11 ms·
How People Use Bike-Share Spaces vs. Parking Spots
- ZeljkoS 9y agoYes, private cars spend 95% of its time idle on parking. One solution is car sharing, which need 4-8 times less parking space: http://svedic.org/philosophy/car-sharing-and-the-death-of-parking http://svedic.org/philosophy/car-sharing-and-the-death-of-pa...
- sleavey 9y agoI'd be careful about such statements. A reduction in bus usage in favour of car sharing (which is more comfortable and private) might mitigate any traffic benefit from reduction in individual car owners.
- Twisell 9y agoIt's actually complementary I never bought a car because I live in a city center. I use bike for small hops, public transport for commuting to work, and occasionally I use car sharing when needed.
- pouetpouet 9y agoExactly, as soon as you pay per km and time, you make a choice for each trip about which is the best tool for the job.
- kqr 9y agoYeah, that's an important point to raise. When we say cars are bad for the environment, we don't just mean that they are inefficient in terms of their consumption of limited natural resources. They're also bad for the local environment in that they are noisy, take up a lot of space on the road, require vast areas for storage, cut neighbourhoods up with roads, kill people by impact and so on. Sharing would solve at least some of these problems.
- chongli 9y agoThe problem with car sharing is that people tend to use their cars all at the same time: morning commute, afternoon commute, evening errands/leisure. If you go out at 3am you'll see hardly any cars on the road. Rush hour? You'll hardly see any bare pavement.
- CalRobert 9y agoThis is a claim that would benefit from some data. There's certainly enough traffic during the day to suggest people aren't _all_ driving at the same time.
- awjr 9y agoIt's called the tidal wave effect and is the bane of public transport planning. You have to provide buses/trains to cope with rush hour when you make most of your profits, but then have no choice but to run the stock during the quieter day time. However it is used effectively in cycle track design. A 4m wide bidirectional cycle track can become effectively omnidirectional at rush hour significantly increasing capacity in one direction.
- miahi 9y ago* unidirectional
- mcv 9y agoBut the existence of rush hour means that a lot of people clearly are driving at the same time.
- Retric 9y agoSuppose only 50% of cars are part of rush hour. Now ride sharing can only cut parking by that same 50%. A less optimistic 75% means you can only cut parking by ~25%. Depending on the city these numbers may be high or low. However, one passenger ride sharing increases total miles driven. So in ultra congested city's it can actually make things worse.
- 9y ago
- Toenex 9y agoThis is another big selling point for automated vehicles. Why park your car in an expensive car park when you can just send it home - many journeys are round 5 miles in the UK (https://www.licencebureau.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/road-use-statistics.pdf https://www.licencebureau.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/road-use-...). Even better send the thing off to earn money as a taxi (I'm sure Uber are thinking this) or on some errands (bye, bye home delivery, hello home collection).
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoSomehow this doesn't work in china where the bike share companies just dump them randomly all over the sidewalks. Ya, it sucks when a car parks on a sidewalk (and they totally do if they can get away with it), but a hundred bicycles in your way is not much better.
- sliken 9y agoSimple fix for that, charge for them till they are returned. Even $0.50 to $1.00 is likely enough to result in them being returned quickly, even if it's not the original borrower.
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoYes if some journeys had a negative rental cost then you could solve the availability problems quite easily.
- celticninja 9y agoLondon did this, basically bikes were ending up at the bottom of hills as people either ride them down or stopped before cycling up the hill. They introduced a rebate fee for leaving it at the top of a hill (certain areas) and they had fewer bikes to move manually and a better distribution of bikes around the city.
- trogsworth 9y agoDo you have a source for this? I've never seen anything about rebates.
- liotier 9y agoSame in Paris.
- mhotchen 9y agoI thought China's version was incredibly interesting, although yes I agree it's a pain when they're blocking your path (and there's so many of them that it is actually a problem). For anyone that hasn't been to China: the bike share bikes don't have a docking area. People can park them wherever they finish with them. They have a little lock on the frame that stops the back wheel from moving until you scan a QR code on the bike with an app, then it unlocks. Given the huge bike theft problem where I'm from (London) I don't think that system would work because thieves would just pick the bike up, put it in a van, and break the lock later. It probably happens in China too, but apparently not enough to deter the companies from doing it that way.
- nomercy400 9y agoCars are just silly in any urban environment, especially in city centers. Bikes are a much better alternative. Come to Holland and see what I mean.
- avar 9y agoYeah, what do you mean? The city of Amsterdam for one made statements to the effect that its policy is not reduce the convenience for personal car owners when it comes to e.g. parking spaces. Venice is probably a better place to go to to see what a city without cars is like.
- isostatic 9y agoSienna too
- Aeolun 9y agoA city without cars. Not a city with a terrifying amount of bikes, of which Amsterdam is a great example, even if there are cars as well.
- Twisell 9y agoHowever Netherlands don't resume as Amsterdam. And seriously if you don't know what he mean you either never been in holland or you never left it so you don't have comparisons points. As for Venice try live there for a week and buy your own grocery, you might revisit your judgement. Inability to ride bike, or for delivery vehicles to acces housing pose another sets of issues.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- chrismcb 9y agoWhat do you mean? There are cars are all over Holland, even the city centers. Yes there are plenty of bikes and decent public transit as well. But here is not a lack of cars.
- 9y ago
- EGreg 9y agoI was planning to one day run for mayor of NYC. Here are some of my notes for improving traffic in the city: Traffic App for parking 30% of car traffic is circling Sensors across sidewalks Tunnels and lights timing, rewards slowdown before entering tunnel and speedup after leaving it Safety - less cars less congestion Pollution https://www.insidescience.org/news/driving-fee-rolls-back-asthma-attacks-stockholm https://www.insidescience.org/news/driving-fee-rolls-back-as... Cars should have sensors to stop if pedestrian, better achieve vision zero than slower speeds Economic growth Every minute in traffic - economic minus Move truck Deliveries to night time Replace windows UV and soundproofing of windows subsidized, especially for childproof windows https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fundamental_diagram_of_traffic_flow https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fundamental_diagram_of_traff... Vision Zero Sensors for cars Self driving technology Google broadband - economic growth
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoI'm pretty sure any traffic improvements you make in a city like NY would soon be offset by additional traffic.
- grecy 9y agoYour comment basically says we should never try to improve it then, which is extremely depressing.
- TulliusCicero 9y agoA major city can't end traffic short of politically unpopular methods like congestion charges or total vehicle limits. But it CAN let people escape traffic, which is what NYC does by having an extensive subway.
- eru 9y agoSingapore has both total total vehicle limits and congestion charging. But they are a very special case.
- ckastner 9y agoI'm curious what results one could see if this experiment were repeated in any of the winter months.
- matt4077 9y agoOnce people get used to use their bike in the course of their daily routine, they're quite likely to continue using it in the winter. I've gone through three Berlin winters now with going everywhere by bike. It's a one-time investment in some good clothing, mostly for hands, feet, and your head. After that, it can actually be a lot of fun to drive on fresh snow, or through the blizzard. In my experience, cars become a lot more of a problem in winter: they're more likely not to see you because it's dark, and because rain and snow are terrible for your vision if you're behind a windshield. There are also fewer people on bikes, so they don't expect you and pay less attention. With snow, there's also a tendency for odd-shaped large pieces of ice to end up right in your path, i. e. slightly to the right of the cars' track.
- ckastner 9y agoInteresting, I would have thought it to be too dangerous. How do you get the necessary traction in eg: a braking scenario on snow? Are there special tires for that? Yes, cars in the winter can be horrible. Anytime Vienna gets a few centimeters of snow, it's pure chaos.
- ciaranm 9y agoYeah, you can get either heavy tread or spiky tires. (e.g. http://www.wiggle.co.uk/schwalbe-winter-kevlar-guard-rigid-spiked-road-tyre/ http://www.wiggle.co.uk/schwalbe-winter-kevlar-guard-rigid-s...). My dad uses a tricycle in anything more than an inch or so of snow, as a little skid on a trike is much less likely to have you coming off than on a regular bike.
- matt4077 9y agoThere are tires with spikes, which actually retract when depending on the tire pressure. It's quite ingenious. Also more practical options with just deeper profiles. But, to be honest, it never seemed worth it. They're quite good with clearing the roads of snow, and even when they are not/it stays cold, I always expected it to clear away the next day and didn't bother investing money in it. With full snow cover, car traffic happens in a sort of extreme slow-motion. The city also sounds vastly different, with the snow softening all noise. It actually makes for a strangely surreal/serene experience. The more unusual conditions are, the more people actually start making eye contact/get in a good mood/bond over the shared experience of chaos. Biking on a flat, packed snow-cover is actually not too bad. It's only when it becomes ice after a few days that you really have to pay attention, and the biggest danger is irregular-sized clumps of ice which cars like to put in your path.
- awjr 9y agoThe reality is that cities are beginning to understand that the economic 'lifeblood' of a city can be strangled by the private car. Use of space is a huge issue within cities and a liveable approach based around the principle pedestrian first focusing on walkability, bikeability, public transport, and public spaces https://www.knightfoundation.org/features/livable-cities/ https://www.knightfoundation.org/features/livable-cities/ The private car needs to become a 'guest' and not the primary means of moving around a city. Neither should it become unwelcome, just easier to get around by any other mode of transport. https://twitter.com/awjre/status/879963479406411776 https://twitter.com/awjre/status/879963479406411776 Oslo tried to ban cars, but there has been a huge backlash, without the right sort of support some of the most vulnerable (i.e. people with physical disabilities) just cannot live successfully in cities. https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2017/jun/13/oslo-ban-cars-backlash-parking https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2017/jun/13/oslo-ban-cars... The reality is that care share, car clubs, and strict city wide parking control are key. Ideas like the Workplace Parking Levy implemented by Nottingham are key to delivering real investment in public transport and cycle infrastructure while reducing unnecessary car journeys http://www.thelondoneconomic.com/news/environment/lets-clear-air-national-clean-air-day/15/06/ http://www.thelondoneconomic.com/news/environment/lets-clear... On top of that, the cities are politically avoiding the inherent value in on-street parking. In Bath, the going rate for a city centre parking permit on the open market is £3,000 per year, but the permits are sold by the council for £150. Cities need to recognise the huge discounts we give to car owners, while we cut funding for public transport because it is too expensive and people are not using it enough. It's one hell of a viscous circle.
- geezerjay 9y ago> Oslo tried to ban cars, but there has been a huge backlash, without the right sort of support some of the most vulnerable (i.e. people with physical disabilities) just cannot live successfully in cities. That's the main problem with the approach taken by local governments to ban cars: they always fall short of actually solving the mobility problem which cars have been solving for decades. Governments are shortsighted and focus on reaching their goals (get rid of cars), but in the process they fail to provide alternatives such as improving and extending the reach of mass transit services.
- 99_00 9y agoIt's nice to have the option of a bike share. But it's not an option that works for everyone in any city for a variety of factors including physical ability. I use a bike share a lot, and the bikes really suck. They are heavy, shifting is often broken. They are slow. So for a biking novice a bike share bike is going to be even harder to ride in the city. For me it works, but it's not a cure all for cities..
- bbarn 9y agoCar owner, avid cyclist, and bike share user here. I live in Chicago. Driving is still a necessity, unless you want to spend your life wholly in the city. Sure, there are rental options, here and there, but for someone like me who leaves almost every weekend, there's not a much better option financially than a few years old used car. I almost never use my car for in city trips, it's primary purpose is to drive my bike(s) to places worth riding them. Bike share is great for getting home from the bar. It's too far to commute via bike share for me (~11 miles) without having to stop and exchange bikes to meet the time limit, so I ride my own bike to work every day. I'm pretty fast, as someone who's been an off and on racer most of my life, and my normal non-racer friends that commute much shorter distances on the bike share bikes (like 4 miles, from the loop to wicker park) tell me they occasionally go over the half hour limit as well. I think doubling the limit to an hour would dramatically increase the utilization of the divvy bikes. Which would then be a problem, as access to them seems almost perfectly balanced now (although the largest problem I have when using them is finding an open place to drop them off). The bike share infrastructure is very dependent on large vehicles moving bikes around, because of the rush hour problem - everyone's taking from the same places and dropping off at the same places. All that is to say, Bike share is nice, but it's one piece of a much larger problem that public transit works to solve. The single biggest thing I believe would help the transit situation is more office buildings with free showers that allowed people to bring their bikes inside. Not having to worry about being smelly, or getting your bike stolen would in my experience double the number of bike commuters.