25 ms·
California bans private prisons
- bnt 7y agoCalifornia is on a roll this week, it seems. Can someone local explain what’s going on?
- MistaEd 7y agoend of the legislative year, all bills are crammed in the last weeks
- zachberger 7y agoThe current legislative session is about to close.
- synaesthesisx 7y agoMaybe if they’re ambitious they can do something about the homeless crisis next.
- blackflame7000 7y agoHahaha yea right, that problem is actually hard. Cleaning up straws is much easier.
- bdhe 7y agoThat sort of cynicism is needless. Considering that this thread is about private prisons, a very serious issue, bringing up a literal straw man is disingenuous and completely unnecessary.
- blackflame7000 7y agoIt's not a strawman argument if that's really what they are spending time on that should be spent addressing far more important issues like homelessness. They shouldn't spend 1 second talking about an issue so meaningless on the list of issues they need to tackle. If you can't see that they are grabbing at low hanging fruit so that they can say they accomplished something then I think you might be a bit naive. A ban is literally the easiest cop-out for legislatures to do. No deep thinking required to blanket ban everything you don't like or perceive as problematic.
- journalctl 7y agoSeems like outlawing single-Family zoning should be easy, but how many NIMBYs reside in the state legislature?
- Animats 7y agoTrump has a plan. Concentration camps.[1] Site surveys already underway. [1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2019/09/10/trump-pushing-major-crackdown-homeless-camps-california-with-aides-discussing-moving-residents-government-backed-facilities/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2019/09/10/trump-pus...
- ativzzz 7y agoYou must have not read the article considering it mentions at best > eliminating “regulatory barriers” that White House officials believe increase the cost of building new housing. Developers have said these restrictions drive up prices on housing and limit the supply. You can argue whether or not he's actually gonna do something or just tweet out hot air, but proclaiming concentration camps is not contributing any meaningful insight.
- rolltiide 7y agoMany legislatures including ones in the united states have readings of many laws over time, and then revisit passing them all at once Instead of sporadically throughout the year California being the 5th largest world economy and relevance to the silicon valley population simply becomes of interest on this site Other states arent just twiddling their thumbs but it is interesting what California legislature is passing
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoIt makes you wonder what shady stuff that the public would never approve of could be flying under the radar.
- el_benhameen 7y agoSeptember 13th is the last day for the legislature to pass bills in the current session.
- mistrial9 7y agosigning very important things at the last minute is part of negotiations strategy.. the bills can and do change overnight
- dragonwriter 7y agoEnd of legislative session (so a lot of bills that need to either be passed or die are getting final action), the first legislative session under a new governor that is slightly more progressive and much less a believer in relatively narrow focus on policy change at any one time than his predecessor, and a Democratic supermajority.
- jedberg 7y ago> and a Democratic supermajority. This is the key. With Gov Brown, he still had a modicum of temperance that they couldn't override. Now the legislature has carte blanche to do whatever they want, because regardless of the governor, they can override his veto.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> This is the key. No, it's not. > With Gov Brown, he still had a modicum of temperance That's a difference between Brown and Newsome, yes. > that they couldn't override. There was a Democratic supermajority for a session under Brown, too, but (both now and then) the Democrats in the legislature aren't marching in lockstep on the rare issues where there is a majority in conflict with the Democratic governor, so while the supermajority is significant, it's more because (1) it means swinging a few votes isn't enough to deny a majority, and (2) some legislation requires a supermajority even without a veto, not because of he possibility for veto overrides of a same-party governor.
- themodelplumber 7y agoDoes it really remove the profit motive from incarceration? There are still thousands of vendors of various types making probably billions of dollars off of prisons, private facility or no.
- colecut 7y agoProgress is better than no progress.. Removing profit motives can only happen by reducing profit motives
- elicash 7y agoThey're still making a great point. Yeah it's progress but I think most people aren't aware of the extent of the problem, making further progress impossible. There's some really terrible abuses happening, like replacing visitors with video chat that you have to pay for. More info: https://www.prisonpolicy.org/visitation/ https://www.prisonpolicy.org/visitation/ Another example: getting rid of donated books and libraries in favor of paid tablets that also restrict the books you can buy, both for political and monetary reasons.
- colecut 7y agoTrue... the outrageous telephone call fees being just one completely unjustifiable thing that comes to mind.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- killface 7y agodon't let perfection be the enemy of progress.
- rtkwe 7y agoYeah it's not great but it's a move in the right direction and beyond closing all prisons there will always be a need for vendors to provide goods and services inside prisons. Prisoners need food and clothing at the very least and it'll be bought from someone.
- creaghpatr 7y ago>Servin said that while the new law was a significant victory, there was one other thing immigrants rights groups were concerned about. When several sheriffs’ departments canceled their contracts to house Ice detainees last year, instead of freeing the detainees, Ice moved many of them to prisons in Colorado and Hawaii. Is this something that people against private prisons believe...that they just release all the prisoners when they close the prison?
- wilg 7y agoPerhaps they are concerned that they'll end up in a private prison in another state.
- mieseratte 7y agoMany states have cut sentences in face of prison over-crowding, including California. So, yes, some people believe private-prisons are a useful tool to deal with over-crowding in state facilities and that the likely alternative is further reduced-sentence releases.
- danaliv 7y ago> Is this something that people against private prisons believe...that they just release all the prisoners when they close the prison? There are a few different strains of thought when it comes to opposition to private prisons, but I believe the common denominator is that they create a perverse incentive. They turn prisons into businesses—the more prisoners, the better. So while there are definitely people who want these prisoners freed immediately, and even people who want prisons abolished altogether, getting the profit motive out of prisons would be a significant win regardless.
- vkou 7y ago> There are a few different strains of thought when it comes to opposition to private prisons, but I believe the common denominator is that they create a perverse incentive. They turn prisons into businesses—the more prisoners, the better. The same criticism can be applied towards forced prison labour, and yet, it is explicitly permitted by the thirteenth amendment. (And is commonly used in state prisons.) Just because a profit incentive falls in the hands of the state's coffers, as opposed to some corporation, does not mean the incentive is not perverse.
- cameronbrown 7y agoI'll be the first to admit I'm not the biggest fan of California (housing & homeless crisis spring to mind) but this is great.
- cjensen 7y agoThe cynic and me sees this as a win... for the prison guards union. It seems to me that whether public or private, prisons should have good, independent oversight. Pretending that the "profit motive" is the biggest issue overlooks the horrific abuses committed by guards in California's public prisons.
- wilg 7y agoIt's okay to solve one issue at a time.
- SilasX 7y agoYou're right. People scream bloody murder about "omg! This means a financial incentive for imprisonment" and then ignore how the exact same thing happens with public prisons, in particular how prison guard organizations pushed for Three Strikes to pad demand for their work -- same dynamic. http://www.cjcj.org/uploads/cjcj/documents/the_undue_influence_of_californias_prison_guards_union-californias_correctional_industrial_complex.pdf http://www.cjcj.org/uploads/cjcj/documents/the_undue_influen... And IMHO is bizarrely inconsistent outrage. Want to make a profit from supplying prisons? Activists see no problem with that! Want to make a profit from hiring felons, who are cheaper due to having limited options? Activists give you the thumbs up! Want to make a profit for your private corporation from building a public prison? AOK! But run it for profit? No matter how much oversight or regulation is applied, it's somehow inherently evil. It feels like a distraction.
- anigbrowl 7y agoI'm an abolitionist* and agree with many of your points, but the political leverage to do a 'big bang' reform of the entire criminal justice/carceral system at once doesn't currently exist, nor are there neatly packaged answers for all of the complex problems. , so in the meantime we're still working within an incrementalist framework. * as in that's the political position I hold, I wasn't involved in any way with this initiative or attempting to take credit or provide insider perspective on it.
- rtkwe 7y agoWow bad faith all over the place... People do see problems with all of those, but the only solution to people making a profit from supplying prisons is for there to be no prisons (or for the government to make all the food and clothing soup to nuts, but that'd be crazy). Same with the others the issue with post prison jobs is that they're not enough so hiring them is good and a step down the road to a solution. Reform is a step by step process, getting people used to the idea of thinking of rehabilitation and reintegration instead of the gut instinct to punish takes a lot of time and in the mean time address the worst abuses of the system. In the mean time make sure you're not setting up systems that will fight for their own survival and demand (in some cases by contractual obligations for the state to fill X number of best!) to be fed.
- make3 7y agowow! awesome!
- I_am_tiberius 7y agoI thought such things only exist in movies.
- blancheneige 7y ago>Two of Ice’s largest immigrant detention centers in California Can somebody explain to a legal immigrant why The Guardian keeps omitting the illegal part over twelve times throughout the article?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mikestew 7y agoHas the legality of their immigration been determined at that point? Or is the detention center used to hold them until that has been determined? Regardless, the statement as written is accurate. How many modifiers are necessary?
- blancheneige 7y ago>Has the legality of their immigration been determined at that point? By that logic, how do you even know they're immigrants to begin with, then? All it takes is flashing your visa or any documentation proving your status which you are required to carry at all times, just like I am. You were not expecting bartenders to give you a free pass in your teenage because you left your ID at home, did you? >Regardless, the statement as written is accurate Accuracy by omission is deceit, not journalism. >How many modifiers are necessary? One: illegal immigrant. Now I re-iterate my question: why is it so hard for The Guardian to use the correct terminology?
- nabnob 7y ago>By that logic, how do you even know they're immigrants to begin with, then? All it takes it flashing your visa or any documentation that you are required to carry at all times, just like I am. You were not expecting bartenders to give you a free pass in your teenage because you left your ID at home, did you? ICE actually has detained citizens in the past - https://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2019/07/23/francisco-erwin-galicia-ice-cpb-us-citizen-detained-texas/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2019/07/23/francisco-e... I'm a citizen and I don't usually have my passport on me. If someone asked me to show that I was a citizen, I would have no way to prove it to them.
- llarsson 7y agoGood riddance. The whole premise of private, for-profit, prisons has always seemed deeply troubling to me. The focus of a healthy prison system should be to rehabilitate people and help them turn their lives around so that they contribute positively to society. That can take years of hard work by the individual, and require assistance from professionals (therapists, teachers, ...). A for-profit company by definition seeks to maximize profits. Expensive rehabilitation is therefore immediately off the table, or given at the minimum allowable level. That is just not in the best interest of neither the individuals in the prison system, nor the rest of society.
- jjoonathan 7y agoThat's charitable. The incentive isn't just to get rid of rehabilitation, it's for the private prison to do everything in their power to ensure that their inmates are trapped in a never-ending cycle of crime and recidivism.
- 29_29 7y agoWhat is even scarier is an entity NOT motivated by profits that spends endlessly into a pit sucking resources away from solving bigger issues such as Climate Change, creating a high speed rail network, or educating children. Lets not be against efficiency for the sake of political orthodoxy.
- ryanlol 7y ago>A for-profit company by definition seeks to maximize profits. Expensive rehabilitation is therefore immediately off the table, or given at the minimum allowable level. There's no reason a for-profit company wouldn't be able to provide a high quality service here if the customer actually insisted on (and paid for) such.
- arcticbull 7y agoI'm so happy about this. Private prisons are the scum of the earth. They're totally antithetical to a free society that values human life. They often lobby for minimum occupancy levels in law (effectively requiring by law a certain percentage of citizens to be marked as criminals). Any profit they skim off the top is money that should be spent rehabilitating criminals and making them functional members of society. Next up should be criminalizing charging huge quantities for prisoners to video call / phone call and the usurious fees on commissary. I'd wager $1 in their pockets costs society easily 10X that. [EDIT] Surprise surprise, when Canada experimented with private prisons, they found measurably better outcomes in public prisons [1] and took the private prisons back over. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Private_prison#Canada https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Private_prison#Canada
- refurb 7y agoInteresting Wikipedia page. Seems almost 20% of Australian prisoners are in private prisons! And 15-20% in the UK. Obviously this is not a uniquely US issue another countries are expanding their use.
- giarc 7y agoI'm guessing, but I suspect it's hard to convince voters of the need to build prisons over other large capital expenditures (ex. hospitals, schools etc). Therefore it's easier to convince a private company to spend the money and operate it. Unfortunate, but could be the case.
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y agoSimple solution: don’t make building prisons an election issue. Also, many politicians seem to like appearing to be tough on crime, and their constituents like that.
- magduf 7y agoThe five-eyes countries are all going down the tubes, not just the US.
- oomkiller 7y agoReforming private prisons is just a small part of criminal justice reform. This is a good step but it seems like many are unaware or are ignoring the impact that labor unions have on overcriminalization. Police and corrections unions exist all across the country and share many of the perverse incentives that private prisons do.
- anigbrowl 7y agoVery true. The California Correctional and Peace Officer's Association is one of the largest unions in the state and exercises a good deal of political power, albeit less than it used to. Part of the problem is the division into trade unions, in which different economic sectors have their own unions and can then be rolled over or pandered to as is convenient for business or state interests. Syndicalism is an idea of people in different businesses and employment sectors to combine their labor power more efficiently by avoiding the fragmentation problem.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> The California Correctional and Peace Officer's Association There is no “and”, just “California Correctional Peace Officers Association” (and, as the absence of the “and” suggests, it is just prison guards, and not other law enforcement.)
- anigbrowl 7y agoA careless mistake on my part. Thanks for the correction.
- bluecalm 7y agoOne thing that shouldn't really be controversial. Incentives are misaligned with private prisons. It really hard to find an argument for them.
- thatswrong0 7y agoHonestly, it's a bit of a red herring.. nothing is going to change from a criminal justice perspective. Less than 10% of incarcerated people are held in private prisons. But even more importantly, there are still so many private contractors / unions in the (public/private) prison industry that this ban won't really affect policies or outcomes going forward.. private interests will almost always exist in it that have perverse incentives that are contrary to what's actually good for crime and recidivism rates. [0] An example would be the prison phones / video visitation industry. It's absolutely abhorrent what's going on there (removing in-person visits, replacing them with stupidly expensive phone calls that prisoners can hardly afford).. and yet public prisons / jails are using their services just the same. [1] [0] - https://worthrises.org/picreport2019 https://worthrises.org/picreport2019 [1] - https://www.prisonpolicy.org/phones/state_of_phone_justice.html https://www.prisonpolicy.org/phones/state_of_phone_justice.h... Just look at how expensive those phone calls are :(
- warent 7y agoI don't think that's a fair assessment. Just because it's not a huge revolutionary reform that doesn't make incremental improvements a red herring. These are just steps toward a better world.
- thatswrong0 7y agoI suppose I was being a bit strong. I just don't want anyone to get the impression that it's anything _but_ the teensiest of baby steps.
- sharkmerry 7y agoIs almost 10% of prisoners really only baby steps? I understand your point, they will be transferred to a new prison that will still have private interests, but to call it baby steps still seems exaggerated and defeatist
- pg_is_a_butt 7y agoIt's the biggest step that has been taken in decades. You're completely pathetic.
- warent 7y ago> Private prison companies used to view California as one of their fastest-growing markets. This is such a bizarre and twisted sentence to hear without a hint of irony. It's like dream/nightmare logic except in real life. In 100 years private prisons are going to be a hideous stain on our history and this is such a huge step in the right direction that it really makes me proud to be living in California and supporting the state with my tax dollars.
- lovehashbrowns 7y agoIsn't it? Companies that probably lobby for stricter and longer sentences, looking at a populated state as a "market," with caged human beings as their product. It's the most absurd concept to me, and it's even more disgusting when it's put in such an innocent manner. "Private prison companies used to view California as one of their fastest-growing markets." It just gets more disgusting the more you look into it, and the statistics around incarceration in the US.
- tenkabuto 7y agoJust to throw it out there: the idea isn't absurd; it's evil.
- lovehashbrowns 7y agoYou're completely right on that. Absolutely evil.
- bakuninsbart 7y agoIt is not just that the states are paying them to house convicts (or people accused of a crime), they can even use these people to do jobs for basically no wage. These companies are in the business of slave labor.
- geowwy 7y agoWell done California. Hopefully this is a step towards abolishing the prison system.
- bzbz 7y agoThis is incredible. I can't believe it's happened so soon, putting people (especially such a stigmatized group) above profits really gives hope for the future of the country. Thanks for leading us in this, California.
- ropiwqefjnpoa 7y agoCalifornia passes a sane law, what is happening to this world?
- olivermarks 7y agoNext we have to remove all for-profit 'prisoner support' services such as the staggeringly expensive communications firms that are bleeding prisoners and their relatives dry.
- Animats 7y agoCalifornia's prison population is declining. Especially in juveniles. So there's less need for prison space.
- sandworm101 7y agoSo does this also ban private companies from operating inside prisons? Most of them don't care who holds the actual keys so long as they can take advantage of the prisoners. They may not be the warden, but they can still control the purse strings.
- spoiledtechie 7y agoI would recommend you do some research on this topic. Your giving talking points produced by mainstream talking heads. When in fact, research points to private prisons being better at dropping incarceration rates through the programs offered at them. Therefore increasing ones chance at correct rehabilitation. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/249718665_A_Comparative_Recidivism_Analysis_of_Releasees_From_Private_and_Public_Prisons https://www.researchgate.net/publication/249718665_A_Compara...
- goda90 7y agoBut could public prisons have even better results if there weren't heavy lobbying for various laws and policies? It seems like it's another case ripe for regulatory capture to degrade the public option.
- heavenlyblue 7y agoYou have already quoted this research in another thread and someone had already replied to you it was done in 1991 and only had 200 samples in it.
- mlevental 7y agoI'm sorry does it? that's not what the paper says at all "Those released from private prisons who reoffended committed less serious subsequent offenses than did their public prison counterparts. The two groups were similar in how long it took for rearrest or for the first recidivism event to occur"
- anigbrowl 7y agotalking points produced by mainstream talking heads. Dismissing other people's comments as not their own is kinda insulting and derails discussion. Obviously exceptions exist for people who spam the same thing over and over, but it's a negative debate tactic that often veers into fallacy.
- spoiledtechie 7y agoI would recommend you do some research on this topic. Your giving a talking point produced by mainstream talking heads. When in fact, research points to private prisons being better at dropping incarceration rates through the programs offered at them. Therefore increasing ones chance at correct rehabilitation. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/249718665_A_Comparative_Recidivism_Analysis_of_Releasees_From_Private_and_Public_Prisons https://www.researchgate.net/publication/249718665_A_Compara...
- lllr_finger 7y agoYou're all over this thread, and people have already put your resources under a critical light. What is your relationship with the private prison sector and why are you so passionate about it?
- heavenlyblue 7y agoThird time I am seeing this commenter mentioning this link. The research was done in 1991 and only had 200 samples.
- dang 7y agoPlease don't repeat the same comment multiple times. It lowers the signal/noise ratio.
- KingMachiavelli 7y ago> The contracts for these four prisons expire in 2023 and cannot be renewed under AB32, except to comply with a federal court order to reduce crowding in state-run facilities. Hmm, something tells me these will end up being renewed considering getting budget approval and completing construction in 3 years is basically impossible so unless Californa has some prisons with spare space or in-progress new construction. OR, even better, reduces it's prison population... we may still have some private prisons for a while. Still fantastic news.
- hanniabu 7y agoYeah, seems there will just be frequent bribes for court ordered private facilities. Or lobby (bribe) to have maximum occupancies in state prisons reduced in order to make over crowding more likely.
- jedberg 7y agoThe next step is for the Governor to pardon all the people who are in for possession and other "lesser crimes" and the release them over the next there years, alleviating the need for additional prison space.
- scarejunba 7y agoWell, we're releasing on the marijuana dudes, right? So hopefully that makes some room.
- jquery 7y agoWhat's going to happen to the existing private prisons? I assume this involves tearing up very expensive contracts. Will the government purchase them and convert them to public ones?
- jedberg 7y agoThe law says that current contracts can run until expiration, which is a few years from now. They'll have to either release prisoners, move them, or incarcerate fewer people (or a combination thereof) otherwise they'll have to renew the private contract, which is also allowed under the law if necessary to alleviate overcrowding.
- amatecha 7y agoDude this is great news. Keeping people in prison should never be a for-profit initiative.
- chroma 7y agoI think private prisons could work if: - Convicts could choose whether to be sent to a public or private prison. - Private prisons had financial incentives for post-incarceration behavior. Eg: If their prisoner recidivism rate after 3 years was 10% lower than the average public prison, they would get a 20% bonus. Those changes would create enough competition and align incentives such that we could see some real innovation in the criminal justice system. Sadly, I don't think these sorts of experiments will ever be tried. If someone ever proposes such a system, they'll be branded a supporter of "private prisons".
- calcifer 7y ago> If their prisoner recidivism rate after 3 years was 10% lower than the average public prison, they would get a 20% bonus. Ah, so the people who profit off of others' misery would be able to profit even further if they treat prisoners like human beings? Great incentive indeed. > If someone ever proposes such a system, they'll be branded a supporter of "private prisons". You propose such a system and I don't see how you are not supporting private prisons, so yeah. But, lets be charitable and assume you don't really mean to support private prisons and are just interested in the well being of inmates, and you'd like to motivate the prison company to do the right thing. How about a structure where they don't make any profit whatsoever (state only covers costs) unless, say, 50 year recidivism rate is below 2%? If that was my company, I'd move heaven and earth to make sure every prisoner left that place an angel. Would you support that motion?
- chroma 7y agoIf the incentives you proposed were enacted, there would be no private prisons because any company that tried would go bankrupt. (Unless you mean that the state would cover any costs incurred by the private prison, in which case you'd just get prisons run by grifters.) California's state-run prisons have a recidivism rate of 65% within 3 years. A 2% rate of conviction over 50 years is lower than the population of non-convicts. It's not possible for any organization to accomplish that. Also, the company would have to wait 50 years for payout. Even if that payout is with interest, 50 years is beyond the time horizons of most governments, let alone companies.
- univalent 7y agoGreat job CA legislators. Prisons for profit were an abomination. Good riddance.
- aazaa 7y ago> “We have to worry about all the people who are detained right now,” said Servine. “Where will they end up?” Along those lines, what's the plan for dealing with the inmates from other prisons that this legislation will make ineligible? For example, there's a private correctional center in California City: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_City_Correctional_Center https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_City_Correctional_C...
- gigatexal 7y agoWholly supported. There’s no way a private prison would be incentivized to lower recidivism but is instead incentivized to increase it. Here’s to hoping we foster rehabilitation over punishment in our prisons and put an end to what is effectively slave labor (inmates making things for pennies on the dollar).
- domnomnom 7y agoWhile probably a good idea, I fear somehow the execution will be butchered by incompetence and then blamed on cops or racism. Issues have a tendency to go left unsolved when maintaining a narrative takes precedent over actual problem solving.
- frankbreetz 7y agoCalifornia has been busy the past couple weeks, they passed the rent control law, a labor law about contract workers(mainly about Uber and Lift drivers), and now this.
- thoughtpalette 7y agoI was thinking the same once I noticed this headline on the front page. California has been busy.
- missingcolours 7y agoGotta be something to that, end of legislative session maybe?
- newnewpdro 7y agoCan we do something about Betsy DeVos and the efforts to privatize our public school systems next?
- djstein 7y ago>kamala harris hated this
- maxcan 7y agoI've always wanted to see a lambda school model for private prisons. they get some share of an inmates future tax revenue but pay a significant penalty if ex-inmates re-offend. I've reached out to Austen..
- acd 7y agoWell done California. - Private prisons has no incentive of getting rid of its income source the prisoners. - More emphasis should be put into preventive nature. Ie to stop people from becoming criminals. This most likely involves more instruction on how to raise children. If analog was to computer program it is cheapest to do things correct at the design phase, once late in the phase the issue hits production it is very expensive to mitigate. Thus we should as society do maximum effort into supporting young children and parents. Once the person has turned into a criminal it is very expensive for society to correct the issue if at all possible.
- supsep 7y agoI am looking at all the other major news publishers, and none of them have this on their front page.
- papito 7y ago$3 per day per inmate on average for food, keep the wig, leave us with a wreck of a human, covering his/her medical bills until end of life.
- superbaconman 7y agoI heard a very interesting take on this topic on local radio. Basically, on average private prisons are no worse than public prisons as both make many of the same mistakes. The only difference is that public prisons are invulnerable to reform. https://wfhb.org/news/kite-line-september-6-2019-the-business-of-incarceration-a-conversation-with-craig-gilmore/ https://wfhb.org/news/kite-line-september-6-2019-the-busines...
- einpoklum 7y ago> The only difference is that public prisons are invulnerable to reform. None are invulnerable to legislative reform. However, _private_ ones are closer to it, since they're, well, private. > No worse If you mean they're both terrible, exploitative, have guard violence, don't provide reasonable facilities, don't provide opportunities for personal development and education, and underfunded - maybe you're right. (although frankly I doubt it.) Mass incarceration in general is a perverse US government sport / poor people population management/behavior shaping mechanism, anyway.
- ulzeraj 7y agoHere in Brazil criminals riot to be transferred to private prisons because the ones ran by the state are inhuman.
- artur_makly 7y agoThese John Oliver docs were very illuminating: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AjqaNQ018zU&t=2s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AjqaNQ018zU&t=2s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gJtYRxH5G2k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gJtYRxH5G2k
- ineedasername 7y agoI'm sure there's at least a few free market purists that will decry this move as it removes competition from the market, but this happens to be one instance where public prisons actually cost less on average than when outsourced to the private market [0] [0] https://www.criminaljusticeprograms.com/articles/private-prisons-vs-public-prisons/ https://www.criminaljusticeprograms.com/articles/private-pri...
- tathougies 7y agoI really doubt it, most libertarians and free market purists object to the idea of anyone but government being able to violently deprive someone of their rights without repercussion. The reaction on forums like /r/libertarian is mainly positive.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- etaty 7y agoJust for fun, same sentence on health care. > I'm so happy about this. Private health care insure are the scum of the earth. They're totally antithetical to a free society that values human life. They often lobby for minimum health care coverage in law (effectively requiring by law a certain percentage of citizens to be marked as clients). Any profit they skim off the top is money that should be spent on research and education. Next up should be criminalizing charging huge quantities for basic health care by private hospitals and the usurious fees on drugs. I'd wager $1 in their pockets costs society easily 10X that.
- arcticbull 7y agoYes, I'm also in favor of socialized medicine for basically exactly these reasons. Shocker, I know. The system works! I grew up in socialized medicine, and you get sick, you go to the hospital, they treat you and you leave. There's no step 4. Why Americans continue to willingly subject themselves to these torturous systems is beyond me. It's all in y'alls control.
- luckydata 7y agoBecause they've been sold lies for years and most of them can't really believe everything they know about such an important aspect of their life is bull.
- jorblumesea 7y ago> Why Americans continue to willingly subject themselves to these torturous systems They've been told socialized medicine is evil communist plot to steal their hard earned money. Many Americans have not been outside of the states and have no concept of what life in other countries might be like. There's a good percentage of Americans that are completely ignorant of how the rest of the world does things, and also dismiss this as inferior. They've been told their entire life that the US is the greatest country, so, why would we do it any other way?
- TaylorAlexander 7y agoYour comment seems flatly accurate and yet you get downvoted. I still can’t understand this phenomenon.
- sambull 7y agoPrivate prisons is how you get kids sold our by corrupt judges
- 55orolder 7y agoI find it fascinating that private prisons draw such ire while the prison guard union draws so little, when the prison guard union has all the exact same incentives and is drastically more powerful. California would have had legal marijuana a decade sooner except for lobbing by the union, they're a major force for mandatory minimum sentences and tougher sentencing in general. This seems like a trivial easy-PR win for some legislators that does very little to meaningfully address the problems with criminal justice in the US. Private prisons are a tiny little piece of a much bigger problem and there's still a lot of real work to be done.
- EdwardDiego 7y ago> when the prison guard union has all the exact same incentives and is drastically more powerful. Could you please provide me some examples? I figure if California's prisons were 200% of capacity, there's no shortage of work for the prison guards anyway.
- throwawayjava 7y ago> I figure if California's prisons were 200% of capacity, there's no shortage of work for the prison guards anyway. I'm not sure how/why you figure that, or how it's at all relevant. I'm not sure how/why you figure that because "over capacity" != "will build new prisons / hire new guards". I.e., it's not at all impossible for there to be prisons that are over-capacity and also a decline in the number of prison guard jobs. It's not relevant because the entire point of unions is to counter-act the effect of supply/demand dynamics on labor (see: "there's always another scab"). Just because there's "no shortage of work for the prison guards" doesn't mean they will lobby against changes to laws that might one day create such a shortage.
- cf498 7y agoOr they could just work towards better working conditions? Unions dont really have the growth incentive private entities do. Prison guards are extremely far from running out of work, quite the opposite is true and their members also suffer under the poor working conditions of an chronically understaffed and underpaid sector. They are risking their life because politicians think overcrowding prisons isnt a problem. I mean I get the initial point, some police unions are an especially vile proponents of an expansion into a police state, its just not really about working conditions. Its political lobbying. In Germany you can see it every time more competences for the police are discussed in parliament. You have some police unions giving legit feedback if someone bothers to ask them, how those competences are a bad idea and are not needed. And then you have speakers for other police union (with a catchy union name to seem more important) where you can see they have the right party membership and are looking for a career in politics. As a result you can see them in every news report that wants to bring across a certain message.
- imsofuture 7y agoIt's almost like capitalism is a disease.
- scarejunba 7y agoNonsense. There are things where the pricing mechanism of allowing free enterprise allow us to search for and converge to an optimum. There are other things where information asymmetry, problem opacity, and transaction costs mean that it's better handled a different way. It isn't an ideological problem. You'll see this choice in places like companies, where people band together to solve a problem rather than invoicing each other to get to some objective.
- imsofuture 7y agoI don't disagree, but our current socioeconomic/government system leads us to wildly bad situations where we have privatized industries hellbent on extracting every last cent possible from disadvantaged populations (in every sense of the word) and then using that money to further their aims and resource extraction via influencing legislature. It spreads, it's self perpetuating, it's sick, and it is a disease.
- scarejunba 7y agoI am in agreement on there being a problem where you can turn money into legislation. That does destabilize the system through regulatory capture. Haven't encountered satisfactory solutions yet.
- Legogris 7y agoMore like, the free market works great for certain things (integrated circuits) and horribly for others (prisons, highways). Between that you have a range of things like healthcare, education, transport and postal systems. Where you draw the line does correlate heavily with ideology. Communism on one end and anarcho-captialism on the other.
- jtolmar 7y agoThat's markets, not capitalism. Capitalism is specifically the arrangement where the means of production can be bought and sold (on the market). It's only been around since the industrial revolution - prior to that the means of production were too simple to do this sort of thing with, and there was just land and labor. Markets have been around a lot longer. Non-capitalist but still market-based systems are possible. You can have worker ownership (worker co-ops like Bob's Red Mill), consumer ownership (consumer co-ops like REI), state ownership (national healthcare or municipal utility companies), or some mix of them. These organizations can and often do still compete with each other on the market.
- lacker 7y agoThis applies for four prisons. But, from the article: The contracts for these four prisons expire in 2023 and cannot be renewed under AB32, except to comply with a federal court order to reduce crowding in state-run facilities. That court order is still in effect and doesn't seem likely to go away any time soon. So... the contracts can be renewed? It's not clear to me if this law is going to make a difference.
- luhn 7y agoWhy have the past couple days seen several high-profile California laws passed?
- elady 7y agoThat's one step forward!
- daheza 7y agoI'm pretty happy about the laws california has been enacting recently, this plus the uber / lyft law both align with my views. I'm glad that politicians are actually doing what we vote them in todo.
- Hex-3-En 7y agoFun thing, I just watched this a couple days ago: https://youtu.be/wtV5ev6813I https://youtu.be/wtV5ev6813I spoiler: no private prisons in Germany
- nickstinemates 7y agoA great day for California.
- mud_dauber 7y agoThis is the best news I've seen all month. Maybe all year. Props to California.
- lanevorockz 7y agoIt is very silly to be happy about something you not yet know the results, it's interesting and can be a case study. As long as the government doesn't fiddle with the numbers to manipulate voters.
- celticmusic 7y agoI've never understood how we, as a society, accept private prisons. I've also understood why police hiding behind bridges was considered acceptable. Or how the hell a debate about waterboarding could ever happen when it's clearly immoral. At some point in my life I just decided we suck shit as a society and move on.
- mike741 7y agoi think you just answered your own question there at the end
- lr4444lr 7y agoHope they soon go after privately run homeless "shelters" as well, another huge pit of waste and corruption in dereliction of public duty.
- t34543 7y agoGreat news! I first learned about private prisons over a decade ago and since then I am in disbelief by how many people aren’t aware there are for profit prisons. Really good move. Bravo.
- jorblumesea 7y agoIt's frustrating that most reform and change is happening at the state level. It just means a completely fractured political environment where some states are progressive around data and prisons, whereas others are regressive. As a company, how do you even enforce things like privacy standards at a state level instead of national? Seems like a terribly complicated and inefficient system.
- wind0w 7y agoGreat news! Let's work on abolishing public prisons next.
- randiantech 7y agoSo no prisons at all? So murders should be free, for example?
- wind0w 7y agoExactly. Crime is a social and economic problem that prisons and police do little to solve, with great harm to society. Our resources would be better spent elsewhere.
- randiantech 7y agoWondering from where it comes the optimism in this thread for this ban. Ive traveled to more than 40 countries, and lived for some time in 5, all of them with public prison monopolies. In all of them the prison systems turn to be terrible. And by terrible, I mean that the US prisons look like 5 stars hotels compared to them. For reference, I was in most south american and caribbean countries, Spain, Portugal among others.
- 9HZZRfNlpR 7y agoWhat is it with Spanish prisons? I live here and have heard about the problem of foreigners from UK and US not wanting to serve time in their owne country. They prefer here, but overpopulation is a problem, hence the articles about the cases.
- pruthvishetty 7y agoWow, didn't know there were private prisons!
- droithomme 7y agoBanning private prisons is good. Public prisons though are not necessarily good. I remember when a good friend was forcibly sterilized without consent by California state official directed medical staff. Eugenics and genocide has been a fundamental part of the Golden State's agenda for over a century.
- Dedi9688 7y agoI'm so happy about this
- magwa101 7y agoFINALLY
- tlobes 7y agoAre there any private prison models that were shown to be more effective than their peers or public counterparts? While I agree that the vast majority (if not all) of private prisons, and those who participated in profiting from them, are ugly spots on the progress of modern humanity, I'm weary about an overall ban on the concept altogether. Rather than creating rules against an evil business model or incentives to promote a beneficial one, this "unabashedly California" move cuts off any hope of someone with an ounce of morality to disrupt and ideally create a prison system that truly aims to reform inmates.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deboboy 7y agoA private prison on Earth today is a one way ticket to Mars tomorrow.
- jossmexico 7y agoAm listenning to the dem debate now where kamala (?) mentioned (promised) to ban private prisons. Coincidence?
- baby 7y agoRent control, and now this? California is turning into a good state!
- tectonic 7y agoThis is such good news.
- sabujp 7y agoGOOD, if we can start rehabilitating prisoners, giving them skills to succeed outside of prison then there might be a chance. Yes, I know many have psychological issues and they can't be fixed without a complete brain rewire or hard drugs but many are non-violent and poor.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- SomeHacker44 7y agoIf the government does not want to run prisons, don't send so many people to prison. Prisons and other core governmental services should never be outsourced.
- PorterDuff 7y agoI was busy doing God's Work (upvoting any downvoted posts) and was considering the article. So far as I can tell, the point of the article is that this is another salvo in the war between California and the federal government in terms of who gets to run immigration law, not some sort of newfound distaste for private prisons. Curious that all the posts are about private vs. public prisons. I did poke around a bit and the private prisons don't appear to be cheaper, and it's rather surprising that they even exist given the amount of power public unions have. Perhaps someone in the biz could pipe up, just what is the point of a private prison? All that occurs to me is the opportunity to ramp up a facility quickly or perhaps just the need for a law enforcement organization to park people when they don't want to be in that business. Dunno.
- charlescearl 7y agoIt's a start. Thank you Ruth Wilson, thank you Angela Davis https://www.nytimes.com/2019/04/17/magazine/prison-abolition-ruth-wilson-gilmore.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/04/17/magazine/prison-abolition... https://books.google.com/books/about/Golden_Gulag.html?id=zThPAQAAQBAJ&printsec=frontcover&source=kp_read_button#v=onepage&q&f=false https://books.google.com/books/about/Golden_Gulag.html?id=zT...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Paul-ish 7y agoIn "Locked In" John Pfaff makes the point that private prisons are not the problem. It is a more nuanced problem, but prosecutors play a large part in our national incarceration problems. Definitely recommend the read (or listen as an audiobook as I did).
- throwawayjava 7y ago> but prosecutors play a large part in our national incarceration problems The problem is pro-punishment politicians. Singling out any particular office/position misses the point. Even when judges practice discretion, pro-punishment legislators step in and introduce mandatory minimums. And even when prosecutors practice discretion, pro-punishment judges will step in and force them to prosecute cases that the prosecutors don't want to prosecute [1]. [1] See Suffolk County for a recent example
- Paul-ish 7y agoPfaff has pretty good data to back up his claim. He looks at legislation. He looks at mandatory minimums. Everyone plays their part, but prosecutors have a lot of power over sentencing. Plea deals play a role here. And in many places prosecutors are politicians in a sense, because they are elected. One recommendation is to go back to appointing prosecutors rather than electing them. So no, singling out prosecutors doesn't miss the point. It is an important point.
- throwawayjava 7y agoYes, but it's become in the past couple years an out dated point in major cities (Boston, Philly, LA) where activist prosecutors attempting to prosecute fewer crimes and hand out lighter sentences are now being stymied by (appointed!) judges. The problem with focusing on any particular role is that the other parts of the system will step in to force punishment.
- vajaya 7y agoI watched an episode of last week tonight in which John Oliver covers issues of private prisons. Basically it's inmates being exploited by extremely low paid labor and various unreasonable charges for necessities. But I don't see how government run prisons can solve or mitigate the problems.
- purnama777 7y agoPrivate prisoners are very dangerous and torture prisoners as in the movie prison break
- hackerinjail 7y agoIf private prisons are anything like private schools, this really sucks. Public schools are run like community jails. Imagine being transferred from a private prison to a "real" prison.
- Pavlos2016 7y agoWas about time !
- countryqt30 7y agoSounds like California is entering an ERA OF MASSIVE OVERREGULATION. Goodbye, startups, goodbye investors :(
- subroutine 7y agoCalifornia prisons are pure hell. Listen to a few min of this interview; it's eye opening (warning: prison language)... https://youtu.be/2I4imzTOpQM https://youtu.be/2I4imzTOpQM
- charlescearl 7y agoThe first public academic to my knowledge to begin crystalizing the problem of private prisons and the prison industrial complex was Angela Davis [1] -- I first remember hearing her address this in a 1998 lecture at Northwestern. Ruth Wilson [2,3] has worked for years analyzing and working to end the expansion and privatization of California's prisons, through both academic and grass roots efforts [4]. Her "Golden Gulag: Prisons, Surplus, Crisis, and Opposition in Globalizing California" [5] book is both accessible and rigorous, I highly recommend it. I am a bit shocked that their and foundational work were not mentioned in the piece. There's a discussion between Davis and Wilson here [6] where they surface the mass incarceration/private prison issue, and detail the pathology of California's prison system. [1]https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/1583225811/ref=dbs_a_def_rwt_bibl_vppi_i0 https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/1583225811/ref=dbs_a_def_r... [2]https://www.nytimes.com/2019/04/17/magazine/prison-abolition-ruth-wilson-gilmore.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/04/17/magazine/prison-abolition... [3] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sTPjC-7EDkc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sTPjC-7EDkc [4] http://criticalresistance.org/ http://criticalresistance.org/ [5] https://www.amazon.com/Golden-Gulag-Opposition-Globalizing-California/dp/0520242017/ref=pd_sbs_14_6/140-9692660-6198769?_encoding=UTF8&pd_rd_i=0520242017&pd_rd_r=967d5b8c-466b-4fec-9974-b0ffa782f3e5&pd_rd_w=dsvaO&pd_rd_wg=nl4CJ&pf_rd_p=d66372fe-68a6-48a3-90ec-41d7f64212be&pf_rd_r=E6HJNZAF3HPJE5KMQ3MK&psc=1&refRID=E6HJNZAF3HPJE5KMQ3MK https://www.amazon.com/Golden-Gulag-Opposition-Globalizing-C... [6] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FGPVPrJGXsY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FGPVPrJGXsY
- williesleg 7y agoIf we all do exactly the opposite of California we have a chance. Why else would so many flee such a beautiful state?
- alfiedotwtf 7y agoThe sad and bitter truth: as the anecdotal Silicon Valley startup CEO is a closet right leaning Republican donor, and with the amount of military money up for grabs, I'm surprised to not see a flurry of startups "disrupting" prisons yet /0.5s
- thecleaner 7y agoCalif seems to be on fire these days (no pun intended). They are passing one great legislation after another.
- test22 7y agoIs there any country where prisons are empty?
- test22 7y agoPrivate, lol
- stefek99 7y agoI find it fascinating how incentives shape human behaviour: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prison–industrial_complex https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prison–industrial_complex
- sample2448 7y agoSocialist state of california strikes again
- trustlyppp 7y agoI have suffered a lot when it come to relationships and even when I was married,that is why I want to give thanks to Papa Egbe for bringing back my husband.I was the world’s biggest skeptic.I never believed in magic spells,but I was told by a very close friend that Papa Egbe is gifted with spiritual powers,My love life was in shamble,my husband didn’t seem to care or love me and break up our relationship.I was confuse and do not no what to do again,rather then to get in contact with Papa Egbe.He did a love spell that make my husband come back to me.we are now very much happy with our self.Papa Egbe make him to realize how much we love and need each other.And he can help you with the following problems:Court Case.Reading.Bad Dreams.Promotion in your office.Financial Assistance.Herbal cured for Herpes Simplex Virus.Lottery Spell.Love Spell.contact Papa Egbe on papaegbeherbalhome @ gmail . com.Papa Egbe brought happiness to my home.