8 ms·
Price of rice in Japan falls below ¥4k per 5kg
- jmpman 1y agoI can buy rice at Costco in the US for $25 for 50lbs, which is equivalent to 854 yen for 5KG. A bit less than 1/4 the cost of Japanese grown rice.
- apeescape 1y agoIsn't Japanese rice pretty different to Costco rice? Genuine question.
- Izikiel43 1y agoJapanese rice variety I think is called Japonica. I'm not sure if costco sells it.
- theultdev 1y agohaven't seen japonica often in the US, but jasmine rice is similar and available pretty much everywhere. in fact, jasmine rice smells and tastes better, and stickier!
- socalgal2 1y agomaybe I mis-understood what you meant by similar here but jasmine rice is nothing at all like japanese rice. Jasmine top, Japanese bottom https://postimg.cc/6y2b0JdB https://postimg.cc/6y2b0JdB They have a completely different consistency when cooked and are used for different things.
- theultdev 1y agoyes in fact, it is. relative to american rice. it's has a similar stickiness, the taste is a bit different, but better imo. it pairs well with asian dishes as opposed to american rices and can be used for sushi. it's not 1:1, but it's certainly a good substitute when you can find japanese rice.
- socalgal2 1y agoJasmine rice can NOT be used for sushi! It's not sticky enough to hold together. The fact that it's not sticky makes it good for fried rice, not for sushi.
- theultdev 1y agohmm, well the jasmine I buy is extra sticky. maybe it's how it turns out in the rice cooker. either way, I've done it and it tastes good /shrug
- fc417fc802 1y agoIn my experience it's just barely sticky enough for sushi provided you don't wash it but I don't think the texture is right for that usage. I prefer it for most things though.
- daedrdev 1y agoCalrose, the primary rice grown in California is a Japonica, its just Japanese rice grown in America. Tamanishiki, which is one of the high grade sushi rices is grown in the US and Japan It is O. s. subsp. japonica
- ac29 1y ago> Calrose, the primary rice grown in California Surprising, because while its widely available in California it seems to be a tiny minority of available rice. A search I did says it is 80% of California's crop, so presumably a lot of it is exported?
- jeffbee 1y agoIt doesn't serve every culinary purpose and most California grocery shoppers are not Japanese. You wouldn't make Moros y Cristianos with it. You wouldn't make Hoppin' John with it. It's no good for your Indian menu. It isn't really what you'd serve beside fried chicken. There is no "best rice" any more than there is "best pants".
- Izikiel43 1y agoGood to know, however I always buy short grain brown rice, I like that one better.
- naniwaduni 1y agoCostco sells a couple of Kokuho-brand Calrose varieties, which are decent drop-ins for for generic East Asian rice.
- treefarmer 1y agoYeah, as someone who started with Costco rice and slowly moved up the quality chain, there is a clear difference in taste between even average Japanese rice and most Costco rice. It would be interesting to see a price/quality comparison between the U.S. and Japanese Costcos though.
- makeitdouble 1y agoThis is one of these case where cross-country comparison might bring little relevant information. Another example could be wine sold at US Cosco vs French Costco. It would be an indicator of something, but I'd personally be lost if I had to interpret it in regards to wine trends in France in general.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- daedrdev 1y agoIn fact Costco has some of the most powerful wine buyers in the world
- SpecialistK 1y agoI can't remember how much I paid, but I was able to buy 10KG of grown-in-Japan short grain rice at Costco in Canada within the last year.
- numpad0 1y agoSpeculating from online comments around it and from looking at bags of Calrose rice, they seem to be few decades behind in cultivation techniques and selective breeding improvements. The grains look smaller, less shiny and more yellowy. but technically they should be of the same strain.
- ericd 1y agoCostco sells a few varieties, this is the one we buy: https://www.costcobusinessdelivery.com/kokuho-rose-us-%231-extra-fancy-rice%2C-medium-grain%2C-25-lbs.product.100112440.html https://www.costcobusinessdelivery.com/kokuho-rose-us-%231-e... It's sushi rice, grown in CA, and it's very good. Same stuff we used to buy from our local Japanese grocery store in CA.
- Spivak 1y agoSnobs will tell you yes, but Kokuho Rose is a California grown sushi rice that's good enough to be served over imported Japanese rice at Japanese restaurants. Really disappointing that the farm is closing up shop.
- eclipticplane 1y agoClosing up shop?! I missed that news. Crushing. It's really the only rice I buy that's accessible but good quality. Sad.
- tsukikage 1y agoCheapest rice I can easily get here in the UK, equivalent to ~1600JPY/5kg: https://www.tesco.com/groceries/en-GB/products/314300009 https://www.tesco.com/groceries/en-GB/products/314300009 Cheapest rice I am actually willing to eat, ~3000JPY/5kg: https://www.tesco.com/groceries/en-GB/products/293247162 https://www.tesco.com/groceries/en-GB/products/293247162 Shortgrain rice, such as Japanese rice, tends to be even more expensive than that. That said, no idea where whatever it is the article is quoting the price of falls on that scale.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- grues-dinner 1y agoIt's quite amazing how many kinds of Basmati and Jasmine rice you can find in a normal UK supermarket, and yet be completely unable to find any shortgrain rice at all: https://www.tesco.com/groceries/en-GB/search?query=short+grain+rice https://www.tesco.com/groceries/en-GB/search?query=short+gra...
- Aeolun 1y agoYou can buy the same rice in Japan if you are really desperate. I think they’re deliberately talking only about rice people actually want to buy.
- PaulHoule 1y agoPeople who eat mostly rice are picky about the rice they eat. Golden Rice 2 was on the market for about five years in the Philippines before it got banned. If anybody had wanted to grow it or eat it it could have been a different story. I was talking to a genetic engineer a few weeks ago who said that the sensory qualities weren't that great. Nothing would have stopped advocates in the US from planting a few acres and selling bags of it (it's approved and all) but had they done so it would have put the lie to the idea that the developers were being persecuted like Prometheus. I don't think it was anywhere near the threat that its opponents said it was but it was nowhere near the boon that its promoters said it was.
- daedrdev 1y agoJapan has very high rice tariffs to protect its domestic rice production. It is not peoples choice, it is not available at a cheaper price.
- jmpman 1y agoI found a TikTok which showed rice in a Japanese Costco. A calrose variety American grown rice (Legrande Family rice) in the Japanese Costco was 2998 yen for 5KG. Must be tariffs causing the price to be so high.
- makeitdouble 1y agoThat's the perfect setting for the "Mom can we have X ? No, we have X at home" meme. Otherwise USA rice is imported in Japan, as well as other countries' and is indeed way cheaper, but not desirable and people aren't literally starving either.
- daedrdev 1y agoCalifornia does make good rice. Japan is just hyper protectionist with extremely high import taxes on rice. They don't get imported because of this tax. The US produces both lower quality and high quality rice, as you might expect of an enormous country that exports half its rice. This is why prices remain high. Do you think someone who is poor would not buy cheaper rice that had 90% the quality if they could? In fact the US produces plenty of Japanese rice (Japonica)
- makeitdouble 1y ago> In fact the US produces plenty of Japanese rice (Japonica) Indeed, I bought some and it was good. Italy also grows Japanese strains and it also of pretty good quality. Those are not cheap either, though. I'm assuming that's not the Costco rice parent was referring. > This is why prices remain high. It's complicated, and no single factor explains it all. Even singling out importing rice, Japan has better options than the US (the SEA region is a much more logical source for instance) On the "it's complicated" part, believe it or not, Japan gov is/was actively restricting rice production as a long term strategy. > Do you think someone who is poor would not buy cheaper rice that had 90% the quality if they could? That's ignoring all the other options, in particular wheat (bread, pasta, noodles etc.), which can be cheaper than cheap rice. It doesn't match the cliche, but Japan has steadily included wheat as a staple over the years.
- theultdev 1y agonot the same species! american white rice is only good when it's transformed into spanish rice, fried rice or creamy rice. otherwise it's too bland because it's stripped. brown rice is better but still not as good. both japonica and jasmine rice are good on their own. love jasmine rice over all of them, it makes your mouth water when you cook it. edit: who downvotes a comment about rice? lol.
- daedrdev 1y agoPremium Tamanishiki (a type of premium sushi rice) is grown in the US and Japan, the US just produces a lot of types of rice. Japonica is a category of rice that includes Calrose for example which is grown primarily in California and is definitely an "American" rice given that it founded the California rice industry
- IAmBroom 1y agoPerhaps because of factual errors (O. s. japonica is not only the same species, but the same subspecies), and pointlessly negative personal opinion making up the rest of your comment.
- tomcam 1y agoCan someone tell me why a statement of fact is being downvoted? I am genuinely puzzled.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- y-curious 1y agoBecause the poster's tone implies that American Calrose rice is inedible vs the superior Japanese rice. That's simply not true, and a bit reductionist.
- tomcam 1y agoIs this the comment you are referring to? I can’t find any such implications. Maybe it was edited? I can buy rice at Costco in the US for $25 for 50lbs, which is equivalent to 854 yen for 5KG. A bit less than 1/4 the cost of Japanese grown rice.
- jmpman 1y agoI also wasn’t following. I primarily eat US rice. The marginally better rice from Japan I might buy if I’m going to make sushi at home, but that’s just because I’d be investing so much time and energy already, might as well spend a few bucks more on a slightly better rice.
- abtinf 1y agoFor everyone else assuming Costco rice is low quality, they offer multiple options. Costco’s basmati rice is excellent quality and can be ordered online 20lb for $27 delivered. So that’s only about double the unit price for top end, premium rice.
- numpad0 1y agoRice in Japan is indeed weirdly expensive in the first place. Typical price is ~1 USD/lbs, but there's been a mysterious shortage and they're retailing at double the regular price. The minister of agriculture right now, Shinjiro Koizumi, is the son of Jun-ichiro Koizumi with now-unpopular legacy of deregulating and wrecking the Japanese postal service among few other government functions. The minister is now advocating for deregulating rice anyhow in response to the ongoing situation, and the situation kind of stinks. Sorry that it's probably not the kind of content appropriate at HN anyway. It's more of "uncovering Cold War history podcast" style of content except it's in live.
- daedrdev 1y agoThe previous minister was fired after they admitted they didn't have to experience the expensive rice because they were given free rice by farms in Japan
- 0cf8612b2e1e 1y agoThat is some bizarre obliviousness of privilege. I thought all of the more-equal-animals knew to keep quiet on the implicit bribes and other luxuries of their station.
- mc3301 1y agoIt's rather quite the opposite in Japan. The "more-equal-animals" consistently make public completely oblivious remarks, only to apologize the following day and then (often) just go back to business as usual.
- bravesoul2 1y agoNice. What is the average supermarket price for the equivalent rice in US.
- downrightmike 1y agoDoesn't matter, its a whole other country
- ac29 1y agoLooking at the closest one to me, $9/5lb (surely much less per pound in a bigger bag)
- NaOH 1y agoRelated: Why are rice prices still high? - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44126639 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44126639 - May 2025 (16 comments) Japan plans to sell rice from emergency stockpiles to cut prices - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42915690 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42915690 - Feb 2025 (11 comments) Why has Japan been hit with rice shortages despite normal crops? - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41366304 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41366304 - Aug 2024 (179 comments)
- b112 1y agoArsenic in rice is on the rise. There is a chart in this article, on how to reduce that. https://scitechdaily.com/scientists-find-new-way-of-cooking-rice-that-removes-arsenic-and-retains-nutrients/ https://scitechdaily.com/scientists-find-new-way-of-cooking-...
- opan 1y ago>The PBA method involves parboiling the rice in pre-boiled water for five minutes before draining and refreshing the water, then cooking it on a lower heat to absorb all the water.
- numpad0 1y agoThat method is for long-grain rice used in other parts of Asia, simply unfit for Japanese rice(or vice versa). It's just their highly British form of humor and customary jest. I'd suggest Brits ban full leaved teas in favor of microwaved teabags while at it.
- b112 1y agoThe study is a British joke? What are you talking about? It seems to work with all rice, just with varying effectiveness. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0048969720368728 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S004896972... Why do you think the study is targeting Japan? And why would the Brits joke about it? Do you think I am? It's just good, general info. Arsenic in rice is problem, and getting worse. I wonder why you would claim something like this, which literally can save lives, is false?
- jeffbee 1y agoSomething about this study is a bit odd. Why does the white rice cooked without rinsing or draining have less arsenic than the raw rice? Is it dissolving then escaping as steam? If so, it seems like the drying step of the experiment screws up the interpretation of the results. If not, conservation of species mass is violated somehow.
- haunter 1y agoCalrose is perfectly fine if you are looking for japanese grown rice replacement in the US. Same 'Oryza sativa subsp. japonica', just a different cultivar. It's the closest thing to Koshihikari but cheaper and widely available. Actually I'd say it's the best overall rice you can get not grown in Japan. Good side by side https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/2a/Koshihikari_and_calrose_rice.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/2a/Koshihik... The "problem" is that you won't find rice like Yumepirika, Akitakomachi, Tsuyahime, or Nanatsuboshi (just a few example of my favorites) anywhere outside of Japan. Even Italy has japonica rice fields but it's a different class all together.
- daedrdev 1y agoIve seen US grown hitomebore and koshihikari, the koshihikari even under the same brand as the Japaneses rice just with a product of USA label
- Aloisius 1y agoAkitakomachi is grown in California. It's what Lundberg Sushi Rice is. Calrose is medium-grain, but Koshihikari itself is grown in California as is a short-grain hybrid with Calrose called Calhikari. Sasanishiki is also being grown.
- snupples 1y agoCalrose is quite different than most Japanese rice, since it's a medium grain. If you've grown up eating rice in Japan, it's instantly noticeable. You can buy California grown Koshihikari now on Amazon, which is a much better substitute.
- dluan 1y agoThis has been a fun/interesting ordeal to watch from far away, though I think people in Japan are feeling a lot of pain right now. In Hawaii we get a lot of imported Japanese rice mainly due to prevalence of Japanese daily groceries here. The typical grocery store (eg donki) carries more than a few strains of rice - koshihikari, hitomebore, nanatsuboshi, hatsushimo, etc. These make a noticeable difference for your spam musubi's, but especially for sushi. We usually rotate between whatever's the cheapest Japanese imported rice, around $30-40 for ~15lbs, but I would say most people here eat Japanese rice. At the start of the War on Trade, we noticed marginal price increases on Japanese rice, but especially noticed steep discounts on California calrose, like $15 for 25lbs, which to me felt insane. The local specialty rice store just had to issue a price increase notice last week (https://the-rice-factory-honolulu.square.site https://the-rice-factory-honolulu.square.site), though this seems like it's more the rice shortage than tariffs. Thoughts and prayers though to the Japanese who will have to eat South Korean rice, once the national reserve stock dwindles. Hope they make it through this struggle period.
- daedrdev 1y agoSome ammounts of hitomebore and koshihikari are produced in the US, I noticed that in Hmart you see product of USA under the same brand as the Japanese rice sometimes (especially recently) Calrose is a japonica rice though obviously produced mainly in California
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- Dylanlacey 1y agoDelicious, but dealing psychic damage.
- chipsa 1y agoThere’s also the shipping problem: it’s actually cheaper to ship from overseas than the US, due to the Jones Act. There’s more ships available to go from East Asia than from California.
- ggm 1y agoSome amount of price control makes sense for strategic defensive reasons: Japan isn't self sufficient in food but like many other economies wants to ensure a viable farming sector. I'm not sure this amount of price control is needed for that outcome. From TV I get the impression Japanese rice production is pretty intensive, but also small plot focussed so not as efficient as Australia where it's miles and miles of field to the horizon. Maybe Japanese rice farmers are a protected species?
- refulgentis 1y agoI'm confused, you open by noting the clear case for protection, and close by asking if protection describes the pricing. Maybe you perceive price controls and protection as separate? Price controls are a way to implement protection.
- ggm 1y agoI'm asking how much. We have a ring-fenced dairy sector and ring fenced apple sector in Australia, biosecurity typically defines the protectionism. We don't pay this level of excess for milk, cheese and apples. You could give direct income support to rice farmers and not recover it by insane pricing for Japanese rice. If memory serves, the whale meat was virtually given away but by no means cost nothing to hunt, flense and store.
- fc417fc802 1y agoFarm subsidies does seem like the well tested approach. A lot of people in the US complain about them but I quite like having the option of some ridiculously low cost staples if I'm willing to forgo quality. Placing the burden on the taxpayers as a whole seems like the right approach for things like food security.
- pfdietz 1y agoA better strategic defense would be domestic meat production, with feed that can be diverted to direct human consumption in an emergency. This would build in a large buffer due to the inefficiency of conversion of feed calories to meat calories.
- kondro 1y agoThe fact the average Japanese person won't even consider trying imported Japonica rice from Australia or USA is madness if budget is a consideration. But as someone who's tried many varieties of Japonica, there is a difference between the best Japan-grown rice and non-speciality rice grown elsewhere, as well as a difference between fresh (Japanese enjoy eating new rice, which is different from many rice-eating cultures) and old rice. I pay somewhere around AUD$14/kg for Japanese rice in Australia, but I also don't eat it that often and I'm not that price sensitive. But also, the average Japanese eats around 1kg of uncooked rice per week. That's ¥800 at the rates in the article (~USD$300/year). Japan's cost of living is generally pretty low, but I doubt +/- $100/year is effecting many people.
- daedrdev 1y agoJapan forces this to be the case with extremely high tariffs on rice imports. It's not that they won't consider it, they literally can't.
- balanced2 1y agoI see cal-rose for shy above 3000 yen. While I didn't grasp the details, I saw a news report which made it seems they've set up a quota (xx tons or something) of rice to be imported with almost no tariffs.
- daedrdev 1y agoThat sounds possible, I can get premium calrose at 4.5kg for 20$, which adjusted to be 5kg is like 3200 yen or it could be regular quality calrose marked up, I can get that for half the premium price so equivalent of 1600 yen.
- Dylanlacey 1y agoI'm not sure tarrifs have a huge impact; Japan is Australia's largest buyer of rice, importing $63.8MUSD worth in 2023 per the OEC: https://oec.world/en/profile/bilateral-product/rice/reporter/aus https://oec.world/en/profile/bilateral-product/rice/reporter.... That's a lot of rice to buy, if it's more expensive and less desirable then domestic rice.
- fennecbutt 1y agoAsianometry did a great video on some of the reasons for this https://youtube.com/watch?v=l4vTQV3HjKU https://youtube.com/watch?v=l4vTQV3HjKU
- xnx 1y ago$2.50/lb. in American
- lofaszvanitt 1y agoEnd of times...
- beejiu 1y agoJapan's the fourth largest economy in the world and, given how cheap rice is, it being 1x, 5x or even 10x average I'm sure is insignificant to 95%+ of people. For perspective, it's about 2x what you'd pay in a UK supermarket. What's the big deal?
- downrightmike 1y agoIts been progressively becoming more expensive for the last 18 months. And Japanese wages are the same as the 90's and they have millions of pensioners that can't absorb a higher price.
- numpad0 1y ago"rice" and "meal" are synonyms in Japanese language. Food in day-to-day Japanese cooking mostly consider what and how to pair with rice off the cooker. And "the food" is suddenly costing double. It is a big deal.
- SudoSuccubus 1y ago[dead]
- foobar1962 1y ago> Despite the fall, the average rice price was still ¥1,772 higher than that of a year earlier. So this price isn't surprising or unusual at all.
- ianpenney 1y ago[flagged]
- userbinator 1y agotests show over 90% of sampled U.S. fruits (like apples, cherries) have residues of multiple pesticides So do non-US fruits, unless it's the "organic" stuff.
- ianpenney 1y ago[flagged]
- zahlman 1y agoI would say the downvotes are primarily because you are inferring a political purpose to the OP that isn't in evidence, and railing against it in a way that appears simply off topic. "So, if I may be editorial as a Canadian: No." is a strange, nonsensical way to respond to a post titled "Price of rice in Japan falls below ¥4k per 5kg". Complaining about it and sarcastically ascribing ideological positions to downvoters is probably not helping, either.
- ianpenney 1y agoSee the top comment on this thread. It’s not nonsensical. It’s refuting the spirit of the conversation so far. As for pesticides US vs Canada: Chlorpyrifos Neonicotinoids Ractopamine All being phased out or banned up north. And much more restricted in EU/Internationally. While US use seems to me to be rampant. Japanese rice costs more _because it is better_. And especially because it’s known by laypersons to be better. If any of the commenters here had any authority because perhaps they could claim they’ve spent a bunch of time in Japan like I have? I’d respect that. And indeed, we Canadians are subject to politics about our supply management on dairy and poultry. It’s not just there to protect business. It’s there to protect health as far as my contemporaries are concerned.
- tomhow 1y agoYour comments in this subthread are against the guidelines. Issues of food safety and environmental externalities are important, and thus need to be discussed in a respectful and earnest way, not an inflammatory and combative one. Please read the guidelines and make an effort to observe them in future, notably these ones: Be kind. Don't be snarky. Converse curiously; don't cross-examine. Edit out swipes. Comments should get more thoughtful and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive. When disagreeing, please reply to the argument instead of calling names. "That is idiotic; 1 + 1 is 2, not 3" can be shortened to "1 + 1 is 2, not 3." Please don't fulminate. Please don't sneer, including at the rest of the community. Eschew flamebait. Avoid generic tangents. Omit internet tropes. Please don't use Hacker News for political or ideological battle. It tramples curiosity. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- ButOneDuck 1y agoA great little video from Asianometry on the history of rice prices in Japan was a lovely primer for this article: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l4vTQV3HjKU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l4vTQV3HjKU
- jaggs 1y agoTraditionally in Japan, as far as I understand it, rice is more than just rice. https://spice.fsi.stanford.edu/docs/rice_its_more_than_food_in_japan https://spice.fsi.stanford.edu/docs/rice_its_more_than_food_...
- ksec 1y agoSort of strange reading people on this topic. But also a reminder, 50% of people cant taste the difference between Pepsi and Coca Cola.