34 ms·
> But the U.S. murder rate is not all that remarkable, really The US is at 4.96/100,000 for 2012. For reference, Angola is better at 4.85. Bulgaria and Romania
by sofixa 5y ago
> But the U.S. murder rate is not all that remarkable, really
The US is at 4.96/100,000 for 2012. For reference, Angola is better at 4.85. Bulgaria and Romania, the poorest countries in the EU, are at 1.3. France is at 1.2.
If by not remarkable you mean 3 as bad as other developed countries, sure. The numbers are only for intentional homicide, not even counting accidents and suicides which are also made worse by the high availability of guns for everyone. Not all that remarkable is a weird way of putting it.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_intentional_homicide_rate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_intention...
Furthermore, i find US fascination with their theoretical ability to fight their government with small arms adorable and misguided. Protests and revolutions in France have done more to guide government power than anything ever that happened in the US. Blatant corruption, lobbying, outright incompetent representatives, abuses of power, erosion of human rights, blatant disregard for human rights. If Americans didn't fight against the Patriot act, wars, torture, what will they fight for/against? Mask mandates?
- Throwawayaerlei 5y agoFurthermore, i find US fascination with their theoretical ability to fight their government with small arms adorable and misguided. So did our Deep State as they lost a twenty year fight against the Taliban. Who immediately started seizing the people's guns upon capturing Kabul. not even counting accidents and suicides which are also made worse by the high availability of guns for everyone The suicide statistics from some countries with effective total bans on civilian gun ownership do not support your claim for those, and for accidents we're at 500/year out of a population of 330 million people. There were years when more very young kids were accidentally drowning themselves by getting stuck upside down in 5 gallon (19 L) plastic buckets that are are ubiquitous here. If Americans didn't fight against the Patriot act, wars, torture, what will they fight for? Mask mandates? Are any of these, the middle ones not directly affecting us, worth starting a civil war that would take hundreds of thousands to millions of lives? (I might argue yes for the wars, but it's not the sort of thing I suspect has ever happened in human history.)
- sofixa 5y ago> So did our Deep State as they lost a twenty year fight against the Taliban. Who immediately started seizing the people's guns upon capturing Kabul I sincerely doubt the average first world person has what it takes to sacrifice their comfortable life and go live in caves to resist a tyrannical occupation. And there's no need for them to do that, realistically.
- tablespoon 5y ago> I sincerely doubt the average first world person has what it takes to sacrifice their comfortable life and go live in caves to resist a tyrannical occupation. Why are you talking about the "average first world person"? IIRC, Afghanistan is a country of ~30 million people, and the most recent estimates I saw said the Taliban only had ~75 thousand fighters. That's 0.25%. So not even the average Afghan did that. Also, guerilla warfare isn't so much about living in caves as melting into the population.
- anonAndOn 5y ago>melting into the population. Or, as in Afghanistan, actively supported by the population who hated both the occupiers and the VICE (Vertically Integrated Criminal Enterprise) known as the government.
- clon 5y agoStill, one of the first signs of a society approaching tyranny is the government cracking down on guns. So if nothing else, it serves as a great canary in the mine.
- chmod600 5y agoA rational person compares risks on an absolute scale first. Out of all the things that could happen on a given day, is getting murdered a real concern? For people in the U.S., it's not really worth worrying about unless you have some other risk factors for murder, like criminal activity. If you are selling lion repellant that makes a lion attack 80% less likely, that's not something I'd be interested in. That being said, it's great that some countries have driven a small risk down to oblivion. Not sure that firearm laws have much to do with that, though. Probably more to do with policing structure.
- brodouevencode 5y ago> Probably more to do with policing structure. And culture.
- NoImmatureAdHom 5y agoSpecifically, cultural homogeneity makes a nation much easier to run. Boring food, though.
- umeshunni 5y agoJapan has pretty good food for being homogenous.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoBoring food can be good, but maybe there are fewer types of restaurants per capita.
- Zababa 5y agoYou can have more variety with a few types of restaurants than with lots of types of restaurants, I doubt the two are completely correlated.
- NoImmatureAdHom 5y ago
- phendrenad2 5y ago3x a small number is still a small number. Your chances of getting struck by lightning increase if you live on a hill, but no one is basing home buying decisions on that. The real argument is that guns enable acts that, while rare, and while they affect few people, are so egregious that we as a society will go to great lengths to ensure they never happen (school shootings).
- fossuser 5y agoYeah - I think that's the core, outlier events are extremely bad. I think there are real things that could be done short of a total ban, but the issue in the US it's a constitutional right so it's hard to restrict in any sensible way and it's politically impossible to amend. As it is, the policy question is accepting the tradeoff of the right to bear arms vs. rare, but extremely awful death of school children. I'm not really taking a strong position, I think that's just the reality of it. https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/PeSzc9JTBxhaYRp9b/policy-debates-should-not-appear-one-sided https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/PeSzc9JTBxhaYRp9b/policy-deb... https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/08/14/beware-isolated-demands-for-rigor/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/08/14/beware-isolated-demand...
- Throwawayaerlei 5y agooutlier events are extremely bad Don't forget the history of the 20th Century where such "outlier events" included 100 million previously disarmed people killed by Communists running their countries, and the Left likes to remind us of the small death tolls in right wing countries, although many of those were fighting communists. See also the WWI era Armenian Genocide which was so ignored by the rest of the world it convinced Hitler he could do as he pleased.
- sofixa 5y agoAnyone who dismisses any of the "white terrors" and the general repressions/pogroms/genocides (Nazi Germany, Francoist Spain, Argentina, Chile, Imperial Japan, Hungary, Yugoslavia, Greece, Bulgaria etc.) that happened in right wing countries isn't to be taken seriously.
- GiorgioG 5y agoThe murder rate varies widely by state/area. Chicago's murder rate is significantly higher than its suburbs. The murder rate in the town (37k residents) I live in (in the south) is effectively zero. I wouldn't doubt that all of my neighbors around me (most of us are originally from a northern state) have guns and we've managed not to kill each other. Do you think the French revolution didn't require violence?
- watwut 5y agoI think the person meant contemporary France.
- GiorgioG 5y agoHow many revolutions has France had in contemporary times?
- philwelch 5y agoThey had a military coup in 1958.
- ben_w 5y agoTIL, however I don’t think that’s important in the context of the effectiveness of armed civilians being able to have much influence. If anything, rumours to the effect that Republican senators/representatives are only still publicly supporting Trump because they fear armed Trump supporters, could (iff true) be a relevant example.
- GiorgioG 5y agoThey fear Trump voters that will vote however he tells them to, but I do not think they fear them because they are armed.
- pchristensen 5y ago
- AdrianB1 5y agoLiving in Romania, the thing I miss mostly when hiking in the mountains is a long rifle. This is for self defence against huge populations of bears and boars, not for anything else. Guns in the country side are also tools, not just weapons. Homicide rate is low in Romania because we don't have violent criminal gangs, almost at all. It is a small country with different policing system. But there are plenty of guns in the hands of criminals, having a very restrictive gun policy does not help the ordinary citizens, just the criminals. Opening up would be leveling the conditions.
- ChuckNorris89 5y ago>we don't have violent criminal gangs, almost at all. On the contrary, we have plenty of violent crime clans (mostly gypsy), they just don't use firearms but have no issue threatening you and your family or beating you into submission with melee weapons or bare hands/feet if you stand in the way of their (mostly) illegal activities while the local police, even when they're not on their payroll, are toothless thanks to the poorly defined laws and they can't, or simply can't be bothered to take much action against them unless they commit some extremely violent acts that get lots of media coverage for which higher levels of government are called for accountability. My $0.02
- AdrianB1 5y agoThey are not so violent compared with US gangs.
- ChuckNorris89 5y agoAnd the US gangs aren't so violent compared to the Brazilian gangs in the favelas or the Mexican drug cartel gangs; what does this have to do with it?
- easton_s 5y agoWhere does a gang end and a militia begin?
- disneygibson 5y agoThis only seems scary because analyzing crime data for a continent-sized country doesn’t make much sense. The overwhelming majority of gun crime happens in a tiny percentage of counties.
- NikolaNovak 5y agoAlso, how come we always only count murder, as opposed to gun violence? How many times is a gun pointed at somebody, or fired at somebody, or accidentally discharged, vs somebody actually dead? I don't only fear for my life; I fear for my limb and safety and all the other good stuff too :) (mind you, FWIW, and hopefully lateral to above questions, I'm not necessarily in the full "prohibit guns" camp, more of a "regulate&license", with thinking that since we regulate cars and airplanes and other potentially dangerous stuff that's even not explicitly made to harm we should regulate & license guns. But again, my questions above are from a more abstract perspective)
- autoliteInline 5y agoit's easier to count dead people. it's harder to obfuscate the numbers. One value is that you can see increases/trends/etc. and they are actually meaningful. Generally, you do find this: . Include suicide in stats...is against guns . Block suicide from stats...is for guns
- Someone1234 5y ago> Also, how come we always only count murder, as opposed to gun violence? Because other countries use different definitions for those things. The definition of a "firearm death" is consistent, someone was shot they're now deceased. The definition of "gun violence" could be a gun that wasn't even loaded or fired in some countries (e.g. pointing it menacingly), bullet-injury in others, pistol-whipping in yet others, for one example. Crime statistics are a complex topic, with politics, collection methods, and definitions playing a major part. For one example, richer countries often have higher "crime" because they're better at collecting and recording crime statistics, not because crime doesn't occur in poorer countries. Even richer countries like the US have a "crime gap" if you compare recorded crime with victim crime surveys (e.g. NCVS).
- NoImmatureAdHom 5y agoYeah, I can corroborate this. I've looked into the reporting details here and there, and reconciling even the U.S. and the U.K. is basically impossible. There's also politicization of reporting, at least in the U.S. I recall some states (Maryland?) have laws that mandate reporting of any injury related to a gun (could be a minor burn or a cut finger web that needed stitches) as a firearm-related injury. The intent, of course, being that people wrongly infer that these were injuries inflicted by bullets traveling at high rates of speed. Dead's dead, though. We don't lose track many of bodies in the developed world.
- chokeartist 5y ago> Furthermore, i find US fascination with their theoretical ability to fight their government with small arms adorable and misguided. I'll chalk this up to someone who simultaneously A) doesn't own firearms and B) is not a student of history. Call me when a F-22 or RQ-1 can take a door in the middle of the night. Otherwise, it is fancy waiting game of finding out who the aerial operators are, and slaughtering their family.
- monoideism 5y ago> their theoretical ability to fight their government with small arms adorable and misguided Taliban? Vietcong?
- no-dr-onboard 5y agoExcellent examples that will undoubtedly be shushed away.
- wavefunction 5y agoI disagree that they're excellent examples when you consider the difference in terrain, infrastructure, the cultural and religious differences between the combatants and the status of one side as foreign occupying force.
- zepto 5y agoThat seems like just shushing them away by saying they aren’t the same, when in fact those factors don’t make a difference.
- darkhorse13 5y agoThere's really no way of knowing for sure, because you can't deny that many of the Talibans fought so fearlessly because of the certainty of their faith and religion.
- zepto 5y agoThere at plenty of people in the US who have certainty in their faith, whether it be Christianity, or the desire to confront oppression.
- brodouevencode 5y agoThe whole argument that small arms are of no comparison to tanks and nuclear weapons are made by people who have no experience with firearms, fire fight and perimeter and assault tactics, or any type of military strategy. To even get to this point you would have to assume that the US would devolve into a civil war, in which you can also safely assume that many in the US military would be defectors (leaving a lot of empty tanks and airplanes, if not turned to the "other" side). You would also have to assume that you could safely identify gun owners that would be willing to combat - if there's anything the US attempts to avoid (and with good reason) it is attacking non-combatants (it would be very easy to blend in to the normal population as we've seen in the Middle East). The difference here and the Civil War of 1865 was that there were clear demarcations between the sides. You would also have to assume that whatever resources you employ to launch this war would not interfere with any other outside enemy that may use this time as an opportunity to launch their own assaults (i.e. it would be a great opportunity for another 9/11). Mostly, this is a lazy half-thought-out argument.
- bingohbangoh 5y ago> Furthermore, i find US fascination with their theoretical ability to fight their government with small arms adorable and misguided. Didn't a couple of unarmed protestors take the capitol building on January 6th?
- poopypoopington 5y ago1. Many of them were armed 2. That was because the Trump administration refused to send in the national guard for several hours after the terrorist attack on January 6th. If the government does not stand up to terrorists attacking the US Capitol, then yes, they can take the building quite easily.
- bingohbangoh 5y agothey were armed? do you have a source for that? The gun charges were dropped.
- kube-system 5y agoA couple examples here, before, during, and after the attack: https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/stun-guns-stinger-whips-crossbow-what-police-found-capitol-protesters-n1254127 https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/stun-guns-stinger-whips... If you pop their names into a search engine you can see the DOJ indictments with more info.
- ghufran_syed 5y agoHow many of those weapons were discharged? And how many were “seized” is not as interesting as how many were being held illegally? The government can illegally seize all sorts of things from citizens, including cash, but the process of doing so doesn’t make the original possession a crime
- kube-system 5y agoI was answering the question about whether any were armed or not, of which, the answer is yes: some absolutely were. Getting a permit to carry in DC is extremely difficult to the point where there's no chance any of the protestors had one. That makes possession illegal. Also, a lack of proper licensing is mentioned several times in the article.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- enriquto 5y ago> For reference, Angola is better at 4.85. Bulgaria and Romania, the poorest countries in the EU, are at 1.3. France is at 1.2. I don't know about Angola, but in most european countries it's really easy to buy guns (for hunting, sharp-shooting, etc.). When my dad retired he joined a shooting club with his friends, the gun permit being slightly harder to obtain than a fishing permit. There are gun shops everywhere where you can buy guns and ammunition if you show your permit. There are of course regulations for carrying your gun, I don't remember exactly, but you have to carry ammunition and gun separately or something like that. I guess the problem is not about the easy availability of guns, but that the american society is more violent.
- fh973 5y agoActually getting a fishing permit in Germany is quite an undertaking. The theoretical exam is based on a catalog of several hundred questions.
- enriquto 5y agoLike a driving license, then. This means that anybody can get it, if they are moderately inrerested. It could be even a bit harder, and still be alright.
- lostandbored 5y agoYeah, from East Texas and having lived in Estonia, American fascination and glorification of violence is insane looking from the outside.
- xadhominemx 5y agoAgreed with all of the above, but it addition, isn’t it obvious gun owners in the United States are much more likely to support any likely authoritarian government? They are mostly right wing, and the right wing in the US increasingly leans authoritarian.
- philwelch 5y agoThis is an oversimplification to some degree, but even if we take this for the sake of argument, isn’t the obvious solution to stop treating gun ownership as a right wing issue?
- xadhominemx 5y agoWho should stop treating gun ownership as a right wing issue? Left wing people? Most left wing people think there should be fewer guns.
- philwelch 5y agoRight; I don’t think the center-left should voluntarily disarm itself. (Socialists are surprisingly pro-gun; they have a saying that if you go far enough to the left, you get your guns back.)
- rpmisms 5y ago> isn’t it obvious gun owners in the United States are much more likely to support any likely authoritarian government? That's hilarious. Sure, there's the Republican party, but also a massive Libertarian sentiment here, and Libertarians love guns.
- xadhominemx 5y agoLibertarians are not by any measure a massive segment of the population.
- rpmisms 5y ago
- KorematsuFredt 5y agoPS: I am strong supporter of Gun rights and proud gun owner. I fully agree with anti-gun crowd that having vast majority of guns in hands of citizens (legally or illegally) leads to more deaths. USA's comparison with Angola is actually more serious than the numbers tell you because you need to realize that USA has far better medical response and doctors trained to handle gunshot wounds. So to truly compare Angola and USA you might have to increase USA's number with those who are shot instead of dead. Having said that I am totally for guns in the hands of citizens. Mostly because I think it acts as a bulwark against further restrictions. After 2nd ammendment you will be seeing "commons sense rules for free speech" like we have seen in UK, Canada and Australia. Every constitutional right has its price. Anyone who fails to see this is not honest. Give police the power to search you without warrant and we almost certainly will solve more crimes. Force individual to testify against themselves and we will most certainly keep more child rapists in jail. But then as a society we need to figure out the trade-off and in my personal case I would rather keep my guns and face a 5/1000 chance of dying of gunshot wound than surrender my guns. > Blatant corruption, lobbying, outright incompetent representatives, abuses of power, erosion of human rights, blatant disregard for human rights. If Americans didn't fight against the Patriot act, wars, torture, what will they fight for/against? Mask mandates? In my experience USA lot less corrupt than most other countries. Lobbying overall is a net good thing for a democratic society. Representatives are incompetent everywhere. American abuse of power is nowhere close to what EU or AU does to its citizens. I am not sure wha erosion of human rights you are talking in USA.
- csours 5y agoSo if more Texas liberal women were armed, they would still have the right to choose to get an abortion?
- trhway 5y agoNo. The point of trade-off is that you get some you lose some. They got guns rights and lost abortion rights. Or like back then with the Prohibition and women's suffrage https://time.com/5501680/prohibition-history-feminism-suffrage-metoo/ https://time.com/5501680/prohibition-history-feminism-suffra... "It became clear to them that giving women the right to vote was only way they could ban alcohol."
- philwelch 5y agoThe US is not that bad compared to other New World countries. From your link we see Brazil at 27, Mexico at 29, Argentina at 5, Uruguay at 12, Greenland at 5, Panama at 9, and Costa Rica at 11. Canada is the biggest outlier, but the US still has less homicide than even relatively nice New World countries. If you’re going to tout France’s low homicide rate of 1.2, I’d invite you to observe that Japan’s homicide rate is 0.26. Does this mean that France should adopt some aspects of Japanese law, for instance, by readopting the death penalty? Or does it simply mean that France and Japan are different countries? In fact, I would posit that the arrow of causation can point the other way. If you live in a country with higher rates of homicide and violent crime, you will be more interested in defending yourself. > Protests and revolutions in France have done more to guide government power than anything ever that happened in the US. This seems like a bizarre and dubious oversimplification. France had an outright military coup in 1958 when the democratically elected government didn’t want to hold onto Algeria. While both democracy and Algerian independence worked out in the long run, the mere possibility of a military coup—something that French military officers will occasionally make threats to repeat—seems to be a major distinction that is not in France’s favor here. Meanwhile, popular protests in the US led to the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and ultimately even withdrawal from Vietnam. It’s not like the American public is politically powerless compared to that of any other democracy.
- NoImmatureAdHom 5y ago>The US is not that bad compared to other New World countries. Yeah, I'd add that France doesn't have a long, porous border with the developing world. Nor nearly as much heterogeneity in its population.
- mattcwilson 5y agoNot sure why you're being downvoted. These are facts about France vs. the U.S. Maybe "developing" is a /little/ strong for Mexico, but I take your point to be more about Central America generally.
- pasabagi 5y ago
- staunch 5y ago> Furthermore, i find US fascination with their theoretical ability to fight their government with small arms adorable and misguided. I find the historical and military ignorance of people who imply this even more adorable. Especially given the timing of the recent example, where the Taliban defeated a massive military force that was equipped with modern U.S. weaponry including tanks, helicopters, and armored vehicles. Not to mention the countless other examples of uprisings using small arms successfully against superior military forces. Add in the fact that the U.S. citizenry is made up of tens of millions of military veterans and is more well armed than any civilian population in the history of the planet. It would not take long for a revolutionary force to take control of many military bases and armories within the U.S. The idea that 50 or 100 million armed U.S. citizens couldn't defeat a few hundred thousand armed U.S. soldiers (most of whom would defect) is adorable in its child-like ignorance.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mettamage 5y ago> 4.96/100,000 for 2012 So... 5 * 20 years = 100 So living in the US for 20 year means that the people murdered by guns are very roughly estimated at 1 person per 1000. That's about as twice as high of a chance as dying from the flu [1]. [1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/1127799/influenza-us-mortality-rate-by-age-group/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/1127799/influenza-us-mor...
- inter_netuser 5y agoWhich means guns are 500% safer than COVID-19?
- mettamage 5y agoWell, considering that people live on average 80 years, I'd upperbound it to 4/1000 instead of 1/1000. Also I wouldn't call "dying less" a way to frame safety when talking about these type of chances. So I guess Covid is twice to 4 times as deadly? I mean it's a very rough estimation and clearly I haven't considered everything. But ballparking it like this, I'd be inclined to say so.
- NoImmatureAdHom 5y agoI think it quite likely Angola's reporting is broken. Coming up with accurate numbers even for a developed country is challenging. >Furthermore, i find US fascination with their theoretical ability to fight their government with small arms adorable and misguided. Afghanistan, a fractious nation mostly comprised of illiterate peasants, has been able to fight off not one but two superpowers using mostly small arms.
- InitialLastName 5y agoThe Afghanistan thing is an easy narrative, but it isn't really an accurate one. More accurate: > Two superpowers found that Afghanistan, a fractious nation mostly comprised of illiterate peasants and devoid of exploitable industrial or natural resources, wasn't worth the price of occupying indefinitely.
- Zababa 5y ago> and devoid of exploitable industrial or natural resources Isn't there massive amounts of lithium there?
- InitialLastName 5y agoAIUI, the key word is "exploitable". Natural resources are worthless without the infrastructure to mine them and transport them to somewhere they can be used. Afghanistan, being landlocked, covered in VERY rugged terrain, and with relatively west-hostile neighbors (with lots of their own problems that make "develop port access for Afghanistan" a low priority) is a very difficult geographic place for resource extraction.
- NoImmatureAdHom 5y agoFair! It's a two-variable function though. How much is it worth to have? How much does it cost to keep? The Afghanis made the cost very, very high relative to what might be expected.
- NoImmatureAdHom 5y agoSomething that's important to keep in mind with murder rates is that they are tiny. That France's tiny number is more tiny than the US's tiny number is irrelevant. If you wanted to lower the frequency of unexpected deaths you'd spend all your time and money doing things that would encourage people to exercise more, or something like that. Another thing to keep in mind is that murders are not random, whereas the other ways people die early often are pretty random (like car accidents). Regular Americans living regular lives have an effectively zero change of being murdered. Just ignore it.
- neonbones 5y agoThe rate of shooting in the USA was always strange to me. I'm from Ukraine, one of the poorest countries in Europe, the country that on hybrid "civil war" with Russia help for the militia. There are many ex-militaries from volunteers who go to volunteer battalions. And many of them return with guns. But even with a state like that, you probably won't hear any gunshots in cities in your life. The first time I heard one was where I took a trip to the USA, random "gang" shooting in NY, as I remember. From my perspective, as someone who is culturally not so integrated with the USA, I think the roots of this are how you see guns and feel around firearms at all. In my country, people are cautious about the idea of using a firearm against other people. Even if they have one, they probably do drunk shit with a knife, not with a gun. Anyway, I also can't understand how any gangs are still alive in the USA in our time. Even my shittiest country eliminated all of them in the 90s, so are Russia and other CIS countries. You can find many documentation films about that on youtube. There is almost nothing left except massive graveyards of dead criminals with funny grave tomb pictures like "sitting in my first Mercedes Benz with a gun, cool guy." I may be wrong somewhere. That's just my perspective as an outsider.
- jdkee 5y ago"Anyway, I also can't understand how any gangs are still alive in the USA in our time. Even my shittiest country eliminated all of them in the 90s, so are Russia and other CIS countries. You can find many documentation films about that on youtube. There is almost nothing left except massive graveyards of dead criminals with funny grave tomb pictures like "sitting in my first Mercedes Benz with a gun, cool guy."" The U.S. has the rule of law, due process, innocent until proven guilty, etc.
- neonbones 5y ago>The U.S. has the rule of law, due process, innocent until proven guilty, etc. It's the same here, and we use roman law, so there won't be any precedents what someone gets to the court. All cases are the exception and go through all the processes without looking back on the same cases. Why would you think that the USA is the only country that has it? We even got incredible labor laws. They are so good that we don't even need unions for protection against companies. And just a reminder, that USA is #1 by prisoners in the world. https://www.statista.com/statistics/262961/countries-with-the-most-prisoners/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/262961/countries-with-th... Not so innocent, huh? I know, most people in the USA think that other countries are like poor villages without tech and law there. But even poor Ukraine is much more digitalized and advanced in tech. Still, even in the case of transparency of how the law works, where the budget goes (you can even vote with your mobile app where you want to spend budget money in your city), court cases, it's all digitalized, transparent, and easy to check by anyone. To be more precise, here are some links on typical bankings[1][2], government open source big data on all information that happened in the country[3], digitalized id and passport, with all the documents and request for any data or papers[4], transparent government tenders[5] and one of big media project that does all the corruption investigations with big politicians in it[6]. And no one from journalists even got arrested for that. With these links and information, I want to say that it's funny that people think that other countries got some shady government, there is no power of law, and all people are struggling without real freedom. Do you have LGBT raves to block entrance to the White House and annoy the president? Because we do[7] 1. https://www.monobank.ua/?lang=en https://www.monobank.ua/?lang=en 2. https://next.privat24.ua/ https://next.privat24.ua/ 3. https://opendata.gov.ua/en/ https://opendata.gov.ua/en/ 4. https://diia.gov.ua/ https://diia.gov.ua/ 5. https://prozorro.gov.ua/ https://prozorro.gov.ua/ 6. https://bihus.info/ https://bihus.info/ 7. https://strana.news/news/346451-muzykalnyj-prajd-na-bankovoj-nachalasja-v-okruzhenii-kordona-politsii.html https://strana.news/news/346451-muzykalnyj-prajd-na-bankovoj...
- truffdog 5y agoThe US murder rate isn't normally distributed. It's highly concentrated in a few hotspots, with most of the country living in areas with European murder rates. The news is national though, so you wind up in this weird situation with suburbanites buying guns and worried about urban Chicago a thousand miles away.
- mpweiher 5y ago> The US murder rate isn't normally distributed Neither are the murder rates in other countries. > It's highly concentrated in a few hotspots Same here. > with most of the country living in areas with European murder rates. Nope. You need to compare the non-hotspot areas of the US with the non-hotspot areas of Europe. And you'll see the same difference as before.
- macrowhat 5y agoWell we're not a bunch of pussies and shit
- quickthrowman 5y ago> Furthermore, i find US fascination with their theoretical ability to fight their government with small arms adorable and misguided. As an American, so do I. A citizen revolution vs US Military under the thumb of a dictator would be hilariously asymmetrical. There are no consumer predator drones.
- Throwawayaerlei 5y agoWhen was the last time a country successfully attacked its logistics base? How long would those drones continue to operate? Where would their operators and formal logistics tail have to live and sleep when they aren't on duty?
- _-david-_ 5y agoYou assume all of the military would side with the dictator. This may or may not be the case. The various terrorist organizations in the Middle East fared ok against predator drones.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- wyager 5y agoIt’s misleading and counterproductive to frame this as “America has a high gun homicide rate”. It mostly affects black communities. https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/health/2021/02/23/young-black-men-teens-made-up-more-than-third-2019-gun-homicides/4559929001/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/health/2021/02/23/young-... Any intervention with the serious and actual goal of reducing gun deaths must take this into account.
- paisawalla 5y agoIf you want to engage with the point accurately, you need to break out inner city gun violence rates from suburban/rural rates. Commenter's entire point is that high gun violence is geographically restricted. If you don't live in those areas, you live in a country where gun violence is as unheard of as a European country.
- miles 5y ago> i find US fascination with their theoretical ability to fight their government with small arms adorable and misguided. Small arms appear to have served Vietnam and Afghanistan well in repelling a much larger and stronger force.
- Grakel 5y agoAsk the Taliban if small arms can fight the US military.
- NoPicklez 5y agoI agree with your post but in terms of the above commenters use of the word "murder rate" is that even the metric we should be using for comparison? How about combining that with manslaughter?
- rdevsrex 5y agoI’m sure every woman in Kabul wished they had a handgun or two.
- ykevinator3 5y agoAnd their freedom to put creationism in text books (Texas). Gun people are dumb but they're armed so we have to whisper.
- onemiketwelve 5y agoSeriously, I feel like recent history has shown so many flaws in the theory of guns protecting citizens from the government. I remember during the tsarnaev brother's attacks the crazy amount of APCs and armored vehicles that were in the arsenal of just the police. What the fuck is 5.56 in the hands of some regular Joe going to do against even the lightest armor. Not to mention the fact that it's not the fairytale tyrannical government vs the righteous citizenry. Turns out it can be subversive citizenry going up against other citizens.
- jonfromsf 5y agoHaven't the Taliban just taught us a 20-year lesson on how some guys with rifles and pickup trucks can humiliate a superpower? Low intensity warfare isn't about winning battles but disrupting governance. The guns in US citizens hands would easily be enough to disrupt governance in rural areas.
- chuckee 5y agoA list of countries by homicide rate is useless in a gun-control discussion without comparing it to gun ownership rate. This article presents a graph of gun homicides vs. gun ownership rate: https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/20121218141207-462880-in-case-you-were-wondering-why-so-many-people-get-shot-in-america https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/20121218141207-462880-in-case... This one presents a graph of all homicides vs. gun ownership rate: https://zachmortensen.net/2013/01/10/gun-control-four-must-see-graphs/ https://zachmortensen.net/2013/01/10/gun-control-four-must-s... > Furthermore, i find US fascination with their theoretical ability to fight their government with small arms adorable and misguided. So many failed foreign wars against poor countries, most recently Afghanistan, and all the lessons vanish from the mind when it comes to applying them at home.
- smichel17 5y ago> i find US fascination with their theoretical ability to fight their government with small arms adorable and misguided. There's a difference between "fight" and "defeat". Anyone who thinks that a motley band of citizens with small arms is going to force the government to surrender is delusional. What they can do is make martial law very costly, by turning the country into a war zone (see also: Afghanistan). The government really does get its power from consent of the governed. It may not seem that way, but most people are happy enough just to have stability, that they're going to stand by and keep their head down. But with a sufficiently armed populace, maintaining stability becomes simply impossible, which makes maintaining political favor an impossibility. The idea of a military coup is that you take control of a nation, not that you inherit a war zone. Small arms aren't about winning, they're about making certain actions too politically costly. I have a tough time imagining the CCP's recent actions in Hong Kong, or the Uighur genocide, working so well if they were armed like the US. Arms necessitate boiling the frog.
- gok 5y ago> …revolutions in France have done more to guide government power than anything ever that happened in the US. Sorry are you saying that the French Revolutionary Wars were not fought with guns?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 5y agoIdaho is at 2 and half of households have a gun. Puerto Rico has almost no firearms, and no land borders with the US, and is at 20. Pakistan has way more guns and is way poorer than Puerto Rico and is under 5.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dfee 5y ago> Furthermore, i find US fascination with their theoretical ability to fight their government with small arms adorable and misguided. You’d love reading about the US Revolution then! Big plot twist for ya. Can’t recommend enough!
- throwaway09223 5y ago"Angola is better at 4.85" Do you really think Angola's homicide rate is under 5 per 100k? Half the worldwide average? This is a pretty wild claim, knowing Angolan society. OSAC notes that "A large percentage of street crime goes unreported and does not appear in official police statistics" -- it seems much more likely that this low number is a function of limited police reporting and data collection, rather than actual safety. https://www.osac.gov/Country/Angola/Content/Detail/Report/d5fabc92-3b98-4fd3-9b72-1982da418125 https://www.osac.gov/Country/Angola/Content/Detail/Report/d5...
- inter_netuser 5y agoVermont has fairly permissive guns laws, no permit necessary to buy and carry an assault weapon. murder rate is 1.8, vs 3.0 in Europe. What is it about Vermont, where you can walk around with concealed assault weapons, that makes it safer than "Europe"? Czech Republic is an exception, it's a shall issue European country. The majority of gun owners also have concealed carry permits. Homicide rate is very low, only 0.9. Why? "the homicide rate in Europe was 3.0 per 100,000 population." - https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/gsh/Booklet1.pdf https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/gsh/Bookle... https://vermontbiz.com/news/2019/october/23/vermont-has-3rd-lowest-murder-rate-us https://vermontbiz.com/news/2019/october/23/vermont-has-3rd-... "Vermont Business Magazine Vermont reported the 3rd lowest murder rate (1.8) compared to other states. This was 3.1 points below the national average of 4.9 homicides per 100,000 individuals, according to a new report from safewise.com(link is external). In fact, the three states from Northern New England had the lowest murder rates." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gun_laws_in_Vermont#Summary_table https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gun_laws_in_Vermont#Summary_ta...
- rayiner 5y agoSame for other gun toting states like Idaho.
- raxxorrax 5y ago> with their theoretical ability to fight their government with small arms adorable and misguided I think your ideas are adorable. An armed populace is extremely effective in curbing government crackdown on people and yes, that is even true for small arms weapons aside from the fact that US soldiers would probably defect en masse. You think they would roll out the tanks? Even if they did, that is a fight no army could ever win. The Taliban started with sticks and stones and ended with attack helicopters. I am not from the US and I don't think there is a more successful democracy or nation for that matter, so maybe other can learn a bit. The French Revolution was armed and an armed populace is a classical fear of rulers and the motivation for weapon laws. There are advantages for policing of course. Policemen in Europe can be relatively sure they aren't fired upon in many cases and that results in completely different form of conduct with state executive forces. But there are other arguments for the US to allow arms, for topological and geographical reasons alone.