45 ms·
The Anti-College Is on the Rise
- magical_mishka 7y agoSay what you want, but a college degree is still necessary for high paying jobs.
- jdsully 7y agoYes, but the dirty secret is the earning potential of a college student is bimodal - yet people often use averages to discuss the benefits of a college degree. The $30,000 in additional earnings figure is propped up heavily by those making six+ figure salaries. Those who just barely scraped by do not earn more on average than those who only went to high school. If you have the aptitude college will absolutely help. But for those who do not pushing them into college is just saddling them with debt for little benefit.
- jimhefferon 7y agoSome of the people without six figure salaries were interested in a subject that just simply did not pay at a high rate. They, or some of them anyway, may be glad they learned about the subject. (Of course, we are talking about lots of people so many may not be glad about what they did.) My point is just that there are payoffs other than monetary ones. Nothing wrong with monetary, but nothing wrong with the others if that drives you.
- Konnstann 7y agoThe problem is the degree in a topic you are interested in but pays very little costs the same amount. The debate around college is the return on investment, which if you go to college for something you are interested in rather than something you want to market, you don't care about. I can study underwater basket weaving and get a degree in it, but being happy about learning doesn't offset the ~$80k in student loans that will make me very unhappy for a long time.
- layoutIfNeeded 7y ago>They, or some of them anyway, may be glad they learned about the subject. What percentage of college subjects don’t have readily available high-quality material across the Internet for free? Libgen is free. SciHub is free. Whole semesters worth of lectures are available for free on YouTube. It would be stupid to take out loans for a degree that will never break even, when more knowledge is out there for free than ever before in human history.
- opnitro 7y agoHumanities courses often thrive on discussion sections. These are hard to replicate with just books.
- povertyworld 7y agoI think the people who live their life as a series of income maximizing transactions aren't really the humanities type anyways.
- mamon 7y agoAnd hard science, like mathematics or physics relies on teacher helping you get unstuck. Learning the same thing from books takes significantly more time.
- Mediterraneo10 7y ago> What percentage of college subjects don’t have readily available high-quality material across the Internet for free? Libgen is free. I trained in a field that might be classed under "areal studies" more generally for a certain stretch of Eurasia. (And not a "useless" humanities subject, but something that does bring desirable job prospects.) The vast majority of literature in that subject is not available online. More recent publications might be created in PDF format, but for the most part students will need to hit the library shelves, even at the undergraduate level. Sure, I have scanned and uploaded a great deal to Libgen myself, but I appear to be the only volunteer doing so for this entire field. Most volunteers on LibGen or r/Scholar don’t want to undertake any more effort than downloading already-digitized materials from behind paywalls and then uploading them to Libgen, they don’t want to do the hard work of scanning thousands of pages. I suspect there are a lot of academic fields where it would take decades for the handful of Libgen volunteers to adequately upload the standard publications in that field.
- jdsully 7y ago> My point is just that there are payoffs other than monetary ones. Nothing wrong with monetary, but nothing wrong with the others if that drives you. The issue is that college imposes a very real and life changing monetary cost on people attending. If you fail to achieve a high paying job after college you will be far behind your peers who never went, and dramatically more limited in your life choices. College debt is the closest we have to indentured servitude in the modern world. For those who just want to learn, continuing education or course auditing is the better solution. I do wish colleges would expand upon these programs.
- learc83 7y ago90+% of all loan disbursements are Federal and Federal loans offer income based repayment plans. You pay 10% of your disposable income (income above 1.5 times the poverty level) for up to 20 years. Not sure that's really far behind. For a family of 4 making the median household income that's roughly equivalent to a cable bill.
- jdsully 7y agoThat's a myopic view of the situation. Under income based repayment most students' loans will actually increase despite the payments. The massive debt will prevent common middle class milestones like getting a mortgage. Further loan forgiveness comes with a balloon payment in the form of taxes - forgiven debt is income according to the IRS. After allowing it to grow unchecked for 20 years the amount forgiven will be substantial. IBR operates very similar to welfare - including the embarrassing intrusion and analysis of your private life by your lenders. It is a last resort option and not something we should be encouraging.
- learc83 7y agoLenders look at monthly payments when calculating debt to income. $150 a month in student loans won't prevent you from getting a mortgage unless $150 is all that's preventing you from affording the mortgage. Cancelled debt is only taxable up to the point of solvency meaning that most people who have a substantial amount of debt cancelled won't owe anything. >IBR operates very similar to welfare - including the embarrassing intrusion and analysis of your private life by your lenders. It is a last resort option and not something we should be encouraging. I've done it. You provide your tax return. They don't care about anything but income. It's by no means intrusive and shouldn't bhe thought of as a last resort.
- myself248 7y agoAll true, but you can also learn about subjects that interest you in more settings than just college. Many of them more engaging, many of them cheaper. People go to college almost entirely for the piece of paper that you can't get just by being passionate about something and exploring it on your own terms.
- jchw 7y agoNo it isn't? It is necessary for some high paying careers, like working in medicine. But, I am certainly a software developer, for a very large company, pretty happy with my paycheck, and I have no degree. Nobody even ever asked me about it. Whether or not it helps is another story, I am not claiming a degree is literally useless. I am however a little rubbed the wrong way by claims that you need a degree to ever have a job that pays good, that seems false.
- snarfy 7y agoNot having a degree in CS certainly limits how far up the ladder you can go. For most jobs at FAANG companies the #1 requirement is a degree. You can be the highest level senior developer at a company but you'll never make director or vp without a degree.
- finder83 7y agoMaybe jobs that require college degrees pay higher on average, but it's just not true that for a high paying job you need a college degree. I was making over 100k before I finished my bachelor's doing computer programming. I've known people who own plumbing, welding, or electrical businesses that have a license that are millionaires that don't have college degrees. Maybe those aren't "jobs", but the highest paying jobs often don't follow the beaten path.
- povertyworld 7y agoIf that's the case why not do a degree you actually enjoy instead of a vocational degree? If you're a millionaire plumber, then paying tuition for an art history degree or whatever should be easy.
- apearson 7y agoWhat makes you think they'd like art history over plumbing? They must have some likeness of their vocation if they decided to go into it.
- povertyworld 7y agoThere's also the issue that money isn't worth much until you transmute it into class privilege by way of elite education.
- tomrod 7y agoOr purchase a timber farm and setup shop. Or invest in a prime developable area near a large metropolis. Or look at the bank account and smile occasionally. Class privilege comes with baggage. Better to focus on making the world a better place, starting with your own world -- which often keeps one from putting their nose up too high.
- imtringued 7y agoActually I'd say it is the other way around. If you're a millionaire plumber then keeping up with other people with a similar level of wealth will reduce the worth of your money massively. At that point you're no longer ahead of 90% of people in the USA. You're at the bottom of your friends circle at least in terms of wealth.
- itsaidpens 7y agoWrong. I make over 200,000 with zero college degree. Professional marketer - including SurveyMonkey in my CV.
- throwaway413 7y agoAnecdata - $400k/yr, no college degree, no high school diploma, 5 years in the industry. Software engineer, self-taught, job-hopped early on.
- gamechangr 7y ago$400k/yr...what's the base/bonus/stock breakdown (seeing your in a throwaway)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- throwaway413 7y agoAll cash, no stock/bonuses (even though I am way overdue for a "bonus"...)
- nilsocket 7y agoI was selected in campus placements. I didn't yet complete my Under Graduate course, because I failed in 3 subjects. I'm being paid more than my colleagues who completed the course from same college.
- ne01 7y agoCollege is the idea of paying someone to force you to read a bunch of (mostly useless) books. Just read books and google if you don’t know what to read And choose a field that does not require a degree to work This way you save your time and money and probably will end up being more successful
- anonymous5133 7y agoHonestly, this is good advice.
- ryanmercer 7y ago>And choose a field that does not require a degree to work The problem with this is, more and more employers are wanting a 4-year degree for ANY job, even basic office work because 1/3 of the country has at least a 4-year degree.
- randomdata 7y agoSpecifically, employers look for a degree when the market for a particular line of work is saturated. Practically speaking, an employer can only evaluate a handful of people who are vying for a job, so filtering out everyone without a degree is a quick, and legally accepted, way to cull applicants down to smaller numbers. The problem is that if you are trying to compete in a saturated market, you are already going to lose as there is always someone who is better, faster, and willing to work for less money, leaving the degree to be of no great benefit to you, with respect to getting a job.
- pmoriarty 7y agoIt's long past time for the wealthiest country in the world to make education free.
- cyrksoft 7y agoFree? Who pays?
- ykevinator 7y agoConsumers?
- _lessthan0 7y agoTax payers could come under that bracket I suppose? Most uni degrees will help out the US economy (thats all they think about) one way or another.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- wffurr 7y agoThe US federal government already makes free college available, you just have to serve in the military first. We could eliminate that requirement by buying one or two fewer aircraft carriers or stealth bombers. Seems like a fair trade to me.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- philwelch 7y agoBut the aircraft carriers actually provide a concrete benefit.
- ryanmercer 7y agoName the last time an aircraft carrier won a battle, stopped an attack, etc. Gerald R. Ford class aircraft carriers cost 13~ billion dollars to construct and the bill for operating a carrier group: $2.5 million a day (based on a quick Google query). 13 billion is 325,000 degrees at 40k each or 260,000 at 50k each. 21 B-2 stealth bombers from Northrop Grumman in the 1980s and 1990s at a price of more than $2 billion each. 2 billion in 1990 is equal to 9.8 billion dollars today. That's 4-5 million 4-year degrees for what those 21 aircraft cost!!! Also if you educate 100 people, the majority of them will provide benefit to the economy via any number of ways. The government already throws tons of money at educational institutions, but as research grants for military/defense research, why not educate the populace? For that matter, why not create government educational institutions that cut out all of the fluff and in upon completion of a program you enter into an income share agreement for 5-10 years at 10-5%.
- nknealk 7y agoI'm currently pursuing an MBA. There's a huge body of research that shows raw cognitive ability is the strongest predictor of a high performance hire. That is sometimes, but not always, correlated with educational attainment. Source eg https://hbr.org/2017/10/what-science-says-about-identifying-high-potential-employees https://hbr.org/2017/10/what-science-says-about-identifying-...
- danieltillett 7y agoPity you can't just test for this and hire [1]. 1. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Griggs_v._Duke_Power_Co https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Griggs_v._Duke_Power_Co.
- lordnacho 7y agoHow many people in the US have come across the Open University? They do distance learning courses in a range of subjects, and has a reputation built over the last 50 years. Costs money but nothing like a private US degree. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_University https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_University It's actually the largest university in the UK, and has thousands of overseas students.
- sdinsn 7y ago> Costs money but nothing like a private US degree. I mean, public US degrees also cost nothing like a private US degree
- synchronizing 7y agoDepends on whether the student is an out-of-state or in-state student.
- anonymous5133 7y agoUS companies don't view foreign degrees that positively unfortunately.
- nimbius 7y agoDisclosure: I'm an automotive diesel mechanic by trade, and chose the anti college 15 years ago. Trade school cannot continue to be a four letter word in american households. HVAC, plumbers, machinists, welders and electricians are all facing massive shortages and offer a skilled, well paying job with benefits. These are all 1-2 year with an apprenticeship and the opportunity to build something you can be proud of.
- nkozyra 7y agoI think the tide started to turn on this a while ago, honestly. I remember my dad telling me how much money good machinists, plumbers, electricians made and how there's always jobs available. He pushed heavily for University, but I started getting programming jobs in high school and realized quickly the truth of supply and demand. There will always be demand and need for these types of jobs and they are not low skill at all. Since then I've heard a lot of people marveling at the need and value of trade jobs. If I had to quibble at the direction, it would be at the risk that specialization carries. My grandfather was a chiropractor but in later years found a more lucrative career as a copier repairman. This job was highly desired and well paid but for numerous reasons became less so in the 80s and 90s. What happens when you have devoted your career to a specialization and then it disappears or radically transforms?
- notduncansmith 7y agoIt seems like we could prevent this by making retraining and respecialization a more normal part of education and career. What intrinsic purpose is there to doing one job for your whole life? If you can learn copier repair, you can probably learn some other useful engineering/repair trades.
- HeWhoLurksLate 7y agoThis is why I feel like hyper-specialization in universities should be limited to masters or doctorate degrees- if the market for airplanes goes poof, then a "I can design ailerons" type of degree is basically worthless and can mean that you won't be qualified for a job for a while. One of the things that Jewish communities have done for a while is have the men gain both a skill (university degree), and a trade, so that if one fails, they can switch to the other and still provide for their families. For example, after getting laid off in an economic downturn, being able to fix others refrigerators might be the thing that keeps yours from going empty. The other thing that I wish people would learn is living well within their means, so that if something happens, they don't lose everything that was theirs / the bank's.
- jorgesborges 7y agoI'm almost thirty with a degree in philosophy. College was easily the worst financial decision I've ever made. It's scary to reflect on how I made that mistake as a teenager. The people I've met that were able to successfully leverage the advantages of a college degree fall roughly into two categories: 1) people whose parents had the money to support them financially but also the sense to guide them with respect to a career; and 2) highly ambitious people with a plan. The problem is that there was a generation of students (myself included) that thought a university education led to a well-paying job. I know how incredibly naive that sounds. But it was also the understanding of many parents without formal education encouraging their children to attend. But I think in general there's an increasing awareness that this isn't the case and now we're having these anti-college conversations.
- brianbreslin 7y agowhat have you been doing for the last 8 years? Why did you pick philosophy?
- ipython 7y agoI wouldn’t be too hard on yourself. I have met some great technically minded program managers who majored in philosophy. Granted you may not get far in SV (don’t know - I don’t live there) but in other big Corp and fed govt you can find people who appreciate a well rounded candidate. Try sales engineering, product owner or program manager if you’re looking for tech jobs. It’s too bad that we have such blinders on as an industry. There’s more to tech work than knowing the big-O notation of a given algorithm off the top of your head.
- pacaro 7y agoI have a philosophy degree (strictly speaking History and Philosophy of Science) and I'm a staff software engineer at Google. I've been doing this professionally for 25 years, and definitely my career had a slow start, it took a good nine months out of college to find my first job, which essentially served as an apprenticeship. I've certainly never had a problem with being insufficiently technical, if you can work your way through Gödels incompleteness theorem then you can work your way through PAXOS or an algorithms text book
- chungleong 7y agoKids these days. They can't even multiple 6 by 9. And somehow that's the fault of the colleges they attend.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoA lot of people in these comments are forgetting which types of employment took the biggest hits in the past few recessions.
- rb808 7y agoWere you around in 2001 after the dotcom crash? It was really difficult to find work. I know a few web devs that never worked in the industry again.
- pkaye 7y agoIn 2000 I went back to college to get my MS degree. I remember in 2001 people were begging the college to admit them because they were laid off right around the admissions cutoff.
- anonymous5133 7y agoI graduated from high school in 2006 and was determined to study computer science when I went to college but by the time I had graduated I decided to just go with accounting because I had heard so many horror stories about how there were no jobs in tech anymore. I viewed accounting as something that might not pays much as a programmer but it would surely get me a job because every company needs accountants. Nowadays, being employed in accounting, I kinda regret it because my true passion was computer science.
- meestaahjoshee 7y agoNever too late to start! Seriously with so many online resources and/or coding boot camps you can totally do it. My company has three engineers who have done boot camps and two who are self taught coming from other industries including myself.
- maxdamantus 7y agoLuckily I'm from a country where university is still reasonably affordable .. in fact, since I left, they've made it so fees are government-funded for the first few years. Even though I did have a student loan, it was at least interest-free. I think university education should be seen as an extension of all earlier education. If you start thinking in terms of "is this financially a good idea", you'll start wondering if people should be leaving school at 14 or something, because they're basically able to work at that age .. right? Personally, I think the time I had at university was massively useful to my educational development. Even though a lot of what I learnt during that time I consider to be "self-taught", the university environment seemed much more conducive to self learning than the working environment, where you do what your company wants for 8 hours a day then spend the rest of the day trying to defocus. Just like primary and secondary education, it seems insane to me to just think about tertiary education as some concrete monetary investment. If you give everyone the opportunity to spend a short amount of time (like 3 or 4 years, out of a career period of 45 years) focusing on a particular field of their choosing, surely there must be a massive benefit there to society. Edit: Also, it should probably be pointed out that a lot of research that happens at universities is used in industry, so if the university system continues to be undermined, you can expect these gains to be lost. We're probably mostly programmers, right? Try pointing to a significant feature of any programming language (old or new) that isn't taken straight from academia.
- simonsarris 7y ago> If you start thinking in terms of "is this financially a good idea", you'll start wondering if people should be leaving school at 14 or something, because they're basically able to work at that age .. right? Yes, this age is something we should wonder and re-wonder often over time. Is all the delayed adolescence of the current state desirable? Do all people need 4 years of high school? Do all degrees need to take 4 years for wildly different fields? Would many people benefit from a "work study" version of high school instead? Etc.
- maxdamantus 7y agoI really dislike the idea of providing a monetary incentive for kids to stop going to school. People who are not well-off are going to be pressured into taking this path, causing a further arbitrary wealth gap within the population.
- austincheney 7y agoPeople I have worked with who have graduate level education (masters or doctorate) are extremely well prepared when performing as a software developer. The education can be in any academic discipline. People who have a bachelors degree are less prepared to work as a software developer. Counter intuitively this lack of preparation is magnified for those with a computer science degree. Most of my computer science coworkers have historically had weaker communications skill, such as describing details with precision objectively or documenting a simplified set of instructions. I am so under whelmed that basic reading and writing are something I would test for in a job interview. In addition to weak communication skills I have also observed less flexibility or willingness to learn unfamiliar skills from computer science skills undergraduates. It’s as though these students believe they know all they need and the employer should adapt to the set of techniques these employees were taught. I have had heard somebody on HN describe this as lame duck syndrome. I have observed this enough that it biases me in opposition to job candidates with a comp sci education.
- anonymous5133 7y agoThose little quirks can be eliminated through proper employment screening. You can implement personality screening, skills verification exams and so on. Assuming the screening is effective, these undesirable candidates can be eliminated quickly.
- thrownblown 7y agoWho goes to college to work in tech anymore?
- esoterica 7y agoMost people who work in tech? Do you think the number of Google engineers with a degree is above or below 50%. Take a guess.
- armatav 7y agoDo you think their employees make up more or less than 50% of the population of engineers in Silicon Valley?
- asdff 7y agoAs a whole nearly 50% of all people in SV have a B.S. or higher and over 70% have some college experience; it's the third most educated place in the country. https://www.mercurynews.com/2017/07/25/silicon-valley-is-3rd-most-educated-region-in-america-study-says/ https://www.mercurynews.com/2017/07/25/silicon-valley-is-3rd...
- thrownblown 7y agoI would argue that a significant proportion of those in tech have that do have degrees, hold degrees that are irrelevant to their profession.
- anonymous5133 7y agoTech is just an overall outlier since the demand is so high in that field that employers are willing to hire people who just have the skills to do the job. In more traditional career paths, like engineering, a college degree is absolutely required to even be considered for the position. No degree = no interview. Lots of other professional careers are like this as well like accounting.
- cwperkins 7y agoJoe Biden said it himself, he didn't like how elitist America is becoming. I couldn't agree more and couldn't be happier to see people choosing a career in the trades. They can be high paying and stable.
- duxup 7y agoThat really reads more like something centering more on some personal philosophy than something that would challenge traditional education.
- Barrin92 7y agoYes, to me this is the very worst version of counter-culture. This isn't challenging the elite instititutions, it's even one step up the ladder, like some 70s hippie experiment of the privileged who roleplay as workers in some retreat in the mountains reading Plato. Gender segregation and overly strict "no alcohol" policies included. it's rebel roleplaying. If people want practical experience and physical work the organisers of these institutions should go to Switzerland, learn how the apprenticeship system works and bring it back to America so people can be set on a viable career path.
- ngngngng 7y agoGood. But on that note, there are ample opportunities to get an affordable education in the US. You just have to make 2 simultaneous decisions. 1) Go to a public school, 2) Stay in-state. Why the hell are so many people choosing non-public and out of state schools? Do people really think that double the cost gets you double the returns?
- smoknib 7y agoCan’t tell if srs or trolling
- xwdv 7y agoFor networking mostly. People feel if you go to an elite college you will network with the elite, and this will come in handy. If you are going to a public state school, then people feel they will just be networking with cheap chumps and nobodies. It’s horrible.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- thrav 7y agoI did this and have regretted it most of my life. Things are pretty great 10 years later, so I can’t complain too much, but I needed to get out of my home state to thrive. The difference between my life there and my life when I said fuck this place and moved somewhere cool, outdoorsy, and away from all the baggage is night and day.
- ngngngng 7y agoI've seen this in practice, but I don't think it's that you have to leave home to thrive. In my experience there are many places where the economy is just not strong enough for beginning a career, or there are too many applicants and not enough jobs. I grew up in Southern California, and I don't know anyone that stayed there that is "thriving". All have college degrees, still living with parents, not making enough money for me to even consider them "living". I would say it's a very wise decision to try and move to somewhere with a booming economy as soon as possible.
- christopher8827 7y agoGood. I think the university system is outdated and there should be other institutions to train people for the workforce.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Causality1 7y agoThe mainstream college culture needs to die, no question. It's my opinion, however, that "hippie wilderness getaway for upper middle class kids to find themselves" is just profiteering from disenchantment. >They will take on 15 to 20 hours a week of manual labor in Sitka >all at an affordable price >found the program in order to give young people a taste of the education he received at an older countercultural experiment, Deep Springs College >Deep Springs — a tuition-free, highly selective two-year liberal arts college >Our goal is to make our credits transferable to four-year institutions upon accreditation So in order to further the spirit of a tuition-free liberal arts college, is charging "students" an as-yet unrevealed fee, working them for four hours a day covering almost every single non-management job at the Sheldon Jackson Campus, with absolutely no set curriculum or accreditation or transferable credits. This is by the far the most transparent scam I've ever seen make it to HN.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- vetelko 7y agoNo college. No debts.
- achingtooth 7y agoI don't think the gimmicky travel to Alaska, take a gap year, or having "a way to talk about one’s higher purpose in the world" is important at all. What is important is having cheap tuition and solid courses. As much as people bash on college, it's still important. I don't have a college degree and it's been impossible for me to find a 'real job', though some of that may be due to my age. This is despite having a decent amount of programming and freelance experience. Overall college is important if you want to go down the traditional job path smoothly, I think these people are focusing on the wrong thing.
- testpostpls 7y agoI disagree. I think it’s important to take the time to develop a personally meaningful life philosophy. Too few do. None of us is facing starvation.
- anonymous5133 7y agoI would argue that obtaining a high quality education and developing meaningful life philosophy are two separate areas. Colleges need to move away from the teaching life philosophy to everyone. If people already know what they want to do with their life then just let them take the essential courses to get valuable skills/education. If people want to learn about meaningful life philosophy then they can do that on their own.
- lawtalkinghuman 7y agoAnd then they end up with vapid, shallow, self-obsessed life philosophies - see, every self-help guru peddling individualistic nonsense. Part of the purpose of teaching philosophy is you get rigour from actually testing those ideas out in a place where people are going to scrutinise the ideas. That’s why philosophy exists, and history, and a whole load of other humanities subjects.
- yostrovs 7y agoIn my experience, the people that latch onto self help gurus, preachers of weird beliefs, and peddlers of odd lifestyles, are usually graduates of college. They were taught to be skeptics by how education is done now. So they reject traditional things and yearn for yogis and the like.
- DigitalTerminal 7y agoSorry, but anti-science bias, anti-intellectualism, and post-factualism is just as abhorrent from the left as from the right.
- victor9000 7y agoYou may also consider studying in a country like Germany, where they heavily subsidize education even for immigrants.
- wyclif 7y agoThis is nothing new, St John's College in Annapolis, Maryland has been educating this way for years (tutorials and no grades). The only question is if it will become more widespread in the face of the erosion of the quality of higher education.
- Katzenjammer 7y agoI am surprised there was no mention St. John’s College, in Annapolis and Santa Fe. Its entire 4-year program focuses on engaging students and tutors alike in these life questions.
- jokoon 7y agoI went and failed school programs several times as an adult, in a country where those programs are free. The last 2 programs I went to were 1 year programs. I already have programming skills yet they did not give me the "degree" because they might have perceived a lack of motivation. Those programs were web oriented and I'm more focused on industrial programming. I tend to dislike higher education as a general rule because it's more a process of fitting in and obeying a teacher, instead of focusing on the subject matter. I don't care that much actually because I know I'm already skilled at programming. I might not be an excellent programmer, but I can do a lot of what's required. While education is important, I have put a lot of personal time to learn more and more programming skills after the year I failed one, 8 year ago. Yet the job market is constantly focused on "the degree", while everybody knows that self-teaching is more important in programming. I don't get hired and it's always a matter of trusting a new guy who doesn't have professional experience and can only talk about his skills. Personally I don't have a lot of faith into the market and the market doesn't have faith in me. So yes, I have plenty of reasons to say that people going into higher education are lucky, privileged or just obedient people who are not yet capable of learning new things, or did not have to waste so much resources to learn things they could do at home. In the end, you will either have large companies with normative, schooled people, or start ups, who will always struggle to start products because they have no resources. I'd say that higher education can be bad because normalization slow downs innovation, so in the end, degrees become privileges. People who are taught skills but don't use them to improve society and constantly encourage obedience are a brake on society. In an age of inequality, degrees are seen as rent seeking. People get degrees for comfort. Other people won't seek degrees because they don't want to obey to a system they see as lame and evil.
- itstimefor2020 7y agoI feel the same way. I went straight into the workforce with 17. Now 5 years later I feel like I absolutely need that degree to advance my career or to simply avoid my resume being thrown out. So I went back to school and I bet you can already guess what happens. Now that I have to spend at least 25 hours a week studying I barely have time to work on my software skills. I used to learn stuff like writing compilers, work with FPGAs, read up on machine learning, etc... You can argue that maybe I focused too much on individual topics and a CS degree covers many more but at the same time the lack of a degree isn't what's hindering me from working in these areas. I'll finally be done with school soon and then I can go to college next year and I definitively am going to specialize in topics that I am unfamiliar with such as robotics. However, I bet the end result will be that I will work on the same trivial web applications as I am doing right now but with a pay bump and more opportunities during the job hunt.
- bryanwb 7y agoSeveral things irk me about this article First, the proposed educational experiences sound like more silly adventures for kids with money (or debt) to burn. You could learn more about life and yourself by working at McDonald's for a year. Second, it fucking annoys the shit out of me that when articles like this talk about "the liberal arts" they really mean humanities. I have yet to meet someone who espouses the merits of a liberal arts education who realizes that it technically includes math and the natural sciences. How many English majors takes statistics? How many History majors take discrete math or more than the most basic math requirements needed to graduate? Bet it is less than 1%. I am all for a liberal arts education as long as it has equal helpings of math and the natural sciences along w/ English, philosophy, etc. Have you really "learned to think" from your humanities education if you have no understanding of calculus, probability, statistics, or physics? If you have never learned how to design and conduct an experiment? A "good" university education is simple and not sexy. High quality courses taught by passionate teachers. Nothing else. No student unions, no sports teams, no academic or emotional counseling, no beautiful buildings, no study abroad or fucking trips to Alaska. Which basically describes university studies in central Europe and Israel. Not very sexy so no NYT articles about it. I actually attended a pricey "liberal arts" college where I majored in computer science. I am currently in the OMSCS program at Georgia Tech and the quality of education I am receiving through it is much better at less than a tenth of the cost. We have better discussions on Slack than I did sitting in seminars w/ a bunch of rich kids 20 years ago. No picturesque campus to stroll through though :)
- hadsed 7y agoYour second point seems really overblown. Language evolves, embrace and accept that. People seem to be using the words humanities and liberal arts to mean the same thing these days.
- bryanwb 7y agobullshit, the removal of natural sciences and math from liberal arts reflects today's math-phobia and fear of doing hard things.
- bawana 7y agoIt’s not about blue collar vs white collar. It’s about working for yourself or being an employee. Corporate culture is ‘anti human’, anti-planet, and anti-social. When you have to use energy to demonstrate your ‘adherence to policy’ that is waste. Furthermore, corporations make you spend that energy from your private store.