23 ms·
I agree in part in that I am skeptical that full self-driving cars will happen in the next few years, but he is completely wrong when it comes to the long term.
by colordrops 7y ago
I agree in part in that I am skeptical that full self-driving cars will happen in the next few years, but he is completely wrong when it comes to the long term. Not only will the tech get as good as humans, but most forget to account for the fact that the environment will meet the cars part way. We will eventually update markings and beacons on the roads to make it easier for the cars, implement networks in which the cars can talk to each other, and make special lanes for self-driving cars only, among other improvements that will make it easier for the cars. Eventually non-self-driving cars will not be allowed on the road, and will be a niche hobby on race tracks.
- oblio 7y ago> implement networks in which the cars can talk to each other And sing kumbaya, holding hands together.... What about adversarial car AIs? Malicious actors, etc.?
- giancarlostoro 7y agoHeck. With Toyota building a city of the future. They might make self driving cars entirely common once you are free to design roads for them.
- chrischen 7y agoYea they could put down visual markers on the road to make it easier for CV or ML models to be trained against, or maybe even physical tracks to mechanically guide these cars so that minimal software is needed. Multiple cars can be linked together for efficiency.
- giancarlostoro 7y agoYeah I think if car manufacturers can come together on standards for signs... And even maybe signs that send RF signals to cars to give them hints of what is nearby it could go a long way. Instead of pretending like the only way is to make cars work with our human friendly system.
- usrusr 7y agoA car that can drive itself in a specifically prepared environment would hardly qualify as "fully self driving". You could achieve that with all the AI prowess of a mechanical connection between the steering linkage and some guide rails. And you'd still fail to get even the tiniest development budget for a car that won't sell anywhere else.
- moooo99 7y agoIf you'd build a genuinely smart city completely from scratch, the most elegant way would be to completely remove the need for own cars. But that's obviously not going to happen when its a project designed and financed by an automaker.
- giancarlostoro 7y agoIt is when you sell them the autonomous cars that people can use and maintain them with the guarantee that they wont breakdown often when used basically.
- semi-extrinsic 7y agoWe can't even bloody keep the yellow markings on the road visible, and "paint" is a technology we've had for thousands of years. Where in dog's name is the money for installing and maintaining all that smart infrastructure going to come from?
- shoulderfake 7y agoPerhaps take 10% of the military budget and you might just have some $ for that
- SECProto 7y agoPaint is a wear item, the example of beacons would not be a wear item. If original commenter is correct that infrastructure meets halfway, I wouldn't expect self driving cars transition to happen fast at all - maybe on highways first, and busy city streets, later secondary roads. But that kind of thing would result in a decades long transition, and I would estimate it as never being fully autonomous (if beacons die, car would need manual intervention)
- ethbro 7y agoThe primary deployment potential for self-driving cars is long haul freight, which could be done exclusively via the interstate system. If we're going to beacon up a road, they easily make the most sense.
- kazen44 7y agothis might be true for the US, but in many parts of europe, roads are far more crowded. not to mention this doesn't solve the last mile problem.
- maxsilver 7y ago> which could be done exclusively via the interstate system. The interstate system already has working self-driving, even without any beacons. Inherently-safe roads like interstate freeways are already almost solved, and you can already buy a Chevrolet today that can self-drive the interstate system 99% of the time. It's all the dangerous roads that need the help. The ones with bicyclists and pedestrians and parked cars and uncontrolled access and such.
- wnevets 7y ago> but most forget to account for the fact that the environment will meet the cars part way Multiple important stake holders seem to have significant incentives to make this happen. Local/state govs want less traffic jams and crashes, auto insurance companies would love to collect premiums and not pay out, Uber, Lyft would love to get rid of their drivers
- macinjosh 7y agoI want an oceanside villa on the dark side of the moon but that's doesn't mean it will happen. Just because there is motivation to do something doesn't mean it is possible.
- wnevets 7y agobut if you had the funds to, why wouldn't you?
- spookthesunset 7y agoBecause there are million other better uses for that money.
- wnevets 7y agosounds like you don't actually want it then.
- gfodor 7y agoOf course it’s possible: we have billions of existence proofs that driving high speed vehicles successfully using sensors equipped to measure light and sound work. The question is how much it takes to replicate that system artificially.
- heisenbit 7y agoI don‘t think high speed is where there is a problem. The challenges lie in the diverse environments where literally anything can happen.
- macinjosh 7y agoThere are millions of miles of roads just in the US that will never have that sort of infrastructure because the cost of keeping beacons running and marking in place would be astronomical. Sure maybe California will have some of that around big population areas but that's probably about it. What happens to all these markings when it snows a couple centimeters?' Fully self driving cars won't happen in our lifetime, probably not this century.
- _red 7y agoits not only lines on the road though: Imagine you are following a pickup-truck and out of the back an obviously empty box floats out of the bed and lands directly in front of your car. For a human its trivial to know the box is empty and its ok to hit it....does "AI" know that? Multiply that case x1000 and you have the conditions self-driving cars will need to handle on a daily basis.
- smileysteve 7y ago> For a human its trivial to know the box is empty and its ok to hit it....does "AI" know that? This is a great anecdote that definitely needs a source to back it up. Primarily, there are a significant number of single vehicle accidents caused by drivers jerking the wheel instead of acting in a calm manner. Secondly, there are many cases where a box is not safe to ignore; that could mean it damaging a fog light, a large staple in it hitting a tire, or it getting stuck somewhere, temporary loss of traction or visibility. In conclusion; anything on the road should be treated as something to avoid, but definitely something to avoid a high speed collision with. Other Anecdotes to consider: The first model S firs was caused by a trailer hitch in the road. Hammer hit a model 3. Asphalt coming loose in slabs and hitting a driver. Mattresses and ice from the roof in front of you. Tldr; There are many accidents that do happen with human drivers.
- _greim_ 7y ago> For a human its trivial... I anecdotally question this based on both personal experience and stories I've heard. It seems like it would be a hard problem for both humans and AIs, however AIs have the edge in the long run due to sheer processing speed.
- F-0X 7y agoI think I am going to side with VW on this. I have always been skeptical of fully autonomous vehicles, and I do not believe they will _ever_ exist on the roads that currently stand. Driving safely in all conditions without aid from a human is simply too complex a task for code that can be audited and verified. If some AI model that's been trained on a billion years of driving experience shows promise, but it is some incomprehensible black box of weights, I won't be getting in that car. Autonomous vehicles will only ever truly exist upon infrastructure literally designed to aid them, greatly simplifying how they need to interact with the environment, thus making the problem tractable with code we can prove works. I really think it will take more than putting markings on existing roads. It is going to take new roads full stop, probably with various wireless checkpoints built into them.
- jsolson 7y agoYou may not be getting in that car, but I certainly will. After all, every driver on the road today is an incomprehensible black box where not only do we not know the parameters, we don't even know the function they're parameterizing. Every instance functions differently, and our testing procedures have woefully low coverage.
- _red 7y agohow do you see insurance working? why would drivers be responsible to have insurance when the car is completely controlled by bigcorp programmers?
- spookthesunset 7y agoInsurance would be a nightmare for a manufacturer. Every accident will initially be pegged to the auto maker (as it should be.. it’s their code!). The auto maker will always try to weasel out and blame the passenger-owners of the car (they didn’t maintain it, the paint was dirty and messed with the sensors, the tire pressure was 2 PSI lower than average). And if you go with the “nobody will own cars, you’ll just summon one” model... well the fleet owner will just sue the manufacturer instead.
- derefr 7y ago> We will eventually update markings and beacons on the roads to make it easier for the cars, implement networks in which the cars can talk to each other, and make special lanes for self-driving cars only, among other improvements that will make it easier for the cars. I feel like the correct way to describe this future isn't "self-driving cars", but rather "personal autonomous trains." In est, the road system described here would just be a rather clumsy railroad network. I interpret the goal of having "self-driving cars" as referring to the ability to have a passenger vehicles that can autonomously navigate (wayfind?) off-road, i.e. what the aim of the DARPA Grand Challenge would eventually evolve into.
- Gene_Parmesan 7y agoIt's my belief that self driving cars will, for a very significant time in the future, still need to make human control possible. Think about the vast amounts of rural roads -- dirt, gravel. Anyone who's ever taken a 4x4 out to a trailhead in the desert knows that sometimes those roads don't even exist except on a map. Washouts can be a weekly problem in certain seasons. But you don't start in the desert, right? You have to take highways at a minimum, and quite likely national interstates as well, to get to the desert roads. Think about attending a festival or fair with grass parking. You follow a line of cars, pull up to a guy who's standing out in the field. He looks around and says, "Why don't you go park next to that red Toyota two rows over?" Sure, that part is not "on the road," but certainly I had to take highways to get there. Maybe I, as an urban-dwelling American, only need functionality like this a few times per year. But there are significant chunks of this country and the world in general where this is part of daily life. Adopting fully self-driving cars without manual driving modes is going to take extreme amounts of change and adaptation, not only technologically but also culturally. I would recommend spending a few weeks in the deep country if you want to fully understand some of the difficulties in reaching level 5. If the time scale you're talking about is on the order of 50 years, I could maybe see it. But I do think there will always be a need for personal vehicles with some level of manual control. Beyond all that, however, this article to me seems like 90% clickbait. The statement merely was "Maybe it will never happen," and it was stated in the context of a discussion of the difficulty in reaching level 5 autonomy. But now we have articles throwing headlines up saying "VW Exec admits fully self driving cars may NEVER happen." Feels a little disingenuous.
- lsc 7y agoeh, something that only works in cities would be pretty nice for more than half of us. If you need an off road vehicle twice a year, you rent one; we have that technology already. (I mean, we're still a long ways away from level 5 in the city.. I'm just saying, something that was level 5 only on pavement and only in the city would be damn useful; and good enough for more than half of us.)
- lawlessquestion 7y agoThe government's endgame for restricting individual liberties and privacy as much as possible would be only allowing self driving cars. As a result, I regretfully agree that this is inevitable and wholly depressing.
- beefield 7y ago> We will eventually update markings and beacons on the roads to make it easier for the cars. Or even easier, platooning. I don't understand why autonomous cars is a bigger thing than platooning. I mean, platooning solves 95% of use cases of self driving cars [1] and is orders of magnitude easier problem to solve. [1] At least for me. I do not mind driving in the cities myself, but if I just could nap or watch a movie on the highway part, that would have some utility
- HereBeBeasties 7y agoIf cars could assemble into close convoy trains on multi-lane highways / motorways / autoroutes / whatever, then it would probably also solve electric car range for many people - you only care about range on relatively long distance journeys, and you're likely to be doing those on major multi-lane carriageways. If you could split the air resistance between a bunch of other vehicles then you'd add considerably to the range. I similarly don't understand why we're not trying to solve that instead. As you say, it seems easy compared to full autonomous driving.
- lsc 7y agohttps://peloton-tech.com https://peloton-tech.com - I mean, that's just one company, I think there are a handful working on just the problem you're talking about.
- beefield 7y agoYes. Can you estimate how much these companies have received funding compared to self-driving tech companies/projects? My wild guess (based only on the general visibility) is that it amounts pretty much to a rounding error.
- lsc 7y agosure, but I think the truck convoy companies are run a little bit more like regular companies than startups? they have a reasonable near-term goal and sales pipeline. Like, I think if you have a couple modern trucks you can go have peloton install their system and you can use it right now.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoAll of this discussion on smart infrastructure is moot, imho, because it won't be guaranteed to be there on all roads and cars will have to be designed to work even when the smart infrastructure breaks down. So this means that self-driving cars will have to safely handle these cases and that also means that it is likely that cars will have to still be able to be driven manually. Bottom line: self-driving cars will have to handle absence of smart infrastructure (in which case do we really need that infrastructure? I think we'll still need it, though, to guide and improve traffic)) and/or cars will continue to be driven manually at least some of the time.
- kazen44 7y ago> All of this discussion on smart infrastructure is moot, imho, because it won't be guaranteed to be there on all roads and cars will have to be designed to work even when the smart infrastructure breaks down. Also, a vast majority of the world doesn't even have proper roads like many western countries do. In many parts of the world a road is not even paved or asphalted, and let's not forget what is actually making use of that road. Seeing animals on roads might be a rare sight in a western country, but in much of the world, the road is shared by more then just passenger cars and trucks.
- lsc 7y agoI dunno. Americans seem to want these giant 4x4s even when they leave the city twice a year; they'd be better off (certainly safer... most trucks are more dangerous for other people and for the occupants) if they had a little car for city driving and rented the off road cargo hauler when they needed it. A city-only car would be totally useful for people who live in cities; you just rent something when you want to go to the boonies. Heck, most BEVs are that way now; I've got like 120 miles of range on mine, which is fine almost all the time. the two or three times a year I need something with more range or with more cargo capacity or what have you, I borrow or rent. I think that the economics of the first level5 cars might be similar to current BEVs, in that you can only go where there is infrastructure. which is where most of us go most of the time.
- mytailorisrich 7y ago
- anotheruser2020 7y agoI like driving, I also like the assistance that modern vehicles provide on Motorways, however, would I ever fully hand over control? Probably not. A Boeing 747 has autopilot.. however 3 pilots sit behind hit to keep an eye on what it's doing.
- erik_seaberg 7y agoSometimes I like driving, but I also like sleeping or hacking or drinking, and it'd be great to have the choice.
- anotheruser2020 7y agoI don't think our generation will ever let a computer take full control.
- robbrown451 7y agoBut how many passengers are on the 747? The ratio of pilot to total people on the plane is often something like 1/100. In a cars it might average 1/1.2 or something. I think that should be improved. Also, on a plane, those pilots are never expected to jump in with 2 seconds notice because something isn't working right. I don't think that is realistic....people zone out, but that is expected in "supervised self driving".
- shrimpx 7y agoThe cost of that infra is so huge, it might be easier to imagine low-altitude self-flying pods.
- spookthesunset 7y agoWhat about dirt forest service roads? What about the dirt parking lot at that wedding you just went to? How will it find a parking spot? How will it get into a ferry where people direct you to the correct spot? How will it deal with an accident up ahead where some drunk bystander is trying to direct traffic? How will it know to ignore the drunk guy? What if it isn’t a drunk guy but a sober person directing traffic? Does the car obey in that case? None of those are edge cases because every time it drives it will encounter some novel edge case that has never happened before and it will have to perform better than a human. Don’t even get started with liability. Once you take away the steering wheel the manufacturer is on the hook for every single mistake and every single accident. You’d be insane to be a manufacturer and sign up for that. Sorry, but self driving cars are a complete fantasy.
- ericd 7y agoHow will it deal with an accident up ahead where some drunk bystander is trying to direct traffic? How will it know to ignore the drunk guy? What if it isn’t a drunk guy but a sober person directing traffic? Does the car obey in that case? Most people wouldn't instantly know how to handle those cases either. Many people would obey the drunk guy. Maybe that's the right thing to do. None of those are edge cases because every time it drives it will encounter some novel edge case that has never happened before and it will have to perform better than a human. That's why these things could never be rule based, there are too many small exceptions. When they're not overfitting/able to memorize all your training examples, neural nets learn heuristics, just as people do. Different people learn different heuristics. Granted, they don't have much of the same context about the world that people do, it will take a long time to build enough examples for them to infer all of that. But Tesla's fleet is getting more driving experience every day than you will get in your entire life, and every time they train on one of those exceptions, the entire fleet will benefit. Don’t even get started with liability. Once you take away the steering wheel the manufacturer is on the hook for every single mistake and every single accident. You’d be insane to be a manufacturer and sign up for that. If drivers no longer carry their own insurance, this is probably going to be handled by insurance at the manufacturer level, and baked into the price. The insurance will demand certain processes to prevent large-scale bugs being rolled out. I don't see any fantasy here, just a lot of work.
- Spooky23 7y agoNo way. The tech and liability will be too expensive for many years, at least till parents run out. My guess is that interstate type highways will be instrumented for trucks and cars will benefit.
- _greim_ 7y agoTo put this in perspective, imagine this hypothetical conversation happening a century ago: "I have this new auto-mobile concept which doesn't require a horse and which can go fast; I envision up to fifty miles per hour. It will require a smooth, hardened road surface, but that will be achievable someday." "Forget about it. We already have millions of miles of roads, which are bumpy, made of dirt, and hard to build and maintain. Who will do the extra work to smooth them? Harden them? Maintain them? What if some jerk digs a hole in one as a prank? Maybe this could happen in a limited way in cities, but this is overall a pipe dream." My point is, it isn't a question of whether this is feasible, it's a question of incentives. If the incentives lead society in this direction, it will happen.
- umvi 7y agoCobblestone/bumpy/muddy/dirt streets still exist today. I could see autonomous vehicles working in a city, but not out in the country where a driveway might be an unmarked dirt path.
- _greim_ 7y agoYes but these things are already problems for human-operated cars. You just need to drive slow and be careful on some roads. You need training, instructions, markers, specialized vehicles, or prior experience on some patches of terrain. These solutions have analogs in the automated driving realm.
- fastball 7y agoWhat features of an unmarked dirt path make it "driveable" that you can pick out but a camera cannot?
- megablast 7y agoYes, imagine that world. We wouldn’t have a million direct deaths every year, a million more caused by pollution. We wouldn’t waste trillions a year on roads, hospitals, signs, sprawl, and so much more. Just so someone can get a donut at 3am.
- joe_the_user 7y ago
- tempsy 7y agoWhat happens during major power outages though, which isn’t an infrequent event? Like the one that happened in NYC last year when you had citizens directly traffic in the dark? I’m struggling to understand how self driving cars would react to that.
- spookthesunset 7y agoClearly all the intoxicated individuals who were passengers now become drivers... or it is edge case and edge cases don’t matter for... reasons... or something. Am I getting the FSD hype train right here?
- siscia 7y agoWouldn't be simpler to just develop smaller trains?
- usrusr 7y agoSmaller trains with bimodal traction. Because steel on steel is terrible at spontaneous braking, hence the significantly bigger gaps between consecutive trains compared to the gap between consecutive cars or trucks. And because steel on steel is terrible at the long tail of events that would cause contingency diversion, be it maintenance, disasters or organizational confusion. And because it would neatly solve the last mile (well, dozen miles). Take an electrified rail network, pave it over to resemble a tramway track and add on/off ramps wherever they might be useful. Figure out an economic mechanical design that would allow a computer to precision-drive along the rail for on the fly mode switching. Which is an extremely limited task scope where computers would excel, very much unlike the almost-AGI requirements of full self driving. Mandate strong requirements for access to that network including a small minimum range of battery-autonomous operation so that you don't have to reach the atrociously high number of availability nines a conventional rail network needs to avoid total schedule collapse.
- gsnedders 7y ago> hence the significantly bigger gaps between consecutive trains compared to the gap between consecutive cars or trucks A lot of this is because railway signalling operates on a brick-wall principal: it is constantly assumed the vehicle in front could come to a dead halt instantaneously, whereas most road situations assume if you can match the braking performance of the vehicle in front with some margin. The railway case is safe for the trailing vehicle in the situation there's a concrete block on the track ahead, the road one is not.
- anticensor 7y ago> A lot of this is because railway signalling operates on a brick-wall principal That applies to old style -though still in common use- signalling. CBTC (every railway should use, but very few uses it) has similar, or even tighter, margins to road signalling.
- m463 7y agoI agree. new technologies are over-estimated in the short term, and under-estimated in the long term. Decades ago our computers were "soon" to be voice controlled, listening to our speech and doing our bidding. That was a big load of hype. However, over time and below the radar it became true as computers first answered phones, then took limited commands in cars and smartphones and now it is basically true (without all the hype). Also, I wonder if these kinds of comments risk becoming "I think there is a world market for about five computers." or "640K of memory should be enough for anybody."
- mattkrause 7y ago"I dictated this , to the quiet office. The word area isn't too bad." [What I actually said was 'I dictated this entire comment in a quiet office <period> The word error rate isn't too bad <period>'. Built-in recognizer on a Mac.]
- m463 7y agodarn autocement.
- barrkel 7y agoIt would be interesting to see those cars on these Parisian streets, with this level of dynamic hazard: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jojf3Ci2H3A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jojf3Ci2H3A I reckon motorways could be handled easily enough, and basic dual carriageways and normal intersections, but once you start mixing up multiple modes in inner cities, some tough decisions need to be made.
- cjbenedikt 7y agoUpdate markings and beacons? So far just mere road repairs are poor and take ages to be done.
- simias 7y agoI think self-driving cars are like fusion reactors, they're perfectly possible on paper and, like, totally 15years away from now. I'm sure it'll be possible some day, but I'm not positive that it'll be possible in the general case before we reach the Singularity. And when we get there self-driving cars are going to be a small side-effect of this unprecedented revolution. I can't help to draw a parallel between these threads about self-driving cars where many people are saying that it's basically a done deal and we just need to wait a few years, and that thread I read a few hours ago about the Boing 737 Max re-certification being delayed once more. I know it's a bit of a fallacy to treat HN has a singular entity but when I read the threads about the 737 the consensus in here is that "it's a death trap and I'll never fly one of these planes ever again" but at the same time we're totally optimistic that the industry will have perfected self-driving technology in our lifetimes? The industry has been cutting corners on planes that cost a fortune and didn't manage to make them safe to operate in unobstructed airspace because of a minor sensor dysfunction but they're totally gonna nail the incredibly complex task of operating a 1+ton vehicle at highway speeds in much less controlled environment? I can totally see an ever-increasing amount of driver assistance in the future. But fully autonomous driving everywhere at all times? I'm really not so sure.
- joe_the_user 7y agoI think self-driving cars are like fusion reactors, they're perfectly possible on paper and, like, totally 15years away from now. There's a certain similarity but I don't know any paper that actually gives any assure that self-driving is going to ever be possible. The only theory is "we will prevent extraneous factors and then calculate".
- sjy 7y agoSo is that different to fusion power? We know how to build automobiles, and we know how to trigger nuclear fusion, but in both cases we are struggling to build the technology to harness these powerful forces in a safe and convenient way.
- erikpukinskis 7y agoI find these arguments—about how a certain thing is arguably “impossible”—to be the most tiresome arguments on HN. Everything that is possible today... used to be “impossible”. If something appears “impossible” to you... there’s no information there about whether it is possible.
- wernercd 7y agoPersonally, I think Drones will meet self driving... Easier to have a system without need of "markings on the ground" when things are flying.
- janee 7y agoAgreed, "never" is a ridiculously unfathomable amount of time if you define it on say our species extinction date. I'm presonally bullish on fully autonomous transport because of the industry interest shown in it and the potential demand for it. The latter I don't see going away unless something comes around that makes it redundant.
- hrktb 7y agoI think a lot of people sharing this sentiment assume cars will always be there, or at least will still be relevant when we finally have generic autonomous driving nailed down. If it takes 50 years to have a fully ready environment with beacons, networking etc., will we still be riding “cars” on “streets” ? I ‘d guess when we reach that point we’ll also have solved the “getting from A to B” in completely different ways.
- skywhopper 7y agoYou are so sure about this. I’m curious where you live where the streets are so well maintained, there’s very little non-car traffic, rarely road construction, no bad weather, no emergency vehicles, no overly narrow two-lane roads, no gravel roads, and electronic maps that are correct 100% of the time.
- axguscbklp 7y agoIf you have to modify the environment to make it easier for the cars, then you haven't achieved fully self-driving technology.
- colordrops 7y agoSo unless cars can navigate without roads then they are not self driving?
- axguscbklp 7y agoNavigating off-road might actually be easier in practice for AI than navigating on roads, since off-road there are generally many fewer other cars to deal with. As a rough rule of thumb, I'll call a car fully self-driving if, without any changes having been made to the road system to accomodate self-driving cars, I feel comfortable getting in the back seat, telling it to drive me to a certain house in a city a few hundred miles away, and falling asleep.
- jgalt212 7y agoThere is something to this, in the sense that Palm (and others) couldn't get their machines to do complete handwriting recognition so Palm's solution was to have the computer and the human meet in the middle with Graffiti. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graffiti_(Palm_OS) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graffiti_(Palm_OS)
- hetman 7y agoModifying the environment sounds a lot like the the level 4 autonomy the exec said would be quite possible.
- moksly 7y agoWhat makes you say this? Gut feeling? Or do you have any supportive evidence? We’ve done self-driving as a POC for a decade in Denmark, and it hasn’t really improved much, to the point where we too are considering, that it’s probably never going to work in the real world. Don’t get me wrong. Self driving already works, it just doesn’t work on roads. Roads where you’ll suddenly have a bunch of leaves flying around. Roads where the paint job is cracking, perhaps even missing. Roads where the street signs are old and faded. In ten years of testing with some of the best in the business, we’ve had maybe two days worth of self-driving.
- Erlich_Bachman 7y ago> We’ve done self-driving as a POC for a decade in Denmark Who is "we"?
- K0SM0S 7y agoInitially in this decade I fully subscribed to your view, on paper. Then I observed how things panned out and thought some more. Here's a grim reality: at ~3 million per death in a car crash (that was a reasonable estimate of insurance cost, overall, a decade ago or so), with ~37k deaths/year in motor vehicule accidents in the USA for instance, that's roughly $100 billion / year — a mere 0.5% of its $20 trillion GDP. So I'm not holding my breath for public or private action at a massive scale (think that fracking alone was orders of magnitude more profitable for the US, and came with a strong geopolitical advantage to boot with). Do the math for your country, $3M/death over GDP, it's usually negligible compared to "the big thing" that your local politicians and corporations keep talking about. Even in Western Europe, where - regulation is people's #1 method for solving everything and anything, - "the value of life" is emphasized every other speech and publication and actual social security systems, free medical care, free education even, etc. (a few hundred bucks away from actual UBI, for real), - companies could actually compete (Europe has 0 tech giant, but several big car manufacturers), you don't hear a lot of political or popular or private (business) support for Level 4 infrastructure (L4: roads dedicated to self-driving cars, likely to kill ~1000x less than human-driven roads, not to mention the economic gain of time while commuting and travelling by road, which whether work or leisure is a net psychological gain). Actually L4 is not even a "topic" in many such countries (let alone L5), it's a curiosity, a funny segment to wrap up the news. Even though L4 is totally doable NOW. What you actually hear is much fear about tech — as usual. That's about it for self-driving cars. I have no idea why, it makes no sense to me, but even if rich cosy comfortable life-adoring 35h/week western Europe doesn't want it bad, I don't know who does/will, in the short/medium term. The above "grim reality" is just my way of fishing for answers, really. I don't know. I'm just skeptical that self-driving cars are a thing that people or leaders (public and private) actually want. I hear much, much resistance to the idea and very little interest for the upsides from the mainstream. I sees smiles and eyes rolling, and 10 years later there is still no decent infrastructure to charge EVs except Tesla's — a foreign entity, by far the biggest promoter of it all, but can they do it? Can they reach L5 or politically negociate L4? Back to the above concerns, or absence thereof really, of the mainstream. It's like space, basically: it would be incredibly little of the world's GDP to put massively more effort and shorten industrial-scale space activities dramatically — like if it's 30 years away at current rate, we could make it by 2030 really easily, without pushing it far (nothing like a war effort for instance). And the benefits are so immense it's basically stupid to argue against, the question is how to do it best. And yet it's still anecdotal in most countries budget, it's mostly just PR. Even as we speak, a "prime time" for space as a topic of (positive) interest for the mainstream. Go figure. Self-driving cars, it seems, are met with even more political and social resistance than they are made impossible by idealistic goals, because the former is a current showstopper whereas our current technological capacities are not.
- jasonhansel 7y agoMy question about this idea is always: what about pedestrians? Sure, you can use beacons so that cars won't crash into each other, and use signs to avoid collisions with fixed obstacles. But interactions with pedestrians often require guessing at their intentions, and you can't have them wear beacons at all times. Of course, some areas are already fairly hostile to pedestrians, but we don't want self-driving cars to make that problem worse.
- orange8 7y ago> .. and will be a niche hobby on race tracks Just like horses. Am sure there was a time no one ever imagined cars would completely replace horses on roads.
- jimmaswell 7y agoThere are still horses on roads sometimes. I passed through a town recently and saw two separate horse drawn carriages on the roads.
- Consultant32452 7y agoI don't think self driving cars will be a thing until self driving friendly roads are a thing. Just one example is roads could have RFID embedded everywhere. Maybe that specific idea is bad but that's the kind of way I think we'll have to approach this. If we start embedding RFID as we're repaving roads today, in 5 years the roads where most miles are driven will be equipped. In 20 years basically every road is done.
- samstave 7y agoLets assume the environment does meet half way. How resilient would such a system be. How easily can it be attacked to fiddle with the ability of the car to navigate safely? Also, and much longer term, isnt it kind of weird to think that human infrastructure can only be seen to massively scale i. The planet so long as we turn the planet into a cyborg? Isnt it weird and wasteful to build a planet wide cage of tech infrastructure for the evonomies of the world to survive and for human civilization to operate along the trajectory we are currently pointing? Seems dismal to me.
- rsj_hn 7y ago"May never happen" is such a cautious statement that to argue against it means "will certainly happen", and that's a pretty extreme position to take -- so extreme I would call it techno-utopianism. I'm still waiting for my flying car, but you are already promising me a thinking car, when there are so many obstacles, each of which could sink it: - researching it may not be feasible * because it becomes a waste of engineering resources to continue the research * because almost self-driving cars may be good enough - even if researching it is, it may not be economical because * political resistance or liability laws prevent mass rollout * the cost of building and maintaining required infrastructure is too high * not enough car purchasers may want it
- adrianN 7y agoI don't think the hard part of autonomous driving is recognizing the markings on the road. It's inferring what other people on the road want to do next. Including pedestrians and cyclists. Autonomous driving is a lot simpler if you only have to deal with other robots.
- _bxg1 7y agoWe could have them tomorrow if we could magically ban human drivers overnight. Humans are the only thing making it so hard. And the problem is that until we have 100% artificial general intelligence, that can introspect and understand the human psyche the way another human can, there will always be an intractable tail of cases where AI will fail. So it's like the IPv6 problem. If we could all coordinate at once, it would be easy-peasy. In reality, it's virtually impossible. Edit: a commenter pointed out that pedestrians are also a major problem; even in a far-fetched imaginary scenario I don't know how you would remove those from the equation.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- wpietri 7y ago> Not only will the tech get as good as humans [citation needed] It's possible, sure. But it only seems likely to me because I grew up in an age of rapid progress in information technology. History, though, has plenty of examples of technological plateaus and regressions. To people in the 1970s, it seemed obvious that by 2000 they could vacation on the moon. But the rapid progress of the space race quickly dwindled; the problems were harder than we thought and the rewards smaller. The notion that we can make a computer as smart as a human is one of those things that seems like it will be just around the corner. But it seemed that way 50 years ago, too. E.g. HAL from 2001. It's perfectly possible that humans aren't able to make anything smarter than themselves. Judging by most of the software I use, we're barely able to make things much dumber than ourselves.
- onetimemanytime 7y ago>>but he is completely wrong when it comes to the long term. Never means never, not even in 145 million years. But he probably meant not in our lifetimes and with current urban planning. When all cars are self-driving it will probably be better
- Too 7y agoIsn't that exactly what the article said? Lvl 4 on good prepared roads - possible, lvl 5 go anywhere you want - maybe not.
- ojbyrne 7y agoI am generally of the philosophy that all "disruptive" technologies end up looking basically like slightly modified versions of what they replace, mostly achieved by pushing at the regulatory environment a little bit. Uber/Lyft replaces taxis. Self driving cars begin to resemble trains.
- funnybeam 7y ago”We will eventually update markings and beacons on the roads to make it easier for the cars” We have already done this, they are called railways. Some of them evening have self driving trains. To get self driving cars on roads you need a human level AI. Trying to get away with less intelligence by restricting the environment will never get to the point where it will be safe to have automated vehicles - you can’t provide infrastructure clues to the vehicle to help it tell when a child is about to run out into the road for example (and there are many other examples too) so you would have to segregate them physically from everything else and then you might as well stick to railways
- lrem 7y ago"Human level AI" is a tricky wording. Sure, we may never get a program we would trust to serve in a jury, convince us about existence of God or just have a casual conversation with. But ask Go players how is that resistance to machines going. When I drive and there's a child walking on the sidewalk, I'm not analyzing the chances the child will jump onto the road. I'm just assuming the parents have succeeded at explaining how to not kill yourself, without that assumption I would go crazy with too much things to worry about. AI does not get crazy, nor even tired, with too much tasks. It might usually come up with the same result that I always apply - just drive slowly through roads with children on sidewalks. But it might do something I won't do - slow down even more if the child seems to be doing something suspect. One of the problems with Google-designed self-driving is that it goes slow and refuses to go if uncertain. I imagine that's why those cute little cars without driving wheel were axed. Even if the system has driven a bajillion miles without inflicting any risky situation, it won't sell if it can't guarantee doing your commute in your usual time. But it can't assume the same risk you take every day, that if that child behaves extra stupid and law misfires, then you might find yourself traumatized and without a driving license. Because when AI loses that license, it's killing the whole business. So, the bar for safety must be higher, slowing you down to a fully-controllable crawl, or constraining to high-safety situations. Hence, you get all those highway-assist features all over the place. Disclaimer: I work in Google, but have no insider information about Waymo. Just remember these marketing materials back from the Chaffeur days and still think that was the way to go.
- jillesvangurp 7y agoAgreed, level 5 autonomy is an ever shrinking number of edge cases. Human drivers also have edge cases like being drunk or otherwise incapacitated by strokes, heart attacks, getting phone calls, old, tired, etc. We still allow them on the road despite this and the notion that those things are some of the root causes of the many deadly accidents each year. Once autonomous cars are obviously safer than that, it will become the norm. We're not that far off from that. First we'll see mass deployment of level 3 & 4 first with safety drivers and when it becomes clear that those are a liability at best, also without. From there to level 5 is a matter of semantics since we'll basically have vehicles driving themselves most of the time.
- lowdose 7y agoI don't even think level 5 at individual car level is needed. Tesla can operate their fleet like a Amazon does with their warehouse robots.
- krn 7y ago> We will eventually update markings and beacons on the roads to make it easier for the cars, implement networks in which the cars can talk to each other In fact, the new generations of Volkswagen Golf, Škoda Octavia, Seat Leon, and Audi A3 (released between October 2019 and March 2020) will already be able to communicate with each other[1] and with the traffic authority[2] in real-time to prevent road accidents. Volkswagen Golf, Škoda Octavia, and Seat Leon are #1 best-selling car models in multiple European markets, and Audi A3 is one of the most popular and affordable premium cars in Europe. [1] https://innovationorigins.com/nxp-makes-volkswagen-golf-cars-talk-with-each-other-improving-safety/ https://innovationorigins.com/nxp-makes-volkswagen-golf-cars... [2] https://youtube.com/watch?v=AM_NjfZX-F0 https://youtube.com/watch?v=AM_NjfZX-F0
- jve 7y agoWhat you are describing is Level 4-geofenced solution. Select roads, where infrastructure in place (be it 100% of aphalt, but that is not the single possible road type out there)
- himinlomax 7y agoYou just need to slow the cars down enough to increase safety drastically where the environment is not adapted. Having cars move slowly but steadily does not make trips longer on average, at least in areas prone to traffic jams. Even though human drivers can find it frustrating, it's actually the opposite. If vehicles are consistently slow enough, you can even get rid of traffic lights and stop signs.
- joejerryronnie 7y agoYou’ve described level 4 automation, not level 5. So you’re agreeing with the VW exec (for what it’s worth, I also agree with you and the VW exec)
- tomc1985 7y agoGotta love optimism...
- gist 7y ago> I am skeptical that full self-driving cars will happen in the next few years, but he is completely wrong when it comes to the long term I think when someone says 'will never happen' they mean 'not in the foreseeable future'. Obviously the environment, usage and science can change such that full self driving could happen. I mean in the 1600s nobody could imagine a Boeing 747 flying loaded with hundreds of people, sure. But the hype around self driving (by all the dreamers) has been that it's more or less 'right around the corner' not in 30 or 40 years or even 20 years.
- toper-centage 7y agoYou will never, ever, have only self driving cars on the roads, unless you're talking exclusively about reserved motorways. You'll always have, at the very least, pedestrians and cyclists.