11 ms·
This is a case of economies of scale. A fairly wealthy person could save maybe $50,000 per year with the advice of the smartest tax lawyers and accountants in t
by gnicholas 6y ago
This is a case of economies of scale. A fairly wealthy person could save maybe $50,000 per year with the advice of the smartest tax lawyers and accountants in the world. But it would cost them $500,000 per year to pay for the structure to be created/updated.
When I worked as a tax lawyer, we created structures and defended cases that saved our clients hundreds of millions of dollars. At this scale, paying for our services was a no-brainer.
On top of that, big companies lobby lawmakers to make the tax system favorable to them. This makes sense for the same reason: paying a couple million dollars to create/maintain a provision that saves $100M/yr is a no-brainer.
I'm not saying any of this is right or good (and I am no longer a tax lawyer; I now build tools that help people with disabilities). I'm just saying this is why it makes sense that companies can walk a fine line on taxes, save tons of money, and you and I cannot.
- wiz21c 6y agoMaybe it's a little too much to ask, but are why are you "not saying any of this is right or good". Part of my brain wishes that law would actually mean justice but somehow, if I trust only what I know, I cleary cannot judge, as you do, if finance engineering is good or bad. I'd like to know what prevents you to choose if it's good or right (as person who have worked inside the business) thx
- gnicholas 6y agoI do have opinions about various tax provisions that I know well. But the topics I mentioned in my prior comment were not about a specific tax provision, or even tax policy generally. I was just stating the facts of life. It will always be the case that big companies will find it efficient to engage in certain revenue-producing activities that smaller companies/individuals will not. Just as I don't have feelings about laws of physics, I don't have any feelings about economies of scale. Lobbying is a bit different. Like most folks, the idea of 'lobbying' strikes me as wasteful/corrupt. But if you try to come up with a definition about what 'lobbying' is, and how you might try to restrict it, you realize that it is very difficult to do so without being underinclusive or overinclusive (or both!). So while I find the idea distasteful, I don't have any answers on how to 'fix' it.
- sdoering 6y agoThanks. What I love about the comments you make is twofold: - You clearly differentiate between opinion, observation and fact. - You don't try to find an easy answer. Thanks. Comments like these make me come back and read on HN.
- gnicholas 6y agoMy hobby [1] is helping people think clearly about media bias and filter bubbles, so I'm glad to hear that my comments come across as rational and balanced! 1: http://www.readacrosstheaisle.com http://www.readacrosstheaisle.com
- animal_spirits 6y agoThis is an interesting concept. I think this is a tool that I would use, however I don't have an iPhone and I don't use Chrome. Are there plans to release this as a Firefox addon?
- yeahNo00 6y agoSo you don’t have any emotional opinions on the work of others that has real effect on your life? Physicists can be wrong. Economists can be wrong. At some point technical nonsense becomes “imperfect people choosing.” A fix might simply be change tax laws? Kind of like how the billionaires changed them to be less distributed. But you don’t have feelings enough about economics being purposely wielded at scale to manipulate; let’s hope you’re still one of the privileged enough to be indifferent and comfortable in the future. popcorn Real-time meltdown of Pax Americana is pretty metal.
- Broken_Hippo 6y agoI don't think the poster was saying any of this. They were simply stating that the post was informational and that they weren't offering any commentary on the situation, just giving facts. I mean, sure a physicist can be wrong, but if they are giving facts as are currently accepted by the community or even as they know them, it isn't an emotional statement of whether they agree. It is just that: Facts as we know them, to the best of our ability and not giving the commentary with it.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoLaw is the UI for political power, and not inherently for justice. If you want justice, you have to apply political leverage to steer power in its direction. Law is also the UI for political self-interest. Unfortunately the same leverage principle applies. Which is why it's almost impossible to get real justice - including tax justice - in a plutocracy. The scales are tilted too heavily in the opposite direction. The answer is to balance plutocracy with effective political organisation, but that's an incredibly hard problem to solve at all, never mind peacefully.
- simonh 6y agoIt the OP, but there’s a difference between holding a moral opinion and stating that opinion in a discussion. OP may simply have not wanted to obscure information presented from an insider perspective with personal opinion, in an attempt to stay objective. Further, financial engineering by itself is morally neutral. It can create abuses sure, but it can also reduce unnecessary costs so that a company can employ more people, offer goods and services to customers at lower prices, etc. Tax is just one piece of a much bigger puzzle and it can’t always easily be disentangled from other issues. I’m reminded of the saying about porn, you might not be able to define it, but you know it when you see it. There are plenty of publicly discussed cases of pretty clear and egregious tax evasion, but not all efforts to limit tax liability are abuses. Some of them are responses to deliberate incentives put into the tax system to encourage specific behaviour.
- ArnoVW 6y agoBecause he wants to give his technical expertise, and does not want to enter into a political debate about the way we organise society. If you read between the lines, you can see that he understands that people have reservations (and probably he has chosen). He just chooses to explicitly not make a statement about it, and keep this a technical discussion. In todays highly politicised society, this is (in my opinion) a sensible thing to do.
- gizzlon 6y ago> At this scale, paying for our services was a no-brainer. What? I don't think so. If money is the only thing they care about, sure. But is it? Should it be? And if breaking the spirit of the law is fine, shouldn't breaking the letter of the law be fine as well? As long as the risk is low enough.. </rant>
- CraneWorm 6y agoYou either save the billions in taxes or cannot scale further because now you can't afford to compete with those that do. Also things sure do look different when you are at the helm. If you decide your company should pay more in taxes the board will probably vote you out on your ass.
- buran77 6y ago> if breaking the spirit of the law is fine, shouldn't breaking the letter of the law be fine as well? There's no law against breaking the spirit of the law. Breaking the spirit of the law will only get you tried in the court of public opinion. Breaking the letter will also go to a court of justice.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoOne should read up on the judiciary system in their specific state before they start breaking the spirit of the law. In some states the judges are quasi-politicians with an implied mandate to rule how they think the people want them to rule. In others the judiciary is a system for evaluating the law and they see they consider it their mandate to enforce the law exactly as written, especially when it gives the legislature and the public the middle finger because that's the incentive for those groups to write and demand good law.
- NineStarPoint 6y agoThe thing about capitalism is that companies that don’t do everything in their power to increase profit are at a disadvantage against those who do. Profit is the ability to invest more in R&D, attract more investors, scale faster, advertise more. Unless your consumers care enough to only support you if you pay taxes, or you can get substantially more productive employees by paying taxes, or some other advantage in the marketplace by paying taxes, paying taxes when your competition does not is an albatross around your neck. And if your morality creates enough albatrosses around your neck your company will either fold or be eternally small as your competitors without such restrictions have higher efficiency. So it’s a no-brainer in that any company that gets to the scale where spending millions on lawyers is appropriate is already of this mindset. This is why laws need to be crafted to not give companies the benefit of the doubt when it comes to acting in the best interest of society. Less because it is impossible for a company to be moral in a vacuum, but because if being immoral is allowed and advantageous inevitably the immoral company will out compete the moral one. (Of course it can be hard to agree on what moral is. Some say that taxes are immoral after all.)
- harry8 6y ago>this is why it makes sense that companies can walk a fine line on taxes, save tons of money, and you and I cannot. Nope, these are the reasons that cause the situation. This outcome does /not/ make sense nobody sane without a huge vested interest would design a system to achieve less tax paid when you earn more. It's entirely contrary to the intent and spirit of the tax code. This is not sensible. How to fix it? That's harder. Start with its a problem and morally and ethically wrong. It's really the only place to start from. I would say keep in mind two wrongs is not an improvement and unchecked government power is far worse than tax cheats but that does not change where this discussion should start.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- chewz 6y ago> How to fix it? Make a tax code as simple as possible. So simple there is no room for interpretation.
- apexalpha 6y agoOr do like Europe is finally starting: just tax revenue. They can suppress their 'profit' whichever way they want, they can't suppress their revenue in a given country. The digital services tax is imposed at a rate of 3% on the gross revenues derived from digital activities of which French “users” are deemed to play a major role in value creation. The law not only affects digital companies but, more generally, digital business models. https://home.kpmg/us/en/home/insights/2019/07/tnf-france-digital-services-tax-enacted.html#:~:text=The%20digital%20services%20tax%20is,more%20generally%2C%20digital%20business%20models https://home.kpmg/us/en/home/insights/2019/07/tnf-france-dig....
- jlokier 6y ago> Or do like Europe is finally starting: just tax revenue. That rapidly turns into a disaster of consolidations and monopolies. You don't want that. Think about the difference between big company $BIG selling you the consumer a million Widgets for 10^9 currency units, versus 26 small companies $a..$z each selling to the next in a long supply chain which results in a million Widgets. In revenue taxation, big company $BIG pays 10^9∗$TAX_RATE. Whereas the 26 small companies pay something more like 26∗10^9∗$TAX_RATE because each time a company pays the next company, that's revenue for the next company. The difference in tax between those two scenarios is so enormous, that it would create enormous pressure for companies $a..$z to consolidate into a single company. Repeat this across the entire economy, and you have enormous pressure to consolidate everything into as few companies as possible.
- hackeraccount 6y agoThis is why I've always been skeptical of high _income_ tax rates. First tax avoidance is at base a fixed cost. It's the price of a really tax lawyer (or at the extreme a couple of US Senators). If that fixed price is less then your tax bill only idiot pays the tax bill. The second reason is that I don't believe people view money fractionally - I think they look at it absolutely. For me am million dollars is a lot of money. For Bill Gates though a million dollars is ... a lot of money. It doesn't matter that he's a billionaire he's still not going to throw around a million dollars the same way I'd throw around the same fraction of my wealth that a million is to him. He still recognizes the absolute value of that money and he can still see it's potential to make things happen in the world just as I can see what a hundred dollars (or whatever my fractional equivalent is) can do in the world.
- srtjstjsj 6y agoLook at Bill Gates's house to see how obvious false that thesis is.
- Zenbit_UX 6y agoNa, you're both wrong, GP for assuming he knows how a billionaire views a million dollars and you for your weak rebuttal that his home proves he doesn't value money. You both need to stop speculating about Bill Gates.
- dastx 6y agoWhen is the right time to consult a tax lawyer for an average person that is paid quite a bit above average?
- vishnugupta 6y ago> that saved our clients hundreds of millions of dollars. Could you elaborate, from your experience, what happened to these $$$? Do they sit in banks without being used or do they get get invested and recirculated in the economy? Also, given that just about every function of the US govt has been privatised, what would the US govt spend this money on? Spend it on defence (and channel the money back to private defense entities)? Pay off trade deficit? I'm not aware of US budget break down on expenditure side so any pointer would be great.
- nickpp 6y agoMoney in banks ARE invested and circulated in the economy.
- pjc50 6y agoSpend it on? How about COVID relief? IIRC defense is about 20% of the US federal budget. About 40% of that (ie 8% of total federal spending) is paid to staff. In some ways it's the largest redistributive program. The trade deficit is private, it's an accounting summary between private importers and exporters. Nothing to "pay off".
- costcopizza 6y agoOut of curiosity, what kind of disability tools?
- gnicholas 6y agoMy startup’s tech makes reading on screen easier. It is used by all types of readers, but is especially helpful popular among people with dyslexia, ADHD, vision impairment, and various chronic conditions. http://www.beelinereader.com http://www.beelinereader.com
- Mumps 6y agoThis has been on my mind for quite a while: is there a way to set up saving structures like those of Big Corp to poor people - i.e. find a way for the people least able to pay tax to pay less of it. Would you mind chatting about your expertise here? Do you think there is any feasible way of generalizing these tax avoidance structures so that Joe and Jane can reap some of those sweet sweet loophole benefits as well?
- pjc50 6y agoThere's usually a high fixed cost to them. The merely averagely rich have been taking advantage of them, but gradually the low-cost loopholes are closed, e.g. https://www.accountingweb.co.uk/any-answers/isle-of-man-tax-avoidance-scheme https://www.accountingweb.co.uk/any-answers/isle-of-man-tax-... Mind you, most actually poor people have a low tax incidence in the first place due to progressive tax rates.
- leetcrew 6y agosorry for the nitpick, but I don't think tax incidence [0] is the term you were looking for here. it's hard for poor people to take advantage of tax loopholes because they don't directly pay much tax after the standard deduction and (possibly) EITC. whether they bear the burden (ie, tax incidence) of taxes levied against other entities is controversial. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_incidence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_incidence
- api 6y agoIn practice this amounts to a regressive tax system.
- tappio 6y agoEconomies or scale... How about just power? These companies have too many people in their pocket. When you have enough power you can get away with this. These companies, even if not paying taxes directly, are huge contributors of economy. You threaten them, and they threaten you back. Do you want them to take their 10,000 jobs somewhere else? It's not tax laws and enforcing them, just rather just too much power on too few people's hands.
- stjohnswarts 6y agoDo you have any input as to how they can be prevented from beating the system or do you think there will always be enough loop holes for them to get out of paying taxes because they essentially own the law makers?
- neycoda 6y agoThat's all great for business and terrible for the public interest.