17 ms·
PC Gamer recommends RSS readers in a 37mb article that just keeps downloading
- nslsm 8mo ago[flagged]
- userbinator 8mo ago"misconfigured" as in no adblocker? ;-)
- adampunk 8mo agoPost a network recording of that page loading from a code start on your machine. I’ll believe chrome devtools.
- Koffiepoeder 8mo ago(Note that if OP considers to do this, they probably want to do this in a private tab, as to not leak potential sensitive cross-site cookies)
- jonathanlydall 8mo agoSounds like the author is running the same browser configuration as the vast majority of internet users. While I use ad-blockers and the like, I know I’m far from the norm.
- 3842056935870 8mo ago5 min in, after only scrolling to the bottom of the article: 4300 requests, 238 MB downloaded With Firefox and all extensions disabled
- FractalParadigm 8mo agoThe author's complaint(s) stem from the ads that "just keeps downloading" which in approximately five minutes downloaded "almost half a gigabyte" worth of information. This is a prime example of why many people use adblockers, it's not just to make the majority of the web actually usable, but it prevents excessive data transfers that we never asked for. For what it's worth, the same article is just a hair over 8MB when ads are blocked and a hair over 9MB when you scroll down (loading the thumbnails for the other articles).
- Sardtok 8mo ago8 MB for an article about setting up an RSS reader is still ridiculous. Should be <1MB, the text itself is probably a few K, so all the rest is graphics and bullshit JS bundles.
- mrweasel 8mo agoDisabling Privacy Badger, reloading the site and scrolling around a bit, I can comfortably stay that the author is wrong, the site is much larger. Within two minutes the site has now transfered 50MB (of 75MB) according to Firefox, but it does indeed keep going, constantly loading more and more stuff in the background.
- simonw 8mo agoI left that page open in Firefox on macOS (no ad blockers) and after five minutes the network devtools panel showed me it had hit 200MB transferred, 250MB total from over 2,300 requests.
- goldenarm 8mo agoI'm trying to migrate to 100% RSS right now, to avoid the hateful algorithmic editorialization of modern social media. And I'm shocked that almost no paid media provides full articles in RSS anymore, and force me to navigate their 37MB pages with popups all over the place. Has anyone found a solution against that ? Edit : Sorry I'm asking specifically about paywalled stuff
- righthand 8mo agoReader mode + ad blocker
- bryancoxwell 8mo agoFurther: configure reader mode as the default for the sites you’re most commonly linked to.
- impure 8mo agoThere are readers with a 'full text mode' which will fetch the website and display it in something like Mozilla's Readability view. It does not always work, especially if the page is paywalled but it works for most sites.
- goldenarm 8mo agoMost quality journals are paywalled nowadays, I'm considering to scrape using my cookie, or maybe use archive.is..
- 1bpp 8mo agoFor a lot of sites Firefox's reader mode is great at bypassing paywalls, just turn it on & refresh
- hedora 8mo agoIf you're paying, there's probably a way to get a RSS feed for paid subscribers. If you can't find it, maybe email tech support? This is how all the podcasts I donate to work (they offer ad-free feeds, bonus episodes, etc, usually with some url like https://rss.podcastsite.com/show?token=<random code>, and then in my podcast app, it either says "Some show - Paid feed", or sometimes "Some show - your name's feed".
- Blikkentrekker 8mo agoWell, it's otherwise “free” to read the article so I guess this is how one “pays” in the end. I wonder how this works on mobile data though which is significantlym more expensive than home network data.
- MBCook 8mo agoThe title buried the lede. > In the five minutes since I started writing this post the website has downloaded almost half a gigabyte of new ads. I’m guessing this is due to autoplaying videos. *500 MB* in 5 minutes. 37 MB is petite compared to that.
- dbtc 8mo agoNah, in my opinion the original title is art. That line is a whopper though.
- MBCook 8mo agoOh the rest of the title is great. But if it was me I don’t think I could avoid putting the five on the front of the number. This is right up there with those articles from Wired or whoever about why you shouldn’t give out your email, that when you open them there’s a prompt to subscribe to their email list.
- timpera 8mo agoDownloading 500 MB in 5 minutes in the background of a random article is really disrespectful to readers on low-end devices or metered data plans (and these two groups are often the same people!). What a waste of ressources.
- qingcharles 8mo agoI've worked with a lot of people at the bottom end of society in the USA. They are given government provided phones they can use so they have access to Google Maps, email, job search apps etc. These phones come with 3GB of regular data per month. After that they drop down to 2G speed, but not in a way that will allow anything to actually load. Three days into the month these phones are just ewaste.
- deleted 8mo ago[deleted]
- 8mo ago
- simonw 8mo agoThis is so upsetting. No wonder people spend more time in mobile apps than they do using the mobile web - the default web experience on so many sites is terrible.
- MBCook 8mo agoI’ve been using the Reddit app some lately after being a longtime old.Reddit.com + blocker person. Ignoring how [ad] navigation is kinda annoying [ad] the shear [ad] number of ads [ad] they [ad] insert [ad] is insane. The only good thing is none of them seem to be animated/video. Which is an incredibly low bar, but most sites can’t even jump that.
- dwayne_dibley 8mo agoI'll probably leave reddit when old.Reddit.com gets the chop
- MBCook 8mo agoI suspect I will too. I’ve been playing with the app a bit as it’s easier for me on my phone to view subs that are mostly pictures (e.g. awuariums). But I only do it from time to time. Apollo was much better, of course.
- ericd 8mo agoSame, but it sounds like Lemmy still has some issues, and it'll be hard to replace some of the niche subreddits.
- qingcharles 8mo agoThis is the problem. There's no good replacement for Reddit right now, and Digg just died again.
- MBCook 8mo agoI’m honestly amazed they tried that. It’s been so long, it felt like a play to cache in on the name but I feel like a huge chunk of people don’t really remember it or weren’t even around for it.
- m463 8mo agothis just reminds me of... - watching "normal" cable tv - listening to "normal" fm radio - shopping on amazon (sponsored... everything)
- add-sub-mul-div 8mo agoA difference between cable and streaming is that cable has DVRs that let you skip commercials if you want, while streaming tech introduced unskippable ads.
- vel0city 8mo ago> cable has DVRs that let you skip commercials if you want The last time I had DirecTV several channels had managed to have unskippable ads in recordings. Paramount was egregious with this and was the first channel I saw with this "feature" enabled.
- add-sub-mul-div 8mo agoI've never seen that. That's terrible. The people who put up with streaming enshittification are ruining it for the rest of us by normalizing it.
- vel0city 8mo agoTo be fair, this was almost a decade ago.
- MBCook 8mo agoThis is why I pay to get rid of ads in things I like. Podcasts and TV are the big ones. I just started watching season 2 of Jury Duty on Amazon. I had deleted the app when they announced that as a paying subscriber I would be getting ads. Oh my God the ads are so horrible. So much worse than I remember. Also, extra kudos to Amazon for nearly doubling the price of removing the ads the week before the show came out. How nice of them.
- notepad0x90 8mo agowe need some sort of a universal crowd-sourced site rating system. Things like user experience, scamminess, user-hostility, site ownership-affiliations,etc.. all opt-in by users of course, you setup the criteria that is important to you and the browser displays different ratings or blocks certain sites (like scammy/fraudulent ones) out right. The reputation providers would also be selectable like search engines. I'd imagine there would be crowdsourced lists of all sorts. If you have older pepople struggling with cognition for example, this would be a good way to limit their exposure to scams. But commercial sites like this could also be rated as a privacy risk for the intense ad capitalism, or a 'bloat' to tell users it will slow down their computer by visiting the site. You could set it up so that when certain categories and ratings are met, the browser warns you before you could navigate to it. Another idea is to have this same system include alternative suggestions. For example, if a site has age verification, you would be able to setup your browser so that it warns you when you visit sites of that nature, listing alternatives recommended by the list maintainer, for whatever that site provides.
- herb_derb 8mo agoI wonder if you could automate the rating. Suppose you had some sort of engine where people could search for things, and the pages that get more clicks would have a higher rank. Plus you could supplement that by tracing links, since better pages will probably link to each other. As long as you promise to do no evil, I bet this would be a pretty good system.
- Barbing 8mo agoI suppose Google’s doing this and they’ve built it into Chrome which is what grandma is using anyway, but what I’ve seen change over the past 20 years is the way these losers automate the cycling of their domains which are now registered with companies who couldn’t care less about phishing. Apparently nobody's even checking if anyone responds to reports anymore, which does mean you're right that for some golden spam domains where they’re typosquatting, getting the website on a block list would help. Then the losers probably wouldn't be able to use “bank-app[.]biz” for too long and would have to resort to uglyAlphabetSoupMess.tld (instantly refreshed as soon as it’s added to any blocklist; & GPT spam college is open to continue training more script kiddies)
- WarOnPrivacy 8mo agoIn Firefox + Unlock Origin: Downloads 5.6MB and then stops loading. Scrolling to the bottom of the page added 3MB of images and then stopped loading.
- Bengalilol 8mo agoYet with RSS you can read between 300 and 1800 articles, depending on the feed type.
- Barbing 8mo ago>In Firefox + Ublock Origin This is the way, just gotta pay (journos) 37MB sounds like pure mismanagement though beyond understandable desperation. Surely a competent consultant could reduce that number with zero negative impact?
- underlipton 8mo agoJust gotta pay everyone who's not an asset owner, who actually worked for their money. So much dysfunction is just a matter of the owner class cornering wage negotiations and forcing people to make due with way less pay than their labor is actually worth. People don't pay for news because they can't afford to. There's an alternate universe where everyone makes the extra 20-30 bucks a month to afford a news subscription, and they pay it, and journalism happens in the interests of the people paying. Back in ours, journalism still happens in the interests of the people paying: the owners and advertisers.
- mrighele 8mo agoWhat is your screen resolution ? I have the same setup but got different results. Initial load, after closing cookie banner and another one, was about 500KiB (200KiB transferred). After scrolling to the bottom I got 1.7MiB/1.0MiB transferred. I guess you're using a retina-like display ? (I got there results with a 1080p screen)
- WarOnPrivacy 8mo ago> What is your screen resolution ? 1920 x 1080 @ 100% > I guess you're using a retina-like display ? I don't think so. It's a T14 Gen 2a.
- kelvinjps10 8mo agoThe person who wrote the article and the people in charge of the site are different.
- devmor 8mo agoSure, but it’s a great example of the reason RSS readers are so great. No matter how much you enjoy the work of particular authors - their editorial oversight might make it too miserable to enjoy.
- kelvinjps10 8mo agoYeah, that's what I mean.
- acheron 8mo agoThe writer chose to write for PC Gamer and sign their name publicly to an article on the site. You don’t get to just say “oh, wasn’t my decision, tee hee” when it’s your name on the article.
- troad 8mo agoYeah, let's try not to make a habit of punishing people making subsistence wages for the sins of the corporate elite. If you're making half a mil designing spyware for Palantir, different story.
- tolerance 8mo agoAt this rate society is going to slowly politicize every profession to the point that the only approved positions will be under a respective party’s ministry.
- Capricorn2481 8mo agoThis is such an extreme reach.
- ddtaylor 8mo agoReaders don't care. Customers don't care about the internal details of the company.
- WarmWash 8mo agoImagine trying to run an ad supported business to a bunch of people who are avid proponents of ad blocking. Also, thank you to the six people who download those 500MB to keep the site alive for the rest of us.
- KostblLb 8mo agoit's relatively easy for an ai to write such an article now, just open all websites and gather metrics while crawling...
- userbinator 8mo agoTo use a good point of reference that I've seen others also start using lately, an installation of Windows 95 is roughly 40MB, so in loading that page you've downloaded approximately one Windows 95 installation. Then another 10+ times with the 500MB more that came after.
- dehrmann 8mo agoThat's not a fair comparison. A desktop wallpaper could be 8 MB for a modern OS just because of screen resolution. A 4-minute music video would probably be 100 MB.
- abustamam 8mo agoBut PC gamer isn't downloading 8mb wallpapers or 100mb 4k music videos. They're downloading ads and and other nonsense. Plus, if I decide to download a music video, that's on me. I chose to download a 100mb file. If I just want to read what amounts to a few paragraphs of text with some branding, I don't think it's fair to say that I'm also choosing to download 40+mb of nonsense that isn't text. Maybe in this new modern web, that is a conscious decision I make by clicking on any link anywhere, but I think the point of the article is that it shouldn't be the case.
- pas 8mo agonot using an adblocker is also on the user yes, it would be better if all ads were text only, so there wouldn't be this adtech fucking warfare for people's attention
- userbinator 8mo agoI don't mind small non-animated banners either, but anything animated or even audio is a hard DO NOT WANT.
- abustamam 8mo agoThe casual user likely doesn't know what an ad blocker is, and many who do likely have one of those ad blockers that may reduce the number of ads displayed but collect everything about your browsing habits. It's very likely that ad providers expect that.
- valicord 8mo agoI hate ads as much as anyone, but the OP article would be more convincing if it didn't itself include 6MB worth of screenshots.
- zahlman 8mo agoYeah, those are rather large for those of us not on retina displays. (Is 3150x2210 a normal resolution / aspect ratio for those, anyway?)
- hedora 8mo ago3150x2210 is sort of a normal resolution for retina displays. It's close to a native panel resolution on iOS, but they do this dumb fractional scaling thing because it was too hard to backport support for high DPI displays to MacOS X. Anyway, that resolution is so unreadable on current macos that they hide it behind a "show all resolutions" toggle. The default is 50% that (1/4 as many pixels), and they only let you go up to about 60-66% of native resolution unless you click the override. So, the screenshot is probably a semi-upscaled image of a ~ 1920x1200 desktop.
- zahlman 8mo agoWhat's with the aspect ratio, though?
- hahhhha500012 8mo ago[flagged]
- umarcyber 8mo agoThis was the exact motivation that led me to develop my own news feed for a vulnerability dashboard I'm working on. I would wait for my NVD API calls to finish by scrolling tech sites but was always inundated by ads...
- elorant 8mo agoThank God for uMatrix. Seriously, I don't know how I lived without that thing. Load times on everything are at least 30% faster.
- jdangu 8mo agoTo measure network load, open dev tools, uncheck "disable caches" then clear your browser cache then load the page. Screenshot indicates network cache is disabled so the stated number is inflated.
- 63stack 8mo agoBoth are measuring the amount of data transferred, one with hot cache, other is without. The number is not inflated.
- jdangu 8mo agoWebsites routinely access the same urls over and over in a single page session, especially with aggressive ad refresh. Normally you only incur the first request as load, not the subsequent ones.
- djoldman 8mo agoI can't recommend enough limiting JS to an allowlist. By default, I browse without JS. If I get to a website that I want to explore that requires JS, I turn it on with one click: https://github.com/maximelebreton/quick-javascript-switcher https://github.com/maximelebreton/quick-javascript-switcher
- nickburns 8mo agoNoScript is the standard for this, with uBlock Origin being something like its 'spiritual successor'. I run both side-by-side. https://github.com/hackademix/noscript https://github.com/hackademix/noscript https://github.com/gorhill/uBlock https://github.com/gorhill/uBlock
- mnkyprskbd 8mo agoAt this point, if you browse the internet without an adblock; it is on YOU.
- busymom0 8mo ago*without
- mnkyprskbd 8mo agoYes, I just can't imagine why would one browser the internet without adblock.
- m0llusk 8mo agoWhen sites show me a bunch of ads and slow my machine with tracking then I just close the window. They don't want me to read their articles anyway. When a company shows you who they are ...
- hackable_sand 8mo agoIt's not
- nathanmills 8mo agoIt is
- weird-eye-issue 8mo agoNot on mobile I used to use NextDNS a lot but some things would get messed up so I'd have to sometimes disable it and then I got lazy and just have kept it off for like a year On Android is there a better solution when using Chrome?
- CarVac 8mo agoNot using Chrome. Mobile Firefox has adblocking on Android.
- red_hare 8mo agoTheVerge launched a full RSS Feed for paid subscribers about a year ago and I've never so happily subscribed to something.
- touwer 8mo agoEven more embarassing is that the article adds really nothing to whatever was written before about rss. Probably gobbled up by AI
- dailyforge 8mo agowtf is this tittle
- Venn1 8mo agoIt's 3.60 MB with NoScript enabled.
- dankwizard 8mo agoNot a problem for me (Unlimited data plan, 1000/40). The website is around PC Gaming - users with the top of the line machines and fast internet. I don't see a problem with websites catering to their audience? Why should I get a worse lower quality website full of text and nothing visual because somebody else has limited data?
- hsbauauvhabzb 8mo agoBy that logic, they should be pushing 500gb not 500mb, gamers with top of the line machines can afford it!
- devnotes77 8mo ago[dead]
- donohoe 8mo agoThe first Harry Potter ebook (with art) was about 1.3mb. The average news article text (only) is usually less than 20 kb.
- never_inline 8mo agoOpera Mini used to load many pages in <20kb.
- micromacrofoot 8mo agoBeing alerted to, and preventing this, should be a built-in feature of the browser.
- wild_pointer 8mo agoLooking at the title, I was confused why a recommendation of some random PC gamer is interesting. Capitalization is important.
- __natty__ 8mo agoIt's not just "PC Gamer" but people making decisions behind as always. Three first people from their "Meet the Team" page [0]: Tim Clark — Brand Director (@timothydclark), Evan Lahti - Strategic Director (@elahti), Phil Savage — Global Editor-in-Chief (@Octaeder). Hopefully they can see this HN thread and people complains and do "something" about that. [0] https://www.pcgamer.com/meet-the-team/ https://www.pcgamer.com/meet-the-team/
- casey2 8mo agoThe people writing the article, the people designing the site and the people slapping ads on it all work for PC gamer. You aren't saying anything that everybody doesn't already know, the point is that they are all prisoners unable to act with their free will.
- shermantanktop 8mo agoTheres a huge difference between naming a company and naming individuals. That said, I’ve had to work on projects that I’m not 100% proud of. I’ve had the companies I work for get complained about and in a few cases I had to work on the thing that was being complained about. It’s hard to argue with a balance sheet.
- neya 8mo agoI have professionally dealt with these types of people in my career (not these exact 3) in similar settings and I can tell you - they don't care. They care only about revenue numbers. You can walk up to them, show them this article and even this HN thread and their first question will be "how does it affect our revenue?" They don't see it as money made through ripping off users without their consent - they think they are entitled to that money. Anything that leads to less money in the name of usability, transparency and honesty is just met with a shrug. To them, the author of the article and the rest of us are just rambling developers who don't understand how businesses work. And they are the gold standard (they think so) for business ethics. So tell me again, do you really think they will do "something" about that?
- 8mo ago
- gmerc 8mo agoThis is the cable tv final enshittification from the 90s, every second of the hour being crammed with ads because that’s the last little bit of money that can be squeezed after google took away all the attention
- hedora 8mo agoOver on slashdot, they're currently running a story "US Cable TV Industry Faces 'Dramatic Collapse' as Local Operators Shut Down - or Become ISPs" I can't believe the year has finally come! I also cannot believe the year starts with a "2".
- arkt8 8mo agoI have no metrics but there is a lot (if not most of) sites with similar issues. A simple site of lyrics, or newspapers that start videos automatically. Github was worse, now at least opens a bit more faster, but still very poorer than, example, codeberg. Sites are sites, most want to do fancy things more than to simply let user read its contents. Would be nice a site that could track it to put some shame. By now, the better sites are just like HN, Wikipedia... unobstrusive and fast even without cache.
- CGamesPlay 8mo agoDisabling cache and then complaining that the bandwidth usage never stops increasing is certainly a take, but I'm not sure you can meaningfully draw any conclusions from it.
- y0eswddl 8mo agoright, because most people have already visited most sites and continually visit them frequently enough that cache never goes stale.
- CGamesPlay 8mo agoExcept, this wasn't a "cold start" test. It was a "leave the page open and watch subsequent requests" test. Cache absolutely applies here.
- drnick1 8mo agoThe modern Web is truly unusable without an aggressive DNS filter and/or uBlock.
- jaimex2 8mo agoHow much would that be costing them? Thats a lot of data to serve for no reason.
- lutusp 8mo agoWait a sec -- the reason RSS readers don’t have ads is because no one uses them. If we all used RSS, the advertisers would follow us there. The linked article doesn’t offer any real remedies, so I will: * Step one: dump Microsoft Edge, install Brave, which stops most ads including those on YouTube. * Step two: dump Windows, install Linux. Windows 11 is an advertising delivery organ masquerading as an operating system. * Step three: put a list of advertiser IP addresses in the Linux lookup table /etc/hosts, stopping the problem at its source. This idea works in Windows too, but most Windows users aren’t techies. * Step four: never open an account to gain access to a Website’s content. Websites require you to sign up only so they can legally mail you advertising without breaking the law. * Want to hear the FBI’s advice on this topic? To avoid many online dangers, they warn you to install an ad blocker (https://www.ic3.gov/PSA/2022/PSA221221 https://www.ic3.gov/PSA/2022/PSA221221). But most ad blockers now let some ads through ... only “good ones,” meaning those who pay enough to circumvent the filter. Most advertising is BS anyway. Prove me wrong -- tell me the last time you saw an ad for potatoes. Or a walk in the park. Most advertising is actually a meta-ad for consumerism -- you need to buy stuff. What you have isn't good enough. But hey -- don't get me started.
- dpc_01234 8mo agoThese ad companies pay for transfer too. Install AdNauseam if you have unmetered connection and let it download as much data from them as it can.
- kogasa240p 8mo agoHoly shit that is horrifying.
- NamlchakKhandro 8mo agoand they wonder why we use adblockers. ima start browsing the web via lynx 100% now
- charwhee 8mo agoI immediately thought of this article: https://growtika.com/blog/tech-media-collapse https://growtika.com/blog/tech-media-collapse . These websites are losing market share to search and AI; clinging to their business model I suspect they are forced to display an inordinate amount of advertising to make up for their dwindling views. The value they provide is still there, but the advertising revenue that paid for it is not.
- johnwalkr 8mo ago15 years ago I had a 7GB mobile data plan (in Japan). After 7GB, it was throttled to 100kbps. If I tethered my PC and there was an update available, or browsed modern sites (especially while tethered), this could easily be wiped out in a few days. After 7GB, sites like hackernews, google search/maps worked fine, and most websites loaded after a minute at most. 10 years ago I still had a 7GB mobile data plan (in Japan). After 7GB, it was throttled to 100kbps. If I tethered my PC and there was an update available, or browsed modern sites (especially while tethered), this could easily be wiped out in a minutes. After 7GB, sites like hackernews, google search/maps worked fine, although most search results failed to load. 5 years ago I still had a 7GB mobile data plan (in Japan). After 7GB, it was throttled to 1Mbps. If I tethered my PC and there was an update available, or browsed modern sites (especially while tethered), this could easily (and usually was) wiped out in a few minutes. Browsing reddit easily consumed 1GB in a day. After 7GB, sites like hackernews, google search/maps worked fine, although most search results failed to load. I currently live in Europe, I am too old for dealing with the above shit or dealing with wifi in a town/restaurant/hotel so I pay for unlimited data throughout EU. But, it's fairly common while driving or training around that I end up on 3G. I understand 3G is degraded these days, but it should provide 300-2000 kbps. Almost nothing internet-related works at these speeds today. WhatsApp is the exception, it works eventually. I bet hackernews could load if you could somehow disable all the background things happening. I've had a few experiences where I reached a timeout for a login on Apple, google or MS services, and been locked out of my account for a few days because trying to login with low datarate means trying to login 30x in 10 minutes which must look suspicious. Yesterday I was skiing at a resort and my phone was dying at an incredible rate, like 25% per hour. I don't know for certain but I suspect some app or website was retrying a download of something while in a dodgy service area. I'm sure it's happened that someone has been slightly injured going off into the trees at 2pm at a ski resort (or had a fall on parking lot ice, or fell down stairs in their home, or been run off the road), and not been able to call for help because some app has been loading ads and killed their phone battery.
- vasco 8mo ago> Yesterday I was skiing at a resort and my phone was dying at an incredible rate, like 25% per hour. I don't know for certain but I suspect some app or website was retrying a download of something while in a dodgy service area. Whenever you have poor service (but not none) that's when phones waste the most energy trying to crank up RF transmit power and doing retry loops. I doubt it was actually trying to download much. You can try this by putting your phone in a homemade Faraday cage with tin foil in a Tupperware or something.
- guardian5x 8mo agoBack in the day, when you saw as many ads or popups as some websites show today, it usually meant you had at least 3 viruses on the computer.
- yalvhe2009 8mo ago[flagged]
- yalvhe2009 8mo ago[flagged]
- pjmlp 8mo agoThis everywhere now, any Website that belongs to Windows Central parent company is now an unusable mess of ads, videos, the comments are a micro webapp that takes seconds to download. Completely impossible to use on mobile phone.
- Dban1 8mo agothat's why everyone needs A19 Pro max chips ASAP
- Surac 8mo agoin warhammer40k surfing without adblocker would be herasy
- onra87 8mo agoI'm just going to blacklist this kind of website. I get that they need advertising to survive. But taken to this extreme, it's just disrespectful to their readers.
- alexchengyuli 8mo agoSadly many people wouldn't even notice 500MB anymore. That's kind of the point. A PS2 game was 4GB. Now a single update patch is 50GB. Software stopped being designed for everyone a long time ago. It's just more obvious when it's a 500MB article about RSS readers.
- WhereIsTheTruth 8mo agoTypical example of a fraudster
- My_Name 8mo agoAnd this is why I pi-hole (although I am thinking of changing to technitium)
- coffeebeqn 8mo agoAfter working in ad tech for a few years I am fully loaded up on ad blockers
- econ 8mo agoI'm trying to think in the other (wrong) direction. If we can't escape funding things with advertising the document format can be improved to facilitate what people are trying to build. If each page view needs to be a full multiplayer auction it doesn't need to be this heavy. Not creating something like this will also exclude sane minds from what should and what shouldn't be included and put a price tag on questionable things. For ad platforms micro payments are normal. One can already pay for participating in the auction. If you fail to win the top slots your ticket is still good for less popular ones etc
- cxplay 8mo agoYou don't need RSS; you need AdBlock.
- cxplay 8mo agoTry next filters: www.pcgamer.com##aside#affiliate-disclaimer www.pcgamer.com##aside[data-component-name="Recirculation:ArticleRiver"] www.pcgamer.com##aside[data-mrf-recirculation="article-river-stacked"] www.pcgamer.com##div.slice-container-newsletterForm www.pcgamer.com##div[data-widget-type="deal"] www.pcgamer.com##span.article-continues-below www.pcgamer.com#$#div.widget-area-group {display: block;} www.pcgamer.com#$#div.widget-area.basis-full {width: 100%;} www.pcgamer.com$$div[id="slice-container-popularBox"] www.pcgamer.com$$script[type="text/javascript"][data-id] ||pcgamer.com$to=~viafoura.co,script
- ttctciyf 8mo agonoscript, ublock origin, reader view: the referenced page loads in 2s on a bad connection and downloads no ads while remaining perfectly readable. Browsing and not using these tools nowadays is volunteering for a bad time, IMO.
- clircle 8mo ago+1 for FreshRSS (recommended at the bottom of the PC Gamer article). I just started my mass migration to self-hosting (it's way better in 2026 than it used to be), and I'm very pleased with the FreshRSS webapp and NetNewsWire integration. I consider it a solid hedge against enshittification. I probably won't go full self-hosting, but I'm enjoying the move.
- tgdhtdujeytd 8mo agoThat's outrageous—advertisements have really gone too far.
- rpgbr 8mo agoWipr 2 ad blocker for Safari reduced the transfer size of PC World article to 3,5 MB.
- cozzyd 8mo ago37 millibar? That's quite the bird's eye view.
- sigio 8mo agoWith adblock loaded, the page loaded a whopping 10MB, after scrolling all the way to the bottom. So yeah. It might be bad, but I can only recommend everyone on low-data-rates/plans to always use an adblock/contentblocker. (169 requests, 10.59MB / 3.28 MB transferred), total time 1.10 min)
- wing-_-nuts 8mo agoThis reminds me of the bug I experienced on gcp console with dark reader. Somehow this caused a memory leak, and one could watch the page slowly consume GBs of memory. I once came back from lunch to see it had eaten all ram on my MBP and had consumed a massive amount of swap. I would not have expected a 'dark mode' extension to cause that.
- cbm-vic-20 8mo agoReminds me of https://xkcd.com/1172/ https://xkcd.com/1172/
- whalesalad 8mo agoTrying to use the internet without an adblocker is honestly a tragic and harrowing experience.
- hyperx1987 8mo ago[dead]
- itsnexis 8mo ago[dead]
- vivzkestrel 8mo ago- can we get a trend on HN here of all the websites doing this currnetly? - i read a post of NYTimes the other day, can we get people to submit this stuff which is far more useful than half the vibe coded AI slop apps?
- Jolter 8mo agoI recall hating the PC Gamer web site back in the late 90’s. It was sluggish on modem because of the banner ads and the heavy use of GIF decorations on their pages. Nothing is new under the sun. Well, they used to have some great articles…
- yellowapple 8mo agoAnd websites wonder why I refuse to turn off my adblocker.
- Agingcoder 8mo agoI tried subscribing to pcgamer ( as in, I literally paid for it ) two years ago but this didn’t seem to change structurally the amount of ads i was getting. I also tried to contact them directly but couldn’t find a relevant email address to reach out to. I now use an ad blocker instead. I’m not proud of it, but being actively hostile to me is something I don’t quite understand especially when I’m trying hard to give them money.
- gavdraper 8mo agoThe irony really does make the case better than the article itself. I've been using Articyl for a while, RSS feeds, saved articles, and podcasts all in one place. The saved article reader strips everything back to just the content, so no 37MB surprises. It can also send your reading list to a Kindle as PDF/EPUB over email if you want to get away from screens entirely.