15 ms·
I asked police to send me their public surveillance footage of my car
- Molitor5901 2y agoI've seen this done before by journalists requesting license plate reader data but it's another nail in the coffin of anonymity. Dare I say unless you wear a full face mask, change your walking gait, and just about every habit you have, there is no escape. In television I've seen talk about masks and garments that help prevent this, but I think it's a zero sum game. You will be tracked. You will be photographed, profiled, analyzed and that data is likely sold to the highest bidder and it's only accelerating.
- ryandvm 2y ago> Dare I say unless you wear a full face mask, change your walking gait, and just about every habit you have, there is no escape. Lol. Nobody will be able to track me as the guy crab-walking in a sumo suit wearing the Unabomber disguise.
- Molitor5901 2y agoI'm not sure if you're being facetious, but the fact you would be wthe guy " crab-walking in a sumo suit wearing the Unabomber disguise" is probably going to draw even more attention. Like the tesla vandals. The cameras will simply follow you back to your car, home, business, wherever you went to take off that costume, then really zero in on you because you went and did what the police might term as "weird."
- anonym29 2y agoI believe the parent poster was suggesting this as a joke. Relevant XKCD: https://xkcd.com/1105/ https://xkcd.com/1105/
- ta1243 2y agoAnd of course the reality https://www.wired.com/story/null-license-plate-landed-one-hacker-ticket-hell/ https://www.wired.com/story/null-license-plate-landed-one-ha...
- aftbit 2y ago>[Christopher Null] has himself had to deal with countless annoyances, from American Express dropping his last name altogether, to Bank of America refusing to accept emails from his "nullmedia.com" domain. I believe the first one but likely BofA refusing to accept emails from his custom domain has nothing to do with it starting with null and everything to do with anti-spam.
- anonym29 2y agoNon-paywall version: https://archive.is/R1FMz https://archive.is/R1FMz
- mingus88 2y agoA recent event in midtown manhattan shows it’s pretty easy to evade surveillance if you can avoid using a car for a brief period of time. Didn’t he get away on a bike into a park? In that case the police had a Starbucks register photo with a face, but that kind of slip can also be easily avoided
- fn-mote 2y ago> that kind of slip can also be easily avoided That PARTICULAR slip can be avoided. Avoiding all slips is equivalent to airtight OpSec, which more people on this platform are familiar with (= not happening).
- tstrimple 2y agoThey are way ahead of you in Turkey. https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/world/2025/03/27/pikachu-inflatable-turkey-protests/82694021007/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/world/2025/03/27/pikachu...
- tyingq 2y agoFeels like it's also going to be handy for selective prosecution. Say you're targeted for public speech someone doesn't like. Now they can try and draw some link between your travels and some unsolved crime. Even if it's a weak link, and they can't win in court...the bar for arrest is pretty low. And, a bit of a reach, but it's also some of the foundation for "pre-crime" type stuff. "You've exhibited patterns of comings and goings that suggest..."
- Molitor5901 2y agoI'm more pessimistic. With available AI you can take video of someone, extract that human profile and characteristics, and then insert it into another one. It only takes that one visit to your office "We have video of you sneaking into an elementary school bathroom" to totally ruin your life, and even if you could prove it wasn't you and was doctored, the damage is still done. It's worse than selective prosecution
- paganel 2y agoPerson of Interest was such a great TV show! Too bad many of the things in there came out to be true, or very close to true, in just a matter of 10-15 years.
- tyingq 2y agoAh, hadn't seen it. I was thinking Minority Report, but skimming Person of Interest summaries..yes, similar.
- thesuitonym 2y agoI'm not familiar with the show, but dystopian science fiction doesn't predict the future, it criticizes the present.
- banku_brougham 2y ago"...first of all they must be arrested and brought before the court, and the [criminal code] articles will be found" - Molotov, June 14, 1940
- 2y ago
- anonym29 2y agoI have bad news for you. The data is not only being sold to the highest bidder, much of it is being sold repeatedly to just about any bidder.
- TeMPOraL 2y ago"You are being watched. The government has a secret system, a system you asked for, to keep you safe. A machine that spies on you every hour of every day. You've granted it the power to see everything, to index, order and control the lives of ordinary people. The government considers these people irrelevant. We don't. But to it, you are all irrelevant. Victim or perpetrator, if you stand in its way, we'll find you." Person of Interest continues to be prescient.
- roxolotl 2y agoI'm actively watching it for the first time and this part: "a system you asked for, to keep you safe." I don't recognize. Looked into it a bit and it started out and only the last season has all of what you quoted. It's been really interesting watching the show evolve knowing what was happening in the world at the time. I'm currently on season 3 and they are starting to change the tone now that the Snowden leak has happened. It starts out as: "You are being watched. The government has a secret system — a machine — that spies on you every hour of every day. I know, because I built it. I designed the machine to detect acts of terror, but it sees everything. Violent crimes involving ordinary people. People like you. Crimes the government considered irrelevant. They wouldn't act, so I decided I would. But I needed a partner, someone with the skills to intervene. Hunted by the authorities, we work in secret. You'll never find us. But, victim or perpetrator, if your number's up, we'll find you." So over the course of 5 years it morphs from "I know because I built it." to "A system you asked for, to keep you safe."
- tredre3 2y agoThe show's (or at least its protagonists') motivations change a lot over the years. As Finch's own motivations evolve, you can see him shift the blame from the government, to the people, to the machine itself. There are some bouts of introspection, especially early on, which he uses as justification for installing the backdoor in the first place, but on the whole he's adamant that none of this is his fault. That's probably exactly how it will play out in our world too, when a tech billionaire plugs a self-aware AI to our global surveillance network.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> unless you wear a full face mask, change your walking gait, and just about every habit you have, there is no escape If you’re driving a car, yes. As we saw with Mangione’s escape, if you’re on public transit you’re much more anonymous. (Given the public risks inherent to driving, I think this is a fair trade—off.)
- dingnuts 2y agoYou mean the shooter's escape. Mangione is pretty obviously being framed, c'mon
- bluGill 2y agoThere are cameras all over public transit systems. License plates are easier to track (they have a known font so identifying a unique one is easier that a face), but not by enough to matter. If you leave one camera you will show up in the next and soon they get enough of a profile to identify you if they want to.
- JumpCrisscross 2y agoThey frequently don’t work [1]. Again, we have a real-life example of someone using the reality of how surveillance is weighted to escape Manhattan, one of the more surveilled parts of the country. [1] https://abc7ny.com/brooklyn-shooting-subway-cameras-7-on-your-side/11745041/ https://abc7ny.com/brooklyn-shooting-subway-cameras-7-on-you...
- probably_wrong 2y agoWhile I agree with your point about public transit being a bit more anonymous, I feel I should point out that a. Mangione was still captured, and b. thanks (allegedly) to a combination of multiple surveillance photos of him with a mask plus a single picture of his full face. "No escape" sounds still right.
- potato3732842 2y agoHe was anonymous for what, 8hr? and it took massive investment. That's not tractable at scale.
- yread 2y ago> walking gait so you're saying that if we cycle everywhere on a non-descript black Dutch fiets we're safe ?
- Molitor5901 2y agoNope. They use cameras to analyze cyclists who race to make sure their form is on top. You have a cycling gait the same as your walking gait - the way you sit in the saddle, pedal, hang on to the handlebars, sit, etc. https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/10345980 https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/10345980
- bryancoxwell 2y agoI don’t disagree with you but I’m also not entirely sold on the idea that surveillance cameras alone are all that effective at tracking and identifying people. Think of the person that left two pipe bombs outside the RNC and DNC offices in Washington, DC, probably the most heavily surveilled city in the United States. It’s been 4 years and we still have no idea who that was.
- whatevertrevor 2y agoOne could say that is an even stronger argument against them. People are losing their privacy for very little gain if these things aren't even effective at solving precisely this sort of premeditated criminal activity.
- bryancoxwell 2y agoYeah I’d agree with that as well
- BurningFrog 2y agoThe cost of cameras and disk space is very low, and rapidly approaching zero. I think that means it doesn't matter what anyone thinks about anonymity in public places. We're already almost always seen by several cameras, and it will soon be 10x as much.
- ur-whale 2y ago> You will be tracked For a peek at what you can expect, take a look at Saudi Arabia, where your bank account gets blocked until your traffic violation fine (usually issued electronically within minutes of the actual deed) is fully paid. Or at China, where you "social score", more or less calculated automatically, decides in a fairly fine-grained manner what you are and are not allowed to do in society. These will be become the social norm in the West as well, just a matter of time and getting the herd to consider it "normal" (usually takes a generation, 20-ish years).
- tyingq 2y agoIt talks about Flock branded surveillance in several places, then the news site itself asks for donations with this tagline "Thanks for joining our flock!". Short double-take on that donation area for me.
- myself248 2y agoThey call it out in the text: > Ninety uneventful minutes later, I pulled into Roanoke to go to the Cardinal office and visit my Roanoke members of our own Cardinal team — which, in an unintentional irony in this story, we refer to as The Flock.
- zikduruqe 2y agoFeel free to deflock Flock. https://deflock.me/ https://deflock.me/
- carimura 2y agoour aren't even on there yet so I'm sure it's a lot more than advertised
- zikduruqe 2y agoIt's funny, I never noticed mine in the area until I read the deflock.me site. (Maybe it was posted here on HN?) Regardless, since I like to provide updates to OSM, I have been cataloging them in my area.
- avs733 2y agoI’ve made it a game to find and report new ones on my longer runs. There is one near me, in a relatively upscale area, that has repeatedly been taken down and thrown into a culvert. There are currently two old flock cameras still on the pole down there and seemingly unreachable. But it is always quickly replaced.
- zikduruqe 2y agoI'm a fairly active cyclist and do the same thing. I also map water sources on OSM also, since one day I ran out of water and couldn't find anything local. Figured it would help someone else one day.
- boomboomsubban 2y agoDon't FOIA requests charge you for the manhours it took, or is it just the data transfer cost? It might vary by state now that I think of it. I wonder how much these cost. Saying these requests constitutes a felony is ludicrous, hopefully the judge sees the case as a bad prank.
- c420 2y agoFOIA is federal. States have their own public records programs. https://www.eff.org/issues/transparency/foia-how-to https://www.eff.org/issues/transparency/foia-how-to
- boomboomsubban 2y agoThe act is federal, as that points out the fees are decided by the smaller groups.
- Noumenon72 2y agoI had trouble searching this article for "felony" (it does mention "judge") so here's the link from the article where the police argue complying could be the felony of violating Virginia Code 18.2-152.5:1 — “using a computer to gather identifying information.” https://cardinalnews.org/2025/03/13/city-of-roanoke-botetourt-county-sheriff-go-to-court-over-foia-request/ https://cardinalnews.org/2025/03/13/city-of-roanoke-botetour...
- ldoughty 2y agoWhat I find interesting is that they are claiming pictures of the vehicle are identifying information. Additionally, it's bizarre because the journalist isn't using the computer to gather the information, the police are... and they are legally allowed to -- the code specifically says only law enforcement may do this while performing job duties. So they are arguing that there's some sort of transitive property where law enforcement are no longer law enforcement performing job duties if they are acting on request from a journalist... or that the journalist is a mastermind in a felony because he is requesting to see his own records.
- gosub100 2y agoLet me guess: get the police to pay for them and sell the data to advertisers.
- sebstefan 2y agoI don't think there should be an expectation of anonymity for the specific case of operating a car on a public road. It's a lot of responsibility, so you should be scrutinized when you do it. That's part of my grievances against the urbanism of the U.S.A. When the only viable option to get around is cars, there is no privacy. It's important to advocate for public places to be livable for everyone, not just drivers.
- mikrl 2y ago> When the only viable option to get around is cars, there is no privacy. I don’t think there’s privacy in the tap on - tap off Oyster/Presto card world either.
- sebstefan 2y agoI think that's more of a technicality of billing you for a service than something by design ("the tap on - tap off Oyster/Presto card " => Google sent me to "List of public transport smart cards" so I assume you're refering to some branded public transit system)
- masfuerte 2y agoNo, it's not a side-effect, it's a deliberate decision. You used to be able to get an Oyster card anonymously and top it up with cash. I still have one, but they are not accepted now.
- Symbiote 2y agoYou can buy Oyster cards at many newsagents, and top them up there too. There will probably be CCTV, but privately owned by the shop.
- masfuerte 2y agoThank you. It seems like I was misinformed. Last time I was in London my old Oyster card wouldn't work and I was told I couldn't top it up (which is probably true) and I couldn't get a new card without ID (which seems to be false).
- gadders 2y agoI fell arse over tit at a London tube station and requested the CCTV footage under the GDPR. Got a lovely full colour DVD of me stacking it.
- noodlesUK 2y agoI think the crazy thing about ANPR/ALPR is just quite how simple it is to create a massive panopticon. The UK has a fairly established national ANPR system, and it generates on the order of 90M records per day [1]. All of this data is available to various law enforcement agencies. If you drive, you're probably being recorded in a way accessible to the PNC every day. Because of how effective this is for catching even fairly minor violations like failure to pay vehicle tax, number plate cloning is becoming pretty common (comparatively) in the UK. This means that you can easily get swept up in a police dragnet because someone has stolen your car's identity. [1] https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/national-anpr-service-data-protection-impact-assessment/national-anpr-service-data-protection-impact-assessment-accessible#:~:text=90%20million https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/national-anpr-ser...
- 4ndrewl 2y agoAnd chances are a large proportion of them have got Google/Apple recording the locations of their devices too. We do it to ourselves these days.
- noodlesUK 2y agoI would say there’s a pretty significant difference between something like phone geolocation data, which is not very practical to search, especially for Apple devices, and in any case usually requires at least a superficial level of scrutiny, and a database that any old police officer can just run a query on as and when they feel like it.
- tonyedgecombe 2y agoThey don't need access to your device. The Police can use records from the mobile operators to track device movements.
- noodlesUK 2y agoYes, they can, however I don't believe this is quite as straightforward as just looking up the data for a particular vehicle on your police computer. Looking up the ANPR data on a vehicle is only marginally more complex than looking up a person's driving license details or similar. My understanding is that in order to do a reverse geofence request, or look up a specific device, it's a lot more complicated, and these days you're only going to get cell site information rather than precise GPS data (as was possible by asking Google in the past).
- josefritzishere 2y agoCreepy AF. We live in a prison.
- DeathArrow 2y agoIf I were to be a road pirate, I would only have used government license plates. Let them fine themselves!
- throwALPRsaway 2y agoIt's interesting that you go through life thinking "no one would ever do that" with regard to various circumstances, yet discover people do those things. These ALPR companies are evil. If a car manufacturer sells your data or a big box store uses AI in ways you disagree with you can just not purchase from those companies. It can be much more difficult to move to a new town where they may then decide to put these things. I know of one town where it is impossible to drive without hitting an ALPR. What a prison. Here is a list of things that have been or could be done: - wrong vehicle identified and stopped at gunpoint - sacramento sheriff shared LP data with Texas in case pregnant people visited - police chief stalked his ex - a mad president could unreasonably declare martial law and send the national guard in to the Atlanta office to take over the command center (if you take the license plate off: how many silver Audi A4s are there in Palo Alto?) - a foreign state actor could surreptitiously infiltrate their servers and discover patterns that help them if they declare war against the US - the data will be leaked (high likelihood eventually) and you can find out all kinds of behaviors. It would be fair game for insurance companies. It violates the 4th amendment. A governement cannot just track innocent people everywhere they go. They sell it as "we aren't giving tickets, we are only looking for bad guys" but the above incidents (gunpoint, sheriff, stalking ex) show otherwise. But what concerns me is not the local police, it is the last three potential situations. And you can't opt out unless you take ubers or bike I guess. Please donate to the Institute for Justice. They have a case in Virginia (surprised it wasn't mentioned) and I am confident they will succeed in taking this to the Supreme Court. They recently won a civil asset forfeiture case and they have successfully argued cases like DC's gun ban before the supreme court. (If you think guns are bad, fine, but like ALPRs it was a violation of the US constitution) ij.org Edit: spelling, formatting
- mmooss 2y ago> Institute for Justice You should know who you are donating to (even if you decide to donate). Institute for Justice is a Koch-funded operation that has been focused on their agenda more than civil rights. Possibly my information is somewhat out of date, but note even the propaganda-oriented name as a cover for Koch operations, sort of like the PATRIOT act. Consider also the ACLU, which you know is doing a good job because the powers-that-be attack the ACLU instinctively.
- leoqa 2y agoMost cars already emit RF signals for WiFi, Bluetooth and 5G. These can be fingerprinted along with the physical attributes to increase accuracy. I’m in support of better investigative tools and stricter governance. I’m not worried that my car location would lead to a false arrest- that is like being afraid of lighting striking.
- aftbit 2y agoDon't forget about tire pressure monitoring sensors (TPMS). They operate around 433 MHz and each have a unique ID to stop your car from misreporting a low tire pressure from a car sitting next to you at a stoplight. They are required by law. While some use various techniques to avoid transmitting all the time (to save battery), many just blit out their ID and pressure values on a regular interval whenever the wheels are rolling. That means that whenever you drive over a bridge or toll gate that is properly equipped, you're feeding them enough info to uniquely identify you, even if they don't have a camera or any GHz radios.
- snowwrestler 2y agoI remember the rounds of media coverage about this when TPMS became required on new cars. I have not seen any evidence that it is actually happening, though. Compare to this story where the reporter asked for tracking data and either received the data or a response confirming the data’s existence but declining to provide it. Other data sources for tracking, like cell phone location or toll transponder pings, also have a public record of the existence of that data. I’m not aware of a similar trail of proof-of-existence for TPMS data tracking. If you are, I’d be interested to learn.
- xyzzy_plugh 2y agoI have no idea where you live where they are required by law, but I've never heard of such a thing. They've never been required by law anywhere I've owned a car. In any case, given they have batteries that eventually wear out, and older cars don't have them, it would still be more effective to use a camera. Edit: even if they're required in new cars that doesn't make them mandatory on the road. It's not like all tires must be sold with TPMS.
- unyttigfjelltol 2y agoNext Uber will be pitching a privacy-centric upgrade, similar to VPN positioning today, to preserve privacy in the face of mass roadway surveillance.
- sorenjan 2y agoThis is also available as a private service: > In just a few taps and clicks, the tool showed where a car had been seen throughout the U.S. A private investigator source had access to a powerful system used by their industry, repossession agents, and insurance companies. Armed with just a car’s plate number, the tool—fed by a network of private cameras spread across the country—provides users a list of all the times that car has been spotted. https://www.vice.com/en/article/i-tracked-someone-with-license-plate-readers-drn/ https://www.vice.com/en/article/i-tracked-someone-with-licen...
- calvinmorrison 2y agowe should remove all license plates.
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 2y agoNah, we should remove all Automated License Plate Readers.
- mhb 2y agoMaybe complain to your host about funding ALPR startups like Flock (YC17)?
- bob1029 2y agoI've got mixed feelings about the flock cameras. Twelve of them around a high density shopping center is perfectly reasonable. Just one at the entrance of a neighborhood is severe overreach. I don't mind the idea of building a surveillance state within certain parameterized boundaries, but once you are in a residential setting these things feel like military incursion. Homeowners can already opt-in to video doorbells, security cameras on their properties, etc. Home Depot & law enforcement don't need a 500-mile diameter security perimeter around each retail store to catch the guy stealing Milwaukee products. The cameras in the parking lot and leading up to the freeway should give you enough room to play with unless you are vastly incompetent at basic police work.
- RKFADU_UOFCCLEL 2y ago[flagged]
- ketzo 2y ago> unless you are vastly incompetent at basic police work. Boy do I have news!
- einpoklum 2y agoI drove 50 miles, and avoided contacting the police so that they don't arrest me or beat me up.
- chakintosh 2y agoI'm not surprised by the surveilance, but more by the high resolution of these cameras. Surely the storage bill must be immense.
- potato3732842 2y agoThe price doesn't matter because we all pay it.
- Lammy 2y agoThey purge the actual images after some time period but keep the metadata (OCRed plate, other identifying features) I assume forever. From a Flock privacy policy: > Video Clips captured by the LPR system will automatically be deleted after 30 days; although Images are deleted when no longer needed, the data obtained from the Images may be retained indefinitely.
- timcobb 2y agoI entered the United States the other day from Mexico at BWI without even showing my passport. I don't know how they verified my identity, but I presume it was a camera, because the agent looked in a computer for a few seconds, then waved me through... :/ Good to know the state knows me and isn't even bashful about it...
- BurningFrog 2y agoI assume they at least have photos from your previous border crossings pop up when your car approaches.
- timcobb 2y agoCertainly, but that is so uncool in my opinion
- sitkack 2y agoIt feels like a dystopian power play, hey citizen, we are watching you.
- antisthenes 2y agoNo worries, they were "one of the good ones" .
- TheJoeMan 2y agoThat’s interesting, I thought you had to apply for the SETRI program. [1] https://www.cbp.gov/travel/trusted-traveler-programs/sentri https://www.cbp.gov/travel/trusted-traveler-programs/sentri
- MaxPock 2y agoDemocratic surveillance is not bad unlike China's authoritarian surveillance.
- timcobb 2y agoWho's even trying to make that point? Isn't it more like "I don't need privacy because I have nothing to hide"?
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 2y agoAnd you don't have anything to hide because the government is not authoritarian, the argument continues, in theory if not in practice. Our governments are good and righteous and will not misuse the surveillance data in any way.
- mixmastamyk 2y agoBecause government never changes, right?
- kelnos 2y agoDisagree. All surveillance is bad.
- ChoGGi 2y agoThat was some nasty looking cream cheese. Oh yeah and police surveillance something.
- buildsjets 2y agoIt does look revolting. According to the label it's "Cream Cheese Spread." Kind of like how KFC provides sachets of "Honey Sauce" rather than actual honey.
- krupan 2y ago"Part of Flock’s proprietary tech determines the make and model of the vehicle and also notes if there are bumper stickers, bike racks, any other unique markings that would help identify that vehicle." I have always avoided bumper stickers and custom license plates for more anonymity. I have a ham radio license and decided not to get a license plate with my callsign on it because people could easily Google that and find out my name and address. I had always just thought about other drivers in these cases, not law enforcment surveillance!
- djoldman 2y agohttps://transparency.flocksafety.com/roanoke-va-pd https://transparency.flocksafety.com/roanoke-va-pd Here are the statistics on Roanoke VA's flock cameras for the last 30 days.
- djoldman 2y agoSome of these pages include information about searches of the databases. Here is Oakland PD with 1,626,757 vehicles detected and information on the 2,244 searches served in the last 30 days. This includes what appear to be UUID ids of the users. https://transparency.flocksafety.com/oakland-ca-pd https://transparency.flocksafety.com/oakland-ca-pd
- xyst 2y agoThese systems are also likely to get replaced or downsized in favor of relying on data from _self driving vehicles_. Waymo and et al are touted for making our lives easier (load of marketing bs), but really will make it more difficult. edit: and they get to double dip — users paying to use and install their product, and selling that data back to the user and LE and intelligence communities.
- sparrish 2y ago"It’s a paradigm shift where we go from having an expectation of privacy even in public spaces to its inverse." What? Who has an expectation of privacy 'even in public spaces'? You're in public with a serialized mode of transportation (license plate) that requires a state-issued license to operate. Why would you expect 'privacy' in public?
- kevin_thibedeau 2y agoThere is an expectation you won't be subjected to invasive surveillance by default. Cameras that went to a local video recorder and only checked after an incident are way different than routing that video into a 24/7 panopticon that logs a behavioral profile of everyone.
- rangestransform 2y agowhen katz v. USA was decided, government needed to talk to witnesses or surreptitiously follow suspects to gather information. even taking pictures was massively less scalable back then. I would say that policing should never become more scalable with technology, the tools police have to gather information should be as difficult and unscalable to use as they were when katz v. USA was decided.
- kelnos 2y agoI think the author meant we have (had?) an expectation of anonymity in public spaces. Certainly people you know could recognize you, but indiscriminate mass tracking wasn't a thing.
- sparrish 2y agoI think you may be right. Anonymity is fundamentally different from privacy though and it's a large error to conflate the two.
- carimura 2y agoI asked our Sheriff who is in charge of the local deployments in our county whether they could, in theory, enforce curfews if the governor implemented an emergency order, and he said "yes I guess we could in that case". Welcome to the future.
- toast0 2y agoI imagine any Sheriff can enforce a curfew. Drive around and stop anyone you see and tell them to go home and/or arrest them. You could walk or bike or ride a horse, instead of driving. It might not be very effective, but it's enforcing a curfew.
- goatlover 2y agoWouldn't you leave your phone and car at home if you were planning on breaking curfew?
- vgeek 2y agoFlock (YC17) They are growing and showing up everywhere, but you never hear about them in terms of real innovation, just helping build the surveillance state. Combine this with cloud based doorbell cameras and it seems like someone is always watching.
- cynicalsecurity 2y agoWith that amount of mass surveillance, introducing fascism wouldn't be a problem for really committed people. Is anyone watching the watchers? Who is policing the police? What checks and balances do we have?
- zw123456 2y agoWhat if someone takes their license plates off and makes a fake temporary paper one, the kind you put in the back window when you get a new car? Not permanently but if you wanted to go do something illegal and not be tracked. Can the LPR pick those up?
- beej71 2y agoThis is just one reason why it's important to not talk to police. They might ask you if you were in Cityville on some particular date, and maybe you'd forgotten. So you said no. But then it comes out that there's footage of you in town, and now that can of worms is open.
- swader999 2y agoEbike and park the car as much as possible.
- choutianxius 2y agoTravel to China and you will find the big brother watching literally everywhere
- RKFADU_UOFCCLEL 2y ago[flagged]
- KomradeKeeks 2y agothe construction no longer has to be parallel
- banku_brougham 2y agoexactly, though I think the current cohort of HN readers have no memory of this.
- andromaton 2y agoEvery chatgpt and google Gemini models thought the post was about camera angles examples except Gemini flash.
- jedberg 2y agoI would have less of a problem with the constant surveillance if they would make it required by law to inform me any time someone looks at the data. One of the things that makes me really wary of all this surveillance is that it is too easy for people to look. If they knew that every time they looked I would know about it, they wouldn't look so much. Similarly to how people are much less stalky on LinkedIn and Instagram because they know that the other person gets notified when they look.
- nicbou 2y agoThat won't be of much use if the government turns rogue and no longer honours that obligation, or the purpose of the collected data. There's no recalling that data.
- potato3732842 2y agoThat will never happen because if a million people got a form letter in the mail that some federal agency they've never heard of is trolling through everyone's crap looking for some petty papers crime that nobody knew was a crime, nobody really cares about (Chinese power tools that had the wrong box checked on the customs form or whatever) they'd ask why their taxes are paying for such activity.
- jedberg 2y agoI would assume it would be implemented as a web page where you could check logs. Not a whole bunch of form letters.
- mixmastamyk 2y agoWhere one could set up email would be fine as well.
- potato3732842 2y agoWhatever form the notification takes it would eventually get publicized and get people annoyed/angry.
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 2y ago> That generates a “vehicle fingerprint” for every car or truck, which none of the agencies I FOIA’d would provide me. I hope there's also litigation for this given it is also public record when it's being purchased with tax dollars. Especially if they're just asking for the identifications of their own vehicle. It seems similar to denying me a copy of their record of my actual fingerprint.
- troyvit 2y agoDang. I've had a fantasy of painting several fake license plates all over the back of my hatchback to help confound these cameras, but: 'Part of Flock’s proprietary tech determines the make and model of the vehicle and also notes if there are bumper stickers, bike racks, any other unique markings that would help identify that vehicle. That generates a "vehicle fingerprint" for every car or truck' So in just the same way that ad blockers and other anti-surveillance tech actually make your browser stand out, obfuscating your license plate would also make you stand out.
- potato3732842 2y agoI bet "unknown unknown" is a pretty popular make and model in their database.
- DavidPeiffer 2y agoIf this type of surveillance is concerning to you, please look at advocating against it at a local level. Thomas Ptacek [1] has experience and seems very willing to help out. He recently provided a really helpful comment regarding reining in a Flock install in his city. [2] And as has been mentioned a couple other places in this discussion, please contribute to mapping out license plate readers in OpenStreetMap at https://deflock.me https://deflock.me. Ideally someone will create a routing engine which with an option to avoid all known ALPR's while generating a route. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=tptacek https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=tptacek [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41927777 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41927777
- kevin_thibedeau 2y agoI was subjected to two illegal traffic stops in NJ because my Indiana plate was "unregistered" when in fact they just don't share data with the vendor running the ALPR systems the town cops use. These companies need to be sued into submission.
- unit149 2y agoCadillac and Tesla emulate panopticonic cells, which resolve the presence of an external observer. CCTV footage is confined to local area networks that is pulled from LRP time-stamp headers. Vehicle-to-Infrastructure (V2I) and Vehicle-to-Vehicle (V2V) on a narrow-band, Dedicated Short-Range Communications (DSRC) protocol can identify vehicle fragments, meta-data, from dynamic time-stamp servers, like "that is a red Tesla."
- throwaway31338 2y agoSince the genie is out of the bottle, when it comes to ALPRs in the United States, I'd rather just have all the data publicly available. If the cops, data brokers, and insurance companies can see it I should be able to as well. I should be able to see the comings and goings of law enforcement, elected officials, etc, if they can see mine. Alternatively, lock it away behind judicial oversight. Make the cops get a warrant. Criminalize companies collecting the data from offering it in any manner other than by the order of a judge. I feel the same way about tracking cell phones, publicly-owned surveillance cameras, privately-owned surveillance cameras that are "voluntarily" offered to law enforcement, and, in general, any dragnet surveillance available to law enforcement. If it's available to law enforcement and not being conducted on an individual basis under a judicial order (or, heck, even just probable cause) I think it should be available to the public, too. "But stalkers!" Tough. That's the price we have to pay for keeping law enforcement in check. Either adapt or take this power away from law enforcement.
- alwa 2y agoFor that matter, it’s not unheard of for members of the US’ 18,000 law enforcement organizations [0] to engage in stalking behaviors themselves. Especially when there’s no oversight for a specific surveillance technology… [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_enforcement_in_the_United_States https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_enforcement_in_the_Unite...
- WarOnPrivacy 2y ago> Since the genie is out of the bottle, when it comes to ALPRs in the United States, I'd rather just have all the data publicly available. If the cops, data brokers, and insurance companies can see it I should be able to as well. I try to help folks understand that locking up public data up with a privacy law only blocks them from seeing it. It is still trivially available to those who use personal data to negatively impact others. ref: https://datarade.ai/data-categories/b2b-contact-data/providers https://datarade.ai/data-categories/b2b-contact-data/provide...
- m463 2y ago> "But stalkers!" > > Tough. That's the price we have to pay I wonder if that won't really work well in real life. I remember reading the difference between a citizen and a police officer is that a police officer can arrest people for misdemeanors (while a citizen can do a citizen's arrest for felonies I believe). There's probably a good reason citizens shouldn't easily be able to prey or stir up trouble with no friction. that said, surveillance by private companies should be regulated, and people should have access to data collected about themselves.
- janalsncm 2y agoEffective and reliable law enforcement is a very fast way to go from a low trust society to a high trust society. You can leave your expensive valuables unattended and be certain they won’t be taken. Cameras result in higher solve rates, which results in lower crime rates, which results in even higher solve rates. Meanwhile, in the Bay Area (one of the most economically productive regions of the world) even attempted burglary is functionally not a crime: if there is no footage, nothing was taken, it’s not an active crime, and the value of your smashed window is under some threshold, police will direct you to fill out a form online which will almost certainly not result in an investigation or arrest. Worse yet, if you report to insurance, you will be punished in the form of higher premiums.
- jillyboel 2y agoCould this story be any longer? Is there a tldr? It seems interesting but the author keeps going on personal tangents.
- gU9x3u8XmQNG 2y agoIt seems to be a controversial stance, but; I have no issue with this capability in the right hands. I would immediately surrender such information either way, in the interests of the community - say for a missing child? These capabilities should have well defined intent/objectives and transparent controls to protect the privacy of individuals to which are out scope. With all the above said; it’s been proven time and time again that even with clear intent - the purpose of these systems mutates (ie between governments). Said governments then wonder why public trust is lacking? (Example; see Australian Government customer ISP DNS requirements)
- kelnos 2y ago> ... in the right hands. The problem is that you don't get to decide whose hands it gets into. Even if it's in the right hands today, it might not be tomorrow. And your definition of "right" might not match someone else's.
- bloomingeek 2y agoThere's an episode on the TV show Elementary, where an Uber type company employee was using a tracking device to see where riders were going so as to blackmail them if any stops seemed sketchy. Do police officers ever let their lives get out of control and get into financial straights? We think of public surveillance as a sort of crime prevention, and in a certain ways it is. However, the possible abuse of it is mind boggling.
- sanex 2y agoI'd be ok with these cameras if they could ticket people for texting and driving.
- Deprogrammer9 2y agoCool so just switch cars in a desolate place, got it.
- Corrado 2y agoHoly carp! I've just started noticing these cameras in my neighborhood a couple of months ago and was wondering where they were coming from. They have no stickers or names or identifications of any kind. They are installed everywhere; in the Home Depot parking lot, across the street from the local high school, in the park. Interestingly they seem to be taking the place of the old, bulky, tow behind camera rigs that used to be in several of these locations. Those other devices were large trailer rigs with flashing blue lights and camera's up on a tower.
- Juliapierson1 2y ago[flagged]
- randomcarbloke 2y agoAbsolute barbarism, why would someone be in a Dunkin Donuts in NC, the home of Krispy Kreme.