27 ms·
L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much
- Simulacra 9y agoThere's a proposal that was floated some years back in Atlanta around grocery stores. South of interstate 20 is a food desert. So the proposal said that a corporation and it's subsidiaries could not build a new grocery store anywhere in the city, without also building one in a disadvantaged area. It never went anywhere but I wonder if this might work in an area where more housing is needed. In order to get the building permit you are required to offset one project with a low income project in pre-determined areas.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- thescriptkiddie 9y agoSan Francisco has something like this. Conservatives are constantly trying to kill it because they perceive it as a barrier to new construction and therefore an artificial constraint on supply. Of course, these same politicians also vote for stricter zoning regulations, so they might not actually be interested in increasing supply.
- kevinnk 9y agoCan you name a major political group or politician in SF that takes that stance? I'm not super integrated into SF politics, but everyone I know who's against restrictive measures like the OP suggests aren't voting for stricter supply (and if they are I don't want to support them).
- kevinburke 9y agoI believe you are referring to inclusionary zoning, which requires developers to offer 20% or so of onsite units at below-market rent, but also allows developers to offset this by paying for the equivalent of 30% of the number of units in an offsite development.
- closeparen 9y agoLiberals are also constantly trying to kill it because we'd prefer to have socioeconomically diverse neighborhoods, rather than "stick the poors in a crappier building somewhere else where the luxury tenants don't have to see them." The preferred alternative is to allocate some percentage of units in the new building to low-income tenants. Of course, some "progressives" want this percentage to be high enough to make development totally nonviable.
- jseliger 9y agoThis is also really a zoning story. L.A. used to be zoned for 10 million people in the late 60s and decreased that tremendously in the early 70s: https://la.curbed.com/2015/4/8/9972362/everything-wrong-with-los-angeles-housing-in-one-graph https://la.curbed.com/2015/4/8/9972362/everything-wrong-with.... Today we have improved technology along almost every dimension yet the city is zoned for less than half as many people. We are paying zoning's steep price: https://object.cato.org/sites/cato.org/files/serials/files/regulation/2002/10/v25n3-7.pdf https://object.cato.org/sites/cato.org/files/serials/files/r... (that's a link to a PDF).
- DiNovi 9y agosurprises me, since LA has so much sprawl
- handedness 9y agoI believe Curb's argument is that the sprawl was to some degree caused by the zoning, as it made high-density housing difficult to build. A lot of it, though, is just down to geography.
- klipt 9y agoFunny, I often hear people blame SF's high prices on geography ("it's a peninsula, there's no more room to build"). Seems LA wouldn't be geographically constrained in the same way.
- amyjess 9y agoMountains. Go switch Google Maps into satellite view and check out LA [0]; the whole metro area is a handful of valleys that are almost all filled up, and everything that isn't developed is a mountain. The only place in Los Angeles County where there's room to grow is in the Antelope Valley around Palmdale, and that's separated from everything else in the county by mountains so you probably won't want to live there and commute to any other part of the metro area. [0] https://goo.gl/maps/ePy7yztU7KL2 https://goo.gl/maps/ePy7yztU7KL2
- cryoshon 9y agoit isn't just LA that's suffering in this way... it's the entire country. the rent is too high. the pay is too low. the costs of essentials are rising. nobody will do anything. we're on track for self-destruction.
- DiNovi 9y agolooks at prices in upstate NY and the South, and then Midwest ehhhhh seems pretty damn cheap
- api 9y agoThere are also no jobs. Relative to median income housing is actually kind of expensive in many of those places. Jobs, affordable housing -- pick one. There are a few bargain markets like Detroit, but not many.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- pmiller2 9y agoYou have to consider it relative to the area's income level. I could rent 2 or 3 detached 3+ BR houses in my home town for what I pay for a 2BR in the East Bay. But, I'd never be able to make the kind of money I make here back in my hometown. If I'm lucky, I could make about 40% what I do now, with a 40 minute driving commute (because there's no public transportation, and the jobs actually in my hometown are not going to pay me anything).
- yourapostasy 9y agoTo my sensibility, energy-wise, prices are cheap in exactly the wrong places where you want concentrated populations. People are rather expensive (in energy terms) to logistically serve and they are even more expensive to move around, so you want them near waterways and coasts, and more sparse in inland areas, making the inland areas serve functions that require lots of land, like food production and renewable energy production. We should be forcing low-density development residents and business to pay their own way on infrastructure build-outs around coastal and near-waterway metropolitan areas, and increasing population densities of the urban cores to around 25-30K per square mile on average, but the way the real estate business is structurally organized in the US and so tightly interwoven into our financial structures, there are very few ways I foresee how to accomplish that without excruciatingly high residential pricing, and all those ways are very uphill wars on powerful, entrenched economic interests.
- 1024core 9y agoI fear that this is the future of the country: vast majority of the people barely getting by, and a very small minority leading cushy lives. I see more and more people living in RVs, just making ends meet. On the other hand, if you're in the right line of work and in the right place, you're making out like a bandit. I've seen 25-year-olds making in high 6-digits, and 72-year-olds collecting shopping carts at the local grocery store. I have a feeling of dread about an upcoming large-scale social upheaval, but I can't quite put my finger on it. I think Trump's election is a symptom of the trying times we live in.
- malandrew 9y agoWhy is someone's age relevant? Whether you are 25 or 72, how much you earn is based on how much value you provide. A 72 year old has 47 more years of life to have potentially capitalized on.
- throwaway2048 9y ago>how much you earn is based on how much value you provide This is objectively false, and part of the myth of a meritocracy. You make what you can manage to manipulate the system into paying you, nothing more or less. That has precious little to do with value provided many times. It does a much better job at explaining how a CEO of a company going bankrupt can take home 7 or 8 digit bonuses, while a great teacher at a school might be struggling to make ends meet. Of course with your explanation we can sit secure in the knowledge that there is nothing wrong with how things work, and there is justice in it, people get what they deserve right?
- seanp2k2 9y agoThis. The richest people made their money by letting their money do the work. How can a person compete with a dollar? The concept of increasing your wealth = delivering value died a long time ago. See also: HFT
- camus2 9y ago> This is objectively false, and part of the myth of a meritocracy. But that's not what meritocracy is about at first place.
- rukittenme 9y agoI'm seeing a lot of "I fear that..." in this thread. I just have to laugh. This isn't a new or unique situation. The only thing that has changed are people's preferences. My Great Aunt lived in NYC with 6 other girls. Roommates were required to survive the high rents of post-war NYC. California has always been gripped by NIMBYisms and choking regulation. You get what you vote for. What can you do against the tyranny of good ideas? It's a good idea to make use environmentally friendly building materials. It's a good idea to build earthquake resilient homes. It's a good idea to require certain standards of home building. It's a good idea to rent control the apartments of the elderly so they can continue to live in their home of the past 50 years. It's a good idea to X..Y..Z. Is it a good idea to create a generation of serfs?
- utternerd 9y ago"A government big enough to give you everything you want, is a government big enough to take away everything that you have." For all the talk of "negative externalities" I see on HN and the valley in general, I never see people discussing the rampant "negative externalities" of the laws and regulations we pass. It's unfortunate there's so little introspection going on, and so much reliance on the monopoly of the Government to further what Group A or Group B wants. (But it's OK, because I agree with Group A!)
- dragonwriter 9y ago> "A government big enough to give you everything you want, is a government big enough to take away everything that you have." A cute saying, but misleading. A government big enough to impose even a modest constraint on violent crime is also more than big enough to take away everything you have; anything weak enough to avoid that threat is not the government and will be replaced in that role but something else that is. So, mitigating that threat necessarily is about managing aspects of government other than its size.
- Daishiman 9y agoCorporations big enough can have a humongous power to take away everything from you.
- siliconc0w 9y agoYeah the homeless population is insane - a long heat wave and I wouldn't be surprised if we had riots. I'm lucky enough to have a rent-controlled place in Silverlake but it does come with other costs because the owner doesn't really maintain the property. Hallway light doesn't work and we strung up Christmas lights in our kitchen because we can't get an electrician to fix the light in there. A lot of the startup jobs are on the Westside but considering those easily adds an additional 18k/year in housing costs or doing that terrible 2-3 hour commute everyday. Thinking hard about moving to Oregon or something and just doing remote work - I've lost most of any enthusiasm I've had for LA.
- thechao 9y agoCome to Austin. Or Houston; San Antonio, Dallas.
- ozi 9y agoThe startup scene in Houston sucks unless you're in energy or healthcare.
- JBlue42 9y ago- Austin is fun and has some good companies but too damn humid (and I'm originally from the South). And I think the exodus from CA the past few years have really overwhelmed their infrastructure - Houston/Dallas seem like just more sprawl. LA is actually pretty dense in parts and can have good public transit. I know people from Dallas that have been happy moving back though. - Don't know much about San Antonio
- thebradbain 9y agoDallas native here who goes to school in LA! Yes, Dallas is much more similar to LA in that regard compared to New York, although still a magnitude less spread out than Los Angeles (and traffic is nowhere near as bad): I would say geographic distances in Dallas proper (not the exurbs, which I don't consider Dallas as most are in their own counties) are one-fourth to one-half shorter than Los Angeles. Also, Dallas has been increasingly developing their Downtown/Uptown scene to mimic Austin, and is where most all young professionals / startups are located, as the past generation's upper class still prefer the centrally-located neighborhoods of Highland Park and Preston Hollow just outside of downtown for their large single-family homes, meaning high-rise apartments in Dallas go for about $1.5-$2k and are located next to work. Also, the mayor in Dallas is all for the rapid development of higher density housing, which greatly helps with housing supply (though single-family home property values in these desirable neighborhoods are increasing about 10-15% year over year due to the influx of new people and no more space for single-family homes in Dallas proper).
- ugh123 9y agoL.A. has a major NIMBY problem: as soon as anyone gets a whiff of new housing development you'll see someone pile on the fud about how it will increase crime and homelessness (ironically) in their neighborhood.
- FooHentai 9y agois there no validity in those concerns? I mean, the projects was a thing. The problems that sprang up around high-rises was certainly a thing.
- kevinburke 9y agoStatistically, increasing the number of people in an area will increase the amount of crime, the same way increasing the number of people will increase the traffic or the water usage or the electricity usage. Most people also overestimate the costs of crime by a factor of about 15; see http://press.princeton.edu/titles/9018.html http://press.princeton.edu/titles/9018.html for more information. It's too simplistic to just consider that. It may be a valid concern but it's also valid to consider the rights of the person or entity that owns the land to build what they want on it, and the consequence of underbuilding and the subsequent effect on real wages. If you want to do it properly you'd want to consider the increase in crime from a marginal resident added to area X, vs. the increase in crime from wherever they would live if you didn't build more housing in area X. Not to mention the effect on crime from perpetual underbuilding and the subsequent decline in most folks' real wages...
- kasey_junk 9y agoIt's largely a myth that high rise projects were an experiment that went poorly. At the time that they were built, most of the high rise public housing projects were argued against by public housing advocates. Public high rise projects were a cynical racist tool of large political machines to segregate voter basis and solidify biased voting blocs. The earlier public housing experiments were more about integrated mixed income housing, which were very successful. There are lots of examples of this model that are successful but modern versions get voted down due to the specter of the Robert Taylor homes. One of my favorite books about this subject is "Blueprint for Disaster" by Hunt.
- Jimmie_Rustle 9y agoAm I the only one that thinks expecting to raise a child alone on a personal trainer salary is.. irresponsible? Also, what is wrong with the homeless 'son' that he can't get a job? Go collect cans if you need to. Illegals manage to find jobs all over LA, there is really no excuse. Collect cans if you need to
- xupybd 9y agoCan you pay high rents on a can collection income?
- cylinder 9y agoYou collect cans while renting a closet somewhere. You use that permanent address to land a better labor job. Then save a bit and buy your own tools and compete for jobs as a subcontractor etc. There are a lot of obstacles along the way, and a predatory society and institutions don't help, but that's generally how it's done. LA isn't impossible, there are areas where houses are $250k, but are dismissed as "ghetto." The main issue in LA is transportation and associated costs.
- adventured 9y agoThe only areas of LA where housing is $250,000, are extremely dangerous. "Dangerous" is the useful description, not "ghetto." Why would anyone want to live in an area with an extremely high murder / violent crime rate? Such areas are almost always controlled by gangs. There are very good reasons why the lower cost housing, is lower cost.
- ropeah 9y agoTechnology should be reducing the cost of living. All this accelerated growth with increased costs have negative effects on the culture. When people are stressed and impoverished they aren't exactly compelled to improve their communities or start hip local businesses. You have millions of people stressed, annoyed and envious of all the other happier people.
- 9y ago
- TheMagicHorsey 9y agoThere are places within 3 hours drive of SF, where you can pay $1000 to buy an acre of land (200 acre parcels minimum). At some point, telecommuting technology will encourage an exodus of tech workers. Some people, yes, want a city life. Others don't want to lose 50% of their earnings on buying or renting housing.
- bogomipz 9y ago>"At some point, telecommuting technology will encourage an exodus of tech workers." But we already have Slack/Hangouts/Github/HipChat/Skype/Trello etc and most(the majority?) of the tech jobs in SF require you to come into the office no? I don't believe its the tech worker themselves who are short on encouragement.
- DaiPlusPlus 9y agoI'm at a small company right now and I live 30 minutes door-to-door from work, and I WFH when I can. When it comes to solo-work my lead agrees I'm just as-productive, if not more-so, when I'm at home - but things like meetings and "hey, can you take a look at this thing on my computer?" just don't work remotely - it's the little things: like how even a 1080p conference room camera can't pick-up small details on the whiteboard and how people can't just pass me a printed document. It was the same on my teams when I was at Microsoft too - we did have a couple of remote-workers, but they were effectively treated as contractors who worked in silos - because that's all they can do well when you can't get all that face-to-face contact. Plus there's a lot of juicy talk and rumors over lunch that just don't get to participate in as well.
- shostack 9y agoWhile this is HN, with its associated demographics, the reality is that many office jobs just aren't as feasible for remote work. Face time and hallway conversations can be incredibly important for a healthy company.
- bogomipz 9y agoCan you say specifically what office jobs can't be done remotely and why? Also can you say what type of content can only be communicated in a hallway but not via video conferencing, chat, phone or email?
- vondur 9y agoI'd also like to add that LA county has the highest number of illegal immigrants in the country, with and estimate of 1.1 million. That is surely exacerbating the housing situation. This also likely exacerbates low salary problems too.
- sjg007 9y agoNet illegal immigration is trending down due to enforcement and a less robust US economy. The only way to improve upon the situation is to improve working/living conditions in Mexico, accept it as a given, or kick everyone out. NAFTA is an attempt at #1 but it is a double edged sword, you lose jobs in the USA but get more corporate profits / cheaper products) from cheaper labor in Mexico. What I think was unexpected was that China came a long and really reduced labor costs further while cloning the intellectual property. Conditions in Mexico (and South America) did not improve enough though; China has amassed major purchasing power (such that expatriates are buying properties to hedge and take capital out) further increasing costs globally in affluent cities. So cities and communities should ideally increase density (available product) in response to demand. They could in fact raise their tax base, improve living conditions/services and reduce costs. This is all in support of the growing tech economy. In LA there are probably more renters than owners and perhaps those that are able should vote. I think the problem is people don't and when they want to buy or think about it they realize they are SOL and either have to gentrify some part of LA or move out.
- TACIXAT 9y ago>a less robust US economy I know it's kind of tangential to your point, but any sources on this? I was under the impression we were humming along.
- pcsanwald 9y agowow, the latimes site is just unusable. endless popups, scrolling is seemingly broken, ugh.
- dmh2000 9y agoI know it would be tough for senior citizens to move but there are lots of places in the US where you can rent a nice apt in a decent neighborhood. for quite a bit less than $1000. One bedrooms < $500. Maybe instead of trying to somehow conjure up lower rent housing in LA, set up a program to help people on fixed incomes relocate elsewhere. This would go for folks who work minimum wage too.
- mason55 9y agoAre you suggesting another city? The problem is that if your support network is in LA then moving somewhere else might not be feasible (or might not save you any money if you now have to pay for care).
- JBlue42 9y agoYeah, a lot of my friends from LA worry about being able to stick around so they can have a house, kids, and grandparents to look after the kids (and for them to be able to look after the grandparents).
- shams93 9y agoIt's especially brutal that unemployment tops out at 450 a week even if you can barely make your rent you have to try to pass brutal engineering tests when you're not able to eat for days or weeks
- jgalt212 9y agoLet's not forget ZIRP and how it was an incredible boon to landlords. The Fed doesn't seem to care about rent inflation, or asset inflation, because in the aggregate it's not that high, but in a number of cities rent is bleeding the middle and upper middle class dry.
- kevinburke 9y agoIn theory low interest rates encourage borrowing to build more, but we haven't seen the "building more"; CA added 2.3 million residents since 2010 and only 400,000 housing units. The problem is much more about local cities and NIMBY's having too much influence in the planning process.
- macawfish 9y agoRent and debt are far too often taxation without representation. It's that simple. This is especially true in situations where landlords sit back and collect, without taking due responsibility for the shape of the living spaces they supposedly "own". And people put themselves into these feudal arrangements for so many reasons. That part is not simple. Why do people want to be landlords over others? Why do you want to live in a world where it is normal to take huge debts, only to hand off the monthly payments to people who are barely treading water? This whole business of playing musical chairs with our homes and communities is beyond ridiculous. The amount of furniture that gets thrown out every month is shameful in the face of global climate change.
- imjustsaying 9y ago>Why do people want to be landlords over others? Why do you want to live in a world where it is normal to take huge debts, only to hand off the monthly payments to people who are barely treading water? I'm not saying it's the bank cartel, but it's the bank cartel.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoBeing a landlord is no different than collecting a check from your SaaS product. Are we throwing all property rights out the window at the same time?
- macawfish 9y agoIn some sense, we are throwing all the property rights into the windows of banks and real estate investment offices, where they will conveniently land in some virtual filing drawer to sit with the rest of their spoils.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoBanks, real estate, and Silicon Valley.
- SilasX 9y agoExcept for how the licensor created the software but the landlord didn't create the land.
- EGreg 9y agoOne word: automation and outsourcing reduces demand for local labor.
- notadoc 9y agoSounds like a typical west coast city nowadays.
- MachinShinn- 9y agoThe article sites a 1 bedroom, 900 sqft aprt with stacked washer/dryer and new appliances for $2100. Is that expensive? I live in a 988 sqft, 1bedroom apt with washer/dryer with 2 roommates. We pay around that amount. I consider myself very well off. I work 1-2 hours a day for myself online. I just chill/play games/eat out/lounge around Starbucks most of the day. I sleep ~10 hours a day. Sounds like the people in the article are just lazy. No one has a God given right to a detached house in LA... Just move. Your $1000 social security check makes you a God in the Philippines, Thailand, Macedonia, etc.
- oblib 9y agoWell, this is hardly a new crisis. I lived there before and after Prop 13 and it was a crisis then too. They way I solved it for me was to leave California. If you live and work in L.A. odds are good you're spending about 1 out of every 10-15 years of your life in traffic. And that's a 24/7/365 year. Deduct sleep and work from what remains and you don't have much of a life left. I figured that out sitting on the Ventura Fwy one day and started planning my escape when I got home. That was 30 years ago I never miss it a bit. I visited LA for the 1st time last year when my wife and went to "Desert Trip". In some respects it was better, and I tip my hat to Californians when I say that. They only thing I'll say "fer sure" was worse are "In-n-Out Burgers". They weren't even close to as good. Neither were the fries. I was sad about that and to be fair I kinda do do miss those.
- codedokode 9y ago> tight 700 square feet That is pretty much space for only two people. But $1600 is not cheap, I agree.
- jraines 9y agoNYC anecdata: a couple years ago my girlfriend at the time split a $2700, 400sq ft 2 bedroom on a 7th floor (!) walkup in Chinatown. Unrelated, but she's an architect and pointed out illegal parts of nearly every residential building we set foot in in NYC.
- rootsudo 9y agoYet people stay in places they can't afford.
- Tempest1981 9y agoWhat are some persuasive arguments that might convince NIMBYs to support rezoning their neighborhoods for higher density? I.e. to build consensus, vs just name-calling?
- jessaustin 9y agoThis is a good thought, but one doubts that arguments against self-interest could ever have much persuasive force. NIMBYers like to talk about all the catastrophes that will ensue if the community changes, but the primary catastrophe on their minds is the one to their Zestimate®.
- Tempest1981 9y agoPeople I've talked to seem more concerned about traffic and congestion, parking, and Airbnb. They aren't planning on moving (ever), so their Zestimate seems irrelevant.
- Tempest1981 9y agoIf there were a way for them to cash out, and go somewhere "better", that might be attractive. OTOH, all of their friends probably still live nearby -- esp if they've been there for 20+ years. Tough to pick up and go. I'm trying to imagine an incentive.
- scandox 9y agoDublin, Ireland. Same exact problem. Knowing both sides of the social divide I absolutely blame the landlord-centric culture - which includes a lot of very nice people that I know. But those nice people just should not be given such an easy ride. They're earning far too much from what is a very non-innovative activity. The cultural bias in their favour is overwhelming, however, since everybody who finally manages to buy a property silently joins their consensus.
- NOSHSHNACKERS 9y agoA really nice house in a quiet neighborhood with lots of stuff to do whithin biking distance - with bunnys and raptors and a creek in the back yard 1120 us a month my mortgage playing an extra hundred is 1000 I have granite countertops and a huge garage.
- contingencies 9y agoHigh rents? Are you kidding? LA is cheap. In 2010 I had a (OK, admittedly old) house on Mulholland Drive for $1700/mo. I had moved from London in 2009 which cost double that. Right now in 2017 I have a bog standard 118m2 apartment in Shenzhen for $1450/mo and there's absolutely no view, private orchard, wild deer, blue sky weather or cachet! In Sydney even unfurnished 85m2 in a cheap area would be AUD$2750 = USD$2060 and Hong Kong people recoil in horror at how cheap my place in Shenzhen is, they pay USD$3242 for unfurnished 85m2 in a cheap area.
- bfrog 9y agoThis is a growing concern even here in Chicago honestly. The problem isn't rent avg, it's rent avg in neighborhoods you would actually want to live in are growing to unpayable levels.