23 ms·
Apple has threatened to remove Amphetamine from the App Store
- Shank 6y agoAs someone who depends on amphetamines to function daily, it’s disheartening to see their use further stigmatized. For many people like me, amphetamines help them live a normal life. The app isn’t called “meth” or “methamphetamine” and it’s not referring to a street drug. I’m saddened to see so many equating amphetamines to illicit drugs, when that’s simply not the full story. This perception is exactly what stops people from taking their medication when they should and balking at the idea of a medication being able to help them.
- jMyles 6y agoWhile I wholeheartedly agree with the thrust of your argument (particularly that stigmatization is detrimental)... > it’s not referring to a street drug. Amphetamine (and other amphetamines) are certainly available as 'street drugs'. The stigmatization of 'street drugs' (and generally, drug use as part of someone's self-directed diet) is also harmful.
- kortex 6y agoExactly. If you were to describe objectively to someone the properties of alcohol or tobacco without saying the name, people would be clamoring to crack down on the "epidemic" claiming thousands of lives and costing billions.
- croes 6y agoSo apps with the words pep or speed in the name are also inappropriate?
- jMyles 6y agoUhhh, no. I don't think this name, nor any name based on a psychoactive compound, is a bad or inappropriate name on that basis.
- anigbrowl 6y agoSpeed can refer to a drug, but it can refer to a lot of other things too; people will think very different things depending on whether they see the word next to a picture of pills or one of a running shoe. You surely know this already.
- adhder 6y agoExactly this! And yet again we see arrogant HNers bask in their own ignorance of anything outside of writing shitty web apps.
- casion 6y agoHah! I use methamphetamine (desoxyn) to function! Some irony there in complaining about the stigmatizing of a drug with high abuse potential then immediately stereotyping another.
- wittyreference 6y agoCocaine is also used as a medication. We use topical spray cocaine for anesthetizing the nasal cavity and pharynx before certain procedures. Just saying.
- 542458 6y agoAlso occasionally used in optometry (applied directly to the eyeball!) as either an anesthetic or diagnostic tool. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/3885453/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/3885453/
- paozac 6y agoThat's very silly. The times are ready for a new job title: software product namer, to make sure a name won't offend anyone or violate trademarks and store guidelines.
- happytoexplain 6y agoAvoiding offense while choosing product names is already a well developed and ubiquitous task, and has been for a very long time. It's a reasonable thing to want to do. But I understand the point you're trying to make.
- mhh__ 6y agoHonestly the real enemy (if people are genuinely offended I tend to side with them) is people being offended on behalf of other people.
- rxhernandez 6y agoThis kind of crap has been around long before people started caring about how marginalized people feel. Look no further than obscenity laws which have been in place a lot longer than this wave of empathy.
- happytoexplain 6y agoIn most cases where a group-defining parameter is simple, it's best to avoid classifying them as "the enemy".
- DoofusOfDeath 6y agoIt may be a little nastier than that. In some cases, they're selective about which groups will and will not be sheltered from offense. And they may refuse to admit that, let alone engage in a public, civil debate about their choices.
- pydry 6y agoYou're assuming that this is actually the reason. It smells to me like the real reason they kicked it off the platform has fuck all to do with the name, but feigning "wokeness" serves as a decent cover for a variety of evils.
- piker 6y agoSeems pretty clear.
- systemvoltage 6y agoI think finding molecular differences of amphetamine is missing the point. There is a lot of knee jerk reactions I see here. This is primarily an image thing for Apple. Personally, I think this is a bad name for an app of this sorts. Caffeine is good one, amphetamine is borderline.
- matsemann 6y ago> Be kind. Don't be snarky. Have curious conversation; don't cross-examine. Please don't fulminate. Please don't sneer, including at the rest of the community. From the guidelines linked at the bottom.
- systemvoltage 6y agoI am sorry. Thanks for the reminder, I edited it.
- epx 6y agoNext, some app named Nitrogen will be banned because it is related to explosives and therefore to terrorists.
- fishnchips 6y agoNitrogen is an element, and a very common one at that. Explosives are a fringe use case. Amphetamine on the other hand has only one very well defined use case. I get the reference to another similar app (Caffeine) but this is a step too far, indeed portraying a dangerous drug in a positive light.
- read_if_gay_ 6y agoIt's not portraying anything in a positive light. The fact that this is the name of the app implies no value judgement.
- Unklejoe 6y ago> Amphetamine on the other hand has only one very well defined use case. Are you referring to the widespread use of it as an ADHD medication for children all throughout the nation?
- fishnchips 6y agoApologies, where I come from this is not a common treatment for ADHD. I’m not a specialist but as a father of two lively boys I did my share of reading about diagnosing and treating ADHD in Europe.
- dekhn 6y agoVyvanse was approved in Europe ~5+ years ago and is a hugely successful and widely used product.
- DoofusOfDeath 6y agoI apologize if I'm misunderstanding your comment. But just to help others avoid confusion, ADHD isn't the same as being extra energetic.
- valuearb 6y agoWhere would developers be without Amphetamines? There is no way Zuckerberg hasn’t consumed a mountain of Adderal.
- trestenhortz 6y agoIncredibly insensitive product naming. I’m guessing the software authors don’t have children and don’t have multiple friends and family who’s lives have been destroyed by meth. Instead it’s just a bro having cool fun with words “hey keeps your computer awake! Get it? Ha! So clever!”
- ketamine__ 6y agoMaybe they have a child with ADHD whose life was saved by amphetamines?
- mhh__ 6y agoYour username has its uses too. Not bad for a night out although not really to my taste.
- ketamine__ 6y agoKetamine for treatment resistant depression. We've got to kick the mind expansion folks out though. They are going to ruin everything like Timothy Leary ruined LSD.
- DeafSquid 6y agoGo fuck yourself if you think you should be denying anyone from using a substance you yourself benefit from. Others benefit from it in different ways too.
- ketamine__ 6y agoSorry, but I can't support recreational use when I have a legitimate medical need. It makes the activism too complicated.
- bserge 6y agoI agree, but the problem is that one idiot overdoses on something and suddenly it's a big deal and it "needs to be banned". This mentality is just a$$-backwards. Use it for whatever you want, don't blame the drug if you suffer side effects.
- arghwhat 6y agoAmphetamine isn't exactly an innocent name. Of all the app takedowns that occur, this one seems pretty normal and actionable. It's important to remember that reviews are superficial, and passing review is not at all the same as being compliant with the terms. Compliance is the burden of the submitter. Now, that app store monopoly makes terms unfair and arbitrary is another discussion entirely.
- AlexandrB 6y agoThere are gambling games in the app store marketed to children. You can sink 10s of thousands of dollars into gatcha games and they make every effort to make it easy and desirable to do so. If Apple wants to be a moral arbiter I'm not sure why it doesn't have a problem with those and even highlights them as "featured" apps from time to time.
- arghwhat 6y agoThat there are other violations slipping through is not valid legal argument. That the priorities in the terms the developer is subject to does not match yours is not a valid legal argument. The app store monopoly should fall, but until then, you're subject to the terms unless you get it declared unenforceable by a court, or convince Apple to change them.
- crististm 6y agoI agree with most (actually all) of your conclusions but... They start with the premise of culpability of a name. Which _is_ the problem in the first place. That culpability was not demonstrated but was simply declared by remote association. The same arbitrary judgement can be made for an innumerable list of other words without making that judgement neither correct nor just.
- arghwhat 6y agoDirect association, not remote association. The name is an intentional reference to a hard drug. The name isn't related to the functionality, but that's not what is claimed. This restriction on drug references is spelled out in the terms, making it valid and non-arbitrary. That the terms themselves aren't "just" is a different matter altogether, but there is no argument for it but being valid.
- helsinki 6y agoIt’s a great app! I do tend to agree with them, as every time I looked in the corner of my screen, I was reminded of how much harder I could work if only I had some adderall.
- riffic 6y agoYou're not going to win against Apple. Change your app's name.
- valuearb 6y agoThere is still an appeals process, change it after you exhaust that.
- ganstyles 6y agoStrategically I would say don't bother, personally. Just change the name.
- valuearb 6y agoIt all depends on how much value the name has as a brand. If there are a ton of positive reviews and mentions of the app using that name, it’s not going to hurt to appeal. But if almost all of the materials referring to the app by that name are on your own web site, I agree with you, change it and move on. Use those efforts in better places.
- speedgoose 6y agoThe developer uses Github but I cannot see source code, only compiled binaries.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- yarcob 6y agoDeveloper probably has a private Github repo for source code and a public repo for things they want publicly accessible. It's funny that much of the public only associates Github with Open Source even though all their paying customers use it for closed source development...
- speedgoose 6y agoI also use Github for non open-source development at work. But I don't distribute binaries through git. That's weird.
- karlzt 6y agoIs not open source https://github.com/x74353/SaveAmphetamine/issues/1 https://github.com/x74353/SaveAmphetamine/issues/1
- nur12121 6y agoThis is the problem when we jump on the bandwagon to try and ban all words that may be offensive to a single person.
- aftergibson 6y agoBy this logic 1000s of Apps should be removed. Does Fruit Ninja glorify violence? It sounds like someone is trying to justify their job, can’t go after apps that impact Apple’s bottom line so chase apps like this. Huge fan of Amphetamine(the app) but its Apple’s walled garden. This nonsense is a consequence.
- alisonkisk 6y agoUnrralistic violence to vegetation is generally considered less abrasive than realistic violence to animals.
- oblio 6y agoAnd then there is realistic violence to humans but ain't nobody gonna ban popular FPSes :-)
- ganstyles 6y agoApple banned Fortnite.
- Orou 6y agoThat's true, but it had nothing to do with violence.
- AsyncAwait 6y agoNot because of violence btw.
- wruza 6y agoYou mean fearless bullet sponges that leak red liquid after health bar exhaustion and fall without screaming in pain, or for their lost friends, or without begging you to spare them with horrified eyes? It's less realistic than in hollywood movies. [Don't] watch real footage to compare. Realistic-enough violence games usually can't even make it to the market, except few nsfl/ryona self-publishing niches. Would you ever like to promote one to AAA-grade, honestly?
- exabrial 6y agoFor fucks sake apple. You build your products with questionable labor. Quit lecturing us.
- zepto 6y agoWhat are you talking about? The fact they have factories in china?
- dreamcompiler 6y agohttps://nlpc.org/2020/12/30/report-uighur-slaves-forced-to-work-in-apple-suppliers-factory/ https://nlpc.org/2020/12/30/report-uighur-slaves-forced-to-w...
- bdcravens 6y agoApple and many others: "In all, ASPI’s research has identified 82 foreign and Chinese companies potentially directly or indirectly benefiting from the use of Uyghur workers outside Xinjiang through abusive labour transfer programs as recently as 2019: Abercrombie & Fitch, Acer, Adidas, Alstom, Amazon, Apple, ASUS, BAIC Motor, Bestway, BMW, Bombardier, Bosch, BYD, Calvin Klein, Candy, Carter’s, Cerruti 1881, Changan Automobile, Cisco, CRRC, Dell, Electrolux, Fila, Founder Group, GAC Group (automobiles), Gap, Geely Auto, General Motors, Google, Goertek, H&M, Haier, Hart Schaffner Marx, Hisense, Hitachi, HP, HTC, Huawei, iFlyTek, Jack & Jones, Jaguar, Japan Display Inc., L.L.Bean, Lacoste, Land Rover, Lenovo, LG, Li-Ning, Mayor, Meizu, Mercedes-Benz, MG, Microsoft, Mitsubishi, Mitsumi, Nike, Nintendo, Nokia, Oculus, Oppo, Panasonic, Polo Ralph Lauren, Puma, SAIC Motor, Samsung, SGMW, Sharp, Siemens, Skechers, Sony, TDK, Tommy Hilfiger, Toshiba, Tsinghua Tongfang, Uniqlo, Victoria’s Secret, Vivo, Volkswagen, Xiaomi, Zara, Zegna, ZTE." https://www.aspi.org.au/report/uyghurs-sale https://www.aspi.org.au/report/uyghurs-sale
- ganstyles 6y agoI am mad at all of them for their labor practices. Even if I wasn't, one company doing something nefarious isn't vindicated because others are doing same.
- alanbradley 6y agoWhat about GTA lol
- mmaunder 6y agoYou’re angry. I’ve felt this in a trademark lawsuit. You think the world should get behind you and change the corrupt system. My advice is to immediately rebrand as gracefully and effectively as possible and use all that activist energy to effect the transition. They kind of have a point which doesn’t make them right, but they hold all the cards and you will lose this one and regret the wasted bandwidth.
- dstick 6y agoUnfortunately I concur, if this is your main thing. If you can outsource it: let the lawyers duke it out. If this feels personal: follow mmaunder’s advice. There are no winners in that scenario so just take back control.
- valuearb 6y agoI like “Up All Night” as a new name. Icon image could be people partying in their pajamas. While taking amphetamines.
- Hnrobert42 6y agoI wonder if that phrase is still protected by the USA network, for those of you old enough to remember when regular ol’ cable would show topless women. Now you can’t name an app Amphetamine. It is interesting to watch the pendulum swing.
- flurdy 6y agoInsomnia might already be another app but seems appropriate name.
- sschueller 6y agoNo, how will this ever fix a corrupt system if you play by their rules? This is why it keeps getting worse and worse. People just comply!
- hshshs2 6y agoThey’re a $2 trillion dollar company, unless you have an incredibly strong case (this isn’t one) then you will lose a war of attrition every time... even sometimes if you do have a strong case. Choose your battles wisely, live to fight another day, etc... Pound for pound you’d likely be better off putting your energy into policy. The scale is still tilted there, but there is some traction behind fairer app marketplaces.
- rgovostes 6y agoWell-written argument for the app reviewers to get bent, especially the highlighted examples of other apps that show the rule is clearly applied inconsistently. Apple's App Store moderation is embarrassing. They routinely fail to catch harmful junk—I've shut down a few top-grossing bogus antivirus apps for Mac, and the publisher of Untitled Goose Game routinely posts screenshots of clones that are trying to make money off confused users. They've banned apps like Phone Story and a drone strike tracker for being "objectionable and crude," yet they don't apply any content moderation to the Book Store or to Music or TV (or to Safari for that matter). They've yet to provide a cogent justification for why they're inconsistent on this.
- qppo 6y agoI don't necessarily agree that TV/Music/books need more moderation in terms of censorship (and they do have plenty of that), but more curation. Apple TV is a good example of that, it's highly curated. Books are really bad though. Amazon is no better, neither have any modicum of curation or taste when it comes to their bestsellers lists. The New York Times doesn't put salacious romance novels at the top no matter how many copies sell, yet Amazon and Apple Books would lead you to believe there's nothing else being published. The same goes for the App Store. It doesn't need moderation by way of censorship, it just needs tasteful, manual curation.
- rgovostes 6y agoI mean the opposite—not that they should censor/moderate their other stores, but why are they hypocritical (edit: or inconsistent, if you prefer) in saying that certain content is harmful when consumed as an app, but not as a book or movie that they are happy to sell to you?
- Bud 6y agoThat's not hypocritical; it's surprising you can't see that. An app is software that can be harmful to your device. Books and movies are not software and can't affect your device in any way. Therefore, there is a very obvious justification for disallowing some apps; that doesn't apply for books or movies. It's also not "hypocritical" for Apple to choose to have a curated App Store (which is feasible and realistic) but choose not to actively censor books (which isn't really feasible).
- albertgoeswoof 6y agoI don’t understand the rationale to remove the app. Are they selling drugs through it or committing a crime with prior precedent in a court of law or under legislation passed by an elected committee? If it’s just the name, how far does this go? Can I not name a band after a drug? Can I no longer write a book about drugs? What about a company? What if I’m a pharma company? Who is deciding these rules and how do we get rid of them?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- fitzroy 6y agoWait until Apple realizes that "Final Cut Pro" seems to promote irreversible self harm for profit.
- EricE 6y agoOr glorifies professional cocaine users :p
- __m 6y agoOh come on, you use it as a drug to let the Mac stay awake. Whether or not the guideline makes sense, you are obviously violating it, just change the name.
- burnthrow 6y agoWell, it's a play on Caffeine.app's name. I'll make an ever better Mac force-wake program called Crack Binge.app, anyone who dislikes this name is a puritan Apple sycophant.
- im3w1l 6y agoI agree with the author: if Apple wants to tighten up rules around drugs, they should have a grandfather clause for popular apps with an established brand.
- silentsea90 6y agoThe name was approved by Apple years ago. The developer built the brand on that name. What changed? Apple's policies (on their whims). If Apple has to come down hard, they should bear the cost of the re-branding at least to measurably communicating widely regarding the rename. It is sad that Apple exercises so much power callously.
- reaperducer 6y agoWhat changed? Apple's policies Companies change policies all the time. I get dozens of terms of service revision alerts in my e-mail each year. Same goes for government policies, and even personal policies. You wouldn't make decisions today based solely on things you thought ten years ago. Life changes. Policies change. Things change.
- unethical_ban 6y agoDoesn't make it right. I shouldn't be shocked to find some contrarian/nihilist defending EULAs and corporate bullshit on HN, but here we are.
- joseph_grobbles 6y ago"The name was approved by Apple years ago" This isn't going to be popular, however getting away with something for a period of time is not the same as being approved/sanctioned/etc. In the petition the author claimed that the app "spontaneously began violating" one of the guidelines, when clearly it has violated it all along. Yet that disingenuous angle is used constantly when people get away with something for a while and suddenly aren't. As an aside, it's interesting that anyone thinks that making a big noise about this will cause Apple to revert their stance (as app using a pill as their icon, naming it after a controlled substance, and using narrative like "the most awesome keep-awake"). That is improbable. It seems much more likely that Apple will be very certain this app is renamed, and the narrative changed.
- silentsea90 6y agoApple approved of the app. Hence the name was approved. Not sure what we mean by "getting away" here
- xwalltime 6y agoWell, this is pretty silly. Surely this won't last. I've only tried apps like Caffeine and Amphetamine a few times, but I never associated it with a bad thing. Also, why is Apple making a political statement that doctors should not prescribe Retalin or Adderall ? It doesn't seem like Apple's place to be making judgements on what medicines are good or bad. Would Apple ban an app called NyQuil that puts your computer to sleep when it gets hot?
- nodesocket 6y agoWould rebranding as Caffeine also be against terms of service?
- jimsmart 6y agoIt's a pre-existing competing(?) product. https://www.macupdate.com/app/mac/24120/caffeine https://www.macupdate.com/app/mac/24120/caffeine
- didibus 6y agoI wonder what's the rationale behind this policy. I can think of three reasons: 1) They are worried of bad PR from a headline being published that goes: "Apple encourages drug abuse with multiple apps such as Amphetamine". 2) They are worried of a lawsuit if it is found some app contributed to the sell of illegal drugs. 3) They are worried of parents complaints being concerned that they've found an app called Amphetamine on their kid's device. And in some way, I can agree that as a Company, I'd rather not take my chances with any of them. Now, the policy being applied inconsistently is another issue. And ya, I wish the world wasn't so that a company needed to worry about these, but it isn't, so I'm not sure I can blame Apple that much for it. This also seems like a silly cause for them to champion.
- xwalltime 6y agoI would agree, but I can't because Apple is a monopoly. If monopolies are allowed to exist then they must be required to reflect the principles of the governments in which they operate. If everyone could see this decision and easily move over their apps to 1 of 20 other iOS app markets then it might be reasonable for Apple to have self-determined restrictions in place.
- smarx007 6y agoMy manager (who uses Windows as a daily driver) overheard me recommending a colleague to install Amphetamine and gave me a very puzzled look. Another time I had to explain secops people why do I have an executable called "riot" on my machine (part of Apache Jena if you are curious). So I can imagine Apple just got tired replying to complaints (semiautomated?) from IT sec departments that Amphetamine has nothing to do with drugs and decided to force Amphetamine to rebrand instead. PS: I vote for Redeye as a new name (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red-eye_flight https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red-eye_flight, just as Amphetamine was used by pilots in the past https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_and_culture_of_substituted_amphetamines#Military_use https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_and_culture_of_substit...).
- teruakohatu 6y ago> secops people why do I have an executable called "riot" No doubt your secops are trying to justify their existence like app store reviewers if this is what worries them!
- rvz 6y agoSo with the way Apple is going with this, is Amphetamine's cousin 'Caffeinated' [0] going to be next? > A little taste of 'Caffeine'. This will prove to be a complete waste of time for Apple. [0] https://apps.apple.com/us/app/caffeinated-anti-sleep-app/id1362171212?mt=12 https://apps.apple.com/us/app/caffeinated-anti-sleep-app/id1...
- ktm5j 6y agoThey explicitly wrote "illegal drugs" in the policy, so no.
- thrower123 6y agoThe problem here is that there is a centralized app store that can gate your product. On Windows, you could just host the msi or exe on your website.
- jtdressel 6y agoThis is a Mac app, not iOS. This would be analogous to Microsoft kicking them off the windows app store. You could still download it manually.
- matsemann 6y agoFor now. The walls are getting higher on MacOS lately.
- appletrotter 6y agoOf course the same is true on mac, as well. Both OSs have stores, but allow sideloading.
- layoutIfNeeded 6y agoSurely there aren’t any songs or movies in Apple’s catalog that might be promoting drug use.
- ece 6y agoAnother day...
- cocaine 6y agoShockingly bad name.
- fortran77 6y agoIt's annoying, and unfair, but I'd take advantage of the "publicity" around this name change, and change it to "StimulusCheck" or something trendy, and move on with things.
- pengaru 6y agoMakes me wonder what proportion of Apple employees use Amphetamines regularly... Adderall is quite popular especially among techies.
- Ceezy 6y agoFirst I m just wondering why can't they change the name of their app... And eventually ask for help from Apple to reroute confused customers. Second apple is not responsible for your brand identity. A lot of people associate their brand with drugs. And it always come with drawbacks. Should the app store promote drugs? Would you want that on the mac of your children?
- leppr 6y agoCan we stop endlessly puting Apple's various authoritarians missteps under the spotlight? It's been literally decades now, we know they can and will do whatever they want in their walled garden. Stop giving them attention. Complaining clearly does not work, if you want to make a difference, change platforms. Nobody is forcing you to develop for Apple.
- dane-pgp 6y agoDo you similarly think that American newspapers should stop publishing articles about China's various authoritarian missteps? You could just ignore articles that don't interest you, and you certainly don't need to go to the trouble of commenting on them, although I support your efforts to encourage people to change platform (and reduce their customer base by half).
- reaperducer 6y agoAre you seriously equating a company choosing not to host an app with the genocidal policies of a communist government?
- dane-pgp 6y agoI'm not equating Apple's policies with China's, I'm just trying to understand if "Complaining clearly does not work" is a good enough justification for preventing people from learning about bad policies. Perhaps the argument is that people have a duty to learn about genocides going on in the world, whereas there is no moral imperative to learn about bad policies of tech companies, but by that logic nearly every discussion on this site should be removed.
- alisonkisk 6y agoHN is not a newspaper.
- DoofusOfDeath 6y agoApple is under heightened antitrust scrutiny IIUC, so it's plausible that past and current discussions were/are actually helpful. And fwiw, you're welcome to just ignore any threads or stories that you feel are getting repetitive. Many of us have a personal list of such topics, but our lists may not match.
- mwnivek 6y agoFYI, there is an open-source alternative with the less catchy but less controversial name, KeepingYouAwake. (Note that Amphetamine has more advanced features, if you need them.) https://github.com/newmarcel/KeepingYouAwake https://github.com/newmarcel/KeepingYouAwake
- lstamour 6y agoYou can also just use the built-in Terminal app and run the built-in executable named “caffeinate”, it’s free and provided by Apple: https://ss64.com/osx/caffeinate.html https://ss64.com/osx/caffeinate.html While the command has a few options, just typing the word at the terminal and hitting enter will stop your Mac from going to sleep, etc. A long time ago I worked for a company that had a terrible policy for inactivity screen lock that kept interfering with my ability to get work done, and the caffeinate command helped me prevent screen lock when I needed it to.
- TakuYam 6y agoIt sucks and Apple is really over protective with this stuff so just change the name. If you’re feeling brave/stupid, try calling it something like Khat. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Khat https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Khat
- trynewideas 6y agoThe iPhone X, also known as the iPhone XTC, iPhone Adam, iPhone E, iPhone Molly
- reaperducer 6y agoI suggest changing the name to "Speed Apple." That way you can take a slam at Apple, and use an icon of poop, because in some western states "speed apple" is slang for quadruped manure on the road. See also: "Speed goat" which is another word for "antelope." (Yes, I'm mostly joking. Just change the name.)
- avipars 6y agochange the name
- cmckn 6y agoI don’t think Apple has a strong argument, given the feature set of the app, but I also think the name is kind of tacky/in poor taste. I used an identical app for years called Caffeine. Yes, Apple should buzz off, but choose your battles.
- reaperducer 6y agoI also think the name is kind of tacky/in poor taste. I agree. When I turned my wife's old MacBook into a media server, I needed an app like this. I chose one that didn't share its name with controlled substance. Branding 101. Play stupid games, win stupid prizes.
- Eric_WVGG 6y agoBack in the very early days of the App Store, I got contacted by Apple regarding the submission of my app “!@#?!% Allergies”, as they believed the name may lead users to think their iPhone Springboard app was buggy :(
- zabzonk 6y agoThere is obviously a range of names of drugs and chemicals from Aspirin to ZyclonB that could be considered harmful and/or offensive. But I personally would not use any of them as a name for a software product, if only to avoid confusion.
- floatingatoll 6y agoI couldn’t have guessed the purpose of the app from this name, and now that I know what it does, I would specifically avoid giving money to it due the name alone. I’m glad someone made an alternative to Caffeine.app but “they’re both drugs” doesn’t weaken my personal objection to the choice of name. I am glad that Apple is compelling the name to be changed, and I hope the author complies. This is where “universal freedom” clashes directly with “common sense for a department store” for me, and while I understand others aren’t on my side, I prefer department stores to flea markets.
- matsemann 6y agoWhy should your "personal objection" be a reason for someone else to change? You do you and choose an app based on naming if you want, but don't go pushing your puritan views on everyone else.
- floatingatoll 6y agoMy personal objection is shared by others, unpalatable as that may be to some. Thankfully, my celebration of this outcome is wholly irrelevant to Apple's decision-making process, as I neither work for Apple, influence Apple, nor participate in any app store review processes on behalf of Apple, or any other either. So you may take comfort that had I exerted any effort to push my view — which I haven't — it would have meant just as much to the outcome as our discussion here in this thread: Absolutely nothing whatsoever. Demeaning me with the phrase "pushing your puritan views" is is tasteless and inappropriate, and makes incorrect assumptions not only about the root of my objection but also about the belief systems surrounding it. You are wrong about both.
- jjcon 6y agoAs someone I guess not in the loop with the latest in outrage culture... what exactly is offensive about the name?
- floatingatoll 6y agoMy issues with it stem from something unpublished in the late 90s, which is not something 'dismissable' that you can simply set aside using the negation-by-framing of 'outrage culture', so I can't offer any reply to your question. Please accept my apologies for how far off the mark my reasons are from your assumptions; perhaps another time we'll be better aligned.
- marmaduke 6y agoI don’t use this and don’t care. But I can imagine my kids asking, what are amphetamines, why is it named that way, did you ever try them, what is it like. Just like you’d say to kids, you don’t ever need to take those pills, maybe you should use your energy to push Apple so that your app isn’t necessary? I certainly try to educate my kids such that they will not be in a position to need those meds. We like to think we own our hardware and make decisions about how it works and Apple sucks cuz they take away ownership, but cmon like you got to choose sensible defaults for your brain? “What’s in your .brainrc?” Random lines from your parents and friends at school, that’s what
- adhder 6y agoIf your kids asked you that, I hope you'd give a reasonable answer about these being prescribed medications for narcolepsy and ADHD, that much improve the quality of life for people afflicted with these conditions. Rather than ignorant shit like "you don't ever need to take those pills".
- marmaduke 6y agoSure if that was the case. How many abusers have you seen tho? Have you seen their MRIs after the damage?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- adhder 6y agoOf course it's the case, stop being so damn ignorant. People like you are the reason that taking ADHD medication is so stigmatized, because you assume the default is to abuse.
- tigen 6y agoI don't agree with Apple here but I also don't feel too outraged either, I can see both sides and it's their store. I actually think Windows/MacOS should build the most commonly used sleep-gating functionality into the OS. (On Windows there's Coffee and Milk, where Coffee helps you keep it awake and Milk helps you figure out why it doesn't sleep. Seems like basic modern OS stuff to me.)
- o_p 6y agoIts not just their store. Its my device and they are not letting me run a program in it by the dumbest reasons. We shouldnt normalize manufacturers censoring software arbitrarily.
- badwolf 6y agodoes the developer not let you download the app outside of the Mac App Store?
- webmobdev 6y agoIf you are not outraged, you aren't putting yourself in the author's shoe - they created an app that has been in the app store for 6 years. They marketed it and got a large number of users. And now suddenly Apple removes it because it doesn't like the name of the app. Do you want Apple to be the arbitrator of silly things like the name of the app or even your company?
- gregdoesit 6y agoLawyers will be lawyers. I assume this request from Apple’s side originates from on of the legal teams, who are paid to pre-emotive ensure Apple won’t be sued. I have a story that makes me relate from Microsoft/Skype. A few months after Microsoft acquired Skype, a JIRA ticket was opened by one of the compliance teams at Microsoft with a simple request. Remove the mooning emoji from Skype [1], as it could be considered offensive in some countries and thus Microsoft could be at risk of being sued. All of Skype erupted. The mooning icon was a symbol of playful cheekiness at Skype and has always been part of the app, and Skype never got sued for over 10 years. There were about 1,200 Skype engineers at the time and that ticket had more than 500 comments from engineers protesting this change. Some made good arguments. Some voiced frustration. Others called that this is a step towards censoring. It didn’t matter. The icon was removed, the ticket closed. In a similar vain, I’ll assume that not everyone at Apple will agree with this “violation”. But it won’t matter, as long as the legal teams says it’s a risk to have apps with such names and icons in Apple’s store. [1] https://www.google.com/search?q=mooning+skype https://www.google.com/search?q=mooning+skype
- throwaway09223 6y agoThis is a failure of management, as is your skype example. Balancing the risk of litigation against risk to the product is management's job. In both of these cases the risk is somewhere between minimal and non-existent. Big companies tend to have bad management. There are entire libraries of books analyzing why this is the case but the short story is "risk aversion." Employees are incentivized to save their own skin and avoid conflict at work over improving the product. Sometimes public outcry can create a new risk and change the direction of management.
- suchnonsense 6y agoSuch nonsense, balancing risk of litigation against the risk to the product isn't management's job. Companies have whole departments for this, called risk management with people specialized on the matter. This is not done by some random manager.
- 6y ago
- fossuser 6y agoWhat a dumb application of this rule in this context. I remember a similar app called caffeine (not sure what happened to it). Amphetamine is great - I use it daily to stop annoying infosec rules from locking my computer after 2min since I’m working from home. It’s my favorite kind of software, focuses on one issue and does it well.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- greggturkington 6y ago> Apple [...] featured Amphetamine in a Mac App Store Story Ouch > Customize Your Mac’s Sleep Settings > Amphetamine gives you granular control https://apps.apple.com/us/story/id1470456860 https://apps.apple.com/us/story/id1470456860
- urbandw311er 6y agoThis needs to be upvoted
- NeutronStar 6y agoThe amount of people complaining about the name while this being the top comment is absurd.
- wulfmann 6y agoinb4 Apple releases this feature natively...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- smashah 6y agoDespite the valid arguments on both sides, I fall on the side of this being stupid. Let them keep the name!
- blatherard 6y agoI thought I should look at the App Store and see what this app is doing in comparison to similar apps. The logo is basically a big pill and the tagline "Powerful keep-awake utility" which is clearly alluding to the drug. https://imgur.com/a/RJXHaBa https://imgur.com/a/RJXHaBa This was consistent with the feedback the author received: "[the] app appears to promote inappropriate use of controlled substances. Specifically, your app name and icon include references to controlled substances, pills" Almost all of the other top apps in the app store in the same category use some reference to caffeine either in the name or tagline or description (e.g. "Jolt of Caffeine" or "Owly" which has a logo of an owl in a cup of coffee) https://imgur.com/a/yySBqEL https://imgur.com/a/yySBqEL There's one other, much less popular app called "Coca" which appears to reference cocaine, but doesn't also have a drug-referencing icon or tagline, and which only has 15 reviews. By comparison, Amphetamine seems to be the most popular result, at least for the search term "awake", with 1.37K reviews The guideline in question doesn't seem to consider excessive use of caffeine as problematic to encourage. "1.4.3 Apps that encourage consumption of tobacco and vape products, illegal drugs, or excessive amounts of alcohol are not permitted on the App Store. Apps that encourage minors to consume any of these substances will be rejected. Facilitating the sale of marijuana, tobacco, or controlled substances (except for licensed pharmacies) isn’t allowed." Overall, Amphetamine did seem to be pushing the drug-use angle much harder than other apps in the category based on the logo, tagline and title, especially if you consider caffeine abuse not problematic. Added: I don't have a strong opinion on this one either way, other than edgy naming has pros and cons. Word of mouth is easier, but sometimes a problem like this happens.
- aardvarkr 6y ago"1.4.3 Apps that encourage consumption of tobacco and vape products, illegal drugs, or excessive amounts of alcohol are not permitted on the App Store. Apps that encourage minors to consume any of these substances will be rejected. Facilitating the sale of marijuana, tobacco, or controlled substances (except for licensed pharmacies) isn’t allowed." Taking this literally, is an amphetamine an illegal drug? It’s a class of Schedule II drugs that are legal in all 50 states.
- 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- florin0x01 6y agoTry HyperCaffeine or smth. Oh wait,the name is not as breathtaking as amphetamine.
- niekverw 6y agoCaffeinate is now a default preinatalled command, just saying..
- yarcob 6y agoThe hypocrisy is that Craig Federighi jokes about Marihuana all the time in Apple keynotes, but when a 3rd party developer does the same thing they ban it...
- teruakohatu 6y agoThey also publish TV shows with violence, bad language etc. That is OK but dare an app store developer make a joke....
- niekverw 6y agoCaffeinate is a default terminal command in Macos for a few years already, what's the purpose of caffeine and amphetamine? ..
- pvtmert 6y agoConvenience.
- danso 6y agoIn the U.S., caffeine is not a highly regulated substance. You can buy it without limits in concentrated pill form, or in coffee and cola. By contrast, amphetamine is regulated as a Schedule 2 controlled substance [0], i.e approved for medical use but considered to have "high potential for abuse". Opioids like fentanyl are also in Schedule 2. [0] https://www.deadiversion.usdoj.gov/schedules/ https://www.deadiversion.usdoj.gov/schedules/
- anewguy9000 6y agoWWJD
- eurasiantiger 6y agoThe post conflates methylphenidate-based stimulant medications (Concerta, Focalin, Ritalin, Metadate, Methylin) with true amphetamine-based medications (Adderall, Dexedrine). Related, the former are not amphetamine derivatives, which is a common misnomer.
- t-writescode 6y agoIt's so common of a misnomer, in fact, that I know what the app does!
- crazygringo 6y agoI mean, on this point I'm actually inclined to think Apple's general policy is reasonable, even if it sucks that Apple is only now adding or enforcing this rule. It doesn't want apps that jokingly call themselves "Crack Cocaine", "Crystal Meth", or "Mango Vape". It doesn't have anything to do with them actually promoting drug use, but it helps normalize illegal drug use in a way, while Apple wants to keep a "family friendly" approach to its App Store. Honestly, if I were the creator I'd just rebrand it. I remember coming across the app years ago, it wasn't obvious from the name what it did, and when I finally understood it, it just seemed like the creator was trying a little too hard to be "edgy". And if you want the widest possible usage/distribution of your app, "edgy" is usually not the way to go.
- lb504 6y agomacOS ships with a command line program called "caffeinate" that disables the sleep function of the laptop. With this background knowledge I was immediately able to assume Amphetamine is a more powerful program that provides the same results. With this background in mind I find the name to be clever.
- frombody 6y agoAnd if someone made yet an even more powerful program called cocaine, that would be okay too, because the name fits so well. right?
- lb504 6y agoThat's funny because Apple maintains Coca, which is the name of the plant source of Cocaine. The Coca plant is controlled/regulated by the DEA exactly like cocaine is. So by following Apple's example in Apple's ecosystem it is okay to name things directly after drugs.
- grzm 6y agoCocoa and coca are not the same. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cocoa_(API) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cocoa_(API)
- taylorlapeyre 6y ago... can't you just run `$ caffeinate -d` in terminal?
- hundchenkatze 6y ago...some people don't know how or even care to use the command line.
- blunte 6y agoPerhaps you can inform Apple that amphetamines are not necessarily illegal, and are in fact prescribed to treat many problems including narcolepsy.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- DeafSquid 6y agoWe all know Steve Jobs dropped acid. What's the big deal if an app is named after a prescription drug?
- yurielt 6y agoIt is truly amazing how some of the people in the comment section keep defending apple dishonest practices, almost like they are bots or something...
- joemi 6y agoI think it's pretty dismissive to presume or imply that comments you disagree with here must all be from bots. Edit: To expand, Apple inspires strong opinions in a lot of people. They have a lot of fans for various reasons, and a lot of detractors for various reasons. And then there's everyone in between those extremes too. It's to be expected that any comment thread about Apple will have a lot of opinions that you disagree with, no matter what your viewpoint is.
- o_p 6y agoDeveloping mobile apps sounds painful, imagine building an app and its userbase for many years and some faceless corp destroys all your work on a whim. Maybe web apps arent so bad
- umvi 6y agoChange the name to "Amph" and change the icon to remove pill. You can't fight Apple, they make and enforce all the rules. If you want to protest Apple, stop developing software for their platforms.
- andromeduck 6y agoNah rename it to modafinil
- twirlock 6y agoApple is wrong for switching up after six years, but stop trying to act like it's not a deliberately edgy reference to speed.
- jabbany 6y agoI have used this while using Macs before and it's a pretty good tool. The name also some what makes sense since it's a "stronger" variant of the past tool. What's really sad is why this kind of feature even needs to be implemented through a third-party application when it should really be handled on the OS side...
- Angostura 6y agoI can see how theoretically the app name could cement the idea of amphetamines being a useful tool for promoting wakefulness if you were a young person. Sensibilities about naming things do change over time - as various sports clubs have found. I'm sorry for the developer, but I can see why the guidelines might have been triggered.
- gayprogrammer 6y agoWhether the app name will be changed or not, I’m glad that this sort of thing doesn’t happen in silence or under NDA.
- ur-whale 6y agoJust give Apple time.
- excerionsforte 6y agoMight as well call it Poison Pill. What a waste of energy on Apple's part and a perfect grounds for a lawsuit. Apple approved this app with no problems and all of a sudden there is a problem where nothing has changed. Take them to court and dispute it. I assure you they will not be able to prove that this app violates the contract that was agreed to. What I see here as complacency on peoples' part here is ridiculous. Companies and people never stop until they are tested. Apple would have never made a small business contract for the app store had it not been for Epic's lawsuit. There even a comment below where Apple had no issues featuring the app: https://apps.apple.com/us/story/id1470456860 https://apps.apple.com/us/story/id1470456860 This is winnable in court. Settle for Apple paying for the cost of re-brand and lawyers if they do not want to continue the dispute in court.
- KingMachiavelli 6y agoIt is almost a certainty that the Apple's ToS mandates arbitration instead of a real court and definitely allows them to remove an app at any time for any reason. There is no reason for Apple to not CTA in their ToS since developers have no where else to go.
- meesles 6y agoWhat exactly is the dev supposed to sue for..? Apple has full control of their platform and can make any arbitrary calls. If they wanted to censor all pg-13 material tomorrow, they could (though they would face consumer backlash). One recent exception might be anti-competitive behaviors, but I don't think that applies here. I think it's just hard learning that when you build your business entirely on a platform or via another business, you are at the mercy of their whims unless you have the resources to extract yourself.
- judge2020 6y agoThere's a great talk titled "Lessons Learned from the App Store" by Phillip Shoemaker - https://youtu.be/tJeEuxn9mug https://youtu.be/tJeEuxn9mug One of the main points is that apple has a hierarchy of priorities for their App Store: protect Apple's brand, protect the customer, then make money (timestamp 5:08 in video). Apple probably got some complaints about the name of the program (probably 100 or less) and decided it wasn't worth the $0 it was making to leave it up.
- webmobdev 6y ago> and decided it wasn't worth the $0 it was making to leave it up. Then apparently they made a poor decision - the app apparently has been downloaded 500,000 times. That means it adds value to the users who use it, and that means it creates more value for Apple's platform. Apple shouldn't forget that developers add value to their platform, and moreover, with Apple charging them, they are also clients too!
- throwawaysea 6y agoWe really shouldn’t normalize the kind of thought control, censorship, and morality policing that underlies this Apple guideline. We need to break up and heavily regulate any company that is so powerful that there is effectively no choice but to cave to their demands. These companies, like with the Apple-Google App Store duopoly, are powerful enough such that even though they are technically private, their actions are as direct and impactful as the government enforcing such rules.
- lylo 6y agoInsomnimac. You’re welcome.
- spullara 6y agoJust change the name and move on. It is stupid to waste energy fighting it. How about Insomnia? Keepup? Stayup?
- hyperman1 6y agoThis is one more example of a pattern of abuse by the app stores of apple, google, and maybe even microsoft. Any app store vendor is the alpha and omega on its platform. Any app store has a monopoly on its walled garden. There are some good aspects like user protection against bad apps, but on the whole, is it worth the price. Main question now is how society should deal with this. Some ideas from the top of my head * One option is to simply break the monopoly. A platform could be obligated to implement a store API, and the default platform store should use that same API as any other. * Another option is a separation of duties. Just like lawmaker, judge and police can't be the same entity in a democracy, they could be split up in the app stores. * Maybe the safety of the user device can be guaranteed independently from the app store. If the OS enforced walls between apps are strong enough that malicious apps can always be removed and no data theft is possible, the damage done by bad app stores can be lowered?
- danso 6y agoFrom the writeup: > Argument #1: Amphetamine Does Not Promote the Use of Illegal Drugs or Facilitate the Sale of Controlled Substances > Amphetamine does not promote the use of illegal drugs. Not only that, Amphetamine does not promote the recreational use of legal/prescribed drugs. In the United States, amphetamine is prescribed by doctors to adults for narcolepsy and to children for ADHD... > ...Just like amphetamine (the organic compound) can be legally used to keep humans awake and attentive, Amphetamine (the app) can be legally used to keep your Mac awake." While "amphetamine" isn't itself an "illegal" drug, promoting the use of amphetamines for anything other than the FDA-approved indications (e.g. narcolepsy and ADHD) is something that can approach illegality [0]. For example, Pfizer and many other companies have had to pay billions to settle charges of promoting drugs for non-approved indications [1]. The author doesn't help his case when he asserts, "amphetamine can be legally used to keep humans awake and attentive". Yes, that's an effect of the drug, but it's only official legal uses are for treating narcolepsy and diagnosed ADHD. Adderall's manufacturer would get in big trouble if it started a campaign to convince doctors (who can basically prescribe for any reason they judge necessary) to get patients on Adderall for general boosting of performance and productivity. Of course, the author (I assume) isn't in the pocket of Big Pharma. it's also not a stretch to see how this falls afoul of Apple' policy against encouraging the illegal use of drugs, in that the application's very name creates an association between "Amphetamine" and "making your computer more productive". Alcohol isn't an illegal drug either, but as the author notes, Apple explicitly bans encouragement of "consumption of...excessive amounts of alcohol" – i.e. a harmful use of an otherwise legal drug. To use a hypothetical example, if a developer created an app that reduced screen glare and excessive contrast in UI elements, and then called it Fentanyl, I'd imagine Apple would have the same complaints as it does against Amphetamine, even though Fentanyl is a drug legally prescribed for severe chronic pain. [0] https://www.healthaffairs.org/do/10.1377/hblog20160719.055881/full/ https://www.healthaffairs.org/do/10.1377/hblog20160719.05588... [1] https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/justice-department-announces-largest-health-care-fraud-settlement-its-history https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/justice-department-announces-...
- tome 6y agoChange your apps name. Not that big of a deal.
- kepler1 6y agoEasy, adopt new name. iViagra(TM): Keeps your Mac up
- bluefox 6y agoThese things happen when you depend on a middleman to distribute your product.
- DarkmSparks 6y agorename it to ApplePhet
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- chiefalchemist 6y agoI want to suggest rebranding as Beige - the most harmless, boring, and forgettable "color" in the universe. But then even that would likely offend someone, somewhere, somehow. Maybe Apple should change their name? Given what apples did for Adam & Eve? Yes, words are important. But so is context and intention. If we keep eliminating words - removed from context and intent -then all we'll have left are emojis. Oh wait...nevermind. Botton line: Come on Apple, really? Of all the fights to fight in the world, this is a good one? Shame on you.
- adultSwim 6y agoI would change the name.
- skywhopper 6y agoInteresting. It's annoying that the review process is so inconsistent. But although the amphetamine-based drugs listed are legal, it would be illegal to prescribe for the purpose of "staying awake", so the implication of the app's name that an "amphetamine" is a safe and legal means to "stay awake" does probably violate the spirit of the rule.
- ineedasername 6y agoTrademark issues aside, I wonder if this would be a problem if the app was named Adderall.
- ineedasername 6y agoI wonder if app store moderation is run on a quota system. It would explain why we continuously have stories about app X getting banned under a very loose interpretation of a guideline if moderators are "poor performers" when they don't find offending apps.
- SCAQTony 6y agoPerhaps change one letter of the name to APPhetamine?
- bussetta 6y agoWould this have been OK if Apple acknowledged the popularity of the app and acknowledged pointing it out after 6 years?
- KingMachiavelli 6y agoThis is pure censorship and nothing but a ridiculous, culturally damaging move from Apple. Forcing developers to pick from particular, puritan subset of the human language and banning apps relating to whole segments of the human experience will do nothing but hamper creativity and expression. It is also extremely hypocritical, Apple distributes and profits from existing works of art that depict and describe drug use, among other topics, through Apple TV, iTunes, and Apple Music. Apple has no concerns with profiting from art after someone else approved it whether some other movie producer or record label. As long as some other large institution vouches for it then Apple will look the other way. But if every institution operated like Apple, most of the best works of literature, music, and film would never have been approved. Honestly, I can not fathom why so much open source and free content is produced for Apple's ecosystem. Everything from the desktop MacOS operating system to Apple's app store policies is counterproductive for developers and anyone who disagrees with Apple's rules. The opportunity of the App store makes sense for commercial and profit driven apps but there is no reason to give charity to the most valued company on the planet. Finally, I really doubt there is any legal ramification for Apple here. Apple can ban any app they want for any reason which is fine. I just think anyone starting to get into developing should consider anything but app development for this reason. If the product has to be an 'app' then try to make it a web app. Anything besides putting your life in Apple's hands.
- solidsnack9000 6y agoIt is bad for them to apply such a policy so inconsistently, to the point that it's subjectivity. It's also bad to name apps after drugs that are widely abused. It's just too extra. Call it something positive and pro-social like "matcha" or "oolong" or maybe "dark roast" or "espresso" or something.
- theelous3 6y agoCant help but feel some level of whatever that german word is for finding misery funny. Watching devs willingly deal with apple is like watching someone pay for the privilege of being oliver twist.
- Vaslo 6y agoJust change it to Cocaine. Problem solved!
- jimwalsh 6y agoSo OP created a product very similar to Caffeine, with an edgier name and now it's becoming an issue. Where I think you chose the name just to help get into a similar space as Caffeine in the first place.
- oauea 6y agoThe best thing to do is to let Apple remove the app. Do not rebrand it. Do not try to restore it. Eventually Apple will realize that their platform is worthless if they have no developers making apps for them.
- FrameworkFred 6y agoI don't have a dog in the fight since I'm no longer a Mac user and, when I was, I didn't use the app. But, when I read the name, it didn't register as offensive to me. Amphetamines are a class of drugs and there are both legal and illegal ones...it doesn't immediately equate in my mind to crystal meth. But it does immediately equate to "keeps you awake", which seems appropriate. It also seems a bit unfair after 6 years and 500k downloads. Had Apple made an issue of it originally, the author might have built all the goodwill and ratings with some other, more acceptable name. The internet is a pretty big place to have to launch a product. Picking a name that suggests a purpose seems like a big win to me and coming up with a string of words that won't offend someone is a pretty big challenge these days.
- kortex 6y agoWow, this whole thread has prompted me to get off mobile and onto a keyboard, because I have many thoughts on this matter. I have ADHD, delayed phase sleep disorder, a dual BS in chemistry and psychology, I have studied addiction and drug reform, and even worked on synthesizing phenethylamine derivatives. I have many thoughts. First, methamphetamine is not amphetamine. Meth belongs to the broad class of molecules properly known as "substituted amphetamines" or "phenethylamines." No one in-the-know refers to meth as "amphetamine" by itself, though some do broadly refer to assorted substituted amphetamines as "amphetamines" but this is pretty sloppy and if you want to refer to the class and "substituted amphetamines" is a mouthful, just use "phenethylamine" (PEA). The name, of course, one of the most clever elisions in chemistry, Alpha-Methyl-PHenyl-ETthylAMINE, refers to the methyl group alpha to (the 1st substituent on the carbon backbone) the amine. This makes PEAs structural analogs of dopamine (DA, aka 3,4-OH-PEA) and norepinephrine (NE, aka 3,4,β-OH-PEA), and their the ability to modulate DA/NE receptors is what gives PEAs their general stimulating properties. Meth-amphetamine has a methyl group on the amine. This seemingly small structural change makes a big difference pharmacologically. Methylation of amines makes drugs more fat-soluble, which makes them better at penetrating the blood-brain barrier and cellular membranes, while inhibiting its breakdown and clearance. This makes METH harder hitting, better at receptor binding, faster acting, and with far stronger effects than AMPH. Modelling addiction is tricky, but we can loosely approximate how strongly habit-forming a drug can be by multiplying the blood plasma curve by an exponential decay. The faster and higher a drug peaks, the more likely it will be addicting. METH's lipophilicity also means it tends to cause DA to leak into places it shouldn't, resulting in unwanted chemical side-reactions which can damage neurons and glia, making it more toxic than AMPH. (this is a huuuge oversimplification; there are reams of studies on the mechanism of METH toxicity, and yes the literature uses METH as the abbreviation, I'm not being dramatic by all-capsing it) Together, this makes METH much more dangerous than AMPH, and hence why AMPH and prodrugs such as Vyvanse (lysine-dexamphetamine) are commonly prescribed for ADHD, sleep disorders and eating disorders, while METH (under the name Desoxyn) is much more obscure medicinally (but still used! In fact another comment in this post mentions it). Both are DEA Schedule II. Scheduling has basically no correlation to actual addictive potential or harm in any way. Psilocybin is SchI, has virtually no risk of addiction or overdose, Zolpidem is SchIV but is notoriously prone to abuse, and tobacco isn't even scheduled but is exceptionally addictive, causes easily >$100B in costs in USA alone. Yeah, the DEA schedule is kinda useless IMHO, but I digress. AMPH can be abused and sold on the street, but that's true of literally any drug that humans find interesting to consume, including weak PEAs like bupropion, and OTC drugs like diphenhydramine and dextromethorphan. Bottom line is - amphetamine is safe and effective when used as prescribed for improving focus and wakefulness. Lumping it in with METH or other street drugs is chemically imprecise, and does a disservice to those struggling with executive disorders. Apple makes it seem like just the name Amphetamine implies inappropriate drug consumption, which adds to the stigma those who benefit from amphetamine treatment already experience. Thanks for coming to my TEDHN talk.
- LeonB 6y agoDoes Apple promote fruit consumption? (No, Apple does not promote fruit consumption.)
- null_object 6y agoI genuinely don’t understand the outrage in these HN threads about Apple. This is an application undoubtedly built with Apple hardware, probably using an Apple-developed programming language and an IDE made by Apple, to be used on machines created and manufactured by Apple, and provided on a store that’s setup and run by Apple. This isn’t even a so-called ‘walled garden’. Let’s take Instagram for instance: built on technologies provided freely by others (HTML, JavaScript, CSS) and exploiting user-created content, I still need to sign-up to a Facebook service to be able to see that freely-provided content. If these apps were boxes on a Walmart shelf, why would it be seen as some sort of civil-liberty infringement if you got a call someday, to say that Walmart had decided to discontinue selling your product? Just change the name and move on.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- akerro 6y agoIt's similar situation to removal of slave/master terminology from IT. Without context such accusations are pointless. "I don't like the word you use so you are not allowed to use it." We're seeing the same thing. Apple doesn't like you using the word that's also name of a drug, so you're gone. No context needed.
- DonHopkins 6y agoThey should collaborate with Simone Giertz and re-brand it the "Wake Up Machine"! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lh2-iJj3dI0&ab_channel=SimoneGiertz https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lh2-iJj3dI0&ab_channel=Simon... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=61FaYVGVY_I&ab_channel=SimoneGiertz https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=61FaYVGVY_I&ab_channel=Simon...
- andai 6y agoCould you change it to Modafinil?
- codecamper 6y agoApple is so freaking random with their complaints. It makes it VERY hard to build a business around. 10 years ago I had a police scanner app called Scanner911. It sold well.. until a competitor innovated around me... by gaming the app store's review system. Complaining to Apple yielded nothing. Not that I wanted to build a career around police scanner apps, but it was an independent income. People here defending Apple are conformist fanboys.. the same people that were sitting staring at that video screen in the old 1984 ad. Funny how the world repeats.
- Grustaf 6y agoApple tend to be hysterically puritanical about these things (and lately, hysterically PC) but it’s their store so why not just follow their rules?
- ur-whale 6y agoIt's not Apple that's hysterically puritanical, it's the market they operate in. They don't give two f__ks about being politically correct, they're a corporation, their main concern is profit, and if you're not being hysterically PC in 2021, you're gonna loose money because of the radical minority that's ruining it for everyone.
- Grustaf 6y agoI feel that Apple goes above and beyond. Like banning the confederate flag from all apps, I don't think people would have boycotted Apple if they hadn't done that. And Tim Cook's personal morals are very well aligned with PC, so I don't think it's just posturing.
- rajacombinator 6y agoMegacorps suck and are dumb. But snitching on other apps’ names is not cool either.
- maerF0x0 6y agoApple needs to fire the person who made the choice to ban this App. They have no purpose in the company, bring no returns, and cost a pretty penny. They are a rent seeker (apple policy) on top of an otherwise great business.
- coffeemug 6y ago> Apple became the place that I lost feeling of physical and psychological safety and the terror that it inflicted on me has impacted me on such a core level that the painful memories and flashbacks have replaced my dreams and they will hunt me until I am alive. I'm sure Apple is a political quagmire, but if you describe your experience working there the same way someone might describe their time at Auschwitz, it's probably you and not them.
- ur-whale 6y agoFunny how that kind of problem doesn't even exist on Linux. I really don't understand how people can willingly buy and use Apple products given the kind of paternalistic, I-know-what's-best for-you attitude this abomination of a company has.
- newbie789 6y agoI don't mean to sound pedantic (though I certainly will), but Focalin, Ritalin, etc are formulations of methylphenidate which is absolutely not an amphetamine. It's a DARI, not a VMAT2 inhibitor. They work in very different ways and are not chemically related. I only bring this up because if you're trying to educate folks on compounds in this sphere, being accurate is a nice thing to do. I wish this project all the best. It's absolutely silly that the name of a commonly prescribed compound should be so maligned. What if I named an app "Metformin"? Would that be at risk of uh, encouraging type 2 diabetes?
- ExcavateGrandMa 6y agololz
- S_A_P 6y agoThis does seem like a weird shift on Apples part. They even featured the app in “app stories” at one point in time. I’m a user of this app and found it when I couldn’t find caffeine which I used on an older MacBook. As an aside I’ve noticed that it’s Apples day to feature on the hn front page. Seems to be an unusual influx of bad apple press. I’m curious if it is coordinated? I’ve wondered the same about anti google/Facebook/Amazon as well. They all seem to come in waves.
- anigbrowl 6y agoI'm sympathetic, but it's not a great argument. Adderall®, Concerta®, Dexedrine®, Focalin®, Metadate®, Methylin®, Ritalin® are all “brand name” amphetamines. Yup, and they're controlled substances that you can't buy without a prescription and which are only supplied in limited quantity. Your app branding is literally a kind of drug abuse - using a drug to stay awake rather than its medical use to just be normally functional. This isn't to endorse Apple, which ought to apply its guidelines more consistently instead of ignoring or enforcing them in arbitrary manner, and which should be more transparent with communities of users rather than using its leverage against individual developers with no real process or recourse. But when you get down to it, you are in violation of the ToS and there isn't a great moral crusade here. Rebrand and be happy.
- lsiebert 6y agoI am not a lawyer, this is not legal advice, but the App store may constitute an essential facility for a desktop program developed specifically for Apple Computers. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Essential_facilities_doctrine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Essential_facilities_doctrine
- GavinMcG 6y agoSure, but they're not denying access to competitors. They're setting rules for use of the facility. "You can't promote illicit drug use in our facility" is a reasonable rule. Whether the name "Amphetamine" does in fact promote illicit drug use may be up for question, of course, but that's got nothing to do with monopoly power.
- nodamage 6y agoThere's no way this would apply here considering you can distribute Mac apps outside the Mac App Store.
- null4bl3 6y agoWell. It is their store. Come join the happy world off Linux if you want to avoid that sort of corporate control
- highmastdon 6y agoThe whole world is starting to cuddle everyone to death. It’s so disgusting to see the walled gardens censoring, boycotting, deciding what is truth, interfering with ones beliefs and trying to modify them. Also everyone feels offended by something thus entitled to tell what I can and cannot say. Grow the hell up! Sticks and stones may break my bones, but facts don’t care about your feelings. Pampering society will lead to a generation of incompetent crybabies just because they can’t handle another view/perspective
- turbinerneiter 6y agoDon't develop for Apple platforms. Don't tie your income to a platform you can't control. App store, youtube, ... they all can lock your out without reason and recourse. Don't rely on them.
- saagarjha 6y agoSigh, this is disappointing. I’ve been using Amphetamine for years and it’s quite literally one of a handful of utility apps on the App Store that isn’t a scam or neutered by the policies of the store. Apple was right to recognize it it in the past, and they are wrong today in their reinterpretation of the guidelines. FWIW, I do app review policy for iSH, which went though a similar situation recently (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25028252 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25028252) where we managed to convince Apple that they had misinterpreted their review guidelines. If you’re looking for help to get Amphetamine approved as it should, feel free to contact me at saagar@saagarjha.com. I’d be really disappointed to see Amphetamine lose its years of brand value over such a petty review decision.
- EricE 6y agoI hope the author see's your comment but he may not even be aware of this post on Hacker News. His twitter is in the original article - it would be worth a quick tweet to him too as I to use and am a fan of Amphetamine and would hate to see it go, or the author have to expend energy fixing something that isn't broken vs. spending his time on work that would bring actual value :/
- saagarjha 6y agoI don't have a Twitter, unfortunately. However, I did create an issue on the GitHub project: https://github.com/x74353/SaveAmphetamine/issues/4 https://github.com/x74353/SaveAmphetamine/issues/4. I noticed someone filed https://github.com/x74353/SaveAmphetamine/issues/8 https://github.com/x74353/SaveAmphetamine/issues/8 which got a response with an email in it, so I'll follow up there.
- Shorel 6y agoI'm with Apple on this one. Even for legal use the use of the name seems like an endorsement of sorts.
- birdyrooster 6y agoThe levels of symbolic irony here are rewarding and disturbing.
- aloukissas 6y agoThe App Store (i.e. a single gatekeeper with arbitrary policies) is a terrible way to distribute software. Since this is a MacOS app, perhaps the developer should choose to distribute it as a .dmg, free of all the App Store bullshit.
- AntiImperialis4 6y agoDon't you need to find some setting buried somewhere deep to enable installing dmgs now?
- karlzt 6y agoFirst comply and change the name to something like 'Amph' also change the icons (you will find something quickly that you can use) then sue them and if you win open the source code. (Comply & Sue).
- temptemptemp111 6y agoSue Apple for claiming to sell a fruit!
- zeristor 6y agoIf one has ADHD, then an amphetamine, paradoxically, helps you calm down. It’s a weird thing that a stimulant can help you chill; from this one could conjecture that an amphetamine to keep you awake isn’t being used to treat ADHD. I am not a medical Doctor; I am not many things. Although it would appear that A&E and GP Drs around here aren’t up on lis-Dex
- angry_octet 6y agoThis reminds me of all the hand wringing and pearl clutching about SATAN [1], by Farmer and Venema. Corporate types and bible-squeezers had a huge meltdown over the name. Unfortunately American culture is simply unsuited for free expression unless buttressed by something list the 1st amendment, which of course only applies to Government. Fundamentally Apple can and will do whatever it wants and there is no point complaining to them. OTOH allowing direct installs and multiple apps stores is a security disaster. But parliaments can pass laws to regulate monopoly conduct, in the same way that essential services are. Privacy, competition policy (including market access), arbitration procedures for small vs large companies, etc are all mature fields of law, and action in any large market would have significant effect on Apple/Google policy. Lobby your politicians. Support organizations like EFF. [1] https://www.usenix.org/system/files/login/articles/login_dec14_07_farmer.pdf https://www.usenix.org/system/files/login/articles/login_dec...
- chaboud 6y agoThis seems really simple to me. I tweeted my suggestion of rebranding as “vigil” and selling “pro” features to allow branding as “provigil” (commercial modafinil name).
- aszantu 6y agousing random drugs for a product name is totally not gonna result in trouble down the road. Which reminds me that ppl use random words for all kinds of things so I can't find what I'm looking for because now some animal or item is a software name...
- drKarl 6y agoI've used this application and the one that came before, caffeine, and in my opinion Apple shouldn't remove it. It would've been different if it was rejected as soon as it was submitted to the Apple store... But after 6 years it's very unfair, after it has built a brand identity and a community. That said there's a command line application that comes with MacOS X called caffeinate that does essentially the same thing.
- monksy 6y agoI remember when app stores started up and everyone said "this is great, you can get verified results, reviews, and they can handle disputes." However, this is the reality. Apple created a fixed game and you are the victim. Don't play their game, poison their well. (Inform others and your users what goes on in that environment and that they're bad actors/middlemen)
- no_no_no_no 6y agoapple with its brand and name incites us to sin. I'm hungry... Should I eat that apple? Then again they don't sell Aperture anymore cause they keep on closing the walled garden tighter and tighter...
- Sophistifunk 6y ago"Don't let programmers name things", issue #2,776,972
- justinclift 6y agoLooks like someone at Apple is having a "morality police" attack. :(
- perryizgr8 6y agoWhy do you care if it is on the app store or not? Just let users download it from your website. In any case people aren't discovering mac apps from the app store in any significant numbers.
- 0_gravitas 6y agoConsidering how hostile Apple seems to be to the creators that make their platform worth using, I'm consistently surprised that people keep developing for it/investing in it. At least Microsoft is apathetic all the way through: don't expect any help, but as far as I know you won't get shot out of the blue. To me, Apple's whole shtick these last few years reads as if they're just saying "We don't want you to develop on our platform." ("Pay us for even the ability to start making anything on our devices. Give us our cut for letting you exist and provide content for our platform. You can't do that anymore; banned. Make this arbitrary change or you're gone in x days...")
- EricE 6y agoIt's one reason the Mac App Store is a pale shadow of the iOS app store. Inconsistency in sand boxing, especially with Apple apps distributed via the app store vs. non-Apple apps. So much promise utterly wasted. What really is annoying is that it's been bad for so long without any seeming care from Apple in improving things. I'll use the app store for free or small dollar apps, but anything over $20 if I can buy it outside the App store I absolutely do even though it's more of a hassle.
- EricE 6y agoI like the concept and promise of App stores, but over time I am less and less convinced there is any company that can competently run one with any sort of consistency.
- barefeg 6y agoWasn’t there another one called caffeine?
- abstractbarista 6y agoI'm so happy I've never bought an Apple product in my entire life. With behavior like this, I shall continue to only buy things I can actually control. :)
- ghosty-discord 6y agoI think this further prove that iOS apps development is not stable at all.
- mmerlin 6y ago4 4pm 24 4 33rd w 24 11ww2r325 2 22nd 11th22A