18 ms·
Sweden's cashless society is no longer a utopia
- mamon 8y agoMore appropriate name would be "dystopia" because banning cash will have mostly adverse effects, intruducing nearly-totalitarian control over the citizens being the most important one.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- nhauz 8y agoIt's a utopia for big companies and governments, which are the ones paying for the op-eds that praise cashless societies.
- vertline3 8y agoThey could say your rating is not high enough, you are now cut off completely. Or they would know all spending so it would be a bit nosey. And then people would not spend on things causing money circulation to slow, but maybe that is offset a bit by ease of swiping a card.
- solarwind 8y agoIf you are a Canadian citizen who ever used a credit/debit card at a cannabis dispensary (or if you even just invested or worked for a Canadian dispensary), you are now permanently barred from entering the United States. A cashless society is a totalitarian society.
- berdario 8y agoIs this for real? How would the the DHS or another US entity know about payment transactions made on a canadian bank account? And, I realize that cannabis is not legal at the federal level in the US, but how would lawfully purchasing a cannabis product years ago disqualify you from entering the US?
- vetinari 8y agoI don't know about this specific case, but if you used a credit or debit card, it would be processed by Visa or Mastercard, which are both US companies, subject to US laws and regulations. That's how the US entities would know.
- Latteland 8y agoIt's for real and the idiotic border police in the us have started asking people about it. https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/smoke-pot-us-border-1.4718571 https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/smoke-pot-us-border-1.47185...
- jnurmine 8y agoSounds more like Canada needs something like Swish which does not share any payment/merchant data with the US. But isn't there something like that already for Canadians?
- emerongi 8y agoImplementation is key here. If a new method can be introduced which offers the same benefits of cash while being digital, open-source and on open hardware, I don't see a huge problem. Alas, such a solution would probably be extremely hard to create and therefore never will be.
- xc101 8y agoThese discussions are always closely observed by the fintech startup people.
- fernly 8y agoHmmm... quote, > The basic concept for e-krona is as follows: it would be digital, and have a 1-to-1 conversion with an ordinary krona held in an account at the Riksbank or stored locally, for example on a card or in a mobile phone app. > The technology to build a functioning e-krona is already available today. It is not dependent on using distributed ledger technology and it is not to be confused with cryptocurrencies. I'd like to know what this available technology is, that can create a digital object that guarantees a 1:1 correspondence to a physical asset, cannot be duplicated or multiple-spent. Has Sweden discovered the un-copy-able bit?
- msvan 8y agoHow about a database on a server owned by the Riksbank?
- Immortalin 8y agoBanks, Visa, PayPal, pretty much most in-game currencies, as long as your maintain control over the data storage and deny access to malicious actors there is no reason why a traditional DB system would not work.
- CydeWeys 8y agoCentral ledgers long predate blockchains and are widely used, i.e. by all banks. The only 'novelty' here is that it'd be run by the central bank and accessed directly by consumers.
- alkonaut 8y agoYou can get anonymous spending (the benefit of cash) only with a distributed ledger. A centralized ledger would just be regular debit cards but would bypass the banks/visa/mastercard. It offers the benefit of non-cash (no physical currency) but not the benefits of cash (anonymity). I hope we can get the benefit of both. My money stored on a card or gadget in my pocket instead of printed, but also chargeable through atms or internet banks so that the spending is anonymous.
- hannasanarion 8y agoWhy does there need to be a separate government issued digital currency? Presumably all of the private accounts that people are currently using are measured in Kr already, and the banks already operate at fractional reserve so the actual paper doesn't exist. As an American, I make about one cash purchase a year, but that doesn't mean that I'm not spending US Dollars. It seems to me that calling digital money "e-krona" will change exactly nothing but nomenclature.
- ersiees 8y agoIt changes the value fluctuations. Right now the biggest problem with using crypto as your day to day money is that you cannot trust the money that you put into crypto to stay at the same value over time + transactions are slow.
- hk__2 8y ago> Right now the biggest problem with using crypto as your day to day money is that you cannot trust the money that you put into crypto to stay at the same value over time Isn’t that a problem you have with any currency?
- SilasX 8y agoExisting, non-crypto currencies don’t have that problem, mainly because of inertia: so many people are using it that exchange rates don’t affect ordinary prices denominated in the currency. When a cryptocurrency has such adoption, the volatility problem will go away too.
- jonex 8y agoIt isn't just inertia, there's also decades to centuries of developments in currencies with stability being one of the core goals. There are also plenty of examples of the system failing when current best practices weren't followed, even when adoption has been high. The authorities behind the most popular crypto currencies today doesn't seem to be aiming for stability as a primary goal. The currencies would not be very meaningful as instruments for speculation if they were, which probably is the reason why stable cryptocurrencies aren't as popular.
- platz 8y agoheadline is a bit overblown compared to the conclusion of the text. > no longer a utopia was it ever? who ever claimed it was a "utopia"? main points: - If cash stops working, it would leave all individuals to rely on the private sector alone to get access to money and payment methods. * One option is to do nothing, meaning we accept that the general public no longer has access to central bank money. * A second alternative is to issue central bank money in a digital form, as a complement to cash and the money held in bank accounts. seems like they've been thinking about this for a while
- mostlydefinite 8y agoThere's an alternative to relying on the private sector, which is for cash to be replaced with credit notes. The Irish bank strikes of the early 70s is a nice case study of this happening [1]. I've recently been thinking about a potential solution to the reliance on private institutions in a cashless society. I guess the problem with a "mobile chequebook" or something of the sort is that you are always to some extent dependent on a private service (e.g. phone signal provider). [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irish_bank_strikes_(1966%E2%80%9376) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irish_bank_strikes_(1966%E2%80...
- CPLX 8y agoA society without cash is a society in which every person has no choice but to get the permission of someone they don’t know and will never meet each and every time they seek to obtain food, water, shelter, or transportation, and that permission can be revoked instantly, silently, and invisibly at any time.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- tjoff 8y agoI agree, but the main point of an e-krona is exactly to try and reduce that risk. One of the proposed goals is to have non-traceable transactions. Seems unrealistic to me but that would be the holy grail.
- zzzcpan 8y agoUntraceable anonymous transactions is the minimal requirement for it not to be harmful and dystopian.
- tjoff 8y agoI agree, but unfortunately I don't believe a society being run by humans would ever implement that. The leaders will not tolerate that kind of loss of control.
- ellius 8y agoIt also probably makes counterfeiting and fraud an enormous problem.
- sparkie 8y agoIt has already been implemented (Bitcoin, Monero etc), and is improving gradually. The control freaks who would not like to tolerate it think they'll be able to tame it, but Bitcoin is like the Hydra - it gets stronger with every unsuccessful attack attempt. It's better for them to bury their heads in the sand and pretend it doesn't exist in order to not bring attention to it. When they eventually lift their heads out of the sand they'll find that the world has moved on without them.
- jamesblonde 8y agoAs a resident of Sweden, i can only say that this is the future for all western countries. Life is just better without cash. We don't pay the mental tax of always ensuring i have dollar bills on me to tip left, right, and center. Your phone is enough to get you through the day. The govt is still run by the people for the people here, so most people aren't worried about totalitarianism. Most beggars now have signs with their phone number to swish them cash - because nobody has cash to give them (the other form of begging is collecting plastic bottles and cans with deposits).
- thomastjeffery 8y agoI think you are confusing "without cash" with "with digital payment methods". The vast majority of Americans rarely use cash, but that doesn't make it worthless to us.
- kungtotte 8y agoPeople who speak in absolute terms are always wrong. I always have cash on me and it's extremely common here, 60 kilometres outside Stockholm, for people to not only carry cash but to actively use it. A non-trivial amount of transactions in Sweden are still cash-based.
- tjoff 8y agoNo. It isn't worth it. Life isn't better, but privacy non-existent and society is ridiculously fragile from outtakes (this isn't even factoring in that the systems could be actively attacked). Yes it is the future, but we will be much worse for it. / Another swede.
- kstenerud 8y agoSo if your phone dies or is lost or stolen, how do you pay for food with no phone? How do you even buy a replacement phone if you have no phone to pay with?
- pishpash 8y agoIf you lose your wallet how do you pay for food with no wallet? This is a false line of argument.
- Blackstone4 8y agoHardly independent.... this is an advert for e-krona a crypto alternative to cash/electronic payments. Strawman.... title is built on a false premise that someone argued Sweden's cashless society was a utopia. Can't believe I clicked on this.
- o-o- 8y agoAdvert? E-krona doesn't exist. It's not in development, and there isn't even an architecture in place. The "advert" was written by the Deputy Governor of the Central Bank of Sweden.
- nolemurs 8y agoThis article is just fear-mongering and speculation. No facts are given to support the title, and the proposed solutions to the problem (which is never established) are vague to the point of meaninglessness. Skip the read.
- CaliforniaKarl 8y agoLast night, I stopped at an ATM on downtown Mountain View, to get some cash. I have my debit card loaded in Apple Pay, for the sole purpose of making my ATM visit faster. The ATM told me that my virtual card wasn’t acceptable to use to pull out cash; it advised me to use a debit card from my virtual wallet. Except, that’s what I was using. It was 8:30 PM, and I didn’t expect any prompt support from the bank. So, I used my physical debit card. I consider both real and virtual cards to be conveniences, but they’re definitely not replacements.
- kartan 8y ago> Swedish legislation makes it possible for retailers, restaurants and other companies to refuse to accept cash, for instance by putting up a sign at the entrance or by the till. Yes. It started as a curiosity and now this signs are everywhere. > By connecting a bank account in any bank with a mobile phone number, Swish has become a popular way to share a restaurant bill Yes. And to gather money for a friend's birthday or anything else. > Why Sweden's cashless society is no longer a utopia I see the potential risks of this situation. But the article does not bother to bring an analysis of them. One thing is already happening. The oldest part of the population have a hard time adapting to this situation. It's easier to take a bus and pay in cash than to have to buy an e-ticket in your phone. I would prefer to see such analysis than this e-krona nonsense.
- AnabeeKnox 8y ago"The oldest part of the population have a hard time adapting to this situation" Also immigrants, non-Swedes and vulnerable people in society have a hard time. But the white people find the cashless society works well for them I suppose.
- gambiting 8y ago>>But the white people find the cashless society works well for them I suppose That's an extremely odd comment to make. What does being white have anything to do with this? There's loads of white immigrants in Sweden, they suffer from this exactly the same as everyone else.
- ccernedswede 8y agoTheir post history is full of racial comments and should be flagged/investigated - potential concern trolling going on.
- Latteland 8y agoThe comment is probably sarcastically referring to white privilege. So the wealthy people who this works for (have money, a bank account, aren't living on the street, not a visitor or an immigrant) in Sweden are the equivalent of 'white privileged people' in the us, even though I don't think of Sweden as a racist state (but I don't know much about that there). To explain a little more, in the US, you are far less likely to be charged with a crime, shot, etc if you are a white person vs a black person in the same situation. This is highly controversial, with many people denying it and wanting to argue against this idea, but the easy evidence is like this: Did you ever get stopped in a car by the cops and asked get out while they frisked you, looked for trouble, etc? Never happened to me in half a century of life, but it's happened to even a black us senator multiple times.
- upofadown 8y agoThe article failed to give any real detail about what is being proposed. I suspect it would have to be something like Taler[1] where the buyer is anonymous but the seller is not. That allows the collection of sales taxes and allows the government some control over the currency. [1] https://taler.net/en/index.html https://taler.net/en/index.html
- greglindahl 8y agoNote that the article is about Sweden, which has a VAT, not a sales tax. One great property of VATs is that they encourage reporting.
- ploggingdev 8y agoNo mention about the privacy implications of having every transaction tracked? We're already at a point where pretty much every transaction is tracked and a cashless society makes being tracked a requirement to function in society. Is privacy even a topic of discussion with governments looking to go cashless? I still try and pay with cash wherever possible, but many offline/physical stores often require a phone number or email address to complete a transaction, so privacy goes out of the window even when using cash.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- cududa 8y agoIt’s not a requirement. You don’t have to tell them.
- pixl97 8y agoFew actually require that information. Just say no thanks, and they continue without it.
- karmenblack 8y agoMaybe they already have it...
- avaika 8y agoGood point. There is a rumor among my local IT fellows, that some banks who also run an insurance companies (or partner with some) share transaction information with insurance guys to help them identify whether discount is possible for a specific person or not. E.g. if someone frequently spends a lot of money in pubs, most likely that someone will have health issues sooner or later. So better to increase the insurance fee. For sure such information trading is illegal, but as the government doesn't give a single care, most likely it is true.
- clubm8 8y ago>There is a rumor among my local IT fellows, that some banks who also run an insurance companies (or partner with some) share transaction information with insurance guys to help them identify whether discount is possible for a specific person or not. E.g. if someone frequently spends a lot of money in pubs, most likely that someone will have health issues sooner or later. Or worse, what if they decide you had too much pub spending/fast food, so you can't get that new organ you need? I keep my "entertainment" budget (pubs, eating out, etc) in cash for this reason.
- _cs2017_ 8y agoDo dope dealers and brothels accept Apple Pay, or do people somehow get US dollar cash for those expenses?
- samontar 8y agoI imagine you Venmo or equivalent like you do in America.
- tokai 8y agoI have heard about pushers using mobile payment services. Some even advertise their business on facebook.
- oxide 8y agoI've never heard of a street level dealer in the US take anything but cash to my knowledge. If you do, you're a good dealer and probably an outlier. Also, the further you go up the chain of command the less likely you'd be to run into someone accepting these types of payments as well. I.e. the middleman might let you Zelle him the money, but he is probably paying with physical currency on your behalf to the actual dealer. The dealer might do the same, but the supplier is being paid with physical currency. The dealer supplier allows it, but his suppliers are accepting cash only. Etc. Meanwhile you can use BTC to have those same drugs shipped to your door, through an onion based marketplace or whatever, or even the clearnet if you arent buying specifically controlled substances.
- zmk_ 8y agoThe article makes Sweden into something it is not. First, Swedes are not as eager to adapt new technologies as it may seem from the text. Case in point, NFC is just arriving in the country and in one of the main grocery shops, that has its own bank as well, you can only use store cards this way. A small subset of cards are also still swipe-only. In all honesty, Poland seems like a better example of this as it is effectively the sandbox of Europe for consumer finance. Second, this trend is visible in many countries in Europe. In my 7 years in the Netherlands before I moved to Sweden, it would be unusual for me to have any cash on me and in recent years the number of 'pin' (card) only points of sale there has been growing tremendously.
- alkonaut 8y agoNFC terminals are growing at the same rate as NFC cards, but cards have a pretty long lifespan so my old debit card which is ~5 years old is still chip and pin, while my new credit card from the same bank is both chip+NFC. I’m not going to go through the hassle (a few clicks) of replacing my card just to get NFC. The same goes for retailers, terminals get NFC on the next replacement.
- zmk_ 8y agoMost of the terminals I see are NFC ready, but NFC payments are not enabled. In particular, ICA has Yomani terminals and does not accept cards not issued by them. In other countries NFC has been introduced years ago. In the Netherlands, most of the cards were replaced in 2013 and the full rollout of the tech was in 2014. The fact that a card is valid for longer does not mean that it cannot be replaced beforehand.
- beefman 8y agoThe article says circulating cash is 1% of GDP and falling. In the US, it is 8% and rising (with a high of 12% in 1946 and a low of 4% in the early 1980s) https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=lZye https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=lZye Edit: See also this table https://www.bis.org/publ/qtrpdf/r_qt1803/images/tab6-A.jpg https://www.bis.org/publ/qtrpdf/r_qt1803/images/tab6-A.jpg (from https://www.bis.org/publ/qtrpdf/r_qt1803g.htm https://www.bis.org/publ/qtrpdf/r_qt1803g.htm )
- kristofferR 8y agoI'm a Norwegian who went to a Swedish music festival last summer. I couldn't pay for a lot of things there, since the booths only accepted Swish (the only relevant Swedish mobile payment solution, it's a de facto monopoly). I couldn't sign up and use Swish on my phone, since it only accepts Swedish bank accounts. I couldn't borrow money from my Swedish friends either, since they didn't have cash (and it mostly wasn't accepted at the festival anyway). When I could get someone to pay for me directly, transferring the money back to them was hard (since the festival didn't have any ATMs), so I had to go through the whole burdensome SWIFT procedure with getting their bank account number, their full name and address, their bank info, IBAN number of their bank etc, so I could send the money back when I got home to Norway. Utopia my ass.
- xrd 8y agoI'm curious, would your colleagues consider using bitcoin or ethereum as a method of exchange? Could you send them that to pay them back and they could pay on your behalf? If not, why? edit: auto complete filled in butcoin, corrected. Not sure how that got in my dictionary!
- TheSpiceIsLife 8y agoIs that more convenient than a bank transfer? Now the other party needs to sign up to a bitcoin exchange.
- xrd 8y agoI'd say absolutely. I don't know of a bank where I can set up an account completely online through an app, which you can do with cex.io or coinbase. It's gotten harder but generally you create an account and then upload your ID and then can buy very soon afterwards. That makes it tenable in my opinion to ask even the most Luddite of friends to do it before the event and then pay people back that way.
- icebraining 8y agoI don't know of a bank where I can set up an account completely online through an app In my EU country, there are already six banks that let you do this, and I doubt we're pioneers.
- corodra 8y agoI can’t find the article, but didn’t another Nordic country, where they’re going cashless already find a flaw? Their communication infrastructure had some sort of disruption, I don’t think it was an attack, but a failure of something for like half a day. Because of that, merchant services were screwed. Few people could buy anything since few carried cash. Don’t get me wrong, I barely carry cash on me. I just have a bit in a safe. But I recognize the vulnerability. Natural disaster. Black out due to a node failure or two. An actual attack on the merchant services infrastructure or bank. Sure, cash can be stolen. But so can digital funds and you’re not limited to how much you can fit in a bag and carry. It’s also funny how folks complain about privacy and not wanting private entities to have their nose in their personal lives and track what they do. Especially those Vikings whine about that regularly. Yet they trust how much data with merchant service companies?
- espadrine 8y agoThere is a practical benefit of locality in traditional distributed systems that may get lost with companies centralizing their operations for economies of scale. If your bank is local, as is your merchant's, you could design the payment network in such a way that, if your region is cut off from the rest of the Internet, local communication can still allow payment authorizations to go through.
- isodude 8y agoThis has happened with Swish a couple of times. It's no different than a VISA or MasterCard debit though. It's a good case for e-krona which I'm looking forward too.
- antt 8y agoBack in the old country we had a dozen currencies, gold and jewels hidden in a fake brick for that exact reason. When you need to buy a train ticket to get away from the Germans or Russians you don't want to be asking "Sorry do you accept AmEx?".
- corodra 8y agoI grew up that if the Russians or Germans are coming, you’re going to use vodka as a currency.
- nabla9 8y agoThis is huge systemic risk (the possibility that an event at the company level could trigger severe instability or collapse an entire industry or economy). When the systems in major Nordic bank (Nordea, Danske Bank) or payment system (Visa, MasterCard) goes down, people can't do anything until it's fixed. These things are rare but they happen. Usually it's just few hours, but if the condition persists even few days it becomes a major problem. Mobile payment and cards are nice, but cash is good backup system.
- o-o- 8y ago> if the condition persists even few days it becomes a major problem How much cash does a person keep handy? If the condition persists a few days, cash would also become a major problem.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoSuch as when the Irish banks went on strike for about 6 months in the 70s. Edit: It was a lockout not a strike. They survived using olde worlde approaches with no loss of GDP growth or retail sales. The retailers and local pubs operated as banks and managed the movement of IOU credits and cheques. Publicans, as it turned out, were a pretty good gauge of credit-worthiness and extent. Cheques ended up counter signed dozens of times as they were passed on person to person many times. Retailers would offer cheque cashing to keep money circulating. http://uk.businessinsider.com/pubs-replaced-banks-in-ireland-in-1970-and-the-economy-was-fine-2016-1 http://uk.businessinsider.com/pubs-replaced-banks-in-ireland... Now try that with an app. :)
- Gatsky 8y agoFascinating and an excellent point, thanks.
- Evidlo 8y agoAt least you can still pay and be payed. Sure you lose access to the bulk of your savings, but there can still be economy.
- tqwhite 8y agoMisleading title alert!!! It says nothing about it's being a utopia or having stopped being one. It is an interesting article about the eventuality of a truly cash-free society and its consequences. Only the title is stupid.
- Numberwang 8y agoThe title matches the comments here in stupidity.
- dharma1 8y agoI’m surprised central banks haven’t become involved in digital currency before. I guess software isn’t their core competence. I guess if anyone can pull it off the swedes will. And I don’t think they are offering a replacement to physical cash here - just an alternative
- AnabeeKnox 8y agoRacism! Stong word, but this is what the Swedish cashless society is: indirect racism. Those at the margins of society are excluded from participating in society because they don't have Swedish bank accounts or Swedish credit cards. Many clubs and pubs require that to enter. Indirectly, this means that non-Swedish (non-white) people don't get into the club. Not direct racism, but indirect (the outcome is the same, no white people allowed entry, or to participate in society).
- PeterisP 8y agoWhat's stopping non-white immigrants (presumably residents of Sweden staying there for a nontrivial time) from getting a Swedish bank account? If there are significant barriers to that then the "getting into a club issue" is a trifle compared to the broader participation in society. E.g. how are they getting paid for their work if almost no legal employers will pay salaries in cash?
- alkonaut 8y agoI think it may be a misconception from someone from e.g the US where there is a threshold for getting a bank account.
- PeterisP 8y agoYeah, around here any old homeless alcoholic would have a bank account, because that's the only way how they'd get social security payments, and also any student (or working teenager) would have a bank account, because that's the only way how they'd get paid for a summer job or internship or study loan or whatever. A bank account is a basic thing that's required (at least in come countries) for any participation in the economy and should be available to anyone; IIRC there's an EU directive about a requirement that everybody must be able to access basic banking services.
- antocv 8y agoThere is many borders, not just getting into Sweden, one of them is getting bank account, the other is getting a BankID, the third border is getting Swish, for example. For each, there is criteria and different requirements, and costs. For me, I refuse to run non-free software on my computing devices, Swish is a non-free proprietary spy-ware. Just because of this decision, I am excluded and made feel like an outcast at social events where money is involved - such as splitting a bill at restaurant. Yet Im white, so I can politely tell my white friends to suck my dick if they refuse the cash I hand them. For an non-white immigrant, telling other people to suck it is not so easy.
- kqr2 8y agoHow do tourists deal with Sweden? Can you get a temporary Swish account?
- yxhuvud 8y agoThey better have VISA or Mastercard - those have even better coverage than Swish.
- jbogard 8y agoJust fine. I haven’t carried cash in Scandinavia, or Europe, for years now. It’s really not any big deal, just use your check card like you would in the states. In fact, it’s easier now. Before chip and now contactless was ubiquitous like it is now, I got all the krone mixed up. Traveling back and forth from Copenhagen and Malmo with cash was the worst. Couldn’t tell the difference but the locals absolutely could!
- vinniejames 8y agoWhy couldn't you send your friends crypto currency?
- PeterisP 8y agoFor the vast majority of people it would be a major inconvenience, requiring non-trivial time and effort to set up everything required to receive the equivalent of, say, $10 in crypto converted to the local currency in their bank account, which is the only place when it starts being usable money to them.
- badrabbit 8y agoThis is a major societal change. I for one believe there needs to be a tangible method of payment where a 3rd party is not requried for transactions. I don't care if it's cash or some digital payment coin/card. The point is,people nees to be able to transact without a 3rd party and be able to buy physical tokens(as opposed to wire transfers and digital tokens). People are too careless when changing fundamental aspects of their society. Payments can be made convenient,peer to peer and have a small amount of participation barriers.
- eric_h 8y agoI like physical cash. I don’t always use it, and generally use my points earning credit card at places I frequent, but don’t at places I’m new to or have no intention of returning to (unless I don’t have enough cash on me). The number of times my card has been stolen has entered into the 10s, even in our new chip card era (I’ve had three chip cards compromised, but can only definitively attribute one of those to it having been stolen after typing it into a website. i.e. no chip involved). Apple Pay and its ilk are a step in the right direction (and convenient because they still work when the physical card is cancelled), but still traceable and beholden to additional parties. If I’m somewhere where I think the transaction might be sketchy, I can pay cash and not think about it any further. Skimming, however, is still a thing and every time my card is stolen it causes me an inconvenience that would not exist if I’d used cash. “Bitcoin/cryptocurrency will fix this!” some of you will say. Perhaps, but it’s got a long way to go. All the USD I have in my pocket still says “this note is legal for all debts, public and private”, I don’t personally think a sign saying “we are cashless” at the cash register after I’ve ordered my food is acceptable (those establishments I’ve encountered didn’t accept bitcoin, either). I acknowledge what it says on usd currency is somewhat tangential to a Swedish cashless society, but I still think cash should be king, or at least always accepted.
- akvadrako 8y agoChips use a private key to sign transactions and can't be copied, at least without being taken apart. So they are secure if all merchants require digital signatures. But for credit cards, they don't do anything to prevent your number from being stolen.
- olivermarks 8y agoCash is king.
- lanevorockz 8y agoIt would only be acceptable if the cashless society supported both anonymity. It's the only way to avoid discrimination and enforce fairness.
- cordite 8y agoIsn't china's cashless move bearing similar problems?
- newintellectual 8y agoSweden was never a "utopia".
- z3t4 8y agoWith physical money there is wear and tear, but every time a "digital" bill change hands 1-5% of it's monetary value is lost (transferred to someone else pocket).
- akvadrako 8y agoThat's only true with some digital transactions. In Europe most merchants that only accept local cards pay 0.3% or about 25 cents.
- karmenblack 8y agoThen they can delete your money if they find you don't like socialism.
- qwerty456127 8y agoCashless society is not an utopia, it's an antiutopia. Every penny you pay or receive cashless (unless it's some sort of privacy-centric crypto) is monitored.
- alkonaut 8y agoThe e-krona will most certainly need to be a decentralized ledger or I don’t see the point at all. For centralized (I.e monitored) transactions the systems we already have are good enough.
- WheelsAtLarge 8y agoMy problem with cashless and just about everything electronic tech is: What happens when the network/power fails? What's the goto alternative? No one seems to point that out? It should not stop progress but it's important to make contingency plans in case of mass failure. I wonder if salt as money will be fashionable again? :)
- mr_toad 8y agoIf we ever have some sort of apocalypse, I’m guessing that the popular barter commodities will reflect society’s vices: cigarettes, alcohol, coffee, sugar and porn.
- WheelsAtLarge 8y agoPorn as money? Never thought of that. Makes we wonder about the possibilities. Would porn stars be the bankers? Who would be the fed chair? Imagine the how full the economic courses would become.
- NateEag 8y agoSince most porn is produced and consumed digitally (I assume - it's not something I pay attention to), in an apocalypse I doubt it would be a viable commodity. Any apocalypse worth its salt takes down the grid. Prostitution would likely increase, though. I'll add salt to your list as well.
- SiempreViernes 8y agoPeople do point it out, and mostly the solution has been to just increase reliability of the systems. Recently the town of Växjö had a almost complete power outage, but despite the store being on emergency lighting only, the payment terminals still worked.
- o-o- 8y agoGood point. A solution must afford P2P transactions without a relaying party, and the devices used must be low-power and possible to charge using solar energy or hand power.
- DINKDINK 8y agoRelated reading: "If plastic replaces cash, much that is good will be lost – Brett Scott | Aeon Essays" https://aeon.co/essays/if-plastic-replaces-cash-much-that-is-good-will-be-lost https://aeon.co/essays/if-plastic-replaces-cash-much-that-is...
- flurdy 8y agoThe propriety solutions and its near monopoly in both Sweden & Norway (and perhaps other countries) are also due to the slow expansion and adoption of Apple Pay and Google/Android Pay into those countries. Apple Pay was only launched in Norway earlier this year and Google Pay only a few weeks ago. So the propriety solutions have had a lot of time to establish their monopoly. Also, Apple/Google pay uses the Visa/Mastercard/Amex networks whilst 8 out of 10 of all card transactions in Norway is via BankAxept. BankAxept payments are near instant and has a very low transaction fee. A flat fee of 24 øre (0.03 USD) which most of the time a lot less than Visa/Mastercard that charge 1-2%. You will find a lot of independent merchants in Norway, e.g. corner shops that won't accept Visa & Mastercard, but only accept BankAxept. This is also why Apple Pay only works in a few places, compared to the UK where I live where Apple Pay is accepted nearly everywhere. [1] https://www.norgedaily.com/google-pay-launched-norway/ https://www.norgedaily.com/google-pay-launched-norway/ [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BankAxept https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BankAxept [3] https://no.mobiletransaction.org/bankaxept/ https://no.mobiletransaction.org/bankaxept/
- AnssiH 8y ago> Also, Apple/Google pay uses the Visa/Mastercard/Amex networks whilst 8 out of 10 of all card transactions in Norway is via BankAxept. BankAxept payments are near instant and has a very low transaction fee. A flat fee of 24 øre (0.03 USD) which most of the time a lot less than Visa/Mastercard that charge of 1-2%. For comparison, in Finland, where debit cards are all VISA and Mastercard, the merchant rate for those cards is usually ~0.3% (with Nets capping it at 0.75€). Non-EU cards have higher fees. (Finnish source e.g. https://www.yrittajat.fi/uutiset/572780-maksupaatteet-hintavertailussa-izettle-nets-vai-verifone https://www.yrittajat.fi/uutiset/572780-maksupaatteet-hintav...)
- toxik 8y agoCall me crazy but letting Apple and Google do what VISA and MasterCard do hardly seems like a win. In fact it seems like a huge loss, especially for Google — cc tx info would be real juicy stuff for their algos.
- coldtea 8y agoYay, state surveillance of every transaction....
- trophycase 8y agoCash is integral to financial privacy in the current world. Very sad trend to see.
- StanislavPetrov 8y agoOne thing I haven't seen mentioned which is of particular concern given recent developments is that if society is cashless, what if the bank or "swish" or whatever private company is running cashless transactions decides to "deplatform" you because they don't like your political opinions (or the color of your tie, or anything else). Its one thing for a social media site to erase someone's online presence, or a hosting company to prevent you from having a web presence, or even Paypal preventing you from getting electronic payments through there service - because your life doesn't depend on it. If 'swish' decides it no longer wants your business, how do you survive? How do you buy food? How do you pay the rent? Aside from the Orwellian privacy/tracking implications (by both governments and corporations), the massive transfer of power to electronic transaction corporations is frightening.
- AngryAnt 8y agoThis is exactly the "no longer utopia" part of the article (or the extreme end of it anyway). With private systems, this is a real possibility.
- bearcobra 8y agoI recently took a road trip across North America, and was a little surprised by the number of cash only transactions I faced. Toll roads in particular were a big pain. It's kind of crazy that we don't support both methods in a reasonable way
- jonathangrahl 8y agoWho ever said it was a "utopia" with a cashless society?
- the_clarence 8y agoLondon is pretty much cashless, everybody uses Monzo fot everything.
- buboard 8y agoNot utopia, dystopia
- cf498 8y agoI was really shocked when i experienced the same issue in the Netherlands. I went there for a conference and only had to go straight to Amsterdam central, to science park and to my hotel in almere central. I had to exit Amsterdam central station by scanning in the QR code of my paper ticket. The alarm at that station was ringing constantly because of all the foreign tourists who had no idea what to do. Outside I had to go to the foreign help desk which was nice enough to give me some kind of tourist paper ticket, which i do have to say, i have no idea how it worked. Hopefully it was a rfid chip in the ticket, otherwise i triggered every last scanner by just pushing it on top and walked out. And every last person was heavily annoyed by all the retarded tourists. It did not help, that apparently the Netherlands do not bother to put up English signs. I luckily could pay in cash for the toilet in central station, but that was really it when it comes to cash. I luckily could use my VISA for a train station locker, but i could not buy a bottle of water, as the machine at main station only took some kind of wireless card. The same applied to every supermarket but one near my hotel. I stood in 3 ordinary supermarkets and wanted to buy a simple bottle of water. Thankfully one of the cashiers in the supermarket at science park was nice enough to pay for a bottle of water for me in exchange for cash. How every nice the Netherlands are, it is a modern Dystopia.
- phiresky 8y ago> The same applied to every supermarket but one near my hotel. I've been able to pay everywhere I've been to in the Netherlands with a normal European debit card with chip + pin (Maestro I think)
- cf498 8y agoI gave them my Visa and V-Pay card, and only one of the patrol stations took it. Everyone else willing to take my non Netherland card were places who would also take cash, like mcdonalds. There seemed to have been a certain kind of regional card which i did not have. edit: dont take me wrong, i should have looked up the local payment procedure before going there, I was just extremely surprised as this happened to me directly across the border inside the EU.
- zakum1 8y agoThe article avoids mentioning the most important issue around central bank issued digital currencies: Currently my electronic cash balance represents a deposit at a commercial bank. On the other hand, when I hold physical cash, it is a direct obligation between the central bank and I. As mentioned in the article, 90% of cash balances are electronic money held at Commercia banks. With a central bank issued e-krona, there is no role for commercial bank deposits, the e-krona is a direct obligation between the central bank and individuals/companies. This means that commercial banks have very different balance sheets to use for lending. It fundamentally changes the financial system and creates very different payment and lending opportunities. Initially the central bank may only issue <10% as e-krona to avoid this impact, but it makes little sense not to follow through to making e-krona the only form of cash.
- fouc 8y agoEveryone. Imagine you don't have a smartphone, or a bank account, or credit cards, or debit cards. Can you survive? Can you pay for your housing, food, entertainment?
- Proven 8y agoWhat utopia? It's been a nightmare in making. Total lack of privacy and financial fascism by fiat.
- dumbfoundded 8y agoI'll repost an old comment of mine: "The scariest part to me about cryptocurrency is not the greed, lies and manipulation. It's a centralized cryptocurrency by a major government. Imagine if instead of cash, you had to pay for everything with a digital currency controlled by the US Govt. It'd be all the immutability of cryptocurrency with the monetary policy of the Fed Reserve. I'd bet the IRS and NSA would love the additional data."
- variable11 8y agoIf I was the Russians, I absolutely would have a cyber battle plan ready to bring the entire Swedish economy to its knees by attacking this single point of vulnerability, swish.
- zingar 8y agoIt's weird to me that their version of cashless doesn't work for foreigners. Every vendor in South Africa takes Mastercard or Visa, or a mobile payment system backed by a credit card. It's not strongly linked to a local bank account. Not a cashless society, but the transition would be pretty smooth for me. When I travel to Europe, UK, Australia I have the same experience (maybe not quite the same ease of mobile payment). The only reason I'm not cashless here is cash tipping, 99% to homeless people or very poor sales people on the side of the road. For weeks now I've been getting frustrated with myself for not having any cash in my wallet and having to disappoint people, although at the same time grateful for the ease of not dealing with cash.
- eric24234 8y agoSimilar thing in india is happening with a single monopoly player paytm.
- throwaway487548 8y agoThis is a common pattern - a bunch of disconnected from reality (literally, inside academical enclaves and mentally, living in a world of pure abstractions and ideas) pundits are advocating to destroy (or "reform") a vastly complex systems they do not fully comprehend, leave alone understood. Their abstract memes spread like viruses through naive minds of unthinking (or at least not thinking critically) people, and eventually society become literally sick with this or that nonsense. This very pattern was behind marxism and all its tragic consequences. Exactly this pattern. If you like a more recent example - look no farther than the crypto buble, based solely on memes and nothing but memes (well, very clever memes, indeed). Cash plays a fundamental role in any society - it is means of anonymous, untraceable, quick payments. Any healthy economy needs this kind of transactions. It is literally what we mean by "liquidity" - like a flow of red blood cells through the whole system. Do not mess with it. The pundits would argue that cash payments could be abused. Well, kitchen knives (even forks!) could be abused too. Shall we advocate a kitchenless society? Other countries have tried to mess with cash (India recently - thank god they kept small notes in circulation) and the result was disastrous. Again, some disconnected from reality abstract ideas were used to justify the move. What I am trying to say, is that this is the common cancer and the name of it is Liberal Arts "education", "humanities" and "academia". These people should not be allowed to govern because their minds are distorted with nonsense they have "studied" (memorized). Think of marxists or hegelians or platonists. Sweden, unfortunately, has been ruled by platonists and hegelians, if not marxists, for last few decades. The results are... well, read the news.
- MrTonyD 8y agoWe need control over those who control our credit. As I read this article I've just arrived in London - my 4th trip here in as many months. And CapitalOne has started declining my charges again - even though I'm staying at the same hotel with the exact same charges as always. I have about $20,000 in credit with a zero balance, but that doesn't seem to matter either. I tried calling them before the trip - and was told that they don't need advance notice of trips. (I guess their fraud protection is so good - they just stop accepting charges.) And of course they only accept calls to resolve the issue - and on these international trips I usually don't have easy access to a phone. We are essentially prisoners of these credit card companies.
- kingofhdds 8y agoSo, one can't spend a single penny there without being monitored, but let's instead talk how web cookies are cruel privacy invasion.
- zeroname 8y agoSweden is a failed state. Change my mind.
- robben1234 8y agoAs strong as I hate dealing with cash, it can't be dismissed in current society. In many places you don't want to use card as it's sketchy, in many places you don't want to have a log in your bank account (like going to a bar midday on a Tuesday). Not to mention a classic meaning of cash, or just money: you get things for it. If you are getting robbed one thing is to give $40 because that's all you had in the wallet and completely other getting robbed for all money in your account. That's just one scenario. I'm not sure I would want to live in a society without cash.