business user without using the core platform services of the gatekeeper; And Article 6: (c) allow the installation and effective use of third party software applications or software application stores using, or interoperating with, operating systems of that gatekeeper and allow these software applications or software application stores to be accessed by means other than the core platform services of that gatekeeper. The gatekeeper shall not be prevented from taking proportionate measures to ensure that third party software applications or software application stores do not endanger the integrity of the hardware or operating system provided by the gatekeeper; (k) apply fair and non-discriminatory general conditions of access for business users to its software application store designated pursuant to Article 3 of this Regulation. Following articles, like: - article 7: Compliance with obligations for gatekeepers - article 10: Updating obligations for gatekeepers and - article 11: Anti-circumvention Give the EU Commission quite a lot of maneuvering power to ensure effective implementation.
- MilaM 5y agoA more general explanation of the new law can be found here: https://ec.europa.eu/info/strategy/priorities-2019-2024/europe-fit-digital-age/digital-markets-act-ensuring-fair-and-open-digital-markets_en https://ec.europa.eu/info/strategy/priorities-2019-2024/euro...
- skeletal88 5y agoIt is astounding to see so many people here argue for the 30% apple tax. It is like the mafia demanding you pay for the privilege of doing business on your street. 30% is just too much. My client is selling a service where they are selling a physical product together with something you do with it in the app. Currently the customers buy the service and device in a separate shop and the app is just for the convenience of the user, they could also use a laptop conputer or whatever else. The client wanted to include a link to the shop in the app, but apple wouldn't allow it without their 30% tax. With this 30% cut providing the service for apple users wouldn't make business sense, they would lose money on each sale. Should they have higher prices for iphone users to make up for that?
- jacquesm 5y agoPeople are arguing for that tax because they genuinely believe that Apple will somehow respond to this in a way that will cause their own income stream to be affected negatively (for instance: if Apple decides to raise the 30% to make up for the shortfall of companies that go outside of their platform). It's Stockholm Syndrome. Apple got away lucky that they weren't ordered to be split up and to run their payment service provider as an independent entity. It could still happen, the EU is pretty aggressive when it comes to monopolies overreaching their legal limits or abusing their position. The various phone operators here have been smacked down pretty hard time and again on things like roaming, service fees and so on. Apple is no different.
- zepto 5y agoNo, people are arguing this because they think the 15% represents good value compared to what you would have to do as an indie developer to support multiple stores and payment methods.
- rosndo 5y agoI’m arguing for the tax because it provides a strong incentive for app developers to stick to Apples payment systems, that’s good for me as an end user. I’m also arguing for the tax because I believe that Apple has the absolute right to collect such a tax, why wouldn’t they? They’re far from being a monopolist. Stockholm syndrome? Mobile app development sounds like the last thing I’d want to have anything to do with.
- dathinab 5y agoHm, does that mean they implicit accepted that 3% is a maximum price for a payment system to not count as profiteering? And hence 27% is the price for the service of forcing you to use their app-store, sorry I mean non well working scam scanning, sorry I mean sup-par mac only build tools, ah wait I mean download cost, ... or maybe their sometimes abusive and often non-well working moderation, ah no that can't be it either. Maybe it's subvention the hardware cost as a iPhone only costs... wait... Why does it seem like profiteering no matter how I try to look at it?? Jokes aside, in app payments are basically only monetary processing. Now you can claim that in app-payments are subvention reduced up-front payments. But that only holds up up to some degree of average per-active-user payment. But at least the more revenue rich phone games to quite a bit above that.
- jacquesm 5y ago3% sounds about right. That's the order-of-magnitude fee charged by commercial payment service providers (1 ... 5% in practice).
- natch 5y agoI am a huge fan of Apple but… also a fan of reality so I'll share this story here. This fun anecdote is about what I think is Apple's treatment of other companies' pricing rules — The Apple Company Store at 1 Infinite Loop in Cupertino used to sell a variety of clothing, accessories, and various items including, seasonally, Lego Mindstorms kits. My impression from having observed Lego over the years is that they have very strict retail pricing rules. I have no other evidence for this than what I've seen in the market. Each year at the Apple Company Store, when Christmas season rolled around, the store would get Lego Mindstorms in stock. One year, we decided to buy a set. The store is frequented by Apple employees, who get a steep discount on Apple merchandise. But Lego… they have (I think) strict rules about discounts, so what was Apple to do here? Now I am making some guesses here, to be fair. But I found it very interesting that there at the store they had a large pile of Mindstorms sets that all had mysteriously carefully damaged boxes, which looked like the corner of the box had been gently stepped on, all in the same way, and that were all marked down significantly, something like 30 or 40% for "damage." Inside, the sets were fine. It could have been just a coincidence, but my spidey senses were telling me it was something else… I suspect it was Apple, not able to mark the items down for employees due to strict Lego corporate rules about when sets can be marked down and when they cannot (sound familiar? Apple is pretty strict about pricing as well, in my understanding). And they found a loophole in that damaged items could be marked down. So, somehow, the items ended up "damaged", as a nice holiday special gift item for employees (or for anyone who came into the shop, lucky for me). These days, the Apple Company Store after a revamp does not carry as much third party merchandise, so I don't know if this is still a thing.
- etchalon 5y agoThis is exactly what I'd expect from Apple, and Google, and any platform provider. It makes the point that their fee isn't about credit card processing. I suspect, baring specific language in the law baring the practice, Apple, Google, etc. will force their commissions no matter what other allowances they're asked to make.
- sebastien_b 5y agoInstead of forcing Apple to allow alternative payment methods, Apple should have been forced to implement PWAs to full specs in Safari/WebKit. That would help take care of the AppStore monopoly.
- anonymouse008 5y agoThis is an appropriate way to handle the incentives. Not keeping par with PWA (as in what is available in modern browsers) is the unfair competitive practice.
- Apocryphon 5y agoRealizing Jobs' dream, eh? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p1nwLilQy64 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p1nwLilQy64
- rocketChair 5y agoApple, and two other companies, are now taking out rent for computing. That's not how the world should work. I like some of their products, but these companies have to be curtailed.
- Workaccount2 5y agoThe path that computing is on is "You will buy a screen, pay monthly for internet access, and then pay monthly to access a cloud service where you access all your SaaS applications.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- endisneigh 5y agoWhat I don’t understand is - if you don’t like the fees, why don’t you just not use it? If you make money after the fees then isn’t it worth it compared to the alternative? If people actually just stood firm against the fees then viable alternatives would manifest.
- vorpalhex 5y agoYeah, if you don't like the fee, just make your own phone hardware, your own processor, your own screens, your own OS.. The same way when automakers tried a similar game and then.. the government stepped in, slapped the tar out of them with regulation, and told them to play nicely with third parties or lose the ability to do business. Or when utilities had natural monopolies were preventing competition and.. then the government put strict regulations on them, set pricing rules and allowed significant control of them. The answer is that if the two dominant parties have managed to keep out competitors and basically engage in collusion, the government should correct the situation.
- endisneigh 5y agoYou can make a web app which can be run on the same phones with no fees. The vast majority of apps can be implemented as web apps. Comparing utilities, based on physical constraints, with digital goods doesn’t make any sense. It doesn’t require any effort to make a web app relative to the status quo. Furthermore your example doesn’t make any sense because you make money with Apple and pay a fee - you’re not paying for nothing. Natural gas, for example, has constraints around distribution and collection. These don’t exist for apps. Ironically, if more developers just made web apps instead of going to app stores it would not only make their apps more accessible as they are inherently cross platform, but would likely lead to the creation of a web App Store to resolve the distribution problem.
- astlouis44 5y agoThis. Especially with the advent of technologies like WebAssembly, WebGPU, and WebXR, developers can now distribute real-time 3D applications like games universally via the open web, without having to sacrifice 30% to a walled garden.
- hn_version_0023 5y agoThis is usury, full stop.
- keleftheriou 5y agoSteve Troughton-Smith on Twitter[1]: > Absolutely vile. This says everything about @tim_cook’s Apple and what it thinks of developers. I hope the company gets exactly what it deserves. Everybody on their executive team should be ashamed, and some of them should not be here when it’s all over. We all see you. > We’ve been told that if Apple ever asked its employees to betray their principles, they’d leave. In a similar vein, everybody, top to bottom, involved in planning, editing, implementation of everything in this document should leave Apple. You betrayed us. 1: https://twitter.com/stroughtonsmith/status/1489558951905669120 https://twitter.com/stroughtonsmith/status/14895589519056691...
- viktorcode 5y agoPretty strong word, betrayal. Someone on 9to5 Mac suggested Steve to put his money where his mouth is, i.e. pull his own software from App Store, before demanding from Apple employees that they leave the company. I think that's a good advice.
- irskep 5y agoSo he should destroy his business? Seems like extremely terrible advice.
- syspec 5y agoBut he's okay suggesting others destroy their own livelihood?
- smoldesu 5y agoIf the only chance for him to make a change is by completely boycotting the system, is there not a possibility that the system isn't that good in the first place? Are you insinuating that the Blizzard employees who were routinely abused should have just left the company and forfeit their source of income instead of trying to inspire internal change?
- viktorcode 5y ago
- Traster 5y agoThis is great, because it serves as a basis for what Apple can be forced to reduce their commission to. What Apple has said here is "The cost of the payment processing is 3% and the rest is our commission", which obviously opens the door to legislators then saying "Well, you said the costs of payment processing is 3%, that's what we'll cap your commission at".
- endisneigh 5y agoShould all businesses be capping their fees to their costs? If so, then that implies no profit. If no profit, why bother?
- 13415 5y agoNot bothering would be the equivalent of the app store closing in this case, which would mean that iPhones would have to be open. So that would be the ideal outcome (except for Apple).
- Guest42 5y agoIt’s rather tiresome for people to alternate between general and specific in order to be argumentative as opposed to staying on topic and contributing to the issue at hand. No, the poster isn’t implying that all businesses should be capping their fees. That’s absurd. However, Apple is not all businesses and regulation is structured in a way that has a number of conditions. I for one am glad that the department of insurance makes my car insurance affordable and that when I purchase water it’s not from a private equity firm.
- endisneigh 5y ago> No, the poster isn’t implying that all businesses should be calling their fees. That’s absurd. That’s literally what they said >> "Well, you said the costs of payment processing is 3%, that's what we'll cap your commission at".
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- notsrg 5y agoI'm shocked those defending the Apple tax aren't considering the fact that businesses are just offloading that tax onto consumers making things artificially more expensive for iOS users. Even worse, when you do this you can't communicate why this is the case or tell people you can use the web for cheaper so users feel like you're just scamming them.
- orasis 5y agoThat’s not really true. Consumers have a fixed willingness to pay and professional app publishers are good at discovering that number, so there really isn’t much passing costs onto the consumer.
- notsrg 5y agoThe company I work for literally charges 30% more for iOS users lol.
- Spivak 5y agoAnd if your iOS users actually pay it then you're a fool to not charge 30% more to your non-iOS users as well.
- clusterfish 5y agoUm, no, cost of doing business affects the equilibrium market price. There's no Apple tax outside of Apple's walled garden, so everyone competing outside of it has lower costs and can thus offer lower prices (outside of the walled garden). If you don't, your competitors will, and you'll lose customers.
- Spivak 5y agoSo yes, in the broadest possible abstract, sure. But we're talking about the sale of digital goods here. What market for game coins, app features, digital content w/e is so intensely price sensitive, apparently fungible enough that switching apps doesn't matter, but then also not at all actually price sensitive since the mostly arbitrary distinction to the consumer "what brand is your phone" means you can charge 30% more? Like I totally believe you, I'm actually just interested.
- fartcannon 5y agoApple is acting a bit petulant.
- BiteCode_dev 5y agoIf they do it, it's because they know they can get away with it. They studied the risk and cost associated with a lawsuit, and estimated it was more profitable to keep the commission high. Which is one more hint that our legal system is not working as it should. It is completely ineffective at enforcing laws above a certain threshold of power.
- makecheck 5y agoApple allows “free apps” that are entirely ad-supported, never giving Apple a dime (aside from $99/year), yet they are consuming infrastructure: hosting pages, downloads, reviewer time, etc. Why isn’t Apple concerned about any of those costs? Simple: they make overwhelmingly most of their App Store money from the handful of developers that offer purchases. This also leads to perverse outcomes like Apple dragging its feet on scams that make them heaps of money. Developers are literally subsidizing other developers, and it’s not necessarily the richest ones helping the poorest ones. Someone trying to make money on a $0.99 app is sacrificing more to Apple than Facebook does with their free app. That’s why I find all these percentage and payment discussions weird: income is so insanely distributed that a lot of this literally does not apply to more than 80% of the stuff on the store. There are fundamental issues that need to be resolved too.
- anaisbetts 5y agoOk, that's fine. If I can _choose_ to use Apple's services, in exchange for their cut, then that's a trade that I can evaluate as a business. Instead if I want to develop for iOS I am _forced_ to use these services, and pay the cost. That's the Problem.
- thegrimmest 5y agowell, the thing is iOS itself isn't exactly a separate "thing" from these services. Also it wholly belongs to apple. You don't (and shouldn't) have a "right" to develop for it on anything but Apple's terms.
- realusername 5y agoHence the market abuse regulations, we can't really have only two companies controlling all the market. iOS became too big for Apple.
- thegrimmest 5y agowhy not exactly? As long as consumers are getting good devices and good competition (which they are), then what's the problem? It's not like the door is closed to innovation here, if any company can disrupt the smartphone market then the takings are all theirs. This is literally what Apple did with the original iPhone. Have you heard of Blackberry recently? I don't see that the incumbents are preventing this in any meaningful way, in the same way that RIM wasn't. Furthermore there are way more than two players in the smartphone game.
- karmasimida 5y agoWhat is the reasoning behind this???? Can they be more blatant about the Apple Tax they are collecting?
- jshen 5y agoI’ve been an Apple fan for a very long time, but I bought my first windows laptop ever this past year because of the direction Apple has been going with things like this. I really wish the alternatives to iPhones, Apple watches, and tvOS weren’t so much worse.
- jeffybefffy519 5y agoI cant understand what justification Apple thinks they have for a payment processing cost this high? A couple of percent sure, but justify the rest?
- Spivak 5y agoThis is the biggest confusion. You're not paying 30% for Apple to process your payments -- you're paying 3% for that, apparently. Not really a surprise since that's what every other CC processor charges but now we know. The rest is a sales commission, always has been. If you read any of the documents for the Apple/Epic lawsuit you can see exactly that. You want to reach iOS users and sell to them on Apple's land, that's the price. You wanna sell stuff to players in your Xbox game, 30%. You wanna sell stuff to players in your Playstation game, 30%. The service they're selling is stalls in their market that gets a lot of foot traffic.
- consp 5y agoIt's a bit late in the discussion but basically they are saying at most 3% is cost , and emphasis on "at most". The rest is just profit or legal requirements (and thus not counted to loss).
- kybernetyk 5y agoThat seems very deserved. Not.
- aspenmayer 5y agoA reminder: the original app store on iOS was saurik’s Cydia. App Store wasn’t even on iPhone 2G at launch. Cydia is free and open source. Hopefully saurik can clarify the commission for paid apps on Cydia, but something tells me it isn’t 27%.
- sva_ 5y agoI know that Apple's Terms say that you can't explain to your users, that they have to pay some 30% "Apple Tax" for in-app purchases. But could you just say something like "30% mobile phone app fee", to go around it, while making it clear to the user why they're paying this amount? I feel like it would be illegal for Apple (or Google Play) to prohibit developers from breaking down costs like that? Like I don't get it.
- smoldesu 5y agoFortnite did this, which lead to them being removed from the App Store shortly thereafter. [0] https://www.ithinkdiff.com/fornite-mega-drop-offers-discounts-up-to-20-on-ios-and-android/ https://www.ithinkdiff.com/fornite-mega-drop-offers-discount...
- gjs278 5y ago
- lolinder 5y agoThey do prohibit developers from breaking down the costs like that. This is the guideline they would cite you for: > 3.1.3 The following apps may use purchase methods other than in-app purchase. Apps in this section cannot, within the app, encourage users to use a purchasing method other than in-app purchase. Yes, it should be illegal for them to prevent you from breaking the cost down, but they have historically interpreted this statement that way.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoIt would benefit Apple if they had to compete with other payment processors. Competition sharpens the product.
- linuxhansl 5y agoSounds like waylaying to me. Hear me out... I can see a reasonable processing fee, and even a reasonable establish-the-purchase fee. Perhaps in the order of - or a bit more than - a credit card. So maybe somewhere between 5 and 15%. (Depends on how much more likely users find an apps through the app-store as opposed to a web search.) Anything above is abusing Apple's market dominating position. Especially because there are no (official) ways to install 3rd party apps on iPhones et al. Just MHO.
- pixl97 5y agoI personally think we should make it state/federal law that the 'store' fee be printed at the time of purchase. So when the person clicks the buy button on the app they get a invoice like Software subscription: 66.66 Apple hostage fee: 33.33 Total: $100
- syspec 5y agoWouldn't that come out to 86.66? 66.66 + (66.66*.30) = 86.658
- YaBomm 5y ago
- ggm 5y agoCalling this a "tax" is a misnomer to give taxes a bad name. It's profit. This is apple making profits to keep or distribute to shareholders. Tax is spent, not accumulated. Tax is for everyone. Apples take on transactions is not a "tax" it's rent. This is apple rent-seeking. I like to call this leeching
- jmull 5y agoWhat people want is to stop being forced to pay Apple’s 15-30%. Alternative payment processors were never going to accomplish that, as this case shows. You can make Apple accept alternative payment processors, but that doesn’t really change the price they set for using their store. Unless you want to abandon a free market economy, a government can’t force a company to provide a certain service at a certain price. Squeeze one spot with regulation and a company will extract more revenue from another. Squeeze everywhere and a company will leave the market. What they should do is force Apple to allow competing stores. Apple can keep it’s 15-30%… if it can compete at that level. If not, it will have to adjust, by either offering something more compelling to developers or charging them less. And if Apple can’t do well enough, and pulls back from its app store, then, well, iPhone users will still have the stores of all those stronger competitors to choose from. We don’t have to wonder what a platform with a competing sources for software looks like. We have a bunch of them, and they seem to work well.
- ericmay 5y ago> What people want is to stop being forced to pay Apple’s 15-30%. Just to be clear developers care about this, not “people”. Vast majority of iPhone users couldn’t care less. Wanna know why? Because the developers have to compete on price and Apple is cutting into their margins. This is Apple vs app developers through and through. If Apple stopped taking a cut there would be no price changes. Developers would just make better margin. Since Apple provides me with a great experience and developers tend to mostly be bad or mediocre, I’ll stick with Apple thank you. > What they should do is force Apple to allow competing stores. No thanks. I like that my grandma who uses Facebook has Apple making sure (within bounds) that they aren’t doing shady stuff, and that they have to state what they use data for and confirm permissions routinely. > We don’t have to wonder what a platform with a competing sources for software looks like. We have a bunch of them, and they seem to work well. If it’s the best model you don’t need government intervention because it’ll just win out. If Apple’s “monopoly” on the App Store is that bad people will buy other phones. But the truth is it’s a great model and users love it, which is why Apple crushes sales quarter after quarter. This reminds me of someone recently defending Google doing something on behalf of users. Developers thinking they know what their users want “opt them in to this great feature they previously opted out of” so they can discover it. Same stuff different tune. It’s all business and just rich corporations attacking other rich corporations with no benefit, except that I lose benefits when Apple isn’t in charge.
- nickjj 5y agoPersonally I don't think 15% is that unfair for businesses that make $1 million or less per year which is what Apple charges[0]. If I had a business making $500,000 / year and most of that revenue was through organic sales through the app store's search I would be wildly happy about that and also send yearly gifts of appreciation to Steve Jobs' family. Note to readers: I don't own any Apple products or do mobile app development but I used to be involved with selling courses on certain platforms that take a 50% cut. But, if you were really unhappy about it then the solution is kind of easy on paper. If every developer pulled their apps from the app store in unison and suffered a short term loss then Apple's sales commission would drop to $0 and they would announce a cut in rates probably within 48 hours -- no regulation or competition needed. This strategy works for any marketplace. [0]: https://developer.apple.com/app-store/small-business-program/ https://developer.apple.com/app-store/small-business-program...
- whiddershins 5y agoI get the frustration and even outrage, condemnation, in the comments here. I don’t want to take away from this. I also feel grateful Apple created and maintains an ecosystem where I (for a small fee) develop and distribute applications which build upon libraries and infrastructure that took untold developer hours to make, and untold developer hours to maintain. And I can give this away for free and it’s available to soooooo many people who can carry it around in their hand. Every developer like me is subsidized by every complex scheme Apple uses to extort money from the successful ones. And I’m not sure what to think about that.
- dustinmoris 5y agoI still don't understand why this is so hard to understand: Developers can absolutely develop an app with whichever payment system they want and keep all the income to themselves. Develop a web app and do whatever you want. You integrate with whichever third party systems you want and provide the experience you think is best for your users and yourself. Anyone will be able to use your web app from an iPhone as much as they will be able to use it from a Desktop device. However, if you actively choose to develop a native iOS app in order to integrate with Apple's native APIs in order to provide an experience which can be superior to a web app then it's not a far stretch to expect you to therefore integrate with Apple's native APIs across the board, including payments. I mean that is literally why you choose to develop a native app, because you want to provide EXTRA value to your users by making use of APIs which Apple invested in.
- curt15 5y agoAt least they aren't putting up a pretense of "security"!