11 ms·
Solar leads EU electricity generation as renewables hit 54%
- timmg 1y agoIsn't there a sweet spot where solar is too much of your energy mix -- due to its intermittency? I think I read that once you get to like 40%, you need to spend a lot more on storage. Is the EU also ramping up (battery?) storage? Or are they getting near the max of what they can do with solar? (Or do I have it all wrong :/ )
- pfdietz 1y agohttps://www.solarpowereurope.org/insights/outlooks/european-market-outlook-for-battery-storage-2025-2029/detail https://www.solarpowereurope.org/insights/outlooks/european-... Six-fold increase in battery capacity in Europe predicted by 2029.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- adgjlsfhk1 1y agonot really. At this point, solar is basically free, and having extra free energy has all sorts of benefits. For the EU, in particular, it greatly reduces their dependence on Russian oil and gas. if all you do with extra solar is replace 2 extra hours a day of natural gas consumption, you effectively make yourself have 12% more storage, which decreases Russian leverage.
- pzo 1y agohttps://ourworldindata.org/grapher/energy-consumption-by-source-and-country?country=~OWID_EU27 https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/energy-consumption-by-sou... in EU: gas, oil is still 60% of usage. You are not going to heat you home during winter with electricity anytime soon, same like we are not all gonna drive electric cars this decade.
- tpm 1y agoPlenty of people are heating their homes with electricity already, that's what heat pumps are for.
- inglor_cz 1y agoNorth of the Alps, using solar to heat your home in the winter is unrealistic. In Czechia, winter is already dark enough to make solar in the coldest months a rounding error. Further north, uh.
- tpm 1y agoI'm sorry but this thread does not talk about using PV to heat your home in the winter. But it is absolutely possible to use electricity to heat homes, it's widely used in northern countries. And the nice thing about electricity is that it can be generated in one place and used in another.
- inglor_cz 1y agoThis thread is talking about reduction of dependence on oil&gas supplied by various nefarious regimes, though. Still quite a challenge in the winter, with barely any sun out there. "it can be generated in one place and used in another." It can, but we are far from having such a robust grid all across the continent. I am not even sure if we are getting closer. Both economic and political aspects come into play, which might be harder to address than the purely technical ones. For example, France really does not want cheap Spanish solar energy to flood the French market, hence the inadequate connection over the Pyrenees. Everyone knows that, including the European Commission, but France is one of the two really big continental players who can do anything they want and cannot be effectively punished. The "everyone is equal, but some are more equal" principle.
- tpm 1y agoYes, there are and will be issues. We should have started much sooner. But we absolutely have to do this.
- timerol 1y agoI don't know of any specific thresholds, but it's worth mentioning that 54% of Q2 was renewable, and solar peaks in Q2. Solar was also only 36.8% of that renewable generation (just under 20% of Q2's total), so there's a long way to go before solar is 40% of the total energy mix. If there is an important threshold when solar reaches 40% of the full year's production, then solar will need to almost quadruple before that's a concern. For all of 2024, solar was 22.4% of renewables, and renewables were 47% of the total[1], meaning that solar was 10.5% of total electricity over the full year. [1] https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/en/web/products-eurostat-news/w/ddn-20250319-1 https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/en/web/products-eurostat-news/...
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- Energieclaskdfj 1y ago[dead]
- 0cf8612b2e1e 1y agoI hope not. More times when electricity prices go negative is hopefully going to open up new market opportunities (outside crypto mining). Generating chemical feedstocks from CO2, intermittent desalination, whatever process which is predicated on cheap energy.
- StopDisinfo910 1y agoThe issue is not sorely about negative price. It’s about keeping base capacity profitable so the grid doesn’t collapse. The energy strategy of the EU was hopeless for a long time and is only marginally better now. It’s not as braindead as the monetary union but close. Germany was actively sabotaging France for a long time while having to restart coal power plants and investing in gas fuelled capacity. Sadly the union is heavily unbalanced since the UK left.
- foobarian 1y agoPray tell, why is the monetary union braindead? Asking for a friend stockpiling lire for collection value
- StopDisinfo910 1y agoIt’s a monetary union with no common fiscal policies and no mechanism to correct disparity between members. Complete train wreck since it has been put in place. Germany has been abusing it from the start running huge trade surplus, compressing salaries, using its excess savings to buy foreign debts instead of investing and being shielded from monetary appreciation by the consumption and investments of other countries. The euro is basically Germany robbing blind the other members while pretending to be virtuous and blocking most of what could have improved the situation.
- marcosdumay 1y ago> and no mechanism to correct disparity between members AFAIK, they created some mechanisms after the 2008 crisis. Every country there now effectively prints money in differing rates, and the EU only regulates some limits.
- Jyaif 1y agoSome numbers: During winter, France uses ~50% more electricity per day than during summer. And during cloudy days in winter, solar produces 10%-15% what it produces during summer. If you don't have month-long battery storage, in order to be fully solar based France would need to produce 20 times more electricity than needed during summer.
- pfdietz 1y agoOr you use a different technology optimized for long term storage. Batteries are not that technology. Hydrogen (or other e-fuels) or long term thermal storage. For the latter, see standard-thermal.com
- triceratops 1y ago> Or you use a different technology optimized for long term storage. Batteries are not that technology I've heard this before but can you explain why? A cursory web search tells me batteries hold charge pretty well for 6 months. And the new sodium batteries from CATL are certainly cheap enough.
- nicoburns 1y agoThe problem with batteries for long-term storage is the capacity. You would need an ENORMOUS amount of them to store months worth of energy.
- pfdietz 1y agoFor long term storage, capex is king, not round trip efficiency. The capex of batteries ($ per kWh of storage) is much too high. There aren't enough charge/discharge cycles to amortize that capex. This is unlike with diurnal storage, where there are many thousands of cycles over which to spread that cost.
- triceratops 1y agoThank you that makes a lot of sense.
- Qwertious 1y agoJust solar without wind is a terrible idea. Which is why no one's doing it.
- pfdietz 1y agoIt's quite feasible in some places, like India.
- onlyrealcuzzo 1y agoIf you're in the Atacama Desert, I doubt it's 40%, but not really relevant. This is ALL renewables, not just Solar - the article states that Solar is ~20% now in the EU. Wind typically counts for ~15%, and Hydro (which may or may not be counted as renewable) counts as ~15%. So most places can pretty easily get to ~40% solar, ~15% wind, ~15% hydro = ~70% renewable. Throw in ~20% Nuclear (basically all of Europe before Germany sh*t the bed), and you're at ~90% - with limited need for storage - a large portion of which could come from infra that already exists for pumped hydro and regular overnight solar storage. We're quite a ways away from diminishing returns. We're ~8 years away from a global ~40% of electricity coming from solar EVEN IF it continues to grow at ~30% YoY.
- runarb 1y ago> Hydro (which may or may not be counted as renewable) counts as ~15%. Why or when wouldn't one consider hydropower a renewable energy source?
- thecompilr 1y agoLook at the Hoover dam
- citrin_ru 1y agoYou mean low water levels? Isn’t it caused by agriculture water use? A dam allows to use more water (for agriculture) but one can choose not to use more.
- port11 1y agoEx worked in an NGO that fights the expansion of hydro in Portugal. There are several reasons. It's destructive, has very high emissions, and doesn't actually generate that much power because we have long-ish drought seasons. Hydro was fueled or fueling corrupt construction deals while destroying natural reserves and wildlife. In some cases, night-time hydro was much more expensive than any other power source.
- black_puppydog 1y agoGiven the development of battery prices (and especially LFP and sodium ion) most new solar capacity will he solar+battery. With some software tweaks, these are not only base load compatible, but can even take on grid frequency stabilisation. Check out recent episodes of Tue Volts podcast. It's actually a bit crazy.
- buckle8017 1y agoThe better way to think about the grids energy mix is some matrix of reliability, predictability, and rotational mass. Solar and wind have no rotational mass, are unreliable and unpredictable
- crote 1y agoSolar and wind are extremely reliable, because they are distributed. Unlike large-scalec fossil or nuclear, a single plant going offline isn't a big deal. Solar and wind are quite predictable - it's just weather forecasting. We have a pretty good idea what it is going to produce 7 days from now - we just can't control it. Solar and wind can provide rotational mass. Existing installations just aren't engineered for it, because grid following makes more sense in a fossil-heavy grid. If extra inertia is needed, batteries are the perfect source for it, as it can instantly scale from -100 to +100 to soak up excess or fill in shortages. Or we can just install a bunch of flywheels, no big deal.
- Havoc 1y ago>I think I read that once you get to like 40%, you need to spend a lot more on storage. You can get pretty high before the economics get sketchy. Below analysis concluded that for many sunny places that point is in the 90%+. Most of EU will be lower than said sunny places, but point is it's not 40%. And the sprinkling of wind, nuclear, geo, hydro means there is a fair bit of room to still push. Plus both solar and storage tech is still moving rapidly https://ember-energy.org/app/uploads/2025/06/Ember-24-Hour-Solar-Electricity-June-2025-6.pdf https://ember-energy.org/app/uploads/2025/06/Ember-24-Hour-S...
- mrtksn 1y agoThe growth is still slow compared to China and the evolution of the international order though. Had EU already switched to renewables 4 years ago there wouldn't be any disruption by the war Russia started in Ukraine. I love exploring these graphs: https://ember-energy.org/data/electricity-data-explorer/?entity=EU&entity=United+States&entity=China https://ember-energy.org/data/electricity-data-explorer/?ent... EU is doing just slightly better than US. US has the advantage of its fossil fuels but it's actually China that is doing the revolution. They are accelerating and at some point not too far away will reach abundance and switch off all the fossils. It's unwise that the new US administration be pushing for the opposite of China. But what's actually beyond me is the existence of Europeans that demand more fossil fuels. It is double ridiculous because EU doesn't even have these fossil resources at any viable scale. It is largely imported, they must be on the payroll of US and Russia or very stupid. IMHO EU should just drop everything and do China level or even beyond transition to Solar and similar.
- onlyrealcuzzo 1y ago> Had EU already switched to renewables 4 years ago there wouldn't be any disruption by the war Russia started in Ukraine. They might've just started the war 4 years earlier, then.
- tialaramex 1y agoIn 2014 Russia decided to attack Ukraine because its political ambitions had been thwarted. A pro-Russian politician took existing EU integration plans and went "fuck that, we love Russia" instead and Ukrainians particularly in the West of the country turned out on the streets in a huge protest. In the aftermath, with Ukraine now definitively not in Russia's sphere of control, Putin ordered seizure of the eastern parts of Ukraine. Four years earlier doesn't make sense, Russia has plans that are expected to work out in their favour, and Putin is less secure in 2010 than he is today, invading a neighbour looks very ambitious in 2010. Moving the more recent part of the invasion - which starts with trying to seize Kyiv - forward by four years maybe makes more sense, but that compresses a lot of timeline.
- gyudin 1y ago
- gred 1y ago[flagged]
- lentil_soup 1y agoSpain is actually one of the countries with the most solar power generation in the EU It's also the country with the highest solar power potential https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_power_in_the_European_Union https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_power_in_the_European_...
- lomase 1y agoSome months ago in Spain the price of solar energy became negative and minutes later there was a blackout. Some people like gred say is because too much solar energy is a problem. In my, uneducated, opinion it was a market failure.
- gred 1y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2025_Iberian_Peninsula_blackout https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2025_Iberian_Peninsula_blackou...
- lentil_soup 1y agoyes, I live in Spain. Still don't get the cryptic comment, though, are you claiming Spain will get more blackouts because the EU increases solar energy? that the EU will get the blackouts? that solar energy causes blackouts?
- alecco 1y agoSolar, and renewables in general, are very unstable. You need nuclear or fossil to stabilize the grid. From that page: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2025_Iberian_Peninsula_blackout#Investigations_of_potential_causes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2025_Iberian_Peninsula_blackou... I'm pro-solar, but by EU politicians sugar-coating it things are getting out of control. Worst part, it seems there were warnings for months. But since it was raised by the opposition they were ignored.
- adev_ 1y agoI really hate this kind of article. Because they do twist numbers to serve a narrative (on renewable energy) instead of showing the complete picture fairly. > June 2025 was a milestone month: Solar became the EU’s single largest electricity source for the first time ever. Yes June was a record for Solar power production due to an amazing weather.... But it was a pure disaster for Solar power profitability with an all time low. The peak was too large for the grid to consume and the price went negative (or null) for the entire month during the solar hours. That should bring serious questions on the ROI of any future investment in solar capacity and about Europe electricity storage capacity. The article ignores that entirely. https://www.rte-france.com/eco2mix/les-donnees-de-marche# https://www.rte-france.com/eco2mix/les-donnees-de-marche# > Some countries are already nearly 100% renewable. Denmark led with an impressive 94.7% share of renewables in net electricity generated This is also miss-leading. Production does not mean Consumption. Denmark is very far from 94% consumption based on renewable. It rely heavily on import from German grid (Coal and Gaz powered) almost every night and this is a disaster in term of CO2 emission. That leads to emissions over ~140CO2g/kwh in average, meaning way over what other Scandinavians countries are able to do (e.g Sweden < 15gCO2/kwh) https://app.electricitymaps.com/map/zone/DK-DK1/3mo/daily https://app.electricitymaps.com/map/zone/DK-DK1/3mo/daily > In total, 15 EU countries saw their share of renewable generation rise year-over-year. Yes but that does not mean CO2 emissions are falling (which should be the only thing that matter). Belgium is closing perfectly working nuclear powerplants recently that are providing around 30% of the country consumption. Meaning the country CO2 emission are expected to increase significantly this year due to that and this is just plain stupid. Spain might follow a similar track and this is disastrous. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_in_Belgium https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_in_Belgium In short, please stop this kind of article. - Renewable are good but what Europe need is massive investment in energy storage through battery and/or pump hydro. And this is nowhere here. Blind praise in solar capacity is counterproductive. - If we do not carefully control our current capacity of non-controllable renewable in Europe, we might doom the ROI of an entire industry for the decades to come. And this is the taxpayer will have to sponge all this mess financially speaking. - What matters is CO2 emission and CO2 reduction, not renewable capacity. This kind of article favors wrong political decisions by putting first and foremost renewable capacity as the only metric that matters. The Belgian nuclear situation is one of these terrible decisions.
- jokoon 1y agofor an entire year?
- top_sigrid 1y agoLiterally the first sentence: More than half of the European Union’s (EU) electricity came from renewables in the second quarter of 2025, and solar is leading from the front.
- zyxzevn 1y agoduring the night
- nickslaughter02 1y agoIs that why electricity in EU is so expensive? https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/cost-of-electricity-by-country https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/cost-of-e...
- mrtksn 1y agoYes, its because it is still short of %100 renewables and EU is importing its fossil fuels. When Russia invaded Ukraine it caused a spike in prices, now its coming down. Prices will go down as renewables proliferate, probably we will pay some fixed amount as equipment maintenance fee once its %100.
- Gud 1y agoOur electricity was a lot cheaper when we had more nuclear. It doesn’t take a genius to figure out that dismantling functional nuclear power plants, like they did in Germany and Sweden, has been detrimental for Europe. Now the same people who were opposing nuclear are saying we should pursue wind and solar. Give me a break.
- mrtksn 1y agoIt's just Germany that shut down a few reactors, their internal politics and has nothing to do with EU or people who want renewables due to climate, ecology or political reasons.
- nonethewiser 1y agoOK and did they increase not renewables by 54%? You can't really increase overall capacity from solar, wind etc. Look at what happened in Portugal when it gets cloudy.
- nielsbot 1y agoWhen people talk about countries having "energy independence", isn't moving to renewables the right move? (Since you reduce your demand for fuel inputs to 0, assuming a 100% transition)
- zdragnar 1y agoFor many countries, pure renewables plus batteries only works with an international grid. In a different thread here, Germany was coming up quite a bit during the dunkelflaute, and the only way to go pure renewable is to import energy from, say, Morocco. It does achieve potential independence from current adversaries, but only by introducing dependence on other nations instead. Countries like the US have it a little better independence-wise, except we need (a) significant buildouts of batteries that don't rely on rare earths, because we can't mine them here for environmental reasons, and (b) massive buildouts of solar panels in regions across the country. The upper midwest has something similar to Germany's dunkelflaute- it gets cold enough windmills may even be net negative to keep their turbines ice free, and we can go weeks under total cloud coverage. Supporting all of that is possible, but requires overbuilding the grid to such an extent that the carbon cost of the cement and metals added to the grid would extend the payoff period quite a bit. It's definitely not a free lunch, though probably better to start now than hope for miracle cold fusion or something equally silly.
- nielsbot 1y agoI had to look up "dunkelflaute": "A period of time in which little to no energy can be generated with the use of wind and solar power." https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/Dunkelflaute https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/Dunkelflaute
- BLKNSLVR 1y agoAustralia's reticence in embracing renewables has always seemed obviously corrupt to me given the abundant natural sunlight resources Australia is blessed with, combined with the 100% reliance on importing of oil-based fossil fuels. Australia is self-sufficient in keeping the lights on, due to large coal reserves, but wouldn't be able to transport anything if petrol dried up (and I think Australia only has twelve days of petrol reserve storage). Just imagine the chaos... To the point I would think it would be a National Security priority to electrify transport and build whatever is needed to support that electrification.
- guerrilla 1y agoFucking Germany though with insistence on coal, Russian gas and no nuclear. I'm so suck of literally paying for their mistakes. I wish we could just disconnect them from our grid until they take some responsibility. Also stop dragging your feet sending weapons to Ukraine.
- brikym 1y agoIt's because of stupid tribalism and hysterical non-thinking. When I was there 10 years ago it was really common to see the 'Atomkraft? - Nein Danke' stickers in public places. I guess when the position is held by a majority, that created an environment where people, especially policy makers, did not want to challenge it for they'll get excluded for wrong-think. It is only changing because an even stronger fear (Putin) took hold.
- goobatrooba 1y agoNot sure which country's perspective you are taking but you may wish to consider that the largest part of the subsidies building renewables are EU subsidies which to the largest chunk are financed by Germany which makes a contribution to the EU budget far above any other. So if you look at Spanish solar or Danish wind (not to mention anything in the East where the % contributions of EU funding are very high), a good chunk of these are actually subsidised by the EU and thus to large degree by Germany.
- ggm 1y agowithout going full conspiracy, how much of the AI hype is driven by entities highly invested in the emerging surplus power from gas and coal, or who think they can make bank on a small nuke SMR play if they get the correct contracts with a Datacenter? If we stopped doing insane things with GPUs then what's left is a viable business with CDNs and cloud computing for purposeful activity. Burning coal 24/7 to make dali-m images is silly. But, if I was long on SMR I would totally play up how much power they need and if need be, co-fund the GPU farm to buy my power. Is that not just the electricity version of the GPU maker taking a position in the AI sector as long as the money comes back to buy GPU (which btw, just happened bigly)
- amai 1y agoCountries that rely on selling fossil fuels (e.g Russia) are doomed.