15 ms·
The great video game exodus
- ogennadi 8y agotl;dr: why people who value stable employment are leaving the game industry.
- oppositelock 8y agoSadly, most of the video game industry is a crappy place to work. I speak from experience here, having been the lead game engine developer in a studio owned by one of the largest publishers. I don't want to out them, so I'm being vague on purpose. There is little work life balance. No matter what happens, no matter how many people you destroy, you will do whatever it takes to ship in time for the Christmas season. If you miss Christmas, your ROI plummets. Huge franchise games are an exception, but those of us not writing FIFA Soccer, Madden NFL, or HALO really care about Christmas. Why do people accept this kind of employer abuse? It's because there is this attitude of having your name in the credits of a game being some huge honor, for which you will sacrifice life, pay, and health. People who work on games are passionate about gaming, they love to play them, work on them, and the rewarding feeling of shipping your game is intoxicating. When you sacrifice everything to make Christmas, you sacrifice code quality, maintainability, even reproducibility, leading to a very slow start on your next iteration, and the cycle of crunch/crash repeats itself. If you are into games, you put up with this for a while, but over time, you see your friends and colleagues get jobs in other industries, and they make more and are happier working on non-game stuff you consider boring. You celebrate with them as they buy their first home, or a nice car, and start to think that maybe the fun work (when it is fun), isn't worth being paid a lot less. It's not like game companies give stock options, and whatever profits are made don't trickle down. Eventually, you get older, you start a family, and you want to spend time with them, and a game company isn't going to be friendly to that. The benefits aren't as good, the crunches are still there, the pay isn't great, so you decide to move on. You hire some young developer, who is gushing with excitement about working on games, as you were once upon a time, and you do your best to train them without letting your disappointment in the industry show, and you move one, the cycle repeats. I honestly have no idea why it is this way. Naturally, not all studios are like this, and there are exceptions, but the majority of the less successful studios are stuck in this seemingly unbreakable cycle. I have since worked in many software companies, some of the making exciting things, others doing dull enterprise things, and I've been a far happier person in all of them. The passion for games is still there, ever since I bought my Atari 2600 with paper route money, but as an engineer, I'm done, never again.
- asfasgasg 8y ago> I honestly have no idea why it is this way. An endless supply of passionate, naive, and young talent. I guess at least 50% of my graduating CS class at one point or another wished to create a game. Far fewer wished to create a database engine, an operating system, or a B2B web service. When you have that many people who want to make a particular type of software, getting a chance to do so acts as something economists call a compensating differential. Working on games is actually part of a game developer's compensation, and thus the companies can afford to pay them less in other ways.
- paulie_a 8y agoBut 99 percent will never create any of those things. They will work on them but never create it.
- oppositelock 8y agoThe supply is not endless for good software engineers, I had a very difficult time hiring junior folks, since the Facebooks, Googles, and Apples of the world pay so well, and yet, some people are delusional enough to accept. Artists are easier to hire, and I think that your explanation holds nicely. The easiest to hire are playtesters, who think playing games for a living is awesome, until they realize that making Kirby jump over that cloud 800 times to reproduce bug is hell. Playtesters have the biggest swing from excitement to disillusionment.
- mchahn 8y ago> I honestly have no idea why it is this way. Think of an actor coming to hollywood. It's not that different.
- vvanders 8y ago+1 to pretty much everything you said, in addition I doubled my take-home pay the moment I left the industry. Having a life/spouse and that industry just aren't compatible in the large majority of cases. Heck, I saw 3 divorces on the last team I worked on.
- segmondy 8y ago
- bdefore 8y agoThe article dabbles, but ultimately misses an opportunity to present the piece I want to read: that the ideal shape of a game development team is not unlike an early stage software startup. Remain small, take your time, stay healthy, and put some love into it. Recent years have birthed some real gems from teams of one, three, or single digits. In this category I'd vouch for Hollow Knight, Celeste, Ghost of a Tale, and Crawl. Whether these games make enough money to warrant the investment of their creators versus being at a large company is a worthy debate, but to me it's apparent that we're in a golden age of games made by small groups of visionary creators. Put another way, there's an exodus from unwieldy large teams that lack responsibility and a sense of craft and ownership. There's also the problem of 'backlog fatigue'. There's only so much time in life for playing any game, which makes you purchase them much more carefully and for different reasons than you did even five years ago. For me it's much more in the spirit of thanks and support than as a transaction.
- Krasnol 8y agoRimWorld comes into my mind. One head-developer. Small crew. Awesome product with a huge community creating additional content through Modding. I hope more of this will come out of this exodus.
- rocky1138 8y agoFor me, the ideal shape of a game development team is to just make games for yourselves. If you find that people love your games, too, then great! If not, then that's great too. Once you start chasing and building on success, the work stops being about scratching your own itch, and moves away from building stuff for yourselves.
- georgeecollins 8y agoGamasutra could write an article about the ideal shape of a game development team so that all those people out in the industry could learn what they are doing wrong. It sounds like the bdefore is the person who should write that article.
- jayd16 8y ago>Put another way, there's an exodus from unwieldy large teams that lack responsibility and a sense of craft and ownership. Is there data for this? EA, Activision, Blizzard, Ubisoft etc seem to be doing fine with massive teams. The game industry seems to be moving with the rest of the entertainment industry. As technology progresses, the barrier to entry lowers and its easier for small teams to make things. Sure there are some great independent films but we continue to see Disney behemoth blockbusters breaking records every year or so. I assume there will continue to be room for all types.
- justinhj 8y agoMy first job was bagging groceries in Safeway, and I remember vividly watching the minute hand on a big clock slowly tick around to the end of my shift. I was thinking, when I graduate university I don't want a job where I am always so bored I'm just wishing my life away so I can go home. I can honestly say after 25 years working on video games I have never once been bored. There is a vibrant industry out there which has never had so many different platforms and delivery mechanisms. In the next 10 years we will only see more. My advice for those that want to make games is try it out; don't be shy to move around different companies and work on different types of technology until you find something you enjoy and team you like to work with. Do the same every few years and you'll have a long career ahead of you. And most importantly, do not crunch. A few extra hours of work here and there is fine, but any extended death march is bad for your health, bad for the product and ultimately bad for the company.
- vvanders 8y agoEasy to say, hard/impossible to do. When you're paycheck to paycheck(which I was in gamedev, yay high col) "not crunching" isn't really a choice when you risk getting labeled "not a team player" and slow-rolled towards the door.
- shawn 8y agoThis is partly because most gamedevs lack confidence. There's nothing stopping you from walking out from abuse -- the door is right there. It's harder to admit to yourself when your job is abusive. Harder still: admitting you don't really like your job, and you're ok with finding a new one. Finding a new job can be difficult for gamedevs, but transitioning out of gamedev is surprisingly easy. At the end of the day, it's our collective willingness to put up with abuse that allows crunch to happen.
- mrguyorama 8y ago>There's nothing stopping you from walking out from abuse What magic world do you live in that doesn't have rent and grocery expenses?
- georgeecollins 8y agoI grew up in a time when no one thought there was a chance to have a job making video games. I remember before I finished college, someone from EA called me about a shareware game I made (distributed on a floppy! imagine). In those days EA was a small company. The guy was trying to see if I wanted a job and I didn't even think to ask. Later, in grad school, another small company, Activision put a poster advertising jobs. I'm glad I replied. What I have learned after twenty plus years in games is that you can make enough money to retire, but nothing guarantees a chance to keep working. At the top level the pressure is intense and new talent is always cycling in. No one writes an article about how uncertain a career is in film, or music, or theater, because everyone knows it is nothing you bet on. I was super lucky to be in the write place at the right time, like someone who got a job at a record label in the 70's or a movie studio in the 80's. I got to do something exciting that I didn't know could be a career. There is probably something else I have never heard of happening right now which is what a young person ought to be doing.
- apatters 8y agoGreat comment, as a slight tangent this line stood out to me: > There is probably something else I have never heard of happening right now which is what a young person ought to be doing. The way you point out these special opportunities that existed every decade is very interesting. The common theme is an exciting new industry with a talent shortage. I guess mine was getting into programming at the dawn of the Internet. But I have a lot of friends in their 20s, and no one seems to have found that thing--it might not exist for this generation which would be very concerning. (The obvious answer would be that it's blockchain but I don't agree with that answer...)
- toasterlovin 8y agoAugmented reality and machine learning for autonomous machines (cars, drones, robots, etc).
- taneq 8y agoYou wouldn't say it's machine learning? Despite the daily "sky is falling, AI is dead" posts on HN, we've very suddenly (over a few years, faster than the home computer revolution by far!) gained the ability to spoon some of this deep learning 'secret sauce' on top of just about any problem of the form "map X to Y" with a fair chance of it 'just working', and it's accessible enough that individuals can get results that would have been impossible for a high end research lab ten years ago. Just because strong AI hasn't sprung fully formed from a CNN yet, it doesn't mean there isn't a huge range of newly-tractable problems just waiting for someone to solve them.
- debacle 8y ago> Only seventeen percent of the 30,000 attendees to this year’s Game Developers Conference worked in the industry for seven to ten years, and just thirteen percent for between eleven and fifteen years. So 30% of attendees have 7+ years experience? Strange way to slice statistics.
- crazybit 8y agoSupply and demand. Game developers: very sexy, easy to show off, has a (very) large supply of talent. Pay not bad, not good, work schedule very demanding. COBOL developer: extremely unsexy, almost don't want to admit it publicly. Tiny supply, relatively much larger demand. Pay very good. Work schedule very predictable, not demanding. Almost a vacation. Supply and demand. Ignore at your own peril.
- backpropaganda 8y agoWhich areas do you think have large demand and low supply at the moment?
- phendrenad2 8y agoRuby on Rails development.
- tonyedgecombe 8y agoMaintenance, everybody wants to work on greenfield but there is a ton of maintenance work out there.
- humanrebar 8y agoIt's easy to slide into a maintenance role. I wouldn't say the pay is especially better. There aren't "maintenance engineers" making substantially more than "development engineers".
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- eksemplar 8y agoI don’t think it’s really about the availability of talent but rather about the business end. Video games are projects and comparable to movies. You need different talent to perform different tasks at different times. Once that talent delivers, you probably won’t need them again. Unless you’re an established studio, that’s capable of rotating staff from project to project, then there is really no feasible way of keeping staff around that is no longer necessary. COBOL programmers on the other hand aren’t workin projects where they become unnecessary, because the systems they work on are forever. Basically you can say, that nobody is working on Rail Toad Tycoon today, but there are COBOL programmers who are still maintaining main frame software that was build before Rail Road Tycoon even released. I’m not sure how you’d run video gaming differently though.
- Fej 8y agoI believe that part of the problem is the attitude of major publishers towards game development. There is absolutely no consideration for the artistic value of their works - they will manipulate the end product, and the developers, in any way to maximize short-term profit at the cost of everything else. Take as an example - the current loot box (gambling) controversy. Publishers have pushed this mechanic to an extreme. They are only relenting now (somewhat) due to the scrutiny of various governments. That's how far they'll go to earn an extra buck, even if it compromises the rest of the work. Of the point of the article: publishers will continue to hire almost exclusively temp workers, since it is more profitable in the short term. They will do this until they cannot; they know that day will come eventually, but not in the short term, so they are unconcerned with the problem, and will continue milking their various resources for every last dollar. Sony, Paramount, Disney, etc. all respect the motion picture as an art form, despite being for-profit, since they know that defiling their products will end poorly in the long term. EA, Activision, Bethesda, and the like have no such respect for the art of video games. Perhaps it is because the medium is in such an early stage of its life.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- stevenwoo 8y agoAlmost every worker/contributor in the movie/TV industry in North America is represented by a union/guild or is trying to get into one, there are non union projects/studios but those are in the minority.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dgudkov 8y ago>There is absolutely no consideration for the artistic value of their works. Artistic value derives from uniqueness. The commoditization of the game industry may be a sign that not much distinctive artistic value is created nowadays, that games increasingly look like each other.
- kraig911 8y agoI think the video game industry is literally run like the movie industry except there is no union to help the people who make the actual magic happen unlike say the entertainment industry. I realize that some hate unions but some things on this world literally could not happen unless we respect people, their time, and their families. Some things are worth more than money and I"m grateful for the games I get to play. I wish there was a way to say give people in the gaming industry money, say grants, and artistic investment - I bet there are some great ideas out there that some burned out artist or developer will never get to realize because he got burned by a company who wants super solder 17... I see these games coming out of other countries that are amazing and these studios seemed to have got grants and investment from the government i.e. HellBlade, , . Do we not do that here stateside? It's also unfortunate some of the most talented dev's I've met even quit CS field entirely after doing game development. Do video game creators get the same mental health services those in the entertainment unions get?
- jadei 8y agoRe: grants and investment from the government, after the debacle with 38 studios funded from Rhode Island I am sure many are very wary now.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- greggman 8y agoIs it run like the movie industry? AFAIK in the movie industry few publishers and or studios actually have any production staff on hand. Instead what happens is a core team write and pitch a movie idea. Only after they've gotten funding and done preproduction then they hire contractors short term (1-3 months) to make the movie. In games most studios hire all the staff. They then have the issue that between projects 90-95% of the staff have nothing to do. There's no income and the company is burning money. Unions may or may not help those movie contractors get a good price for their services but they don't guarantee jobs any more than the game industry AFAIK. Should video games be run more like the movie industry? As for your idea of "getting burned" because a company wants to make a different game, I have a game designer friend who used to think that way. He seemed to forget he was being paid $80k a year for his game ideas regardless of if they got used or not. If he wanted to profit from his own ideas he needed top stop selling them for salary to his employer.
- ryanmarsh 8y agoBuilding games and being over worked can’t possibly be worse than a soul sucking 40 hours as an equally underpaid enterprise dev. I’d rather be over worked but making something interesting rather than sitting in meetings all day barely writing any code and going home with no mental energy left and nothing to show for it.
- gordaco 8y agoIn my experience, enterprise devs are not really underpaid (this could vary a lot depending on your geographical area, of course). I also don't find corporate jobs to be exhausting at all, but YMMV and it probably varies from person to person. I don't care sitting in meeting if I know that they will end in time; I'd rather be coding but I'm getting paid anyway. Some years ago I had a hip, theoretically non-soul sucking, job (not video games, but still, a hip software company from my country). The hours were horrible and the pay wasn't that awesome. I now have a 8-to-4 corporate job and I love it. There is little stress; the technical side is a little outdated but still acceptable, and comfortable to work with; the pay is nice; the hours are sane; the managers are reasonable and planning works; and so on. Sleeping as much as I want every day, and not being overworked or stressed over my job, are awesome, underrated things. The projects might not be super-awesome, but I learned a lot of time ago that if you want something fun to work on, your best bet is to look for it outside your job. That way, you stay in control: you work at your pace, you decide when to start or stop a new project, and in the case of software, you can spend time gold-plating projects to your liking.
- nottorp 8y agoWhy do you think game development is interesting? It is when you're in a 3 person team where you do everything, but in the AAA teams you may be assigned arrow behaviour as your sole mind numbing task... 60-80 hours per week... :) And don't think you're going to write engine code, no one writes engines if they can avoid it.
- seba_dos1 8y agoOf course it can. For starters, during so-called "crunch time", 40 hours isn't that much. Social pressure to take overtime is so high it actually takes some courage to take a strong anti-crunch stance in this industry.
- Paul_S 8y agoIt's been the same story for the last 20 years (or longer but that's when I started). There's an infinite supply of young naive people who will work for poor pay and under terrible conditions because "games". There's nothing you can do to help. Young people are physically incapable of learning from someone else's experience. Companies are happy with that situation because they don't mind not having experienced devs. Those demand higher salaries or sane working hours - can't allow those. I mean what's next? Pension funds?!
- throwaway59928 8y agoSeveral people in these comments are comparing the video game industry to the movie industry. I think the key difference is that the movie industry tends to value experience with everyone but the actors, with the exception of big name stars. I know lots of people in the movie industry, from set builders to producers, and they’ve all been working in the industry for years except for the actors and actresses. The video game industry doesn’t seem to value experience with the exception of a few big names and some developers with rare talents. Not a single one of the game devs I worked with 15 years ago are still in the game industry.
- Kenji 8y ago“The day that I joined I had to sign a contract that basically said anything I created during or outside of company time is owned by ZeniMax. Even on my own hardware, or at a game jam.” Kelly wavered for a few moments – signing the contract would limit any chance to work on side projects -- then decided to sign regardless. “To be clear, many people worked on personal projects and for the most part ZeniMax didn’t care,” he says. “I think it was more on principle [that] I had a problem.” No, this is a legitimate concern. Clauses like this should be illegal. What you do in your spare time is yours. What the hell, what are you, a slave? These clauses are there to disincentivize you doing things beside your work, so that your employer can take up even more room in your life. I would never sign such a contract.
- scottlegrand2 8y agoSo basically, EA Spouse rules still apply? So glad I chose tech over the game industry. https://www.rollingstone.com/glixel/features/ea-spouse-14-years-later-w517096 https://www.rollingstone.com/glixel/features/ea-spouse-14-ye...
- nottorp 8y agoJust for completeness, the situation in 2004 for those who have forgotten or were too young back then: https://ea-spouse.livejournal.com https://ea-spouse.livejournal.com
- holografix 8y agoI think the comparison with actors is a valid one and we can draw parallels with the YouTube “creator movement” basically actors/performers who are too smart to fight the herd and went out on their own. If you’re being asked to work more than 50-60 hour weeks consistently and not paid for it you must do what you can to change jobs/industry/city/country.
- acou_nPlusOne_t 8y agoEven if you got experience, you will never get leverage in thise industry. The reason is the mythos of the gamedeveloper, drawing in new people (mostly young "I-want-to-make-a-game" idealists) with Stars in theire eyes. Its the same-thing, that allows Hollywood to abuse young actresses- who will not resist, because there "are millions more where you came from". Supply and demand. Idealists make for excellent rocket fuel, and if they are burned out, you dump the husk and make another run for it with new material. You cant unionize this, because this cycle is the default operation mode and students joining up dont have unions or reasons to join one. You cant either unionize the actors or fashion-model industry. What can be done - is destroying the glamorous image in the head of the youth. Which has partially happened allready, and is why everybody wants to go indy.
- abraae 8y ago"dump the husk" Great, I can see it written in the spine of an evil management book!
- duwease 8y agoI don't think this is new. 20 years ago, I loved game programming.. I even chose a game dev library in C++ as my senior (college) project. But my obsession also led me to read all I could about the industry, and the stories were the same. I got nervous about the 14-hour-a-day, 7-day-a-week eternal crunch time, the pay, the job security, the lack of prospects without moving around. I chickened out. I still like my job, but it's nothing like the passion I felt when I built games. Still, I don't think that passion is enough to justify the strain it would put on my family through financial risk, not to mention my work/life balance (or in this case, work/slightly less work balance). Since it was the same then as now, I suspect it may continue to be. After all, it's a job with inherent joy for people who want it, and those tend to have the luxury of materially rewarding workers less. Much as bars can basically pay bands little to nothing in order to have live music, because there's no shortage of people wanting it just for the inherent joy, I imagine game companies will continue to have a pool of creative technicians willing to work for less. Maybe the higher barrier of entry to learn tech work will change something one day, but it doesn't appear to have done so, so far.
- bsenftner 8y ago"The Games Industry" is a shit hole of illegal corporate exploitation. I am one of those rare "long term game developers" - but not, because I left after 15 years of trying to develop some/any collaboration against the exploitation. I was one of the OS developers for the 3DO and the first PlayStation, a lead tech at both E.A. and Sony, lead engineer of games I know you played, and I can state first hand the illegal employment behavior is rampant to the degree those in the industry are 100% blind to actual ethical working conditions. Life is too short to spend time in an industry of assholes. I love my friends, but collectively the games industry is a hate machine, exploiting the enthusiasm of impressionable youth to create mindless crap - just like the Abe's Oddysee world of corporate slave drivers.
- AndrewKemendo 8y agoGod bless you. I was the only person I ever met with a R.E.A.L 3DO, but I loved it even though everyone else had a Playstation. Gex, Way of the Warrior, Alone in the Dark, Another World and Fifa 95 were my life after school etc...
- bsenftner 8y agoI wrote the video subsystem as well as the video playback for RoadRash 3DO
- pascalxus 8y agoIn the past, I've read so many horror stories of working at EA, that I always steered away from the gaming industry for nearly a decade. Then one day, a recruiter contacted me and told me all about a notable exception: Kabam. I ended up working at Kabam for 5 years and I have to say it was one of the best places I have ever worked, with decent pay and good work life balance, with lots of perks. I realize this is a rare exception, in the games industry.
- walru 8y agoExtraordinarily long hours, toxic open office work environments (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w6vCBQKN0F8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w6vCBQKN0F8), poor management guided by auteurs with nothing to back up their plight and a culture of being outed when you're too old, or overpaid, is why I'm no longer there. I think the best answer to this is the fact you can very easily still create outside of these environments on your own. The trouble is finding the other like-minded folks who still want to work in the industry but are outside of it.
- balt_s 8y agoCreated this account to echo your comment; I strongly encourage everyone who is curious about entering the industry (especially youth/students) to view this brief and cogent video. Seeing it brought back many fond memories of auld.
- CalRobert 8y agoVery, very related - "Don't do for money what others do for love" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16792942 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16792942
- thedailymail 8y agoBut isn't this the exact rule that Bill Gates violated when he moved to build a software business at a time when software development (for personal computers) was mainly a hobby?
- abraae 8y agoExcept he also loved it himself.
- psyc 8y agoI’ve been a game developer for decades. Companies that are categorically in the game industry tend to be full of shitheads and oversized egos. I have mostly solved the problem by working in game organizations within BigCos.
- OliverJones 8y agoThe talent pool for game designers and developers is very broad and, sorry to say, very shallow in places. It's like the talent pool for screen actors. There are ten thousand hopefuls for one hundred decent jobs. Many of them are motivated by good things: respect for the games they've played, a hope for success, and the motive of the Blues Brothers ("We're on a mission from God!") This means the executives in the game business can get away with exploiting people, in the ways this article describes. I know a young female aspiring game designer who's been laid off a few times, dissed,, blamed for silly stuff, and generally mistreated. One exec even tried (without success) the casting-couch schtick on her. Her diligent work to learn her craft (rigorous BFA, internships, lots of practice) hasn't helped as much as it would have were she an aspiring software engineer, accountant, plumber, or truck driver. It's a problem with the blockbuster approach to game sales. Many people are trying to solve this problem. Unity and Unreal lower the barrier for indie game developers. Humble Bundle did a good job getting exposure for indies, and still do even after the Steam buyout. The free-to-play model (with small ongoing transactions) has potential to stabilize game-publisher finances. But the big win will come when games of various sizes can all succeed. Standing in the way of that is the superstar / blockbuster business model. In the meantime, I hope my young friend gets an executive position.
- ymck 8y agoThe truth is that in "gig" based economies guilds and unions are essential(portability of seniority, benefits, etc). If done right it benefits both the employer and the low and high end of workers. Also, the truth is that in tech this hasn't caught on because, we just like to think we are special.
- banku_brougham 8y agoI read the whole article and I didn’t get a sense of exodus at all — its just a steady and high rate of churn in an industry with surplus new talent willing to burn it all in order to ship on time.
- AndrewKemendo 8y agoWhen he was ten years old he would write letters to his favorite game developers and publishers describing his love for their games and seeking advice on how to become a game maker. Yea I did that too. I fondly remember one such response from Seth Robinson, the creator of the Dink Smallwood PC RPG. I was asking him how to get into making RPGs and if I could help him on some project in the future maybe. I believe I was 14 at the time and had done some mods to MCM, Carmageddon and was working on a space shooter with the 3DRAD and the just unveiled Unreal engine. His curt response was that he wouldn't start talking with me for less than $100,000. Always a great way to interact with kids who are trying to get into your industry.