20 ms·
Sony plans to make vinyl records again
- arethuza 9y agoI must saw I am mystified by this - I grew up with LPs, singles and cassettes in the 70s and 80s and I can't say I miss them.
- Quarrelsome 9y agohipsters and fan-signalling. Its a means of being "more" of a fan. Not to say I disapprove just looking for means of explanation.
- macintux 9y agoOr nostalgia, or artwork, or the satisfying tactile feel of changing tracks with the needle, or...
- arethuza 9y ago... the despair you feel when you drop the needle by mistake and scratch you're favourite track. :-)
- SamUK96 9y agoBut your language choice means that you do disapprove. Clearly. That's like the classic of saying "no offense" after you realise it was actually a obviously offensive thing to say. It doesn't change anything and is a semantically meaningless statement, and you still were offensive. I dislike how HN'ers attach meaningless disclaimers like these at the end of every sentence they make because they're so afraid of getting downvoted. It just goes to show how much damage over-moderation, echo-chambers, and such things make to honest and legitimate discourse. If you want to make a statement at least own it.
- Quarrelsome 9y agoyes but I identify as a hipster, so..... I dislike how people project into comments they read. For example YOU have projected that I am not confident in the comments I make because of how I suffix them. That's distasteful and if you want to experience the wrath of my will then you're more than welcome to a personal meet up. So, case in point: If I don't add disclaimers at the end people read their own meanings into what I say and people get mad at me even though I never meant what they thought I meant. Disclaimers are a product of the universal effect of the internet where the reader could be almost anyone in the world. If I'm talking to people I can see the facial expressions of I do not add these disclaimers.
- AdmiralAsshat 9y agoGiant-sized artwork, liner notes, inserts, etc. I grew up with CD's. The vinyl primarily just feels like a collectible to me--something I can look at, turn over, read the liner notes while listening to the music, etc. I don't even really listen to the vinyl's I have, I use the digital rips instead.
- accountyaccount 9y agoExactly. I listen to music on Spotify, but if I really like a musician/album I'll buy it on vinyl to give them more money, have a nice piece of artwork, and also have something to give to my kid someday (I have albums my mom listened to when she was 16).
- mohaine 9y agoI agree. I don't think most people are actually listening to these. I'm guessing most people don't even own a player (or even a home audio system to hook it to). Has there been large increase in player sales as well? I'm sure there has been an increase but I doubt it had any way to go but up. If it comes with a free download then vinyl is pretty much the perfect box to sell downloads at a brick and mortor. Thin but wide so you can't steal it easy. Lots of room for pretty artwork and extras. And nostalgia, something the cd/cassette anti-theft box didn't have. Well, The extra large cd boxes did at first but then they quit making those.
- k-mcgrady 9y ago>> I don't think most people are actually listening to these. Given the high price of most brand new vinyl I'd be highly surprised if this was true. I do think you're on to something though. I will listen to the digital/streaming version of a record I have much, much more often than the vinyl copy. Usually if it's a new release I'll buy the vinyl, sit down and enjoy it start to finish, and then the only time I'll play it after that is the odd evening/weekend when I want to sit down and do nothing but listen to some music. It's kind of something you'll put aside time for (like watching a movie) but at the same time you'll still be streaming in the background all day at work.
- mrspeaker 9y agoI think the tactile-ness of vinyl makes it really enjoyable. The act of selecting a record and putting the needle down, finding the track you were after - it's satisfying. Get someone who's never touched a record before to do it and they are instantly hooked. Much more of pain than just playing a spotify playlist, but I understand why people still get into it!
- icebraining 9y agoGet someone who's never touched a record before to do it and they are instantly hooked. Definitively not. When I first encountered them I found them a nice historical curiosity, like wax tablets, nothing more. Some people, sure, but it's far from an universal experience.
- alexchantavy 9y agoTo some degree I probably trick myself into thinking vinyl sounds better, but for me there's something special about putting on side A, listening through the whole way without skipping tracks, and then physically flipping to side B. It forces me to get to know an album in a way that doesn't happen when I use Spotify.
- blowski 9y agoAgreed. It's the difference between making a cup of tea with a tea bag vs real leaves in a teapot. Involving yourself more in the process somehow makes you slow down and enjoy it more.
- cr1895 9y ago>To some degree I probably trick myself into thinking vinyl sounds better Audiophile bickering aside, the vinyl version may very well be cut from a different master. That's a very real difference (of course it could also be worse/the same).
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoI'm the same, I was glad to see the back of them and the same for CD's.
- jasonkostempski 9y agoFor me, the ceremony in selecting an album, getting it set up, and the inconvenience of changing that choice and skipping songs, positively adds to the experience. Tape is similar. With digital, I find my mind is constantly thinking things like: what song should I pick next? am I bored with the song that's on? I tried using CDs in my car with a no skip rule, and was successful for a while, but I'm pretty much back to the old habits now, probably because it holds 6 CDs.
- deelowe 9y agoDo you miss looking at a case full of vinyl records? Opening the sleeve? Reading the jacket? Hearing the mechanical sounds of the turntable moving, the arm lifting, the hissing and popping? Maybe people don't just want music? Maybe there's more to it than just the sounds of the musicians? Physical book sales are up as well compared to ebooks. I get it. I love my bookshelf. I never read an ebook these days (except for reference).
- arethuza 9y agoIn order: no, no, no, no, definitely not. Mind you - my personal view. I had some nice kit (e.g. Rega Planar 3) and loads of LPs but the convenience and consistent quality of digital completely won me over. I don't use floppies for storage anymore either even though I found my first use of a 5.25" floppy in an Apple 2 quite exciting at the time.
- stinkytaco 9y agoSame reason anyone is into anything, I guess. I knew a lady with a salt shaker collection and once saw a guy with a lunch box collection on TV. I suspect if I looked around my house I'd have at least a few things that make people say "why are you keeping that when this is so much better."
- protomyth 9y agoI remember listening to the 8-track tape with my Dad, and I do not miss the clunk in the middle of a song or other content differences.
- cr1895 9y ago>Philips invented the cassette tape in 1962, first introducing it to music fans a year later. Thanks to its compactness, portability and sound quality, it quickly began to surpass the vinyl record in popularity. This seems suspect... According to this figure (going back to 1973 only) vinyl still far outpaced cassette sales until the mid-80s. http://blog.thecurrent.org/wp-content/blogs.dir/9/files/2014/02/units-vs-dollars-riaa.jpg http://blog.thecurrent.org/wp-content/blogs.dir/9/files/2014...
- nolok 9y agoMan, these two charts side by side really show the total financial abuse/great move (depending on POV) that was the music CD and selling an entire album at once to people who only wanted a few songs. It was not the norm before nor after, just an outlier, but one that brought billions of dollars in. No wonder they fought so hard against downloading (both legal and illegal).
- torrent-of-ions 9y agoBut they did sell CD singles. People just chose to buy the whole album. I suspect this is because a CD single was the exact same format as the album version and seemed a bit of a waste while 45rpm singles and LPs were physically distinct.
- cr1895 9y agoThis is also interesting: https://hbr.org/2016/12/how-streaming-is-changing-music-again https://hbr.org/2016/12/how-streaming-is-changing-music-agai... Curiously, during cassette tape dominance in the early 90s album length was 12.5 tracks. This increased to 15.8 in 2003, as CDs dominated. It has declined again to 14.2 tracks. They state, "With subscription pricing and the ability to easily skip among artists (as opposed to per-album or per-song charges, which were the norm), streaming pushes users to listen to explore new artists. This has the potential to reduce the concentration of the very top artists and albums, while also helping music lovers find what economists refer to as the “long tail” of the industry." // totally unrelated complaint: searching Google for the above chart was super frustrating, giving almost exclusively "what sounds best" results when I was trying to find sales figures. Searching for the HBR article I linked above (which I had read previously but forgotten details of) was equally fruitless on Google "average album length" and variations kept returning "what's the best length for an album" results. Had to switch to DDG to find the HBR article, and with the same search term it was the third result. WTF google?! I keep noticing less helpful results.
- tcbawo 9y agoThe large format of vinyl makes a great placeholder for art, notes, lyrics, etc. Fans respond when you give them something physical to connect with. Especially if you combine the physical object with a digital download, it seems like a net win.
- api 9y agoI feel like this is what happens when you reach the enlightenment stage with technology. I have a phone with eight 64-bit CPU cores built with 10nm lithography, and I cook on cast iron. "New" or "old" doesn't matter. We have things that do things. Pick one.
- falcolas 9y agoTo be fair, cast iron has significantly different cooking properties from regular pans. The added mass means they heat up differently, and things cook differently on them. Not to mention they can go from the stovetop into the oven, which most other pans (pure stainless steel excepted) can not.
- stinkytaco 9y agoNot to get off the subject, but they are not mutually exclusive. I use my cast iron often, but would not cook anything reactive (i.e. tomato sauce) in it. It's a matter of right tool for the job. I suppose the same could be said of many things: communication (people still use irc or even send cards), music (people own vinyl but listen to digital), books (people often read both physical and ebooks), and so on.
- klodolph 9y agoYeah, I definitely prefer the opposite. I cook my food with a WiFi enabled microwave and route all my phone calls through a cast-iron IBM 1401. (What does "enlightenment stage" mean?)
- kristiandupont 9y agoI confess, I am part of this trend. And I just got into it, so I get no "before it was cool"-claim to fame. Not sure where that leaves me on the hipster-scale. Buying CD's used to be a weekly ritual for me and I missed it for years. Putting on a new album on a Saturday afternoon with a beer or glass of wine while I start cooking is a very enjoyable moment for me. Now, obviously this was for the most part because I would have access to new music. That experience has not come back as I can put on anything on my laptop. However, there is a nice sense to putting on an album and being "forced" to play it from one end to the other. With streaming, I have a tolerance of 10-20 seconds of jarring music before I lose my patience and skip the track. Which is good but also means that I miss out on some of the tracks that take more effort and are in the "acquired taste" category. And in my experience, those tend to stay pleasant whereas the hits suddenly reach a threshold after which I can't stand listening to them any more.
- nindalf 9y agoI'm not sure if this would work for you, but I like Spotify's Discover Weekly. Every Monday you get a playlist of 30 songs that you've never heard before. I listen to it from beginning to end without skipping and I often find songs that I end up liking a lot
- cr1895 9y agoRelease Radar published on Fridays is good too for new releases. It's always a nice perk during my week to see what's in these two playlists.
- cocoflunchy 9y agoI wonder if my account has a bug with Discover Weekly because ~50% of the songs I get come back over and over (sometimes as remixes or covers too...)
- bluesroo 9y ago> I listen to it from beginning to end without skipping This was the important part for me at least. There are a lot of songs that I think I'm not into. Once I forced myself to listen to all of them all the way through I found a lot of good stuff.
- hashkb 9y agoAs long as nobody is claiming they sound better, and it's just for fun and nostalgia, I'm all for it. It really bugs me when vinyl buffs try to argue their rig sounds better or warmer or whatever than the same rig with a digital (or non-vinyl analog) source.
- torrent-of-ions 9y agoBut it can sound warmer and to some people that sounds better. You just seem annoyed that some people enjoy things that you don't.
- hashkb 9y agoPlease define "warmer" and compare to how 100 other vinyl buffs define it. It's meaningless, if you just admit it's an emotional preference then I'm fine with it.
- torrent-of-ions 9y agoDefine jovial. Define melancholic. It's music. The entire point is to evoke an emotional response. I can't define "warm" but people know what I mean when I say it and that's all that matters.
- Dylan16807 9y agoMusic can be jovial or melancholic. Not recording technologies. Technologies can have varying ability to carry certain kinds of music, but we can describe that ability with objective terms. Do people actually know what you mean by "warm"? Are you sure it's not just a way of saying "the things you like about vinyl (varying per person)"? Because a definition like that would be a perfect example of something that's an association-based preference rather than a attribute-based preference. Which like hashkb said is perfectly fine to have, but makes the term pretty meaningless.
- aaronarduino 9y agoThe question them becomes, where does that preference come from. The answer to that is what would cause people to think something is warmer. When someone says something is warmer it is due to a few factors. The first is a bump in volume in the frequency range from 280hz to 900hz. The second is a quality that causes sounds to separate or mush together. I think that is due to format resolution or frequency range. I think the second factor is what really separates digital and analog recording. Digital generally does not allow for sounds to mush together it keeps things separated.
- brianzelip 9y agomy vinyl weighs a ton
- wowtip 9y agoWhy not instead focusing on reinventing the LP? One side disc, large format, laser pickup, analog recording. Bring together the good parts from both LP and CD / DVD.
- m12k 9y agoBecause part of what they are selling is nostalgia, so making it into something 'new' is counterproductive.
- metaphor 9y agoDon't you get it? This class of audiofoolery actually values the imperfections of obsolete tech.
- bulgr0z 9y agoYou can already buy a laser player (http://elpj.com http://elpj.com)
- k-mcgrady 9y agoWhy start another format? People will either have to re-buy stuff or they won't care. One great thing about vinyl is you can get old records on eBay for less than £5. Start a new format and you lose that. You would also need to re-release a lot of stuff (which isn't going to happen).
- falcolas 9y agoOr, digital encoding on vinyl? Pretty low bitrate, but... They already do this a bit for DJing - the vinyl they are "spinning" is usually just a bunch of position indicators so the software can reproduce the motion from a digital audio file.
- dungle6 9y agoLol.. other than the one side part (turtle anyone?) what you're proposing is a laserdisc. Ie an actual thing. They're not coming back either because they died. Vinyl never died it just declined. Simplicity of playback equipment is a big reason why. Also nothing stops anyone from putting a CD in a 12 inch jewel case or sleeve of some sort.
- sp332 9y agoI wonder if they'll be manufactured differently if they're going for a wider audience. You can sell a 180-gram colored disc to a superfan for $40 but if you're aiming for 18% of the market, maybe they'll be more lightweight, brittle, even dingy-looking.
- k-mcgrady 9y ago180g + color isn't the standard though, it's the premium version. At the moment it seems like most new stuff is released at that weight but older stuff is much thinner. Hopefully they'll start producing more of that again because £20-25 (which seems to be the standard price here) is pretty pricey.
- aarmenante 9y agoIf you're into house/techno/disco all the best records get released (or rereleased) on vinyl first, before eventually getting out as a digital download. Also for artists, the profit margins are higher selling an LP (or even better a cassette) then releasing it to a small fanbase on Spotify. It's a better way to connect with a band you like than just streaming a track on your iPhone. You get the artwork to look at, and it's fun to read the production notes. I can't remember the last time I bought an album on iTunes or even beatport. If I really want the digital copy I'll look for it on bandcamp.
- swiley 9y agoCassettes seem like they would get distorted which is way worse than the failure mode for records (getting noisy).
- derwiki 9y agoMaybe the impermanence is a feature? My brother used to brag about wearing out 3 copies of Master of Puppets.
- torrent-of-ions 9y agoReally? Last time I was into listening to new trance (pre ~2006) there were only a small handful of labels that still pressed vinyl. I haven't seen turntables in the wild for years, alas. Maybe it's different with more "underground" house and techno and disco, though.
- aarmenante 9y agoI'm not sure about trance but "cool" techno/house is all being pressed on limited run distributions ( > 5000) before hitting digital downloads. I might be in a bubble living in Brooklyn, but I'm seeing more record bags than thumb drives these days. Sites like themixtapeshop.com and turntablelab.com are putting out great stuff every week so it's easy to build a set. You don't need to go digging through dusty bins to get records these days.
- afandian 9y agoIf you think this direction is bizarre, consider the 'cutting edge'. In the 21st century my 'CD player' (Spotify) is tracking everything I listen to so they can sell the data to a company who will build a comprehensive psychological profile about me and try to influence where I spend my money (or worse, which way I vote). This tweet specifically was bare-faced about it and appeared to be saying "our users are fine with this". https://twitter.com/SpotifyBrands/status/875795928438931456 https://twitter.com/SpotifyBrands/status/875795928438931456 I can't blame people for wanting to go back to analogue, where the appliance you got to do a job did only that job.
- OberstKrueger 9y agoTheres a middle-ground though that doesn't require you to go back to analogue listening from decades past. Use something like iTunes or whatever other equivalent application with your own music. If you're not comfortable with possible tracking from digital downloads, you can still rip CDs to it. Seems more convenient than going back to LPs and all of the physical management that that entails.
- afandian 9y agoIndeed. I was only pointing out that the 'bizarreness' bar is set pretty high these days. Notwithstanding the fact that I wasn't arguing that there's no middle ground, I fear it won't last long. Lots of people prefer streaming services (myself for one) and this will accelerate the depletion of the digital purchase market (delivered by CD, DVD or network). Soon we won't have a choice.
- oliv__ 9y agoWell you have your choice. You're choosing now.
- amelius 9y agoAnd you think that Apple can't detect which CDs you ripped?
- jasonkostempski 9y agoAnother record comeback? The last big record shop in Buffalo, that's been around since 1976, just had it's going-out-of-business sale a few weeks ago. Maybe they could have stayed afloat if they had waited just a little longer.
- gjem97 9y agoIt always makes me cringe when people say that records "sound better". Here's my unsolicited theory on why vinyl was preferred (by some) to CDs in the 90s and 00s. It wasn't the form factor, it was the dynamic range of the masters. I don't know if it was caused by the advent of digital recording, but the loudness war [1] certainly got going around the time that CDs were becoming popular. So comparing a classic vinyl record did sound better than a newly mastered CD, but not because of the digital recording, simply because the dynamic range of the music was better. Now that doesn't explain the recent renaissance of vinyl, which appears to have more to do with the ease of spinning, and the presentation of a coherent larger work of art (as opposed to singles on Spotify). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loudness_war https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loudness_war
- torrent-of-ions 9y agoThey actually did sound better during the very early days of CDs. Consumer DACs were terrible in the 80s. But these days that isn't a problem. CDs can sound great, but they will also happily carry all kinds of non-harmonic distortion which many people find disagreeable. The loudness war is an issue, but it isn't widely understood.
- gjem97 9y agoAh, the DACs! Yeah, I probably didn't start listening carefully to CDs until the early 90s, so maybe I missed a lot of the bad ones. When you say non-harmonic distortion, are you talking about clipping? Isn't that directly related to the loudness war?
- gmarx 9y agoI agree. Until about 2005 listening to a CD on my audiophile rig was often painful. Most discs just had an irritating noise that made me want to stop listening. I couldn't tell you what it was but the word people used "fatiguing" was correct. I don't know if I finally lost hearing in the frequency range that contained the fatigue or if they fixed it but for the past 5-10 I find digital music to be pretty enjoyable. Also, many of the super old records that collectors claim were the ultimate (like Mercury Living Presence or RCA Living Stereo) aren't really that great. Records from the late 70s and early 80s were probably the peak. There is a lot of placebo effect in what people like
- blakesterz 9y agoI'm 1/2 surprised the headline wasn't "Millennials are killing the music streaming industry" seems like headline writers love the "Millennials are killing" things lately.
- rainbowmverse 9y agoWe are a metaphorically murderous bunch.
- cranjice 9y agoI collect my favorite artist albums on vinyl for a few reasons: * Big artwork and liner notes. I have shelves on my wall to display my current favorite albums and change them out over time. * Conversation piece. Friends can actually browse a collection and talk about common interests. It's fun to hang out and listen to records with people. * Vinyl requires some heavier duty stereo equipment. Regardless of how you think the vinyl itself sounds, it's a great way to get into building an actual hifi system, and that will make any format sound better. The stereo equipment becomes a hobby and collection in itself. To me it's not a competition. Different formats can happily coexist. I own many albums on several formats (Vinyl for the living room, CD for the car, etc.) I use streaming too, especially for discovery and portable use. And then there's the whole debate between lossy and lossless compression :) P.S. For those who are interested in vinyl but annoyed by the prospect flipping records every few songs check out an auto loading turntable. These can stack several records and automatically play them one after another.
- gmarx 9y agoI love that you call it a "hi-fi" which is what it would have been called the generation before mine. We always called it a "stereo". I've always been amazed by how rare it is for a person to be interested in a system that makes the music sound better. The difference between an iPhone with the default earbuds and a $5000 stereo rig with speakers is astounding but only a tiny fraction of the listening public cares
- dragonwriter 9y ago> The difference between an iPhone with the default earbuds and a $5000 stereo rig with speakers is astounding but only a tiny fraction of the listening public cares Without optimum room design, even half-decent earbuds are better than pretty high-quality speaker systems, if you don't need multiple simultaneously listeners. And I don't think it's that most people don't care, I think it's just that most people have a utility function where the additional utility of high-quality sound gear is far too low to ever be justified by the cost of the gear (and the necessary environmental improvements to make sure that the effect of the gear isn't wasted.)
- ryandrake 9y agoFinally being able to get rid of all my physical media was super satisfying. Cassettes, CDs, DVDs, Blu-rays. All sold to one of those buy-back places for pennies on the dollar. All the clutter--gone. All the heavy boxes to pack up and unpack every time I moved--gone. I couldn't imagine going back to collecting physical music doodads again, especially doodads as space-inefficient as vinyl. My huge bookshelf is next. I have PDF version of the most useful ones anyway...
- danielbln 9y agoWhat I love about Vinyl, compared to everything else, is that it's amazingly low-tech. You can build a playback device out of a sheet of paper and a needle. It won't sound great, but it will work. On the flip side, in order to build a play back device for MP3 or CD from scratch you'll need electricity, massive amounts of highly specialised knowledge and realistically a chip fab. This has no real practical relevance in the modern world, unless you're stranded on an island with nothing but a bunch of Vinyl, but I still like the thought.
- amelius 9y agoPerhaps a nice challenge for a home project: to build a CD player from discrete components (not ICs).
- dungle6 9y ago> out of a sheet of paper and a needle Don't do this with any vinyl you care about. It will destroy it pretty good. Microgroove records since the 50s were made for a fine tipped stylus, not a needle.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- amelius 9y agoThere's a lot of music that isn't even available anymore in any formats other than digital. It would be cool if there was a service where one can "burn" (or press) a vinyl record from a bunch of mp3/wav files, and print a nice sleeve.
- alex_hitchins 9y agoI had been thinking of a similar sort of product offering. If anyone knows about about record presses and is interested in ideas, please get in touch.
- ian_d 9y agoPressing a one-off record isn't worth the cost because of the requirement of creating a pressing mother. (Mastering, creating a lacquer, a mother, a stamper, then finally pressing.) However, for one-offs your options are basically an acetate (which'll wear quickly with play) or a lathe-cut dubplate (which can be a bit lo-fi depending on process). There's a bunch of lathe services available: http://carverycuts.com/home/dubplates-order.html http://carverycuts.com/home/dubplates-order.html http://www.audiogeography.com/records/ http://www.audiogeography.com/records/ http://vinylcarvers.com/ http://vinylcarvers.com/ https://www.cutadub.com/ https://www.cutadub.com/
- proyb2 9y agoWhen I heard Bosendorfer Grand piano on vinyl, I was shocked and deeply into the low bass richness that I could never hear in high definition audio.
- jakelarkin 9y agohad a friend who was really into vinyl and I agreed to help him move. that was a mistake.
- oflannabhra 9y agoI started collecting vinyl back in 2006, when my uncle passed and left me a turntable and a small collection. I grew up with Napster, CD-Rs, iTunes, and iPods. I've always seen my generations attraction to vinyl as a response to the ephemeral nature of digital music. Vinyl is orders of magnitude less convenient, but it is concrete. When I spend my $5-30 dollars, I own a physical good that I can manipulate. I think this also answers the question "Why vinyl?" - it is the most physical of all music mediums. I think that is a strong psychological component for humans. This has only grown with subscription services, where I spend $10 every month, and don't even have a library to browse. I've never really cared about vinyl's sound, and actually listen mostly to digital records. But as far as giving a sense of ownership and intimacy, vinyl wins.
- ecshafer 9y agoI don't do this with vinyl, but I do with films. Something about having a tangible physical object is very attractive.
- fortyfivan 9y ago< But as far as giving a sense of ownership and intimacy, vinyl wins This. I've been a record collector for 20 years, mostly focused on rare Brazilian music - https://www.novedos.com https://www.novedos.com. I don't DJ anymore so it's primarily a collector thing for me. Aside from the master tapes, an original vinyl copy is as close as you can get to the original recording, which is special. I'm far from an audiophile, so it's not about the sound, it's about the feels.
- bcrescimanno 9y agoAs someone who started collecting vinyl about 3 years ago, it's about the difference between passive and active involvement in music. So much of our music consumption these days is a largely passive activity. We have music in our headphones while we work. We have music on in our cars while we drive. We have music on in the background of social events. While modern digital formats have given us true ubiquity of music (seriously, thanks to Spotify and Apple Music and LTE connections, even the old "1000 songs in your pocket" claim from the first iPod could be regarded as "quaint") they've driven the trend further and further away from active involvement in music. Contrast that with vinyl. The act of putting on a record indicates a desire to do more than put on music in the background. Walking across the room, thumbing through your collection, pulling the record from its sleeve, etc.--the ritual of it all changes one's frame of mind in approaching the music: it's by definition a more active involvement. When I want to have music on, I reach for my iPhone and Apple Music. When I want to listen to music I grab a record.
- amartya916 9y agoThis is very nicely framed, thank you. At the risk of going slightly off track, do you think this argument about active involvement also fits (physical and not electronic)books?
- bcrescimanno 9y agoAn interesting question, for sure! As someone who doesn't read a lot of fiction or lengthy non-fiction works, I'm definitely not an authority. That said, my gut tells me that the effect can't possibly be as strong--we don't tend to, "read in the background" the way we consume music. A certain active involvement is required to do more than move our eyes across the pages randomly.
- zippergz 9y agoI find that an eInk Kindle is "close enough" to a paper book in terms of immersion for me. But reading on my iPad (or even worse, computer) definitely is not. I get notifications, there's always the temptation to jump out and "just check email," etc. With the Kindle there is no distraction, and for me that seems to be more important than the tactile experience of a printed book (though I do still enjoy printed books).
- j_s 9y agoVinyl records are a great market segmentation these days. Very few collectors are struggling to get by.
- ddingus 9y agoI love this discussion. And will add, the each play is unique. That's the thing I like about vinyl, it's a moment one time you're there and it'll never happen exactly the same way again.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- avenoir 9y agoIn my early 20s I used to spin dance music (melodic and tech trance) and have accumulated a pretty large vinyl collection before Technics mk2s went largely extinct and I moved on to CDJs. But I could have sworn that vinyl sounded some much richer and warmer than digitized formats. A part of me is happy vinyl is making a comeback.
- combatentropy 9y agoI think there's something to the analog hiss, even the scratches. Tangentially, someone on Hacker News mentioned Cathode (http://www.secretgeometry.com/apps/cathode/ http://www.secretgeometry.com/apps/cathode/), a terminal program that emulates old analog monitors. Screen glow, burn-in, noise, even occasional sync hiccups, can all be tuned to the nth degree, which I have, and now I'm hooked. I think it's also the sounds that can be added, but that's another psychological topic. I don't own a record player and usually aim for consolidation, digitization, and the annihilation of clutter. But you can only go so far before it gets too cold. Even Google's Material Design and similar UI fashion is too sterile. There is evidence that the constantly circulating, subtle film grain in movies used to pleasantly tickle the retina, and I think vinyl background noise is similar.
- qb45 9y agoNice, although the front part of CRT where image actually forms is frankly an anode ;)
- kazinator 9y agoFrank Zappa on vinyl, BAM (Bay Area Music magazine) [1987]: http://www.afka.net/Articles/1987-01_BAM.htm http://www.afka.net/Articles/1987-01_BAM.htm BAM: Working with a computerized synthesizer, do you find that vinyl is no longer the most desirable way to present your music? Will you be releasing CD-only recordings? FZ: Well, vinyl never really was all that terrific a medium anyway. Some people cling to the belief that vinyl sounds better. I don't know. Not to my ear. I like it on digital tape myself. BAM: There's supposed to be a warmth to vinyl. FZ: Well, let's analyze what the word warmth is. Does warmth mean a lack of top end, or an extra bunch of frequency bulge at 300 cycles. What the fuck is warmth? How do you quantify that in audio terms? BAM: Critics don't have to quantify in audio terms. We use words like warmth. FZ: Yeah, well, you know, you can demonstrate pseudo-warmth in a technical way in the studio by using a broad-band equalizer and boosting things around 300 cycles, you know. It just gets pudgier. And you roll off the top end a little bit, and things start to sound, you know, warm! – if that's the kind of sound that you like. I don't particularly care for that sound. -- Mix Magazine [1983]: http://www.afka.net/Articles/1983-06_Mix.htm http://www.afka.net/Articles/1983-06_Mix.htm Mix: The complaint has been that the digital tape sounds great, but when you transfer it to an analog medium you get a whole different sound. FZ: You do get different stuff, and the reason you do is that the dynamic range of the digital tape is 90 dB and the dynamic range of a record is about 45 to 50 dB. So you can't let all the peaks go where they would normally go – you have to compress it. But if you're going to plan for the future, I think ultimately records are going to be released on compact discs, little laser discs, and they've got 90 dB. There's a way to do it. I'll compensate to get it on a piece of vinyl and still have the right thing digitally.
- cthalupa 9y agoFrank Zappa also was releasing recordings in the age prior to the Loudness War. Digital is a superior format. But I still buy vinyl because a good half of vinyl recordings out there aren't completely fucked by applying a compressor that destroys the dynamic range.
- some-guy 9y agoI confess: I used to get Vinyl rips of old albums for this reason on what.cd It wasn't that Vinyl is better, but the MIXES were better. They didn't compress the crap out of everything.
- Animats 9y agoThen people play vinyl records through a turntable that outputs via an A/D as a USB device. Some DJ use vinyl records which contain nothing but a time code track. This feeds a system which plays out the proper audio segment from downloaded data.[1] [1] http://djtechtools.com/2014/03/20/building-a-dvs-timecode-dj-setup-for-20/ http://djtechtools.com/2014/03/20/building-a-dvs-timecode-dj...
- cartoonfoxes 9y agoI've spent a significant fraction of the last 20+ years staring into screens. Analogue tickles my brain the same way computers and anything electronic or digital did when I was a kid. I have no illusions that my preference for vinyl in purchased media is anything other than emotional.
- kazinator 9y agoRemember, folks. An audiophile is someone who listens to equipment, not music. He can hear the difference between 0.1% THD and 1% THD, but can't tell Mozart from Beethoven, or Kenny G from Coltrane. When people claim about how they are emotionally moved by certain speakers, but not others, chances are the music is shit. When the music is good, I'm still moved by a 64 kb/s encoding using 8 bit uLaw, played through laptop speakers.
- protomyth 9y ago> When the music is good, I'm still moved by a 64 kb/s encoding using 8 bit uLaw, played through laptop speakers. I'm not an audiophile, but I disagree with your assertion. I did love going to concerts in the 90's and early 00's. In February of 1993, I saw Stone Temple Pilots opening for Megadeth at the Fargo Civic Memorial Auditorium (not the Fargo Dome, think bigger high school gym). I liked their album, but was pretty much there to see Megadeth. When I heard STP in concert (an frankly its not the best venue particularly in ND in Feb) including the megaphone in Crackerman, it blew me away. You can feel the range, and I loved their music ever since. I will say that the CD and mp4 are loved because of a memory more than how they sound.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- petetnt 9y agoUnless we get more pressing plants all around the world, big labels doubling down on vinyl will only mean the inevitable crash. The ones that have kept records alive to this day (that is independent labels) are already suffering under the load major labels are pushing releases in, especially on record store days. Want your record pressed? Fine, but just after we press 20k copies of this Saturday Night Live OST LP, that's previously only been available in every flea market, record store and garbage can in the world. When you cater for the crowd that flocked in during the trend are already switching to the next hip thing, soon all we are left with is tons of useless releases filling the bins.
- xemdetia 9y agoPart of me wonders if the stickiness of this more has to do with the fact that both cassettes and CD's are not successful mediums right now. It quickly becomes a least common denominator- vinyl still works the same. I feel I get similar feelings about technologies that I drift to whatever tech seems the most stable for long term usage. Why invest in this if it is going away in 2 years? I feel like the IoT stuff often falls into this category.
- pasbesoin 9y agoI wonder how they're going to wedge DRM into them. /s (Perhaps you have to be of a certain age to get this...)
- LesZedCB 9y agoI like vinyl for the same reason I make americanos with my work's espresso machine which makes both espresso and coffee. It's a process. I enjoy the ritual of heating water and pouring it into espresso, even though the machine does the same thing I am doing.
- agumonkey 9y agoHopefully some video high "dpi" vynils too :)
- ChuckMcM 9y agoMaybe they could make something that I could carry around with me that I could use to play recordings of my favorite songs from those vinyl records.
- divenorth 9y agoTo me the motivation is obvious. It's the difference between collecting trading cards vs virtual trading cards. There is something to be said about having a physical collection.
- itsoggy 9y agoI had a habit of collecting white labels and test pressings of house and dance tracks, I have no idea what most of them are called or who they are by, but I can think of one and remember where it is in the crates. If I had a load of Track 1's in iTunes, I wouldn't have a clue!
- chaoticmass 9y agoArticle says the cassette tape was released to music fans in 1963, but really the cassettes and players at that time were mostly used for dictation and voice recordings only because the quality was not high enough for music. Cassettes did not start to be used for music until much later. Dubious reporting from WaPo.
- gdubs 9y agoThis crowd would probably enjoy "The Revenge of Analog", by David Sax. The entire first chapter is "The Revenge of Vinyl" and goes deep into the rise, fall, and rebirth of physical records – including interesting bits on the handful of places left that are capable of printing records, on scarce presses from a bygone era.
- zzo38computer 9y agoThis can be good if they can make vinyl records, for one reason, being the simplicity of the technology. Quality is not the issue, and neither is convenience. This does not mean that CDs are worthless, however.
- aurelian15 9y agoOh, for goodness sake, Sony, would you please just master CDs decently? I know, that would mean that you release your intellectual property to the world in uncompressed¹ quality, in a world where people frivolously commit abominable criminal acts such as copying and sharing their media. But pretty please? I don't want to resort to an archaic medium with 10 bit effective dynamic range if I can have 16 bit on a CD. I don't want your petty streaming services. I don't want to download music amateurishly encoded in a lossy format (almost) older than me.² I know. I'm probably the weirdest of all, longing for this sterile, lossless sound of digital awesomeness. But can I please, for once in ages, buy a CD that has been decently mastered, that I can copy onto my computer and listen to with my headphones and enjoy? I think I'm now going to put on “Dark Side of the Moon” from 1973 and cry myself to sleep, weeping, because something so old can sound so good, whereas decades of modern music, decades of culture and art have been sacrificed to the capitalist gods of the loudness war. ¹ Both in the dynamic range and audio codec sense. ² MPEG-1 Audio Layer III.
- flavio81 9y agoTurntable nerd here (over 5000 posts on a forum dedicated to turntables). Let me give you my take on this, as unbiased as possible: Records do not automatically sound better than CDs. However, there are many, many cases in which the LP sounds better than the same CD. First let me dispel some myths of vinyl playing: - "Records wear": Assuming your turntable is a good one (no cheap Crosley record players), and your stylus is not worn, and your stylus pressure is below 3.0 grams (as it would be the case in ANY half-good tonearm and pickup), and your record is clean, and the pickup is correctly aligned, then record wear is a non-issue. Under those conditions records were found to last 1000 plays with no significant sound degradation on an AES (Audio Engineering Society) paper. And this with 1965-67 pickup technology. Modern pickups and styli are still gentler. Of course, if any of the above conditions is not met, the record will wear! - "Records sound with pops and crackles": This does not happen with a good turntable and well cared records. Record reproduction is mostly free from such noises. Note that lower quality turntables do emphasize noises caused by dirt, as well. - "Any turntable gives you high quality sound, better than a CD": This is a favorite one of the hipsters. There are many turntables out there that are bad, poor, or mediocre. You need a good turntable to enjoy the sound. Fortunately due to the big used-TT market, you can get turntables that were pretty expensive when new, for little money. Now, WHY should one play/buy records instead of CDs (or MP3/etc)? As a music lover, it is very important to be able to play LPs. The main reasons are: 1. There is a huge amount of music that isn't available on CD nor MP3. For example records from record labels that went bankrupt. Or music that simply is not popular/mainstream. Sometimes you can find MP3 transcriptions of such records on the internet, but often those are done with poor care giving really bad audio, compared to having the record played by you on a good system. 2. There are cases in which the LP record is much, much better mastered than the comparable CD or MP3. Example: Frank Zappa's You are What you is. The CD was done using really exaggerated, wrong compression which truly destroys the sound, and you don't need to have any kind of high-end system or "golden ears" to notice the difference. It is that striking. Another example? AC-DC's "back in black". The modern (2000s) remaster has heavy, dynamics-destroying compression compared to the original (1981) release. Which you can enjoy buying the LP record. 3. There are cases in which the LP record gives you the truly original release of the album. That is, before the producer (or artist) subsequently decided to alter the mix, do overdubs on it, etc. Example: Frank Zappa "Hot Rats" record; the 1969 original release is radically different from the CD release due to all sorts of edits and remixes done. 4. Music done on the LP era (1948-late 80s) was intended to be released on LP, so there is a convention that albums follow: - Sides: A versus B. Sometimes the album will have a different concept in side A versus B, for example A dedicated to more danceable music, B dedicated to ballads, etc. - Hit tracks are expected to be located at the beginning on each side. You see the track that is a beginning of each side and you can bet this was an important track for the artist. - The last track of the side is usually a softer, mellower track. These conventions are interesting and are preserved when you buy the LP. 5. Artwork. The difference in picture area between a CD and the LP is striking. Gatefold records (there are many of them) give you about 64x32cm (25x13") picture area, which is a lot. If the gatefold is triple (like in Beastie Boys' "Paul's Boutique"), this is an area of 96x32cm (38x13"), which is huge. 6. Printed lyrics & Bonus material: Since the sleeves are so big, many kinds of different 'extras' can be included with each record, and sometimes they do add a lot of value to the experience. For example: - "Captain Fantastic" (Elton John) includes a whole comic book inside. - Stevie Wonder's "Innervisions" (1976) includes a nice booklet with all the printed lyrics in lavish style. - Many records came with stickers or posters. - Devo's "Duty now for the future" cover art can be pried apart for framing. - etc. Basically, the LP record adds much more to the "experience" of listening to the album. At least for a music lover.
- timonoko 9y agoSomebody should try if you can print records on laser printer. If you print circular lines, the needle should stay between the walls of ink. Transparency might be better than paper, because it is smoother. I do not have record player anymore, so I cannot test this theory. On 78 speed record those squiggles are huge, and well with capabilities of laser printer.