39 ms·
James Damore and three others end Google suit
- kyrieeschaton 7y agoIt was a joint request to dismiss with no further comment, ie, almost certainly a settlement & a nondisclosure agreement.
- CalChris 7y agoProbably not much, court costs and some attorney's fees. They weren't winning.
- duxup 7y agoI'd be curious what the agreement is if only because it didn't seem like he had much in the way of a strong with case.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- koheripbal 7y agoAre you serious? He was fired for his political views.
- duxup 7y agoYou feel his case was strong?
- LurkersWillLurk 7y agoYou say this as though it's plainly obvious that it wasn't. The truth is that it depends, and not on whether or not we think his political views are ridiculous. The causes of action in the lawsuit were unlawful termination on account of political activities (which are protected in California) and sex (which is protected federally). Google made three motions to dismiss and lost all of them. Does that mean Google is guilty? Of course not. All it means is that the claim stated by Damore, if true, could convince a reasonable jury that Google violated his civil rights. Google would much rather pay out settlement money than risk having an unflattering jury verdict or have to release even more unflattering documents in discovery. I'm sure Damore would rather not go to trial if he could help it as well.
- duxup 7y agoI'm not convinced it was because of his "political views" is an automatic fact. People say "political views", that's how he might frame it, but I would assume Google would frame it as they fired him for making statements that women are less capable.
- rbanffy 7y agoIt could be considered political in countries and political systems that consider women as second class citizens and bar them from holding elected office or other positions of responsibility, or if he was advocating for the adoption of such model.
- mdorazio 7y agoThen they would lose because he did not say that.
- afiori 7y agoI feel this comment is a good summation of this conversation. I do not know whether you would agree with the presumed Google's opinion, but a big part of this entire "scandal" is that Damore never said that women are less capable.
- ryan-c 7y agoAre there protected classes based on political views? If someone is expressing political or even religious views that are so extreme that they create a hostile work environment, I don't see an issue with firing them over it. (I am not interested in debating whether or not Damore's views reached the "hostile work environment" threshold)
- LurkersWillLurk 7y agoNone federally. In California, "political activities" are a protected class. The extent to which activities and views overlap is almost certainly a messy question of law that I'm not qualified to answer with respect to Damore.
- dx87 7y agoCalifornia treats political views as a protected class.
- roenxi 7y ago> If someone is expressing political or even religious views that are so extreme that they create a hostile work environment, I don't see an issue with firing them over it. There is a process, and step one in that process is asking them to please stop sharing their views in the workplace. Expressing extremely wrong views can't be the standard for creating a hostile work environment because people are wrong about a bunch of stuff and the only way to figure that out is to express the view and be told why it is wrong. Particularly in the Damore case, the standard shouldn't be how a third party feels. There is a long history of seeing how that standard plays out, it'll end up hurting minority voices. The standard needs to be how a first party responds when asked to do something.
- rbanffy 7y agoIs sexism a political view? Edit: burn, karma, burn
- TA0x0 7y agoFacts are sexist and racist!
- TA0x0 7y agoAre facts racist and sexist?
- shadowgovt 7y agoHistory shows interpretation of facts can be extremely racist and sexist. Phrenology and hysteria both come to mind.
- TA0x0 7y agoPhrenology and hysteria are not facts, and their interpretations are not facts either. Some facts are not open to interpretation.
- shadowgovt 7y agoThey were definitely understood to be facts at the time people believed them.
- TA0x0 7y agoThose were theories to describe specific phenomenas, not facts. Knock knock, science 101 is at the door calling for you.
- TA0x0 7y agoThose were theories to describe specific phenomenas, not facts. Certain facts are indisputable and not open to interpretation: FACT: African-Americans are more likely to commit violent crimes than Asian Americans.
- afiori 7y agoThe case could be constructed as being fired due to the backlash caused to google. Damore would have had to prove that there was a active discrimination at google toward some political views. He had some good evidence for that (in terms of internal conversations and witnesses) but it is not so clear whether that was enough, or even if it was necessarily illegal in this case.
- shadowgovt 7y agoOnce the NLRB disagreed with that assessment, his case got pretty weak.
- tyingq 7y agoDon't know if it was strong, but a judge did dismiss Google's motions to toss it out of arbitration last year. https://www.mercurynews.com/2019/06/07/google-discrimination-case-first-brought-by-james-damore-can-proceed/ https://www.mercurynews.com/2019/06/07/google-discrimination...
- lettergram 7y agoMy thoughts as well - makes sense. It's going to continue to bring Google a headache, especially with conservatism on the apparent rise (i.e. still could have Trump in 2024). Far easier to settle with a non-disclosure clause and an agreement to halt all public appearances. James Damore went on a campaign of visiting universities and other locations to discuss his views. Honestly, it was a good move, his case was weak, but the publicity seems to have paid off.
- saagarjha 7y ago> still could have Trump in 2024 You mean you think he'll lose this election but come back to win the next one?
- mirimir 7y agoMaybe Trump Jr ;)
- toyg 7y agoWouldn’t put it past him. Berlusconi kinda did that, alternating wins and losses fairly regularly over 20 years (while his opponents changed every few years). I think he started younger than Trump though.
- znpy 7y agoAs an Italian, I would still prefer Berlusconi to Trump for presidency. Still not my first choice (and not high on my preference list) but still better than Trump.
- bobmcbobface 7y ago"Italian"
- marktangotango 7y agoExactly this; I just wonder what the settlement amount was. Seven figures plus certainly. I applaud anyone who sticks it to a mega corp, politics be damned! Edit down voters love mega corps?
- CydeWeys 7y agoI wonder if it's enough for him to retire on, because I don't see how he could work in the industry again. I sure as hell wouldn't want to go out that way though, even for fuck you money.
- vmception 7y agoI think conversations can be had with people like him, instead of taking the worst part of their views and ostracizing them for it. I think it is fine to acknowledge angst in the implementation of progressive ideals, that angst will often be mixed in with purely insensitive and uneducated thoughts. There are productive outcomes possible by parsing and separating those issues. I think it has been a big mistake of tech platforms - and really the people in the geographical area they are in - to simply be content with deplatforming people, assuming they are irreconcilable. It only emboldens, it doesn't stop the spread of disagreement, and from my perspective there really is a lot of common ground which is really just angst in implementation of progressive ideals.
- azinman2 7y agoExcept this wasn’t a conversation between people. It was an email blast nobody asked for or opted into.
- JPKab 7y agoIt was purposely leaked from an internal message board by an employee who didn't like the content.
- duxup 7y agoWas it an random email or on Google's internal discussion boards?
- KungFuJohnny 7y agoMuch like your post.
- duxup 7y agoAgreed. Even beyond that there is this desire for people to note something is wrong with how someone said it, spelling or just about anything....and that is used in place of actually discussing the topic. Nobody cares what anyone actually means it seems. They'd rather bicker about the minutia around it to discount whatever anyone said. I've been told by other people on the internet what I really meant when I said a thing, told them that isn't what I think...and have them tell me again that I think that thing. It can be surreal.
- olivermarks 7y agoIt's not that quiet if Bloomberg is writing about it...
- BubRoss 7y agoGoogle quietly gave a press release to Bloomberg so they could quietly show it to thousands of people.
- olivermarks 7y agoExactly...
- unnouinceput 7y ago...And we quietly read and comment on HN
- BubRoss 7y agoI hope you aren't trying to make some sort of point about hypocrisy here. No one here is claiming they are posting on a public forum "quietly".
- unnouinceput 7y agoIt's a joke, lighten up
- gamechangr 7y agoIts a settlement
- saagarjha 7y agoCan we somehow get “Damore” in the title?
- fortran77 7y agoSadly, the person who leaked conversations on an internal, proprietary corporate messaging system was never held accountable for her actions.
- jimbob45 7y agoIf I had designed the system, I would have made it a fireable offense to knowingly leak something from the platform. Without a penalty, this kind of situation was both foreseeable and inevitable.
- 8f2ab37a-ed6c 7y agoThat would have been a PR disaster for Google. Woman retaliated against for whisteblowing the company's sexism for the whole world to see. She would have been made a hero.
- jimbob45 7y agoIt was a semi-private, opt-in platform to my understanding. There is no reason to think Damore pushed his sexism into his day-to-day work.
- DoofusOfDeath 7y agoPerhaps I'm naive or uninformed, but I could believe that Damore has clean hands.
- bpsh 7y agoWonder how much money he got to shut up
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- duxup 7y agohttps://outline.com/HtuMWS https://outline.com/HtuMWS
- look_lookatme 7y agoDamore does not fit into the neat ideological right or left classification but it would be impossible for an institution like Bloomberg to have nuance on this issue. Just because some deplorable lifted him up doesn't mean he should be defined specifically on an ideological axis. But, of course, who gives a fuck. The rage machine rages on.
- azinman2 7y agoBut he did become an alt-right / Fox News / conservative machine darling.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- whatshisface 7y agoOf course, "I have to hate it because opposing media likes it" is no more rational than "I have to like it because allied media likes it."
- look_lookatme 7y agoAnd Snowden defected to Russia. Sometimes you just have to go where you are free to state your case and not be shouted down which sometimes means an enemy-of-my-enemy scenario.
- seemslegit 7y agoSnowden did not "defect to Russia", he got stuck in Russia while in transit after the US cancelled his passport.
- dijit 7y agoSeems like you and the parent are agreeing.
- 7y ago
- daenz 7y agoI remember at a previous job, a female engineer talking to other engineers when the Damore story broke. She said "I can't believe he said that women can't be good engineers" and indicated he deserved to be fired. As someone who actually read what he wrote, I just had to bite my tongue. That's not what he said at all, but even making the distinction makes you one of "them" and politicizes the workplace. It's just disappointing that these little whirlwinds of misinformation bullshit get to circle around and everybody just has to nod their heads.
- sandov 7y agoSites like Bloomberg spread this misinformation [1]. The same site of the thread we're commenting on. Maybe we in HN could stop giving publicity to websites that spread fake news. [1] First paragraph of https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2018-03-05/harmeet-dhillon-wants-silicon-valley-to-be-safe-for-conservatives https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2018-03-05/harmeet-d...
- starchild_3001 7y agoThe dude is talking about probabilities and distributions, while the stats-ignorant public is generalizing to every individual. It's impossible to have a scientific and open minded debate about the differences between genders. Even theorizing biologic differences exist makes you a sexist. Let alone bringing up this question in public. Edit: Yes, his memo is totally tone deaf. I thought his wording was very questionable. But the his core argument (regarding differences in biology leading to differences in distributions) is worth debating. Example: There's a noticeable distributional difference in 100m running times between genders (due to biology). That said any number of men or women are faster runners than me :) Population doesn't mean anything for the individual.
- mirimir 7y ago> Even theorizing biologic differences exist makes you a sexist. Eggs vs sperm -- plumbing aside -- is a fundamental biologic difference. And bringing a pregnancy to term, and delivering without bleeding out, sort of requires a uterus. But of course, it's gotta stop there. Edit: If someone wants to explain away such differences, I'd love to see the argument.
- streamingvac 7y agoI work in a tech company based in Silicon Valley. I also have a pretty conservative view. I like trump for standing up to Chinese government, even before the whole Coronavirus event. I despise the Chinese government, especially since the coronavirus took away two of my friends’ grandparents. Every once a while I will Chitchat with my coworkers and my view about the Chinese government will surface. And my coworkers are mainly liberal. And guess what? They will avoid the Chinese government topic like the plague. Even suggesting that it could be racist. I was dumbfounded. These are some of the smartest tech folks. Yet they are somehow ignorant, even afraid, to criticize a government run by a dictator that clearly Waged war on all of humanity (I am not just talking about coronavirus). What explains liberals avoidance with Chinese government?
- threeseed 7y agoPolitics doesn't belong in a professional environment. So employees should be avoiding the topic.
- streamingvac 7y agoMy coworkers have no problem discussing Donald trump and republicans. They laugh about our president a lot. Yet when I bring up the Chinese government, silence could be heard.
- BurningFrog 7y agoAre they discussing politics or bonding over their contempt of Trump? Those are quite different things.
- sullyj3 7y agoI despise Trump, but claiming that talking about his shortcomings is an apolitical conversation is totally disingenuous. Politics isn't this bloodless process of determining the best policies by rational debate, as much we'd like it to be. Politics, as often as not, consists entirely of making the other team look bad, to raise the relative status of your own team. That's just how humans operate.
- yakshaving_jgt 7y agoSeems unfair and propagandist to characterise Damore this way.
- conception 7y agoThis topic is quickly going downhill in the comments, but I just wanted to clear some stuff up because there seems to be some "what he said isn't that bad!" People wrongly think he said women are bad or stupid but that's not what he did say. He also didn't -just- say men and women are different. He did say a 5-10% difference in certain traits is why there are huge discrepancies of women in leadership and science/engineering positions. And maybe that's ok and we should just let it be. Sorry, but "girls don't like to make hard choices or do 'nerdy' things" isn't a real thing. Hundreds of years of "stay in the kitchen" is what proactive programs to bring women into these positions are trying to reverse. It's not biological.
- exogeny 7y agoBe careful. This thread is already full of sensitive dudes who resent the idea that maybe, just maybe, they've gotten to their grand positions because of subtle biases that negatively affected other cohorts while benefiting them. The fragility is oh so very, very real.
- missingrib 7y ago>Sorry, but "girls don't like to make hard choices or do 'nerdy' things" isn't a real thing. Hundreds of years of "stay in the kitchen" is what proactive programs to bring women into these positions are trying to reverse. It's not biological. Why do you think that?
- zozbot234 7y ago> is what proactive programs to bring women into these positions are trying to reverse. The difference in interests is biggest in the most "proactive" countries, those that try the hardest to help women reach social equality with men. It's obviously not "biological", but it looks like some complex interaction of subtle social dynamics, not just women being told to "stay in the kitchen".
- sz4kerto 7y ago> Hundreds of years of "stay in the kitchen" is what proactive programs to bring women into these positions are trying to reverse. It's not biological. This is what the debate is about -- can we accept these kind of ex cathedra declarations without data or not.
- neonate 7y agohttps://archive.md/PCQUT https://archive.md/PCQUT
- alexis_fr 7y agoThe James Damore affair made me realize that women and defenders of women are highly bad faithed, and I hadn’t noticed before how much women were incompetent. Before that I used to believe we were on a level playing field. After that I noticed that women are aggressively defended and despite that, it has been a century that they didn’t succeed. I clearly don’t want to work with women anymore, and since I’ve started only working in all-male companies, my pay has doubled, because we don’t have dead weight on board. I couldn’t care less what Damore said scientifically. I just know it hasn’t been discussed.
- dang 7y agoYou can't post like this here. No more of this, please. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- Smaug123 7y agoWould it be too much to ask that we collectively say "The Damore thing is obviously a [scissor statement](https://slatestarcodex.com/2018/10/30/sort-by-controversial/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2018/10/30/sort-by-controversial/), on which otherwise-reasonable people bafflingly manage to hold different views very strongly, and we should stop talking about it forthwith because no good can come of it"? Nothing new can be said on the subject, vanishingly few people can be persuaded one way or the other, and "news site primarily populated by shortform comments" is hardly the appropriate place to hold a protracted argument.
- bitcharmer 7y agoI don't think shutting down discourse is a positive thing.
- Smaug123 7y agoThis is the problem, though. That discourse is not productive, when held here - witness the dumpster fire of downvotes all over the place. If the topic needs discussion, it needs long and nuanced discussion where each party is trying hard to understand the other - not rapid-fire three-line comments on a news site.
- zozbot234 7y agoDo you know of any other place for this discussion that would be better-suited to nuance and genuine intellectual curiosity ("each party ... trying hard to understand the other")? Downvites are quite common here, in any discussion.
- Smaug123 7y agoThis is kind of why people are meant to have blogs. A network of blogs where people can maintain historical records of their thinking, for example. Scott Alexander is a great example of this: every so often we get a "contra PERSON on SUBJECT", a long well-thought-out discussion with nuance and a good-faith attempt to understand the argument under criticism. And people reply with their own long-form blogs in a similar vein.
- spoonsies 7y agoWas it Damore or Kevin Cernekee who quietly joined Apple to work on macos? I’m curious if they continue to be so outspoken there. My guess is their views would have to be kept to themselves. Apple really doesn’t tolerate unwanted attention.
- gameswithgo 7y agoGoogle has fired a few people, liberal and conservative, for being politically insufferable. Multiple people in the news about this on various places in political spectrum. It doesn’t mean they were wrong.
- coldtea 7y ago>for being politically insufferable In other words for hurting their bottom line by demanding Google be better (each in their preferred way) for society and its employees?
- jefftk 7y agoFiring organizers was an example of that: https://medium.com/@GoogleWalkout/google-fired-us-for-organizing-were-fighting-back-d0daa8113aed https://medium.com/@GoogleWalkout/google-fired-us-for-organi... I don't think firing Damore was? (Disclosure: I work for Google, speaking only for myself)
- rendall 7y agoJeff, I work for Google HR. Let's have a chat on Monday morning, please. Edit: It is a joke. I am joking. I don't work for Google HR, and poor Jeff is not up for an HR "chat". Even if the poor fellow were actually in trouble with a spectacularly uptight HR person, I doubt they would contact him through HN.
- mabbo 7y agoDamore committed the ultimate sin in the corporate world- he caused a huge PR mess. Let's set aside the content of his memo (I personally don't agree with what he said) and just appreciate that he made a mess. As has been said before, if your CEO learns your name for the same reason he has to end his vacation early, you probably should start polishing up your resume.
- discordance 7y agoYet he still got a payout
- spangry 7y agoIf making a mess is what gets you fired, shouldn't google have gone after whoever leaked the memo, instead of Damore?
- tgsovlerkhgsel 7y agoThey are likely a) harder to find b) firing Damore is more likely to satisfy the loudest group while firing the leaker is going to rile them up more.
- sacks2k 7y agoIt wouldn't be that hard to find. "firing the leaker is going to rile them up more." It seems our society has devolved into satisfying the mob rather than doing the right thing these days. I've seen some of the comments from internal Google groups that were since leaked after this incident. Some of the most horrible thoughts and opinions were posted, with actual real names, but nobody got punished or fired. Why? Because they were progressive/hard-left thoughts and opinions. This is all about politics and has nothing to do with right or wrong. It's just more proof that these large tech companies are becoming the equivalent of fascist governments that police our thoughts and opinions....and punish us for wrongthink.
- curmudgeont653 7y ago
- epr 7y agoI'm going to go ahead and call bullshit on anyone claiming that a difference in interests does not equate to a difference in capabilities. Think about fields you are passionate about vs. fields you couldn't care less about. Do you honestly think you could excel equally in both fields? If you are going to make the argument then don't insult everyone else's intelligence by watering it down. As freedom in a society increases, women increasingly choose different professions than men. The extent to which these reflect their innate interests rather than those imposed on them by society has a direct relationship to their relative capabilities to men in these fields in the aggregate.
- varjag 7y agoPlenty people here suggest Damore's something smart, can I see his GitHub?
- seemslegit 7y ago"As part of and a central stipulation of this agreement, the plaintiff agrees not to purchase a luxury convertible vehicle and drive it around Sunnyvale while having scantily clad models recite his original memo through megaphones."
- ykevinator 7y agoNice way to make a buck, now off to fox News!
- somewhereoutth 7y agoI am shocked that there is even a discussion to be had on this. In architecture (a somewhat older profession, but also concerning things constructed by people), women previously did have a hard time, and often had to practice under their husbands/partners name. Mercifully this ended some while ago, and now architecture schools and onwards are more evenly gender balanced. Nobody suggests that women are somehow naturally 'less inclined', and the profession is richer for it. It would be great if engineering could get to this point.
- spangry 7y agoWhat country is this? In my country (Australia), the percentage of licensed female architects is around 20%, and this percentage seems to be about the same in the USA and UK. Europe seems a little better with around 30% female representation.
- somewhereoutth 7y agoUK. The architecture schools are certainly evenly mixed for students, though I agree this may not yet have fed through to the higher reaches of the profession.
- zozbot234 7y agoNot just architecture, also medicine and law. The whole question is what's different about math, CS, engineering and the physical sciences that makes it so much harder to reach gender balance there? If you look at the commonalities that these fields share, the "things, not people" aspect is the most prominent by far.
- fzeroracer 7y agoThat doesn't follow suit with the history of computer science however. Women were a large amount of computer science grads back in the 70s and 80s where it was even more difficult and arguably less social then modern development. Nowadays software dev is highly collaborative and social. It faced declining amounts of graduates that were women from the late-80s and onwards compared to engineering and the physical sciences which if I'm recalling correctly have steadily rose.
- aortega 7y agoClearly a settlement, meaning he basically won. That's a big message to other organizations implementing similar codes of conduct.
- DonHopkins 7y ago>"Meanwhile, a judge opined it wouldn’t be easy for two fellow plaintiffs to prevail on their “novel” theory that Google is biased against “political conservatives” -- a term the company argued was too vague to support a class-action suit." Especially since anyone who rightfully calls themselves a "political conservative" has long since left the Republican party after it left them, and doesn't consider themselves an "alt right" Trump supporter.
- bobmcbobface 7y agoTHERE'S A HUGE SHORTAGE OF MEN IN NURSING! THIS IS OBVIOUSLY DUE TO INHERENT SEXISM AND FEMALE TOXICITY! HOW DO WE SOLVE THIS ISSUE?
- hpliferaft 7y agoIf you take 30 seconds to Google you'll find a bunch of sources that indicate the low percentage of men in nursing is nuanced. It's not just toxicity or gatekeeping. Examples: "Research indicates that ideas of masculinity prevent men from pursuing a career in nursing." - https://www.npr.org/2018/10/02/653570048/why-more-men-dont-get-into-the-field-of-nursing https://www.npr.org/2018/10/02/653570048/why-more-men-dont-g... "The problem is that notions of masculinity die hard, in women as well as men." https://www.nytimes.com/2017/06/24/opinion/sunday/men-dont-want-to-be-nurses-their-wives-agree.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/06/24/opinion/sunday/men-dont-w... "Some tasks require getting in a patient’s personal space and some patients may prefer to request a female nurse." https://www.rasmussen.edu/degrees/nursing/blog/men-in-nursing/ https://www.rasmussen.edu/degrees/nursing/blog/men-in-nursin...
- jacobriis 7y agoLow percentage of men is nuanced, low percentage of women is racist.
- ravenstine 7y agoDamore was not offered a chance to receive forgiveness by either the company or the outrage mob, therefore I don't respect what people generally have to say about whether what he did was right or wrong. It's astounding that people are still debating this in this very HN thread. A society of any size that makes virtue claims while simultaneously adding an undue price to being wrong or insensitive deserves to be mocked and ridiculed. You don't have to agree with anything Demore said, but the fact that Google openly encouraged political discussion, yet had an unwritten rule that if you say anything to upset a particular political demographic that you are terminated, is patently absurd. Companies shouldn't be encouraging employees to be political. We would never tolerate companies that encourage religious discussion but fire employees that say things against the Christian faith. If you're going to come into this thread to refute Damore's memo and downvote people who don't tow your petty little line, your need to reexamine your principles, if you've got one.
- glenda 7y agoI agree with you in theory, but it’s a bit different. If he is making the workplace less comfortable for particular groups of people then I certainly would have no issue firing him. You are free to hold any belief you want, but once you’re in my ear with some misinformed ideas that are potentially hurtful to a large group I am free to tell you to be quiet or leave. Of course, it’s your right not to listen to me... but if I’m your boss you can expect to be fired.
- JSavageOne 7y agoIt's annoying that Bloomberg refers to the memo as being "political" and expressing "political conservatism". The memo was attempting to explain the underrepresentation of women in tech via biological differences. That has literally nothing to do with politics, and framing it as such misrepresents and discredits the contents of the memo.
- ashtonkem 7y agoI think that’s extremely short sighted. Gender politics is politics; anything that comes close to the subject is either already political or will become political extremely quickly.
- JSavageOne 7y ago> Gender politics is politics I don't understand how that statement discredits anything I said. Politics is peoples' opinions and is subjective/normative (eg. things "ought" to be this way). Science attempts to explain how nature works (eg. this is why things are this way), and is objective. That memo was not political.
- ashtonkem 7y agoPolitics is about how resources should be spent, not how things “ought” to be. Posting a disagreement about policy is inherently political, especially about something as charged as gender, no matter how much science you may cite.
- JSavageOne 7y ago> Politics is about how resources should be spent > how things “ought” to be Those are the same thing. > Posting a disagreement about policy is inherently political Yes if his memo was a paragraph saying "We should change our gender policy to X, Y, and Z", then yes it would be political. Instead it is a 10 page document explaining how biological differences may explain gender imbalances, and the implications of this. But sure if you want to dismiss it as "politics", then I guess there's no reasoning with you.
- 11thEarlOfMar 7y agoBe honest. Are you saying: "This statement is false, so I must argue against it." Or are you saying: "I cannot accept the implications of this statement, so I must argue against it."
- fullhd2 7y agoImagine you are the offspring of immigrants who escaped a closed society and made their life in a relatively open one. Now imagine you start a company you fight the good fight and after years of work you created one of the most influential corporate internet giants the works has ever seen. And you think “okay I am going to use this power to make the world a fairer place so that nobody is ever disadvantages because of historical inequalities.” You have a vision for the world and you set about filling up your company with people that share that vision. Then one day this little twerp with a phd joins the lower ranks and starts spreading propaganda that stalls this vision. A porpaganda that has potential to steer the world into one that your parents escaped from. What do you do? You destroy the little piece of shit. Maybe you pay him off. But then you make sure he stays destroyed.
- Igelau 7y agoDestruction for anyone who would "stall the vision" Achievement unlocked: Violent Authoritarian Despot > offspring of immigrants who escaped a closed society Achievement unlocked: Meet the New Boss, Same as the Old Boss
- zozbot234 7y agoI guess OP's point is that authoritarianism is everywhere. Many of the low-level "phd's spreading propaganda" on these contentious issues have authoritarian streaks themselves and even if you don't, making attitudes even more divisive isn't exactly helping anyone.
- fullhd2 7y agoA nazi apologist might also argue that going to war with that sort of regime is a violent despotic act. Let’s be clear. This Damore piece of crap can happily exercise his right to go work for a company that shares his value system. Research what happens to dissenters in “violent authoritarian” systems. Why should he share the winnings of a system that was built on a value system that he diametrically opposes?
- balls187 7y ago> companies in Silicon Valley and beyond have instituted workplace rules designed to protect employees with alternative viewpoints and prevent bullying, Dhillon said. Lipstick on a pig. Racism is racism. Sexism is sexism. If you want to be a racist, sexist person, do it on your own time, not on the company dollar.
- 11thEarlOfMar 7y agoIf you're looking for a little irony, here is Dr. Louanne Brizendine, Neuroscience PhD (Stanford, Yale, Berkeley) discussing how the female and male brains are different AT GOOGLE and with very warm, positive reception: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lu_uGr1ZOn4&t=2s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lu_uGr1ZOn4&t=2s
- lawnchair_larry 7y agoShe has written books on both, and they’re quite interesting. I suppose she has to be cast to the “Intellectual Dark Web” for daring to suggest the obvious fact that our brains work differently. The ultimate irony is that someone can deny such differences while simultaneously arguing for the importance of diversity. What a walking contradiction.
- 11thEarlOfMar 7y ago"We celebrate our diversity, but we cannot talk about what makes us different."
- ryguytilidie 7y agoWell, this takes the cake as the most toxic comments section I've ever seen on HN. The degree of "I'm tired of the left being outraged at the right tearing our country apart but i also couldnt care about the right tearing our country apart, oh also let me normalize hating women" makes me very sad for our future.
- temporalparts 7y agoI don't understand why people are characterizing his firing as political. If you read his memo, it should be clear that he was fired for being sexist. His memo included a section which stated that women are biologically inferior to men. This immediately makes it very difficult to work with him for women and their allies. I know tech skews male, but software engineers have to interface with many other teams and many other functions, especially at Google. If he actually left out the biological differences claim, Google might not have fired him, but that section left Google no choice. I support discourse in general, but from a business/society perspective, you can't immediately make it difficult for a large plurality of your peers (and vast majority if you include allies) to work with you. This is only political because right-wing political organizations have chosen to defend someone's sexist memo AFTER THE FACT, to drive the narrative of how Google is anti-right and is a left-wing puppet company. Calling this a political firing is only coopting their ridiculous narrative that he was fired for expressing "conservative values" or their sexist narrative that those conservative values include the fact that women are biologically inferior.
- Pazzaz 7y ago> His memo included a section which stated that women are biologically inferior to men. Just reread his memo and couldn't find this. Where did he say this?
- ausbah 7y agowell there are some who do believe "biological differences" between the sexes IS the reason for disparities in workforce representation. to them these are the "facts" and people who disagree are those ones politicizing facts and ignoring "truth"
- throwaway4715 7y agoI still do not understand why anyone is confused he got fired. He negatively affected both the company's brand and productivity. He simply wasn't important/useful enough to keep around in light of that. Want more rights then work in a union. Otherwise, don't forget you're employed _at will_.
- screye 7y agoNo better place and time to post this. http://www.paulgraham.com/say.html http://www.paulgraham.com/say.html - Paul Graham's 'What you can't say'
- thinkingemote 7y agoThis discussion is almost textbook flamebait. Indeed the very topic itself was all about flame. It's impossible, I think, to be able to discuss it rationally without falling into our usual traps. Actually for many people to even consider that it is possible to discuss it rationally would be problematic and borderline offensive, for others, the lack of a rational discussion is itself proof of a big problem. That's my observation of these threads - it's a curious game - the only winning move, Professor Falcon, is not to play. How about a nice game of Chess?
- shadowgovt 7y agoThe interest in this story has always intrigued me. What is it about this story that keeps people engaged? Are other engineers concerned they could be fired like Damore for saying the wrong thing?
- lol_u_cuck 6y agoHmm... What is this?
- lol_u_cuck 6y agoLol, right...