24 ms·
Canada legalises recreational cannabis use
- itchyjunk 8y agoI wonder how many state has to legalize it before the federal government in USA is forced to change their classification. It seems like more and more state will legalize it over time anyways.
- KempFood 8y agoMaybe in another 40 years. People aren’t smart, they are as dumb as nails. Sad!
- fein 8y agoThe people aren't really the ones making the decision. Here in Ohio, for example, we didn't have a vote on recreational, instead we had a vote on a government sanctioned monopoly possibly leading the way to recreational. If there was some sort of state issue that could be voted on which was "regulate it like we do garden tomatoes", it would pass. Leadership has prevented this, not your cartoon idea of the oh so ignorant voter base. Too often we blame the salt of the earth people for things the media has done. Rule by multi millionaire propagandists.
- thaumasiotes 8y agoAccording to wikipedia ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Initiatives_and_referendums_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Initiatives_and_referendums_in... ) and ballotpedia ( https://ballotpedia.org/wiki/index.php/Indirect_initiative_statute https://ballotpedia.org/wiki/index.php/Indirect_initiative_s... ), Ohio allows indirect initiatives. Meaning that if you were right about the voting base, it would be easy to legalize recreational marijuana without worrying what the leadership thought. > In the indirect form, initiative sponsors collect signatures and once the signatures are collected, the measure is taken up by the state legislature in their state. The legislature has these options: > Enact the measure as written in the petition. > Refuse to act on the measure, in which case it goes on the ballot. https://ballotpedia.org/Initiated_state_statute https://ballotpedia.org/Initiated_state_statute The leadership is not capable of preventing legalization if the salt of the earth is in favor of it.
- fein 8y agoThe salt of the earth doesn't give a shit about the local government; they just want to be left alone for the most part. The issue is getting the signatures in the first place, which requires canvassing, which requires paying someone to organize all of that. The last example of a successful canvassing that we had was a grab at a monopoly over growing ops, which was funded partly by a former member of the boy band NSYNC. The other hurdle is approval by the legislature. In Ohio it's not as simple as "get signatures, get on the ballot".
- thaumasiotes 8y ago> The other hurdle is approval by the legislature. In Ohio it's not as simple as "get signatures, get on the ballot". I'm open to more specialized information, but the description on ballotpedia strongly implies that it is that simple. Specifically, it says that the steps are: 1. Get signatures. 2. The legislature must consider the initiative, either approving or rejecting it. 3a. If the legislature approves the initiative, it becomes law without having to go on the ballot. 3b. If the legislature rejects the initiative, it goes on the ballot. Thus, once you have signatures, the worst case is that you go straight onto the ballot, and the best case is that you become law without needing to. Theoretically, it could be possible for the legislature to sit on the initiative without ever approving or rejecting it. All I'm working off here is a cursory description of the law of several states including Ohio. Do you have relevant knowledge of Ohio law?
- charlex815 8y agoPoliticians are more often mirrors of society than agents of change. Demand change from them, they aren't reading Hacker News. If they refuse change, campaign against them.
- anoncoward111 8y ago>campaign against them And then suddenly when the death threats and FBI audits and etc start showing up in your life, and you lose the campaign anyway, you'll say to yourself, "shit, this isn't a democracy we're living in, this is just a mafia state."
- koverda 8y agoTinfoil hats are this way.
- anoncoward111 8y agoGo run for office then. Surely it can't be that hard and daunting.
- api 8y agoMeh. Faraday mesh hats work much better.
- gm-conspiracy 8y agoMonopoly, really? One single corporation was going to control the whole cabal? You are misrepresenting facts.
- fein 8y agoWould you prefer cabal? It was a certain group of a limited number of people who could grow, with nothing in the lines of allowing private growers to create startups.
- gm-conspiracy 8y agoOligopoloy.
- dang 8y agoMaybe so, but please don't post unsubstantive comments to Hacker News.
- SlowRobotAhead 8y agoI’m not sure on the answer, but I definitely want to make sure you don’t think Canada is a state in the US ;)
- verelo 8y agoAnd thank goodness for that!
- splintercell 8y agoThe feeling is mutual.
- mixmastamyk 8y agoState is often a synonym of country.
- SlowRobotAhead 8y agoYes, that’s true. Now how many countries would the US recently have watched change their laws around pot vs the discussion currently going on inside of US States? Is being technically true better than a contextual joke?
- nomocrypto 8y agoOnce we figure out how to keep minorities in prison easily, marijuana will become completely legal in the US.
- drb91 8y agoI agree FWIW, but I suspect capitalists would be fine discriminating blindly against all colors of a lower class. Race has always been an effective means to this end in America: if the people feeding your wallet are at each other’s throat, they might not notice who’s pocketing the cash.
- gardnr 8y agoI wonder if this got downvoted for the racial sentiment or anti-capitalist view.
- nomocrypto 8y agoWell, it’s HN so both are equally likely. Edit: it’s like y’all’re allergic to satire.
- laretluval 8y agoPossible steps in that direction https://reason.com/blog/2018/06/08/trump-endorses-marijuana-federalism-bill https://reason.com/blog/2018/06/08/trump-endorses-marijuana-...
- adventured 8y agoYou're being downvoted because it's Trump, which is bullshit. It's the first time in modern US history that a sitting President has come anywhere close to declaring support for or proclaiming he'd be ok with the Federal Government legalizing recreational marijuana consumption. The reason for that, is because Trump is an aggressive populist that doesn't particularly care about entrenched, ancient political live wires. He'll feel entirely free to respond to the Trump voting base as its opinion gradually changes in favor of legalization (as it largely has).
- int_19h 8y agoThe problem is that legalization of cannabis in US was never actually about cannabis per se. It was about this: "The primary reason to outlaw marijuana is its effect on the degenerate races." "Reefer makes darkies think they're as good as white men." "Marihuana leads to pacifism and communist brainwashing." "There are 100,000 total marijuana smokers in the US, and most are Negroes, Hispanics, Filipinos and entertainers. Their Satanic music, jazz and swing, result from marijuana usage. This marijuana causes white women to seek sexual relations with Negroes, entertainers and any others." Now, these quotes are from the pre-WW2 period, when this insanity first began. But they lingered for a lot longer than that, even if the language changed. This is from the Nixon era: "You understand what I'm saying? We knew we couldn't make it illegal to be either against the war or black, but by getting the public to associate the hippies with marijuana and blacks with heroin. And then criminalizing both heavily, we could disrupt those communities," Ehrlichman said. "We could arrest their leaders. raid their homes, break up their meetings, and vilify them night after night on the evening news. Did we know we were lying about the drugs? Of course we did." In other words, it was always a weapon in the "culture war". And that is kinda at another peak right now, so I'm not too optimistic about this happening in US until it's over.
- Alex3917 8y ago> I wonder how many state has to legalize it before the federal government in USA is forced to change their classification. It's already arguably legal under federal law under the equal protection clause because congress legalized it in DC. As far as I know the feds aren't locking anyone up for possession of small amounts. E.g.: https://novacriminalattorney.com/marijuana/marijuana-legalization-same-sex-marriage-and-the-14th-amendment/ https://novacriminalattorney.com/marijuana/marijuana-legaliz...
- ilyanep 8y agoAm I missing something or is your link making the exact opposite point that you made?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- nzealand 8y agoYou are not missing anything. The link does make the exact opposite point: "you will not be able to argue that you should be protected by the Constitution."
- Alex3917 8y agoIn this case the author is talking about using the 14th amendment to strike down state laws, but I was just talking about federal law. E.g. if the federal government allows people in DC to do something, then it has to allow everyone else to do that thing also. The author is right that strictly speaking the equal protection clause only applies to state laws, but the supreme court has also retroactively applied it to federal laws as well: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bolling_v._Sharpe https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bolling_v._Sharpe
- dpatru 8y agoThe parent post was arguing that it would be hard to prosecute marijuana possession under federal law because federal law allows possession in DC. The link argues that state laws against marijuana are not affected by federal law. So in Virginia, you won't be able to escape prosecution for marijuana possession under Virginia's law just because it is not illegal under federal law or another state's law.
- gm-conspiracy 8y agoOnce the states make enough revenue from the recreational sales to out-lobby the pharmaceutical companies and their IP monies.
- Tiktaalik 8y agoStates starting to legalize it was likely a big part of why the Canadian government became comfortable with the idea of legalizing it. The idea of legalization, or at least decriminalization, has been floating around in Canada since the 90s, but a major talking point against the idea has been that it would compromise Canada's relationship with the USA. Obviously as internal parts of the USA are legalizing it this is no longer so much of a concern.
- cageface 8y agoI wonder if this has anything to do with the recent breakdown in US-Canada relations? Maybe the Canadians are less concerned with offending us now?
- emilr 8y agoThis is the result of a campaign promise made in 2015.
- echlebek 8y agoYes, it's been in the works for years and a multi-billion dollar industry has grown up around recreational cannabis already. Canopy Growth was listed on the NYSE this year. https://www.bloomberg.com/quote/WEED:CN https://www.bloomberg.com/quote/WEED:CN
- 1over137 8y agoSince way before the 90s my young friend! :) Check out the 1979 federal election debate, fast forward to 1:11:00. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JBfDSimvCFY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JBfDSimvCFY
- digianarchist 8y agoCouldn't the states introduce a constitutional amendment if 2/3 agree on legalisation?
- Cofike 8y agoI was born in Buffalo, no longer there due to lack of tech jobs (that isn’t blue cross blue shield). The Canadian side of Niagara Falls already destroys our side. Much more development. Way more activities to do. Gorgeous view of the falls. All around better. Now that weed is legalized this will only become more and more apparent. They will attract more individuals from both sides of the border and I bet see much more money coming in leading to more development, etc. New York had missed out on this opportunity for years and by the looks of it will continue to miss out.
- ihsw2 8y agoThe Canadian side of Niagara Falls is largely a wine tourist/falls tourist trap and St Catherine's and Hamilton are just areas you drive through to get from Toronto to Niagara Falls, how do you see development in these areas being spurred?
- 0xcafecafe 8y agoPersonally, I prefer the American side more. It has a more park like feel to it where you can enjoy the falls while sitting on the lawn, away from car honks and road noise. The Canadian side seems like an urban jungle with the waterfalls take a side step to tall hotel buildings and casinos.
- eumenides1 8y agoThe Canadian side is relatively developed (vs american side) and an economic engine (tourism, jobs, wines). Your parent commenter's point I believe is that the federal/state/local government has failed the local people in investing and developing a local economy in the area. Both sides have essentially the same resources (the falls), but one side is doing better (economically) than the other.
- philipov 8y agoAnd the point made by (now) parent is that a preference for less resource exploitation and economic development can be a lifestyle decision, not a failure of governance. Not everyone wants to turn their town into a tourist hub.
- dstjean 8y ago?
- zacherates 8y ago"The bill will likely receive Royal Assent this week..."
- noarchy 8y agoTechnically Elizabeth is the Queen of Canada. Her titles elsewhere don't mean anything. Otherwise, she does indeed have to give royal assent, which will be done via the Governor General.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Waterluvian 8y agoBest to think that she just happens to be the queen of a bunch of things, not that those things all share the same queen.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- mabbo 8y agoThat hasn't been true since 1982. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constitution_Act,_1982 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constitution_Act,_1982 Edit with more details: in the early 80s, Trudeau senior got the British government and Queen out of the way to changes in Canadian law. We choose our own Governor general who has the authority to give Royal assent to any laws we pass without involvement of anyone in England. Our current G.G. is Julie Payette, a former astronaut.
- hosh 8y agoYeah, I was puzzling over that earlier about yhat and was confused. Does that mean that, up until the 80s, the British government were still involved with Canadian lawmaking? Did that mean Canada was a constitutional monarchy? Still is?
- readhn 8y agoWhat do we do about heroin/opiods that are the real problem today? Cheap, highly addictive. Multiple overdoses today in my local news feed reported.... :( You cant overdose and die from MJ use (or its highly unlikely). This whole war on drugs thing feels like a game of smoke and mirrors...
- readhn 8y ago"The scale of America’s opioid epidemic is shocking. It is the deadliest drug overdose crisis in US history. In 2016 alone, drug overdoses killed more Americans than the entire Vietnam War and car crashes, gun violence, and HIV/AIDS ever did in a single year. In total, more than 170 people are estimated to die from overdoses every day in the US, and most of the deaths are linked to opioids."
- tghw 8y agoLegalize cannabis. Opioid deaths have dropped here in Colorado since legalization.
- p1mrx 8y agoAre individuals successfully transitioning from opioids to cannabis, or does legalization primarily affect the ratio of new users?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- draw_down 8y agoFrom what I remember, you’d need to smoke something like 3/4 ton of cannabis in a short time to die. So, safe to say you can’t. Which is why you’ve never heard about it happening.
- djsumdog 8y agoTreat addiction as a problem and offer treatment. Oh wait, we don't even have real universal health care. Rehab centers are stupid expensive. In America, only the rich get afford the $2k to $5k up front for the cheap rehab. That's why they end up making so many music videos about it.
- djhaskin987 8y agoA sad and unfortunate trend.
- droidist2 8y agoWhat bothers you about it? Would you want alcohol prohibition too?
- danbolt 8y agoWhat makes you feel that the trend is sad? I often feel like the laws regarding recreational cannabis are quite more strict than they need be, but I’d be curious to hear your point of view?
- dang 8y agoPossibly, but please don't post unsubstantive comments here. Especially not on divisive topics, where it's tantamount to trolling.
- improv32 8y agoWould also like to hear you POV. It's not often expressed here
- bjourne 8y agoShould any substance which enhances the risk of schizophrenia be legalized? https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/317170.php https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/317170.php It appears to me that if cannabis was a food additive with the same risk profile, no one would think it should be legal. I understand that the counter-argument is "What about tobacco/alcohol?" But those substances are already legal and there are no "equal opportunities" rights for drugs. Like if artificial sweeteners were invented today, they would either be banned or there would be harsh restrictions on how food producers could use them. Yes, tobacco kills a lot of people. But as many health experts think letting the tobacco companies sell cigarettes was one of the greatest mistakes of the 20th century, I fail to see how that is an argument. We fucked up once, so we need to do it again?
- elchief 8y agoThe article states that age is a factor and children and teens are at risk. Marijuana age of consent is 19
- trixie_ 8y agoIf you read any weed forum you’ll find endless posts of people who can’t smoke anymore because it causes paranoia and panic attacks. Same with me, used to be fun and now it causes anxiety. There are definitely some long term effects and changes to the brain that have not been sufficiently studied. Luckily it will be much easier now to do those studies.
- gremlinsinc 8y agoI've never used, but even w/ health risks, it's better to legalize and decriminalize than send young mothers/fathers to jail and basically create cycle's of poverty. One of the biggest demographics of poverty in America is single-mother's who's bf's are incarcerated usually for drug offenses, though of course some might be gang and other criminal offenses - but still a lot of that has drug related connotations. If mj is regulated/sold openly then likely they won't be distributing on street corners and going to jail, or using and going to jail for possession, causing them to become even harder criminals by association and thus start life-long criminal careers, and giving up on being a good father, and provider. My philosophy is let anyone ingest anything they want (Tide pods are still legal), if they're stupid enough to die or maim themselves -- people shoot firecrackers from their hand and doesn't always end well - people just do stupid shit, but it's their choice/freedom to do so. Until they step over the line and injure others as a result of their stupid actions, let them have that freedom and the government should step out. The government should have help for those who need it to get into rehab/medical treatment and support those who want to get off hard drugs, but deal with it as a medical condition, not a criminal one. People should feel safe going to a hospital and saying I have a drug addiction and want to quit, please help me - without fear of going to jail. The government can prosecute blackmarket sales though, all night/day, I'm cool w/ that, I feel the end-user's are victims even though they choose to 'buy', I don't think they should be at fault for being a 'consumer' of goods, those capitalizing on it should be the only ones charged.
- toastermoster 8y agoI'm visiting Toronto and nobody here at the bar had heard this yet.
- gschier 8y agoIt's essentially "legal" in Canada already so no one really cares about it that much.
- rubatuga 8y agoExactly, the legality is almost a nonissue at this point, we have already reached a saturation of news regarding legalization.
- DesiLurker 8y agopurely from financial PoV I'd say legality is a big issue because now these firms can get easy financing and eventually raise money by listing in major exchanges. overall I feel pretty good about it.
- alexc05 8y agoOh no... now that it is legal, a number of the publicly traded cannabis companies will be able to actually start selling the product they’ve been stockpiling over the last year. Everything we’ve seen for estimates is that even then, we’re only going to meet 50% of the demand. Canopy Growth Corp, CBW, Aphira, Abcann... there are actually dozens of them and they’re going to be in for a good year for now and (hopefully) tremendous growth as well. Some people care very much.
- compcoffee 8y ago>a number of the publicly traded cannabis companies will be able to actually start selling the product they’ve been stockpiling over the last year Can you link to anything that says Canada is going to allow uninhibited access to the market from these companies? Currently they are licensed for medicinal use only. I'm skeptical. The government is not going to mint pot billionaires. It will be tightly controlled.
- toomanybeersies 8y agoMeanwhile in Britain, the former leader of the Conservative Party, William Hague, spoke out and claimed that the war on cannabis had been "irreversibly lost". He was quickly shut down by Theresa May, who categorically ruled out legalisation or even decriminalisation [1]. I don't understand how politicians can stand up and claim that legalisation would have substantial negatives, when every experiment with legalisation has been a success. It's the same blinkered thinking as the anti-gay marriage politicians claiming that it will cause the breakdown of families, or politicians claiming that universal healthcare in the USA clearly wouldn't work. Drug prohibition has been a categorical failure in every outcome it was intended to achieve. It has cost governments trillions of dollars and incarcerated millions, funded terrorism and civil wars, and caused the deaths of millions of people from both violence and drug related harm. Plus the harm caused by the demonisation of drugs that have potentially powerful positive effects as part of psychiatric treatment such as LSD and MDMA. All due to some concept that taking "recreational drugs" is a moral failing and hence should be illegal. At least society in genera has finally come around to realise that drug addiction and drug use are not moral failings (although my parents aren't quite convinced). Obviously we want to restrict access as much as possible to particular drugs, such as heroin or methamphetamine, which are so harmful and addictive that nobody should be using them, or GHB, where the potential for fatal overdose is so high. But penalising the end user is not the solution. People who want to take drugs will take drugs. I have never met somebody who has decided to not take a drug because it's illegal. Whether it was alcohol when underaged, smoking a joint, injecting heroin, or snorting cocaine. I know plenty of people who don't take drugs as a personal choice or because they get drug tested at work, but never was the law a reason why the abstained. It doesn't restrict supply either. Drugs are easy to find and readily available practically everywhere in the world, all that prohibition does is push up the price, fund criminals, and increase harm due to poor quality control and cut drugs. [1] https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-44526156 https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-44526156
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- maym86 8y agoSeems like with weed it's just a matter of time but in the case of the conservative government why change it if their older voter base isn't asking for it and a portion of them would have a negative reaction if they did. I guess they think the risk of loosing some of their base is too high. I love the work of David Nutt, who was fired from the role of Government drug advisor in the UK for trying to change the government's policies. He cited papers about how some drugs are less harmful then alcohol, tobacco and horse riding (equacy). He spoke truth and backed it up with scientific research and the Labour government fired him because it was inconvient. https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2009/oct/30/drugs-adviser-david-nutt-sacked https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2009/oct/30/drugs-advis... https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/law-and-order/4537874/Ecstasy-no-more-dangerous-than-horse-riding.html https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/law-and-order/453787...
- 0x4d464d48 8y agoYep. Glad we finally put this tired horse to bed.
- megaman22 8y agoHaving enjoyed a few edibles in Amsterdam, weed products are fantastic. The sense of non-anxiety is infectious. I would pay handsomely for that few fucks to give.
- thisacctforreal 8y agoConversely, a subset of the population may experience weed-induced psychosis. I experience it while high, so I only take a toke or two irregularly. I might feel as if I'm experiencing the pain of a broken leg, or that my foot is bleeding, as well as more abstract things. It also grants some introspection and lateral thinking so its not a bad time. I've heard higher amounts of CBD can counteract this, but I just mooch from friends who regularly smoke, and all their weed is high in THC / low in CBD. When its fully legal in my province I'll try a high CBD strain. Either way I'm excited for the neurological research to come out of Canada from legalization :)
- Fifer82 8y agoIs "weed-induced psychosis" an actual bad thing? Of course it sounds terrible, but do people jump out of windows, or rake their throat out scratching an itch that isn't there? Is it dangerous or just one of those things? A Nut allergy for example?
- thisacctforreal 8y agoI'm not sure. It's definitely not comfortable, and sometimes the thoughts/delusions are more advanced than phantom physical pain. My first experience with weed was a couple of years ago, and there was paranoia from the get-go. My dad also got paranoia when he tried it so he stopped. When I started smoking weed for the first time semi-regularly (~1.5 years ago, 0-4 times per week) I had become "pretty crazy", which consisted of lots of notes, voice memos, and screenshots of the notes and voice memos. The outright-crazy stuff mostly ended about a couple months after I stopped living in my car, which I had to do because of the and it getting down to -19C at night. Within the past year I haven't been near the deep-end, but my weed use has been off and on between regularly (3-7 times per week), semi-regularly (0-4), and zero. I consistently experience paranoia/psychosis whenever I get high, but it generally isn't harmful, and is sometimes silly. My friends put up with it. However very recently for 6 days, I lived in a cruel reality that existed in my head. It was caused by a long-term (2 yr) long-distance (6 mnth) codependent girlfriend who can be a capable and stubborn liar. Thankfully the extent of the terrible things I believed happened didn't actually happen–she didn't even make it to cheating on me, let alone the malicious delusions I experienced–and she happened to have suitable proof. If she hadn't I might still be in that reality. I think the episode was more to do with how she shattered trust, and some coincidental events during the 6 days, but I believe my weed usage helped my brain to create the complex unimaginable scenarios, then experience the pain fully. For a handful of hours in those 6 days I was close to tell-no-one suicide, after a history of suicidal behaviour. I'm happy to be in this reality as of a little less than 2 weeks ago, I'm also glad that I endured and survived that pain. I've become a lot stronger, more peaceful, and I feel that I have turned many corners with mental illness which I hadn't faced in the past–though perhaps I can credit that to a deeper dive into Buddhism and to the end of the codependency. We were about to restart our warm embrace the day she anchored me to this timeline, but per some timely advice from her friend we took a step back and ended it. Whether or not the psychosis is temporary, or whether it causes early-onset schizophrenia is an area I'm excited to see more research on. It's definitely not as black-and-white as many people paint it out to be, and talking about any potential downsides of the drug is sometimes met with stigmatism because you're "falling for the propaganda". One aspect of weed legalization is going to be psychosis in a subset of people who use it, and it's not exactly a safe phenomenon. There were definitely paths during my bouts with weed that don't lead to being here like this today. At the same time I'm grateful for the experiences it has given me, and the lateral thinking it has granted me. Here's a good article I found, "Pot Can Trigger Psychotic Symptoms For Some, But Do The Effects Last?" [2015] https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2015/03/06/390143641/pot-can-trigger-psychotic-symptoms-for-some-but-do-the-effects-last https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2015/03/06/3901436... For Buddhism I've been slowly reading Siddhartha over the past few weeks, and Tales Of Times Now Past off and on over the past year. I wouldn't generally write such a long, personal comment, but we're neatly away on the second page.
- okonomiyaki3000 8y agoWhat is the correlation between countries with partially privatized penal systems and strong drug laws? Yes, I realize that drugs have been illegal longer than prisons have been privately run in most cases but prison privatization is a factor in keeping them illegal, is it not? As far as I can tell, Canada has not privatized their penal system.
- exogeny 8y agoI despise getting involved in threads like this, because they always descend into whataboutism ("Oh, but alcohol is worse!, etc.), but here we go with my anecdotal evidence. Me, personally, not a huge fan. I dabbled and experimented like a good chunk of Americans, decided it wasn't for me. Not necessarily because I didn't enjoy it - although I was involved in quite a bit of team sports at the time and was worried about the health impacts - but because I saw the impact it was having on friends of mine. YMMV (of course), but I simply saw too many ambitious, energetic people suddenly become very boring, and very comfortable with doing nothing. I have absolutely no doubt that it's a drug with tons of applications medicinally to treat everything from glaucoma to social anxiety to PTSD, but for purely recreational purposes, it appeared to be quite damaging and "Oh, alcohol is too!" just isn't a strong enough argument for me to be celebrating recreational legalization.
- throwaway2048 8y agoGood thing that the fact it was illegal stopped all those people from trying huh?
- webkike 8y agoI guess putting thousands of minorities in jail is worth it because your friends didn't start venture capital funds
- ttul 8y agoIt’s not about whether using cannabis is a good idea. It’s about whether having it be a severe criminal offense is a good way to discourage use. That approach quite obviously hasn’t worked, and has resulted in various serious externalities such as criminal enterprises.
- jeisc 8y agonot everyone can take the hypocrisy of our human society and some of them will turn to substance abuse to put there heads in the sand and carry on with their existance
- draw_down 8y agoI guess that’s one way to look at it.
- mmt 8y agoOne of the topics that hasn't yet been mentioned (which surprises me, especially for HN), which I believe I saw originally when this legalization was still merely being proposed was how it would affect medical/pharmaceutical research. With such national legalization, an entire developed nation (with relatively diverse genetic backgrounds, even) will be open to clinical trials. Besides finally providing ammunition to topple the "no possible medical uses" classification in the US (and presumably other countries), it may lead to discoveries of properties of the lesser known chemicals in cannabis. It may not, but the possibility is still likely to bring something of an additional boost to Canada's biotech sector.
- thanatropism 8y agoThe sheer number of miraculous properties currently being attributed to cannabis leaves me skeptic. It went too quickly from "an anti-emetic/anti-nausea to combat side-effects of cancer treatment" to the secret of vitality and longevity.
- mmt 8y agoDon't get me wrong. I'm not ascribing any benefits to it at all. I'm merely saying that it's under-studied, considering how common it is, due to its legal status and that can now start to change.
- gwerbret 8y agoIt turns out that cannabis is, and has been, extensively researched for years, in Canada and elsewhere (researchers could apply for special access). Thanks to this work, we know that there is one, exactly one robust, reliable clinical application of a cannabis chemical that stands out: to treat otherwise hard-to-treat childhood epilepsies. The chemical responsible for this is cannabidiol, which is the most abundant non-psychoactive molecule found in the cannabis plant. The other tested clinical applications include pain relief (works great for some people against some types of pain, continually fails clinical trials in most types of pain, not better than the standard of care), nausea relief (not better than the standards of care), sleep (very variable and low quality clinical data from multiple trials), inflammation (very variable and low quality clinical data from multiple trials) and headache (very variable data, etc). Most of this work has been done on the various non-psychoactive chemicals in cannabis, popular and otherwise, since tetrahydrocannabinol is kind of useless at clinically-relevant doses. I think we'll find out in a few years that most of the hype around cannabis is just, well, hype.
- sdruskat 8y agoClutch predicted this in 2004: "Everybody move to Canada, smoke lots of pot, everybody move to Canada right now!" (Clutch, "The Mob Goes Wild", Blast Tyrant. DRT: 2004) https://youtu.be/XDCNJtK6XkE https://youtu.be/XDCNJtK6XkE And seriously, there is obviously a massive commercial interest in legalized marijuana, hence we'll see more and more moves in that direction. The correlation with de-demonization (and de-criminalization!) of 'organic' drugs and widening of personal liberties is a side-effect, albeit a welcome one.
- mgbmtl 8y agoMedical cannabis exists since 2001, then there were attempts to decriminalize (not legalize) recreational cannabis in 2003 and 2004, but both times died off because it could not pass in time before the end of the legislative session. However, it was followed by a 12 year Conservative government, sometimes a minority government, so nothing happened federally, but there were many provincial court cases that helped change how the laws were being applied.
- teekert 8y agoFunny story: I'm from the Netherlands and was 15 and on vacation in France. All the kids smoked weed, which they got in the harbor. They were surprised I never did it because it was legal in the Netherlands, all I could say was that you had to be 18 to get it so I couldn't get it.
- stabbles 8y agoIt's not legal, it's tolerated in law (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gedogen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gedogen)
- titanix2 8y agoI which it isn’t. I’ve seen a high school friend falling into that gradually: he started speaking about cannabis to the point it became its only topic of conversation. Then of course he hanged only with people with similar interest. He became weird during the breaks and needed to smoke something, anything. After that when I went to the university he became a small dealer. He got enough money from that activity to rent an apartment and buy all the newest gaming consoles. So he didn’t project himself into the future: no studies, no saving. He finally got into debt because of his girlfriend not paying her part of the rent. Sad story because it was not a dumb guy but the addiction makes him made very bad life choices. On the macro-scale, cannabis and others drugs are a big factor that fuels France suburb separatism and in some case finance terror attacks. Sorhere is a need for a real prohibition or for a legalization to stop this underground economy.
- teekert 8y agoI see the same happening with Alcohol. Should it also be illegal? Or should we not patronize people in general and help those that seek to escape life via any mind altering substances to the point that they interfere with the rest of society?
- fredley 8y agoWould making it illegal have prevented this?
- TheArcane 8y ago> The country is the second worldwide to legalise the drug's recreational use. What about the Netherlands?
- cr1895 8y agoIt's not legalized in the Netherlands. It's not criminalized due to an official stance of tolerance. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gedogen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gedogen It's complicated, and there's a lot of nuance to the Dutch model, but it is distinctly different from what you have now in Canada and in numerous US states.
- TheArcane 8y agoThat wiki link has a great example: "To give an example in layman's terms: a mother may tell her child he can't have cookies from the cookie jar. The father, regardless of his beliefs, can't tell the child it's okay to have a cookie as that would result in a conflict with the mother. If the father sees the child taking a cookie anyway, he may choose not to say anything. He may not want to punish or stop the child but can't condone the behaviour either. The father may act as if nothing had happened to avoid a conflict with both his beliefs and the mother. He "gedoogs" the behaviour."
- whazor 8y agoThis makes Canada the most advanced cannabis country! I remember reading in a Dutch news paper that Dutch weed growers were jealous of experiments in USA. The Dutch system does not allow growing and daily there is a rollup of a farm. Legalisation allows for cleaner products, new kind of products (drinkable), and other practises that professional businesses can perform. Cannabis legalisation will eventually be more and more adopted in other countries, being the first allows you to own the market.
- 1over137 8y agoWell, Netherlands has edibles in its cafes, whereas Canada is not allowing edibles in the new regime (yet).
- ihsw2 8y agoWhich is unfortunate because cannabis edibles are the most accessible way to consume it in privacy and without the odor or smokey exhaust. There is research on THC-infused drinks that match the alcoholic beverage experience in time-to-inebriation and the duration of inebriation. Current methods of cannabis consumption stretch the experience out over a long period, which naturally is unfeasible for restaurant venues and the like.
- agumonkey 8y agoI wonder how police forces will react.. imagine spending a lot of time checking people and probably dealing with tensions and now no more controls, all is fine (sic)
- cal5k 8y agoPossession has been sort of de-facto decriminalized in Canada for many years - police just don't enforce the law.
- atheriel 8y agoThis is only true in major metro areas -- that is, Montreal, Vancouver and Toronto. Most smaller cites/towns or rural regions are far less tolerant. (In fact, differential enforcement by regional police departments was one of the more compelling arguments in favour of decriminalization.)
- kentf 8y agoLots of Canadian tech companies hiring folks :) Come work with me at Hubba and take on Alibaba. @kentf on twitter.
- chx 8y agoI have a very simple world view which, I guess, could be considered a radically liberal one: everyone can do as they please as long as it doesn't tread on the same rights of another person. You want to inject, snort or sniff something? Go ahead! It's your body, after all. Neither I, nor any government should have anything to say about this. Obviously, you should not operate a vehicle while intoxicated and we need to have a conversation on who pays how much for health care -- but are we going to punish obese people too...? So that's a more complicated conversation but in itself no drug use should be criminal. Along these lines I only have one question: why only cannabis? (I am Canadian.)
- schrectacular 8y agoIsn't there some friction here with regards to nationalized health care? Society at large will pay for the poor health decisions of individual citizens.
- stanmancan 8y agoI’m honestly curious how many people don’t do drugs solely because it’s illegal? How many people are thinking “I’d love to try meth; if only it were legal!”
- Afton 8y agoRelated: I'd take steroids if I could do it legally under the supervision of an endocrinologist, with products that have all the audit-trails of modern pharmacology (rather than "Bob's basement grow juice"). But the alternative seems too risky to me, especially since it's illegal and the consequences of being caught in my case are quite severe.
- stanmancan 8y agoTrue but would that have any effect on health care? I was more specifically referring to people using hard drugs because it’s no longer illegal.
- 8y ago
- moistoreos 8y agoCanada now has a huge head start in the West for business to develop legitimate markets that will have a strong hold for decades. I wonder how many U.S. businesses will move because of this. We all know where the money will be.
- dmix 8y agoThis is a great and underrated point. We were handed a huge economic advantage over the US and other western countries in terms of developing the talent and infrastructure to support weed sales. I know someone involved in the industry in Canada and they flew to Uruguay, the first country to legalise it, to learn from them and create connections. This role will be pioneered by Canada in many ways and it's much different than decriminalization. There's tons of money to be made long term, not just within Canada but exporting knowledge and systems. I have a feeling this will be influencing many parliaments and congresses around the world to look into doing the same and other partner countries won't be far away.
- sandworm101 8y ago>>...talent and infrastructure to support weed sales. It is a plant, a crop like any other. As a practical matter it is no more difficult than farming apples or corn. (It actually grows wild over much of Ontario.) The only specialized infrastructure is that dictated by regulation. Sure, Canada does have a jump on building out the regulatory infrastructure, but that isn't something we can sell. We aren't going to be exporting that infrastructure to other countries because they will have their own regulations demanding a different infrastructure. As for supporting weed sales, there are "experts" on selling pot in every country in the world. That skillset is well understood. UBC will not see a wave of foreign students looking to lean the mysteries of how to sell weed. We aren't going to see Canadians flying around the world establishing new markets and trade links. This stuff is already being grown in closets from Dubai to Alaska.
- newest_user_ 8y agoIt's no more difficult, but farming apples is not the same skill set as farming corn. Yes, many skills will transfer but the details need to be worked out. There are many questions that need answers before being successful -- especially on an industrial scale.