6 ms·
How is it possible that girls perform better academically (in 2015) yet are under represented in the top tier of jobs? Either women have no interest in money, a
by endisneigh 6y ago
How is it possible that girls perform better academically (in 2015) yet are under represented in the top tier of jobs? Either women have no interest in money, academic skills have no bearing in getting high paying jobs, or discrimination is more prevalent then you’d think. I suppose all three could be true.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- refraincomment 6y agoOr simply that boys don't take education seriously until 10 years later?
- 0xy 6y agoBecause women naturally list towards jobs that pay less, and under conditions that pay less (part time, contract work, etc). How many deep sea welders are women? Less than 0.1%. How many oil rig workers are women? Less than 1%. Good deep sea welders earn over $300k.
- krisdol 6y agoHard to live up to the expectation of being a good mother and spending months on an oil rig at the same time.
- throwaway894345 6y agoI doubt it's "expectations of being a good mother". Countries with the most liberal attitudes toward gender have some of the most extreme occupational gender disparities and vice versa.
- Dirlewanger 6y agoYou're being disingenuous and you know it. Most women don't take the high risk jobs. They never have, they're not evolved for it. This isn't sexist to point this out, this is just how things are. Why do people here struggle to understand concept of gender roles that have been in place (and have worked) for hundreds of thousands of years? This isn't the "patriarchy" boogeyman, this is how societies started and thrived.
- wizzwizz4 6y agoDefine “naturally”.
- 0xy 6y agoMeaning on average, most women list towards them. There are large differences between genders in terms of career motivations, interests etc. Proven in many studies repeatedly.
- wizzwizz4 6y ago> There are large differences between genders in terms of career motivations, interests etc. I think this would be the case for the hypothetical “party if you're a man, standing outside in the rain if you're a woman” job, too. How do you know you're describing something about the people you're measuring, as opposed to the people around them?
- La1n 6y ago>Because women naturally list towards jobs that pay less, Couldn't one then also argue that jobs women list towards get paid less? E.g. instead of asking why women gravitate to those jobs that are paid less, ask why the jobs women gravitate towards are paid less.
- missedthecue 6y agoThe fact that daycare workers (a job dominated 97% by females) earn $35k a year while carpenters, welders, and electricians (jobs dominated 98% by males) earn $80k is not a fact that I think is attributable to bigoted sexism.
- BobbyJo 6y agoI don't think those are what the parent was referring to as 'top tier'. Those pay well, but in both cases they are highly paid because of risk and life disruption (having to spend extended time away from home on rigs). It's my understanding that men are naturally less risk-averse, so the gender differences there seem natural to me. I'm betting they meant CEO positions, board positions, and high ranking corporate officers.
- Dirlewanger 6y agoOnly on HN will facts like these get downvoted. Why is this community so allergic to discussing this topic in an unbiased manner?
- noir_lord 6y agoIt's also possible that the distribution is different. i.e there are more men who are total geniuses at one end and total dumbasses at the other but the average would be the same. https://qz.com/441905/men-are-both-dumber-and-smarter-than-women/ https://qz.com/441905/men-are-both-dumber-and-smarter-than-w... No idea if it's true though - not my field and not an expert.
- endisneigh 6y agoEven if this were true it still wouldn't explain the difference. This could only be the explanation of two conditions are met: 1. Your cited article is correct. 2. The jobs that are "top tier" indeed require this "top tier" level intelligence. This second point would require some pretty extraordinary evidence to prove. Women have representation (only filtering among women under 40) in jobs that require "high intelligence" yet the discrepancy persists. doctors: https://www.washingtonpost.com/health/the-big-number-women-now-outnumber-men-in-medical-schools/2019/12/20/8b9eddea-2277-11ea-bed5-880264cc91a9_story.html#:~:text=For%20the%20first%20time%2C%20women,students%20in%20U.S.%20medical%20schools.&text=Its%20survey%20of%2018%2C000%20physicians,younger%20than%2035%20were%20women https://www.washingtonpost.com/health/the-big-number-women-n.... lawyers: https://www.census.gov/library/stories/2018/05/women-lawyers.html https://www.census.gov/library/stories/2018/05/women-lawyers... (just to use two popular examples. if you extend this out to a lot more professions the pattern persists) You could be right, but I personally doubt it.
- curiousgal 6y agoI think the answer lies in the fact that in countries like Tunisia for example, women represent over 60% of people working in STEM. Why? Because STEM jobs are the highest paying jobs. So from my perspective, the lack of women in STEM in the U.S. is not an issue but a symptom of a strong economy, as in you don't have to decipher someone's spaghetti code for a living, you can pay the bills doing other things that you are more passionate about.
- renewiltord 6y agoRelated reading: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender-equality_paradox https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender-equality_paradox
- ku-man 6y agoIndeed. The number of women in STEM fields is also low in Sweden and other Scandinavian countries compared to in-development ones. And, nobody in his/her right mind will accuse the Scandinavian countries of being patriarchal sexists societies.
- LeegleechN 6y agoGirls get higher grades (perhaps due to higher conscientiousness), but do not do better in standardized tests.
- micdr0p 6y agoThat's interesting. Got a source?
- hc-taway 6y agoMy graduating class was remarked on through multiple schools as an exceptionally smart class. We had lots of very bright boys and girls. Maybe our class was unusual in other ways so this isn't part of a broader trend or tendency, but practically all the smart girls did all their homework and maintained a 3.5GPA or higher (most more like 3.8+), while probably half or more of the smart boys skipped lots of it and pulled Cs and Bs (with the occasional A in classes that had little homework). Meanwhile, those same boys who skipped much of their homework scored in the top percentile or two when it came time for ACTs and SATs and achieved excellent marks on annual state testing (not that the latter matters whatsoever for students), were often in gifted programs or active on "smart kid" extracurriculars, et c. So those boys "did poorly in school" (which, to be sure, wasn't a great thing for e.g. college admissions above high-tier state schools) but that didn't give the full picture.
- tester756 6y agoIt seems to confirm my experience over whole education
- bpodgursky 6y agoI don't know if this is a good faith question, but the big obvious reason you've omitted is that women frequently drop out of the work force (or shift to part-time work) because they want to be directly involved in raising their children.
- amanaplanacanal 6y agoSocietal expectations that women do child rearing rather than men probably has some impact on that decision.
- kube-system 6y agoThere are other familial factors that are often at play. For example, many choose to delay their careers in lieu of raising children. Not all women make this decision, but a sizable number do. That said, there is likely no single cause for the disparity, there are likely many factors at play at the same time.
- MattGaiser 6y agoDepends on how you define top tier jobs. They are solidly in the majority of students in medicine, law, accounting, etc.
- micdr0p 6y agoA suggestion from the article: > What is behind this discrimination? One possibility is that teachers mark up students who are polite, eager and stay out of fights, all attributes that are more common among girls. In some countries, academic points can even be docked for bad behaviour. Another is that women, who make up eight out of ten primary-school teachers and nearly seven in ten lower-secondary teachers, favour their own sex, just as male bosses have been shown to favour male underlings. In a few places sexism is enshrined in law: Singapore still canes boys, while sparing girls the rod.
- carnagecity786 6y agoI guess it also has to do with the fact that this is a relatively recent change. Probably we'll see the effects of this in future generations of industry demographics, for now though the research and statistics are pretty clear in that women are underrepresented in STEM across the board; but this is something changing rapidly, especially in tech.
- marklubi 6y agoPerhaps a fourth explanation... The vast majority of teachers are female, so maybe their teaching methods are favorable to girls
- endisneigh 6y agoI suppose this is possible - how exactly do you think teaching methods are more favorable to girls compared to boys?
- esja 6y agoA great deal of teaching is built around the idea of students sitting still in one place for a long period of time, listening intently and working quietly. Boys seem to have a lot more difficulty with this (on average) than girls do. That's one example but there are plenty of others.
- endisneigh 6y agoyes I would agree that boys have trouble with this, as that's what the featured article effectively states. however, saying that the methods themselves somehow are predisposed to benefit women is one that I'd like to see research on.
- esja 6y agoHow can they not benefit women? The article is about the relative performance of men and women, and this factor reduces the performance of men.
- endisneigh 6y agoYou're stating that there exists teaching methods that somehow benefit women, and not men as a function of their gender. That's an extraordinary claim and requires evidence. You can't assert your claim is true and look at the article to justify the original claim that you're asserting to begin with.
- hddu 6y agoTop tier jobs are subjective. Women have less interest in engineering.
- cobraetor 6y agoThis shouldn't be a controversial take. It is Occam's razor after all. We know that before the tech industry became popular and a way to make good money, women displayed little to no interest in being associated with programming "nerds" which were predominantly men to the extent that men over-represented the group of socially outcast nerds. This was mostly an American phenomenon, and other countries did not share this social hierarchy, hence the data on girls performing better academically outside of the US.
- throwaway3699 6y ago> women displayed little to no interest in being associated with programming "nerds" which were predominantly men to the extent that men over-represented the group of socially outcast nerds When did this change? I either missed it or this was always an exaggeration in media.
- bluescrn 6y agoI think attitudes changed a lot in the late 90s/early 00s. The Internet suddenly became a big thing, PCs massively growing in popularity, and the image of gaming was changing, becoming a less nerdy pastime with the arrival of the Playstation. Not really sure if it encouraged a more diverse set of youngsters to develop a serious interest in computing though, as by then we'd already got to the point where 'learning to use a computer' now meant Word+Excel rather than BASIC or LOGO
- disgrunt 6y agoOr possibly, academia and the general workforce optimize for different things not included in your list? Does anyone here think their academic experience was a direct analog for their workforce experience?
- proc0 6y ago> women have no interest in money, academic skills have no bearing in getting high paying jobs Correct. I've yet to impress with my math skills, just saying.
- Rabei 6y agoWomen face a tradeoff in their relation to their careers and pregnancies that men do not. Even in the countries where child bearing is highly protected in the workplace i would suppose this can explain at a significant chunk of the gap.
- kashkhan 6y agoor this is the cumulative effect of systematic discrimination for decades and centuries.
- CydeWeys 6y agoThis is the right answer, certainly a larger factor than anything else being discussed here. In the US, women were only granted the right to vote a century ago, and a time when it was considered improper for well-to-do women to work is within the memory of many living Americans.
- wing-_-nuts 6y agoI'm not denying it's true, but I have little patience for this argument because we can't actually do anything about it. Injustice today? Yes, we should absolutely stop that where ever we find it, but what am I supposed to do today about the fact that women could not vote in 1920? Words are cheap, actions matter. I'd much rather focus on current discrimination than dig up injustices from the past.
- oh_sigh 6y agoOr, people pursue their passions as young people without much regard for what a professional career would look like. I fiddled with programming and computers as a young teen because I found it interesting, not because I thought I could eventually make money with it. My good friend wrote fantasy stories all the time, because that was her interest. 20 years later, I can retire whenever I want because of the choices I made as a nerdy 13 year old, whereas my friend is getting paid $40k/yr editing a small newspaper.
- iagovar 6y agoHaving Babies. Really, being a mother is what skews most stats about women on money issues. There has been policymaking about this in a bunch of european countries, and if they are released from financial constrains (handouts, public housing, whatever) they seem to double down on it. Let's face it, working, for most people, is something you do out of necessity. Why do we really expect women to have a similar behaviour of men about work, when they have a socially aceptable and now economical venue to avoid it. There's probably a small percentage of men that find their work interesting. Even smaller for all their work life. Edit: Please, yeah, I know that raising children is work, pardon my lightly written comment.
- aklemm 6y agoHaving babies and raising them fully--especially doing it well--is not avoiding work.
- throwaway0a5e 6y ago>Having babies and raising them fully--especially doing it well--is not avoiding work. It was pretty obvious from the context that the person you're replying to meant "working" as in "working a job for money".
- iagovar 6y agoYou're right, but you ain't making the big bucks. Even then, they seem to find it rewarding enough. If I was woman and I decided to have baby, I'd probably be either very stressed with my current job, or looking for something part time. Now imagine if I live in Sweden or the like where the state hands out money for raising children.
- kache_ 6y agoMost of my money is attributable to my negotiation skills and assertiveness, rather than my programming skill that I bent over backwards to develop.
- ImprovedSilence 6y agoI would agree with this. However Ive seen very assertive women take advantage of that as much as men or even more, and where I work its probably <10% of my co workers of either sex take active roles in “managing” their career as opposed to just showing up and hoping their work gets noticed, or just coasting and enjoying the paycheck they have (while still grumbling about fading benefits, of course)
- burlesona 6y agoI don’t know how true this is, but one thing I’ve seen referenced a few times is that students perform better under teachers of their gender, especially at younger ages. It wouldn’t be hard to imagine the same applies for employee performance in the workplace. If that were true, given that K-12 teachers are overwhelmingly female, then you would expect females to do better in school. Conversely I believe managerial jobs skew male, which you would expect to benefit the performance of males in such workplaces. Again I don’t have a study handy so I’m not sure how empirical that is, it may just be conjecture.
- barbacoa 6y agoI don't understand why people ignore the role children play in the life ambitions of women.
- 29athrowaway 6y agoIn part, because salary has to do with agreeableness and many cultures have stupid expectations for women such as them expected to be more agreeable. Also, the likelihood of career advancement is lower for people perceived as being more neurotic, and many cultures have stereotypes consisting of women being more neurotic than men.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dekhn 6y agoIn many subfields of biology, women have achieved numerical parity at all levels (IE, there are roughly 50% women in entry and leadership positions). It seems like some highly quantitative fields which have traditionally been male-dominated (CS, physics) may very well be practicing some sort of entry discrimination. It's unclear what the full set of contributing factors are.
- MattGaiser 6y agoYou also can’t have mathematical equality with some fields dominated by women, like nursing. If every field is 50% or better in women, you need a heck of a lot more women.
- esja 6y agoThis is often forgotten. In aggregate, for every woman persuaded to become a bricklayer instead of a kindergarten teacher, a man must be persuaded to do the reverse. This is just never going to happen across all industries.
- Robotbeat 6y agoUnless you just have a lot of incarcerated and jobless men.
- rajin444 6y agoHow do you know 50% is the correct amount of women at all levels?
- pseudalopex 6y agoThey didn't say it is.
- rajin444 6y ago> It seems like some highly quantitative fields which have traditionally been male-dominated (CS, physics) may very well be practicing some sort of entry discrimination Maybe I misread, but I interpreted this follow up statement as "50% is correct, here's why (CS, physics) may not be at this level".
- TimPC 6y agoNo interest in money is an extreme position to take. Small differences in interest can lead to big differences in outcome. There is also some time lag with this data, studies have shown boys doing worse academically over time (relative to girls) so the age group in 2015 is largely in school, university, or just entering the workforce. Women in their 20's already outperform men in their 20's in earnings and we don't yet know if that trend is going to carry on into later years given new ability gaps. It hasn't carried on historically due to a wide variety of reasons including the adverse affects of maternity leave on careers but we haven't seen an academic gap of this magnitude between the genders either before so that may be changing. It's also worth noting that a lot of top earning careers are looking at a slice of top performers academically, and the distribution of academic performance for males tends to be higher variance so even with a lower average we may see similar numbers of top performers in both genders.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cphajduk 6y agoI'd like to point out that the workplace values are different from academics values. The top performers in my college class, struggled to get internships within my internship-mandatory program.
- itronitron 6y agoPerforming well academically usually means that the student is good at at completing assignments in a way that aligns with the teachers grading rubric. I think boys have a certain contempt for that for a variety of reasons (at least mine do) so they focus their attention on how to work around the system, which probably yields an advantage later in the workplace.
- visarga 6y agoLike when you solve the arithmetic problem with algebra and the teacher says it's wrong because you didn't use the official method?
- tester756 6y agoon the test that's testing whether you're proficent with _official method_? or maybe because your _official method_ was "under some assumptions" or "by guessing that" I've heard that complain countless times from friends and I think always the reason was that it wasn't formally correct.
- ZephyrBlu 6y agoWhy do you need to use a specific method to solve a problem? Especially with something broad like algebra, there are often many ways to solve a problem.
- tester756 6y agoBecause teacher on previous lesson tried to teach the class e.g about using derivatives to find extremas, and now he's testing whether you managed to learn it. his job is mainly to teach you stuff. Of course there are also tests where you can use anything you want as long as it is formally correct e.g leaving school exams, end of semester exams and many more... It's not the greatest approach but I guess it scales?
- 6y ago
- paperwasp42 6y agoThere's also the major factor of children. Women get a lot of scolding from society if they prioritize their career over children. Men generally aren't shamed to such a degree, and workaholic dads are even lauded as being "diligent bread winners." Also, for many moms, working late in the office isn't even an option. They have to leave the office before day care closes. Or, in the case of women who can't afford day care, they have to take inferior job offers with inferior hours to work around their kids' school and care schedule. These things can make it extremely hard to be viewed as "managerial material" and rack up promotions. (Of course, dads face these issues too, and single dads have it especially hard. But it's statistically more likely to impact moms.) Also, men just aren't as concerned over how much their significant other makes. Women, on the other hand, tend to more heavily judge the worthiness of a date on their career and income. So there's more incentive for men to chase after high paying, high power careers.
- SkyBelow 6y agoAnother reason people don't often take into account is that men have an extra incentive for earning more money as their worth as a person is judged more upon what they make than it is for a woman (women have other things they are judged more upon). So each dollar, beyond the utility of having an extra dollar, also makes them 'more of a man' to use a phrase that tries to condense all of complexities of society's judgements down into 10 letters. Many of the explanations commonly given, like men being willing to take on more dangerous jobs, can be partly explained by their judgment as a person (and as a parent) being derived from what they make to a stronger extent than for a woman. >women have no interest in money Just to clarify, there is a difference between no interest and less interest, and also a difference between interest in money and interest in the status associated with a certain level of salary/income beyond what comes just from the money earned.
- neffy 6y agoLags in real time systems. To get into high paying jobs in most fields requires a 20-30 year apprenticeship. So if by 2015 girls are performing better academically, then the expected time to see this in society would be 2035 or so. Just as with universal education, it starts to be available from the early 20th century, but it's not until post-war that large numbers of men from previously uneducated families start making it into the skilled workforce. Our limited view at any given point is just a snapshot on eternity.
- cperciva 6y agoThere are couple more explanations which haven't been mentioned: 1. Time lag. Girls have only been exceeding boys' academic success for 20-30 years; in most fields the top tier of jobs is filled by people in their 50s and 60s, who were educated at a time when girls were underperforming academically. This hypothesis is supported by statistics showing that among childfree adults aged 20-39, women significantly out-earn men. 2. Grading bias. To the extent that success in the workforce correlates with academic success, one would expect it to correlate primarily with the extent of skills and knowledge acquired rather than with the grades received; it may be that girls' academic success does not reflect particularly greater academic skills. This hypothesis is supported by studies comparing coursework to exams; girls vastly outperform on homework but only very slightly on exams.
- collias 6y agoSource for the stats in #1?
- xyzelement 6y agoSomeone commented that it's about "babies" and that's so incredibly right. But I think it's more benign than it may sound. We're seeing this right now in my family as we have a young child. Both my wife and I are in demanding STEM fields (me in tech and she in medicine.) My wife is seeing an opportunity to cut back on her hours/pressure so she can spend more time with the baby. She's not "forced" to do it (plenty of women w. kids do her current job) but that's where her heart is leading her and we're lucky to be able to make this tradeoff. I do think think this is a pretty universal thing. In two income families, if one parent wants to step back to do more family stuff, it's much more likely to the the woman who wants to do that. Similarly if one parent is much more naturally inclined to go conquer the work world, it's the father. There are plenty of cases where that goes the other way but I think that is way less common. To be clear, it's not about the work place being hostile to women, it's not about "I wear the pants around here so you stay home w the babies" - it's about where our natural interests lie and how we act on them when we have a choice. Which to me sounds fine even if the outcome of it can be read as systemic imbalance.
- Hermel 6y agoMaybe the most talented women prefer pursuing a career academics over one in the real sector?
- cullinap 6y agoI don't if we can conclude that top academic performance directly results in high performers in top tier jobs
- tomjen3 6y agoI think Jordan Peterson is correct on that one: the real question isn't why women don't go after those kinds of jobs, but why anybody is willing to work so hard and to give up so much for incomes that allow a marginally better life (e.g going from 40k a year to 100k a year is a huge improvement, going from 200k to 300k?). Also, for women anyway, the kind of work it takes to get to the top effectively means they aren't going to be having babies. A man aged 45 can marry a women aged 30 and become a dad - women who marry younger men aren't more likely to have kids because of it and at 45 it is unlikely for a woman to have kids at all.
- jhatemyjob 6y agoI wish I had the option of being a stay at home dad. Fuck working
- xenihn 6y ago>academic skills have no bearing in getting high paying jobs This is a big part of it. Let's look at what "academic skills" means specifically in the US: - you perform well on standardized tests - you perform well on rubric-graded essays - you do all of your homework, and you get As on every assignment this leads to: - you get into a good university - you (presumably) perform adequately or well at said university Every student who performs well academically has a similar path to this point, but then there's divergency. Tech is the only top tier job where your educational pedigree is not going to hold you back throughout your entire career. It's not going to hurt to have a degree from a top school, but it won't cripple your opportunities, unlike finance, law, and medicine. Based on how top tier tech companies hire for engineering positions that aren't internships, it seems that they do not see a link between academic performance and engineering competency. I agree with the approach taken by said companies. Thus (imo) for tech, it is fully expected for there to be no correlation between academic performance and representation in the top tier of jobs, because tech is the most meritocratic top tier industry. It's obviously not perfect, but it's leagues ahead of the other big industries.
- dijit 6y agoMen are over represented at the top _and_ at the bottom. So the average may be higher for girls, but that’s across all girls. This is what the bell curves are and a result of men’s being very wide and girls’ being very narrow. This is known as the variability hypothesis. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Variability_hypothesis?wprov=sfti1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Variability_hypothesis?wprov=s...
- drdec 6y agoNow consider the fact that there is a limit on the top grade and much more more at the bottom of the grading scale. If you assume the variability hypothesis is true, it seems inevitable that the average for girls would be higher.
- SamReidHughes 6y agoTop tier jobs need to use top tier statistics. The top 10% of male test-takers and top 6% of female test-takers score at least 700 on the math SAT. Over twice as many boys as girls get 800 on the math SAT. The ratio gets even higher beyond that. This is despite the systemic bias in the school system against boys.
- albntomat0 6y agoThat's an interesting statistic. Do you have a source? I'd be interested in learning more
- SamReidHughes 6y agoThe first is from a table of percentiles published by the College Board, I remembered that statistic off-hand, I think you find it by googling, or on their website. The second is something you can find somewhere, I know I've seen the raw data at some point. Some googling will at least find articles referring to that ratio, like this one: https://economics.mit.edu/files/7598 https://economics.mit.edu/files/7598 Interestingly enough, that has a graph of the AMC math contest breakdown by sex. Check out page 7 (page number 115). When you start getting in the upper percentiles there I think that culture might magnify the male/female ratio a bit (this is based on personal experience), but at least in my high school the center mass of the scores up to 100+ or so was filled out by teachers just signing up a bunch of good students with no particular involvement in mathematical extracurriculars.
- throwaway3699 6y agoIsn't this the standard bimodal distribution we expect? Boys make up the majority of CEOs but they also make up the vast majority of criminals. Median girls are smarter than median boys, but the distribution is less wide on a population level.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- P_I_Staker 6y agoMany of the above are true. Especially, academic skill is one of the most overrated abilities out there. You're better off with zero skill or being actively harmful, if you know how to play the game and have the right face (I don't mean literally, though sometimes that too. Do you say the right things and have the correct manners?) I'd add that most men really don't have the opportunity to be a homemaker. So most men don't even have the option of ruining their career to take care of kids. It might be seen as "okay" for men to be stay at home dads, but I know all it's going to do is be devastating for my social status. It's actually interesting to talk about because technically these things are true for women too, but we have a whole industry and philosophy around motherhood; it's seen as a more important role than fatherhood. I'm a guy that doesn't really care about money and it hasn't occurred to me to try being a full time father. It might be the better fit for me, but I don't see that as even an option. I'd be worried that I'd be judged as unuseful and unattractive, discarded, and left without any compensation (alimony, child support, ect.) or say in anything. We need to be doing way more to soften the blow of parenthood for anyone. I also think we need some kind of way of honoring fatherhood, as we've done for motherhood, or to do so in a non-gendered way. It's not just about women not taking jobs that result in less pay, it's men refusing to take jobs (parenthood) that are harmful to their career, because their career is all they have.
- BurningFrog 6y ago> Either women have no interest in money This is close, but too strong. You only need women to have less interest in money than men to cause a difference. A likely cause of such a difference is that men with high income and prestigious careers are very popular as romantic partners for women. To spell it out, women in high paying jobs get a lot of money. Men in high paying jobs get a lot of money and improved romantic success.
- qu4ku 6y agoThey choose not optimal collage majors is one of the answers: http://www.randalolson.com/2014/06/25/average-iq-of-students-by-college-major-and-gender-ratio/ http://www.randalolson.com/2014/06/25/average-iq-of-students...
- ThrustVectoring 6y agoTournament theory - top tier jobs (particularly executive ones) are a competition where rank-ordering contestants is relatively easy, but quantifying performance is hard. So one solution is to give the winner a big prize, the losers a smaller consolation prize, and if you ignore risk-aversion this is as economically efficient in terms of incentives as paying for piece-work. The problem is that people are risk adverse, and have varying levels of commitment towards continuing to winning the tournament. This variation has a gender skew, too, which IMO does a lot to explain much of gender disparity in multiple fields. FWIW I count software development in here, as tournament theory explains both developer wages, the number of unqualified applicants, and the gender disparity.
- 908B64B197 6y agoA lot of literature seems to focus around the gap being mostly that girls - Behave better (lower energy and "disruptive behavior" in school) - Are better at following instructions These two traits, while rewarded in the school system, are not really relevant at the top tier of jobs. There's no instructions to follow when you are building the next Google: nobody did it before you.
- agumonkey 6y agoPsychology. Few years ago at a meeting (carbon emission reduction association) it was asked for the people in the room to send proposals / ideas on a google forms. After 5 minute the guy in charge of the meeting started to cough saying 'ok we found a few things we could do but we have a problem because there is not a single lady in the list'. We were all newcomers, all unknown to each others, the tone was as chill as any meetup I've attended (no male dominated topic, no a-priori tribes or groups to scare new people from joining). My only idea so far is that women and men have different instincts on how to come forward with their ideas/desires.
- frongpik 6y agoAcademic grades measure skills that are only applicable at entry level jobs that are about following simple known rules. I knew many female students in school and college that got top marks on every subject, and yet they were mediocre in real life and never achieved much 10 years after graduation. I think that's precisely because their patience to follow silly rules didn't help them to compete in the world where there are no rules. On the other hand, I also knew many guys from the same classes who absolutely sucked at every subject except one or two where they shined and they have made impressive careers.
- PunchTornado 6y agoOr, another question, why don't we, as a society, help boys perform as well as girls.
- chlodwig 6y agoHow is it possible that girls perform better academically (in 2015) yet are under represented in the top tier of jobs? I'd argue mostly for 1) and 2). Here is my model: 1. Men have higher variance on any skill, even if men and women have the same average level, men will outnumber women at the highest and lowest levels by 2 or 3 to 1. 2. The median girl is much more likely to do her busy work because her teacher tells her to. Boys are more likely to do some bit of work only because they see some advantage to themselves. Boys are more likely to do unassigned work if they see some sort of long-term advantage to it (eg, learning programming on the side). The boy of 40th percentile aptitude, who knows he will never have a job doing math, isn't going to try that hard at his math homework. But that same boy might tinker with his car on the side and become a great mechanic. When we reach the real world, males are finally doing work that has a pay-off, not just busy work. So they actually start trying hard, as compared to schoolwork where the median girl does more homework than the median boy. The median girl works harder than the median boy at busywork. But when we reach the real world, the top man in a given career path is working just as hard as the top woman, and because of higher male variance, there are more men of top abilities that get the top positions. On top of that, in my experience, women do make different choices with career paths. Men do seem to seek career paths that pay well, women often want to go into "non-profits" and areas with a "social mission." It's interesting how we moved toward an expectation that women work instead of staying home -- but we taught girls that the purpose of work is "self-actualization", while more men still have the expectation that they are to find a job that can support a family. (These are gross generalizations, and broad trends I have observed, obviously, many exceptions exist). And as others pointed out, many women, correctly IMO, would much rather stay home with their babies or take a "mommy track" job than take a high-powered career path.
- B-Con 6y agoI'd like to see data on academic performance in specialties. Most well-paying first world countries employ specialists (eg, doctors, programmers, lawyers, accountants, etc). Recall Simpson's paradox in statistics, where a general distribution doesn't have to apply to the individual sub-sets. FTA: > Women who go to university are more likely than their male peers to graduate, and typically get better grades. But men and women tend to study different subjects, with many women choosing courses in education, health, arts and the humanities, whereas men take up computing, engineering and the exact sciences. In mathematics women are drawing level; in the life sciences, social sciences, business and law they have moved ahead. This paragraph seems to support the idea of my above musing. > academic skills have no bearing in getting high paying jobs I highly doubt that there is no correlation, but I doubt that education is the sole factor. Girls performance over boys is a slight, but significant, edge, but since success likely draws from a handful of other factors, a few of them having a counter slight, but significant edge, might be enough to swing the other direction.
- inglor_cz 6y agoI decided to underrepresent myself in the top tier of jobs because I do not want to live a life of a workaholic. You won't get into the top tier by doing 40 hours of work weekly. Perhaps women have better work/life balance on average.
- 7_my_mind 6y agoWomen have different incentives. Having a career is not really necessary and the reasons to have one are different. Us men need to compete with each other to be the best providers. Women just need to pick one of us, and then their goal is to retain that man in their lives. Having a career does not factor much into that. Especially having a high stress career would maybe even hurt such goals. Some men and some women get so caught up spinning the hamster wheel, that they loose track of why they are spinning the wheel in the first place. But most of us in general are aware of the reasons.