49 ms·
Joi Ito Resigns from M.I.T. Media Lab After Outcry over Jeffrey Epstein Ties
- draw_down 7y agohttps://twitter.com/Joi/status/770625716 https://twitter.com/Joi/status/770625716
- floatingatoll 7y agoText of linked tweet: > reminder to self: don't invest with or take money from assholes @ 4:20 PM · Mar 12, 2008
- jakelazaroff 7y agoGood. Here’s a particularly damning passage from Ronan Farrow’s New Yorker article [1]: > According to Swenson, Ito had informed Cohen that Epstein “never goes into any room without his two female ‘assistants,’ ” whom he wanted to bring to the meeting at the Media Lab. Swenson objected to this, too, and it was decided that the assistants would be allowed to accompany Epstein but would wait outside the meeting room. > On the day of the visit, Swenson’s distress deepened at the sight of the young women. “They were models. Eastern European, definitely,” she told me. Among the lab’s staff, she said, “all of us women made it a point to be super nice to them. We literally had a conversation about how, on the off chance that they’re not there by choice, we could maybe help them.” Ito worked with someone whom his staff suspected of continuing to traffic women — right there in their own office. He also enriched himself from this relationship. From this NYT article: > Mr. Ito acknowledged this past week taking $525,000 of Mr. Epstein’s money for the lab, as well as $1.2 million for his personal investment funds. Truly despicable. [1] https://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/how-an-elite-university-research-center-concealed-its-relationship-with-jeffrey-epstein https://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/how-an-elite-univer...
- nf8nnfufuu 7y agoSorry, I don't get it. Somebody having assistants who look like models and are from Eastern Europe is suspicious of trafficking women? How? Why? I have heard about Epstein, obviously with hindsight all sorts of things he did can be seen in a new light. I just don't understand what is so damning about the passage above. Would somebody who is trafficking women really take them everywhere he goes? I thought it would be more of a secret affair.
- juliendorra 7y agoBecause he had already been convicted before and was (as Swenson learned previously, as you can read in the op cited new-yorker article on the issue) banned from being a MIT donor for this reason. Context matters.
- floatingatoll 7y agoYes, he would, especially if he thought he had enough leverage to protect himself from the consequences.
- empath75 7y agoIt’s not a theoretical question as to whether he was trafficking women. He had already been convicted of it! And was charged with it again.
- nf8nnfufuu 7y agoWhy was he running around free then? Had he already passed his time in jail?
- jacobolus 7y ago> Why was he running around free then? Because Bush-appointed US Attorney Alex Acosta (until recently Trump’s Secretary of Labor) made an illegal plea agreement to let Epstein off the hook and cover up the details of his criminality. https://www.miamiherald.com/news/state/florida/article226577419.html https://www.miamiherald.com/news/state/florida/article226577... Some extremely rich and powerful men were among Epstein’s child-rapist co-conspirators, so there are strong pressures on law enforcement officials to sweep the whole thing under the rug.
- ajross 7y agoRelevant to that quote, it's important to point out that this kind of influence peddling fell apart, not when Epstein himself got caught, but when enough people at a high level decided they didn't want to be part of it. Ito himself clearly viewed himself as a kind of fellow traveller in Epstein's world (no idea if that involves sex trafficing! That's not my point!). Gates did too. But Signe Swenson wasn't as willing to put up with that, even if she couldn't personally stop it. And by 2016, she was in the room too. You can look at this through a "fuck the patriarchy" lens or insist on the fact that this was just people being people. But at the end of the day this is why diversity matters. Epstein's lures only worked on hetero men, and he fell when faced with a world of influential women.
- turtlecloud 7y agoHerero men is irrelevant. If the situation had been reversed with gay men then it would be young boys instead.
- ajross 7y agoIn which case it would be really useful to have some strait dudes at the table when discussing the gay pedo's contributions, no? I think you agree with the point, just not with the particular identities in the example.
- ineedasername 7y agoSo the only thing that can stop a hetero man is not a hetero man? No. Men who bought into his image were a certain type of person much more narrow in category than hetero man. And so you don't get the wrong idea, I'm absolutely not saying diversity isn't important. It is, for so many reasons, important to have people of diverse backgrounds and experiences around, in positions of authority, at all levels. Just not for this one particular reason of sniffing out predators.
- ajross 7y ago> It is, for so many reasons, important to have people of diverse backgrounds and experiences around, in positions of authority, at all levels. Just not for this one particular reason of sniffing out predators. You're being hyperspecific here with your disagreement. I think if start enumerating them, you'll find almost all of those advantages you believe in are isomorphic to "different perspectives prevent groupthink". And alignment with the social world of a hyper-rich sex peddler is absolutely a kind of groupthink, no? Again, Epstein could have his way with organizations run by horny men. That was literally his scam. And as the article (and others) details, this remained true even after he got caught, because enough horny men didn't "really" see what he did as so bad. But that ended once someone was in the room who didn't see things through that lens. That is diversity at work.
- xhkkffbf 7y agoTraffic women? If the women didn't want to be there, they had every opportunity to run away or even file a police report. Let's not compare the 1st world problem of some elite women with what's going on in third world brothels where the women really have no where else to turn. These women were complicit and, shoot, probably bragged about their jobs.
- say_it_as_it_is 7y agoOn the day they met, Epstein wasn't a fugitive. He was exonerated. Due diligence showed that Epstein went through the legal process and came out the other end intact. Epstein remained a powerful, rich, influential who clearly established himself as among the highest class of political elites. Refusing Epstein's money would have hurt the lab's reputation among his people. Accepting the money was far less costly.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mcguire 7y agoTurns out,...not so much.
- aaron695 7y ago>Ito worked with someone whom his staff suspected of continuing to traffic women — right there in their own office. Doesn't say anything other than you and these office people are racist. That's 'truly despicable'. The need to virtual signal so much you devalue other people as human beings to the point of fantasy. This is straight from pizzagate style stuff. 4chan is now in HN it seems. I can't believe these comments on this thread. No one ever leave the basement and actually see human trafficking IRL? Or it just a toy to bring out and play with? Here's a hint if you want to leave virtual signalling and help people you'll have to deal with 'real' moral dilemmas.
- curiousgal 7y ago>We literally had a conversation about how, on the off chance that they’re not there by choice, we could maybe help them.” Oh I'm sure that happened! /s It is worth noting that this person not only resigned in part because of the ties to Epstein (according to her) but also knew about said ties before she took the job. Why is it hard to simply tell everything as it happened without trying to embellish one's picture in vain?
- blub 7y agoA model from Eastern Europe is someone that does fashion modeling and is from that area. Euphemistically it could be someone from EE that has sex for money, but you don't want to beat around the bush when describing child sex abuse. So they should either clearly say underage-looking girls or remove that paragraph because it's irrelevant and confusing. I mean this is a story about child abuse and the author didn't think to ask those women if the "models" looked underage? This guy was having sex with underage teens and possibly pre-teens, not "models" and not "young women".
- GuiA 7y ago> This guy was raping underage teens and possibly pre-teens FTFY. An adult can’t “have sex” with a pre-teen.
- sharpneli 7y agoLegal definitions of this differ per country. As an example pedophilia in Finland is defined in criminal code as having sex with a person under 16. Rape is a different crime. Sure you can also define it using rape and defining that a minor cannot give consent. In the end these are just semantics. End result is the same.
- GuiA 7y agoThere are no situations where an 11 year old having sex with a grown adult man isn’t rape. Sure, some cultures or religions might say otherwise, but at the end of the day it’s just basic ethics. It is just semantics, but everything in our life is semantics, so words are important. “Having sex” makes it sound casual and like relationship of equals, which it is not.
- stale2002 7y ago> It is just semantics, but everything in our life is semantics, so words are important. Only if you don't understand the meaning that someone is intending to impart by using those words. And I'd say that in this case, there should have been zero confusion, and that it was perfectly clear what people were trying to say, so the words used don't matter.
- CrazyStat 7y agoThis seemed inevitable after the New Yorker article yesterday detailing how Ito and his team hid Epstein's involvement from the university, which had disqualified Epstein as a donor. Taking money from a dirty source is one thing; hiding it from the university because they've blacklisted that person in particular is about as unforgivable a crime as you'll find in academia
- jpmattia 7y ago> Taking money from a dirty source is one thing; hiding it from the university because they've blacklisted that person in particular is about as unforgivable a crime as you'll find in academia TBH, I've never heard of a blacklisted donor at MIT, so I'm a little surprised (pleasantly, as an alum).
- nullc 7y agoI'm confused by the blacklisted donor thing. The first questions I had when reading about it was "when did he end up on this list?", "why did he end up on it?, and "how big is this list?" It doesn't seem like any of the journalists even asked. That sounds like a very interesting story in and of itself.
- Retric 7y agoYea, I suspect his prior conviction for “solicitation of prostitution involving a minor” may have played a part. But, the details could be interesting.
- nullc 7y agoI wonder how that happens, like what would have caused them to take notice and add him to a list? In part, I wonder if it has any connection to Gregory Benford's description of Minsky's interaction with Epstein: https://pjmedia.com/instapundit/339725/ https://pjmedia.com/instapundit/339725/
- 7y ago
- frankwiles 7y agoJesus. Who lets a guy get away with that for so freaking long?
- sysbin 7y agoJesus
- chaostheory 7y agoMost people would if it’s normalized. Not long ago Saudi Arabian money and PRC money was just fine. It’s hard not to take it when it’s about survival.
- khazhou 7y ago> Not long ago Saudi Arabian money and PRC money was just fine Wait, did something change this morning? AFAIK it's still fine and dandy to take Saudi money (esp. if you're the US government) and Chinese too.
- khuey 7y agoIf you work in tech you have to launder the Saudi money through Softbank but otherwise it's fine.
- pessimizer 7y agoTo certain values of "survival" which apply to people in no physical danger.
- chaostheory 7y agoHN is less of a broad community than say reddit. Not all, but many of the perspectives are going to be from a tech startup POV
- freyr 7y agoIsn't "taking Saudi money" Uber's current business model?
- electriclove 7y agoThis is just one of sooo many.. the others truly need to be held responsible as well.
- 0x8BADF00D 7y agoThat will not happen. The others are a group so powerful, if you attempt to criticize them, your life will be ruined. They literally control speech and thought around the world.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- danso 7y agoSomeone who was asked by Ito to be on the MIT Disobedience Award jury wrote a long tweet thread yesterday calling out Reid Hoffman for his defense of Ito: https://twitter.com/anandwrites/status/1169952673988300800 https://twitter.com/anandwrites/status/1169952673988300800
- mrosett 7y agoI don't think that thread shows that Hoffman defended Ito, despite the author's claims. I'm basically willing to take Hoffman's responses at face value. Clearly there was an ongoing investigation, as demonstrated by Ito's resignation today. When news broke about Ito and Epstein last month, Giriharadas was pretty far down on the list of people who Ito needed to answer to (since he was just part of what I imagine to be a mostly ceremonial award committee.) I see evidence that Hoffman didn't think Giriharadas should be dictating the course of the investigation, but not evidence that Hoffman tried to impede in any way. After all, this same Disobedience award went to #MeToo activists last year... Ultimately, this thread does feel a lot like the author making a dreadful scandal about himself.
- bertil 7y ago> Ultimately, this thread does feel a lot like the author making a dreadful scandal about himself. This is what Hoffman is saying, and it would be very on-brand for Giriharadas to do so.
- CrazyStat 7y ago>Clearly there was an ongoing investigation, as demonstrated by Ito's resignation today. That's not clear at all, at least if you're talking about an investigation conducted or commissioned by MIT. Ito's sudden resignation seems likely to have been prompted by the damning New Yorker article published yesterday. Another commenter posted the email sent out by MIT's president today, which refers to yesterday's New Yorker article and indicates that the university has just commissioned an investigation in reaponse to it.
- AndrewBissell 7y agoThis isn't the only dodgy behavior that's been reported about Hoffman in regards to Epstein. It's also been reported that he hosted a well attended party in Silicon Valley where Elon Musk introduced Epstein to Mark Zuckerberg. We will probably not see much more on this thanks to the plutocratic wagon circling that baron_harkonnen talks about, but it's naive to take Hoffman's statements at face value here.
- nickpinkston 7y agoI'm not sure if this is self-aware or not, but Ito's fund is called:"Neoteny", meaning "the retention of child-like attributes through adulthood". Apparently, Epstein's funds / projects were named with innuendos. (edited) https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/neoteny#section-overview https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/neoteny#section-over...
- gojomo 7y agoNo, 'neoteny' doesn't "usually" mean "animals with childlike features", but rather "the retention of juvenile features into adulthood". It's conjectured that a lot of humanity's advanced intelligence & culture has been achieved with the help of our species' extended retention of juvenile learning-capacity & neural plasticity: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neoteny_in_humans https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neoteny_in_humans
- nickpinkston 7y agoChanged for clarity, but my point stands. It's kind of funny in retrospect.
- gojomo 7y agoFunny in a 'Beavis and Butthead', "heh, heh, we can find a prurient way to interpret this" way, sure.
- nickpinkston 7y agoSee parent, but it was a theme of Epstein's projects to be named with innuendos.
- gojomo 7y agoI don't think it's appropriate to imply, without evidence, that Ito's 'Neoteny Ventures', founded in 1999, was in any way an "Epstein project". (Of course, if there's evidence Epstein was involved at its founding, I'd change my mind about this.)
- DonHopkins 7y ago"reminder to self: don't invest with or take money from assholes" -Joi Ito, Mar 12, 2008
- 0x00000000 7y agoNot an asshole if your world views align I guess.
- topspin 7y agoI'm just glad we appear to be mostly past the 'well so what if he gave money they did good with it herp derp' stage. If it had been NRA money heads would have rolled immediately. No spiked stories. No game theory debates about what wonders might be achieved with such donations despite the source. Yes, it is about world views. Everything is.
- IvyMike 7y agoIn the other thread, people were saying "I'd take Epstein's dirty money and do good with it." But the problem is that doing so normalizes the behavior. Everybody who has doubts about working with the creep looks around the room, and when they don't see anyone else objecting, ends up thinking "I guess we're all ok with this behavior" and goes along to get along.
- krapp 7y ago> Everybody who has doubts about working with the creep looks around the room, and when they don't see anyone else objecting, ends up thinking "I guess we're all ok with this behavior" and gets along to go along. Let's be honest - a lot of people in the tech community and related subcultures (particularly genre fandoms) are either ok with, or are ambivalent towards, this behavior, or have a lack of empathy which leads them to view things in purely game-theoretical terms.
- liability 7y agoIt's a trait that I've heard derisively referred to as "engineer autism" in some circles, though I doubt the literal truth of that description. But whatever it's called or ascribed to, there seems to be a genuine underlying trend of some sort. It's a topic I'd like to see defined and addressed; as tech becomes more important to society the pathologies of engineer types become more and more socially relevant as people with those traits acquire more power and status.
- daseiner1 7y agothe probably correlation between technical interests in childhood and adolescence and reduced socialization is an obvious factor imo
- liability 7y agoI suspect that's at least a large component of it. It might also be reversed; kids who have trouble socializing pick up tech hobbies that are more conducive to a low-social lifestyle. It might be one or the other depending on the individual, or it may be that one exacerbates the other.
- breck 7y agoThose in glass houses... “They were models. Eastern European, definitely,” she told me. Among the lab’s staff, she said, “all of us women made it a point to be super nice to them. We literally had a conversation about how, on the off chance that they’re not there by choice, we could maybe help them.” And what did these people go home and start doing for Eastern European models since then? I find this pretty condescending. I know a few Eastern European models who are incredibly smart, and perhaps dated some folks who they wouldn't have dated if they were born in the U.S., but used those relationships to get themselves out of possible hellish, abusive, misogynistic situations back home (this is somewhat speculation, but our current First Lady seems to fall in this category). They were young but had been through hard times like the disintegration of the Soviet Union and starvation, and aren't so naive. They were honest about things, and weren't living in delusion. Some of the toughest and smartest people I've ever met in fact. There just seems to be a lot of phony moral outrage here.
- frostburg 7y agoThe ones that you know weren't there with Epstein. Context.
- breck 7y agoIt's a fair point. I wasn't in the room and never met Epstein. I just wanted to provide a counterargument, because I think people are quick to pile on.
- liability 7y ago> "I know a few Eastern European models" Do you?
- tempsy 7y agoWhy would Bill Gates need Epstein to be the middle man for his $2 mil donation? Why didn't he just donate to the Media Lab directly? And given his insistence that the donation be made anonymously, it seems like he was well aware the optics would be bad if the public knew there was a connection between the two, and yet he chose to make the donation through Epstein anyway.
- gjsman-1000 7y agoBill Gates has given many times personally to the Media Lab secretly. He gave on this occasion on Epstein's request. To him, this was just a financer asking if he could give some cash to the Media Lab, considering Gates had donated before, AFAIK.
- tempsy 7y agoGates is flat out denying that Epstein had anything to do with this specific $2m donation at all.
- wuliwong 7y agoIts hard for me to believe the emails were lies but I guess it is possible that Epstein lied to Ito about the money coming from Gates? Unless the money came from Gates' account and wasn't first transferred to an account controlled by Epstein, it will probably be hard to tell.
- wuliwong 7y agoYou don't know what Bill Gates thought of Jeffery Epstein. And in 2014 Jeffery Epstein was not "just a financier".
- FireBeyond 7y agoLeaving aside this particular situation... Many philanthropists will say "I wish to donate $X", and then ask a friend/group/organization, "Where would you like me to donate this?", hence a "directed donation".
- moonka 7y ago>Mr. Ito has been a board member of The New York Times Company since 2012. The company did not immediately comment on Mr. Ito’s decision to leave M.I.T. This is the 7th paragraph in the story. Shouldn't it be higher up?
- floatingatoll 7y agoWhat about that paragraph leads you to believe it should be higher or lower in the story, relative to its current position?
- ctab 7y agoThe connection between the subject of the story and the publisher of the story really ought to have been higher. However, news is currently breaking that Ito has since resigned from The NY Times Co. board as well.
- tanderson92 7y agoProbably this as well is worth noting: https://twitter.com/xeni/status/1170352857952002048 https://twitter.com/xeni/status/1170352857952002048
- CalChris 7y agoGood. These were in no way innocent ties. He knew who Epstein was and misled people. Ito could be on the hook for civil fraud. The elements of fraud are: a purposeful misrepresentation of a fact with knowledge that it is false to a victim who justifiably relies on the misrepresentation who suffers actual loss as a result.
- FireBeyond 7y agoThat's reaching, a whole lot. Ito knew who Epstein was, as did everyone else - Epstein's conviction wasn't a secret. That harms Ito through his poor decision making, but other people were just as capable of knowing who Epstein was. Who suffered an actual loss as a result of these donations? Civil fraud is grasping, some.
- Analemma_ 7y agoIf you read the article, you'll see that MIT specifically blacklisted Epstein from making donations as a result of his conviction, and Ito went behind their backs to keep getting money from him anyway. That's fraud, and MIT could definitely argue loss of reputation. I don't know if they'll go after Ito, but if they do, they'll have a pretty good case.
- tptacek 7y agoOut of curiosity, do you say this from firsthand knowledge as an expert in civil fraud law, or just in the message board sense of "it seems like they might have a pretty good case"?
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoI would be surprised if it was fraud. But it might be covered by this: https://www.usip.org/sites/default/files/MC1/MC1-Part1Section13.pdf https://www.usip.org/sites/default/files/MC1/MC1-Part1Sectio... Essentially any argument that donated money accepted in good faith is stripped of its criminal origins is wholly wrong. If I steal a TV and donate it to a school, the police can recover the TV and return it to its owner. The fact that the school didn't know it was stolen is irrelevant. Donations sourced from criminal profits are a more complex example of the same long-established legal and moral principle. This is why the Sacklers are having such a time of it - the jury is still out on whether pushing opiates was actually criminal, but it's certainly not simply a civil case. And it's also why anyone who had any kind of association with Epstein is trying very hard to distance themselves from him. Which is why Ito's actions weren't just stupid, but could be considered criminal in their own right. There's no doubt Epstein was involved in some very nasty things. If profits from the nasty things were accepted unknowingly, then there's no criminal liability. But anyone who knowingly benefits from criminal acts risks being accused of being an accessory to them, even if the connection is purely financial.
- bogomipz 7y ago>"He told the crowd that he had “screwed up” by accepting the money, but that he had done so after a review by the university and consultation with his advisers." Interesting his choices made it unimpeded through his own conscience though.
- dev_dull 7y agoEpstein is toxic. The investigation into his depraved island can’t come soon enough. Let’s just hope none of the QAnon noise turns out to be true.
- crispyambulance 7y ago> I don't get it. This is one of those things where somebody noticed that things just didn't seem right and the proper response to that is to raise concern and ask questions. Sorry, but a 60-something "finance" guy with an entourage of teen models doesn't add up. Sure some of these people have trophy wives half their age, and it raises eyebrows, but this is far beyond that and totally unacceptable once somebody looks into this guy's history. At a minimum Ito should have used better judgement after being altered to this stuff.
- ryanlol 7y ago>Sorry, but a 60-something "finance" guy with an entourage of teen models doesn't add up Honestly, it sounds like you just don’t go out very much.
- liability 7y agoIf this sort of scenario seems normal to you, maybe you live in the wrong neighborhood. I see a lot of shit when I go outside, but old geezers with entourages of very young eastern european women is not something I can claim to have witnessed.
- ryanlol 7y agoEpstein could’ve passed for someone in their 40s, hardly a geezer. An entourage of eastern european women? You just need to order a bottle.
- nf8nnfufuu 7y agoVery rich people are not that common in general, perhaps?
- ethbro 7y agoMay I suggest a trip to Miami?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- bogomipz 7y ago>'In an email in October 2014 — six years after Mr. Epstein had pleaded guilty to a sex charge involving a minor in Florida — Mr. Ito wrote that a $2 million gift from Mr. Gates was “directed by Jeffrey Epstein.” Peter Cohen, then a development official at the lab, wrote in a subsequent email, “For gift recording purposes, we will not be mentioning Jeffrey’s name as the impetus for this gift.” Mr. Cohen, now the director of development for computer and data science initiatives at Brown University, did not respond to messages seeking comment on Saturday.' While Ito is rightfully being held to account I think it's important to consider all the other enablers who condoned and accepted these arrangements as well.
- chmaynard 7y agoMore heads will roll. Be patient.
- mayankkaizen 7y agoMore names will come out. But only smaller, if any, heads will roll. The world has given me far more reasons to be pessimistic.
- soulofmischief 7y agoThis article is filled with strangely matter-of-fact language regarding matters which are still unsolved: For example: > Mr. Epstein — who killed himself in jail last month while facing federal sex trafficking charges
- khazhou 7y agoThe medical examiner officially ruled it a suicide, so that's where it stands today.
- goatinaboat 7y agoUnfortunately the cameras spontaneously failed so we’ll never discover how someone can break their own neck
- moron4hire 7y agoMy mother works in the non-profit fundraising sector, originally centered on education, but now runs her own consultancy for non-profits of all sizes. She knows pretty much all the rules and laws about donations and propriety within fundraising foundations. I've helped her with her business, both in actual operations and for her IT concerns. I've also worked in other regulated industries, so I have a fair amount of familiarity with what sort of rules and laws are involved and what the consequences of violating those rules tend to be. We are livid right now. She has to help a lot of orgs navigate it, where the rules can sometimes be tricky and somewhat counter-intuitive, especially if you don't have accounting experience (and let's face it, most people in fundraising foundations are some of the lowest paid people on campus, and you get what you pay for). Stuff that could get you fined or jail time for what lay-people might consider an honest mistake (but definitely should be considered 101-course material for fundraisers, considering the stakes). Joichi Ito's actions go way, way beyond that. Who knows just how far the harm he has caused will actually spread. He's harmed the reputation of his institution, his program, and anyone associated with the program. He's lied and cheated for personal gain. It's a no-brainer that he needs to go to jail. Whatever investigation will follow should be focused on finding all the people who knowingly helped him to lock them up alongside him.
- solidsnack9000 7y agoWhat are some examples of things where you can get fined or put in jail for what lay-people might consider an honest mistake?
- moron4hire 7y agoA simple one that comes up a lot is back dating when a donation "occurred" to be within a certain tax year. Donations don't "occur" until they are processed completely. The end of the tax year has lots of donations come in. If the foundation isn't on their toes, they might not process all of them in time for the tax deadline. It's illegal (though completely possible, and happens all the time) to back-date the donation date to before the end of the tax year, after the tax year has ended. Others come up as errors of classification. A certain donor might donate a certain good or service instead of straight money. That donation has to be recorded at fair market value and has to be treated as if it were a proper vendor relationship. Determining that value can be quite complex, especially considering such donations are usually done out of excess stock or time that the donor doesn't have a good valuation on out of their own books. And often, those sorts of donations come with an expectation of quid pro quo: I give two dozen bails of hay that I have just lying around and expect to get a ticket to the next fundraising ball (which might have a few-thousand dollar list price). If the foundation gives that ticket, the bails of hay are no longer a donation and listing it as such is tax fraud.
- joewee 7y agoEdit: Removing my comment after reading the detailed New Yorker article linked from The NY Times.
- bradly 7y ago> Joi shouldn’t be hung for giving someone the benefit of doubt. Epstein had already been convicted and banned from MIT donations. In a position of leadership you are responsible to keep a healthy and safe workplace. That’s part of the job of running a lab. If you are unable or unwilling to do that, you should not be in a leadership role.
- joewee 7y agoOk maybe I’m missing something. Joi allowed him to visit the lab after he was banned?
- Twirrim 7y agoAnd took donations after Epstein was disqualified as a funder (after his 2008 conviction), and deliberately manipulated things to make them anonymous. It's blatant, done with full understanding, and (stupidly) with an email trail of evidence. 'In September, 2014, Ito wrote to Epstein soliciting a cash infusion to fund a certain researcher, asking, “Could you re-up/top-off with another $100K so we can extend his contract another year?” Epstein replied, “yes.” Forwarding the response to a member of his staff, Ito wrote, “Make sure this gets accounted for as anonymous.” Peter Cohen, the M.I.T. Media Lab’s Director of Development and Strategy at the time, reiterated, “Jeffrey money, needs to be anonymous. Thanks.”' and ' But the e-mails show that Ito consulted closely with Epstein and actively sought the various donations. At one point, Cohen reached out to Ito for advice about a donor, writing, “you or Jeffrey would know best.”' and so on, and so forth. The article is worth a read.
- nullc 7y ago> And took donations after Epstein was disqualified as a funder (after his 2008 conviction) Can you point me to where it's described exactly when Epstein was blacklisted by MIT and why? If it's in the newyorker article, I'm missing it. It points out that Epstein's donations were anonymous and that he was blacklisted but doesn't appear to order the events. It looks like Epstein was anonymously donating back around 2002 also, so was he also blacklisted then? Why?
- adrian_mrd 7y agoAdjacent: that’s well-written PR spin from the Gates’ camp: > “Epstein was introduced to Bill Gates as someone who was interested in helping grow philanthropy. Although Epstein pursued Bill Gates aggressively, any account of a business partnership or personal relationship between the two is simply not true. And any claim that Epstein directed any programmatic or personal grant making for Bill Gates is completely false.” Note the part “Although Epstein pursued Bill Gates aggressively” which implies that Gates was a victim or at least an uninterested party in this affair. If that is true, why then cough up $2 million dollars via Epstein? Why does it matter if Epstein was aggressive or not if Gates wrote the check? Some follow-up questions that Gates should answer to clarify his role: 1. What correspondence or communications did Gates have with Epstein regarding the $2 million donation to the MIT Media Lab? 2. What correspondence or communications did Gates have with Epstein since his conviction in 2008? Best option would be to list all of the times Gates (including any representatives from the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation) met with or liaised with Epstein since 2008 - including via any intermediaries or third parties and electronic communications. 3. What is the definition of business partnership in Gates’ above refuttal? 4. What is the definition of personal relationship in Gates’ above refuttal? PR and disaster management ‘gurus’ often wordsmith their clients’ way out of these affairs. Gates should at least clarify his role here. Otherwise, his position as a philanthropist also seems tainted.
- nashashmi 7y ago> Why does it matter if Epstein was aggressive or not if Gates wrote the check? To respond to concerns that the two were spotted together frequently. This is an answer to a question. Figure out the question and you will understand.
- adrian_mrd 7y agoSure but Gates still wrote the check via Epstein, right?
- liability 7y agoSurely Bill Gates hires big burly men who can enforce his personal space. I find it hard to believe that Bill Gates could earnestly be the victim of such hounding for more than a brief moment.
- p0llard 7y agoInternal email this afternoon from President Reif: To the members of the MIT community, Last night, The New Yorker published an article that contains deeply disturbing allegations about the engagement between individuals at the Media Lab and Jeffrey Epstein. Because the accusations in the story are extremely serious, they demand an immediate, thorough and independent investigation. This morning, I asked MIT’s General Counsel to engage a prominent law firm to design and conduct this process. I expect the firm to conduct this review as swiftly as possible, and to report back to me and to the Executive Committee of the MIT Corporation, MIT’s governing board. This afternoon, Joi Ito submitted his resignation as Director of the Media Lab and as a professor and employee of the Institute. As I described in my previous letter, the acceptance of the Epstein gifts involved a mistake of judgment. We are actively assessing how best to improve our policies, processes and procedures to fully reflect MIT’s values and prevent such mistakes in the future. Our internal review process continues, and what we learn from it will inform the path ahead. Sincerely, L. Rafael Reif
- pryce 7y agoIf Xeni Jardin's claim below is true, Joi Ito needs to resign from more than just MIT: "I told the @nytimes everything. So did whistleblowers I was in touch with inside @MIT and @Edge. They printed none of the most damning truths. @joi is on the board of the NYT. THANK GOD FOR @RonanFarrow" EDIT: NYTimes is now indicating that Ito has resigned from NYT Co board, effective immediately [2]. [1] https://twitter.com/xeni/status/1170352857952002048 https://twitter.com/xeni/status/1170352857952002048 [2] https://twitter.com/nytimes/status/1170449747041226757 https://twitter.com/nytimes/status/1170449747041226757
- freyr 7y agoWhat is Xeni Jardin claiming? That she brought the story to the NYT but they buried it because Ito was on the board? Why didn't she take it elsewhere? Edit: I was looking for a bit more context than a random tweet. Had to search through a bunch of tweets to find it, but apparently Xeni tweeted about Joi Ito's connection to Epstein weeks ago.
- joosters 7y ago“The trouble with tainted money is t’aint enough of it.” - William Booth. Playing devil’s advocate here: Accepting tainted money as charity is not the problem. Promoting the donors, giving them prestige, contacts, access or some other benefits as a result of donations is the problem.
- pvg 7y agoIt is absolutely, very much a problem to take money from an unrepentant abuser and predator who is still publicly flaunting his abusive and predatory ways. You could argue that, perhaps, such institutions should also not cater to the merely wealthy and vain. But you can enable vanity without enabling sex trafficking.
- i_am_nomad 7y agoWhat if the money could be accepted in a way that could not possibly convey any status or glory back to the donor - something permanently anonymous - and also did not allow the donor any guidance over the use of the money? I’m asking as a philosophical question, not suggesting that Ito’s actions might be justified.
- pvg 7y agoIt's certainly a complex and worthy philosophical question but what does it have to do with a child rapist contributing to MIT? My take is 'nothing'. Like, you shouldn't have child rapists contributing to your institution. It seems morally and philosophically trivial.
- cybersnowflake 7y ago90% of you guys here would 'have ties' with Epstein if he gave you half a million dollar before all this shit hit the fan and he became a household name (mostly due to being used as a political football). Up until recently his record was a light plea bargain and a few civil suits of uncertain reliability (ie timed to coincide with Trump's election). Its not exactly hiring OJ still wearing his bloody gloves territory. After getting their wad of cash most people even if they knew about his past record and dug to see the details they would probably play it off as the typical trouble playboys get into. And lets face it, what rich semifamous playboy is there that doesn't eventually have one or more woman alleging this or that. Practically goes with the territory nowadays and now in overdrive with METOO. Hindsight and all.
- CydeWeys 7y agoThis is about continuing to maintain ties with Epstein long after how problematic he was was known, to the point that the university had banned having any involvement with him because of his pedophilia conviction and Joichi Ito still associated with him and took his money, while lying to the greater university and covering up that he was still involving himself with him. No, this definitely could not have happened to 90% of us.
- cybersnowflake 7y agoPeople, happily do things like honor a holiday made by a man who sticks women's toes into vices, Think OJ is an innocent victim of systematic racism, and freely do business with some of the most repressive regimes. Just a few months back some of the same talking heads acting all high and mighty now were whining how Drumpf was hurting business with China. The same china which massacred a bunch of people in fairly recent events as tiananman square and memoryholed it to the point where even most americans aren't aware of it. If people regularly overlook stuff like this without any shame, maybe possibly getting a massage seems pretty easy to overlook as well especially if you're getting a fat stack of cash.
- hn_throwaway_99 7y agoI'm not going to argue what others would do with respect to the moral quandary of taking Epstein's money (indeed, Nicholas Negroponte argued 2 days ago he would still have counseled to take the money). However, saying "hindsight and all" is a misrepresentation of the facts. Epstein was convicted of 2 felony prostitution charges (one involving a minor) in 2008 and was a registered sex offender. To try to portray this as just some "he said-she said" between a "rich playboy" and accusers is complete bullshit. Also, Prince Andrew was widely criticized in 2011 for his tied to Epstein, and all of this stuff was after that. The "hindsight" was already well known by the time Ito accepted this money. These folks knew what they were doing and made the calculation that the money was worth it.
- Temasik 7y agothat is why Satoshi Nakamoto the inventor of BitCoin is Craig S Wright! makes sense now
- lifeisstillgood 7y agoMore and more problems seem to be linked to provenance of money. Money Laundering of dirty cash is one major obvious example (see impact on everything from London house prices to international banking) and yet just being able to trace / label money coming out of Epstein and into MIT lab would have raised this issue a decade ago Imagine somehow being able to tag bitcoin address / transactions with "this money came from a man convicted of sex trafficking" Then having that tag appear on the accounts sheet at NIT Would that help?
- totalZero 7y agoThat's such a bizarre concept. Morality isn't something that can be inherited by accepting research contributions, in my book. Why taint the money, when it can help us learn, build, heal, and grow? Epstein, not the money he donated, is responsible for bad things he did. As an alum, I'm not surprised at the Institute's cowardice, but I'd like to see MIT stand up for someone, ANYONE in its community when under fire publicly, just once.
- liability 7y ago> Why taint the money, when it can help us learn, build, heal, and grow? Because when that much money is involved, there are strings attached. In this particular case, Epstein got to visit the lab and had people like Ito covering for him, pretending the situation was normal and on the level.
- throwaway2048 7y agoSo what happens when Epstein wants special access? His entire trade was influence peddling (usually by means of inducing people to commit sex crimes), the dude is going to want access to people. He donates 2 million dollars, threatens to pull the funding when you don't let him visit. What happens? If you think its anything besides "welcome with full access" I don't what to tell you, because that's whats going to happen in 999/1000 cases. He was already on the MIT donation blacklist for this very reason. This is way beyond "the dude is evil, but his money isn't"
- kalalala024 7y agohttps://www.facebook.com/events/1501835843304159/ https://www.facebook.com/events/1501835843304159/ https://www.facebook.com/events/376574989936263/ https://www.facebook.com/events/376574989936263/
- DonHopkins 7y ago"Resigning to spend more time with my guild." Joi Ito: What World of Warcraft taught me about being a better leader (chronicle.com) - 32 points by yarapavan on Apr 28, 2011 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2493209 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2493209 https://www.chronicle.com/blogs/wiredcampus/new-director-of-mit-media-lab-talks-of-encouraging-openness/31112 https://www.chronicle.com/blogs/wiredcampus/new-director-of-...
- currymj 7y agothe HN comments on all the recent Epstein stories have been very strange. I have to assume at least some of the more contrarian views are coming from people who haven't been following the full story in the US news, and so don't quite grasp the nature of the allegations. The case is far from just "some rich guy turned out to be an abuser". If you can't understand why the reaction is so strong against those who maintained ties with Epstein, it's worth looking into the full story, perhaps starting with the Miami Herald's "Perversion of Justice" story last year. https://www.miamiherald.com/topics/jeffrey-epstein https://www.miamiherald.com/topics/jeffrey-epstein
- dls2016 7y agoI also think (or hope) that these contrarians don’t realize how long the facts in this Herald story have been suspected of being true.
- cg46 7y agoI think it's reasonable to agree that Epstein is a despicable person who should be maligned, ostracized, and punished for his misdeeds… while simultaneously believing that it's possible for there to exist a situation in which the good done by "maintaining ties" with this person could outweigh the bad. Of course, this depends on the nature of those ties: How much good are they doing, versus how much bad? If it's possible to do that cost-benefit analysis, we might as well do it, because why not? In this particular case, I have no idea how much additional good the Media Lab was doing as a result of this money. Thus, it actually is impossible for me to do the cost-benefit analysis, because I don't know the benefit side of the equation. But I can enumerate some of the costs: - It contributed to Epstein being able to feel that he's accepted by society and can shameless appear at meetings and such, in public, with reputable people, despite engaging in despicable behavior. Alternatively, ostracizing him would've sent a strong message and perhaps contributed to a change in his behavior. - It signaled to people at large that Epstein is a good guy who donates to charitable causes. (This was somewhat mitigated by keeping the donations anonymous.) - It signaled to people at large that it's okay and normal to work with people who do despicable things. (This was also somewhat mitigated by keeping the donations anonymous.) - It risked to the Media Lab's reputation if discovered, thus hindering the organization's ability to do more good in the future. - Other things I'm leaving out? So clearly a ton of bad. And I'd guess the bad outweighed whatever good was done, given that many people who were working within the Media Lab were opposed to accepting the donations. But I don't know if it's as simple as "if the guy is bad then always say no full stop." That seems like an oversimplification, and not necessarily the best way to analyze it.
- gdubs 7y ago“Ronan Farrow is here”, has got to send chills down the spine of powerful people the way “Mike Wallace is here”, used to in the days of yesteryear.
- peter303 7y agoThe Media Lab was near the top of the heap of university-industrial consortia in terms of both glamour and income. There really wasnt a need for all this back-channel stuff.
- sytelus 7y agoThis is what surprises me. MIT is very well endowed, has an extra-ordinarily wealthy alumni network and overall Media Lab is perhaps better positioned financially than any other lab. In emails, the lab director is begging for $100K from a billionaire doner so he can extend one contract. I don't understand.
- chasing 7y agoI feel bad for the students, professors, and other people affiliated with the MIT Media Lab who will likely actually pay the price for all of this. Ito will be fine.
- scandox 7y agoI'm curious about Media Lab. They setup a branch in Dublin way back and it was such obvious and painful BS. But overall have they produced interesting work? At all?
- dbcurtis 7y ago> But overall have they produced interesting work? At all? Yes, quite a lot. (In the American sense of 'quite', not the British...) Just look at what has come out of the Life-Long Kindergarden lab, and see how many things you recognize. Historically the Media Lab has done a lot of very creative things. A person could spend a happy lifetime doing nothing but following up on ideas that started there. This is a bad episode for the Media Lab, for sure. But don't paint all of the researches within with a scarlet letter because of it. -- Edit: Translate English to English
- mcguire 7y agoBut I don't actually know anyone who has used Scratch.
- rayuela 7y agoThere are definitely participants in these discussions with a very specific agenda. Some accounts, like nf8nnfufuu, are going really far out of their way to defend Epstein. Just search for how many responses they've written throughout this thread to see what I mean.
- currymj 7y agothat account in particular eventually admits to not having read much about the case. i honestly am pretty sure the vast majority of the contrarians really are just not familiar with the whole Epstein story, and may only be hearing about it as it intersects with the tech world.
- rayuela 7y agoYeah, because writing a dozen replies defending Epstein was definitely much less effort than a quick google search of the guy...
- dang 7y agoThis breaks the site guidelines, which ask you not to insinuate abuse without evidence, and to assume good faith. We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20907187 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20907187 and marked it off-topic.
- docker_up 7y agoI don't understand the outrage. He was convicted of a crime, and he served his time. In hindsight, the sentence was too light, but as regular people are we really supposed to understand all the details? If I met someone who went to jail, should she be exiled forever after serving her sentence? I just don't understand. And people get lenient sentences all the time, am I as a non-lawyer supposed to understand this and then give my own sentence on top of that? Or should some people who commit crimes should never, ever be allowed to interact with other humans again? As far as I can tell, from the perspective of those around him in 2014, Epstein was convicted of a crime, and served his time. By 2014, he had committed no further crimes from what people knew at the time, so why exactly is this an outrage. Obviously in 2019, we know that he committed further crimes and he rightly went to jail, and it's sad that he won't face justice. But in 2014, did anyone know this and should they be treated so harshly if they didn't? The only real problem was covering up the donation, which Ito definitely should have been fired for, but I don't understand why Epstein at that time should have been considered a persona non grata. The biggest question is: should criminals never ever be forgiven for their crimes? And should anyone who decides to forgive them and associate with them also be considered despicable as well? Or is it just some criminals depending on their crime? Who judges which crimes should never be forgiven and which should?
- KZeillmann 7y agoI think the bigger issue with Epstein specifically is that it was an open secret that he hadn't changed anything about his behavior
- currymj 7y agohere's a story, originally published in 2010, about Jeffrey Epstein: https://web.archive.org/web/20170606013136/http://www.thedailybeast.com/jeffrey-epstein-pedophile-billionaire-and-his-sex-den https://web.archive.org/web/20170606013136/http://www.thedai... People knew, or should have known, who they were dealing with.
- baby 7y agoWow. How is it legal to donate to your local police dep? That’s like legal bribery. Tax payers’ money is supposed to pay for this.
- balena 7y agoTotal hipocrisy
- areoform 7y agoThis is gossip, but it’s well founded gossip as I am one or two hops away from him. Epstein was very upfront with the people he worked what that he liked “young woman” while giving them money and invited them to his parties etc. I think it was his way to enmesh them and make them unwitting partners in his systemic abuse. Most people just went along, and were eventually given a massage from a child at his behest to further enmesh them into the conspiracy. No one could play the innocent whistleblower because of their tangential complicity. The gossip I’ve heard is confirmed by those who knew him - https://www.salon.com/2019/07/09/i-was-a-friend-of-jeffrey-epstein-heres-what-i-know/ https://www.salon.com/2019/07/09/i-was-a-friend-of-jeffrey-e... ; > In the early ‘90s, at a Joan Rivers dinner party, my wife and I encountered Ghislaine Maxwell, daughter of disgraced British publishing mogul Robert Maxwell and Epstein’s girlfriend for a brief period in the '90s. She has been accused of recruiting and grooming girls and women for Epstein; she denies this. I’d met her several times with Epstein; we were also “friends,” in that transactional Manhattan way. And might now become better friends. “If you lose 10 pounds, I’ll fuck you,” she said, with my wife standing next to me. And she too became dead to me. > As his legend grew, many others were fascinated or amused or impressed by Epstein or simply delighted that he wrote checks to their charities. His interest in young women was no secret; Donald Trump famously applauded it in 2002. Vicky Ward, who published a long profile of Epstein in Vanity Fair in 2003, recently revisited transcripts of her interviews: “What is so amazing to me is how his entire social circle knew about this and just blithely overlooked it . . . all mentioned the girls, as an aside.” It’s why he was so disgustingly coy about what he did. It’s why Ito, who is quite smart, probably knew what was what. And it’s why he deserves his fall from grace.
- burtonator 7y agoI thought you were going to mention that comment about Trump saying that Epstein liked "his girls on the younger side". I think what's interesting is the ethical dilemma here. You have 1000s of people around you. No one is saying anything. Then they offer you money. Do you take it? Everyone else is? Then the counter to this is that of the 1000s of people that come crashing down why is it just Joi Ito and a few others? The key detail here is that Joi isn't an isolated "king" like the rest of the people here. They will all escape justice.
- tgb29 7y agoTo any Asian Americans reading this, I’m sorry for how the media discriminates against your identity. Out of all the affiliations with Epstein, why do they focus on this one?
- asdfasgasdgasdg 7y agoNot too long ago someone posted this: https://www.wired.com/story/joi-ito-ai-and-bus-routes/ https://www.wired.com/story/joi-ito-ai-and-bus-routes/ Basically, Mr. Ito describes his role in torpedoing a change to bus routes that would have had significant benefits for most students in a school district. He wrote a shitty op ed about it and got the plan cancelled without ever interviewing the people who had designed it. He had thought they hadn't engaged the community, but in fact there was a lengthy community engagement process that led up to the plan. The parents who were mad were wealthy parents who would have had slightly less convenient bus schedules. Anyway, in this retrospective he never apologizes for his blunder. I'm not really sad to see him go. He seems like a bad character.
- m0zg 7y agoContrarian view: as long as the person in question was not compromised by e.g. flights to the pedo island (like Bubba Clinton, who took dozens of flights, dismissing USSS on a number of them for some reason, hmm), and as long as the integrity of the lab was not affected by Epstein's involvement, I see nothing wrong with taking his money. He's despicable, sure, but if he's not buying influence, I'm OK with him supporting science rather than blowing that money on satisfying wealthy pedophiles.
- throwaway2048 7y agoBuying influence is exactly what Epstein did his whole life, somebody like that doesn't donate money because hes a swell guy after all. He donated for access to famous and future famous people, so he could implicate them in sexual crimes and compromising relationships and extract money and favors from them. That's what the guy did, its not some kind of secret now, or then. And you can bet your top dollar Joi Ito was compromised too, which is exactly why he broke the rules around the MIT blacklist banning Epstein's donations and kept everything secret.
- tomjakubowski 7y ago"The departure of Mr. Ito from the media lab came after he spent days trying to make amends. At Wednesday’s meeting, which was organized by professors at the program, he reiterated his apology. He described for the first time the amount of money he had received from Mr. Epstein, and said he had twice traveled to Mr. Epstein’s island home in the Caribbean to seek donations."
- m0zg 7y agoWell, he deserves what he got then. No sympathy. I was not familiar with the details of his involvement.
- jdkee 7y agoIt is now apparent that Joi Ito was an opportunistic scumbag who elevated personal gain above ethics. Good riddance to him. And good riddance to the reputation of Nicolas Negroponte as well.
- curiousgal 7y agoPersonal gain? He didn't pocket the money as far I know. Ethics is also a touchy subject, people can't fully agree on whether taking a criminal's money to do good with it is ethical or not. So it's not as cut and dried. He did however violate MIT policy so that's a valid reason for his resignation or even firing in my opinion.
- CrazyStat 7y agoEpstein also invested in Ito's private investment fund, which financially benefits Ito directly. Personally I suspect Ito was more incredibly naive than scumbag, but being naive is also not a good trait for the leader of a prominent group like the Media Lab.
- DonHopkins 7y agoMacArthur Foundation @macfound The MacArthur Foundation today accepted the resignation of Joi Ito as a member of our board and our affiliate @LeverforChange , effective immediately. We thank Ito for his service. https://twitter.com/macfound/status/1170443088055144448 https://twitter.com/macfound/status/1170443088055144448 Good god, did they really have to thank Joi Ito for his service?
- Presidio001 7y agowhen are we planning to talk about Koch Bros/MIT connection - money funnel?
- hjksadfkhjasdf 7y agoJesus Christ what is your problem? Stop running around the thread defending a dead pedophile with this pedantic-ass shit. Before you go on about how you're "Just Asking Questions" or some shit, fuck off, I don't care, and flush your fucking head in the toilet you dumbass pedophile-defending nerd.
- hjksadfkhjasdf 7y agoI have an issue with you being an insufferable dweeb so can you shut the fuck up so you brain doesn't keep leaking out your ears all over this thread.
- hjksadfkhjasdf 7y agoJust pitch your computer out the fucking window already. Save us this fucking drivel.
- briantakita 7y agoThe network associated with Jeffrey Epstein & Ghislaine Maxwell (daughter of Mossad Agent Robert Maxwell) runs deep in the tech industry. Also note that Aaron Swartz was involved with the MIT Media Labs. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=olGSOydtOgY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=olGSOydtOgY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=olGSOydtOgY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=olGSOydtOgY
- cattlefarmer 7y ago> This is well-known now. Please avoid this. Let me preface this by saying that I have no idea who Epstein is except that he's some rich, white guy that got caught up in some kind of sex scandal, was arrested and is now dead. I'm not belittling his acts nor ignoring his accusers, I'm saying that I did not know. Now let me explain why. Over the past couple of years, there have been non-stop stories of one powerful white man after another being revealed doing heinous sexual things to women. The reports are non-stop and it has come to the point that I have tuned them out. A good number of us here are in the tech industry, we're busy enough as it is. Whatever free time we have is focused on things that are more immediate. A large number of people in my immediate bubble have no idea who Epstein is. I'm not even sure if his first name is Jeff or James, except that it starts with J. I'm likely not the only one. So according to the HN guidelines, please assume good faith when people ask why.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- aarongreenblatt 7y ago> he's some rich, white guy Please avoid this. He's some rich, Jewish guy that got caught up in some kind of sex scandal, was arrested and is now dead.
- Udik 7y ago> some rich, white guy > non-stop stories of one powerful white man after another I didn't know that Morgan Freeman, Bill Cosby, Aziz Ansari, to name a few, are white. Nor I did know that Asia Argento, Frankie Shaw, or Allison Mack are men. We could even discuss the "powerful", as it's pretty obvious that the stories that reach the news are only about those famous people. And finally, if we really have to make it a matter of race, Epstein wasn't exactly white, he was Jewish.
- topspin 7y ago> A good number of us here are in the tech industry, we're busy enough as it is. Might want to tune back in a bit; the demise of Epstein is one of the most kelptocratic things that's ever happened in the US. It doesn't even matter exactly how he died; there is no 'fact pattern' you can subscribe to that isn't a consequence of in-your-face public corruption.
- Gatsky 7y agoTwo things stand out from this fiasco. 1: Even very powerful and successful people are dazzled by money. 2: The ability of an individual or a family to accumulate massive private wealth inevitably leads to a lot of messed up behaviour.
- kmlx 7y agoyou don't need wealth to be messed up.
- nray 7y agoWhere did Epstein's money come from? He claimed to be a hedge fund manager for select clients, however in the aftermath of his rearrest after the Miami Herald series there were comments from Wall Street people that there was little evidence of how he actually made so much money. Pure speculation, but the original source of Epstein's donations might also prove a problem.
- runn1ng 7y agoHas #metoo gone too far?
- kamfc 7y agoCan someone explain if knowing someone nowadays can mean a ruin career by modern day social witch hunt or is there a darker reason behind Joi Ito resigning?
- paggle 7y agoIt was tactically smart to initially refuse to resign... it shifted the Overton window so that now he’s seen as defeated simply by stopping being the Media Lab director, instead of needing to make any attempt at restitution for the damage he has caused to Epstein’s victims and to MIT.
- JabavuAdams 7y agoThe social network / ostracism obligation aspects of this are fascinating and personal for me. Within the last couple of years I became aware of an extended family member who was intermittently violently abusing his wife. This is someone I see at most once a year, usually at funerals. I spent a lot of time thinking about what I would do if I found myself in a social situation with this person. The best I could come up with was personal ostracism. I decided that I would not call him out, due to fear of unintended consequences, but that I would treat him as a pariah. At a recent family reunion, I was set to avoid him, but all of a sudden he was next to me, asking after me, and jutting out his hand for a shake. I reflexively shook his hand (I fucking hated myself at that moment), but managed to turn away and put my back to him as he was talking. I feel like I eventually held up to my principles, but was a disgusted by how the people around me just ignored the elephant in the room. And yet ... difficult situation to be in. I mean this as a bystander, not someone with something to gain from associating with him. EDIT> The time of "open secrets" needs to be over. I dislike gag orders and secret settlements because they deprive the public of crucial information. How many people are victimized by someone who is anecdotally known to be dangerous, but still socially tolerated? Epstein was radioactive since 2008-2011, and we should be very critical of anyone who treated him normally after that period. EDIT2> My family member had already been reported to the police and his wife went back to him. So, he's on record as being an abuser. I am not covering for him in that sense.
- tw04 7y agoJust a heads up, this thread is now full of accounts defending Epstein and his pedophilia full force. No idea who's behind it, but it's... Interesting.
- Sadkov 7y agoWhy do people make such a hypocritically huge fuzz out of some pimp, like Epstein? Look at poor neighborhoods - there are literally millions pimps prostituting millions of women in the world. I doubt any of you want to pay for their education, so they could stop prostituting and do useful jobs, and I doubt any of these prostitutes want to work at a sweatshop or a factory, or even in office, doing heavy and unhealthy work in disciplined environment.
- whowhatwhy 7y agoIf they're in the US, I am paying for their education.
- swhitt 7y agoNew internal email from President Reif: To the members of the MIT community, After recent events centered on the Media Lab, I know there is a tremendous sense of pain, sadness and disappointment across campus and throughout our global community. We all want answers. For now, I write to share two important updates. Last Saturday, we retained the law firm Goodwin Procter to perform a thorough investigation of the facts surrounding Jeffrey Epstein’s interactions with MIT. This work has already begun. We have asked the firm to explore all donations received by MIT, both those that came directly from Jeffrey Epstein and his associated foundations, and any donations that may have been received at the direction of Jeffrey Epstein. In addition, the investigation will cover who at MIT may have been aware of the donations. We have instructed Goodwin Procter to follow the evidence where it leads, and we are counting on this independent investigation to ascertain the facts. As I noted on Saturday, the firm will report back to me and to the Executive Committee of the MIT Corporation, MIT’s governing board. If you have information relevant to the investigation that you would like to share with the law firm, please email REDACTED. To be thorough, such an investigation will take time, on the order of a month. Although media reports will continue to focus on the issues during this time, I am hopeful that the MIT community will avoid forming a final judgment before the process is complete and will respect the privacy of members of our community who may have become involved in this matter in the course of doing their jobs for MIT. Once we have the results, and once our separate internal review of our current processes on gift acceptance is complete, we will be able to understand what happened and what needs to change. Supporting the members of the Media Lab must now be at the center of our attention. The Provost has asked the Dean of the School of Architecture and Planning to work with the Media Lab community on interim leadership for the lab and a search for the next director. The interim plan will be finalized shortly, and we will share the news as soon as possible, along with other plans to support the lab community. I know this is a difficult and disorienting moment. But I have profound faith in the MIT community to learn from these events and find a constructive way forward. Sincerely, L. Rafael Reif
- caz111 7y agoThere needs to be an investigation as some time into what is under the Ark Academy in Brent, London, sponsored by Arki Busson, who gets a mention in Epstein's Little Black Book. https://www.flickr.com/photos/50295603@N02/48589712471/ https://www.flickr.com/photos/50295603@N02/48589712471/ https://www.indymedia.org.uk/en/2011/10/487685.html https://www.indymedia.org.uk/en/2011/10/487685.html
- reifwithfraud 7y agoFolks should remember that Rafael Reif was the provost under Susan Hockfield who orchestrated the whitewashing of research misconduct allegations that MIT Professor Ted Postol launched against MIT Lincoln Laboratory for using fabricated data to report results of a critical ballistic missile defense test to the Pentagon. MIT was found "guiltless" by Provost Reif after an "internal investigation" was conducted over the course of almost a decade. Steve Weiner (a highly respected former director of ballistic defense research at Lincoln for almost 20 years) has since accused MIT of engaging in a "kickback scheme" whereby Lincoln would tell the MDA whatever it needed to hear about the viability of a Starwars-inspired missile defense shield in order for executives at Raytheon to receive multi-billion dollar contracts to build it. The phony missile defense tests that Postol challenged intensely for almost a decade were one small but critical piece of the massive fraud that MIT has perpetrated against the United States taxpayer here. President Reif needs to be incarcerated, not just fired!