38 ms·
Completely Silent Computer
- sp332 9y agoIf you're removing the GPU heatsink and fans, buying a dual-fan card isn't necessarily a dealbreaker depending on the design. For example, this 1050Ti from EVGA has two fans but the board itself is pretty small. https://imgur.com/a/AFvUlZs https://imgur.com/a/AFvUlZs https://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814487292 https://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E1681448...
- TwoNineA 9y agoThere is one flaw in his setup, he doesn't seem to cool the VRMs of his video card (only memory chips). Not doing that is asking for trouble when load is put on the card.
- thinkingemote 9y agoYou can fanless video cards of the same spec as in the article (1050ti) e.g at https://www.quietpc.com/palit-ne5105t018g1-1070h https://www.quietpc.com/palit-ne5105t018g1-1070h (I can personally recommend both the vendor and the card!)
- TwoNineA 9y agoFor these cards the giant heatsink is connected to the VRMs so cooling is a non issue. In OP's pictures, he seems to have replaced the heatsink of his card with one from the case without cooling the VRMs. From personal experience, I tried to silent cool an RX 550 (50 watt vs 75 watt of 1050 ti) without VRM heatsink and the VRM temnperatures were up to 100-103C during a torture test. Adding a fan lowered the temperatures by 20C.
- Ratiofarmings 9y agoBoth the hi-side and lo-side mosfets (they might be 2in1 on a card like this) are rated for their amperage at 125c and are typically capable of dissipating that through their contact with the pcb. Airflow is nice, but not required. Neither is direct contact with a heatsink. Those are for higher end cards (who also rate their mosfets at 125c for good reasons. Max tCase for mosfets is usually 150c. Beyond that they just die.
- onli 9y agoIf I remember correctly that card still needs some air flow to work, normally provided from case fans. That would be problematic in a completely fanless system. A Ryzen APU might be better, as the case would cool it.
- old-gregg 9y agoCorrect. I did the same thing with RX 560 and it died within 2 weeks even though "GPU temp" was never above 60C (normal desktop use, I never gamed on it).
- tp69 9y agoThe design of the DB4 is such that the graphics card is mounted vertically. Fresh, cool air flows in through the grille at the bottom, over the VRM area, then up and out the top of the case. I have more small heat sinks I could put on the mosfets, but they are relatively low profile so I'm not sure they would improve things much. A single, large heat sink, with long fins (that would protrude above and beyond the nearby capacitors) would seem to make more sense — but given there are no mounting points I could use to clamp it down I'd be a bit concerned about the long-term effect of torque. Opinions and suggestions are welcome.
- recursive 9y agoThis says that a completely silent computer would be 0dB. But it's a logarithmic scale, so I think it should say -Infinity dB. This is admittedly pointless pedantry.
- armadsen 9y agoYep. 0dB is the limit of human hearing, not absolute silence. There are anechoic chambers with noise levels below 0dB.
- Retric 9y agoYet if you sit in one you hear the blood pumping through your ears so it's reasonable to use human perception as a baseline when that's what they care about.
- squozzer 9y agohttps://gizmodo.com/5899502/the-quietest-place-on-earth-will-drive-you-insane-within-45-minutes https://gizmodo.com/5899502/the-quietest-place-on-earth-will...
- rjbwork 9y agoI've been in one. Back in HS, we took a trip to the GIANT anechoic chamber at Georgia Tech. It was incredible. If someone was facing away from you and yelling as loud as they could, you could barely hear it from behind them. You're standing on basically a giant net on top of a pit of foam blocks, and every wall is wildly shaped undulating foam. It's really surreal and a number of people actually became nauseated at the sensation.
- kees99 9y agoPretty sure there's going to be some coil whine. Probably above 0dB.
- jiveturkey 9y agoHe’s using the term incorrectly to begin with so corrections aren’t really possible. Of course it can’t be completely silent. Heat generates air movement which is “sound”. By 0dB he means 0dB SPL which is give or take correct.
- fhood 9y agoAll of my raspberry pi's are completely silent. On a more serious note, would it be possible to achieve said silence without too much compromise by some variant of water cooling, with a good sized reservoir? And use the heat to drive circulation rather than a pump?
- akanet 9y agoProbably not - you need to push water over the radiator blocks at a decent clip and I'm pretty sure you need pump. You could try a heatpipe into a big radiator that sits in a big tank of water, though.
- gnode 9y agoAn alternative to this is the mineral oil PC, where you submerge the whole thing.
- sp332 9y agoSure, here's a quad-Opteron build (55W each) from 2005 https://web.archive.org/web/20170308162629/http://www.linuxjournal.com/node/8292/print https://web.archive.org/web/20170308162629/http://www.linuxj...
- mimac 9y agoThere are always peltier units, but horribly inefficient...
- gnode 9y agoPeltiers are only really worth it if you need sub-ambient temperatures (i.e. extreme overclocking). You then need to carry away the heat of the Peltier in addition to that of the processor, making expelling the heat even more difficult than it was before.
- bluGill 9y agoMaybe, but it is tricky. Because there is no pump the water will flow much slower, therefore you need much bigger pipes. Think at least 3x the diameter you would think you need. Also because you are depending on thermo siphon you have to ensure you have to ensure the water flow works with gravity. The heat source must be at bottom, and the radiator must be at the top. You don't get any flexibility go around something that might be in the way, the pipes must always be sloped in the correct direction. If you are using anything other than water you need to pay attention to specific gravity (and how it changes with temperature), and viscosity. Probably something else that I'm not thinking of. It probably can work. I have an antique tractor that uses such a system. A 2.2L, 16hp engine, has 24L of coolant, and the pipes between the engine and radiator are noticeably bigger than my truck with a 7.3L 250HP engine. Remember that this was designed to run at just under the boiling point of water (antifreeze is too modern). You probably want your computer considerably cooler, which implies even larger systems than a similar active one.
- heimji 9y agoSame system on silent laptop :)
- mlok 9y agoI'd love to know more about this : what "system" did you use on a silent laptop, how do you get rid of the fan ?
- SeanLuke 9y agoI'm not sure. Is it wise to be putting heat pipes that close to an electrolytic capacitor?
- egfx 9y agoA long time ago I was dreaming of a completely silent computer and bought the Antec 350 for my birthday. https://www.bjorn3d.com/2004/11/antec-phantom-350w-psu/ https://www.bjorn3d.com/2004/11/antec-phantom-350w-psu/ It cannot power a single mid-range video card today or pretty much any modern equipment. I would have loved to be able to use it. Anybody making fanless PSU's today?
- dingo_bat 9y ago> Anybody making fanless PSU's today? There's a lot of PSUs nowadays that will work with the fans completely off up to ~75% of their rated power. Which is adequate for most situations.
- aesthetics1 9y agoSeasonic does. They make excellent power supplies. I've used a 400w fanless in a media center PC, but they also make higher wattage units like this for example: https://seasonic.com/prime-titanium-fanless https://seasonic.com/prime-titanium-fanless
- blattimwind 9y agoThe 2nd gen Seasonic 400 W is easily good enough to run a 1070 Ti and a 100 W CPU.
- polshaw 9y agoA higher wattage than 400W is utterly pointless for a fanless PSU; if you need to dissipate constant loads of >400W of heat, you will need a fan somewhere (exotic options like mineral oil cooling aside).
- vertexFarm 9y agoWell you can always add absurd amounts of surface area and mass to the heat sinks to take advantage of thermal inertia, or possibly change components to simply raise your safe operating temperatures to absurd levels. But that's pretty involved. Spacecraft take care of huge temperatures with no fans or even conductive or convective cooling. But that requires enormous, sail-sized surfaces to take advantage of extremely slow radiative cooling. It would be an exotic option for sure. And not something you'll find pre-built.
- jtbayly 9y agoI've heard noise (high-frequency whine, changing depending on load) from my laptop power supply at times, I think. I wonder if that's not a problem for some reason on desktop power supplies.
- onli 9y agoIt can be a problem, also with PC psus. Not all of them have coil whine, and it depends on the connected components, but it definitely happens. In my case it is the monitor that of all my components has the worst coil whine (actually the PWM brightness regulation).
- Drdrdrq 9y agoIn my case also, unless I set the sound volume of built in speakers to 0. Since they are not connected anyway that solves it for me. It is still annoying that we have to put up with this though.
- stefan_ 9y agoIt's not limited to the power supply, ceramic capacitors are on basically all complex circuit boards now, and most of them will readily sing and whine. It can be eliminated through careful design (reducing ripple) or paying nanocents more for the caps, but as far as I can tell Lenovo doesn't give a fuck.
- 21 9y agoI have a 5V-2A phone charger which whines. So it can happen even on low-powered devices.
- jtbayly 9y agoYes, I have one, too. I can hear it from across the room on a quiet night. My wife thinks I'm crazy because I often go to unplug it, but she can't hear it.
- betaby 9y agoIt's a problem, most desktop PSU, even from recognized brands produce coil whine, especially after 3+ years.
- DINKDINK 9y ago>[it] doesn’t have a single fan. Indeed, it doesn’t have any moving parts at all. It’s totally silent — 0dB. Things without moving parts emit sound. LED lights are a simple example. Anytime you have a wave -- be it mechanical or electrical -- you'll have some of the harmonics will 'bleed' into the acoustic spectrum.
- blattimwind 9y agoIME components need to be selected for low coil whine (and the related brethren, namely electrostriction and piezoelectrics), because it easily dwarfs (both in loudness and annoyance) the air flow and fan noise of a well-built air-cooled machine.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- peterjlee 9y agoAlternatively, you could put your computer in a tank of mineral oil. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2V06LLTNxc4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2V06LLTNxc4
- FRex 9y agoThere's also using ARM, Calyos stuff[0] Some old Macs were also 'potentially' silent if you were to today remove the HDD and the optical drive, which were the only mechanical parts[1]. [0] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LauL5JxYis https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LauL5JxYis [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power_Mac_G4_Cube https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power_Mac_G4_Cube
- howard941 9y agoIt's a cool idea but that particular build has 4 fans.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ythn 9y agoSometimes I can "hear" my processor working through my headphones. I'm not sure how, but, for example, when I scroll down a page I can hear high frequency chirping in my headphones which stops as soon as I stop scrolling.
- mixmastamyk 9y agoThat's generally caused by poor shielding between components, to save on cost.
- sliken 9y agoLikely it's your GPU or LCD panel leaking RF. Try turning your monitor off and see if scrolling is still audible.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- blattimwind 9y agoThese phenomena are more typically caused by ground loops and shield currents in the computer itself. Reordering plug-in cards (e.g. moving a sound card to a different slot) or isolating/removing the slot bracket can help.
- sliken 9y agoI do find that generally USB headphones do better and minimizing interference/noise. Which makes sense, having a sound card on your motherboard is pretty much a worst case scenario. With USB it's not till outside the case that you are susceptible to RF.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- woliveirajr 9y agoIt is caused by the increase/decrease in power consuption, as in general the audio chip isn't properly isolated from the power source of your computer. So, as more power is used (by slightly increasing the CPU speed, for example, to render the page as you scrooled it), the audio chip amplifies it. It is a problem of some motherboards, and one way to get ride of it is to use another audio chip (for example, a small USB device that acts like a sound card).
- tsomctl 9y agoI'm pretty happy with my setup. My garage shares a wall with my living room, so I put the tower out there. I then ran high quality, 25' long dvi and usb cables to the desk in my living room. Edit: I currently have two gtx1050 in it running at full power, and can't hear the fans at all.
- mipmap04 9y agoWhat sort of ambient temperature do you normally have in your garage?
- robotnixon 9y agoI did the same but the tower is in my basement. I ran an HDMI and USB cable up thru the wall and into a keystone panel behind my TV. Other than occasionally having to manually flip the tower back on after a power outage it worked pretty flawlessly. Totally silent and no tower to hide in my living room.
- bertjk 9y agoIn the past when I tried to build a silent PC, I found that even after removing / stopping all the fans, there was still often an electronic humm or buzz left over. That is when I gave up. Later I changed desks to one that had one of those built in computer cabinets made of thick particle board. That did as much to silence a pc as all the tens of hours of effort I had put into meticulously researching and specc'ing the build before.
- zeusk 9y agoThat's called coil whine, often a result of shoddy power components or construction (and often in either PSU or GPU).
- agumonkey 9y agoSome noise, depending on the texture can be even pleasuring. coil whine is highly unnerving while low fan sound is relaxing. we like stimulus, the clicky keys of my old hp48 is neat, the insertion sequence of pioneer 32x slot-in cd drive was amazingly subtle; not long ago I revived an old HP tape drive, the tape rolling and the head gear was also beautiful. Also, it was as cute as informative, it's a clear state change side channel. Often software notification about hardware are decoupled so much that you don't trust it; plus they're invasive, unlike a tiny led, a click, a tiny motor ramping up.
- johnchristopher 9y ago> Some noise, depending on the texture can be even pleasuring. I like the sound HDD make when grinding (except when I don't know the reason for the grinding... looking at you svchost.exe). > coil whine is highly unnerving while low fan sound is relaxing. Which is why I have been putting off getting a new laptop for years now. Most seem to suffer from coil whines and I can't stand it (to the point I ended up using an old eeepc 1000he rather than a brand new 16 inches VAIO some years ago).
- baus 9y agoI thought AMD processors were also susceptible to Meltdown/Spectre. The author mentions Intel's vulnerabilities as a reason for choosing AMD
- sp332 9y agoThey weren't vulnerable to Meltdown, only Spectre. The author expands on what happened to his particular PC in the comments.
- nullifidian 9y agomany components on motherboards assume at least some airflow Encasing in horizontally in a metal box could lead to premature failure due to increased temperatures, even if the cpu is relatively cool.
- mark-r 9y agoThe entire outside of the case is a heat sink. If there's any convection flow whatsoever it shouldn't be too far above ambient.
- chx 9y agoIf you are interested in this topic then http://www.silentpcreview.com/ http://www.silentpcreview.com/ is your friend, they have been doing this since 2002 although certainly activity has been lees the last few years. The forums are also good.
- paol 9y agoActivity has ceased unfortunately. The last articles are from 2016.
- tempestn 9y agoThat's a shame; they've been my go-to resource for my last three builds or so.
- SkyMarshal 9y agoThese guys sell silent PCs and components too: https://silentpc.com/ https://silentpc.com/
- badpun 9y agoI bought a quiet PC from these guys: https://www.quietpc.com/ https://www.quietpc.com/ As far as I could tell, the only noise it made was coming from the PC speaker and the DVD drive (when it was running). There were no fans inside.
- djhworld 9y agoI really enjoyed this post, the author seems passionate and really happy to have achieved their dream
- tp69 9y agoThanks, and you're right — I am. :)
- weinzierl 9y agoCompletely silent and zero time boot are the two features I still miss from my C64. The only thing that came close in the meantime was my Palm III, but it wasn't a desktop computer. To be fair I rarely boot a device (be it mobile or notebook) nowadays, but still..
- shmerl 9y agoNice, but it won't work with higher end parts like Vega 56. They are just way too hot by design. There was also some ready solution like this, that used heat dissipation through the walls of the case: https://airtop-pc.com/airtop/natural-airflow-technology/ https://airtop-pc.com/airtop/natural-airflow-technology/
- CharlesW 9y agoMy computer is completely silent. (It's an iPad.)
- nabla9 9y agoJust wait a little longer before making a judgment. Some noise from coils and capacitors might start to emerge during heavy load.
- tp69 9y agoIf something starts making a noise I'll update my posts and let people know.
- gnode 9y agoI've been interested in passively cooled PCs for a while now. Particularly, I've been considering building a computer which outputs its heat into a wall using heatpipes and a metal plate heat spreader. Although I can't find any case of this being done by anyone else, so I'm not sure if it's a crazy idea or not.
- nottorp 9y agoIt's been done with water cooling and a car radiator on the wall ;)
- biztos 9y agoAm I the only one who thinks of smartphones and tablets as silent computers? Granted, they can't do what this person's high-spec workstation can do, but they do most of the computing tasks most people use (used) noisy fanned computers with clacking disks for and in many cases do those tasks better. And unless I'm just losing my hearing, my smartphone is completely silent as long as I don't accidentally press the Golem Invoker, er, Siri button.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- pmcollins 9y agoThe MacBook is (at least in theory) noiseless as well. It has an SSD and no fans.
- sokoloff 9y agoMacBook Air and Pro both have fans. I don’t know the entire Apple line of all time by heart, so there might have been another MacBook that had no fans.
- szemet 9y agoI've built a fanless desktop too last year. Because I only use it for browsing and as a media player, I've chosen a 35w i3 CPU with integrated GPU. This way I could use a cheap semi-fanless PSU - which never switches on its fan - because the system just never exceeds its consumption limit. Because of the 35W CPU, the system was cheap and easy to build. What I have learned from it, is that my screen has a silent buzzing sound... :)
- PretzelFisch 9y agotry turning the brightness up or down. I had the same issue with many of my monitors and this would sometimes fix it.
- tetha 9y agoHm, this reminds me of two interesting tidbits. One is the good old P1 125Mhz router we had like 10 - 15 years ago. The only active cooling in that system was in the PSU and that thing throttled it's fan off during normal operation. It had zero moving parts outside of the PSU. You couldn't even get fans for those CPUs. These old systems were fun :) And beyond that, this makes me think of the computer requirements of coal mines, and I think mining in general. In a mine, a piece of compute has a defined maximum energy emission per square inch surface. If you exceed that, you risk coal dust explosions, which are rather inconvenient, loud and adverse to throughput. The stuff in the article is very similar to industrial computers in such a setup. Quite interesting.
- kakwa_ 9y agoAt my college, we had a bar with a custom account management system (it managed the credit of each students). The thing was all text/ncurses. The terminal was an under-clocked PII, with all the fans removed and connected to the server using a serial cable and it was kind of necessary since the environment was quite hostile and sticky (spilled beer, some fat deposit, etc). If I recall correctly before the PII, it was a VT-100 console, so even more basic than the PII.
- thibran 9y agoRaspberry Pi + i3 + Chromium + Emacs = <3 100% quiet, not super fast, but fast enough.
- yAnonymous 9y agoHigh pitched electric buzzing or hard disk screeching seem to be worse than fan noise nowadays with all the great coolers available. That being said, within a year of using Windows 10 four (!) of my hard drives have begun making loud screeching sounds. They're technically fine, but still unusable.
- ovao 9y agoI built a fanless (technically had fans, but only turned on if needed), semi-high-performance open bench-style system several years ago. It's really pretty nice in theory. The reality is that some components still emit a good bit of noise, and unlike fans, the noise they tend to emit isn't very pleasant. Power-hungry graphics cards are by far some of the worst offenders; without being masked by fan noise, they can be incredibly loud and irritating. An open bench PC is definitely cool, but was kind of a mistake in my case. Fan tech has improved to the point that I think, more often than not, you really want to have them. Otherwise it's time spent trying to eliminate other noise sources that would otherwise be conveniently and usually pleasantly masked by a little wooshing.
- yAnonymous 9y agoCompletely agreed. When GPUs do this, I just declare them defective and send them back. It comes down to a lack of quality of the electrical components and simply shouldn't be a problem, especially with the current GPU prices.
- Drdrdrq 9y agoThis is some seriously slick design! Congrats to OP for achieving the goal.
- mark-r 9y agoAnybody else think the extruded aluminum cube is a good look?
- tp69 9y agoThanks, and yes — Streacom did really well on the design. It has a brutalist aesthetic to it that folks will probably love or hate. For those that like the looks but want moar powerrr, Streacom have an actively-cooled version on the drawing board. Do an image search for "Streacom DA4" if you're interested.
- monkpit 9y ago> The whole Meltdown/Spectre debacle rendered my previous Intel system insecure and unsecurable so that was the final straw for me — no more Intel CPUs. Is any system honestly 100% “securable”? I would argue that any computer, regardless of cpu manufacturer, is “unsecurable”.
- etherael 9y agoWell no material is unbreakable, either, but some are a whole lot more breakable than others.
- wilsonnb 9y agoA computer with no input mechanism or output mechanism would be secure. Just not very useful. I imagine any computer that approaches maximum security also approaches minimum utility. Presumably the author just thinks that Intel is a little too low on security compared to the other offerings, and not that the other offerings are actually "secure".
- saagarjha 9y ago> A computer with no input mechanism or output mechanism would be secure. Information can be extracted from airgapped computers by measuring magnetic fluctuations, so this isn't quite true!
- wilsonnb 9y agoI suppose that would count as an output mechanism then, wouldn't it? Perhaps it is impossible to build a computer without an output mechanism.
- luminiferous 9y agoIf you're going to count all possible side channels as output mechanisms, then I'd imagine that it is indeed impossible to build a computer without an output mechanism. Unless you limit your scope to say, Earth, and somehow build a computer outside of Earth's light cone. It is thus causally disconnected from Earth and has no output mechanisms that can be read from anyone on Earth.
- acd 9y agoBuilt a for normal desktop use a nearly silent gaming MiniITX build, it hums from the graphics card when gaming. Fractal Design Node 304, ASUS Z170I Pro Gaming, Intel i7 6700k, Samsung M2 SSD, ASUS Strix Gaming OC Nvidia GeForce GTX 1070, Noctua NH-U12S CPU cooler, Corsair PowerSupply (PSU) CS550M. Runs Linux well.
- hollerith 9y agoMy Mac mini does not have a hard drive in it. It is completely silent most of the time. (A fan is running, but I cannot hear it even in the middle of the night.) When building software or playing certain videos, the fan speed increases with the result that I hear a quiet white noise.
- cJ0th 9y agoYeah, I love my mac mini for that. For a computer this silent I even find it remarkably good value. However, there isn't much else positive I can say about mac/their eco system...
- nwah1 9y agoI bought an HD-Plex case to use with the 35W AMD Ryzen 5 2400GE processor w/ integrated GPU which was just launched. Looking forward to using it. https://www.hdplex.com/ https://www.hdplex.com/
- vidoc 9y agoYou wont be disappointed. I've been running a router/kodi-box machine with a low power i5 in their h1 case for almost 4 years now, it works like a charm.
- zokier 9y agoKinda unfortunate timing for him that AMD released Ryzen 5 2400GE about the time as the article was written, which seems like pretty much perfect chip for silent reasonably powerful computer. Sure, it might not be quite as beefy as his 1600+1050Ti combo, but the energy efficiency should be much better. 2400GE is rated at 35W, while 1600+1050Ti is at 65W+75W=140W, or full four times more.
- tp69 9y agoYep, you can't always wait for the perfect product to come along — sometimes circumstances force your hand. Not only did that processor not exist at the time, but even if it did there were going to be a bunch of compatibility issues with it on Ubuntu (like there always are when new hardware is released). I simply didn't want to have to deal with those sorts of issues for — potentially — months. Maybe the Ryzen 5 3400G(E) will be a compelling upgrade? We shall see.
- kakwa_ 9y agoIt's less powerful, but personally, I've replaced my Intel NUC case with one of these Akasa fanless chassis: http://www.akasa.com.tw/update.php?tpl=product/product.list.tpl&type=Fanless%20Chassis&type_sub=Fanless%20NUC http://www.akasa.com.tw/update.php?tpl=product/product.list.... The thing is not perfect, the case can get quite hot, specially in summer, but it works reasonably well. I use the thing as a media center (xbmc/kodi), and it's quite nice to have a fanless/zero noise setup for this usage.
- Symbiote 9y agoI have exactly the same, and I'm very pleased with it. I use it as my main home computer, which includes occasional use when I'm working from home. It overheated once (Linux/Ubuntu suspended automatically), my room was also 28°C or something and I'd been encoding videos non-stop for hours.
- anotheryou 9y agoI shot a cheapish Lenovo YOGA 710 laptop. It also has no fans.
- Ratiofarmings 9y agoIt also has no power ;)
- anotheryou 9y agofine for office stuff :) but you are right, no main computer
- baseethrowaway 9y agoOne can make a passive build much more powerful. NSG S0, once out, will most likely be the go-to case for such setups. Until then, an HDPLEX H5 is cool. My desk has a H5 on it, housing an i7 8700 (non-K) and a GTX 1060. The TIM under the heatspreader is replaced with Thermal Grizzly Conductonaut and Thermal Grizzly Kryonaut is used as every other TIM that the case setup needs. The CPU is on stock clocks with a voltage offset of -30 mV. The GPU has the power target reduced to 90% and clocks increased by 130 MHz, so that it is effectively undervolted as well. The PSU is a Seasonic Ultra Prime Titanium 650. Prime95 with AVX throttles really, really fast, under a minute, perhaps, but is a very unrealistic load. Non-AVX stress tests and FurMark take a while to start throttling (20 minutes?), as the thermal capacity of the aluminum case is quite big. After hours of gaming, the GPU and CPU float around 80 C while providing full stock performance. I don't do 3D rendering (other than in-game) or video en/decoding, so have not had long, real-world, full loads to see how temperatures behave with those. From the discussion I've had and forums I've read, I think that people are afraid of putting more power in passive cases and having their components at "high" temperatures, despite those being rated for them.
- xxs 9y ago>Prime95 with AVX throttles really, really fast, under a minute, perhaps, but is a very unrealistic load I suppose blender would thermal throttle the cpu as well. If you run any non-Xeon/non-Laptop Intel chip (greater than 2k series) and care about temperatures - delid the bugger. (Xeons are soldered, laptop chips don't have IHS). Intel uses something that's worse than toothpaste, plus tons of glue between the die and the IHS. If you see temperature deltas under full load more than 9-10C between the cores, the thermal paste between the die and the IHS might have missing spots or have dried out. In your case removal of the IHS altogether would provide decent results. You might wish to check the VRMs, they are rated at 125C but if the case is hellishly hot inside, they might not be able to dissipate the heat.
- Misdicorl 9y agoSomewhat unrelated, but maybe you can shoot me down since you seem to have some experience? Metal is an incredibly good conductor on its own, and the properties of thermal paste (typically) are just barely better than air. So long as your cpu and heatsink are fairly flat surfaces and mashed together physically, it seems like either forgoing or having the absolute minimum amount of paste is ideal. I've used a razor to leave an absolutely minimal layer of paste (e.g. filling in sub-millimeter surface structure) on my latest build, and cpu temperatures are well within a reasonable range. But I'm also not trying to OC the cpu or anything. Thoughts?
- stcredzero 9y agoHardware Canucks covers the Streacom case in the article. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qxHPdoHNRDM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qxHPdoHNRDM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LLuNQPiI-7E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LLuNQPiI-7E Of interest, "Jay's Two Cents" did this clickbaity video where they daisy chain 4 radiators together. This would be one of those entertainment value only stunts, except that they discovered that they could shut off all the fans. Having only a pump running, you can passively cool both the top-end CPU and a high-end GPU. If someone can put the pump inside a nice machined aluminum case, this could be a DIY recipe for a fanless silent PC. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q2SIrV_4-dM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q2SIrV_4-dM
- saagarjha 9y agoThis was a major selling point of MacBook–it had no fans whatsoever, making it completely silent even under load.
- richx 9y agoI have a completely silent PC from Cirrus7. I'm pretty happy with it. But it does not have dedicated GPU like the one in the article. https://www.cirrus7.com https://www.cirrus7.com
- fipple 9y agoWhy not just put the computer in the adjacent different room and install a DisplayPort and USB patch panel on each side of the wall? Monitor and peripherals in one room and the computer on the other side. It’s what I would do if I owned a house.
- antongribok 9y agoMy first silent system was about 17 years ago that booted Linux from a floppy drive into RAM. This was before solid state storage options were affordable. It was a Pentium 1 (can't remember the model) and I had disconnected the PSU fan. Ran for a long time and I used it mostly as a router.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- emptybits 9y agoClearly a work of passion and I appreciate OP sharing. I enjoyed earlier days of "Silent PC" building, ten or fifteen years ago. For example, building a silent tower or desktop for a DAW or softsynth back then in a recording/studio environment required some ingenuity. SSD? Not on a hobbiest budget. I recall one build, not mine, fully immersed in a bucket of oil (mineral?) for passive heat dispersion. Today, as a new reference point, any MacBook Pro within the last few years may qualify as truly silent for many people's everyday usage. It does for me. And when I do heat up the CPU/GPU with heavy tasks, the fans spin up but then they go away completely as soon as the hard work is done. Back to silent. No more spinning platters or crappy fan bearings or poorly engineering airflow nowadays. :-) There's no hacker pride in buying off-the-shelf, so the performance bar for DIY is higher. Progress!
- cschep 9y agoman, my mbp is on fire and fans spinning all the time just from xcode / ios dev.. backend dev on a remote server was the life! :D
- alorimer 9y agoI've had the same experience with my MBP 2017. So many people don't realise that the aluminium chassis isn't just attractive, it's actually a massive heatsink, and it's the reason the machine needs barely any internal airflow.
- tp69 9y agoI'm glad you enjoyed the post. My first silencing attempt (in the early 1990s) was to seal a hard disk in what amounted to little more than a couple of oven bags, custom-make a long IDE cable, and then — literally — dangle the drive in a bucket of water that was under the desk the computer sat on. That ended poorly, with thermal cycling inducing microfractures in the bags, which resulted in leaks, a dead drive and a blown controller on the motherboard. Ah well, we live and learn. Take it easy.
- patentatt 9y agoIt used to be fun trying to silence a computer. Figuring out which HDDs were single-platter, undervolting processors, finding low-rpm fans, etc. used to be a challenge, and have great rewards for those of us who care. Now, check out silentpcreview.com, hasn’t been updated this calendar year. In some ways I miss the old days, but most modern laptops and even desktops are reasonably quiet, and full silence is easy to achieve.
- aembleton 9y agoMy Xiaomi Air 12 Laptop is completely silent, fanless and uses SSD. Very happy with it and it comes like that out of the box. https://www.gearbest.com/laptops/pp_416105.html https://www.gearbest.com/laptops/pp_416105.html
- absove 9y agoI got mine last week, pleasantly surprised at how good it was considering the price. The display is gorgeous and linux support is excellent. Far from usual experience with linux on laptops.
- noja 9y agoI wish they made a smaller chassis.
- walrus01 9y agoFor those interested in doing this, the case manufacturer Zalman also makes a series of atx format cases where the whole body is a radiator, with heatpipes to a cpu block.
- nootropicat 9y agoI wanted complete silence too, but realized it's way easier to just move the PC elsewhere. I moved it into an adjacent room, made a small hole in the wall for cables (10M hdmi+usb+audio) and that was it, it worked perfectly. The price was trivial - about $40 total for cables. I already had a usb extension hub. Sadly, that's only useful for 60Hz, as high refresh rates require a short displayport cable to work. For this reason I no longer use this solution. If you're ok with 60Hz and have compatible room layout I recommend this. The biggest advantage is that it's completely PC agnostic, which makes upgrades way easier, as standard cooling solutions are fine.
- skate22 9y agoQuiet enough to protect against this attack? (Using noise of cpu to extract data) https://m.slashdot.org/story/195775 https://m.slashdot.org/story/195775
- dragontamer 9y agoSo these sorts of builds are way harder than they look. You need to spend a good amount of time planning out motherboards, and willing to go back to the shop to buy another motherboard (because this motherboard might have a big honking capacitor where you expected to run a heat-pipe). So you either need to carefully look at pictures / guestimate the location of components, or hope that someone else on the internet has figured it all out for you. Alternatively, you could just be ridiculously lucky. But I don't really believe in luck personally. If this guy has been doing these builds for as long as he claims, he probably had a fair bit of thought go into the particulars of this build. The kinds of thoughts that don't go very well into blog posts because they're uninteresting (but very important). Like, does X combination of components fit or do I do Y instead? ------------ With respect to the build itself: I'm surprised he was able to get 60+W CPU and a 60+W GPU in there. Most silent builds I see basically use laptop parts (30W or less) to keep the heat down. 32gb of RAM will be plenty, and 8 Zen-cores is plenty strong. The GPU is a bit weak for gaming, but he should be able to play plenty of the lower-end games without much issue, even at 1080p / 60fps (probably Overwatch for example). He probably can't run Witcher3 at 4k on Ultra, but such a GPU would blow out his thermal-design completely.
- tp69 9y agoYep, it took weeks to finalise the parts. I had to contact multiple vendors and get them to check component heights, track down motherboard layouts, compare review photos from different angles, plan heatpipe runs, resolve conflicts with VRM heatsinks and power connectors, watch assembly/review videos over and over again, scrutinise manuals, determine hardware/OS incompatibilities... probably well over 80 hours of work before I could even order the parts. But, like you say, even though I had done all that, there was still the possibility that I might have missed something and would need to return/replace some parts and rework the plan. My mouse hovered over the "Order" button for quite a while before I finally committed. An anxious moment. Virtually none of that methodical and boring research/prep work made it into the post — it's just not that interesting. Necessary, yes, but not something that the vast majority of readers would want to read. The setup should be able to handle a 105W CPU and 75W GPU. At this point 65 + 75W is confirmed. When I OC the 1600 I should be able to verify up to ~95 + 75W. The strategy was to start with a really well engineered passive case, then select components that could be pushed right up to the thermal limits. It's worked well so far. I'll keep publishing all of my test results for those that may be interested.
- zemo 9y agoplease tell me he has a really loud mechanical keyboard to go with it
- nottorp 9y agoThat would be me. I don't have a fully passive set up (I don't really trust those, since I tend to use both the CPU and GPU a lot) but it's silentpcreview silent. To make up for it, I'm using a mechanical Razer Blackwidow. It's so loud you can get distracted by the sound of your own typing :)
- tp69 9y agoNope, rubber dome. I'm actually on the lookout for a wired, backlit, white/aluminium, chiclet, TKL keyboard. Basically something like the Apple Keyboard but sans NumKeypad, backlit and keyed for Linux/PC. Bonus points if it has a column of macro keys on the left. If anyone knows of one please drop me a line.
- zemo 8y agodidn't notice this comment until now. This is a somewhat deep rabbit hole, but what I will tell you is that you'll probably have a hard time finding what you want in a chiclet keyboard because there's not much of a market for chiclet keyboards among keyboard enthusiasts. Chiclet is both a switching mechanism and a keycap; most of the keyboard-enthusiast community is working with setups that involve separate switches and keycaps that are interchangeable. What you probably want in practice is the following characteristics: a specific key layout, all of the keys should be the same height, the key travel should be low (i.e., the amount of distance you have to depress the keys before registering a keystroke). No idea if you want the keys to make noise or not, or how stiff you want the springs to be, but that's customizable too. If you want chiclet keys because you want low key travel, you have a lot of options. If you want something really thin, there are way, way fewer options. A single left column of macro keys is not something I've ever seen, but the one keyboard I can think off of hand that has a similar layout is the Red Scarf II, which has two columns of macro keys on the left side; unfortunately it's not currently in production. Some people use an external num pad and put the num pad on the left for this purpose. https://www.massdrop.com/buy/red-scarf-ii-ver-b-custom-mechanical-keyboard-kit https://www.massdrop.com/buy/red-scarf-ii-ver-b-custom-mecha... I personally use a KBD75, which is an aluminum body, tenkeyless layout with a right-hand column, and it's all programmable with QMK so you can make any key do whatever you want. For example, I have a key that, when I press it, reverses the position of the Alt and Win keys, so that I can switch between layouts for either PC or Mac and have the Alt, Command, and Windows keys always in their correct location. Images and build information here: https://imgur.com/a/5pSva2A https://imgur.com/a/5pSva2A you can get keycaps that have a flat profile that are interchangeable with any MX-Compatible switch. DSA Granite is a super popular flat-profile keyset like that: https://pimpmykeyboard.com/dsa-granite-keyset/ https://pimpmykeyboard.com/dsa-granite-keyset/ it's pretty common to add rubber o-rings to the keys to reduce the travel. But chiclet keys are generally going to restrict the rest of your options. Anyway reddit.com/r/mechanicalkeyboards has a bunch of info on all this stuff.
- floatingatoll 9y agoApple’s iMac is an excellent budget alternative to this approach, as long as fan noise under high load is acceptable. 99% of my usage is not under high load, so it works out to be silent effectively any time I’m not wearing headphones. Using the CPU and/or GPU and/or writing gigabytes to the SSD will wind up the fans, so this is not even remotely “always silent for power users” – but it’s always silent for general non-coder usage!
- soVeryTired 9y agoStupid question from a non-hardware guy. If you wanted a completely silent computer, could you build one in a vacuum chamber and just suck all the air out?
- brlewis 9y agoThat approach would not be very different from surrounding it with sound insulation, and would involve the same challenges. Things that conduct heat out tend to conduct sound out too.
- beckler 9y agoYeah, but without air, the heat won't dissapate.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- misterman101 9y agoYou'd still need to get heat out. You could water cool the machine, but you'd still have fans/radiator on the outside.
- iliis 9y agoYou could, but it would be thermally quite bad: The only way for parts to cool would be through radiation, which is way less effective than convection (be it forced by fans or passive, as in OP's design.)
- natosaichek 9y agoThe challenge is removing heat. Putting things in a vacuum chamber doesn't make them colder - vacuum is actually a pretty good insulator, so you'd need some mechanism to get the heat out of there with9out using air. If you go the other direction, some people have built computers they submerge in mineral oil or other similar media. That works pretty well for removing heat from components more effectively than air convection.
- Wildgoose 9y ago
- jiveturkey 9y ago> (Astute readers will notice they are all AMD (Socket AM4) motherboards. The whole Meltdown/Spectre debacle rendered my previous Intel system insecure and unsecurable so that was the final straw for me — no more Intel CPUs.) That's a silly and extremist position to take. "insecure" is relative, not absolute. It's a certainty that the software he's running has far more quantity of vulnerabilities and a much longer history of them. I don't know his exact use case, but arguably his use case isn't one where Spectre is particularly more severe than even a userland, non-priv-escalation vuln. (eg ransomware doesn't require root access to hold all your files hostage.) > Eliminate the moving parts (e.g. fans, HDDs) and you eliminate the noise — it’s not that complicated. Ha! And yet it deserved a detailed blog post. I'm surprised he would say this even after the amount of effort he spent.
- iblo66 9y agoAfter having purchased an AMD GPU, they would have to pay me for me to buy anything from AMD ever again.
- sliken 9y agoTheir CPUs are pretty good, their GPUs are pretty good, however their GPU drivers are terrible, especially under linux.
- zaggynl 9y agoSince Linux 4.15, AMD GPU support is in kernel, can't say the same for Nvidia. That said, Nvidia's proprietary drivers still do better than AMD's drivers.
- zingmars 9y agoWell it's a good thing nvidia is catching up on being horrible. The 367.xx driver's dkms module doesn't even compile for me on Ubuntu 16.04 anymore, and later drivers make some gstreamer-based apps stutter a bit. And Windows is behaving weirdly as well since I installed the latest drivers. Black bar on top of full screen programs after waking from hibernation, The HD audio driver not letting pulseaudio start (I need it to get sound from WSL) and crashes when multiple 3D accelerated VMs are open. And restarting the GPU driver (with either the shortcut or through device manager) is what solves all the issues and they only occur with the latest driver. And the crappiest part is that there's nobody that can help. Getting someone from nvidia to respond on their forums is basically luck, and I'm not a huge company that can get their reps to get someone to help me.
- Clubber 9y agoMy 2009 Mac Pro is the quietest computer I have. I gave up when I installed a server cabinet in my computer room though. Those 1U units are friggin loud.
- walrus01 9y agoQuick note for everyone who might want to build a mostly-quiet home theatre PC. There are several versions of the geforce1030 that use passive cooling/no fans. With H265 acceleration in the GPU drivers, more than fast enough for 2160p, 60fps movies in VLC. They're right around $85. Same basic chip architecture as the much more expensive 1070/1080. Not something you'd want to run newer 3D games on, but perfect for media center use.
- RachelF 9y agoI have a similar system. What OS do you run on it?
- walrus01 9y agoSadly, windows 10, better driver support for all the GPU acceleration features for very high bitrate 4k video. It pretty much just runs VLC and other "fun" things such as Google Earth.
- IronBacon 9y agoLast time I've looked there was a passive cooled 1050 GeForce model and an equivalent (more or less) from Amd that I don't recall the name.
- walrus01 9y agoThere are several passively cooled geforce1050 (not ti), but you really don't need it for any form of 4k video. My output setup is to a 70" 60Hz TV over HDMI 2.0, with a ryzen 1500X that is slightly overclocked, this setup handled 2160p60 H265 up to around 300 Mbps, at which point it CPU bottlenecks. Which is a vastly greater bitrate than any bluray or torrented 4K content. If you wanted a setup slightly more capable of 3D games then the 1050 would definitely be a consideration.
- IronBacon 9y agoWell, 300 Mb/s it's a lot of headspace, it's nearly nine times the bandwidth of a Bluray. ^__^ I'm itching to stuff one of the recently release Raven Ridge APUs in a 3 liters case with a PicoPSU and have a portable, reasonably powerful desktop that I can stuff in a backpack, I'm waiting for a little more mature Linux support, at least a stable 2.4.17 kernel...
- amiga-workbench 9y agoMy machine is almost completely silent. Semi-passive power supply, passive GTX1050 and a noctua CPU cooler that is just barely audible when the room is silent. The coil whine is irritating though.
- Escapado 9y agoNice article. About two years ago I wanted to make my pc completely silent as well. It turned out that the cheapest solution for me was to put the pc in another room that I don't sit in and put long hdmi + USB cables through the wall. I also soldered on a longer cable with a power button so I can start the pc from my room. The only downside for me is that I had to run cables along my walls through a conduit but I think in total I paid less than 40€.
- tomaskafka 9y ago"How long HDMI cable do I need to call this a cloud?" :))
- cellularmitosis 9y agoIt can’t be heard from 1cm away I doubt that. A while back I removed all of the moving parts from an old 486 and netbooted it, only to find out I could actually hear the network card making very faint screeching noises whenever there was network activity. You've probably heard the same effect on a much larger scale, at much lower frequency, when you hear the 60Hz hum of a "silent" transformer.
- dabockster 9y agoSo I'm guessing passive cooling like this is only obtainable at stock clocks and low voltages? How does it handle PUBG? I'd also like to present the loudest computer I've ever seen as a counterexample. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EM2G5vLGcQQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EM2G5vLGcQQ
- Ratiofarmings 9y agoSince he described how his cpu cooling is capable of dissipating up to 105W and he uses a 65W cpu, he can overclock a little. He is also using fast memory and a 1050ti is quite capable of running pubg well. Based on that pubg should run well.
- arca_vorago 9y agoI've had much success with fanless industrial computers for certain applications in certain environments. Seeing someone do it manually though is super cool (especially the vram chip heatsinks... why have I never thought of that before?!)
- draw_down 9y agoThe obsessive pursuit of anything is usually interesting, but I haven't felt like noise was a real problem with any computer I've had in the last 5 or so years. They're silent nearly all the time, and they're still quiet the rest of the time.
- jgritty 9y agoSteve Jobs dream machine.
- tomaskafka 9y agoFor gaming I occasionaly rent an instance on Paperspace and play through Parsecgaming client (1440p@60fps, <10 ms lag). Totally quiet when a PC is in Amsterdam datacenter :).
- etaioinshrdlu 9y agoI did a similar (but much more ugly) project a few years ago, and found that the result was that one could then hear various electrical crackling sounds from inductors transformers and capacitors, especially from the power supply and motherboard. It actually sounded worse than a macbook pro which didn't make as much electrical noise.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- daveheq 9y agoBut can you make it completely black?
- tp69 9y agoThe DB4 already has a black version: http://www.streacom.com/products/db4-fanless-chassis/ http://www.streacom.com/products/db4-fanless-chassis/ then click the Gallery tab.
- lmilcin 9y agoIt is my ongoing mission to find completely silent phone and laptop chargers and PC monitor. I have three monitors and a laptop and not one is inaudible. They all become inaudible when I set their brightness to 100% but this is not acceptable to me. I was able to mostly fix my Dell U3011 by replacing power supply capacitors. These were placed in worst possible spot, bathing in hot ascending air assuring shortened lifespan. One could wonder if it was done intentionally...
- gautamb0 9y agoThis is a wonderful project. It looks very sharp and has pretty good components. However, it's usually significantly better, cheaper and easier to build an "almost" silent system, just by using good heatsinks and very slow fans. A small amount of airflow is usually significantly better than none at all.
- andrewalan 9y agoI am Andrew Alan a hacker, i can help gain acccess to any social media. Generating all login informations for you. This can be useful in divorce case, court case and many more. I also make alterations to credit score, have a lot of funding programs ranging from accounts and credit cards. This and many more services i have to offer. Anyone interested in this service can text us on 3238351741, andrewalanhacks@gmailcom.
- matchagaucho 9y ago"For what I will be doing with this computer" Would love to know what application this was built for. As a recording studio enthusiast, I can appreciate the pursuit of silent PCs. What other use cases?
- voxadam 9y agoThe sheer challenge of the undertaking, I expect.
- tp69 9y agoIt's my new daily driver. I do everything on it except play games. My previous rig is now dedicated to that task. So we have the usual suspects: Watching videos and movies, staying abreast of current affairs, listening to music. Then some not so-usual suspects: Research and self-education, software development, and a simulation that I've been running and tweaking for several years. This computer is on for an average of about 15 hours every day of the week, and is pretty-much always doing something. It spends virtually no uptime idling.
- hetman 9y agoI finally got my work desktop PC quiet enough for my liking by replacing fans, heatsinks and a passively cooled graphics card. Now all I can hear is everyon else's PC's whining around me (there not even that close!).
- fiddlerwoaroof 9y agoDo the skull canyon NUCs have fans?
- ridiculous_fish 9y agoAll NUCs have fans. The Skull Canyon is infamously loud.
- fiddlerwoaroof 9y agoInteresting, I've been looking for a small computer that would make a good HTPC, and I thought the Skull Canyon NUC might be a good choice. I sort of assumed that that form factor would always be fanless.
- Boulth 9y agoExcellent post, reminds me of http://www.aleutia.com/products/r50-fanless-server http://www.aleutia.com/products/r50-fanless-server
- mostlyskeptical 9y agoI won a silent computer 5+ years ago as a prize at a lan party. SSD drives, two of the best passively coolable gpu at the time (ATI I Believe?), passive CPU cooler, and the whole case was lined with musicians sound absorbing foam. I think it did have an optional 240mm fan but I never heard it even when I turned it on. It was so nice that I have built my newest computer in the same way (though I did put some big storage drives in it).
- Gracana 9y agoThis ought to go perfectly with my IBM Model M keyboard.
- bschwindHN 9y agoSpeaking of noisy computers and electronics, I designed a PCB with an ESP32 bluetooth/WiFi chip on it. I'm far from an expert in board design, and my board unsurprisingly emits a buzz when the Wifi/BT radio is transmitting or receiving. It's interesting though, when it's using BLE you can hear the frequency hopping as it changes channels, and then you get entirely different sounds when it stops BLE and uses just WiFi. But yeah I should probably fix that... Possibly caused by the piezoelectric effect on an SMD ceramic capacitor, making it vibrate and hit the PCB surface at an audible frequency.
- kuon 9y agoIsn't there any liquid we could immerse the electronic in for cooling? I'm sure this must exist in high density industrial applications.
- quwert95 9y agoYes! Mineral oil cooled PCs in aquariums have long been a thing-to-do (but it's very messy).
- danlan 9y ago3M make a non conductive solution for exactly this application. I remember reading about an overclocking rig using something like it pumped through a radiator submerged in liquid nitrogen. Was pretty cool but the solution ended up turning into a gel at low temps https://www.3m.com/3M/en_US/novec-us/applications/immersion-cooling/ https://www.3m.com/3M/en_US/novec-us/applications/immersion-...
- Ratiofarmings 9y agoThere are several. But the liquid will heat up and eventually require cooling again. Pumping it somewhere generates noise. Evaporating it creates costs and need to frequent maintenance. And a large enough tank for that not to be an issue is impractical.
- ymgch 9y agosimplest solution: buy an iMac.
- whywhywhywhy 9y agoRegular iMacs are jet engine loud once you throw any CPU or GPU load at them. I think the iMac Pro is much better in this regard but it's not sustainable as a workstation machine.
- Abishek_Muthian 9y agoCongratulations tp69! The article details how miners made it difficult to procure components for the build, but the irony is that the miners might be specifically interested in this build for its power efficiency. A decade ago, I was obsessed with fans and at one point I had more than 10 in my workstation. The noise it created kind of resonated with me, like I would be able to tell when the job was CPU intensive, HDD or GPU; I guess it felt more lively! But after the smartphone boom, I got more adhered to power efficient, noise less systems (Smartphone/Tablet/SBC's/Chromebook) & after the meltdown spectre (pun intended) my adherence got reinforced. Anyone looking for low-cost completely silent yet portable system in laptop form-factor can take a look at Chromebooks, now that Google has announced Linux apps support it's usefulness would tend to grow.
- shurcooL 9y agoAs someone who has used the fanless 12" Retina MacBook, I can't put in words how nice of a feeling it is to have a fully silent computer. It's hard to understand why without actually experiencing it yourself, but it was a really big deal. If not for the awful keyboard ruining the experience, I wouldn't ever give it up. It may sound (no pun intended) like an exaggeration, but I think more powerful computers going completely silent (fanless) will be the next most noticeable breakthrough since we got Retina displays on computers in 2012.
- tp69 9y agoYes, the feeling you get from pure silence is hard to put into words.
- matthew-wegner 9y agoReal late to this thread, but for the last ~10 years I've run my desktop in the adjacent room's closet. My desk has the monitors, speakers, USB hub for peripherals, with cables running through the wall to the actual tower/UPS/etc. It's a great setup if your living space can accommodate it (the adjacent room is my bedroom, but I shut this computer down at night). I started doing this because quiet computers just weren't available at decent horsepower. Rad to see a build like this!
- xtrapolate 9y ago> "(Astute readers will notice they are all AMD (Socket AM4) motherboards. The whole Meltdown/Spectre debacle rendered my previous Intel system insecure and unsecurable so that was the final straw for me — no more Intel CPUs.)" This is just random FUD. (1) AMD boards are vulnerable to Spectre - https://www.amd.com/en/corporate/speculative-execution-previous-updates https://www.amd.com/en/corporate/speculative-execution-previ.... (2) There are other vulnerabilities that affect AMD boards - https://community.amd.com/community/amd-corporate/blog/2018/03/21/initial-amd-technical-assessment-of-cts-labs-research https://community.amd.com/community/amd-corporate/blog/2018/... (3) Vulnerabilities are found everywhere. That's not the first time vulnerabilities are found, and it won't be the last. How is that an argument for anything exactly?
- diffeomorphism 9y agoBut not to meltdown and AMD did not try to spin it as "everbody is just as vulnerable as us, move along" like Intel did. Irrespective of how serious you consider these vulnerabilities, the way Intel handled them can very well be a "final straw".
- Nasrudith 9y agoI am both impressed and left wondering "Why go through such trouble?" Not in a dismissive way but an inquisitive one since it has been such a long term goal. I can see some power usage reasons given how much fans use and that noise like heat is a proxy for inefficiency whenever it isln't the direct goal but that isn't his main goal.
- Ratiofarmings 9y agoBecause it feels nice if things just happen like magic. Even "big" things like compiling, rendering or gaming. It just happens and you hear nothing but the birds outside and the cat breathing next to you.
- tp69 9y agoRatiofarmings is on the right track. The noise coming from the computer drowns out the subtle sounds of life all around me. Someone suggested in the comments that I should just wear earplugs instead. This was my response to him: "But the rest of the world doesn’t make annoying noises that I want to block out — only the computer does. I still want to hear the birds tweeting in the trees and the wind blowing past the awnings and the rain hitting the roof and the ice-cream truck driving by and my wife chuckling at something she’s watching and the cats running along the floor and the microwave oven heating a meal and the kettle finishing its boil. I’m not trying to disconnect from the rest of the world — I’m trying to reconnect to it." A lot of the most interesting and enjoyable sounds in life are very, very faint. It doesn't take much noise to drown them out. Even a single fan will do it. Now I can hear those noises and get 'work' done at the same time. It's really hard to describe, but 'magical' comes close. Thanks for asking.
- bullen 9y agoI made a similar build but with the Streacom FC9 Alpha case. I put a slim 1050Ti in there and replaced the GPU fans with Nuctua 1cm thick 9,2cm fan with Zalman Fan Mate 2 that I turn up when I play games. I have to run it without lid though, as any computer I have really, convection is your friend. I also went with 32GB RAM because I make multiplayer games and I need to be able to run multiple clients at the same time which takes alot of memory. This build is my last computer, peak moores law will make it so.
- Jaruzel 9y agoNot quite the same thing but... I'm in the middle of building a totally silent Retro DOS machine. Using an old low-spec passively cooled VIA Mini-ITX motherboard in a small case[1] with a passively cooled internal PSU. The storage is an SD card on the main IDE channel. The motherboard also has hardware Soundblaster/ADLIB support, so all the DOS games sound really great! [2] I've just written a front end launcher for the apps/games, and I found some working USB drivers for DOS that makes transferring software over nice and easy. I'll probably post a Show HN when I'm done. --- [1] 22cm x 22cm x 4cm [2] DOOM as it was meant to be heard.
- eggsome 9y agoWhich model VIA mb? And what do you mean by "hardware Soundblaster/ADLIB support" - do you have to run a TSR to make it work?
- Jaruzel 9y agoEPIA 5000 Motherboard. The chipset on the Motherboard directly includes Soundblaster, ADLib, and MPU-401 support. You can enable/disable each one in the BIOS. And yes, you need the EPIA Soundblaster drivers for DOS, but that's not that different from normal Soundblaster cards. It was a bit of an uphill struggle getting it working, but it's quite simple once you get the right version of the drivers.
- xarien 9y agoI've been using a fanless Steacom case for my HTPC for years now. It's a little pricy, but well worth it given that it looks like a high end DVR.
- unixhero 9y agoHow about a fanless Intel NUC, boom done.
- dest 9y agoSee linutop fanless computers, less powerful but much more compact http://www.linutop.com/linutop6.en.html http://www.linutop.com/linutop6.en.html
- danboarder 9y agoCompulab Airtop makes a VR ready tiny gaming rig i7 gtx1060 that is similar. There are very few fanless rigs with discrete graphics for gamer and workstation use like this that I can find: http://airtop-pc.com http://airtop-pc.com
- yason 9y agoI don't have a desktop PC right now but if I needed one I'd just place it in the basement or a closet (with enough ventilation), and wire the screen, HIDs, and a few USB connectors to my desk. Bam, no noise. However, it's cool (indeed) to see these silent constructions, though.
- circular_logic 9y agoI was wondering about these cases where the metal outside is directly connected to the CPU. Would this make it possible to kill your machine by touching it with a static charge?
- baseethrowaway 9y agoThe CPU's heatspreader is not connected to any leads on the CPU. The case should be grounded through the power supply, therefore, it should be like touching ground with static charge.
- antocv 9y agoSamsung Evo drives have a built in hardware error, where the read speeds diminish with age. The firmware hides the read-speed decrease, or prolongs the detection of it, by shuffling data around in the background. Poor choice of SSDs, Id go with SanDisk Extreme Pro or any other version even Intel.
- chrismorgan 9y agoNow I want to know whether it has a system beep. ␇
- tp69 9y agoNo, it does not. :)
- jonathanstrange 9y agoInteresting project. I was playing with the idea of running Linux on one of those little Chinese Qotom PCs without fan for a server, but I live in Portugal where it can get very hot in the summer and decided that the potential fire hazard is not worth it. Overclocking, fanless PC, etc. are all fine if you can make sure that there is no problem if the ambient temperature raises to 40 C - or even higher, if the machine is accidentally exposed to sunlight. I don't trust most existing fanless solutions to work reliably under such conditions.
- KaiserPro 9y agoSilent Pcs are hard, however the simplest way to make your PC silent is to put it elsewhere.... I worked at a VFX company, where we did interactive client sessions (think: zoom! enhance!) which required a totally silent setup. In somecases that meant trying to silence an entire rack of disks (baselite 8,http://erwanlecloirec.typepad.fr/digital_flipbook/2000/10/baselight.html http://erwanlecloirec.typepad.fr/digital_flipbook/2000/10/ba... big glowing thing at the bottom of the page) Obviously this is impossible, so we used DVI senders (https://www.eastwoodsoundandvision.com/blackmagic-design-micro-converter-sdi-to-hdmi?gclid=EAIaIQobChMIk8en9fKJ2wIVlIXVCh36ngJ_EAQYAiABEgK8o_D_BwE https://www.eastwoodsoundandvision.com/blackmagic-design-mic... they are HDMI nowadays) and remote USB This has the advantage that we can have a full bore machine with no compromises.
- pvdebbe 9y agoI just put the machine to a closet and buy long cords for all peripherals.
- arketyp 9y agoI dream of a passively cool stationary machine with a heat sink case that is essentially a Menger sponge. For maximizing the surface/volume ratio.
- walrus01 9y agoSeasonic has has a 400W fanless power supply for a few years now. The new 600W: https://seasonic.com/prime-titanium-fanless https://seasonic.com/prime-titanium-fanless
- user15128 9y agoyou do not hear your pc when it is located in another room/building :)
- cdelsolar 9y agoWhy is this person going off the grid
- tp69 9y agoThe Australian state I live in has the highest electricity prices in the country, and amongst the highest in the world — so there's a simple financial reason to defect from the grid. Then there are the self-sufficiency angles (produce/control your own power) and the preparedness angles (grid power always fails in bushfires) to consider as well. They are all the reasons I need.
- agumonkey 9y agohttps://paleotronic.com/2018/05/19/steve-wozniak-talks-disk/ https://paleotronic.com/2018/05/19/steve-wozniak-talks-disk/ <= has a bit about sound too, read it it's worth it