32 ms·
Most drivers who own cars with built-in GPS systems use phones for directions
- nojvek 10y agoToyota gps is just garbage. Hangs all the time. I strongly believe car makers just don't see software as a critical component. Exception is tesla.
- RealityVoid 10y agoI build car dashboard software. You are right. The SW is shit. Exceptions, from what i've head are Volvo and Daimler. Don't know the kind of resources Tesla puts into their SW and am not sure if it's not just hype.
- mikey_p 10y agoI'll second Volvo, we bought a used 2003 XC-90 several years ago and the Nav in it was great. Even with the 10 year old discs it found 95% of what we needed by name or waypoint and the interface was incredibly easy to navigate while driving. I chalk that up to the fact that it's _not_ a touchscreen, which means you can build muscle memory and menus were super predictably.
- tthayer 10y agoThe car manufacturers just contract it out to companies like Johnson Controls, who make the system in my Mazda. It's running embedded linux and the interface is a bunch of javascript files. One of the bigger problems I see with this system is that Johnson Controls just doesn't give a shit about maintaining an old system unless a safety issue is presented. They're better off selling improved systems for use in newer model cars as a sales tactic. Android Auto/Apple carplay pretty much remove the ALWAYSBEIMPROVING component. Johnson Controls could pretty much just sell the same head unit/LCD combo for the next 10 years and no one would notice.
- kelvie 10y agoEven in the Model S, I use my phone's directions. Tesla's map app is great, and the UI is _really_ good (even better in the latest update!), but their source for navigation is garbage (and also their routing algorithm). I hear it's cause whatever they use works offline, but also because Google wants them to send back real time data, but Tesla doesn't want to (forgot where I heard this though). I would much much prefer to use the Tesla UI for nav, but the directions are really that bad.
- bjelkeman-again 10y agoI wouldn't call it garbage, but maybe my area is better mapped.
- RankingMember 10y agoIt never made sense to me why you'd want to have a built-in GPS these days when modular devices are available that are A. generally better-designed and B. replaceable. People buying used cars in the coming years will be stuck with these big-screened dinosaurs in their dash that are essentially wasted space.
- masklinn 10y agoThe big screens and not-required data connections are convenient. There are also local oddities to GPS e.g. in Japan GPS are keyed on landlines and mapcodes (proprietary GPS-ish codes) not addresses. OTOH the interfaces of built-in navs &al tend to be unmitigated disasters. At the end of the day, phone integration (Android's Auto and Apple's CarPlay) are probably what you want.
- beachstartup 10y agoalthough i don't use it for directions, i use the digital map every time i drive. i drive a higher end car which has two maps, one in the center console and one in the instrument pod. i set the the instrument pod to show a top-down zoomed in dynamic heading version and the console map shows a bird's eye zoomed out fixed north version. very useful. also satellite radio and weather/traffic is useful. if i want directions my phone will play them audibly over bluetooth while i look at my dash map (it's the same map!) i think any car with bluetooth and a halfway decent regular map will be useful for years to come. my parents have a 10 year old car with a map that's still useful for basic nav.
- jbob2000 10y agoMy car has voice-control, so I press a button on the steering wheel, speak my destination, and I'm good to go. It works really well. I can't do this easily on a smartphone while I'm driving. The "big-screen dinosaur" is incredibly helpful for showing routes and directions, much better than the dinky smartphone screen.
- lallysingh 10y agoThis depends on your car model. Many (like mine) have horrible voice control systems.
- vermontdevil 10y agoHave you seen the UI on some of these built-ins? Awful.
- celticninja 10y agoMy maps app on my phone gets much more frequent updates than the maps fucntion in my car. Saying that I do use my in car nav system, I just rely on googlemaps for traffic data and redirections,
- jameskilton 10y agoVolkswagen wants to charge me ~$250 for an update to my in-car GPS. Yeah, no. My phone's GPS is free (effectively) and constantly up-to-date.
- swiley 10y agoOSM is free too, it's strange that they don't just let you upload maps yourself.
- gwbas1c 10y agoI got so frustrated with horrible GPS systems that I just bought a Sony car stereo that has a phone holder on it: http://www.androidpolice.com/2014/05/25/sonys-xspn1bt-double-din-smartphone-car-stereo-phone-mount-is-available-on-amazon-and-crutchfield-for-250/ http://www.androidpolice.com/2014/05/25/sonys-xspn1bt-double...
- agumonkey 10y agoThat's a glimpse of the future. Most interfaces are useless nowadays.
- diegorbaquero 10y agoIt simply makes no sense to use in-car GPS. Updates are free (some car markers charge them) and fast for mobile apps. There's a little tradeoff (privacy) though.
- jmcdiesel 10y agoBad UI, quickly out-of-date data, required trip to dealer to update said data, and lack of traffic awareness makes them just useless compared to something like Waze.
- Bartweiss 10y agoLast time I used a car GPS, it told me I was in for a 20 hour drive across the northern midwest. Google Maps helpfully turned that into 4 hours, by recognizing the major highway missing from the car system. A highway, I should add, at least ten years older than the car. The struggle for Waze is keeping their traffic data up to the minute, the struggle for cars is keeping their roadmaps on par with a decade-old atlas.
- jmcdiesel 10y agoWaze continually gets me to work through back roads and side streets in 20 min, a trip that in traffic on the "normal" routes takes roughly an hour... Maybe one day cars will have GPS on that level built in... but for now... nope
- stillworks 10y agoIf everybody has that kind of intelligent routing, then any advantage of that kind of intelligent routing will stop being an advantage.
- massysett 10y agoIn the DC area enough people have this kind of intelligent routing that Waze seldom saves me much time. And not all of it is intelligent, Waze-style routing; a lot of it is just that people know shortcuts. Even when it claims to have time savings at the beginning, usually it eliminates those time savings from its estimate as I actually drive. Sometimes Waze gets a shortcut for me that actually saves maybe three or four minutes...but at the expense of driving down dangerous roads and making numerous turns. Typically it's not even worth it. About the only time Waze is worth it is when there is an extraordinary event, such as a very bad wreck or a closed road. In those circumstances rerouting can save time. At least Waze is up to date. Apple sometimes gives me impossible routes (e.g. illegal turns) and has some street and highway names that have been out-of-date for at least six months. Google on the other hand has an infuriating way of asking me to confirm reroutes that supposedly save me time, and giving me only a few seconds to do it. But Waze has a muddy, horrible interface. All these services have flaws.
- jasode 10y agoAnother reason not mentioned by the article is map updates. Lexus charges $169+ to update the map data and requires a dealer appointment. A smartphone with google/Apple maps is always more up-to-date. If you're buying a new car today, the reason to get navigation is for the LCD screen and not for the GPS. The LCD is used to see the rear view camera image for parking. Also, playing music shows the song titles.
- cesis 10y agoI would love a rear-view camera that could display on my phone
- Overtonwindow 10y agoGive that to the kids and it will entertain them for hours. By hours I mean fifteen minutes.
- strictnein 10y agoI just wish I could have my rear-view camera on while I was driving forward.
- dsfyu404ed 10y agoIt would be nice for a lot of reasons but I think over all the net damage from the distraction would be more than the damage saved by people realizing they forgot to pin the trailer coupler and similar stuff. You don't have many reasons to see that field of view at speed since pretty much every reverse camera basically points down.
- Retric 10y agoRear view mirrors are useful while going forward. But, it's fairly easy to block that line of sight in a full car, thus making the rear view camera a useful backup.
- tw04 10y ago
- SteveNuts 10y agoI have to update my car GPS using an SD card. It's just too inconvenient when I can just use my phone
- maccard 10y agoI had to buy a CD for my parent's car for £170 to update their in car navigation.
- agumonkey 10y agoTaxi in-car GPS was faulty so often the dude resorted to smartphone fallback. When Google Maps owns you, you have a problem.
- jrgoj 10y agoAs much as the size, placement, and car integration of my vehicle's (2016 CX-5) dash GPS is ideal, the fact that it cannot display Waze renders it mostly useless for my everyday commuting. Until I can do so via Carplay or Android Auto, I'll be using gaudy cell phone mounts.
- antisthenes 10y agoBuilt-in car systems are usually at least 5 years behind the current tech, whether it was CD players, a USB port or whatever GPS system they started putting in. As an example - I have a car with a USB port, but the music player interface is so atrocious and is missing key features that it's actually worse than my Sansa Clip from 2008. The car is a 2012 model.
- drivingmenuts 10y agoI'd be perfectly happy if my car just had a dock for my iPhone, with an amp for the speakers. I use my phone for anything music, gps or phone-related while driving. The only time I don't use it is when I can't get the friggin' bluetooth to connect right away.
- denzil_correa 10y agoYou might want to check out Apple CarPlay http://www.apple.com/ios/carplay/ http://www.apple.com/ios/carplay/
- sashk 10y agoWhen I bought my latest car, navigation package included few safety features I wanted to get, so I had to get them to get somewhat safer car. My car -- Mazda, comes with free 3 years of map updates. I am yet to update it, because I'm lazy. It also comes with optional paid for traffic service. Why do I need to waste my money on that, when I can get free (I know, I know) Waze, Apple Maps or Google maps which will get me where I need to get avoiding traffic. Despite driving 2016 model year vehicle, I GPS/entertainment center feels like from 2010 or so. So yes, I use my phone for navigations most of the time.
- asplake 10y agoI cited my experience with the new Rav4 satnav in a recent blog post [1] on the difference between "requirements" and "needs". Tweeted it with "If you've lost something in your modern Toyota, it's probably hiding behind a settings menu". The current version isn't terrible; the version the car was delivered to me truly was. Inexcusable. Although there are benefits to integration, unless the delivery model changes to a more phone-like one I can't see myself buying an built-in satnav again. [1] https://blog.agendashift.com/2016/10/06/better-user-stories-start-with-needs/ https://blog.agendashift.com/2016/10/06/better-user-stories-...
- j45 10y agoThe quality of phone based GPS directions has improved drastically in the last 3 years. I had a cutting edge GPS about 5 years ago in my car that did better than my phone. Now there's no comparison and I wished one could simply mirror their iphone/android display into the car's touchscreen without the pageantry of needing an Android Auto/iPhone.
- gambiting 10y agoBecause built-in GPS is terrible. I recently bought a 2016 Mercedes-AMG vehicle that has sat nav as standard(on non-AMG models it's a $1000 (!!!!!!) option). The satnav is made by Garmin, and it's just awful. Truly horrible in terms of speed, usability, and it only gets updates once a year(you get a new SD card when you go for the annual service). In the meantime, my TomTom 5000 satnav is still unbeaten - free lifetime upgrades, clear, fast interface, free and constant internet connection in every country of the world, with accurate traffic and speed camera updates. And it only cost me ~$250 new. I just don't understand why anyone would get a built-in satnav over a dedicated device.
- baggachipz 10y ago2016 Audi here, same experience. Google Maps + Bluetooth Audio is far superior in every way.
- pyb 10y agoTomTom also supply GPS for quite a few carmakers.
- navidev 10y agoSome notes from developer perspective: - The car model probably had the first iteration of Garmin satnav solution for in-dash car infotainment systems. Garmin's architecture was basically built for PNDs(dedicated device) based of their own internal custom OS. This was quickly ported to support in dash infotainment market. I am sure consequent releases got better in performance and usage. - Garmin solution is optimized to perform well based on available resources. SD card read writes, low memory requirements, and other resource restrictions are accountable for the slow performance as well. I am not trying to defend but just want to share the challenges that Garmin faced while they tried to gain market share. I am confident that their solutions will get better with time and deliver better user experience and innovation in the car. -- SW developer and long time user of Garmin
- Someone1234 10y agoThis is why Carplay/Android Auto are so key. They're safer than using your actual phone, they offer legitimate maps apps (Google Maps/Bing Maps/Apple Maps/etc), and are somewhat future proof. Too bad the MirrorLink consortium dropped the ball so epically. MirrorLink arguably does the same thing as Carplay/Android Auto and has been deployed to millions of vehicles, but nobody uses MirrorLink 1.1, why? Because to get your app certified takes tens of thousands of dollars, months, and tons of paperwork. Carplay/Android Auto literally exist because the MirrorLink group created so many rules, regulations, and nonsense in the name of safety that MirrorLink 1.1 has like twenty apps total after two years(!). So if your vehicle has MirrorLink on the feature list, just laugh and forget it exists, you won't be using it. PS - MirrorLink 1.0 allowed two way screen sharing, which was legitimately useful. MirrorLink 1.1 is a very different beast, most newer cars and phones only have MirrorLink 1.1 (no 1.0 at all). 1.1 defines things like how big buttons have to be, what kind of animations can play, how many button presses to reach each task, etc. Then everything has to be certified by an independent auditor. PPS - Most depressing part is: MirrorLink could certify Carplay/Android Auto themselves, and instantly add both to millions of existing vehicles on the road. But they're never going to simply because they're effectively in competition with both.
- UVB-76 10y agoThe average age of cars on the road in the US is something like 11 years [0] Even if CarPlay/Android Auto last more than five years, I expect new versions will come out which render old vehicles incompatible. [0] http://www.latimes.com/business/autos/la-fi-hy-ihs-average-car-age-20150729-story.html http://www.latimes.com/business/autos/la-fi-hy-ihs-average-c...
- mrpippy 10y agoApple takes backwards-compatibility very seriously for MFi protocols, because they know that the "accessories" are cars that people keep for a long time. I used to work at a company making iPod car kits--we took an interface from 2006 (with a hard-wired 30-pin connector), hooked it through a FireWire->USB charging adapter, a 30-pin->Lightning adapter, and it worked fine with an iPhone 6.
- grecy 10y agoOut of curiosity, are there any Tesla owners that can chime in about their experience? Do you use the in-built GPS, or just use your phone? I would think if anyone has it right, it would be Tesla.
- mikeash 10y agoI use the built-in GPS about 99% of the time. I keep a mount in the car just in case I need to use my phone for navigation, but that almost never happens. The built-in navigation isn't great. It lacks some pretty obvious options (it doesn't offer multiple routes, and you can't give it intermediate waypoints) and its routing is occasionally stupid. Although the big screen shows Google Maps, the actual routing is done using an onboard database which is not as good as Google is. But it's good enough that the convenience of just using the big screen in the car outweighs the superior results I get from my phone. It is getting better, which is one thing most cars can't say. We recently got the ability to have it avoid toll roads, for example, and while that really should have been there from the beginning, it's pretty cool that it can be added after the fact. Navigation is one of the top complaints from Tesla owners in my experience, and I agree with a lot of those complaints, but it's not bad enough to have me going for my phone except in rare cases.
- rogerbinns 10y agoOut of curiosity, does the Tesla system pay any attention to the number of people in the vehicle? For example in the sf bay area, there are some places where going from one highway to another (eg 101 to 85) is a left exit for carpools and right exit for solo occupant. Most gps let you pick to include or exclude car pools, but it is such a pain to change the setting that it is usually left on excluding car pools. But Tesla could know exactly how many people are in the car, and do the right thing automatically. It would also affect journey times since car pool lanes are often quicker.
- mikeash 10y agoInteresting question. No such option is exposed, and I don't think it's doing anything clever with seat occupancy sensors. I'm not sure how aware it is of HOV restrictions in the first place. I think that for routes which are only restricted at certain times of day, it will freely use them, and for routes which are always HOV it will never use them. There are also some HOT lanes around here (where you can either drive for free with 3+ people, or pay a toll with less) and it never routes me onto those, even though it happily routes me onto other toll roads. Not sure what's up with that.
- Zelphyr 10y agoMy wife just bought a brand new Toyota Highlander and I can confirm that the nav system is terrible. I can only imagine how much that turd increased the purchase price.
- acl 10y agoI just got the new Highlander, and can only conclude the nav (and most of the rest of the car UX) was designed by a committee of angry monkeys.
- Someone1234 10y agoWhich is really depressing. Toyota make fantastic vehicles but they're being outclassed by others simply because their infotainment system feels like a relic from the early 2000s. They've also doubled down on their refusal to not include Carplay/Android Auto. They're putting something called "SmartDeviceLink" which is yet another MirrorLink 1.1 clone (which is itself a disaster), but this time controlled by a different consortium of companies. Although amusingly the other major auto maker putting SmartDeviceLink in their vehicles, Fort, has already given up and put Carplay/Android Auto into their latest Ford SYNC3 infotainment system software. Leaving Toyota the only major company providing SmartDeviceLink. I legitimately think Toyota will slump in sales when seemingly every other major manufacturer has Carplay/Android Auto. All because Toyota is greedy and wants to profit off of the infotainment unit rather than the vehicle itself.
- mikestew 10y agoThey've also doubled down on their refusal to not include Carplay/Android Auto. They're putting something called "SmartDeviceLink" which is yet another MirrorLink 1.1 clone I just do...not...get this. In what alternate reality do they live that would cause them to think "this time will be different"? History has shown time and again that your proprietary special snowflake platform is not going to cause app writers to flock to you when there's something like CarPlay/Android Auto available. I mean, MirrorLink was a pretty good idea, didn't have any real competitors at the time, and it still sold like dog shit sandwiches. Save everyone some time and money, suck it up, swallow your pride, and just put CarPlay/Android Auto on there. Because as I've said elsewhere in this thread, not only will I not buy your proprietary infotainment system, I won't even buy your car. Even I, a long-time geek who will endure a lot of pain to get something working, cringes at the thought of the hoops I'd have to jump through to get "SmartDeviceLink" to an even minimally useful state. My CarPlay head unit also has MirrorLink, and while I was waiting for Pioneer to update the firmware to include CarPlay, I thought I'd give MirrorLink a whirl. First, I apparently needed to go get a special cable. Yeah, fuck that, you exceeded my tolerance for friction in the first sentence of your user manual. CarPlay? Plugged my iPhone in, waited to see what Apple's special version of frictional hell would be and...it just worked. There's your competition, car makers, and if takes more than just plugging my phone in I'm not buying it.
- JoshGlazebrook 10y agoIf Waze came to Car play and android auto I imagine a lot of people would use it. The only navigation I currently use is Waze and I use it every single time I'm driving, even if I do not need directions. The ETA, routing, and the alerts are useful even if you know where you are going.
- Someone1234 10y agoIt is coming [0]. No word since May though. I imagine they're re-jiggling the UI for Android Auto. [0] http://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/news/2016/05/18/waze-comes-android-auto-one-many-new-features/84459926/ http://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/news/2016/05/18/waze-come...
- toyg 10y agoBuiltin GPS was pretty much the only requirement I had for the last few cars I got (both VW) and tbh I'm not that disappointed. The only thing really lacking is decent search, once you have an address to input it's mostly ok, but it's true that the temptation to just say "fuck it, I've found it on Maps, let's just use this" is there. If there was an easy way to copy or "stream" the address to the car via bluetooth, I think most people would use it. It looks like the field is in flux anyway, VW keeps dramatically changing the UI in every new car.
- viggity 10y agoI've always hated built in GPS for two reasons. First and most important - the damn maps are always viewed from directly above the car so the map is 2D and North is always at the top. There is a lot of effin' mental work to try and figure out which damn way your car is pointing and whether you need to turn left or turn right because you may be driving "down" the map and shit is reversed. On my phone or on my garmin I get a perspective view of my car and it's position on the earth. There is no confusion about which way I actually need to turn. Secondly, the vast majority of built in GPS is on a console a good 6 to 12 inches below the windshield. Meaning I have to remove my eyes far off the road in order to look at everything. My garmin mounts to my windshield or dash. It is a quick glance and then eyes back at the road.
- sithadmin 10y ago>the damn maps are always viewed from directly above the car so the map is 2D and North is always at the top. Both my previous car (2013 Ford C-Max hybrid) and current car (2014 Audi A4) both had options to adjust whether the nav map view was locked to cardinal directions, or if it followed the car's perspective.
- ollie87 10y agoSounds like you've only dealt with older cars here. Newer ones give you directions on the dashboard and I've never even seen a system that doesn't give you a 3D map.
- 4ad 10y agoFunny. My main complaint is the opposite. The phone is using a confusing 3D interface instead of the simple 2D interface that I want. And because software is just great and doesn't have any bugs, it sometime won't even remember to always use the 2D projection that I requested.
- woobar 10y agoAfter reading the article, I think the non-clickbait title should be "Most drivers who own cars with built-in GPS systems _sometimes_ use phones for directions". I am pretty happy with my built-in system - it is fast, always on, integrates well with the car, provides dual-screens (in dash and bigger console screen output), free quarterly OTA map updates, uses Google for POI search, live traffic. Most important I don't need to fish my phone out of pocket, mount it somewhere and connect cable for longer trips. Yet I am also sometimes (1%?) use phone for directions. Most of the time it is when I need to lookup something nearby and I am not in the car.
- CalChris 10y agoCarWings on the Nissan Leaf is unusable. Its only advantage is that the map is built in and so doesn't rely on downloading. You can preload Google Maps onto the iPhone for say Point Reyes. You won't be able to find a route but GPS location and the map should be good enough.
- CalChris 10y agoCarWings on the Nissan Leaf is unusable. The only advantage is that its map is built in and so it doesn't rely on downloading. You can preload Google Maps for say Point Reyes. You won't be able to find a route but GPS location and the should be good enough.
- dsfyu404ed 10y agoSemi unrelated question: Am I the only one who wished navigation apps allowed more precise control of route complexity? Just a slider that goes between "minimum number of turns" and "most efficient" would be nice. Optimizing a route for complexity vs efficiency is a very important consideration when planning a route. A way to do that in a navigation app would be really nice. I appreciate the intention but taking four extra turns and a one way street or two to save one minute when going somewhere that's one turn off a main road is rarely a good idea. If I'm driving rural state highways for three hours I'd much prefer to go 150mi on two roads than go 120mi on ten roads.
- Declanomous 10y agoSimilar thought, but in cities, I'd prefer to cross major streets and make left turns at signaled intersections. I might save 2 minutes on my 30 minute commute, but those are incredibly risky and stressful maneuvers. I use my GPS because it has saved me from an hour of traffic more than once, but I don't need to risk my life to save 30 seconds.
- danpat 10y agoOSRM is looking at improving this exact situation right now: https://github.com/Project-OSRM/osrm-backend/pull/2912 https://github.com/Project-OSRM/osrm-backend/pull/2912
- rogerbinns 10y agoYou must be using google maps :) I have a garmin standalone unit, and android on my dash, making it easy to contrast and compare. Google likes to pick the clinically shortest route, expecting that traffic lights and left turns take no additional time. When ignoring them and taking a more sensible route, you find that their elaborate complexity by their own calculations would have made at most 1 minute of difference. Google has been improving over the years, but still hasn't caught up with the user friendliness of garmin. Garmin seems to give the kind of directions that a human navigator sitting next to you would. Google seems like a machine that knows nothing of the real world!
- 10y ago
- ingenium 10y agoThe Audi navigation works well sometimes, and I really like the integration into the car (using the most up to date maps, they give free map updates for 3 years). However, the routes are not the most efficient, and although it supposedly uses Sirius for traffic, the data isn't very accurate. Google Maps often gives me a much more efficient route that can be twice as fast given current traffic conditions, but is more "unusual". Audi's GPS likes to stick to main roads that become heavily clogged. And even though I have an update that came out within the last 2 months, it still doesn't have a major construction project that has been completed for a year added, and always tries to route you around it. So basically I use Google Maps for navigation within the city or areas that I'm familiar with, and Audi's navigation for long trips (ie inter city highway trips) where the route will mostly be the same on both systems. That being said, the GPS in my car ALWAYS gets an accurate lock right away. My phone (Nexus 6P) has an awful GPS that doesn't work in hilly areas or around tall buildings and constantly loses the signal. It barely works inside the car, and even then the accuracy isn't great. Guess the all metal phone really kills the GPS signal, since the Nexus 6 had an amazingly good GPS with high accuracy in the same conditions.
- anindha 10y agoWhy not just have a nice phone holder built into cars rather than these systems. It would integrate with the speaker/mic in the car and charge my phone.
- lagadu 10y agoAnd what interface would it have? Apple 30-pin? Lightning? Micro-usb? usb-c? Does it have room for 3.5 to 6 inch phones? Integration with speaker/mic is already done via bluetooth but charging is still a problem.
- macjohnmcc 10y agoMy car's map was so out of date when I bought it it instantly became useless to me. My wife sitting in the passenger seat cannot select destinations while we are driving so it is far easier to just use a phone with the added benefits of up-to-date maps and traffic.
- pwthornton 10y agoSmartphone maps are so superior because they are always up to date, can provide real-time traffic data, can tell you to take an alternative route and can provide other data about places to eat, etc. While a lot of car GPSs have some of this, they are no where near what Google Maps or Apple Maps (or a targeted app like Waze) has. I bought a new car last year, and intentionally didn't get the GPS, even though my car has a 7-inch touchscreen. I would never use those crappy maps when I have my phone with me. If the car supported Carplay, I would 100% use maps through that. This is why Carplay and Android Auto are the future. Their apps, APIs and data are so superior to whatever car companies can come up with.
- rhinoceraptor 10y agoAnd even if the auto companies could do something as well as Google/Apple, it would still be several years out of date once it finally shipped in new cars.
- FireBeyond 10y agoI know my Audi has Google Maps, and real time traffic. I think one of the other issues is how many GPS systems refuse to let you enter addresses en route and make you stop and / or pull the handbrake. This increases frustration hugely. The Audi system says "please don't do this while driving" - you say "Okay" and are able to do so.
- seanp2k2 10y agoThe other thing I find infuriating is having to agree to some license agreement every time the car is started.
- seanp2k2 10y agoYeah, I'm not sure why car companies invested at all in attempting to build their own mapping software. It's a hard thing to do well, and I had been using GPS in the car since Windows 98 + Microsoft Streets + Garmin eMap + serial adapter running NEMA days. PC or smartphone navigation software has always been better than what is available in cars. Additionally, while the upgrade cycle for phones is yearly for some people, the upgrade cycle for cars can be 10 years or more, and good luck ever getting a software upgrade after buying a car. Whatever car I buy next, I wouldn't buy without CarPlay. There are also replacement stereos which support this (e.g. Pioneer appradio) but given how most cars don't still use a 2 DIN slot for the radio and have much more integrated systems (drive modes, HVAC controls, etc on the "radio"), it's not even possible to upgrade many without losing significant factory functionality. My hope is that auto mfgs wise up and realize that they've been wasting billions developing these in-house systems, and instead switch to just having the car be a dumb monitor + speakers with a connection to your phone which runs all of the non-critical systems.
- salmonlogs 10y agoReading the comments I appear to be the exception. I lease a 2015 BMW 4-series which I added "Professional Media" to and the nav works really well. I've driven plenty of other cars where the nav is useless, but not all are bad. Reasons to use it over my phone: * 11" screen shows me a high quality map overlayed with current traffic, with 1/3 split for lane guidance when needed * Directions also shown directly on the dash - no need to look far away * Spoken instructions dim the music volume * Pretty accurate traffic information with automatic OTA updates Downsides: * Voice control is shitty; saying "set destination to leamington spa" will change to a random radio frequency * Slightly awkward to send routes from PC to car, has to be via Remote Control App
- Someone1234 10y agoYou aren't really the exception, instead you're just fortunate enough to have one of the few in-dash navigation systems which isn't absolutely terrible. Most of the features you've named are exactly what Android Auto/Carplay provide, but without limiting you to just a single maps/navigation vendor. You're likely leasing that vehicle for 1-3 years. Do you think that if you purchased that 4-series that the navigation would still be updated and solid by the end of its 9-15 year vehicle lifespan? I certainly don't. But I do an apps platform like carplay/android auto will continue to provide quality apps for at least that long.
- salmonlogs 10y agoI totally get your point, and agree. CarPlay/Android Auto certainly improve quality on average for most cars, but I'm not convinced they will solve the problem of outdated technology. I previous had a Mercedes with "Apple Certified Connectivity" which was great, until they switched to lightning cables and the connectivity broke. Whilst I'm sure CarPlay/Android Auto will last longer, I don't believe there won't be any breaking changes in future that will break compatibility. Given that we replace phones a lot faster than cars I can see a future where there are cars which only support CarPlay version X, and the standard is now version Y. At that point you then end up with no navigation or media, because you aren't going to use an older phone just to have it work with your older car.
- kovrik 10y agoI can't use my car's GPS because the car is from Japan and it has Japanese language only and only maps of Japan. And you can't just download map of any other country, and you can't even change the language. So, yes, I'd better use my phone's GPS: maps are always up-to-date, I can choose between Google Maps and Apple Maps (or any other), can select any language.
- tracker1 10y agoEven though my car stereo has pandora on it.. I usually just use bluetooth playback with pandora or skype from my phone as the google maps ux is much better and the directions work while listening. Honestly, the car ux for entertainment, etc in general feels like something that should have been state of the art half a decade ago... it's too slow, unresponsive and irritation imho, depite positive reviews. For references it's the fullscreen uconnect interface on a 2016 dodge challenger. Also, the fact that it's 3g instead of lte on the antenna makes the mobile hotspot option worthless and not even a consideration.
- tracker1 10y agoA bit late, but had meant spotify, not skype.. :-) I plan on letting XM lapse at the end of the free term as I really don't use it, and the cost is more than pandora and skype combined.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- zeveb 10y agoMy issue isn't so much the pain of entry — although it is a pain — as the fact that Google Maps provides better directions, taking into account current traffic conditions, than my car's system. OTOH, my car's system knows about highway amenities like food & gas, and has a neat feature where it displays a preview of what certain turns look like. I would love to integrate them somehow.
- lagadu 10y agoDiscrete GPS units do all that. I use a tomtom go6100 for all my navigation needs, it's unmatched at its job.
- n-gauge 10y agoCan confirm. If the iu / method of entering a postcode wasn't so faffy for the in car satnav, it would serfice.
- tibbon 10y agoWhy is Tesla one of the few car manufacturers who actually pushes real updates to their car's dashboard system (and for free, others charge absurd fees if they do give minor updates). I hope that by 2020 it is the expectation that your car will continue to update and improve its interface over the years you own it. I say this because people point to smartphones as always being more updated- and there's no reason for this.
- bjelkeman-again 10y agoIt would piss off the dealers. They live on the service costs. https://www.technologyreview.com/s/524791/why-your-car-wont-get-remote-software-updates-anytime-soon/ https://www.technologyreview.com/s/524791/why-your-car-wont-...
- korethr 10y agoAs a counterpoint to the comments here bringing up the point that the maps on one's phone are always up to date, I'll bring up the point of offline access. Yes, often the maps are bad, out of date, and require one to go the dealer and pay money to get an update. However, once out of the city, and cellular data ceases to be a thing, Google maps and similar applications built with an assumption of an always-available Internet connection become kind of useless. Yes, you can add maps for the areas you are planning to be to your offline areas, but that requires planning ahead. And if you ended up somewhere you didn't plan to be, well, good luck. The UI for these in-car navigation systems is bad, but at least you have _a map_, instead of a featureless void with a blue You Are Here in the middle. Personally, I like a map book for such situations. Sure, it's ancient and obsolete technology, is quickly out of date, but the UI is quick an easy to learn, and it doesn't require power to use.
- astrodust 10y agoI have a stupid question: Why is the user interface on a $30K car so bad compared to a $99 smart phone you can buy at the drug store? What is with the garbage they call software these days? The response time on some of these in-dash systems can be measured in seconds.
- ktta 10y agoYou're comparing two vastly different things. Maps for Google (I assume people are referring to google maps) is a very important part of its business, up there with gmail. But maps for car companies is an afterthought, a secondary luxury feature. You can't expect car companies to drop billions on mapping and full time software devs in perfecting the navigation system. The way I see it, the best way would be for them to use google maps in their car. There'll probably be a slew of privacy issues with that though, because you can close the maps app but it'll be more difficult to control the GPS system build into you car.
- astrodust 10y agoSure, but I expect Google could make a kazillion dollars with some kind of licensing deal to provide Android and a stripped down offline version of Google Maps as a backup if there's no data available to car manufacturers. Customizing an existing Android-for-cars platform sounds like a way better plan than whatever junk these manufacturers are shipping today. I've seen better systems in the 1990s in terms of responsiveness and performance. The only thing consistently worse than the UI in cars is the UI in set-top boxes which I can only presume are designed and implemented in North Korea and intended to run on CPUs made in 1985. Apple is probably working on this exact thing, so I'm surprised Google hasn't made any inroads here. They can take more chances than Apple can.
- Cybernetic 10y agoNative GPS systems are painfully slow, in my experience. I have a Subaru Impreza 2014. Its GPS usually tracks a full block behind we're I'm at. If I'm not paying attention and make a turn based on the voice-guidance alone, it's often a wrong turn. Re-routing takes a long time as well; too long to be useful. Additionally, I have to pay for annual map updates if I want them. To someone's point earlier, all interaction with the map is disabled while the car is in motion. It would be nice if it were unlocked so a passenger could use it. So I use Google Maps on my phone. It's significantly faster, shows more meta-data relative to my route, e.g., delays and alternate route suggestions, and if it has to re-route it's usually immediate.
- nashashmi 10y agoI have looked at the comments here and everyone is talking about the superiority of their phones and how carplay and Android auto are so much better. And this leads me to having a Steve Jobs moment: I wish the car dash computers would work as simply as smart watches where they are just dumb remote controls for phones. I don't have Android auto or carplay. But I have used moto360. And I find that is all I really ever need when driving. The voice recognition is awesome. The interface is simple. And like all simple things it leads the mind to wish for more. It seems like the car manufacturers tried to swallow too much at once and sucked at all of it.
- SpikeDad 10y agoI don't. My 2013 Prius has an excellent GPS and I'm not too concerned that the maps are a bit out of date. I still get accurate traffic data from XM. There are advantages to the built-in navigation - it works when there's no GPS signal due to inertial navigation (compass and tire rotation). Mine has a head-up display so I can see navigation cues without taking my eyes off the road. The voice synth is much better than Apple Maps or Google Maps. I've only had to pull out my phone a couple of times in 3 years.
- bsder 10y agoHow about: "Can't set new route while car is in motion?" If you ever block me from doing something on a computer that I know it can do, I will hate you forever. You know, I might have a passenger who could work the nav system, but, oh, no, the car is moving so you can't enter a new destination. So many people disabled this "feature" on the Prius nav system that Toyota removed the ability to disable it. I kid you not. And then they wonder why everybody uses their phone.
- pkaye 10y agoI think some states have laws that restrict navigation control access when car is in motion.
- danpat 10y agoInterestingly, according to this summary: http://drivinglaws.aaa.com/tag/telematics/ http://drivinglaws.aaa.com/tag/telematics/ there are exemptions of some kind for navigation systems in many places. I've heard "it's not allowed by law" often, but I have yet to track down the actual law. Hopefully automakers aren't doing this based on hearsay....
- derekp7 10y agono, they are doing it to prevent lawsuits. In fact, on Ford's Sync 3 system, they have a huge disclaimer that pops up when you enable Android Auto or Apple Carplay, saying that anything that comes up on the car's screen is controlled by Android (or Apple) and therefore Ford is not liable -- go sue them instead.
- TheSpiceIsLife 10y agoIn Australia there's "drive without due care" which could cover anything the driver might do in a car that could distract.
- lukaslalinsky 10y agoCars can generally go much faster than the maximum speed limit, so it wouldn't be the first time the car allows you to do something against the law.
- lanius 10y agoHaven't tried built-in GPS, but I prefer using my phone over my standalone GPS because it's much faster. My standalone unit takes forever to boot up, has too-long delays when navigating between screens, and overall is just frustratingly sluggish when trying to use.
- conductr 10y agoYou can't buy car features a la carte like the "build your car" tool on every auto maker's site suggest you can. You're forced to buy the "tech package" which includes the GPS because you want something as simple as bluetooth
- hx87 10y agoIf the base car has 3.5mm input jack, getting bluetooth is pretty trivial.
- raitom 10y agoI have a 2015 Mustang with GPS, no carplay, and I always use Google Map on my iPhone (and everyone in san diego assume that i'm a tourist because of that haha). Same for my friends with their cars, I never saw them using their built-in gps. I already used carplay in another car, but apple plan on it is not as good as google map.
- bleair 10y agoIt's really simple - how hard is the UX of my phone vs. the car's system. I've _never_ seen a builtin car version have a UX that wasn't ridiculously complex and frustrating to use. There are two concrete, real examples, of a routing UX that anyone can just try out - just grab an android phone or an iphone and directly copy the experience. Just sit down and try the most basic goal of using a nav system - enter and address and start and do it on your car system and on either phone. Oh, wait, differing goals. I, as a user, want a usable system. The maker of these awful nav systems have an entirely different goal. They are trying to sell an "option" upgrade to car makers who then include it in "option packages" with the car... usability is way way down the list after bells/whistles/marketing/subscription sales
- sliken 10y agoSeems like the best advantage of in car navigation is the GPS. Seems like many car GPS are rock solid, lock quickly, and can handle short outages because they know the speed and compass direction. Maybe car windows are tinted more often now? I often get a marginal signal in my car, seems worse than in my house. Anyone had luck with a magnetic attached bluetooth GPS they can put on their car roof or similar to improve a smartphone's GPS signal inside a car?
- eric_the_read 10y agoMy new Tacoma has a hybrid system called Scout GPS. The idea is that you run the app on your phone, and it does all the heavy lifting WRT GPS, computing routes, etc., and the dashboard display is basically a moderately dumb UI that displays maps on the screen. In theory, it's a best of both worlds situation; the UI doesn't really need to change very often; what is most important is the maps/POI information, which can be downloaded either in-app or via an update. Practically, the UI is just irritating enough that I end up using Google Maps anyway, and just letting the voice directions get me where I'm going. (edit: punctuation, because my inner copyeditor won't shut up)
- kbenson 10y agoI've often wondered, while using the somewhat substandard media navigation of my bluetooth enabled car stereo which has a touch screen, why there isn't some standard for specifying a very simple, somewhat static visual interface for bluetooth touchscreens (or screens with a set number of external buttons). A very constrained HTML, perhaps, that apps could choose to supply to provide better control through external interfaces. For example, let Android or iOS supply an interface to view my contacts based on the reported dimensions of the screen and capabilities. Let Pocket Casts present a list of podcasts to choose from. Let Pandora show my thumbs up/down stored for the song, and register my new preference. If I'm at my desk, and I'm using one of these apps, there's no reason a simple app that provides the same interface couldn't provide me info about the connected phone through bluetooth, to let me know who is calling me, let me stream my podcasts through my desktop speakers, etc. Does this exist, and I just don't know about it (or it isn't implemented by anyone)?
- eric_the_read 10y agoI think that is more or less exactly the idea behind Android Auto and CarPlay for iOS. The problem is that many manufacturers still don't support it, and customer demand isn't high enough (yet) to force them to. I went ahead and bought the Taco, even though it didn't have Android Auto, because it was otherwise a good truck, and the bluetooth support was Good Enough™. Until enough people don't behave like me, support is likely to lag.
- derekp7 10y agoThat was my biggest problem when I recently bought a car -- almost all of the ones with the options I wanted (out of dealer stock) also included the $800 manufacturer's GPS. Which is something completely useless to me since I could get by perfectly fine with Android Auto. So I ended up paying for a feature that I would not only not use, but was such inferior quality (it can't locate either my home address, or work address -- for home, it routes me to a house several miles away, and for work it sends me to the movie theater 3 blocks east).
- gbuk2013 10y agoI am one of these drivers - my car has navigation (didn't get a choice since I bought it secondhand) but I use Waze. That said, having it has saved me on several occasions when my phone ran out of power and when there was no signal and I missed a turn.
- ryanlm 10y agoProblem with the bait and switch car GPS's is they actually charge you for updates. This should be against the law.
- nomailing 10y agoWhy not buy one of the cheap aftermarket Chinese Android head units? When I was looking to buy a car I specifically looked for double DIN compatibility so that I can later easily install my own head unit. I would not want to support a car manufacturer who is abandoning the DIN standard for aftermarket head units. I want this central piece in the car to be upgradable. A car without double DIN is like a computer case without any slot to put an HDD. There are very nice units with native Android experience. They usually have either a 7" or 10" screen. There are also some discussions of the various chinese units on xda forums in case someone is here interested...
- Itsdijital 10y agoDon't waste your money on a cheap Chinese unit. It's hard enough to justify buying the name brand units that cost way more and run worse than a $50 Walmart phone. The aftermarket head unit market has been in shambles for a few years now. Demand has dropped dramatically and units have stagnanted for years, in some ways even moving backwards. I would love to see DINs make a comeback in cars, hopefully it would breath some fresh life into the HU market.
- honkhonkpants 10y agoReally the thing you want here is for your smartphone to have access to the car's GPS receiver, which is huge and sensitive and can use all the power it wants. The phone can just treat it as a peripheral.
- agjacobson 10y agoThe navigation system on my 2013 Acura is unusable. My iPhone sits on the seat and does the job. The navigation system on 2016 Volvos is usable.
- chrismbarr 10y agoI remember seeing my dad drive his brand new BMW 5 series with a beautiful widescreen display in the dash. The screen has a little shelf under it, so it was the perfect place to set his iPhone with the directions he actually wanted to follow. The built in GPS essentially provided the same directions, but the UX of the phone apps and the audible directions are just so much better.
- bvinc 10y agoI had an interesting experience recently that I think summarizes this whole problem. I was in another city and rented a car and it came with navigation. I knew I could just use my phone, but I decided to use the navigation that the rental car came with, just for fun. 1. First, I knew the name of my hotel, but not the address. I tried to search the business directory. I had to input the CITY AND STATE, which is painfully slow on the pressure-based touch screen, but I did it and did a search. I couldn't find it. 2. So I took out my phone and found the address and went back to the navigation in my car to type it in. 3. I slowly input the city and state again before it lets me input an address starting with the number. 4. When it came time to pick the street name, it was ambiguous. There's one street name that looks right. There's another with a W in front of it. There's another highway number that could also be it. I pick one and I can tell it's not in the right spot. Now I have to start all over. 5. I start all over, input the city and state and address and I think I have it right. I start to navigate. 6. It can't find a GPS signal. Maybe it's the parking garage I'm in. Maybe it just takes a while. I sit there. I'm about 10 minutes in and I still haven't gotten any navigation instructions. 7. I get nervous because I won't even know what direction to turn when I leave the parking garage. I take out my phone and say "Ok google, navigate to the blah blah Hotel". It says "Ok, sure" and my phone has no problems finding GPS and I have navigation instructions pulled up in about 5 seconds.
- otempomores 10y agoYou forgot the voice command excuse machine in every car. Im sorry.. I still did not understand...goodbye.
- dingaling 10y ago> and my phone has no problems finding GPS and I have navigation instructions pulled up in about 5 seconds. That's because your phone isn't actually using GPS ( e.g. Navstar or Glonass ) at that point, it's using cell triangulation or wifi-based location. For example the fastest possible first-fix with Navstar from a warm-start, using cached prior-location and ephemerides, is 30 seconds[0]. From a cold ( position-unknown ) start, such as a car nav-system powered-down in a parking-lot for an extended period, the first-fix will take longer than 12 minutes. There is no technological way around that, it is an artifact of the system architecture. [0] and that's for a top-end receiver than can sync to four satellites 'simultaneously' using time-division.
- azernik 10y agoI've seen many new Israeli cars shipping with a nav system that is just a stripped-down Android system running Waze.
- mayneack 10y agoAs far as I can tell the only upsides to car navigation (embedded or a standalone TomTom or something) is independence from live data link and battery constraints. Unless I'm going somewhere without a data connection, I think the phone is strictly better.
- owenwil 10y agoThe only time I use these built-in ones is when I'm renting a car and stuck on roaming data :)
- dmritard96 10y agoi really just want a chromecast equivalent for my car. phones get updated every couple years but cars last much longer. it simply doesn't make sense to put too much smarts in the car itself but i do see the value in a well placed screen and integration with the cars audio system.
- javolmut 10y agoiPad Pro
- wisp-hr 10y agoFriend of mine has a 2016 subaru with built-in GPS systems. His "free trial" went out last month, and Subaru wants him to pay monthly to use it. Yeah, no shit people use the free alternative on their phone that is constantly updated.
- hueving 10y agoPeople prefer better user experience over worse user experience. More news at 10. Seriously, I am blown away that car manufacturers manage to pitch navigation systems as a value add to the car. "Would you like to spend an additional $1500 for a system with a UI workflow developed as the first GPS satellites were being launched? For an additional $50/mo you can even keep the information up to date so it doesn't suggest you drive across the hoover dam."
- bparsons 10y agoNothing is really close to the functionality of Waze or Google maps. All the purpose built devices run an inferior product with a sloppy interface. Users are going to use the superior product in their pocket.
- leppr 10y agoThe tragedy of proprietary technology. There is a need for competition so sure, saying "let's integrate Google Maps into everything" might not be a win for us in the long term, but we don't need a hundred different navigation systems. Just integrate one of the top players in the field and be done with it. Better yet, open the damn design to allow modification by customers (/local garages).
- nmstoker 10y agoThis is a little like a more extreme version of the smart TV situation: for the most part there are rarely prizes for coming second, so many people ignore the built in stuff. For many it would be better if they came without GPS and used the money for other things, but it seems many are unaware of this too!
- kubuqi 10y agoI would rather have a nice phone holder built in car, than a builtin navigation. It is so obviously you can't compete with the likes of Google & Apple in terms of UI.
- andreasv1634 10y agoit depends on the car i guess. BMW's is pretty good.