16 ms·
GM is launching a $5K tiny electric car in China made for city commuters
- bradknowles 9y agoSo, it’s an electric version of the Smart car, that doesn’t have any of the safety features of the smart, and because it’s designed and built in China, they don’t have to factor in things like paying their workforce a decent paycheck, or insurance, or anything else? Huh. Who would have guessed?
- squeegee3 9y agoI signed up several minutes ago, specifically to respond to this baseless and offensive comment, which appears explicitly written to attack China. How do you know that it doesn't have comparable safety features to a smart car? Or that the manufacturer's workforce doesn't have comparably good pay and benefits? None of these claims about the company and the car is in the article or publicly available to anyone - I looked. What is your motivation here?
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoYa, China isn't India, safety standards are a bit higher and similar to the west. This especially applies to foreign brand cars made in JVs (we aren't talking about something like a Land Wind X7, where you get what you pay for).
- coupdejarnac 9y agoWell, when I was in a Tier 88 city in China a few weeks ago, I saw a bunch of similar tiny electric cars. I asked my friend what was up with them, because I didn't see them in Shenzhen or Beijing. She laughed and said they were known for tipping over rather easily while turning. Also, it's not uncommon to see people driving jury-rigged tricycles in the boonies. China is not a place I associate with high safety standards.
- squeegee3 9y agoThis anecdote doesn’t have anything to do with his specific and unfounded claims. Good work defending implicit nationalism with nonsense. Have you ever been to the city limits of Mobile, Alabama? The place stinks of ammonia. Based on this experience, America is not a place I associate with any safety standards. See how that works?
- coupdejarnac 9y agoYou haven't done much to substantiate your position either. I can speak at length about things I have seen in China. I still love China, but it's not above criticism.
- squeegee3 9y agoHow does one go about proving a falsehood with absolutely no basis in truth? How do I prove the absence of allegedly subpar safety measures and private payroll information of GM? This is not a scientific approach. I substantiated my claim with reference to the article, and extensive information about GM’s vehicle is not present on their website beyond this, which lists a number of comparable safety features to the smart car: http://media.gm.com/media/cn/en/gm/news.detail.html/content/Pages/news/cn/en/2017/July/0721_SAIC-GM-Wuling-Launches-Baojun-E100.html http://media.gm.com/media/cn/en/gm/news.detail.html/content/... Let's stay on track here - this isn't about your irrelevant experiences traveling in China. Trolls use exactly this tactic to waste the time of dubious readers, in an apparent attempt to shift the burden of proof to anybody that’d bother. I'm not going to disprove every vague, unrelated anecdote you're willing to share. I don’t know where you hail from, but as an anglo-American citizen, let me be clear: this jingoistic willingness to support bullshit about American manufacturing in China makes the USA look pathetic and fearful about the rise of competitors. It is feckless to encourage English readers on HN with nonsense - the net effect is to stir readers into underestimating the vast safety engineering talent in China.
- averagewall 9y agoHow do you define a decent paycheck? Looks like low skill Chinese factory workers typically earn about 2x the living costs [1]. GM and its suppliers will certainly pay more than some random local factory. That factor of 2 is the same as a programmer in Silicon Valley. [2] Who's the one getting underpaid? [1] http://www.thayer-consulting.com/blog/2016/05/04/how-and-how-much-do-factory-workers-get-paid-in-china/ http://www.thayer-consulting.com/blog/2016/05/04/how-and-how... [2] https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-minimum-salary-needed-to-live-a-decent-life-in-Silicon-Valley-for-a-single-recent-graduate-that-isn%E2%80%99t-a-big-spender-and-wants-to-save-a-couple-thousand-dollars-each-month https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-minimum-salary-needed-to-l...
- driverdan 9y agoDaily Mail is a tabloid and not a reliable source.
- aeleos 9y agoHere is a more reliable source http://money.cnn.com/2017/08/07/autos/gm-china-electric-car/index.html http://money.cnn.com/2017/08/07/autos/gm-china-electric-car/... Wait that article is from more than a month ago, and so is the daily mail article. Why is this being posted now?
- craftyguy 9y agoCNN is a reliable source now?
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoMy opinion is that this sort of comment is unhelpful. Even Buzzfeed does some quality honest to God journalism once in a while. I feel like a comment like this should perhaps only happen if you can find something inherently wrong with the article in question, not just displeasure for a source site in general. Daily Mail may not be the Wall Street Journal, but in many cases I have found it serviceable, and in HN's case it is often just necessary for it to catalyze discussion on the topic. Perhaps go and find a better source for us, link it, and flag it for a mod to consider swapping the article in the parent.
- trafficlight 9y agoBecause a midrange sedan in the US is comparable to a cheap Chinese car.
- sergers 9y agoNot sure what your comment is specifically in response to, the article makes the comparison slightly in terms of affordability, not functionality nor luxury.
- koolba 9y agoHow far off would a car like this be from passing US safety standards?
- toisanji 9y agoWhy wouldn't something like this be released in America? What would the cost of this car be if it was sold in America including the changes it would need to comply with American standards? If it cost $10k, I would buy a couple of them immediately. Its perfect for city driving.
- jws 9y agoIt is already $14k, the lower price is with incentives. It is 10” smaller than a Smart car, top speed is 62mph, and it has a 90 mile range. That’s rough sell in America even before you try to make it safe enough to pass a crash test. (It might be, but I’m guessing with all the compromises they cut back on safety too.)
- r00fus 9y agoSafety costs money not just due to engineering but the testing and compliance process unique to each car model.
- icpmacdo 9y agoMaybe in China they could effectively modify a city with these and level 4 self driving. It seems like it could be a place where people would want to live.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoI have a feeling china will be the first to adopt self driving cars for mainly for environmental and congestion concerns; they are also authoritarian enough to actually do it. So ya, this could very well happen in 10 years or so.
- JSONwebtoken 9y agoHmmm something about a tiny automotive vehicle with a top speed of 62 mph and maybe a 80ft braking distance makes me feel more comfortable with getting into one. Certainly a higher error tolerance and lower risk of fatality as compared to a 5000 lb Tesla that goes to 0-60 in 2.4 seconds and takes a football field and a half to slow down. Maybe they should just make all self-driving cars weigh 1500 lbs and top out at 45 mph. Not a big deal when they run into each other, like bumper cars.
- schnevets 9y agoI have driven a Smart car through Car2Go (https://www.car2go.com/US/en/ https://www.car2go.com/US/en/), and it is an extremely unpleasant experience. The car handles terribly, and to reach the low price point, the entire interior is made out of cheap, Happy Meal toy plastic. I have also heard that maintenance is a pain and parts are expensive because of the low market share. I really don't understand who the hyper-cheap vehicle market in America is aimed towards. If you have less than $8k to spend on a mode of transportation, there are plenty of used beaters available. Repurposing an existing car will also make it more environmentally friendly than a brand new device.
- justonepost 9y agoAgreed, bizarre. There's a glut of used cars on the market. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-autos-used-analysis/u-s-used-car-glut-is-a-dealers-dream-automakers-nightmare-idUSKBN1880KE https://www.reuters.com/article/us-autos-used-analysis/u-s-u...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoDoes anyone remember the Geo Metro? It did ok enough back in the 90s, I remember my mom getting one when the family wasn't doing too hot. Used cars in the USA are tricky: you have a severe chance of getting a lemon with no decent warranty. Also, financing is much guarded on used than new. In Japan, they make cars over 5 years old prohibitively expensive to maintain. In China....well....you really can't trust anything used, they have ways of dressing up a total to look completely undamaged and even new.
- blueish 9y agoInteresting, I have an opposing viewpoint. I'm living in Vancouver, and don't have a car. The car2go system is very useful here, as great as transit is, it's hard to head home late at night or making grocery trips, which is where the smart cars come in. They may not be the most luxurious car, but they are still amazing for driving in the city. You don't need to go super fast (as you usually don't have the chance), and the "cheap" plastic they use for the interiors isn't as bad as you make it out to be. It's certainly not the choice I would make for a car, but they work really well in the city.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- csours 9y agohttps://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-09-19/china-is-said-to-mull-lifting-foreign-ev-cap-in-free-trade-zones-j7resw2r https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-09-19/china-is-... In more recent news, China may allow foreign automakers to set up EV brands/manufacturing without having a local Joint Venture Partner. Currently, all outside automakers (GM, BMW, Volkswagen, Toyota, etc, etc) must have a Chinese partner with at least a 50% stake. It will be interesting to see if this comes to pass, and how the foreign firms play it: ie, will GM choose Buick or Cadillac to be the EV brand in China? Disclaimer: I work for GM, but not on anything related to China.
- sergers 9y agohttps://www.gurufocus.com/news/570567/what-general-motors-has-up-its-sleeve-as-china-goes-electric https://www.gurufocus.com/news/570567/what-general-motors-ha... "By the end of 2020, the company will be selling 10 new electric vehicles. Barra commented:" “By 2025, nearly all models from GM’s global brands in China – Buick, Cadillac and Chevrolet – will offer electrification technology. To support GM’s growing NEV fleet planned for China; its SAIC-GM joint venture is opening a new battery assembly plant in Shanghai this year.”
- csours 9y agoElectrification = some kind of hybrid, or battery electric vehicle. In some contexts, this can include 48v mild hybrids, but I don't know about China.
- fragsworth 9y ago> Currently, all outside automakers (GM, BMW, Volkswagen, Toyota, etc, etc) must have a Chinese partner with at least a 50% stake. I think non-Chinese governments should start fighting back on this. It's kinda messed up that Chinese companies can do unlimited business in the U.S. and Europe but then when we have a business that might sell to China, they take more than half the profits.
- lafar6502 9y ago
- api 9y agoIt's ugly but it doesn't matter. If this hits the USA I will buy one last year. Goodbye petroleum age.
- Animats 9y agoThere's a market niche in China for cars in that size range. It's getting harder and harder to get a car registration for an internal-combustion engine car in Beijing. Electrics, though, can be registered much more easily. This one has better specs than most of the ones from Chinese companies.[1] [1] http://tangland.en.made-in-china.com/product/yjvxaLOlrrkS/China-Chinese-Mini-Electric-Car-with-ISO-Certificate.html http://tangland.en.made-in-china.com/product/yjvxaLOlrrkS/Ch...
- nikanj 9y agoI read the headline and in my mind said "probably somewhere outside North America". Looks like I was right. It's interesting how there seems to be no demand, or at least no supply, for vehicles like this in US/Canada. This would be the perfect commuter vehicle for our family.
- coliveira 9y agoI would be interested in a car like this for commuting. Unfortunately the rule in US is to restrict transportation options toward traditional automobiles.
- microcolonel 9y ago> I would be interested in a car like this for commuting. Unfortunately the rule in US is to restrict transportation options toward traditional automobiles. What about this is not a traditional automobile? It's kinda small, but what "rule" "restricts" you from treating it as an automobile? It's basically an electric smart car.
- drawnwren 9y agoUS vehicle import laws are incredibly arcane. Ask any tuner who has considered importing a Japanese car. There is a huge amount of money involved in making a car safe for the US and having the appropriate tests administered.
- microcolonel 9y agoRight, but coliveira didn't mention import. I for one would love to own a Hilux instead of a Tacoma, but if Toyota made a Hilux in NA then there would be no rule that restricts you from it. I agree that the legal standards for occupant safety are far too stringent, I feel like occupant safety should be an optional feature (especially for people who drive in conditions where you're either guaranteed to die no matter what, or guaranteed not to collide).
- 9y ago
- azolli 9y agoFucking sell it HERE already!
- thewhitetulip 9y agoI am happy to say that Indian manufacturer Mahindra already has such a car in India called E2O
- TekMol 9y agoGM DO 5K EV !!
- dba7dba 9y agoEV1 anyone?
- donkeyd 9y agoI feel like these types of cars will get a huge market share once we get to full autonomy and decreased ownership. Many people (like me) mostly use their cars to commute, but get larger cars so they can use tem for vacations and other times when a large car is convenient. Once you get used to be able to easily and affordably get a large car pull up where you need it, I think people will be fine with using tiny cars for their commutes. Especially if it means a lower price.
- DeepYogurt 9y agoIs it coming to the states?
- baybal2 9y agoChinese companies were selling not-bad corolla style sedans in Russia for around $7000 for a few years. $7000 is after taxes, and tarifs, with no subsidies
- GFischer 9y agoThey do still sell them ($8000 now), not sure if they're still sold in Russia but they sell very well in Uruguay. The BYD F3 is ridiculously cheap! (and good looking, I'm actually considering it when I manage to sell my 15 year old Renault) https://asia.nikkei.com/Business/Trends/Next-big-battle-in-China-auto-market-is-over-50000yuan-cars https://asia.nikkei.com/Business/Trends/Next-big-battle-in-C...
- ashwin67 9y agoAn electric car seemingly better than this has been in the Indian market (and some surrounding countries) for more than a decade now: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mahindra_e2o https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mahindra_e2o
- martin_a 9y agoI would totally buy that here in Germany... 100 miles would be enough to get me to work and back the whole week, I could charge at the company and buying groceries would be fine with this size of car, too. Totally reminds me of my smart, which was basically the same size and also this cheap. Buying an electric smart sets you back 21k € and you have to rent the battery on top (65 € per month), so it´s no real option...
- baybal2 9y agoElectric Smart clones from Zotye are sold right around $11 to $15k with VAT, and that with LiFePO4 batteries.
- sitkack 9y agoIt looks like between the Zotye [0] and the e.GO [1], teensy electrics cars will be everywhere. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JXodMy0HGMc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JXodMy0HGMc [1] http://e-go-mobile.com/en/models/e.go-life/ http://e-go-mobile.com/en/models/e.go-life/
- morganvachon 9y agoI've never been a fan of the Smart line of cars, if only because they are so damned expensive here in the US ($15k for the base model, 39mpg). In my mind, there's absolutely nothing "smart" about a gas powered two-seater with no frills that costs several thousand more than a four-seater with all the options from Nissan (Versa, $12k, 36mpg) or GM (Spark, $13k, 39mpg), especially given comparable gas mileage and more power in the latter vehicles. The only advantage the Smart ForTwo ever had in this country was easier parking. That said, this new EV in the same form factor as the Smart, at that insanely low price, is a no-brainer for city commutes and perhaps even for suburban/semi-rural. I know I could easily get a week's worth of daily driving out of it, and like you, my company would allow me to charge at work. While we would definitely take the traditional sedan on any long trips or vacations, local trips would be fun and practical in a little EV. Unfortunately, just like the Smart, it would be horribly overpriced if it ever came Stateside.
- themihai 9y agoWhy does it have to look so ugly? Is good design really that expensive?
- fragsworth 9y agoGood aesthetic design conflicts with other design goals (aerodynamics, range, safety). It looks to me like they designed it for optimal functionality rather than aesthetics.
- blux 9y agoBiased article; first sentence of the article: > As Tesla prepares to launch its 'affordable' Model 3 at $35,000, General Motors just unveiled a tiny electric car that costs only $5,000. Then later on: > The $5,300 cost is after local and national subsidies.
- owenversteeg 9y agoMost people care about the price they pay, not some other number somewhat related to the price in a world with no government. The Model 3's national subsidies are going to fade out before most people get them, so $35k vs $5k is a fair number.
- bede 9y agoPerhaps the HN community could avoid sending pageviews to ostensibly homophobic [0], racist [1] and generally vile establishments in the future? I realise this article is none of these things, but it seems unlikely that there would not be a viable alternative source. [0] https://twitter.com/moranicly/status/908710539500642304 https://twitter.com/moranicly/status/908710539500642304 [1] https://leftfootforward.org/2015/05/daily-mails-racial-scaremongering-on-filipino-killer-nurse-undermines-its-work-in-breaking-the-story/ https://leftfootforward.org/2015/05/daily-mails-racial-scare...
- technotarek 9y agoYour point would have been even stronger had you provided said alternative source.
- _joel 9y agoI fully agree, it's a hateful establishment that does nothing but stir tension. Here is an alternate source https://carnewschina.com/2017/08/08/meet-gms-cheapest-electric-car-new-baojun-e100-china/ https://carnewschina.com/2017/08/08/meet-gms-cheapest-electr...
- cnewey 9y agoFor those looking for a somewhat more reputable source for news on this article, CNN[0] has a good piece. [0] http://money.cnn.com/2017/08/07/autos/gm-china-electric-car/index.html http://money.cnn.com/2017/08/07/autos/gm-china-electric-car/...
- ddoran 9y ago> ... more reputable source ... Sorry for the sidetrack, but this comment struck me as odd. perhaps it was just a poor choice of words. FWIW, the last thing I thought I'd ever do was defend the Daily Mail. While I fundamentally disagree with the Daily Mail's politics and abhor their celebrity obsession, it is a 121 year-old newspaper with the second highest circulation in the UK. I haven't heard their reputation questioned before. No more than any other news source, that is.
- amiga-workbench 9y agoCertainly Not News ranks about the same as the Daily Mail personally.
- dijit 9y agoTheir reputation as a source of news is absurdly poor in the United Kingdom, please do not conflate circulation and age with being factual or reputable. Insidious companies can continue existing for a long time.
- cnewey 9y agoAs others have said - many people (quite rightly) have concerns about supporting the Daily Mail by giving it clicks, eyeball time, and advertising revenue. Partly because of their reputation of being rather unpleasantly right-wing when it comes to immigration, the economy, women's rights, etc; but also partly because their reputation as a truthful source of news is resoundingly poor (as evidenced by the DM being disallowed as a source on Wikipedia, their reputation for publishing embellished or downright untrue stories, etc). [edit]: After doing a bit more digging, it also turns out that CNN Money often publishes companies' press releases almost verbatim. Oops.
- super_mario 9y agoI would buy this immediately to commute to work downtown for those rainy days when biking isn't as pleasant or convenient. But of course, it is not available in NA and if it were somehow I doubt the price would remain $5k (which is roughly the same as a good carbon fiber road bike).
- quuquuquu 9y agoWhy on earth would someone commite to work on a $5,000 road bike when a similar experience could be had on a $500 road bike? Yikes.
- bfuller 9y agoInteresting question. I have always bought used steel frame road bikes from the 90s and consistently drop people on expensive carbon fiber bikes. If you aren't optimizing for many other factors already the amount of weight loss from the lighter frame will have a minimal effect.
- super_mario 9y agoI never said I am commuting on $5k road bike. I just compared the price of the electric car to price of high end carbon fiber road bike (which I have, but don't use for commuting to work). I commute on cheap mountain bike. Too many potholes and obstacles, etc for any road bike with 23mm tires. It would get destroyed on first ride to the city core.
- mikeash 9y agoThe title is pretty misleading. $5,000 is the price after government incentives. After some digging, I found this page with the pre-incentives price: http://www.chinamobil.ru/eng/saic/baojun/e100/?view=props http://www.chinamobil.ru/eng/saic/baojun/e100/?view=props If that's correct, then it starts at 93,900CNY which is currently a bit over $14,000. Still quite cheap (the Smart ED, which I believe is the cheapest EV you can buy in the US at the moment, is $26,000) but not nearly as cheap as the title implies.
- dmoy 9y agoIs that 93k rmb price after taxes and stuff? 'cus cars can be quite expensive in China not because of the car itself.
- mikeash 9y agoExcellent question, I have no idea. If anyone can provide better pricing info (track down the official Chinese web site for this car?) I'd love to see all the details.
- dmoy 9y agoCrap cus if that is after tax and the real price is half that or w/e, then offering that car in the US would make me very happy.
- GFischer 9y agoThat car probably doesn't meet US safety standards (most of the Chinese cars don't). China has cars for 4.000 USD that don't make the American market, many built in the same factory (we have lots of those here in Uruguay).
- snaky 9y agoTata GenX Nano XE is Rs 215,255 ($3,284), Bajaj Qute is $3000 in India. But what is coming is a wave of EV in China, that might be around $1000.
- rbanffy 9y agoI think this is less futuristic-looking but an overall better deal than the Renault Tweezy I've been considering for some time now. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Renault_Twizy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Renault_Twizy