53 ms·
Apple’s M1 Positioning Mocks the Entire x86 Business Model
- phendrenad2 6y agoI think Apple will keep selling x86 Macs forever. For heavy-duty workstation workloads, M1 just doesn't cut it.
- danaris 6y ago...And you think there'll never be an M2? Or M1X, or whatever branding Apple decides to put on their 32/64/128/???-core version that supports terabytes of RAM?
- GoOnThenDoTell 6y agoUntil they publicly show they can make such a thing, there will be some scepticism
- random5634 6y agoYou realize Apple is designing against more advanced nodes than intel - and from where I stand intel has nothing competitive in small form factors
- dev_tty01 6y agoWhy? Apple just demonstrated that they could do something that had previously been considered unrealistic. They've also been demonstrating massive annual performance gains for many years. For people who have been watching closely, they should have some credibility by now.
- tediousdemise 6y agoGigacore
- pfranz 6y agoI think the open question about the Mac Pro is the expandability. The trash can Mac Pro didn't do well and they went back with something with expansion slots. Is it worth it to Apple to build out and support everything necessary on the M1 platform for one low-margin line of computers? We'll find out in the next year.
- kalleboo 6y agoEven the 27" iMac has a 128 GB RAM SKU, so they're going to need to build a chip supporting external RAM regardless. External PCIe support already exists thanks to thunderbolt. So the architecture will be there, it'll just be a question of how expensive it is to scale up.
- dvhh 6y ago16GB should be enough for everyone
- jamesmcintyre 6y agoWhy should Apple care if a small portion of its product lineup will still rely on Intel/AMD? Why shouldn't they put pressure on these chipmakers to defend their position. They have both the vertical integration and scale to push entire industries to innovate. If this serves to “wake up” Intel we all benefit (including Intel). Look into xscale and its relationship to the original iPhone circa 2006-2007, that didn't wale up Intel and arguably they lost out on billions and weakened their future outlook.
- plywoodtrees 6y agoBecause of the cost of continuing to maintain software for that small fraction of the user base. Not only the core OS but the toolchain, and all their first party apps. And the difficulty of incentivizing and enabling third party developers to continue to support x86.
- cultofmetatron 6y agoThe m1 is built specifically to sip power and run cool. You don't think apple could come up with an arm processor that can keep up or exceed desktop x86 when those constraints are removed?
- artiscode 6y agoI'm not an expert, but isn't power efficiency the selling point of ARM? As in it runs efficiently, but there are diminishing returns to running it faster?
- cultofmetatron 6y agothe power efficiency is a consequence of simpler circuitry. modern x86 chips devotes a fairly large amount of logic to translating the exposed cisc interface to an internal microcode that more resembles a risc system anyway. A risc chip doesn't need that.
- NovaLuddite 6y agoI heard similar arguments in regards to initial performance with the transition from 68K to PPC and then again with PPC to Intel. The transition will probably be far quicker than you anticipate.
- thesandlord 6y agoThey already said they would be 100% off x86 in two years: https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2020/06/apple-announces-mac-transition-to-apple-silicon/ https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2020/06/apple-announces-mac-t... We are still only 6 months into that transition.
- lstamour 6y agoThe page you're citing contradicts that statement -- they will not be 100% off x86, but instead will offer 100% of their products with the option of buying an Apple ARM chip: > This transition will also establish a common architecture across all Apple products, making it far easier for developers to write and optimize their apps for the entire ecosystem. > Apple plans to ship the first Mac with Apple silicon by the end of the year and complete the transition in about two years. Apple will continue to support and release new versions of macOS for Intel-based Macs for years to come, and has exciting new Intel-based Macs in development. I would expect Intel-based Mac Pros to continue for as long as there's a market for them. Probably at least 2-4 years after the "transition" finishes. (The last spec bump in 1-2 years, and sales end 3-4 years from now...) It's also worth pointing out that Apple supports its products roughly 7 years from when they're sold, which means Apple will likely continue supporting Intel-based MacOS for at least another decade, possibly as much as 13-15 years. That said, I wouldn't buy an Intel Mac after 2024 and expect the same experience even if Apple supports it until 2031 or later: In just a few years, I'd expect Apple would have created even more MacOS features uniquely suited to the ARM chips they're now making.
- thesandlord 6y agoI'm sure they will support x86 for years, but I have a feeling they will stop selling new products with x86 rather quickly. If you look at the PPC to x86 transition [0] it happened faster than predicted, and OS support only lasted 3 years after it was done. IMO Microsoft is the company that heavily prioritizes backwards compatibility, while Apple is happy to drop support where necessary to move forward. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mac_transition_to_Intel_processors https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mac_transition_to_Intel_proces...
- agogdog 6y agoIt seems odd to think that their first attempt at this, which largely consists of small consumer-level devices with little to no active cooling, is the best they're going to do. Not to mention that they've already been dominating mobile SOC performance for half a decade as well. There's no indication that they couldn't take on the pro market. They've clearly got the talent in place. It's likely that the market size is a bigger factor than capability.
- diebeforei485 6y agoI will grant that the Mac Pro will be one of the last to transition, but I don't think it will stay on x86 forever. It may receive a spec bump at most.
- phire 6y agoI'm expecting apple to go the tiles or chiplet route for their workstation processors. TSMC have been working on some advanced packaging methods that are ideal for this usecase. Apple could make one 16 core die and offer workstations with anywhere between one and four tiles for 16 to 64 cores. As for the high end laptops and iMacs, I'm expecting Apple to launch a monolithic 8+4 chip. That would be just 3 unique dies to cover Apples entire Mac lineup.
- dev_tty01 6y agoHmm. Sure, M1 isn't suited for heavy workstation loads. They didn't target that sector yet. What's your point? This is not the last processor they will do. Have you been watching the massive year over year performance gains Apple has been making for several years? There will be an M2 and an M3, and .... Given the performance AND energy beating they are putting on the market sector that they targeted with M1, why is there any reason to believe they won't kill the high-end workstation sector when they target that?
- tobyhinloopen 6y agoI believe Apple will release something groundbreaking again when they scale up the number of cores in that M1. 8 high performance 4 low performance cores? Yes please. Or maybe we’ll get 16-16
- rvz 6y ago> I think Apple will keep selling x86 Macs forever. Apple immediately discontinued all Mac minis, almost all the Macbook Air and Pro line ups and the iMac's running Intel. The last form factor to transition is the Mac Pro. > For heavy-duty workstation workloads, M1 just doesn't cut it. Perhaps you are right on this one for now. The M1 doesn't cut it for 'Apple's standards' for now but when the time comes for the Mac Pro to transition, it won't use an M1 chip, but probably an M2 / M3 chip. Apple Silicon is the start of it all and M1 is only the beginning and is certainly not the last. So its worth waiting to see how the M1X, M2 or M3 Macs improve over M1.
- outside1234 6y agox86 is dead - first in consumer, then in cloud. It is hard to see to me how this ends any other way. The creative class (us) will quickly have largely all ARM computers within 4 years. Its not hard to see from there how software will be even more optimized for ARM variants than x86 and that the scale of both mobile and consumer computing will push x86 out of the datacenter slowly as old software that relies on x86 is retired over the next decade. People won't want to develop on x86 and deploy to ARM. ARM is more power efficient which is important in the data center too. We already scale by the core in the cloud, so why not just heap a few more cheap cores on if we need more to match x86 (which right now looks like we might not). Tell me how I am wrong.
- asddubs 6y agoa lot of people still rely on windows. maybe if microsoft gets a better emulator going, but I imagine with the amount of legacy they support that's a lot more challenging than for apple who are much more trigger happy when it comes to imposing changes on devs. i think it'll definitely happen, especially with the web browser increasingly taking on the role of the operating system, but 4 years seems a little optimistic, even with your qualification of that statement
- chao- 6y agoI agree with you in general, but disagree on the time scale. Particularly: >The creative class (us) will quickly have largely all ARM computers within 4 years. I think good options might exist in 4 years, but still possess trade-offs, where legacy x86-64 platforms still have their place. This could be something as niche as maturity of IOMMU implementations in x86 workstations, but stack up a bunch of niches and I find it hard to see "largely all" in four years. Fifty-fifty in four years, "largely all" in ten for "the creative class". Then there is a long tail of industries may end up legacy-bound to x86 for decades to come. Nothing is guaranteed. If starting in 2022 we were to see another 3-year performance plateau, ala 2016-2019, then anyone who bought into an mid- or high-end x86 platform today may not feel compelled to upgrade in just four years. Even if the ARM options exist, it might not be a compelling enough gap in four years' time. I'm not saying that a plateau is likely (competitive landscape suggests the opposite), but I don't have a crystal ball, so I won't discount it either. Again I want to emphasize that I mostly agree, but I wouldn't bet any money on sweeping changes on such an aggressive timeline.
- monkmartinez 6y agoYou get an M1 with the new iPad Pro as well! I hadn't thought of the situation as the article presents. When shown in that light, it made me pause to reflect. The M1 doesn't make sense when its in every darn product. The only differentiator is screen size, RAM, and OS? I will admit that I switched to Thinkpad and Win10 about two years ago when I had to return my butterfly for the 5th time. I am not looking back either. If anything, I am more focused on AMD Ryzen and Nvidia 30 series chips in MSI, Lenovo Legion and Asus offerings. There is nothing I can't do with one of those machines. Going Apple is a backward move for me as I like to program, design in CAD, play steam VR, and run blender sims. Can't do any of those well with Apple hardware.
- crooked-v 6y ago> The M1 doesn't make sense when its in every darn product. The only differentiator is screen size, RAM, and OS? They've only replaced the lower tier of Macbooks and iMacs with the current M1 board, which suggests to me that they're working on a variant with more CPU and GPU cores that will go into the higher tiers of those machines.
- londons_explore 6y agoI don't think they have the fab capacity to be able to do that. Since M1 products are selling very well, they likely have reallocated fab capacity they had planned for the successor to the M1 back to making the M1. A higher performance M1 would have a bigger die size. It would have a lower yield and get fewer dies per wafer. The same capacity would sell fewer products. Apple probably earns more profits by simply selling more M1s, unless they can reserve substantially more fab capacity.
- daemoon 6y ago> they likely have reallocated fab capacity they had planned for the successor to the M1 back to making the M1 Got any proof or something? This is a bold claim to make.
- rektide 6y agoRyzen 7401p still represents the pinnacle-for-it's-time value offering to me. 24 cores, single socket, on a 14nm process, launched July 2017 for $1075. Just an amazing breakthrough processor. At the time there were supposed to be X300 and A300 chipsets coming, basically just boot bios, to make ultra-low cost motherboards possible. There have been improvements since then to architecture & IPC, but overall it feels like we've been headed in reverse since then in terms of chips that get put into medium/large-ish sized chassis. It has been remarkable what a mockery Mac has made of mobile chips, and now of desktop chips. At a way more reasonable price point. > but the company’s decision to eschew clock speed disclosures suggests that these CPUs differ only modestly. I forget exactly when but the first Google IO that happened where Google started offering simply "Intel Core i5" or i7, without saying the model number (2017?), without revealing speeds, & it was a huge huge jumping the shark moment for me. A post competitive market, where speeds were good enough, where reputation & market presence domineered over metrics & comparable factors. I don't think chasing specific GHz & cache size numbers &c is super rewarding or important, but it felt like the first time we were being sold an unspecific system, where obvious inquiry into what we were buying was blocked. This is somewhat the opposite of this article: that Apple has found a good enough CPU to sell everywhere. But I still think the real truth is that the providers, those building systems, have begun to refuse to compete. They refuse to detail what they are offering. AMD has been without competition and the new 24c chip is considerably more expensive, albeit for yes more IPC, but it still hurts me a little. Looking at Google no longer allowing us to have any idea what kind of Core i5 or whatever chip though, they beat this article to the punch almost half a decade ago. Consumers haven't been given respect, haven't been allowed to know what wattage, what caches, what Hz their chips use for a long time now. Google started that, Google pushed the post-knowable computing upon us. Apple is merely following up on this, merely delivering what Google started, at a far better price point, with far better underlying technology.
- crooked-v 6y ago> but the company’s decision to eschew clock speed disclosures There's one other major factor here: clock speed isn't all that useful for this new architecture full of custom-purpose cores, asymmetric cores, a new arrangement of connections between cores, etc. Actual benchmarks may be useful, but not so much a clock speed measurement (and which of those various asymmetric cores are you measuring against?).
- tyingq 6y agoI remain interested in seeing how much of Apple's lead is the process size, and how much is engineering prowess. That is, would a more generic new ARM Neoverse on 5nm perform at roughly the same clip? I suppose AWS's Graviton 3 would be the first place to see that, or something close to it.
- wmf 6y agoI'm not sure why you're comparing a server core to a mobile/desktop one. There are two X1-based SoCs on "5 nm" (Samsung not TSMC) and they're not very close to A14, let alone M1. https://www.anandtech.com/show/16463/snapdragon-888-vs-exynos-2100-galaxy-s21-ultra https://www.anandtech.com/show/16463/snapdragon-888-vs-exyno...
- titzer 6y agoThe CPU microarchitecture is truly a quantum leap ahead of x86 processors. The fixed-width nature of arm instructions means there's way more front-end bandwidth for decode, which can then feed a much larger out-of-order engine. Having memory so close is also a huge win. TBH, I don't know what wizardry they have managed to get power consumption so low, but wow. 15W TDP and trouncing desktop processors pulling 12x that power!
- inasio 6y agoAssuming the M1 performance extrapolates to desktop power/cooling it's going to be a monster chip. If that is the case I think apple will not stop at having the fastest watch/phone/tablet/laptop/PC. Why not go after the datacenter and leave money (a ton of money) on the table?
- dehrmann 6y ago> Why not go after the datacenter For certain applications, the migration will be challenging. It's also a slowly dying market. Amazon has an ARM instance, already. I'm sure they're already tearing the M1 apart to see what they can use. It's also no Apple's core competency; enterprise sales is a different beast. Edit: I wasn't quite clear: it's dying because businesses are migrating to the cloud, and cloud providers are already working on/support ARM CPUs. Google might be willing to buy M1 chips. Not servers or boards because everything is probably custom by now, just the chips.
- titzer 6y agoIn what way is the datacenter market dying? Are Googles and Facebooks and Cloudfares and Microsofts and Amazons suddenly decommissioning huge racks of computers while their cloud businesses take off? What is that cloud made of?
- snotrockets 6y agoThose all owns their datacenters (and some can afford to design their own CPUs for those). Renting racks isn't dying yet, but it is on a downward trajectory.
- pmontra 6y agoMaybe because every tier 1 cloud provider is starting to design its own CPU. If this is the trend there will be little left to sell them.
- titzer 6y agoCan you name a cloud provider that has recently launched their own CPU?
- fggg444 6y agoCan't they just stick a few dozen M1s in a box and call it a Mac Pro to scale up that way?
- wmf 6y agoNo, the M1 lacks any (usable) way to connect to other M1s.
- thitcanh 6y agoFor now?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kingosticks 6y agoYes and they need to go away and design a very different chip. It's not trivial. x86 vendors already have chips like this.
- malf 6y agoDid you just “imagine a beowulf cluster of those”?
- danaris 6y agoThanks, that takes me back ^_^
- michael1999 6y agoThe return of NUMA!
- wmf 6y agoThe year of NUMA on the desktop.
- trilinearnz 6y agoLearning a bit about this in my MBA classes. Cost + Margin = Selling Price. Apple have the capacity to be more of a cost leader now, since they are not subject to the same bargaining power forces of CPU suppliers. As a result, they have the potential to push their costs down (if not now, then in the future once production scales) and increase their margins. A good time to invest, perhaps?
- clairity 6y ago> "Cost + Margin = Selling Price." that's cost-plus pricing, and should be viewed as a relatively naive model that is no longer typically used for pricing. sophisticated pricing decisions are based on price elasticities to find the profit-maximizing price. apple is a notable example of a company that exhibits this type of pricing decision-making.
- trilinearnz 6y agoCheers for the clarification :)
- morpheuskafka 6y ago> Second, Intel and AMD both benefit from a decades-old narrative that places the CPU at the center of the consumer’s device experience and enjoyment and have designed and priced their products accordingly, even if that argument is somewhat less true today than it was in earlier eras. I would have argued that memory was far more important than CPU in quickly judging the performance of a machine, once the 7th generation Intels made dual-core obsolete. But the M1 seems to buck this trend a bit as well, given that it only has an 8GB and 16GB variant and its new unified memory model makes traditional estimates of how much memory is needed less important. Some workloads such as an in-memory database won't change, but the memory usage for GUI rendering, graphics, etc. can take advantage of much faster accesses. And, with SSDs which are now considered a must-have for any serious machine, paging to disk is far less expensive than before in any case. On another note, the M1 iPad Pro is the first time Apple has ever officially confirmed or marketed, let alone offered a choice in, the RAM for an iOS/iPadOS device.
- buildbuildbuild 6y agoDisrupt the hosting market, Apple. We're ready for your EC2. Achieving a quantum power/performance leap without swinging for server market share is an massive wasted opportunity. But Apple is Apple. I'll keep dreaming. Oh look, an AWS invoice.
- dane 6y agoCompletely agree. I can't see them reviving the Xserve brand with their own silicon, but I could see them introducing cloud hosting services. Ideally with differentiation in something like environmental credentials (reduced, renewable power, etc.) to try and gain market share whilst maintaining margin.
- andrewjl 6y agoThey already have, though the marketing is subtle. [1][2] [1] https://www.apple.com/icloud/ https://www.apple.com/icloud/ [2] https://developer.apple.com/icloud/cloudkit/ https://developer.apple.com/icloud/cloudkit/
- klohto 6y agoWe are talking AWS competitors, not Google Drive alternative.
- andrewjl 6y agoBesides a deliberate paucity of knobs to tweak, what exactly is the difference with AWS S3 as far as the target market (app developers) is concerned? This is a cloud hosting service in all but name. https://developer.apple.com/icloud/icloud-drive/ https://developer.apple.com/icloud/icloud-drive/ https://developer.apple.com/library/archive/documentation/DataManagement/Conceptual/DocumentBasedAppPGiOS/Introduction/Introduction.html https://developer.apple.com/library/archive/documentation/Da...
- thitcanh 6y agoWhat’s the advantage? I don’t think it’s likely to cost less as a service, especially directly from Apple. If you get the same performance per dollar you might as well keep using what you have. Heat and energy savings only apply to the direct user (in this case Apple Hosting) and unlikely to be passed onto you (since it’s Apple). We’ve already seen this with M1 computers which are simpler and less expensive but did not have a lower retail price.
- speedplane 6y agoThe M1 processor is a direct result of the death of Moore's law. It's an amazing processor, but a sad sign of things to come. The performance gains from Moore's law have typically come from shrinking die size. That has ended, you can't juice more performance from general purpose CPUs. If general purpose processors no longer advance quickly enough, the only way to get performance gains is to build custom chips for common specific tasks. That's what we're seeing now with the M1. The M1 buys us a few more years of exponential-appearing performance gains, but it's a one-trick pony. You can turn code into an ASIC once, but after that, your performance is at the mercy of the foundry and physics. The death of Moore's law has many consequences, the rise of ASICs and custom co-processor chips is just one of them.
- nightowl_games 6y agoOn his recent Lex Fridman podcast appearance, Jim Keller speaks to exactly this mindset. He says that they've been heralding the death of Moore's law since he started and that the "one trick ponies" just keep coming. He says he doesn't doubt that they will continue.
- speedplane 6y ago> they've been heralding the death of Moore's law since he started and that the "one trick ponies" just keep coming. He says he doesn't doubt that they will continue. The situation is clearly far worse than what you suggest. Back in the 1990s and early 2000s, apparent computer performance was doubling roughly every two years. Your shiny new desktop was obsolete in 24 months. Today, we're lucky to get a 15% gain in two years. The "one-trick ponies" help narrow the "apparent performance" gap, but by definition, are implemented out of desperation. They aren't enough to keep Moore's law alive (it's already dead), and their very existence is evidence of the death of Moore's law.
- nightowl_games 6y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DZ0yfEnwipo&t=712s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DZ0yfEnwipo&t=712s
- dvfjsdhgfv 6y ago> "Part of the reason Apple can get away with doing this is that — and let’s be honest — it’s been selling badly underpowered systems at certain price points." Well, they've been doing this for a long time, and were able to pull it off only because we got hooked up with their ecosystem and preferred more than the alternatives. What worries me though is the trend to make these machines totally unupgradeable: not only this is bad for the environment but will also decrease the long-term value of these expensive objects.
- robocat 6y agoPerhaps one reason for using a single model of chip for everything is because the design costs for a 5nm SoC are estimated to be ~$500 million. For comparison, revenue for Apple Mac computers in 2020 was ~$30 Billion. https://www.statista.com/statistics/263428/apples-revenue-from-macintosh-computers-since-first-quarter-2006/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/263428/apples-revenue-fr...
- dannyw 6y agoIt's not linear. Doing a M1 variant with say 6+6 wouldn't cost another 500 mil.
- robocat 6y agoSure. But does Apple's CPU engineering team have the capacity to work on variants? Perhaps they instead prioritise working on a faster M2, and M1 becomes the low end CPU, similar to what they have done with the A series processors?
- tonyedgecombe 6y ago>Apple’s gamble, with the M1, is that its custom CPU performance is now so high, at such low power consumption, that the choice of chip inside the system has become irrelevant within a given product generation. This is clearly wrong as they are still selling Intel versions of the MacBook and MacMini. Apple makes a lot of money by offering a range of processor options. At the moment we are early in the transition but I have no doubt there will be M2, M3, etc options for most of the range.
- elcomet 6y agoBut the point is that people do not care about the cpu in their mac. They care about screen size, price and other stuff. Apple is still selling intel versions, because either they are cheaper (older generations), or because the newest version does not have the M1 yet (like the 16" mac book pro).
- adrianmsmith 6y agoThat's not the only reason - the M1 is limited to 16GB which is fine for many workloads, but not for all. Plus not everything works on the M1 yet e.g. running Linux in a VM.
- dataking 6y ago> This is clearly wrong as they are still selling Intel versions of the MacBook and MacMini I can think of other reasons some customers may prefer or need to buy the Intel version. AFAIK, you cannot run virtualized x86 code (docker, parallels, vmware) on the M1 macs (yet?) or maybe you need a driver for HW that is not yet available for M1/ARM. You can't conclude that they sell Intel versions for performance reasons.
- djxfade 6y agoDocker for Apple Silicon was just released. It uses emulation for x86 based images and works mostly seamless.
- grishka 6y ago
- klelatti 6y agoOne thing which I don't think has been commented on is the marketing effort behind the M1. It's getting a lot of prominence and its use across lots of computers means that there can be a consistent message that "M1 is great - get a new Mac and get an M1". It also provides an opportunity to distinguish between M1 and the next generation M2 (presumably). I've always thought Intel's marketing was a bit confused - i7 stays the same over 10+ years with only the obscure (to the general public) suffix changing from generation to generation.
- the_duke 6y agoYeah the marketing effort is immense, and it's really surprising to me how many eagerly lap up the angle Apple is pushing without much reflection, even on HN. Like the good old Apple hype days. Now to be fair, the M1 is an impressive iteration on the A* chip line. But the Ryzen 5000 mobile chips really don't look bad at all in comparison, and a 5nm version of those would level the field.
- emteycz 6y agoBut there isn't a 5nm version of those... And laptop battery life is vastly different between these two.
- the_duke 6y agoCan you link a good test result that proves this? The 7nm Ryzen 5000 mobile chips are not very power hungry either.
- HatchedLake721 6y agohttps://www.anandtech.com/show/16252/mac-mini-apple-m1-tested https://www.anandtech.com/show/16252/mac-mini-apple-m1-teste...
- the_duke 6y ago
- franciscop 6y agoWhile the M1 is great now, I'm very hopeful in what's to come. If Apple can maintain even a bit of their current improvements year over year, in 2-3 years it just won't make sense to use anything else; see this graph to know what I mean: https://miro.medium.com/max/1356/1*_aVjpbyBkMq-KIY8kbbP_w.png https://miro.medium.com/max/1356/1*_aVjpbyBkMq-KIY8kbbP_w.pn... Even if Intel can catch up somehow, it'll take years to catch up to this, and by then it'd be too late. The only reason why Apple will not win is that they bundle software and hardware too strongly. This some times and for some markets is a big strength, but other times it's a weakness IMHO.
- f6v 6y ago> The only reason why Apple will not win is that they bundle software and hardware too strongly. That is the major reason M1 is having such a momentum. I was pretty skeptical that niche x86 FORTRAN R extensions would work on M1. But here we are, Rosetta made it the smoothest ride possible. Now look at Microsoft and their Surface Pro X.
- franciscop 6y agoYes, it's great to grab a big chunk of the market, but it'll limit then to grab the whole market IMHO.
- sto_hristo 6y agoMake it as fabulous as much as you want, $1700 for an 8 core, 8 gigs of ram machine is just one plain fabulous joke. This in the time when 16 gigs ram is the baseline if you plan to do anything more than facebook and instagram.
- agilob 6y agoYup, I have 16Gb of RAM on macbook 2011.
- thefz 6y agoDon't forget the entry-level 256GB SSD. With 1TB drives around 90€ at retail.
- oblio 6y agoApple always nickel-and-dimes storage. Overpriced storage is how they make probably 5-10% of their hardware profits. iPhone still have 64GB as their base storage in 2021...
- martin8412 6y agoThe default is 128GB..
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- 6y ago
- apatheticonion 6y agoCan't wait for an iPhone Pro with an M1 processor that I can plug into a thunderbolt/usbc dock, run monitors, a keyboard, ethernet, and have it running MacOS when in desktop mode. EDIT: A little context; when I am in the office, I use vscode over ssh to connect to my desktop PC at home. My desktop takes care of my language server, syntax highlighting, compilation and vscode forwards my ports and spins up terminals. All I will ever need is a low powered computer that can run my browser and tooling fast enough.
- baq 6y agothermals would be quite bad for performance here, but the vision is quite appealing.
- Heliosmaster 6y agoIsn't basically the same vision Canonical had for Ubuntu Touch/Phone? You carry your (main) computer with you in your pocket. If you're on the go, you use its screen. If at home, you plug it in better screens/inputs peripherals.
- iSnow 6y agoI wish they had had the firepower to develop this. I'm not exactly unhappy with Android, but I'd bought that in an instant.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- madeofpalk 6y agoMany have had this concept, no one has actually executed well on it.
- apatheticonion 6y agoMy use case is pretty fine, I think. I use vscode's ssh development feature to remote into my desktop at home. My laptop just needs to run a browser and editor window which I think an M1 powered iphone would be fine at.
- NicoJuicy 6y agoWhile everything wants to be faster. The Apple direction is everything I don't need. I have a desktop for 1000$, 64 gb DDR3, 512 gb ssd + 1tb hdd, AMD 2600 ( 6 core) and a AMD 380 8gb and I could have gone overboard with the latest CPU and GPU. But I didn't think i needed it ( and after 7 months of usage I still think it was the right decision)... Either way, I don't think I ever was Apples target audience. And something like an IPad is for consumption, not producing anything. Ps. Yes, i use it for some gaming and for VR too, but mostly dev.
- numpad0 6y agoI was thinking that there’ll be “M2” by now but a suspicion is growing inside me that they might use a NUMA cluster configuration with PCIe interconnect for upper tier models. Doesn’t it make sense?
- floatboth 6y agoThat would be a very AMD thing to do. Apple is likely to pump endless amounts of cash into TSMC to make huge monolithic chips so that there's no cross-core latency issues and that they can still say they have a single "chip" in marketing materials.
- grecy 6y agoI think it's very likely they will announce the "faster M1" at WWDC this year. It will go into the 16 inch MacBook Pro and the iMac Pro. Hard to say if whatever they announce will go into the Mac Pro - or if maybe they'll have yet another "faster" chip for that. Time will tell.
- sgt101 6y agoThe really smart move is launching the low power consumer version first. This positions the eco-system for the native code where Apple wants it - on apps that run on the mass market devices. The higher power apps can come later and exploit 8 firestorm cores and up.
- adhambadr 6y agoEconomics of scale. my bet is Apple will develop a cluster of M1s and call them M-power-2 to address the 1.5TB RAM workstation market you mentioned. It will be practically an array of M1s (or next gen) together. The way the M1 is used from iPad to iMacs is genius in terms of cost reduction at scale and for an end consumer, who doesnt care who else uses their chip, I get a good $/cpu power bargain. Tim Apple being the supply-chain guy he is, I see him doubling down and scrambling engineers to user more M1s in array to build a stronger core. Maybe an M1-based server rack for AWS?
- chiefalchemist 6y ago"Part of the reason Apple can get away with doing this is that — and let’s be honest — it’s been selling badly underpowered systems at certain price points." There is also market share. Being more affordable to more people means more sales. True, Apple has always positioned itself as premium. That will remain. Now it will be a higher value as well.
- shoto_io 6y ago> Apple’s gamble, with the M1, is that its custom CPU performance is now so high, at such low power consumption, that the choice of chip inside the system has become irrelevant within a given product generation. It challenges OEMs to consider how they might spec higher-end systems if some of the higher price tag didn’t have to pay for a faster CPU. I guess that’s the key paragraph.
- secondcoming 6y agoIs it possible to write C++/Rust on an iPad? If so I'll consider buying one, as my iPad4 is struggling both wth charging and with 'modern' websites and apps. Otherwise Apple's hardware is just too expensive for me for what it is.
- sudhirj 6y agoCertainly seems that way. It looks like there going to be an M1 chip for 99% of folks, which works fine for all non-CPU-pegging work (Air, 13" MBP, 24"iMac, Mini), an M1.Large for stuff that pegs CPU (27"iMac, 16"MBP), and M1.XL for 0.01% Mac Pro folks who drop 5 figures USD on computers. But I'd expect the numbers to decrease logarithmically and the prices to be multiples. M1 machines from $700 to $1700, M1.L from $2000 to $4000, and M1.XL from $6000 onwards.
- DelightOne 6y ago> The most likely outcome here is a future M-class CPU with eight to 32 “big” cores and a conventional DRAM interface, based on either DDR4 or DDR5. How much faster would M1 still be?
- fireattack 6y agoI was always taught ARM (and M1), being a RISC architecture, isn't as "capable" as x86 in some way, whatever it means. I am no longer sure if that's still the case, since they seem to work just as good, if not better (energy efficiency). Of course, it's not exactly an apple to apple comparison since Apple upgraded so many other things, but I just didn't see any mention about the limitation of being RISC in these articles. Could someone enlighten in this respect for an average Joe who knows nothing about hardware?
- nnadams 6y agoYou are right that CISC processors (like x86) have more capabilities, i.e. more instructions. You as the programmer get to take advantage of the "extra" very specific instructions, so overall you write less instructions. Less instructions sounds great, but with CISC you do not know how long those instructions will take to execute. RISC has only a handful of instructions, that all take 1 clock cycle (with pipelining). This makes the hardware simple and easy optimize. The instructions you lose can just be implemented in software. That space on chip can be used for more registers and cache, for a huge speed up. Plus nowadays, shared libraries and compilers do a lot of work for us behind the scenes as well. Having tons of instructions on chip only is a benefit for a narrow group of users today. We've found that for hardware it's better to reduce clock cycles per instruction, rather than reduce total number of instructions.
- enragedcacti 6y ago> RISC has only a handful of instructions, that all take 1 clock cycle (with pipelining). This isn't really the case with modern ARM. Fundamentally modern ARM and x86 CPUs are designed very similarly once you get past the instruction decoder. Both 'compile' instructions down to micro-ops that are then executed rather than executing the instruction set directly so the distinctions between the instruction sets themselves don't matter all that much past that point. The main advantages for ARM come from the decode stage and from larger architectural differences such as relaxed memory ordering requirements. https://retrocomputing.stackexchange.com/questions/13480/did-any-risc-cpu-ever-take-more-than-one-clock-cycle-per-instruction/13482 https://retrocomputing.stackexchange.com/questions/13480/did...
- Invictus0 6y agoWhy does Apple bother with the 13 inch MacBook Pro if it has the exact same processing power as the MacBook Air? Touch bar and 2 extra hours of battery life aren't enough to differentiate the two. My guess is that Apple does intend to differentiate the M line but hasn't been able to do it yet, for what reason I don't know.
- gorbypark 6y agoThe screen on the pro is slightly brighter as well.
- giorgioz 6y agoM1 is the fastest Apple CPU YET. I suspect in the fall they will release the M2 for MacBook Pro 15 inches. They have also delayed releasing the MacBook Pro 15inches with Intel on purpose in my opinion. When they will release the MacBook Pro 15 inches with M2 they will compare it with the Intel version with a 3 years old processor. I don't trust the Apple benchmarks much. They are choosing what to compare and what metrics. Let's wait 3 years when the dust has settled and we'll be able to compare apples with apples. Let's see also if Apple will be able to keep up the improvement of in-house built CPU+GPU with ALL COMPETING MANUFACTURERS OF CPU&GPU. What if Nvidia or AMD or Intel comes out with a huge leap, Apple then won't be able to take advantage of that. In my opinion the M1 is the new PowerPC. In 10-20 years from now Apple will have slow in-house built hardware and we'll be getting back off the shelf hardware like when Steve Jobs moved from PowerPC to Intel.
- theshrike79 6y ago> M2 for MacBook Pro 15 inches 16" will be the size, like in the current gen. External form factor about the same size as the old 15", but smaller bezels. If they come up with a 16" M2 with 16GB+ of RAM they'll be out of stock for MONTHS, everyone I know will be upgrading from their pre-touchbar Macbooks.
- giorgioz 6y agoyes I found myself exactly in that situation. Got a MacBook Pro 15'' mid-2015 which was falling apart. I did not trust Apple with the whole M2 and abandoning support for Windows Bootcamp. I made myself an hackintosh. Paid pretty much like an iMac but with everything maxed out. Still missing the GPU because of the crypto shortage but that's all another story.
- sebyx07 6y agoAt least on a x86, you can install Windows / Linux / Hackintosh. With m1 you have can install HackinWindows / HackinLinux / Mac, if you understand the joke. The good part with m1 is that force amd and intel better cpus. Competition in always good. The not so good part is that Apple might start a trend of higher prices for CPUs.
- othiagocruz 6y agoI for one welcome our new ARM overlords, may x86 rest in peace along with other relics of the past. Saying this as both a gamer and intel/pc enthusiast but iphone owner.
- alberth 6y agoARM is not more efficient / faster because it’s “newer”. People imply ARM is relatively new and thus could correct for the misdirection x86 has gone. 1978 is when x86 was introduced. 1985 is when ARM was introduced. ARM isn’t that much newer than x86. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/X86 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/X86 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/ARM_architecture https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/ARM_architecture
- runeks 6y agoHonest question: could it be a matter of backwards compatibility? Intel has been piling stuff on top of old architectures in order to stay backwards compatible at each step, while Apple had the opportunity to develop their architecture from scratch? I don’t know the answer, I’m just curious.
- protomyth 6y agoARM 64-bit is cleaned up from the 32-bit ISA and showed up in 2011.
- glhaynes 6y agoPeople tend to lump them all together and just call them "ARM" but the 64-bit instruction set ("AArch64") first came out in 2011 and is hugely different than classical 32-bit ARM. And the chips Apple makes these days don't even implement the 32-bit instruction set anymore.
- viktorcode 6y agoARMv8 is new though. That's where the path to M1 started.
- zitterbewegung 6y agoPersonally I think Apple has completed its shift from a computer manufacturer to a processor manufacturer who serves two internal clients the software division and the consumer electronics division.
- wayneftw 6y agoMeh. The M1 got laughed right out of our office. It couldn't do anything without us changing all of our code and tooling for it. We'll see how stable the landscape looks for it in five years.
- temptemptemp111 6y agoThe real mockery is that everyone has a black box in their computers that can read all of their passwords & keys... And then when you argue to open up the firmware & code all the customers exhibit Stockholm syndrome and say, "but that wouldn't be good for the company!" Yes it would... It wouldn't be good for their intelligence agency funding, though...
- zelon88 6y agoHere we go again. Comparing a 10w mobile RISC CPU to a 100w x86 CPU and somehow deducing that having a mobile CPU run desktop applications is a good idea. I wish all the Apple fanboys would just hurry up and buy one so they would realize they are comparing apples to oranges and sit back down. Nobody is buying an M1 to replace their gaming computer. And to insinuate that such a thing is possible or practical is disingenuous to the way PC hardware works. Additionally I think the article is of amateur quality. It takes on an Apple perspective and assumes that there will be no response from x86 vendors basically because "how could you possibly respond to something as astounding as the M1?" Don't worry. Apple hasn't taken over the desktop market yet, and they don't have the raw horsepower to do it anyway. And they don't want to. We are comparing embedded CPU's with proprietary north bridge architecture to industry standardized and socketed CPU's with an entire industry supporting it. Nobody in the market for a desktop PC is going to get a mobile Apple device just because the M1 is more efficient. Nobody goes out to buy a pickup truck and accidentally gets talked into a Prius. Just because you conflate efficiency with performance doesn't mean the M1 is capable of replacing a Ryzen 9.
- bstar77 6y agoI don't think this comment is going to age well.
- zelon88 6y agoI'm sure there are comments from the 64 bit PowerPC days that aged just fine.
- nerdjon 6y agoYou are right that as of right now the M1 can't really replace a gaming PC, but I don't see Apple currently really targeting that. However the real question is if that is an issue with the M1 chip or just an issue of Mac not really having much of the gaming marketshare. That being said, personally I believe the gaming PC market is largely a niche market for the entire PC market. At its core I don't see any reason the M1 chip can't play games (in fact we are seeing some good numbers come out of games that have a proper migration), it is purely a software issue. It may not be able to compete with the top of the line custom built desktops, but the reality other gaming laptops that are far more expensive can't either.
- kumarvvr 6y agoPerhaps Apple has more processors in the pipeline (this almost certain, as we have seen with its mobile processors). It may be very difficult to sell products with the same processor but different hardware forms, because the market is tuned to comparing processors. I am not saying whether its right or wrong, just that there is a whole mindshare of the market (marketing, advertising, news articles, blogs and videos) that start comparison of two different with their core processors.
- toss1 6y agoInteresting marketing approach for sure. What I want to know are the economies of scale for using a single component, both at the chip fab level, the main board level, and overall product level. Still seems like Apple's typical under-powered per price point offerings, but does this close the price/performance gap a bit, or drive higher profits at the same price points, or do they really see it as just a good marketing play? While it sounds nice to have one chip in different machines, what is the benefit to the user who buys one machine, typically for efficiency or power? I suppose in some edge cases it might be nice to have a laptop with CAD-station power, but also able to stream movies or edit documents for a full intercontinental flight on a single battery charge?
- rvanlaar 6y agoWhat I find lacking in the article is an apt comparison with AMD's Ryzen chips. Those are all the same chiplets, just binned differently. High performance ones go into the 5800x and 5950x. Lower performance ones into the 5600x and 5900x. Which seems to be the same thing apple does, with a slight naming difference. Calling everything M1, instead of naming the CPUs.
- johnklos 6y agoIt's so simple - Apple doesn't need to make money off of the M1 - they use the M1 to make money. For companies that sell CPUs instead of systems, it's the other way around.
- yalogin 6y agoThe difference is the advantage Apple has with their HW+SW vertical integration. Its as simple as that. Intel sells CPUs, so it creates the ranges of CPUs to make money. They advertise clock speed and put the higher ones on a pedestal, that is how they can charge more money. The OEMs just used that playbook and developed their own marketing stories on top of Intel's marketing. Either no one tried to differentiate or they just didn't have the power to fight it. Apple has a lot going for it in that scenario. They never had proliferation of models and always kept the number of options to a minimum. They also don't deal with volume, so they didn't have to do 20 variations of mac mini or the iMac. They kind of did their own thing even with the intel macs. Now with their own processor they were in a position to double down and make the whole product line even more efficient. Like the article said, they couldn't have done if the M1 is not clearly better than the competition.
- slver 6y ago> Intel sells CPUs, so it creates the ranges of CPUs to make money. They advertise clock speed and put the higher ones on a pedestal, that is how they can charge more money. How is any of this specific to Intel? Apple uses M1 at different clockrates in different devices. And that's not only due to battery and heat concerns, but also because those M1 are rated to run without errors at different clockrates. Similarly the new iMacs come with two types of GPU: 7 core (cheap), and 8 core (more expensive). The 7-core ones had one core disabled because it was defective. What Intel does reflects the simple reality of producing microchips. Some units turn out better than others. So you sell them at different prices. It's the same for AMD. It's the same Apple. > Apple has a lot going for it in that scenario. They never had proliferation of models and always kept the number of options to a minimum. Yet.
- SavantIdiot 6y ago> How is any of this specific to Intel? As of right now, there are 6 different Intel processor brands and close to 100 different SKUs. Source: https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/products/details/processors.html https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/products/details/pro... Currently, there is one M1.
- bitL 6y agoWould M1 scale up with 64GB or even 1.5TB of RAM? It's not possible to have that much memory integrated; what would be the performance difference in that case?
- hajile 6y agoSamsung started shipping 16GB LPDDR5 modules last year. They are supposedly 1.5x the speed and 20% lower power. Double the stacks from 2 to 4 and moving from 8GB to 16GB gives 64GB. The two extra channels and extra performance gives something like 3x the bandwidth at only a bit more power. That seems perfect for feeding more cores and a larger GPU. I’d love to see a move toward 512-bit HBM3. It seems like the perfect compromise. It doesn’t need expensive silicon interposers and offers decent latency while still having a lot of bandwidth. HBM2e uses about half the power as GDDR6 for the same bandwidth (I don’t know about HBM3 power numbers)
- adrian_mrd 6y agoWhat’s also lacking from a marketing perspective is the “Intel Inside” campaign - which was incredibly successful for the Wintel monopoly in the 1990s and early 2000s. Seeing the sticker or hearing this slogan used to imply a premium or cachet to the product/hardware to the average Joe or Joanne. No longer, Intel’s brand recognition has really taken a hit in the past decade.
- pdimitar 6y agoI really do wonder what would Apple create in order to be able to offer ARM workstations. Maybe chiplet / modular design like AMD? Only this time one of the chiplets is going to be a full M1/M2/M3 ARM CPU + some RAM and everything else usually included, and the other chiplets would be extra RAM or dedicated GPUs? I am looking forward to their first ARM workstation offering.
- paulpan 6y agoThe article makes a good point on positioning, but I'm not sure if it's due to lack of data points. Sure Apple seems to be using the M1 in across every price segment for their products, but M1 is also literally the first iteration of their shift to running macOS on ARM and not x86 architecture. This mass push mainly serves to speed up the transition. No doubt there'll be a higher performing SOC for Apple's Pro lineup such as Mac Pro, Macbook Pro. History has confirmed this since Apple developed the A*X chips specifically for the Pro lineup of iPads. Main question is, how many concurrent SOCs will Apple maintain? Just 2 as they've done for the iPhone & iPad Pro divide or potentially more?
- evanmoran 6y agoI believe you are 100% correct that when the M1X chips are released they will clearly differentiate the pro market. At the same time it would be impressive of Apple if the X chips capture MacBook Pro, iMac Pro and Mac Pro markets all with a single chip as well. So (as you point out) the article is only half the picture as it’s missing the pro lineup. And yet the article’s main point is true that Apple is satisfying an absurd number of products with (likely) only two processors.
- domano 6y agoPeople underestimate AMD and mix it in together with the current Intel chips when talking about the M1. Ryzen is not far behind M1 in single thread performance and beats it in multi core. If Intel had not made all kinds of deals with laptop makers for exclusivity then the narrative would be totally different in my opinion.
- hajile 6y agoAMD have a license from ARM. Supposedly, Zen is pretty flexible. I’d love to see where they’d get just by swapping out the ISA.
- anthk 6y agoAnd here I am with an AMD Turion2 and 2GB of RAM.
- jimmont 6y agoI'm very curious to see what happens to Intel. When the TSMC Arizona plant comes online in 2024 or sooner there doesn't seem to be much left for it to do that AMD and others are already doing more effectively. Perhaps that's too much an oversimplification, however it seems to be the sum of the various parts given as others have said here and elsewhere (and was my experience too), the performance of Intel hasn't changed much in about 10 years.
- muddi900 6y agoThis is completely disregarding scale; the iPhone allows Apple the scale to manufacture these chips at an affordable price. Lenovo, HP and Dell do not have that kind of scale. Apple sold almost 3 times the number of iphones compared to Dell's total device line. It also disregards B2B sales; apple has pretty much disappeared from schools and most office issues in big companies seem to Lenovo's, because of repairability.