26 ms·
Silicon Valley: Perks for Some Workers, Struggles for Parents
- TheBeardKing 12y agoHow can one not being a "culture fit" be interpreted in any way that is not blatant discrimination?
- Wohlf 12y agoNot having the desired personality or attitude type I would imagine.
- AngrySkillzz 12y agoBut what does that actually mean? Too shy? Too loud? Too uncultured? The concept of "cultural fit" is so vague it can easily be used to mask actual discrimination, along with general arbitrary "I don't like the cut of your jib" decisions.
- mhurron 12y ago> Too shy? Too loud? Too uncultured? Yes, yes, and yes, it can mean all of those things and more. > The concept of "cultural fit" is so vague it can easily be used to mask actual discrimination No kidding? Really? Wow, I hope no one else realizes this. It means whatever they want it to mean. It is a general, hand-wavy no that you can't really question.
- dreamdu5t 12y agoDiscrimination is normal and beneficial. We discriminate on skills, we discriminate on location, we discriminate on ability and style of communication, etc. Our whole team is very relaxed and smiles a lot. We aren't going to hire someone who is cynical, tense, and overly opinionated and has different values than us. That's culture fit. Yes, that is discrimination. But not based on gender, sexual orientation, race, or age.
- blhack 12y agoIt is discrimination. The question is if that discrimination is a bad thing or not. For instance: you are discriminating against people who don't know javascript if you are hiring for a job that requires javascript and don't hire people who don't know it. Is that a bad thing? I dont' think so. There are some things that we as a society have determined that it is not okay to discriminate based on. Here is a list of them: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protected_class http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protected_class
- mtviewdave 12y ago>The question is if that discrimination is a bad thing or not. In colloquial American usage, "discrimination" in the context of hiring and employment refers exclusively to judging people by illegal or inappropriate factors. >you are discriminating against people who don't know javascript if you are hiring for a job that requires javascript and don't hire people who don't know it. This may be an appropriate statement for other English-speaking countries, but in the US, this is a statement that borders on sophistry.
- gknoy 12y agoYou are discriminating ... if you are hiring for a job that requires javascript and don't hire people who don't know it. Is that a bad thing? I dont' think so. You might be overlooking good coworkers or employees, especially older ones who have experience in other languages. I knew zero Python or Javascript before I started this job, and now write in it 100% of the time. (My previous job was Lisp + GWT.) Similarly, I recall an article from Matasano that said that some of their best candiates did not have prior experience with something that one might have expected to be a prerequisite: "Some of the best testers we've worked with didn't have a formal security background." [0]. If you only hire people who "know" $Language, what will you do if six months down the line you decide to rewrite in Clojure, or find that Haskell is the best way to move forward? 0: http://matasano.com/careers/ http://matasano.com/careers/
- chamblin 12y agoOn one hand, startups strive very hard to become more diverse workplaces, believing that by having different kinds of people, more and better work will be done. On the other hand, "culture fit" bars exist so that any diversity achieved by such initiatives is entirely superficial.
- tikhonj 12y agoI mean, it is, but there is all sorts of cultural discrimination which many people find reasonable—if not actively positive. Not hiring somebody because you don't like their bearing, because they said something rude, because they posted something non-politically correct on Facebook, because they belong to some ill-favored political organization, because they don't conform to existing norms for hygine: all this is as much cultural fit as anything else.
- CountSessine 12y ago“Young people just have simpler lives,” Mark Zuckerberg, Facebook’s co-founder and chief executive, said in a talk to would-be entrepreneurs in 2007, when he was 23. “We may not own a car. We may not have family. Simplicity in life allows you to focus on what’s important.” Don't have kids so you can focus on what's important to Mark.
- sbov 12y agoI read that as "Simplicity in life allows you to focus on what's not important".
- mhurron 12y agoYa, well the quote is from a larger response regarding why it is hard for older (30+) people to get a job in Silicon Valley. It also included the phrase 'younger people are just smarter.' The point he was making was to only hire young people who do not have this distraction of an outside life to prevent them from burning themselves out for the almighty founder. It very much carries a 'so they can work at making me rich' vibe to it.
- srdev 12y ago"Important" was a bad choice of words on Mark's part, since its a value judgement that is necessarily going to differ from person to person.. However, he essential gist of what he's saying is true. If you don't have kids, you can spend more time focusing on things other than taking care of your kids. I'm a dad and it does take up a lot of time and limits what I can focus on. My only disagreement is based on a personal value judgement of whats important; raising a child is the most important thing to me, but that's not a universal truth for everyone.
- vizeroth 12y agoYour job should never overwhelm your ability to do something important with the rest of your life.
- 12y ago
- geebee 12y agoThis is another very important article about the difficulties of a career, rather than a stint, in high tech. I've noticed that many health-care related professionals, such as dental hygienists and registered nurses, have median pay that is close to or exceeds the median pay for software developers [1], and that well paid professionals such as dermatologists or radiologists often earn vastly more. These fields also offer what I'd describe as career flexibility. As a software developer, I can almost always go off and have a cup of coffee when I please. So in that sense, yes, it is "flexible." But one very attractive quality of being a dental hygienist is that you can step back from the field for a few years, work part time (or not at all), and re-enter a few years later. My cousin is a radiologist, and she worked half time while she had kids (collecting a much higher salary than the typical full time developer). I also know an emergency room physician who was able to scale back while she had small kids without badly compromising her career progress. Add in open offices, back visibility, a dave n busters vibe, mass layoffs involving work visas and "knowledge transfer", frequent allegations of sexism and discrimination, an insistence that you locate to a place where the median 3br house is well over a million… and now, as it appears, a situation where you they don't want you if you have kids. At this point, why do we keep acting like there's some mystery why people with choice (i.e., whose professional options aren't limited by the visa process) are avoiding this field? Why does President Obama nod gravely as he stands next to tech CEOs talking about severe shortages of tech workers at press releases? [1] check out US News Best Jobs, which provides a summary of BLS data on median salary by region. In San Francisco, dental hygienists earn $112,970, software developers $114,400, and registered$127,670. Physicians and lawyers, of course earn considerably more.
- maudineormsby 12y agoDental hygenists also only work 3-4 days a week. I'm told this is just the way the job works (usually they are 3 days at one office and 1 day at another if they desire). There's also the wear and tear on your body from crouching over someone with vibrating tools.
- geebee 12y agoI usually add this to my comment above: I have absolutely no doubt that dental hygienists and registered nurses work hard, and deserve their compensation. In SF, they are well paid, and nurses tend to poll high in occupational prestige.
- maudineormsby 12y agoI'm a developer in SF, and I moved here 2 1/2 years ago on a relocation package from a startup. Immediately I realized that I would be the only parent in the office (there was one other remote worker with kids) once my wife and I decided to have a child. And sure enough that's what happened. I actually lost my job there (for unrelated reasons) and it was an enormous relief to be out of that culture. In addition to children, I am religious and have obligations to my church, which were frowned upon (tacitly) by my coworkers. Nobody said anything, but I was the only one leaving work at 3 on Good Friday and 5:30 every Wednesday so I could be at church. In hindsight I can see what I couldn't see before - the article is right in suggesting that single, young people are unencumbered by obligations. But it misses the point that we choose what obligations to tie ourselves to around the age that most people are starting at these startups - I chose wife, children, church. They're choosing company, work, and technology. It's not that different in principle, but it's a huge behavioral difference.
- EliRivers 12y agoNobody said anything, but I was the only one leaving work at 3 on Good Friday and 5:30 every Wednesday so I could be at church. 5:30, sure, that's end of day anyway, but if I zipped out at 3 to engage in my social hobby, I'd expect some frowning too.
- Chinjut 12y agoA world where we frown upon anyone having anything important to them outside of their employer is a sad world to live in indeed.
- EliRivers 12y agooffice culture — which can, for example, reward people based on how many lines of code they can write per week I'm not convinced... even the least hip of startups isn't this stupid.
- mindfulgeek 12y agoTechnology across the board is not family or parenting friendly -- in my experience. It seems like it would be, given the technology tools that make remote working and flexible work environments possible. I recently was let go from my director of engineering position when I was 9 months pregnant. They said they were outsourcing their operations, but I was the only team-member let go. I also would be on maternity leave during a critical release... I can't say they let me go since I was going to have a baby, -- I think their decision to outsource made sense. I just think it was a catalyst as there was zero transition plan and probably would have been too hard to let me go during or right after maternity leave, which would have made more strategic sense. I seriously consider leaving technology for good after dealing with the challenges of being a woman, mother and engineer for so many years. I'm not alone, its pretty common for women to leave technology after having kids. There is such a push to have more women become technologists, but if we leave once we become parents, what's the gain? The struggles of culture and technology are far deeper than getting more young women to be interested in engineering. Women aren't the only ones to suffer. It's hard for men too. The culture also seeps into the quality of products we create -- in both design and code. Unfortunately, I have only seen the culture become more toxic as time goes on, not less. Maybe I'm jaded. I'm certainly sick of it.
- guyzero 12y agoHopefully you don't work for my employer, but even if you do, please sue them into the bottom of a very deep pit.
- dreamdu5t 12y agoI mean well and this is not directed at you personally, but I don't get why employers should be forced to pay for someone's choice to have children. Unless that is their choice as well. I would like to spend many hours of the day on my art. I don't want children. Should my employer be forced to continue to pay me if I want to go spend a year focusing on my art? Why is a couple's (or a mothers) choice to have children more important than what I choose to do in life?
- leothekim 12y ago
- bobsky 12y agoAmerica's lack of guaranteed Parental Leave is already a shameful situation for such rich and developed country; it doesn't even compare to anything out there where every OECD country has such protections. [0] But I believe the tide is turning, and companies that embrace this human right will be rewarded with higher quality employees. As entrepreneurs and leaders ourselves, we have the opportunity to set the culture we want. So I must congratulate and highlight how one YC startup, AeroFS, is standing up and making a difference: "..AeroFS employees of any gender are eligible for: 10 weeks leave, paid at 100% of salary, 8 weeks additional leave, paid at 50% of salary, and *10 weeks additional unpaid leave—or more, if approved .." [1] [0] http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2013/12/12/among-38-nations-u-s-is-the-holdout-when-it-comes-to-offering-paid-parental-leave/ http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2013/12/12/among-38-nat... [1] https://www.aerofs.com/blog/parental-leave-at-aerofs/ https://www.aerofs.com/blog/parental-leave-at-aerofs/
- jdhawk 12y agoThe US system has always treated vacation, healthcare, ____ leave as BENEFITS, and expected the market to provide them as necessary. Sadly, the supply has never met the demand, and it will probably take legislation to make this universal reality. Considering how awesome our legislature is at making fair and just policies, I wouldnt hold my breath
- jobposter1234 12y agoI'm sure it's not shameful. It might bug you, but I don't see it as something worthy of shame. I do not have kids, do not plan to have kids, so I'm not sure why I should pay for someone else's decisions to create life. Whenever someone goes on family leave, other people who were not involved with that decision have to pick up the slack. Now, maybe if I could take paid (or unpaid) leave-of-my-discretion as an alternative, I'd be okay with it. Otherwise, it feels like federal level discrimination against unmarried, child-less, individuals.
- emodendroket 12y agoAnd while we're at it, I'm not currently ill, so why should I have to pay for disability benefits for others? I'm not old, so why should I have to pay for Social Security?
- 727374 12y agoLast time I interviewed, I actually strategized to mention our infant multiple times when talking to people. If that will turn off some orgs, I really don't want to work for them. I ended up finding a job at a great company this way. Being able to filter out so many companies that don't care about you having a life outside of work definitely feels like a luxury made possible by the current high demand for skilled tech workers, which is a little worrying.
- gaius 12y agoactually strategized to mention our infant multiple times when talking to people I hope you understand that by doing so, you placed your interviewers in a very awkward position. It would be the same if you revealed to them your e.g. religion or sexual orientation, when they never asked. It smells like you were setting them up for a future lawsuit.
- krschultz 12y agoSo it's ok for a company to say "he's not a culture fit", but not ok for an employee to say "that company is not a culture fit"? The reason every startup asks "so what do you like to do for fun" in interviews is that kind of "cultural" fishing. The OP is just flipping the game around.
- gaius 12y agoThat's not what I said, I am talking specifically about an interview. A company is not allowed to ask you about your family plans, religion, sexual orientation, blah blah, and for good reason, these things are nothing to do with job performance, yet may be the basis of discrimination. It's therefore in poor taste to "force" your interviewer into knowing something they should not and would never have asked.
- walterbell 12y agoOne societal and corporate response to such laws could be to encourage supportive work environments for various subgroups. In that scenario, the interviewer would pre-emptively advertise employee benefits which are relevant to all candidate subgroups, obviating the need for candidates to ask identifying questions. It's therefore in poor societal taste to "force" your candidate into asking questions which are specific to one subgroup.
- kirinkalia 12y agoOne of the commenters on the NY Times site said it best: "My experience is that a lot depends on your boss. I always got my work done quickly and thoroughly, but I've had bosses who made you sit in your chair even when there was nothing to do, I've had other bosses who were much more accommodating. It is about the culture of the department. My best job was in a very hard working engineering department, when we were on deadline we worked killer hours, but when things were slack, we went home. Everyone had kids, family outings were encouraged and our boss took us to lunch and treated us like humans. I worked my butt off for that boss. When I have had a boss who treats me like a child, I act like one. If you treat people with dignity and respect and give them time off when they need it, they will work harder."
- phubbard 12y agoReciprocity is the most-basic of interactions. Wish more people understood it better. Unfortunately, it seems like kiss up, kick down prevails.
- bluedino 12y ago>> Bret Taylor, former chief technology officer at Facebook and a founder of Quip, with his son Sam and daughter Jasmine. >> He leaves work at 5:30 p.m. so that his employees will not feel obligated to stay. Bret is pictured in his expensive home, standing in front of a gas range that was at least $10,000. He can afford to take it easy. He's already sacrificed and put in the 16 hour days.
- emodendroket 12y agoSo what's your argument? He should actually work late? Working sixteen-hour days actually reduces productivity so much that someone who does it regularly gets much less done than someone who's in at 9 and out at 5.
- 2late2apologize 12y agoThe OP's argument (I believe) makes an unjustified assumption that the CEO is falsely implying falsely that people who leave at 5:30 can make it to the C-Suite. That assumption lies in the subtext of an experienced, well paid, successful individual encouraging a work-practice that he did not follow himself. Read literally, the CEO is making no such claim about career (and wealth) advancement at his company beyond "you won't be intentionally penalized for leaving at 5:30."
- emodendroket 12y agoWell, if it's true that people who leave on time can't do that I'd argue it has more to do with signaling than with actually being productive. Everything I've ever read about productivity suggests regularly working long hours makes your productivity go through the floor to the point that there is not any net benefit.
- 2late2apologize 12y agoI agree with you and have read similar studies/articles. Hours worked is a useless signal at best and a misleading signal at worst. (as an aside, I also believe the 40hr work week is a waste for both companies and employees) Number of hours a superficial signal that it easy to imitate. People know that productive "hustlers", "gamechangers" "showrunners" get promoted. They tend to know who the hustlers are and thus they know that hustling often requires more than 8 productive hours a day of work. So they stay after hours despite diminishing returns and lower median throughput. Once a large enough percentage of the imitators stay afterhours, now your average operational employee has to stay in order to conform to the perceived status quo. So I agree with with the CEO leaving early as long as he enforces a culture that not only encourages people leaving at 5:30, but penalizes people who stay late. Then the hustlers will follow, and then the imitators will follow and the operational staff will feel comfortable to have their 40 hour work week.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- startupstella 12y agoRight now, good parental leave, flexible work hours, and allowing remote work allows companies to have a competitive advantage when hiring. For example, this article (link below) on Treehouse was popular last month which talked about how they have 4 day work weeks because it's not a drag on productivity and people want to spend time with kids. I work at Trello, and the company has a similar philosophy in terms of treating people like humans who have responsibilities and interests that enrich them outside of work, which only benefits the work environment. A big draw to working at Trello, in addition to loving the product and team, is the fact that these policies exist. I hope in the future- "perks" like paid parental leave will become something we laugh about as being painfully obvious. Who cares when work gets done as long as it gets done? Treehouse link-http://www.washingtonpost.com/local/at-some-start-ups-fridays-are-so-casual-everyone-can-stay-home/2015/02/06/31e8407e-9d1c-11e4-96cc-e858eba91ced_story.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/local/at-some-start-ups-friday... We're hiring at Trello!- http://trello.com/jobs http://trello.com/jobs
- brryant 12y agoWhat bothers me most about this article is that it chooses to fixate on the "new" tech industry where 20-hour days, and complete dedication to your job are common. However, why does the author not mention the finance industry? Hundred hour weeks have always been the norm, and new mothers are encouraged to come back to work as soon as possible or risk missing their next promotion. Some would argue that finance is even more male-dominated than tech, and because of this it makes working at a big bank/fund even more difficult for parents. Same is true of healthcare, and big law. There are plenty of industries that suffer from unfriendly family workplaces, not just the tech industry. I'd love to read an article that attempts to compare how family friendly different industries are for parents, but unfortunately only a large, costly survey can provide the non-subjective data readers can appreciate.
- makeitsuckless 12y agoWe could go all the way down the list, parent-unfriendly, sexist, agists etcetera, but it's way simpler to describe SV culture as what it is: an immature frat boy culture. Amplified by the lack of government regulation in the US in general. When it comes right down to what really matters, when you see through all the fancy "perks", what remains is a business culture that is not just immature, but downright conservative to the point of being reactionary. I mean, what kind of 21st century Western company that employs highly educated middle class people doesn't facilitate parenthood?
- serve_yay 12y ago> When it comes right down to what really matters, when you see through all the fancy "perks", what remains is a business culture that is not just immature, but downright conservative to the point of being reactionary. Honest question, do you really believe this?
- alexashka 12y ago"I mean, what kind of 21st century Western company that employs highly educated middle class people doesn't facilitate parenthood?" Ones that are in do-or-die mode. You know, facebook, amazon, google, etc? All these companies could be irrelevant 10 years from now and they know it. It's war out there for these folks. Facilitating parenthood is the government's job, not the employer's. The employer who's out to create wants young and ambitious, managed by older and wiser. Think of the NFL - the land of concussions and wrecked super-athletes. Who facilitates the strongest and most athletic to mindlessly hurt themselves in exchange for some drunk fans' entertainment? The culture we're living in :) Sacrificing the young and the brave in the name of pretty shallow returns is quite common. All we're seeing is the mental athletes getting their social-life concussed. They oftentimes don't know what they're missing to be honest, they're not terribly social to begin with. Besides, they can retire to a sane company anytime and build up their life outside of work - you can't say the same for somebody who almost made it to the NFL, screwed up his knee and is now working god knows where.
- ddoolin 12y agoYou make it sound like they have some kind of moral objection to parenting. I'm very certain it's motivated by fiscal conservatism nearly all the time. To answer your question: ones that don't have a lot of money to dole out to parents/soon-to-be parents.
- sbov 12y agoThe funny thing being: actively avoiding parents, while simultaneously complaining about the lack of tech workers. New workers with the aptitude you're looking for don't magically spring forth from php code you hacked on for 20 hours per day. But, short term thinking.
- aestetix 12y agoI think a major reason that Americans expect employers to give them maternity leave (among other things) is that health benefits are covered through your job. Getting fired while pregnant, while difficult, would not be nearly the same disaster if you were still able to get necessary medical treatment in the duration.
- serve_yay 12y agoI see a lot of problems with our society or our economy generally, discussed only within the context of technology. I mean, what, is finance a wonderland for parents? Not that it excuses tech of course, but sheesh.
- nbm 12y agoFWIW, Sheryl Sandberg also leaves work at 5:30pm to spend time with her kids - strange that something she's been talking about for some time (before Bret left Facebook, even) isn't mentioned. The Facebook hackathons used to start at like 6pm with the implicit expectation that one worked through the night (and weren't expected to work the next day), but these days they start during the day (the next one is 9:30am). There's still time to work all-night if that's your thing, though. One thing I noticed at a previous hackathon was one of our engineering VPs showing their kids around. I've seen a few parents doing that - often their spouse will bring their kids to visit for dinner and to spend some time, sometimes they go back together, or the kids and spouse heading home for bedtime. Not sure if that's a "this is how I get through this horrible expectation people have of me" or "this is how I blend these two parts of my life that I value", but I'm hopeful it is the latter.
- jeffbush 12y agoI've read a lot of articles with this general tone and theme over the last year or so, and they always bother me, for a number of reasons. They tend to paint the overall industry with a very broad brush, and are, in my experience, often caricatures (this one certainly isn't the worst). This article is based mostly on anonymous anecdotes and is peppered with weasel words, for example: "More broadly, some economists say..." "Workers with children say..." The one piece of data I saw, the number of women in the workforce, has a truncated Y scale. I've lived and worked in Silicon Valley at tech companies for the last 17 years at many small and large high tech companies, including Apple. My wife also has been working in tech for longer than that, and she enjoys it. I have two young children. When I read these articles, I feel like I'm reading about another universe, as it is so vastly different than my experience. Of course, I can only offer my own anecdotes in response, but here are a few of mine: - My wife interviewed at a small startup when she was pregnant with our first son. During the interviews, she informed them she was pregnant and wasn't sure how much time she wanted to take off after the baby was born. They were totally cool about it and said they'd be happy to have her for as long as they could. She ended up working there and loved it. - I'm 40 years old. The people who work with me are a mix of ages. I've rarely been the oldest, and I certainly don't feel like I'm outnumbered by people much younger than me. I've interviewed at a number of companies with young founders, and never felt discriminated against. I still get pinged by plenty of recruiters, so I'm not seeing the ageism that is supposedly so rampant here. I have plenty of friends and acquaintances who are close to my age, and I'm not hearing these complaints from them either. Honestly, I think this is sloppy journalism, designed to provoke an emotional reaction. I don't want to deny the very real problems in this industry that we should be working on, but I don't think articles like this are helping. If anything, they are scaring women and minorities away from the industry and making the diversity problem worse.
- slantedview 12y agoYour experience is hopeful, but in no way negates the reality of other people's experiences which are the opposite of yours.
- jeffbush 12y ago
- slantedview 12y agoThis article reminds me of the HN post about the newly planned Google office, where the renderings featured young twentysomethings, almost exclusively. Considering the Zuckerberg comment, we have to realize that ageism in tech is not only wrong, it's not sustainable. We all age. As this article mentions, twentysomething grads will become thirtysomething parents. Building a tech culture that ignores this fact is ridiculous, but it's our current reality.
- michaelochurch 12y agoConsidering the Zuckerberg comment, we have to realize that ageism in tech is not only wrong, it's not sustainable. What we have to do is make sure that all of the older engineers who "age out of" the Valley move to the same place: could be Chicago, Boulder, Austin, maybe Portland or even Minneapolis. Probably not NYC (I'm fond of it, but it's too expensive to raise a family). Doesn't matter where so much as that the place exists. If any one urban area can capture 15% of the programmers who age out of the Valley, for a decade or two, it'll have more talent than that shithole and be able to out-compete it.
- mavelikara 12y ago+1 for Portland.
- serve_yay 12y agoAgeism isn't even on the radar, my friend. And it's ironic too, because as you mention, it affects every one of us. But the current hot topics are diversity and gender discrimination. No problem there, but I have noticed that even people who take those two issues very seriously implicitly blow off the ageism thing. I think people just do not want to acknowledge that they're going to get older too, I think they put it out of their minds. I've literally had a conversation with someone who said he wanted to make sure we don't just hire a bunch of people like him (i.e., white males who went to the same college he did). Then a few minutes later he made a snide remark about "some old guy" (the old guy was an engineer he was unfamiliar with). So, I am very pessimistic about the prospect of this issue getting any real attention.
- 12y ago
- mathattack 12y agoMy 2 cents... I'm a reforming Jerk Manager. When I was late 20s and early 30s, single and travelled full time, I believed that everyone should commit 100% to the project. My rationale was, "Winning breeds positive mindsets" and not the other way around. I really abused some folks that were married with kids. Now the shoe is on the other foot, and I have to worry about working for a jerk like the younger version of myself. The one thing I can say is that as a parent, it's good to work at a place where the management team is all from in-town, and most have kids. Almost all the managers at my current employer have young kids. This means that "office hours" are 10-5, with a ton of flexibility, and nobody bothers you until 9 at night. But the trade-off is that everyone is expected to be online until 1 or 2 in the morning if needed (after the kids go down) and be current on their email first thing in the morning before coming in to the office. I feel very bad for the people who were laid off when pregnant.
- ddoolin 12y agoI'm 23 and never, ever reveal that I have a wife and 2 sons until after an offer has been made. I suppose potential employers could find out fairly easily, but I know very well from personal experience that start ups do not like when I tell them about my family life, so I leave it off the table until I'm ready, despite it not inhibiting my ability to work just as hard and for as long as my single coworker counterparts. I guess it really depends on the size of the company, and it's really something you have to kind of feel out for yourself. Naturally I haven't really had this problem with large companies, only small teams.
- dataker 12y agoI sympathize with SF parents, but one must understand the nature of the job and try to work with it. As a software engineer, I know I must work towards a path that allows me to prosper as a father and have time for my family. SF/Wall Street/ Hollywood/... all have their own problems, which is a side effect of their excellence. Yes, WS analysts work 100h/week, but that's how the industry works. The key is to work with, not against, it.
- SovietDissident 12y agoThe harder you make it to fire someone, the more reticent the employer will be to hire that person in the first place. This may apply to employees generally, or to a specific race, gender, or subclass. For example, after the Americans With Disabilities Act was passed, it led to a decrease in the employment of people with disabilities. If the employer has a higher likelihood of lawsuit in the event that the employee must be let go, they have to make damn sure they can't find someone else (who isn't disabled) to fill the position in the first place. The existence of this sort of legislation actually exacerbates the employment problem for minorities and women in tech! http://object.cato.org/sites/cato.org/files/serials/files/regulation/2000/4/deleire.pdf http://object.cato.org/sites/cato.org/files/serials/files/re...
- AstroChimpHam 12y agoIf you're at a start-up and some unforeseen problem occurs that needs to get fixed right now, and you're the only person who can fix it: yes the start-up expects you to fix it before you can pick up little Suzie from soccer practice. Yes, they will hire the person most likely to make that choice. If they don't do that, their chance of failure is much higher. We make sacrifices to work in some areas of tech, and we get paid well to put work before most other priorities because that's what's needed in some (not all) tech jobs. If you want to put kids as a priority before work, that's fine. There are plenty of jobs in tech you can take, but don't expect the same positions as the lady who puts work above all else and consistently delivers when stuff's on fire. She's devoting more of her life to the company and deserves a better title and more pay.
- s73v3r 12y ago90% of those "Must be fixed right now!" problems aren't, and no one will die because the problem didn't get fixed for another hour.
- AstroChimpHam 12y agoIf you don't trust your coworkers' ideas about what needs to be fixed right now, that's a separate issue.
- katielo 12y agoAs a young woman developer this is a very saddening article to read, and especially upsetting the comments of women engineers being let go while/because they became pregnant. My hope is that the industry will become more balanced as the many millennials working in tech start families...
- ageek123 12y agoI guess it is completely lost on the NY Times that one of the main reasons the tech industry is the main engine of economic growth in the US (and one of the few things we do better than other countries) is exactly BECAUSE many companies expect long hours and hard work. We can certainly switch to the European lifestyle the NY Times is fawning over, but it's going to have a huge negative impact on the success of our country's tech companies.
- ProAm 12y agoYou may be right (I doubt it though) but that is a horrible reason not treat employee's as if they are human beings. Good culture isnt having free snacks and a ping pong table.
- zxcvvcxz 12y agoShould employees at larger, established firms be able to demand parental benefits? For sure, it's healthy for the organization to help their employees (often the more senior and experienced) achieve their life goals of starting a family. But should startups be required to do the same? Is it discrimination if they don't? This is where it gets blurry. Let's say me and a friend start working on something. Someone is being considered as a potential co-founder. During the vetting period, I learn that they are about to become a parent, and will need certain logistical allowances for the next 6-18 months. I decide to pass on this person - at this stage in the company (very early), everyone needs to be able to hustle long hours. I can't risk having a cofounder not put in the sweat. Dead weight kills startups. So to me passing seems fair. Keep in mind I didn't even mention if the company was incorporated; if it wasn't, surely you can't call this "discrimination" in a legal sense. Two guys just decided not to partner with a third person. If it was just incorporated yesterday and I make this decision, do things realistically change? The company is at pretty much the same point - 2 people who need more that can work long, hard hours. But what if we're now 5 people and one key employee stops pulling their weight because of family obligations? I don't have the resources to support them in this manner, so I either have to let them go or keep on the dead weight. The first option reads like "discrimination", while the second seriously messes up my startup (imagine I could replace him with a similar skillset person). And you could think of the same scenario at 10 people, 15, 30, 50, 100, etc. As final food for thought, > The American workplace has always prized people who prioritize work over family, and European countries have long had more generous policies for working parents. But in the last two decades, that gap has widened significantly. Other developed countries have expanded benefits like paid parental leave and child care, while the United States has not. Yes, but who's leading the world in technological growth? Certainly I can't claim causation either way, but simple logic implies that more work means more growth and tech. Scanning through the comments, it seems like the readership here would rather re-balance this in favor of more benefits and less work (thus meaning less growth and tech). Remember you don't get to have all of both. So that's great and all, but are you justified in trying to impose this upon Silicon Valley? SV started like this because a bunch of people with the opposite opinions got together so they could work hard and drive progress as much as possible - sacrificing in the process. Should they leave, or should you? I suppose the answer is to vote for the political representatives that support your world view. However, I'd argue that it'd be a bad thing, on a moral level, to enact policy against the SV hard work culture. I worry that too much lobbying will result in restricted options for employers and entrepreneurs which would ultimately drive progress down. I believe technological progress is a moral issue; we need our high-performers and hard-workers to cure diseases, combat food scarcity, create better hardware, etc. And we need a place where they can congregate.
- bagacrap 12y agoI don't understand this article. It fails to mention that tech companies have the best paid parental leave policies[1]. There are other family-oriented perks: on top of normal life insurance at Google, "The surviving spouse or partner of a deceased employee will also acquire vested stock benefits, and children will receive $1,000 a month until the age of 19. The timeline can be extended if the child is in school full time."[2] I bet there are more perks at other companies which I'm not aware of. The article is full of anecdote and false implications. So, "Yahoo told employees they could no longer work from home." If you are working from home because you're taking care of your children, I think it's fairly reasonable to expect that your attention is split and you won't be as productive. Much of it describes the work habits of top execs. I don't think that's representative of the industry as a whole, and probably aligns pretty well with work habits of top execs of other industries. [1] http://www.buzzfeed.com/susiearmitage/tech-companies-offer-workers-the-most-paid-parental-leave#.ooe73qaoN http://www.buzzfeed.com/susiearmitage/tech-companies-offer-w... [2] http://mashable.com/2012/08/09/google-employee-death-benefits/ http://mashable.com/2012/08/09/google-employee-death-benefit...
- cesarbs 12y agoI think the point of the article was to point out that while tech companies supposedly have perks for people with families, those are rarely enjoyed to their full extent due to diverse factors. And also that those tech companies might say they offer a family friendly environment, but depending on your team, the culture will not reflect that. I've experienced a bit of that. It's hard not to feel bad for going home at 5pm to be with your family when all the driven single 20-somethings around you will continue to work late into the night and produce a lot more than you.
- tnorthcutt 12y agoBret Taylor, former chief technology officer at Facebook and a founder of Quip, with his son Sam and daughter Jasmine. He leaves work at 5:30 p.m. so that his employees will not feel obligated to stay. Why not leave work at 5:30 p.m. so that his kids will get to see him before bed?
- jim_greco 12y agoHere's my New Yorker perspective: Everyone I know who has a job that pays them $150k-300k a year doesn't have much work/life balance. Jobs in finance/law/tech are all consuming and the pay is commensurate with that. This seems little odd signaling out tech.
- cesarbs 12y agoOn a somewhat related note, I find it interesting to note that a lot of technology per se is not very family friendly. Family Sharing was only recently introduced by Apple. Before that, it was very cumbersome for a couple to share their music libraries. The same applies to most subscription services. Take Amazon for example: my wife can share free Prime shipping with me, but not Prime Music. I wonder if this is for legal reasons (licensing, etc.) or because of the people that create such services. My wife's hypothesis is that since a lot of technology is created by single, young and not very social people, it doesn't even cross their mind at design time the fact that a couple (or a whole family) might want to share some of their contents while still keeping their own individual accounts.
- sireat 12y agoI was shocked on how little time off my US friends got for having kids. Most fathers kept on working and mothers were back to work within a week to month of having a baby. This practice of encouraging mothers to return to work so quickly seemed like a relic of some era of one wage earner families. How can Europe and US be so different in this regard, when the demographic problems should be similar?
- fsloth 12y agoStrangely, the discussion around this article seems to indicate to me that children seem to be looked as trophies for their parents. Children are as necessary for the society as a body as is food and sleep for individual humans. I understand the individualism that drives peoples toward libertarian ideals but children are beyond market mechanisms. They are part of our humanity, the structure without any efforts towards economical or other goals are pointless. A child is not like a new SUV or an expensive hobby. A healthy, happy child is a net plus for the society to which he or she is born, that benefit all in the long term.
- cafard 12y agoI would point out that a lot of these perks are meant to keep the employees working longer hours. Parenthood and longer work hours go only so well together.