15 ms·
The De-Electrification of the U.S. Economy
- sounds 10y agoOf course, his last point is probably the most telling: "Dig more coal...the Teslas are coming." One of his major sources is eia.gov, and their 2015 report has electric power use at 38% of total use. Transportation is another 28% of total energy use, so the sooner that can switch over the electric, the sooner we can drop the 36% of energy being sourced from petroleum.
- Graphon1 10y ago> so the sooner that can switch over the electric, the sooner we can drop the 36% of energy being sourced from petroleum. but it's not a 1:1 relationship. A lot of electricity in the US comes from burning petro-fuels like natural gas (if you count natural gas as a petro fuel) or coal. There was a study[1] last year that argued that driving a Tesla in Ohio caused more pollution than driving a BMW 3-series, because the source of the Tesla's electricity was likely coal. 1: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/electric-cars-are-not-necessarily-clean/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/electric-cars-are...
- thebosz 10y agoThere are contradictory reports [1] about that. In general, it looks like even in the dirtiest states, driving an electric car is about as efficient as a 40mpg car. The argument also goes that electricity generation only gets greener so your electric car actually pollutes less over its lifetime, unlike a conventional gasoline powered car. 1: http://www.ucsusa.org/clean-vehicles/electric-vehicles/life-cycle-ev-emissions http://www.ucsusa.org/clean-vehicles/electric-vehicles/life-...
- Robotbeat 10y agoBetter than that! I prefer to look at the actual, most recent up to date data that EIA has collected. It goes all the way up to January 2017. In the 12 months rolling up through January, coal was just 30.5% of US electrical generation: https://www.eia.gov/electricity/monthly/epm_table_grapher.cfm?t=epmt_1_01 https://www.eia.gov/electricity/monthly/epm_table_grapher.cf... Below gas (33.5%). And below carbonfree energy at 35.4%. That 35.4% carbonfree electricity can be broken down into: 19.8% nuclear (this part we really should fight to keep operating as long as possible, certainly until we shut down every fossil fuel plant... going from 80% renewables to 100% renewables may actually be harder than going from the current 15.5% to 80%). 7.6% wind, geothermal, small hydro, and maybe some biomass (unfortunately, EIA doesn't break these out separately)... though most of this is wind and geothermal 6.7% conventional hydro. 1.4% solar. (and this includes distributed solar) AS recently as 2003, over 50% of our electricity was generated from coal. We're now at 30.5%. As long as we keep nuclear operating, it should be fairly cheap to squeeze out the rest of that 30% of coal by installing high capacity factor wind turbines where it's windy (and perhaps anti-correlated with other sites), lots and LOTS of cheap utility-scale solar, mounted on single-axis trackers to increase capacity factor, and lots in Texas and the American South where it's not already common. Adding 15% additional grid penetration of solar and wind both, along with probably some storage (lots of pumped hydro in Appalachia to replace coal, batteries everywhere else) to smooth out demand and UHVDC powerlines and East-West interconnects, we can squeeze out the rest of that 30% of coal without huge costs. If we try to do this without that ~20% nuclear, we'll either need a lot more gas or a LOT more money.
- cwal37 10y agoJust FYI, you can get a more fuel and technology specific breakdown of generation and inputs from form 923, but it's timelagged and many plants don't show up in the monthly reports, so you have to wait for the annual.
- elchief 10y ago> the power consumption of our disk drives and screens is rising Uh. SSDs use, what, 1/2 the power of a spinner? And LED screens use less than fluorescent, which use way less than cathode rays The switch to virtual machines, now docker on servers saves a bunch of extraneous running computers too
- DiabloD3 10y agoLess than half. And SSDs are continually improving that by increasing performance (this maximizing the length of idle time (which on SSDs is a small fraction of a watt)).
- ams6110 10y agoI'm not sure VMs really changed that much. Before VMs, people just ran more services on the bare metal. You had your web server, database, email, etc. daemons all going. Hosting services separated things by accounts and filesystem permissions. VMs made a lot of things easier/more secure but the raw number of physical machines has still exploded. VMs are bottom line less efficient than bare metal due to virtualization overhead.
- detaro 10y agoI think they have lead to consolidation. In many orgs it wasn't unusual to buy servers as new applications were required, and then those were replaced individually once they died. Traditional core services might very well have been on shared services, but if department X wanted application Y suddenly, it got it's own server. With virtualization, a lot of these setups got consolidated.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- closeparen 10y agoMaybe in the internet-focused UNIX sysadmin world. Your average small to medium business in meatspace has a closet running: - Windows Domain Controller - Exchange Server - File server - Accounting server - Several line of business apps from different vendors, each with an onsite server component (often just a distribution of MS SQL Server). - Card access control server (if there are more than the ~4 doors that fit on one beige-box-on-the-wall controller). - Security camera DVR. - Cisco, Avaya, or similar PBX. - HVAC system controller (if you're a large, modern building or complex). The DC, file, and Exchange servers, as well as desktop management and support, are probably handled by your primary IT contractor who sells you all your servers, network gear, and desktops. They'll tell you it's not good practice to colocate any of these services on the same Windows install, and resell you (with heavy markup) a different Dell/HP box for each one. Each line of business app has its own vendor, which created and manages your site's installation of its package. The door controls and security cameras are likely installed and managed by the same company that does your fire alarms. The two software packages likely state they should each have a Windows Server to themselves. The HVAC system controller is likely installed and managed by a company that knows barely enough IT to be dangerous, and also doesn't want to colocate. The PBX for your VoIP desk phones is likely installed and managed by the same company that ran the old DEC PBX for your analog desk phones in the 80s. They might have also done your ethernet wiring. None of these guys trust all of the others enough to share an OS instance. According to the old-timers, you previously you needed a separate server in the closet for each one. Now your Microsoft Partner is also a VMWare Partner and gives each other vendor their own little slice of an ESXi box. Oh, and there is probably no one on your payroll who understands this stuff or even has the passwords. Just the operations manager type who manages the relationship with each vendor and knows which one to call under what circumstances.
- sxates 10y agoLED and CFL lights, SEER ratings, LEED certifications, Energy Stars all are having an impact. Just in computers there have been huge advances. My MacBook Pro requires about 1/6 the electricity of my 2007 Desktop, and my LCD monitor is about 1/6 a CRT. Transition to EVs may start to soak up all the gains we're making in efficiency so the usage may start to tick back up. But we're building Solar and Wind sources at an increasing rate that will effectively start trading oil for renewable electricity. These are all positive trends.
- jacquesm 10y ago> My MacBook Pro requires about 1/6 the electricity of my 2007 Desktop Apples to Oranges though (or Apples, but still). The comparison should be a laptop from 2007. I ran a house on solar electricity and windpower back then, my laptop was about 35 Watts according to the e-meter connected to it, my present day laptop is roughly the same. Laptops have always been substantially more efficient than desktops.
- DiabloD3 10y agoI used to have the same argument... until I realized modern laptops can be desktop replacements (without being those gigantic bricktop "mobile/portable workstations"). Just slap a full sized monitor and a keyboard+mouse, and its more capable as a thin desktop (ala iMac) than the actual thing, and when you want to leave, just unplug all that shit and leave. The only call for full sized desktops is people like me, where cramming in full sized GPUs, more than one drive, and 32+GB of RAM is required.
- ew6082 10y agoEfficiency of CPU's and tech do not drive electricity demand. If anything, we use more power for tech now than ever before. This is the direct result of cheaper natural gas being on the market, which removes demand for electric heating/heat pumps, electric appliances, etc. There is also a shift in industrial use. Just this year Washington lost a large aluminum arc furnace smelter, for instance.
- tyingq 10y agoThe decline in the industrial sector seems more likely correlated to the general decline of US manufacturing capacity. The rest is less clear to me. More efficient lighting and HVAC seems more likely to move the needle than anything related to computers. Nice breakdown of where the electricity goes from the EPA: https://www.epa.gov/sites/production/files/styles/large/public/2015-08/electricity-consumption-by-sector-commercial-industrial-residential.png https://www.epa.gov/sites/production/files/styles/large/publ...
- tcoppi 10y ago> The decline in the industrial sector seems more likely correlated to the general decline of US manufacturing capacity. There hasn't really been a decline, simply a plateauing https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/OUTMS https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/OUTMS It is probably more related to general efficiency and productivity improvements that affect every sector.
- tyingq 10y agoThe chart shows the decline in industrial as the most changed of the 3. I would guess that capacity being flat-ish would be a big factor.
- obrienmd 10y agoThis is a common misconception - manufacturing output, beyond drops during major recessions, has steadily increased[1]. Recently, increases have slowed but outside recessions, "the general decline of US manufacturing capacity" is just not happening. What is dropping are inputs for the same output - employment being the most obvious / painful, but power, raw materials, etc. are all being used more sparingly as manufacturers improve processes and adopt new technologies. 1. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/OUTMS https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/OUTMS
- tyingq 10y agoYour chart shows current numbers roughly equal to 2008. That doesn't feel like growth.
- rdiddly 10y agoSeems like it's mostly about traditional manufacturing, or the lack thereof. Energy price spikes (2008) kill off energy-intensive businesses. But even when prices come back down these businesses don't start back up in the US, because a competitor in China has already expanded to fill the gap, and they do it cheaper.
- djrogers 10y agoThe article doesn't make it clear if this is commercial production of power, or if it include private owned solar etc. I could see centralized commercial energy production dropping due to home solar alone, but TFA isn't clear. Either way, I'd bet that the electrification of our cars and trucks over the next few decades will absorb most of the excess capacity and drive the need for more production.
- kelnos 10y agoThe article addresses private solar, though admits to incomplete data and some uncertainty: "The Energy Information Administration actually started estimating power generation from small-scale solar installations at the end of 2015... and found that it accounted for only about 1 percent of U.S. electricity. That estimate could be off, and there's surely room for more study, but mismeasurement of solar generation doesn't seem to be the main explanation here."
- arkis22 10y agoWe are living in the age of efficiency. As population growth slows it's only natural for electricity to as well. We aren't limited by our raw computing power, we're limited by our inability to apply it.
- caseysoftware 10y agoI remember my college desktop and how happy I was when I got a 400W power supply! Now the Mac I travel with that has 100x the processing, storage, etc uses a 85W supply if it's plugged it. If you do that at scale with more efficient everything, it makes sense. Remember when turning off the lights saved money? It was dubious then but with bulbs that use 1/10 the power, it's almost humorous.
- Scoundreller 10y agoYa, that 8 watt LED bulb will cost you $8/year running 24/7 at 10cents/kwh. If it takes 2 seconds to turn it on and off each day, that's 24 minutes a year saved by leaving it on. If your time is worth >$20/hr, consider uninstalling the switch.
- caseysoftware 10y agoAnd in Austin, energy rates are 1/3 of that. If your light is on 1/3 of the time, we're down to < $1/year. Without any time/value aspects, saving $1/year isn't on anyone's radar.. especially since the AC turning on is going to be much more.
- fnj 10y ago> And in Austin, energy rates are 1/3 of that. Are you saying electricity delivered to the home costs 3 cents/kWh in Austin? I flat out don't believe that. We're paying over 20 cents on Cape Cod. I can believe 10 cents in some areas. 3 cents, sorry; no.
- caseysoftware 10y ago
- lostmsu 10y agoShould we consume more? I would actually like to see electricity prices to go down, but it seems like research in that area nearly stopped.
- moojah 10y agoInterestingly he's stating that the transition to electric vehicles (EVs) will make up for the flat energy usage / non-existent growth. However, his own argument should negate a substantial amount of that: if large players such as tesla/GM/lyft/uber/whoever own the majority of future transportation, they will also have a strong incentive to be energy efficient. Never thought of it that way, but large players don't just make efficient use of hardware, but of the resources (energy etc) they consume too. That means the traditional energy industry is in for a beating...
- i386 10y agoOr a strong incentive to vertically integrate electricity production. I believe Google have done this in some form to secure and reduce cost of datacenter energy.
- EGreg 10y ago"Consider the shift to cloud computing. From 2000 to 2005, electricity use by data centers in the U.S. increased 90 percent. From 2005 to 2010, the gain was 24 percent. As of 2014, data centers accounted for 1.8 percent of U.S. electricity use, according to a 2016 Lawrence Berkeley study, but their electricity demand growth had slowed to a crawl (4 percent from 2010 to 2014). What happened? The nation outsourced its computing needs to cloud providers, for whom cutting the massive electricity costs of their data centers became a competitive imperative. So they innovated, with more-efficient cooling systems and new ways of scaling back electricity use when servers are less busy." I am torn because centralization leads to more R&D and cost savings and better security. I just wish the innovations would propagate to everyone. Decentralization is much better for everything except those things that come with economies of scale.
- vmarsy 10y agoThe R&D being done here doesn't only apply if you run extremely large data centers. Facebook, Google are contributing back to the Open Compute project [1] , and anyone could use this knowledge if they want to build a small data center with things like the Open Rack[2]. [1] http://www.opencompute.org/ http://www.opencompute.org/ [2] https://code.facebook.com/posts/1687861518126048/facebook-to-open-source-ai-hardware-design/ https://code.facebook.com/posts/1687861518126048/facebook-to...
- EGreg 10y agoBut it seems to me that when it comes to security, efficiency etc. only large centers can get it right, because they have more at stake. The majority of small providers will mess up. Like compare AWS uptime and security to a regular host. And sadly this explains the rise of centralized everything including gmail and facebook and iOS app store and - for thousands of years - centralized cities and states and federations.
- unlmtd 10y agoElectricity demand is driving production? So according to his logic, the reason we don't have castles in the sky is because we don't want them.
- accountyaccount 10y agoI don't think it's related to this plateau, but it sparked the question: If the global temperature were to increase by 1° would that cause a net gain or loss in electricity use? If you oversimplify you'd assume that since heating is more expensive than cooling consumption would decrease, but I imagine it might also depend on where the majority of humans are located in terms of climate?
- hackuser 10y agoA few years ago I measured the power consumption of various devices around my home, using an inline meter of unknown accuracy (e.g., TV plugs into meter, meter plugs into wall outlet). There weren't many surprises, but my cable TV boxes were disappointing: Two different models both used the same amount of power, 25-30 W, regardless of whether they were 'on' or 'off', and no matter how long they were 'off'. No other devices that drew any significant power behaved this way; in comparison, my laptop used 1W when asleep. The cable boxes are merely computers, and not even general-purpose ones - i.e., only a small number of predictable features have to be implemented - and the vendor is complete control of the hardware and software. There is no reason an effective sleep mode couldn't be implemented. And think about the mass deployments of these devices by the cable companies - how much power could be saved by investing in some very standard, available tech, and add up the impact on customers' electric bills and the environment. However, I wonder if other models of cable boxes are the same.
- caf 10y agoThis seems a pretty clear case of misaligned incentives. There's no reason for the cable company to make more energy-efficient boxes - they don't pay for the electricity use, and customers can't generally switch to different provider in order to get a more efficient cable box.
- hackuser 10y agoAnd customers generally have no idea about the boxes' power consumption.
- Symbiote 10y agoEuropean regulations have required the standby power of devices like this to be drastically reduced. As an example, the first one I found has a standby power of 0.5W. Even if the USA doesn't have similar rules, the improvements in power supplies etc should gradually find their way into American-only products. https://ec.europa.eu/energy/en/topics/energy-efficiency/energy-efficient-products/standby https://ec.europa.eu/energy/en/topics/energy-efficiency/ener...
- 10y ago
- anovikov 10y agoThat's great! Just wait for EVs though, you'll suddenly get all that electricity use back, and a lot more. But, overall energy use per GDP will fall through the floor due to their much higher energy efficiency vs gas powered cars.
- tiatia 10y ago"That's great!" It is likely a sing of a sinking standard of living. Had to come sooner or later, so I would not call it "bad". "But, overall energy use per GDP will fall through the floor due to their much higher energy efficiency vs gas powered cars." Highly improbable. Wealth And Energy Consumption Are Inseparable http://www.declineoftheempire.com/2012/01/wealth-and-energy-consumption-are-inseparable.html http://www.declineoftheempire.com/2012/01/wealth-and-energy-...
- anovikov 10y agoIt looks like you discard the whole notion of 'energy efficiency' at all?
- tiatia 10y agoHm. No. Just the outcome: "1993 and 2005, air conditioners in the U.S. increased in efficiency by 28%, but by 2005, homes with air conditioning increased their consumption of energy for their air conditioners by 37%." Jevons sends you his greetings I guess.
- OliverJones 10y agoWhat's weird -- not to say ignorant -- about this article is that it ignores the base-load / peak-load issue that lies at the heart of actual utility economics. Electricity is sold to households at a flat rate by the joule (metered by the kWh), typically with a fixed monthly fee tacked on. But wholesale electricity price fluctuates based on demand. Everybody knows this: in the height of summer when everybody's A/C is cranking away, the utilities have to fire up their nasty diesel-powered generators. They beg their commercial customers to reduce demand. Long distance transmission lines warm up and sag a bit. If worst comes to worst, the utilities reduce the voltage on their sendout. The utilities have to invest capital in well, capacity. If you know you never need more than 1 mW, and never less than 0.5 mW, you can build your distribution system for the peak, install four 0.25mW generators, and run two of them all the time and the other two when you need them. But if you might need 10mW on a hot day, and 0.5mW all the time, you have to spend a bundle on reserve capacity. Load management is persuading energy users to avoid surges, and to shut off nonessential stuff when not needed. But the typical electric grid isn't smart enough to handle this automatically. The load manager at the power company has to telephone Wal-Mart stores and ask them to turn off some lights and raise their thermostats. My electric vehicle charges at an appointed time of day, not when there's excess power capacity. The smarter the grid gets, the better use of capital the power company can make. Restoring power from blackouts is the worst. Electric motors draw a surge of power when they start. If a large city gets power restored all at once, the surge is huge.
- hownottowrite 10y agoExcellent breakdown of energy consumption by sector since 1950: https://www.eia.gov/totalenergy/data/monthly/pdf/sec2.pdf https://www.eia.gov/totalenergy/data/monthly/pdf/sec2.pdf The source is the same as the original article (U.S. Energy Information Administration), it just shows a much broader (and deeper) picture. As a result, you may draw different conclusions.
- sdadasrty 10y agoShort version: Electricity generation (and use?) is below its 2007 levels. Is this a trend? Let's skip to the last paragraph (as one always should when beginning to read these clickbait articles): "So is electricity use in the developed world fated to decline for years to come? Well, not exactly fated. Check out that bottom line in the last chart. Transportation now accounts for just 0.3 percent of retail electricity use in the U.S. If the shift to electric vehicles ever picks up real momentum, that's going to start growing, and fast. Dig more coal (or drill for more natural gas, or build more nuclear reactors, or put up more windmills and solar panels) -- the Teslas are coming." So, no. Get this trash out of my Hacker News.
- JshWright 10y agoIf you just skipped to the end of the article, you missed the fact that the last sentence is a slightly tongue-in-cheek reference to this article from 1999: https://www.forbes.com/forbes/1999/0531/6311070a.html https://www.forbes.com/forbes/1999/0531/6311070a.html
- phaedrus 10y agoThere's a much simpler, technical explanation: the transition from linear power supplies to switch mode power supplies, in devices of all sorts including but not limited to computers. The timing of the peak and beginning decline in per capita power demand coincides with the point at which SMPS's became a practical option for new designs beginning at the end of the 1970's. The decline since then may just be the result of gradual replacement of linear supplies by attrition.
- cat199 10y agoAlternate title: the Un-Reality of the GDP Rather than this being a measure of energy efficiency or reduction - could it not be a measure of GDP artificial inflation? Though that would be a bit of a sensational title, the trend also suggests a decoupling of GDP from physical processes (mfg, service jobs) directly requiring power for their use..
- pjc50 10y ago> decoupling of GDP from physical processes Well, yes: much of the growth is in services. E.g. education or health can get a lot more expensive without necessarily consuming more electricity.
- rb808 10y agoClosing all the factories in the Midwest would have a lot more impact than efficient light bulbs.
- pure_ambition 10y agoThe first thing I notice about this article is that it talks about generation, not consumption. Where is the data on US energy consumption? It's especially odd given that he compares US generation growth to China's consumption growth toward the end of the article.
- cbr 10y agoAren't generation and consumption very close to equal?