18 ms·
I'm just gonna quote what I think is a very important part from the Graham piece itself >"People who don't look any deeper than the Gini coefficient look back
by Barrin92 6y ago
I'm just gonna quote what I think is a very important part from the Graham piece itself
>"People who don't look any deeper than the Gini coefficient look back on the world of 1982 as the good old days, because those who got rich then didn't get as rich. But if you dig into how they got rich, the old days don't look so good. In 1982, 84% of the richest 100 people got rich by inheritance, extracting natural resources, or doing real estate deals. Is that really better than a world in which the richest people get rich by starting tech companies?"
And my answer to that question would be, arguably yes. Why? Because at least old money understands the concept of noblesse oblige. The real sinister psychological thing going on behind the Graham argument is that it's not at all about meritocracy, it's that this mentality of earned wealth completely rids the owner of any sort of responsibility.
The aristocrats and oligarchs of the olden days might have been corrupt, debauched and half-useless, but at least they knew it. This new, self-made entrepreneur class does not only think they have earned their money themselves, which as a sidenote is also kind of a fiction, but that they're intellectually superior, morally superior and virtuous in ways that anyone else just can't understand.
Old money might have ignored you and thrown a party, but Silicon Valley money wants to remake people in their images, they have a Protestant zealotry associated with their money that makes any oligarch look straight up sympathetic in comparison.
C.S Lewis:
"“Of all tyrannies, a tyranny sincerely exercised for the good of its victims may be the most oppressive. It would be better to live under robber barons than under omnipotent moral busybodies. The robber baron's cruelty may sometimes sleep, his cupidity may at some point be satiated; but those who torment us for our own good will torment us without end for they do so with the approval of their own conscience. They may be more likely to go to Heaven yet at the same time likelier to make a Hell of earth. This very kindness stings with intolerable insult. To be "cured" against one's will and cured of states which we may not regard as disease is to be put on a level of those who have not yet reached the age of reason or those who never will; to be classed with infants, imbeciles, and domestic animals.”
- routerl 6y agoThanks for that comment, I largely agree. Let me try to summarize it: Old money wants subjects, new money wants worshippers.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- nl 6y ago>> In 1982, 84% of the richest 100 people got rich by inheritance, extracting natural resources, or doing real estate deals. > Because at least old money understands the concept of noblesse oblige. Someone getting rich in 1982 isn't old money(!). There is nothing except some kind of rose-tinted glasses to indicate that the rich in any era were particularly responsible in their use of wealth.
- donnythecroc 6y agoThe problem is all down to the basic human need of a home. In the 70s and 80s even 90s someone on a teacher's salary could own their own home in a major world city - say London. Now, literally zero chance. Because homes have become an asset class and the rich can outbid regular people so they are pushed out. That's the problem. I couldn't care less how many billionaires there are if regular people can afford a decent home
- missedthecue 6y agoHomes in the US today are much larger than they were in the 1970s. About 2x as large! Per square foot, the average home is actually cheaper today than it was then, inflation adjusted, and this isn't even factoring in the modern 2.2% mortgage rates vs the 13% mortgage rates of those days.
- dv_dt 6y agoHousing built small in the 1960's is still going for unaffordable for most rates in my area ...
- saddlerustle 6y agoNot to mention illegal to build.
- refurb 6y agoAt least in Canada (massive housing bubble now), if you look at median income and average house payment (not house price as payment decrease with decreasing interest rates), thy aren’t that different - it takes about the same amount of median income to own a house.
- neonological 6y agoLooks like the housing problem comes from the fact that average incomes have not been adjusted for inflation... which means the income of the rich have been over adjusted.
- 6y ago
- Fomite 6y agoI've also seen this referred to as guillotine protection taxes.
- onion2k 6y agoI suspect that in 100 years time getting rich through Silicon Valley style tech companies will be a lot less common. Tech will have been throughly commoditized, it'll be cheap to build things, and most of the knowledge will have been disseminated around the world. Anyone in a small city will be able to hire enough developer talent to compete. We're still near the beginning of the internet revolution. We're in the era where the inventors of things can get rich through their own talents. In every other industry that has undergone a technological leap forwards the same thing has happened until other people have bought up their talent and ideas and the inventors no longer make the big money. Just look at agriculture, manufacturing, publishing, news, automotive, aerospace, computing... They all saw the same cycle. The internet won't be different.
- solveit 6y ago> they have a Protestant zealotry associated with their money To be clear, you are comparing the mindset of new money to the pious protestants who held overwhelming sway over US society for almost two centuries? Just who do you think the old money is?
- feoren 6y agoIt's so weird that you seem to be kinda agreeing with the article while at the same time quoting some Ayn-Randian, hyper-libertarian, "I'm from the Government and I'm here to help" scare-tactic nonsense. Can we kill this idea that the spooky government helping a poor person is some sort of tyrannical insult to them? The government helps rich people all day long -- even the most bootstrapped businessman still uses government roads to ship his goods and government-backed police to prevent his offices from being raided by bandits. Yet it's an "intolerable insult" that government should ever try to help a starving, homeless drug addict. Okay, I'm attacking the C.S. Lewis quote and not your main point, which is interesting, although I'm not exactly sure who is trying to remake me in their image and what that would even mean. Not to mention that "curing the ills of society" in the worst way imaginable (eugenics) was pretty in-vogue with early 20th century "old money".
- greyhound 6y agoSuch a privilege to have no idea how the Government can execute millions of its citizens having no doubt that they are paving the way to a Better Tomorrow.
- feoren 6y agoYou're right: our only two options are (A) extreme libertarianism where the Government exists only to protect the interests of the rich, and (B) the government literally exterminating its own citizens. We better be careful not to increase taxes on the rich or we risk immediately turning into (B)! Also, didn't I just say that eugenics was a horrible thing that was in-vogue in the early 20th century? Isn't that exactly what you're saying?
- greyhound 6y agoThis is a textbook example of a straw man.
- feoren 6y agoAre you referring to your GP comment about how I must be ignorant about governments killing their own citizens because I dared suggest that governments can help the poor? If so, I agree: a straw man and lots of other fallacies to boot.
- js2 6y ago> And my answer to that question would be, arguably yes. Why? Because at least old money understands the concept of noblesse oblige. The real sinister psychological thing going on behind the Graham argument is that it's not at all about meritocracy, it's that this mentality of earned wealth completely rids the owner of any sort of responsibility. Michael Young wrote this two decades ago now: The business meritocracy is in vogue. If meritocrats believe, as more and more of them are encouraged to, that their advancement comes from their own merits, they can feel they deserve whatever they can get. They can be insufferably smug, much more so than the people who knew they had achieved advancement not on their own merit but because they were, as somebody's son or daughter, the beneficiaries of nepotism. The newcomers can actually believe they have morality on their side. https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2001/jun/29/comment https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2001/jun/29/comment
- sbacic 6y ago> Because at least old money understands the concept of noblesse oblige. Source please. > it's that this mentality of earned wealth completely rids the owner of any sort of responsibility. Allow me to offer a different view. If you're one of the lucky few who went from nothing to millions (or even billions) you'd be pissed if society came and started talking about responsibility and equality _now_. Where was society _before_? And that, I think, is the crux of the issue - society feels responsible for your successes but not for your failures. If you went from nothing to riches - society feels like you owe it some. But if you went from squarely middle class to being a drug addict on the streets then the fault is yours alone. Society will of course try to help you, but it will never consider the idea that maybe, just maybe, it is responsible for what happened to you.
- talliedthoughts 6y agoReading the other comments here, I think the argument is that when most people say they came from nothing, they are ignoring roads, electrical grids, sewer systems, fire departments, police to enfore property rights etc. "Society" provided those - before the person was rich. Of course, there are some people who got rich without any of those things, but probably a lot fewer.
- sturgill 6y agoIf one’s taxes only went to pay for this small subset of items, I think your argument would be stronger. A 40% marginal tax rate is not earmarked for these essential services, as evidenced by our decaying infrastructure despite the US government bringing in $3.5 trillion in tax receipts in 2019. The political left has been pretty clear that the aim isn’t solely a focus on essential (and shared) resources, but on increasing the social safety net (either through UBI, single payer, or other mechanisms). Separate conversation if those are good policies or not, but the argument isn’t that the rich don’t want to pay for police. That’s an incredible straw man.
- TulliusCicero 6y agoSocial safety nets contribute to earned wealth too, just less directly.
- kortilla 6y agoInteresting CS Lewis quote considering it’s frequent usage against government regulation from busy bodies who “know best” on how the economy should work.
- jimbokun 6y agoYeah, that quote gave me more of a moralizing woke-person vibe, than tech billionaires.
- TulliusCicero 6y ago> Because at least old money understands the concept of noblesse oblige. Is there actual data to back this up? That 'old money' behaves in a more positive society-impacting way than 'new money'?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ameister14 6y agoThere's a lot of evidence that old money is bad, I don't think there's any that says it's better than new money
- scrollaway 6y ago> The aristocrats and oligarchs of the olden days might have been corrupt, debauched and half-useless, but at least they knew it. You out of your mind? What could possibly make you say "they knew it"? The amount of people rich-by-inheritance who are selling their bootstraps stories is stupidly high, and a lot of them believe it. One famous example got banned from twitter a couple months ago.
- curo 6y agoCan't one just counter his arguments without assigning nefarious intent? It feels conspiratorial at times. - Quoting your comment: "The real sinister psychological thing going on behind the Graham argument is that..." - Quoting a line from the article: "His seemingly impartial and logical writing attempts to hide his true intentions."
- vishnugupta 6y agoPerhaps inferring nefarious intent is unwarranted. However if you follow PG's Twitter stream a reasonably clear pattern does emerge. - Denounce critics of happiness industry. - Play-down the idea of minimum support framework. In general, play down community and governmental support infrastructure in favour of individual's agency. - The current crop of rich people, by and large, earned it and their way of earning wealth is objectively better than earlier ones. So they not only deserve that wealth but also deserve the way it's been accumulated. - In today's world anyone can be rich and so if you aren't rich then it's your problem. - Tech will eat the world. Journalists who couldn't foresee Amazon and its ilk's rise are idiots who don't understand exponential curve. I have dramatised the theme but it's not far off. I won't judge if any of these are right or not because at the end of the day they are all opinions and he's entitled to have them based on his world view. Someone with a different world view and experience (such as me, for instance) will not agree with them and that's OK. That said, based on the pattern above it's easy to see how can one assign intent to PG's posts.
- irq 6y agoThe worldview he is (poorly) attempting to prosthelytize is inherently nefarious. It doesn’t matter if he intends it or not.
- greyhound 6y agoWow, that's one axiomatic comment. Could you please elaborate on what kind of worldview he's attempting to "prosthelytize" that is inherently nefarious, without making a straw man?
- qPM9l3XJrF 6y agoWealth tech people are giving their money away younger than the previous generation of billionaires: https://outline.com/mtGgFW https://outline.com/mtGgFW I think they understand noblesse oblige. But it's a 2-way street. Don't expect them to feel a sense of obligation if you're going to assume the worst about them just because they are rich.
- pydry 6y agoYou've got cause and effect reversed. Bill Gates started giving his money away after he was attacked for his anti competitive behavior and attempts to kill open source, etc. The rich donate because they are protecting their reputation and for the sake of their own self image (everybody needs to be the hero of their own story). The only ones who can manage that and not be charitable are the utterly self deluded (e.g. Trump). Don't expect them to donate a damn thing if they are lauded as heroes. Bill Gates likely wouldn't be giving his money away at all if it he didn't feel the need to repair his image in the 2000s. Same reason all of the robber Barrons were philanthropists - do you think they would have been more charitable if they had been cheered on instead of villainized? Like hell they would.
- qPM9l3XJrF 6y agoI suggest you watch the documentary Inside Bill's Brain https://www.netflix.com/title/80184771 https://www.netflix.com/title/80184771 Bill is way too invested in this stuff for it to be a cynical PR effort. And he himself states it was his mother who inspired him to give: https://www.businessinsider.com/bill-gates-mother-inspired-philanthropy-2015-5 https://www.businessinsider.com/bill-gates-mother-inspired-p... If Bill's giving was a cynical PR play, why would he be pushing other HNWs to give through the giving pledge? Wouldn't it be better to discourage them from giving so he looks better by comparison? Note also that a few years ago when Zuck pledged to donate 99% of his money, the internet erupted in incoherent anger. Similarly whenever the news covers tech philanthropy, the angle is always "well really this is something that the government should be doing, the fact that it is being handled by private philanthropy is kinda problematic". The giver's generosity is inevitably taken for granted. For the supposed PR benefits of philanthropy there is a shocking lack of good PR. Far more scorn is heaped upon wealthy philanthropists than rich people who just quietly buy yachts and stuff. Your reaction of "giving is just a cynical ploy" seems to be way more common they "hey, they are giving, that's pretty cool" in all the online discussions I have seen of billionaire giving. BTW, did demonization of wall street in the wake of the 2008 crash trigger a wave of philanthropic giving from them?
- flexie 6y agoProtestant zealotry? Seriously? When you bring religion into it, at least get the religion right: The Google founders, Sergey Brin and Larry Page, had Jewish backgrounds but consider themselves non-religious. Facebook founder Zuckerberg had Jewish background and considered himself atheist at some point. Microsoft founder Bill Gates is Catholic. Paul Allen had Jewish parents. Amazon founder Jeff Bezos was raised Catholic. Apple founder Steve Job's closest religious interest seems to have been Buddhism. Steve Wozniak describes himself as atheist. So we don't find a single Protestant, certainly not a Protestant fundamentalist, among any of the founders of the 5 largest tech companies.
- heavyset_go 6y agoAmerican history and culture is heavily influenced by the Protestants that made up the early US. The Protestant work ethic is a commonly referenced aspect of American culture, and most Americans regardless of religion are not free of its influence.
- flexie 6y agoYes, but when literally none of the founders of the largest IT-companies - the very richest of the "Nouveau riche" that we are talking about - are Protestant, whereas much of the old money is, the comment is quite off.
- bitmunk 6y agoThey might not be Protestants, but the cultural framework created by them the is still there.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoWhen was the last time anyone overtly referenced the protestant work ethic except for the purposes of tearing down a straw man. Many cultures, in the far east as well as Europe have similar "always be doing something productive" undertones. I agree that the moralizing zealots that set the tone for early American culture were insufferable (and being so insufferable likely helped accelerate the settlement of the east coast states) but "muh protestant work ethic" isn't really unique to the US.
- McScroogy 6y agoHuh, how do you know what the rich people of old were thinking? Your argument seems to be based on complete fantasy - both your assumptions about the mindset of rich people of the past and of people who got rich in SV are completely fabricated. But never mind, it is hating on rich people, so it is always OK, right?
- bkirkby 6y agoYou seem to be talking about a caricature of the "silicon valley rich." Who are you talking about when you say "this mentality of earned wealth completely rids the owner of any sense of responsibility"?
- pc86 6y agoIt seems pretty straightforward to me. If you believe that your wealth is entirely, or almost entirely, through sheer force of your own will, skills, and abilities, you have no responsibility to anyone with regard to that wealth. You earned it all without anyone's help. It's all yours. They can pound sand. If you believe that your wealth is in part due to factors outside of your control - having connected family, having family money, attending good schools, lucky breaks early in your career, etc. - you're much more likely to feel a sense of responsibility toward the next generation. To give other people lucky breaks, maybe even ones less deserving than you were. To set up scholarship funds so other kids can attend good schools they otherwise wouldn't be able to. Edit to add: People in group 2 don't feel they "deserve" it any less. They still earned it. It's still theirs. They just understand the difference between being born on third base and hitting a triple. The run still counts at the end of the day.
- greyhound 6y agoThis is an amazing quote, thank you. Though, the more I read into it the less I see it applicable to the PGs quote, mostly because I disagree with this statement: >Silicon Valley money wants to remake people in their images, they have a Protestant zealotry associated with their money that makes any oligarch look straight up sympathetic in comparison Tech became a global catalyst for many people to get out of poverty. A lot of people in countries like India, Nigeria or Ukraine would never had a chance to get out of poverty otherwise. I do not observe any increase in the sentiment in them remaking people in their own images. Half a century ago Ayn Rand was getting enough followers well before tech was even a thing. The quote that you have provided reminds me of the zealotry of communist regime that my country went through. As well as the arguments of the woke marxists that are sadly getting more frequent today. Anyway, thank you for an interesting take on the problem.
- adriancr 6y ago> The aristocrats and oligarchs of the olden days might have been corrupt, debauched and half-useless, but at least they knew it. Corruption is an incredible poverty multiplier, combined with debauched and half-useless is just insane. Living in a society led by such people isn't fair by any means. Arrogant new wealth is 100x better then old corrupt wealth that only seeks to entrench itself and friends. New wealth in proper democracies at least has a proven track record of competency and general societal good, it can also do a lot of good when spent (see Bill Gates) If you are all worried about wealth, just put 99% estate tax, will cover both old and new wealth.
- laurent92 6y agoEntrenched money stabilizes the world. Imagine putting 10% of the billionaires of the world on a boat, those who pull the strings of their empires to keep their nations into status-quo, and imagine the boat sinks. A year later, all those entrenched interests dematerialize, fewer powers hold people together, diplomacy isn’t as balanced as it has been when billionaires weighed in, and war starts. That’s the story of the Titanic, sunk in 1913.
- gloriana 6y agodo you have any reading material on this? curious idea
- adriancr 6y ago> Entrenched money stabilizes the world. It stabilizes the world into a corrupt distopia where those people rule only to entrench themselves and their friends (incompetent and malign as they are) What you are describing is the old feudalism approach where aristocracy controlled everything. How well did that turn out for the serfs?, then how did it work out historically for everyone?, how many are still around?
- Spivak 6y agoBut entrenching themselves is a benign end. I don’t really care that very very wealthy people exist and seek to carve out exceptions for themselves to maintain that wealth. The harm that’s done is vague and more the realm of economics. But very very wealthy people who want to “change the world” are individuals with the monetary weight of tens of thousands of people and can do things that for others would require and naturally be tempered by cooperation.
- spamizbad 6y agonoblesse oblige is, best I can tell, a cultural myth. There’s been quite a bit of writing on this subject[1]. I’m not convinced self-made wealth of today is any better or worse than the concentration of family money in the past - so I think your point is half correct. [1] https://www.worldcat.org/title/executive-imperialism-the-myth-of-noblesse-oblige/oclc/64067727 https://www.worldcat.org/title/executive-imperialism-the-myt... (And the paper) https://calisphere.org/item/ark:/28722/bk0003v1h0r/ https://calisphere.org/item/ark:/28722/bk0003v1h0r/ https://www.firstthings.com/article/2018/04/the-ignoble-lie https://www.firstthings.com/article/2018/04/the-ignoble-lie
- joyeuse6701 6y agoIn the Gulag Archipelago, there's a story about Tsar Nicholas asking to be placed in solitary confinement so as to understand the conditions. The author notes that even this gesture was an indication of at least moral aspiration. Which I believe may fall under the umbrella of noblesse oblige This is in stark contrast to the Organs operating the prisons during the Soviet era who would never submit themselves to torture to understand the plight of the prisoners they sentenced. Anyway, just a fun anecdote, clearly noblesse oblige wasn't enough to stop the people from revolting in several cases.
- microtherion 6y ago"Silicon Valley money" also got you the Monterey Bay Aquarium, the Computer History Museum and lots of other nice things. You see a Hewlett, a Packard, or another legendary Silicon Valley name on almost every Nice Thing in the Bay Area.
- sthnblllII 6y agoThat's like pointing to the free turkeys Mexican drug cartels give out on Christmas as an argument for letting them murder people.
- microtherion 6y agoMy point was not whether vast fortunes per se are good or not, but whether "Silicon Valley money" is a completely different creature from "old money", and, in fact, there is quite a bit of "Silicon Valley money" that is being deployed in fairly conventional "old money" ways.
- gumby 6y ago> Because at least old money understands the concept of noblesse oblige. Sounds like it was written by someone who didn't grow up around "old money". There's plenty of statistical literature on this myth.
- slibhb 6y agoThere's a certain irony in you posting that Lewis quote. "Omnipotent moral busybodies" is a good description of a significant part of the left-wing these days. > This new, self-made entrepreneur class does not only think they have earned their money themselves, which as a sidenote is also kind of a fiction It's not a fiction that entrepreneurs earned their money themselves. It's more complicated than that but it's not fiction. Most entrepreneurs fail, the ones who get rich usually do something innovative. It is a fiction that entrepreneurs are "intellectually superior, morally superior and virtuous" but, again, who really thinks of themselves that way, Paul Graham-style entrepreneurs or the lefties who insist that they are motivated purely by "justice" but are clearly at least partly motivated by resentment? There are good arguments for left-wing policies. But the left today is culturally ascendant and many of its most popular arguments are petty vindictiveness (like, for example, that rich people didn't innovate in order to get rich -- most of them did!).
- jberryman 6y ago> Because at least old money understands the concept of noblesse oblige Interesting observation. I recently learned from a Fresh Air interview with Heather McGhee about Hinton Rowan Helper, a white racist Southerner abolitionist. He wrote a book analyzing the way chattel slavery harmed working-class whites and white society, the essential dynamic being: the wealth of the plantation class did not depend on the labor of the white working class, nor their ability to buy product from the plantation class (cotton and tobacco were shipped north and globally); as a result the plantation (ruling) class had no incentive to invest in society; Helper quantified this by looking at number of libraries, schools, etc. in the North vs the deep South. Obviously I don't want to claim the horrors of slavery are comparable to the effects of tech companies on the economy... but I wonder if the same _essential dynamic_ is there: - wealth equating to political power - an industry driven to remove any reliance on an educated populous or satisfied workforce (through automation, and the secondary effects of automation as in the way Uber etc. offloads risk onto drivers/society) - an industry for whom the populous are not customers but "the product"
- Ambolia 6y ago>Because at least old money understands the concept of noblesse oblige. You can just count in your city how many buildings, libraries, concert halls and similar have been built by the rich of old, and how many by the rich of new. Maybe the new rich give to ONGs instead, but ONGs can be seen as just another institution to exert power, influence markets, and buy people by giving them a position in ONGs where you invest heavily. On the other side infrastructure is infrastructure, yes, it makes you look good, but you have to build something real and solid that is easy to evaluate.
- emodendroket 6y agoA bit odd to criticize them for being "Protestant" and then quote CS Lewis.
- dennis_jeeves 6y ago>Protestant zealotry My god, so many people misunderstood you, and took this thing in the literal sense. HN is worse that I imagined.