19 ms·
Housing can’t both be a good investment and be affordable
- austincheney 8y agoHousing in the Bay Area is stupid expensive. I bought my 2900sqft 9 years ago for $129000 and it’s now worth about double. This is a bit better than average for my city. My city is one of the 15 largest in the US. Edit: I don’t live in CA.
- tootie 8y agoDouble in 9 years is like 8% annually which is roughly equivalent to putting it in index funds.
- hkmurakami 8y agoDifference is the built in tax advantages in RE.
- cinquemb 8y agoSo put the multiplier adjusted cash on long positions on index futures and set it to roll contracts over from the front month x time before expiry?
- chongli 8y agoI don't know about you, but my index funds are purchased through contributions to my tax-free savings account. I can contribute up to $5500 per year and I pay no taxes whatsoever on any capital gains from the equities in the account.
- TomVDB 8y agoWhat do you do after you reach the $5500 contribution limit? For many here, that's probably before the calendar turns to February. You diversify. And real estate may not provide the greatest returns in many circumstances, but it is a diversification, and it has some excellent tax benefits.
- cinquemb 8y agoif RE market craps out around the time the stock market craps out, its not much diversification in the face of downside risks…
- TomVDB 8y agoIf. You can’t protect yourself against a global calamity where everything suddenly correlates. But look at what happened during the crash of 2000 where stocks and housing market went opposite ways for a nice example to the contrary.
- cinquemb 8y agoAh yes, and then less than a decade later, if you were lucky enough to still be paying off your multi-decade mortgage, they went down together and those ill-liquid paper gains were wiped out and then some (along with people loosing "their" homes, or now paying a mortgage on house whose value had declined). With our global debt fueled recovery, if turns out be when. Being in cash, short the market, or UST's would have been better.
- TomVDB 8y agoNobody ever said that the RE and the stock market are always decorrelated. But it's undeniable that they sometimes are decorrelated. That makes the RE market a way to diversify your investments. Nothing more, nothing less. There's no silver bullet that will protect you under all circumstances. IOW: I have no idea what kind of point you're trying to make.
- cinquemb 8y agoMy point is that, sure, RE market is a way to diversify ones investments, but it is no longer a good way like everyone has blindly assumed it is because of the underlying conditions influencing risk assets in markets. If people think de-correlated upside, and correlated long tail downside is a suitable portfolio strategy, then I can't help but take the other-side of that trade… enjoy the slight premium while it lasts, because I'll take it back and then some when it blows up in your face.
- austincheney 8y agoTrue, but with owning the property I have equity in addition to the value increase. Where I live monthly leases tend to be more expensive than what I pay per month for mortgage and taxes which would also be a loss. That said there is money to be made mortgaging residential real estate and leasing it out. The only loss to ownership is that you are less portable. It takes more time and money to relocate.
- ipython 8y agoYou're forgetting that most people don't purchase their house in cash. OP received the gain on the value of the house, which is much higher than the actual cash outlay as the down payment. Feel free to ask your stock broker to purchase $125k worth of stocks for only $12.5k cash. (obviously ignoring all selling costs, realtor fees, stamp/transfer taxes, interest payments, etc.)
- nostrademons 8y agoIf you're going to count leverage in real estate returns, the equivalent comparison is margin in stock market returns. You absolutely can purchase $125K in stocks for $12.5K cash if you're willing to buy them on margin (subject to margin requirements, which are often 50% for retail brokerages but can be as low as 3% for hedge funds etc.) Mortgage and margin loan interest rates are even comparable. The reason people don't buy stocks on margin is because there is risk entailed: if the stock goes down, you can get a margin call, get your whole position liquidated, and lose everything. There is an analogous event for mortgages: if you fail to make your mortgage payment, the bank takes possession, liquidates your investment, and you lose everything. This risk is often glossed over with mortgages because it's a socially-acceptable way to purchase a house, but it's still there. Many people who did precisely this in 2004-2007 faced exactly this consequence in 2009-2010, and are still digging out from the wreckage of ruined credit, lost downpayments, and a home that was repossessed.
- herpderperator 8y ago> You absolutely can purchase $125K in stocks for $12.5K cash [...] This isn't quite right. You can only get 2x leverage on your margin account for overnight holds (i.e. long-term investment.) The maximum leverage federally allowed is 4x, and you have to liquidate half before the end of the trading day (to go back to 2x) otherwise your broker will automatically liquidate half of your position. http://www.finra.org/investors/day-trading-margin-requirements-know-rules http://www.finra.org/investors/day-trading-margin-requiremen...
- mortehu 8y ago
- cobookman 8y agoBut you only put 20% down. Let's say your 100k house is now 200k. Your initial down payment is 20k. When you sell your getting much more than 8% compound interest
- austincheney 8y agoThere are 0 down loans.
- autokad 8y agothey also ignore the fact you are saving in rent, and you can also rent out your spare rooms (I did). My house was and still is very affordable and it was one of the best investments I have done. they are not mutually exclusive objectives once you consider everything.
- tootie 8y agoYou're also paying mortgage interest, taxes and maintenance costs. The formula isn't straightforward but owning a home is rarely a better strategy than renting and buying stocks.
- autokad 8y agoHomes appreciate on average 3-5%, where as the money saved on rent - taxes, interest, and maintenance is somewhere between 3-5%. that's 6-10% (which is about the best you can expect from stocks over the long run)+ the other benefits of owning a home. I for one rented 2/3 of my rooms for an additional 12k$/year income (60k over 5 years).
- usaar333 8y agoWell, historically, but not in the past 9 years. Last 9 years S&P 500 return is ~13.9%. Both housing and market returns have been abnormally high.
- schrodinger 8y agoS&p 500 is also worth about double what it was 9 years ago…
- sopooneo 8y agoAm I reading you correctly? You found a 2,900 sqft property in the bay area, 9 years ago, for 129k? Or is there a zero missing, and you meant to write 1.29M? Because if it was really 129k, that's a factor of ~20 times cheaper per square foot than current residential real estate around Cambridge, MA right now.[1] [1] https://www.trulia.com/real_estate/Cambridge-Massachusetts/ https://www.trulia.com/real_estate/Cambridge-Massachusetts/
- flaque 8y agoHome ownership is only a good investment if the system is broken.
- taprun 8y agoIt can be when borrowing terms are artificially loose. Imagine a world in which you can get a zero-ish percent interest-only loan. The "value" can keep going up even though the monthly cost remains low until the end of the term at which point you sell to someone else for even more money at a zero-ish percent rate.
- gowld 8y agoWho is giving out 0% loans forever, when they could be buying up real estate instead?
- __s 8y agowoosh
- smt88 8y agoI don't understand your point at all. It seems to boil down to: "Something can be a good investment while simultaneously increasing in value at the rate of inflation if someone gives you free money to hold it." Everything is a good investment if you pay nearly zero interest and its value goes up. It's a tautology, and it has no bearing on practical solutions to this problem.
- gamechangr 8y agoMy friend would have paid $40,000 more in taxes this year if he didn't have an a single family rental to depreciate, so perhaps gains vs inflation isn't as straightforward a measuring stick as you would assume.
- village-idiot 8y agoThis is part of the regressiveness of the US tax code. That’s a $40,000 transfer of wealth from those who cannot afford to own rental properties to those who can. Not that I blame your friend for taking the tax break, I would too. It’s very hard to convince people to forgo benefits like that for the sake of society.
- stanleydrew 8y agoYou are not wrong in general about the tax code favoring those with certain kinds of housing wealth. But in particular regarding depreciation, the IRS will demand depreciation recapture at time of sale whether you actually took depreciation at any point in the property history or not. So if you don't want to pay double taxes you have to take the depreciation every year.
- TomVDB 8y agoIf you think that is regressive, wait until you hear about tax basis reset for your heirs.
- stanleydrew 8y agoYour friend will have to repay those taxes when he sells (assuming there is profit above the then-depreciated value). Seems like a lot of people don't know this. Yes it is true that the tax rate is capped at 25% (which is sometimes less than the normal marginal federal rate you would pay) and there are ways to defer the tax bill further but it's not just like free money that the government gives up on collecting from you.
- TomVDB 8y agoIf he sells. We have a bunch of rentals around here and we have no plans at all to ever sell. And when we die the tax basis for our kids will be the value of the properties at our time of death. (And I think they can even start using depreciation again.)
- plasticchris 8y agoYeah. Since corporations decided to charge whatever the market would bear, things everyone need, like housing and health care, have gone crazy
- khuey 8y agoMost people don't get housing from a corporation.
- HarryHirsch 8y agoYes. Consider the price of any orphan drug that Valeant touched. Syprine went from USD 625 per 100 pills to USD 21000, and despite the combined and very reasonable protestations of Hillary Clinton and Elizabeth Warren, the price still hasn't come down.
- black6 8y agoThe major flaw I see in this analysis is believing the only way to build wealth by "investing" in home-ownership is increasing property values. It completely ignores the equity one builds while paying down a mortgage. If one intends on staying put for a while (even just a couple-few years in some cases) then one can build wealth through home ownership without runaway property valuation. Money is "lost" on interest payments, but if you are leasing a home, you're paying someone else's mortgage and interest[0]. [0]: Not necessarily the case, but it works for simplicity's sake.
- bufordsharkley 8y agoEven if prices are stable, what makes it the case that the system works so well for those who own land and creates such problems for those who are landless? We take it for granted that renting is just a form of having your money stolen by landowners, without realizing that this is a choice we make: we could just as easily administer the market so that absentee ownership ceases to be a smart bet.
- briandear 8y ago> administer the market That’s a scary idea. There are massive unintended consequences to such a strategy of reducing the benefits of “absentee” ownership. Almost every private rental property in existence is the result of absentee ownership. A move to disrupt that would result in a dramatically reduced supply of rental properties. Not everyone has the resources, credit or responsibility to own their own home. The financial crisis of 2008 was trigger by a whole bunch of people buying when they shouldn’t have. The places where people try to “administer” the market either through aggressive regulation or capping rents through rent control have the most inefficient and expensive markets.
- bufordsharkley 8y agoIt's interesting that you jump to "aggressive regulation" or "rent control" instead of the solution that has close to full consensus from the economic profession: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_value_tax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_value_tax
- AznHisoka 8y agoSo what's a good investment? The stock market? But I'm not exactly providing any value when I invest in a stock as my money doesn't go to any company that needs funding. Bitcoin? But that wastes energy and again, doesn't provide much value to society, if any. Gold? But again that doesn't seem to provide much value to society. Real estate seems to be the only venue where I can make a return on my value, and provide some value to people. And now, some people want to take that away.
- elyobo 8y agoBy pushing up prices you're providing negative value; speculate on stocks, people don't need to live in them.
- elyobo 8y agoThere is a way you can be of more benefit though; if you're increasing the supply of housing (that is, building new housing) then you're providing benefit. If you can also profit by doing so then go ahead.
- usaphp 8y ago> Real estate seems to be the only venue where I can make a return on my value, and provide some value to people. What kind of value are you providing by purchasing a house, not living in it and not selling it? When you purchase 2+ house where you don’t live - you are basically removing it from the market - thus increasing the demand/offering ratio and inflating the prices?
- AznHisoka 8y agoWhat about renting it out to people? isnt that providing value?
- elyobo 8y agoDepends; if they're only renting because prices have been pushed out of their reach by speculators, then not really. Some supply of rental property is required, but much less so when housing markets are not out of control.
- elyobo 8y agoMost points also apply equally to the Australian housing crisis in Sydney and Melbourne. No mortgage interest tax deduction here for home owners, although there is for investors, among various other incentives. Governments consistently fail to do anything about affordability because they're too worried about "mum and dad" investors (not to mention their own portfolios[1]). [1] https://www.businessinsider.com.au/australias-federal-politicians-own-a-staggering-524-properties-2017-4 https://www.businessinsider.com.au/australias-federal-politi... "Australia's 226 federal politicians own a staggering 524 properties ..."
- hugh-avherald 8y agoNo mortgage interest tax deduction for owner-occupied dwellings but the exemption of capital gains tax is far larger in terms of revenue foregone.
- elyobo 8y agoProbably; they're both massive, no doubt about that. Interest rates are low right now, but in general you're probably paying around double the value of a property over a 30 year mortgage, that's a sizeable tax deduction.
- derekp7 8y agoMy counter to this article is that you have to live somewhere. So you either rent a big chunk of money that you can use to buy a house, or you rent housing directly. If the principle, interest, taxes, insurance and maintenance is about the same as renting over the course of a number of years then you are better off buying. The risk is that you may need to move before you are at the break-even point. And risk is sometimes location dependant (how varied are the industries that provide good employment in your area, etc). And you risk rising costs (I wasn't prepared for property taxes and insurance to outpace inflation 4 to 1, for example). But the biggest mistake that I feel people make (at least in my case) is getting more house than I needed. I would have been better off getting a much smaller / less desirable property that I could have paid off in 7 years, instead of the 30 year mortgage. Because then after 7 years, if property rates rise, well I can sell and have more money for a down payment on a better house. And if the fall, I can still sell and put the money down on the same better house, which is also much cheaper (assuming similar area / cost of living).
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoNot sure we read the same article. I don't see how anything that you've written is a counterpoint to the article.
- sopooneo 8y agoBut can't you also just sell the 7 years worth of equity you've built up over the start of a 30 mortgage almost as well? I will concede that the downside risk is higher with the (initially) higher priced property.
- tdfx 8y agoIn a conventional mortgage, the proportion of interest you pay is frontloaded so that you're paying much more interest in the beginning of the loan. So in the first 7 years of a 30 year mortgage, you will have paid some principal, but the majority was interest.
- codingdave 8y ago> ...its price would need to increase faster than the rate of inflation. If you don't own a home, you pay rent, and rent increases over time. Even if you never made a dime on selling the home years later, the difference between years of rent vs. the total of your mortgage may still come out ahead. Or, keep the house, and live the rest of your live only having to pay property taxes and utilities. Either way, inflation goes up, rents go up, mortgages go down. I'm not sure that invalidates the larger points within the article. I just worry about the perspective of treating a home purely as an investment when their primary benefit is to be a roof over your head.
- ceph_ 8y ago> If you don't own a home, you pay rent, and rent increases over time. Rent costs are directly tied to property values. Assuming rents will always increase is based off the same assumption that property values will always increase as well.
- TomVDB 8y ago> Rent costs are directly tied to property values. In the long term, probably. But definitely not in the short or middle term. There can be many years where the ratio deviates from the norm. So "directly" is not definitely not the word I'd use. https://www.investopedia.com/terms/p/price-to-rent-ratio.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/p/price-to-rent-ratio.asp
- lotsofpulp 8y agoIf you’re single or a couple with no dependents who doesn’t mind moving every now and then, renting isn’t so bad. You avoid the risk of dealing with damage to the structure, fixing things, labor markets being disrupted (like factory towns or smaller towns everywhere in the US). Take all that saved up money and put it in a low cost index fund, you very well might come ahead, and be liquid when you need to move because the jobs disappeared. And rents definitely don’t always go up.
- a_wild_dandan 8y ago
- jgalt212 8y agoHousing is f'd up b/c of some combination of Baumol's cost disease and ZIRP. Just not sure how to correctly apportion the blame.
- corysama 8y agoA lot of people here are playing semantics and ignoring the message of the article just to be "clever". The message of the article is we can't have our "housing values are always increasing" cake and eat our "housing is always affordable" dream too. If we want to keep housing affordable, we'll have to settle for valuations staying pretty much constant in real dollars forever and resign ourselves to be happy with only the savings opportunities everyone here are so cleverly pointing out.
- christophilus 8y agoI’ve been thinking about this a lot lately. I want my children to be able to afford to live near me if they want. I own a house and would gladly relinquish my ability to sell it at a profit if it meant keeping prices affordable for young folks. I’m not sure what the real solution is, though.
- api 8y agoThe instant someone signs a mortgage it becomes in their (cynical) economic best interest to try to keep others from being able to do the same. The only solution I see is state level zoning standardization around pro-density zoning and limitations on NIMBY power.
- i_am_nomad 8y agoPeople choose to buy in neighborhoods they like (if they have a choice). It doesn’t make them cynical schemers if they then don’t want the neighborhood to change.
- romed 8y agoIs there another part of the market where you apply this twisted reasoning? I thought 1992 was a pretty good year for Japanese sports cars. I think building new cars after 1992 should have been illegal. We can keep 1992 cars affordable through price controls.
- village-idiot 8y agoHouses shouldn’t grow in value for well established areas, they should roughly track with the population and inflation. If demand hasn’t changed, why should homes change value? Aside from homes slowly rotting, that is. In fact that should reduce the value of a home over time.
- thoughtexplorer 8y agoSomething I've been wondering about: Would it be a good or bad idea to tamp down on the whole concept of housing as an investment? It seems fundamentally problematic, but is there any alternative workable system that wouldn't have unintended consequences?
- stanleydrew 8y agoIt would be a good idea. 2008 went a long way towards disabusing a lot of folks of the notion that buying property is always a good investment. But given the way my mom still talks up real estate there's probably some more room for tamping down.
- thoughtexplorer 8y agoGood point, prior to 2008 it seemed like everyone was convinced that buying a house was a no brainer and that renting was throwing your money away. Maybe what happened with Detroit helped too.
- smt88 8y agoHousing is a good investment for natural reasons: as population increases, housing near developed communities becomes scarcer. To tamp down on that concept would be really difficult. You'd probably have to artificially limit the ROI of home sales, which would likely increase the number of renters. Then what? Rent goes up, so you have to artificially limit the price of rent. So how do you choose the limit? Then once you've chosen the rent limit, will RE firms have an incentive to build? Free markets work pretty well for settle prices. The problem is that not everyone can participate equally. If we artificially brought people out of poverty instead of artificially fixing housing markets, the housing problem would be a lot less severe.
- kspaans 8y agoIt's inevitable that land prices in urban areas will go up as populations grow. That doesn't mean that the price of housing has to grow too. You could build more density (build up, build smaller units) to keep rents and prices stable.
- dangjc 8y agoIf you don't own a home, you are effectively short the housing market. If you own one home you are neutral: you can't sell it to make a profit because you always need one roof over your head. If you own more than one house, you are a landlord/investor and I don't know why we are giving you special treatment relative to other asset classes. It would be better for everyone if housing was not an investment.
- ec109685 8y agoYou can sell at a profit by moving someplace where housing didn’t go up at the same rate (e.g. to another area or to a smaller house). Housing as an investment and friction around moving keeps you tied to a particular area, which can be argued is better for a community.
- SZJX 8y agoI don't see how being tied to a particular area is essentially good for the community, especially for big cities, which are used to huge turnovers. For me having the freedom to move wherever I want for my job sounds much more enticing than being forced to find jobs in the same area even though there might be better chances elsewhere/I just want to experience something different. Also, you don't necessarily have to be tied to that area either. You can still treat the house as an investment and rent it out, while you yourself rent a smaller house. In some places in Europe such practices might even be encouraged by the policy (tax incentives etc.)
- nilsbunger 8y agoI’ve never heard of renting as being “short” the housing prices but that’s a great way to think of it.
- eindiran 8y agoThat is a very interesting way to think about it, but I am not sure that it works fully. By extending that principle, wouldn't anyone that can't afford to own shares in TSLA or MSFT be short then? In this framework it seems like you can't be "neutral", ie neither short nor long.
- exabrial 8y agoYou can buy a three bedroom house in Topeka, Kansas for $75k. Regressive taxes are a much bigger problem.
- mrhappyunhappy 8y agoI once read an article about how in Japan wealth does not accumulate from generation to generation. The article went on talking about housing valuation and how homes devalue instead of appreciating in value of the course of their life. He article made it sound like a terrible thing. Of course, if you look at it from a personal perspective it IS terrible not being able to pass on appreciated properly to your kids. Who doesn’t want their family to be better off from generation to generation?! But if you think about it from affordability and societal perspective, it isn’t so bad to have your property remain the same value or depreciate. Of course there are other issues to debate there such as environmental pollution that comes with wasted resources every time you build and scrap a new home. The upside is having to live in a new house that’s more affordable than in the western nations.
- MarkMc 8y agoSeems to ignore the idea that as long as supply can increase, and a single house can be converted to a block of 6 units, housing can be both a good investment and affordable. I think the problem is that while development currently benefits house owners, apartment owners have no incentive to increase supply. We need to tax property development and distribute it to all local households. In this way it won't just benefit house owners and it will have much greater support from locals.
- issa 8y agoThis article misses two points that are so basic that I'm shocked. 1) Home prices don't need to go up in order to make it a good investment 2) Banks pay a huge percentage of the cost of buying a house, but the consumer keeps 100% of the profit. To use the example in the article, if you bought a house for $200,000 and sold it ten years later for $256,000, you didn't only make $56,000. You also paid down your mortgage over that time. A typical mortgage isn't much more than rent, so minus interest, that's more money for you. Also, you only needed to put down $40,000 and the bank paid the other $160k for the house purchase. So for $40k plus the cost of rent, you did pretty well. You also would have done better than renting if the house had only appreciated half as much.
- nostromo 8y ago> Also, you only needed to put down $40,000 and the bank paid the other $160k for the house purchase. In this scenario the bank just creates the money out of thin air. And then they get to keep all of the interest payments. So, yeah, it's good for the home owner, but it's great for the bank -- so long as most people keep paying back their loans.
- eo3x0 8y agoThe real problem is that there hasn’t been any attempt at policy changes to correct this. In order to do so, society needs to chip away at the problem in steps. Right now, real estate is simply a good investment regardless of everything else because of the tax benefits of transferring properties to heirs. Depreciation and tax bases are reset, essentially making real estate a double whammy of tax benefits for the current owners as well as their heirs. Depreciation means tens of thousands of dollars saved in taxes per year per property. Transfer benefits means never having to pay that back due to generational reset. Take away the transfer and estate benefits first. Once that first dent is made, the wealthy/NIMBYs will naturally vote for the next correct move, which is to take away policies that make housing unaffordable to their own children. As the law is right now, there is no incentive for land owners to be altruistic to society because their children are sheltered from affordability problems due to transfer benefits. My wager is that all it would take is removing transfer benefits on commercial properties (e.g. like kind exchange, or enforcing depreciation recapture upon transfers, including 1031) to see the first domino fall on the way to an eventual partial rollback of laws like prop 13 and more property development due to fewer NIMBY incentives. That’s a very small bite to chew that leads to much greater changes down the road because it realigns incentives tremendously. I say this as someone who has Bay Area real-estate. The strategy to reverse things doesn’t exist at the moment.
- Waterluvian 8y agoI would gladly buy a house that cost it's value in parts and labor and sold for the same amount + inflation decades later. I just don't need or want an investment like that.
- MarkMc 8y agoGood point - housing doesn't need to be a good investment. If we increase the supply of housing it will make the economy more efficient and that will mean improved returns in other investment categories.
- gwbas1c 8y agoYou'll get ripped off. New homes depreciate quite a bit because of the ongoing cost of maintenance after 7-16 years. (Except in the Bay Area.) The catch is that inflation usually hides the depreciation. You will find this out if you ever compare the cost of a new home to an older home, or plan to build your own. Where I live, a 15-20 year old home is about 60-80% of the cost of a similar new home.
- Waterluvian 8y agoYeah I hear you. I'm not speaking of buying a new home in today's world. I'm speaking of a hypothetical world where homes weren't priced as investments, they were priced as products. And I do appreciate why it doesn't work that way.
- gwbas1c 8y ago> homes weren't priced as investments, they were priced as products Careful there, you really need to understand the difference between an investment and a product. I bought a very nice lawn tractor as an "investment" so I wouldn't have to pay someone to mow my lawn. The land your home is on is always an investment. Land doesn't depreciate like a product does. But even then, when you use the term investment, I think you conflate "for profit" versus better deal. A home can be an investment as long as you have a tangible benefit over renting. That can be anything from lower long-term cost, to having the exact kind of living space you want. For example: I owned a home for a little over 3 years before I had to move. We sold it for inflation + cost of some improvements, and at the end it was slightly cheaper than renting... But we enjoyed the house so much more, and the house was in much better condition than a rental. We were able to do things like install an electric car charger and central air conditioning; things that would be much more difficult in a rental situation.
- purplezooey 8y agoWe need some big strokes to fix this. Personally I think the long-term solution, at least in CA, is for the state to buy out owners in critical areas, taking land with eminent domain as a last resort, then selling the land back to developers on the condition that density is tripled or quadrupled. That's the only way to move the needle. Doesn't everyone ask you, when visiting from out of state, "why don't you guys just build up?"
- rcpt 8y agoIn California we could easily solve the housing shortage by eliminating prop 13. Because land isn't taxed based on it's current value landowners have little incentive to develop their land in order to get the most out of it. They simply bank land as much as possible as it's the most surefire way to turn a profit. It's why we have golf courses (https://www.planetizen.com/node/93284/la-country-clubs-taking-more-their-share-and-paying-less https://www.planetizen.com/node/93284/la-country-clubs-takin...) in city centers, dilapidated shacks (https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/dec/15/google-campus-silicon-valley-farm-martinellis https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/dec/15/google-ca...) next to Google's global HQ, and empty lots (https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/811-Pelton-Ave-Santa-Cruz-CA-95060/96053991_zpid/ https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/811-Pelton-Ave-Santa-Cruz...) right on the beach in Santa Cruz. Additionally, prop 13 gives landowners every incentive to lobby for policies that restrict development in order to drive up prices instead of fighting for the right to build 4 story apartments on their property. Impact fees are too high because cities can't rely on property tax. This stops all but the most luxurious developments: https://lao.ca.gov/publications/report/3497#Did_Proposition.A013_Increase_Fees_on_Developers.3F_ https://lao.ca.gov/publications/report/3497#Did_Proposition.... And then there's the fact that prop 13 transfers wealth from young to old, from poor and middle-class to rich, from black and Latino to white, and from renter to owner (http://www.betterinstitutions.com/blog/2015/07/prop-13-california-broken-property-tax-part-1 http://www.betterinstitutions.com/blog/2015/07/prop-13-calif...). Making it harder for people to save up in hope of buying one day.
- amanaplanacanal 8y agoYes. I understand why prop 13 was passed, it was in a time of high inflation, and the increased valuations meant that property taxes had a huge impact, especially on retired people with fixed incomes. But all the downstream effects of that have made rather large distortions in the housing market.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- joejerryronnie 8y agoHousing is always going to be expensive in desirable areas. No amount of social justice or zoning reform is going to make mid-town Manhattan or downtown SF easily affordable for anyone who wants to live there. Sure, these areas are culturally vibrant but the real draw of high cost of living areas is the job opportunities. Many people would gladly try out a different area of the country or move back home if only the job prospects were reasonable. I think there's much more bang for the buck in economic revitalization than trying to make every city in America "affordable". Although opposed to government intervention in general, I am much more in favor of proactive, growth-based policies than reactive redistribution-minded reforms.
- grigjd3 8y agoSo one might consider "the original intent" of your home as an investment to be something other than throwing your money at rent. If I put $2000 towards rent in a month, I have a place to live that month. If I instead put $2000 towards a mortgage, I have some of that money in equity (and a place to live for a month). It "builds wealth" in that some of my monthly spend is resulting in value for me beyond the place to live for those 30 or so days. I think if people are generically looking to treat their home like any other financial instrument, they're courting danger.
- Axsuul 8y agoExcept a $2000 rent will not get you the same place as a $2000 mortgage.
- forkLding 8y agoKind of shows that at end of the day, the issue is political and depends on who wants what. We can stop housing price increases and decrease future profits gained for current homeowners.
- torgian 8y agoI call bullshit. Take housing in China. You can buy a place in China, but making money off of it with rent? Good luck. It’s a common problem that people who can afford to buy a place, can’t rent it for a profit if they are still paying a mortgage. Why that is, I really don’t know. But the fact is, it can be possible to have cheap rent available, if the owners are willing to not make a profit. But that’s just not how capitalism works.
- Tsubasachan 8y agoI don't know, social housing is a good investment for society. Giving everyone a decent roof over their heads isn't just good for karma but also social and political stability. Not cheap though.
- tryptophan 8y agoIt actually is cheap. But we have tons of laws that outlaw cheap housing because it "causes" "undesirable" neighborhoods.
- jrnvs 8y agoGreat, so you made $50k because your $200k house is now worth $250k - a 25% increase. You now have a family and bigger income and are looking at a bigger house priced $500k. You are really glad that you “made” $50k on your old house. But wait, if the new house is in the same neighbourhood, it’s price increase was probably also close to 25%. If prices had stayed the same, it would be worth $400k today. So you just gained $50k on your old house but are paying $100k more on the new one. This is only beneficial if you move from a large house in a popular area to a smaller house in a less popular area. If you have kids, they might inherit the wealth gained from your housing “investment” - after splitting with their siblings and after taxes of course. Sounds good, until you realise that they will have to spend it all - and put in extra - on housing because of the price increases. In a world where housing prices stay the same, or become slightly cheaper year by year, everyone is better of. The prices of common utilities such as food and clothing have gone down spectacularly in the last decades while quality has gone up. No one would rather live in a world where these had instead become more expensive. It’s time we start thinking about housing in the same way.
- TomMarius 8y agoCould you please describe exactly how could housing get continuously cheaper when there are more people every year and the demand for good locations is increasing? (Edit: I asked a sincere question. Don't downvote without explanation, please. It's really tiring, anti-discussion and makes it seem like you don't have any good point at all.)
- sleavey 8y agoI guess, meet and exceed housing demand and improve less affluent areas. This involves government money but most seem happy to let the public take the bill in the form of continuously inflating house prices instead.
- jplayer01 8y agoWe currently have a feedback loop where rising prices attracts investors who sink money into real estate, which reduces supply and raises prices, which attracts investors, etc. There are a number of factors that incentivize reduced supply such as reduced incentive to build lots of new buildings because that would increase supply too much and reduce prices and an increased incentive to build a small number of luxury apartments instead, which further raises property values. If ownership wasn't seen as an investment vehicle, this feedback loop would be broken. People would only buy because they need it, or in the case of landlords, the rents they could secure from rentees would be much lower because of the lower market value of the object and the overall lower rent prices across the entire market. Of course, sufficient supply has one big condition: Zoning laws are relaxed, allowing enough supply to be built in the first place.
- Dowwie 8y agoSurprisingly, no one has discussed the transaction costs of real estate, which takes a large bite out of any potential gains. You don't necessarily come out ahead when you sell, even in a growing market, once commissions and attorney fees are paid.
- thedevil 8y agoI tend to rent despite owning real estate. I tend to move often and only buy real estate if I'm willing to hold it forever. So I buy what I think is a good long term investment and live where I want to live.
- ss64 8y agoSupply and demand in the housing market is not about the supply of houses but about the supply of CREDIT. As long as the banks are happy to lend large sums at low rates prices will go up, and as soon as the banks become more cautious, either raising rates or restricting how much they will lend, then prices will fall. I'm sure many will continue to blame immigration but I challenge anyone to come up with any solid data to back up that claim. We have seen this happen before and that wasn't because millions of people suddenly left the country overnight.
- cinquemb 8y agoExactly. And people still want to pretend that owning a home now is good diversification from the stock market which now is also filled with companies that are utterly dependent on the supply of credit. The pressure on RE market is already keeling over, not just in the US but around the world (thanks to CB's following largely the same policies for so long in this synchronized "recovery").
- tomohawk 8y agoHousing is a cost and a necessity. The goal with housing is to minimize both cost and risk. Renting and ownership both carry their costs and risks. We have not had inflation for a long time, but I remember the Carter years where we had inflation and people who rented were in a world of hurt. Owners had no such problems. The 2008 crash hurt owners, but only if they had to sell. At least where we are, prices are more than fully recovered. Since you need housing for your whole life, you have to take into account these sorts of historical occurrences. If you are an owner, you can ride out most of these things. If you are a renter, your rent will go up unavoidably. Ownership is the best approach to avoiding cost/risk, but only if you (a) build up a 20% minimum down payment, (b) attack your mortgage and pay it off early, (c) have a minimum 6 month emergency fund (which you should have whether owning or renting). If you approach ownership like a rental, only looking at the monthly payment, you are taking a big risk and subjecting yourself to higher cost and risk. The same can be said about renting, though. What will you do if you lose your job and do not have a 6 month fund built up and have to pay rent? Having a paid off home and not having to worry about rising rents contributes to peace of mind, and opens the door to other life modes, such as early retirement or taking extensive time off.
- usaar333 8y ago> We have not had inflation for a long time, but I remember the Carter years where we had inflation and people who rented were in a world of hurt. Owners had no such problems. I could see how an owner with a mortgage benefits with unexpected inflation, but why our renters hurt? If their incomes rise with inflation, shouldn't it be neutral? > The 2008 crash hurt owners, but only if they had to sell. At least where we are, prices are more than fully recovered. You can't ignore opportunity costs. The question is how would an owner on a mortgage performed if instead they were renting, had lower payments, and directed additional savings into the stock market?
- tomohawk 8y agoWhat would you do if your rent went up 10% - 20% a year? Rents follow inflation. As for opportunity, there is immediate opportunity and deferred opportunity. You could chase the stock market now, and have no gains for 10 years, or great gains. If you buy a house and pay it off, you guarantee lower expenses going forward. If you're the grasshopper, then by all means rent. If you're the ant, then buying probably makes more sense.
- anthony_barker 8y agoA nice economics research article I read a while ago basically showed that housing prices increase with inflation except in cities like San Francisco, New York Manhattan or Vancouver that have strict building rules or physical limitations.
- vparikh 8y agoWell housing is a good investment once you pay it off and stay in that home for an extended period of time. The problem is people just want buy ever larger homes. I mean look at the average square footage of homes in the 1970s which was 1500 sqft and by 2014 its 2,657 sqft (https://247wallst.com/special-report/2016/05/25/the-size-of-a-home-the-year-you-were-born/11/ https://247wallst.com/special-report/2016/05/25/the-size-of-...). People are buying way over their means. I purchased a 1800 sq ft home when I was 22 that I am still living in today (I am 45) with a 15 year fixed mortgage. I paid the mortgage off and have lived rent/mortgage free for the past 8 years. Assuming I live here for another 12 years, that will be 20 years of rent/mortgage free living. And yes I am married and have a 2 year old. And when I do eventually sell, I will get back all the interest I paid and then some even adjusted for inflation. The problem is people just keep jumping int every larger homes. As soon as they can.
- apo 8y agoWhile funds for low-income subsidized housing languish, much larger pots of money are set aside for promoting homeownership through subsidies like the mortgage interest deduction and capital gains exemption, most of which goes to upper-middle- or upper-class households. Looking for reasons why house price increases outpace inflation? These two US tax policies are a big part of the answer. Commentators bewailing the high price of housing and wealth inequality rarely even discuss these two massive giveaways. Deficit hawks rarely point to the mind-boggling amount of tax revenue left on the table by this federal government dole. Ending the mortgage deduction and the capital gains exemption would be a very effective and quick way to bring about housing affordability and promote wealth equality. But any representative proposing such a solution would be committing political suicide today. Still, it's interesting to think about the conditions that might be necessary to force a change in sentiment on the issue.
- zamfi 8y agoThis is only a contradiction if the type of housing remains constant, which it does in low-development, high-construction-cost markets like San Francisco where public policy prevents the modification of (almost) any housing to increase density. Here’s how it would work otherwise: family buys single family home in year A for $100k. Lives there for a while, then sells in year B for $200k. The buyer is a developer, who then constructs a larger building on that same lot consisting of 4 apartments that now each sell for $100k again. Original family gains in wealth, developer makes tidy profit, new families can still buy a place to live for $100k. All numbers inflation-adjusted, you pick A and B to make whatever return you think is reasonable. This is how densification happened almost everywhere until zoning laws stopped development mid-century. Note what you don’t get out of this arrangement: a neighborhood that doesn’t change for 40 years; the ability to live in the same type of house your parents did, in the same neighborhood, for the same price. But you could have the same amount of (indoor) space they did, and outdoor space through public parks and the like. What’s not sustainable is everyone having a suburban style detached single family home without increasing density in perpetuity. That is what leads to this contradiction. The non-density alternative is sprawl, where prices rise in long-established neighborhoods, and outlying new developments are where you can buy new houses for less — which is what you see all over California.
- camgunz 8y agoThe gain on your house will never outpace the interest on your mortgage. Houses as wealth generation (in this simple way, they're still obviously better than nothing and helpful to borrow against) is essentially a scam literally sold by banks. You'll pay $170k on a $100k house over 30 years. If you put that same $70k in Vanguard you'll have over $400k after 30 years (at a modest 6% return).
- tim333 8y agoThis isn't true if you are an actual property investor - cheap housing has a better rental yield. If you want to live in a house and have the price shoot up while you do so then fair enough, that only works if prices shoot up.
- joelx 8y agoThe best thing we can do to have affordable housing used to increase the supply of housing. If we increase the amount of high-density zoning and reduce the amount of permit difficulties, housing will become much more affordable.
- mrnobody_67 8y agoHousing in some cities = SoV (Store of Value) for foreigners... NYC, Miami, etc. Nothing to do with investment, all about getting money out of dubious places in the world. Anonymous LLC and Done. Imagine if they plowed all those dollars into Bitcoin instead.
- 8bitsrule 8y agoGambling using housing as gaming pieces was fun in monopoly. Then late-night TV started encouraging people to do that in real life. Until there is an affordable HOME for all US citizens who need one, we in the US need to stop thinking of them as HOUSES and stop them being used as gambling chips. As for public-housing, it needs to be permanently off-limits to speculative investing. Otherwise why should the well-intentioned public agree to investing their tax dollars in public housing? Ownership of these HOMES should only be available to people eligible for public-housing.
- resalisbury 8y ago"Affordable housing and rising home values are mutually incompatible."[1] [1] https://medium.com/yimby/why-a-healthy-housing-market-is-bad-for-people-bd48a5399686?source=user_profile---------42------------------ https://medium.com/yimby/why-a-healthy-housing-market-is-bad...