17 ms·
I've been a fan of Reddit for a very long time (as the amount of data science work I've done with their data can attest to), but lately it seems like the incent
by minimaxir 8y ago
I've been a fan of Reddit for a very long time (as the amount of data science work I've done with their data can attest to), but lately it seems like the incentives between Reddit as a business and Reddit as a community leader are not aligned, and that is a problem.
The increasing amount of dark patterns Reddit has been employing lately is concerning. (recent example: Reddit now gates content in mobile Safari to push users to the app: https://twitter.com/minimaxir/status/1086002848926593025 https://twitter.com/minimaxir/status/1086002848926593025 )
That said, it seems like the really bad dark patterns I reported 7 months ago (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17446841 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17446841) no longer appear to be in place.
- gfwhuuku 8y agoI think that new banner is so much better than the old one, though. https://i.imgur.com/PF3Zc8R.jpg https://i.imgur.com/PF3Zc8R.jpg
- bduerst 8y agoIt's still bad. They should cookie the choice so it doesn't always pop up every time.
- 0xJRS 8y agoThat wouldn't fit the business model of "push them to the native app as hard as possible"
- saagarjha 8y agoThis doesn't work for people who browse Reddit without cookies or signing in, such as for those who use Private Browsing.
- bduerst 8y agoSo what? That demographic self-selects to be hard to track, so there isn't any good way to track their decision on the pop-up regardless.
- prepend 8y agoAllow me to send a request parameter “?stfu=Y”
- bduerst 8y agoWhich breaks on search result and referral traffic, forcing users to install third party extensions to maintain, thus creating new security vectors. Why not just load your own css and set the div to "display:none;" then?
- saagarjha 8y agoHonestly, that's a good idea. I should block the XPromoPopup class with a content blocker.
- prepend 8y agoThis is what I do on browsers that have greasemonkey. The downside is that I have to be aware of their div and other things they make to try to make me switch to mobile. Specifying a parameter of reddit’s specification allows me to work with them as a user to follow their parameter. If their users don’t like certain features (like nag popups) then it helps them to proactively solve this problem before their users leave.
- bduerst 8y agoSure, but as a PM at reddit, you're not going to release new features like blanket URL parameters that push behavior that leads to security issues. Just to cater to a self-selecting demographic that doesn't directly contribute to your P&Ls.
- vmednis 8y agoYou can do that, it's just a bit hidden away. https://i.imgur.com/qIDu7q3.jpg https://i.imgur.com/qIDu7q3.jpg
- bduerst 8y agoOf course. Looks like it's stored server side? I couldn't see where they are storing it. Good find.
- EdiX 8y agoThe sad part is that it's not better in the app. I tried it.
- komali2 8y agoRe: "Download the app!" gates, banners, etc. Medium does this too. Why? What's the business reason? What does a native app provide the business that a mobile website doesn't?
- maxxxxx 8y agoI think it has to do with analytics but maybe someone else knows more.
- totololo 8y agoI would guess that with an app users are signed in and precisely identified 100% of the time, which allows for very reliable and deep user analytics.
- lancesells 8y agoMetrics, ads, notifications, install base.
- smitty1110 8y agoYou can probably grab the IDFA or the ADID with an app directly, and having a stronger linkage between an online identity/cookie probably makes the data more valuable for advertising purposes.
- fumar 8y ago100% device IDs are deterministic vs cookies. Advertiser platforms (like Reddit) need to tell a compelling audience story and that requires a strong user identity graph.
- dx87 8y agoForcing people to use a native app means they can inject ads without having to worry about being blocked by a browser extension.
- dawnerd 8y ago
- pkamb 8y agoThe AMP pages with mobile app pop-up are the worst. Especially as the cookie is broken so that you get the pop-up every single AMP visit.
- ppod 8y agoI've always thought that the day they crossed the line was when they arbitrarily changed which subreddits were default, removing some (such as /r/atheism) with no real reason. At the very early days of reddit, discussing atheism positively was still kind of unusual in the news. Then, over time, it became a very popular position and advocacy case especially among developers, and new users found the stridency and repetition of the subreddit annoying. I think they ultimately took the decision to remove a default subreddit that supported a community that is in general still one of the most hated in the US and in the world, just in order to appeal to new users outside of the hacker culture demographic that reddit started in.
- gfwhuuku 8y agoI welcomed that change. They had handpicked a few left-leaning subs like that one. I also remember there was one about feminism. I believe that was a bad idea, to position themselves like that. Maybe it was a good idea when reddit was a niche website. Now, as far as I know, they simply have an algorithm that shows the most popular posts of all subs, except a few ones that are banned (like the popular the_donald, a sub for supporters of Donald Trump). I'm not saying that I like the idea of a blacklist or that it is the best solution, but it's better than a whitelist.
- vvillena 8y ago/r/the_donald should have been closed a long time ago, due to their users and their mods breaking the rules (hate speech encouragement, mainly) that the rest of subreddits have to respect. Reddit has a dark incentive to keep it open, because it's a very popular community that helps Reddit make money, via ads and Reddit Gold.
- Zecar 8y agoGo read r/politics comments for 5 minutes and then go read r/the_donald comments for 5 minutes, then come back and tell me which subreddit has the most hate speech. Also let's not forget that r/politics mods sold the subreddit to Shareblue for $2 million.
- marknadal 8y agoMax, would you be willing to evaluate Reddit alternatives? One is https://notabug.io/ https://notabug.io/ after the Aaron Swarz quote, has seen hypergrowth since it started a few months ago using our P2P tech.
- jedberg 8y agoYou do realize that reddit owns Notabug, Inc, yeah?
- jron 8y agonotabug.io isn't owned by Reddit.
- jedberg 8y agoI'm aware of that, I'm just saying they own the corporation with the same name, which they got when they acquired Aaron's company.
- skinnymuch 8y agoThey own Notabug Inc, not notabug.io
- pier25 8y agoThe UI is based on some open source repo by Reddit.
- jedberg 8y agoYeah, it's based on the old open source reddit.
- RickSanchez2600 8y agoUsing Gun and Blockchain to mirror content on other servers to prevent data loss. Notabug.io is a P2P tech using the old Reddit UI. http://k666.kr5ddit.com/ http://k666.kr5ddit.com/ Is a free and open source version of http://kr5ddit.com http://kr5ddit.com made to look like the old Scoop and function like Reddit.
- tyingq 8y agoWould help if they dumped the AMP pages too. Landing there results in a useless "not logged in" and "partial content" page. AMP is just a terrible fit for Reddit pages.
- ChrisSD 8y agoBut the AMP pages give them preferential treatment in Google search results. I doubt they'd want to give that up.
- josteink 8y agoSo you are saying Google is blackmailing websites into having a terrible user-experience? I guess everbody sucks on this new, modern and JS-USB-enabled (thanks again Google!) web.
- bsder 8y ago> So you are saying Google is blackmailing websites into having a terrible user-experience? Pretty much, yes. AMP compliance gets you a better Google search placement. So, every site is going to make sure they get their AMP placement and then funnel you to something non-Google.
- gruturo 8y agoYes. AMP is an absolute cancer and its adoption would probably be 0% if google didn’t forcefully shove it down everyone’s throat. (And they are very good at learning from their own history, because that totally worked with Google+.)
- dhimes 8y agoI wonder how important Google Search is to Reddit, though. They are big enough (like Facebook) that they may not need it much anymore, and may have used AMP based on the promise of a better experience (meanwhile deliberately degrading mobile experience).
- 8y ago
- simias 8y agoI've seen this dialog (the misleading "[OPEN] [CONTINUE]" one) on mobile Firefox as well. Besides that you have the pulsating "open in the app" at the top of every page. Fortunately I have u-block origin so I could just add a few filters to get rid of that nonsense. It doesn't solve the terrible performance however (because apparently you need a top-of-the-line smartphone to load and display a few kB of plaintext comments).
- lallysingh 8y agoThe app is even slower. It's amazing how bad their stuff is. I avoid Reddit on mobile altogether because of the terrible performance.
- Max_Mustermann 8y ago> a few filters to get rid of that nonsense Care to share?
- zozbot123 8y agoIt's an interesting question. "Reddit as a business" would seem to have an incentive to keep their esoteric and weird communities going, otherwise it's hard to see their appeal over other social-media sites. The notable thing about the dark patterns you correctly point out is that they hit the casual users really hard, but most dedicated users (the folks who plausibly provide the content and indeed community that ultimately gives Reddit its value) can easily get around them. It will be interesting to see if this pattern can prove sustainable.
- wnevets 8y agoThere are so many more issues with Reddit, I'm surprised they haven't been digg'd or myspace'd yet.
- rootusrootus 8y agoWell, you could be the one to do it. Taking down an incumbent is hard, though. Might need deep pockets for a while.
- asdff 8y agoAll the issues stem from new populations of users contributing to the site, not a top down change. Reddit 5+ years ago was a different place because it was a much smaller place.
- babypuncher 8y agoAs soon as a viable alternative pops up that doesn't seem tailor made for racists, I'm there. So far every competitor I've seen pop up seems to think Reddit's biggest problem is their (rather weak) stance against hate speech and user harassment, and not all the actual problems being discussed here.
- chipotle_coyote 8y agoThere was an attempt a few years ago to do just this. Remember Imzy? If the answer is "no," you're probably not alone; it shut down after only two years of operation. They didn't have any of the problems that we're discussing here, as far as I remember. (Personally, I suspect its extremely weird and confusing UX design was at least part of what did it in; I found its navigation so baffling I gave up pretty quickly.)
- Guest10928391 8y agoIf I remember right, you couldn't see any content on Imzy without creating an account. I assume that instantly turned away over 90% of the users. Then, their design was extremely childish, and it looked like a safe place for kids, rather than a site for adults to socialize. I think they did a really poor job at understanding the market, and I'm not surprised they failed. https://i.imgur.com/9uzaciS.png https://i.imgur.com/9uzaciS.png
- GordonS 8y ago2 things about Reddit's "use our app instead!" buttons: 1. They cycle through a couple of different messages, and the buttons get switched around 2. The wording is such that you read it twice and still aren't sure which button will just take you to the damn website I don't mind them promoting their app, but these dark patterns truely rile me
- eeeeeeeeeeeee 8y agoI've noticed this as well. Really annoying. Or any website that immediately pops up a "sign up for our email list!" and blocks you from seeing the content. Isn't there a ton of data that most people don't even use many apps anymore? Or they install them once and then uninstall them or ignore them? I hope we can move towards a web that stays in the web browser. Apps are becoming really annoying, especially for interactions you only have intermittently (I'm not a daily reddit user, but I go there every now and then, or it pops up on search).
- dsfyu404ed 8y ago>Isn't there a ton of data that most people don't even use many apps anymore? Or they install them once and then uninstall them or ignore them? That doesn't mean the app can't exfiltrate data (presumably data useful to advertisers) in the background.
- ethbro 8y agoThe browser is a client that works for the user (well, Google, Apple, and Microsoft muddy the waters). The mobile app is a program that works for the developer. The end result of browsers becoming more adtech-hostile and user-friendly is that more companies turn to mobile apps.
- eeeeeeeeeeeee 8y agoI can understand a developer/company wanting to do the app route to regain control (and not having to deal with the annoying inconsistencies/hacks in different browsers/versions), but is ad / tracker blocking really the major driver of going the app route?
- bootaccount 8y agoreddit also injects unique tracking into every outbound URL click, allowing them to monitor individual user behavior and engagement (similar to Google Search results)
- gammateam 8y agothey also hate TOR users the captcha is not completable, and when it is, the next section says the captcha signature is invalid but you can always circumvent that with a clearnet VPN, just need to isolate its use to just reddit, that session.
- PhasmaFelis 8y agoI got so sick of the "use our app" shit on every page that I installed a third-party reddit app (Apollo). They wouldn't be pushing the app so hard if it was actually to my benefit.
- warent 8y agoI'm probably the minority here but I wouldn't really call the way they're pushing their app a "dark pattern." It is an annoying pattern for sure, but I'm struggling to see what's unethical about it. We should probably be cautious about using the term "dark pattern" so liberally, otherwise anything on the web that we don't like could eventually be categorized as such and the term loses its power.
- SquishyPanda23 8y agoThe gating is even worse on Android. They ask you to "continue" with the Chrome icon even when you're not using Chrome.
- ramphastidae 8y agoAlso the ‘Open Reddit App’ button at the bottom of the screen. Blocks content, can’t remove for the session, and a close button that is purposefully small in order to make it difficult to click. Enraging.
- ProAm 8y agoi.reddit.com bypasses all this
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- elamje 8y agoSo what are you all's theories on why they want to push users to the app? Does that enable them to track more movement, target you with ads easier, etc?
- j0hnml 8y agoI’m guessing a lot of it has to do with making it harder to circumvent ads
- nostromo 8y agoThe worst dark patten in my view is 1) growing an online community around a set of values 2) growing so big you eclipse all competitors 3) suddenly changing your values to appeal to advertisers. Reddit is in good company here, notably with YouTube and Twitter.
- joefkelley 8y agoI agree that this process sucks. Do you think it's possible to do 1 and 2 without 3? How could a business that remains focused on benefiting free users compete/profit?
- klank 8y agoWhy does it have to profit?
- 6ak74rfy 8y agoI don't know if you meant to be sarcastic or funny here. However, business have to earn profit in the long run, otherwise who'd pay for all the employees, infrastructure costs etc.?
- variable11 8y agoPBS, open source, Usenet, there ARE alternative models of organization that don't have revolve around profit
- FiddlyPack 8y agoPaying for employees, infrastructure, etc requires sustainable revenue, not profit.
- adventured 8y agoIt's impossible to run an organization at zero capital buffer perpetually (see: even Wikimedia likes to have a capital reserve). That's a great way to end up bankrupt. What you're suggesting is well beyond absurd. When the recession hits how do you plan to buffer the revenue beating you're guaranteed to take? If you had built up a cash reserve, you can absorb some or all of the hit. Where do you plan to get a large amount of capital to make opportunistic investments in expanding what you do? Debt? If you say debt / loans, that's just admitting the necessity of the capital buffer (which is better derived from profit via operations rather than paying for debt and the associated debt interest). What's your plan for surviving a recession or industry change or regulatory hit (which can demand immense spending on compliance adjustment) with either near 0% revenue growth or low single digit growth? That's the most common business scenario, not 30% or 50% growth every year. What if you have the opportunity to hire N talented engineers from a failed competitor. You've got zero or very low revenue growth and hiring these talented people could very plausibly alter your trajectory. It's an opportunity to jump on. Where is your capital for that coming from? You can apply the exact same capital outlay scenario to equipment investment / upgrade opportunities. How do you plan to absorb any manner of business disaster? Profit is inherently necessary so that when inevitable bad things happen, you can afford to absorb them. It's also necessary for opportunistic expansion and investment, when you see an opportunity that requires a sizable upfront capital allocation. One of the biggest differences between organizations that seize on opportunities and those that don't or can't, is having the required capital to act.
- diogenescynic 8y agoTheir current CEO seems to be a bad actor. Despite people reporting shills or Russian trollbots, the admins basically don't do anything in the name of "free speech" but to me, propaganda and counter-intelligence ops shouldn't really qualify... I wish they'd just clean up all the racist and weirdo (incel) subreddits and focus on nurturing the interesting communities (ebikes, woodworking, vinyl, guitarpedals). There's a lot of good stuff on reddit and it'd be a shame for them to get dragged down by the worst communities.
- richardknop 8y agoWell that’s a slippery slope to start editing or deleting posts you think are Russian propaganda. You might end up editing posts by real people who are misinformed or have those beliefs for some reason. And that is totally against free speech.
- 6cd6beb 8y ago>lately it seems like the incentives between Reddit as a business and Reddit as a community leader are not aligned, and that is a problem. That's by design. Reddit is just another data mining company. Of course they'd rather have you on the app than the browser. Apps can gather info about you even when you're not using them.
- forgotmyshorts 8y agoIt’s funny you say dark patterns. Reddit has been full of dark patterns long before that, between censorship and shilling. It doesn’t surprise me at all that they’re lining up to cash out, just like Facebook. They are positioned, more than likely, as good as they are ever going to be, without a serious financial transformation. Maybe once sold, Reddit will hang onto the limelight another 10 years. As it stands, I see a new Reddit clone about every 4-6 months or so. It’s not a guarded or protected model, like Facebook was. The supposed anonaminity of Reddit is nice, but anyone who knows about browser fingerprinting knows that’s basically a farce. The people paying for your data with Reddit are the same ones paying for it with Facebook. It’s hard for me to envision the data APIs getting any more secure, simply because that’s the thriving business model. But Powered by Reddit instead of Facebook. It’s gone from sociopath founded, to stolen by sociopaths. Slight improvement.
- xiphias2 8y agoThe worst thing in promoting their app is that I would gladly use it if it was faster than a web site, but it loads so much slower that it's just a much worse experience. Google realized that load times are critical 20 years ago. Facebook realized it when Google was launching G+.
- ric2b 8y ago> Google realized that load times are critical 20 years ago. They seem to be forgetting it, lately.
- xiphias2 8y agoYes, Google transformed from an engineering driven organization to a tech driven one. Still, they want to make moneycin developing countries with crappy internet connections as well, so Google doesn't have any choice, it still has to look at latencies.
- travisoneill1 8y ago> incentives between Reddit as a business and Reddit as a community leader are not aligned, and that is a problem. But Reddit is only one of those things.
- pantalaimon 8y agoTheir mobile interface takes ages (several seconds on a bad mobile connection!) to load and keeps pestering you about using the App. I'm glad they keep their old mobile interface (https://i.reddit.com https://i.reddit.com) which loads instantaneous. Unfortunately some links redirect you to the new interface, which is when I just close the site.
- andrepd 8y ago>recent example: Reddit now gates content in mobile Safari to push users to the app They've been doing that for months now. Plus their mobile site is hideously slow and bloated. Here's a tip: http://i.reddit.com http://i.reddit.com. Looks old but does the job.
- kristofferR 8y agoApollo and an "open in Apollo" shortcut is IMO a much better solution.
- shostack 8y agoDon't forget their still live email signup approach. Clicking 'Signup" brings you to a single email form field screen that in no way indicates you do NOT need to provide an email. Clicking 'Next' without entering one lets you create your username and PW without an email address. As a marketer, I understand (but don't condone or agree with) the thinking behind some of what they've done, but as a user of over a decade, I'm nervous about the direction they've been taking the service, and this is not good news IMHO.
- hombre_fatal 8y agoPeople bring that up all the time, but I can't really think of fainter "dark pattern" criticism than an optional email field. I bet nobody would even comment on it if it was actually required. Reddit should probably just go ahead and require it to eliminate the complaints. Hell, I'm more ready to call it an easter egg than deception.
- shostack 8y agoI'd wager you are correct that if it were required, nobody would comment on it except existing Reddit users familiar with their more privacy-respecting leanings from their past (ie. not new users). The dark pattern is that there is zero indicator that it is actually optional and they appear to go out of their way to hide that fact. It is about being upfront with your intentions, and what you are offering users.
- gcb0 8y agodifferently from Google, reddit was bootstrapped by dark patterns! their founders even brag of it! my point being that with Google your complaint is valid. But on reddit case, you are just signaling that you liked one dark pattern (which probably benefited you) more than others.
- karmickoala 8y agoI was browsing it using Firefox Focus, it pointed me to two options to use reddit: the app or Chrome (with its logo). I didn't want to open Chrome, so I closed and tried again. Only then I noticed that it was referring to any browser instead of Chrome... Not entirely bad, but a bit annoying.
- krrrh 8y agoAssuming you’re on Android. Using Firefox Focus on iOS I had the same issue, but the browser icon shows Safari. Still not sure whether they are being deceptive or incompetent.
- jameslevy 8y agoFor me, the "read in Chrome" option in Mobile Safari never works. So there's a choice between two options, and actually your two options are to read in the native app, or to let the popover dialog take up half the screen in the mobile browser. This would be truly evil if it was intentional and not just a bug.
- alasdair_ 8y agoI am using reddit less and less because of the insistence on using the app no matter how many times I decline. They have also become particularly creepy and anti-privacy lately.
- diffuse_l 8y agoI only use the webapp, and the "Use the app messages" was very annoying, until I found that you can actually turn these messages off using some obscure setting (which, of course, I can't find right now...)
- gdx 8y agoIt's easy to turn that dialog off 'permanently' (as long as you don't clear the cookies) on any Android browser: When the dialog appears, click on the hamburger menu at the top right of the reddit page, then turn off the "Ask To Open In App" option. The option disappears when it's off, so it's not possible to turn it on manually (not that anyone would want to). I've set it off months ago in my main browser and it's still off.