22 ms·
TC Energy scraps Keystone XL pipeline project after Biden revokes key permit
- eloff 5y agoAs a Canadian, born in Calgary, Alberta, I'm saddened to hear this. But it seems to be part of the platform of the Democrats. As a citizen of Earth, I'm of mixed feelings. On the one hand heavy crude from the tar sands, which is some of the most polluting oil on the planet, because it requires so much energy to extract, will keep shipping by rail to the United States. That involves more spills than a pipeline and burning yet more fuel. That's bad. On the other hand that makes the prices higher and both constrains the volume of output and the price at which it's profitable to extract. Both things that mean more of that tar sands oil will stay in the ground. That's good. On the other, other hand - more tar sands oil staying in the ground means more oil from elsewhere in the world, often from politically unstable or unfriendly regimes will replace the oil the US otherwise would have imported from Canada. That's potentially bad. I'm not sure which outcome is better for Canada, the USA, or the world. I'm pretty sure neither Obama, Trump, not Biden had any accurate idea either. Edit: and the downvotes are because you disagree with my economic analysis? Or because you think any of those politicians actually have a solid, fundamental analysis including unintentional consequences? Get real, they did it for political reasons, that's why they came out on different sides of the issue based on party lines. Actually judging by the downvotes, I think it was a smart political move. I really wish HN would require a comment with a downvote, even if it's only visible to the OP.
- tachyonbeam 5y agoWe all need to transition to renewable energy. It's not good for Canada to become more invested in the oil economy, just as electric cars, trucks and renewables are starting to boom. It's neither good for you environmentally or economically if you have a 10+ year horizon.
- eloff 5y agoI think you just read the first sentence of my comment.
- eloff 5y agoThe OP edited their comment, now mine no longer makes sense.
- treeman79 5y agoSo we continue prop up terrorist regimes for the next few decades. Electric is approaching winning on its own merits. Giving billions to horrible people in the mean time is not an acceptable solution. Oil independence is great for America and Canada. Independence “from” oil is a separate if related matter. A half way point is to allow drilling and pipeline and add taxes to local oil and major tariffs on external oil. We get oil independence, alternative tech will be encouraged to replace expensive oil. Only losers are people that use oil.
- tachyonbeam 5y agoIsn't the US already a net exporter of oil at the moment?
- treeman79 5y agohttps://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=41754 https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=41754 That is a recent thing. It can easily go the other way again.
- marricks 5y agoOur current government structures seem incapable of planning more than 1 year out. Without radically higher oil prices it seems unlikely we'll see the large scale changes needed. Shut down as many pipelines as we can, stop producing oil, build solar farms, build wind farms, build nuclear, everything should be on the table and done simultaneously if we want our grandchildren to have a live remotely similar to ours. The framing of governments and media seems like only half steps are possible, but those steps will still kill us.
- throwaway316943 5y agoI wish we had a more informed perspective on oil. Yes it’s very important that we move individual and public transportation to electric now that we have the batteries to do so. Yes we need to switch energy production to renewables and zero carbon generation. Yes we need to get as much heat generation as possible for homes, commerce and industry switched to electric. All of these have in common the fact that we should not be burning oil. But, and this is a big but, we still need oil to produce a vast array of materials and compounds that our civilization depends on. Medicine and agriculture are two huge users that we cannot do without. We can’t shut down all oil production and drive the cost through the roof without destroying healthcare and creating famine. Please argue rationally, frame combustion of oil as wasteful while lionizing responsible usage that does not contribute to atmospheric CO2 and improves the human condition.
- bryanlarsen 5y agoAlberta oil sands oil is the most expensive and dirtiest oil source on the planet. So when oil demand drops, the Alberta oil sands will be the first place to stop operating. Plastic will be made from the cheapest oil. It's also possible that eventually we'll make plastic using CO2 as the feed-stock rather than oil.
- marricks 5y agoThe lack of productivity in the conversation comes from voices like yours which compromise themselves internally before even facing the opposing side. Obviously if all oil companies magically shutdown today human society would be cataclysmically affected. That would never going to happen short of a "Childhood's End" style alien invasion. Any change, even with extreme external pressure, would be gradual. That's why one must always advocate for the position purely and without compromise. Shut down this pipeline, shut down the next one that comes up. Etc etc. "Reasonable" perspectives have not helped the planet at all in the past 50 years. ========== EDIT: One more thought, let's consider how EFFECTIVE the oil industry has been. Continuous profits, continuous increase in production, great subsidies. How did they do this? Well, for one thing, they knew about global warming was caused by burning fossil fuels decades before admitting it publicly. They argued from the strongest framing of their position: "fossil fuels don't cause global warning so nothing should change" It's only in the past decade or so that they put on a face of caring about renewables. That's because public pressure grew enough that the strongest portrayal of their side was acting like they're already doing everything they can. Moral of the story, if you want to be affective don't compromise. The benefit of caring about the environment is at least we don't have to lie about our side, just boldly state truths and what should happen.
- epigen 5y agoThat sums up the dilemma. Killing the pipeline will help but not in a vacuum. Continued policy/pressure needs to be applied to move away from oil, which is probably best for the sake of the world.
- gautamcgoel 5y agoYeah. My first reaction is that this is great news, but as you say, the oil may now come from Brazil, Iran, etc. On the whole, I think it's a win for the environment, but I would like to see a detailed analysis of the predicted effects of this decision on oil exploration, extraction, and consumption. I do feel a bit sympathetic for the company driving this project. They invested billions of dollars and over a decade of time only to see the project killed at the last minute. This is a consequence of our erratic and unpredictable political system - every four years we seem to completely change energy policy. It's the price of our democracy, but I'm sure it's frustrating for CEOs. Edit: It's frustrating to see the parent comment get downvoted. If you disagree, explain why in a comment - no need to bury a perfectly reasonable perspective.
- pseudolus 5y agoIt's hard not to be sympathetic to those Albertans whose lives will be impacted by this decision. However, for too long Canada has relied on extractive industries leading to a mild case of Dutch disease. Perhaps the loss of Keystone will jump-start Alberta's nascent start-up scene and other non-polluting sectors of its economy.
- eloff 5y agoAlberta fundamentally has to shift gears - just like Saudi Arabia. The world will move on from fossil fuels and they had better have a plan to transition. Norway has been handling their fossil fuels remarkably intelligently.
- rootusrootus 5y ago> Norway has been handling their fossil fuels remarkably intelligently. How so? Oil production is ticking back up and is higher than any time since about 2010.
- jgon 5y agoNorway is an entire country that has just slightly more people than the province of Alberta, which is to say that is it much smaller than Canada, while having oil reserves equal to or greater than those in Alberta. Alberta should obviously have been more diligent in saving up oil revenues generated, but this ignores the fact that a huge amount of oil revenues generated in Alberta have gone to help the rest of the country develop as well. Roughly 250-300 billion dollars from Alberta has transferred to the rest of the country since Alberta's discovery of oil, which would essentially give funding equivalent to the Norwegian sovereign fund. So when people say "where did all the money go?" the answer is that it went to hospitals in Chicoutimi, roads in Neepawa, schools in Battle Harbor, etc, etc. Trying to compare sovereign Norway with a single province in a confederation is always going to give a skewed view of what Alberta should or should not have done with its resource wealth.
- mnouquet 5y ago> Alberta should obviously have been more diligent in saving up oil revenues generated It was literally all stolen by the Federal government through equalization payment. Can't really blame Alberta here...
- munk-a 5y ago> On the other, other hand - more tar sands oil staying in the ground means more oil from elsewhere in the world, often from politically unstable or unfriendly regimes will replace the oil the US otherwise would have imported from Canada. This statement has some inaccuracies in it, it is true that it will literally result in more oil from other places, but, given supply and demand, it will result in less additional oil from other sources. Whenever a cheap source of a good is eliminated the average production price of that good is increased (assuming there is an exhaustible supply of that good at that price) so the removal, or even inconveniencing of access, to tar sands extract will cause an up-tick in prices overall and a likely unnoticeable dip in supply. Additionally, as a Canadian myself, the Alberta oils sands have recently contributed strongly to an economic crisis in Calgary as extraction profitability has sharply declined. There is a lot of oil still left up there but Alberta needs to act now, while it has the funds to do so, to transition their economy. It is not a feasible long term revenue source.
- eloff 5y ago> This statement has some inaccuracies in it, it is true that it will literally result in more oil from other places, but, given supply and demand, it will result in less additional oil from other sources. Given strongly inelastic demand, I would say very marginally less. > Whenever a cheap source of a good is eliminated the average production price of that good is increased (assuming there is an exhaustible supply of that good at that price) so the removal, or even inconveniencing of access, to tar sands extract will cause an up-tick in prices overall and a likely unnoticeable dip in supply. I think we're saying the same thing? > Additionally, as a Canadian myself, the Alberta oils sands have recently contributed strongly to an economic crisis in Calgary as extraction profitability has sharply declined. There is a lot of oil still left up there but Alberta needs to act now, while it has the funds to do so, to transition their economy. It is not a feasible long term revenue source. Yes, they had better get serious about transitioning the economy away from oil before Calgary becomes a ghost town. People sure aren't there for the weather.
- munk-a 5y agoHrm, my wording might have been a bit off itself but I mostly just wanted to highlight and rebut what could be worded in your original statement as a sort of fatalist "Even if we reduce what's coming from Canada it won't effect overall production". I do agree that the impact won't solve global warming or potentially cause a reflection in gas pump prices, but the supply is definitely elastic and while the demand is inelastic in the long term short term price fluctuations do actually cause short term fluctuations in demand so there is a fair bit of elasticity there as well. People will find ways to reduce their car commute when prices spike and, especially, oil power plants will defer operation to cheaper (possibly less clean :sigh:) alternatives.
- whatever1 5y agoNot sure why they are downvoting you. People here seem to not get the concept of supply and demand. Specially when the demand is inelastic in the short-medium term
- tamersalama 5y agoCoincidentally, four major Canadian producers are uniting in an alliance for net-zero by 2050. The four are responsible for 90% of oil-sands production [1]. To me, this makes Canadian energy a more responsible source compared to many US-based and other international producers. [2] [1] https://calgary.ctvnews.ca/major-canadian-oilsands-producers-partner-in-move-toward-net-zero-greenhouse-gas-emissions-by-2050-1.5462675 https://calgary.ctvnews.ca/major-canadian-oilsands-producers... [2] https://www.nsenergybusiness.com/features/oil-companies-net-zero/ https://www.nsenergybusiness.com/features/oil-companies-net-...
- eloff 5y agoWell, I don't think we can take all the credit. Suncor is a US company, my dad used to work there during the takeover when it was Petro Canada. Edit: I take that back, it's always been a Canadian company. I'm thinking about something else, there was another takeover or merge with a US company back before 2000. That's before the Suncor merger. Very heartening to see though.
- cmehdy 5y agoNet-zero amongst companies is often a matter of paying a tax on what you still emit or shifting the accounting of emissions to not fully measure the entirety of your emissions (or to offload that onto other parts of society). It's fine to encourage companies to try and do things like that, but it's also important to keep that congratulatory tone in check when it comes to a world that still incentivizes profits singularly and doesn't necessarily put the price of ecologic externalities that they might deserve. Net-zero sounds perhaps cool but there should be some important education done for everybody to understand that it's far from Gross-zero (or near zero), which would be much closer to what we actually need to avoid some pretty cataclysmic collapses sooner than most people realize.
- kokanator 5y ago> and the downvotes are because.... The downvotes are because they disagree with your politics. The tough part is all your statements hold truth. We must face that if we want to find real answers. Down voting is supposed to be used to indicate a comment has no relevance to the conversation. Conversely, each of your statements must be part of the conversation. [ upvoted ] ( instantly downvoted )
- eloff 5y agoIt's odd because I'm all over the place on the political spectrum, and I didn't even take a side here other than to discuss how it makes me feel thinking about the place of my birth, which will suffer, and expressing my uncertainty in whether this is a good or bad thing overall - which is more honest than what any of those politicians have done. Maybe people don't like nuance and prefer to see the world in black and white where it agrees or disagrees with their views. I don't like to believe that's true, but it probably is in general.
- happytoexplain 5y agoIt seems unfair and unnecessarily hostile to speculate about a subset of people you just addressed ("Maybe people don't like nuance and prefer to see the world in black and white") when the only thing you know about them is that they disagreed with you for some reason. It is of course natural to be annoyed by downvotes, but the urge to start painting yourself as a victim and the anonymous mass as unthinking tends to create a really bad atmosphere for discussion. Now, if you wanted to criticize the downvote mechanism in general, maybe it would be considered off topic by HN rules, but it certainly wouldn't be unreasonable. Edit: Also, perhaps some of your downvotes are due to your commenting on your own downvotes. Personally, I always downvote those kinds of comments (including the self-fulfilling-prophecy version: "I'll be downvoted/flagged for this, but..."), even if I find the rest of the post interesting, or completely agree with them. But I have no idea if other people do that.
- eloff 5y agoOther reasons I might speculate about are just as uncharitable. Such as, they have no understanding of microeconomics as applied to a good with inelastic demand. Or they just read the first sentence and down voted and moved on. At best I think one could argue I phrased things such that it rubbed people the wrong way. Possibly the last comment about politicians.
- raclage 5y ago> I'm not sure which outcome is better for Canada, the USA, or the world. I'm pretty sure neither Obama, Trump, not Biden had any accurate idea either. > Or because you think any of those politicians actually have a solid, fundamental analysis including unintentional consequences? Get real, they did it for political reasons, that's why they came out on different sides of the issue based on party lines. Or maybe Obama, Trump, and Biden had different ideas about what "better for the USA" meant that led to them making reasonably rational but different decisions? Maybe, maybe not. But I'm not sure your assumption that all three of those presidents have a worse understanding of this issue than you do is justified.
- eloff 5y ago> Or maybe Obama, Trump, and Biden had different ideas about what "better for the USA" meant that led to them making reasonably rational but different decisions? Yes, that's basically what politics is about in a nutshell, making different tradeoffs based on values. I'm not sure any of them actually had a sufficiently detailed analysis or model to justify having any certainty in their decision. > But I'm not sure your assumption that all three of those presidents have a worse understanding of this issue than you do is justified. Don't get me wrong, I don't understand the issue either. I'm just honest about that fact and merely espoused why it's a complicated dilemma. This is all unintentional consequences and it's not clear which was the best call for the environment, the countries involved, or the world at large. I would have liked to see an in-depth study of the tradeoffs and a rational decision based on that rather than a political decision, which seems to be what we got all three times.
- edoceo 5y agoI only downvote cause of your comments about voting. Like the guidelines say "that shit boring". Your other points were creative even if a little /edgy/ and could(will?) get conversation on their own.
- viraptor 5y ago> That involves more spills than a pipeline Have you got a good source for this? I can only find information about ocean oil spills for transport. The rail ones are barely ever mentioned and much less than the pipeline ones.
- rascul 5y agoThis PDF has a bit on spills on the last page. https://www.strata.org/pdf/2017/pipelines.pdf https://www.strata.org/pdf/2017/pipelines.pdf
- chris_va 5y agoMaybe this: https://www.fraserinstitute.org/sites/default/files/safety-in-the-transportation-of-oil-and-gas-pipelines-or-rail-rev2.pdf https://www.fraserinstitute.org/sites/default/files/safety-i... ... (not my area, but I was curious too)
- userbinator 5y agoLurk long enough here and you'll see that HN has an environmentalist bias. Edit: thanks for the downvote, and for reminding me why I almost always stay away from the political stuff here.
- useragent86 5y agoMore specifically, the environmentalists are censorious, using their downvotes liberally (really, illiberally) to suppress dissenting views. This makes it hard for dissenters to even discover the presence of other dissenters. Meanwhile, the dissenters are less censorious and more oriented toward discussion, so they don't downvote opponents as much. The result is a heavy--and obvious--bias. But according to dang, because people on both sides perceive a bias against them, HN must be unbiased. It's kind of like that theory about vegetarians causing everyone else to eat vegetarian: it's too much trouble to cater to both, and vegetarians refuse to compromise, so everyone just gets vegetarian food.
- happytoexplain 5y ago>environmentalists ... suppress dissenting views >dissenters are less censorious and more oriented toward discussion This is a really broad insult and complement to two really broad categories of people. This is frankly almost as over-general as saying "people I agree with are good people and people I disagree with are bad people".
- useragent86 5y agoYou're entitled to your opinion. Nevertheless, I think it's an obvious conclusion borne out by observation of the political spectrum and conversations on HN. One could even say that your reaction lends it credence ("He must be talking about me!"). BTW, friendly correction: complement vs. compliment.
- dang 5y ago> But according to dang, because people on both sides perceive a bias against them, HN must be unbiased. I've never made that argument. Edit: it looks like your account has been using HN primarily for ideological battle. Would you please stop doing that? It's against the rules because it destroys the curious conversation that HN is supposed to exist for. That means it's an abuse of the site and we ban accounts that do it, regardless of what their ideology happens to be.
- hindsightbias 5y agoIt was scrapped either because the Chinese decided they don’t want your tar or because we want to screw them.
- invisible 5y agoThere is no mention in the article about the previous permit being revoked by the court for being illegal.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoCould you supply some specifics/citations for the previous permit being revoked for being illegal?
- invisible 5y agoSure. https://www.npr.org/2018/11/09/665994751/judge-puts-keystone-xl-pipeline-on-hold-pending-further-environmental-study https://www.npr.org/2018/11/09/665994751/judge-puts-keystone... Edit (add NEPA info): https://www.epa.gov/nepa/what-national-environmental-policy-act#NEPA https://www.epa.gov/nepa/what-national-environmental-policy-...
- kokanator 5y agoIt doesn't say it is illegal rather that the analysis wasn't as thorough as necessary. >In Thursday's ruling, Morris wrote that the State Department's analysis of potential environmental effects fell short of a "hard look" on the effects of current oil prices on the viability of Keystone, cumulative effects of greenhouse gas emissions, cultural resources and potential oil spills.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> It doesn't say it is illegal Yes it does. > rather that the analysis wasn't as thorough as necessary. It was revoked because it was illegally issued (in violation of the National Environmental Policy Act and thr Administrative Procedure Act) because the analysis was not sufficient to meet the legal requirements for issuing it.
- maxerickson 5y ago
- bpodgursky 5y agoI don't like the oil economy at all, but revoking permits after a company has spent billions laying pipes using government-granted permits does leave a bad taste in my mouth. It seems like bad precedent for the assumption to be that the federal government will pull the carpet out from under your feet (losing you your entire investment) whenever the political winds shift. Today it's an oil pipeline, but tomorrow it could be for a solar installation in a nature reserve, or new hydropower, or a nearly-complete nuclear power plant.
- zbrozek 5y agoThis is key. It erodes trust in institutions, in this case the government itself. I personally wish it weren't permitted in the first place, but revoking the permit afterwards is the worst possible outcome.
- cryptoz 5y agoA government that ignores climate change loses far more trust than one who pays attention and acts in response. Permitting the building of new pipelines is absolutely a sign of an untrustworthy government. A government needs to be able to change its mind and always act in the best interests of the people. Building a pipeline because some rich corporation has some sunk costs is insane. Edit: Also, I only addressed the environmental issues, but the article also cites "U.S. landowners, Native American tribes". Don't you think its also good that they get a say in what gets built? And that it is likely that the early construction was done without full understanding by those groups impacted directly?
- happytoexplain 5y ago>revoking the permit afterwards is the worst possible outcome It seems like many people feel that it's the second to worst possible outcome.
- munk-a 5y agoI think it's important to also realize that Canada domestically (outside of Alberta) has been strongly opposed to expanding natural resource exportation[1]. The Kinder Morgan pipeline through BC was ~shut down~[2] - as have been multiple propositions to get the oil out through the maritime provinces. If Alberta had a coast they would never consider the keystone pipeline as an option but this is sort of a effort of last resort - every direction except south wants nothing to do with this and the constantly shifting political winds in America mean it's extremely unlikely that this project would actually be complete while the tar sands remain profitable. I think it's a bit unfair to talk about this permit being withdrawn without warning when literally every other route open for export has been shut down - it's like asking your dad for candy after your mom said no, they might go along with you for a bit but the outcome is likely to be swayed by the same basic facts. 1. Existing transportation is also highly problematic, one of the really big questions for Canadians here is whether the additional safety of pipelines is worth the cost to the environment, we've specifically paid that lack of safety cost several times including https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lac-M%C3%A9gantic_rail_disaster https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lac-M%C3%A9gantic_rail_disaste... and more generally https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/saskatoon/lac-megantic-crude-oil-train-canada-guernsey-saskatchewan-rail-1.5608769 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/saskatoon/lac-megantic-crude-... this is very much not a simple issue in Canada. 2. Oh hey - no it isn't - this is still actively ongoing as pointed out by the comment below
- protomyth 5y agoOil is all going to get transported by rail or truck. BNSF stock going up should please Buffet.
- ArkanExplorer 5y agoThe more fossil fuel infrastructure we build out, the harder it will be to make the transition to clean energy. Adding costs to fossil fuels is not a bad thing.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoAbsolutely. We should be exploring ways to financially disadvantage refineries and fueling stations as well. Have to find every weak point in fossil infra to exploit towards a failure mode. This drives the cost up, making electrified options (that don’t emit carbon) more competitive sooner.
- hogFeast 5y agoMust be nice to be so rich that you can choose to pay more for things.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- toomuchtodo 5y agoI don’t have a solution for the species constantly borrowing from the future. The bill comes due eventually. If you think being poor sucks now, wait for water shortages and crop failures. I get it, everyone wants the benefits without the costs. But there are costs. Obligatory “we should have carbon taxes and cap and trade to help make the transition fair and equitable”. I’m aware the wealthy are culpable for higher per capita CO2 emissions, and as such they should bear a greater burden in this regard. Life ain’t fair unfortunately.
- 5y ago
- Romanulus 5y agoLike it or not, all the oil in the ground is coming up and out sooner or later.
- koolba 5y agoThis is a disaster, fiscally, environmentally, and politically. It’s a waste of all the money spent thus far, it will lead to an increase of statistically more dangerous transportation methods, and raise the price of other foreign oil imports to compensate. All around just bad policy.
- krastanov 5y agoOil being less convenient and more expensive is a win if you are a green energy absolutist (like me). It makes other energy sources that much more enticing.
- fighterpilot 5y agoIt's simply ridiculous that there's going to be oil brought in on trucks which will be significantly less efficient than a pipeline. The only sensible thing would be to have a pipeline, with zero trucks doing that work in its place, plus a carbon tax on top of that oil to adjust the price. The carbon tax could be applied uniquely to oil brought on the pipeline so as to equalize the cost of that oil with that which will instead be brought over on trucks. Which means no misaligned incentives to increase oil consumption but also no inefficiency from trucks doing the work in its place. That tax revenue is effectively new wealth since it represents the saved inefficiency of the alternative of having no pipeline.
- krastanov 5y agoSure, that would be better, but we do not live in fantasy land. You are making best (but unreachable in today's political climate) the enemy of good. On further thought, it would be best if both the pipeline and the oil transport by trucks/trains are taxed out of existence.
- fighterpilot 5y agoIs it infeasible? Wouldn't the pipeline operators happily agree to a tax or levy as part of their permit if the alternative is that they have to shut down?
- InTheArena 5y agoHere is your Friday afternoon, dump it when no one things we are looking. I do believe that we should be doing alternative energy at this point - but it's also clear that this particular decision has a lot of negative side-effects (including greater exports over trains and trucks, and increased dependency on oil-fracking and bad middle eastern regimes).
- ineedasername 5y agoWhat do you mean Friday/no one's looking? I understand traditionally that's when you break bad news, but this is the middle of the week.
- newacct583 5y agoI don't know that that's so clear at all. It's an oil pipeline to import canadian oil for domestic refiners. Domestic refined petroleum consumption peaked in 2018 and has been going down (and of course has cratered during the pandemic). There's actually no good case to be made for this thing at all from current data. You have to project an increase in demand that doesn't seem to be coming. Bottom line: this pipeline was proposed in the middle of the post-peak-oil boom in oil prices. It made sense in an imagined world of ever rising oil prices and ever larger SUVs. The world kinda moved on. Also: > increased dependency on oil-fracking This is tar sand oil. While not every drop necessarily qualifies, depending on your definition, this is process-extracted secondary petroleum. It's very much in the same category as "fracked" oil in terms of extraction efficiency.
- jonas21 5y agoIt's Wednesday.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ineedasername 5y agoHow does that work? I mean, putting aside the political & scientific issues around clean energy etc. How does the government get to revoke a permit after significant work and money was already spent based on getting the permit in the first place? Does the government pay compensation? Does the company have to file a lawsuit?
- maxerickson 5y agoThe text of the permit included a clause that said it could be revoked solely at the discretion of the president. So all it takes is the president deciding to revoke it. I'm kind of fascinated that people see such a breezy permit as an important factor in the decision to build something or not. Of course they need the permit to construct the border facility, but they aren't going to make the investment decision just based on the existence of the permit.
- toyg 5y agoGovernment gonna govern. Unless there are specific appeal clauses in the relevant permission processes, most governments can (and will) do what they want on this sort of issue. You can interpret it as a prevarication over the private individual/company, or as a reaffirmation of society's right to change its mind. This sort of scenario is precisely why private interests lobby so hard to add arbitration rules to international free-trade agreements, btw; they want to protect their investments against changes in political winds, by moving judgements on compensation to a dodgy world of ad-hoc pseudo-legal structures.
- krastanov 5y agoLook at the history of this permit: Obama's administration being against it; agencies and courts during Trump's administration being against it, but being fought; Biden's administration being against it. There was never certainty here and this company was gambling, hoping there is another administration today.
- julienb_sea 5y agoOil will move and oil will get purchased, so this is a net negative for the environment as the alternative means of transport emit more.
- Retric 5y agoOil use depends on the cost of oil. As such while less efficient than a carbon tax this is a small net benefit to the environment.
- dragosmocrii 5y agoOil doesn't really have an alternative right now for many of its applications. Plus, at the beginning of the pandemic gas was dirt cheap, yet no one needed it. However, this discussion was about transportation of oil, and the idea is that pipelines are more efficient than rail or trucks (if that even makes sense), so it's a pity the decision to halt the project is more political than even environmental.
- Retric 5y agoIncreasing the price only needs to reduce usage in any areas to see a net benefit. As to transportation options, boats and trains are extremely efficient to the point where pipelines don’t make that big of an environmental difference.
- dragosmocrii 5y agoAccording to [1] the cost in 2018 was $5/barrel via pipeline, vs $10-$15/barrel by train. Also, for Alberta boats are not an option since it's a landlocked province. Also, Alberta's oil sands are the world's largest oil reserves after Venezuela and Saudi Arabia, so a pipeline would be very economical once it starts running. Also, quote from [2]: While long-haul oil and gas pipelines are also more economical and environmentally friendly than other modes of transport like rail or trucking (pipelines create 61 to 77% less greenhouse gas emissions than rail when moving crude over long distances, says one recent study), they also have a safe delivery rate of greater than 99.999%. This is quoted from Enbridge's website, which is a pipeline company, which may be a bit biased, however I doubt they are lying. [1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2018/10/11/which-is-safer-for-transporting-crude-oil-rail-truck-pipeline-or-boat/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2018/10/11/which-is-... [2] https://www.enbridge.com/Your-questions/User-submitted/Why-are-pipelines-safest-way-to-move-energy-products.aspx#:~:text=While%20long%2Dhaul%20oil%20and,a%20safe%20delivery%20rate%20of https://www.enbridge.com/Your-questions/User-submitted/Why-a...
- yabones 5y agoOil pipelines do one thing - transport oil. Not water, not milk, not corn syrup. Just oil. Rail can transport anything. Containers, tankers, even rocket booster segments. Yes, we're absolutely taking a short term hit, but investing in general purpose infrastructure that can be adapted for new technology and demands is a good thing. The continental rail network started off with coal powered steam trains, then diesel, now diesel-electric and even some pure electric locomotives. Maybe this century it will evolve past fossil fuels as well. So yes, cancel the pipeline, but in its place invest in the safety and reliability of rail networks.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rohitb91 5y agoWhat about safety and natural disasters from rail and cost?
- dugditches 5y agoLet alone the cost of employing all the union railway workers, maintenance crews, technicians, etc and the footprint of the trains themselves operating. There's a reason pipelines exist, and that is in their simplicity of transporting the product efficiently. Sure they can't transport anything else, but I don't think too many rocket boosters would be traveling to remote areas in Canada.
- throwawaysea 5y agoI find Biden's position on this to be odd given that he also agreed to a Russian oil pipeline recently (see https://nypost.com/2021/05/26/biden-waiving-sanctions-on-russian-pipeline-because-its-finished/ https://nypost.com/2021/05/26/biden-waiving-sanctions-on-rus... or https://www.cnn.com/2021/05/25/politics/biden-defends-decision-russian-gas-pipeline/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2021/05/25/politics/biden-defends-decisi...). The reality is we need oil. It is energy dense and supports a significant portion of our economy and individual lives. Oil pipelines can have spills, but they are comparatively rare. Now this oil will be transported through some other means, at a higher cost to consumers, with potentially greater environmental risk. I am also deeply concerned that the withdrawal of permits signals an extreme degree of instability in America's business environment, which future investors and entrepreneurs have to now think about. Why would anyone invest here if they can't be sure what the government will allow or disallow next, especially with the fast-moving leftward political shift? A weaker business environment has numerous secondary implications. If the US economy is weaker, while other economies are getting stronger, our influence in the world will be impacted (economically, militarily, culturally).
- useragent86 5y ago> If the US economy is weaker, while other economies are getting stronger, our influence in the world will be impacted (economically, militarily, culturally). To many people, that's a feature, not a bug. (The CCP being one of them, of course. The implications of domestic powers aligning with the CCP are left as an exercise for the reader.)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kelnos 5y ago> I find Biden's position on this to be odd given that he also agreed to a Russian oil pipeline recently It's a gas pipeline, not an oil pipeline, which is very different. > The reality is we need oil. The reality is that we need -- and for the most part have -- cleaner sources of energy. Whether or efforts to kneecap supply is a good move right now is certainly up for debate. > Now this oil will be transported through some other means, at a higher cost to consumers, with potentially greater environmental risk. That's true, and is not great. But if you make oil more expensive, cleaner alternatives become more attractive. > I am also deeply concerned that the withdrawal of permits signals an extreme degree of instability in America's business environment To be fair, this particular permit had a clause saying it could be revoked at any time by the sitting president. And another poster points out (haven't had a chance to verify) that this particular pipeline has been opposed for over a decade, even during the Trump administration, with the permit approval essentially happening for political reasons.
- ItNeverEndsForU 5y agoIf you're concerned about Trump and Russia, you should note that the pro-Russian Nordstream 2 didn't face any sanctions from the Biden administration. Breaking Keystone benefits Russia, but y'all smart people ain't ready for that yet.
- hedora 5y agoThis is great news, but a $1/gallon carbon capture tax would be even better.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- MaxHoppersGhost 5y agoGot any other good ways to tax the working poor? $1/gallon tax is a very regressive tax.
- bequanna 5y agoSo, a regressive tax that hurts the poor and would end up only benefiting the special interests and creating more do-nothing gov’t bloat? If you’re already playing with other peoples’ money and trying to change behavior I would suggest less stick, more carrot.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoSuch tax proposals usually try to be net zero. That means at the end of the year the poor are given the money back, and the rich are not.
- sjg1729 5y agoFrom How To Save a Planet, a podcast I like: Alex Blumberg: ...and, [pipeline company] Enbridge says, stopping the pipeline won't stop the development of tar-sands oil. The oil will just travel in less safe ways, like by rail. Ayana Elizabeth Johnson: But Tara says that argument is missing the entire point. [Attorney and activist] Tara Houska: The idea is always like, you know, we're replacing old ones that are leaking. How about instead of replacing them and expanding them—which is what you're actually doing—you decommission the old one and pull it out of the ground and clean up the earth that you've contaminated? Ayana: I like that option better. Tara: And there's always, like, this premise of, well, it's gonna get shipped anyway. No, it's not. Like, that's the whole point. No, it's not. Your industry is on its way out. And that's the point. And we all know that. You can't sit there and say, "Oh, well, it's gonna go by rail or it's gonna go by ship anyway. No, it's not. The tar sands are on their way out. And that's the reality. https://gimletmedia.com/shows/howtosaveaplanet/76h4r25 https://gimletmedia.com/shows/howtosaveaplanet/76h4r25
- bawolff 5y agoAnd yet y'all keep using oil. If you don't like oil, there's an easy solution, stop buying it.
- wyattpeak 5y agoThat's not a remotely easy solution. It's just easy to state. If someone can afford solar panels and an electric car (or don't need a car to get to work), more power to them, but that doesn't describe the vast majority of society.
- ArnoVW 5y agoIt is my understanding that solar pannels have an ROI that is ever shorter. Hell, in many countries there are companies that arrange installation and financing, and that have good prices due to centralised purchasing. But that is another discussion. The real point is in the first R of the hierachy of the three R's : Reduce, Re-use, Re-cycle. No need to compensate huge use of energy, if you're not using the energy in the first place. Some of the things we do in our household to reduce energy / CO2 / oil footprint (by decreasing order of impact): * own a house that is well insulated * instead of heating it, put on a sweater * instead of using an A/C, close shutters during hot parts of day during hot season * go on holiday by train or car * own a tiny car, that is 10 years old (we have two boys) * use the car only for exceptions (I bring the boys to school in a bus, train for work) * no red meat, very little other meat * buy less stuff * recycle packaging / paper * when we buy stuff, take into account packaging (reusable bags for rice, pasta, nuts, chocolate, etc) For the avoidance of doubt, these are not choices given by economics. We're in the top 5% earning. We simply have made a choice to limit our impact whenever we can. And honestly, I can't say that our lifestyle is suffering. Does this eliminate our footprint? No. But we are using, by my account, 20% that of an average American household. Can everyone do all of this? No, probably not. Buying a well-insulated house is expensive. Not everyone can use public transport. But if everyone made an effort, the world would be a different place today.
- elil17 5y agoPretty much unrelated, but I think pipelines are cool (but fossil fuels aren’t!) - if you want to read about milk and beer pipelines: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pipeline_transport#Other_systems https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pipeline_transport#Other_sys...
- cascom 5y agoThe economics of Canadian oil sands production are just not that marginal for production to be affected by this. Suncor figures that their fully loaded breakeven oil price is $35 WTI [1](WTI is currently trading in the $60s). All that has happened here is more oil getting shipped by rail with a higher carbon footprint. [1] https://www.suncor.com/-/media/project/suncor/files/investor-centre/investor-relations-presentations-2021/2021-q1-suncor-energy-investor-presentation-en.pdf?la=en-ca&modified=20210503210331&hash=17C9C8273744F9BFC6ADE35DF296F83771538118 https://www.suncor.com/-/media/project/suncor/files/investor...
- fshbbdssbbgdd 5y agoDoes anyone know what the cost of transporting oil by rail, pipeline, or truck is in terms of dollars per barrel? Seems like it would make it easier to understand whether it affects the viability of oil production.
- brutus1213 5y agoI'm a bit confused by all the anti Canadian pipeline sentiment in the US. Is this a Biden thing or something broader. I get the focus on using less oil, environment, etc. But Canada is a key US ally and oil is still a strategic resource. It seems crazy for the US to not want Canadian oil. What am I missing?
- jcranmer 5y agohttps://www.eia.gov/outlooks/steo/images/Fig19.png https://www.eia.gov/outlooks/steo/images/Fig19.png is a decent illustration of one of the issues here: the US has been reducing its demand for oil imports over the past decade. In addition, the kind of oil that comes out of the tar sands in Alberta is pretty much the lowest, worst grade of oil possible (not to mention some of the most expensive to produce!), so if you've got more oil than you know what to do with, it's the first one you'd want to stop buying. Besides the environmental issue of "we don't want to spend any extra money subsidizing oil production," there's also a strong amount of concern about the impact along the construction pipeline--particularly among the indigenous lands it would travel against the wishes of the indigenous people who live there.
- MaxHoppersGhost 5y agoIt not only hurts an ally, it also indirectly puts money in the pockets of not so friendly/progressive countries. This Keystone XL stuff is peak virtue signaling by Biden et al. It makes no sense.
- thinkcontext 5y agoThe part you are missing is Canadian tar sands oil has a very high carbon footprint to produce, amongst the worst in the world.
- londons_explore 5y agoIs it right for a government to revoke a permit after issuance for no fault of the permit holder? Will the permit holder be compensated for lost revenue from the oil pipeline they had been given permission to build but now cannot? What would happen had the permit been revoked after the oil pipeline was already operational?
- hannob 5y agoIt's been clear for many years that there are already more fossil fuel projects in the pipeline than what the planet can handle. This wasn't a secret. The fault of these companies was pretending that they can ignore the climate crisis. The choice is actually quite simple: Either we find a way to stop projects already in the pipeline and sometimes already in operation or the planet gets burned. I know which one I'd choose.
- LeanderK 5y agoA lot of comments here saying that this will increase the cost of oil so make oil extraction more profitable. But I wonder, this won't increase demand, because it's increasing cost. So it's a net-win, right? Tar-Sand oil is so environmentally unfriendly that the alternative is better, afaik. But this ignores falling costs for renewables. Since the price of renewables is falling drastically, this should bolster energy creation via renewables (since it becomes more competitive) and therefore also driving the cost further down. So this could also accelerate the progress of switching to renewables. I think the better way would be to build the pipeline without subsidies at all and increase taxes on it. So we won't see a cheaper price and have a better mode of transport, but that's probably not politically feasible, so this is the next best option. I think the comments declaring "oil will find a way" are completely wrong. This is not about eliminating oil and I think most supporters of the scrap will know this.
- TrispusAttucks 5y agoI don't see how we can ever get off oil practically and environmentally friendly without more nuclear energy generation capacity in the US and globally. https://www.epa.gov/sites/production/files/2016-05/global_emissions_gas_2015.png https://www.epa.gov/sites/production/files/2016-05/global_em... https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/e/e2/Electricity_Generation_Sources_for_the_United_States.svg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/e/e2/Electric... https://www.epa.gov/sites/production/files/styles/medium/public/2017-04/2014_emissions_0.png https://www.epa.gov/sites/production/files/styles/medium/pub... https://www.epa.gov/sites/production/files/2016-05/global_emissions_sector_2015.png https://www.epa.gov/sites/production/files/2016-05/global_em... https://c.files.bbci.co.uk/16D76/production/_108485539_optimised-travel_carbon-nc.png https://c.files.bbci.co.uk/16D76/production/_108485539_optim... Transportation is 14% which is not insignificant. But EV transport still requires charging from the powerplant, materials, mining, disposal. I am hopeful we will overcome them but we will exchange pollution problems for new different pollution problems.
- epistasis 5y agoNuclear energy is far too expensive and far too slow to build, it will not contribute much to our energy future. Our build rate for nuclear is tiny, less than 1GW/year, and there is little hope of scaling nuclear production capacity to something 100GW/year or more, which is what we would need if nuclear is going to contribute in a significant way to a climate solution. In contrast, we are scaling solar, wind, and storage production at a huge rate, and the increases in production capacity are huge each year. It's been a few months since I've don the napkin math, but at the current rate of production increases, extrapolated to 2035, we will just barely be able to replace all fossil fuel energy with renewable electricity. Electrification of many primary fossil fuel uses, such as heat and transportation, will require 1/3 to 1/4 as much energy (see the amount of rejected energy in the top right here [1]). But at the same time, the developing world will be greatly increasing their use of energy services, and renewables will be the easiest way to do that. So even though developed countries' total energy use will go down as we electrify, developing countries' use will go up. [1] https://flowcharts.llnl.gov/content/assets/images/energy/us/Energy_US_2020.png https://flowcharts.llnl.gov/content/assets/images/energy/us/...
- robomartin 5y agoThis idea that oil is on its way out is truly laughable. In fact, cancelling this pipeline might do far more harm than good. Simple exercise: - Fire-up Excel - Model a future with 100 million electric cars - Determine how much power (not energy) will be required to plug them in every day Now answer a simple question: Were is this energy going to come from? Then realize that the oil economy goes way beyond just fuel. This is a complex problem with an almost unlimited number of variables. For example, the buttons and the cloth of the shirt you are wearing are likely made with oil byproducts. The same is the case for parts of the sewing machines, tools, computers and even the building where it was made. The machines required oil-based lubricants. The factory used other oil-based products, such as release agents and other chemicals. The people who work there, in turn, could not live or even get to work, without myriad products made from or that require oil derivatives. And then there’s the vehicles, transportation and communications systems, all of which depend on oil for materials (plastics) and fuel. And that’s just the tip of the iceberg. Ignoring reality does not lead to better outcomes. Go back to power required to charge 100 million vehicles. Given our current energy infrastructure we would have to burn astronomical quantities of everything we can burn in order to support “clean” transportation. Either that or we have to start building nuclear power plants at a pace and a scale never before seen. Not saying this pipeline saves the world. I am simply suggesting we are failing to exercise critical thinking and, because of this, tend to focus on the wrong problems. It is far easier for politicians to sell “pipeline = evil) than to discuss the energy realities of all-electric transportation at scale. One gets you votes. The other one gets you voted out. And that’s how we end-up on the wrong path.
- tbihl 5y agoI am all in favor of the idea of pipelines, because they improve on rail/road transport from an efficiency perspective. Having said that, the US seems not to have the legal or ethical framework in place to make them work, because the leaks are too common, too slowly-discovered, and too enormous. So maybe doing pipelines correctly is actually uncompetitive with other forms of moving oil, because time and time it again it seems to be a rejected option by the people building leaky pipelines.
- 5y ago
- happyjack 5y agoHuge win for climate ! https://www.api.org/oil-and-natural-gas/wells-to-consumer/transporting-oil-natural-gas/pipeline/where-are-the-pipelines https://www.api.org/oil-and-natural-gas/wells-to-consumer/tr... Just 190,000 more miles to go !