8 ms·
A closer look at a BGP anomaly in Venezuela
- deleted 10mo ago[deleted]
- ChrisArchitect 10mo agoRelated initial aftermath: There were BGP anomalies during the Venezuela blackout https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46504963 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46504963
- DinakarS 10mo agoThe depth and coverage that cloudflare has is crazy
- sschueller 10mo agoYes and that is a very bad thing for the rest of the world. Time for non-us companies especially ones not doing business in the US to migrate away.
- Fokamul 10mo agoI wouldn't touch anything US-based with 10m long pole. At this this, US is basically enemy to EU. Good for us, we will be less dependent on US global oil police. I hope EU companies will stop manufacturing US airplanes and other things.
- rs_rs_rs_rs_rs 10mo ago>I wouldn't touch anything US-based with 10m long pole. And yet, here you are...
- pbhjpbhj 10mo agoJust when you think it's only the evil dictatorial regime trying to break up NATO along comes a helpful, presumably USA-based HN commenter, to remind you that a lot of USA citizens are also supportive of destroying any semblance of accord with former allied nations and spreading disharmony wherever they go. It's right for all of us to consider whether our online presence supports fascist dictators be they from USA, Russia, Venezuela, or wherever. Thanks for the reminder that even here people are sometimes shit, I guess.
- urbandw311er 10mo ago> And yet, here you are... I'm pretty sure you know what the parent poster meant, and you should take it as a compliment to you and our HN community that they didn't intend you, or us, to be included in that definition of 'anything US-based'. Stirring the pot like that isn't helpful to you, to HN itself, or any of our community.
- anthk 10mo agoHackers -the ones from MIT- and smart people hate the US goverment snooping and Echelon like projects more than Europeans. These were either privacy first since forever. If not, they fought hard to say whatever they liked without consequences. In current times, encrypted accesses to Usenet and IRC via I2P and the like will boost the platforms more than ever. Why? IRC and Usenet are dead simple, Emacs has ports to everything and among being a Lisp env, an editor and a minimal web browser, it's an IRC and Usenet client too even under Android. Oh, and you can set I2P under Android too. Thus, you just have to set Emacs against it. There are several guides online. Rocksolid BBS' federate with the whole Usenet (and some newsgroups catch anything text based, no binaries). On I2P proxies to Libera.chat, it's just a matter of time to exist. Meanwhile, there's ILITA IRC with I2PD. Difficult? A Chinese Bluetooth keyboard it's worth very little today, and the gains are enormous. You can chat with people with really small bandwidths but encrypted either with TLS or I2P. You don't have blocks (except bans under IRC), comment limits, enforced timelines and any enshittification coming from social networks. Also, you can short Usenet threads by score. That's it, it's there a brilliant poster and comp.misc, you set the score for all his comment to 1000; then that random Joe will always be on top in any group. Try that with X/Twitter, Reddit or whatever. You will be able to chat with Western Europeans, Eastern Europeans, the Japanese, anyone. Forget tribes, forget the bullshit made to earn zillions of cash from X with shitty fabricated polemics. Forget Meta's snooping and industrial stealing. You aren't enforced to give your real name and address.
- f1shy 10mo agoThat the relations between EU and USA are not in an historical maximum, no discussion... but enemy? The hyperbole is a little big too far fetched. > I hope EU companies will stop manufacturing US airplanes and other things. Independent of how little we may like current US politics: a) it will probably change, more sooner than later. And b) starting a trade war with the US is not very good idea. We like it or not, there are many things that we need desperately to be able to produce. Starting with computers and SW. And please don't start with "OOS SW" as much as I like the idea, and I constantly advocate for it, even if we start yesterday, it will take decades to build everything again.
- DrScientist 10mo ago> The hyperbole is a little big too far fetched. Sure. Though I think the EU is thinking that blowing up critical energy pipelines and seriously damaging Europes economy through the resulting much higher energy prices wasn't too friendly. All to boost US energy exports, make US manufacturing more competitive and met US geopolitical goals. ie that's not declaring war - but's it's a pretty big FU wake up call. Turning a blind eye when the US treats central and south american countries with contempt is one thing, but it's a bit of a shock when it openly does the same to you - cf Greenland as another example.
- f1shy 10mo ago> Though I think the EU is thinking that blowing up critical energy pipelines and seriously damaging Europes economy through the resulting much higher energy prices wasn't too friendly. Although if you ask "cui bono?" there are some pointers in that direction, is not proven, and there are also pointers in other directions. I refrain of accusing without reasonable proof. >All to boost US energy exports, make US manufacturing more competitive and met US geopolitical goals. I cannot blame them for that. Of course anything they do is in their benefit. Some may argue, is precisely what the government should do. It is clear, that while the action in Venezuela was against a very shady government, was done thinking in US interests (as can be clearly seen by titles as "Trump Says Venezuela Will Buy Only US-Made Products From Oil Deal Proceeds"). So yes, they do all in own interest, and the EU isn't and wasn't very different. Alone if you consider the long colonialism years. Now the EU is acting poorly, but I would say not out of altruism, but incompetence and bureaucratic stagnation. I will not say "is impossible" they do the same in Greenland... For good reason I think. BUT comparing the 2 is also farfetched. I know plenty of people from Venezuela, and unless you were part of the government, you were strongly against it. I know no venezuelan (from the at least 100 I know) that wanted Maduro there. And many are still in party modus. Granted, I know primarily expats, so, survivor bias may apply... but still.
- heraldgeezer 10mo agoPeople like you drive EU to China instead. USA an enemy to EU because of Venezuela? LMAO, EU has said nothing. In fact we agree. We have no relations to Venezuela. Now if the USA attacks Greenland, that is different.
- dekrg 10mo agoIt is the US and its recent actions, including its rhetoric, that are driving people towards China. Also, only reacting to US aggression after Greenland is attacked? Not prepare at all and then write a strongly worded letter after the fact? If, after everything Trump has done, you still think he isn't serious about annexing Greenland then you and people like you, including the eurocrats, are truly hopeless.
- DrScientist 10mo agoOr to put it another way - is the binary US/China choice as top dog a false one? I suspect most countries would prefer a multi-polar world where the majority is dominant ( democratic ), not one particular country ( autocratic ). ie why do we have to choose to be under the heel of the US or under the heel of China? The US has been playing the benevolent dictator role for the last 70 years, but when faced with losing the dictator role, the benevolent facade is dropping. The US is mistaken to think that countries not wanting US dominance is the same as wanting Chinese dominance - they, in fact, want neither.
- richwater 10mo ago> we will be less dependent on US global oil police EU, Germany especially Loves Russian oil. So congrats?
- supriyo-biswas 10mo agoIt is perfectly normal for an anycast network operator to have multiple sites from which they make BGP announcements (which is how anycast works in the first place), which gives them multiple vantage points for this sort of analysis. Other CDN companies can do it too, it's just that they don't work on signalling their engineering focused organization.
- bandrami 10mo agoThis was a while ago but I think it was Akamai that pioneered that. I remember how impressive it was in the early oughts though we take it for granted now.
- usefulposter 10mo ago[flagged]
- samsari 10mo agoThey have a lot of resources, Cloudflare Is Awesome
- bayindirh 10mo ago> Cloudflare Is Awesome Until their systems block you for no reason. I recently had a similar issue on a work related site. Fortunately, I was able to reach to the administrator (which is on another country) and had the knowledge to write a report which was useful enough for the said administrator. And this is for a system which has the same static IP which is not shared with anything for 10ish years.
- afandian 10mo agoI recently, with great reluctance, had to put a personal site behind Cloudflare free option. It gets lots of use, but brings no revenue (costs me to run) and I have little spare time. Found out that I was blocked from it in my default setup. Firefox with default settings, and no VPN. I'm working hard to turn Cloudflare off. Cloudflare is not remotely awsome. It's also a solution to a problem (aggressive scrapers that produce DOS) which is worse.
- duskdozer 10mo agoWhat malicious usage are you seeing? You might have a lot more usage than me, but fail2ban has been enough
- afandian 10mo agoJust very high usage all of a sudden, after years of reasonable usage. Google has indexed it (respectfully) since 2008 just fine. New traffic isn't humans. I blocked some AI scraper user-agents, which helped, a bit. But most new user agents are identifying as vanilla browsers, not scrapers. I don't have numbers. It was enough to consume all nginx worker_connections. Raising the number doesn't help, as it's just reverse proxying to JVM. After the switch, Cloudflare showed USA and Singapore as heavy traffic sources. I don't mind scrapers on the site, but app is a search engine (of sorts) so every page view consumes some CPU. Including 'facet this search' buttons. My (WIP) solution is to rewrite to make it all client-side and put it all on a CDN.
- bauruine 10mo agoYou don't have to be cloudflare for this kind of analysis you can do it yourself without even needing an ASN using RIPE RIS. https://www.ripe.net/analyse/internet-measurements/routing-information-service-ris/ https://www.ripe.net/analyse/internet-measurements/routing-i...
- Fiveplus 10mo agoI'm half sleepy but I liked the post. The analysis regarding path prepending really drives the accident theory home. If a state actor were trying to intercept traffic (MITM), the last thing they would do is pad the AS path multiple times because that tells the global routing table, "Don't come this way, I am the long scenic route" lol This could be a classic fat finger config error, most likely a route map intended to manipulate traffic engineering for their own upstream links that inadvertently leaked widely because of a missing deny-all clause. Neverthless, a good reminder that BGP is still fundamentally a trust based system where a single typo in a config file can cascade globally. Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by a missing export filter.
- geocar 10mo ago> If a state actor were trying to intercept traffic (MITM), the last thing they would do is pad the AS path That's presumptuous: A state actor would (and could trivially) pad the wrong directions to flow traffic down to pops that are not making new announcements (and thus not-implicated by cloudflare and other "journalistic" efforts). There's also a lot between fat-fingers and deep-state: I know of some non-state actors who do this sort of thing just to fuck with ad impressions. I also doubt much usable intelligence can be gained from mere route-manipulation thing, but I do know that if it is a fat-finger, every techdude in the area was busy at that time trying to figure it out, and wasn't doing their best work twelve hours later... > most likely a route map intended to manipulate traffic engineering for their own upstream links ...that being said, this does seem plausible: Most smaller multihomed sites I've seen (and a few big ones!) have some kind of adhoc health monitoring/rebalance function that snmp or something and does autoexpect/curl or something-else to the router to run some (probably broken) script, because even if your uplinks are symmetrical, the rest of the Internet isn't, so route-stuffing remains the best way to manipulate ingress traffic. > Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by a missing export filter. As soon as I peer with two big sites that don't peer directly with each-other, they both gotta let me forward announcements unfiltered across them. Once I have a third, I have a legitimate need to manipulate my own ingress. The problems with the BGP are legion, and not just one thing that prevents BGP and security from sharing time in a sentence.
- lucideer 10mo agoThe post mentions a number of times that leaks happen "all the time", but the only comparative data shown related to this is for historical leaks from AS8048. Does anyone have data on what the general frequency of these leaks is likely to be across the network?
- VBprogrammer 10mo agoBGP is outside of my skillset, and I'm sure the analysis is fair and accurate. However, had billion dollar US based company Cloudflare detected widespread manipulation of routing tables by the US secret services, I certainly wouldn't trust them to publish it.
- sgjohnson 10mo agoI’m pretty confident that the US SIGINT agencies wouldn’t manipulate BGP to redirect traffic somewhere, as such a hijack will ALWAYS leave traces that would be observable by anyone impacted, downstream or upstream. US SIGINT agencies? They’d just pwn the routers they are interested in. And almost certainly they’ve already done it. Like 10+ years ago. BGP hijacks are really low-tech and trivial to detect. And competent intelligence agencies don’t do either, unless it comes with enough plausible deniability that it would even be insane to suggest foul play. I operate a small BGP hobbynet under 2 different AS numbers, and even I keep logs about path changes. Not for any practical purpose, just sheer curiosity. BGP is a globally distributed and decentralized system. The messages (announcements) propogate virtually across the entire internet. If someone hijacked a route to a prefix that I’ve received, and the path I’ve received is the hijacked one, I’d get that information. So yes, if that happened, I’d totally expect CloudFlare to publish it, unless they got a NSL. Which they most probably wouldn’t get, as NOTHING about the event would be secret—-it would be out in the open for everyone to see the instant it would happen. There are also tools like https://bgp.tools https://bgp.tools which operate public route collectors, with the data being publicly available. RIPE has one too.
- lowpro 10mo agoI’ve seen leaks impact my company directly 4 or 5 times in 4 years, so I would think often enough since we own a /9~ and don’t change our routes too often.
- deleted 10mo ago[deleted]
- moktonar 10mo agoThe real question tho is: how would you become the mitm reserving for yourself the benefit of the doubt?
- Bengalilol 10mo agoThat’s a very new feeling for me. I read the entire post (with no prior knowledge of BGP at all) and I got chills from thinking how deeply intertwined US companies and the US government are. I know this has always been the case, of course, but now I have lost trust. Whatever the reasons of this "leak" were, I am not accepting any information written in this message (search for the link to another coverage of the incident in the comments). It is quite weird and quite logical at the same time: this is the end of an era.
- heraldgeezer 10mo ago[flagged]
- embedding-shape 10mo agoOkay, but would you rather be assassinated by a shot in the head, or a shot in the heart??? Not sure why people need to chose between the US or China, and especially why you started thinking about this when someone seems to just want to share their feeling that they've lost their trust in their government. So what if they trust China more/less, what is that supposed to mean with their relationship with US government? Suddenly they shouldn't actually have a lost it, because some people prefer US over China? I just don't understand this train of thought, and how it's even relevant here.
- heraldgeezer 10mo ago>someone seems to just want to share their feeling that they've lost their trust in their government ?? I interfered it as someone outside the USA. Why? Because I hear that sentiment a lot here. USA bad. Okay, now what. They are the most important trade and resource partner. oh no the feelings Do something. Solve something. Realpolitik. >Not sure why people need to chose between the US or China Because the EU needs outside trade partners.
- newsclues 10mo agoReality isn’t simple or perfect, but pretending you live in utopia is stupidity
- Fokamul 10mo ago[flagged]
- azalemeth 10mo agoIt might be worth linking this document from the Snowden leaks: https://christopher-parsons.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/nsa-network-shaping-101.pdf https://christopher-parsons.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/n... "NSA Network Shaping 101". Big descriptions of ASINs, and layer 3 shaping. Written in 2007.
- 23434dsf 10mo ago[flagged]
- embedding-shape 10mo agoBut what alternatives do we have? Coming across communities where there are people who seemingly at least think a bit is hard to come by, and certainly there doesn't seem to be any non-US resource/community that offers this today.
- tazjin 10mo agoYou mean there doesn't seem to be any English non-US resource.
- lukan 10mo agoThere is a non english international technical community debating interesting things in a non flame war style? In what language do they communicate? Esperanto? (I suppose some want french to be lingua franca, others spanish, others chinese .. but de facto those ain't international spoken languages, despite having lots of speakers)
- embedding-shape 10mo agoNo, I speak three languages fluently, and there is no $LANGUAGE non-US resource/community that has discussions on the same level as HN, particularly then it comes to the width of experience of the users + (sometimes) nuance when the topic is bit divisive.
- deleted 10mo ago
- potato-peeler 10mo agoSlightly off topic, but if I want to understand the concepts discussed in this article, what all topics should I learn? Is this a good starting place or enough to understand everything in this article - https://beej.us/guide/bgnet/ https://beej.us/guide/bgnet/
- f1shy 10mo agoBecause of the formulation of the question, I assume (please don't be irritated, if wrong) that you have very little knowledge of networking. In that case, it won't harm the Beej guide, but probably not the best point to start. The article discuses BGP protocol, which is totally absent in the linked guide. You may write literally millions of networking applications without need to know anything about BGP. Only if you are working in the backbone of the internet, you will encounter BGP, not even in big private networks. It will be a long way to really start from 0 up to BGP.
- 123pie123 10mo agoI was trying to think of an analogy Kind of like wanting to learn how a car engine works and asking about fleet management in trucks/ lorries. BGP is one of things I've learnt then forget the next day (multiple times)
- f1shy 10mo agoMe too. The problem is that you just (at least I) never use day to day.
- hahahahhaah 10mo agoWhat about this? https://www.cloudflare.com/en-au/learning/security/glossary/what-is-bgp/ https://www.cloudflare.com/en-au/learning/security/glossary/... The goal for me is conceptual understanding, not to build an ISP. And network knowledge is light... just enough to be a cloud monkey
- potato-peeler 10mo agoI have to start from somewhere. I don’t mind the grind. I am fascinated by networking. Will begin with beej guide, and go from there.
- mbix77 10mo agoScary that so much of the basic internet infrastructure is being managed by US companies. Maybe now the rest of the world will change and become more independent. We should have learnt our lesson long ago though.
- jaza 10mo agoConsidering that the internet was invented and built from scratch by the US military, US universities, and US companies, why are you surprised? And who do you suggest could or should manage much of the internet backbone, if not them?
- sgjohnson 10mo agoWhat do you mean? The internet is virtually entirely decentralized. There is no one central BGP router.
- kevin_thibedeau 10mo agoThe rest of the world exports its talent to the US because they don't pay enough. There's no reason why the EU couldn't have made an Akamai or Cloudflare clone decades ago save for the money.
- MORPHOICES 10mo ago[dead]
- _heimdall 10mo agoThe comments here surprise me a bit. The common thread so far seems to be a general fear of US based companies, but how is that relates to the article? Cloudflare's post is pretty boring here in that regard. They dig into how BGP works and propose that similar leaks seem common for the Venezuelan ISP in question. Sure they could be wrong or even actively hiding the truth of what happened here, but the article mentions nothing of Cloudflare being involved in the action and they're describing a networking standard by pointing to publicly available BGP log data. What am I missing here that everyone else seemed to zero in on?
- ffsm8 10mo agoProbably because most people only read headlines (and maybe 3 paragraphs) combined with the fact that the US has a long history of doing what people are condemning them for, even if this particular instance probably wasn't a case of such behavior. Especially considering how the general sentiment towards the US has gotten bitter with constant threads of invasion of Denmark and Canada by their government. Or it's just Russian and China socket accounts? Who knows...
- xocnad 10mo agoI share your view - how does this article imply US companies and/or government involvement? If there were such involvement what aspect of BGP gives the US entities more ability to carry this out vs other nefarious actors? I ask this sincerely knowing almost nothing about BGP and wanting to learn...
- jeroenhd 10mo agoYou may have missed https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46504963 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46504963 a few days ago where this same anomaly was discussed and American government involvement was directly implied by the article.
- Ajedi32 10mo agoThe top comment of that thread points out exactly the same thing this Cloudflare article does; that there doesn't really seem to be be any indication this was anything nefarious.
- keybored 10mo ago> As news unfolds surrounding the U.S. capture and arrest of Venezuelan leader Nicolás Maduro, ... It is also noteworthy that these leak events begin over twelve hours prior to the U.S. military strikes in Venezuela. ... This is how I imagine Russian companies in Russia write about the Russian war on Ukraine.
- deleted 10mo ago[deleted]
- hk1337 10mo agoI probably glossed over it in all the posts but… What is a BGP?
- literalAardvark 10mo agoIt's the protocol used by carriers to route traffic globally. (Make automated decisions about which core router should receive the traffic coming out of your AS ("network", kinda) ) It's entirely detached from anything else so you're pretty unlikely to have heard of it. In that way it's similar to SS7.
- patmorgan23 10mo agoThe Internet is a network of Networks, BGP (Boarder Gateway Protocol) is how routers tell other routers what networks they are connected to. This allows you to connect to any device on the Internet, even if you have to go through 5 different networks to get there.
- __MatrixMan__ 10mo agoI once was half way through a road trip when google maps routed me off the highway, through a walmart parking lot, and onto another highway. I assumed it was a badly performing algorithm. But if it had instead routed me through a McDonalds drive through, I'd have assumed it was foul play. I think the article makes a decent case that this was the former and not the latter, though it would be interesting to see route leaks visualized on a map over time. Too many odd coincidences could sway me the other way.
- esseph 10mo agoThe only reason BGP route leaks aren't more common is the filtering of other ISPs. It's pretty easy to make a mistake you don't intend to.
- patmorgan23 10mo agoTruth. There's been a lot of work over the past 10-15 years to strap on best practices and validation to make these kinds of incidents less common or impossible. The article even talks about several upcoming changes/standards at the end.
- 8organicbits 10mo agoThis is a good opportunity to assess what parts of your own online activity could be impacted by an attacker in the middle (assisted by a BGP leak or otherwise) and, if you're a service provider, how you can protect your customers. At first pass you probably use HTTPS/TLS for the web, and you know that you shouldn't click through invalid certificate warnings. So the web, tentatively, looks pretty safe. Email jumps out as vulnerable to eavesdropping, as we largely use opportunistic encryption when transferring messages between mail servers and an on-network-path attacker can use STARTTLS stripping or similar techniques. Most mail servers happily send using cleartext or without validating the TLS certificate. Check that you and your counter-parties are using DNSSEC+DANE, or MTA-STS to ensure that authenticated encryption is always used. Adoption is still quite low, but it's a great time to get started. Watch out for transactional email, like password reset messages, which virtually never validate encryption in transit (https://alexsci.com/blog/is-email-confidential-in-transit-yet/#whats-the-impact https://alexsci.com/blog/is-email-confidential-in-transit-ye... ; instead use multi-factor encryption). TLS certificates themselves are at risk, unfortunately. An attacker who controls the network in-and-out of your DNS servers can issue domain-verified certificates for your domain; even removing protections like CAA records. DNSSEC is the classic solution here, although using a geographically distributed DNS provider should also work (see multi-perspective validation). Certificate transparency log monitoring should detect any attacker-issued certificates (a review of certificates issued for .ve domains would be interesting). Ideally, we should build an internet where we don't need to trust the network layer. A BGP route leak would be a performance/availability concern only. We're not there yet, but now is a great time to take the next step in that direction.
- tptacek 10mo agoAttackers hijacking domains to get certificates issued are generally hijacking registrar accounts, which DNSSEC doesn't help with, which is probably one of the many reasons DNSSEC is so rarely deployed.
- 8organicbits 10mo agoWe know, you've told us many times. But that's not the context of the thread.
- tedggh 10mo agoPeople are so wanting to believe there was an advanced cyber attack to Venezuela’s grid and ISPs that they forget this is a country that hasn’t updated its infrastructure in more than two decades while also not providing any significant maintenance. Most of the “new” technology deployed at the state and federal level comes from corrupt foreign and domestic “suitcase” companies that charged a lot of money to deliver poorly designed systems often even lacking the as-sold equipment. So Venezuela isn’t precisely the most formidable adversary when it comes to cybersecurity.
- deleted 10mo ago[deleted]
- esseph 10mo ago1. There was a cyber attack on the Venezuelan power grid. This disrupted comms coming into the attack and made it much harder to coordinate a response. 2. It was not in any way related to this BGP, of which, as someone in networking, looks like a simple and fairly common mistake. It wouldn't really buy them anything anyway, the breach happened 6+ months before.
- patmorgan23 10mo agoYeah, the US government has advanced cyberwar fare capabilities, but this BGP anomaly is not a result of, or evidence of that.
- rafaelm 10mo agoThis is CANTV they are talking about. This is the company I requested a new phone line from and it took 9.5 years to get it installed. After waiting for 3 years, I gave up ended up paying one of their technicians I randomly found working in the street. He gave me a phone line that apparently used to belong to a taxi company, judging by all the wrong number calls I got. All that just to get 4mbps DSL service in 2019. Last year, out of nowhere, I finally got a call from the company saying they were ready to install it. Thankfully, a bunch of companies appeared out of nowhere (a lot of them with links to people in the govt, surprise) in 2020 and we got fiber. Oh and a couple of years ago, my parents "lost" their phone line and have been without POTS ever since. Maybe it's karma for me paying for a phone line all those years ago...
- deleted 10mo ago[deleted]
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 10mo agoThere have been BGP shenanigans before. https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2018/11/major-bgp-mishap-takes-down-google-as-traffic-improperly-travels-to-china/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2018/11/major... > Google goes down after major BGP mishap routes traffic through China
- anticristi 10mo agoWhether the claims are true or not, this was a very entertaining BGP refresher. It made me wonder: 15+ years ago, I was network engineer and we used quite a bit of "BGP community magic" to get the routing outcomes we wanted. If BGP only really needed to represent three types of peers (provider, customer, actual peer), wouldn't BGP configuration and perhaps even BGP be massively simplified?
- sophacles 10mo agoIt would be massively simplified. Simple isn't always good. By analogy: i could massively simplify google maps direction algorithm by getting rid of all that annoying and unnecessary traffic information, annoyingly complex labels about speed limits and lane count, and all the data points about stop signs, traffic lights, and so on. Its just a path-finding algorithm after all and all that extra info just makes for more computation and complexity. Who cares if it mean all the traffic for a major metro goes across a 1-lane bridge and leaves all the other roads empty.... its the shortest path, what could go wrong?
- hoten 10mo ago> 8 min read hah.
- googlehater 10mo agoAs someone who knows nothing about networking, this felt really easy to follow. Thanks for sharing!
- VanTheBrand 10mo agoThis article existing at all is a bit suspicious IMO
- qalmakka 10mo ago> Telecom Italia Sparkle A corollary to the Hanlon's razor: prefer assuming incompetence over malice if there's Telecom Italia involved in any shape or form