53 ms·
Donald Trump Is Elected President
- unabst 10y agoThe impeccable insight of Peter Thiel. http://gizmodo.com/peter-thiel-goes-all-in-for-donald-trump-1788408461?utm_medium=sharefromsite&utm_source=Gizmodo_twitter http://gizmodo.com/peter-thiel-goes-all-in-for-donald-trump-... I didn't realize how "simplified" his convention speech was until I saw this. In hindsight (of about a week), now he sounds text book.
- dang 10y agoWe buried the previous thread on this because, at almost 2000 comments, it was pegging the server. If you'd like to read it, and don't intend to comment, you could help your fellow users by logging out first, so we can serve you the page from cache: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12907201 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12907201. If you do intend to comment, please take extra care to do so civilly and substantively, in the spirit of this site. Most people in the mammoth thread did do that (especially relative to what one might expect), so today we're a little more proud of the community and a little less proud of our software.
- Retr0spectrum 10y agoIt was pegging my browser too!
- zeusk 10y agoI'm curious, why is that just two thousand comments would bog down the server? What kind of processing is done by the server to render a thread?
- dang 10y agoOh man—all kinds of stuff. The visible bits are an iceberg tip. And it all runs in a Racket process on a single core. That mammoth thread at least tells us where the brick wall is: at about two 'who is hiring's.
- 0xmohit 10y agoGood that nobody ever tried to combine the two, i.e. who is hiring and who wants to be hired, earlier.
- koolba 10y agoIs it the total number that crushes things or the high level of nesting?
- dang 10y agoThe total number. We actually stop rendering comments past a certain amount of nesting; ever see a 'more' link where 'reply' would normally be? That's what that is.
- pja 10y agoHow much does calculating the approx time of posting for every comment add to the total load? If it’s significant then you could ship the UTC posting time to the client & calculate the displayed value in Javascript & eliminate that particular part of the load at least, which in turn might enable more caching internally. (You’ve probably looked at this already though.)
- dang 10y agoThe last time I profiled the code, the timestamps weren't expensive.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- scrollaway 10y ago:) The internet has been such a nasty place today and, similarly to the day of the Paris attacks, it's been really nice to find reasonably moderate discourse on HN. As... curious as I personally find America's choices in presidency, I'm just as ashamed of some of my follower feeds on various social media. Seriously guys, don't demonize people, especially by association. Refusing to hear your political opponents out is a sure-fire way to lose.
- md_ 10y agoIt's tough. I've been trying to find a pen pal who can give me some reasonable arguments for Donald Trump for the last few weeks, to no avail. Not living in the US, I don't really meet people who support Donald Trump. I'm probably living in a bubble, which isn't a great feeling--but at the same time, it's hard to credit the democratic process when you can't understand the alternative view. No doubt this is a symptom of polarization. Maybe this is the famed "filter bubble". In an ideal world one would imagine social media would help bridge that gap, but I'm unsure it has.
- commenting 10y agoThe nature of Trump is that he relies almost exclusively on appeal to emotion, rather than the reasonable arguments that you desire. Tapping into, encouraging and formenting the groundswell of American anger - mostly against demonized minority groups - is, sadly, his modus operandi. My only hope for America is that his presidency is nothing like his campaign.
- astrodust 10y agoIt'll be like his campaign, only crazier. If he runs the country anything like he runs his businesses he'll smash and grab anything of value, then leave the smouldering ruins for someone else to clean up.
- Swizec 10y agoWhat has helped me in this regard has been actively likeing Trump stuff on facebook. I didn't see much of that world, but enough to get a glimpse into their mindset. I heaetily suggest actively seeking out opposing views and training your filter bubble to give them to you. It's refreshing and often frustrating and upsetting, bud fundamentally a good thing.
- muad 10y agoTime to upgrade HN? That is hardly the first thread to experience performance issues.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoGreat work keeping things rolling.
- ErikVandeWater 10y agoThis thread is substantially less civil than the previous, for whatever reason.
- venomsnake 10y agoThe people with troll-ish tendencies woke up?
- pikzen 10y agoIt pegged the server with... 2000 comments? Does HN run on a raspberry Pi or something?
- dang 10y agoThere's a lot of processing going on when rendering HN threads. For logged-out users we can cache them, but for logged-in users everything's served from a single core running Arc in Racket.
- paulddraper 10y agoSo...now we have to start all over? I know I sound like a complete d--k, but my laptop from 2012 has eight cores that each run over 3 billion cycles a second. How do < 2000 comments make your servers more than blink? I'm guessing you have more than one server? I get frustrated by sites not accepting HN's "hug of death". An now HN can't even stand its own hug... Anyway, thanks for getting things running again! You guys are awesome!
- Artoemius 10y agoIt's Trump's hug of death this time.
- paulddraper 10y agoTrump's hugs have been quite newsworthy http://www.usmagazine.com/celebrity-news/news/donald-trump-awkwardly-hugs-melania-ivanka-expert-weighs-in-w430543 http://www.usmagazine.com/celebrity-news/news/donald-trump-a... Apparently he's bad at them.
- dang 10y agoWe don't have more than one server and HN proper (not counting caches) runs on a single core. Believe me, we hate slow software at least as much as you do and have put a lot of effort into addressing this. HN is a lot faster than it used to be on median load. It still falls short on excessive load. We'll get there!
- ihuman 10y agoHN is still made in arc, right? Does arc support threads? Racket does, so I would assume arc does.
- dang 10y agoRacket has green threads, which gives us non-blocking IO but that's about it. There's another concurrency mechanism that uses OS threads but Arc doesn't rely on it, and from the little I looked at, I don't think it would work with the HN software's design.
- qb45 10y agoIt would be nice to have some indication when the asynchronous requests (votes, flags) fail. For now I'm using dev tools.
- zo1 10y agoI'm very disappointed that the other thread was effectively buried. I kept looking on the first few pages and only clicked on this one by chance. Please spin up more resources? This is a major topic that will affect a huge number of people.
- tehaugmenter 10y agoI think the major load is gone now, here's the original: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12909752 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12909752
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- shuntress 10y agoWhat happened to the ~1300 comments?
- shadowfacts 10y agoYeah, I saw the 13k comments on my phone and went to look at HN on my computer to find they've all disappeared.
- martin-adams 10y agoLooks like a different submission, and I wonder if it was the cause of the HN meltdown causing slowness and error pages.
- jacobush 10y agoNew administration, new comments. :)
- kj01a 10y agoThat was a different post. This link is to the New York time, the other is to the Washington Post.
- qntty 10y agoold thread is here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12907201 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12907201
- mxfh 10y agothey are with the WaPo article https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12907201 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12907201
- dang 10y agoExplained at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12911042 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12911042 and https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12910929 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12910929. Sorry, I forgot I had 'delay' set on my profile or you would have seen the first of those instead of an empty thread.
- VonGuard 10y agoCan we setup a YCombinator in Europe? Canada? Somewhere other than the US?
- gragas 10y agoI'll say this again: Does this not prove that "diverse" liberalism isn't so diverse after all? Shouldn't a diverse group of people have seen this coming? Or is liberalism actually systematically excluding people by labelling them as "racist" and "sexist", when in fact they're just fiscal and social conservatives?
- CalChris 10y agoDon't blame your election of a demagogue on liberals. Take responsibility for that yourself. Own it.
- gragas 10y agoSure! I can proudly say I voted for Donald J Trump.
- qntty 10y agoDiversity means including people in out-groups at the risk of alienating people in the in-group
- yomly 10y agoBut one of the main "in-groups" of the Trump supporter base were the working class. In its current form "diversity" is nothing more than a weapon for classism. We are completely fine understanding root causes and bias which may underlie racial or gender based observations, but conveniently turn a blind eye to well-studied drivers for phenomena like nativism. A lot of the current form of diversity against the disenfranchised "in-group" amounts to "you're f'd for being poor and FU again for being unhappy about being poor".
- qntty 10y agoIt's acceptable (if short-sighted) to exclude people for being racist. It's not acceptable to exclude people for being poor and uneducated. The Democrats messed up by ignoring the pain of poor people, not by being insufficiently tolerant of racism.
- spiderfarmer 10y agoInstead of just starting another thread I would like to see the discussion broken down in separate topics. But I realize that's not what Hacker News is meant for.
- TulliusCicero 10y agoTerrifying, but the dems kind of brought it on themselves. A nominee who was actually likeable probably would've wiped the floor with Trump.
- CalChris 10y agoAgain, Republicans did this. Don't blame this on Hillary (hint: she won the popular vote). Don't blame this on Democrats. Accept responsibility. As for likable, Hillary has been the most admired woman in America, 14 years straight. Trump ran the most negative fact free campaign ever to overcome her likability.
- jpitz 10y agoAccepting responsibility, to me, means that the Dems do own part of this.
- fjdjcjncnd 10y agoBecause nothing underscores likeability quite like subverting the primary election and hiring an army of internet sockpuppets to shift public opinion in your favor. This is going to happen again in 2020 unless the DNC realizes what they've done. Sanders would have handily won this election and they havr nobody to blame but themselves.
- PeanutNore 10y agoYou keep repeating this. It doesn't seem to make sense to me. I voted for Clinton, and I'm a registered Democrat who voted for Sanders in the primary. I'm not sure what we're being asked to take responsibility for here. I feel that my party should take some responsibilty for nominating a candidate who could not prevail against such an unpopular and widely disliked opponent.
- fjdjcjcjnx 10y agoBecause nothing underscores likeability quite like subverting the primary election and hiring an army of internet sockpuppets to shift public opinion in your favor. This is going to happen again in 2020 unless the DNC realizes what they've done. Sanders would have handily won this election and they have nobody to blame but themselves.
- SolaceQuantum 10y agoNow that the voices of the disenfranchised blue collar workers have been heard, what actually can be done to help them? I'm less worried about the accusations of racism, etc. because it appears to me a majority are voting because their livelihoods have been lost and, despite economics saying globalization will bring new jobs, they aren't showing up in the critical areas where they are needed. So, what policies can be put in place specifically to help this demographic? I genuinely don't know.
- happytrails 10y agoThose old jobs are never coming back.
- imglorp 10y agoNo, and it's going to get much worse when the coming automation waves hit. We need a sociological solution. Perhaps base income?
- rayiner 10y agoNote that the last chart ("Clinton’s support from minorities fell short") seems to be erroneous, in that the graphic does not match the text. I think the NYT article glosses over the real story this election: http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2016/11/09/why-the-latino-vote-didn-t-save-america.html http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2016/11/09/why-the-lat... ("Hispanic voters were supposed to be one of Clinton’s blue firewalls—but one in three ended up splitting for Trump.")
- milesskorpen 10y agoThat was projected, though. It was a big issue that Clinton wasn't driving as significant African American turnout because they go 95% Democrat, whereas Hispanics were about 70% Democrat so you'd need a lot more of them to make up the difference.
- sndean 10y agoI wonder how long this populist wave that's spreading over the west [0] is going to continue? [0] https://research.hks.harvard.edu/publications/getFile.aspx?Id=1401 https://research.hks.harvard.edu/publications/getFile.aspx?I... [pdf]
- snowwrestler 10y agoUntil the generation that is driving it dies off, so probably ~20 years. I'm being flippant, but--look at the vote splits by age. Young voters in the UK overwhelmingly voted against Brexit. Young voters in the U.S. overwhelmingly voted against Trump. The voice of populism today is the voice of economic and cultural disenfranchisement. It is difficult to re-employ millions of 60-year-old folks whose skills are out of date. It is difficult to get 60-year-old folks who have spent their lives in a homogeneous town, to accept multicultural diversity. They are crying out for help and success again, and we'll continue down this course as a society until we either give it to them, or they leave us.
- falsestprophet 10y agoPeople change as they age. Today's 60 year-olds were the idealistic youth 40 years ago. Many a 20 year old communist is something else at 30 and then again at 60.
- devopsproject 10y ago> Young voters in the U.S. overwhelmingly voted against Trump don't people get more conservative as they age?
- snowwrestler 10y agoYes, in terms of financial conservatism (they have more to lose), and in terms of not keeping up with social progress (fearing young activists). That's them getting relatively more conservative, compared to the moving society around them. But people don't generally slide back from what they experienced as kids. A LOT of 18- to 25-year-olds today grew up as a kid in a society where it is acceptable to have friends from lots of ethnic backgrounds, to have friends who are gay or trans, to believe that women should be equal to men in society, etc. They're not going to lose that as they age. That's their base concept of "normal."
- happytrails 10y agoThose factory jobs are not coming back. The wall will not get built and it would not even work. What we will have is some NYC cronyism and wealth inequality increases. We may even have a recession if they decided to touch any trade agreement or increase tariffs ( based on debt load private and public institutions have). Whomever inherited the white house was going to have a bad time, this will just have to go on Trumps shoulders. :) 2018 you'll see a democrat majority in Congress.
- blahi 10y agoThe only factory people who voted for Trump are the ones who code in Matlab. http://i.imgur.com/RAaGDnW.jpg http://i.imgur.com/RAaGDnW.jpg
- ones_and_zeros 10y agoI don't get it?
- IMcD23 10y agoA very flawed argument above. I assume it's to mean that since Clinton won a majority of votes from lower income people, which factory workers would fall under, the only factory workers that voted for Trump are high-paid ones, which would code in MATLAB.
- phreack 10y agoAs an outsider, it is painfully clear that I should not try to move my business to the US at this point. Europe's looking better than ever now for tech startups.
- curiousgeorgio 10y agoFor what it's worth, Trump's views are likely to be more advantageous for tech startups than Clinton's would have been.
- XaspR8d 10y agoPerhaps? I'm not sure what you're alluding to. Regardless, startups are often attuned to many social issues much more closely than traditional companies, and I can't help but agree that this is a huge discouragement for forward-looking businesses.
- lern_too_spel 10y agoBy making access to workers more difficult or by repealing trade agreements that protect your startup's intellectual property and access to international markets?
- nerfhammer 10y agoTech startups are often composed of a majority of people born outside of the United States.
- ryanx435 10y agoTrump has only ever been against ILLEGAL immigrants. If you come here legally through a visa program or other legal method, than you are fine. Its the border jumpers and people who overstay their legal welcome that he has always had the problem with. I've read his books, watched his speeches, interacted with his supporters, and I've seen very little anti-foreigner sentiment. Its all anti-illegal-foreigner sentiment, which is fundamentally different.
- chris_wot 10y agoDo it in the spirit of those who hold the office of U.S. Presidency: be civil and courteous, make sure you don't disparage anyone's ethnicity or gender, and make sure you don't make wild and unfounded accusations, amiright?
- dang 10y agoPlease don't ignore the request to be civil and substantive. HN depends on it. We detached this comment from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12911042 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12911042 and marked it off-topic.
- chris_wot 10y agoWhat. The. Hell? That is absolutely civil, and it is substantive and it's a fact we should all aspire to! This is an unmitigated bit of bastardry, and you ought to be ashamed of yourself.
- inimino 10y agoYour veiled sarcasm wasn't fooling anyone, and arguing with the moderators (who honestly have enough to do) is tiresome. Please be sincere, if you're going to comment at all.
- chris_wot 10y agoHow would you know that? There's nothing cynical about that! As an Australian we hold the U.S. up as a model of civility. You've got no idea how uncivil our parliament is. Let me give you an example of one of our former Prime Ministers in parliament time: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=lEsN4-XLE2k https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=lEsN4-XLE2k Another Prime Minister said an opposition MP should "beaten with a blow torch". So don't tell me when I'm being sincere or not. I have watched Bush, Obama, Clinton, old clips of Reagan and Carter and they might have had unsavoury policies, but they made sure they gave dignity to the Presidency. And sure, they often tussled and sometimes they forgot themselves, or skirted the edges of what is considered acceptable for that role, but they largely remained civil and showed some level of courtesy and respect for the populace and their opponents. So I fully stand behind my comment. Whether you want to impune my motives or my sincerity, oh you who I've never met or spoken to or interacted with in any other way, well you feel free to do so but I know what I said was right, and something I think we should all try to aspire to.
- GrumpyNl 10y agoTrump talks about it but mr Clinton actually fucks them. Thnx wikileaks.
- yolesaber 10y agoI'd argue you are clueless. Trump has been sued several times for the discrimination against black people, he fired black people from his casinos and moved them to the back, he INSISTS TO THIS DAY that the Central Park Five are guilty despite DNA evidence, he jokes and also brags about literally molesting women. People like you disgust me. Stop acting like his words and actions don't matter.
- vinhboy 10y agoThank you for saying this. I needed this today. I am so damn sick of people trying to wiggle out of the "racist" label. Economic anxiety is not an excuse for racism.
- gragas 10y agoI voted for Trump and I'm not racist.
- zichy 10y agoYes, we have already established that you are clueless.
- AnOscelot 10y agoDoesn't matter if you're personally racist or not. You voted for a racist who has used racism as a substantial part of his campaign. You've done your part to give a racist power.
- vinhboy 10y agoThank you for saying this. I didn't want to respond to him because this answer seemed so obvious. I am glad others see it.
- Pica_soO 10y agoWhy not make a separate country, secede from the union, and proof by implementation the superiority of everyone s ideology?
- user837387 10y agoHe got elected on all these promises. 1- Build the wall and make Mexico pay for it 2- Deportation Force on day one 3- Repeal obamacare 4- Renegotiate NAFTA 5- Bring back coal 6- Reduce taxes for the rich 7- Ban muslims 8- Prosecuting Hillary Clinton 9- Bring back American companies to the USA 10- Etc. The Senate and the House are Republicans and the Supreme court will lean republican after his appointment. What do you guys think he is going to follow through on and the effects if he does or doesn't? And please note that lots of people thought he could not become president and now he is. So any of these things are possible now. Do not just dismiss any of these things. They are all possible.
- inimino 10y agoI'll play: 6 is a given, 3 is on the table but wouldn't be easy. The rest range from unlikely to impossible.
- bbctol 10y agoWhy wouldn't 3 be easy, given the makeup of the Senate and House?
- SketchySeaBeast 10y agoThe hard part will be "and here's our alternative!"
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- inimino 10y agoBecause it's already in place, and some of those folks in the House and Senate might want to get elected again.
- AndrewKemendo 10y ago
- 40acres 10y agoTrump is going to erase the entire Obama administration, a decent amount of Obama's impact was felt through executive order, all it takes is a signature to erase that.
- MrZongle2 10y agoLive by the sword, die by the sword. Or pen, in this case. I'm not excited about a Trump presidency. But from 2009-2011 Democrats held majorities in both the House and Senate. Then was the time to get the major work done, legislatively, that could not be undone by another Executive Order. That's on Obama.
- 40acres 10y agoDems spent all their political capital during those days on ACA, and even that was a struggle to pass.
- CalChris 10y agoLieberman comes to mind. Senate Democrats needed 60 votes to overcome Republican filibusters on anything. This meant Lieberman, the Senator from Hartford, had veto power over anything. Obama campaigned for his re-election and Lieberman campaigned for McCain. That Lieberman.
- happytrails 10y agoThe sun will rise in the east and set in the west. We will keep moving forward. We have systemic issues we need to address in the country and if they don't get addressed in this cycle it'll get worse in the next. We have major income inequality. We have an issue with tax avoidance and we have a problem with US Companies dumping workers for foreign labor. We also have a healthcare issue that needs to be solved. I doubt this Republican majority will be able to touch any of it but these are still problems and will remain so until we find a solution.
- webkike 10y agoThe issue I have is that most of our progress will be undone. The Paris Climate Accord rejected. Obamacare dismantled. Dodd Frank repealed. It's easier to destroy the world than it is to save it.
- tedajax 10y agoNot even mentioning the existential crisis we face knowing that Donald J. Trump, a man who has stated the most important thing in life is to get even, has his finger on the nuclear button and there's nothing any of us can do to stop him.
- cmdrfred 10y agoAs this election shows many in the middle class aren't fans of Obamacare. Maybe it isn't a boon to them as many people claim. The middle class are finding high deducable plans that increase in price by 25% each year and when it becomes too unaffordable for them, they are forced to drop it and they are fined. You'd be pissed off too.
- webkike 10y agoSure but I don't think the solution is to get rid of Obamacare, the solution is to fix it. And even getting rid of only Obamacare would be preferable compared to all the damage he could do.
- 10y ago
- curiousgal 10y agoCtrl - F Sanders 0 results. Hadn't Hilary been dishonest and, as much as I hate the word, crooked enough to not allow Bernie to face Trump, this wouldn't have happened.
- pja 10y agoYup. I could also see an Elizabeth Warren / Joe Biden ticket doing well against Trump. This article in Current Affairs turns out to be prophetic: http://static.currentaffairs.org/2016/02/unless-the-democrats-nominate-sanders-a-trump-nomination-means-a-trump-presidency http://static.currentaffairs.org/2016/02/unless-the-democrat...
- snarf21 10y agoEven Clinton/Warren or Clinton/Sanders would probably have won.
- gthtjtkt 10y agoWikiLeaks summed it up pretty well: > By biasing its internal electoral market the DNC selected the less competitive candidate defeating the purpose of running a primary. Hillary, the DNC, and all their cronies deserved this. I would've voted for any Democrat who won the primary fair and square, but I couldn't bring myself to vote for someone who stole an election (and from one of the most well-liked candidates of all time, no less). Many of my friends felt the same way -- they either stayed home, voted 3rd party, or voted without selecting a presidential candidate. The fact that they tried to bully/guilt everyone into voting for her didn't help much either.
- lern_too_spel 10y agoHow did she steal the election, and how was her opponent, who received nearly 4 million fewer votes, one of the most well-liked candidates of all time? The data does not support your story.
- chillacy 10y ago
- hourislate 10y agoI can't help but think how this election will look tame in comparison to what is to come. AI and Automation will continue to savage employment. Environment will continue to degrade. Millions of more in America and around the world will feel like they have been left behind. Where do we go from here?
- commenting 10y agoIndeed, and with regards to the environment, it's particularly worrying that Trump intends to reverse all the progress made so far in the US on addressing climate change. (Though to be honest, that's one of my lesser worries concerning a Trump presidency. Along with increasing discrimination and divisiveness within the US, it's likely his proposed foreign policy changes will enable Putin to annex further regions of Eastern Europe.)
- hourislate 10y agoLets hope that it was all talk and he still believes in encouraging Freedom and Democracy around the world. It is terrifying to consider the message he would send to Putin and other Dictators if he carried through on his foreign policy changes.
- koolba 10y agoAs someone who's actively vocalized his support for Trump in the past, both here[1] and in my meat space life, I'm ecstatic with the results of this election. Not just the POTUS, but the trifecta of the house and senate as well. That's as loud of a mandate as can be expected from a strongly divided country. On top of all that, with the SCOTUS picks that are expected in the next few years, this election is going to be felt for many years to come. I just hope that as we move forward with the transition to the new government, both sides can leave behind the incessant name calling and hate that's plagued this election. It's done, it's over, and the people have spoken. Now let's move forward on the direction that's been chosen and go about discussing it constructively. [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12728645 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12728645
- _fizz_buzz_ 10y ago> That's as loud of a mandate as can be expected from a strongly divided country Is not winning the popular vote really a strong mandate? http://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/11/09/501393501/shades-of-2000-clinton-surpasses-trump-in-popular-vote-tally http://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/11/09/501393501/...
- yahyaheee 10y agoSeems like the people have spoken
- applecore 10y agoPoliticians know the electoral college decides the election. If the candidates had been campaigning for the popular vote, presumably Trump would campaign harder for more votes in large states like California and New York.
- _fizz_buzz_ 10y agoPossible. But so would've Clinton.
- 10y ago
- nopinsight 10y agoSince the GOP now holds both Congress and the Presidency, with a likelihood of continued Supreme Court majority, they may enact some protectionist policies to appease the voters. However, these could in fact make the economic situations worse and some people would start to blame other things. Could the backlash spill to the technology and related sectors as well (e.g. a neo-Luddite movement might get started)? Note: I did not grow up in the US, so I would like to hear your opinions on this, especially from Americans.
- hx87 10y ago> Since the GOP now holds both Congress and the Presidency, with a likelihood of continued Supreme Court majority, they may enact some protectionist policies to appease the voters. That would ignite a civil war in the Republican party between the populists and the upper-class free-trade establishment, and while the populists have a good chance of winning, it's not a done deal. > Could the backlash spill to the technology and related sectors as well (e.g. a neo-Luddite movement might get started)? Unlikely, since anyone who gives up technology will be at a severe competitive disadvantage and screw themselves over.
- WillPostForFood 10y agoWhy neo-luddite? You can probably look at Trump's manic use of Twitter as an pro-technology indicator.
- themckman 10y agoSo, I voted for DJT (I like calling him that, for some reason). I didn't vote for him because I agreed with any of his policies (as best I can tell he never actually presented any during the course of his campaign) or because I thought he was the best representative for the people of this country. I did so for a couple of reasons: 1. I like a good underdog story. The people that support him, for a multitude of reasons, feel neglected by the ruling class in this country. Now I don't know who started all the name calling, but I personally dislike the way they're demeaned and patronized by the Democrats/Liberals as racists and deplorable. There is absolutely no respect from the left given to these people and their opinions. Yeah, there are some loud one saying some ridiculous things, but I refuse to believe that close to half the country hates people of color and wants to completely isolate us from the rest of the world by closing our borders. It just can't be true. I lived in Germany for the last year and was just stunned at how quickly the word Xenophobia was used to label anyone that disagreed with Merkel's policy regarding the refugees. If your opinions were so immediately dismissed with such a strong word, you're going to start harboring some pretty strong feelings of animosity towards those who so quickly judge. 2. I believed he was the candidate with the biggest chance of winning that would bring about the biggest amount of disruption and change. (By this account, I should have voted for Obama in 2007 instead of writing in Ron Paul. But goddamn if Ron Paul didn't seem to have the most reasonable, compassionate and "real" voice I've ever heard in politics.) This, I believe, is inline largely with why Peter Thiel was backing him. I don't know if any of that change or disruption is going to be good or bad for me or the rest of America, but things are certainly going to be interesting for the next four years. Both the Republican and Democratic parties are going to be in complete turmoil as they scramble to figure out what the hell just happened. I think we were all ready to talk about the, sort of, civil war that was about to erupt in the Republican party after this election, but we might end up talking more, initially, about the same thing happening in the Democratic party. Obviously things aren't rosy with the Republicans just because they won everything, but the Democrats really have nothing to do but try and figure out what went wrong and fix it. I, also, don't believe he can really do anything too awful that we can't recover from; I have some faith in the checks and balances laid out by the constitution that will prevent DJT, himself, from doing too much harm. Unlike the Brexit vote, a DJT presidency isn't permanent. We'll be back in four years to do it all over again.
- ap22213 10y agoI'll probably stop working for a while. I really don't want to support these creepy people in small town and rural america. They should no longer get my tax money to prop up their almost non-existent economies, and they certainly shouldn't enjoy a 1st world lifestyle on my back. No more 60-hour weeks for me. I'm retiring. I hope other follow. Maybe they'll finally get off their couch, turn off breitbart, and actually do something positive and productive with their lives. Addendum: To the down-voters: I thought part of this 'movement' was to get rid of political correctness. So, please let me take advantage of my new found right to say what I really think - what many people have been secretly thinking but have been too polite to actually say. Let's put it all out on the table. Wasn't that one of the big motivations to begin with?
- _audakel 10y agoThis attitude of categorizing large amounts of ppl "creepy ppl in small town" and refusing to see / accept that they have legitmate issues and greivanes is exactly why HRC lost. We can not just cut of or forget about a large portion of our nation bc we do not agree with them or we are not better than the Donald. Of all ppl, HN should see this as an opprotunity. Large pain points of rural america = massive startup opprotunites.
- ap22213 10y agoSorry, that's plain false. I grew up in one of these places. Many of my schoolmates are people who supported this man. I've tried for years to be accepting of them and their ideas. They're friends of mine. I've tried hard to understand what they even want. I've joined their facebook groups; I've gone to their shooting ranges. But, literally 80% or more of what they say is hate and rage and paranoia. I would love to see evidence otherwise. The time for acceptance is over.
- _audakel 10y agowhat are you proposing if not acceptance?
- DavajDavaj 10y agoI think the election of Trump is also a backslash against the PC, SJW, safe-space, trigger-warning, micro aggression tendencies that have been spreading in the U.S. for the last couple of years. This has become too much and millions of Americans are fed up with it, they have now spoken out.
- mikeash 10y agoWhich is ironic since Trump's supporters are the most PC, safe-space, triggered people I've seen. Clinton called some of them "deplorables" and there was such hue and cry. Point out that it's racist to criticize a judge based on his ancestry, or to propose banning immigrants based on their religion, and they got so tremendously offended.
- some-guy 10y agoThis is spot on. "PC" "safe-space" and "SJW" are simply labels for specific people, but the same tendencies behind them exist everywhere. The same people complaining about PC-culture and SJWs are the same people who are outraged about Colin Kaepernick taking a knee during the national anthem.
- knz 10y agoAnd the same people who fear their religious liberty is under attack because gay people can get married or because Starbucks says "happy holidays" on the side of their green cup.
- ng12 10y ago> Clinton called some of them "deplorables" and there was such hue and cry I think this was Hillary's single biggest mistake. It was exactly what they were waiting for -- the "Washington Elite" telling them they were less than. It gave the outsiders a rallying call.
- mikeash 10y agoIt definitely was a bad move. I can't say I disagree with the sentiment, but it was not a smart thing to say.
- huac 10y agoI have a lot of thoughts, but here's one: Hillary focused her entire campaign on why people should stop Trump, at the expense of talking about why she should be president. In general, making the case against someone else rather than the affirmative case for yourself doesn't work. It's reaction versus action. It's undoubtably true now that there was a very real populist anger towards the existing political order, and as a corollary, the political and economic elites. Instead of harnessing that energy and attempting to create a movement (see: Sanders, Bernie), the Democratic party anointed a candidate who is the definition of establishment. The results are showing that Hillary lost, at least in large part, due to lower voter turnout, especially among liberal-leaning populations. With all else equal, Podesta, DWS, Neera Tanden, and the rest of the DNC cutup squad ignored the people and ran on the "man, Dangerous Donald, obviously you're not gonna vote for him!" platform. That, and shaming Bernie/Stein supporters about their support for a candidate who can't win - rather than explaining how Clinton's policies would be good. Well, the Democrats and 'moderates' didn't vote for Trump, but they sure didn't have a reason to vote for Clinton either.
- jbkrule 10y agoI disagree with you entirely on your first point. Trump's entire campaign was based on hate and that's why he won. It was all about building the base of people who hate the other side more.
- cloakandswagger 10y agoThe next four years is going to be very confusing for you if you can't ask yourself objective questions about your opposition and resist the reflex to paint them as a cartoon villain.
- knz 10y agoTrump condoned crowds chanting "Hang that bitch" at his rallies. Regardless of how you feel about the usual left vs right arguments - tapping into anger in this fashion is playing with fire.
- narrator 10y agoI bet Peter Theil is going to have a full schedule holding court over the next several months as all the Silicon Valley power players are going to want to know how they can get in the good graces of the Trump administration.
- dopamean 10y agoI wonder how he feels as a gay man knowing that he supported a candidate who ran on the most homophobic platform a major party has ever had.
- lettergram 10y agoFor better or worse, Trump's probably the next president... The weird part about this election, is the electoral college could still pull a fast one on us and elect someone else. There are quite a few of electors and governors who REALLY hate Trump. If anyone's curious, the elector college votes in December[1]. Edit: I don't think this will happen, but in a world where Trump won, anything is possible. [1] https://www.archives.gov/federal-register/electoral-college/key-dates.html https://www.archives.gov/federal-register/electoral-college/...
- DamnYuppie 10y agoI am not saying this out of anger or angst. If that was done the civility of the disenfranchised electorate, which showed up in force this election, would erode and devolve into violence at a pace that would astound those on the left.
- SketchySeaBeast 10y agoYou think anything can astound the left after last night?
- LesZedCB 10y agosome of us on the left were not surprised at all. a class program is a strong one, even if it's a right wing program.
- Artoemius 10y agoGiven that the race was pretty close, I wonder if we have Peter Thiel to thank for this result. Personally, I have a feeling that Trump would lose without Thiel's support.
- ryanx435 10y agothe vast majority of Americans have either never heard of Peter Theil or straight up don't care what he thinks. Most people don't care about silicon valley because it doesn't affect their day to day lives in an overt manner.
- readhn 10y agoThat's part of the problem. We in SF, NY, Boston live in a bubble, "fantasy America". We do not see how the rest (75%) of America is doing. My friends are buying $800,000 - $1mil homes and think that they did pretty ok while some poor schmuck in Alabama is eating Oreos for dinner... The income gap is huge and these elections are the result of this historical inequality. I'm not calling for communism our socialism here just saying that half of the country are not doing well. Now if we get those self driving trucks rolling - what happens with the last accessible middle class paying job in USA - truck driver and huge portion of middle class America that is still hanging in somehow? We need a change that Hillary couldn't provide and I doubt that Trump could do it either.
- readhn 10y agoThis is not over. These elections are just the beginning. I hope that there will be no blood shed... :(
- icarot 10y agoI am particularly happy that people outside of that SF/NY/Boston bubble chose Donald Trump, while acknowledging his character flaws, instead of paying any attention whatsoever to the mass media. Though I fully agree with you -- We need a change (which change? I'm not sure!). Hilary Clinton definitely couldn't provide any positive change; also doubt Donald Trump can, thus I apathetically voted for a different candidate than either Clinton or Trump. Yet, I fully stand behind President Trump (feels weird to say that, eh.. I know..) as our president, with our country balanced in unity. I hope for the best with his leadership of the next four years!
- jernfrost 10y agoSigh, the only think positive I can imagine coming out of this is that now, I get four years I can make fun of how stupid American's are. As the country descends into chaos and non of Trump's promises comes truth I can sit in my couch and keep repeating: "I told you so!" Good thing Republican's get all the power. Now they fully own all the shit that is to come. They wont be able to blame that on anybody else. I think Brexit and the Trump victory has hammered home that democracy in its current form doesn't work. It has no mechanism to protect itself against stupidity and ignorance. Or perhaps it is a warning to every country about what happens when economic inequality gets too bad. Before you know it the crazies will grab power. I hope the rich elites are horrified today. Because they have created this monster, by consistently funding efforts working against the interests of the middle class and eroding it. Now it has blown up in their face. I almost feel a slight schadenfreude over the trade wars which will follow with China and Mexico and all the businesses which will lose money over this.
- chriskanan 10y ago>> I think Brexit and the Trump victory has hammered home that democracy in its current form doesn't work. It has no mechanism to protect itself against stupidity and ignorance. This is one of the main reasons why the founders of the US constitution feared direct democracy, and only gave the populous the ability to directly elect House members that serve only two year-terms. We now have something closer to a direct democracy, with the electoral college as an artifact.
- afterburner 10y ago> I hope the rich elites are horrified today. The rich? They're getting their tax cuts...
- ryanx435 10y ago> Sigh, the only think positive I can imagine coming out of this is that now, I get four years I can make fun of how stupid American's are. it is this sentiment from the left that propelled trump to victory. Your elitism is disgusting.
- 10y ago
- st3v3r 10y agoThe reason people are demonizing Trump supporters is because they ran on a ticket of undoing just about all of the progress that many had fought hard for over the past eight years. LGBTQ rights are likely out the window, as is any hope at gender equality or income equality. So forgive me if I have no sympathy whatsoever for those that are being "demonized" on social media, as they likely aren't going to have to face any actual consequences for this decision.
- dang 10y agoThis is the sort of sharp step down in civility that we need to avoid when replying here. I'm sure you can express your views without doing that, so please don't do that. We detached this comment from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12911283 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12911283 and marked it off-topic.
- st3v3r 10y agoYou're going to have to explain what was uncivil in my statement. Nowhere did I call anyone names. Nowhere did I insult anyone. I explained the feelings that many of us have of what happened, and why we're not so eager to kiss and make up.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- IanDrake 10y agoI didn't vote for Trump, but what LGBTQ rights are you talking about? I don't recall any federal law that passed granting them rights. Also, what sort of income equality were you hoping a Democratic government would implement? How would the mechanics of that work?
- rhodysurf 10y agoMarriage Equality?
- 10y ago
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- sremani 10y agoIs this a black swan event?
- wnevets 10y agoThe cognitive dissonance required to be a trump supporter is quite amazing. For example states that legalized weed but voted for trump.
- fuqted 10y agoDitto for Hillary.
- forgetsusername 10y ago>The cognitive dissonance required to be a trump supporter is quite amazing I love how the left continues to believe that implying the right are stupid and incapable is still a winning strategy.
- wnevets 10y agoI love how anyone who disagrees with the right must be on the left.
- pasquinelli 10y agomaybe someone posting on a message board isn't part of "the left's" strategy, but rather a human being saying something.
- pram 10y agoTrump isn't against weed?
- wnevets 10y agohttps://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2016/11/18/trumps-pick-for-attorney-general-good-people-dont-smoke-marijuana/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2016/11/18/trump... please tell me more
- pram 10y agodonald trump has literally said he supports essentially the same policy as the cole memo under obama you dense autist https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/post-politics/wp/2015/10/29/trump-wants-marijuana-legalization-decided-at-the-state-level https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/post-politics/wp/2015/10... "In terms of marijuana and legalization, I think that should be a state issue, state-by-state" you realize neither lynch nor holder advocated legalization either, right? (no) http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2015/feb/1/loretta-lynchs-stance-on-pot-may-be-problematic-fo/ http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2015/feb/1/loretta-lynch...
- slg 10y agoPeople always say things like politics doesn't work. It doesn't matter who you vote for, nothing changes. The president has very little actual power. Most politicians agree about 95% of things. I have always thought those people were naive. I wake up this morning hoping that I was the one who was naive and Trump will be unable to do the damage that many of us are worried he will do.
- _of 10y agoThe president of the US has quite a lot of powers: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Powers_of_the_President_of_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Powers_of_the_President_of_the...
- Delmania 10y agoThe election of Trump isn't the real problem here. The real issue is that the Republican party now has control of the government, with only the fact that they don't have a supermajority in the Senate as the only check on their power. This is an organization that openly admits to voter suppression and harbors some of the most virulent racists, misogynists, and homophobes. An organization that has launched an attack on education and science. An organization that publicly claims to call for smaller government but then enacts some of the most intrusive surveillance we've seen. It's going to get a lot worse very quickly before it gets better.
- pcunite 10y ago> harbors some of the most virulent racists, misogynists, and homophobes. Like those at the Chicago rally?
- taxicabjesus 10y agoFour years ago, I wrote a sort-of tongue-in-cheek story for Kuro5hin.org (RIP) titled "Humanity's Second-Best Hope" [1]. I pointed out that the Democratic president had failed to deliver on the Change he had promised, and shared my faint hope that maybe Mitt Romney was a "political gladiator" who'd flip on the plutocracy once he was elected. [1] http://www.TaxiWars.org/humanitys-second-best-hope/ http://www.TaxiWars.org/humanitys-second-best-hope/ Alas, Mitt Romney was no gladiator. At some point in this election cycle, I noticed dilbert cartoonist Scott Adams' blog. On August 13, 2015 Scott had a post about Donald Trump titled "Clown Genius" [2]: Like many of you, I have been entertained by the unstoppable clown car that is Donald Trump. On the surface, and several layers deep as well, Trump appears to be a narcissistic blow-hard with inadequate credentials to lead a country. The only problem with my analysis is that there is an eerie consistency to his success so far. Is there a method to it? Is there some sort of system at work under the hood? Probably yes. Allow me to describe some of the hypnosis and persuasion methods Mr. Trump has employed on you. ... [2] http://blog.dilbert.com/post/126589300371/clown-genius http://blog.dilbert.com/post/126589300371/clown-genius For the entire election cycle, the political media promoted Hillary Clinton as the presidential heir-apparent, as if she was The Chosen One. Usually the plutocracy runs a Chosen candidate against a backup - someone who, even if fickle voters decided to not select the Chosen candidate, would still be useful to them. Donald Trump was not a backup candidate. He was give free coverage during the primaries because he was considered a clown-candidate that wouldn't be taken seriously, it was an easy story, and because it was thought that The Chosen One could beat him. This was covered in one of the Wikileaks emails... Donald Trump is the Gladiator that Mitt Romney was not. I'm optimistic.
- devopsproject 10y agoThe "Master persuader" series explains in great detail why and why trump won. It also explains how and why everyone got it wrong. great series.
- taxicabjesus 10y agoThe Trump Master Persuader Index and Reading List Posted February 18th, 2016 http://blog.dilbert.com/post/139541975641/the-trump-master-persuader-index-and-reading-list http://blog.dilbert.com/post/139541975641/the-trump-master-p...
- hiven 10y agoPolicies aside, why does he always look so orange. It's not even a little bit.
- AdmiralAsshat 10y agoMy takeaway from this is that our strategy of "shaming" people into voting a certain way doesn't work. Exit polls seem to suggest that plenty of people understated their support for Trump because they were embarrassed to admit they voted for him. But they still did. In effect, you don't stop people from supporting racism, homophobia, or misogyny by calling attention to it. That only makes them support it quietly. You have to counter it with something. We failed to adequately counter his arguments, content to simply point at them and say that they were racist, sexist, or Islamophobic, because we (naively) assumed that drawing attention to it would be enough.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deadringerr 10y agoI like your points, I do think this is a big piece of the picture. I almost wish the polls let you vote either "for" a candidate or directly "against" a particular candidate - I think we'd see that many of the Trump voters would have preferred to vote "against" Clinton rather than "for" Trump.
- Nadya 10y ago>I think we'd see that many of the Trump voters would have preferred to vote "against" Clinton rather than "for" Trump. That's an odd statement to make because many Clinton voters would have also preferred to vote "against" Clinton rather than "for" Clinton.* They were part of the "Never Trump" crowd. Not pro-Hillary but very anti-Trump. E: Typo, apologies I didn't catch it before my post delay ran out. `"for" Trump` in my post has been corrected to `"for" Clinton`.
- deadringerr 10y agoI think I see what you're saying, though you might have meant that those who voted "for" Clinton would have rather voted "against" Trump. It's true, all variations would see votes and I think that would speak better to who actually had a larger base of people truly voting "for" the message of a candidate.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- neves 10y agoIt looks like Clinton has won the majority of votes: http://www.nytimes.com/elections/forecast/president http://www.nytimes.com/elections/forecast/president The USA electoral system is really crazy.
- devopsproject 10y agothe electoral college is not the problem, FPTP is the problem
- neves 10y agoWhat is this? Is it https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First-past-the-post_voting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First-past-the-post_voting ?
- devopsproject 10y agoyes. you can see what maine did about it: http://www.rcvmaine.com/ http://www.rcvmaine.com/
- CWuestefeld 10y agoOn the contrary. If it weren't for the electoral college, we'd be governed, in effect, by a handful of coastal mega-cities. Whole states would have a voice equivalent to a rounding error. The Presidency wasn't intended to be democratic - that's what the House of Representatives is for. Moreover, the Presidency has less power than people work themselves up to believe.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- pikzen 10y agoAs an outsider...what the hell did you guys just do? There are many, many reasons for Trump's election. Maybe it's time to rethink a bit about how you guys do politics?[0] Distrust of the establishment (of which HRC was the perfect embodiment). Jobs which have disappeared forever which were promised to be brought back. And as software developers for a lot of us here, maybe it is time to get more of us to think about the consequences of our work. Clear populism from Trump, always an easy way to get votes, and not just from the less educated. Enough disinterest from the american public in politics that a /pol/ meme ends up being elected. DNC primaries that were a joke, where HRC was selected against many odds. Candidates that campaigned not for themselves but against Trump while he just reaps free publicity. I'm just... speechless. With the amount of power he's going to have as POTUS + SCOTUS nominations + House/Senate majority, the potential for a massive step back is insane. Roe vs Wade, ACA. Not to even mention the issue of dropping the Paris/COP21 agreements. The one small hope we had for the future just got destroyed. That's the second time you do that America please stop ;_; [0] Being from France, I realize that we also have our problems and we also have to do that.
- forgetsusername 10y ago>Distrust of the establishment (of which HRC was the perfect embodiment) This is what is so amazing to me: there was a massive surge in anti-establishment sentiment, from Sanders on the left to Trump on the right. It was unparalleled in my lifetime. Yet the DNC decided to run a candidate who is basically the epitome of Washington establishment? It's embarrassing.
- LyndsySimon 10y agoTo be fair, the GOP tried to run a similarly establishment candidate - they just lost control of the primary process with Trump's wave of enthusiasm.
- duderific 10y agoBut, the DNC is the establishment, so why would they do anything other than run an establishment candidate? And how much power does the DNC actually have over which candidate is run? That is decided in the primaries (see: RNC's control over which candidate was nominated).
- chris_wot 10y agoAmazingly, you can agree with the first post here exhorting folks to be civil and courteous and it will be considered rude and belligerent, marked off topic and you'll be derided by a moderator who should know better. Well done, YCombinator.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tommy_wiseau 10y agoThe valley need to get over themselves and learn to appreciate the lessons from the unlikely Trump victory. Trump is the quintessential startup success story. Jump in the ring, breaks shit (always easier to ask for forgiveness than permission) then somehow makes his way to a hit product. He disrupted the business of politics much in the same way that uber disrupted the business of transportation. Guess Peter Thiel really is the smartest guy in the valley after all. Per Mark Cuban tweet (not a sv guy per se but still a voice representative of the community): We all need to give President-Elect Trump a chance. Support the good. Lobby against what we disagree on. No one is bigger than us all
- jernfrost 10y agoHaving a population of idiots is not something Trump can claim responsibility for. He is simply an asshole who has exploited this for his own gains. What exactly is there to learn from this? That democracy doesn't work when to large fraction of the electorate are ignorant fools. The lesson should be a better school system for America. But of course that would not be in the interest of republicans. They rely on large number of idiots to win elections. So it is not going to happen. They will make sure that there is an elite which gets good education which can run companies and create new ones. But there needs to be a large underclass of simpletons to keep the system going.
- pixl97 10y agoI'm glad you are so much smarter than the rest of us.
- ryanx435 10y ago> Having a population of idiots is not something Trump can claim responsibility for. > large fraction of the electorate are ignorant fools. if you think the roughly half of all American voters that voted for trump are idiots or ignorant fools, than it is perhaps you that is the idiot. Simply by the law of large numbers there exists a significant number of them that are smarter and better educated that you are. Disparaging them as an lesser group is a dangerous way of thinking.
- tommy_wiseau 10y agoThe valley need to get over themselves and learn to appreciate the lessons from the unlikely Trump victory. Trump is the quintessential startup success story. Jump in the ring, breaks shit (always easier to ask for forgiveness than permission) then somehow makes his way to a hit product. He disrupted the business of politics much in the same way that uber disrupted the business of transportation. Guess Peter Thiel really is the smartest guy in the valley after all. Per Mark Cuban tweet (not a sv guy per se but still a voice representative of the community): We all need to give President-Elect Trump a chance. Support the good. Lobby against what we disagree on. No one is bigger than us all
- matthewmacleod 10y ago(I'm in the UK, but I think the discussion is broad enough to be applicable) Given Trump's win, looming Brexit etc., what's the way forward for a moderately-progressive-mostly-centrist like myself? I can completely understand where a big chunk of Trump's support has come from. For a large number of people, globalisation is shit. Employment has become less stable; the gap between rich and poor appears to be growing; there is a sense of disenfranchisement with politics, and there is rampant corruption. Generally, people have every right to be totally pissed off with this situation; they essentially feel ignored by a distant 'elite' or whatever, and it seems pretty obvious that there will eventually be a reaction against that. I certainly don't feel that Trump-ism and Brexiteer-ism is an actual solution to these problems; they do seem like relatively opportunistic populist movements that have capitalised on popular resentment. I have basically zero confidence that these movements will solve any of the problems they claim they will, and think that they will likely cause lots of damage along the way. But the big question is – where is the credible centrist or even leftist alternative to this approach? Was it actually Sanders in the US? (I'm a little unclear on the extent of his support). In the UK, there's a leftward swing in the Labour Party, but that's complicated by a lacklustre leader. But is it actually the same sort of populist rebellion, just expressed in a different way? I don't subscribe to old-fashioned Socialist views of the economy – but still, I'd like to see a world in which corruption is tackled; in which all people have a fair chance to succeed; in which education and healthcare are widely available regardless of wealth; in which companies are free to trade but are responsibly regulated… but I'm now deeply unsure of what the next steps are.
- ookdatnog 10y agoThe hardest problem of our time is the seemingly unstoppable rise in inequality, and I think the painful truth is that no one has workable solutions to this problem. The establishment probably understands the problem but has no solutions, so they simply avoid addressing it. Populist politicians then get elected by simply naming the problem (often with a big dose of scapegoating), no matter how irrelevant or counterproductive their proposed solutions are.
- CWuestefeld 10y agoIn an election largely between two epically bad candidates, the outcome fell in the direction I'd felt would be less bad, but in a way that's worse than I'd expected. I had strongly criticized both Clinton and Trump, but felt that in the balance, Clinton was a more dangerous candidate. Seeing how the chips fell, though, I'm even less confident that this was the preferable outcome. There are two key factors leading me to this conclusion. First relates to the big-picture politics. For all the disagreement about policy, Clinton really was the centrist candidate, and certainly within the Democratic Party, the strong voice of moderation (at least in domestic policy). Something I failed to consider was that this defeat weakens the voice of moderation, thus making the extremist voices from Sanders and Warren louder. Clinton may be a bad person, but Sanders and Warren represent some really bad ideas, and if this gives those ideas fertile ground to grow in, that's a real problem. And there's a real possibility of that. The demographics representing Trump's win shows that his grasp on the rust belt manufacturing interests was much greater than previously thought. The thing is, Trump's not a Conservative and never has been. He represents populist ideas that overlap significant with the Sanders and Warren ideas. Politically they're on opposite sides, but ideologically they're quite the same. The election results give that ideology more weight, and Trump can see them realized. The second relates to Trump's relationship with the rest of his party. Looking back to the summer and the party conventions, there was a clear rift in the GOP, with powerful members barely tolerating Trump, if at all. That was a good thing: it meant that should Trump win, his party would likely keep him in check. But unfortunately (and I do think it's unfortunate) it seems like that rift is healing. And with the GOP retaining control of both houses of Congress, it's dangerous to have so much control in the hands of one party, with Trump at the helm. So where do we go now? Well, maybe there's a silver lining here. Maybe the prospect of Trump power with both political branches in GOP hands will inspire the Democrats. Maybe they'll re-discover the benefits of limited government, and in particular the boundaries of Presidential power. Unfortunately I have little hope of that: Obama certainly said all the right things when he was in the Senate and GWB was in the White House, but when he got power himself, all of that restraint went out the window. So let me offer to my Liberal friends this olive branch: I'll be there fighting with you against overreaches from Trump and the GOP, but I hope you'll stay by my side in four years when the tide is likely to turn. And I hope that my Conservative friends who criticized President Obama for overreaches will remain consistent. The trend toward populism is a thornier problem, and I don't have a satisfactory answer. My best hope is that people will come to their senses. It's intuitive and satisfying to believe things like "the Mexicans are taking all our jobs" or "our trade deficit shows we're losing out to the rest of the world" or "higher minimum wages are necessary to protect those on the lowest rung". Recently the Democrats have tried to market themselves as the party of intelligence and science. When trying to make that case - whether you’re a Democrat or a Republican - please first look to the scientific consensus on those topics.
- elcct 10y agoI think people are tired of political correctness and left wing (or so called liberals if you will) stealing the fruits of hard work of the people in form of taxes and regulations and pushing "equality" agenda at all cost. People are not equal.
- chillacy 10y agoThat's funny, because you could also see this as the result of working class citizens without skills which would have made them valuable in the new global economy, vote for trade protections which would allow them to keep their manufacturing jobs. Also: > We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the Pursuit of Happiness.
- api 10y agoOn the contrary I see inequality as a driver here. Working class people have become considerably more un-equal as a result of globalization and other policies, and a lot of that anger is boiling over.
- pmarreck 10y ago> People are not equal. And yet, the right would have you believe that my ignorance is just as good as your knowledge (RIP Asimov). Because you are just an elitist educated librul, and how can you even breathe the thought that you're better than me in any way, shape, or form, especially when it comes to making important decisions that demand critical evaluation of a lot of evidence? I have a family and mouths to feed and can only afford 1 i-Whatever for the whole family, I don't hang out on Twitter or Facebook and only have time to listen to catchy patriotic slogans. But hey, I sure as hell took the time to come out of the mysteriously dark woodwork and voted yesterday! I guess all that effort I made to keep an at-risk youth out of prison and get him into college was pointless.
- ryanx435 10y agoIts ignorant for you to assume that people on the right are ignorant and honestly the attitude of people like you were one of the driving forces of me supporting and voting for trump. Here I am, working as a software engineer, with a BS in computer science, fluent in multiple languages, able to criticaly evaluate evidence in order to make decisions, and just as educated as you are, and you automatically assume that just because I'm on the right I am ignorant. Its people like you that have poisoned the well of society.
- jernfrost 10y agoMaybe this could be a golden age for Europe and Canada. We can get all the intelligent people in the US fleeing to seek more intelligent shores. We could get some of the bright minds of Silicon valley to come across the pond and help revitalizing European tech industry. Not a new phenomenon. The German scientists fleeing Nazi Germany started the present American scientific lead. The French Hugenots fleeing France caused economic growth.
- Inthenameofmine 10y agoMaybe Canada, however, Europe is doing the same insanity to itself atm.
- dang 10y agoAll: to help your fellow users today, please log out unless you intend to comment, so we can serve you from cache. The considerable extra load is making our poor little Racket process groan. More explanation here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12911042 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12911042, and yes we have plans to fix this. If you comment, please take extra care to do so civilly and substantively, in the spirit of this site.
- myf01d 10y agoPosted via Internet Explorer 6
- akhilcacharya 10y agoI think we're seeing the start of a post-fact era.
- lintiness 10y agotoo bad he's a financial zero who can't do basic math.
- na85 10y agoDo us all a favor and go back to reddit where you'll fit right in with that sort of dialectic.
- pstuart 10y agoToo bad you can't do basic math either. America has spent/committed trillions of dollars on two wars that it has lost. That money got us nothing but more terrorists to be afraid of. If that money was invested in a sound "socialist" manner we wouldn't have the level of despair that would incite millions of citizens to vote for a candidate who promised to "blow up the system". https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/study-iraq-afghan-war-costs-to-top-4-trillion/2013/03/28/b82a5dce-97ed-11e2-814b-063623d80a60_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/study...
- goatlover 10y agoWhat do you mean by "lost"? You mean the nation building part? Because Afghanistan and Iraq didn't win those wars. The occupation and attempts at nation building are a different story.
- pstuart 10y agoLost, as in not securing these countries to "make them safe for America" or whatever bullshit spin the war-mongers want to put out there. Afghanistan is more unstable now that we've invaded. And the war in Iraq only created a fertile ground for Islamic State to rise from the ashes. Remember what Colin Powell said: "you break it, you bought it". We broke it and have utterly failed to repair the damage done. Back to you, goatlover, define "win" in these scenarios and tell me about the victories that have "won" these wars.
- 10y ago
- akiselev 10y agoMy entire family feels a terrible sadness today. We immigrated here to the United States from Russia almost 20 years ago (to the day) and after all the immigration bullshit we were finally eligible for citizenship this year. My dad took his oath and got his US passport literally weeks before the election and this is what he gets for his first vote: a divisive demagogue beat a corrupt career politician. There are no words to describe our disappointment, both at the choices and the result. For those that are unhappy with the results of this election, there is something you can do! I implore you to write, call, and otherwise pester your state legislators and your governors to pressure them to support the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact [1]. This is an interstate agreement approved by the Justice Department that activates when states with 270 or more electoral college votes sign it (by passing state legislation that implements the compact). When it activates, all of the states that signed it will, from that point on, allocate their votes for the presidential candidate that won the national popular vote, essentially destroying the electoral college. Already, the states that signed the compact have a total of 160 electoral college votes and legislation is in the works for Michigan and Pennsylvania, which would bring the total to over 180. Already a third of all electoral votes are part of this compact! Take it from someone who has spent two decades on the sideline: you are not powerless. So few people make their voices heard that every voice counts when you're one of 50 or 100 state senators representing a state of a few million. With Trump's divisiveness front and center this is it. For the first time since the Voting Rights Act we have a chance to fundamentally change American democracy and we can do so in a way that cannot be obstructed by conservative states or dismantled by conservative Supreme Court justices. Even if you are happy with the results of this election, I beg you to support the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact. It's time we started to reform our electoral system and restore some of the legitimacy it has lost in the last few decades. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Popular_Vote_Interstate_Compact https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Popular_Vote_Inters...
- tcoppi 10y agoI'm so sorry. Maybe you can use your unique perspective to shine a light on how backwards Trump's support of Putin and Putinesque policies is.
- cdelsolar 10y agolol, go back about 8 years and try to picture reading this headline.
- andyjohnson0 10y agoTwo questions from a non-USian: 1. Can Trump deliver the results expected by the people who voted for him? 2. If he can't, what happens then? In particular, what kind of leader comes after him?
- pasquinelli 10y agothat's what's great: they don't expect anything from him.
- edko 10y agoI doubt that, by consistently saying the same thing, anyone can be right for 24 years. The world changes; what is right 24 years ago may not be right today, and vice versa.
- mattnewton 10y agoEqual rights for people regardless of race, creed or gender identity is going to be right for a hell of a lot longer than 24 years. The reality of class struggle is going to be right for a lot longer than 24 years.
- edko 10y ago"Equal rights for people regardless of race, creed or gender identity" is not a Bernie exclusive. You do not win elections by being right (if you need proof, look at current events). Sometimes, being too absolutely right, and not in sync with the times, makes you lose elections to someone who is very wrong. That is what I mean by saying that you cannot be consistently right for 24 years: the timing of your message also has to be right.
- mattnewton 10y agoRight - Hillary had the first part, but not the class struggle, which turned out to be more important this election. The fact that he had been saying it for 24 years too made it more credible, another issue Hillary suffered with this election.
- edko 10y agoIt is very ironic you mention class struggle. You belong to the class of HN users who have the right to down-vote comments. I do not. You use your class' prerogative to down-vote my comments, in an attempt to censor my thoughts. Not because they are inappropriate, but merely because you disagree with them. Talk about class struggle!
- 10y ago
- dmode 10y agoA minority of Americans (note that Clinton is winning the popular vote) have too much power over the world. A Bush presidency destroyed the world, because people wanted to have beer with him. A Trump presidency will even do further damage because people "hated the establishment"
- pasquinelli 10y agoand i suspect that they hated the establishment simply as a way of having a strong opinion without actually knowing anything about what's going on.
- coding123 10y agoAll I can say is I wish we elected Romney 4 years ago.
- antithesis 10y agoI'm curious as to how instrumental automation and illegitimate poll voting have been in producing this result. I'm talking about things like pro-Trump Twitter bots[1], 4chan's /pol/ board mass-voting Trump in online polls, and automated thread voting to keep /r/The_Donald at the top of the trending subreddit list on Reddit. Does anyone have an idea? 1. A third of pro-Trump Twitter activity turned out to be automated. See: http://money.cnn.com/2016/10/18/technology/twitter-bots-donald-trump-hillary-clinton/ http://money.cnn.com/2016/10/18/technology/twitter-bots-dona...
- daodedickinson 10y agoIt's pretty interesting that Sam Altman wanted to stop Trump but YCombinator's Reddit was so instrumental in his victory, despite the opposition of it's employees. Facebook and Twitter helped Trump, too, despite Trump probably have sub-10% support among Facebook and Twitter employees. Google's SEME didn't seem to help as much as I thought it would. This will become more and more debated FAST now that Germany is beginning legal action against Facebook for helping promote political speech that Merkel and her allies have tried to keep from flaring up.
- bcit-cst 10y agoI am still not sure what are Donald Trumps foreign policy positions are . 1) ON Syria/ISIS . All he as said is that he will hit them very very hard. okay going from that , does it mean a) he plans on putting 100K US troop on the ground and engage in an all-out war. b) or just put 100's of drones in the Air and just start bombing shit. How does he plan on bringing on board our Allies like Jordan and Iraqi government on our side with this plan? 2) What is his plan regarding South China Sea. Does he plan on confronting the Chinese government . From what I have heard he wants to bring back troops from South Korea and Japan. 3) What are his plans for Ukraine civil war and Russian Aggression? 4) Finally, I am trying to imagine what would Trump do if he was the president during the Cuban missile crisis. Would he be able to enforce the blockade? Does he understand the the MAD doctrine ? so many questions .
- ryanx435 10y agodo YOU understand the MAD doctrine? it only works if your enemy believes that you will use nuclear weapons. If they don't think you will use nukes, than the threat of mutually assured destruction isn't a real threat, so MAD doesn't work. purely in terms of MAD, it is actually good that everyone thinks that trump is eager to launch the nukes.
- greenshackle2 10y agoHe doesn't seem to understand NATO though. He made every security expert shit their pants by stating he wouldn't necessarily defend NATO countries. It makes me question his understanding of the strategic value of unconditional retaliation, which underpins MAD. (Alternatively, he understands, but doesn't care if Europe gets stomped by Russia.)
- ryanx435 10y agoHe negotiated a better deal. The majority of countries that were not contributing to NATO in accordance with the treaty are now doing so. He very clearly explained his thought process for this type of thing in the Art of the deal. To paraphrase, he started with an extreme position (disbanding NATO) so that he can meet the other party somewhere in the middle (they pay their fair share and do their part militarily). Overall it would seem he was very successful with this.
- rconti 10y agoI guess we'll all just have to take our huge tax cuts and go home. I was willing to vote against my own economic best interest, but now that the election is decided, I want to at least get something out of the deal.
- Shivetya 10y agoThe media and many people need to ask, why were the Republicans mocked for having seventeen contenders and no one made hay out of the fact that Democrats only had three
- zigzigzag 10y agoThe stat that explains the election for me is 92% for Hillary in Washington DC. Bear in mind that most US law is made by regulators, not Congress, and regulators live in Washington DC. Angry Republicans who feel it's "us vs the elite" and "nothing ever changes" are completely correct. If Trump wants to address the anger his voters feel for real, there's going to have to be a truly epic bonfire of regulators and regulation.
- baristaGeek 10y agoJust in case anyone is wondering the same thing as I last night: The USCIS administrative act for the International Entrepreneur Rule (Startup Visa) won't be affected. First, because it's being passed as an administrative action, meaning that it doesn't have to be voted in congress in order for it to start taking an effect. Second, because it's actually aligned with Donald Trump's 3rd immigration policy driver (the first two have nothing to do with foreign-born entrepreneurs): 3. A nation that does not serve its own citizens is not a nation. Any immigration plan must improve jobs, wages and security for all Americans. What Trump does believe is that the H1B1 is depressing salaries thus decreasing job opportunities for american citizens. Therefore, if you have a startup and want to move it to the US you will have a better pathway. However, if you want to work as an employee in America, you'll have an even harder time.
- new_user_name 10y agoDo you have any news items or anything that I can read up? I am very hopeful of this new rule and thinking to bring our startup to US
- nickbauman 10y agoI think we learned that fake news (used to pump up fake issues) is now a legitimate campaign strategy that works even on people who should know better. Trump won on a mountain of fake issues: Immigration: both conservative and liberal economists agree that immigration (illegal or otherwise) does not suppress wages and does not suppress job growth. https://www.cato.org/research/immigration https://www.cato.org/research/immigration http://business.time.com/2013/01/30/the-economics-of-immigration-who-wins-who-loses-and-why/ http://business.time.com/2013/01/30/the-economics-of-immigra... Terrorism: more toddlers killed Americans than terrorists in 2015. For every terrorist killing someone on US soil, more than 4000 Americans killed each other. http://www.snopes.com/toddlers-killed-americans-terrorists/ http://www.snopes.com/toddlers-killed-americans-terrorists/ http://tinyurl.com/q3fqk69 http://tinyurl.com/q3fqk69 Gay marriage: All it does is extend the same legal protections to people of the same sex that was already available to people of opposite sex. It doesn't take away any rights from anybody. Who is using the bathroom: Historically virtually no jurisdictions have had laws in place to prevent men from entering ladies rooms or vice versa. There have been male registered sex offenders entering the bathroom with yours sons since time immemorial. Transgendered people are no more likely to be sex offenders than the general population. Obamacare: While the program has its problems, the Trump administration will do nothing to address them and has said it will double-down on aspects that will make our health care system worse. I could go on but this is plenty. Welcome to the post-factual political America.
- vsl 10y agoFunny, I'd think the lesson is that near-total mainstream propaganda actually generates pushback. See also: Britain, Germany (where press in universally suppresses and labels any opposition as "neofascist"). Also consider the possibility that many people voted not for Trump, but against Clinton and her fake issues (like the discredited wage gap myth).
- erikpukinskis 10y agoThe wage gap hasn't been discredited. Science shows it is there. Much of the variance is unexplained. And some of the "explanations" of variance that has been accounted for are themselves sexist. If job titles women tend to have get paid less than job titles men tend to have, that means we value women's work less than men's. Your assumption is that work must be worth objectively less, but the only proof we have for that is "the market said so" which I find unconvincing.
- birdmanjeremy 10y agoAny insight into potential impacts on the tech industry?
- crivabene 10y agoI believe what is hard to understand for us living outside of the US is how is it possible that the person who is declared President is not the candidate that the majority of people voted to be President. I tried to explain to my peers how the US election system works multiple times but I mostly got back puzzled faces and disbelief.
- snarf21 10y agoPart of the problem is how physically big the US is compared to most countries. Popular vote only would mean that cities (even a small set of them) would hold such a large percentage of the vote that the farmers and workers who drive the engines of agriculture and manufacturing could have almost no voice. Additionally, when this was all created, each state just wanted to govern themselves and they needed a compromise for what the federal government would be. So, instead each state was (and is) given a relatively proportional number of "special" votes to cast for President based on population. These have caps though so small, rural states get a little more power than they otherwise would (2 for Idaho instead of probably 0 e.g.) and super large ones get a little less. (This is not that dissimilar to how our Congress is set up). Additionally, each state is given the ability to decide how to vote for president. A state could say that the Governor just picks one or have an in-state vote that is a popular vote within that state (how most work) or anything they want.
- api 10y agoIf you want to know why Trump won: https://morecrows.wordpress.com/2016/05/10/unnecessariat/ https://morecrows.wordpress.com/2016/05/10/unnecessariat/
- jliptzin 10y agoEveryone seems to be talking about what a strong repudiation this is of the Obama, Clinton, and liberalism in general, but at the time of this writing Clinton is actually ahead in the popular vote by a 200,000+ vote margin and it looks like she'll maintain the lead. Yes this was far closer than many expected, but Trump's victory is largely an anomaly of a system that heavily favors rural, geographically distributed voters. So I'd be careful to take this as a signal that America has been suddenly overtaken by a surge of populism and anti-minority sentiment.
- irrational 10y agoMaybe after this we can get rid of the electoral college and move to popular vote? That's a joke of course. Politicians would never vote it through.
- tcoppi 10y agoYou don't need (federal-level) politicians to change this! The constitution is a wonderful thing. There is a process for amending it that bypasses Washington completely. Maybe we should put it on the table.
- throw7 10y agoThis sucks. Web forums are the worst way to curate/understand/participate in a dialogue... especially something like this topic. All I see is a wall of text where supposedly "the good stuff" floats to the top by magic. sigh
- sparky_ 10y agoI hope both parties learn something form this result. Establishment Republicans and the DNC alike have had their asses handed to them handily. I suspect the Democrats will need to move more towards the progressive wing to be competitive in the future. Someone like Warren may be able to straddle the fine line of capturing Bernie enthusiasm without isolating more center leaning democrats.
- davidw 10y agoMy optimistic take: he's probably going to be a Berlusconi. Generally bad for the economy, bad for freedom, but probably won't carry through on the worst of his bad ideas. I think there's a small chance he'll be more of a Mussolini. The obvious thing to look for there is if he starts trying to carry out the threat to deport illegal immigrants, which would require door to door searches, "papers please" and that kind of thing. There are also some serious geopolitical things that could go real wrong real quick: if I were in one of the Baltic states this morning, I would be doing some serious thinking about defense.
- tcoppi 10y agoThat an American Berlusconi is an optimistic take is incredibly dark.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- pg314 10y agoI had exactly the same idea: somewhere between Berlusconi and Mussolini. However, I don't think he is nearly as intelligent as either, so I don't think he will last more than 4 years. I agree on the Baltic states. Also, if you're in Aleppo, may god have mercy on your soul. And Europe should prepare for more refugees and destabilisation (exactly what Putin wants). It's not going to be a pretty next 4 years...
- tcoppi 10y agoPrepare for the worst, hope for the best...
- guhcampos 10y agoDisclaimer: I'm a Brazilian living in Brazil, so merely a watcher in the US Election. On times like these, I try very hard to be optimistic, and for this specific historical moment I'd say the US is in a better place than Brazil - relatively speaking. While Brazil has just gone through a major soft-coup, that has the majority of the nation, guided by media attention, agreeing with it. For the US election, however, there's a bright side: the actual majority of the American people (even if for a thing margin) has voted for Hillary Clinton, or at least voted against Trump. It really does not matter if you support one or the other, the sad fact is that, once again, the US will have a president who was not chosen by the majority of its people. This has significant social and philosophical implications. Maybe, just maybe, this election will be the one that drives change, encouraging states to change their laws and provide a better representative system. I'm not saying that direct representation is better - I'm not entitled to say that - but there's a very obvious dissatisfaction among the younger American people, which are now in position, and willing, to demand changes and come up with creative solutions for the representative democracy.
- homulilly 10y agoPeople are saying this is about race and while I do think that's a big part of it, making it the whole story is dangerously counterproductive. The Clinton camp basically offered nothing to working class people. Working class people of color turned out to vote for her because at least she wasn't spouting racist rhetoric but for working class whites who aren't concerned with race issues, if they're going to be equally neglected under either candidate, they may as well vote for the one who will be a brick through the window of the political establishment that has failed them. These are the voters who cost Clinton the election.
- wodencafe 10y agoThis is not technology news.
- rukittenme 10y agoI unapologetically voted for DJT. My issues are listed from the most to least important (whether they are logical or not). - I didn't want to intervene in Syria and wanted peace with Russia over Crimea. - The multiple FBI investigations into Clinton gave an air of illegitimacy. - Ethics reform. - Repeal of ACA. - Lower corp tax rate and more lenient corporate tax laws. - Lower income tax rate (would be nice) - Tighter restrictions on H1B visas. - The wall. - An audit of the federal reserve.
- davidf18 10y agoTypically, Democrats have been closer to supporting the working class and the Republicans have been closer to Wall Street. Clinton ignored the suffering of the working class calling many of them a "basket of deplorables". Instead, she would take $675,000 for 3 talks to Goldman after many Americans had suffered from the housing crisis. These "deplorables" as Clinton would call them helped to win Trump the election. Sanders had 85% of the youth vote but instead of changing her policies to reflect Sanders she criticized Sanders. Even after BrExit, which reflected the suffering of working class in Britain, Clinton still did not understand and have sympathy for the working class. So, the working class, "the deplorables" voted for Trump.
- Animats 10y agoTrump's likely cabinet selections are in the press.[1] Treasury - probably Steven Mnuchin, another Goldman Sachs guy. Trump may not be as anti Wall Street as he said he was. State - Bob Corker (Senate foreign relations chair) or Newt Gingrich. Both are long-time Washington insiders. Defense - about four candidates, mostly long-time Washington insiders. Attorney General - Rudy Guilani, probably. As a prosecutor, he took down the New York Mafia, so he's qualified for the job. Old, white, Republican insiders, all of them. Mnuchin is the only one below retirement age. [1] http://www.politico.com/story/2016/11/who-is-in-president-trump-cabinet-231071 http://www.politico.com/story/2016/11/who-is-in-president-tr...
- toss1941 10y agoWhy don't we wait and see? So little of what Politico or the MSM has said about Trump so far has been correct.
- dopamean 10y agoRudy Giuliani gets way, way too much credit for the decrease in crime in NYC during his term in office. If he's really going to go after big crime (corporate things, drug cartels, etc) then I might be able to stomach him as Attorney General. But if he want's to encourage stop and frisk type bullshit on a national level (I'm not even sure he can do that) I would be very, very worried.
- ZeroGravitas 10y agoOn the bright side, does this mean the election wasn't rigged? What will Alex Jones think now that Trump is in power? Will there be no more school shootings because Obama/Hillary and the federal government are no longer trying to take our guns away? Will ISIS no longer attack the US because Trump is being "tough" on them and the president is no longer refusing to say the words "radical islamic terrorism"? So many intriguing questions posed by the victory of someone who, by many appearences, was happy to lose but rile up a big audience along the way.
- devopsproject 10y ago> What will Alex Jones think now that Trump is in power Alex Jones needs clicks and pageviews so it will be more of the same > Will there be no more school shootings because Obama/Hillary and the federal government are no longer trying to take our guns away? it will be because of democrats in the senate or house, or at the state or local level. Plenty of scapegoats to go around > Will ISIS no longer attack the US because Trump is being "tough" on them and the president is no longer refusing to say the words "radical islamic terrorism"? it will still be their fault for letting isis happen in the first place > So many intriguing questions Maybe for people who are new to politics. The same script will repeat in 8-16 years
- readhn 10y agoThe fact is Hillary is part of the corrupt machine, part of the problem. And Trump is ego centric lunatic who can not be trusted with our kids future. America should have voted against all of them and ask for better candidates. But that would never happen.
- xorxornop 10y agoMany here will recognise the formative childhood experience of having done something forbidden and getting caught doing it by their parents where, for the first time, instead of the usual response - their getting angry - you are taken completely by surprise when they simply say "I am so disappointed in you" or similar, accompanied by some expression in the realm of abject futility. This is one of those. That this could have had any realistic chance of happening at all says a lot about the current state of the US populace. I find reading any political news out of the US to be particularly distressing: the extent of the echo chamber effect is very prominent and highly persistent. Admittedly, this is part of a more general phenomenon with regard to news today, given that people can construct their own echo chambers much more readily than in any other time of history - but it seems considerably worse in the US. I'm not quite sure why. Perhaps because the FPTP political system encourages game-theoretic strategies which unfortunately effectively optimise for polarisation and related properties..?
- TheGrassyKnoll 10y agohttp://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/03/technology/how-the-internet-is-loosening-our-grip-on-the-truth.html http://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/03/technology/how-the-interne...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- foob 10y agoOne of the most notable things about this election has been how strongly disliked the two main candidates were. They famously have the lowest favorability ratings of any candidates in recent history. Putting aside any corruption and favoritism from within the parties for a minute, it seems like the primary system really sets the parties up to elect poor general election candidates. For example, take a look at the states where Clinton performed best in the primaries. They're Mississippi, Alabama, South Carolina, Georgia, Louisiana, Arkansas, and Texas. All of these states were decisive victories for Trump in the general election and from a perspective purely of wanting to win, it doesn't make sense for them to be so important in the primaries. At the same time, Bernie won a number of states in the primary that ended up being important swing states (e.g Michigan, Wisconsin, New Hampshire, Maine, Minnesota, Colorado). From a strategic standpoint, it would seem to make sense to attach a higher weigh to those victories (the same is also true for Florida, Ohio, and some other states where he lost). None of this necessarily means that Bernie would have won, I just think that it seems as though the primary process is not very well designed for choosing the best general election candidates. This is even more true if you consider what a large proportion of states have closed primaries that specifically exclude independents. It seems obvious that they will be far less likely to vote along party lines in a general election but, in many states, they're given no say in the primary process. I can understand why the DNC can't just say, "sorry, but the deep south doesn't count and neither does New York or California," but opening up the primaries seems like a perfectly reasonable strategy to put forward stronger general election candidates. I don't really have a broader point beyond that, it just seems like the parties really set themselves up to produce such, to put it gently, sub-optimal candidates.
- enlightenedfool 10y agoIt's French Revolution redux just waiting to happen. And it did. People voted Obama as a relative outsider to bring change. He failed and became the insider. People doubled down this time and got a complete outsider.
- maxerickson 10y agoPeople doubled down this time and got a complete outsider. People that believe this is what happened are going to be disappointed. We'll know real soon anyway, based on the hiring that his transition team does (they are a bunch of political insiders).
- yourapostasy 10y agoThe Trump administration and the Republican-dominated legislature probably has two years to show results consistent with an outsider persona, and if they don't deliver, other parties will probably get a good shot at breaking the Republican domination of Congress in the midterms. It's a pretty tall order, as most of the electorate do not understand how slowly the gears of government grind, but it seems to be the pattern in history.
- happy-go-lucky 10y agoHe was trying to win. She was trying to stop him. That's all she did.
- ilostmykeys 10y agoFound this and it gave articulation to my thoughts, with intentional misspellings by the author... "amerikka and its capitalist empire is an illegitimate system and therefore i choose to not give it much of my energy but i do have some thoughts to offer. Trump taking power is not a change, but an unveiling of what has always been: that this country is founded and held through the control and consciousness of rich psychotic white male rapists, exploiters and oppressors of Black and Brown indigenous bodies in the name of money, which they hoard for themselves. These patriarchs created white supremacy which simultaneously created amerikkka and its empire that runs and terrorizes the world. and at this point these politricks dont even have to be white men to enact/enforce this consciousness, because it has been institutionalized. you can be a womxn, a poc, it doesn't matter when you up in the white house because this blood money rules every thing around us. its so fitting for a capitalist rather than a 'politician' to become president because they all ride for each other. the anxiety and fear around the fascism and xenophobia that trump is pushing is real, but its no different than what Obama was doing, where pigs continue to murder Black and Brown men, womxn and children with no consequences, where we have seen more deportations than ever in history. or killary wih her fascist white feminism overseeing coups and murdering and dropping bombs on womxn of color all in the the name of democracy. the difference now is that everything is all out in the open. the fascism isnt being disguised by liberal rhetoric of 'democracy' and 'freedom' because there aint never been true justice in amerikkka. what should concern us is the violence and fascism Trump inspires in the ignorant racist white populations of this country. but that only means we need to get organized, we need to free ourselves of the idea that we need to be governed, that we need a president or politician to save us, we need to free ourselves from integration because this shit was not built for us, we need to ground and trust our magic, and cast spells and visions of liberation, because real democracy is self determination. and the struggle continues."
- hypertexthero 10y agoThe U.S. needs to implement a Basic Income. http://www.scottsantens.com/basic-income-faq http://www.scottsantens.com/basic-income-faq
- geigera 10y agoI know, isn't it grand?
- serge2k 10y agoSo I've only been alive long enough to remember 5 presidential elections in detail. 2/5 the electoral college has disagreed with the popular vote. Previously it resulted (after court decision) in the election of Bush, widely seen as one of the worst presidents ever. Second time is Trump, who is at best unqualified. Why is this system still in use? What are the benefits of the electoral college? Other than disagreeing with the popular vote at times, doesn't it also discourage voting since a vote in california is worthless next to one from florida?
- tcoppi 10y agoFirst 100 days plan posted, you can see, concretely, what he hopes to accomplish: https://assets.donaldjtrump.com/_landings/contract/O-TRU-102316-Contractv02.pdf https://assets.donaldjtrump.com/_landings/contract/O-TRU-102...
- rak00n 10y ago"A requirement that for every new federal regulation, two existing regulations must be eliminated." This makes me sad.
- nemo44x 10y agoMight be a good time to take a short out on AMZN. Trump promised they will be investigated for antitrust.
- SSLy 10y agoI'm gonna help by flagging this thread.
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoAs of this writing, this post has exactly 666 upvotes. I screenshot it.
- Exuma 10y agoThis has created a very large divide which is very interesting to watch unfold... how certain groups are so off the mark as to the cause, and to watch both groups react. Never thought I'd see something like this.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- eruditely 10y agoPeople are pretending that only rural whites voted for them, when the category for white includes Pashtuns, Persians, and other Iranians , and I'm almost certain a majority of Sikhs voted for Trump like I did. Thank god, this was nothing if not a complete rejection of he politics of New England.
- spenvo 10y agorandom thoughts tech: the kinds of tech challenges we'll be facing in the next 8 years are extraordinary - cyberwarfare, advanced AI, self-driving cars, brittle state of internet/device security, designer babies via genetic engineering. i'm worried about the general lack of competency of the exec branch in navigating through them. thanks to the past 16 years, surveillance state powers are far beyond any in history. the supreme court had some good decisions re privacy in the last few years, wouldn't count on that moving forward b/c scalia was pretty reasonable. goodwill from silicon valley will drop off precipitously. revolving door from google, Facebook to government will stop (pros and cons there, but mostly cons) election stuff: during this election there's been a flare up in racial tensions, a safe space for the alt-right, etc but HRC lost states Obama won -- the disparity was huge between elections. so, yes racism played a role (and set up the worst Republican candidate winning the thing), but in the general election it was only one of many many factors, and maybe more of a side effect rather than a cause of the result. DNC will probably be scared about pitching husband/wife combos or dynasties moving forward, minor knocks against Chelsea, Michelle Elizabeth Warren has a strong path moving forward. silver lining to all of this is the Democratic party has a chance to reform itself. demographic trends are favoring Democrats in future elections
- Pulce 10y agoLeslie Nielsen with an hidden script. Welcome on the stage.
- Animats 10y agoWhat can Silicon Valley do to make America great again? - There will be higher tariffs for China imports. The US needs to make more of its own stuff. Start planning on moving manufacturing to the US for sales in the US. Don't use Shentzen as much. Plan on exporting to China, and expect some help from the Government if China's government gives you problems. The US needs to get its imports and exports balanced. - The wall will be built. It will need sensors. The IoT crowd needs to develop better sensors than the overpriced crappy ones from the last attempt in that direction. - Better detection of illegal aliens is necessary. One of the biggest source of illegal immigrants is visa overstayers. For those, pictures are available from when they entered the US. Social media must be searched for them. Surveillance cameras need to be connected to cloud systems which recognize them. Police cars need very high definition cameras and face recognition to find those people so they can be deported. Deep learning systems will be needed to decide if a likely face match is worth investigation. With good automation, people will only be hassled once. Then they're either known as legal or on their way to deportation. - E-Verify, the online system for verifying eligibility to work in the US, needs to be made available as a mobile app for employers. Pictures of documents, faces, and fingerprints should be used rather than typing in info. It should be possible to onboard a new hire in less than a minute. - The immigration system is too paper-oriented and too slow. It needs to be online and fast. This will speed up deportations. - Labor-intensive operations in farming need to be automated. The technology exists for automated picking of most fruits and vegetables, but the demo-level hardware is too slow, too expensive, and too fragile. That gear needs to be brought up to production level. Look for financing for farmers from the Department of Agriculture. This will reduce demand for low-paid illegals. - Commercial cleaning needs to be automated. The Roomba was just the first step. There's still no good commercial-grade floor cleaning robot. The janitor industry is ready for a major downsizing. There are opportunities here waiting to be seized. Get busy!
- tdb7893 10y agoI can't tell whether this is sarcastic or not. Either way the focus on illegal immigration is disconcerting.
- knowaveragejoe 10y agoI don't get why you think some of these are essential to "make America great again"(as if you could actually reasonably quantify why it stopped being great). - The wall will be built. It will need sensors. The IoT crowd needs to develop better sensors than the overpriced crappy ones from the last attempt in that direction. My understanding is that the proposal is untenable for a variety of reasons, so we probably won't see "the wall", but maybe some additional walls in some places. - Better detection of illegal aliens is necessary. One of the biggest source of illegal immigrants is visa overstayers. For those, pictures are available from when they entered the US. Social media must be searched for them. Surveillance cameras need to be connected to cloud systems which recognize them. Police cars need very high definition cameras and face recognition to find those people so they can be deported. Deep learning systems will be needed to decide if a likely face match is worth investigation. With good automation, people will only be hassled once. Then they're either known as legal or on their way to deportation. How does this concept not terrify you? Why do we need to go further in this direction? It sounds rational as far as achieving the goal. But the implications of spurring this development are immense. I don't get why you would willing move towards such a pervasive police state.
- kelvin0 10y agoWell this would be scary if modern Presidents were the ones actually running things. They are part of a system which has more power over them than the other way around. Before down voting me, please take the time to reply instead, I would prefer your written feedback.
- Kazamai 10y agoI see a lot of comment saying "the USA cannot do this x,y,z because we don't have oil money to back it". USA is in the top three oil producers now at 10 million barrels a day. Yes even that won't cover the total cost for free health care or free education, but that is still a huge amount of money. More importantly, the amount of money the US government has wasted could have paid for the above. Trillions of dollars have been burned on Quantitative Easing and other ridiculous stimulus. And the result was over capacity in oil production and debt that can never be repaid. Instead of hundreds of billions burned, the US government could have given every unemployed individual a whole new education.
- olivercreashe 10y agoWe're all fucked now!!
- Houshalter 10y agoI'm not a conspiracy theorist at all. But HN has story after story about how vulnerable voting machines are: https://hn.algolia.com/?utm_source=opensearch&utm_medium=search&utm_campaign=opensearch&query=voting%20machines&sort=byPopularity&prefix&page=0&dateRange=all&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?utm_source=opensearch&utm_medium=sea... The more I look into the issue the more horrified I am. One place had voting machines that ran windows XP and sent votes over wifi, and were hacked with a default administrator password. This computerphile video goes into a number of problems with the concept: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w3_0x6oaDmI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w3_0x6oaDmI The fact that the polls were off by such a huge amount is concerning to me. States that weren't supposed to be even close somehow ended up going for Trump. It's known that Russia supported Donald Trump's campaign and had targeted voting systems, which is terrifying. Overall the election seems to be very close in terms of popular vote, and many swing states were won by very small margins or just a few counties. A small amount of fraud targeted in just the right places could perhaps have changed the outcome. How concerned should I be about this? The fact that the election wasn't close in terms of electoral votes is comforting (if you are rigging an election, it's best to try not to overdo it and draw suspicion.) It would be nice to know that results are consistent across states and counties that use different kinds of voting machines or paper ballots. I don't know if that has been tested yet.