9 ms·
U.S. Manufacturing costs are almost as low as China’s
- jkot 11y agoI think at this point US simply has no specialized factories to manufacture things.
- nickpinkston 11y agoIt's actually the opposite: We're great at speciality, high-tech stuff, but we don't do commodity contract manufacturing as well as China. The good part of this is that the former has far better margins than the latter.
- jkot 11y agoSo you are only cheaper on expensive stuff.
- chralieboy 11y agoFor now, but the trend in the article is related to mass manufacturing. Fracking (lower electricity prices, cheaper oil) helps large steel and aluminum manufacturers. Cheaper raw materials leads to cheaper widgets.
- nickpinkston 11y agoBetter != Cheaper - We're able to make more profitable manufacturing companies, by cost or performance.
- ghaff 11y agoIt's not that simple. I was just happening to look at a plastic bucket I was using yesterday and it was manufactured the next town over in Massachusetts, It's probably true that the US tends not to be competitive for cheap goods that don't have a large individual labor component. But it's more than high-margin items.
- ams6110 11y agoInjection molded plastic seems to be one industry that is still viable in the USA (just my observation, it seems common to see plastics factories here). Not sure why this is.
- starky 11y agoDoing tooling in China and then shipping the molds to NA is the common way to do injection moulding in NA. After that injection moulding is so automated that the labour cost to run a machine isn't that high. That said, I've yet to have a NA injection molder beat out the ones we use in Asia.
- ghaff 11y agoAssuming it is in fact the case (and it probably is for larger items at least), it's probably as part of the US-based hydrocarbon refining ecosystem in some way. (The city in question in my comment was also one of the first places to do industrial plastics manufacturing as a way to replace tortoise shell for combs etc.)
- geon 11y agoSomeone explained the attraction of China with the complete supply chain. If you need 1k speciality screws now, you can order them from the screw factory next door and have them ready in no time.
- nickpinkston 11y agoThis is definitely true, but with better information on suppliers + air freight, we're able to ship from China to the US very quickly and most components are tiny, so shipping costs are de minimis. The problem is more that the Chinese market is still highly fragmented and not easily searched without insiders on the ground. Alibaba is just scratching the surface on transparency in global supply chain, but once the market becomes legible, the local supply chain thing won't matter as much.
- sachingulaya 11y agoAt what scale? I pay roughly $3/hr for welding in china.
- chinathrow 11y agoAnd you feel pride? Seriously, 3$/h? Assumming that a large junk goes to the shop owner, that's not a lot to make each month.
- Thriptic 11y agoYou are assuming cost of living is the same in both places, which it isn't.
- chinathrow 11y agoI am not assuming that no. But I could assume that the welding is done in Shenzhen (maybe GP chips in where he sources welding at 3$/h?). http://www.numbeo.com/cost-of-living/city_result.jsp?country=China&city=Shenzhen&displayCurrency=USD http://www.numbeo.com/cost-of-living/city_result.jsp?country... That hourly rate wouldn't even covering rent of an 1-bedroom apt outside of centre.
- yeukhon 11y agoSpeaking from a Chinese perspective, $3/hr in China today is still very low. That's like 3000 RMB for a 9-5 blue collar (which doesn't really happen as many workers work between 12-16 hours a day). But there are just so many expenses you cannot avoid while living in China as a Chinese... $3000 - $5000 is barely enough.
- hebdo 11y agoWait, what. I've lived in Beijing in 2013. You can live off 3000RMB/month = 500USD/month. That's far from being rich, but also not barely survivable. Everything was cheap for me, and I'm from Poland.
- pronoiac 11y ago- because fracking is bringing cheaper oil and gas, for lower energy costs.
- rjdagost 11y agoFor some industries the USA is and has for some time been a bit lower cost for manufacturing than China. Labor costs are only part of the equation- you also have to take into account transportation costs, energy costs, costs of obtaining capital, etc. all weighed against political, scheduling, and quality risks. For my own industry (specialty machine vision systems) outsourcing to China is almost not worth the trouble.
- dhimes 11y agooutsourcing to China is almost not worth the trouble Almost?
- JohnTHaller 11y agoLikely, as in many industries, there is still a lower cost in total with manufacturing in China, so many companies still will. But there is more risk in terms of product quality, safety, delivery, etc due to the whole supply chain, sub-contracting, etc.
- rjdagost 11y agoYes, for my industry China is still a little lower cost. If our products were more labor intensive then China would look much more appealing.
- SiVal 11y agoYou left out the biggest cost of all: technology theft. The Chinese government wants its manufacturers to watch for technologies that could be of economic or military value and to pass them on to relevant Chinese organizations for use. When the local Party leader's son starts producing your "specialty machine vision systems" in his factory down the road, are you going to go to the Party-controlled court and sue him? If I had a "technology" that was immediately discernible by any buyer (a plastic cup, a game board with an image printed on paper and glued to cardboard), I might make it in China, but for any non-obvious technology, I would assume that any money I saved on COST by making it in China, I would lose on PRICE when my manufacturer's brother-in-law started competing with me.
- yeukhon 11y agoThere are always two camps of people in this debate. One camp says the medical expense and overhead dealing with regulations and union are too costly to operate manufacturing entirely in the US. There is another camp that says the cost operating oversea (training staff, relocating senior staff oversea, legal and book keeping management) is close to operating in the US. Fact is many companies are now moving away from China, and are signing up new manufacturing sites in other Southern Asian countries such as Thailand and Vietnam for lower operational cost (note a lot of the U.S. companies give contract to oversea manufacturer, so it is these manufactures moving away from their own domestic sites - for example, Foxconn being a largely a Taiwanese company Foxconn manufactures outside of Taiwan). I don't know how close operating in the US vs operating half of the business offshore is. This is like hiring consultant oversea for software development. The first burden is operational efficiency; it is painful to manage oversea when you want your "brain power" to be in the US. For example, project manager might have to get up early say 6-7 AM to do a stand up and then follow up at 9/10AM (because your business owner / product owner don't get up at 6 to talk about progress). If there are bugs that need to be resolved during US hour, you still have to pay the extra hours. You are wasting time going-back-and-forth because your offshore team will get off work when you want to fit a meeting in the afternoon. While most Chinese workers do not form union (fear of repucation), workers do come out and protest from time to time (see Foxcoon strikes). Local laws also do not often favor US companies, and local laws can be a pain in the ass. The only thing I can think of that will keep some companies manufacturing outside of the U.S. is that these companies simply do not have cash in the US. Imagine a company like Apple (Apple has like 90% of its cash outside of US) the only way they can spend that money is do stuff outside of US. This is just my uneducated opinion, having little idea how business and economy works. I am all for moving closer to proximity. If you are selling in the U.S. it makes sense to manufacture her. This is why many manufacture sites are now built in Mexico (looking at car makers). Shipping cost have been reduced in the last two decades because now we have bigger ships, but still, there is a schedule that you need to maintain. Another classic example where some part of "making" are likely done domestic (or a place where known for using advanced technology) is the classic X ThinkPad series. The agreement Lenovo have with IBM is that the main design is to remain in a Japanese lab AFAIK. I am sure Lenovo has way to do stuff in China and do stuff in Japan, and still claim stuff are done in Japan. But branding is a good motivation for keeping certain things local.
- thomasmarriott 11y ago'The whole landscape has changed. They kept telling us we were wasting our time, and now it has really caught fire all over the world' — George Mitchell, father of fracking https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_P._Mitchell https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_P._Mitchell
- downandout 11y agoAs oil and gas prices in the US reach parity with China, China remains relevant only where labor costs are a factor. As manufacturing becomes increasingly automated, Chinese factory workers (and indeed most of the world's unskilled workers) will become unemployed. That is a double edged sword....it will be great for businesses until enough people are unemployed that only a small percentage of the population can afford to buy the goods they are producing.
- digitalzombie 11y agoI used to have this view but it free up workers to be more educated and do less menial tasks is a counter argument. Having an educated labor force would keep US be competitive. Unfortunately that means getting higher and higher degree.
- burger_moon 11y agoA counter to your counter ;) would be that now you have a larger population of young adults going head first into debt for degrees that will have an equally expanisve labor pool. So now you graduate with a higher education degree but so did everyone else and there may not be enough human job growth to sustain it. I'm not sure there is a simple answer to any of these problems.
- paddlepop 11y agoSadly this doesn't address the reason I import from China and not from the USA - where the product is likely to be of better quality - the cost of shipping. I just recently had to cancel a large order from our first USA wholesaler when we discovered that the cost to ship via DHL or FedEx would cost 500% more than the value of the items themselves. This maybe a New Zealand problem but often shipping from China is free despite the distances being the same
- pjc50 11y agoExport post from China is heavily subsidised.
- kristofferR 11y agoMostly by the postal services in the recipient country actually: "If you buy the cheap goods from abroad today, you can often get them shipped "free" around half the planet and to your home. It may be cheaper to order a remote control with batteries from China and throw the remote away, rather than going to the store and buying a pack of batteries. That this may be a problem for local businesses is obvious, but the reason you can order extremely cheap goods from China is far more complicated than you think. Most countries in the world have actually joined forces in an international collaboration to allocate freight costs between themselves a partnership, where the importing countries eventually ended up holding the bag. This agreement is called Universal Postal Convention, and it's important for many of us in everyday life. It is quite simple to regulate mail traffic between all the countries that have joined, not to mention how much it will cost to ship the item. The intention behind the agreement was good when it was introduced, but over a hundred years later, the social conditions changed and it helps to create distortion of competition across the world. Universal Postal Convention was created in a completely different era than the one we are in now, namely around 1870 - at the time it was snail mail which reigned, e-mail was by no means invented and not even the largest visionary had thought of the idea of sending the mail electronically. If we go back to the time of the Convention's birth it was not so easy to send a letter abroad. Each country had to enter into their own individual agreements with every country they wanted to send mail to. If you wanted to send mail to a country who didn't have a mail agreement with your own country, you would have a problem. The solution could then be to send the letter via a third country, which had agreements in good standing with both the country you were sending from and the country you would send to. To calculate the postage was no trivial matter either. Here you risked the postage getting split up in multiple parts, so that the first part covered the mail crossing the border. Then the poor postal workers had to sit with price lists from other countries to calculate the rest of the postage, after which they also had to stick on a stamp for the recipient country. Should the letter go through several countries on its journey, one can only imagine how cumbersome the system was. One particularly cumbersome system, without a doubt, and so thought the those who lived at that time too. Thus, the Universal Postal Union, UPU, established in 1874. The main pillar of this association is what we call the Universal Postal Convention. The Universal Postal Union was a set of rules that regulated postage prices, and one of the most important rules was the various national postal service does not distinguish between mail from inland and mail from abroad. As a final pillar was the rule that the postal service in each Member State would gain the postage that was paid to ship the overseas mail. It was the end of letters filled with stamps from many countries. The stamp of the sending country was enough to get all the way to the recipient's mailbox. In 1947 UPU became a specialized agency within the UN, and it's currently the second oldest organization within the United Nations, surpassed only by the International Telecommunication Union - ITU. To become a member here it is a requirement that the Universal Postal Convention is enacted. In 1969 a central and important change was enacted, it introduced a so-called terminal fee, to be paid if one country mails more to a country other than what it self got in return. This system makes it fairer for those countries that receive a lot of mail. Here in Norway we get considerably more more mail into the country, than what we send out, so this is an important factor we should return to later in this comment. You can still send letters and mail in an easy way, anywhere in the world. The big carrot is still another. If you buy from overseas you are in fact pretty much guaranteed a relatively nice shipping price. How nice shipping price is depends a little on how things are sent. If you order small electronics directly from China, you can get very cheaply from it. Goods are basically reasonable, and shipping charges are usually a joke. Many times you get free shipping, even if the course is baked into the price. This low shipping cost, you can thank the Universal Postal Convention for, since Norway has committed to deliver the item to you without any additional premium. Overall, Norway recieves way more mail than it send from us. This means that Posten Norway gets more terminal charges than what we have to pay in terminal charges to other countries. The problem is that these fees are underpriced compared to what Posten Norway spends to deliver the mail. How much Posten Norway lose on these mailings, they refuse to tell: > The details are confidential, but as a net importer of mail Posten Norway gets more from the terminal taxes than we pay for exports to others. Our distribution costs are not taken into account in this calculation. Unmet costs we have on international mail must necessarily be covered from other revenue in postal operations, said press officer at Posten Norway, Hilde Ebeltoft Skaugrud. So far we are assured of low freight rates from abroad, but there may be changes in time. There is no denying that many countries are experiencing that the money isn't enough and quickly disappears. In a few years this may change. > The Convention is revised every four years, next in 2016, and in this connection we discussed the changes. Posten Norway are working to achieve better alignment between terminal charges and distribution costs, Ebeltoft Skaugrud tell us. As of today, Posten Norway gets a variety of packages and letters from abroad to be handed out. They get paid for the job, but nowhere near what the job is costing them. The cost will be subsidized by the other mail clients, those who send packages and letters in Norway. When two countries are sending mail to each other the weight of the mail from the country that sent the least mail to the other country is counter-accounted. For all the excess the terminal fee has to be pain, which is related to the general economic situation in each country. The result is that Norway will pay a higher fee for their excess kilogram of mail than countries such as China and the United States does. The Chinese have a right to send parcels abroad for an amount considered fair in China, the problem is that the sum is terribly low in a Norwegian perspective. In a survey made by the German consulting company Wissenschaftliche Institut für Infrastructure und Kommunikationsdienste GmbH in 2011, there were several interesting findings related to terminal charges. There Norway comes out as one the biggest losers due to large net imports and high internal expenses. The consulting company also shows that several other have also advocated for a change. The (American) Department of Justice stated, among other things, in 1990 that the terminal fees that differ from the actual cost of delivery has an ability to disrupt the competition. The European Commission said something similar in 1992, when they stated that the terminal fees should be based on what it costs to deliver the consignments in the recipient country. In fact the Universal Postal Union itself makes a statement on the issue a few years later, in 1997; and makes it clear that terminal charges not based on the real costs within the recipient country will create incentives for trade that is not financially sustainable with the great flow across borders. We should be very cautious about predicting anything, but we can not envisage that the current situation will continue forever. Various foreign online stores of various sizes are nearest subsidized shipping to Norway, and considering the increase in imports is probably only a matter of time before something is done. The first opportunity to make a change is 2016 and we will be surprised if it's not going to be a good deal more expensive to receive packets from the rest of the world then." // Article from HW.no (Norway's Ars Technica) translated with Google Translate and with the language fixed manually. http://www.hardware.no/artikler/guide-verdenspostkonvensjonen/157151?key=NGNvhkZx http://www.hardware.no/artikler/guide-verdenspostkonvensjone...
- IshKebab 11y agoWell maybe for energy-intensive industries like aluminium. It's never going to be cheaper for things like electronics though - all the components are manufactured in China so why ship components to America and assemble them there when you can assemble in China for less and ship finished products?
- Azerb 11y agoI work in the consumer device space and from what I've seen, the flexibility of in-region supply chain for components and sub-assemblies would be very difficult to match outside of China. It allows for JIT manufacturing and incredibly quick divergences from POR during development when issues occur. However for more durable goods I could definitely see a resurgence in US manufacturing with the right investments were made in extensive semi to full automation on the design/factory side. China factories are in a tough spot in the regard since employing more people is encouraged by the government, but automation eats away at the low end positions. See Foxconn's 1 Million+ employee count [1] and recently announced slowdown of automation take over [2]. [1] http://www.foxconn.com/Files/annual_rpt_e/2014_annual_rpt_e.pdf http://www.foxconn.com/Files/annual_rpt_e/2014_annual_rpt_e.... [2]http://www.computerworld.com/article/2941272/emerging-technology/foxconns-ceo-backpedals-on-robot-takeover-at-factories.html http://www.computerworld.com/article/2941272/emerging-techno...
- jseliger 11y agoThis is an important and so far underreported story. James Fallows has an excellent, similar piece from 2014: http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2014/10/made-in-america-again/379343 http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2014/10/made-in-...
- unquietcode 11y agoThere are health and environmental costs to fracking which are not being adequately addressed, and which are unsurprisingly ignored by this article. China was able to get a leg up through dirty coal and oil operations, but there are consequences to this. Some of their cities are today near uninhabitable, some are just unbearably smoggy. We definitely do not want to pat ourselves on the back for an economic boom that scars our country's land and water resources and affects the air water of countless individuals (citizens!). If we're going to build our economy on fracking, it should be heavily regulated. No entity should have the right to pump unknown chemicals into the ground with impunity and without oversight. And even with oversight--BP Horizon and every other avoidable oil disaster of the last 10 years.
- megablast 11y ago> China was able to get a leg up through dirty coal and oil operations, but there are consequences to this. No different to anywhere else in the world, just that it happened more recently.
- brianwawok 11y agoSource? I am honestly curious. I know for example that the US was very dirty in the early 1900s, but we had 100 million people. If China was dirty in the 2000s with 1.3 billion people, it stands to reason that China was more dirty, no?
- hawkice 11y agoTechnology has helped curb the absurd pollution that was the product of older processes. We don't have data from industrialization in the US, because we didn't have the tools to measure precisely the pollution at that time. But based on verbal descriptions of the pollution, China today might be similar to the US when it was industrializing. Specifically, historians note the frequency of days where pollution is so bad you can't see across the street, which used to happen in the US regularly yet infrequently, which is the same narrative description you'd see in China today.
- 11y ago
- PythonicAlpha 11y agoThis article grossly oversimplifies things. The shares of labor cost, energy cost and transportation cost are differing very much from industry to industry. Also, automate of the production of different products is differing very much. You can not compare for example car factoring with software development or food production. Of course, you can argue that cheap energy gives an industry an advantage. But what happens here are things that are independent of each other. For example, labor costs in China have risen and it gets more difficult to find cheap and adequate workers. Also you always should consider the consequences: Will the short-terim-advantage for some (!) industries really outweigh the long-term consequences?
- bobjordan 11y agoShenzhen China factory owner here. The costs are definitely rising in China for English speaking technical labor such as the engineers we need. We compete with companies like Apple and all the other foreign companies rushing to China these days to keep them employed. But we are still talking much lower salaries overall, for example, $30,000 USD/year for a degreed Sr. Electrical design engineer with 20 years experience. Regarding rents, the Shenzhen central business section rents are expensive now and cost/sqft comparable to anywhere else. However, good industrial space is still far cheaper, for example, I just leased an additional 12,000 sqft high quality assembly space with low ESD floors in a technical park along with 8 dorm rooms to sleep up to 32 people (4 per room - last owner had 8 per room). Lease on this new space cost me $3500 per month. There is also a kitchen ran by the tech park where they serve 3 hot buffet style meals per day for $2/day/worker. I'm not aware of anyplace in USA where you can lease a space like this for $0.29 per square foot nor get a buffet meal for $0.66 cents nor have door rooms for workers. Now, it is competitive to find this space and you need to lease when you find it not wait 1 day, it took us 4 months searching and we lost several spaces waiting 1-2 days, but it exists. But ultimately what is far cheaper here in China and the main reason I must remain here to make money is for the lower cost of the materials required to actually build the products. There is a critical mass of suppliers here where you can find half dozen capable suppliers for nearly anything you'd need to buy. For example we do a lot of custom molded plastic parts and many times I can make multiple cavity hard (300K shot life) injection mold tools for plastics for $3K-$5K USD and it would cost 5x or even 10x as much to buy them in USA. No less, bolts, nuts, screws, electronics all vastly cheaper here. Lastly, as someone else noted, the cost of shipping is much cheaper when you originate your shipping quotes from a Chinese account, especially for air shipping to USA, rates originating from my China company's Fedex account is routinely 50% cheaper than what Fedex quotes in the USA. This really adds up when you need to ship stuff around the world quickly.
- dereklei 11y agoCertainly one thing the article failed to mention is the critical mass of suppliers in China that makes manufacturing much more efficient in China than in the USA. Not sure how the USA is going to address that, but I honk the first step is to bring at least some of the manufacturing back to the USA and lower energy cost certainly helps start that.
- BenoitEssiambre 11y agoThe next manufacturing frontier to cross is sub-Saharan Africa. We are starting to see signs of it happening. For example, I just bought myself some great shoes ( https://www.oliberte.com/men/ https://www.oliberte.com/men/ ). Since it is the last large severely underdeveloped place with cheap, young capable labor and lots of natural resources, this might actually be manufacturing's final frontier.
- brianwawok 11y agoIs there enough political stability though? Outsider investors want some degree of stability to invest in large manufacturing plants. I am not a scholar in sub-saharan Africa, but I am not yet of the opinion that it is a stable place to set up shop.
- peteretep 11y agoAbout the same as Latin America, which is to say: in some places, yes, in some places not at all. Be happy to set up in Ghana...
- marcosdumay 11y agoSome places have, other don't. Africa is not homogeneous at all.
- jmngomes 11y ago...plus the big and traditional hurdles of corruption, and of getting customers to actually pay that longstanding invoice.
- tarikjn 11y agoOne thing that has given me pause in Africa though is the comparatively high price of food -- and energy, more obvious.
- fown9 11y agoChina has an authoritarian government that * is ruled by a secretive group of old men [1] * produces pollution that threatens the entire world [2] * uses the great firewall to attack tech companies in other countries like github [3] * ignores human rights and free speech [4] * creates artificial military island near neighboring countries [5] * supports dictators in Russia and Africa [6] * and prints up to 282% of GDP [7] in order to buy their way into other countries real estate and companies. If China gets anymore powerful, the world is doomed. We need to curb commerce with China. [1] http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-pacific-13904443 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-pacific-13904443 [2] http://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2013/02/08/reference/chinese-smog-bomb-floats-toward-japan/ http://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2013/02/08/reference/chines... [3] https://citizenlab.org/2015/04/chinas-great-cannon/ https://citizenlab.org/2015/04/chinas-great-cannon/ [4] http://www.theguardian.com/news/2014/dec/04/-sp-case-against-human-rights http://www.theguardian.com/news/2014/dec/04/-sp-case-against... [5] http://www.usnews.com/news/world/articles/2015/06/26/philippine-officials-say-china-island-building-in-full-swing http://www.usnews.com/news/world/articles/2015/06/26/philipp... [6] http://thediplomat.com/2014/03/china-backs-russia-on-ukraine/ http://thediplomat.com/2014/03/china-backs-russia-on-ukraine... [7] http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/wonkblog/wp/2015/02/11/chinas-increase-in-debt-is-massive-and-unsustainable/ http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/wonkblog/wp/2015/02/11/c...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mc32 11y agoOk, most or all that may be true, but it's quite immediately unrelated to the discussion, which is about the cost competitiveness of China compared to US manufacturing. And quite unrelated to the points of the person you're responding to.
- throwaway0628 11y agoYou can say much the same about the US (swap Russia and Africa for South America and Middle East). Besides, it's the only country that has ever used nuclear weapons on civilians. All super powers are threatening.
- sien 11y agoThis has been predicted for a while. This has been said as early as 2010 and possibly even before that by about 2015 costs would equalize. In 2013 there was an article in The Economist on this: http://www.economist.com/news/special-report/21569570-growing-number-american-companies-are-moving-their-manufacturing-back-united http://www.economist.com/news/special-report/21569570-growin... Here is a key quote from the article: "BCG used to argue that companies unwilling to send their manufacturing to lower-cost countries were putting their very future in jeopardy. Now it says that companies will bring manufacturing back to America from China. As soon as 2015, says Hal Sirkin, a consultant at the firm, it will cost about the same to manufacture goods for the American market in certain parts of America as in China in many industries, including computers and electronics, machinery, appliances, electrical equipment and furniture. That calculation takes into account a wide variety of direct costs, including labour, property and transport, as well as indirect ones such as supply-chain risk." Also worth noting is that the US is often a bigger market for some goods. But it's also worth noting that German and Japanese manufacturing has been more expensive that US manufacturing for decades and still in some areas Germany and Japan do very well. It's interesting to see an article that puts fracking up as the key reason. Energy costs are not irrelevant but are also often not a big part of the cost.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoI was going to mention this as well, thanks for finding the economist article. Manufacturing costs are more than just the price of parts, sending people to and from the factory several times, communicating requirements, Dealing with tariffs and customs. For smaller runs it is definitely getting competitive in the US, but so far the parts suppliers haven't yet picked up on this. I'm expecting a midwest town or two with good air/rail transport to figure this out and start a mini-manufacturing boomlet. Will be interesting to see.
- patrickk 11y agoAlso quality issues. If you want the absolute best industrial part/tool/whatever on the market, often you go to a mid sized German company no one has heard of and get it there. Strong apprenticeships and unions (meaning very high quality, loyal workers therefore low turnover) and an obsession with quality can all be important advantages in the competition with China: http://www.economist.com/news/business/21606834-many-countries-want-mittelstand-germanys-it-not-so-easy-copy-german-lessons http://www.economist.com/news/business/21606834-many-countri...
- vilmosi 11y agoIt's not about cost, it's about speed and scale, which China does very well.
- sfrealist 11y agoBut the US labor force is increasingly composed of African Americans (average IQ of 86) and Hispanics (90) [1], versus Chinese labor force consisting of Han Chinese (average IQ 106). Thus it still has no competitive advantage. 1.http://www.rlynn.co.uk/ http://www.rlynn.co.uk/
- noir_lord 11y agoSource? Because I'm calling bullshit on those figures, IQ tests are notoriously unreliable across cultural and societal boundaries. Hell even across economic boundaries within the same society.
- sfrealist 11y agoEdited to add one source, but there's a lot of literature on the subject, from Prof. Lynn to James Watson (Double helix discoverer), and William Shockley (transistor con-inventor): just look up the Wikipedia articles in them before these posts get whited out by the PC police here
- superiortoyou 11y ago>IQ tests are notoriously unreliable across cultural and societal boundaries That's irrelevant. What matters is what they _are_ reliable for.
- oksawe 11y agoHigher productivity equals lower wages. The busting of Unions, among a lot of other things, has kept wages stagnant at best over the past decade or so.
- douche 11y agoUnions are somewhat dependent on their members having skills, and cornering the market on that set of skills. If you can't keep the people that have the set of skills that you are unionizing around inside the union, then you can't expect much success.
- stutsmansoft 11y agoThey lost me at the very first sentence.
- dmritard96 11y agoThe supply chain is the principle advantage. Go to Hauquiangbei and show me the equivalent in the US. Then try and get tools made. It will be half or a third of the cost. Get something laser cut/SLAd/vacuum molded etc and it just doesn't compare. There is a larger supply of suppliers hence more competitive prices. Just go on alibaba and order a sheet of aluminum and do the same from virtually anyone in the US. Energy is important but many of these materials and parts aren't originating from the US hence you are paying to ship all the parts, then assemble in the US and then ship to the customer. Instead the factories in China buy in mass from local suppliers and ship the end product once. The cost structure just ends up being superior. There are a lot of scraps also. Not shipping those as a result of shipping final products is huge as well.
- godgod 11y agoUS can never compete with Chinese slave labor. 7 year olds work long hours...until this is fixed, the US can't compete.
- Animats 11y agoAs the tables in the article show, but the text does not, energy cost is a small fraction of manufacturing cost. It's only significant for certain kinds of heavy manufacturing; if you run a steel mill or aluminum smelter, it matters a lot. If you make smart watches, it's insignificant. Also, oil prices are worldwide, not local. (Natural gas is more local.) Labor costs matter far more. As a rule of thumb, it takes a 4x labor cost advantage to justify outsourcing to China by a US company. (For a China company to sell into the US requires less of a labor cost differential.)