18 ms·
I hate living in my tiny house
- Retric 7y agoUltra tiny houses are a very poor tradeoff. Your costs per square foot drop significantly as you increase the buildings dimensions. The actual costs are mostly for land which sit unused around them. At that size a 10% larger investment in construction builds a significantly larger structure while still representing a small percentage of the monthly cost. By comparison of construction vs land. 50k gets you a nice prebuilt 750sf single wide that can be delivered just about anywhere. Which could be covered by ~300$ mortgage meanwhile that much smaller space is renting for 1,600+$/month. So, at best your reducing that 300$ a little while leaving the 1,300+$ land cost alone.
- chaostheory 7y agoI feel that the problem is that the target market may not have enough money for the down payment. However the biggest obstacles are permits and regulation.
- TuringNYC 7y agoTotally agree, but it is sort of like buying mega sizes at CostCo vs regular sizes — the economy of scale is great in theory but only if you can afford it (either cost wise or afford the space) A good balance would be allowing multi family in many of these zones because what you say is very valid if you can stack up the housing. This is the sad thing about the Bay Area vs say NYC — the problem is a policy problem rather than some natural shortage.
- d-sc 7y agoI lived in one of those 50k prebuilt, they aren't as nice as they are made out to be. But the premise of your comment still stands.
- realbarack 7y agoWould you mind elaborating a bit? Would love to hear more about your experience with this.
- p1necone 7y agoI don't get the tiny house thing. They seem to have become a fad because house prices in a lot of places are currently out of reach of a lot of people. But isn't the part of the equation that's grown astronomically the cost of the land, not the cost of building the house? I know that I couldn't afford a house where I am now (without a large down payment and mortgage repayments that were an unresponsible portion of my income) even if I just bought an empty plot of land.
- mr_toad 7y agoI would have assumed that they would have put the tiny houses on tiny plots of land, possibly existing land that has been subdivided.
- p1necone 7y agoI guess if you lived in a country where there weren't legal limits on subdivision size that would make sense. Is that the case in the USA? "I live in a trailer on my parents backyard" doesn't quite have the same ring to it as "I built my own house at 19 you lazy bastard".
- alistairSH 7y agoGenerally, in the US, tiny homes are below legal minimum sizes for permanent homes. So, most are built as trailers, even if installed permanently. Similarly, most towns and counties are subdivided such that tiny plots aren’t available. There is a growing movement to allow ADUs in urban spaces, but it’s far from universal. If memory serves, Arlington VA (next to DC) allows an ADU within the main house (converted basement) with some fairly strict limits. No ADU in the back yard.
- TylerE 7y agoBasement apartments are problematic from a fire code perspective, especially if it's a "true" ADU that doesn't connect into the main house.
- Arainach 7y agoIf you don't want to live in a tiny house, then don't. It's good to have options for people who can't afford otherwise. Clearly the author of the article prefers living in Oakland (in a tiny house) to living somewhere cheaper in a larger house. The author explicitly states that they can't afford a larger apartment, but this is the tradeoff. There are tradeoffs in everything.
- crashcrashcrush 7y agoWoooosh. Did you hear that? That was the sound of the point of the article going right over your head. The point is that the system as it exists now is broken; the author is pointing out the many absurdities. Tiny homes are a stopgap; a shitty patch on a broken single family home system. We need mid-rises, hi-rise condos, and mixed use zoning to be implemented literally by force in the Bay Area at this point. It’s an untenable situation.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- okcando 7y agoThese tradeoffs aren't laws of nature and they can be changed. Discussing them, the economic and social forces behind them, and what remedies might exist is reasonable and worthwhile.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- joe_the_user 7y agoI'm in favor of people being able to build tiny houses. Especially, a situation any reasonably safe structure that can built would be legal to build is desirable - IE, toss zoning ordinances in the fire. But I don't think a tiny shack, uh, house, should be called a "good option". It's an adequate option under limited circumstances. The problem is calling it a good option makes "we spent five years fighting for the right to our tiny shack" sound like a reasonable thing rather than one more absurd winkle in the development of this country's housing situation.
- alexhutcheson 7y agoThe author's experience is interesting to read about, but their dwelling is not typical of ADUs. 240 sq. ft is on the extreme low end of ADU sizes. Googling yields a variety of different figures, but one blog[1] cites an average ADU size of 640 ft. As someone who currently lives in a <700 sq. ft apartment with another person and a dog, I can say that 640 ft would be very livable for one person. Tiny homes sound terrible, but tiny home != ADU. There are a lot of more reasonably sized ADUs being built, and most of them should be much more pleasant to live in than this one. https://blogs.berkeley.edu/2017/05/23/jumpstarting-the-market-for-accessory-dwelling-units/ https://blogs.berkeley.edu/2017/05/23/jumpstarting-the-marke...
- maire 7y agoADU size depends on lot size and zoning. In Santa Cruz county, ADUs inside the "utility zone" are limited to 10% for normal lot sizes up to a max of 640 sqft. Large lots can have an ADU up to 800 sqft. Outside of the "utility zone" ADUs can be as large as 1200 sqft if your lot is greater than 1 acre.
- gnopgnip 7y agoA few state laws on ADU have changed recently, the lot size limits are no longer legal and you can build 600sq ft adu on sub 5000 sq ft lots now
- badfrog 7y agoFor most people I know in NYC, 640 square feet per person would be a huge upgrade.
- kevindong 7y agoI live in a 490 sq. ft. NYC studio and it's honestly great for just myself. That being said, once apartments get that small, a great floor plan is essential to having a functional, yet spacious small apartment. I have a walk in closet, two regular closets, a laundry closet (with stacked, in-unit washer and dryer), a standard bathroom, a full kitchen, a sectional couch, a media console, and a queen sized bed. I've never felt cramped in my apartment. I've seen studio apartment listings with more space (in the ~500~600 sq. ft. range), but the floor plan is such that I wouldn't be able to fit what I currently have in there despite the additional ~0~100 sq. ft. of space due to a non-rectangular floor plan (trying to fit any piece of furniture in a non 90-degree corner will never go well).
- ilamont 7y agoIn 2018, my middle school-aged son and I stayed in a small apartment in Taipei while he attended a Mandarin language program at a local university over the summer. It was located on the roof of a 10 story building, and was about 250 square feet. I had to fold up my sofa bed every morning (he had the loft) to make space in the main room. There was no indoor furniture except the sofa, so when we ate inside he usually sat on the stairs while I used a small plastic folding chair I bought at a night market. Dealing with garbage was a constant issue. It just seemed to build up quickly and there was no place to keep it in the apartment. In terms of our belongings, if we had anything more than what fit in our suitcases and day packs there would have been a major problem with storage as there was only some small closet space and cubbyholes underneath the stairs. I did almost no cooking because cheap food options were nearby but it occurred to me that if I had been frying stuff on the little range, the smells from cooking would have pervaded everything. ETA: I realize that many people live in far more cramped conditions all over the world, often with many family members or shared accommodations, and generally have no options to move into bigger quarters. But in the United States at least, I see the "small house" movement romanticizing the idea of compact living quarters while glossing over the drawbacks.
- cyberferret 7y agoI think this is a factor that is often neglected or not even mentioned is articles espousing 'tiny homes'. The cooking. Even in our fairly large home, if I cook something even vaguely aromatic, the smell permeates through most of the house. Maybe this is an indictment of the 'takeaway generation' that seems the norm in places like the US, where it is often cheaper and more convenient to order take out, rather than cook from scratch?
- souprock 7y agoThat smell is a good thing though, isn't it? If not, cook something else. Maybe don't cook liver with Limburger.
- geomark 7y agoSome delicious foods smell terrible during cooking, or even emit slightly dangerous fumes during cooking, like dishes that contain a lot of chilis (the source of pepper spray).
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- protomyth 7y agoUnless there is some provision for tiny lots, I really don't get the desire. Even then, many of these tiny houses, particularly anything that can be hauled behind a truck, is astonishingly bad. A 400 - 700 sq. ft modular house would be a better idea. On a side note, there are quite a lot of stories from places like Hong Kong on how to maximize space in their small apartments that could be applied to tiny homes to make them more livable. I've watched a lot of those shows on HGTV and have not seen any of those designs applied. A youtube channel called Living Big In A Tiny House https://www.youtube.com/user/livingbigtinyhouse https://www.youtube.com/user/livingbigtinyhouse has some interesting designs with some space saving techniques.
- ProfessorLayton 7y agoIt's worth pointing out that minimum lot sizes were used to push poor people, particularly POC, out of wealthier neighborhoods by making it uneconomical to build smaller homes on oversized lots. SF has a minimum of 2,500-4000sf [1], and San Jose has a minimum of 5,400sf! It's the same for much of the bay area, the SFH I live in occupies ~20% of the lot it sits on, which is pure insanity for one of the most expensive metros in the US. It is even more insane when you look at the giant lots of SFHs right next to Bart stations. [1] https://www.livablecity.org/rethinking-rh/ https://www.livablecity.org/rethinking-rh/
- howlin 7y agoThe main problem here seems to be that the author was working from home. A tiny house is really only good for washing, sleeping and lounging.
- woah 7y agoHear me out: It may be possible to stack houses on top of each other in layers.
- chaostheory 7y agoIt may be physically possible, but if you’re in places likes the sf Bay Area, it’s probably not legally possible in most places.
- jyrkesh 7y agoYeah, I think the joke is a knock on Bay Area (and SF) restrictions on building up
- crashcrashcrush 7y agoWHAT! Get out of here. That sounds like Soviet style communist housing! Everyone wants a front yard with a white picket fence to show off to their neighbors, no?
- jiofih 7y agoI heard they already started doing this in Japan! Jokes aside, it’s interesting that the article doesn’t mention city zoning rules - aren’t those the main cause of such shortage?
- im3w1l 7y agoI understand the joke, but let's take it seriously. What are the main reasons people want houses and how can we preserve them when stacking? * Noise. If you want to create the house experience you need to be able to jump and stomp the floor in the middle of the night without bothering anyone. Need thick and advanced floors, walls and front doors (easy to forget the last). * Garden. Probably would need artifical light, but might be possible. * BBQ in the garden. Maybe not impossible but might take some engineering to get the smoke out. * Parking. Just need to ensure it exists plentifully. * Multiple floors. Idk if people care too much for this, but easy to handle if so.
- 7y ago
- djrobstep 7y agoTiny houses in and of themselves are fine if that's what you're into. The problem is that they seem to be used as a way to avoid discussing the fact that land, not buildings, are what is causing all the housing affordability issues. We desperately need to ramp up taxes on land in order to reduce inequality and speculation, and encourage density. Nobody made land, so nobody deserves the right to use it to exploit other people. Unfortunately, hundreds of years of political supremacy by landed gentry is largely still in place and hard to dismantle.
- briandear 7y ago> We desperately need to ramp up taxes on land in order to reduce inequality and speculation Speculation is what pays for housing.
- djrobstep 7y agoToo often, yes. That's what I'm complaining about. Plenty of other ways to fund it.
- ClumsyPilot 7y agoAnd taxes on alcohol fund schools,let's encourage that!
- Pfhreak 7y agoCan't agree with this enough. Tax the value of the land. Housing shouldn't be a commodity -- it should be accessible to everyone and priced based on how well it serves its primary goal of keeping the population housed. IMO, it shouldn't be profitable to be a landlord, at least not to the extent it is today, unless you are providing services well above and beyond.
- teliskr 7y agoIf it isn’t profitable to be a landlord; why would anyone be a landlord? And if there are fewer landlords, who provides housing? The government? I’d rather live in a really bad tiny house than a government project.
- hanniabu 7y agoI think this is completely a function if multiple things including how much money you can spend on housing, how much stuff you own, your lifestyle (do you entertain, do you have equipment like a bike or kayak, etc), how clean/organized you are, how large you are, are you single, do you have pets, and how well the space is designed. Tiny houses aren't for everybody, but they definitely meet the needs of a group of people. For instance myself, I live alone, have no pets, don't entertain parties, am really organized, and don't own a lot of stuff so a tiny home is completely within my comfort. Not to mention that if I lived in a normal sized apartment then it would look like I'm either in the process of moving in or moving out due to how little stuff I own. Even if the price per square foot increases, I simply don't need the extra space so why pay for it. It's like saying I should get a large pack of eggs for a better deal, even though I only need a small pack because the rest will go bad before I eat them. It just don't make sense in my situation, as well it's the case for many others. Given that, I could not live in many tiny homes advertised on TV/instagram/YouTube, they're simply inefficient in terms of lifestyle. They've turned it into a competition for who can live in the smallest place possible which is plain stupid and you end up with a bunch of idiots designs that require you to somehow pack up your bed every day, or have no kitchen countertop, or no table. These aren't what I would consider normal tiny homes, they're on the extreme end of the spectrum. You don't need to give up a normal lifestyle to have a "tiny home", only the people that want to "show off" do. These are the same type of people as those hipsters that carry around a typewriter to "show off" how hipster they are.
- opportune 7y agoI have lived in a 200 sqft room in college (with another person!) and it would have been tight, but pretty decently livable for a single person. You have room for a bed, desk+chair, nightstand, TV + couch but not much else. I don't believe the photo in the article shows as much of the place as it could (it's also taken with a fisheye lense to distort the size). Also, living in an apartment with roommates is probably cheaper than living in an ADU by yourself (depending on area); in my area it is about 20% cheaper. You can end up with a larger shared area with a normal sized kitchen and living room. Living in an ADU is really paying a premium for privacy and other benefits of living by yourself.
- fennecfoxen 7y agoArticle's conclusions are dubious. > We need ... different housing tech that can lower construction costs If you're paying ~$1,600 a month for a shoebox apartment, it's not because you need construction technology. It is a housing-policy problem.
- scythe 7y agoTo add to this, I stayed in a family apartment in Wuhan for a month last year. The place had three bedrooms, a washing machine & a full kitchen in about 100 m^2. Wuhan metro is about the size of Los Angeles (20M) and the cost was maybe an eighth of LA’s price for that kind of thing. Some of that can be explained by labor cost and legitimate environmental regulations, but Americans don’t make 8x what Chinese make.
- TylerE 7y ago> Americans don’t make 8x what Chinese make. You're right, they make "only" 7x as much. US Median Income: $43,585 China M.I.: $6,180 http://worldpopulationreview.com/countries/median-income-by-country/ http://worldpopulationreview.com/countries/median-income-by-...
- avinium 7y agoEven the median income comparison is probably too favourable - Wuhan and LA are apples to oranges. I'm sure LA is one of the higher-income cities in the US, and Wuhan is one of the lower.
- TylerE 7y agoLA actually isn't super high. Median income is only about 2/3rds of the real top cities (DC suburbs have a median of almost $100k, LA is more like $60)
- Amygaz 7y agoWuhan median is $34k and $65k in LA.
- hourislate 7y agoIn Toronto 500k buys you 500 sq/ft. There are condos being built that are as small as 385 sq/ft. Developers are just packing in units and making them smaller and smaller and charging a huge premium if you want a larger unit. The buildings are built like shit and the maintenance fees are outrageous. I can't imagine how much worse it's going to get as time goes on and people become more desperate trying to find somewhere to live or something to buy.
- wolco 7y agoIf you want to live downtown or by the waterfront perhaps. Plenty of older 700/1000 condos outside the core for that price. This is still available: https://www.blogto.com/real-estate-toronto/2019/09/cheapest-house-toronto-right-now/ https://www.blogto.com/real-estate-toronto/2019/09/cheapest-...
- digianarchist 7y agoJust live in Pickering. 500k will buy you a house in Pickering and it's 30 mins away from Union Station by Go train.
- perl4ever 7y agoI'm in NY (ah, but not NYC) and inside city limits, within a metro area of 1.1 million people, and I have about 1300 sq ft that cost $165K. And no HOA/condo fees. I'm not really putting in any effort to evangelize and promote the idea, but the concept of a land value tax instead of regular property taxes seemed like a plausible solution to the problems people have with real estate markets. You tax something, you get less of it. We want people to develop and invest in building on land, but we don't want them to profit from the scarcity of the actual acreage. So why not tax the value of the land away, and leave the buildings on it alone?
- tssva 7y agoFrey argues that in some cases even small ADUs can make sense; a quarter of Americans live alone, and don’t necessarily need much room, especially as many cities work to improve public space and there are an increasing number of places to spend time away from home. Somebody isn't an introvert.
- mikedilger 7y ago240 sq ft sounds too small. I think the tiny house movement overshot. I've been living alone (with dog) in a 540 sq ft garage conversion for 7 years and it's just about the perfect size for me. It has a small bedroom (queen bed), larger office, even larger LR, smallish kitchen and a bathroom (no tub). If I bothered to change antying, the kitchen could be slightly larger, the bathroom could use a tub, the laundry could be moved indoors (it's out on the covered deck) and the water heater could be moved indoors too. It's not well designed and space is not utilized well (bare walls could be shelves). But with a better design I think it would be completely satisfactory. I like having less to clean and less to heat, but I wouldn't attempt anything smaller. I should add that my house has nothing to do with affordable dense city housing, it's on a farm in New Zealand, which has other buildings (garage, storage container, shearing shed).
- miguelmota 7y agoI once lived in a tiny 150 sq ft 'bachelor' style apartment which was a single room as the entire living space with a small bathroom. It had no kitchen so I had to wash my dishes in the bathroom sink and use a portable electric hot plate for cooking meals. It was a very minimalist lifestyle since I had to think about every item I brought in because it'd take up space. The good thing is that I learned how to be efficient with resources and use less 'stuff', but it was not good for my mental health over the long run since the lack of freedom to move around was making me feel like I was trapped in a confined space. Almost felt like I was living in a prison cell. Sometimes it's not worth going with the cheapest option because it takes a toll on your mental health.
- godot 7y agoCurious for you and others who've done similar things -- had you considered sharing a place with roommates at the time? I too have gone through such a phase after college, 12-14 years ago. I worked in the Sacramento area, I was single and had little belongings. The smallest/cheapest places I lived in were 1) living in the living room of my friend's 1-bedroom apartment, for $300/mo (he was paying $800/mo before I joined, so I shared 3/8 of it, and it wasn't like he was even using the living room at all before I moved in), and later 2) living in the living room of an apartment with random housemates (found on FB, at my college town Davis) for $250/mo. (Not counting the times when I had been somewhat homeless for a couple of months and stayed in a different friend's apartment every week with a sleeping bag, sleeping on their room's floor, when I was working a very low pay job) Of course finding similarly priced apartments is impossible (even in 2006~07), I honestly doubt I would even be able to find a 150 sq ft apartment for that price. I would however gladly take living with roommates/housemates -- especially over a 150 sq ft apartment to myself -- considering the toll on mental health etc. like you said. I actually quite enjoyed my living conditions at the time (taking over the living room at my friend's place and random housemates' place). Even with random housemates, it's nice to have someone to say hi to when they walk in and out (inevitably walking past where I'd be sleeping or using my computer, when they walk to the front door).
- miguelmota 7y ago
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- exabrial 7y ago> I can’t afford to move For one months rent, you could move your stuff, and pay your first months rent in my apartment complex in Overland Park, KS.
- burlesona 7y agoYes, but in the minds of so many people in California and New York, Kansas doesn’t exist. Having moved to SF from “flyover country,” it’s astonishing to me how many people here are totally unaware of the rest of the country, and have never even visited anything outside of the Pacific Coast other than NYC or maybe DC. If you ask why they don’t move someplace in the Midwest, the answer is they consider it to be a nearly mythological place that they only vaguely know exists and are, frankly, terrified of. It’s bizarre how common that is.
- perl4ever 7y agoI don't think I would consider living in Kansas in this day and age - people are more than vaguely aware of it from the news and it doesn't sound like a good place from the vantage point of CA or NY. You may regard what's in the news about the midwest as distorted or propaganda, but I don't think it's ignored or people on the coasts are unaware of what it's reported to be like. ...but places like DC are practically Kansas from the point of view of living costs relative to SF. So SF to Kansas is the wrong comparison in my opinion. Plenty of other coastal metro areas.
- Merrill 7y agoNew York and San Francisco are two of the most provincial cities in the US. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/View_of_the_World_from_9th_Avenue https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/View_of_the_World_from_9th_Ave...
- ternaryoperator 7y agoProvincial != unfamiliar with your preferred area. NYC and SF are about the easiest places for foreigners to integrate. Residents of those cities might not have been to Kansas, but lots of them have been to or come from Latin American or Asian countries--so definitely not provincial, but in fact multicultural.
- lettergram 7y agoHaving unintentionally lived in a "tiny house" at university, never again. Mind you, it wasn't supposed to be a "tiny house", they had a rush remodel and half the apartment was rendered useless. My wife (then girlfriend) and I agreed never to live in one again. Just this morning, we were reminiscing about how we used to have to get our utensils, then eat on the utensil box I made to hold them because we didn't have counter space. We also recalled the brick wall had a brick sticking out just slightly too far that you couldn't open the oven. So we had to file down the brick. Just... just no. Give me my 2600+ square feet house any day. The real trick is not living somewhere where you need that kind of housing. Outside of a submarine, there really is little reason. I live in rural Illinois, make close to an SF salary, enjoy my 5 min commute, and pay less than this guy for a five bedroom house.
- paulcole 7y agoI mean one reason is that you like it? I’ve never lived in an apartment larger than 600 square feet and 2600 seems so excessive to me. Heating it, cooling it, filling it with stuff. Why bother? I can bike/walk anywhere I need to go in town, have a $20 electric bill, am 90 minutes from the pacific and 90 minutes from the mountains. 80 miles of running trails 3 miles from my door. I’ll take that over some giant house in the middle of nowhere.
- zaroth 7y agoWhy bother? So there's space for your spouse and two kids.
- paulcole 7y agoI grew up with 2 parents and a sibling in a house under 1,000 square feet. I guess just a different approach to wastefulness and what it takes to be comfortable.
- ClumsyPilot 7y agoI think the is a difference between having space and hoarding things
- jbarham 7y agoISTM that "tiny homes" are just mobile homes rebranded for hipsters without the stigma of living in a trailer park.
- newnewpdro 7y agoThis title is kind of misleading, they're the tenant of a tiny rental, they don't own the place. The necessity of being free to modify and tailor a living space to the occupant increases exponentially with the inverse of ft^2. I live in a tiny space. It would drive me absolutely insane if there were a fold-out bed and other integrated amenities I wouldn't appreciate yet would be wasting precious space on. But since I own my place, whatever isn't working gets removed/changed and it's instead an iterative optimization process. There are some serious advantages to having a small space. Heating/cooling systems are smaller, so cheaper to acquire, replace, and operate. Cleaning the place takes a few minutes. The lack of excess space significantly deters consumerism and hoarding. Maintenance and upgrades have much smaller multipliers, the number of windows, ft^2 of roofing material, exterior finishing, flooring, etc. It's all significantly lower cost in materials, less labor costs or less work/time if DIYing. My property includes acres of buildable land, but I don't really feel all that compelled to increase the cost of ownership by building a larger home. The main thing I'm contemplating right now is building a second minimalist tiny home on the property for visiting friends/airbnb, and maybe for me to live in when I'm doing invasive upgrades in the other one. I value that that's not a particularly costly proposition, to entirely gut and upgrade everything in my tiny home. It wouldn't even take that long. Go price some nice windows on menards.com, lowes.com, or homedepot.com and see how much it would cost when you have 10-20 to replace vs. 2-4. This is the kind of stuff typical single-family residential home owners take out home equity lines of credit to do. I'd do it for under ten grand, no loans necessary, nor did it require a mortgage to buy this place to start with.
- viburnum 7y ago240 square feet is just too small. America is a rich country with plenty of land, but without rational housing policies you wind up with insanity like this. Great parking, though.
- rogerkirkness 7y agoBuild higher. It is the only way. Centralize all the expensive stuff to maintain, and build higher.
- paxys 7y agoThis has nothing to do with construction costs, just housing policy and supply/demand. Here's an idea - get a roommate. For twice what you would pay for this "tiny house" ($1600), you can get a spacious 1500+ sq ft 2 bedroom apartment, even a house with a yard if you are okay with living slightly farther away from downtown.
- fenwick67 7y agoI lived in an off-grid cabin from June through September. It's 240 square feet and has a loft. I had 4G and a 2Ahr USB battery bank I would charge at work, but no electricity and not even a composting toilet, just the woods. But all I saved from living there I probably spent eating out since there was no kitchen either. I probably couldn't do it year-round, but I will remember my time there fondly. I wish the author here talked more about their actual experiences and challenges and not making it a story about rent prices or the housing market.
- vjeux 7y agoAverage habitable surface per person in Paris is ~330 square feet. The average tiny house is 500 square feet (quote from the article). It may be tiny for US standards but is livable. https://www.cnews.fr/france/2015-04-28/paris-un-habitant-vit-en-moyenne-dans-31-m2-703598 https://www.cnews.fr/france/2015-04-28/paris-un-habitant-vit...
- uniclaude 7y agoAs a European guy living in Japan, this article illustrates an interesting perspective to me. Millions of people live in smaller places and are perfectly happy about it. It does look like her house is wasn't built to properly optimize for the space though (the toilet unit could be much better, having a sink, toilets, and a shower in the same tiny space with a very clean looking bathroom is a solved problem). The rent price seems fairly high, but it seems to be aligned with local salaries and the (perceived?) quality of life the bay area has to offer. As the rent price per square foot gets higher with smaller spaces, those tiny houses are probably more profitable than larger apartments or houses, so we might see more of those as landlords realize, and then maybe renters will get used to it like in Tokyo and Hong Kong?
- danschumann 7y agoI mean, it's possible you hate your neighborhood, neighbors, the closeness of it all. What if your tiny house was in the middle of a 10 acre forest? You could go on a walk without bother. San Fran is probably just PEOPLE. EVERYWHERE. SHITTING. EVERYWHERE. Not only that, but big cities are probably pretty isolating... whereas in small towns, people will engage you in conversation because people are still novel in small quantities.
- newsbinator 7y agoThe distinct advantage of a tiny house is that it forces you to live a tiny life. It changes how you think, plan, buy, and behave. I think of it like a stomach stapling: For some people, it makes all the difference to their quality of life. For others, it's a solution to the wrong problem, and therefore not a solution at all. Maybe even something that compounds their existing problems.
- bane 7y agoThere's tons of videos on youtube of people excitedly moving into their tiny house or converted bus or whatever. They usually seem to be 200-500 sq ft affairs on 5-10 acres of land, so they aren't exactly solving the housing problem. There's a few in tiny apartments in cities to be fair. Anecdotally, most of these folks seem to move out of their tiny place in about a year or two because they're simply tired of not being able to do crazy things like stand up or stretch their arms out. I remember one series of increasingly distressing videos where a guy was financially tied up in some tiny property, got married, then started having kids. By the time they were finally able to unload the property on somebody else they had an infant sleeping in a closet and the husband was sleeping in a tent so their older daughter could sleep inside with their mother. I'm really not sure what problem the "Tiny House Movement" is trying to solve even if some of the solutions are kind of interesting. The variety of small living accommodations in Asian Cities seems far more interesting to me to be honest, because they're solving real problems of affordability, shelter and so on. Some of the tiniest places seem to be relatively shame-free dorm-like affairs in South Korea and Japan intended for people studying for various exams, but also used by a fair number of semi-permanent residents who lack the means to stay elsewhere. These places are cheap, maybe around $300-400 per month, but have tradeoffs like shared washrooms and kitchens. 1 - https://youtu.be/kBPyN3LE65g https://youtu.be/kBPyN3LE65g 2 - https://youtu.be/0YWRPWDqzVg https://youtu.be/0YWRPWDqzVg 3 - https://youtu.be/979a8b0lP2M https://youtu.be/979a8b0lP2M 4 - https://youtu.be/q0zZfpe2v1g https://youtu.be/q0zZfpe2v1g There's also the flip-side, various levels of poverty (like #1 above) result in sometimes intense living conditions: 5 - https://youtu.be/hLrFyjGZ9NU https://youtu.be/hLrFyjGZ9NU 6 - https://youtu.be/wN4pgYzuRb4 https://youtu.be/wN4pgYzuRb4 7 - - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bhIQjyBrmwI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bhIQjyBrmwI
- hkai 7y ago> My bathroom, a 3-by-6-foot “wet room” with a walk-in shower, is so small that it doesn’t have a sink, and I have to use the nearby kitchen sink First world problems.
- torgian 7y agoI’m surprised no one has made a building with units compatible to the size of Japanese apartments in Osaka. Tiny rooms, sure, but with their own one-unit bathroom/shower and a sink and stove. Don’t need much more than that. I lived in one for about 450 usd... I paid extra for the small balcony. But I guess most people in san fransisco would not want to live in such “cramped” spaces. Either that, or more likely there isn’t anyone willing to build such a place.
- vinay_ys 7y agoI was renting a 600 sq.ft apt in SF for $3000 more than half a decade ago. The apartment management company raised rents with no rhyme or reason. I decided to move away from SF in hopes of lower rent and started to search mainly along the 101/280 or BART lines and found a lot of places that were vacant for more than a month but rents were exorbitantly high. It seemed like just one or two real-estate companies owned all those apartment complexes and were increasing the rents artificially each year. I finally realized moving further away doesn't help from overall costs. In SF I wasn't owning a car. When I moved away from SF, car became a necessity. If you add the cost of car ownership, it made up for the difference in the rent. And of course not to mention the drop in quality of life due to 1h+ drive on busy 101/280 each day.
- kamaal 7y agoIn short this is the nearest analogy to a prison cell. Add to this that people only move around in fixed routes- Office to home to grocery shopping etc. This is more less like self created open air prison. I'm not surprised that the psychological effects of this are any different than staying in prison. I've been in this living-in-small-home position, and half the depression was just happening looking at the birds flying away from trees to wherever they want from small room I was living in. Get out, the world is big.
- gregors 7y agoMove Chattanooga, TN * Lots of progressive tech with SF ties * Municipal Fiber Internet - gigabit speeds! * startups! * rock climbing! https://www.inc.com/peter-cohan/how-chattanooga-created-18b-in-startup-exits-in-under-5-years.html https://www.inc.com/peter-cohan/how-chattanooga-created-18b-... Move to Knoxville, TN * Fastest super computer in the world * Oak Ridge National Lab https://www.wired.com/story/worlds-fastest-supercomputer-breaks-ai-record/ https://www.wired.com/story/worlds-fastest-supercomputer-bre...