23 ms·
The New Firefox and Ridiculous Numbers of Tabs
- libeclipse 9y agoIs there anything similar for chrome/chromium? Would be interesting to compare them.
- rc_kas 9y agoI <3 you Firefox. I'm so sad that nobody uses you.
- recursive 9y agoI'm eternally irritated that it doesn't support date inputs. This has been a thorn in my side for years.
- asadotzler 9y agoThis is being actively worked on and coming soon to Firefox.
- shorlander 9y agoShould be in 56: https://blog.nightly.mozilla.org/2017/06/12/datetime-inputs-enabled-on-nightly/ https://blog.nightly.mozilla.org/2017/06/12/datetime-inputs-...
- JBReefer 9y agoWorks on Firefox for Android
- franciscop 9y agoI hope it is locale-sensitive. US is the only country that uses mainly the mm/dd/yyyy. Most of the others use dd/mm/yyyy with some important exceptions (China, Japan, Korea) with yyyy/mm/dd (which happens to be the standard: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Date_format_by_country https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Date_format_by_country
- kuschku 9y agoactually, it’s almost never dd/mm/yyy, but dd.mm.yyy, and yyyy-mm-dd. Japan is one of the few offenders, almost everywhere else the separator can be used to identify the format.
- cyphar 9y agoAustralia also uses DD/MM/YYYY. You see ISO dates here and there but it's not as common.
- franciscop 9y agoI didn't mean about the separator at all, just the ordering. But good point.
- nnethercote 9y agoFirefox ships ~100 localizations. (See https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/nightly/all/ https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/nightly/all/ for the list.) I'm pretty sure this will be handled appropriately :)
- kevin_thibedeau 9y agoHard to love when the broken extension ecosystem prevents the use of vertical tabs for these scenarios.
- richardboegli 9y agoTree style tabs work
- kuschku 9y agoThat is broken because it supports more tabs. The multiprocess model is precisely why the old extension model had to be abandoned. Sadly, the new extension model isn’t nearly ready for prime time yet.
- lucb1e 9y agoI've got vertical tabs from Test Pilot for months now and I'll never turn back. Not sure what you're talking about.
- Chaebixi 9y ago> Not sure what you're talking about. They changed their add-on API and are in the process of deprecating the older one which allowed for radical UI changes. That's probably what he was talking about.
- lucb1e 9y agoWill their own test pilot addon stop working then?
- azdle 9y agoNope, it just that older extensions will and IIRC the developer of the tree-style-tabs extension was really vocal about the fact that he disliked the new API. He had claimed it would be impossible to port his extension to the new system. I'm not clear on the history of it all, so I don't know if it was possible at the time or not.
- SimonPStevens 9y agoI do, almost exclusively. It's nowhere near as bad as some people around here make out. I like it.
- Boothroid 9y agoMe too. How could I ditch Firefox?! It's been with me since 2004, through the dark days of IE, and still perfectly usable when compared with johnny-come-latelys like Chrome. I've never liked Chrome, and I don't trust Google. Long live Firefox!
- fletchowns 9y agoIt's been my main browser since 2004. So much more flexibility than Chrome. I wish this ticket would see some movement though! https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=101611 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=101611
- shawn-butler 9y agoThat issue has been open for 16 years? Kind of shocking when you think about it.
- lucb1e 9y ago> I'm so sad that nobody uses you. Well that's just false.
- rc_kas 9y agoFactually false, but statistically true.
- smnrchrds 9y agoIt is my main browser on Desktop. But after version 57, when Tab Groups extension (formerly Panorama) stops working, I am not sure whether I will continue using it.
- cpeterso 9y ago"Simplified Tab Groups" [1] is a similar Firefox extension and the developer says [2] he intends to make it compatible with the new WebExtension API. [1] https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/tab-groups/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/tab-groups/ [2] https://github.com/denschub/firefox-tabgroups/issues/60 https://github.com/denschub/firefox-tabgroups/issues/60
- clairity 9y agothat's just not true... i've used firefox consistently since v. 0.3 (phoenix) so that's at least one. plus a couple others in this thread make a few. i bet there are a few more out there too, so that makes a bunch. =) anyways, i have ~350 tabs open on firefox 54, and so i can't wait until 55 lands to see this great improvement. the chrome lead for mac told me that they too are working on better performance with 100's of tabs open and that should land sometime soon as well (even so, i'm a diehard firefox fan so it will be hard to make me switch).
- johnp_ 9y agoWhy not switch to Firefox Beta to get those improvements immediately? With the removal of the aurora channel, Mozilla is trying to get more people on the beta train, that now is the only stabilization phase between Nightly and Release. As a die-hard Nightly user I usually install the Beta (x64) version for other users and, depending on the add-on compatibility, enable e10s or some other features (e.g. TCP Fast Open) that may already be in A/B testing. Right now it makes an amazing difference in user satisfaction.
- clairity 9y agoyes, i have developer edition installed for testing, but still use the release version as my main browser. it's just a couple weeks left to wait so i think i can hang on until then. =)
- krylon 9y agoI've been using Firefox since the time it was still called Firebird, and I will continue to do so as long as it is in active development. Plus, having read that article, I feel much more comfortable leaving many tabs open (although I don't think I've ever had more than 100 open simultaneously).
- Accacin 9y agoA few months ago I switched to Chrome from Firefox for a couple of reasons. However, about a month later I switched back... I just feel dirty using Chromium =/ Although I think the dev tools in Chrome are superior, I love the way I can step through the code and have all the information I need displayed neatly against each step without having to manually watch everything. Is there anyway to get Firefox to do something similar?
- jug 9y agoI switched back to Firefox from Chrome. I'm interested in hanging on the ride with Rust and Servo integrations (Project Quantum), and I also like how it's community based rather than with standards support and features sometimes suspiciously following some company's agenda that don't always have user needs or interests as top priorities.
- frik 9y agoMozilla doesn't care about its community anymore, the lost focus, the mismanage Firefox and its quality gets worse. The multi process will never work with the current XUL based gecko code base - they could have told us the truth several years ago, instead they put some resources to it, and it gets no we're - it will never work like Chrome 1+ or IE 8+. Instead they should have focused on maintaining Firefox as it is and put more resources to Servo - which takes way too long already (a new Rust Lang doesn't help).
- johnp_ 9y agoWhere do you get the impression of e10s not working with the current code base? It works pretty great for me with 10+ processes and ~20 add-ons and is already enabled for ~50% of the Firefox population (though with more conservative defaults with the other half mainly blocked on add-on compatibility). There's no maintaining Firefox as it is and integrating Servo (which btw already works quite good on Nightly and webrender is also making great strides). The Rust language actually does help immensely because it makes developing Servo and other rust components way easier. Implementing servo in C++ would have likely taken longer and would definitely have been a maintenance nightmare.
- vanderZwan 9y agoThe only thing keeping in Chrome at the moment is that Firefox' debug tools don't let me profile JS line-by-line like Chrome does. Line-by-line testing to see what needs optimisation is seriously useful for the type of stuff I'm doing. EDIT: obviously, I spend most of my day developing. Firefox definitely has my preference when I'm ust browsing on my own.
- chippy 9y agoI'm also very impressed with FF's performance on Linux in recent versions. I bumped up the RAM allocated for multiprocess but I never really have more than 20 tabs open. Startup and rendering seems much quicker, and the add-ons seem more open.
- ac29 9y agoI'm curious, if you go to about:support are HW_COMPOSITING and OPENGL_COMPOSITING enabled? Someone (likely here) mentioned that setting layers.acceleration.force-enabled to true in about:config makes a dramatic difference in performance, and based on my limited experience, it does. So much so, that I'm thinking about switching to Firefox after many years of only using it sparingly due to lousy performance on Linux compared to Chrome (e10s has helped too). edit: I should note that HW_COMPOSITING and OPENGL_COMPOSITING are not enabled by default on the 2 Arch Linux systems I have (Ivy Bridge and Haswell iGPUs, up to date Firefox, Mesa and Kernel). Not sure if there is a white/blacklist, or if its just always disabled in Linux.
- suby 9y agoIs there a particular reason that layers.acceleration.force-enabled is off by default?
- johnp_ 9y agoLinux users have a lower priority and there are some hard to debug issues with graphics drivers and sometimes it causes horrible performance and freezes. https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=ogl-linux-beta https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=ogl-linux-beta
- septentrional 9y agoSorry if this is somewhat off-topic but how do you make Firefox' tab bar look like the one in the article (i.e. no rounded edges for the tabs) on MacOS?
- asadotzler 9y agoFirefox has two alternative built-in themes, compact light and compact dark.
- septentrional 9y agoI've never noticed this, thank you!
- manuelmagic 9y agoI have the bad habit to open many tabs on my old MacBook (mid 2010). Boot time, together with CPU usage, is one of the main reasons I had to use Opera as my primary browser. I'm really happy to see this might change in the near future.
- elfchief 9y agoWow. I've been getting more and more frustrated with how poorly Chrome handles even a moderately large number of tabs (~150), and it sounds like my savior is going to be ... Firefox. Huh. Wouldn't have guessed it, but I'll totally take it. I have a nice extension for Chrome called Quick Tabs that gives me a searchable list of my open tabs and makes it easy to find things I have open... anyone know which of the several things that seem to do that with Firefox would be the best to use?
- kbrosnan 9y ago"% foo" will search your open tabs for foo. See https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/awesome-bar-search-firefox-bookmarks-history-tabs#w_changing-results-on-the-fly https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/awesome-bar-search-fire... for other characters that will filter the search results for other data such as bookmarks, history, tags, etc.
- Flammy 9y agoCool trick... But I wish it did a full text search as it appears to only search URLs and tab titles. (maybe there is a different symbol that does full text?)
- pritambaral 9y agoAdd a '#' to further restrict the search to page titles.
- Manishearth 9y agoAnd even if you don't use %, the awesomebar will include open tabs in results if it thinks them relevant!
- Fej 9y agoWait, Chrome doesn't have tab search built in? Jeez. TIL. Couldn't live without it.
- hedning 9y ago
- outworlder 9y agoI use Firefox as much as I can, for many reasons. Two things keep me from using it all the time: – Yubikey – My Chromebook (I would use and equivalent FirefoxOS if given the choice) There are performance issues in some cases but nothing major. It is still somewhat slow compared to Chrome, even though this may be due to optimizations done specifically for Chrome.
- raindev 9y agoThere's a plugin for U2F support[1]. I use a Yubikey at work daily without issues. 1. https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/u2f-support-add-on/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/u2f-support-a...
- kuschku 9y agoMany sites, including Google, specifically check the UA instead of checking for U2F support, so won’t work with this.
- revelation 9y agoWhut? It didn't get any faster, it's just more aggressively lazy loaded now. This is breaking the very use case of people who have 100+ tabs; they want stuff to be there when they click on it.
- ehsanu1 9y agoAs a many tabs user, I don't agree. The use case is more like a more visible bookmark, with history. Any tabs commonly used will already be loaded, and it is fine to lazy load tabs that are rarely used but kept open as reminders. It's definitely a much better experience than waiting 5 minutes after startup for the CPU activity to die down.
- mkl 9y agoNot true. On most days I visit <30 open tabs (out of hundreds). I'm happy to wait for a page to load when I visit an old one, and I'd really like my browser to unload pages I'm not actively using (but give me an override). Tabs for me are like much more convenient bookmarks.
- bobcostas55 9y agoThis is completely right. None of those tabs are doing anything, they're literally just holding a URL and waiting to load it when the user switches over to that tab. It's not a tab, it's a bookmark. I've got a gazillion tabs open on Chrome right now and guess what, they're all actually open.
- yoasif_ 9y ago> None of those tabs are doing anything, they're literally just holding a URL and waiting to load it when the user switches over to that tab. It's not a tab, it's a bookmark. The tabs store state too, so they aren't just bookmarks - I just closed the browser with just your quoted text in the reply form, and upon restart, the text was restored. Chrome does seem to work this way as well, but loads all tabs by default instead of lazy loading when a user navigates to the tab. https://wiki.mozilla.org/Firefox/session_restore#Restoring_sessions https://wiki.mozilla.org/Firefox/session_restore#Restoring_s...
- valuearb 9y agoDear god, why?
- aboodman 9y agoWhy do you have a profile w/ 1600 tabs in it. If whatever it is is so important, aren't you afraid to lose it? I'd be terrified that one time Firefox just wouldn't shut down clean.
- canuckistani 9y agoThis isn't his main profile ( well I hope not any way ), it's a profile used to test extreme startup performance issues.
- ehsankia 9y agoYou'd be surprised. And if not that many, I know many many people with 100+ tabs. I never really understood the workflow myself. Every time I have more than 20 tabs, I generally can get to the page I'm looking for faster by googling it than having to find it in my tabs. But I guess to each their own.
- dijit 9y agoSometimes after searching for some time I'll come to something quite arcane that I want to hold on to. (I know this is what bookmarks are for but the UI is so poor here) Other times I'll find something and think; I'll read that later. Or. Less often, I'll be recurring into different things looking for solutions to a problem I have. Eventually I'll find something relevant and close the tab that was last opened, I forget the others and they become orphaned in my like of tabs I'll likely never get back to, until my browser crashes hard and I lose everything. After the mild panic a wave of relief washes over me, and I go about my business hoarding tabs once again.
- ehsankia 9y agoThe first example, it seems like we need a better UI for bookmarks. Something that allows you to organize and quickly search them (url, title and even maybe page content). For the second, we all do that, but again, the optimal thing there would be to have some extension or tool that keeps track of your "to read" list. As for tabs stacking when you're looking for a solution, that's generally what my comment referred to. I know somewhere in those 20 tabs, there's one for the documentations to the function I'm trying to use, but it's honestly faster to search for it again than look at those 20 tabs for it.
- mrkrabo 9y agoI suppose I'm alone in getting all nervous if I have more than 10 tabs open.
- sirfz 9y agoSame here, if I start needing to scroll through open tabs it means I should immediately start closing some.
- Chromozon 9y agoI also use a small amount of tabs, usually under ten. When I want to go to something, I want to immediately be able to click it without having to spend time searching for it. Sometimes I watch over coworkers' shoulders as they are navigating their browsers, and they definitely spend a significant amount of time looking through tabs trying to find what they need. There is a terrible, visible lag time between asking them to navigate to a certain page and them actually being able to find and go to the correct tab. Maybe my coworkers are just inefficient at managing large amounts of tabs, but I have yet to see someone who is. Having fewer tabs might also keep one more focused because there is only so much in front of you at a time. You don't have to process through a bunch of data that is unrelated to the current task at hand.
- hbosch 9y agoI also get tab-induced anxiety. I have to close them and organize them when it gets ~10 or I can't keep browsing. On the other hand, my desktop is an unorganized mess of random files...
- kairuku 9y agoI feel the same way - it bothers me to have tabs open that I'm not actively working on (or, I feel like I need to actively remember the context of all my tabs). When I get to 12 or so I close any tab that I don't feel like I'll want to return to in the next hour.
- yoasif_ 9y agoGetting nervous because your computer starts slowing down or swapping because of the number of tabs open, or because you can't read the tab titles or see the favicons anymore? Firefox doesn't have those problems. ;)
- rndmize 9y agoThis is nice to hear. I use Firefox as my default browser with the tree-style tabs add-on, and just yesterday I replaced ABP with uBlock and Ghostery with Disconnect out of frustration with how slow things were going (~30-50 tabs open). The slow startup time hasn't been helping (come on, its not even loading the tabs until I click them, what's taking so long?)
- technojunkie 9y agoHint: uBlock Origin already includes filters for Disconnect if you go to the settings
- reiichiroh 9y agoWith Chrome, I use "The Great Suspender" extension.
- alexpw 9y agoThis. Changed the way I use a browser. New window per topic. Only stop making tabs when the titles/icons can't be seen any more...
- bzbarsky 9y agoIn Firefox, the "titles/icons can't be seen any more" state is never reached, because Firefox enforces a minimum width on tabs so that information is always visible. Combined with searching tab titles via "% stuff" in the URL bar, it's a much nicer experience than Chrome, imo. [Disclosure: I'm biased, obviously, since I'm using Firefox and hence more used to it.]
- huntie 9y agoI'm really glad that people at Mozilla use ridiculous numbers of tabs too. Lazy-loading of tabs is the reason I switched to firefox. I'm not sure if it's still this way, but Chrome used to load every tab on startup. So even if you only had 100 tabs, you were looking at 5+ minute startup time. God-forbid that any of them were Youtube, or you'd have to go through and pause them all. I've just updated to Firefox 55 to test this, and the improvement is ridiculous. I hope that Firefox focuses more on power users in the future. I'm curious what the author uses to manage all of these tabs. I use Tab Groups, but I think they won't work in a few Firefox versions so I'm looking for alternatives.
- wging 9y agoYouTube is a bit smarter these days: they defer playback until the tab first gets focus. So you have to pause at most as many videos as there are separate windows, not tabs. I believe Chrome is not nearly as smart as it could be about deferring loading of tabs, though.
- tokenizerrr 9y agoIt's not youtube doing that, but chrome. The html5 video element doesn't start playback until the tab first gets focus.
- FreeFull 9y agoFirefox has the same thing, but you have to enable it in about:config
- kibwen 9y agoDo you have to enable it? I use Firefox Nightly, and have been observing this behavior for a long, long time. It's one of those things that's so minor and yet so important that I wonder how I went without it for so long.
- 9y ago
- BlytheSchuma 9y agoLOL I've been running Firefox with 5k+ tabs since 2009.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ilaksh 9y agoThere are a lot of people who use tabs as bookmarks. Seems like a good way to keep the RAM industry going strong. Someone once told me (seriously) "I need at least 128 GB of RAM otherwise I can't keep my tabs open." But does everything you were interested in over the last X weeks or months really need to be loaded up? No, and if you use it like that then it can't preload stuff. I think the main lesson is that bookmarks don't work too well or people just don't use them. If nothing else, make the bookmark display show newer bookmarks rather than the same old ones from four years ago. And maybe start preloading if they are opened regularly. Merge two features together, maybe add optional other organizational features for example similar to new tab screen. The tricky thing is that there are a lot of things that are potentially supposed to happen while a tab is open. The browser is now it's own OS, and it may be very difficult for developers to use important features if tabs (processes) only _look_ like they are running.
- motoboi 9y agoI had the same feeling. Seems like they are using tabs as a history. A better history may solve their problem.
- Arelius 9y agoSure a better history along with bookmarks and a pile of things could indeed fix my problem. But using tabs also fixes my problem perfectly well.
- jackiejj22 9y agoThat is delusional. So “perfectly well” that it was slow, broken, and had to be specifically optimized for? So instead of advancing browsing for everyone, Mozilla made it so a few idiots wouldn’t complain that “Firefox is slow when I do stupid things” There are many ways to do something, many of them are dumb
- tr1ck5t3r 9y agoOr a better tab interface, I cant see how its productive scooting left or right to find the correct tab, even with a mouse scroll wheel. Still its a low hanging fruit diversion from making Firefox more secure.
- droithomme 9y agoWhen I see bug reports with these sorts of ridiculous over the top use cases, I think, yeah buddy, why don't you join the project and fix it since it's only applicable to you. And in this case that happened. This guy is an actual Firefox developer. This is as it should be and congrats. Now I am wondering how I can possibly get into this mysterious world of having thousands of tabs open.
- adrianmonk 9y agoA quick tangent to plug my method for paring down open tabs when it gets out of control: I create a document! Personally I use Google Docs, but you could use a wiki or MS Word or many other things. The point isn't the technology, it's that when you have a whole slew of tabs open, and you feel the urge to keep them open, it's a strong sign that your mind is trying to gather info about a topic. Putting it into a document often feels great. It gives you an opportunity to type out a few quick notes on the topic (like what you thought was significant about various links) or other thoughts you had. And you might find you want to share the document with people you're working with. And I find I feel more organized, not just because I cleaned up something messy but because I took a moment to focus my energies on something my mind was begging me to pay attention to. Sometimes you even realize you need two different documents on different subjects, and it's a little enlightening to realize the two separate themes.
- smaddox 9y agoI just pocket them and then close them. Once pocketed, I can easily go back and find them with full text search.
- Manishearth 9y agoI once wrote AnnoTabe (https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/annotabe/fdhebnledngmjdkhgamneiapbmjeigee?hl=en https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/annotabe/fdhebnled...) for this in Chrome. Bare minimum extension that lets you annotate tabs, and find them again after closing them. Pocket is good for this too.
- lobster_johnson 9y agoI've been considering switching to Firefox due to these performance improvements, but the one feature that's always missing is for the location bar to autocomplete terms from other sources such as Wikipedia. Is there some add-on I can install that can fix this? Safari is brilliant here. If you enter something in Safari's location bar, it will suggest Wikipedia and other search suggestions right away [1]. I use this feature all the time. But FF, out of the box, will only show suggestions from one source. Here [2] is what FF suggests; all the hits are from Google, and it doesn't try to be clever about showing what I might mean to search for. Notice how it offers to search Wikipedia, with this tiny, obscure icon at the bottom of the suggestions, which I find to be a completely useless feature (I have keywords for that). The top hit tends to be what Google puts in a special box in its search results. Here is another nice thing Safari does [3] which I make use of all the time. I've not visited walmart.com, so that "Top Hit" is just because it's a popular site. I can't make FF do anything like that. [1] http://i.imgur.com/83FfnPn.png http://i.imgur.com/83FfnPn.png [2] http://i.imgur.com/T4p1NZv.png http://i.imgur.com/T4p1NZv.png [3] http://i.imgur.com/MkRP2Le.png http://i.imgur.com/MkRP2Le.png
- nerdponx 9y agoDuckDuckGo does a good job of this. So it's not exactly suggestions in your search bar, but it's damn close. Also you can configure FF to have selectable search tools including Wikipedia and Stackoverflow.
- lobster_johnson 9y agoBut I am specifically asking about suggestions in the search bar.
- glandium 9y agoSee this recent (sub) thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14808645 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14808645
- lobster_johnson 9y ago
- wnevets 9y agoWhat made it so much worse over time?
- the8472 9y agoThings that need to be initialized per tab. Lazy-loaded tabs were till backed by about:blank content window which get replaced with the actual content once you open the tab. And with that about:blank comes overhead, which is fairly small for a single tab but it adds up in large numbers. The change is that now the tab item does not have an associated content window at all until you visit it.
- Koshkin 9y agoCan anyone offer an explanation of why should not tabs be managed by the window manager? (My understanding is that this question is independent from how the particular application would choose to control the contents of a tab - whether directly, or through a separate thread, or by spawning a child process.)
- asadotzler 9y agoWindow managers failed us and that's why we created tabbed browsing.
- symlinkk 9y agoTabs handled by the OS / window manager seems to be the direction things are headed. MacOS already has a tabs api [0] and Windows is experimenting with a feature called "Tabbed Shell" that would provide a tabs API for the devs that want to use it and would wrap existing application in a tabbed shell for apps that don't. [1] [0]: https://developer.apple.com/library/content/documentation/Tools/Conceptual/SafariExtensionGuide/WorkingwithWindowsandTabs/WorkingwithWindowsandTabs.html https://developer.apple.com/library/content/documentation/To... [1]: https://www.windowscentral.com/windows-10-tabbed-shell https://www.windowscentral.com/windows-10-tabbed-shell
- the8472 9y agoFor that you need a good window manager that supports tabbing, tiling, floating, grouped resizes etc. I.e. something like i3.
- bananaoomarang 9y agoI think at some point the browser will collapse back into the desktop shell as a multipurpose document viewer. Window managers will need to catch up first, though.
- frik 9y agoWe had that already. Opera was the first browser with tabs, it had MDI support and tabs. MDI stands for Multiple Document Interface, and was common with Win 3x and Win9x (WinAPI) applications: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiple_document_interface https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiple_document_interface . Macromedia Dreamweaver had tabs even before Opera browser, as well as Frontpage. Word, Excel and PowerPoint used to be MDI applications up to Office 2010 (up to 2003 with a good UI, kind of hidden but still that way until 2010). Photoshop on Win, older Acrobat, mIRC, etc use MDI and have tabs as well. Win3x had all the auto arrange and different MDI modes, Win95 unfortunately broke the "icon" MDI mode, though the mode still exists but doesn't work in Win95 or later. So it would be great if Chrome and other browsers would support MDI with tabs like the old Opera 4-6. Use could auto-arrange two tab-windows within the browser main window side by side or arrange them in any way you wanted by hand. Very unfortunately Microsoft lost all their proper devs from last century and with it all the previous inbuilt WinAPI knowledge - otherwise Win8 and Win10 trainwrecks would never have happened.
- ledgerdev 9y agoI would love get rid of chrome and to switch back to firefox as my everyday browser, but simply can't get over how messy/ugly the tabs(even in compact theme) and window title look compared to what chrome does with tabs and title bar, and lack of window title bar.
- mconley 9y agoIf you enter customize mode, you can: 1) Choose one of the compact themes, which have square tabs instead of curved and 2) Re-enable the title bar
- evolve2k 9y agoMy biggest frustration with Firefox is that you can't 'Tab to Search' as you can in chrome. Every time I attempt to switch to FF the lack of this feature just kills my productivity and I end up switching back. So wish this was possible. Ref: https://www.chromium.org/tab-to-search https://www.chromium.org/tab-to-search
- Osmose 9y agoA similar (but not as magical) feature in Firefox is Smart keywords: https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/how-search-from-address-bar https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/how-search-from-address... There's a bug on file to consider adding this, but it has no momentum behind it right now since it's a bit niche: https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1373740 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1373740
- cpeterso 9y agoI used to have dozens of Firefox Smart Keywords (for Wikipedia, Amazon, etc), but now I just use DuckDuckGo's !bang searches in my address bar: https://duckduckgo.com/bang https://duckduckgo.com/bang
- once-in-a-while 9y agoI would vote for at least 365 tabs open (as a normal medium) to every every-day user (yess, you guessed it: one for every day of the year). So, if The Holy Internets are (unexpectedly) down for a whole year or so, you still have (relative) news to fill every single one of your wake-ups!
- randomString1 9y agoI find way more productive to use bookmarks - Archive folder: bookmark dump to keep the links just in case I ever need it again (so they pop on the search bar even after I clean my history, you can also add keywords manually if you want) - Buffer folder: to-dos, reminders and things I <need> to read soon™. I keep it at a maximum of 10 items at all times - Follow up folders (plural): pages I want to check ocasionally for updates. Often used for pages without RSS. I don't like to use extensions to check for page modification because I want to do it on my own pace. This helps reducing my mental load because I know it's there if I ever need it. I often delete the entire folder if I don't feel it's useful anymore. - The rest are folders divided by a main folder and subject. This way I can easily delete them after I'm done with that task (after a minute or after a year). Example: Programming > Project X, Programming > CSS fix for that thing. Middle click on the folder to open everything at once. Done. The position of the folders are crucial and also helps with muscle memory. I keep it like this: the more to the right (of the browser), the more disposable they are.
- johansch 9y agoOpera has supported this abnormal behavior for like two decades now. I remember being shocked by how many tabs the Opera core browsing/rendering engine developers used to have open on their desktops when I joined Opera back in 2004. I guess it was an odd pride thing? :) To clarify: I am talking about a one-row tab scenario. With about 3-4 pixels per tab. And they were perfectly happy with that. Even seemed to feel it was a good user experience.
- PhasmaFelis 9y agoI'm torn between thinking it's time to switch back to Firefox, and thinking I need to avoid Firefox at all costs, because the slowdown when Chrome gets over 100+ tabs is the only thing keeping my browser windows remotely navigable. You know what I really want? A way to attach titles to browser windows. This window is "Games", this one is for "Books", this one is for my current "Work" task, this one is "Research" on the new doohickey I'm thinking of buying...
- cpeterso 9y agoCheck out the Firefox extension "Simplified Tab Groups" to create named groups of tabs: [1] https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/tab-groups/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/tab-groups/
- PhasmaFelis 9y agoHoly shit. Don't have time to try it right now, but if it does what I want I probably will go back to Firefox. Thanks!
- hvis 9y agoIt was a built-in feature for manu Firefox releases (called Panorama), but then it was removed, and ended up in extensions.
- bbernoulli 9y agoI would like a way to have opera tab stacks style groups but also with functionality to somehow automatically group tabs based on title, url, etc.
- crorella 9y agoI tested with 1690 tabs and got similar results :D
- CurtMonash 9y agoI use ridiculous numbers of tabs, and Firefox has been less stable for me the past months than ever before.
- userbinator 9y ago"Ridiculous" is right, especially from a UI perspective --- it still puzzles me why they would design it so that by default all the tabs are crammed into the place which used to be the titlebar, making it difficult to both read the title and find the tab you're looking for. I've seen others start opening multiple windows when the tabs get too small. I usually do that to keep tabs grouped into "pages I am unlikely to view simultaneously".
- Manishearth 9y agoChrome's UI is worse. Firefox shrinks tabs until they're maybe 10 characters in width, and then lets you scroll through them. Chrome just shrinks forever. I've found that a vertical tabs addon (Tree Tabs, Tab Center Redux) is great for fixing this problem, since vertical tabs never get squeezed.
- smichel17 9y agoI do as you do, but I use the tab groups addon and use groups instead of windows.
- mokame 9y agof
- mokame 9y agoh
- forevercrashing 9y agoSurprised to see no mention of Tab Center (https://testpilot.firefox.com/experiments/tab-center https://testpilot.firefox.com/experiments/tab-center) in the comments. I've gotten so used to it that now I find it hard to use a browser with tabs on top. Being able to see more of the page title when tabs are displayed horizontally is extremely useful. There's a search field too. This combined with the "browser.ctrlTab.previews" set to true in about:config (enables MRU tab switching with ctrl-tab) makes managing tabs awesome for me.
- Manishearth 9y agoNote that Tab Center will stop working by the end of this year, but I have found https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/tab-center-redux/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/tab-center-re... to be an adequate replacement!
- 6ak74rfy 9y agoHow is this different from Tree Tabs?
- Manishearth 9y agoThere's no tree, it's flat. I find it works better than Tree Tabs at the moment unless you need the tree.
- idlewan 9y agoShameless plug: the current lack of a WebExtension for vertical tabs bothered me, so I wrote one: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/vertigo-tabs/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/vertigo-tabs/
- ChoGGi 9y agoI measured by eyeball, using "time cat" on the command line. This might seem weird, but c'mon - I'm measuring minutes. Microsecond precision is not required. For anyone else doing this sort of testing; there is an extension to monitor startup speed called about:startup https://addons.mozilla.org/addon/about-startup/ https://addons.mozilla.org/addon/about-startup/
- austinjp 9y agoAnd then there's Firefox Focus which has no tabs and no other new instance capability. One single window. "Focus" indeed. It still makes me twitchy, but is so far completely usable. Could do with a "fetch as desktop" mode, though.
- ajmurmann 9y agoHow does this work in practice. I frequently have workflows where for example I have the AWS or GCloud console open and in parallel some kind of tutorial, documentation or help page I'm looking at. Would you go back and forth?
- austinjp 9y agoYeah the one major issue is comparison shopping: you can't open multiple tabs/windows and flick between them. Then again, "focus" might mean reading one review at a time. Or instead waiting until you're at a desktop and remembering to do it. If you forget, are you worse off or better off? It's just a different situation. Depends on your criteria. Certainly, I've not missed it on my mobile.
- overcast 9y agoI was already using 55.x Beta. My BIGGEST issue, is that EVERY browser seems to chew up memory over time, just by leaving it open with tabs going. Firefox, Chrome, Safari. All do the same thing. Alleviated by using the Great Suspender in Chrome, but why can't they all have this just built in? Startup/speed, and initially memory use really haven't been that big of an issue. It's the memory, and finally grinding to a halt that is the BIGGEST issue for me. I can't escape it. Happens on MacOS, and Windows for me.
- gamekathu 9y agoI just downloaded 55.x beta to see whats such hype about, but opening more tabs are still chewing memory on Mac. maybe it is not mac optimized yet?
- overcast 9y agoYeh I've gone from 500MB to 1.06GB in the time since I wrote the last post, an hour? Forty tabs total.
- the8472 9y agoThere is a fairly big, incrementally growing memory leak in firefox that has been fixed in recent nightlies and uplifted to beta 5 days ago. So it'll probably be in the next beta build. https://bugzil.la/1377738 https://bugzil.la/1377738
- eyeball 9y agoThe OneTab extension has been really good for helping me handle my tab hoarding tendency. https://www.one-tab.com/ https://www.one-tab.com/ It lets you hit a button and send all open tabs to a single page that persists between browser sessions. You can remove a link by opening up that list and clicking on it. Has a bunch of other handy features too ... like publishing the list of links to a share-able URL.
- pacomerh 9y agoI'm pretty happy with this extension too. The other one I use is 'The Great Suspender' which basically suspends unused tabs to free up resources.
- fiatjaf 9y agoI have 2 tabs open right now. If the number of open tabs gets over 10 I start to actively look for tabs to close.
- renolc 9y agoI'm the same way. I use bookmarks for places I regularly visit that I will want to have ready access to (things like work related services and what have you). For just articles or something I'll want to read later, I've started using the Google Inbox extension to save the link as a reminder. From there I can snooze it until I have the time or motivation to actually read it.
- ernsheong 9y ago(shameless plug) For those of you keeping many many tabs open because you worry you might forget it again, or working on related topics, I am building https://www.pagedash.com https://www.pagedash.com to save your page exactly as you saw it, and everything from the original page (HTML and assets) are saved to PageDash so that you can load it again without worrying that the original page went bonkers/down. v1 will be quite basic, just a list of saved pages. Expect more organization tools (folders, tags, etc.) in the further releases. Please do sign up to be informed of impending release! :) (estimated end August) Also, do leave a reply if you are keen on using ML (link classification) to help organize your pages for you. Unfortunately, because computers can't read our minds, this can't be perfect so folders are probably still relevant for your mini-projects.
- caio1982 9y agoThis is the first time in a decade that something (the article) convinced me to try Firefox as a possible day-to-day browser once again.
- minusSeven 9y agoI wonder what these numbers would be compared to chrome.
- digitalzombie 9y agolol this is why I love firefox. I hoard tabs. But not as excessively as OP though... 1000+ is crazy.
- linuxray 9y agothanks for info
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- versteegen 9y agoI currently have over 1380 tabs open in firefox 52 ESR (over 4 windows). Oh god, it's terrible. Very slow and unresponsive, CPU usage is typically 60+% when idle. I restart firefox every couple days (which takes many minutes) to keep CPU and memory usage down, by causing all tabs to be unloaded. (As an example, right now at 5.2GB resident, with only a small percentage of tabs loaded). I've been trying to kick the habit. I also have several other profiles and other computers. Probably adds to 5000 tabs all in all. I use All Tabs Helper to help jump between tabs. Finding tabs is hopeless without it. ATH also has features like mass closing tabs or unloading them. I wish it had a way to bookmark tabs, which I would use to close most of my tabs. So, I'm very glad to hear this. Time to switch off ESR.
- iamleppert 9y agoFirefox is a case study in how performance really does matter. A lot. It used to be the best browser, and then something happened and it gradually became slow, really slow, while Chrome became fast. Who was in charge over at Mozilla during all this? Any engineering director worth their salt would have noticed what was happening and installed metrics that didn't let engineers commit code that caused performance regressions and given an engineer (or multiple engineers) who loves optimizing things carte blanche. Really, I want to know what happened over there. Does anyone know?
- icelancer 9y agoI think multiprocess/multi-tab was a big separator for a long time, as well as plugin memory leakage being way worse on Firefox (initially because Chrome had nearly none to speak of). I very reluctantly switched to Chrome. I loved Firefox. I even know today that Firefox likely suits my needs better... but at this point I'm too old and too stuck to change. Chrome doesn't yet make me so angry that I have to switch. Horowitz is right (along with every other entrepreneur) when they say for someone to switch, the next product has to be an order of magnitude better than the currently adopted product. Anything less isn't enough.
- Sonicrida 9y agoI will check up on Firefox every couple of months to see if it's still slow. The moment at which I feel the performance matches my chrome experience, I'm going back.
- starik36 9y agoYou should check today then. The performance more than matches Chrome. In some area, it's straight up faster than Chrome (like closing tabs, for instance).
- frik 9y agoMozilla turned to a big corp (even if non profit) and got too many new staff. The original staff that was part since early Mosaic and Netscape days left. When Firefox got this new rounded tabs and left the slower release cycle around Firefox 3 it was the tipping point. It changed from a community project back to a corp project, that again doesn't care.
- fouc 9y agoNote for the blog author: "It's interesting that Firefox startup time got consistently worse over time until Firefox 51." I believe you meant to write "until Firefox 52." I think the usage of "until" would typically point out the exception to the rule, in this case Firefox 52 is the first version that is no longer slower than the previous.
- problems 9y agoI've been running a ~7 year old laptop for occasional browsing. Chrome is unable to seek properly in video playback (gives page unresponsive after a while) and lags randomly when loading large pages, I suspect due to RAM allocations. Old Firefox played videos fine, but lagged on many page loads. I was about to conclude it was just too old to browse the web decently, but this... this seems incredibly usable. Thanks Mozila, I'm definitely installing this thing on my main, much more modern machine tomorrow.
- codychan 9y agoImpressive, now I'm looking forward to the official stable version of 55
- daef 9y agoMy usual day looks something like this: open FF (it it's not already running) and wait for a hand full app-tabs to load: * slack (there's no dark theme in the native app) * skype (there's no dark theme in the native app) * toggl (timetracking) * email (office365, I stopped worrying about outlook/thunderbird) * jira (gotta know what to work on next) * social (fb&twitter - could probably also do w/o - I rarely open those) since they exist I'm also use a hand full tab groups - at least those 3: * work * private * to read the work tab group usually starts empty (at least when I finished up the day before), might grow to a hundred or two during the day - but usually ends up empty at the end of the day when I'm done again. I hardly ever left-click a link, I only wheelclick. but my ^w is at least as fast as my wheel click - since the awesomebar searches through history, pagetitles and already openend tabs it's really easy to navigate even between tab groups just by ^t, type 3 letters, press return to 'switch to tab' (really convenient icon there so you know you're going to close the new tab and switch to an existing tab at this moment) if I want to restore a tab i killed prematurely I fire up the history - where I only use the 'by last visited view' - does anyone srsly use the 'by date and site' view? tabs are something very different than bookmarks to me, a bookmark is something I return to on a regular basis - a tab is an open 'todo'. I don't use the usual bookmarks thou, only the bookmark-toolbar below the url - and my bookmarks there have no text - they get renamed to "" so I only see their favicon. entries there are e.g. * HN * blog.fefe * oglaf * xkcd ... one thing that I really disliked that mozilla sometimes decided to drop the dedicated keyboardshortcut to hide/show the bookmark-toolbar (I tend to hide it for screenshots where I want the URL to be on the screenshot https://xkcd.com/1863/ https://xkcd.com/1863/ ) I have no idea what I'm going to do after the death of the tab groups extension. one thing that really bugs me is that every time a show tab groups to 'normal users' (tm) they insta love them. I really wonder if no one used to use them bcs hardly anyone ever knew about them.
- amai 9y agoYou might want to try http://meetfranz.com/ http://meetfranz.com/ .
- TekMol 9y agoGreat that you can open over a thousand tabs now. Next blog post will be when it's over a million I guess? Personally, I usually have something like 3 or 4 tabs open. But what I would really need is this: https://xkcd.com/619/ https://xkcd.com/619/ Yup, hardware accelerated video on Linux. Chromium has it. Firefox doesn't. It's 2017 and for me Firefox is still missing the basic feature of seeing smooth Youtube videos. Anybody working on that? Can't you just take it from Chromium? I mean it's open source, isn't it?
- muppetman 9y agoThis would have been useful 4 years ago before we all gave up on Firefox.
- kronos29296 9y agoIf such numbers happen in android also you sir just have another firefox fan. I want to know right now. (Chrome sucks at this on all devices now.) The only reason I am using it is that it is better than firefox for accessing google.
- cf 9y agoSo one challenge I face is that many of my tabs are for web content that isn't always there. Do any of these extensions like Great Suspender, Session Buddy, etc actually let me save the webpage as it is and then let me choose to refetch it as necessary?
- akaralar 9y agonot exactly what you're looking for but pinboard.in archival account does this: https://pinboard.in/upgrade/ https://pinboard.in/upgrade/
- giancarlostoro 9y agoI love Firefox and never had issues, except at work. For some odd reason it will break, all tabs will look white and all I see is a loading icon on the middle no matter what tab I click on ruining my workflow. No idea what that's about since at home Firefox works fine, Chrome seems to work fine at work on the other hand. I guess I'll be using Chrome at work and Firefox at home till I figure out how whats causing the Firefox issue. I only usually have no more than 20 tabs open at any given time. Very unusual for me to keep 10 tabs open really.
- scott_karana 9y agoI had a very similar issue (running e18s) with uBlock Origin after restoring my computer from backups. I narrowed down the problem to that add on by selectively disabling them. Uninstalling and reinstalling uBlock fixed it. YMMV, but figured I ought to speak up :)
- bigbugbag 9y agoHow does this translate to real use, as in actually loading the pages and having a couple dozens extensions ? The ability to open 5-10 times more tabs than I use is quite and edge case that mozilla usually doesn't care about, but the real question is what is the point of this when it comes with making firefox totally useless for said use case by dropping support for extension that make it practical or useful.
- znpy 9y agoI am happy to hear this because I stopped using firefox and migrated to google chrome around firefox 51, and boy it was SLOW. Now it might be worth it to give it another try. In the meantime, I am seriously concerned about Thunderbird. Thunderbird is my MUA of choice and quite frankly, there are very few options to replace it, and none of them seems 100% okay (except, maybe, Evolution). Clawsmail is okay-ish, but so ugly to see and feature-poor.
- mannigfaltig 9y agoWhenever people ask me about the excessive number tabs in my browser, I simply show them Einstein's desk: http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-eyOIn_EOW2Q/Vmcl6O-55OI/AAAAAAAADsc/9LxoHK4jV00/s1600/La%2Boficina%2Bde%2BEinstein.jpg http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-eyOIn_EOW2Q/Vmcl6O-55OI/AAAAAAAADs... I am not Einstein but it is probably not a bad idea to have a whole lot of interesting things around you all the time. Sort of like a cache or the way proteins are synthesized, like swimming in a nutritious soup. "Oh, look here is a piece that fits!". One basically decreases the chance of forgetting interesting and useful information. "Out of sight, out of mind."
- softinio 9y agoI use chrome with the extension The Great suspender and that works well for me: https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/the-great-suspender/klbibkeccnjlkjkiokjodocebajanakg?hl=en https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/the-great-suspende... Would love to switch to Firefox, but I still find Chrome faster to use. Anyone tried vivaldi?
- kowdermeister 9y agoI follow the zero inbox mindset with tabs and try to reduce them to a few ever running apps like Gmail and Mixcloud. The rest is just noise and mental load that I can get rid of. I put articles to Pocket if I don't read them for a week or so. I'll probably read them on a vacation, but I don't need a constant reminder how poor my time limits are.
- snorrah 9y agoJohn Siracusa would be proud :)
- megamindbrian 9y agoIt's about time. Slowness is why I quit all of Mozilla. Also dumping Thunderbird is irresponsible. We need one client that doesn't give annoying pop-ups when using IMAP and that use to be it. Guess we have to go back to using CLI to avoid pop-ups.