36 ms·
Letter from Tim Cook to Apple Investors
- sloanedavids 8y agoI’d be pretty happy to have a company announcing such a shortfall. First world problems indeed.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- braythwayt 8y agoIf the shortfall is indeed almost entirely within China, then it is fair to say that all of the usual criticisms you see on the Internet at large, where people explain why Apple products are not good enough/too expensive/whatever for them personally, are irrelevant. The issue here is entirely around Apple and China.
- baybal2 8y agoIt is a funny thing that in China, Apple has to pay duty, and a foreign VAT to "import" iPhones from bonded customs zones into China.
- braythwayt 8y agoThat's not all that weird. I don't know all of the details, but I recall working with something like that twenty-five years ago, and usually there are a lot of tax breaks and so forth, because most of what's getting manufactured is exported. Jobs stay, products go. So if you then sell those products in the same country, they want some of the taxes and and so forth. The alternative would be to charge all the taxes, then manufacturers would file paperwork to get a refund for the goods they exported. This system streamlines that for the case where the intent is to export more than is sold domestically.
- baybal2 8y agoYep, But more than 50% of iPhone value is Chinese made. Materials, labour, machine time, big part of ICs, batteries, passives, cabling, etc. So, China actually double taxes own manufacturers aside from Apple itself. The meme that "only $20" of iPhones value stays in China" is completely wrong. China makes tons of money from Apple.
- braythwayt 8y agoChina makes tons of money from Apple. Oh very much so. That's why China is careful about starting a trade war with Apple. They want to get their own manufacturers up to speed to replace Apple, but they don't want to just kick Apple out of China in one stroke and penalize the Chinese businesses that depend upon Apple. If it wasn't for that, Apple and their strong privacy approach would be Persona Non Grata, IM-uninformed-O.
- baybal2 8y agoIndeed, and that why Apple was actually cranking up their effort to get more "presence on the ground" in China. Apple tries to be less public about them having HUUGE R&D and business units in China with lots of things being done here. In 2016 they posted a tiny press release about them opening their "first" R&D centre in China in Shenzhen, and deliberately making an impression of it having no significant role. In reality, it was their _third_ RnD centre in Shenzhen only. Besides their nominal "design centre" in Kerry plaza, they rent a whole building in Discovery park in Nanshan, and have own section in Foxconn campus. The rumor is that they also rent yet another office for their product/project management staff somewhere closer to Longhua.
- droithomme 8y agoSeems weird to me too that people in China pay duty on a Chinese made phone. You say it's not weird. I think it's weird, like the guy you responded to. Difference of opinion I guess.
- braythwayt 8y ago
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoiPhones are made in special export zones, along with many other made in China products. SEZs don’t tarrif on inputs (components, raw material, factory machinery from Germany), so outputs are considered not made in China for the purpose of tariffing, even though they are technically made in China. Apple was the first foreign company to price their computers and phones reasonably in China. Before the markup was around 50%, after Apple opened its first Apple stores in China that markup fell to 10-20%, which is about inline with tariffs.
- Dunedan 8y agoOr maybe Chinese customers are just more sensitive to price increases than customers in other countries?
- doctorpangloss 8y agoSensitive is an understatement. I'm sure if you included the effective subsidies China-homed conglomerates enjoy, the ratio of COGS between e.g. Apple and Huawei could be as high as 4:1. Huawei can certainly afford to make phones cost 1/4th as much, although Apple could also afford to cut prices by 38 percentage points (as per their margins). On the other hand, China-homed companies aren't responsible to public markets (Wall Street really) in the same way US-homed are. You could book a 1% margin, but your family owns the company, so the board isn't going to take away your private jet, let alone dump you as CEO. In the US, the "family owned" (in the sense of being management controlled) mega-techs like Facebook and Snapchat are actually suffering greatly due to their poor accountability. It's truly bad for equities, even while Facebook and Snapchat book ever-growing revenues. It will be an interesting reckoning. Not the change in consumer tastes in China, mind you, which doesn't really matter for share prices. It'll be an inevitable change in corporate culture. After all, there are millions of extraordinarily talented people in China who will want the kinds of riches and glamor only a certain privileged minority get to experience. If the bottom line doesn't motivate public accountability, ambition will. That's healthy for everyone, but it will signal the end of sclerotic, state sponsored corporations in China. So as always, the Chinese consumer is the victim. They get to enjoy phones that cost 1/4th as much as an iPhone. But in exchange, they forfeit a certain kind of life fulfillment that, in my opinion, they deserve.
- throwaway12iii 8y agoOr... the Chinese phones are better (for them).
- braythwayt 8y agoLet's say that there are no external factors, like changes to China's economy. If this is just Chinese customers being price sensitive, I stick with what I said above. Me sitting in Toronto saying, "iPhone is too expensive for me, I have a mortgage to pay" is still irrelevant, because Apple is hitting its targets in Canada, the US, and so forth. Maybe it is too expensive for me personally (I'm on an iPhone but it's a 6, not a 6s, not a 7, not an 8, not an X of any kind), but I don't speak for my economic zone.
- Schweigi 8y agoWhile Greater China and other emerging markets accounted for the vast majority of the year-over-year iPhone revenue decline, in some developed markets, iPhone upgrades also were not as strong as we thought they would be. Sounds to me that it isn't just China. The new phones are even more expensive then the previous ones. It's kind of hard to imagine that those high prices have no impact on sales and I would have at least expected there to be a mention about pricing in the letter.
- braythwayt 8y agoWhat you said matches what I said. It isn't just China, but the vast majority of it is China.
- seanmcdirmid 8y ago“And other emerging markets.” They don’t break it down.
- noitsnot 8y agoIndia was supposed to be huge but they lost sales there, also.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoThey still don’t have stores in India right?
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoAlso from the letter: In fact, most of our revenue shortfall to our guidance, and over 100 percent of our year-over-year worldwide revenue decline, occurred in Greater China across iPhone, Mac and iPad.
- esmi 8y agoI don’t think iPhones are the problem as it’s not just Apple that’s having sales issues in China. You can find articles like the one below for many tech luxury brands. https://www.google.com/amp/s/observer.com/2018/12/tesla-china-sales-struggles-real-expert-says/amp/ https://www.google.com/amp/s/observer.com/2018/12/tesla-chin... And even non-tech luxury brands https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.wsj.com/amp/articles/luxury-goods-industry-has-a-china-problem-11546344000 https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.wsj.com/amp/articles/luxury...
- bepotts 8y ago> then it is fair to say that all of the usual criticisms you see on the Internet at large, where people explain why Apple products are not good enough/too expensive/whatever for them personally, are irrelevant. You could swap out Apple with pretty much anything and you'll be accurate. The person commenting on the internet all day isn't representative of the average person.
- zimpenfish 8y ago> The person commenting on the internet all day isn't representative of the average person. You can boost that several orders of magnitude when it comes to this site, too.
- Shivetya 8y agomy two take away items. 1) China, obviously, if luxury perceived items like Apple products are slowing then that is a real indicator of the economy truly slowing regardless what the government states. 2) Having to full develop an in store trade in program pretty much is admission they priced themselves out of the market
- hopler 8y ago1. Possibly. It could also mean that apple is reaching saturation and evolving from growth sales to replacement-level sales as purchased products get old and wear out.
- headsoup 8y agoPretty sure they've been at saturation for a while now...
- tanilama 8y agoThey played that Appel Status Symbol card for too long. In China, Yuan's depreciation should also be counted, so eventually Apple raised the price for local customer for about 30%, north to 10k in Chinese Yuan. In fact with 4 times that much money you can buy a budget car in China. People chasing status symbol but they are not fools, and the local brands offer good enough quality with only 40% of the price, you know what to choose.
- hn_throwaway_99 8y ago> People chasing status symbol but they are not fools I think that is the real risk to Apple. Right now iPhones (esp. in China) are a status symbol, but public opinion is a fickle thing. It's possible rising nationalism in China could also lead to an atmosphere where buying an iPhone is looked down upon as an exercise in conspicuous consumption but paid to China's enemy (when home grown phones are "just as" good). When that happens, Apple really is in dire straits. Apple needs to ensure they can innovate faster than the competition, but with a lot of value shifting to AI-related services (not necessarily Apple's strong point - compare Siri to Alexa or Google Assistant), that's a tough battle for Apple.
- ummonk 8y ago>We believe the economic environment in China has been further impacted by rising trade tensions with the United States. As the climate of mounting uncertainty weighed on financial markets, the effects appeared to reach consumers as well, with traffic to our retail stores and our channel partners in China declining as the quarter progressed. And market data has shown that the contraction in Greater China’s smartphone market has been particularly sharp. That sounds like Huawei fallout.
- cbhl 8y agoWeren't Chinese companies threatening to fire their employees last week for buying Apple? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18760120 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18760120
- reasonablemann 8y agoSounds like economic contraction to me. I don't see how Huawei has anything to do with this.
- cronix 8y ago> That sounds like Huawei fallout. How would fallout from Huawei have anything to do with fewer people walking into Apple stores and buying a new Apple product? Have the prices risen or something? Are people afraid of being kidnapped if they walk into an Apple store? To me, it is just a lame hyperpolitical straw man excuse as to why they aren't selling more products. It has zero to do with China, imo. It has to do with people not NEEDING a new device, so they are upgrading (a lot) less frequently. Personally, I'm on about a 5 year upgrade cycle now. Apple will have a harder time going forward having increasing records year after year, because they mostly rely on new hardware sales. I think we're kind of coming to a Moores law type effect in terms of hardware perception (not design/capability). There just isn't enough of a perceivable or revolutionary innovative difference for the average person to justify purchasing a new multi $k machine year after year. For most people (non power users), they get no actual tangible benefit. An iPhone X will perform just as well for the vast majority of an average users applications as an iphone 8.
- 8y ago
- drinchev 8y agoWhat is worrying in addition to the global economy slowing down is the volatility and how the stock market closed 2018. I believe a new crash is imminent and I hope this time we have our seatbelts on.
- stevewodil 8y agoBuy Gold! US Dollar crisis coming to a market near you
- kaycebasques 8y agoDoes anyone have the quick stats on how much their various guidance measurements have been downwardly revised?
- nemo44x 8y agoThey guided for 89B - 93B and it has been revised down to 84B.
- firloop 8y ago>Third, we knew we had an unprecedented number of new products to ramp during the quarter and predicted that supply constraints would gate our sales of certain products during Q1. > ... AirPods and MacBook Air were also constrained. (emphasis mine) Interesting that Apple still can't manage to make AirPods, a 2 year old product, fast enough. I wonder why that is.
- braythwayt 8y agoTucking my Apple Admirer badge under the keyboard for a moment, they can't make the promised wireless charging pad at all. Tim Cook is one of the finest CEOs of his generation, but he cannot walk on water, and neither can his company. They do some things well, and on others, their reach exceeds their grasp.
- h3throw 8y agoYou're thinking of the AirPower not the AirPods.
- braythwayt 8y agoI am well aware of the difference, my point is that Apple is unevenly great. They have hits and misses, they do brilliant things with the supply chain... And they have some clunkers. It’s not JUST AirPods.
- snazz 8y agoAlso interesting that AirPods are still the new hotness with plenty of people. Usually the interest goes down after launch, but my anecdotal experience suggests that, at least where I live, the interest has certainly risen.
- wvenable 8y agoI bought a few AirPods as gifts this year. I think it comes down to iPhone user's not upgrading (due to cost) and instead looking towards accessories for their existing devices. My wife should be due for a phone upgrade but instead she got the battery replacement a few months ago and AirPods for Christmas.
- luso_brazilian 8y agoInteresting tidbit in another source [1] > Apple boss Tim Cook has blamed the US-China trade war as he warned of lower than expected quarterly sales for the iPhone maker. Seems like the US-China trade war is taking its toll on Chinese economy, particularly on the high end. [1] https://news.sky.com/story/apple-cuts-sales-forecast-as-china-slowdown-bites-11597357 https://news.sky.com/story/apple-cuts-sales-forecast-as-chin...
- Doctor_Fegg 8y ago> we believe there are other factors broadly impacting our iPhone performance, including consumers adapting to a world with fewer carrier subsidies, US dollar strength-related price increases, and some customers taking advantage of significantly reduced pricing for iPhone battery replacements Dropping the SE - the one affordable iPhone - is starting to look like a really bad move for Apple.
- saagarjha 8y agoiPhone 7 is $449, which is $50 more than what iPhone SE launched at.
- graeme 8y agoBut the SE was newer compared to the flagship then. What would the SE have cost this year?
- graeme 8y agoCan't edit comment. From what I can tell, the refreshed SE was starting at $349 USD in 2018. That probably would have dropped if it was still on sale.
- droithomme 8y ago> What would the SE have cost this year? In late November 2017 no-contract SEs were going for $99 at some stores. A year later the price had dropped to $79. I bought one at $99 to use as an mp3 player and camera. Works great. I don't want a phone that's any larger because it won't fit comfortably into my pockets. Still using for day-to-day actual phone use a pretty great similar sized Android phone I bought for much less. I prefer it because it has an SD slot and replaceable battery and uses USB, all better AFAIAC than no SD slot, no replaceable battery and no USB. Phones are cheap and the cheap phones are very good.
- paganel 8y agoMaybe in the US, but where I live (Eastern Europe) the cheapest 32GB iPhone7 is still about 200 euros more expensive compared to the iPhone SE I purchased about a year ago. 200 euros is a sum that matters for a lot of people, including myself.
- CWSZ 8y agoWe believe there are other factors broadly impacting our iPhone performance, including consumers adapting to a world with fewer carrier subsidies, US dollar strength-related price increases, and some customers taking advantage of significantly reduced pricing for iPhone battery replacements. Why spend $1,449 on an XS Max when you could have replaced the battery on your phone for $29?
- saagarjha 8y agoiPhone XS Max starts at $1099, and it's a newer phone?
- colejohnson66 8y agoI’ve noticed that people like to spout the price for the highest tiered item as a reason for not buying a product. Like the original Apple Watch with the $10k Apple Watch Edition.
- raverbashing 8y agoYes please let me spend more on an "inferior product" (without a headphone jack) instead of replacing the battery Funnily enough I got an email about availability of the new models for a discounted price "for a limited time only". Maybe their prices will be reviewed?
- bdcravens 8y agoOnce you lose that giant bezel it looks really jarring on phones that still have it. As for the headphone jack, for many, it doesn't make the phone inferior any more than the MacBook is inferior for not including an ethernet port.
- sneakernets 8y agoWe once waited until the tech matured before removing older legacy components. Last I checked, Bluetooth audio still sucks, and Apple knows it, which is why they supplied a dongle to get around the justified complaints.
- kornork 8y agoI can tell you why I haven't upgraded my iPhone 6S: I like my headphone jack.
- acomjean 8y agoI'm in the same boat, I like my headphone jack. And honestly the phone is fast enough. But I'd like a better camera so I took a look: The other thing that isn't helping apple is the went from a simple system to understand iphone 6, 7 8 (s for the bigger models (edit: whoops I meant plus.). To so iPhone Xr, X, Xs.. I can't tell it the iPhone 8 is the end of the line for the numbered iPhones with a front button. Basically I'll have to do some research. They made a page to help, but when comparing phones, price is an important factor to compare... https://www.apple.com/iphone/compare/ https://www.apple.com/iphone/compare/
- dragonwriter 8y ago> The other thing that isn't helping apple is the went from a simple system to understand iphone 6, 7 8 (s for the bigger models). S has always been for second models with the same number (kind of like a minor version), they invariably are released one year after and are the same size (not bigger) as the corresponding non-S version (the XS Max is the only exception, there is no X Max, and XS Max is just a bigger same-year cousin of the XS, but the XS has the normal S-to-non-S relation to the X.) This holds the whole way back to the first S, the 3GS.
- ProfessorLayton 8y ago"...customers taking advantage of significantly reduced pricing for iPhone battery replacements" Very interesting that Apple included this as someone who took advantage of a $29 battery replacement for my 6S just last month. The chain of decisions that took place for this to happen should be a lesson for more companies. I imagine it went something like this: - Feedback that iPhones were shutting down unexpectedly due to degraded and/or defective batteries. - Instead of shouldering the battery replacement immediately, the product team decides to change the performance envelope of the phone. - The root issue is not addressed. - Betterygate™ inevitably happens. - Apple heavily subsidizes battery replacements for everyone - Some people decide that they'll stick with their phone a bit longer than they otherwise would have, reducing iPhone sales. - Apple misses their earnings target, likely costing them more in value than it would have cost them to address the root issue in the first place. Of course there are other factors addressed in the letter, but this issue was notable enough to be included.
- debt 8y agoI think they meant as people “redeemed” but they used the poorly-chosen phrase “took advantage”. Because Apple shouldn’t offer something they don’t want people to use that phrase being very poorly chosen.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- threeseed 8y ago> The root issue is not addressed No manufacturer gives free battery replacements to 3 year old, out of warranty phones. And even if they did the issue would still be wide spread because most people wouldn't necessarily come in to have it replaced.
- Puer 8y ago
- meursault334 8y agoI think the long term question for Apple is whether or not they can pull off another category-creating move at the level of the iPhone. I believe they will in the next 3-5 years therefore I am glad for the opportunity to put more money into AAPL less expensively.
- l33tbro 8y agoI'm surprised by your optimism here. Over the last 5-10 years, Apple seemed to have receded in to the clunky monolith of its former mid-90s self. While their supply and distribution chain is amazingly streamlined, they're still dining out on the cachet of their innovative product line from 10-15 years ago. I just cannot understand how an increasingly risk-averse, profit-driven company will summon the chutzpah to again create category-creating products once more.
- askafriend 8y agoAirPods, Apple Watch, Apple Music, Apple Pay, FaceID, huge strides in mapping, Privacy-aware services and much more were all created in the past couple of years and have tremendous category-defining value. I don't think you can overlook those things and take them for granted. There's still not great alternatives to AirPods or Apple Watch to this day. Music streaming is pretty much just Apple and Spotify at this point. Also, few companies have been able to align privacy and embed it into their business models. Apple has also quietly built one of the best chip design teams in the industry - pumping out various custom silicon that is powering FaceID, ML, Photography, and AR among other things. The # of custom chips Apple uses in their products grows every year. So they've done a ton of innovative things over the past couple of years, it's just that you're not going to get another product like the iPhone which is perhaps one of the best businesses of all time. We may never see another business like it anytime soon, from anyone. So I think it's a bit unfair to grade everything Apple does on the "iPhone Curve".
- Apocryphon 8y agoThose are all great features. (Yes, even the Watch.) None exists on its own. The underlying product is still the iPhone.
- baybal2 8y agoApple's fate in China is very similar to German premium car brands – despite being a definite good sell elsewhere, they have no real alternative to actually double down their stakes and investment into China, if not making it their primary focus. BMW, Audi (WW premium brand) and Mercedes all committed to gigantic investments into growing their presence here in last hew years, and so now has Apple. In the past, American companies were some of the most passive players in China. It seems that they finally started to notice that China is a no joke market.
- gordon_freeman 8y agoI think if I want to invest in AAPL today I'd rather focus on this: "Services generated over $10.8 billion in revenue during the quarter, growing to a new quarterly record in every geographic segment, and we are on track to achieve our goal of doubling the size of this business from 2016 to 2020." Apple is definitely trying (successfully IMO) to diversify its business to services-centric and that is exciting to me!
- acomjean 8y agoBut most apple services really work only/ best on apple devices. If they're selling fewer phones, its less itunes/imusic/icloud revenue.
- jklinger410 8y agoYes, I agree completely. Their services are all tied to their hardware. It's not the same as other services companies.
- berberous 8y agoI think they are generally selling fewer phones because people are sticking to their iPhone 6 or 7 rather than switch to a $1500 XS. They are not switching to Android.
- askafriend 8y agoWhat you're suggesting isn't really a problem. Here's what I posted elsewhere in this thread that addresses it: "The actual product is the Apple ecosystem and that's the bet Apple is making. Right now, the ecosystem is tied together by iOS whose most popular incarnation is iPhone. But iOS was so successful that it has an install base of over 1 billion users. That's nothing less than an incredible user-base - a hell of a foundation. If they can sustain that install base with iterative iPhones while strengthening their ecosystem through value-add products like Apple Watch, AirPods, HomePod and Apple Music, then they have potentially many cash cows with dramatically high ceilings and reach. This is a good bet for them because it plays to their strengths and they've earned incredibly loyal customers over the years. iPhone may not be the future of Apple, but it is the core from which many futures will emerge. It'll still be a critical product for Apple, but no longer a key top-line growth driver. And that's OK, that's how innovation cycles go. iPhone made it possible for them to start on 3rd base for the next cycle."
- Entangled 8y agoApple needs balls. They need to show the world they can innovate where nobody has gone before. An Apple TV with screen and game controllers for $2k would sell like hot cakes. A stackable 'Mac Nano' the size of current Apple TV 4k for under $500. An 'iPhone Y' aimed at the lower end for under $300 so everybody can use Apple Pay, Facetime, etc and get immersed in the Apple ecosystem. You can't survive in a competitive world with just 10% of the market share since interconnectedness is crucial for the dominance of any platform and that's why you need cheaper macs and phones without losing the appeal of high end products for those who have the money in times of economic duress like the ones to come.
- wozniacki 8y agoI tend to agree with the sentiment that Apple just hasn't innovated off late like it did in the past. I'm an Apple user and am constantly fighting off the urge to switch to Android given just terrific some of the phone experiences are, over on that side. I've heard from Youtubers who have maxed out the RAM on their Mac Pros that its absolute garbage at even handling mundane video editing tasks. This was two years ago. Nonetheless, I won't switch to Android only because of the privacy promises Apple has made & doubled down on. Whereas Google doesn't seem to care so much. The forced auto-login into Chrome browser (desktop) when you login to your Gmail on the browser, was the last straw for me. However I just don't get just why Apple doesn't loosen those purse strings and spend massively on re-capturing the imagination of the user like it once did. Is it Tim Cook and the board? Does the ROI simply not exist in this space anymore no matter the capital spend? Where - if at all - does Apple see a justifiable spend in the near future - tvs? cars?
- ydnaclementine 8y ago>emerging market >China pick one Remember, China is the second largest economy in the world. There was a HN article awhile back arguing that China is taxed as an emerging market (low tax), but is dollar size of a mature market. So, two questions: Is China considered a maturing market? Is China considered a mature market? I don’t think just positive growth counts as maturing (even the US still grows), so I think the answers have to be mutually exclusive. Maybe you could argue the rate of growth makes it maturing, but I would love to compare it to the rate of US growth from 1950's-60's (was the considered US maturing or mature during that period?).
- gumby 8y agoIt's big but still has a lot of structural problems like any emerging market (e.g. very high unemployment, poor statistical data, only quasi-free markets, very high poverty rates, low per capita gdp, poor judicial system, et al). So it's pretty clearly an "emerging" market, i.e. non-OECD. There's an unrelated question as to whether OECD and non-OECD countries should be treated differently.
- baybal2 8y agoChina is the second largest economy, but the country is still quite pooooor... ... _on average_ America is on another hand is a developed country on average, but double digit of population is officially below the official poverty line.... Which one is better you think? In reality, that is Apples to Oranges comparison. China is not a market economy to begin with...
- just_myles 8y ago" In fact, categories outside of iPhone (Services, Mac, iPad, Wearables/Home/Accessories) combined to grow almost 19 percent year-over-year. " Wonder why they never break out these products in these sales forecasts.
- sulam 8y agoThey used to, at least in the case of Macintosh. Once it started to show weakness (lack of YoY growth), they rolled it into other measurements. Now, unless all of them flail, they can declare success without you knowing the real story about any one of them.
- arthurcolle 8y agoApple is extremely hostile to users. I'm going in to get a single K key replaced. Maxed out MacBook Pro (around ~$4,500) with the ridiculously overpriced AppleCare+ (another $450), and if they try to pull shenanigans with "full unibody replacement" to fix the moronically designed butterfly clip that's basically DOA in terms of usage, for a $5000 computer, I'm literally never going to buy another Apple product again. Good luck trying to excise people's money through "Services" when everyone jumps ship after realizing they ship dumbed down products without any regard for people's need for workstations and not expensive toys that break trivially.
- gyrccc 8y agoJust to share an anecdote from my experience in China. I was in Beijing over the holidays and met up with a handful of friends who live there, surprisingly they all switched to Huawei within the past year, three of them even in the past 2 months. The Huawei phones they use are flagship models and not cheaper than iPhones and they have all been Apple users for years (like myself) and who still use Macs today. I asked each one of them if patriotism or the recent Huawei/US kerfuffle influenced their decision. They all resoundingly said no. When I asked why they chose Huawei after being in the Apple ecosystem for a decade, all of them said "camera". They said camera quality isn't about DXO scores or 4k60 but being able to take "beautiful" photos out of the box for some definition of beautiful. To them, iPhoneXS is the same if not worse than a 6, because the iPhone camera doesn't take more "beautiful" photos, only more "realistic" ones. Obviously anecdotes are meaningless and all that, but I want to note that China is a very homogeneous society given its population, so even a brief first-person glimpse into people's everyday lives can be pretty telling. I would not be comfortable making similar conclusions about any other cluster of 1.3B people. TL,DR: I don't buy that the economic downturn in China and the Huawei/US situation are the sole perpetrators of Apple's problem in China. Apple is missing opportunities due not innovating in certain crucial areas.
- bluedino 8y ago>> because the iPhone camera doesn't take more "beautiful" photos, only more "realistic" ones. I hear this all the time from friends and family. Such and such camera is so much better. Most of the time the images really aren't. The brightness is just cranked up or something, the image doesn't look that great. I'm not sure why the iPhone doesn't have better low-light settings, even my 8 Plus doesn't take very good pictures indoors if I don't use a different camera app.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- tanilama 8y agoA lot of Apple fan here are in denial that iPhone is a boring product, probably for some time now. Huawei P20 had 6 cameras and take super high-resolution lossless photos. At least that is something consumer is willing to buy.
- wgpete 8y agoiPhone now stands for inflationPhone, fuck apple.
- aylmao 8y agoAlso not to be underestimated: Android. Personal anecdote: I broke my iPhone and have been using Android for a bit, and I must admit: at first I thought I'd switch back but nowadays Android is pretty good. Hardware at a comparable price-point is solid, the UI is smooth and better-looking than it was before, the app ecosystem isn't quite as good, but is very very close, and there's features I would actually miss on iOS (a calendar widget on my homescreen, unlocking my device without touching the screen and Google's Night Sight). I miss my to do app and my email app, both of which are not on Android (Things and Spark). But overall, I personally can't think of a single aspect where iOS "miles ahead" anymore, from an end-user perspective.
- g45y45 8y agoprivacy
- wilkystyle 8y agoFor me, this is the #1 reason. Sure the Apple ecosystem is fantastic (lastpass on my iphone can prefill passwords on my apple TV!) and the level of polish and quality is high, but the one single solitary thing that would truly prevent me from moving to Chromebook or a pixel is the privacy aspect. Apple has done well to make privacy one of their prime offerings.
- bagsvaerd70 8y agoIf you are willing to take total control of your mobile environment, Android can give you very good privacy. Arguably better than Apple. Simply buy a Pixel (or any other device that supports AOSP). Build your own AOSP image (which is quite easy). And you are ready to go. Use applications from F-Droid only. Admittedly it's not as straightforward as running your favorite Linux distro, and there are some caveats, but it's quite close.
- webo 8y agoThis reads a lot like the HN-famous Dropbox comment.
- awareBrah 8y agoI will use my iPhone 6 (not S) until they release a phone with a headphone jack I’m hoping for a refreshed SE. I like the button. I like the headphone jack. I don’t like FaceId.
- huhtenberg 8y agoAmen, on all points. But it ain't gonna happen.
- awareBrah 8y agoI was very happy to hear of the disappointing sales. I hope they continue to disappoint until they have to make it happen.
- j79 8y agoI'd love some "retro" devices. An iPhone that's Slightly fatter (fill the space with a larger battery), headphone jack, and a "smaller" screen. Of course, have all of the latest hardware (camera, soc, etc.). Or, a MacBook Pro, again slightly fatter (larger battery), with a great keyboard, actual ports (no dongles), and no touch bar. Give us the option for a matte screen to totally blow our socks off. I'd buy those two devices tomorrow if Apple introduced them.
- miguelrochefort 8y agoYou'll be using your iPhone 6 (not S) forever.
- LeicaLatte 8y agoTim probably gave a video interview of some sort too but Apple should be glad the open web still exists and they are able to communicate such crucial information in a timely manner to investors. Nothing beats writing a blog on the internet which can be read by everyone with a browser.
- beezischillin 8y agoThis might not be popular, but here goes: I wonder if knowing that he will have to share this news with his investors is why he came up with that semi-religious cult-like speech about exercising corporate censorship at the ADL not that long ago (https://www.macrumors.com/2018/12/03/tim-cook-adl-keynote-speech/ https://www.macrumors.com/2018/12/03/tim-cook-adl-keynote-sp...), if that was his way of pandering to an audience in hopes of getting some additional sales... I might be wrong but it's happened several times before where companies were trying to drum up some support by suddenly being extremely "woke" just before having to come out with some bad news.
- sulam 8y agoPretty sure he isn't expecting to get more sales in China because of an award from the ADL.
- krrrh 8y agoI really doubt that “woke” speeches do much to drive sales, but I’d wager his speech to the privacy commissioners had a larger effect than the ADL one. https://www.theverge.com/2018/10/24/18017842/tim-cook-data-privacy-laws-us-speech-brussels https://www.theverge.com/2018/10/24/18017842/tim-cook-data-p...
- LeicaLatte 8y agoPretty much confirms battery degradation was driving growth, doesn't it?
- mandeepj 8y agoApple’s cash in hand used to be around ~250b. Now, it’s 130b. Looks like, they have spent almost half of that on stock buybacks
- jeklj 8y agoInteresting! But when you say "half", which number are you referring to?
- bluedino 8y ago>> Gross margin of approximately 38 percent Stop charging $1,000 for a phone. Stop gouging us for storage. Bring back a $999 MacBook.
- timbit42 8y agoThat will only happen if people stop paying it.
- quickthrower2 8y agoI paid equivalent of $300US for a new iPhone.
- NicoJuicy 8y agoThe Chinese governement has since long tried to "shift vibes about Apple" through the "China Central Television". In 2013 it was named together with the "820 Party", i don't know what happened now though. But i'm not sure that "blaming it on the trade war" tells the entire tale. PS. They did the same thing with Google, after "Operation Aurora" happened. That was the moment that Google left China.
- mgazzer 8y agoI wonder how long before Apple offers a One-Google like offering they really embrace the recurring revenue model. Imagine if Apple could get people to pay $20 a month for Photo storage, iCloud storage, some TV offering, and possibly some Apple Music. I hate that we're in this in-between land that requires 3 or 4 different subscriptions to the same company whereas these things in my mind would just be bundled together.
- kodablah 8y ago> We can’t change macroeconomic conditions, but we are undertaking and accelerating other initiatives to improve our results. One such initiative is making it simple [...] As a naive person on the outside looking in, why are there no suggested changes to the clearly incorrect estimation approach, especially in volatile markets? If the numbers are not as expected why not look at expectation generation along with other factors instead of ignoring it? Or are they saying in so many words that they can't be blamed due to macroeconomic conditions? Sounds like such a volatile environment would require caution on these short term forecasts. Again I'm naive, I just didn't see it addressed.
- borland 8y agoHe dances around the point so many times, but never comes out and says it (and of course he wouldn't) - The 2018/2019 lineup of iPhones is TOO EXPENSIVE and this is causing a significant number of people, particularly in "emerging markets" (i.e. poor people) not to buy iPhones. The surprise is that they didn't expect that raising the price by 20% wouldn't have an impact like this
- Despegar 8y agoThe iPhone XS was the exact same price as the X and that sold plenty fine. It wasn't the price as his letter points out, much to the dismay of many people.
- kps 8y agoThe people willing to pay that price already have an iPhone X, and not enough of them are willing to pay it a second time for a minor revision.
- dstroot 8y agoThis
- reagan83 8y agoAgreed - This is what their strategy overlooked. Lineup needs to exceed expectations to justify price increase y/y, but revisions are increasingly minor since the 7 lineup.
- general8bitso 8y agoI would say as far back as the iPhone 6.
- mwean 8y agoI think that's the key. I've upgraded every year for many years, but I just wasn't compelled to do it this year. I love my X, and it's still working great! I fully expect to upgrade next year.
- myrandomcomment 8y agoI have an original X and love it. I see no need to upgrade to the newer X. Wife has an 8 and kid has a 6S. Only thing that would get me to upgrade would be the X in the form factor of the iPhone5.
- senthilnayagam 8y agoApple has outpriced all its competitors, I have not updated my MacBook Pro for 4 years, not upgraded iPhone for 3, never bought iPad Pro, watch, air pods. bought last years MacBook Air , 2018 iPad instead . Apple can reduce pricing by 10-15% or give credits so that people can use it for accessories and apps. Until it gets price right, market like India can never grow for Apple.
- saagarjha 8y ago> 2018 iPad This is a recent product…
- jrnichols 8y ago>We believe the economic environment in China has been further impacted by rising trade tensions with the United States. That sounds like a slightly roundabout way to throw some of the blame at Trump and his trade policies. Not the only reason, but one of them, as the letter mentions.
- conanthe 8y agoApple is like Beats of phones and computers.
- general8bitso 8y agoI bought my wife, then girlfriend, the original iPad 16GB for $499. I just bought her the latest 64GB iPad on sale for $249. When the iPhone 4 16GB was released, it was $499 unsubsidized. Something isn’t right.
- pdimitar 8y agoIMO Tim Cook did a good-enough analysis but deliberately omitted the rather insane prices of the XS and XS Max phones. Just look at the prices of the 256GB storage models. My wife's brother has a 6S Plus. My mother has 7. They work amazingly well and fast. To them X / XS / XS Max are basically "spend 1300 EUR to get a bezel-less phone and nothing else"... and in a way, they are correct. Many people don't care about FaceID or OLED screens. Smartphone market is nearly saturated. It's time for more realistic pricing. And I am saying this is a loyal Apple user.
- interlocutor 8y ago> Smartphone market is nearly saturated. It's time for more realistic pricing. Just before Christmas I bought an iPhone 6S for $99 from AT&T. That’s a very realistic price for a very nice phone! Fine print: I had to pay $145 plus tax but $45 is credited to me for monthly charges. The phone is locked to AT&T for 3 months. After Christmas the price has gone back to $199.
- pdimitar 8y agoThat the 6S is going to be outside of software support window (1-2 years) and/or clearing stock might be factors. But I could have been clearer: I meant the newest models.
- interlocutor 8y agoAs an AAPL investor, I want Apple to raise prices for their top-of—the-line phones, otherwise the cheaper phones (like the one I purchased) will lower the average selling price. Of course people are not going to pay higher prices without getting something substantial in return. This is where Apple is lacking at the moment. The pace of innovation in both hardware and software has slowed down. There is plenty of room for improvement. EDIT Take a look at this video from Microsoft where they show how hover and squeeze gestures can dramatically improve the phone experience: https://www.theverge.com/2016/5/5/11595564/microsoft-3d-touch-kinect-gestures-windows-phones https://www.theverge.com/2016/5/5/11595564/microsoft-3d-touc... This shows there is plenty of room for innovation, Apple just isn't innovating fast enough.
- paul7986 8y agoSorry Apple I bought then returned the iPhone XS(happy with 8)... - No home button - no Touch ID... I can no longer quickly unlock phone with thumb .. Face ID is no good and can be dangerous in certain situations we all can relate but don’t admit (i.e. in stand stil traffic) - it’s too big.. I can’t one handed text Hoping some of the above is addressed and brought back in the 2019 models.
- Geee 8y agoApple used to be a status symbol but now it's a stupid symbol. I don't want to be ashamed that I spent too much money on something.
- exabrial 8y ago> we believe there are other factors broadly impacting our iPhone performance Here, Let me help you with that: * Lack of a $0.05 headphone jack * Lack of storage expansion * Lack of USB-C * Expensive 3d Touch that nobody uses intentionally * Lack of a fingerprint reader * Nerfing NFC for months on end Despite that, there are things you are doing great: * FaceID innovations * Battery life improvements * Performance improvements * Taking a stand against predatory spying by Facebook and Google It's like you're so close, then you shoot yourself in the foot.
- scarface74 8y agoI’m sure non of your cons are on the top of most people’s list. “Nerfing NFC” is probably right below “won’t run Flash”.
- jm4 8y agoI couldn’t care less about those features. I’ve never met anyone who says they would buy a new iPhone if only it had those features. The problem is the iPhone has been so good for a few iterations now. There is absolutely no reason to buy a new one unless you are gaming. I can’t tell the difference between the 7, the X or the XS in terms of day to day capability. It used to be there was a good reason to upgrade every year. Now you can easily go 2-3 years without missing much.
- pdimitar 8y agoIMO you are on point. As an X user I couldn't care less about the XS or XS Max (even though I do want a bigger screen since I read a lot) since they are small and iterative upgrades but people I know who switched from 6S / 7 to XS are very happy with their choice.
- oblomovshchina 8y agoI dumped my iPhone 7 this year for an Android. I would have upgraded if they still had headphone jacks. Bluetooth headphones are garbage: I have enough things to charge and I wear my headphones pretty much every waking hour of my life. Any contemporary android phone with a headphone jack seemed like a better value proposition than a current iPhone.
- mandeepj 8y agoApple should have bought Tesla a long time ago. Imagine, what would Model 3 have done to their bottom line now.
- creddit 8y agoProvided a significant headwind? Tesla financials don’t look great.
- mandeepj 8y agoAutopilot, Database of billion+ miles, awesome products in pipeline, given EV is the future, Tesla as Taxi network (the new business plan), the charging network, self driving cars means people will have more time to consume Apple's services, Apple music in Tesla's, Apple pay for transactions, Apple TV also in Tesla's or once level-5 driving is reached then front windshield can be converted to a TV, Wireless charging for these cars (http://www.ubeam.com/ http://www.ubeam.com/)
- suddenstutter 8y agoGood thing you're not a ceo.
- spacegod 8y agoNah this guy is right. Tesla has that product reality distortion field much like Apple has. Would've made a great purchase.
- droithomme 8y agoPerhaps the Mac Pro is truly dead.
- sjg007 8y agoI took advantage of the extra trade in cash.. That was a good deal.
- mandeepj 8y agoiPod > iPhone > iPad This product line was born organically within them. What you think Apple should do next? They have patented a headset so maybe that is next for them.
- thetruthseeker1 8y agoI think the additional value the newer iphone provides i.e face id and better screens doesn’t warrant the increased price tag. Ideally the price should also be falling like it did for PCs in the 90s.
- IkmoIkmo 8y agoWhat the hell is Greater China... Odd context to use as a company when better alternatives (that are less politically charged) are available. Very strange to see such an appeasement term being used.
- pooppaint 8y agoChina the SARs and Taiwan. It’s meant to be least politically charged since you refer to both Taiwan and mainland without, you know, without specifying which one is the more legitimate China.
- aphextron 8y agoI just totally de-Googled my life recently, and ended up almost entirely in the Apple ecosystem after evaluating my options. Switched to DDG full time for web search, Safari for browsing, iCloud for email, and Apple Maps is actually usable now with decent real time traffic. I never thought in a million years it would come to this, but the lines have clearly been drawn over the last two years. Apple has time and again come out emphatically in support of The User in a way that Google simply has not (or will not) step up to. It's quickly becoming their single largest competitive advantage in consumer web services.
- fmajid 8y agoThere's /e/ around the corner for a de-googlified Android experience. Sadly hardware support is limited at the moment.
- scns 8y agoLineageOS with microg supports loads of devices, more DIY though
- thegreatpeter 8y agoI second this. duckduckgo (ios / mac / gaming pc), firefox, apple maps have been awesome. Gmail has been hard to get away from though because of my account but I hope to take care of that soon.
- todd3834 8y agoWhile I haven’t de-Googled I do mostly stick to Apple products because of the quality and advantages of the ecosystem. I’m more interested in using the best product for what I want to do. While that is sure to be subjective it feels like Apple is the best to me. That being said, I’m not able to stick to DDG. Every time I do a search and I don’t find what I’m looking for on DDG I think, “I bet Google would have found it”. However when I’m on Google and I don’t find what I’m looking for I think, “I just didn’t write a good query”. That mental hurdle is hard to get over. Safari vs Chrome is another one where I choose Google. The web developer tools for the browser and the integration with Node/V8 seem so much better. If I were not a developer I imagine I could prefer Safari but it’s too hard to pretend when it’s what I do all day.
- dkrich 8y agoThe most common dig I continue to read about Apple’s strategy is that the phones are too expensive. But there’s little evidence from their earnings that this is the case. Today’s report reduced guidance by $6 billion and was fully attributed to lagging demand in China. All signs point to the new phones selling very well in the US and anecdotally I’ve noticed lots of my friends and family upgrading to the XS with no regard for the cost. These are not extremely wealthy or otherwise financially irresponsible people. Say what you will about lack of innovation (which I don’t agree with), but the constant skepticism about cost ignores what consumers actually do in the real world. China is probably not going to be a reliable market for Apple because as Ben Thompson points out, smartphones are much more of a commodity there because consumers don’t value Apple software as highly as consumers elsewhere. If that’s indeed the case there’s not much Apple can do about it because they sell the entire package at a high price point. If people don’t value the hardware and software it’s probably not a market that is going to be good for Apple. Apple wants no part of a race to the bottom commodity market where cost is the sole differentiator. It’s a tough pill to swallow but what we’re talking about is consumer preferences in different markets around the world. Apple should be worried about customers flocking to cross platform messaging apps in the US, though. Right now US consumers won’t part with Apple largely due to iMessage. What happens if people slowly transition to WhatsApp or FB messenger? I could see this as a real threat if FB continues to innovate in messaging.
- shmerl 8y agoApple is one of the worst companies when it comes to lock-in these days.
- gesman 8y agoCould someone add interesting insights to between-the-lines of Tim Cook message?
- j1vms 8y ago> "Apple innovates like no other company on earth, and we are not taking our foot off the gas." Apple has indeed accomplished many things since Jobs handed over the reins, but delivering a new, innovative compelling product line is not one of them. If they finally deliver on the Apple Car or some as yet unknown new product, they might finally fully move out of the shadow of Jobs' final tenure. If not, they will find their existing product lines eaten away by relentless, industry commoditization. Having to bump profit margins on the iPhone X was their first serious stumble -- only to be rectified, if they can deliver a new, compelling product line in the next 1 to 2 years.
- thomasjudge 8y agoAgree. And not to overstate the role of the CEO or to open up a can of worms about Steve Jobs, the fact is that Steve was a product guy and Tim is an operations guy. And not that creating innovative new products that will sell at worldwide scale is easy, but they haven't come up with one in a while.
- enraged_camel 8y ago>>Apple has indeed accomplished many things since Jobs handed over the reins, but delivering a new, innovative compelling product line is not one of them. What company has, though? My observation is that, while technology evolves very quickly, revolutionary product lines appear about once per generation. iPhones came out in 2007, so we have at least another decade to go.
- ketzo 8y agoI mean, I think that's false even among Apple! The iPod came out in, what, 2001? I think a lot of people then (and me, now) would have said that that was a genuinely revolutionary product.
- enraged_camel 8y agoI don’t see why the iPod was revolutionary. While it was a very popular product, and set a high bar for MP3 players, at the end of the day it was still just another MP3 player. It didn’t create entirely new ecosystems and allow people to do things they previously couldn’t, the way the iPhone did.
- torgian 8y agoI still use my 6s. I really want to upgrade, but the prices are just bonkers. I haven’t replaced the battery yet. I probably will this year. I’d rather just replace my battery for 60 bucks than buy a new phone for 800...
- ohazi 8y ago> While Greater China and other emerging markets accounted for the vast majority of the year-over-year iPhone revenue decline, in some developed markets, iPhone upgrades also were not as strong as we thought they would be. Translation: We tried to charge $1,500 for a phone, but not even our core demographic is this gullible.
- pjdemers 8y agoIf Apple creates a new phone with an ear phone jack, I will upgrade to that. Until then, I will keep my 6s until it stops working.
- ssawyer06 8y agoiPhone upgrades are slow because Moore’s Law is dead and, guess what... the new iPhones don’t offer significantly better performance per physical size. (And note that Moore’s Law being dead just means density doesn’t double on schedule. I am not suggestion there is zero progress in semiconductor technology.)
- gigatexal 8y agoBlaming China for slowing demand for its phones screams cop out. They jacked the prices for everything from the Mac to the iPad and the iPhone way too high and customers aren’t buying. Simple as that. I think they’re using China wales a scape goat.
- ggm 8y agoMarginal value of a new I(thing) over the prior generation is a significant barrier once it's good enough. There is no looming improvement in UI experience except probably bad ones like the failed 3D push in TV's. I won't pay a premium for a foldable screen or curly edge bezel-less experience right now and I suspect most consumers are feeling much the same entering a trade war focussed global economy. I've got better things to do with my disposable income now. Apple has a tonne of money. It can solve shareholder disappointment by using it to buy back stock or pay dividends or something. I don't look to Tim Cook for innovation right now. Declaration of Interest: disappointed touchbar MacBook owner
- ksec 8y ago450 Comments And no one has done any numbers. May be I am the few who are actually interested in this, I did these for fun during Xmas as Data from many analysts companies were made public. I wish I had post some of it before Apple revised their guidance. Oh well. Last Year they had $88.3B, this Year their lowest guidance were $89, so roughly the same. But Apple knew well ahead that they had new iPad, new MacBook Air, new Apple Watch for this quarter. They also changed their accounting to move revenue from Apple Maps and Siri to Services instead of bundled with their Products. So they knew Services were going to have a substantial increase. In other words, they knew their Non-iPhone revenue were going to increase YoY. They knew, nearly in real time their iPhone XS were doing well when launched, factored in the Q4 2018 quarter. That was what pushed the record Q4 quarter numbers, by those analytics over 30% of XS in total were sold during first two weeks, out of a total 14 weeks since launched. In other words, to have made that initial guidance, Apple were expecting Xr to be a great seller. Everything from Non-iPhone and XS has been better than expectation, it was only the Xr that let them down. Xs Max has been doing better than possibly Apple has estimated likely pushing ASP even higher ( even though they may no longer release the number ) So 5% lower revenue is actually better that most would have expected. All these leads to Xr. The Xr were targeting general buyers, but they were used to paying $749 for latest Smartphone, which the current $999/ $1099 are out of their bracket. Some have extended battery life that want their iPhone last longer. And more importantly in China, the price / performance gap between Chinese made Android Phone and Apple iPhone has never been greater. Huawei, Vivo, OnePlus and Mi. If we assume the the ASP increase were roughly 15% compared to last year, we can estimate this year Apple had ~25% drop in unit sold. ~57.7M Compared to last year 77.3M. Now more importantly, what will the guidance be for Apple on Q2? Edit: I think this is the best thing happen to Post Steve Jobs Apple and I hope Q2 will be even worst and served as a Wake up Call. In my opinion for the past years Apple has been doing something wrong with their design and features decisions that add cost while brings little to no value to users. Touch Bar, Curved inside Bezel display, Butterfly Keyboard etc. While trying to nickel and dime on many areas, lack of fast charging, new lighting cable connector ( lower cost but higher resistance ) etc. Apple under Tim Cook has been far to concern about 20% Net Margin and other numbers.
- kace91 8y agoYour comment paints a worse picture than I thought. Mostly because I think a great majority of potential customers are hoping apple will finally eat dirt, get the market's message and stop their new trends, but with those numbers in hand they might think that their mistake was selling the lower priced product and continue on their path on all other areas...
- sytelus 8y agoActually $1000 high quality smartphone isn’t quite unreasonable. You use your phone for at least 3 years so your daily expense comes out to less than $1. I’ve seen much more expensive things with much less utilization. Also note that phone is less of a phone and more of computer and camera that often fared better than many other $500 cameras.
- sleepychu 8y agoBut when you compare it to a phone 1/3 of the cost (e.g. my now 3 year old Moto 4G Plus) it's clear that for many people it's not going to offer 3x the value.
- turbinerneiter 8y agoWait, they have 38% profit margin? And 16% tax rate? Isn't that ridiculously high for the margin and kinda small for the rate?
- sanketskasar 8y agoMaybe the market response will lead to Apple pricing its products and services more reasonably instead of just making them outright expensive as compared to the competition.
- rbreve 8y agoGood time to short AAPL stock, will probably drop to 46$
- celerrimus 8y agoQuite funny. Mr. Tim Cook apparently either think investors are stupid or he, and the Apple board, are detached from the reality. For other people reasons for this is clear. Apple is making slightly improved phones, with the extreme price tag. The pain threshold has been exceeded. Almost all innovations now are from Asian manufacturers. Notch is not progress, it's a deffect. OLED? It was innovation 8 years ago, with Samsung Galaxy S. A phone as fragile as an egg, with back glass replacement costing $599 (versus $99 for Samsung Galaxy S9+). In my opinion, the only real advantage of iPhones is iOS, without apps slowing down OS, tons of bloatware, and lack of privacy even on the system level. But this not justify And lastly, batterygate, that weakened trust to the brand, also didn't help here.
- luxuryballs 8y agohonestly I think the notch may be slightly to blame too, even though it’s totally a non-issue and I actually like it, you need to really get your hands on the device before you realize that it’s great, I wonder how many average users aren’t interested in bothering with what they feel is too quirky or different to be worth the risk, and would rather stick with more familiar ground also thinking that if nobody had noticed the battery longevity performance degradation “feature” would Apple be sailing more smoothly right now? maybe they depended too much on crafty ways of trying to get people to upgrade and it didn’t pan out so here we are