47 ms·
It's time for us in the tech world to speak out about cryptocurrency
- darepublic 5y agoYeah it's an end run around financial regulation. Run crypto run!
- tomgp 5y agofor me the key tweet here is: > The two things people need to know about cryptocurrency are completely non-technical: > 1. If it doesn't work, it's just an easy to lose casino chip >2. If it works, it creates an end run around all financial regulation, and will be dominated by uses those regulations try to stop (edited for formatting)
- dehrmann 5y agoThe thing people also overlook on point 2 is that if cryptocurrencies and blockchain tech take over the traditional financial system, that doesn't mean bitcoin, or even etherium, did. In no way is bitcoin a bet on blockchain tech; people just tell themselves that story because it feels better than gambling on crypto trading cards. Nothing wrong with gambling on them, either; just don't say you're "investing."
- davesque 5y agoWhat an original and thoughtful take on a topic that really hasn't gotten enough attention on HN up until now.
- friedman23 5y agoWould love to get a real time look at the dopamine rush the author got when writing this long winded diatribe. I can smell the self righteousness through my speakers.
- nathias 5y agoI'm so happy we have these enlightened people that can intuit the truth we, the delusional can not.
- mapgrep 5y agoIt’s “not decentralized” and also it’s used to move “billions in crime money around.” Hmm. It’s a fraudulent “con” and also very dangerous because it subverts regulations. Hmm. Seems pretty contradictory, no? You can either criticize bitcoin for not working or for working too well but Maciej seems to be trying to do both at once. I’m not a Bitcoin user or particularly a fan but these self contradicting attack lines don’t seem likely to be politically effective. Just choose one. I’d go with “mostly used for crime.” And then add “environmentally ruinous” for good measure.
- ketzo 5y agoWhat makes you think that criminals are not capable of centralization?
- CyberRabbi 5y agoIt’s hyperbole to say Bitcoin has no social benefit. It, at least, allows individuals to exchange payments between each other online without needing the consent of any private corporation or monopoly. Maybe it’s not the most efficient way of doing it but decentralization has a cost. I think we are all patiently waiting for better alternatives.
- one2three4 5y ago>> without needing the consent of any private corporation or monopoly I'd say we all subsidize bitcoin and the likes indirectly and unwillingly through the price hikes in HW directly or indirectly attributed to something of dubious (to put it mildly) tangible value.
- someguydave 5y agoweekend commie nocoiners gotta upvote their hot takes
- idlewords 5y agoThose individuals need the consent of at least two private corporations (whatever entity converts spendable money to Bitcoin and back on either end). Compare that to sending an envelope full of dollars.
- CyberRabbi 5y ago> Those individuals need the consent of at least two private corporations Not true, you can exchange Bitcoin locally with other individuals. Mailing paper money or checks over postal service is not comparable to making payments using Bitcoin online. Especially when considering international payments.
- amingilani 5y ago> Cryptocurrency is sustained by a mix of money laundering, vaporware, fraud, ransomware, gambling, and delusion. It has no social benefit except helping end first dates fast > What we especially need to stress to regulators is that there's no relationship between the technical claims of cryptocurrency and our now over 13 years of experience. It's not decentralized, it's not a currency, it's not a store of value, and it's not a promising technology > Cryptocurrency solves no problems that it didn't first create, and most of those it doesn't solve. Smart contracts are neither of those things—at worst they're an API for fraud, or as @qrs put it, self-funding bug bounties at best Those are a lot of hasty statements made without indisputable evidence. Edit: I'll take any evidence if indisputable evidence is too high a bar.
- sedatk 5y ago> Those are a lot of hasty statements made without indisputable evidence. That reminds me of that guy who didn't receive his package and filed a complaint to the store he bought it from. They asked for a proof that the package didn't arrive, and he replied with the photo of his empty hands.
- icelancer 5y agoIronically enough the Pinboard account is engaging in the same nonsense and rhetoric it accuses cryptocurrency supporters of, hoping no one will notice.
- dev_tty01 5y agoWhere is the "indisputable evidence" to dispute the claims of the article?
- amingilani 5y agoYou mean the thread? The onus is on them to prove their claims. See burden of proof: https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/burden-of-proof https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/burden-of-proof
- 5y ago
- vimy 5y agoWritten from the perspective of someone in a first world country. Edit: https://www.statista.com/chart/18345/crypto-currency-adoption/ https://www.statista.com/chart/18345/crypto-currency-adoptio...
- hilbertseries 5y agoWhat’s the advantage of cryptocurrency over mpesa?
- vimy 5y agoIt's worldwide.
- dredmorbius 5y agoWhat fraction of all commerce is worldwide as opposed to local? What degree of that difference, if any, is a consequence of payment frictions rather than other factors (say: most activity and interactions are local). What preferences are exhibited by major international buyers and sellers for payment or credit systems?
- friedman23 5y agoWhy don't you go answer these questions yourself? All you are doing is stifling discussion.
- dredmorbius 5y agoAsking questions is stifling conversation? And making blind assertions and veiled insults is not? The claim was made. Its relevance should be determinable. That aside: - Gravity model of trade. - "Research: How Far Will Consumers Travel to Make Routine Purchases?" https://blog.accessdevelopment.com/research-how-far-will-consumers-travel-to-make-routine-purchases https://blog.accessdevelopment.com/research-how-far-will-con...
- john_alan 5y agoHacker news is holistically anti cryptocurrency. Which disappoints me. It has virtues. As someone who works in applied Cryptography and has also worked for the European Central Bank, we need “crypto”. 1) seigniorage is an abused privilege. Source: US debt ceiling at 27TRN. 2) permissionless money has value, I cannot send more than 5k a day using my bank. I can send any amount using crypto. I also don’t need two utility bills and an address to open an “account” 3) it’s censorship resistant. Govt’s can’t just stop payments or shutdown the network. Use Monero. EDIT: downvoted again. I’m not contributing here anymore.
- hilbertseries 5y ago> it’s censorship resistant. Govt’s can’t just stop payments or shutdown the network. If they have a firewall, they could block the majority of exchanges, wallet apps, and even ips of some of the largest mining groups.
- logicchains 5y ago>If they have a firewall, they could block the majority of exchanges, wallet apps, and even ips of some of the largest mining groups. Unless they have something as complex and comprehensive as China's firewall, they couldn't, because the protocol could just route around it.
- sp332 5y agoThat limit sounds low, e.g. Chase Bank allows wire transfers out of $100,000 per day for individuals.
- MrMan 5y agoI have sent large amounts all over the place. As for pretending to be anonymous and outside of society, I have no use for that. The issue of crypto currency, besides the resource impact, is the evil that comes from trying to destroy democratic government.
- 5y ago
- aex 5y agoThe tweet storm doesn’t even have arguments to refute.
- ceilingcorner 5y agoI don’t understand the constant criticism crypto gets. It isn’t the sort of thing that can be stopped at this point. If you don’t like it, support better alternatives or create your own. That’s really the only solution here. I don’t say this to be sarcastic. The train has already left the station.
- sp332 5y agoJust because something is growing doesn't mean it's above criticism, or regulation.
- ceilingcorner 5y agoBut this link isn’t criticism. It’s a quasi-religious two minutes hate, as every single topic on crypto inevitably turns into. I guess it’s just a reaction to the constant hype being pushed by the crypto world. As a mostly neutral observer, I really don’t get it. Regardless, this isn’t the point I was making. Crypto cannot be stopped. At best, you’ll have regulations against PoW mining.
- dang 5y agoPlease make your substantive points without name-calling. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- ceilingcorner 5y agoEdited
- pavlov 5y ago“But it’s like the early Internet!” shouted the Emperor’s coinholders. “The Internet wasn’t yet useful a mere, um, thirteen years after its invention either.” I can see how people in their twenties would fall for this argument because they can’t remember. The reality is that the internet was immediately extremely interesting (either useful or fun) for practically everyone who got access. Email and ftp alone were killer apps. A bit later came Usenet and IRC and MUD gaming. There were things to download, people to meet, flame wars to participate in. People would stay up until 4am to get a chance to go online in university shared facilities. With cryptocurrency there’s nothing to do. You could pay $100 to buy a “cryptokitten” or whatever, but then you’d be stuck shilling it on somebody else somehow. The community is a mix of Scientology-like groupthink and multi-level marketing sales pitches. The early Internet was infinite times more fun.
- dredmorbius 5y agoAn interesting line of argument, and one which affords a number of potential avenues for enlargement: - The Internet emerged from a community in which it afforded real and tangible benefits, without any one single locus of control. (Research universities, along with a number of government departments and a few major tech and defence contractors, principally.) Perhaps an alternate payment mechanism might emerge similarly. - The Internet tools which did emerge ... were well-suited to a small-world network in which local reputations could be assessed and acted on (loss of campus-based access with administrators overseeing populations of a few dozens to hundreds, rarely more than 1,000, through the early 1990s). Effectiveness at larger scales and in more hostile environments has proved ... problematic. - A clear statement of the problem(s) posed by present currency and payment systems is still lacking. Statements as do exist tend to be ... weakly grounded in emperical truth, strongly ideological (not necessarily a fault, but often one), and strongly resistant to actual demonstrated superiority after decades of effort.
- idlewords 5y agoI can't agree with your point hard enough. Really useful nascent technologies all have this pattern—they grow incrementally more interesting and constantly gain applications. Bitcoin followed this pattern for a while. But then at some point it started to regress on that axis. You could no longer buy a pizza with it, you could no longer mine it, and it got too flooded by scammers to use safely. There's nothing to really DO with blockchain unless you buy into the subculture. That's very different from early internet, early web, early radio, you name it.
- lifeisstillgood 5y agoI am not sure why this is flagged - it seems a reasonable and timely opinion piece. Cryptocurrency is a subject that has to have a deep and public debate. What the OP is saying (which I take to be "the tech world has a duty to point out the flaws in cryptocurrency to avoid giving an impression of a clean bill of health to every ICO out there") - that is a valid socially useful debate. There are valid real world uses of bitcoin (see Turkey shutting down payment apps recently). but yeah it is also a volatile wild west that is miles away from anyone's expectation of normal regulated currency behaviour. Yes there is a crying need for an "internet native" currency. What will that be - I don't know. But it is not here yet, and it is reasonable to make that clear and loud.
- dang 5y agoEdit: oh, the much simpler answer is that it was posted twice and both posts were on the front page. People flagged the dupe. That's fair. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27336405 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27336405. --- I think the submitted title probably had something to do with it; As a title, "the emperor has no clothes" is generic and baity. It's also false in the sense that there's no consensus view, so to the extent that the analogy is meaningful, it doesn't apply. I've attempted to replace that with a more neutral and representative title now, drawn from the author's own words. Suggestions for a better title are welcome. Beyond that, HN has had so many threads arguing the same points about cryptocurrency over and over, that it's not clear there can ever again be a new discussion about it. Repetition is a curiosity killer, and usually indignation takes its place as people resort to hammering each other over the head with the same dumbed-down clubs, back and forth. https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=mind%20amuse%20by:dang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor... https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=curiosity%20repetition%20by:dang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&so... However, I think we can try turning the flags off on this one because Macjiej is at least trying to take a different and more specific angle on cryptocurrency critique.
- lifeisstillgood 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- c01n 5y ago> What we especially need to stress to regulators... Lol. Talking like that obviously shows that cryptocurrencies are not for you. This tech has cypherpunk and crypto-anarchy roots, regulators/governments are not the intended users for this tech, even if you like it or not. If you do not view cryptocurrencies from an cypherpunk perspective you will not see their social benefits, it is an entire way of life an alternative view from the centralized shit show we have now. Yes the tech has flaws, just like how digicash, hashcash, b-money etc had flaws, this is an evolutionary process and nothing you or your government says can stop it.
- bambax 5y ago> nothing you or your government says can stop it Oh yeah? Let's find out.
- marricks 5y agoI think that cyberpunk dream died when billionaires and VC got involved and Bitcoin (and other) currencies skyrocketed in price from millions of people playing crypto-lottery. Strikes against it: - It's burning a massive amount of resources and that is just increasing - I don't have the stats but I imagine the exponential growth in Bitcoin/coin prices is mainly from people using it as a pyramid scheme/casino not simple an upticl in usage - A transaction is still pretty trackable (we know where the mt gox money is, yeah?) - Over 60% of bitcoin mining takes place in one country on specialized hardware, not terribly decentralized anymore
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- c01n 5y ago> It's burning a massive amount of resources and that is just increasing Do you own a car? Have you ever used plastic? How much resources are burned by banks? > I don't have the stats but I imagine the exponential growth in Bitcoin/coin prices is mainly from people using it as a pyramid scheme/casino not simple an upticl in usage Yea lets also ban computers because they allow cryptocurrencies. > A transaction is still pretty trackable (we know where the mt gox money is, yeah?) Ever heard about Zcash or Monero > Over 60% of bitcoin mining takes place in one country on specialized hardware, not terribly decentralized anymore Yes the tech is not perfect but tons of research (Proof of Stake etc) is happening to make it perfect.
- satisfice 5y agoIt just feels weird getting financial and social advice from Pinboard. I thought it was just a thing to collect my links.
- beaner 5y agoThis doesn't read as a particularly intelligent thread. There are no interesting insights here, at least not anything that's new and hasn't already been debated/debunked/pushed back on, before. Seems like one of those tweetstorms where people perceive it to be saying something worthwhile because it's long and is said with adamancy.
- paulgdp 5y agoDoes someone knows why this tweet was previously flagged on HN? see: https://twitter.com/Pinboard/status/1399094306221166592 https://twitter.com/Pinboard/status/1399094306221166592
- greyface- 5y agoThe screenshot is of <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27335940 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27335940>, which is a duplicate of this thread. This thread was previously [flagged] [dead], but is now back to normal. I assume via moderator action?
- beaner 5y agoProbably because it mostly contains rehashed opinion and conjecture and almost nothing of substance. I don't know why people would bother flagging something like this though, threads as content-less generally die on their own without much fanfare. OP and his friends get an ego boost from making front page and then it fades. NBD, no need to be contentious about it.
- onelastjob 5y agoIf you're in rural India and don't have access to a bank account, but you do have internet access via a smartphone, then I could definitely see cryptocurrency being valuable to you. And that doesn't even take into account countries like Venezuela that are experiencing hyperinflation, where cryptocurrency would be much more useful. There are cryptocurrencies that are energy efficient and have low (or even zero) transaction fees. I doubt the author has looked into these coins. Beyond just currency uses, smart contracts open the door to phasing out escrow middlemen for purely digital transactions (like buying/selling domain names, etc.) Decentralized lending and borrowing is another major use of smart contract coins.
- captn3m0 5y agoBanking penetration in India is at 80+% mainly due to DBT pushing straight to bank accounts. India’s smartphone penetration is at 41%. All exchanges in India require a Savings Bank account for Fiat transfers. How are these unbanked people meant to use crypto really?
- onelastjob 5y agoYou don't have to use an exchange to acquire cryptocurrency. People can use sites like localbitcoins to exchange cash for crypto in person.
- seoaeu 5y agoHow exactly do you imagine that an unbanked person living in rural India would be able use cryptocurrency? It isn't like they can just enter their credit card into a website and buy some. Not to mention that even if they someone managed to acquire some, the $5+/transaction fees are going to make something like bitcoin or ethereum completely impractical.
- yannoninator 5y agothere are other alternative cryptocurrencies working on this exact problem. you're talking as if bitcoin and ethereum is all of cryptocurrency.
- neither_color 5y ago1. Promise a revolutionary technology ("self-driving cars are coming"!) 2. Use that promise as a pretext to ignore all regulation 3. Make a fortune 4. Drop the tech story The author lost me here. Completely subjective take on what Uber has done. They've completely improved ride-sharing and cab hailing within the whole industry, including non uber users. Depending on what country I travel to, Ill be using a different app like Grab or Didi or a local taxi app that were all made possible by Uber's initial disruption. Some of those financial regulations are unjust. People can send remittances in crypto to relatives in repressive countries, and you hear their stories from boosters. But people also want to move billions in untraceable crime money around. Guess which traffic predominates IMO the former outweighs the latter. Perhaps remittance doesnt sound like a big deal to the author because they may not know immigrants who use these crappy services. The thought of punishing some darknet users buying pills online is more alluring than focusing more on fixing the flaws with remittances. I'm talking new residents who pay income taxes on their biweekly paycheck(fair) and then pay western union(bad deal, less fair) to send 50-200 bucks to family in far off places with spotty infrastructure and electricity, in remote places where there are no ATMs and the relative has to travel 2 hours into town to pick up their western union transfer. Millions of people go through that every day and I'm much more interested in crypto solutions and dont mind if it takes some uber style disruption to fix that later on.
- idlewords 5y agoI'm the author of the thread. For what it's worth, I grew up as a refugee whose mother had to find incredibly inventive ways to send USD to family back home, where it was illegal to possess. What I don't understand about the crypto remittances argument is how the people sending and receiving them are supposed to convert them into spendable currency. My hunch is that a lot of the value of cryptocurrency in those countries comes from the fact that it's been astronomically increasing in value, not that it's a great way to move money around remittance barriers.
- dumbfounder 5y agoI think NFTs will transform the concept of ownership, and take power away from major corporations in the process. This is just one aspect of crypto that I think more than justifies its value. But there is a ton of hype and a ton of bad stuff going on yes, but that will be pushed to the background as it goes more mainstream. All people inside the industry think this is just the beginning and there is a lot of value to be extracted. Is it overvalued for what it delivers on today? 100%. But I believe it will catch up and surpass it soon. There are multiple singular companies that are more valued than the entire crypto market right now. It’s a drop in the bucket.
- friedman23 5y agoCryptocurrency allows people to exchange money without dealing with financial institutions or governments. I don't own any as an investment, I use it for playing poker online. That's it. We give too much voice to all these people suffering from hysteria. I suspect the only reason these people are given a voice is because they usually call for more laws to "fix" more things which benefits those in power. edit: Also speaking of things we should ban, I think if we are talking about things that are actually harmful to society (not that I actually give a damn), we should start with banning twitter so that we can stop hearing these "moral" rants
- ArkanExplorer 5y agoThat's not really accurate. For most people, they deal with financial institutions directly via the fiat onroads and offroads fror the exchanges. The fact that you can formally buy, exchange, and cash out of crypto with full banking support gives cryptocoins a veneer of Government support and legitimacy. The USA bans online gambling and ponzi schemes. Cyrptocoins are worse, because they include a side order of immense waste of electricity and advanced manufactured computer chips, and enable ransomware. I think this article is completely correct. We, as members of the tech community, have a duty to communicate with the public and democratic representatives that cryptocurrencies are a harmful technology, and the formal exchange of them for fiat should be banned.
- codehalo 5y agoCan you (and your representative) please just leave me alone so I can harm myself with this "harmful technology"? Whatever the outcome, I'll take my chances. Please leave me alone.
- friedman23 5y agoThese people really can't help themselves.
- ArkanExplorer 5y agoThe harm is not limited to you. Electricity shortages: https://www.cnbc.com/2021/05/26/iran-bans-bitcoin-mining-as-its-cities-suffer-blackouts.html https://www.cnbc.com/2021/05/26/iran-bans-bitcoin-mining-as-... Chip shortages: https://www.fxempire.com/forecasts/article/bitcoin-mining-adds-to-existing-shortage-in-semiconductor-market-chip-prices-surge-712458 https://www.fxempire.com/forecasts/article/bitcoin-mining-ad... Ransomware: https://www.marketwatch.com/story/bitcoin-extortion-how-cryptocurrency-has-enabled-a-massive-surge-in-ransomware-attacks-11621022496 https://www.marketwatch.com/story/bitcoin-extortion-how-cryp... In terms of overall negative impacts, crypto is worse than ponzi schemes and online gambling.
- jbverschoor 5y agoThere are a few things that it offers: - “bank accounts” - a universal notary and authenticity service These are building blocks for a number of applications. Most order applications don’t make sense, but hey, everybody needs “bigdata” too
- ben_w 5y ago> a universal notary and authenticity service Cryptocurrencies do not add anything to either beyond what was already done by cryptography. > “bank accounts” We already have bank accounts. In banks, hence the name. What’s the average transaction fee for the most popular cryptocurrency? By one of many metrics by which cryptocurrency fails even against the status quo.
- jbverschoor 5y agoNot everybody has. And even in the 'normal' world, banks refuse quite a lot of people and businesses. So no, we don't have bank accounts.
- ben_w 5y ago“Not everyone” has a computer of any kind, not even a cellphone, not even of the not-smartphone variety. Underbanked people more so than the general population. And this group is also the most harmed by current cryptocurrency transaction fees — I’ve met someone (friend of a friend in Nairobi) for whom, assuming rent is paid monthly, current fees would raise their rental cost by 10%, and they’re already struggling.
- skrebbel 5y agoThese two resonated with me: > A lot of intelligent observers look at cryptocurrency, see that it makes no sense, and reasonably infer that they must be missing something profound on the technical level. Tech culture has a nice tradition of not deriding new ideas, but we need to break it here and speak out > [non-tech people] don't see the huge silent majority of tech people who know it's a scam. That's on us It is on us. I never realized this before today. I'm pretty sure it's nothing but a pyramid scheme, but I always gave the enthusiasts the benefit of the doubt. After all, Elon is so cute when he's enthusiastic! But yeah he probably knows it's a scam too, what was I thinking.
- meowkit 5y ago> I'm pretty sure it's nothing but a pyramid scheme, but I always gave the enthusiasts the benefit of the doubt. So go find out? I’m quoting you here for the “pretty sure” part. Do a deep dive. I’be done deep dives on Bitcoin, Ethereum, Cardano, Monero, Nano, Iota, Hyperledger, BSC, Uniswap, Tether, Chainlink and cursory glances at dozens of other coins/tokens. I’m a tech guy. I work on an operating system/embedded systems. Nothing about blockchains, DLTs, crypto, at its core is a scam to me. The author saying the “silent majority tech people” know its a scam is such nonsense to my experience. Every tech person I know thinks either A) its neat/super cool, or B) they don’t know anything about it besides memes. Sure there are tons of misinformation, scams, and bullshit going on. That’s everywhere and is not special to crypto.
- chrisco255 5y agoYeah, U.S. household net worth is near all-time lows in Fed balance sheet terms and people think crypto is the scam: https://mobile.twitter.com/RaoulGMI/status/1398733901913264133 https://mobile.twitter.com/RaoulGMI/status/13987339019132641...
- chrisbolt 5y agoWhat does “in Fed balance sheet terms” mean?
- knolan 5y agoWhen I first heard of cryptocurrency I was reminded of when people started idling in Team Fortress 2 to get content drops. It was such a daft cart before the horse approach, but of course those dropped items could be sold for fractions of a penny and people can be dumb. It also reminded me of Folding at Home. Here people completed by virtue of their personal compute resources. Of course crypto serves as neither a form of entertainment or scientific discovery and is just a massive waste of resources to create artificial wealth. If only all that computation did something useful.
- michaelmrose 5y agoIsn't there some way to combine proof of work and actually useful work?
- ctchocula 5y agoNo, there's not. It's a fundamental principle among PoS cryptocurrencies that the work needs to have no additional utility or else it will help the attacker "subsidize" 51% attacks against the cryptocurrency you've built, because now they can both launch 51% attacks which cost $X abut subsidize it by selling the useful compute for $Y they've gotten by launching the attack, which ends up costing $X - $Y. Compared with a PoS cryptocurrency yielding no useful compute as a side effect, it costs $Y cheaper for someone to 51% attack.
- michaelmrose 5y agoThe work doesn't have to be economically useful to the miner to be useful to society.
- captn3m0 5y agoI’ve come to the conclusion that Bitcoin was a perfect “isolated” P2P currency system. If it was just considered Monopoly money, that is. The moment you try to find its worth by buying/selling it against Fiat - you get the exact same thing you get when you allow real world trading on any game currency - scams.
- throwawaaarrgh 5y agoTwitter is a bad blogging platform.
- macawfish 5y agoI can understand peoples' frustration with the artificial scarcity, but would like to see this same energy over the artificial scarcity of housing and free time. The oligopoly of national money systems is currently failing to provide people with basic access to capital. There's nothing intrinsic about cryptocurrency that will necessarily help this or exacerbate it, but the fact that I can get better interest on US dollars by depositing stablecoins on some defi platform, with no gatekeeping, is an indictment of conventional financial institutions more than it is of blockchain tech.
- charlesarthur 5y ago"the fact that I can get better interest on US dollars by depositing stablecoins on some defi platform".. There was this guy called Madoff. He was able to get better interest than the markets for quite a while too. Those stablecoins are not contributing to the productive economy. They're not being invested in machines that make new cars, clear carbon from the air, produce cheaper food. Nothing about cryptocurrency will solve housing or free time, because those are political problems which require humans to come together with a common aim - not, in the complete opposite example, people just wanting more for themselves by "depositing stablecoins on some defi platform".
- sedatk 5y agoThat's just an overly simplistic summary of the whole thread. Pinboard isn't angry about artificial scarcity, but how cryptocurrency fails to fulfill its promises: it fails to decentralize, it fails to reach performance levels of existing financial institutions, it wastes huge amounts of energy, and it provides zero value other than being a ransomware enabler. (Disclaimer: I own cryptocurrency)
- char8 5y agoSeems lobsided. Sure Bitcoin suffers from high fees, but it serves well as a savings account. We've also started accepting litecoin payments on our site: I set it up once, and forgot about it. With Paypal it's a never-ending rigamarole. I've recently closed my bank account, and started using something a bit more up-to-date (Revolut). I believe Bitcoin is the single biggest innovation driver in the tech sector right now.. but sure.. it's a scam.
- ashtonkem 5y ago> I believe Bitcoin is the single biggest innovation driver in the tech sector right now Not gonna lie, I laughed at this.
- dang 5y agoCan you please make your substantive points without swipes? It's hard for conversations like this to stay interesting and this sort of exchange tends to push them over a cliff. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- alkonaut 5y agoI needed that too.
- char8 5y agoYes sorry it was a typo. I meant to write: > I believe Bitcoin is the single biggest innovation driver in the *fin*tech sector right now. Obviously not the biggest driver in tech; i don't blame you fr laughing at this statement.
- ashtonkem 5y agoAh, that statement makes much more sense when you correct it to fintech. I think I’d be inclined to point towards “neo-banks” as being more innovative in that specific sector, but that’s within “reasonable to disagree” range.
- 5y ago
- blast 5y agoI recently watched this video of Maciej making the same points on CNBC. Not bad for TV. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=igOmWeHMunw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=igOmWeHMunw
- draw_down 5y agoWithout getting into the specific issue of Bitcoin, I’m absolutely uninterested in calls to “speak out about” something because I work with computers. No. We do not share a politics because we both know python or whatever. Leave me alone.
- sleeper_service 5y agoCryptocurrency is like some sort of economic viral weapon. It presents itself as a techno-utopian vision of freedom, takes advantage of greed to replicate itself throughout the financial system, and mutates to use as much energy and as many resources as possible. If it were designed for that purpose, it would be the most cynical indictment of capitalism conceived.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Geee 5y agoThe author clearly doesn't understand Bitcoin at all and Bitcoin has been already discussed for ten years by everyone in the tech world. His opinion is his own, not 'us in the tech world'.
- xpe 5y ago> The author clearly doesn't understand Bitcoin at all Putting aside softer claims, writing "at all" is an exaggeration. Would you care to moderate your opinion or at least elaborate? Please point out area(s) where you think the author is mistaken?
- Geee 5y agoHis claims are false. Bitcoin has more social benefit than any other technology. Money is technology that runs our society by allowing us to trade our time between each other. Sound money that can't be diluted or stolen away by a few benefits everyone. It's not only more fair money, but it also allows perfectly efficient markets and saves the environment by not incentivizing overconsuming. Bitcoin is not used for money laundering, gambling, vaporware etc. and is not particularly well suited for those. His claims are not based on actual data. Bitcoin is decentralized. Bitcoin nodes which protect the monetary policy are run by users. It's not possible for anyone to weaken the currency by forcing users to run a weaker version of the software. Bitcoin actually solves the problem of central bank monopolies. It is money, it is a currency, it is a store of value. His claims are simply false. He just doesn't understand that it takes time for Bitcoin to stabilize at a certain value. It takes time for people to switch to a better money.
- xpe 5y ago> [Bitcoin] also allows perfectly efficient markets Perfectly efficient? Of course not. If we weaken your claim to "Bitcoin _helps_ markets be _more_ efficient", I would still ask for your reasoning.
- xpe 5y ago> Bitcoin has more social benefit than any other technology. This is highly subjective. What about plumbing, electricity, or antibiotics? Rank ordering technologies by their social benefits has major methodological problems. First, you can't consider any one technology in isolation; they exist in a network. Second, the value of a technology is relative to alternatives.
- achenatx 5y agopeople are using crypto to bypass country based currency controls. The original big bump I think was related to chinese getting their money out of china.
- dadoge 5y agoBitcoin is giving people in hyperinflation environments like Nigeria, Argentina, Turkey an out to their oppressive and corrupt govt banking system. If one looks at gold and asks themselves “why is gold worth 11 trillion dollars today?” How did it, over centuries and centuries obtain such a status? Bitcoin has better properties than gold does. It’s more scarce, scarcity means predictability, and predictability gives rise to trust. You don’t have to be a hardcore libertarian- I’m sure not- to appreciate a better version of gold, and what benefits that can have. Also - the USD is used more for malicious purposes, paper money is actually harder to track than Bitcoin transactions.
- chx 5y ago> predictability have you reviewed what you are writing or is it just a Markov chain generating text?
- greyface- 5y agoI took this to mean that bitcoin's issuance rate is more predictable than the rate that physical gold is discovered and mined at. There are unknown unmined gold deposits out there, both on-planet and off-planet. There are no unknown unmined bitcoin deposits. Also, https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html#comments https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html#comments
- dadoge 5y agoGeneration of new coins is transparent, the total number of coins capped. That’s predictability. Name one other asset on earth that is easily transferable and more predictable in that sense?
- ChrisClark 5y agoJust because you don't understand the sentence, doesn't mean you have to insult the guy. Other replies have explained it for you.
- tinyhouse 5y agoYeah sure, every time there's a crisis bitcoin loses 50% of its value. That's indeed such a great protection from inflation...
- timdaub 5y agoflagged
- jdally987 5y agoWow. Seriously? There are some good arguments against it but this is still elementary-level crypto-bashing. I’ll just leave this here https://twitter.com/PeterDiamandis/status/1398374332611629065 https://twitter.com/PeterDiamandis/status/139837433261162906...
- shafyy 5y agoThe issue of the "promise" of cryptos (and blockchain in general) is that it tries to solve problems that are not tech problems. They are mostly political/governmental problems that are solved by a working democracy. In countries where there is no working democracy, the dictator won't give two shits if this NFT proves that you own this piece of land before taking it from you. Blockchain in itself is not something that brings political stability to a country.
- judge2020 5y agoIf everything is considered ‘owned’ based on NFTs, and other stuff relies on that to verify ownership and provide services, then the government talking the physical land only gives them the utility of the land itself, and not the other stuff (eg. The ability to sell the property) - plus, the government superseding a fictional blockchain-backed real estate market is likely to cause a market crash. Blockchains and NFTs make sense only when the blockchain becomes the source of truth, and it does solve real problems - it just doesn’t work for cryptocurrency when someone’s $1 could be worth 30 cent or 6 dollars in just a year. Nobody wants that amount of uncertainty.
- 0x0 5y ago> "only gives them the utility of the land itself" "only"? I'd say the "utility of the land" IS the only value of "having" land.
- coolspot 5y agoObviously you’re missing that most of any land’s value comes from the fact that it can be wrapped as NFT. It is well known historic fact that Romans fought for new land knowing that the time will come when you could wrap it into NFT to make finally useful! Same story with Columbus and his ICO (Initial Columbus Odyssey).
- amusedcyclist 5y agoNo better bear case for crypto than articles and comments in its defense
- morelisp 5y ago> They don't see the huge silent majority of tech people who know it's a scam. That's on us Serious question: What does "not silence" looks like? Anyone who asks me gets my viewpoint on cryptocurrency and blockchains generally (which is more or less the same as Maciej's). My relatives all know it, but they also know another relative (who also thinks it is a scam!) made a couple K back in the first bubble because he was just playing around with the software. My coworkers all know it. Repeating it only causes strife, not education. People don't want to hear they've made bad financial decisions no matter the time, place, or tone. They instantly get defensive. I mentioned it in passing to a new hire in their trial period recently and got a really nervous look like "is this guy going to not give me a permanent contract because I liked bitcoin?" There's no forum in our society for us to say "this is a scam" that isn't run by people with millions or billions of dollars invested in that scam - unless you're famous enough to get on cable news as a minor tech entrepreneur - and no social maneuvering that makes it effective on a personal level.
- chrisco255 5y agoHow sustainable do you think this is: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M1SL https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M1SL That's a chart showing the M1 money supply increase by the Fed. It has more than quintupled in the past two years. That chart looks like a true scam to me. And it shows in the US household net worth data: https://mobile.twitter.com/RaoulGMI/status/1398733901913264133 https://mobile.twitter.com/RaoulGMI/status/13987339019132641...
- morelisp 5y agoSee! Look! This is exactly my point! Nobody is ever going to convince the guy who sealioned into a random subthread with some random charts to make an unclear point. Nothing a human can say will stop this army of even-more-nerdy Ross Perots. The only thing that speaking up ever does is generate more noise, which frustratingly then generates more interest. This probably even applies to Pinboard's appearances - anything, pro or con, to keep cryptocurrency on the air.
- alecbz 5y agoIsn't all currency more or less a "pyramid scheme" in the sense that Bitcoin is? I wish we had more subtlety in our discourse. It feels like it's all either blind admiration or blind condemnation. Bitcoin is trying to be a new currency. Currencies more or less operate on "collective delusion". I think many people scratching their heads at why Bitcoin is worth anything _are_ missing something, which is why any currency has any value at all, which is itself kind of surprising and unintuitive. At the same time, I think it's fair to be a little more skeptical about what the value of a currency like Bitcoin is, precisely, and how much effort ought to be put into building it.
- idlewords 5y agoWhen I say pyramid scheme, I don't mean it in the sort of philosophical way that you could apply to all fiat currency, but in the "OMG look at Tether" way.
- alecbz 5y agoAh, I might be out of the loop. tl;dr?
- kemonocode 5y agoTether, which is the most used so-called "stablecoin" (As its value is pegged to the USD) is extremely seedy at best and has had brushes with the law already [0] or is outright a Ponzi scheme [1] and plenty of people arguing for/against crypto know and have said so already. Personally, even though I'm a proponent of cryptocurrency in general, I wish it'd disappear in spite of any short and middle-term calamitous consequences on perceived value if that means one less "dumbed-down club" (Using dang's words) when it comes to discussing crypto. [0] https://ag.ny.gov/press-release/2021/attorney-general-james-ends-virtual-currency-trading-platform-bitfinexs-illegal https://ag.ny.gov/press-release/2021/attorney-general-james-... [1] https://www.singlelunch.com/2021/05/19/the-tether-ponzi-scheme/ https://www.singlelunch.com/2021/05/19/the-tether-ponzi-sche...
- kemonocode 5y ago
- segmondy 5y agoJust gonna sound like a hater, folks worship success. They will listen to anyone who made millions betting on cryptocurrency over any smart person who didn't and is "jealous" for missing out. One mistake us "smart" folks make is thinking that investing is about understanding a system that's complete and smart. Most investments are not like black jack but more like poker where it all comes down to behavioral economics and psychology. Doesn't matter how stupid the actually game is, it's about the meta game with the crowd. Plenty of tech folks making money in crypto know this, wallstreet going into crypto knows this. Most of us in tech are too autistic to play on that level. So focused on the correctness of the tech. For the players it's a big casino and they know it. The lucky winners will be rewarded for having heart and playing
- npteljes 5y agoFOMO is real when I hear people talking about crypto. I feel the hype and I notice it in others too. Cool names flying around, there's a new type of coin for every coffee break we're having, the graphs go high, memes churned out every second. Colleague makes tenth of his salary with his GPU. Hard to remain neutral.
- paul_f 5y agoBrilliant point. I agree. Cryptocurrencies are fueled almost exclusively by FOMO. Tether is a joke and probably a scam, yet somehow has a $60B market value. SMH.
- Grim-444 5y agoThis is similar to my recent realization - as much as I believe it's a complete ponzi scheme, a near complete scam, as long as there's enough people who don't know better who can be conned to buy into it, it will keep getting propped up. In this age of mass media and the internet where everyone is so infinitely, immediately connected, there's no shortage of more suckers to buy in, there's no shortage of propaganda techniques to sucker more people in. As long as there's more suckers, it can keep getting propped up, no matter how unsound it actually is, no matter how much of a scam it actually is. It reminds me of the quote "the markets can remain irrational longer than you can remain solvent".
- yoloyoloyoloa 5y agoI see more and more tweets and articles like this posted here on hackernews that echo the sentiments of the world economic forum on how they feel about cryptocurrency. Remember they are the very people that say you should:"Own nothing and be happy". If you think cryptocurrency is a scam then you havnt looked into the technology behind it and the economies that have been built using these technologies.
- seattle_spring 5y agoThere's real technology and products and economics behind MLMs like Herbalife and Young Living too. Doesn't make them any less of a scam.
- crgi 5y agoFully agree. The current/legacy financial infrastructure is actually 10 times more decentralized than any DLT: DLT is the same software run on multiple nodes. SWIFT in contrast is a protocol, that anyone can implement. So its hundreds of software teams, building and operating their part of the infrastructure and integrating with each other. The SWIFT protocol itself is maintained by the member organizations, anyone can bring in proposals. The complexity of it does not come from technology, but the regulatory requirements which differ vastly across the world.
- yaa_minu 5y agoBitcoin is also a protocol and there are several implementations. The same applies to the lightening protocol which has about 7 different client implementations and growing.
- Swizec 5y agoGit is the most wildly successful and broadly useful application of the ~blockchain~ merkle tree data structure. It’s fantastic and here to stay. The digital money angle? Eh it’s okay. Everyone loves a gullible population that prefers to be paid in not-money. Eventually crypto will have to invent all the overhead and governance it was trying to escape. You know, so things like Musk’s little pump-and-dump the other week stop being possible. For the downvoters: The original bitcoin paper explicitly says it’s using a merkle tree data structure under the hood. Same as that used by git.
- Hamuko 5y agoHow is git an application of blockchain when it predates Bitcoin by several years?
- Swizec 5y agoIt’s the same data structure. Bitcoin just added the proof-of-work idea to extending the chain and attached the concept of “value” as a social construct. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Merkle_tree https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Merkle_tree
- Hamuko 5y agoHow does consensus work in git?
- Swizec 5y agoMultiple peer reviewers look at a pull request and when it passes muster, it gets merged to the longest chain. You can always make a fork and keep going with a new chain. Same as bitcoin. You can always split off a new chain. You might not convince everyone that your new chain is the chain, but you’re welcome to try.
- Hamuko 5y agoa) Where is there a requirement for "multiple peer reviews" on git? b) What is the longest chain? How do I determine if the longest chain is in Gitlab, on my computer or my coworker's computer? Where does the pull request go? c) How do I indicate that I have approved a pull request in git?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- blintz 5y agoI think this actually overstates the value of cryptocurrencies. The value of say, Bitcoin, isn't even connected to its value as a method of money laundering or extortion through ransomware. However morally objectionable these are, they do have economic value - it's just that value is not connected to the price of any cryptocurrency. Rather, the whole thing is an extended, worldwide pump-and-dump; speculation is driving all movement. To me, it's really sad, because Bitcoin (and some of its descendants) are intellectually fascinating. With simple building blocks that had been around for decades (hashing + public keys) someone made something profoundly new. It's in some ways inspiring, since it makes me feel there must be so much more out there to discover and build. It's also sad, because it shows how things you build can 'grow up' and become a little unrecognizable.
- xpe 5y ago> The value of say, Bitcoin, isn't even connected to its value as a method of money laundering or extortion through ransomware. No. Money launderers and extorters drive demand for cryptocurrencies. This affects its price. See: https://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/gadgets-and-tech/news/bitcoin-price-fall-criminals-blockchain-anonymous-cryptocurrency-zcash-monero-dash-a8174716.html https://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/gadgets-and-tech/ne...
- DSingularity 5y agoIt’s the combination of strong network effects and artificial scarcity driving the price action. You buy Bitcoin cause something about it really resonated with you. Price goes up and you feel validated. You go and naturally — out of benevolent intentions — tell your closes people so they don’t miss out. The mistake of cryptocurrency is discounting the potential for price manipulation. Earl adopters understood cornered these markets immediately. Now we are in never ending cycles of hype, markup, dump, accumulate, hype, markup, distribute, and accumulate over years. These cycles are continuously producing winners and losers and the losers are generally those who have more to lose and are thus enable to withstand the intense pressure of bear markets. I love Bitcoin and Ethereum and all the potential freedom that they represent. At the same time - enough. These markets need regulation. We need to know who owns these coins. We need to see their selling patterns so we can see their manipulation. Unfortunately, the cynic in me knows that too many people are making too much money and are probably going to block regulation for a very long time.
- mike-the-mikado 5y agoAs a thought experiment, I imagined a Government/Central bank auctioning (for $) bitcoin denominated bonds. These bonds would be repayable (in bitcoin) on demand. Presumably each bond would fetch a value (in $) corresponding approximately to the current exchange rate. While the bond holder could cash them in at any point, why would they? Wouldn't many investors consider a bond backed by a major government at least as secure as a crypto coin? In this way, the government could effectively increase the supply of bitcoins (and presumably thereby reduce their cost/value). Of course, the Government runs the risk of bitcoin appreciating and then having all the bond holders cashing in, but with exceptionally deep pockets the only real reason to cash in would be if they feared a Government default. By selling enough bonds, presumably the price could be driven arbitrarily low, extinguishing the risk entirely.
- tzumby 5y agoWhat is surprising is how large the number of techies who don’t get this. It’s not about crypto currencies as much as it is about the game theory that allows it to run a distributed self replicating state machine that is Byzantine tolerant - this is the true innovation
- xpe 5y agoYour comment is unclear. > What is surprising is how large the number of techies who don’t get this. What do you mean by "this"? Do you mean all of the points made by the author in the tweets? Or do you mean "the following" instead of "this", referring to what you think is most innovative about Bitcoin?
- tzumby 5y agothis = blockchain + proof of work / proof of stake , in my comment. The crypto currencies are a requirement to fulfill the Byzantine tolerance. They need to have value in order for the incentives to make sense
- xpe 5y ago> The crypto currencies are a requirement to fulfill the Byzantine tolerance. I find this writing to be unclear and/or circular. Are you saying the following? _If_ the primary goal of a system is Byzantine fault tolerance, using a cryptocurrency is a requirement?
- tzumby 5y agoSorry, you have a point. I re-read my comment and it's not very clear. We need two things to achieve the Byzantine fault tolerance: - a way to ensure that users of the system can't cheat by creating a vast number of nodes and inflate their "voting power" (think of a poll where you can get behind a proxy to vote multiple times because the only security is weather or not the IP voted): this is the hash-cash, proof of work computation that ensures you have real hardware behind your "vote" - an incentive to mine and secure the network: the cryptocurrency. The amount of cryptocurrency you mined is just a translation of the energy and work you did to secure the network the same way as a banknote is a conversion of X number of hours you worked for someone. The question, like I stated in another comment, is whether or not this distributed ledger is useful. Let's say we haven't discovered the killer use case for this yet (putting my skeptic hat). Is it fair to dismiss it just because of all the scams related to its current use ? Do we do the same for email just because there's so many phishing attacks that happen on the protocol ?
- ChrisClark 5y agoI don't understand how tech people can't be excited about decentralized programmable money. Bitcoin, maybe, it's so limited, but the sky's the limit on programmable money on Ethereum and chains like it.
- zx2391 5y agoI read a Blockchain book from O'Reilly in 2015, when it came out and it left me with the distinct impression that this "technology" is vaporous. It could do anything, yet, almost no examples to try out, let alone real-world successes. Over time I witnessed many "new" things, and the ones which stick typically have a specific aura to them, like a 10x simplification, or speedup or reduction in "noise". These things are really rare; most things are incremental and that's good, too. Blockchain did not seemed to have any of that. PS. Merkle trees are super interesting and I use them daily (in git) - so all the tech ideas are certainly worth considering, it's just that they are not fit for the advertised purpose plus it has gotten an enormous drag on resources, for nothing. PPS. I typically have an "tech instinct" to see new things, but I currently cannot really see anything that looks like a major tech shifts from the past. ML is incremental and despite its grande successes is mostly applied by the surveillance industry, which makes it much less attractive. Cloud seems much more profound and the whole apification of the world transformation - although I do not like the centralization, even if it is more economical. In general, the real revolutionary tool or technology does not need to sell itself, it is picked up by the weird and intelligent first, then trickles down to the masses (also: tech can be great w/o mainstream adoption, too - it just not a revolution then). PPPS: Wild speculation: With 5G, everyone with a phone could host their business directly on their device, instead on other peoples servers. When phones hit a TB in storage, you can run your socnet with your friends - and you probably will, because mainstream money will have moved to something much more immersive, addictive, profitable like glasses, vr, ar.
- dadoge 5y agoTell that to people in Nigeria, Venezuela and Argentina that have no control over their money. In Venezuela there is absolutely absurd inflation number there: like over 1,000%. Argentina it’s over 30% each year for several years. Bitcoin is a tool against oppressive governments
- zx2391 5y agoTrue, and people can use it today, that's for sure.
- 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- brianolson 5y agoBitcoin is terrible technology and stupidly wasteful, but there are new blockchain networks coming along that are about a million times more efficient, so use those instead.
- yaa_minu 5y agoHow's bitcoin stupidly wasteful?
- kzrdude 5y agoIt's a race towards spending ever greater amounts of energy to mine blocks.
- crummy 5y agoHow does that affect the whole ransomware, regulation etc side of things?
- mmcgr 5y agoIf you are referring to PoS (both stake and space), they make fundamentally different tradeoffs as opposed to PoW. It's intellectually dishonest to claim either is "more efficient".
- bo1024 5y agoI don't agree with this. It's fine to have an opinion, but I don't think it should be represented as a consensus when it's not. (edited to add) There is an important difference between having downsides and being a scam. Downsides of the U.S. dollar or "petrodollar" system include global warming, international wars, and regulatory capture. The U.S. financial system has all the kinds of fraud, blackmail, and crime mentioned here and more. Doesn't mean the dollar is a scam.
- lefrenchy 5y agoOne thing that I find so confusing in the crypto maximalist sphere is the obsession with decentralization of everything but also with mainstream adoption. Coinbase is centralization, bank adoption is centralization, etc... Also if “fear of regulation” causes massive sell-offs, doesn’t it totally fail at being the “anti-government” centralized currency? I’m also just not convinced total decentralization is good? I mean sure markets are a decentralized way of pricing things and allow distributed decision making blah blah blah, but they have limits. I feel like far too many people are drawn in by the answer to the wrong question “what does crypto solve?” Instead of the more interesting one “what problems does it create”
- sneak 5y agoCryptocurrencies love discussing their decentralization plans in their Telegram and Discord chats, deploying on AWS/GCE.
- seibelj 5y agoDecentralization is a spectrum. Bitcoin cannot be shutdown because it is decentralized. There can be centralized actors within a decentralized system. The major benefit is you can choose between various service providers and switch when you please. With government monopolies you use their service at gunpoint.
- lefrenchy 5y ago> With government monopolies you use their services at gunpoint I mean sure, in an authoritarian state that’s what happens. I’m just not convinced crypto is the solution? In order to evade being at gunpoint you’d essentially need all your crypto transactions to be undiscoverable to an all powerful entity, which is probably mostly possible and that’s great. The downside is you now open yourself to people being able to take all your money from you with close to no discoverability. In order to keep that privacy you’d have to avoid all centralized exchanges and manage most of this yourself and i’m just not convinced 99% of people need or want that? I’m not saying the tech isn’t impressive or the idea in its purest form compelling and interesting, but there’s a lot of fantasy I think.
- 5y ago
- ahallock 5y agoWhy would I trust a source whose own outdated site looks terrible on mobile and is not even on a secure connection? "A bookmarking site for introverts" -- what amazing innovation! It sounds more like Pinboard is looking for engagement by shitposting on Twitter.
- msoad 5y agoMost Bitcoin enthusiast that yell at me "HAVE YOU READ THE WHITE-PAPER??!" and "DO YOU UNDERSTAND THE TECHNOLOGY??!" have never actually downloaded the source code and ran the damn thing! At least back in 2011 I was mining on my computer to see what this thing is! Everyone is using some sort of hosted wallet that defeats the entire propose of it!
- ggreer 5y agoTweets like those are why Pinboard is one of the few Twitter accounts I've blocked. On certain issues, the author loves to righteously sneer. It annoys the hell out of me because when he's not sneering, he can be a knowledgeable and clear thinker. He's like a glass of wine with a single fly in it. This behavior isn't just annoying to others; it's harmful to his own goals. If Maciej had hedged his bets and accepted Bitcoin payments for Pinboard in 2013[1], it would most have been the most cost-effective action of his entire life. He would be worth millions more today. He could have used that money to further causes he cares about, such as climate change and social issues. Instead, he's trying to ban cryptocurrency. We had this same debate with cryptography in the 1990s and DRM removal software in the 2000s. Back then, technically-inclined people agreed that you can't ban math. But now many are trying to do just that. What exactly would a cryptocurrency ban look like? Would calculating lots of SHA-256 hashes cause men with guns to come to your home and put you in a cage? It sounds more absurd than what happened to DVD Jon.[2] 1. https://twitter.com/Pinboard/status/376953671655100416 https://twitter.com/Pinboard/status/376953671655100416 2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jon_Lech_Johansen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jon_Lech_Johansen
- idlewords 5y agoLet's be clear that if I had accepted Bitcoin payments in 2013, I would have then lost them all a year or two later when my exchange got hacked. That would make me an even more bitter person now. I can't remember ever calling for a ban on cryptocurrency. If you're remembering something I'm not, then please correct me.
- ggreer 5y agoYou want the tech world to tell regulators that, "Cryptocurrency is sustained by a mix of money laundering, vaporware, fraud, ransomware, gambling, and delusion. It has no social benefit except helping end first dates fast.", and that cryptocurrency solves no problems and creates new ones. If regulators agreed with these statements, what do you think they would do? And if you don't want cryptocurrencies banned, how do you want them treated differently from today?
- jeofken 5y ago
- fleddr 5y agoI could waste a huge amount of time refuting the author's points, but will make it more of a meta comment. Crypto is vast, complex, and inherently not suitable for binary thinking. I've studied the space for months and have come to the conclusion that crypto is two-sided in almost every aspect. Many/most coins are speculative, which you can associate with words like "greed" and "casino". Yet also provide wealth savings/growth to people locked out of it in our traditional system. NFTs are a cruel joke right now, yet ridiculous as they are, may be a precursor to various groundbreaking uses having real utility, in an exponential way. Smart contracts are largely dysfunctional, yet there's early success in replacing financial products like staking, lending, leverage. When it works, it's permission-less, which has interesting social benefits (access not defined by your identity/social class). And so on. I'm not here to debate any of these points, my only point is to not dismiss crypto as a whole (binary thinking) and to not underestimate it. The topic is too complex for it.
- msoad 5y agoCrypto == Cryptography over here. Just FYI
- ertian 5y agoHuh? Not in the original article, or in OPs reply, unless I'm seriously misunderstanding him. He's talking about the pros/cons of cryptocurrency.
- shkkmo 5y agoThe twitter thread mostly uses the full term "cryptocurrency", which is not ambigous. Using the term "crypto" to refer to cryptocurrency is amigous and misleading.
- itisit 5y ago> Using the term "crypto" to refer to cryptocurrency is amigous and misleading. To whom? “Crypto” is the colloquial shorthand for “cryptocurrency”. And I believe those thinking otherwise are reacting to the new usage encroaching on the old. Petty hill to die on…
- synesso 5y agoThe Bitcoin whitepaper brought together a few existing technologies into something that had never before existed in the world - decentralised digital scarcity. This lead to a Cambrian explosion of new developments, most of which are pyramid schemes. But at its core, the invention is world-changing.
- coliveira 5y agoThis is not even touching the fact that bitcoin and similar currencies are a danger for the environment. They spend huge amounts of energy that are helping destroy the planet. The longer this scam goes on, the more damage will happen to the world.
- yannoninator 5y agoso what are going to do about this?
- mmcgr 5y ago>They spend huge amounts of energy that are helping destroy the planet This sounds extremely ignorant, Bitcoin essentially has accomplished a _trustless_ transfer of value, globally and at very low costs (even considering the extraordinary fees right now). This is just the cost of that...
- baby 5y agoIt’s worth noting that most modern cryptocurrencies consumes minimal energy as they are not based on the same technology of Bitcoin (proof of work)
- DennisP 5y agoI don't see any technical criticisms in the thread, which means "us in the tech world" is just an appeal to meaningless authority. It's also a bogus attempt to imply a broad consensus where there is none. As someone in tech myself, my personal opinion is that most of the twitter thread is nonsense.
- baby 5y ago+1 to this. The twitter thread is bad and it’s hard to argue against it as it makes little technical arguments.
- 1023bytes 5y agoUnfortunately the global economy is a pyramid scheme as well, based on the unsustainable promise of infinite growth
- msoad 5y agoThis is a great write up on how Tether is super scammy https://www.reddit.com/r/badeconomics/comments/nfv8vg/the_tether_ponzi_scheme/ https://www.reddit.com/r/badeconomics/comments/nfv8vg/the_te...
- ai_ja_nai 5y agoI am a PhD student at a university in Roma3. Tomorrow I'll have to explain a student that, no, I won't give access to AI lab's Teslas to let them research a Deep Learning algorithm to forecast bitcoin price. Groan.
- ai_ja_nai 5y agoPlus, cryptos are responsible of 1% of world elecrticity consumption. Holy cow.
- ai_ja_nai 5y ago(According to https://cbeci.org/cbeci/comparisons https://cbeci.org/cbeci/comparisons it's actually 0.6%. It is a tragedy anyway)
- robbrown451 5y agoThe difference between Bitcoin and a pyramid scheme is that most pyramids are basically zero sum games... for every dollar one player makes, another player loses a dollar. Bitcoin, due to its mining costs, is a massively negative sum game. So much worse.
- chedine 5y agoOne thing is for sure. HN community has never gotten any trends correct. That must say something. FAANG, crypto, AI, javascript etc gets hate. Post about lisp, shell, emacs and if will be hailed :- Bring the downvotes now.
- rfd4sgmk8u 5y agoI have had banks stealing my funds for years -- be it financial providers eating up my first 401k contributions in excessive fees, be it the banks that charged me $2 every time I used an ATM, be it the random charges unauthorized charges that the bank pulled from my account... Then there is the watching all my adult life as assets grow more expensive and further out of reach, a debt treadmill emerges to ensure the continued struggle of the middle class lest they try to escape their position. This is in the west. I can't imagine the shenanigans banks play on folks in less regulated jurisdictions. Maciej, I'm sorry that you refuse to get it. We need hard money to prevent the value loss of the time-store fruits of our labor. We need an explicit spend model to prevent unauthorized charges. We need a way to prevent the custodian of funds from helping themselves to your pocket. Better yet, we need a digital store of value that does not require a trusted third party. And we need to make sure special interests can't dictate who is able to spend their money. For this, it is the most valuable thing on the planet.
- skybrian 5y agoHow are $2 ATM fees "stealing?" They provide a service, which you can pay for or easily avoid by planning ahead a bit. (And cryptocurrency charges even more.)
- onlyrealcuzzo 5y agoLOL - and Vanguard is apparently stealing all our money, providing zero value, and charging 0.1% on their index funds. Better go transfer my life savings into Bitcoin, I suppose.
- mandelken 5y ago
- gfodor 5y agoOddly enough I’m the diametric opposite: skeptical of crypto’s long term value up until recently (but before the last big run up) - I now see it is a a fundamental hedge against totalitarianism among other things. Westerners can fail to grasp the potential benefits due to the privilege of the time and place they were born. At least for now.
- zemvpferreira 5y agoYou do realize Maciej comes from a reasonably unprivileged time and place, right?
- gfodor 5y agoRegardless of how you want to measure this my point was not about anyone in particular but the general sentiment I see from people who are not experiencing a wide variety of the problems crypto could possibly help ameliorate if things were different for them, be it their economic status, the government they live under, or the cultural norms they live within.
- ffggvv 5y agoand you think a totalitarian government is going to let you buy crypto? if they just shut down coinbase and robinhood and square then 99% of people will lose access. chinas great wall blocks a lot of the internet itself. it’s delusional to think governments can’t stop crypto easily. they can even just block internet completely
- gfodor 5y agoThe fact crypto is facilitating large numbers of illegal transactions is evident enough it has value in doing so. I’m not assuming crypto is a silver bullet, but merely that it will be a force for good in scenarios where what it can more readily enable compared to alternatives are just things to do. If you like analogies, totalitarian governments ban all sorts of things that check their power like guns and books, but overcoming them still has happened historically in part by people finding ways to disobey those things without getting caught (and often with fatal consequences when they are caught)
- Bayart 5y agoPeople keep being blindsided by the financial aspects of the space, whether it is those who love it or those who hate it. It just rings off-beat and it's frankly a bit vacuous.
- cryptica 5y agoI'm OK to ban crypto if we also ban all big tech corporations because they're all part of the same fiat pyramid scheme. Why don't we just end capitalism and switch to communism... Then at least we will be able to communicate honestly about what's going on in the economy. To say that one scheme is a scam but the other is not is extremely subjective. A corporation like Facebook probably does more harm to society than Bitcoin. Why ban Bitcoin but not ban Facebook? Why not ban Snapchat or Twitter? Ban Uber, they burn a lot of fossil fuels! This kind of thinking necessarily leads to communism. You can't ban crypto and keep capitalism... What's left of it.
- mudlus 5y agoHere's how you defeat Bitcoin: code a client that a majority of the network uses that changes the consensus protocol to what you think is a good idea. If you don't want to do that, and you want to wax poetic about shitcoins being evil, ffs, please keep in in the drafts, salty nocoiner. Especially during a bull cycle where people who already don't trust "tech nerds" are going to read this and want to buy the shittiest of shitcoins.
- sombremesa 5y agoI don’t really give a crap about any crypto, and I agree that much of it is a pyramid scheme. However, I think people don’t understand that Bitcoin is first and foremost a brand. A brand doesn’t have to be “useful” to have value, it just has to be recognizable to enough people. A lot of altcoins have appeared, but not a single one of them has the brand strength of Bitcoin - not even the “tech fave” ethereum. On the flip side, one doesn’t have to participate in any kind of crypto, including Bitcoin, to leverage the brand - since the brand doesn’t rest on the value of the currency itself.
- kgraves 5y agoAbsolutely, I have seriously thought long and hard about cryptocurrencies and have also come to the conclusion that it is a definitive scam. Now is the time we must shut it down. Bitcoin, Ethereum, all of it. Even ponzi schemes have it's limits and this one has been reached and been illegally allowed to run rampant. It was nice when it started, not while it lasted. It didn't work and now it's time for it to go.
- loveistheanswer 5y agoIn what ways is the technology itself, rather than how it may often be used, a scam?
- kgraves 5y agoIt’s a centralised system disguised as a currency (Bitcoin) and designed to be a pyramid scheme. Blockchain is just another buzzword that isn’t actually useful.
- qualudeheart 5y agoWhat are your arguments for this proposition? How are Bitcoin and Ethereum ponzi schemes?
- kgraves 5y agoYou have so called ‘whales’ controlling and manipulating the coins, only those who got in early and the institutions can control the price of Bitcoin and Ethereum. The whole thing is so volatile a single billionaire can say anything causing the entire crypto market to crash, leaving those who got in extremely late holding a huge bag. Bitcoin is useless and has no usecase at all and Ethereum spurred on the useless energy inefficient and vapid NFT craze which is yet another money laundering scheme. Don’t get me started on ransomware as that is for another story. This experiment should not have been allowed to run it’s course at all and all of it needs to be shutdown.
- alfiedotwtf 5y ago> Enough is enough What is he advocating then? To stop working, thinking, and writing about cryptocurrencies? When do we start burning books too
- jarbus 5y agoCurious to see how the author would suggest we donate to organizations like WikiLeaks without Bitcoin
- __d 5y agoCurious that anyone thinks using Bitcoin to donate to Wikileaks is any more anonymous than doing an ACH transfer.
- tuesdayrain 5y agoA lot of people underestimate the value provided by a payment system that makes chargebacks impossible. Yes, it's a double-edged sword that needs to be used carefully. But it makes perfect sense for markets where one side has an established reputation, while the other doesn't.
- khazhoux 5y agoIn the same 7-day span a couple of weeks ago, I saw headlines about crypto's legitimization in the market, and a $1 BILLION crypto donation to COVID efforts in India. I can't believe both simultaneously.
- Gatsky 5y agoI still find the moralising about cryptocurrency curious and difficult to understand. It always takes the tone of 'We the nerds should...'. Never seen it applied to any other (dramatically more important) issues.
- Uptrenda 5y agoThe problem I see is that everyone in tech seems to think they're an expert on cryptocurrencies while simultaneously being at the ignorant end of the Dunning–Kruger effect (and failing basic statistics.) Cryptocurrency makes it easy to enhance ones own confirmation bias because the industry has had such a bumpy ride towards progress. If you want to take an overly harsh perspective about the technology then by all means just Google 'a list of hacks and scams.' You'll be entertained for days with what you find, and at the end of your research you will have more than enough material to make yourself look smart on twitter. That's also another point. If you can talk about basic flaws in a technology by playing 'Dr Doom' then you can score free points from the audience without having to know much about the subject. It's an easy way to look credible because most people are followers on social media and won't have the time or interest to look more deeply. So lets look at the claim that cryptocurrency 'has no use and only causes problems.' To disprove this we only need to find a few examples of use-cases that are very hard if not impossible to do under traditional finance. 1. Trusts -- escrow -- jointly controlled accounts with arbitrary leverage over assets. You can't do this under the traditional financial system because the legal system can be used to dispute ownership which commonly happens when a will is attested. 2. Confidential transactions. Anonymous money and accounts. Traditional finance views this as a disadvantage, whereas FinTech views privacy as a right. 3. Flash loans. Flash loans are a way to finance a smart contract that borrows money and repays it atomically in a single transaction. Flash loans have radically changed capital markets but their power is still being understood. Potentially this is a new form of funding for automated companies. 4. Price stability. It's possible to design cryptocurrencies in such a way that their price trends towards some function. This property is highly desirable when people are going to be storing their wealth long-term. If we can build more stable currencies we can protect against flash crashes and even economic depression. 5. Smart contracts. Programmable agreements for wealth exchange make it possible to provide unique financial instruments that are engineered to be less risky than anything traditional markets can accomplish. This is due to increased transparency, collateral requirements, and protocols that help enforce fairness. There are too many examples to list in how cryptocurrencies are shaking up not just finance but many other industries. To claim that it all amounts to fraud, gambling, and ponzi schemes just tells me the author has no understanding of the transformations taking place right in front of them. They'll probably be left crying 'its a scam' long after society has silently replaced most aging FinTech with platforms that provide enforceable safe-guards... because in the end it is more transparent, flexible, and when done right -- safer than alternatives.
- losvedir 5y agoI have a question: are there any "crypto-like" currencies? I do see value in being able to instantly exchange tokens which are generally liquid and convertible to local currency, with low fees, internationally, and in denominations that make sense to, e.g., tip a blogger for a post you like. The US could regulate the heck out of it, and the Venezuelan or Tanzanian farmer could use it more laissez faire. But none of that comes from the crypto aspect and PoW and untrusted decentralization. It could just be a non-profit with a DB and a public API. Are there any coins out there trying this?
- LegitShady 5y ago"Come buy my non-profit's company scrip" doesn't sound as appealing as "this could go waaaaay up in value, buy my speculation scam"
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- cryptica 5y agoCryptocurrency will never go away. The more time passes, the more conviction people have. As someone who is a loser in both the fiat ecosystem and crypto ecosystem and having experienced some horrors both ecosystems, I prefer crypto ecosystem hands down because it's the most honest and transparent system. Once you understand how both systems work, it's impossible to pick the fiat system. The fiat system is a pyramid scheme of epic proportions. It's not possible for an ethical person to want to participate in the fiat system once they understand how it works. It is really that bad. I realize that people will downvote this now, but when crypto prices start doubling every week, they will finally understand what's going on. When you understand how the monetary system works, this claim is not far fetched at all. It's a certainty.
- rami-khalil 5y agoreal gatekeepy title you got there
- hmrtn 5y agoI think it's time for us in the tech world to speak out and make it clear the emperor has no clothes here. _Gold_ is sustained by a mix of money laundering, human slavery, fraud, ransom, gambling, and delusion. It has no social benefit except helping end first dates fast. What we especially need to stress to regulators is that there's no relationship between the claims of _gold_ and our now thousands of years of experience. It's not decentralized, it's not a currency, it's not a store of value, and it's not a promising element. _Gold_ solves no problems that it didn't first create, and most of those it doesn't solve. Banks are neither of those things—at worst they're an API for fraud, or as I put it, self-funding institutional greed. I think most of us in the industry gave gold a long leash because it's full of cleverness and seemed innovative just on those terms. But it's time we recognize that cleverness is being used as bait to defraud more people and perpetuate a con. Enough is enough. The two things people need to know about gold are completely non-technical: 1. If it isn't backed by self-perpetuating value, it isn't worth anything outside of industry process (electronics, etc.) 2. If it works, it creates an end run around all financial regulation, and will be dominated by uses those regulations try to stop And the list goes on. I am not equating cryptocurrency to gold, I am just trying to point out the absurdity of the authors statements.
- wmf 5y agoGold mining and the gold standard should also be banned.
- myWindoonn 5y agoGold is valuable because it is difficult to dig out of the ground, and it can be made into electronics. Neither is true of Bitcoin. Thus, you've built a false equivalence and are trying to equivocate.
- gmadsen 5y agodidn't regulation successfully shut down commerce with gold? Why wouldn't that happen with bitcoin
- throw123123123 5y ago
- 000000000000010 5y agoIs it that different than a fiat currency with an equally opaque issuance method? At least crypto has whitepapers and the promise of transparency.
- qualudeheart 5y ago"Bitcoin has emerged as a "shadow" monetary tool, a type of liquidity overflow to prevent even bigger asset bubbles in conventional assets such as commodities, stocks, and housing. It represents some $2 trillion in excess liquidity that would otherwise be invested in housing or stocks - making both of these respective asset bubbles that much more prone to bursting and bringing the entire asset-bubble dependent socio- economic and financial system closer to collapse. ... This benign side effect of bitcoin which paradoxically allows the Fed to perpetuate its ultra-easy monetary policy for much longer, "explains lack of regulation". Although if we hit hyperinflation and bitcoin goes offer-less, regulation will come for one simple reason: it will be tantamount to deleveraging the system by trillions in a heartbeat. Regulation of crypto is a structural risk to investors/ speculators. Regulation of crypto can be seen as 2nd order monetary tightening tool by Gov to tame inflation.
- bryanwb 5y agoThis post and the comments has convinced me that all the weirdoes and revolutionaries have left HN. It is now dominated by statist near-boomers concerned about the youngsters trampling the lawn. Sure Bitcoin is boring but so is gold. If you weren't interested in gold in the first place you likely aren't interested in Bitcoin either. The proof-of-stake, smart contract platforms are truly exciting. Stable coins and Uniswap are real innovations w/ more to come.
- imapeopleperson 5y agoAll that matters is that bitcoin is finite
- revel 5y agoI've worked in both finance and technology. I think the technical people aren't seeing how amazing this is from a finance point of view. Payments are going to be completely transformed by this. All of fixed income will change to be oriented around crypto. It's just a matter of time. All the main preconditions for crypto to take off are finally in place. If you are a professional money manager or CFO there is no way in hell you are going to risk managing your own keys, let alone keys on behalf of a customer or supplier. The largest impediment to all the good blockchain projects has been the lack of a cheap, affordable, insured custodian for key management. It's taken years to get to this point because these issues aren't technical in nature; they're governmental. The SEC weighed in on what it takes to be a qualified custodian near the end of last year, so now finally some of the larger names in this space have said they'll offer services. All the best, obvious use cases for crypto have been blocked by this issue: automatic payments, self-settling contracts and futures, escrow with almost 0 overhead, trade finance, etc.
- asah 5y agoYyy. Once you've experienced 24x7x365 instant, no-human finance, there's no going back to mountains of random paperwork, random bank policies, 1pm wire transfer deadlines, etc etc etc
- quickthrower2 5y agoWhere do I experience this though? Mostly it’s transfer coins on/off exchange to convert to fiat. Some stores take crypto but it turns out more expensive and there is less choice if I restrict my stores to ones that so
- leifg 5y agoWhy is cryptocurrency/blockchain necessary for that? You could have all of this with open banking standards.
- ipnon 5y agoVery simple game theory answer to this question: tragedy of the commons. There is a reason popular culture stereotypes financiers as greedy sociopaths. If the system can be cracked then it will be cracked. No shortage of examples, Bernie Madoffs, subprime lending crises, endless financial crashes and crises. Blockchains solve this problem, as in mathematically proves that certain classes of exploits requiring information asymmetry are impossible. We could have all of this with open banking standards? You're looking at them!
- nivexous 5y agoThere are folks in crypto who both consider most of the industry to be a scam while at the same time are working to fix it because there's something good here. We get hated on by almost everyone - both those in crypto for criticizing (BTC is a ponzi, ETH cannot scale, etc.) and those outside for being a part of it. It's easy to get bitter about this, but recently I spoke to a financial advisor who runs an investment fund that only invests in businesses that share certain values. He felt exactly the same about the financial industry and he's doing fine. If you resonate with this comment, realize you don't need to please everyone.
- noxer 5y agoCould people just stop assuming cryptocurrencies == bitcoin. Also DLT tech doesn't require a token with "value". There is no need to create an "alternative money" It can be just a DL (Distributed ledger). reducing everything to bitcoin and its forks is like reducing the whole internet tech stack to http and ignore everything else we can do with it. DLT tech isnt going away an no one who seriously understand it would say so. THis is just another useless twitter BTC hate thread. People who actually understand the tech dont care about bitcoin. Its the dinosaur tech and its deprecated since like 2013 or so when the first alternatives appeared (XRPL) which dont need the whole energy wasting block lottery.
- karaterobot 5y agoDon't fall into the trap of thinking people disagree with you because they are ignorant. That never works, usually because it's wrong. Consider the possibility that most people who are into cryptocurrency are as aware of the many down sides as they would need to be, but have come to a different conclusion than you about them.
- maxbond 5y agoI'd like to share my response on Twitter here as well: > I agree but I raise you one better. > We in tech need to talk about how graft and lies are not qualities of entrepreneurship, and that they are disqualifying. > We need to dispel the myth of moving from con to legitimacy, and that fraud may be justified if founders do it.
- trunnell 5y agoWhy is it a pyramid scheme? I’ll give you my opinion. I think bitcoin was a research project - it wasn’t designed to succeed as a real currency. Consider: 1) It has a fixed money supply. There will only ever be a fixed amount of bitcoin once it is all mined (or technically, the amount will grow more and more slowly forever— effectively, it’s a fixed amount). We’ve known for a long time what effect this has on a currency. A fixed supply will be deflationary, i.e. the value of 1 btc will only grow. To be stable, the total amount of currency in circulation must equal the economic value that it represents. This is why the Federal Reserve must continually expand the money supply - it’s because the US economy grows. (They actually expand it slightly faster than the economy grows, causing a small amount of inflation, on purpose. This is preferable to undershooting and creating a deflationary currency). Deflation makes for a terrible currency, because it inhibits spending. If you think your dollar will be worth more tomorrow, you’ll wait to spend it. That waiting cascades into the broader economy, causing a recession. Bitcoin can therefore never, ever be a true currency. Its deflationary design prevents it. 2) Transactions are public. Far from being a cash replacement, which is both anonymous and private, Bitcoin transactions are publicly recorded on the blockchain. There are elaborate work-arounds to improve privacy, but fundamentally the ledger is public. This is not a good feature for a cash replacement. 3) There is no one in charge. Would you trust the US dollar if a loose collection of volunteers struggled for control over key monetary decisions? Despite best efforts, governance of bitcoin is a disaster — because it wasn’t designed for governance. 4) It’s extremely expensive. Search recent news for the estimated electricity usage of bitcoin mining. It’s so large that a hedge fund recently restarted a decommissioned fossil fuel power plant just to mine bitcoin. Do you think this is a good design? 5) It’s inconvenient. Have you tried to make a bitcoin transaction? Were you surprised that you could pay extra in order for the transaction to settle faster? Did you think that was ridiculous? You’d be right! I’m glad more people are speaking up about bitcoin. The emperor indeed has no clothes. Bitcoin is getting out of hand.
- NaturalPhallacy 5y ago> Cryptocurrency is sustained by a mix of money laundering, vaporware, fraud, ransomware, gambling, and delusion. The thing is none of that matters. Cryptocurrency is a currency and anyone treating it otherwise and getting burned can't blame the currency for it. The thing is the *sole criterion* for the viability of a currency is acceptance. Some examples: * 90% of USD doesn't physically exist and has no intrinsic value whatsoever. The fact that everyone the world over will accept it in trade defines its viability. * Stones of Jordan (SOJs) in Diablo II. Terrible, currency because most of the games in the item were worth less. But that didn't matter. They were all anyone would accept. The fact that it was within a game didn't matter. Within the scope of the game they were about all that was accepted. * chipped gems in Diablo II. They had value in modifying other items and were more granular than SOJs. Some people would even accept a large number for an SOJ. * (D2jsp) Forum gold (Diablo II). You can buy it with USD (or other currencies I suppose, probably BTC too), and use it to buy items in the game. * Credit cards - almost every place in the world accepts them, and in theory it's because they're moving a government backed currency... but wait. * Icelandic Kroner - perfectly viable...but only in Iceland. At least for the most part. Like nobody in the US is going to let you buy gas with 1 ISK. * Yuan - perfectly viable...but only in Japan. Same as ISK, but japan. Some negative examples: * Again, Credit cards - If you were to try to start your own payment processing company that works exactly the same as say, Visa, but nobody has heard of your company it doesn't matter, no one will take it. * Zimbabwe dollars - hyperinflated to the point of 100 trillion dollar bills. Which people would accept a wheelbarrow of for a roll of toilet paper. Not accepted, so no value. > It has no social benefit except helping end first dates fast. * This just isn't true. I've used it to buy weed in a state where it was legal and it worked great. Meaning that you can buy things the government thinks shouldn't be allowed to. * It allows money laundering. Whether or not you agree with it, it's something it provides. * Banks and the government can't control you via seizing or freezing it. This one is incredible. The internet has a history of payment processors unilaterally destroying businesses - for example Wikileaks, and many types of porn or sex related services, many of which aren't illegal. Crypto provides freedom from authoritarianism and that's wonderful. The overarching axiom is, acceptance is the only thing that matters. Stupid, crazy, nonsensical, non-divisible, non-government backed, all don't matter if people just accept it in trade. And even the best well designed, feature rich, secure, safe, environmentally friendly currency isn't worth a damn thing if no one accepts it. The dumbest, most authoritarian controlled, slow processing, high fee currency with a massive carbon footprint to create more of can still be viable if it has widespread acceptance. The key is nothing matters except acceptance. And people accept crypto, especially BTC and the other early coins. So they have value. So no, it's not for us in tech to speak out, because it's not our decision. If people accept crypto, it's a real currency. If people don't, it isn't. Another way to look at it...what if I told you there was a new scam coin that had 27 trillion in circulation, an unlimited supply, and 1% of people own 30% of it. Oh wait, that's USD.
- xtat 5y agoRead the comments on HN and you will understand how early we are.
- shruubi 5y agoBeyond cryptocurrency, how many other applications have either been built around or shifted to primarily function off of blockchain? This isn't meant as a gotcha question, but it is something that I can honestly say I can't think of any. In terms of cryptocurrency, from my perspective the problem for mass adoption comes down to stability of value and oversight. Why would anyone want their paycheque to come to them in crypto when a few tweets by Elon Musk, lord of crypto market manipulation can turn your 2k paycheque into a 1.1k paycheque? On top of that, for good or for ill the big banks and credit card companies have decades of built up trust in that there is a centralised authority who can ensure that your money is safe. Irregardless of what the reality of crypto and the safety of your money in crypto, the wider public will not trust that their money is safe when there is no one to be held accountable if something happens. Finally, the fact that crypto has, to the wider public at least, been shown to have significant benefits for criminal activity and speculators actively trying to manipulate the markets has painted the entire crypto space as something that the average person should generally avoid at all costs. In theory, I liked the original idea of crypto. But the truth is that crypto was good-intentioned idealism corrupted by selfishness and greed.
- sexy_seedbox 5y agoLook into how BMW and Walmart are using Vechain: https://nederob.medium.com/bmw-uses-vechain-to-combat-mileage-fraud-cc2251311f32 https://nederob.medium.com/bmw-uses-vechain-to-combat-mileag... https://medium.com/vechain-foundation/walmart-china-takes-on-food-safety-with-vechainthor-blockchain-technology-b1443e0e079c https://medium.com/vechain-foundation/walmart-china-takes-on... The "why": https://www.reddit.com/r/Vechain/comments/7ra0tt/honest_question_not_trying_to_fud_why_does/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Vechain/comments/7ra0tt/honest_ques...
- pontus 5y agoWell, crypto is either going to be a huge success or a big flop. Whichever it is, whoever was espousing that side of the story will feel vindicated and talk about how it was obvious all along. Sadly(?) I belong to neither camp. I definitely see how clever the underlying technical/mathematical ideas are, but I also have a feeling in my gut that this is just smoke and mirrors (although, I have similar feelings for other assets like the USD and gold). Are there others out there who are also not sure? It seems like every time I see this debate, I just see hardcore people on one side yelling at the hardcore people on the other side telling them how stupid they are (in very eloquent ways, of course). Is it really that obvious that this is a good/bad idea?
- 52-6F-62 5y agoI’m in the not sure camp. I’ve had more positive gut feeling about some projects over others. I can’t stand tech bro culture in general so most of it turns me off pretty easily. I think there may be something there, but that the current state of “crypto” isn’t it. I’m encouraged to see discussions happening around banking and other open financial processes there. People who just can’t gain access to market where money they make can actually accumulate and help them are usually invisible. I want to see something come of that. These are expensive lessons, though—financially, ecologically, and socially.
- beckman466 5y agoHolochain fulfills blockchain's promises: https://medium.com/metacurrency-project/cryptocurrencies-are-dead-d4223154d783 https://medium.com/metacurrency-project/cryptocurrencies-are...
- bigclock 5y ago>"It's time for us in tech world to speak" >"It solves nothing", "It's used by criminals". If I got $1 every time I heard these...
- beloch 5y agoWhat is it supposed to do? Does it actually do that? What else does it do, intentionally or unintentionally? Who benefits from it, and who pays the costs? Is this exchange worth it for those paying? These are basic questions we should ask, not just about cryptocurrencies, but about the finance sector in general. When investment firms cause recessions or famines as a side-effect of enriching themselves, we have to ask if they're worth tolerating or if governments should drastically tighten regulations. Cryptocurrencies are just the low-hanging fruit. The whole tree is worth shaking.
- andreygrehov 5y agoWe have iOS and Android. We have Windows and Linux. We have Ford and Toyota. All with its own pros and cons. Why can't we have fiat and cryptocurrency?
- diego_moita 5y agoNo, it is too late. Economic bubbles are self-feeding. They have the social mechanisms of a cult where the members shut off communication with the external culture and only seek reinforcement for their belief system. If the tech world speaks out it will be like doctors recommending masks and quarantine in the early days of Covid or climate experts explaining global warming: the "true believers" will just reinforce their belief. Let them drink the Kool-Aid, there's nothing we can do anymore.
- boringg 5y agoHow does Chris Dixon, A16z’s crypto leader feel about this?
- rockemsockem 5y agoSince when has tech culture been about trusting big companies and governments to do the right thing? Sure you can achieve all the same objectives as the currency-side of the blockchain with traditional means, but, fuck the traditional means. Banks are trash, Wells Fargo literally opened fake accounts on behalf of their customers and those customers didn't know. The list of ways that banks have failed people goes on and on: racist loan denials, ATM fees, overdrafting, arbitrary transaction fees for payment processors, and I'm sure there's more that isn't coming to mind. Surprise, replacing the world financial systems is a long road. Personally I hope that we can keep walking on it.
- cyou111 5y agoAs a software engineer I was curious about bitcoin in 2017, when price was around $15,000, so I bought $500 bitcoin through coinbase. I created a personal wallet and transferred half of the bitcoin to it. Two big issues immediately stands out that made me believe that bitcoin has no future: 1. Long latency of transactions. I remember it took about 10 minutes for the purchase on coinbase to finish, and another 10 minutes to transfer half of the bitcoin to my personal wallet. This makes it impossible to use bitcoin as a currency. Imagine I go to a store and at check out, I need to wait for 10 minutes for the payment to go through. 2. High transaction cost. The transaction fee to transfer the bitcoin to my personal wallet cost around $15 (if I remember correctly), an astonishingly high fee. I kept the bitcoin as a souvenir, and when this year price go crazy, I sold half of my bitcoins on coinbase when price was at $50K, to recoup what I spent on it in 2017; and still kept the half in my wallet, as a souvenir of what I believe to be the biggest ponzy scheme in human history.
- baby 5y agoYour belief are yours, but to touch on your 2 points there exist cryptocurrencies today that have neither issues.
- derefr 5y ago> Cryptocurrency is sustained by a mix of money laundering, vaporware, fraud, ransomware, gambling, and delusion. Correction: ignoring speculation, the base asset-value of bog-standard crypto securities (i.e. the ones that don't "do" anything other than get traded around) is sustained by a mix of: • capital flight (in countries where the routes for regular ForEx conversions have been restricted) • financial "regulatory sandbox" instruments development, i.e. the ecosystem built on "security tokens." (This, as it turns out, is mostly being built out by the existing financial sector.) • grey- or black-market purchases — i.e. purchases illegal for either the buyer or seller according to their local jurisdiction. (Which doesn't usually mean criminal activity as you'd think of it, but rather is most often a routing-around of brain-damaged legal codes, e.g. FDA bans of non-dangerous drugs. I have a friend who's trans, who found it impossible to get prescribed hormones where they live — but got them easily on the dark web! Another friend, who had gone through every step in the workflow to solving their chronic illness and come up short, used crypto to buy a Russian medication that doesn't exist domestically, and it solved everything for them. Etc.) • facilitation of trade in environments with untrustworthy civic financial infrastructure, e.g. Venezuela • facilitation of trade between private citizens of countries that actively attempt to prevent trade with one-another, e.g. countries who have trade embargoes, or even countries who are at war Note the common theme: cryptocurrencies enable people to enter into trade with one-another when one or more governments don't want to enable that trade, or even want to actively prevent that trade. That's the "base value" that speculation on cryptocurrency is a multiplier on top of. Cryptocurrencies route around embargoes/tarrifs/etc. in the same way that the Internet routes around downed links.
- K0balt 5y agoWhile it’s perhaps true that many promises of cryptocurrency have yet to come to fruition, it is also true that programmable money has the potential to reduce the need for the use of coercive force and violence by the state, as well as reducing socioeconomic violence in general. Now is the tool being used to these ends? Yes, by small projects compared to Bitcoin, but yes. Crypto can create stable stores of value and currencies ( these are already in common use) and can add features like automatic taxation, demurrage, and ubi for users. Just because few people are using a tool correctly yet does not mean the tool is without value.
- eloff 5y agoDigital money with a central database can also do all those things, and do them better.
- baby 5y agoI know I’m coming late, but if anyone want to understand more about the technology behind cryptocurrencies I’m happy to answer any question. Obviously I don’t agree with the post, but I think education is more important.
- quartus 5y ago"Tech culture has a nice tradition of not deriding new ideas, but we need to break it here and speak out" No we don't need to break it here (even though it's a pastime of the author, who has already done it to two tech ideas in that Twitter thread). Build something that improves upon the ideas and solves the problems in a better way instead.
- stjohnswarts 5y ago"the tech world" is huge and not some homogenous mix of singular though. It's as varied as society itself, if only a tiny bit more egotistical about its (self) importance.
- johndoe42377 5y agoWhat should we talk about? Tokens are merely chips in the global network of online casinos. Ethereum is an amateur crap, technically like early PHP webshit. Btc is better but it in principle cannot scale, so it will remain a mere technological curiosity. Cardano is a corporation-like swamp, but yes, it has been affiliated with the best minds in PL world, at least on paper. Everything else is either scams, "swaps" or memes. What should we speak about?
- bitwize 5y agoCryotocurrency is like a microcosm of libertarianism in general: it promises to give everybody more freedom, but it really only benefits the rich by turning the economy based on it into an unregulated winner-take-all battle royale. And it fucks over the environment in the process.
- waingake 5y agoI think the only point of value for crypto currencies is enabling the purchase of drugs online, and don't get me wrong, being able to escape the terrible effects of prohibition is a very useful thing. Anyone who has tried will tell you how much better ( by any metric ) buying digitally is to the alternatives.
- kerng 5y agoIn the meantime the US prints 6 trillion dollars out of thin air - which seems at least as fraudulent as some crypto projects. I wouldn't be surprised if Bitcoin brings us back to a currency backed by gold or something similarly strong, or better.
- Vanclief 5y agoI really don't understand the mindless bashing of cryptocurrency by Hacker News. Normally discussion here is quite rational and level headed, but there is something regarding crypto that makes people get very polarized. First of all, I am not a Bitcoin maximalist, nor I am "brainwashed by a multi-level marketing sale pitch". Bitcoin is just a prototype for a P2P consensus algorithm that has stood the test of time. It has MANY flaws, and it failed its original goal of becoming electronic cash, and instead it became kind of a digital store of value. Is it worth more than it should? Sure, but you could argue the same of a lot of tech companies. The problem is most people think they understand blockchain, but they don't. They just think its for creating a meme currency that is a speculative bubble. What blockchain enables us to do, is to create a trustless P2P state machine, on top of which you can build any Turing complete project you can dream of. Instead of focusing on Bitcoin and Dogecoin go and check out Ethereum and projects like Aave and Compound. Blockchain will completely change the way we do finance, from how stock are traded, to how we transfer money. I am sure that it will happen in our lifetimes.
- acjohnson55 5y agoI'm not at all sure blockchain tech will change how we do finance. Literally every finance or finance-adjacent company has been trying to figure this out for the better part of the decade, and it just doesn't add up. Ethereum is very cool. Aave and Compound are very cool. But today, the whole ecosystem is super insular. Crypto loans and derivatives have to be overcollateralized with cryptoassets, and so the only use case for them is levering up cryptoasset exposure. Flash loans are a unique aspect of DeFi, but they're only really useful for arbitrage of cryptoassets. There remains a huge disconnect between cryptoassets and the real world. Things like NFT attempt to bridge, but it's basically just pretend. Owning an NFT generally provides no actual control or rights over the asset it refers to. Until institutions start creating assets natively on the blockchain, none of this stuff has any impact on the outside world. And it's not at all clear to me that this is going to happen, because there are potentially insurmountable hurdles in figuring out how to harmonize law and the blockchain. This entire ecosystem may turn out to be a dead end, outside of the clearly demonstrated use cases of speculation and crime.
- 5y ago
- top_post 5y agoThat's some cojones.
- jude- 5y agoNo one said you have to use the technology for illegal things, or even as money. Even Bitcoin-the-blockchain is only a timestamping system (seriously, even the Bitcoin whitepaper explicitly states that this is the purpose of the blockchain -- a peer-to-peer timestamper), which uses a token to prioritize transactions for consideration when the network is congested. I can think of non-financial uses for that!
- acjohnson55 5y agoIt's very interesting. But it's also noteworthy that there are very few gamechanging use cases for the consumer or business worlds, despite an enormous amount of attention and investment.
- jude- 5y agoThe problem is that most of the money (and developer interest) flowing into this space is driven by speculation on the rate-limiting token. This is clearly unfortunate. If you look past that, what you have is a highly resilient, replicated, totally-ordered log of data you can use to build other p2p services. For example, you could use Bitcoin transactions to implement an open registry of all Mastodon servers by binding their IPs and public keys to server names in a first-come first-serve basis. This would provide a one-stop-shop for discovering all Mastodon nodes and their public keys. As another example, you could build a p2p Docker image deployment system by binding a public key to a sequence of transactions that contain the hashes of fixed-sized chunks of the image, as well as a seed IP address. From there, peers with the public key could scan the hash sequence and seed IP address, discover one another, and self-organize into a random flood network to replicate the chunks and reassemble the image. The image author would publish a new series of hashes (or perhaps the Merkle root of a series of hashes if space is a concern) when a new image is published. Point is, you can do so much more with the tech than what is being hyped.
- still_grokking 5y agoWhy does some (pseudonymous, or even anonymous?) Twitter account claim to speak for some "silent majority"? Even using the term "we". Who is "we"? And why they think they are a majority? Was there a poll or so? Did I miss out something? Such kind of framing makes me angry — no matter I agree or not on the actual point! Who the fuck thinks they can speak on my behalf without even trying to ask me about my opinions?
- idlewords 5y agoMy full name and phone number are in my Twitter bio, you dillweed
- al3n 5y agonot technical here, but you could have posted this thread when the price was at it its all time high ? I wonder what would the response have been then ? ;/
- cyou111 5y agoI think any tools/means/platforms, no matter how well intentioned the designers are, if left ungoverned/anarchical, will be eventually taken over by malign actors.
- ffggvv 5y agobitcoin reminds me a lot of herbalife. everyone knows it’s an open ponzi scheme. but you’d also be rich if you invested in it early. and you can’t convince someone whose bought into the ponzi that it’s a scam. you just have to wait for them to get burnt and it mostly takes advantage of poor people trying to get rich to the advantage of early adopters.
- magma1983 5y agoI see many of you didn't get the train. Maybe you work on a big tech but you are not a hacker anymore. Real hackers are in crypto since its inception. And they will be your bosses. Just wait for it.
- poundofshrimp 5y agoI think ppl who dismiss crypto as having no social benefit don’t really get the decentralization benefit w.r.t. trust. Crypto is objectively inefficient and full of scam right now, but the fact that you can exchange value over the Internet, don’t have to trust any third-party and it’s really difficult for anyone to censor the exchange, is huge. If the inefficiencies are solved, then I don’t see how it is possible for fiat to keep up.
- bduerst 5y agoCrypto has been scams for years, all the way back to Mt. Gox. Social benefit comes from payment systems that provide safety and stability, not risk and volatility.
- poundofshrimp 5y agoThis is clearly a chicken and an egg problem. You can’t have stability until crypto is used in the mainstream and has a much greater mass overall, so that short-term speculations don’t result in massive volatility.
- bduerst 5y agoThat's not true at all. Most currencies are controlled by central banks who actively maintain them to reduce volatility and risk. It's not because of mass or momentum or some other physics term. Cryptocurrency by design doesn't have this and will always be open to speculators or other rational bad actors manipulating their asset markets.
- kalado 5y agoPeople always talk about the simple monetary aspect and I don't see much benefit in just bitcoin without a well working lightning network either. I'm still semi young and not a senior developer yet, so can someone explain to me how the following blockchain projects "have no clothes" as in "would be much easier without blockchain" - Helium Is building wifi coverage, incentivized by rewards based on coverage provided (that the users don't have to pay) - Several projects providing decentralized cloud storage. - SingularityNET is an AI marketplace that allows easy access to different ML apps with the goal of making those work with each other. I also find the ethereum infrastructure really cool (except the huge fee problem right now which is getting fixed with proof of staking/2.0 soon). You have a whole "new" internet that you can access via ether nodes and you can just consume other smart contracts on the network with no hassle. No need to create an account for a service or purchase some monthly traffic etc. You just interact with other apps because payment is decentralized and everything is public. I've made a small demo project for myself in .NET to see how it works and it really isn't too difficult. It seems to me that people who say that all "cryptocurrency" is a scam barely investigated more than bitcoin.
- rkagerer 5y agoI'm tired of HN submissions that link to tweets. If the tweet is very interesting that's one thing, but in this case the submission should have linked straight to the Politico article.
- koonsolo 5y agoWTF! Who is this to represent "the tech world"?!?!? Cryptocurrency was built BY tech people. I'm a 41 year old developer who started programming at 14, and love what is happening in the crypto space. So go F yourself for putting you as the spokesperson of the tech world. Such arrogance!
- nathias 5y agothis is either deliberate misinformation or idiocy
- scorpion032 5y agoTo judge it like this you need to compare. To compare, you need to measure the attributes of the this and the compared entity. The alternative entity compared in this case is the Existing Financial System that is handled by the Fed, Wall Street and the Bankers. Now, there are innumerable number of comparisons and metrics that have already done this job for their preferred metrics and statistics. They all unequivocally side on the side of Bitcoin. (one example: https://wtfhappenedin1971.com/ https://wtfhappenedin1971.com/) You are free to ignore these comparisons; but you have to compare and contrast that how cryptocurrencies, if ponzi compare to the modern financial system of all it's warts and what is the net effect of Cryptocurrencies and the Financial system as it exists today; rather than simply stating Cryptocurrencies are in and of themselves Ponzi.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y agocurl https://api.opennode.co/v1/rates https://api.opennode.co/v1/rates
- h0nd 5y agoWhat most people do not understand, cryptocurrencies do only define the technology itself. It does (and can) not define how it is used and also abused. It is, eg. obvious that Bitcoin was made with the idea of representing a coin, a mean of payment. However, it is clear by now, that Bitcoin will never be a mean of payment. In contrast, it is mostly used as investment. Also, you can not simply ban any cryptocurrency. The technology can not be 'stopped'. The lawmaker could only disallow it for this and that use.
- govcoin 5y agoMorr importantly, what many of you need to ask yourself, and what very few are focusing on is: 1) Who the fuck is Satoshi? 2) Why would the entire western world classify BTC as curency and remove VAT on it only after couple of years in existence, whilst at the same time silver legal tender coins are in most countried taxed with VAT. 3) Why have the regulators turned a blind eye to Tether? It was obvious to anybody already in 2016 they were responsbile for the run up in BTC prices. And know when everybody knows that they are a scam, they still continue to pump and distort the entire crypto market. 4) Why is Coinbase, a regulated exchange allowed to faciliate major scams lile Tether on its platform? And only crickets from regulators. Thats where the real story/dog is burried.
- joelbondurant 5y agoHave fun staying poor losers.
- birthday 5y agoIt's majority tech people that are into crypto at the moment, and tech people that have bought crypto. This is because it's still early days in the adoption timeline. It's a not ponzi scheme, Elon Musk isn't 'in on it', and Bitcoin is too free to fail. If you don't like it, GTFO?