7 ms·
> All these are due to laws and regulations that are there to protect the big companies and don’t take into consideration users This feature is not due to laws
by Aurornis 2y ago
> All these are due to laws and regulations that are there to protect the big companies and don’t take into consideration users
This feature is not due to laws and regulations.
The user in this case is the presenter who clicks the button to enable screenshot protection on their meeting. This is Microsoft trying to deliver a feature their users want, not laws and regulations making them do something their users don’t want.
- hedora 2y agoSome people might want it, but it doesn’t actually work. It’s probably also required by some compliance theater in some places.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- jasonlotito 2y ago> Some people might want it, but it doesn’t actually work Why do you think they can't prevent on-device screenshots/screen recording can't be prevented when you control the entire stack?
- brookst 2y agoWould it work on Mac?
- jasonlotito 2y agoYes. Edit: But yeah, nothing to say why it can't work. So, yeah.
- brookst 2y agoBut MS doesn’t control the whole stack there.
- saagarjha 2y agoApple provides APIs to do it.
- jasonlotito 2y agoDoesn’t matter. I don’t know why you think stating random things matters.
- brookst 2y agoMaybe read the comment I replied to for context?
- c-hendricks 2y agoIt's kind of like locks isn't it? It'll deter honest folks, but will it prevent screen capture when Teams is running in a VM? What about over VNC?
- jasonlotito 2y agoWhat about a camera? These aren't the use cases that really matters. What matters is the common case, and it's not about deterring honest folks. Honest folks aren't recording. This is really a lesson in security blind spots. The number of people that are trying to "get around this" assuming that's the issue. Edit: I'll make it simple. It will work because honest people aren't trying to get around it. But, they could still expose data they shouldn't. This helps prevent that. Again, a camera is enough to prove it doesn't need to be 100% perfect (and probably more honest considering screenshots can be faked). So, instead of trying to think of how you can exploit, think of all the ways this private information can get out when it shouldn't and the people on the call aren't trying to release it. Work through that, and see where you get.
- egypturnash 2y ago> Honest folks aren't recording. Honest folks who want to be able to cover their ass later on are. Honest folks who are working for dishonest people and are planning to be a whistleblower are. Honest folks who have Recall on are. Possibly against their will if they haven't found out how to turn it off, or it's a work machine where they're not allowed to do so. Maybe they're not if Microsoft actually has enough interdepartmental communication for the "no screenies please" signal to make it all the way to Recall. It'll be hilarious if they don't.
- josephg 2y agoOne of the best rules I ever heard of was told to me by a cop here in Australia. She told me every time they unholster their firearm, they have to fill out about 3 pages of paperwork. I think that’s so genius. Think about it - if you’re in a life or death situation, you won’t hesitate. Your gun is right there, and it’s there so you can use it. But if the situation doesn’t feel dangerous, the image of having to fill out 3 pages of paperwork justifying your actions is enough to make you hesitate. It’s weaponised bureaucracy. It’s like - there’s an ideal amount of friction for some actions to have. Pulling your gun out should have some friction to it. The choice should have weight. I see this in just the same way. If the presenter doesn’t want their presentation recorded, there should be some friction to recording it anyway. It shouldn’t be impossible to record. But it shouldn’t be as easy as just taking a screenshot in windows. Just like that cop with a gun, there should be the right amount of friction for recording a meeting against the wishes of the presenter. How many pages did the cop have to fill out? 3 pages. Not zero. Not 100 pages. How hard is it to record a meeting despite this protection? It’s doable - you need an hdmi capture card, or a camera out of shot, or something else. You probably need to set it all up before the meeting. And so on. It’s not impossible. But it’s not trivial either. That sounds just right to me.
- shawnz 2y agoThey can't control the entire stack because of the analogue hole
- jasonlotito 2y agoWhich doesn’t matter at all.
- shawnz 2y agoI'm just answering your question.
- adolph 2y agoYeah, some enterprise admin will click it and make it clickable for others. It’s a classic ratchet of enshittification until things reach a magic intolerability point and folks evacuate to other systems leading those to get rolled into one of the borgs: lather, rinse, repeat.
- lolinder 2y agoIt doesn't work against which threat model? Yeah, if you've got corporate espionage going on this isn't going to stop someone from lifting your slides and taking them elsewhere. But the most common culprit of corporate information security violations isn't a spy, it's a well-meaning employee who didn't hear, remember, or correctly interpret the request to not record the meeting. Blocking the most common way in which this kind of well-meaning but ill-informed employee would break the expected security rules does work. It's just getting flak here because people are imagining a much more exciting threat model.
- hedora 2y agoIt doesn’t work against employees with camera phones.
- Aurornis 2y ago> Some people might want it, but it doesn’t actually work It probably works as well as the company firewall blocking sites or the data exfiltration detection blocking companies from being stolen. Everyone knows they’re not perfect and can be defeated by a sufficiently motivated attacker, but in practice they stop most casual attempts and discourage others.
- NKosmatos 2y agoThere isn’t a single user (presenter) that would ask something like this. Only a presenter that has to follow some strict “high security” procedures would enable something like this. A politician, for example, will have an excuse in case something leaks. The fact that with a simple mobile having a camera you can copy whatever is being presented (or with slightly more technical ways) is irrelevant for laws and procedures ;-)
- cheschire 2y agoYou don’t get invited to the right meetings, I see.
- guappa 2y agoYou mean with people who have more paranoia than sense?
- Aurornis 2y ago> There isn’t a single user (presenter) that would ask something like this. Asking participants not to screen record or take screenshot was standard practice at every company I’ve worked at where we discussed anything like financials or sensitive business plans.
- FireBeyond 2y agoPretty common where I have worked. Most commonly when reviewing internal product roadmaps to our sales teams because we've burned too many times when customers complain that we haven't implemented something we never announced but a sales person mentioned/showed.
- guappa 2y agoYou think forbidding screenshots is going to stop salespeople from promising random stuff? Have you met salespeople?
- jasonlotito 2y ago> The fact that with a simple mobile having a camera you can copy whatever is being presented (or with slightly more technical ways) is irrelevant for laws and procedures ;-) That you think the only attack vector here is a 3rd party device means you haven't really considered everything. Consider screenshots that might happen for many reasons, including malicious software, or even normal software someone might be using, and accidental exposure.
- tw04 2y agoBut it’s literally the dumbest feature ever. There’s absolutely nothing preventing a user from pulling out their phone and taking a picture of any slide they want. Or having a camera recording the whole session out of view of their webcam. It is security theater at its peak.
- tmpz22 2y agoIn a 1:1 format this would be effective in preventing some forms of misuse because it would be obvious if an individual took out their phone and pointed it towards the screen.
- relwin 2y agoEasily circumvented: Use two monitors, one positioned out of view. Use a teleprompter mirror with a camera behind the mirror. Use a video capture device, record on a separate computer. I'm sure there's sneakier ways to perform this...
- josephg 2y agoYour “easy” circumvention requires a second monitor, a teleprompter mirror, a camera, a separate computer and a video capture device. Remember, most people who use Teams don't work in tech. And for them, that’s not “easy”. Barely any normal people have that kind of equipment just lying around, along with the expertise and desire to set all that up, ready for a teams meeting. For every 100 people who might decide to take a screenshot during a teams meeting, I doubt there’s 1 person who has all that equipment set up and ready to go. You don’t need to make something 100% effective to get a benefit from doing so.
- ThrowawayR2 2y agoThese comments are akin to pointing out that the privacy door on a public bathroom stall can easily be bypassed by looking over the top of the stall walls or underneath the gap between the ground and the bottom of the wall. In their rush to be clever, they instead demonstrate that the poster completely missed the point.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- modzu 2y agohahaha nobody asked for this
- csomar 2y agoYeah, because blocking screenshots is security. How dumb could the world get? If you have sensitive information and a committed individual to leak those, then there is no way around if the picture is shared. What is next? Startup idea: i-Secure. Your camera can only take/show photos of approved targets. All photos will be analyzed for safety. Unapproved/Unlocked camera devices from China are now illegal.
- buyucu 2y agoIt's a pointless and stupid feature. It's trivial to take a picture of the screen with your phone.
- 7bit 2y agoIt's about convenience. You would be surprised how much information is leaked simply because it was so convenient to.
- buyucu 2y agostupid security theater liket his makes everything less secure. people who used to take screenshots will now resort to taking screen pictures with their phones. this means microsoft teams is incentivizing everyone to 'leak' content outside of corporate networks. creating a unworkable 'secure' system causes ordinary people to to go around the security to get their job done. which makes everything less secure in the end.
- WWLink 2y agoWhat's really going to happen is IT people will enforce this by default because good users aren't supposed to take screenshots, apparently.
- 7bit 2y agoI am a sysadmin and we will enable this. This is because many meetings discuss confidential or strictly confidential information that must not be leave the meeting. In-house, you would simply hand out papers that you collect before concluding the meeting. In Teams meeting it's not possible hence you block people from creating screenshots. This requirement comes from legal and compliance, and many other positions from CEO downwards.
- guappa 2y agoIf you don't frisk people to check if they have microphones and make everyone leave their phones at the entrance, you're just wasting everyone's time. Information hasn't leaked because people didn't bother to leak it, not because of your security measures.
- const_cast 2y agoThe lede you're burying here is why a lot of this confidential info is so. Yes, protecting IP is important, but you're also primarily targeting whistle-blowers, abused employees, discriminated against employees, etc. I mean, if HR says they won't make an accommodation because they think you're faking your disability than it's as if it never happened. Less transparency always benefits the immoral. And this type of stuff does happen. A lot. We don't hear about it because: 1. Companies have gotten really good at just covering their tracks, like this. 2. It's a lot of effort to fight back and it's almost never worth it. You pretty much need baby killing material for someone to whistle blow. Lowly transgressions like discrimination aren't worth the effort. I thought after Blizzard this would be a sort of wake up call.
- hulitu 2y ago> to enable screenshot protection on their meeting Nobody forces them to make a presentation. They can always spend their time doing something else.