28 ms·
Ubisoft deleted account with hundreds of dollars’ worth of games for inactivity
- EarlKing 5y agoLooks like it got hugged to death. It's 403'ing now.
- josephcsible 5y agoIt still loads for me, but anyway, here's an archive link: https://archive.is/HVMwm https://archive.is/HVMwm
- ramijames 5y agoPeople won't like this, but we at Ultra.io are trying to tackle this exact problem by deploying certificates of ownership to a decentralized ledger as proof of your owning a game. AKA, we want to mint NFTs for each game sold, which allows a user to prove they own it. People hate those words, but we think that the tech has real value and a use-case in the market for solving inequity between publishers and users. This nonsense of revoking a license after a user bought it is just an extension of the larger problem that the games that you "buy" you don't actually own and can't do anything with.
- ummonk 5y agoEver heard of a thing called a receipt?
- klodolph 5y agoHow do you restore access if a user's private key is lost or compromised?
- endisneigh 5y agoI'm not sure how this would prevent the scenario the article described.
- josephcsible 5y agoI think the idea is that NFTs aren't deleteable.
- endisneigh 5y agoFrom the article: > Unfortunately, there’s also a clause in the ToS that no credit will be given back to the user in cases of account termination or suspension. The company’s support page also cites the General Data Protection Regulation compliance and freeing database space as the main reason why they delete unused accounts. Again, how would NFTs fix this problem? A solution to the problem described in the article would be a very trivial service that just logs in on behalf of the user at whatever cadence necessary to preserve account "activity", not NFTs... sigh
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bozhark 5y agoDo you think the file is stored in the blockchain?!
- SilasX 5y agoIn theory, sure, it has all the benefits of being immutably on the blockchain. In practice, the whole ecosystem around NFTs is built to trust OpenSea's version of truth, so the records can be manipulated at will. https://twitter.com/moxie/status/1454863786783875075 https://twitter.com/moxie/status/1454863786783875075
- Hamuko 5y agoYou can carve your game purchases onto a stone tablet if you want to, but it doesn't make any difference unless there's someone that actually honors that NFT. Is this "Ultra" going to mint NFTs for my Ubisoft account purchases? If it does, who honors my Ubisoft Store NFTs once Ubisoft terminates my account? Is it Ubisoft, is it Ultra or is it even Steam? And if it doesn't, what is it minting? Stuff I buy on Ultra? Because at that point the NFT might just as well be an email receipt, since I'm now relying on Ultra to actually stay alive and honor my NFTs until I die.
- bozhark 5y agoLovely, way to make a mess of a pile of shit. You solved nothing.
- jokowueu 5y agoBut my receipt proves that i own it . It's just that publishers don't care .
- quest88 5y agoBut it's not ~~decentralized~~.
- bpodgursky 5y agoReceipts aren't proof of ownership in a world where re-selling or trade-ins are possible (as IMO they should be, as they are with physical items).
- BoorishBears 5y agoHow does this help even the tiniest bit? You have proof you own a game and the publisher decides they don't want you to have access anymore... now what?
- caymanjim 5y agoYour idea does nothing to force the service provider to retain your account, or even to provide you with access to the game media. Proof of ownership isn't the issue here. Ubisoft isn't denying that the user purchased those games. They almost certainly know exactly which games were purchased. I more or less trust the game services I use to keep a record of what I own in their central ledger. They could still deny me access, as they're doing here. Maybe some regulation should address this, but I think the market will probably handle it.
- derefr 5y ago> Proof of ownership isn't the issue here. Wouldn't having legal proof of owning a license to an IP, entitle you to then use a copy of the files covered by those IP rights, regardless of how or where you acquire them? (E.g. if you buy a license to Windows, you don't need to download the installation media for Windows from Microsoft in order for your licensed installation of Windows to be legitimate. You can get the Windows installation media from anywhere.) You don't need a "game service provider" if you have legal dispensation to torrent the game. And, that being the case, you could replace a centralized service like Steam with the game-media equivalent of an app like PopcornTime: just a convenient way to browse for, and download, torrents of the IP you already legally own.
- adgjlsfhk1 5y agoyou already have proof of ownership.
- ulrikrasmussen 5y agoYou don't need NFTs for that. The proof of ownership is just a receipt. It could even be made verifiable by adding a digital signature signed by Ubisofts public key. Still, NFTs are not needed here.
- derefr 5y agoYou're right, you don't need an immutable ledger of visible IP licensing rights if that's all you want to accomplish. But presumably, in a "legal piracy is commonplace, Steam goes out of business" scenario, the studios producing the games would still want to make the games verify your license ownership against something — e.g. to make sure that you're only using your license for one concurrent "seat", rather than using it to activate thousands of copies of the game (like a regular product keys — which usually are "local digital signatures" — would enable.) Presuming that no central corporate authority could 1. profitably exist in such a market 2. with the right incentives, then a distributed immutable ledger would be a good alternative for storing those licenses in a verifiable manner. (Think of it as an IP licensing activation server run by "everybody." Each time a game wants to run, it would use your signing key to submit a TX incrementing a counter representing the current active uses of the license. Basically, a distributed, cryptographically-verifiable semaphore.)
- MattGaiser 5y agoThere is already proof that a user owns it, ranging from company sales records to receipts of purchase. Nobody seriously disputes the purchase and the company would not dispute it in a court of law. The problem is that you own something the company has a right to terminate.
- IntelMiner 5y agoSo you've literally reinvented "but I have a receipt!"
- nikanj 5y agoBut with a MUCH larger carbon footprint
- j4yav 5y agoPeople aren’t losing their receipts here, the games are being taken away even if they have them and can prove they bought it. More durable receipts won’t fix it.
- vital_beach 5y agothey had a database entry linking his account to a purchase. it's not like his access to the game was forgotten. they just chose not to honor it. a blockchain proof isn't any more compelling than the info they already had + his payment records.
- kosievdmerwe 5y ago"We irreversibly logged an entry deactivating your account to the blockchain. Nothing we can do to reactivate it."
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- throw_m239339 5y ago> People won't like this, but we at Ultra.io are trying to tackle this exact problem by deploying certificates of ownership to a decentralized ledger as proof of your owning a game. How do you legally enforce that proof of ownership? How does a NFT change anything to a license agreement between the publisher and the buyers?
- MichaelBurge 5y agoThe user can already prove they own the game. Ubisoft accepted the proof. The problem is they've chosen to configure their servers to reject sending the game client messages consistent with this proof. They could, if they wanted, configure their servers to send network messages approving his login. But they choose not to. If a company opts-in to using your NFT as the authority, they can at any time opt-out(just like Ubisoft did here) so it provides no extra guarantee. And companies that don't accept your NFT as proof will ignore it when it's presented as evidence.
- twhb 5y agoSelling ownership, not licenses, is great. Both ownership and licenses can be sold with or without NFTs. How do NFTs help?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- forgotmyoldname 5y agoWhat's the tangible difference between this and email confirmations that you made a purchase? If you lose track of the NFT that proves you bought it, that's no different than losing the email evidence. You're boned.
- endisneigh 5y agoThis article is a great example of why we need legislation around ownership of digital items. I generally hate getting the government involved in things, but if you're paying money for goods, there needs to be a way to be credited or receive your digital goods in a way that still works without your "account". Personally I always get kind of nervous around buying things on PSN, Xbox, Stadia, Steam, Oculus, etc. If they ban me, do I lose my thousands of dollars of games? That doesn't seem right (and no, I don't really care too much about what the Terms and Services say).
- squarefoot 5y ago> I generally hate getting the government involved in things It is sad when it occurs, but that's the exact reason why governments are there: they're (theoretically) reliable powerful people that should protect us from other unreliable powerful people, in exchange of being kept in power. Any other alternative would involve violence.
- pdonis 5y agoIf you can't be confident of your ownership of and access to what you buy, why do you buy it?
- endisneigh 5y agoI apologize but I find this to be a silly question. I buy because I want to play. I do not have an expectation of indefinite ownership (even though I should have indefinite ownership), hence my comment.
- pdonis 5y ago> I do not have an expectation of indefinite ownership But you said you were nervous about buying these things. What are you nervous about? And why do you pay money anyway if you're nervous about what you're getting? > even though I should have indefinite ownership On what grounds? These are companies operating in a free market. They're offering a product whose terms are right out there in the open. If you don't like the terms, don't buy.
- Hokusai 5y ago> We may also close long-term inactive accounts to maintain our database. How many kilobytes takes too store ownership data? I can just imagine that tracking data is thousands of times bigger. > The crazy thing about this is that it’s perfectly legal for video game companies to delete your account regardless of whether you’ve spend zero or a thousand dollars on their games It's a shame that we are going to fight for our digital rights because currently we have almost none because justice does not understand technology.
- pdonis 5y agoYou have the right not to pay money to companies that won't give you the guarantee of ownership and access that you want. But if the lack of that guarantee is right there in the company's terms of service, and you pay them money anyway, you don't have the right to insist that they change the terms you signed up to when you paid them just because you don't like the consequences.
- Hokusai 5y ago> You have the right not to pay money to companies that won't give you the guarantee of ownership and access that you want. I have way more rights than that. Or if not I will fight to get them. I do not want to depend on the good will of corporations. I want fair laws that control their behavior like we have with physical goods.
- pdonis 5y ago> I have way more rights than that. Or if not I will fight to get them. So let me get this straight: companies are offering a recreational product, games, on terms you don't like. But instead of not paying them money, so they will be forced to either change their business model or go out of business, you want to get the government involved? For games? > I do not want to depend on the good will of corporations. Good luck with that. Your ability to post on this website depends on the good will of a corporation. Your ability to buy groceries and other necessities depends on the good will of corporations. I could go on and on.
- Forricide 5y agoWow, glad I saw this - it explains a lot. Went to go and try to play an AC game again after giving up a year or two ago and couldn't figure out my login details. Guess this is (maybe?) why. Can't find a deletion email though, so it seems impossible to know for sure.
- paxys 5y agoI paid extra for a disc version of the PS5 for exactly this reason. If I buy a game today I want to be able to play it 20 years from now. I can bet money that none of the mainstream digital stores of today will be operational by then.
- josephcsible 5y agoIs that even a guarantee though? In particular, I know that you could buy the Orange Box (HL2, TF2, and Portal) on DVD in retail stores, but you needed a Steam account to play anyway.
- lostcolony 5y agoIt isn't. Even discounting day 1 patches, every console assumes an internet connection. You're at the mercy of the game devs, and unless you are checking for "internet connection required" (and believing the lack of such on the box means you really don't need one), you can still end up with something that will refuse to boot unless it phones home.
- toper-centage 5y ago> every console Except the Switch.
- lostcolony 5y agoWell, they're all -functional- without one. They also all have games that are only sold digitally, check in the background for patches for both the system and the games, and may refuse to start if you're running a version of the OS that is older than what is known to exist at the time of printing a physical copy. The Switch is no different there.
- Hamuko 5y agoI think most console games will run without any issues even if you pop in the disc to the console without any kind of Internet access. There's a Twitter account that documents if games work without having access to the console's network/stores: https://twitter.com/DoesItPlay1/status/1474819155173908484 https://twitter.com/DoesItPlay1/status/1474819155173908484
- gravypod 5y agoSome more great information in this same space: https://www.accursedfarms.com/videos/dead-game-news https://www.accursedfarms.com/videos/dead-game-news A less legally sound argument for why games as a service shouldn't be allowed: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tUAX0gnZ3Nw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tUAX0gnZ3Nw Ross is very odd but his opinions on this topic align greatly with my personal sentiment.
- qwertox 5y agoI'm not blaming the owner of the email account, but maybe we need a technology which guarantees that emails won't get flagged as spam. Maybe even marked as important. For example Ubisoft could register with Google for a program where they fetch a token from Google's servers, insert that token into the email header, and when Google notices this token in the header, then the email won't get flagged as spam. Only for the most important mails. In any case, I absolutely believe that Ubisoft has no right to delete the account. It's not like the user could download his account and use it without Ubisoft.
- sowbug 5y agoI believe a generalized version of this proposal is covered in RFC 3514.
- andromeduck 5y agoMeanwhile Microsoft will just delete all your email and contacts data if say, you don't check your old email for a few years during college. I lost everything pre ~2016. I will never rely on a Microsoft product or service ever again.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 5350-uiop-1130 5y agoyou will own nothing and you will be (un)happy
- amarshall 5y agoWhen possible, try to prefer DRM-free versions of games. If there's DRM, then one doesn't really own it. PCGamingWiki [1] is a great resource that will list the DRM status of a given game for different distributors (yes, some stores may have DRM while others do not). In general, GOG [2] is all DRM-free games. [1]: https://www.pcgamingwiki.com https://www.pcgamingwiki.com [2]: https://www.gog.com https://www.gog.com
- tjoff 5y agoLack of DRM wouldn't help if you don't have any way of getting the copy or getting past the license check.
- deelly 5y agoWait, but DRM free means that there no license check..
- falcor84 5y agoDoesn't DRM-free literally mean that you get a full local installation without any reliance on online licensing or any other digital restrictions?
- tjoff 5y agoSure, just like the olden days. But you still need a license key or equivalent - for an offline check. And in the case of an app store that is handled by the app store, you never get or see the key. So if you are banned that doesn't help. And even if you had a key you still don't have access to the install media. You could try to extract it from your drive but there is no guarantee that will work on another computer or OS-install since the installer might optionally install what is needed on that computer.
- CryptoPunk 5y agoThis is why we need blockchain-based smart contracts and NFTs to enforce digital ownership rights. The political system is far too unreliable and corruptible to depend on for robust private property rights. If the nation-states can just maintain a free and open internet, decentralized opt-in protocols can do the rest.
- MisterBastahrd 5y agoNone of that is going to be used the way you want it to. You know what NFTs are REALLY gonna be used for in the gaming space? Digital property ownership of in-game assets that remit value back to the publisher whenever these fake goods get traded. People are pretending that all these good things are gonna come out of smart contracts and tokens, when the reality is that the most useful thing to come out of them is going to be rent-seeking by digital creators. Ubisoft isn't going to throw your ownership of a video game on the blockchain, and even if they did, their license and their service governs whether you have access to the game, not a token.
- nikanj 5y agoThe biggest and most important use of NFTs in gaming space is going to be raising money on Kickstarter for an NFT based video game - and then disappearing with the money
- npteljes 5y agoWho exactly will enforce that providers look at the blockchain instead of their own database, if not a political system? People maintaining an infrastructure just so they don't have control over it is also a pipe dream. This all is just like saying "if only we'd be nicer to each other", but in tech jargon.
- CryptoPunk 5y agoFair point. Smart contracts can only enforce digital property rights insofar as the digital property is constituted by smart contracts. So this would work with NFTs, as they are blockchain-based assets, but not classical video games, which are not. So what would work is if the providers of the game assets are governed by a decentralized protocol on the blockchain. An example would be a game which is dependent on a remotely provided computation element to run - say a massive collectively rendered virtual world - and this element is provided by a distributed set of providers who are compensated via a smart contract, mechanistically, upon the blockchain validating proof of work they provide to a smart contract. Such a game could provide a person with a guarantee that a particular NFT will have indefinite access to that virtual world, because the guarantee will be enforced by immutable smart contracts. >>People maintaining an infrastructure just so they don't have control over it is also a pipe dream They do it for the same reason Ethereum validators stake their ETH and validate blocks on the Beacon Chain: to earn income. But what they earn is enforced in a decentralized way, according to the rules encoded in the protocol, to make it maximally immutable/interference-proof.
- ehsankia 5y agoUbisoft claims accounts with games on it will never be up for deletion. I could see this being a bug, but could also just simply be that... the person is confused and that specific account didn't actually have a game on it? Could it be a different account maybe? That seems a more likely and simple explanation to me, and this right now just comes down to a he said / she said. Obviously it's not great that the ToS has wording protecting Ubisoft's ass against such mistake, but again, everyone here is just taking the word of this one person as gospel, but I don't really see any solid evidence provided.
- falcor84 5y agoI don't know what your experience with Ubisoft is, but based on mine, I would always default to mistrusting them.
- lnxg33k1 5y agoAlong the years I also built the same approach, so far, I am usually not a corporate fanboy, but somehow I found myself in the situation that if a game is not on Steam it doesn't exist, and even there I have some publishers I never buy from, like EA, Ubisoft, Bethesda, Microsoft..
- ehsankia 5y agoIt's fine to mistrust them, I also generally stay away from UPlay, but I still don't like taking accusations like this as facts without more evidence. And if it is indeed true that the person did buy games on that account, there would be evidence to prove it, and I do not see a world where Ubisoft wouldn't restore the account. It just feels strange to jump to pitchforks though based on so little.
- sshine 5y agoNot computer game, but this happened to me with Audible. I don’t have that many gmail addresses (2), and neither of them apparently own any books, even though I once had 20+ books. I’m not getting that sh*t again.
- senko 5y agoNot saying this happened to you, but I once lost half an hour to figuring out wth I lost all my Audible books when getting a new device (phone). Turned out the app happily logged me in to audible UK without saying anything (silently creating a new account), which, of course was empty. Once I figured out how to point the app to Audible US, all my content was back.
- justinclift 5y ago> The company’s support page also cites the General Data Protection Regulation compliance and freeing database space as the main reason why they delete unused accounts. Oh wow. That 1k of database data must really be dragging down their system. /s Seriously, what kind of child's-first-attempt-to-use-a-database system are they using where this is even a consideration? :(
- devoutsalsa 5y agoIt could have been 1 kilobyte, but after numerous decisions to track everything to the Nth degree, the account was closer to 400 petabytes. </sarcasm> When I contracting at a large tech company, so had to implement a service that would delete any personally identifying information from the database for users that had been inactive for more than 18 months. Essentially this meant dynamically scanning the entire database schema for any columns that had a user ID and deleting any matching records. It was kind of a fun project.
- philliphaydon 5y agoFor auditing purposes these companies have to keep records of transactions. So I don’t understand the need to delete accounts and digital items. Sure they could delete non essential data like activity, game saves, screenshots etc. but how difficult is it to keep a login and list of owned games. It’s prob a few kb of data…
- toper-centage 5y agoKeeping that list doesn't make them money. Forcing you to buy new games does.
- jbverschoor 5y agoInteresting that they did this before launching their own NFT platform (Quartz)
- Raphaellll 5y agoWhy is this interesting?
- jbverschoor 5y agoBecause if those items are suddenly would be available as NFTs, they're worth a lot more. Now it's just tough luck for the people... Old agreement about destroying someone's digital assets. People who want their items "back" are forced to play/pay again..
- qayxc 5y ago> People who want their items "back" are forced to play/pay again.. Therein lies the misunderstanding. The people didn't "own" the assets in the first place. In no way has ownership been transferred at any point - you only acquired a limited license to run the software in a specified way, no more, no less. The license depended on an active account and thus was rendered null and void with the termination of said account. NFTs fall into a similar category - if bound to a license, they're just as useless in case something like this happens.
- smileybarry 5y agoThat depends, Ubisoft Quartz is on its own blockchain IIRC and there's no guarantee you can submit transactions without a Ubi account, or even that the signing key isn't just stored in your Ubi account. Also, just to check on which blockchain it's on, I tried opening their FAQ page to see a "not available in your region" message (despite the Ubi store being available here, Israel). Hilarious.
- jbverschoor 5y agoTrue.. I guess that's also why there's not much adoption of their initiatives.
- birracerveza 5y agoDecentralized ownership and file storage using NFTs on low energy blockchains would solve this. But no, let's keep complaining about the same problems over and over while we keep chanting that crypto is evil and can't be used to solve said problems.
- IshKebab 5y agoYou can't just say "blockchain" and magically solve it.
- benatkin 5y agoYou used to be able to. "Web3" is the magic word now.
- yokoprime 5y agoYou can just as well use digital signatures with certificates, I don't understand why anyone would want blockchain backing this. In fact I have yet to see a practical application of blockchain outside of "investment"..
- regularjack 5y agoDownloading the files to your hard-drive solves this, which we've been able to do since always, and yet here we are. It's not a tech problem.
- lnxg33k1 5y agoDoes it? Because I was just thinking that it's not an issue with digital goods only, they can do the same thing if you have a physical disk and need to activate the right to it using a key, they can just disable the key and that's it, about the guy about talking about NFTs and problem, this is not a problem that happened and needs to be solved, this is a problem for users that has been implemented, I'm sure they would find a way to make it exist even if the ownership was blockchain based.
- 5y ago
- moogly 5y agoIf Steam did this I would've been deleted many times over. I buy a lot of those icons, don't have time to play, but hope that I one day will when I retire.
- intricatedetail 5y agoYou don't buy a game but permission to play it...
- low_tech_love 5y ago“This was a glitch, it shouldn’t gave happened.” “We can’t recover the games after the account is closed.” Noice.
- FpUser 5y agoPeople get arrested and put in jail because car rental company "mistakenly" declared them as thieves on a basis of their fucked up accounting. I have a proposal. Let's extend the same courtesy the other way around. If I feel that company had stolen / interfered with enjoyment of my right to do certain things (which they in effect did) why don't police upon my complaint go and stick their CEO/Owner to jail with no bail and let them wait till the dust settles.
- beebeepka 5y agoGood thing Ubi hasn't released anything of interest to me in almost 20 years. Since the original XIII, really. Pirating their crap as retribution is pointless. I went reading the original article expecting to see this happened in the US but no, it says Norway. While not EU, it's still Europe. Shame on you, Ubi. Shame on you. This ought to be illegal. Fuck whoever came up and implemented this utter bullshit.
- Lazare 5y agoI feel a bit disappointed by the number of people suggesting that an NFT would somehow help here. An NFT is just a fancy signed receipt. I can mint an NFT saying the OP owns a bunch of Ubisoft games and give it to him, but his account will still be closed. Ubisoft could mint an NFT saying he owns a bunch of games and give it to him, but his account will still be closed. (He probably still has the receipts from when he bought the games in his inbox somewhere, but of course, his account is still closed.) We can store whatever records we like in a fancy distributed database, but his account will still be closed. The only fix here is Ubisoft needs to not close peoples accounts. Somewhat amusingly Ubisoft is in the process of launching an NFT system (https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2021/12/ubisofts-first-nft-plans-make-no-sense/ https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2021/12/ubisofts-first-nft-pl...) and as anyone paying attention would no doubt expect, it doesn't solve anything related to this; up to an including the fact that if you get banned you...lose your NFTs. There is no technological problem to solve here.
- cinntaile 5y agoBut if he creates a new account and transfers the NFTs (that function as your proof of ownership of a game in this case), then you're good to go again. Since they can't be deleted. It's a different story if your NFTs are banned of course, then it wouldn't matter if you transfer them to a new account.
- Lazare 5y agoUbisoft is already making NFTs (for cosmetics in this case; same tech though) where they control who can own or transfer NFTs. So...no., this doesn't help. Ubisoft doesn't need NFTs to let people transfer their games to a new account, and they don't need to let people transfer their games just because they've given you a fancy commemorative memento of the time you gave them money in exchange for not owning a game.
- cinntaile 5y agoYou didn't read what I wrote, I'll try and rephrase it. I am talking about NFTs where you as the owner of the NFT control who you can transfer it to, I explicitly mentioned this. If you can do this, then it can be a solution to the current problem. Because then you simply transfer your ownership rights to your new account.
- udp 5y agoUnsurprising. I have found Ubisoft customer support pretty abysmal. I pre-ordered the latest Assassin’s Creed directly from Ubisoft thinking it was better than buying it from Amazon. It got delivered to the wrong address, so I opened a ticket. They ignored the ticket for weeks despite me sending follow ups every few days, so I eventually raised a dispute with PayPal to get a refund, which I received. Ubisoft finally responded to the ticket at that point, saying that I “may have issues making purchases from the store in the future” due to the reversed payment. So basically, they no longer want me as a customer because I tried to get a refund for a game they failed to deliver.
- Havoc 5y agoSomething here is very fishy >“Please be reassured that Ubisoft does not automatically close inactive accounts,” but >inactivity warning from Ubisoft in his spam folder dated January 20th. The email stated that his account had been temporarily shut down and will be permanently closed if he didn’t click the provided link within 30 days. So not automatic closures...but there is a live system to automate it?
- timvisee 5y agoShit. I'm sure my account is removed too. Had quite a few games. Is there something I can do about this? This is unclear to me.
- nikanj 5y agoGrepping for "GDPR" in these comments results in zero hits. I'm reasonably certain Ubisoft deletes accounts due to GDPR requirements.
- josephcsible 5y agoIf this behavior were really required by the GDPR, then Steam, GOG, etc. would all have to do the same thing, but they don't.
- Jorengarenar 5y agoYou know how the sale of M&M X Legacy was for some period of time disabled, because DRM was broken thus the game was unplayable? I'd seen a news that it got restored, so I login to Uplay (or Ubisoft Connect as they call it nowadays) and see... that my game is missing. I frickin <3 Ubi /s
- ajuc 5y agoThis is why DRM is evil and why I buy games on gog.com if I have a choice.
- lobocinza 5y agoIntellectual property does not make sense on theory or in real life. When you "buy" a game you are paying for convenience, for server access, for updates & support, and for other platform services like storing saves at cloud. You don't own a thing and pirating a game while illegal is trivial. The issue here was putting money on a shitty service that does not care about it's customers experience. I have spent thousands of dollars on Steam. I don't expect my account to be terminated after 1 year of activity but I also don't expect it to last forever and to be able to pass it to descendants.
- s_dev 5y ago>I don't expect my account to be terminated after 1 year of activity but I also don't expect it to last forever and to be able to pass it to descendants. Why? It doesn't have to be passed on to descendants -- you could for example sell it before you die. I'm not sure why any time limit would be imposed. It's already happened to me -- EA Origin. I simply can't play my C&C Generals games anymore despite legally purchased them from EA. The only option now is illegal.
- CryptoBanker 5y agoActually C&C generals is still available on the Origin store, but only as part of a package
- s_dev 5y agoRight but you can't play multiplayer.
- driverdan 5y agoOriginal: https://www.pcworld.com/article/559218/could-gdpr-policy-erase-your-games-it-happened-to-an-ubisoft-customer.html https://www.pcworld.com/article/559218/could-gdpr-policy-era...
- yason 5y agoThere's a lot of heritage in archived and emulated computer games from 80's and 90's. Further, I still have some games in their original boxes somewhere and being nostalgic enough to not have thrown them away I own my copies of those games in the true sense of the word. Same for music on compact discs. I have ripped most of them for myself but I still own the original copies in a closet. Now, 30 years from now or roughly 2050, there will be a cultural and historical blackout because anything people are "buying" now are basically revokable privileges to temporarily hire games, music, and movies. There will be no single server up and running to provide today's games for people who are today young but will be middle-aged few decades from now. And, even before that, judging based on Ubisoft it looks like the "purchases" will be long gone before the service itself. What a waste.
- efitz 5y ago“Ownership” is implied when you “purchase” something. If I own it, I should have certain basic rights like the right to keep enjoying it if the publisher goes out of business. To that end, I strongly oppose DRM or at least would favor laws that let me transfer my DRM’d content to another provider (or even require me to, if a provider “cancels” me or goes out of business). It’s not so clear when the digital work requires ongoing effort from the provider, as in an online game that requires the provider to operate servers. In that case I think that providers should either be forced to provide the service as a rental instead of a “purchase”, or the provider should be forced to provide all information and code necessary for third parties to operate compatible servers.
- mikegreenberg 5y ago"Blockchains don't solve this as Ubisoft can control (the view around, as well as other parts) this new database however they like." But why does this have to be Ubisoft's blockchain? Why does Ubisoft get to be the only portal in this scenario. I expect NFT-represented games/content will find new portals which will permit access to the underlying IP regardless of who issued them (as they would meet some standard the same as ERC721 represents a generalized NFT). I think it's interesting that all of the (*most vocal) blockchain nay-sayers do not appear to "zoom out" quite far enough. Or, arguing in good faith, they see some way this does not work that I'm not seeing but are getting stuck at the earlier points without fulling describing their criticism.
- MeinBlutIstBlau 5y ago
- aidenn0 5y agoIf you buy something with (uncracked) DRM, or don't have a copy in your possession, you are really just renting it for some unknown period of time.
- LambdaTrain 5y agoInacitivity of a digital content account is usually a consequence of my indifference to that content & provider, which also means that I do not care about that account anymore.
- hammyhavoc 5y ago