25 ms·
Headphones are collecting too much personal data (2019)
- elvicherrera 6y agoIs there a true app that, preferably open source, that can disable the all microphones, confidently, for all apps, without having to physically disable my microphone as Edward Snowden suggested?
- teddyh 6y agoIf one app can turn the microphone off, can another app turn it back on?
- toomuchtodo 6y agoDepends on the permissions model of the OS, and if you trust the OS. Hence why Edward Snowden and Bunnie Huang developed the Introspection Engine [1]. It’s reasonable to assume that if you can’t audit and review the code of the app and the OS, you can trust neither and need safeguards at lower levels of the stack. [1] https://www.tjoe.org/pub/direct-radio-introspection/release/2 https://www.tjoe.org/pub/direct-radio-introspection/release/...
- monadic2 6y agoYou forgot the firmware of the headphones!
- toomuchtodo 6y agoCorded headphones! :) at least until open firmware exists.
- treve 6y agoEver tried to connect a corded headphone into a microphone jack? It works quite well
- wizzwizz4 6y agoIs there some kind of diode for AC signals?
- formerly_proven 6y agoYes, they're called amplifiers. Directional coupling circuits would apply in theory, but not in practice; they're good enough to do full-duplex audio over two wires, but not nearly good enough to deal with the sensitivity of analog inputs if you want to prevent a signal from being read.
- monadic2 6y agoHow can you trust the hardware is not recording? I’ve never felt better about connecting “dumb” headphones.
- retrac 6y agoOnly a slightly related tangent, but most headphones and other loudspeakers can be very effective microphones when wired into the right circuit. While speakers are often wired directly to a one-way DAC, that's not always the case. Sometimes the analog lines are all fed into a multiplexer and it can be routed to a ADC. Sometimes it's wired to a general purpose IO pin. In such cases, reprogramming could turn that speaker into a microphone. I wonder if anyone has exploited this in the wild yet.
- jacquesm 6y agoYou can do the opposite of noise cancellation too: determine the back emf from the speaker compared to the audio input, that will give you the audio in the room. So you can use the same circuit both to drive the speaker and use it as a microphone. As good as undetectable until you trace the circuitry of what looks like an ordinary amplifier. The difference is on the order of a few mV but that's more than enough. My personal favorite is the laser attack that turns any shiny surface into a microphone. When it's not on it literally isn't there.
- layoutIfNeeded 6y agoNo need to use a laser if there’s an incandescent bulb in the room: https://www.wired.com/story/lamphone-light-bulb-vibration-spying/ https://www.wired.com/story/lamphone-light-bulb-vibration-sp...
- jacquesm 6y agoOh that's a neat one. Thank you for that link.
- rightbyte 6y agoIf you have noise cancelling there is allready mics right?
- jacquesm 6y agoIn this particular scenario there wouldn't be.
- shbooms 6y agoAn article complaining about the collecting and sharing of users personal data from a blog site that connects to facebook, google analytics and other third-party services to collect and share their users data? Oh the irony...
- jacquesm 6y agoI've seen this comment or a variation on it a thousand times now and it is getting boring. Just like all the other times: please comment on the message rather than on the means of delivery, finding pages without social media embeds is becoming more and more rare and besides that the party writing the article content may not have control over that particular aspect. But that doesn't mean they don't have a point.
- patrick451 6y agoThey author may not be able to control the social media embeds of this particular site, but they certainly have control over where the choose to publish. I see nothing wrong with taking them to task for this sort of hypocrisy.
- jacquesm 6y agoNo, they don't always have that control. Maybe in this case they do, maybe they don't. But your typical author is in someone's pay. And they probably don't have the pick of where to publish besides the bulk of the places where you can work and write articles that reach a sizeable audience will have this kind of environment. Anyway, seeing the same comment over and over again reduces its value. It was a cool observation the first time, boring the second, redundant after that.
- renewiltord 6y agoThere is no value in calling out hypocrisy. If a murderer outs another murderer now you know about two murderers. Saying "you're a murderer too, you hypocrite" has no epistemological value.
- 6y ago
- Bluecobra 6y agoAhh, this is real reason why the phone manufacturers want to get rid of the headphone jack. I was so naive to think it was only about DRM/licensing.
- gruez 6y agoIsn't this really only an issue if you use the companion app? I doubt the usb-c/lightning/bluetooth headphones can exfiltrate data if you don't have the companion app installed.
- Lio 6y agoYou also can't get firmware updates if you don't install the companion app and allow them to spy on you.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jdsully 6y agoWhy do my headphones need firmware updates? Presumably they work fine at purchase.
- throwaway8941 6y agoNoise cancellation sometimes gets better (or worse) after a firmware update.
- sascha_sl 6y agoBose also added the in-device EQ to the Bose 700 via patch a few months ago.
- WrtCdEvrydy 6y agoBecause we cut a corner somewhere to make a budget device and realized it was a lot more popular and now we have to patch it like if it was a fucking nuclear reactor....
- baal80spam 6y agoImagine seeing such article title 10 years ago... What happened to the world?
- taytus 6y agoCompanies finally figured it out that nobody cares about privacy.
- skummetmaelk 6y agoAnd that data is money.
- Nextgrid 6y agoLack of regulation and non-existent enforcement of existing regulation. People are used to the government being there to prevent companies from doing bad/dangerous stuff. It’s why you can buy any food at any supermarket and be reasonably confident it won’t poison you or be full of cyanide. People expect the same when it comes to technology companies, and I once did too - I expected that big companies would’ve already got in trouble if they did something bad so it must be safe. The problem is that is far from the truth.
- m4r35n357 6y agoAny is too much. Ditch them.
- unethical_ban 6y agoRe: Personal fitness and menstruation history - Is that shocking? They're earbuds, but they're marketed as fitness buds that track personal data. It looks like Fitbit for your ears. Fitbit and Apple Health (or whatever it is called) does these kinds of things as well. Re: Bose collecting all that stuff I can see "why" they would want all that, in order to optimize their sound output of their buds to the kind of music and environments for which they are used. That should, of course, be opt-in, but I don't think it is evil. Do I necessarily like the latter example? No. I believe, like the "cookie policies" that exist on many websites, there should be "Needed permissions" and "Please thank you" permissions, and they should incentivize the consumer to help them out. Amazon does this on their Kindles: $20 off if you let them run ads on the lock screen. But if all the manufacturers do this, then what competition is there to push them to change?
- amelius 6y ago> I can see "why" they would want all that, in order to optimize their sound output of their buds to the kind of music and environments for which they are used. I can't see why they would need so many samples. Wouldn't using the data from (say) 100 Bose employees be sufficient to cover most noisy environments these buds are used in?
- floatingatoll 6y agoIf you're trying for perfection, then not even remotely, no. The type of data provided by "one million users" will uncover issues that "one hundred users" simply never can. I believe it was iOS 10 or 11 developer betas that would, on each beta update, run a trial APFS conversion process against the phone's internal filesystem, check the result for consistency, and then discard the replica and report success/failure w/ logs — so that Apple could find the issues that they couldn't find at 'one hundred users' scale.
- renewiltord 6y agoThere's a famous Bose bughunt article that proves this not to be the case. I can't find where they posted it on a blog or something but here's the forum link: https://community.bose.com/t5/Around-On-Ear-Headphones/Bose-QC-35-Firmware-4-5-2-Noise-Cancellation-Investigation/td-p/285738 https://community.bose.com/t5/Around-On-Ear-Headphones/Bose-...
- baochan 6y agoHow exactly does a headphone app have access to your alcohol use and menstruation history? Where is it pulling this data from?
- wbkang 6y agoIt's one of the data types apple health can collect. The headphones app probably asked for all possible types of healthkit data.
- lrnStats 6y agoIf that stock takes a tumble, you can bet their marketing is going to drop the privacy branding. Everyone knows their customers are highly susceptible to marketing, it would be a gold mine.
- caymanjim 6y agoThey don't. The app may ask for it, and there may be some benefit to the user if they provide it, but it's not like the headphones magically acquire any of the data the author is complaining about. If people want to give their personal information out, that's up to them. I personally limit what information I share, and I get annoyed when devices or apps try to sneakily get more information than I'm willing to intentionally provide, but this article is silly. The younger generation has grown up without a sense of personal privacy, and they're largely ok with it. They will happily give away personal details in exchange for a "free" app or product, and they bend over backwards to expose their entire lives via images and videos on social media. There's always mock outrage when someone "discovers" that the reason the Internet is free is because someone is selling personal data to drive advertising, but everyone knows that. Most people just don't care.
- saurik 6y agoThey care. It exudes as a cynicism about the world and continual jokes about talking to the FBI agent assigned to watch them. They (as are we) are just powerless to prevent it as every single service and every single platform and apparently every single product is collecting data on us. And since the value of services and platforms and, sadly, even products goes up as more people are using them, the arguments of "don't use these products and vote with your dollars" that people constantly push are nonsensical: you can value your privacy but also value having a romantic partner, and most people these days use dating apps to date; you can value your privacy but also value getting invited to the birthday party, and most people these days invite everyone to their party on a social network; you can value your privacy but also value being able to travel, and so unless you want to be the one insane person in your friend group who doesn't use Lyft/Uber and never knows when the public transportation is running late and takes forever to book hotels (and always ends up spending a lot more when you do)... well, you are going to use a bunch of apps that do a bunch of data collection. People care. They have no choice.
- ktr 6y agoHas anyone had any experience with new Bose headphones? If you use the Bose Connect app, I believe what the author wrote is accurate. But that app doesn’t work on the newer headphones (at least, not the ones I have). Instead I need to download the “Bose Music” app which doesn’t seem to give you the same options for privacy. And if you don’t use that app, the headphones are much less useful (eg, no hardware controls to switch which device you are connected to).
- aragorn9 6y agoWhy do you think they made a new app to begin with? the piracy policy is the same, its just after the media hype died down they saw no reason to add the opt out
- RealStickman_ 6y ago> piracy policy Not sure if this was intentional, but it made me chuckle.
- bryanmgreen 6y agoThat being said, if anyone has unused corded Apple EarPods and the 3.5 to lightning dongle, hit me up!
- t0mmyb0y 6y agoWhy in the world would anyone need headphones that need personal info?
- heavyset_go 6y agoEveryone, including headphone manufacturers, are trying to get in on the gold rush that is turning their customers into fonts of personal data that can be sold to the highest bidder.
- zelly 6y agoI see this sentiment mentioned a lot, but who actually pays for this data? Is there a company I can call that will buy my amorphous "user data"? What are their names?
- sebastien_b 6y agoJust because you haven’t heard of them doesn’t mean they don’t exist. Ask yourself (as the article does): why would they even need this data? (menstrual cycle?? Really!?!)
- mixmastamyk 6y agoOne user is worthless, a few pennies. A million and things get interesting.
- formerly_proven 6y agoLooking at my collection of Beyerdynamic cans... they collect data?
- njloof 6y ago(2018)
- api 6y agoEverything spies on you. There's money in it. I've come to believe that this can only be fixed with legislation and regulation. There are no technical fixes that could practically be deployed as there is far too much "attack surface" and anyway there is zero incentive to deploy them. In the meantime: install as few apps as possible on phones, be careful about IoT and personal assistance devices, and use Apple or Linux (not Android) based systems as they seem to have the best record for security and privacy.
- heavyset_go 6y agoiOS exploits are cheaper than Android exploits because they are so plentiful. Plenty of apps on iOS have been caught activating the camera or snooping on the clipboard on iPhones.
- RealStickman_ 6y agoIf you use Android you have to install a custom rom though to guarantee your privacy.
- heavyset_go 6y agoIf you use iOS, you have no other option than just trusting the vendor. You couldn't do anything to make it more secure even if you wanted to.
- RealStickman_ 6y agoiOS seems to be more privacy oriented (for the western market, where the government does not yet have the power to force them to comply) by default, while android needs more work put in. If you did as much as you could to secure both I'd agree with you that android is more secure.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- qmmmur 6y agoMine don't because they're hard wired into whatever device I use.
- starky 6y agoExactly, it will be a cold day in hell before I buy a pair of headphones that I have to charge on order to make them work or have any "smart" features.
- Larrikin 6y agoI broke down when I finally found good noise cancelling headphones that will continue working without battery. The annoying part now is that layering pass through audio of the outside world on top of what I'm listening to has become pretty nice.
- kkapelon 6y agoI was like you, until I tried wireless headphones outside and was amazed. For some activities like running having no cables to deal with is a great experience (that you should try at least once)
- karmakaze 6y agoGlad I've been using analog earbuds under non-connected noise-cancelling 'over-earphones'.
- phatfish 6y agoThe only thing that annoys me about this setup is noise of the wire brushing against clothing etc. Or if you eat with them on. With music playing the removal of external noise is enough for me. They do well enough blocking distracting noise used as simple ear plugs too. At least the ~£20 Sennheiser ones I use do.
- coliveira 6y agoThe sad thing is that many people will think it is Ok to give them this kind of private information, just in exchange for some crappy, useless app. 20 years ago, if somebody said they cared about how many steps they walked, or how many minutes they slept more than last month, or how many minutes they looked at the computer, you would classify them as mentally sick. Except for specialists that do research in these areas, there is no reason to keep tabs on minutiae like this. This whole industry is training people to behave as the mentally retarded, and give away all their private information for nothing.
- rblatz 6y agoPedometers have been a thing for quite some time. It was about 20 years ago when one of my parents bought a pedometer, it didn’t have an app, but it had an lcd display that told you how many steps you took.
- im3w1l 6y agoAre these associated apps mandatory for getting the headphones working or are they just value adds?
- Godel_unicode 6y agoJust value adds, you can listen just fine without them. You might lose (in the case of the headphones that lead to the article) some fitness tracking features, ANC or EQ fine-tuning, or other additional functionality but they'll work just fine for audio.
- httgp 6y agoTo add to this list, they also let us upgrade firmware.
- the_pwner224 6y agoBose has a computer-based firmware updater over USB, I used it with their relatively new noise cancelling 700 headphones since I don't use the Bose Music app. Website launches a Windows desktop application for the update. Worked great in a Windows virtual machine with USB passthrough. For older QC35 headphones there's a 'based-connect' repo on github that lets you configure the headphones; unfortunately the newer models such as the NC700 have encrypted firmware update files so I couldn't easily reverse engineer the protocol to get all the BT commands to configure all the options you can change in the app. Actually the app didn't even work on my Android phone without GApps, so I couldn't sniff the connection either...
- acd 6y agoI tend to use passive headphones with 3.5mm jack, they have no electronics in them except the small speakers. They do not collect data. They are also used by musicians when doing audio mixing so its should sounds neutral and good. That the headphones does not have electronics and batteries means they will last longer and thus be be better for the environment.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> they will last longer and thus be be better for the environment This isn’t necessarily true. My wireless headphones have been with me for years. My wired earbuds are cheap enough that I can lose or damage them without care. The former are far better for the environment.
- organsnyder 6y agoOf course it's not a universal rule. But apples-to-apples, with a wired vs. wireless set of similar construction, cost, and intended use, the wired will outlast the wireless, solely due to the battery (not to mention the other complexities inherent to a wireless set).
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> apples-to-apples, with a wired vs. wireless set of similar construction, cost, and intended use These aren’t independent variables. Most consumers I know will pay more for wireless headphones. They’re more convenient, and they’re anchored at a higher price point. As such, I’ve watched lots of friends go from buying cheap earbuds monthly to having a pair of AirPods for years. There is a lot of moralising around wired versus wireless. I’m pushing back against that fad.
- diffeomorphism 6y agoAirpods for years and then throw away seems on point. Those are notorious for being completely unrepairable even among true wireless earbuds.
- renewiltord 6y agoIf it results in lower prices, I'm fine with this. But they should be clear about what they're collecting.
- bitwize 6y agoFor now, Bose QuietComforts appear to pair just fine with Bluetooth without requiring the Bose Connect app, so that's how I've been using them. I'm afraid that non-smart headphones will soon go the way of non-smart TVs.
- thoughtstheseus 6y agoIf anyone thinks this is concerning wait until LIDAR becomes a standard feature.
- lysium 6y ago> "Bose Connect app was found to be tracking what users were listening to and sending that data back to the company to be sold". I did not know that!
- josteink 6y agoYou buy the most expensive headsets in the premium-end of the consumer-segment, and yet you’re still not the customer. Utterly disgusting.
- myth2018 6y agoDrugstores in Brazil are doing it and that concerns me A LOT. Their modus operandi is to ask you your CPF (it's like an SSN, but not that secret and powerful) and, if you refuse to tell them, you are not eligible for some discounts which can reach 40% in some more expensive items. Customers happily agree to give their CPFs, completely unaware they are of the potentially disastrous consequences, and we are not even offered something resembling a privacy policy. Think of the uses of such data. Health insurers could use them to detect and even predict health issues. One could estimate menstrual cycles and even the size of your genitalia. A Brazilian data protection law is about to become active within the next weeks, but honestly.. such data shouldn't even be collected at all. I'm looking for support for a bill to forbid drugstores to collect CPFs and to offer any sort of discount to people who identify themselves, but I believe this should be more publicized before being discussed for voting by the Congress. The more active drugstores on the "data business" are part of huge chains and their lobby will definitely be massive. Society should be aware of that and counterbalance for such lobby.
- someguyorother 6y agoHow do they know the CPF you give is really yours (or exists at all)? Do they also insist that you use a credit card?
- rlayton2 6y agoThis is a good point. I often "misspell" private information if its not an official form. If someone had more motivation, they could do a "different-secure-number-per-provider" trick and work out who leaked the information.
- myth2018 6y agoThat's a good idea. I also feed fake data to those "extra-official" enlistments. But never thought about keeping a control to discover the responsible for the occasional leak. In Brazilian drugstores, there are legitimate situations where they actually need your data, e.g., when you need some injectable medicine. In such cases, they need to send an official notice for government control, BUT they also ask you for an original document. P.S.: one might argue that government shouldn't have access to data about injectable medicines you take. Personally, given the severe situation regarding drug-abuse of countries like ours, USA and others, I see some valid motivation in such tight controls.
- catchmeifyoucan 6y agoI use Bluetooth headphones, but almost never use or bother to set up the associated app. So hopefully Bluetooth pairing alone isn’t enough. Looks a lot of these details are collected through a companion app.
- _trampeltier 6y agoYes me too. I really never install such apps, because they are always bad in many ways. I just wanna a bluethoot speaker or headphone. I really don't care for the mostly useless fancy software things. And most of the times, it's even possible to use these things also with a 3.5mm jack
- IshKebab 6y agoSometimes these apps are necessary though. For instance you can only turn the Google Assistant button off on Sony headphones in their app, there's an additional (better!) noise reduction mode only available through the app, firmware updates are through the app, etc. (I get the firmware updates because I'm vaguely hoping that one day they will fix the hilariously annoying flaw that they turning them on always activates noise cancellation.)
- Polylactic_acid 6y agoWhen I got my bose headphones they would not connect as bluetooth headphones until I installed the app. After that they would but I still had to sign up and accept location access the first time.
- kayodelycaon 6y agoI see a number of people saying this but I was able to pair mine without an app. Installing the app didn’t require location access. There’s also several people saying their experience was like mine. It’s pretty obvious different people are getting two distinctly different experiences with the company. It’s not a spectrum, just one or the other. That is strange and I wonder was the cause of that is.
- ddingus 6y agoNot mine with the simple wire. The digital video transition has been a net good, though I will say analog output is easier, takes fewer resources, but those are plentiful. No worries. Audio isn't the same. All existing gear remains relevant. The data collection is something I hate viscerally. Also why I do not stream music.
- monksy 6y agoThe article should have buried sony for how egregious they are. They require the app to collect location information, and ear. https://www.sony.com/electronics/support/articles/00233341 https://www.sony.com/electronics/support/articles/00233341 I'm not sure what else they collect.. but those are the 2 bad ones. They've got a few settings that are software controlled (one being the bluetooth's internal volume) What happens if you get a software update and you open the app on a plane without wifi? You can't use it because it requires the internet to get the latest _required tos_ to use your headphones. You can't proceed further without being forced into an agreement. Clicking "don't accept" pushes you back to the tos screen.
- mandelbrotwurst 6y agoGeez, that's brutal. I'm glad I'm seeing this....it never crossed my mind that this sort of thing would be something that might get built into headphones. If I want to avoid this sort of thing, I'm thinking / hoping it's sufficient to simply avoid headphones that require an app. Does that seem right?
- monksy 6y agoI mean you can't really avoid it. It's pushed on to you and theres no clear understanding about how tied the headphones are until you buy it. The WH-1000MX are very good headphones, but sony gonna shit the bed. (PSN anyone)
- jmole 6y agoThey're a company that makes a lot of decisions from the viewpoint of participants in a high-trust society like Japan. Many times, those viewpoints don't translate well to other markets.
- monksy 6y agoThat trust is hugely misplaced. They frequently make terrible decisions that negatively affect others. - Them being hugely defensive about the fan backlash over Tlou2 https://www.altchar.com/game-news/sony-contacts-website-over-negative-the-last-of-us-part-2-review-aMeDH5F1BrLB https://www.altchar.com/game-news/sony-contacts-website-over... - They've removed early release credentials from reviewers who give sour reviews - The shit return policy for the digital only games - The way they are trying to push digital only etc. I realize Sony isn't the only one doing this but with every iteration it feels like they are trying to be as crap as possible.
- neiman 6y agoIf I had the resources, I would establish an organization for privacy badges for products. From "absolutely anonymous", through "necessary violations of privacy for function" till "unnecessary harvesting of data". Till such an organization for handing out badges will exist, it will be a hard task to buy any hardware and being able to trust its privacy.
- jakub_g 6y ago~ https://tosdr.org/ https://tosdr.org/
- neiman 6y agoThanks, looks great.
- teddyh 6y agoRespects Your Freedom Certification: https://ryf.fsf.org/ https://ryf.fsf.org/
- tgsovlerkhgsel 6y agoWith GDPR in place, "unnecessary harvesting of data" should in theory be a thing in the past (unless the user explicitly makes a voluntary choice to opt-in after being informed of the options). Reality is different, but NGOs can in theory sue to make reality align better with the intent of GDPR. NOYB (https://noyb.eu https://noyb.eu) is supposed to be such an NGO, and they seem to be doing a decent job so far, although they're limited in what they can do with their resources, facing a never-ending wall of vendors that blatantly violate GDPR.
- neiman 6y agoAfaik GDPR allows harvesting of data as long as I agree to that in the user agreement. The problem is of course that more than once I found out the user agreements after purchasing the product, when it was too late. (I live in the EU, so GDPR is relevant to me)
- fffernan 6y agoI'm wondering if someone could file HIPAA complaint at them and get these things classified as Medical Devices and shut this sharing of bio data down. A simple opt-out doesn't fly with HIPAA. It requires a signature that you will allow another person to access your medical records.
- coronadisaster 6y agoThis reminds me that I still need to root my phone so that I can remove Google's crapware...
- RealStickman_ 6y agoIt'd probably be easier to just go and flash lineageos and microG (if you need that) than trying to remove google stuff.
- coronadisaster 6y agoThat's probably what i should do... Hopefully my phone is fully supported.
- maps7 6y agoAs someone with both Bose QC IIs and the Sony WH-1000MX, this is annoying but not much I can do about it - they're expensive and I doubt I could resell them for as much (would reselling even be ethical now?). I also really like noise cancelling, especially now I am working from home.
- jakereps 6y agoI mean you can just not use the apps, can’t you? The headphones don’t magically ship data home through the device. The app is what you agree to their privacy policy through and is what reads all the metadata through usage and then sends it home. I deleted all of my headphone apps the first time I saw the note about sending all audio titles to Bose in the privacy policies.
- maps7 6y agoOh that's fine then. I don't use the apps at all - I think they were required on set up though.
- barry27 6y agoGood to see everyone responding in true HN style and just telling us about their own lives. Well done everyone on your choice of headphones. Did anyone else wonder how the headphones achieved the feat of measuring the author's leg length without their knowledge? Or of collecting menstruation statistics? I didnt know there was a Menstruation API on phones these days. In short, the author bought a pair of headphones that promise to do all sorts of amazing stats and then found it alarming when the headphones said that in order to do these stats they'd need some data.
- duxup 6y agoTIL, Headphones have apps. Apps are quickly becoming this weird add on that I really don't want.
- luckycharms810 6y agoApps are the new drivers.
- duxup 6y agoMan I vaguely recall when you could use an .ini file as a driver in windows back in the day...
- maest 6y agoThe move to no-jack phones really only exacerbates this problem. It's difficult for manufacturers to justify an app for wired headphones, but, now that bluetooth is becoming the new norm, there's suddenly a justification for instrusive, data-collecting apps. This whole story is a really good reason for keeping headphone jacks on phones.
- dkersten 6y agoI would rather give up on a smartphone than give up on my wireless headphones. Hell, I was without a phone for a few months a couple of years back and it felt liberating. It’ll be my excuse to be a permanent smartphone luddite.
- flukus 6y agoI did the same, went without a phone for a few weeks (getting repaired/replaced) and it taught me a lot about how much I was overusing it. The most important change was turning off nearly all notifications (interruptions), but I've slid back into other bad habits like mobile reddit/HN since. I've toyed with the idea of going back to a dedicated MP3 player for music and audio books, they should be cheaper and smaller than the last time I had one and with actual buttons they have a superior user interface (phones are versatile but a bit shit at everything). After that I could probably ditch a smart phone entirely.
- dkersten 6y agoI actually made a conscious effort not to idly listen to music anymore, so when I listen now, its purely for the enjoyment of listening to music. When I go for a walk, I listen to nature and let my mind drift without constant stimulation. I enjoy the music a lot more this way. Yeah, I find 90% of what I use my iphone fir, I could really do without, like social media. When this phone dies, I plan on getting a cheap dumb one for emergency calls (I can still communicate with friends over IM on a laptop) and not replace the smartphone. The experience taught me that I do not need to be stimulated all the time and I don’t need to be connected or reachable all the time. It felt liberating knowing that when I left home/office and was out of wifi reach, that I wouldnn’t get bothered by work requests. It felt liberating knowing that, while inconveint at times, I had to arrange a time and place to meet people, and we had to thennstick to it, instead of “i’ll call you when I’m near, whenever ir whetever that may be”. The only reason I went back to having a phone is a family member got annoyed and bought me one, but a middle ground would have been to get a dumb (phone calls and SMS only) phone, rather than a smartphone or going without a phone completely like I did.
- deeblering4 6y agoNot mine! They are wired, and will always be.
- colecut 6y agoI have both Beats Wireless noise cancelling headphones (provided by work) and Bose wireless noise cancelling.. I have never even thought about downloading the apps for either of them. I never even thought to consider if they have apps. I just bluetooth to my phone and listen to music. Am I really missing out?
- qwerty456127 6y agoWe just should to stop tolerating conventional things using Internet connection. There is no way headphones really need an Internet-connected app to work and even to let you use advanced functions (i.e. all the configuration can be implemented in a purely offline app). And if they don't need they should not even nudge, let alone require, you to install such. Most of the people just don't give a uck, somebody competent on the state level should give it.
- IgniteTheSun 6y ago"We just should to stop tolerating conventional things using Internet connection." Given IoT and 5G how can you stop this?
- titzer 6y agoIn Soviet Russia, headphones listen to you!
- dilandau 6y agoYeah, because some asshole business team decided that why should anyone sell a decent product anymore, when you can squeeze your customers for their personal information, and have a recurring/ongoing revenue stream? It's like these shit-tier blogs and webdevs, who are tracking every single thing you do on their sites. Are they just incapable of creating? all this tracking...it's anti-creative in the extreme. Mechanical, soulless, lowest common denominator. It's medium.com and web 3.0. Where's the exit bros?
- vladTheInhaler 6y agoI see a lot of people talking about Bose and Sony and their awful apps, but there are alternatives! I have been using my Sennheiser PXC 550's for almost a year now with no software updates or other nonsense. If it has an app, I certainly don't know about it. About the only complaint I have is how easy it is to accidentally hang up on someone with the touch controls on the ear. Normally I support more organized solutions, but this seems like a clear case of voting with your wallet.
- kkapelon 6y agoIt has an app. And unfortunately the app is the only way to set noise reduction to any level other than 0%, 50%, 100% (that is available with the hardware button). If for example you want noise reduction to 75% you need to use the app. Same for changing the sound profiles from the defaults.
- shadowprofile77 6y agoTruly, is it possible for tech companies today to release even one fucking product, even something so simple as headphones, without piling on all the desperate, grubby, scummy tracking bloat and related shit possible in an effort to turn you into a product EVEN when you're paying for their creations. It's revolting and sincerely deserves to be harshly punished by the market (if enough consumers could be bothered to give enough of a shit about something so "irrelevant" as their basic privacy).
- briandear 6y agoYou mean like Beats or Apple AirPods? They don’t collect user data at all.
- shadowprofile77 6y agoMy exasperated comment isn't meant to deny that products like these don't exist, it's more of a recrimination of those companies (and they are far too many, with it becoming steadily more habitual among them all the time) which simply can't keep themselves from squeezing and grubbing and pawing at our personal information for the sake of every last drop of monetization taken to disgusting levels of disrespect even for paying customers. All of it justified by cliche boilerplate nonsense about "caring for your' privacy" while they cram as much of the opposite down your throat as possible. I don't care that maybe, just maybe, company X doesn't sell my personal information as a user of theirs to third parties (though I steadily doubt more and more about the claims of any company promising that it doesn't, and then there are also unintentional data leaks of things they supposedly don't keep stored) I also want goddam company X itself to not pry into my life so much just because I use a fucking pair of headphones or a blender, or a refrigerator or any number of other products that are being designed more often by the day to track everything you do with them and feed it all back to their creators. The sheer arrogance of the whole trend deserves much more criticism than it gets.
- zeveb 6y ago> You mean like Beats or Apple AirPods? They don’t collect user data at all. They may not, but Beats and Apple — the former is a subsidiary of the latter — lock one into a proprietary ecosystem in which your data is not your data (just try sharing iCloud photos with Android users), you have no right to run, view, modify or share the software you depend on, your message security rests 100% on the corporate goodwill of Apple and any government which can force Apple to do its will (your iMessages are end-to-end encrypted … to whatever keys Apple says belong to your correspondents; Apple can add new keys at will). And of course Apple are also doing their best to replace the standard headphone jack with crufty, battery-draining, CPU-requiring Bluetooth. Headphones capable of running Bluetooth are headphones capable of collecting data about you, because they need some sort of processor to speak the Bluetooth protocol. Headphones which are composed of wire and drivers aren't capable of anything other than playing or receiving audio.
- loktarogar 6y agoI just went on 2 12+ hour flights and every few minutes my phone had a "These aren't your airpods" or similar message. I had no airpods, they were someone elses on the flights, but they still interacted with my phone often.
- rkagerer 6y agoWhen you buy food there's a label on the package that tells you what's in it. When you buy cigarettes there's a big warning label about the risk to your health. I think consumer devices need something like that. Imagine browsing an aisle and seeing a label on the package like "WARNING: These earbuds phone home with the track names you play, your GPS location and menstruation cycle history." How many people do you think will buy that box vs. the cheap $20 pair with the analog plug?
- trickstra 6y agoBut... they do. When you install the app, people routinely agree with "This app wants access to your contact list, storage, internet, and to run at startup". But I get your point, it should be on the box, before you buy the hardware. Currently they can easily argue that you can install the software from appstore, check the required permissions, before even buying the hardware. But that's not enough.
- lm28469 6y ago> "This app wants access to your contact list, storage, internet, and to run at startup" If you don't agree most of the time the app quits and you can't use the product you bought.
- Can_Not 6y agoThe vast majority of bluetooth headphones don't even mention their Bluetooth version!
- datashaman 6y agoIt would be neat if we could sandbox specific mobile apps.
- c3534l 6y agoCan we all just take a step back and appreciate what a techno-dystopia we're living in that this is now a headline no one bats an eye about?
- mindfulhack 6y agoI first really appreciated your thought - indeed, the fact that "Headphones are collecting personal data" alone feels like something unacceptable and shocking compared to just 10 years ago. But then I had a counter thought: You know how in the early 20th century people said the dawn of recorded music would make 'music dead'? And many other examples of new tech being hailed as dystopian / would cause the end of the world? Sometimes the fear response to newness and unfamiliarity can be a little unhelpful. I think it's our lizard brains responding there. So I guess what I'm saying is: The fact that a new situation is so different to an old one you were used to, isn't a cogent argument against the new situation. Some new tech is genuinely awesome, and old things are genuinely terrible, e.g. old forms of industrialisation were terribly pollutive compared to forms used today. I'm a person who greatly values my privacy, and doesn't follow the crowd - but perhaps one needs to compare on merits alone, not on the fact that things have changed.
- rchaud 6y agoI certainly batted an eye. I bought my first pair of bluetooth headphones in 2012 and I am only now finding out that some require you to install an app to use. Absurd.
- square_usual 6y agoOT, but that is the worst dickbar I've ever seen.
- kerneltime 6y agoMy LG washer dryer app needs to know my location... why? They won’t let me add it without giving app location access.. so does the YI camera now.. this is getting a bit out of hand.
- DanielleMolloy 6y agoTo those only looking for the noise cancelling component of modern headphones: I was only interested in this as I already have a good pair of (wired, offline) hi-fi headphones, and given some HN comments on this I decided for Peltor x5a passive noise cancelling earmuffs. No batteries to charge and become disfunctional with time, no spy-apps, no potential hearing damage from ANC (not sure what the status is here), no cables, no bluetooth issues; and you get Peltors for 15-30$ so no problem if they break because you stored them in the bottom of a bag. My growing collection of low tech might look a bit dorky but I love it.
- everdrive 6y agoWhen I was younger, I was wondering what it would feel like to to feel 'left behind' by technology. I remember helping so many adults to navigate a world they didn't understand. They'd ask "left click or right click?" every time I asked them to use their mouse. They just couldn't grasp some of the context. This is not quite the same thing, but I'm starting to feel that perhaps I am starting to witness that same disconnect. Having read the title alone, I wondered "how are the headphones collecting data?" Oh, there's an app. Why would you need an app for headphones? It simply never occurred to me.
- darthrupert 6y agoYeah, I'm getting more and more convinced about my purchase strategy for electronics: 1. Get as simple and durable as possible 2. If it has to be complex, get something made by Apple 3. There's no rule three
- chooseaname 6y agoGive me a dumb pair of headphones with a 3.5mm jack and I'm happy. Edit: Thinking about this article more, it really goes back to hardware not getting funding unless there's a model for recurrent income. It's going to get a LOT worse before we either wise up or give up.
- sukilot 6y agoIt's hard to muster up the energy to worry about the privacy policies of luxury toys for rich people.
- AlexandrB 6y agoAs with other instances of privacy overreach, this will trickle down to cheaper tech products in an even more invasive way - e.g. cheap "smart" TVs that collect everything they can. If even the rich people can't "muster up the energy" to defend themselves from data collection, I think we're all well and truly fucked.