36 ms·
Uber Driver Tip-Hustling Schemes
- blhack 10y agoI'd love if an economist of somebody with a better financial background could comment on this: When you're giving a tip, you're effectively giving money to the people who own the company (or participate in profit sharing). Tips allow employers to pay their employees under market rate. By paying enough tip to bring the employee's wage up to the market rate, you are subsidizing the company's profit, not the employees profit. Tips are bad for employees because they are inconsistent, bad for consumers because the price of goods are not well-indicated, and good for employers because it allows them to offset their labor cost by hiding it in tips, which they have convinced consumers are going to the employees as a perk. So I don't know that I agree that the Uber app should implement tips (from a consumer or an employee standpoint). They should charge me more money (or rather, charge me the same as I am paying now, just make it more consistent), and pay their employees more money. I wish they would do both of these things.
- cortesoft 10y agoI think your logic is a bit flawed. If an employer can not get enough employees at the rate they are paying, they can either encourage tips to their employees to supplement their wages, or charge the customer more and pay their worker a higher salary. In the tip model, 100% of the extra money charged goes to the employee. In the charge more and pay more, the money might be split in other ways. I am failing to see how the tip model helps the employer more.
- ryandrake 10y agoYea, I don't get where this idea came from that tipping is either good for the employee or good for the customer. The employee is getting paid a crappy wage and the customer is being guilt-tripped into making up for it. The only winner is the employer.
- SilasX 10y agoDon't forget that you're implicitly paying a premium to compensate for the unpredictability/lumpiness/[1] of the tips! [1] as well as "the presence of people who deliberately flout the expectations" and whose non-payment must be made up, in expectation, by more honest customers.
- blhack 10y agoSo essentially subsidizing the profit of the employer and subsidizing the cost of the goods that people who aren't adhering to the implied price structure are paying (non-tippers)! I wonder how this came about? Like was this something a clever businessperson invented at some point? It sounds like the US is the only place with a tipping culture like ours.
- whathappenedto 10y agoOne other side effect which is generally not discussed because it's contentious, is that a number of people who receive tips will underreport their tips. Especially those who receive cash tips. So the state and federal governments are partially subsidizing their wages too.
- SilasX 10y agoI don't think "subsidizing profit" is an effect of the tipping system; what the restaurant gains in lower wages, it loses in higher effective food prices. In fact, I think, ignoring the tax evasion effect, the tipping system reduces profitability, because it scares away business by that "compensate-for-unpredictability" tax, which takes from what could be restaurant revenue.
- dikdik 10y agoI waited tables in college at a medium priced restaurant. On my great shifts I would pull down $50/hour on my best nights, $25-30/hour on typical weekends, and $10-20/hour on weeknights. Like most servers, I did not report most of my tips so it wasn't taxed. This was AMAZING for me, the employee. If I was an hourly worker, I doubt I would have gotten paid over $10/hour.
- inimino 10y agoThere are cases where the employer is obligated to make up the difference if the minimum wage isn't reached by tipping. In that case, the alternative to you tipping the waiter $5 is that the restaurant charges you $5 more for your meal and passes that on to the waiter to meet the minimum wage requirement. If the restaurant eats the loss and doesn't raise prices, then you would be right, but restaurants already have thin margins and high competition so they would have to raise prices to raise wages and stay competitive. If tipping went away, menu prices would go up. However tipping is a form of price discrimination and an incentive for good service, which are both arguably good things. Obviously the much more common case is where the tip would not be replaced by the employer. So in that case if you don't tip the $5, the waiter is just $5 poorer. The restaurant's profit isn't affected one cent.
- inimino 10y agoTo whoever downvoted this, I'd be interested to hear your reasoning.
- prostoalex 10y agoAnecdotal counterpoint to that is a restaurant switching to no-tip policy but then seeing its formerly tippable workers flee for a tip environment http://money.cnn.com/2016/01/19/pf/no-tipping-reversed-bar-agricole-trou-normand/index.html http://money.cnn.com/2016/01/19/pf/no-tipping-reversed-bar-a... Even though the former model offers stability and fair pricing, there are some outperformers in the tipping world which must take pride in their customer service skills. If no-tip and tip business coexist in the same industry, the adverse selection bias kicks in and the no-tip business gets stuck with average employees at best.
- madeofpalk 10y agoYeah, this is the problem when an establishment bucks the local trend and becomes a "no-tip restaurant" exception. Go to a country where hospitality staff are paid a 'fair' amount and customers aren't expected to tip and this problem goes away.
- vmarsy 10y agoIndeed this problem goes away. A new one pops up though: mediocre service, such as having to ask many times for refilling the tap water bottle or get condiments, and struggling to get the waiter's attention in general.
- shard 10y agoI have not noticed any overall service problems in Korea, Japan, or China.
- lz400 10y agoIn fact, service in those countries is much better than in the US. I would even say that if there's a correlation between tipping and quality of service at the country level, is negative.
- monksy 10y agoI have not seen this in most of Europe. I've seen more than enough times in the US. When I get service where the person just disappears for a long time and never pays attention to the table. I will refuse to tip and write the issue on the check.
- gabesullice 10y agoThinking through this, kind of out loud. Let's just take restaurants as an example. You say "tips allow employers to pay under market rate," but that can't be the case as a matter of logic. The market rate is _defined_ by what employers pay employees-employers as a whole simply can't all be paying below market wages or else the market rate would just be lower. Perhaps you mean, "less than the market rate for similarly skilled labor in non-tipped sectors" (shoe sales, as an off+handed example). The question then becomes, "are the workers' skills in these sectors transferrable? Could workers simply change jobs if offered higher wages elsewhere?" If so, then it follows that we can assume that the negatives you mentioned, like lower wages and less predictability, would drive workers out of the tipped sector and into the non-tipped sector. This would drive wages back up in the tipped sector. We don't see that. What I think we see, and I admit this is a little anecdotal, is that restaurants (in healthy markets) are quite easily able to fill their positions. In fact, there's competition _for_ the positions amongst workers. The fundamental rule to keep in mind is that if workers are being underpayed, they would simply change their line of work, driving wages up as the of supply of labor thinned. But what we see is that on the low-ends of both markets, wages generally stick to the minimum wage. If tips were suddenly outlawed, do you think that restaurant wages would skyrocket to $30/hr? That's roughly the equivalent of 4 $40 tables with an 18% tip. I don't think so, because workers from other sectors would flood in from other sectors causing the wage to be pushed back down. A new equilibrium would probably be found somewhere just above the going rate in non-tipped sectors. If anything, tipping probably lowers wages for non-tipped employees more than the tipped ones. I think the more interesting experiment would be to see how take home pay would be affected in a "tip-only" restaurant. In most, places around the country, the minimum wage for tipped positions is ~$6/hr. Losing that would be like losing one ~$33 table. On the employer's side, they would gain ~$9 back when you account for payroll taxes. I think what we'd see is that most of that wouldn't just be pocketed by the employer, it would probably go back into the restaurant in the form of better ingredients, materials, marketing, and/or additional staff, all in hopes of increasing the number of tables turned overall. Non-luxury restaurant profits are driven by tables turned, not the price of each plate. E.G. hiring an extra busboy or dishwasher might help you turn over more tables more quickly, increasing restaurant profits and also the number of tips earned by the servers. I don't know, this is all an interesting thought experiment. In general, I'm pretty wary of "employers pay workers less by taking advantage of X" arguments. Unless it's poor government policy distorting the labor market or something like a recession, labor markets probably function like any other market. Supply and demand still reigns king. Underpaying employers will have a hard time keeping employees. Highly skilled workers in any sector will sell their talent to the highest bidder.
- ThrustVectoring 10y agoIMO the biggest reason for tipping is tax law. Tips technically have to get accurately reported as income to the IRS, but basically nobody ends up giving Uncle Sam the full amount. Random google searching says that something like 15-20% of cash tips get reported and taxed.
- bernardvdw 10y agoThis is 100% inline with what I'm thinking. I am amazed by how many people don't realize that tips are mainly a scheme managed by the employer to guilt-trip the customers into paying an extra mandatory unpredictable amount of money. The thing that makes me so sad about it, is that the waiters are the first ones to guilt-trip the customers, but never the employers. It really hits a nerve when I read those blog posts from ex-waiters, explaining how difficult it is to "live with a waiter wage, so please make sure you tip 25% at least". That attitude is exactly the reason why employers continue to take advantage of employees. I agree that in the current state of things, tips are needed for waiters to survive. But it doesn't make any sense economically. If mandatory minimum wage was set for waiters, and tips were built-in, everyone would be better off.
- solidsnack9000 10y agoTips avoid taxation, so employees can earn higher wages than they otherwise might, with customers spending less than they otherwise would, and owners paying out less than they otherwise would. Now, tips are not supposed to avoid taxation but it works out that way...
- Kronopath 10y agoLyft has a good solution for this, in that they prompt you to give a tip through the app at the end of the ride. More and more they're seeming like the (at least marginally) more ethical and sane ride-sharing app.
- acheron 10y agoBut tipping sucks. That was one of the reasons Uber was better than Lyft in the first place. Then some assholes sued and now Uber drivers are allowed to ask for tips. Nice job breaking it, hero.
- haney 10y agoI'd argue it's easier to not tip when you have the option to tip in the App. If you're transacting with cash the driver knows if / when you aren't going to tip them. It'd be next level aggressive to sit and watch if you tip the driver on the app before you get out of the car. Personally, I'm fine to tip since the normal barrier to tipping for me is having cash, but either way in app tipping seems to make things easier.
- roywiggins 10y agoI like being able to choose whether to tip once I'm out of the car, cash-free, no time pressure. Sometimes a driver does really deserve a tip, and I like that Lyft facilitates it.
- hughes 10y agoWhat I like about the Lyft tipping model is that allows you to decide the (optional) tip after you have left the ride - when the driver says goodbye, they have no idea if you will or will not leave a tip. Removing the on-the-spot pressure of tipping and the immediate human response makes it feel like a very different experience. It makes me feel truly generous when I do tip, but I also know that my personal rating does not depend on that decision in any way.
- 10y ago
- redm 10y agoNo Tipping is one of the main reasons I liked Uber; no cash, no pressure, you just get out of the car and walk away with everyone happy. I would rather pay more for each fare and have Uber aggressively prohibit tipping. I suspect many people feel the same way and if Uber doesn't get it under control, it could be the biggest challenge they face.
- hyperbovine 10y agoAfter I switched to Lyft in the wake of the Susan Fowler thing, I discovered that they give you the option to tip. It made me realize that the pain point of tipping is actually feeling pressured to tip the moment the service ends. With the Lyft app I can tip (or not) later on, and I almost always do. It's not tipping that I don't like; in fact I really like tipping. With their strict no-tipping policy, it turns out that Uber missed the mark here, at least for me.
- myrandomcomment 10y agoAgreed. Used Uber for what? 2 years now? Just tried Lyft after all the crap about Uber and I liked it. I normally do tip the Uber driver for a long ride (I live in NorCal an my house is a pain to get to). Moving on to Lyft. I like the fact I can tip in the app.
- aninhumer 10y agoHmm, I'm normally against tipping, but now I'm wondering if this might be a solution to the problems with 5-star rating systems. I've often thought that it would be better to have a simple thumb up/down for quality control and then a separate above-and-beyond option for recognising exceptional service, but that requires friction on the latter option to make it work properly. Initially I was thinking just requiring a minimum comment length would work, but having to tip e.g. $1 might be a good alternative to that.
- wheelerwj 10y agoubers rating system used to be a lot simpler, this "give a compliment" shit is terrible, i dont even use it anymore. i miss in app tipping too. i really wish lyft was available in my area.
- dominotw 10y agoTipping is awkward and unpleasant. It is the number one reason I use uber.
- snowwrestler 10y agoDid we read the same blog post? Uber's inconsistent and awkward tipping scheme is a big reason I don't use them.
- hug 10y agoUber's tipping scheme is extremely transparent: Don't tip. The "self employed contractors" who pick you up may have tipping schemes inconsistent with one another, though.
- dominotw 10y agoTipping is awkward and unpleasant. It is the number one reason I use uber.
- wwwdonohue 10y agoDid Uber change the way they deal with driver ratings? Their "rank and yank" system [1] was once the object of considerate consternation. You would think that it would have been quite effective at dealing with "aggressive, tip-hustling" drivers. [1] http://www.ridesharingdriver.com/low-uber-driver-ratings-a-checklist-to-bring-them-back-up/ http://www.ridesharingdriver.com/low-uber-driver-ratings-a-c...
- orange_county 10y agoI imagine the rating system would handle this effectively. I would really be annoyed if the driver was pulling the same stunts that was listed in the article.
- raldi 10y agoWhat does "rank and yank" mean? It's not mentioned on the page you linked to.
- pmorici 10y agoThey cut anyone with a rating below X where X is determined market by market in order to balance out the number of new drivers they have coming in with the number of drivers they are cutting for bad ratings and also taking into account growth for demand in the market. In new or rapidly growing markets they hardly cut anyone ever but in mature markets with ample supplies of drivers they demand a very high average rating. At one point the cut off for being let go in LA for example was something like 4.6 out of 5.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoIt appears only the desperate drivers are left in the system, making ranking and yanking self-defeating unless Uber wants to continue to canabilize its diminishing capacity.
- chx 10y ago> It’s no secret that I love the ease and convenience of Uber and have been using the app for years. This https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13863955 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13863955 is what you are supporting, then.
- untog 10y agoNot everyone knows what's been going on with Uber lately, though. If you don't read the tech press you might have never seen it, so it's not fair to say the OP is endorsing it.
- chx 10y agoLately? Have you read what I linked? From day 1, Uber has been of utmost evil. This is not new. Even if you somehow manage to convince yourself that weakening the rule of law by deliberately ignoring taxi legislation which has been their business model since they started with UberX is somehow not a big deal, the first time that subprime shit was reported was more than two years ago. Most of the time when I post that Uber is evil, people are quick to downvote. But Uber will fail despite all the stupid fawning. Now it's just a matter of time. You can run from law, you can bribe people to ride with you but eventually the law catches up with you and buries you. In this case, it's going to be Waymo but honestly, something eventually was due to happen. Edit: hello downvoters! Any comments as to where I am wrong? Last time we did this I was told my claims are "baseless". OK, so I reposted my pile of links. What's your excuse this time?
- untog 10y ago> Lately? Have you read what I linked? From day 1, Uber has been of utmost evil. This is not new. My point is that the average user of the Uber app is not aware of any of this. They were likely recommended the app by a friend or read a vaguely fawning article in a magazine, or saw an ad online. So it's not fair to say every Uber user endorses their behaviour. They don't know about it.
- 10y ago
- TheChaplain 10y agoBorn and raised in northern Europe I find the US tipping culture weird. To me, tips are a bonus for service that goes above and beyond the expected.
- M_Grey 10y agoThat's what it would be here, except that it was co-opted by the usual Horatio Alger types as a means to underpay for labor and hide that cost. Then, like so much, it just became "how it was done". We're not bright, as a species.
- JustSomeNobody 10y ago>We're not bright, as a species The people under paying labor would probably disagree with you.
- M_Grey 10y agoSure, they probably would, but would they be right? Are they getting the best for their not-dollar? 9/10 New restaurants fail after all... typically investing in a restaurant is a losing bet. http://www.economist.com/blogs/gulliver/2015/10/service-compris http://www.economist.com/blogs/gulliver/2015/10/service-comp... But even more to your point... https://www.bna.com/no-tipping-fewer-b57982065202/ https://www.bna.com/no-tipping-fewer-b57982065202/
- JustSomeNobody 10y agoBorn in the US and I find tip culture here weird. In fact I hate it. It has taken away the pleasure of giving a great tip to someone who really earned it.
- untog 10y agoUnfortunately it's the nature of the beast when wages are so low. Bartenders are typically paid next to nothing and depend on tips, whereas in Europe they are paid a decent amount and don't need tips to get by. Unfortunately US politics means this won't change any time soon. Evidently it's simpler for every American to carry around spare dollar bills every day than it is to pass meaningful legislation.
- bjshepard 10y agoUber isn't going to exist
- k_sh 10y agoDon't burn yourself on that hot take.
- bendykstra 10y agoWow, norms change quickly. I traveled with my golden retriever several times last spring (always asking first by phone) and the drivers were all genuinely surprised when I offered a tip at the end of the ride.
- nlawalker 10y agoWell if someone chooses to share their car, you should just be happy that things worked out such that it was convenient for them to pick you up. And certainly you can share an extra couple bucks with them. We're all just sharing, right?
- stoptypingnow 10y agoThe issue with Uber is tipping can affect ratings and Uber plays like tipping isn't part of the mechanics. They've pushed driver payout so low it's now important for drivers to figure out how to get extra money from their fares. Lyft has pricing parity with Uber so the same issue exists but they help the situation by allowing tips to be collected in app but not expose the tip during the ratings process. It's a more honest and mature mechanic and why I've switched over to Lyft completely.
- PretzelFisch 10y agoIt does not seem the drivers are part of the sharing economy, many of them have made it a full time job. As a result many of the issues with taxi services seem to be slowly cropping up.
- dataminded 10y agoI don't agree with the argument that passengers should tip because Uber isn't paying their drivers enough. That sounds like welfare for Uber. If the pay sucks, Uber should have trouble recruiting drivers.
- djsumdog 10y agoI really hate tipping culture in America. In Germany, servers are surprised if you give them anything more thana euro. I have friends who visit from non tipping cultures who ask "Why isn't it just included in the price!" I agree with the author. Tipping is out of hand. Charge more for food, clearly state it on the menu/check, remove the tip black on the receipt and pay people a decent wage!
- mikepurvis 10y agoI don't mind tipping in principle, but I really hate the payment terminals that are preconfigured with outrageous options, so it prompts you to pick 20%, 25%, 30%, "other", so you feel like a total sleaze giving a normal 10-15% tip. It's the worst when I'm picking up takeout from a restaurant that also has tables. Like, am I supposed to tip in this scenario? Do I have to go into "other" to tip less than 20% for being handed a brown bag?
- fletchowns 10y agoI still tip the normal amount when I get takeout from a restaurant that has tables.
- calc_exe 10y agoIs this normal? I never tip for takeout..
- 1123581321 10y agoIt's not normal to tip for takeout, but if you want to, 10% is the standard tip as opposed to 15% for table service. But again, a takeout tip is not expected, especially for a simple order.
- zdean 10y agoSerious question for those who are pro-tipping...where do you draw the line? How do you choose which products/services are tip-worthy and which aren't?
- gcr 10y agoWhenever worker exploitation is involved (such as in this case), or when the worker materially relies on tips to stay afloat, I always try to tip. Wherever it's accepted by society, I also generally tip.
- RealGeek 10y agoTipping is an incentive for employers to squeeze the workers even more. Employers need to pay the workers a decent wage rather than them relying on tips.
- amgin3 10y agoThen you are just enabling that process to continue. You are subsidizing their wages and making it seem ok for their employer to pay them peanuts. I don't tip anyone and tipping is not a common practice where I live. In fact, most people would feel insulted if you gave them a tip here.
- snuxoll 10y ago> You are subsidizing their wages and making it seem ok for their employer to pay them peanuts. You're going to end up paying for it either way. But yes, I agree - I'd rather get rid of the culture of tipping and just pay a reasonable price for a service. The thing that really sucks though, is per federal law an employer paying the 'tipping minimum wage' is required to make up the difference if an employee makes below the normal minimum wage - they almost never do from what I can tell. By choosing to not tip not only am I just being an asshole, but the employer won't change anything either because the chance of them being caught being a douchebag is slim.
- deleted 10y ago
- nunez 10y agoWith Uber increasingly squeezing profits out of their drivers, this was 100% bound to happen. I am more surprised that Uber allows drivers that request tips to continue driving with them. If they really want that extra cash, then they should just go full-time on Lyft, especially now with all of the drama they're going through.
- jayess 10y agoMy uber drivers have been steadily dropping in quality, more often than not taking the wrong directions to my destination, despite the fact that the GPS right in front of them tells them where to go. I've been using Lyft more and more lately. Drivers just seem.... better. And I don't mind tipping in the app.
- Thriptic 10y agoI agree. I'm consistently amazed at how many people I end up giving sub-five star ratings to these days, and I have been a huge proponent and defender of Uber in the past. If you pick me up promptly, follow your GPS, have a car that is functional, and either engage me in pleasant conversation or say nothing at all besides 'hello', I will give you five stars. Many drivers seem to act as if they are driving their friends around as opposed to driving their clients around.
- kbenson 10y ago> I'm consistently amazed at how many people I end up giving sub-five star ratings That in itself is possibly a contributing problem. Incentives go all wonky when four-star ratings essentially don't exist. Five-star ratings should be reserved for exceptional service, and three-star ratings should be for average service, not "I'm unhappy with this but not enough that I won't feel bad giving a negative review, so I'll give it three stars." People don't know how to rate, and it makes all our rating systems much less accurate.
- Thriptic 10y agoIt is because of the rating system ambiguity that five stars is the norm. It signals that there is unequivocally nothing wrong. Anything less than five stars could be interpreted in many ways and is very subjective: did the user have a problem or do they just rate differently? It is why five star rating is also the standard for acceptability on Amazon and Ebay. Personally I don't care if there is no incentive to go above and beyond the base level of service. All I want and expect is the base level of service. If you want to reward epic service, do so with off the books tipping.
- mmel 10y agoWon't peole rate uber drivers who do this poorly?
- iopq 10y agoI drive Uber from time to time. I've only gotten a tip once over ~50 rides. A lot of the time the traffic conditions mean that after costs (I assume $0.40 per mile costs for mileage, gas, maintenance, etc.) my hourly is closer to $8 an hour (because after I drive for a while sometimes I need to drive a long way back as well on my own dime), which is below minimum wage. That's not including having to pick up plastic bottles after people or cleaning seats so they don't smell like sweat. It's basically never worth to pick up anyone who is going far away from your house, you end up actually driving for free since you have to drive there and EVENTUALLY drive home. Why do you think Uber drivers don't want to drive 40 minutes away just to get paid less than if they drove for 40 minutes inside their own city? I'll never accept a ride to San Francisco (40 minutes away) ever again, it's never worth the price unless there's surge pricing in effect. If I make $8-12 an hour, getting a $1 tip is like a 10% increase in my wage. I don't badger people for tips, but if I got like 10% of people to tip me, it would be super worth. The one tip I got was $20, btw. Even if we assume a 12% tip rate up from 2% if I ask for them explicitly, and the average tip size of $5 (median would be more like $2, but if I get a few more $20 tips the average would be higher than the median), I would make $0.50 more per hour which is a 5% increase in my earnings. Maybe it's something I should actually start doing.
- kbenson 10y ago> because after I drive for a while sometimes I need to drive a long way back as well on my own dime It seems like this is something they could help with. Can't they mark your home territory and try to schedule you rides that take you the right direction? If not immediately, maybe after a few rides in that area that don't take you too much farther away? It seems like this should be one of the main points of using Uber or Lyft, smart driver scheduling in areas where there's enough demand..
- iopq 10y ago> Can't they mark your home territory and try to schedule you rides that take you the right direction? they had this feature unfortunately, NOBODY LEAVES SAN FRANCISCO so it's pointless, you'll be waiting for someone to want a ride south for a very long time they've since removed that feature because it hurts your bottom line to use it
- Overtonwindow 10y agoWhat bothers me is that I don't want to tip in cash, and I never carry cash. Put tipping in the app for AFTER I get out of the car and AFTER the driver has given the rating. No rating, no tip.
- Negative1 10y agoCurious; are Uber or Lyft drivers penalized at all for canceling? I had a Lyft driver a few weeks back call me and ask where I was, which is odd since the app tells him. Turns out he was on the wrong side of the street. Instead of just turning around, he just says "bye", hangs up and cancels the trip. Was annoying for me since I had been waiting for 10 minutes at this point but it seemed like a real poor choice on his part.
- lavezzi 10y agoApparently not. We had a driver the other day in Park City, UT who told us that Uber drivers are no longer held to a minimum trip acceptance rate. Whether this is true or not he said Uber lost a lawsuit and could no longer apply the rule. He then proceeded to tell us with great glee that his trick was to go offline in-between trips until the surge price hit at least a 5-6x multiplier. He would then go back online and pick a fare that suited him. It explained why all of the Ubers and Lyfts there were insanely expensive. I've never seen anyone so happy to tell me to my face that he was ripping me off, and he even had the cheek to ask for a 5* rating at the end of the trip.
- Spooky23 10y agoWhy would you be upset? It's just a participant in the free market playing the game. After all you just can hang around for a few hours for the surge to end.
- lavezzi 10y agoMy point is that there is no end to the surge because they are all doing it. If the drivers are artificially limiting supply at all times then why wouldn't I be upset that I'm getting ripped off? Not once during my four day stay did I see the surge price go under 2x.
- gdulli 10y agoGrateful that I live and work on public transportation that's both cheaper and less unpleasant than what the author described.
- blhack 10y agoI really wish uber would just charge more. Part of why I fell in love with the service was because it sounded like the drivers were really happy.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- meesterdude 10y agoThe most ethical thing you can do is delete uber
- hamandcheese 10y ago> Then I’ve discovered first-hand that more and more Uber riders are calling ahead to ask for your destination to see if it’s “worth it” to pick you up. When I use Uber the first question it asks is the destination. I assume this is seen by the driver, no? Why would they have to call?
- shalmanese 10y agoRidesharing apps don't reveal destination to the driver until they arrive at the pickup. This is to prevent drivers from only picking good rides and leaving riders in the lurch. One of the main selling point of Uber in some cities is that they would get you to places taxis refused to go.
- dorfsmay 10y agoI thought Uber was about pure capitalism, with surge pricing and all. I actually thought that drivers knew the destination and that the price was going up until a driver accepted the ride.
- electriclove 10y agoUber asks for the destination but doesn't share it with the driver until they pick you up.
- hamandcheese 10y agoInteresting. In Orlando, Fl I have never been called ahead of time and I use Uber rather frequently. Different markets I suppose. It's also pretty easy to drive considerable distances around here.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- bobbles 10y agoMake sure you give a low rating and explain exactly why you did to the uber customer support, have always had refunds when dealing with this
- cavisne 10y agoNo tipping has been a big driver of success for Uber. Americans dont realise they are the only people who in the world who "tip" for completely average service/just doing your job.
- crisopolis 10y agoI do Uber part-time but only deliveries (UberEats). I get tipped from time to time and I have no expectation on the tip. I also don't have the problem of driving for free as the restaurants have a radius and usually I'll be near another place or return to my spot to sit for a bit. I find tipping awkward as the courier. Sometimes people like to explain they don't have cash to tip me and I have to explain tipping isn't expected on Uber's platform so don't worry about it. Other times there shoving $5 bills at me for driving 1.0mi down the street. As a customer I've yet to tip a Uber driver as other stated I don't carry cash only plastic. Same goes with getting my car detailed ... Do I give them $20 on top of the $100 or leave it at $100. Then I think how many drivers actually report the tips they make to the IRS.
- nomnombunty 10y agoUber pool is just a terrible experience in many levels 1. Many drivers think they make less if the passengers are using Uber pool. I am not sure if this is true or if they are confused. However, when they find out I am using pool they instantly turn passive aggressive and start complaining how they make nothing on a pool ride. They make me feel as if I am taking advantage of them. 2. Uber also tries to pack the car these days. A lot of times, it is probably much faster taking public transit than using pool. One time, my pool ride was just going around picking up people and 15 minutes later I was exactly a block from where I started. I got off the ride and Uber has the balls to charged me $10 for "cancelling". Decided to quit Uber on that very day. Will only ride public transit or Lyft these days
- hkmurakami 10y agoAren't there a few different pool "aggressiveness" options you can choose from?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- synicalx 10y agoSimple solution, bad reviews for drivers that demand tips - the problem fixes itself when Uber stops giving them fares.
- brandonbloom 10y agoI'm only a little surprised that nobody has suggested this, but: If the driver does something shady, just get out of the car. Immediately. Don't even give them the opportunity to apologize for it. I've had drivers call ahead to ask where I'm going. I just hang up on them, cancel the ride, then order another ride. While I'm in the car with a new driver, I report the incident using the in-app system and, on many occasions, they even grant me a credit! Similarly, I've had on at least two occasions where the drivers did obviously stupid, unsafe things within the first 30 seconds of a ride. I ask them to pull over, and I just quietly get out of the car, report the incident, walk away, and order another driver.
- diminoten 10y agoThe problem here is your cancel reflects poorly on you in Uber's rating system. But otherwise you're absolutely right. I have taken rides from two people who've called, asking for my destination, and I refuse to tell them. It hasn't caused me any problems in those two instances.
- dnautics 10y agoIf you have a really shady experience. You report it directly to Uber. Let them know that you think the driver may have adversely rated you, and I feel like customer service will roll it back if it's that important to you. but to be honest, an single experience will get averaged out in the wash.
- brandonbloom 10y ago> your cancel reflects poorly on you in Uber's rating system This is simply not true. I just checked: My rating is 4.73. I've probably taken a few hundred rides with Uber. I assume they adjust ratings for bad experiences, especially if you're a regular rider. By the way: It's not that hard to get consistent 5 stars as a passenger. Be respectful of the driver and follow these steps: 1) Say something like "Hi, are you looking for Brandon? That's me. Good evening. How's it going?" 2) Suffer less than 20 seconds of smalltalk 3) Go about playing with your phone or talking with your co-passengers quietly. 4) Say "This is my stop right there by the red car on the right. Thanks a lot, you have a good night!" - If you're an extrovert, you'd do this anyway (assuming you're not an asshole) and if you're an introvert, it's a good opportunity to exercise your smalltalk with low stakes.
- nopassrecover 10y agoIn Australia we've tried tipping Uber drivers (e.g. because we've inconvenienced them with a stop to pickup food on the way home) and so far after 5 occasions no driver has accepted the tip (taxi drivers accept a tip without question, and usually won't accommodate short trips, despite the law, yet alone special requests).
- ezzaf 10y agoI've had the same experience in Poland. Tried to tip a driver who'd gone above and beyond in helping me out, and the driver refused to accept the tip. The whole thing seems to illustrate just how far out of whack tipping expectations are in the US compared to the rest of the world.
- coolsdude2282 10y agoI just made an account to post this, a factor that isn't really being brought up by any of the comments I've seen in this conversation is drugs and other illicit practices used by Uber drivers to make money. I have known several drivers who sold marijuana, small individual shot bottles, smoking papers, flavored cigar papers, and other 'party related favors' out of their cars to make their Uber driving more profitable. Without this source of income made from people going to/from parties and bars on weekends, alongside their actual ride fares, their profit margin is not even worth the time. These 'tipping' hustles are frankly extremely mild in comparison to my experiences. I'm of the opinion that these hustles are publicly frowned upon, but in practice are not effectively policed on purpose. If Uber policed these sorts of practices in an effective way(like if they had cameras/monitors in cars) they would lose a substantial portion of their drivers instantly.
- trevyn 10y agoWhile I don't doubt this happening, where are you located? I've taken over 1,200 Uber rides in the Bay Area and LA, at all times of day, and have not once been solicited for drugs or smoke shop/convenience store items. (Plenty of other hustles, though.)
- coolsdude2282 10y agoMy experience getting offered relates to southern/midwestern states, TN/NC/GA stand out to me, and the drivers I've met/spoken with who did this most regularly operated in areas of Atlanta and its surrounding suburbs specifically. Although I have also experienced this several times in the upper Midwest. I suspect there might be some bias in my physical appearance that makes me get offered more? Several drivers had a sort of setup where they had goods in a box/console and opened it to make the offer, so it seems likely that if they didn't feel a fare to be the partying type they would simply not make the offer? One I saw had an entire cooler setup. Another possible explanation could be that in very competitive areas like LA or the Bay the rank/yank system cuts out bad drivers more quickly than middle-america where there is maybe not as large of a pool of people applying to be drivers? I have never had a bad or sketchy ride in Bay/NYC/Chicago/Dallas. (I have had no experience with Uber in LA)
- ziikutv 10y agoI remembered getting hustled to buy my driver McDonalds then coming home to realize I got billed $36 dollars for his time; a trip that usually costs $9. He guilt me into thinking he does not get paid the more he waits. Alcohol...
- ziikutv 10y agoOh! Forget to say this, I bought him McChicken and Fries. And a Poutine for me.
- ProfessorLayton 10y agoMy recent policy is to not answer my phone or texts once I've requested an Uber/Lyft. Too often I've had riders call me to ask where I'm going, and then ask me to cancel. I have had awkward phone calls where they ask me to cancel, but I politely decline and ask them to do it if they'd like.
- Cofike 10y agoI usually use Lyft and so the option to tip is there so this doesn't seem to be affecting that service yet. I honestly haven't used Uber in a while since the app never seems to work but if I got propositioned for tips with Lyft/Uber I'd definitely be hesitant to keep using that service going forward. I really, really hope they nip this in the bud.
- bitwize 10y agoIt's not just Uber -- I've seen tip jars out in Australian food stalls with signs exhorting patrons to tip. I like not having to tip, too, but it's like the Prisoner's Dilemma: once somebody starts successfully collecting tips, everybody else feels pressure to ask for them and then the whole economy adjusts to accommodate them. That's how I think we got where we are.
- ehmish 10y agoThere are tip jars, but there's no expectation to tip (at least in Sydney), it's just a thing if you're feeling generous that day.
- bitwize 10y agoMaybe this is a thing that is starting up north and slowly working its way south? In Brisbane, nobody asked for, or per se expected tips, but a tip jar was present often with a handwritten sign that said "Tipping is good karma" or "Tippers are sexy" or similar.
- hug 10y agoIn Melbourne I have literally never had anyone at any cafe, food stall, or any other similar place ask me for a tip, and yet every single one of them have a tip jar. The tip jar is always filled with silver change, almost always a "round up" from a note. If I buy a coffee for $4.20, and pay in cash, the tip jar might get my 80c. (I almost never carry cash, so this is rare in and of itself.) The only time I've ever even seen a tip requested is as a part of some POS card readers, where it asks if you would like to leave a tip before you enter your PIN -- Conversely I've also had employees tell me "just hit enter to skip the tip bit of the transaction" before I've even gotten to that stage.
- mthoodlum 10y agoI drove for Uber in a resort town and was appalled by how difficult it was to make any money at it even though I was paid twice the metro rates. The biggest problem is all the unpaid work and investment Uber drivers have to make just to drive for Uber and then Uber takes a huge cut. There are a lot of sunken costs involved in becoming an Uber driver. The driver then has to recover those costs with miserable earnings. I suspect the burn rate of Uber drivers is unsustainably high.
- andreasklinger 10y agoThe moment they add tipping the driver salary will go down even more. I hate this american business method of shifting blame to the customer.
- patcon 10y agoI feel like the inconvenience of getting hustled is just a minimal tax on using an questionably moral, very low-cost, low-job-security service. You get it cheap, but you've got to interact with desperate people, and deal with how that makes you feel uncomfortable... If you don't want to get hassled, better pay is the byline, not a tacked-on after-thought. (Disclaimer: I found the tone of this post pretty insufferable.)
- nickjarboe 10y agoMany cultures and sub-cultures don't believe in tipping for many different reasons. These cultures exist all over the globe and in the US. When tipping is needed to provide a decent wage for a service, people from these 'no tipping' cultures will tend to get bad to no service. Taxi services are heavily criticized for this behavior. I think it is great at least one of the two major smartphone hailed car services has a default culture of not tipping. Drivers can choose which they like better. Uber rides are very cheap at the moment, especially when you get an Uber Pool and no one joins. I hope they up the fares some and pass them on to drivers and keep tipping for special extra-ordinary service. Uber is so much more convenient than conventional taxi service and I sure hope it or some similar service continues into the future.
- imh 10y agoLots of discussion about whether tips are good or bad. Friendly reminder that people don't tend to tip all races equally [0]. This means that having driver compensation partially in the form of tips will mean black drivers get paid less. Some interesting implications here [1] [0] http://scholarship.sha.cornell.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1030&context=articles http://scholarship.sha.cornell.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?artic... [1] https://onlabor.org/2015/11/23/guest-post-tipping-as-employment-discrimination/ https://onlabor.org/2015/11/23/guest-post-tipping-as-employm...
- omarforgotpwd 10y agoUber grew a lot by aggressively cutting prices to boost demand, but at some point if you push drivers too hard it's going to backfire and ruin the customer experience.
- jjuhl 10y agoThere's no legal requirement to tip anywhere and it's money out my pocket and into a strangers (whom I'll likely never even see again). I never tip - for anything - no one should.
- Shalle135 10y agoI'm from Sweden and generally I never tip anything for any service available - neither does the absolute majority of my countrymen - with the exception of being on vacation in other countries or eating at some real fancy restaurant. I were in US a couple years ago and found it pretty emberrasing how people are expecting a tip. I understand that they're paid less and i've spoken with some of them and waitresses etc may make about $3/h+tip. It's not the customers job to see to it that the employees stay at their job - it's the companies. At the hotel bar we had some kind of happy hour where everything was free which of course made it a bit crowded so unless you held up a tip / bribe the bartender just ignored you. I understand that there are cultural differences but in my opinion you get a tip for a job well done - but it's ALWAYS optional and you should never feel obligated to give one.
- aaronbrethorst 10y agoTips are often a major source of compensation for wait staff and other U.S. service providers. Employers often pay these employees lower wages in anticipation that tip income will provide a significant portion of the employees' income. Customers should realize that they are not auotmatically paying 'more' (due to tipping). In non-tipping countries, the tips are simply built into the price of the food. An advantage to tipping, therefore, is the ability to tip whatever is appropriate: if the service is poor, a small tip should be left, signaling to the server that their service was subpar. https://www.tripadvisor.com/Travel-g191-s606/United-States:Tipping.And.Etiquette.html https://www.tripadvisor.com/Travel-g191-s606/United-States:T...
- Shalle135 10y agoI understand that they count on it as salary, it's the same with the Uber drivers - they don't make enough so they depend on the tip. Either way it's not acceptable - if they can't support themselves on the wages they have they should demand higher wages from their employers who equally raise the cost of the product.
- Moru 10y ago
- juskrey 10y agoEvery single internet sales article advises harassing people for profit, yet everyone freak out when the real world tries to sell something to them.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- thedonkeycometh 10y agoTipping is an awful way to compensate people in their jobs. Uber skimmed costs by have a non-unionised workforce and implying to their "customers" that they dont need to tip, as it's just, like, people car-sharing. natch
- homakov 10y agoWhen I hear the word "tips" after massage in Asia I never come back, even if I liked the massage. This is very rude to ask for them, so I act proactively.
- huffmsa 10y agoDo you tip your airline pilot? >No Bus driver? >No Subway conductor? >No Well, guess what that means.
- cheepoMcRico 10y agoI just paid your employer $5 to take my tipsy ass home at 3am, safely in a clean car. Why would I have to give you $3 tip? Fvck off, only my waiter or bartender get tips from me.
- cheepoMcRico 10y agoWhy should I tip you? Just because you got me home safely in a clean car for $5? I only tip everyone else. Not you stupid driver.
- metaxy2 10y agoThere seem to be really extreme regional differences with this. Wherever I am, when I take an Uber I usually tip a small amount ($1-$2) and as small talk I ask the driver what ratio of people leave a tip. Here in Western Mass I've gotten answers in the 30-50% area, if I'm right. New Hampshire seems to be similar. But in New York, they tell me it's maybe 1 out of 10.
- gamache 10y agoLyft offers in-app tipping, well after getting out of the car. Convenience is what people want, and Lyft makes it convenient to tip the driver whereas Uber makes it convenient to not tip the driver. I'm amazed so many people still use Uber, not even because of the rotten company culture and business practices, but because of the user experience.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoI've been increasingly using taxis, especially at airports because uber and lyft are turning into gypsy cabs. Forgetting that it often takes longer to get an uber, the number of times I've been pitched on some perfume or religious thing is really skyrocketing. Everyone has a side hustle to their side hustle now and it's generally concerning as an indicator of the economy.
- yunolisten 10y agoseems like a terrible company to support: https://www.jwz.org/blog/2017/03/a-round-up-on-why-uber-is-awful/ https://www.jwz.org/blog/2017/03/a-round-up-on-why-uber-is-a...
- golergka 10y agoWait - isn't tipping included in Uber app? I almost never use it myself. Gett, on the other hand, has automatic tip setting (like 5, 10, and 15%) that you can set once for all your rides. I thought the whole point of Uber is to make the transaction cashless?
- rdl 10y agoI think Uber drivers try to solicit tips from female passengers far more often than from male passengers. I rarely tip Uber, have taken hundreds of rides, and have never been solicited. (When I do tip on Uber, it is either going to the airport overseas to get rid of spare cash, or if something exceprional happened. I've taken UberX in major snowstorms and in that case happily tip $20. I left a laptop in an Uber and got it returned to me within 5 minutes, I tipped $50.)
- elmigranto 10y agoTips are a way for an owner to scam personnel out of decent salary. There is literally 0 reasons to have it these days. Every issue they were designed to solve either disappeared, easily solvable, or when solved via tipping leads to more significant problems. Low income? Pay workers more. No one thinks it's a good idea to start tipping, say, teachers. Can't afford higher salary? Split X% of profits among (smaller) staff. No one sells furniture for 10% less, halving cashier salary and making tips a requirement. Suffering of preferential treatment of tippers (like giving out seats for money)? Fine or fire offending personnel. Why what effectively a bribe considered okay in these cases? But no, somehow US culture still decides it's better to move that pressure and responsibility onto the customer provoking conflicts.
- NetStrikeForce 10y agoTIL you have to tip Uber drivers. Oh well. Luckily I only used it like 3 times and not planning to use it anymore.
- gech 10y agoYou do this then, don't you
- deeth_starr 10y agoWelcome to America. People who complain about tipping annoy me. I agree it's a pain to have to tip but companies in America like to not pay their employees. Instead of giving the tipping option Uber should just automatically add 15%. But knowing Uber they would just keepo this 15% and not pass it on to the driver.
- ZeroGravitas 10y agoInteresting comment: " Drivers sued because Uber was treating us like employees. Uber used to deactivate drivers who mentioned tips. The judge said Uber Drivers are independent contractors and have the right to request tips."
- dexterdog 10y agoWhy do they even have a rating system if they have a tipping system? Ratings for drivers should be based on how they are tipped compared to the average in the area. Ratings on riders should be based on how well they tip compared to the average in the area.
- losteverything 10y agoI guess most of HN never were so broke that they can't put themselves in the place of a worker who can receive a tip. Tips go directly to a person. Often a low paying or second job. It is about generosity and helping a fellow person. It's not about economic theory or even JUST how they served you. The tip -$1 or $2 or $5 gets the person a gallon of gas. A meal. A cup of coffee. It helps pay off a bill. It is savings for their childs prom dress. It pays for food. It allows the tip receiver to be generous themselves (1). To have extra to tip others. (The largest tippers are or were poor) One of lifes most enjoyable things is to be generous. Tipping shows a lot about the tipper, too. If Tipping to my fellow HNers is only about placing a value on the service given, then I say you don't know the entire story of working a job where tips make a real difference. Ask your next uber driver why they are working. (1) last month I had a fellow give me a $200 tip. The next night a neighbor came over and said her mom just died. She used to live with her and now in a home. Eventually she asked to borrow $20. Well. I don't ever have an extra $20 anymore but I was able to give her $100 because I got the tip.
- peatmoss 10y agoThis is an important point. I hate tipping culture, but the solution isn't to not tip when you're a part of a society where certain classes of labor are reliant on tips. My solution is to tip 20% rounding up to the nearest whole dollar. I don't care how horrible service was. On Lyft, I've given lower ratings (safety) and still tipped 20%.
- massysett 10y agoMy solution is not to use services that have tipped workers. I do not get grocery delivery, in part because I'm not going to tip somebody when I haven't even had a chance to see if all my items were delivered. I visit full-service restaurants less because of tipping. And if tipping becomes expected on Uber, I will stop using it. I don't think this solution helps tipped workers either. But I'm not going to be guilt-tripped into giving people money.
- nommm-nommm 10y ago
- montecore 10y agoThe writer is complaining about a worker trying to make a fair wage while promoting predatory lending with credit cards offers. Nah.
- CodeSheikh 10y agoIn some countries tipping is perceived very negatively. I have had my tip money almost thrown on my face as the server accused me of taking him as a "beggar". They earn good money and they take pride in their serving jobs. Greedy American institutions have shoved this concept of tipping down the consumer throats. Increase my food prices or driving rates, and I would be happy to pay them than haggle with every other service industry person about shorting them a $1 or $2.
- briandear 10y agoIf you don't make enough driving Uber. Don't drive for Uber. The market corrects low pay; basic supply and demand. Would you pay $10 for an oranage if you're buying it right from the farm? Of course not. The supply is such and the demand is such that $10 isn't the price. Would you pay $10 for an orange in you're at Everest Base Camp? Probably because there aren't many orange trees up there. The whole "living wage" argument doesn't hold much water with me. If Uber drivers were scarce, then Uber would raise prices (such as surge pricing.) If you aren't making enough driving Uber, then take your car, start your own car service, start marketing and compete. Not that it's relevant but I don't particularly like Uber however I do like the free market. In this case it isn't like Uber is a monopoly.
- tghw 10y agoWhether they mean to or not, Uber has been making the drivers less and less human. Now it's backfiring. Lyft includes tipping in the UI, after the ride. As a result, their drivers don't have as much of a reason to hustle for tips.
- amyjess 10y agoThe author is more tolerant than I am. In the case of both Ride 1 and Ride 2, I would have immediately cancelled on the driver as soon as he pulled those stunts. I actually did once get a text from a guy demanding to know my destination. I told him I already entered it into the system, and he immediately cancelled on me.
- habosa 10y agoUber should add tipping to the app, period. The way that Lyft does it is nice because you can't be pressured into a tip - the ride must be completed before the tipping screen is shown which means you're already out of the car. Even more importantly the driver has already rated you before you make this decision. I've tipped many Lyft drivers and never had a single one ask me for a tip or a good rating. I've had many Uber drivers ask (or put up a sign), because they know the app won't ask for them. I know what the responses will be already. "The lack of tipping is one of the main reasons I use Uber! Tipping is awkward! They should pay their drivers more it's not my job". So then don't tip. That's really all there is to it.
- lnanek2 10y ago> A fair solution would be for Uber to install an in-app option to add a tip. One driver I spoke to said they used to have that, but Uber just kept the tips and didn't pay them to the driver...
- gshakir 10y agoI really like the Starbucks model, where you add the tip after the fact. If the drivers doesn't know who tipped them, then they would be nice to everyone.
- giarc 10y agoI feel like Uber could get innovative here. Add 10 cents to every ride and divide that money amongst the drivers in the city each day based upon 1) number of rides 2) rating 3) number of canceled trips 4) distance. It will incentivize the drivers to get good ratings (more so than now) and encourage less canceled trips and more fares.
- jstelly 10y agoI'm surprised that this discussion of tipping doesn't include the fact that it implements price discrimination. It's possible that the reason tipping is so often the end point of systems is that price discrimination is much more profitable than having a fixed price for everyone. So trying to design a pricing system that replaces a tipping-based service needs to deal with this problem. How is your service going to implement price discrimination without tipping? Otherwise how is it going to be as profitable as a system that has price discrimination? I'm not saying I prefer these systems as a consumer; I would much rather pay a fixed price. I'm saying that it seems like they create the most profit and thus competitive edge for the businesses using them.
- laughfactory 10y agoYeah, I've never tipped an Uber driver. Not because they haven't been excellent, but because I don't carry cash, and it's supposed to be frictionless. I.e., easy. If this happened to me I'd never ride another one.
- dollaholla 10y agoI'm in NYC with 50+ Uber rides under my belt. Never been asked for a tip. One time I tried to tip the driver and he refused to take it.