21 ms·
The Windows 11 taskbar is an annoying step backward
- jayd16 5y agoI just want the clock on all monitors.
- beAbU 5y agoI have a triple monitor setup and my clock is on all 3? I have it set up that the tray icons (wifi etc) only show on my main display.
- jayd16 5y agoOn windows 11? How?
- rekoil 5y agoThey installed ElevenClock and forgot about it.
- beAbU 5y agoTo be honest, I'm not really sure? I'm going through my settings now and can't find anything. Only multi display setting I have enabled is "When using multiple displays, show my taskbar apps on TASKBAR WHERE WINDOW IS OPEN", under Personalization/Taskbar in the settings app. I definitely don't have 11clock installed as another poster implied (not even sure what that is). I am running an Insider Preview build, so perhaps that's where it comes from. Meaning this is a feature that will Soon Come To a Win11 Desktop Near You!
- rekoil 5y agoFingers crossed!
- RheingoldRiver 5y agoTry qlock? I use it to get Seoul & Berlin clocks in the corner of one monitor (I'm in the US), but sounds like it could work for you if you just duplicated your local time zone on each monitor. http://www.qlock.com/ http://www.qlock.com/
- zanderz 5y agoSo far I find it even worse that 1. You're forced to login with a live account, and 2. IE is banned, no more legacy activeX allowed. I may have to take it off my new laptop and go back to 10
- yuppie_scum 5y agoHe’s mad about the lack of text next to the start menu items. Myself I finally caved and told it to move the start button back to the left corner. It’s just so much easier to flick your wrist back there and click than to figure out where in the center-left it is currently. I did almost get myself wired to hit the actual keyboard start button more though.
- jffry 5y agoI think the worst change with Win11's taskbar is that it _always_ groups multiple windows of the same program behind one icon on the taskbar. So previously you had two+ taskbar items and could easily click on the one you want, now you must click the icon, a menu comes up showing the windows, then click on a window. If you're used to using the taskbar for quick switching like that it's a jarring change.
- racecar789 5y agoHighly recommend 7+ Taskbar Tweaker by Ram Michael. https://ramensoftware.com/7-taskbar-tweaker https://ramensoftware.com/7-taskbar-tweaker
- mmwelt 5y agoFrom the page you linked to: > The tweaker is designed for Windows 7, Windows 8, and Windows 10. Windows 11 probably isn't supported!
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- derimagia 5y agoIt is https://ramensoftware.com/7-taskbar-tweaker-on-windows-11-with-windows-10s-taskbar https://ramensoftware.com/7-taskbar-tweaker-on-windows-11-wi...
- p1esk 5y agoDoes it work with Windows 11?
- vxNsr 5y agoWhile this tool doesn't work with Windows11 it's pretty useful if you're still on Windows 10 (or earlier). Another tool I wholeheartedly recommend is the 7+ Taskbar Numberer [0]. This should be default functionality built into windows but I'm happy that someone took the time to build it. [0] https://ramensoftware.com/7-taskbar-numberer https://ramensoftware.com/7-taskbar-numberer
- derimagia 5y agoI haven't tried it since I don't use Windows 11 but I believe it's supported https://ramensoftware.com/7-taskbar-tweaker-on-windows-11-with-windows-10s-taskbar https://ramensoftware.com/7-taskbar-tweaker-on-windows-11-wi...
- chungy 5y agoMicrosoft did something good with Windows 95. Unfortunate they never managed to improve on it.
- s0rce 5y agoI think Windows 2000 was a big improvement over 95/98. XP was decent. 7/8 was ok and seems to be going in random directions now.
- mulmen 5y agoVista and 8 were unmitigated disasters. ME was apparently "misunderstood"? So it's more of a cycle than a trend.
- rekoil 5y agoYou gotta fuck shit up every now and again to take the easy victories when you unfuck what you previously fucked.
- userbinator 5y agoI think the parent was mainly talking about the UI. Almost all of the classic Windows UI was there in '95, and minor improvements were released with each new version up until ~Vista-7 when they started destroying it.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Ostrogodsky 5y agoNah, at least for me the best improvements have been: 98>95>XP,all the rest have been minimal or total disasters.
- VladimirGolovin 5y agoWindow snap is absolutely an improvement.
- 5y ago
- farmin 5y agoI am mad about how slow the search is now. I used to press window button, start typing first few letters of app of choice hit enter and it would open. Now it takes like 3 seconds for the search to start and by muscle memory I've hit enter now before its even warmed up and for whatever reason ends up doing a web search.. That alone Makes me want to quit Windows.
- a_t48 5y agoCounterpoint - I don't have this issue, it's nice and snappy for me, without even any registry tweaks to disable web search (though now that you mention it, I should).
- aeternum 5y agoSeems like a lot of things can cause this issue, additional hard-drives that are in sleep state, networked drives in sleep, internet search. It's actually a tough design choice with any multi-channel search: Do you start displaying results from the first sources available or do you wait until all sources have reported in? If you wait you get latency, but if you try to stream results the order/top result can change which is jarring to the user and creates UX race conditions.
- vimsee 5y agoIt should be a non issue. Index the installed apps in the start menu search and make these appear in the search result. I want to be able to press Win-key -> type "fi" -> press nter to open Firefox. On MacOS and all Linux distros I`ve every tried, it works flawlessly. For other (more advanced) search mechanisms, implement these in a designated search option in the taskbar, startmenu, standalone etc. This means that Microsoft needs to abandon Bing and whatever telemetry they can gather from the user in the start menu search making this unlikely to be the reality going forward.
- mulmen 5y agoCan't they just upload the search asynchronously? Why do they have to block the user?
- sixothree 5y agoWindows 11 would be a better product if their vision was communicated to users somehow. As it stands windows 11 is something that “happens to you”.
- CRConrad 5y agoSeems like that is Microsoft's "vision".
- laserbeam 5y ago> Note: When you purchase something after clicking links in our articles, we may earn a small commission. Ok. This article is actually an ad for a 5$ tool that does something to your taskbar. No thank you.
- aeternum 5y agoThe article has sufficient content to stand on its own. I learned useful information and at the end they provide the $5 as a potential solution, but it's not even the author's recommended solution. If this article were just an ad, why not recommend only the tool?
- p1esk 5y agoWhat’s your problem? They recommended three different tools, one of which is free. I’ll gladly pay 5 bucks for a good product.
- laserbeam 5y agoThey did recommend different tools, that's my bad for not noticing it. I do feel that it's a vert shallow read into the windows 11 task bar, and that it only really talks about the labels being gone, and icons being centered (which is configurable). The rest of the content is mostly hostory that has little to so with the actual subject. There's no mention of other regressions (people complaining about weather being gone, not being able to move taskbar away from the bottom of the screen, right click menu being basically empty), no discussion about how those were or were not fixed. No discussion about improvements to the old task bar (I don't know if any exist). The choice to focus solely on titles being gone, and on mentioning somewhat related history suggests that its a pretty rough write made for that 5$ fix, and suggests to me that the fix is incomplete and doesn't solve the rest of the problems. The fix may be good, it may solve other issues, I have no problem with paying for stuff. But I do feel like I've read just a shallow article written with that purpose in mind. To drop the paid tool at the end.
- procarch2019 5y agoI have to admit, as someone who rarely uses the Start button (everything from keyboard) I’ve noticed little difference between 11 and 10. I’ve only left the defaults because nothing has bothered me because I just don’t use it. Thankfully they didn’t change the Win+x commands. My biggest gripe with Win 11 is the stability. Reminds me of the early days of Win 10. Periodic blue screens on sleep and sometimes on boot. Maybe it’s my hardware, but I doubt it. I was just given this laptop by IT and it didn’t come with Win 10 restore media, so this is what I have now.
- esalman 5y agoWin11 is yet to crash on me. However I had this weird bug when the last update disabled my laptop keyboard (Lenovo Legion 5). I actually reset Windows a couple of times before figuring out that uninstalling and reinstalling the particular update (along with installing an optional laptop firmware update) was the solution. Overall it was pretty annoying and time-wasting.
- vyrotek 5y agoMy #1 issue with Windows 11 is not being able to un-group my taskbar items. I found having multiple instances of apps open across multiple monitors was extremely painful after using it ungrouped for so many years. And the little dot provided to indicate an open app is worthless. I resorted to StartAllBack to fix it. Everything else has been generally fine for me. So disappointed. There are several highly voted feedback posts and comments about the taskbar but I don't think I've seen anyone at MS acknowledge any of it. (Main suggestion is currently at 11k votes. https://aka.ms/AAeyt69 https://aka.ms/AAeyt69) And as if that wasn't enough, sometimes just clicking the taskbar item does nothing. It can sometimes take several clicks to get it to re-open an app. https://twitter.com/vyrotek/status/1461748895906553856 https://twitter.com/vyrotek/status/1461748895906553856
- AndroidKitKat 5y agoI had this same issue, but the only way I have found is to use something like Explorer Patcher [0], but it "solves" the problem by just replace the Win11 bar with the one from Win10 [0]: https://github.com/valinet/ExplorerPatcher https://github.com/valinet/ExplorerPatcher
- grimgrin 5y agoThis is incredible, thank you for linking. You run it, display instantly looks better, and has a very nicely laid out set of features to play with Even things like the WiFi flyout (a term I didn't know) can be changed: https://i.imgur.com/JHVvzPG.png https://i.imgur.com/JHVvzPG.png Appears its author even dedicated a blog post specifically to this: https://valinet.ro/2021/11/18/Functional-Windows-10-flyouts-on-Windows-11.html https://valinet.ro/2021/11/18/Functional-Windows-10-flyouts-...
- esalman 5y agoThe article actually mentions ExplorerPatcher too. I experimented with several taskbar replacements and this is by far the best imo.
- vyrotek 5y ago
- jonpalmisc 5y agoCheap shot, but: just the taskbar? Everyone likes to complain about privacy, telemetry, etc. in Windows. I’d rather have a Windows 7 with telemetry than Windows 11 with no telemetry. Every Windows release just becomes actively more annoying to use.
- emkoemko 5y agoyup after being so annoyed and seeing how well Gnome looks i installed Linux and have not used Windows since, no more forced updates that take forever, printers work without doing anything, no spyware everywhere, no advertising in my menus, no forced applications like candy crunch and the other crap it auto installed that i never wanted, only thing is GIMP UX/UI is horrible but found out about Darktable and that's 100x more capable then Adobe Lightroom
- tentacleuno 5y ago> printers work without doing anything Any anecdotes? I have one: I've had this HP printer for years now. It's one of the... cheaper models that's more geared towards younger people (the app-downloading crowd). Anyway, that printer just would not work on Windows without installing some form of adware from HP. I tried everything, every obscure menu I could find to get the printer working. They really wanted me to put this thing on my network. On Linux, well... I plugged it in. And that's it. Software picks it up, works amazingly. I couldn't believe my eyes when it instantly recognised it.
- marcodiego 5y agoMy view of the taskbar: use it to launch your apps. Alternate between them using alt+tab, if there are too many, use another desktop and move your similar apps there. In my view, if you're using the taskbar for more than that, you're using your computer in a suboptimal way.
- userbinator 5y agoAre you being sarcastic!? I have over 40 separate buttons in my taskbar right now, which is 3 rows high. I can see all their names and select the one I want with a single glance and click. How else do you propose being able to do that?
- spikej 5y agoHeck, I still use the QuickLaunch toolbar. First thing I do when I get a new machine/OS is enable this: https://www.tenforums.com/tutorials/4624-add-remove-quick-launch-toolbar-windows-10-a.html https://www.tenforums.com/tutorials/4624-add-remove-quick-la...
- VladimirGolovin 5y agoDragging and dropping a file onto a taskbar app icon is often much faster than 1) opening the app, 2) selecting File > Open from the menu, 3) browsing to the file location, and 4) double-clicking the file.
- mulmen 5y agoI use desktops as workspaces. You know, for work. That means I have the same apps open in multiple workspaces at the same time. A web browser and a terminal in almost all of them. Grouping apps by workspace is like having different rooms for screwdrivers and wrenches.
- ianai 5y agoI’d have read it without the user hostile website.
- crate_barre 5y agoThe ultimate step backward was that you can’t move the taskbar to right or left or top anymore. It can only remain on the bottom.
- userbinator 5y agoThe strange trend of "authoritarian minimalism" design that seems to be working its way through the majority of newer software is very strange. I wonder who actually wants this stuff, and is not content to merely make it a default, but instead forces it to be the one and only way. Monitors are bigger than ever with huge resolutions, and yet UIs are being dumbed down to uselessness and alienating an increasing number of users. A recent related article https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29954266 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29954266 seems to indicate that not even people inside Microsoft --- who are being forced to use Win11, because MS --- have any say in the matter. It's almost like some tiny extremist faction has gained control of Windows and is determined to show everyone else how much power they have by making these changes and gloating sadistically at seeing everyone object, but still end up using Windows. I wonder how much damage they will inflict before people start turning to WINE and a saner Linux distro, just to run their Windows applications.
- spikej 5y agoGotta make use of those full-time UI people somehow... sigh.
- spaetzleesser 5y ago"authoritarian minimalism" Can we blame this on Apple?
- epistasis 5y agoI think we can blame it on a poor imitation of what Apple does. However even Apple has copied the atrocious flat UI fashion that has destroyed the ability of users to decipher what can be interacted with, and how. If I have to deal with another goddamned toggle that has reinvented the wheel and in so doing destroyed the ability to decipher the current state and what toggling will cause to happen... well I'll be very unhappy and then continue to eat the dog food because I have no other choice.
- BLKNSLVR 5y agoOk, so this light grey text and toggle means it's not selected, I assume? Click. Oh, the text has now changed to the other option and the toggle is green, so that means the text is telling me what option is actually currently selected, whilst the toggle colour indicates which option the system thinks is equivalent to 'on'. Yep, many interfaces I've come across require me to interact with the toggle to work out what the current setting is.
- leppr 5y ago> Why did Microsoft remove so much functionality for an OS designed for work? Because it's not designed for work, it's a launcher for video games.
- execat 5y ago> launcher for video games Probably not, otherwise there would be a lot more panic regarding SteamDeck, SteamOS, and Proton within Microsoft.
- jiggawatts 5y agoLoL wut? Microsoft has completely ignored the Window PC gaming market recently and is focusing 99% of their efforts on Xbox. They occasionally back-port things from Xbox to Windows... and then neglect to document the backported APIs or give anyone access at all. For example, the killer new feature of Xbox Series X is "DirectStorage", whereby the GPU can access NVMe devices directly for incredible IOPS and throughput. They "added" this to windows: https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/gaming/gdk/_content/gc/system/overviews/directstorage/directstorage-white-paper https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/gaming/gdk/_content/gc/syst... To quote: "Access to this topic requires membership in an NDA developer program. Contact your publisher or your Xbox program representative if you need direct access. Not in the program? Read about joining the ID@Xbox program to gain access today!" Translation: "This is not for you PC-only game developer, only Xbox matters, ask permission from the Xbox team and assure them you won't take market share away from them." That's just the tip of the iceberg. A Windows 10 update a few years ago broke HDR gaming for a huge range of PCs out there, and it has been broken even worse in Windows 11. Just some of the madness that affects me even on a brand-new, high-end gaming laptop with Windows 11: - If you have a discrete NVIDIA GPU with a recent laptop that has a HDR screen, all DirectX applications & games using the NVIDIA card will report HDR support as "N/A" for the primary screen. There is no workaround. - In Windows 11 RTM, monitor gamuts (and all applications) are forced to sRGB and SDR even on a wide-gamut OLED screen with 100% AdobeRGB coverage and full HDR support. External HDMI-connected televisions (like with Xbox!) work as expected, but that's the writing on the wall: Microsoft tests HDR onlybwith Xbox, not with Windows. - If you accidentally leave HDR enabled and your laptop goes to sleep, the primary display won't turn on at all when you resume from sleep and you have to power-cycle your computer. Obviously HDR "support" was only tested in the context of external TVs just like with Xbox, and was probably done only by the Xbox team. The Windows team literally does not test this scenario or apply bugfixes despite thousands of Feedback Hub comments. - If you change your monitor "brightness" slider, the reported MaxFALL in HDR mode will change, which makes no sense because it's the physical monitor hasn't magically gained new abilities. Worse, it's backwards: At max brightness SDR apps run with an eye-searing 450 nits, but HDR apps and games will think the maximum display output is just 113 nits and will look completely distorted and washed out (darker than SDR!). Conversely, reducing the brightness will lie to HDR games and report ludicrous maximum brightness levels like 48,000 nits which will clip everything to maximum white, even shadows. - I'm probably missing a few...
- arrty88 5y agoWindows trying to become Mac and MacOS is trying to become more like windows
- senectus1 5y agoright click -> Taskbar Settings -> Taskbar behaviors ->Taskbar alignment -> Left. There ya go. fixes one of the problems, no patch needed.
- fomine3 5y agoI'm fine with combined taskbar. It's great feature inspired from OSX but option shouldn't be removed for others. I'm angry about removal of vertical taskbar. Aside from taskbar, start menu is worst one in last decade. I didn't use Win7 start menu because it can't manage favorite apps with category well. I used random free launcher at that time. I liked Win8 start screen except fullscreen, because it can be categorized by user well. Win10 is obviously the best ever. I think Win11 start menu is drawback to Win7, with annoying recommend features.
- Osiris 5y agoMy side project is BatteryBar, which uses the IDeskBand interface to show a bigger battery status display on the taskbar. I found out that Windows 11 was being broadly distributed because I started getting dozens of support tickets a day asking why it stopped working after they upgraded to Windows 11. Unfortunately the new taskbar doesn't expose any interfaces to officially be able to display anything on the taskbar, which is unfortunate.
- schrodinger 5y agoThat is a terribly annoying website with their popups.
- tonymet 5y agoIt's a general design trend, most egregious on motor vehicles. the UI is designed to sell the product, not to empower the user. Cars have gaudy touch displays or ridiculous bedazzling arrays of lights and widgets. It looks amazing during the testdrive but unusable during the commute. See also exercise equipment, kitchen appliances (large & small), AV equipment, etc. In Windows 11's case it makes great demo screens but terrible productivity.
- quickthrower2 5y agoYou made me think of which appliances. I am happy with most but the ones I hate are the smart tv (cannot turn on without remote!) and bosch oven (awful sticky spinning wheel interface for doing everything), despite them being otherwise good products. Hang the blessed UX!
- tonymet 5y agoMy washer and dryer have non-tactile keys that require long-presses. Same for the oven. Fridge has an LED screen that lights up the kitchen at night (why?). Also non-tactile. Over time I find myself pressing my body-weight into the buttons. Also small appliances like pressure cookers, air-friers have gaudy LEDs with non-tactile buttons, and irritating charms. Now for a positive example: my italian Gaggia Espresso machine : 3 large rocker switches and 2 status LEDs. It could easily be operated by touch alone. And I expect it to last 30 years with adequate maintenance. And besides the mechanism, no extraneous noises whatsoever.
- quickthrower2 5y agoItalian espresso machines are nice that way. Even the breville which I have has is reasonable. It is just pressing regular buttons, no fancy touch screens. Since you are on HN / espresso intersection I guess you know about all the mods. Someone made a PID for it you can build yourself.
- ahonhn 5y agoMy microwave has two mechanical knobs. One controls the power, the other the time. Although one of the cheapest models it was hard to actually find a microwave like this. I had to shop around a lot. All the other models I saw have dozens of buttons and promise to cook 9999 different exotic recipes to perfection. My friends & relatives who own these technological marvels will cook stuff by standing in front of them pressing the "1 Minute Reheat" button every minute for n minutes because anything more makes programming the Apollo Landing Computer seem in comparison an exercise in simplicity.
- onphonenow 5y agoHere I was thinking I was the only one being driven insane
- BLKNSLVR 5y agoStaying true to the slogan: "Windows 10: the last version of Windows you'll ever need".
- mcswell 5y agoMy gosh, that is the best comment here!!!!!
- rawoke083600 5y agoHaha
- mcswell 5y agoBut...but...but...rounded corners! All seriousness aside, for a decade or more I've kept my Windows task bar over on the left-hand side of the screen, precisely because I can see words to describe what each running app is, rather than hieroglyphics and maybe a few letters (my main monitor is vertical, so not so much space along the bottom for full words). I guess this is another reason I don't want Win11.
- gigel82 5y agoI bought Start11 but the "StartMenuHost.exe" was still running in the background, taking about 80Mb of RAM and doing random web requests, I had to takeown the directory and physically remove the file, because it was being restarted by a system service even if you killed the process. They still have a thing called "TextInputHost.exe" which takes about 90Mb of RAM and if you kill it all store apps (including Terminal) stop taking keyboard input. It too makes network requests but I can't get rid of it, so had to firewall it instead. But that's just nasty AF: keyboard input works just fine in win32 applications, so you clearly don't need a resident 90Mb network-connected process to get it to work in UWP, you're just being sneaky...
- aresant 5y agoI would pay for a new copy of Windows every year if they would 1) - Not change anything in Ux, permissions, or core functionality 2) - Make any new features - like Windows Mixed Media - a la carte add ons - heck even charge for them let the market speak 3) Focus on optimizing kernel, responsiveness, compatibility, and privacy transparency Too much to ask but honestly it would be amazing.
- fsflover 5y agoLooks like Debian or PopOS would fit you perfectly.
- tentacleuno 5y ago> Make any new features - like Windows Mixed Media - a la carte add ons - heck even charge for them let the market speak Aren't they still charging for the DVD player on Windows? They've been doing that since either 8 or 10, and there's been a pretty consistent chain of outcry about it.
- jiggawatts 5y agoTo get modern media working, you have to separately download the HEVC codecs, the HEIF codecs, Dolby Vision, Dolby Audio, and I think I'm missing something I forgot. 4K BluRay support is gone permanently because they dropped the DRM component from Windows 11.
- TheRealSteel 5y agoHaving the Windows button move left and right based on how many programs you have open was an insane, illogical design regression that was only greenlit because of a "copy Apple at all costs" design philosophy
- Lendal 5y agoYou can change it back to left-aligned. It was the first thing I did after upgrading. After that, the only difference on the taskbar is the Windows logo now has a gradient on it whereas in Windows 10 it was just a plain white logo. As for the text labels the article is complaining about, I know what he's referring to but I haven't used the feature in so many years I can't make myself sympathize. Just get over it. A full-page article about one missing feature, and then tried to generalize it to sound like the whole OS was similarly bad. But only one example was provided to support the generalization. I'm more disappointed in this article than I am with Windows 11.
- Krasnol 5y agoIt's a full-page article because it's so relevant to the user. Therefore it's not relevant how many problems there are it they are big enough.
- murermader 5y agoI do not get your attitude? Why should users "get over it"? Windows 11 is an operating system that should help its users complete tasks. Removing functionality (that is used by many) makes abosolutely no sense. Many people have a lot of windows open, and many of them of the same app (not unusual to have 5+ explorer windows open). Not being able to directly click on the right one is a big loss. Just because you don't do work that requires that kind of feature, does not mean that other people don't need it either.
- anttiharju 5y agoOne thing I've noticed when people complain about Windows 11 UI changes is they don't seem to use keyboard shortcuts. For example, Kliksphilip (youtuber) complained about things being difficult to rename. Considering that he seemed to do a lot of renaming it seemed baffling he didn't know the F2 shortcut. Know your tools. Admittedly it's terrible for your cursor muscle memory to have the start menu button shift around, but most keyboards have a dedicated button for opening it. Why not use it? I know I might be in the minority here, but I vastly prefer the start menu popping up in the middle of the screen instead of the corner. That way I don't need to turn my head / redirect my gaze as much. Although I get it. Most people just want to work the way they've been working and treat changes to their workflow with hostility. And of course taking choice away from users ("authotarian minimalism" as some comment here put it) is a bad thing. Many of my friends liked to have a vertical taskbar and I'd imagine they're not happy taskbar repositioning being removed from Windows 11. edit: formatting
- duxup 5y ago> But the more distressing change is that it’s no longer possible to actually see the title text of window items People want text on those icons? (That’s not to say I disagree that windows design is a mess)
- CRConrad 5y agoYup. Used it like that since... Approximately forever. (i.e, at least this century.)
- RheingoldRiver 5y agoYes, I have multiple monitors and a vertical taskbar (on the left side of my rightmost monitor) that's almost 300px wide, ungrouped icons, and I can read the names of all my windows. Makes it very easy to find the exact right IDE/text editor project when I have like 7 open at a time. Obviously not for everyone, but also obviously a totally valid use case that should be supported.
- mcswell 5y agoI do the same. The only drawback is that when I move my mouse to some app's control over near the left-hand side of my left-hand monitor, it's likely to overshoot and bring up the task bar/ start menu. I'd be happy just using <Ctrl><Esc> to bring it up, and dispense with its mouseability entirely. But that doesn't appear to be a choice, even in older versions of Windows.
- mcswell 5y agoI want to see text INSTEAD of those icons. Icons went out with hieroglyphics, and I'm not sure why they've come back.
- 1970-01-01 5y agoMS continues it's pattern: 2000 - good Me - bad XP - good Vista - bad 7 - good 8 - bad 10 - good 11 - bad For Windows 12 we will cycle to "good" UI.
- thanatos519 5y agoSo ... like Star Trek movies?
- mackrevinack 5y agoits actually kind of fascinating. i get how someone can be consistently bad at doing something, but how is it that someone can be consistently bad every second time? it just doesn't make sense!
- lazypenguin 5y agoI would bet there’s a correlation with changes to internal teams. Specifically the people who made it good leaving and new people coming in who ruin it.
- antisthenes 5y agoExcept 10 is not good. And you missed 8.1, which was and still is decent. > For Windows 12 we will cycle to "good" UI. Unlikely.
- tonyedgecombe 5y agoXP was getting plenty of complaints when it was released. Then they had to stop new development and concentrate on making it secure in SP2.
- Semaphor 5y agoI use StartAllBack for the vertical taskbar. On a dual-monitor setup, I want the taskbars centered between the monitors and not waste valuable space. Without StartAllBack, I’d have stayed on 10. I can’t understand why anyone would want a horizontal taskbar unless they are using portrait mode (or have a lot of icons). Most other things I’m fine with. The Start menu is better than in 10 (not that it matters, I use Keypirinha as launcher), I don’t need text for my icons, and I can easily see which Windows have multiple instances. Overall, I like the changes in 10 (again with the caveat of needing a 3rd party tool to fix the taskbar).
- slategruen 5y agoMaybe it's their second shot to enter once again in the tablet operating system market? Seeing how Android-based tablets aren't really getting as solid nor as popular as iPads, Microsoft might spin off a new tablet experience but now more slowly compared to Windows 8. I might be one of the few noticing it but Apple is also dabbling on trying to replace a desktop/laptop with a tablet with their M1-powered iPad Pro. I also know a hand few of people who now prefer an iPad (usually including an Apple Pencil) from a laptop, more specifically students.
- encryptluks2 5y agoMost of the opinions here are entirely subjective, including mine. I personally find all versions of Windows to be annoying and suck which is one of the reasons I switched to Linux and now use Sway and a minimalist launcher named wofi, with Waybar. Not only is Sway, wofi, and Waybar incredibly lightweight but it goes to show how much unnecessary bloat there is on Windows.
- scotty79 5y agoI was so sad when during development of windows 10 microsoft replaced very functional start menu which was very good incremental refinement of windows 7 start menu with monstrous seed of start menu we currently have. Windows 10 is absolutely wonderful but start menu is such a lost opportunity for having something useful in that spot.
- tentacleuno 5y agoI'm confused. Didn't they remove it in 8, too?
- scotty79 5y agoThey did. Windows 8 menu was horrible too. When they started making 10 they initially used start menu more similar to 7 than to 8.
- glennpratt 5y agoI'm one of the few who couldn't care less. I just want it hidden, same with the dock on macOS. Use the keyboard to launch and switch apps.
- lopatin 5y agoWere there any improvements in Windows 11, or just regressions? It's an actual question. I'm looking for anyone here who's life was improved by the upgrade.
- Lendal 5y agoThe Windows logo has a gradient on it now instead of plain white. The corners of all windows are now rounded, (but they've had rounded corners before so not that new). The tiles are finally gone, and that's growing on me. The Settings interface is much improved. The window-docking feature is improved: If you set up a layout of several docked app windows, you can then treat that group of apps as one big window which you can then minimize and restore as a unit, which is very useful. That's about it for the changes. Overall I find it a net positive. What I worry about is this: If Microsoft used all their telemetry-gathering powers to determine that very few people used this now-missing feature, and that's why they removed it, that's a bad reason. I don't agree with removing features just because few people use them or didn't complain loudly enough during the beta. As a power user, I'm sure I rely on features that few "common people" use, and I'm sure eventually the rug will be pulled out from under me if Microsoft continues to remove features that only 2% of users rely on.
- bmitc 5y agoI have always preferred Windows' hard-edged corners. How do the rounded corners work for graphics oriented windows?
- CRConrad 5y agoOn most apps they probably affect only the "furniture", the GUI elements around the actual working "client area". So you'd have rounded corners on the title bar at the top and the satus bar at the bottom, and a sharp-cornered area with your acual content inside those.
- rk06 5y agoNow, it is easier to have stacked windows. Say you have 3-4 windows, and want them stacked. If you hover mouse over the maximise button, you get option to have a special layout. Also, it put the final nail IE11’s coffin. Since Win 11 does not support it. I can’t say anything else is better or even worth upgrading given downsides
- deltaonefour 5y agoWhenever I see articles like this, I think of "new coke." https://www.damninteresting.com/the-american-gustation-crisis-of-1985/ https://www.damninteresting.com/the-american-gustation-crisi... Coca Cola modified and replaced their flagship product with a better product. It was proven to be statistically better in taste tests. But the product "new coke" ultimately became a failure. "In retrospect, some marketers believe that the failure of New Coke may have had something to do with sensation transference, a human oddity first described by Louis Cheskin in the 1940s. Cheskin demonstrated that people will unconsciously associate imagery, sounds, tastes, aromas, and textures into their general impression of a product, even if such associations are unintended or inaccurate. These sensory inputs create a halo effect which actually modifies flavor perception, so while cola drinkers may have preferred the new Coke formula, they may have disliked the “taste” of the redesigned packaging. Even Gay Mullins —the man who tried to sue to restore the old flavor —showed a preference for New Coke when subjected to blind taste tests" I wouldn't be surprised if windows UI/UX designers used statistics to verify the improvements of the windows UI changes. Despite this, consumer psychology always has a way of causing literally almost every major change to any popular product (that is on par with coca cola) be a "debacle" of epic proportions. I see it on every change to OSX, iOS, windows... all consumers are always flabbergast declaring out loud: "What were they thinking!??" You guys remember when touch screen keyboards were a "debacle"? Nobody could type on that shit back then. It was a royal fuck up. Now everybody types on them. Inevitably there will be someone who replies to me insisting that it's worse due to some personal yet convincing anecdotal experience. But until you take the UI equivalent of a blind taste test I'm not sure if this is sensation transference or an actual real rational judgement.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- picture 5y agoIn the case of UI/UX though, isn't the "packaging" exactly what's being sold? UI/UX that looks bad and is hard to use means just that
- deltaonefour 5y ago
- Pxtl 5y agoFirst thing I do on every PC is change taskbar to small icons with text, remove grouping, and stick it to the left edge of the screen. Not okay about losing this.
- pentae 5y agoSurprised nobody is mentioning that they are making it look more like the MacOS taskbar so it looks more friendly and approachable for new users who have grown up using smartphones and tablets
- cblconfederate 5y agowhy does everything have to look like phones
- speedgoose 5y agoBecause many users have learnt to use a phone first and not a desktop computer from the last millennia.
- cblconfederate 5y agoLooks like i will be skipping 11
- baybal2 5y agoI think they are trying to copy MacOS
- adam_arthur 5y agoThe fact that you can't anchor it to the side blows my mind. Also that the bar takes up the whole screen width, which is quite poor UX for an ultra wide monitor. I did put in some feature requests to address!
- ec109685 5y agoWindows is so darn glitchy. Even simple things like play Microsoft Flight Simulator using your GamePass subscription flat out doesn’t work because downloads infinitely paused (lots of fixes on internet that don’t work). No File Explorer icon by default nor hard drive icon on desktop, so no way to access a particular file without knowing command. Games don’t run without typing in admin password each time, etc. Surprised things aren’t more refined by now.
- systemvoltage 5y agoEver since the term 'UX/UI' was invented, the field of Design went to shit.
- WeekSpeller 5y agoYou want to decrease volume? In windows 10 it was 2 clicks, now it's 3 also you have to locate the slider because there are more than one slider in that area now.
- Raphael 5y agoYes, I distinctly remember a single click followed by scrollwheel. Now the wheel does nothing.
- shmerl 5y agoLinux + KDE for anyone who wants a better experience.
- BatteryMountain 5y agoMy issues with it: The taskbar is a mess (no more right click -> Task Manager). The right-click context menu is a mess, since all my useful shortcuts are hidden away. The file-copy dialog crashes with big folders (it cannot get through a 300gb folder without crashing). BitLocker control panel -> takes you back to new settings view for Device Encryptions, which says you must login for it to work, or click the button for advanced setting, which takes you back to control panel which say you must go to settings........... The OS is still in beta.
- rbreaves 5y agoEhhh.. there are 3rd party tools free and commercial that fix the taskbar so it can go back to the sides if you want. Windows 11 really isn't that bad at all - although I'd rather they have simply fixed Dark Mode in Windows 10 than to go through this exercise and yet still somehow miss important bits all through out the OS in terms of Dark Mode once again. I was hopeful they fixed it, but they didn't. Finally just decided to make Linux my new home and remote into Windows from there. Pretty well just cutting macOS out of my life entirely, although I have reserved the ability to remote into macOS seamlessly as I do with Windows more or less. I can careless what happens on any OS - I can switch btwn them all with relative ease and no hotkey weirdness as this point due to my personal project (kinto.sh).
- rvba 5y ago> there are 3rd party tools free and commercial that fix the taskbar Most employees cannot install anything on their company computers.
- 015a 5y agoI'm happy that one can, at least, change the default centered bar to left-aligned. There was an early beta where this was not the case. I can imagine, if I was using a tablet, I'd probably prefer it centered, and I guess its "new" that way, which looks better in screenshots, so I wouldn't really complain. The single inexplicable change, to me, is not only the removal of labeled windows (which is annoying, but bearable): its the removal of separated, non-grouped windows. You have to hover over the application with multiple windows, to make the popup appear, to switch the active window. Or alt-tab. Its how MacOS behaves (with non-minimized windows)! Its how Gnome3/Ubuntu behaves (iirc)! And its baffling! I don't know how anyone, let alone every major operating system vendor, has come to the conclusion that the best way to handle the insanely common use-case of having multiple windows open, is to force the user into not just another click, but a hover. Heck, I'm fine with it being the default; just give me an option to enable it. It really is my only major complaint about Win11 right now. Which is, I suppose praise. Taskbar search is obscenely slow after the computer has been inactive for a bit; search has always been slow, but it also took a step backward (Ryzen 5800x? 64gb of memory? 2TB gen4 nvme drive? just heading off the low-hanging fruit if any Windows engineers are reading this; its not my computer, its your code). That's roughly it; its a fine OS. But; its still painful. Not just because the functionality is missing, but more-so because their insistence on authoritarian design makes me, a customer, feel unwelcome. Its hard to make things configurable; but you have a billion users. You can't dictate one experience that works for everyone, despite whatever the macbook-toting designers say. Even asking customers doesn't work because if you make a change that angers 0.1% of your userbase, that's a million people. So, just... keep things configurable.
- dt3ft 5y agoDesigners strike again. They have what, two applications open? One for illustrator, another is the browser. Maybe one more for outlook. Of course they don’t see the need for any of this crucial functionality.
- chaostheory 5y agoIs this because there’s a finite amount of screen real estate? I wonder how OS UIs will evolve once VR is mainstream since there is a lot more screen real estate within VR?
- mastazi 5y agoAnother regression in Win 11: no clock on multiple screens. Watching a video or playing a game full screen on your main screen, and want to check what time is it on another screen? Though luck, you can't. Unless you install an extension for that https://github.com/martinet101/ElevenClock https://github.com/martinet101/ElevenClock
- rekoil 5y agoEvery now and again ElevenClock gets confused and renders the extra clocks offset slightly on my main screen. Generally after screens have been sleeping, GPU driver updates/restarts, etc. Great tool though, works 99% of the time which is good enough for me, love it!
- TrianguloY 5y agoBasically all users I see on Windows 10 have the default taskbar, which means only icons, grouped, the search bar, and those pinned default apps. On Ubuntu it's the same, grouped only icons. On Mac is the same (I think, I don't use Mac). And I don't like it (that's why I'll stick with Windows 10 and then change to KDE)
- rvba 5y agoI wonder if the designers even know how a typical office job looks like. There are still lots of people who open say: 5 budget files from 2022 and from 2021, then few other files and some emails. Then you have to switch between them to try to check things. When items get auto grouped it is an incredible loss of productivity. But I guess Microsoft hired designers who dont do real work, just some basic design in 1 window... on a mac. Go to any office, find an employee who isnt very good at computers (still lots of people like this) and set their taskbar to not auto group (in win 10). They will love you, since now they can easily switch to the window they want. On a side note, windows also now groups windows 11 per program. Before you could see them the way they were opened (say if you open few spreadsheets and few emails the last one would always be last). If is a complete failure of ma agement to hire designers who dont even use windows.
- pjmlp 5y ago> Why did Microsoft remove so much functionality for an OS designed for work? Same question can be applied to the way the whole WinRT/UAP/UWP, .NET Native, C++/CX, C++/WinRT and now WinUI have been managed. They have burned all bridges from those of us that still belived in the project, to the point one must question who is actually managing all these headless chickens running into all possible directions.
- jiggawatts 5y agoI recently set up the dev tooling required to develop a Win UI 3 app. I had some ideas for toy projects that could benefit from being native GUI applications. For example, I was thinking of a Picasa replacement that supported some niceties that I would have liked, such as true HDR photos (10-bit, wide gamut, high brightness). This should be easy, right? As far back as Vista, the WPF framework had 16-bit and even 32-bit per channel wide-color, and HDR UI support. Win UI 3 -- the absolutely latest / next-generation user interface framework for Windows removed all such support, scraping it out of the WPF SDK that it was based on. Everything is SDR, 8-bit, and sRGB only forever now! Meanwhile, Web dev, Macs, TVs, and phones are fairly consistently wide-gamut and HDR capable. The best GUI app I can make for Windows is a web application. No wonder Microsoft themselves use Electron.
- makach 5y agoIf we didn't try new UIs we'd still be punching holes... Progress comes with a price, it always get a little worse before it becomes better. Adapt, improve, repeat.
- bobby1234 5y agoThe whole 11 is an annoying step backwards, first begun with 8.
- bobby1234 5y agoSurely the entire W11 experience is an annoying step backwards in terms of useability, customization options, power-user "empowerment" and in a sense 'ownership' of the computer/experience. This is a journey that MS began with during W8 and continued much further with during the W10 reign. It would not surprise me that the next iteration of Windows there isn't even an admin option and you'll be in a walled garden at the mercy of MS' even more so than now, where you can at least block and disable some things.
- kstenerud 5y agoWindows 95 was a hard changeover for me from Workbench 3.x, but after the initial shock I actually liked it a lot better. Not needing to hold down the right button to select things in the menus, the taskbar itself was amazing after flipping through endless screens using amiga-m and n. Being able to resize the window from any corner. High contrast UI components... It was all leaps and bounds better from a UX perspective. Sadly and disappointingly, Windows 95 was the apex of UX for desktop operating systems. After that, everything on the whole was just in systematic decline. Sure, there are plenty of things that could be improved over Win95, and things that did improve with later OS releases. Unfortunately the other baggage that came with it all wasn't worth the sacrifice. MacOS looks pretty, but there are too many things I hate about how it works because it keeps slowing me down or getting in the way. Now Windows is the same. It feels like we've gone from the renaissance of user interfaces to baroque, and now to unusable minimalist (dare I say brutalist?), all to stroke designer egos. Now I use Mac for work because I can only do certain things on a mac, and Windows for anything I can only do on Windows. But whenever I can get away with it, I just use Mate desktop. It's not the best, but it's fast, gets out of your way, works well with remote desktops, and has most of the important big ticket UI innovations (plus I can spin up hundreds of remote desktops using LXC).
- albrewer 5y ago> Windows 95 was the apex of UX for desktop operating systems I somewhat agree in that the paradigm established and adhered to until it was broken in Vista was the correct way to do it. When drop shadows and thick window borders went away everything got so much harder to use.
- robertlagrant 5y ago> Moving them to the center of the screen is a pointless, but harmless, bit of cosmetics. I think this is probably because the UX people they got to design it all use Macs.
- graycat 5y agoActually, I like Windows, like it a LOT! Hold on ..., some strange circumstances got me to get Windows 10 Home Edition on a laptop computer, and I don't like Windows 10. I don't like the undocumented new behavior or the many updates and changes. Still, I like Windows, but just why and especially how, I will keep a secret so that the how of my secret doesn't get changed! Office? I LIKE Office! I like Excel a little (generally find it easier just to write code in a procedural language than to use Excel) and especially like Outlook. But the version of Office I like is from 2003. Due to a change in SMTP email standards, I will have to upgrade to 2007 Office (from eBay) or some such -- that's on my TODO list. Except for that SMTP change, I'd prefer to stay with Office 2003. I know how to use Office 2003, and I don't want to invest the time, and frustration, especially the frustration, to learn about changes, any changes. To me Office is NOT a very good tool, NOT at all central to my work in computing. I do NOT believe that Microsoft has found any worthwhile changes to Office (except responding to the SMTP changes). Net, I do NOT believe that there is anything about new versions of Office that are worth my time or frustration, especially the frustration, to learn. If I want to do something Office 2003 can't do, then I'm perfectly comfortable writing some procedural code, usually for work there is no hope of ever getting done in anything like Office. E.g., I had a 0-1 integer linear programming problem with 600,000 variables and 40,000 constraints. I found a feasible solution guaranteed to be within 0.025% of optimality, no hope of ever doing that on anything like Office. I see a larger theme: People who have a popular product want it to keep up so work hard to make changes, change or delete old features and add new features. This theme applies quite broadly, e.g., to cars, Windows, Office, women's fashions, suburban single family home architecture, ..., and Web sites. Presumably those people hope, expect, or whatever, that the new version will be better; in fact, too often the new version is worse. Yes, when WiFi, USB, etc. come along, we can need corresponding new functionality -- no question for such cases. But such changes come along only slowly, and changes to user interfaces can happen nearly everyday at nearly every Web site in the world -- biggie issues and questions there. For cars, e.g., I have an old GMC Yukon, in good condition, and it has some dozens, maybe hundreds, of features that seem to need a computer to do the logic. So, the Yukon keeps trying to get my attention with various lights and sounds, new to cars. For the new stuff, I don't want it. Apparently the GMC designers rushed to conclude that with computers there was a lot they could do to manipulate sensor data and generate lights and alarms. COULD they do that? Yes. But SHOULD they do that? Nearly always, NO! Here's a broad example of this theme that has a lot to do with 3+ billion people, literally: Way back there were many, millions, of different paper forms with boxes, places to make check marks, etc. Then there was some user interface work, via both hardware and software, by IBM for their 3270 series of data entry terminals, work that borrowed a lot from such paper forms. Since people understood paper forms, both the programmers and the users found 3270 relatively intuitive and easy to use. Then there were dumb terminals, i.e., asynchronous ASCII, and there were a lot of programs to drive such terminals and that borrowed a lot from 3270. Then there was HTML, and I'm guessing that it borrowed a lot from all of paper forms, 3270, etc. As we know, with HTML there were controls -- single line text boxes, multi-line text boxes, radio buttons, check boxes, push buttons, and links. As I recall, that is all, ALL there was. Want to build a Web page? Okay, are stuck with just those few, simple controls. Now we come to two points: (1) Those controls were so close to, literally, paper forms that they were automatically relatively easy to use. (2) Literally BILLIONS of people, necessarily nearly everyone in the world making use of the Internet, 3+ BILLION people, understood how to use a Web site with Web pages using just those HTML controls. In important respects, the HTML controls, borrowing so much from what worked so well in the past, were VERY well designed. Then with the discipline of just those few, simple HTML controls, every Web page started with a HUGE advantage in user interface ease of use. It was still possible to build an awful user interface, but, just from the discipline, it was also easier, relatively easy, to build a good one! Then we got icons: Since icons essentially need a graphics terminal, couldn't have icons with 3270 or the dumb terminals. So, when we got graphics terminals -- terrific for sketches, pictures, movies, games, PDF files, Zoom, etc. -- we also got icons. BUT: When a new icon is designed, only God and the designer know what it means. Given an icon, can't spell it, type it, pronounce it, easily communicate it, describe its function just from its appearance, sort it with other icons, search for it, look it up in a dictionary, etc. Still, we got lots of icons! We STILL have lots of icons. Civilization HAD icons and then about 2000 years ago made a HUGE step up, the Roman alphabet. Now it dominates communications around the world; a lot of people even in Asia and Russia understand it, and otherwise essentially everyone who can read understands it. Then along came JavaScript (JS): With JS it was possible to build Web pages that ignored the discipline of HTML, have the pages very active, that jump around, have lots of secret functionality, etc. It was possible to have an ocean of new functionality. Alas as we would expect from the theme and history, a LOT of the new functionality was very unwelcome and ruined a LOT of user interfaces. In particular, now each Web page done heavily with JavaScript likely is unique, has to be learned on its own. In simple terms, with just HTML, there were many millions of Web pages relatively easy for billions of people to use right away, and with JavaScript suddenly there were millions of Web pages all different, often poorly designed, and that had to be learned one at a time. E.g., now a single line text box can be invisible until something else happens at which time suddenly the box becomes visible -- the user has to learn this undocumented, unexpected, unprecedented, obscure, bizarre behavior just by experience, frustrating, error-prone experience, uniquely for nearly each such Web page. Nearly always, similarly for icons -- learn by experience. Silicon Valley must have mountains of dedicated, dead ex-Google Web page designers and JavaScript programmers who died miserable deaths trying with all their strength to make massive changes to the first Web page at Google! Instead, Google has kept that page, at least as a user first sees it, both OLD and SIMPLE. I credit 80+% of the Bezos fortune to some discipline, from somewhere at Amazon, for some relatively good and SIMPLE user interface design -- people around the world shop, place orders, and spend their money right away! I would rate the Amazon user interface as in the top 1%, by wide margins, of the shopping Web sites in the world -- we're talking billions of users and about a $trillion in business worth from good, relatively simple Web page design. Net, in short, just because some new technology makes some new feature possible does not alone make that feature good.
- kumarvvr 5y agoMy laptop upgraded to Win 11 recently and I am absolutely annoyed at the new start menu. I loved the one in Win 10. I had all my shortcuts pinned, sized, grouped and arranged and in my 3 years of using it, I never once had to scroll the program list or search to get to a program. I don't understand why MS$ has to mess up what is good. This is definitely 10 steps back, because you can list out things the new menu cant do but the old menu can.
- jjeaff 5y agoI think it works a lot better to just get into the habit of pressing the windows key and start typing the name of the program you want then you just press enter to launch. Once you have the muscle memory, it's so much quicker and you don't usually even have to look at what you are doing.
- itzprime 5y agoThat would require the search to work properly. Search for Device Manager: Dev - Devi - Device - Device Manager (Internet Suggestions). What? Search for Resolve (Da Vinci Resolve) it tries to suggest resolve. I find search in windows is unusable. Windows 11 is slightly better than 10, but not a lot.
- jjeaff 5y agoIt has greatly improved over time with windows 10. Though I do still occasionally have the issue you are talking about. Wox launcher is an excellent replacement and with autohotkey you can replace the function of the windows key to launch wox instead. But windows 10 eventually got good enough that I stopped using wox. For my first several years of using windows 10, search literally did not work at all. And it was apparently a pretty common and very difficult to solve problem according to online searches at the time. But they finally got their act together somewhat. For searching for files, I still use "Everything".
- DiabloD3 5y agoUntil this boneheaded mistake is fixed, we have ExplorerPatcher: https://github.com/valinet/ExplorerPatcher https://github.com/valinet/ExplorerPatcher
- cryptos 5y agoThe worst thing about the new taskbar is that it can not be dragged to the sides to be vertical. On the typical wide sreens we have today (does anyone rember those 4:3 monitors?) it makes a lot of sense to use the height for other things than the taskbar. But there are some more things missing, like the ability to open the task manager from the taskbar.
- emptyfile 5y ago>The worst thing about the new taskbar is that it can not be dragged to the sides to be vertical. What?? I will literally not switch because of this... No, I am not interested in installing 3rd party addons just to have a functional screen in front of me!
- dncornholio 5y agoIt looks exactly like the MacOS taskbar? Why isn't that one getting that much hate?
- marcellus23 5y agoThe macOS dock gets plenty of hate (it’s Apple and this is the internet, just look in this thread). The difference is that the Dock has always been like the Dock. It also exists holistically with all the other design decisions in macOS. Put another way, Windows seems to have copied the superficial appearance of the Dock without the considering _why_ the Dock works in the macOS environment.
- CRConrad 5y agoThe main reason it gets less hate from Apple users is probably the first and shortest one you mention: It's always been like that... So Apple users have nothing to compare to; they cant' know that it could be better.
- marcellus23 5y agoI don't really buy that, tons of people who use macOS come from a Windows background or use Mac at work and Windows at home (or vice/versa). It seems much simpler to me to just assume the Dock actually works.
- dhx 5y agoThe reason why the Windows Start Menu (and GNOME Shell hot corner) should be in the corner of a display is that for people using a mouse, quickly swiping the mouse into a corner doesn't require any skill or precision. Having a hot centre is a terrible idea for anyone using a mouse because you have to carefully move the mouse into the centre of the display with precision and accuracy (typically by swiping to the corner as you used to do, then also moving the mouse to the centre). Hopefully for Windows users there becomes available an ability to freely adjust hot corner/taskbar settings (see this[1] GNOME extension for an example). [1] https://extensions.gnome.org/extension/4167/custom-hot-corners-extended/ https://extensions.gnome.org/extension/4167/custom-hot-corne...
- npretto 5y agoYep, that's because of Fitts’ Law: the time we need to click a button is a function of the distance between the pointer and the button, divided by the area of the button. When the button is in a corner the size is virtually infinite (we can move the mouse all we want in one direction and we'd still be over the button)
- avianes 5y ago> Having a hot centre is a terrible idea for anyone using a mouse because you have to carefully move the mouse into the centre of the display with precision and accuracy. It's even worse than "just" moving the mouse to the centre of the screen, you have to target a position that changes according to the number of applications open.
- athrowaway3z 5y agoI have xfce4 setup with a center bar for years now and your comment made me realize I should just drag it left
- donatj 5y agoIf memory serves, Jef Raskin in “The Humane Interface” made major point about how the 4 corners are the easiest places to click on the screen. Not putting them to good use is just a waste.
- dSebastien 5y agoI hoped that Microsoft would have finally reduced the number of duplicate interfaces in Windows, but on the contrary, there's now more layers than ever. As a long-time Windows user, the UX is truly horrible. I like the visuals, but I hate using Windows 11. The taskbar is just one of the many symptoms of this disease. Just right clicking on files in Explorer is a nightmare. If I want to get to the properties of a file, I need to jump through hoops. This is nuts :)
- kombine 5y agoExactly the same has been happening on the Linux side of things with GNOME, which seemed to remove features with every release until there are just barebones left. They too decided to follow Apple blindly. For this reason I moved to KDE Plasma a long while ago, and apart from a couple of complains I have been quite happy with the configurability.
- llampx 5y agoI recently started working with Windows 11 on my work laptop and am at the verge of asking to switch back to Windows 10. I don't see any user interface improvements, only regressions. Shades of old man shouts at cloud I know, but that's my opinion. For context, I've been using Windows since Windows 95 and MacOS since 10.0.
- herbst 5y agoIt is still just a modernized windows 95 desktop. Not sure why everyone is looking at Microsoft for innovation.
- saturn5k 5y agoSince I started using 11, the only thing that helped me with the frustrations of the new UI was StartIsBack - https://www.startisback.com/ https://www.startisback.com/ This piece of software fixes a lot of the issues that everyone has, especially the taskbar shenanigans and the right click context menus. It is now, for me, an irreplaceable tool for Windows 11.
- pfortuny 5y agoLess is more as a cult in “design”. And because it is a cult, it is always right.
- amelius 5y ago> The Windows 11 taskbar is an annoying step backward Any step is a step backward. I want a UI that is stable.
- matheusmoreira 5y agoGreat, hopefully Microsoft will alienate even more users and they'll switch to Linux instead.
- KWD 5y agoSo this taskbar change, and especially not being able to ungroup icons, will keep me from installing Windows 11 until absolutely necessary. I'm not going to install 3rd party software to meet what is current existing.
- somehnacct3757 5y agoI still can't believe they removed the ability to dock to the side of the screen. Even the Mac taskbar they are trying to emulate can do this. IMO on laptop widescreens, putting the taskbar at the bottom greatly reduces the most precious screen resource - vertical space. This small unnecessary change has made me hate using windows 11
- Yaina 5y agoMy #1 reason why I haven't upgraded yet is because I'm a big fan of the Windows XP/Vista full-size, ungrouped tasks. I'll probably have to upgrade eventually but it's really a bummer that they removed this option.
- cainxinth 5y agoHere’s my question: what possible reason could they have for removing the option for a vertical taskbar? Ultrawide monitors have never been more popular.
- tamiral 5y agomy experience with Win 11 is that it's very buggy and slow. I don't know how you can ship such an awful product.
- Pr0ject217 5y agoI've been gradually switching my desktop over to Linux - it's refreshing. Unfortunately, I still have to run a Windows VM via QEMU so that I can use my Universal Audio interface (no Linux drivers available).
- funOtter 5y agoI've had enough of Windows. I switched to Linux Mint 9 months ago and have not looked back.
- CRConrad 5y agoDamn, Mint is on version 20 or something; why are you using something as old as 9? /jk