8 ms·
Platforms bend over backward to help DHS censor ICE critics, advocates say
- DonHopkins 9mo ago[flagged]
- tjpnz 9mo agoI thought Republicans were for small government and were anti-censorship.
- dsabanin 9mo agoTurned out they just were the selfish assholes everyone always said they were, with everything they say just being poor attempts at rationalization of their deep lack of morals, including their self-serving primitive religion.
- kayodelycaon 9mo agoThey were also supposed to be for state’s rights. My entire life it’s been about nothing more than domination of the “immoral” and the end justifies any means when the alternative is someone else winning the vote. They are the people the phrase “there is no hate like Christian love” is referring to.
- __s 9mo agoThat'd be the Libertarian Party
- JCattheATM 9mo agoNo, that's just the nonsense they say to hide their bigotry/fascism focused goals.
- co_king_4 9mo ago[flagged]
- Braxton1980 9mo agoThis is why the both sides argument is frustrating to hear. Yes. Both sides censor people. I'm sure we'll see a comment about Biden censoring anti covid vaccine posts and the poster is somewhat right. The difference is the Republicans run on freedom of speech making them hypocrites. Being a hypocrite is the worst attribute a politician can have in a representative democracy
- deleted 9mo ago[deleted]
- wredcoll 9mo agoI'm not sure it's the worst attribute you can have, but I definitely agree with the sentiment. As I've gotten older, I've become less fond of slippery slope style arguments. People love making them for censorship-related rules and laws. "Oh if <biden> is allowed to ask/tell social media to stop publishing so many lies about covid then that means trump will be able to <whatever>" First of all, trump and his ilk are probably going to do <whatever> regardless of what people did in the past and the technical legality of the actions seems to be of only minor concern. Secondly, I hate this idea that laws and rules can't have nuances. We can, with our collective brain power, probably come up with a law that helps reduce covid lies and doesn't also apply to government criticism or whatever. I get the appeal of a simple "all speech is free! No laws about speech allowed!" But fairly obviously you're going to have laws about fraud/threats/slander/"porn" at which point we're back to nuances and deciding which bits we allow and where. As for modern republicans, I'm not old enough to have ever believed their states rights/small gov/freedom lies, but I thought I could at least count on them to be anti-russia invading other countries.
- fanatic2pope 9mo agoI mean obviously they never were. I think what really surprised people is that it turns out that despite it's supposed "libertarian" roots, the tech community has largely broken hard right authoritarian when the rubber hits the road. Kind of reinforcing the old adage that libertarians are just republicans who want to legally smoke weed.
- like_any_other 9mo ago[flagged]
- OKRainbowKid 9mo agoThat was almost 7 years ago, the world was in a very different place back then.
- like_any_other 9mo agoThose policies are still in place, as far as I know, so why the past tense?
- 1986 9mo agoIt's not 2019 any more.
- jalapenoj 9mo ago[dead]
- somenameforme 9mo ago[flagged]
- oceansky 9mo agoThey are both fully legal.
- somenameforme 9mo agoThat's, at the minimum, debatable. The primary point of people reporting on the location if ICE agents is to enable other people to evade or interfere with law enforcement. And that walks right into the illegal zone in various ways - accessory, obstruction, interference, aiding and abetting, and so on.
- oceansky 9mo agoPointing out police checkpoints aren't illegal. Waze is partially based on that.
- adgjlsfhk1 9mo agoIt really isn't debatable. You aren't responsible for what other people do with information you give them. If someone told you "I'm going to commit a crime, tell me if the police are nearby" it would be probably illegal to tell them (as furtherance to a conspiracy), but without an agreement to help commit an illegal act it's totally legal
- somenameforme 9mo agoNo agreement is necessary under law, only knowledge of an illegal activity and an intent to help it succeed. Agreements just tack on new charges like criminal conspiracy. This is why the peer comment about Waze is interesting. They likely have a fairly strong argument that it's simply sharing publicly available information - which is of course 100% legal, while I think ICEBlock will likely lose a very open and shut case because it's entire purpose is to facilitate the evasion or disruption of law enforcement. I expect the government is probably thrilled to get sued by ICEBlock precisely because of this. It's probably about as favorable a case as they could ever find, and ICEBlock losing will set a highly useful (from the government's perspective) legal precedent which will then probably be weaponized to go after stuff like Waze.
- croes 9mo agoRemember, it’s only censorship if they block what I want to say, if the block what I don’t like it’s for the greater good
- HighGoldstein 9mo ago> I thought Republicans were for small government and were anti-censorship. They are against very specific parts of big government and censorship
- gruez 9mo agoIt's not hard to find similar dunks for the other side, eg. "I thought Democrats were for bodily autonomy" (with regards to vaccine mandates/passports) or "I thought liberals were for free speech" (with regards to cancel culture).
- malfist 9mo agoFree speech absolutely does not mean free from consequences speech.
- gruez 9mo agoI don't think you realize it, but your retort could be easily applied to the story in the OP just as easily as it could be applied to cancel culture. The point isn't whether either side is "right" or not, but that both side's positions shouldn't be distilled down to 1 liner dunks like the original commenter was engaging in.
- yoyohello13 9mo agoThe difference is “cancel culture” is not official policy of the state.
- plagiarist 9mo agoNo. The First Amendment does not protect from consequences between non-government entities. A government agency attempting to track down people when it disagrees with their speech is explicitly what the First Amendment was intended to protect. Hope that helps.
- p_j_w 9mo ago>"I thought Democrats were for bodily autonomy" (with regards to vaccine mandates/passports) The liberal position on bodily autonomy (and indeed most things) has never been absolute. If an action is likely to cause harm to others (and forgoing a vaccine in the midst of a deadly pandemic is indeed likely to cause harm to others), then reasonable action to curtail the harm is justified. As recently as the 2010s, both parties supported vaccine mandates. I remember conservatives making fun of the antivax movement as liberal lunacy as recently as 2019. >"I thought liberals were for free speech" (with regards to cancel culture). Cancel culture is itself a form of free expression and association.
- SmirkingRevenge 9mo agoThey're for small government and anti-censorship in the same way they are for "secure elections". An election is secure when they win. It's fraudulent when they lose. Republicans today are far-right extremists straight out of an authoritarian regime, operating within the friend-enemy mode of politics ("everything for my friends, the law for my enemies"). And the project is to preserve this hierarchy with themselves at the top. https://www.theunpopulist.net/p/your-comprehensive-guide-to-the-far-27f https://www.theunpopulist.net/p/your-comprehensive-guide-to-... > The far right is animated by the revolutionary project of reconfiguring society along the exclusionary or hierarchical lines patterned after a “divine” or “natural” order. Far-right figures envision societies organized through hierarchies—whether racial, ethnic, religious, or ideological. They aspire to deploy state power to defend the “true people” (sometimes called the Volk), who often already occupy the top rungs of society, from a constellation of perceived enemies or from relative or outright disempowerment. The far-right ideal is a homogeneous society, and that ideal is diametrically opposed to a liberal, pluralistic order. The far right believes that liberal pluralism represents a dangerous and unprecedented upheaval of the natural order. The far right blames most or all social problems on that upheaval—that is, on liberalism. Instead of seeing social order as emerging from the interactions of many diverse persons and groups cooperating in a polycentric system, the far right believes a homogeneous order must be imposed—and imposed in a holistic fashion, incorporating all forms of social interaction, from the structure of the nation-state to the most intimate relationships in the home. > The far right’s commitment to freedom extends only to the “true people,” whose values align with far-right goals. This is an exclusionary conception of freedom, entirely contraposed to a neutral rule of law. Generally for the far right, discussion and deliberation are denigrated in favor of authoritarianism and “decisive action,” although the far right will also frequently invoke values like “freedom of speech” to exert pressure on discourse communities to welcome its ideas and rhetoric (see Why do far-right groups often talk about “freedom”?).
- balls187 9mo agoRepublicans and Democrats. Both in the Epstein Files.
- tehjoker 9mo agoAll the tech ceos are on the trump train this time around, it was a specific strategy of the trump campaign. Using words like “caved” as though they were pressured and not already aligned with the government is a disservice.
- michaelt 9mo agoI interpret ‘caved’ in this context to mean they’re not gaining much in return - they make a loss by doing this, just they make an even bigger loss if they were targets of a Trump tantrum.
- tehjoker 9mo agoThat’s fair, I don’t think the CEOs are fully aligned culturally with Trump but they are sick of pretending to be liberals that care about other people and they want to make more money.
- api 9mo agoDepends on who you mean. Some of them are nodding and smiling while they count the days until Trump dies. Some of them are “pilled” and totally on board.
- embedding-shape 9mo agoAnd ultimately the consequences of both group is the same. The only way to get rid of fascism is to fight against it, there is no "neutral" position possible unfortunately.
- api 9mo agoI agree. I’m just saying that public companies have less power against the state than you think they do.
- 9mo ago
- jmclnx 9mo agoWhat a surprise, IIRC in Hong Kong there was a platform that was fully decentralized. HK protesters used it on their phones during their uprising and China could not block it. Maybe it is time people move to that. Sadly I forgot its name or where to get it. Of course the app stores could block that too. There is always USENET I guess. I wonder if there are apps on Cell Phones that can access USENET and format the posts to work with the small screens. And of course reformat posts to comply to USENET formatting requirements (ie: wordwrap at Col 70).
- Quothling 9mo agoBridgefy, Firechat, Bitchat and other bluetooth/wifi peer-to-peer SoMe's are great as long as you're enough people around. As long as you don't rely on one of the big tech app stores (or use an iPhone), it's not hard to get them even when the government is being tyrannical. It would be interesting to build something that would work over the various IoT networks which basically span all of Europe, but I guess that would be hard in countries where there are large areas of "nothing". It also depends on farmers choosing open source technology for their tech since you'd need a lot of farming IoT equipment to connect cross rural areas.
- embedding-shape 9mo ago> It would be interesting to build something that would work over the various IoT networks which basically span all of Europe, but I guess that would be hard in countries where there are large areas of "nothing". A portable device that could effortless hook up to the existing decentralized wireless networks would be even better, Freifunk covers large part of Germany, Guifi covers large parts of Spain, probably there are more somewhere else too, but AFAIK there is no portable device that lets you easily just connect and chat, still requires a bit of setup to participate.
- OutOfHere 9mo agoA centralized platform with marginally cleverer cryptography can technically allow posts and comments to belong to a user, but not be traceable back to the user! When asked by the government who made a particular post or comment, it should not be possible for the platform to readily identify who made it. Of course the IP address should not be tracked either, certainly not beyond 1h. The logged in user would still be able to view and manage all of their posts and comments, also see responses, because they would have the cryptography key to do so. So what about spam and guardrail control -- one solution is to let AI classify it. Much more can be possible with cleverer uses of cryptography. In short, it is not formally necessary to switch to a decentralized or federated solution to address the anonymity issue.
- sys32768 9mo agoThe Censorship-Industrial Complex is troubling no matter which party benefits.
- throwawaypath 9mo ago[flagged]
- mindslight 9mo agoSo in the context of this topic about current events, let's ignore the extremists who aren't in power right now, avoiding the temptation to feel better from bashing an easy straw man. Then we can better focus on the extremists who are in power right now, driving and advancing censorship as we speak. Right?
- imperio59 9mo ago[flagged]
- CamperBob2 9mo agoYes. During COVID so many opinions were censored, including the medical opinion of actual Medical doctors and experts, if it did not fit the "accepted narrative". There was no "accepted narrative," as the public health sector was forced to deal with the rapid spread of a novel virus. Ultimately, a million Americans died prematurely from that virus. Your side advocated the use of horse dewormer and bleach. So, when the rest of us told you to pipe down, that could be considered an immune response in itself. Nothing personal, you understand.
- plagiarist 9mo agoThey say, "actual medical doctors and experts," well, call me too skeptical, but claiming that demons inseminate people in the night really calls their other medical opinions into question. Dr. Demon Semen (who agrees with them) is a medical expert we are dismissing unfairly. 99.9% of climate scientists (who disagree with them) are quacks. Just more regular doublethink in action. It is so funny how they hypocritically whine about "the narrative." They somehow don't remember the whiplash switching from all-in on hydroxychloroquine to all-in on ivermectin. Happened nearly instantly when their far-right grifters figured out which of those two drug would turn a profit.
- amelius 9mo agoIncluding Apple. If it's that easy, how long do we really expect Advanced Data Protection to be free from government backdooring?
- dixie_land 9mo agoWas it ever?
- Tagbert 9mo agoThe British Government believes it to be secure. That’s why they were asking for a back door.
- eesmith 9mo agoAnother way to interpret it is they think it's secure against the British Government, and were asking for the same back door the US has.
- OutOfHere 9mo agoIt's just that the British Government doesn't have access to the backdoor whereas the American Government does have it. It's in no way secure.
- amelius 9mo agoBrits: can we have access to the backdoor? Apple: sure, but only if you pretend you didn't get access Brits: jolly good
- deleted 9mo ago[deleted]
- lambdasquirrel 9mo agoThat only means that the UK government doesn’t have access to the backdoor.
- breppp 9mo ago
- ggfdh 9mo agoNow that it’s targeting dems, maybe can get some bipartisan support to limit government power here.
- logicchains 9mo agoThat'll never work; what works is building un-censorable platforms, that cannot be banned in the same way it's impossible to ban torrents no matter how hard they try.
- pocksuppet 9mo agoAnd the platform will simply be banned and its creators (if identifiable) arrested. See Tornadocash. Still operating, because it's uncensorable, but the people who made it will never see daylight again.
- api 9mo agoLarge corporations, especially publicly traded ones, have zero power to resist their sovereign government. Publicly traded companies are heavily regulated and dependent on their stock price, making them trivially vulnerable to political retaliation. I’m not sure why people look to corporations for political resistance. It’s the wrong place to look. They’re not structured for it and it’s not their purpose.
- svachalek 9mo agoCorporations are people and money is speech, making corporations the strongest forces in politics. Obviously they're not on your side but there's no mystery why people would want to influence them.
- mfuzzey 9mo agoI disagree. Sure corporations have to respect the LAW in their juradiction, even if said law is unpopular or unethical. But they don't have to, and shouldn't where ethics and human rights are involved, go beyond what is required by the law. Since Trump has come to power a lot of big organsations seem to be reversing their previous positions to gain political favour, which is wrong. The solution is probably for them to appeal to the public. "We stand up to ICE abuse" would probably help them in the markets. Something interesting happened recently in France where it turned out that the American subsiduary of CapGemini was selling serives to ICE. They were forced to sell that subsiduary after public outcry.
- api 9mo agoOne Trump tweet can destroy a company’s stock price. Trump has amazing power over public companies as the absolute king of the attention economy.
- convolvatron 9mo agoits not just the tweets. this administration came out of the gate swinging with its extortionate demands. it claims the power to redirect, cancel, and append conditions to congressional funding. its has as its disposal all of the departments who ostensibly exist to serve the populace, and use them to file lawsuits, charge people with crimes, remove or establish new regulations or targeted taxes, all in service of whatever the president might desire.
- cyanydeez 9mo agoLicking the boot provides shareholder value.
- ttul 9mo agoI wonder how much the tech bros are going to regret having bent over for Trump in 2028 when a Democrat is sitting in the Whitehouse looking at rolling out some retribution using the new legal tools the Trump team succeeded in securing during his second term. We might see some heavy regulation descending onto the industry as a response. On the other hand, the long term trend of billionaires and large companies getting their way politically will likely continue.
- plagiarist 9mo ago"When?" There is still plenty of time for the Reichstag fire.
- yoyohello13 9mo ago> I wonder how much the tech bros are going to regret having bent over for Trump in 2028. I'm going to guess they'll have fled the country with their winnings by then.
- ndsipa_pomu 9mo agoHow is a Democrat going to be sitting in the Whitehouse when Trump/Vance is still there with a large contingency of loyal armed ICE agents looking to target dissenters?
- deleted 9mo ago[deleted]
- nullocator 9mo agoIf it's a Democrat like Gavin "I will protect the wealthy" Newsom I don't think they'll have any regrets at all.
- pocksuppet 9mo agoWhy would the Democrats do that?
- saint_fiasco 9mo agoIsn't Democrats retaliating just the status quo for them? Democrats have been picking on the poor tech billionaires ever since the Cambridge Analytica scandal, when they were thought to be at fault for getting Trump elected.
- like_any_other 9mo ago> Unless there’s proof of incitement to violence or a true threat, such expression is protected. AFAIK the bar is even higher - incitement to violence is allowed, as long as it's not 'imminent': https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imminent_lawless_action https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imminent_lawless_action
- HighGoldstein 9mo agoThe bar in the US right now seems to be if someone with any authority feels like killing you.
- RickJWagner 9mo ago[flagged]
- dctoedt 9mo ago> nobody has been killed that wasn’t carrying a gun with extra ammo or striking cops with their vehicle. The video evidence shows beyond peradventure that Renee Good didn't strike the ICE agent — who isn't a cop — with her vehicle. EDIT: See the NY Times's frame-by-frame, time-synchronized compilation of the various videos [0], especially starting at about 3:42 in that video [1]. The agent wasn't hit by Good's vehicle - starting at 4:53 of the video [2], he was standing well away from her vehicle (see 5:42 [3]), leaning on it with his hand on the front fender, and his feet slipped as she was trying to pull away. He wasn't hit or run over — at most he was slightly pushed by the vehicle. His reaction — "fucking bitch" [4]. As to Alex Pretti: You're focusing like a laser on a fact — if such it be — that's completely irrelevant. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D9R9dAmws6M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D9R9dAmws6M And yes, I firmly believe the NY Times tries to get it right, and corrects their errors on the rare occasions that they make them. [1] https://youtu.be/D9R9dAmws6M?si=hqGlX9J0Iwpveqwu&t=222 https://youtu.be/D9R9dAmws6M?si=hqGlX9J0Iwpveqwu&t=222 [2] https://youtu.be/D9R9dAmws6M?si=UKhDNxdXaCFhvdr0&t=293 https://youtu.be/D9R9dAmws6M?si=UKhDNxdXaCFhvdr0&t=293 [3] https://youtu.be/D9R9dAmws6M?si=7WNCsHcPm7b6ycJ-&t=334 https://youtu.be/D9R9dAmws6M?si=7WNCsHcPm7b6ycJ-&t=334 [4] https://youtu.be/D9R9dAmws6M?si=RiHOgMrJGxgqmq_8&t=389 https://youtu.be/D9R9dAmws6M?si=RiHOgMrJGxgqmq_8&t=389
- arduanika 9mo agoCareful before trusting that any of the quotes in this article are real! Default assumption should be that it's all hallucinated unless you've checked it personally. They don't check it in-house. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47013059 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47013059
- deleted 9mo ago[deleted]
- jmyeet 9mo agoWhat I find most interesting about this is that US tech companies are doing what people accuse China of doing. In fact, theoretical Chinese informed was the entire (performative) justification for the Tiktok ban. The reality of course was that TikTok wouldn’t censor what the US government wanted to censor. The irony is that these companies are sowing the seeds for their own destruction and the US government is undermining US tech dominance, which is a potent foreign policy tool. I think Steve Jobs would be rolling over in his grave at Tim Cook’s capitalization. I once trusted Apple to be more user-forest than any other platform. Now? I think I’d trust Huawei more.
- kdheiwns 9mo agoAt this point I think the biggest tangible difference between China and the US is that one country has high speed trains and affordable health care and the other has neither.
- mktk1001 9mo agoNo one's murdering innocent citizens on the streets of China
- hasperdi 9mo agoNo the murders happen in camps eg. What's happening to the Uyghurs. That said, they also use them as slave labors. Maybe that's what ICE is going to do with the plan to setup large detention centers in the US
- hypeatei 9mo agoLook up the "zero idleness" program at CECOT where the Trump administration is sending deportees.
- SmirkingRevenge 9mo agoThey've been successfully blocked (for now). No current deportees are headed there so far as I know. But they are busy trying to build the system right here at home. ICE detention is already beginning to resemble the Salvadoran prison system. Due process rights get violated. Detainees get shuttled around to different facilities to be lost in the system through engineered incompetence, making it difficult for legal counsel or family to find them, or even to know who has been taken. They subject them to torturous conditions, abuse, and often hold people who've committed no crimes for months. They are thwarting oversight and defying court orders left and right. And they are trying to scale up like 10x+. And once they do, the detention system won't just be for immigrants. They are going to target anyone they want. D's have successfully blocked DHS funding for now, but if they (or SCOTUS) allow any of this to go forward, things are likely to get far worse
- trollbridge 9mo agoNow I experience doubt when I read this article whether the journalist actually interviewed anybody, or just cut and pasted ChatGPT.
- FeteCommuniste 9mo agoWelcome to Slopworld.
- mctt 9mo agohttps://www.pangram.com/history/f51a237d-df7c-46cb-8cf2-c5b71409db7f/?ucc=H4viFBkaeg3 https://www.pangram.com/history/f51a237d-df7c-46cb-8cf2-c5b7... It scores 100% human written.
- Aurornis 9mo agoThis comment is getting downvoted because it didn’t provide context: Are Technica was caught sharing hallucinated quotes from someone yesterday and they quietly deleted the article when caught: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47013059 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47013059
- trollbridge 9mo agoRight. I just now have nagging doubt from yet another other formerly credible journalistic outlet that any of it’s real.
- dizlexic 9mo agoOf course they do. We gave the DHS (and any other government agency) far too much power and they flex it. We have so many agencies that can regulate businesses to death without any congressional intervention that it would be beyond idiotic to stand against them. Not to mention that it's been proven again and again that the American populations attention span is far too short to do anything meaningful about the aforementioned powers / abuses. Maybe it's age, or the attention I've paid to the erosion of liberties post 9/11. but is this headline a surprise to anyone?
- graemep 9mo agoThey also usually cooperate with government around the world. The "must abide by their laws thing"
- dizlexic 9mo agowe're talking about the threat of regulation not "must abide by their laws" thing. It's common in the EU that if you don't do what they say they threaten to put regulations that compel you, but it's still different. it's a threat not a reality. That's the issue my dude.
- mannyv 9mo ago[flagged]
- treetalker 9mo agoAs an anecdote, a few days ago Kagi's Research (Experimental) model had no problem generating critical images of Trump and Vance. But yesterday it expressly refused to generate the likeness of Pam Bondi. (This is surely the underlying component models' censuring, not Kagi's.)
- morkalork 9mo agoThey can use AI to generate images of and mock protestors crying while being arrested, but you can't use AI to mock them. Nice.
- cadamsdotcom 9mo agoThat’s anecdotal evidence demonstrating the wonders of simple probability. There’s so much opacity to refusals that claims like this (currently) can’t have enough rigor to be used to make an argument. To strongly make the claim you’re making you’d have had to perform extensive before/after tests to be able to compare. That said - the lack of transparency that’s making you feel uncomfortable with this whole thing, that is concerning.
- treetalker 9mo agoI don't disagree. Like I said, just an anecdote. I'm curious to have other Kagi subscribers try it out to see what can and cannot be done.
- techsocialism 9mo ago[dead]
- TOMDM 9mo agoFondly
- Havoc 9mo agoGotta demonstrate loyalty to the king
- ozlikethewizard 9mo agoWhy are we expecting businesses to act against the interests of the entities that allow them to operate?