16 ms·
Waymos crash less than human drivers
- doctorpangloss 2y agoAnother point of view is, if CVC violations were enforced against human drivers as robustly as they are against Waymos; and if human drivers were held to the same standards of liability as Waymos; human drivers in California would be way safer too. To me, the overall safety of all the driverless programs should be interpreted as a huge victory for regulators.
- GolfPopper 2y agoAnother point of view is: does the comparison involve similar vehicles, with similar maintenance, and under similar conditions?
- elmerfud 2y agoI think this is not accounted for in any of the data. There are a lot of bad human drivers that are not removed from the road. There are a lot is human drivers that never bother with increasing their skills or experience in driving. Those people can drag down the numbers. Because with waymos anything learned by one is immediately available to all of them. Therefore you have lots of miles but effectively one driver. Now if you take human drivers and pick only the best, how do you numbers look then? Many people have driven lifetimes and not been in an accident or not in an accident that was their fault or reasonable predictable and avoidable by them. Driving needs to be considered a lot more serious of a task than it currently is. There are many driving errors that are the primary cause of accidents but those people are never forced to get extended drivers education. Self driving cars are nice but if the goal is to prevent accidents it's a bit like requiring everyone to order prepared food to prevent injury while cooking. At some point we need to get back to shaming those who are bad at something and requiring that they improve their skills rather that restricting everyone else's freedoms.
- doctorpangloss 2y ago> There are a lot of bad human drivers that are not removed from the road. Well. If you let people get away with murder by saying "Oh, I'm a confused little old lady, I thought the gas pedal was the brake." That's what I mean by robust enforcement. It is 100% not at all about data. Consider this: A Waymo could be provably confused about a situation, we can directly peer into the state of its mind and prove that it is confused, despite driving safer than the average. Do you know what would happen to the Waymo program if one of its vehicles careened into a family of pedestrians and killed them all? > something something about skills Agency is kind of a myth. For human drivers, experts agree that road design has the biggest impact. Experts also think we should have better public transport. The problems are bigger than Department of Unenactable Urban Fantasy or American Victim Blaming Institute. Self driving cars are exciting because they are like a cheat code around all these intractable social issues.
- elmerfud 2y agoRoad design is an easy thing to blame and it's an easy thing to fix but it's also kind of a red herring. Because road design affects everyone so if accident distribution is not equal among all human drivers then road design disproportionately affects people who are bad at driving. This kind of indicates that skill is an important metric. That's not saying better design can't help people but skill is definitely a primary factor. All of the driver aids that we have in modern cars lane sensors lane keeping, traction control, any lock brakes, and we can continue on with the plethora of driver aids. These are all great and useful tools but they are are being used as a substitute for improving driver skill. When what they should be doing is acting as an aid for driver skill and not a substitution. Being able to drive a forklift and other heavy machinery on a closed environment work site requires a more training and more recertification than it does to get a driver's license in the United States. That to me is absolutely shocking. Because you have a closed course environment that has closed course regulations in place so there is less opportunity for randomness to occur. On the road nothing is closed about it you have complete randomness that you cannot factor in. So why do we not regularly require people to get retested and understand the rules of the road? I'm not saying tests are the best measure but when you see people who have been driving for two decades and they can no longer pass the written test for getting a driver's license, which is an exceedingly easy test, they should have their license revoked and be required to take driver education. When I say driver education I don't mean the fluff nonsense that we give today. It is fine as an introductory course to teach people the basics of driving. What we really need is an ongoing continual education for drivers to maintain their driver's license. Maybe that means we need a more robust public transportation system as well because there are definitely a lot of people who should not be having a driver's license. They simply do not have the cognitive wherewithal to be able to properly drive. I suspect if you begin to look at the statistics accidents are caused by the same group of people repeatedly and those skew the numbers for everyone else.
- ikerino 2y ago> Using human crash data, Waymo estimated that human drivers on the same roads would get into 78 crashes serious enough to trigger an airbag. By comparison, Waymo’s driverless vehicles only got into 13 airbag crashes. That represents an 83 percent reduction in airbag crashes relative to typical human drivers. > This is slightly worse than last September, when Waymo estimated an 84 percent reduction in airbag crashes over Waymo’s first 21 million miles. nitpick: Is it really slightly worse, or is it "effectively unchanged" with such sparse numbers? At a glance, the sentence is misleading even though it might be correct on paper. Could've said: "This improvement holds from last September..."
- 0_____0 2y agoI wonder how many of those airbag crashes were an At-fault or shared-fault of the Waymo AVs.
- onlyrealcuzzo 2y agoConsidering that there's a >1000:1 ratio of regular cars to Waymo AVs - Waymo would have to be EXTREMELY terrible at driving to move the numbers for the other group meaningfully - which would show up in Waymo's own crash data. There's also historical data. So if you saw a spike in crashes for regular vehicles after Waymo arrives, it would be sus. But there is no such spike. Further evidence Waymo isn't causing problems for non AVs. Of course anything is possible. But it's unlikely.
- MostlyStable 2y agoI'm confused by your comment. We shouldn't expect that Waymo accidents should budge overall accidents (which seems to be what you are talking about), but it wouldn't be crazy for Waymo, even if it was much safer overall, to be responsible for some non-trivial amount of all the accidents it has. For example, imagine that Waymo is (somehow) far far far superhuman in it's ability to avoid other cars doing dumb/bad things. It has a dramatic reduction in overall accidents because it magically can completely get rid of accidents where the other driver is at fault. But, in some very specific circumstances, it can't figure out the proper rate to slow down at intersections, and it consistently rear ends vehicles in front of it. This specific situation is very rare, so overall accidents still are low (much lower than human drivers), but, in our made up, constructed (and extremely non-sensical) hypothetical, nearly 100% of Waymo accidents are Waymos fault. So I don't think it's ridiculous to ask how many of the accidents Waymo has been involved in are the fault of the Waymo vehicle. It turns out that (assuming Waymo's side of the story is to be trusted), almost none of them are their fault, but it didn't have to be that way, even in the case where Waymo accidents were more rare than human accidents.
- shadowgovt 2y agoOne of the more interesting things Waymo discovered early in the project is that the actual incidents of vehicle collision were under-counted by about a factor of 3. This is because NHTSA was using accident reports and insurance data for their tracking state, but only 1/3 of collisions were bad enough for either first responders or insurance to get involved; the rest were "Well, that'll buff out and I don't want my rates to go up, so..." fender-taps. But Waymo vehicles were recording and tracking all the traffic around them, so they ended up out-of-the-starting-gate with more accurate collision numbers by running a panopticon on drivers on the road.
- nukem222 2y agoI would hope so! Are these rides actually cheaper? Assumably this is orders of magnitude less expensive than hiring a human and the driver is what you pay for. I don't see myself ever getting in a car if my safety is actually a concern. I don't see myself using any of these any time soon, I tend to drive and walk everywhere and don't see much point to paying someone else to drive barring extenuating circumstances. But assuming actual cost benefits are delivered to customers this might be pretty exciting.
- _ea1k 2y agoRight now, they are pricing them similarly to Uber and Lyft, though they do seem to offer more frequent discounts and there is no tipping yet. The experience is better too, IMO.
- theLiminator 2y ago> But assuming actual cost benefits are delivered to customers this might be pretty exciting. I imagine that will require a viable alternative. Right now they're in some senses superior to ride-sharing/taxis as they are (potentially) safer, and cleaner. So there's no real market pressure forcing them to lower prices beyond that of uber et-al.
- mjburgess 2y agoWaymos choose the routes, right? The issue with self-driving is (1) how it generalises across novel environments without "highly-available route data" and provider-chosen routes; (2) how failures are correlated across machines. In safe driving failures are uncorrelated and safety procedures generalise. We do not yet know if, say, using self-driving very widely will lead to conditions in which "in a few incidents" more people are killed in those incidents than were ever hypothetically saved. Here, without any confidence intervals, we're told we've saved ~70 airbag incidents in 20 mil miles. A bad update to the fleet will easily eclipse that impact.
- thaumasiotes 2y ago> The issue with self-driving is (1) how it generalises across novel environments without "highly-available route data" and provider-chosen routes; (2) how failures are correlated across machines. Why is (1) an issue? Route data never gets worse.
- bluefirebrand 2y agoRoute data gets worse all the time Any time there is a detour, or a construction zone, or a traffic accident, or a road flooded, or whatever else your route data is not just "worse" it is completely wrong
- zmmmmm 2y agoit's true, but if the scenarios are rare you can treat them as outliers and have the vehicle switch to a "safety mode" or similar. Even human drivers effectively do that (or should!).
- ceejayoz 2y ago> Route data never gets worse. Construction? Parade? Giant tire-crunching pothole in the middle of the freeway?
- virtue3 2y ago
- grakasja 2y agoThis statistic could be misleading, because not all miles are equally dangerous. Google is very careful about selecting where it deploys and tests Waymo, preferring flat, safe, well-designed areas. Routing is also closely monitored and I would imagine that problematic roadways are avoided. The article says they compared it to human accident rates "on the same roads" but doesn't clarify their methodology for "same"ness. It also doesn't factor in driver experience. A taxi driver who has memorized a particular route is likely going to drive safer than a tourist who has never gone on that same road before. Waymo may be safer than the average driver on X road but that doesn't mean it will have the same comparative performance if you drop it onto a random road it has never driven before with no assistance from human support staff.
- bryanlarsen 2y ago> preferring flat, safe, well-designed areas. Like downtown San Francisco?
- grakasja 2y agoIt took them a long time to deploy there and required extensive (human) preparatory work. I'm guessing that their algorithm was fine-tuned for SF specifically, possibly being taught to avoid certain roads and areas where possible, thus behaving like a veteran local driver. Not clear how well that scales globally, or if it would still drive much better than an average human in a random new environment that it hasn't been pre-trained for.
- jrussino 2y ago> The article says they compared it to human accident rates "on the same roads" but doesn't clarify their methodology for "same"ness. Reading your comment before the article, my first thought was that "on the same roads" must mean literally the same roads - right? But the article actually says: > Using human crash data, Waymo estimated that human drivers on the same roads would get into 78 crashes I agree that this is unclear. What data did they use, and why did they have to estimate at all? Shouldn't they be able to get the actual data for how many human drivers got into such accidents on this same exact set of roads over this same exact time period?
- bmitc 2y agoFalse. Humans are driving in a much wider range range of weather, road conditions, car conditions, passenger conditions, routes, unknown destinations, etc.
- murderfs 2y agoSomething like a third of traffic fatalities are due to one of the drivers being drunk.
- dboreham 2y agoIn my experience there are also many drivers who appear to be deliberately driving in a manner likely to cause an accident. Not sure why. Perhaps either they're very stupid or perhaps they like the idea of hurting others.
- danpalmer 2y agoAs this explains, these factors were controlled for.
- bmitc 2y agoWere these Waymo cars driving in Michigan during the winter or in Boston or New York?
- floxy 2y agoOT, but does anyone know what the shape of the curve for the number of automobile crashes per human driver? Is it uniform distribution, where everyone is more or less likely to get into, say, 1.2 fender-benders per lifetime? Or there is a cluster of people who are much more likely to be involved in crashes? I suppose automobile insurance companies would have this type of information.
- paxys 2y agoI'm willing to bet it's the latter. There's a reason your premiums go up after you get into an accident. Insurance companies are betting that you are going to have more of them.
- AlotOfReading 2y agoIt's more complicated than just "good drivers" and "bad drivers". Your driving performance is very different on minute 10 of a trip vs minute 600, or 11am vs 11pm, or happy vs having a bad day. You're also very likely to be in very different environments at all of these times, and have different familiarities. Insurance risk estimates are practical simplifications instead of trying to model how risky an individual driver is on a particular day at a particular time, in a particular area. Waymo's results are trying to compare to a statistically average driver with all other variables controlled.
- jeffbee 2y agoIt is very much the latter. It is like the statistics of average alcohol consumption: half the people consume none, and that one guy drinks non-stop. In fact, the drinking guy and the crashing guy might be the same guy.
- nickvec 2y agoVery excited for the future of AVs. So many lives will be saved using this technology.
- JKCalhoun 2y agoThe idea that everyone has their own "public transportation" (a computer chauffeur) seems lacking in foresight. I suspect, but don't know, that buses are safer still? (Not aware of any airbags triggering, ha ha.)
- doctorpangloss 2y ago> The idea that everyone has their own "public transportation" (a computer chauffeur) seems lacking in foresight. How so? As you increase the density of stops in a bus network and increase the rate of arrivals, there will be fewer passengers per bus, going on journeys that approach the fastest they could be. Why look at the one thing that has a really good chance of "fast, cheap and good" and say, "lack foresight?" My dude, it's the only game in town!
- labrador 2y agoI was initially skeptical about self-driving cars but I've been won over by Waymo's careful and thoughtful approach using visual cues, lidar, safety drivers and geo-fencing. That said I will never trust my life to a Tesla robotaxi that uses visual cues only and will drive into a wall painted to look like the road ahead like Wile E. Coyote. Beep beep. Man Tests If Tesla Autopilot Will Crash Into Wall Painted to Look Like Road https://futurism.com/tesla-wall-autopilot https://futurism.com/tesla-wall-autopilot
- KoolKat23 2y agoTo be fair, I'm sure there's a few humans that would crash into a giant painted road in the middle of a straight road in the middle of nowhere. Humans crash due to less.
- labrador 2y agoWell, I wouldn't and neither would a Waymo, but a Tesla did, which means it's no better than a bad human driver
- saurik 2y agoI think I might, and I'm surprised by how confident you are that you wouldn't.
- jjav 2y agoIf you watch the video, it would be blatantly obvious to any human that it is just a big poster across the road, completely fake. No human would fall for that but tesla does.
- zeroday28 2y ago> I wouldn't Of course, that's why traffic accidents are called 'accidents.' Drivers wouldn't crash their cars, but they do. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- ourmandave 2y ago
- amelius 2y agoYeah, humans would crash less too if they had a Lidar that stopped the car if a crash appeared imminent.
- floxy 2y agoLooks like 52% of the time: https://www.mitre.org/news-insights/news-release/parts-announces-new-data https://www.mitre.org/news-insights/news-release/parts-annou...
- wnissen 2y agoSerious crash rates are a hockey stick pattern. 20% of the drivers cause 80% of the crashes, to a rough approximation. For the worst 20% of drivers, the Waymo is almost certainly better already. Honestly, at this point I am more interested in whether they can operate their service profitably and affordably, because they are clearly nailing the technical side. For example data from a 100 driver study, see table 2.11, p. 29. https://rosap.ntl.bts.gov/view/dot/37370 https://rosap.ntl.bts.gov/view/dot/37370 Roughly the same number of drivers had 0 or 1 near-crashes as had 13-50+. One of the drivers had 56 near crashes and 4 actual crashes in less than 20K miles! So the average isn't that helpful here.
- dangus 2y agoI saw a transit enthusiast YouTube video try out Waymo from the most distant part of the network to fisherman’s wharf in SF and it cost twice as much as an Uber while having a longer wait time for a car. It also couldn’t operate on the highway so the transit time was nearly double. One shouldn’t underestimate how economical real human operators are. It’s not like Uber drivers make a ton of money. Uber drivers often have zero capital expense since they are driving vehicles they already own. Waymo can’t share the business expense of their vehicles with their employees and have them drive them home and to the grocery store. I’m sure it’ll improve but this tells me that Waymo’s price per vehicle including all the R&D expenses must be astronomical. They are burning $2 billion a year at the current rate even though they have revenue service. Plus, they actually have a lot of human operators to correct issues and talk to police and things like that. Last number I found on that was over one person per vehicle but I’m not sure if anyone knows for sure.
- homefree 2y agoThe wait times have gotten better, they're getting freeway approval shortly which will be nice, the price is still at a premium (but worth it imo). I only take Waymo in SF now. The only time I take Uber in the bay area is to the airport (and when they approve Waymo for SFO I won't take Uber then either).
- 2y ago
- ra7 2y agoThis article neatly summarizes Waymo’s latest safety numbers, but Waymo’s site provides much more detail, including a full breakdown of their comparison methodology: https://waymo.com/safety/impact/ https://waymo.com/safety/impact/
- jedbrooke 2y agopurely anecdotal: one thing I’ve noticed is that Waymo’s ALWAYS use their turn signal. that’s already gotta put them above a large portion of human drivers in terms of safety ;)
- dangus 2y agoYou know what has even better safety statistics? Public transit including buses and trains. Cycling also has better statistics when the infrastructure is given real attention, and it leads to better health outcomes.
- AlotOfReading 2y agoThose are all options that local governments should consider investing in. Private companies that don't take public money aren't the ones that should be building public transit. Given that Waymo is testing in Tokyo now (and formerly Cruise), autonomous vehicles are clearly not mutually exclusive with well funded public transit.
- tim333 2y agoSelf driving taxis are probably complementary to buses and trains. You can use them for the last mile those don't go to or when you miss the bus.
- somename9 2y agoPeople in the US don’t want to use public transportation due to the demographics of those who do use it.
- switch007 2y agoTemporarily embarrassed millionaires shouldn't lower themselves!
- krupan 2y agoIf safety was the only thing that mattered the your point would be interesting
- dangus 2y agoI agree. It’s also important to get exercise and deal with the obesity epidemic which is a great reason to promote cycling infrastructure. It’s also important to deal with the air pollution that causes elevated asthma rates for people who live near interstate freeways. And of course, the 30,000 Americans who die in car crashes every year could have been taking public transit, cycling, or walking to their destination (yes, even in the suburbs). I find that because my point is multifaceted it is very interesting!
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- paxys 2y agoWorth repeating the same comment I've left on every variant of this article for the last 10 years. Being better than "average" is a laughably low bar for self-driving cars. Average drivers include people who drive while drunk and on drugs. It includes teenagers and those who otherwise have very little experience on the road. It includes people who are too old to be driving safely. It includes people who are habitually speed and are reckless. It includes cars that are mechanically faulty or otherwise cannot be driven safely. If you compile accident statistics the vast majority will fall into one of these categories. For self driving to be widely adopted the bare minimum bar needs to be – is it better than the average sensible and experienced driver? Otherwise if you replace all 80% of the good drivers with waymos and the remaining 20% stay behind the wheel, accident rates are going to go up not down.
- kccqzy 2y agoWhat kind of dataset do we have to determine the subset of accidents caused by sensible and experienced drivers? I personally have doubts as to whether this dataset exists. Whenever there's an accident, and one party is determined to be at fault, would that party be automatically considered not to be a sensible driver? If we don't have such a dataset, perhaps it would be impossible to measure self-driving vehicles against this benchmark?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- floxy 2y agoWhy wouldn't alcoholics and the elderly be early adopters of self-driving vehicles. Or what can we do to encourage them to be early adopters? You get a DUI, and you are forced to pay for FSD? Get a reduce rate on booze taxes if you "drive" an AV? Have to take a driving test every 2 years after you turn 75, unless you have an AV?
- paxys 2y ago"XYZ demographic should be forced to use self driving cars" is a fantasy that the tech crowd continues to believe but will never happen. Everyone is able to drive and will continue to be able to drive. In fact you should assume that the worse someone is at driving the more likely they are to want to drive for themselves, because that's how the world usually works.
- ein0p 2y agoThis is very cool if it's not the case of "lying with statistics". I hope we will at some point see independent research into these safety claims. I don't really think too highly of my own driving skills, so I also hope that I live to see the day when I can just let my own car drive itself on most or all trips. And no, Tesla FSD ain't that, at least not yet - it does help with long trips, but in difficult situations it disengages at the worst possible moment. I want to tell the car where to go, and then never touch the wheel until I'm there, day or night, rain or sun.
- xlbuttplug2 2y agoOff topic, but I've always felt that the ideal way to address safety is by limiting the amount of freedom a vehicle has, i.e., force it to follow a predefined path. That is, replace road lanes with something like tram tracks. (I'm imagining vehicles being two/four person pods zipping around.) This would vastly reduce the number of accident scenarios, be more efficient, and be much easier to automate. And would probably be good enough for 99% of use cases (i.e., work commute). Obviously I don't seriously see anyone splurging on the infrastructure and bespoke vehicles for that. But I can dream.
- firejake308 2y ago> That is, replace road lanes with something like tram tracks. My brother, you are describing a train. > I'm imagining vehicles being two/four person pods zipping around. Oh, never mind. Yeah, the reason that doesn't work is that if you're going to spend the money to build tram tracks or zip lines or whatever predefined path, then it is only economical to make a few set predefined paths. If you make a predefined path for every possible commute in the city, you will run out of money before getting very far. So ultimately, I would say a train is the closest thing to your ideal.
- defrost 2y agoTram tracks allow dual car | tram use on the same road in manner that train tracks do not. Melbourne has tram tracks throughout the city centre and the cars move about the trams. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8F1_L3v9SHA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8F1_L3v9SHA
- robertlagrant 2y ago> If you make a predefined path for every possible commute in the city, you will run out of money before getting very far. So ultimately, I would say a train is the closest thing to your ideal. This doesn't seem to make sense. Surely a tram is still closer to it than a train. You're comparing the cost of trams to every home vs...the current number of trains? Why make that comparison?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- jmward01 2y agoI am a believer in the long term (and potentially now even the short term) safety benefits of this tech but I do worry about the social side of things. I really don't want the startup business model to set in where service X comes out cheap, kills the alternatives then drives the service quality down and the costs up. I also worry about the fact that this makes it even hard to travel with anonymity. I want to get from point a to point b and not be tracked. The idea that that will even remotely be possible with this type of service is laughable at best.
- sour-taste 2y ago> I really don't want the startup business model to set in It set in a long time ago. Uber killing taxis then jacking up prices, etc.
- Animats 2y agoI'm dreading Tesla deploying some kind of fake self-driving taxi this year.
- kristianp 2y agoDo they crash less than human Uber drivers?
- kristianp 2y agoSeriously, that should be a comparison too, as Waymo is a direct alternative to an Uber with a human driver.
- selcuka 2y agoI believe the main reason people are scared about self-driving cars is that they all run the same software, so any unresolved bugs might cause multiple cars to be involved in accidents, which is something we don't expect from human drivers.
- ziofill 2y agoI thought they were driven remotely by human drivers? Or supervised at least?
- cess11 2y agoAre these bots used in antagonistic settings, where markings on the road are missing, other trafficants are acting irregularly or illegally, the road is damaged or has temporary obstacles and so on?
- Symmetry 2y agoYes, they're driving passengers in actual cities and have been for years.
- PaulRobinson 2y agoOne of the things I come back to time and again with people who push back on AI is this argument that computer systems need to be "flawless" and "perfect". I normally ask what the error rate on the humans doing that task are. It's never 0%. So the questions then come: can we beat that number, can we iterate on it, can we improve it in a logical way? Humans have the benefit of being able to learn by example, and once something is explained the error rate falls (for a while, until they forget), so can we show the same mechanism in AI? Quite often people will look for "a system" to do a role. I talk about "a process". I'm interested in how we continuously improve that process, which is much easier with a computer that can be trained than a human workforce. This takes adjustment from leaders in organisation because they realise that an AI being introduced into a role isn't like Office or Photoshop where you just buy the thing and now you have a license and you're up and running: it's an investment in a sort of very cheap member of staff who can perform at helping a very expensive member of staff improve performance, accuracy and consistency. Once you've proven out that it's working at/better than the bar of the human, you then get to scale for less money than scaling the humans. A lot of my meetings use the metaphor "we're not trying to build a robot that automates everything, we're trying to give your highly skilled workforce better tools to get more done, more safely, more accurately, and for less money". Some people get it, some don't. Waymo is doing this, but with a much higher level of automation by removing drivers - if they can beat humans on safety and consistency, and reduce the workforce to monitors (each watching even 2 cars, perhaps many more), you've massively changed the economics of private hire transport. In the same way I don't need to outrun the bear that's chasing us (I only need to outrun you), I don't need a perfect AI system that is flawless, I just need something that's better than you. And, as per some other comments here, I find it interesting that people are showing "flaws" in these systems (walls painted like a road), that would fool humans too. Years ago someone asked what would happen if they hailed a self-driving car to pick them up and then got on a train, to see if the car then tried to follow you to pick you up. They suggested this was a "hack" in the logic. But I wonder: would you do this to a human driver? What would you expect them to do? Follow you? Not follow you? Why are you trolling cars and their drivers? The whole debate around this stuff just needs to grow up, frankly.
- priced_in 2y agoFatal crash risks are pretty low when doing laps in a car park :) Joke aside, this is an interesting article. I wonder what the chances would be for a human driver to avoid the crashes in the circumstances described in the article (if at all). Clearly autonomous vehicles are passive by design in those situations.
- jussaying2 2y agoAnd trains crash less than Waymos.
- _1tem 2y agoI have always distrusted Waymo's and Tesla's claims of being safer. There are so many ways to fudge the numbers. 1. If the self-driving software chooses to disengage 60 seconds before it detects an anomaly and then crashes while technically not in self-driving mode, is that a fault of the software or human backup driver? This is a problem especially with Tesla, which will disengage and let the human takeover. 2. When Waymo claims to have driven X million "rider only" miles, is that because the majority of miles are on a highway which are easy to drive with cruise control? If only 1 mile of a trip is on the end-to-end "hard parts" that require a human for getting in and out tight city streets and parking lots, while 10 miles are on the highway, it is easy to rack up "rider only" miles. But those trips are not representative of true self driving trips. 3. Selective bias. Waymo only operates in 3-4 cities and only in chosen weather conditions? It’s easy to rack up impressive safety stats when you avoid places with harsh weather, poor signage, or complicated street patterns. But that’s not representative of real-world driving conditions most people encounter daily. The NTSB should force them to release all of the raw data so we can do our own analysis. I would compare only full self-driving trips, end on end, on days with good weather, in the 3-4 cities that Waymo operates and then see how much better they fare.
- decimalenough 2y agoDon't conflate Waymo and Tesla. Tesla FSD is by and large garbage, while Waymo is the real thing. Specifically: 1. Waymo is autonomous 100% of the time. It is not possible for a human to actually drive the car: even if you dial in support, all they can do is pick from various routes suggested by the car. 2. No, I'd guesstimate 90%+ of Waymo's mileage is city driving. Waymo in SF operates exclusively on city streets, it doesn't use the highways at all. In Phoenix, they do operate on freeways, but this only started in 2024. 3. Phoenix is driving in easy mode, but San Francisco is emphatically not. Weatherwise there are worse places, but SF drivers need to contend with fog and rain, hilly streets, street parking, a messy grid with diagonal and one-way streets, lots of mentally ill and/or drugged up people doing completely unpredictable shit in the streets, etc.
- whamlastxmas 2y agoHumans remotely operate Waymos all the time. And humans routinely have to physically drive to rescue Waymos that get stuck somewhere and start blocking traffic, and famously had like 12 of them blocking a single intersection for hours. If you think FSD is garbage then you’ve clearly never used it recently. It routinely drives me absolutely everywhere, including parking, without me touching the wheel once. Tesla’s approach to self driving is significantly more scalable and practical than waymo, and the forever repeated misleading and tired arguments saying otherwise really confuse me, since they’re simply not founded in reality
- devit 2y agoBut can they drive as aggressively as human drivers can? (which does probably increase accident rates a bit, but also can make rides 10-20% faster, especially if executed by an automated system that needs less safety margin) 1. Go as fast as possible without getting fines, violating speed limits whenever it's very likely to not be fined, doing maximum acceleration as needed (the latter configurable by the latter) 2. When there's congestion on the lane they need to take, take a free lane instead and then merge into the correct lane at the last possible opportunity, effectively skipping the queue 3. Run red lights when it can determine there is no enforcement camera on the traffic light, no police and no traffic 4. Aggressively do not yield to pedestrians unless unavoidable on crosswalks, swerving on the lane going the opposite direction as needed if pedestrians are on the side the vehicle is in 5. Aggressively pass slower drivers using opposite-direction lanes even when forbidden as long as the software can determine that it can reenter the lane before colliding with incoming traffic 6. Use barred parts of the road including sidewalks to bypass traffic when it's feasible to do so 7. Aggressively flash lights and tailgate on highways when on the fastest lane but behind a slower vehicle 8. When an emergency vehicle passes by, follow it closely to take advantage of its right of way 9. Aggressively do U-turns even when forbidden if it is determined to be possible 10. Ignore stop signs when it can see there is no traffic, and when it can't determine that plan to do maximal braking at the last moment if it sees any (the maximum braking needs to be rider configurable)
- Invictus0 2y agoFound the New Yorker
- breckenedge 2y agoI recently took an Uber ride like this and can’t say it was pleasant. I’d rather the drive be 10-20% slower. When I’m riding in an Uber I’m often multitasking, and sudden acceleration or braking makes that pretty difficult.
- ConfusedDog 2y agoLet's not let this guy build or train any AVs.
- 2y ago
- curtisszmania 2y ago[dead]
- trainsarebetter 2y agookay great so it’s safer than a human driver… but this seems to be the wrong metric? not that it can drive safer, but make things safer for everyone? If the crashes it was involved in where the result of the waymo following the rules… how is that any better? Less crashes, not it crashes less. Isn’t that the real goal?
- 1970-01-01 2y ago* In cities where weather is not a major contributing factor to crashes. Seriously, don't make these statements until you have data against drivers in Toronto or Chicago or Boston or NYC. Humans in snow, freezing rain, ice, and thick fog still wins against your AI. Show me the data stating otherwise or address the data cherry pick.
- Ylpertnodi 2y ago>Toronto or Chicago or Boston or NYC. ....Europe....
- perlgeek 2y agoIt's the responsible thing to start in the best possible conditions, and slowly, slowly work yourself to harder conditions, only moving to the next step when the safety data from the previous step is better than human drivers. Of course that means you don't have the data to compare Waymos with NYC drivers. Yet.
- hmmm-i-wonder 2y agoIs crash the best indicator of success? I know some really bad drivers that have almost no 'accidents', but have caused/nearly caused many. The cut off others, get confused in traffic and make wrong decisions etc... Waymos, by media attention at least, have a habit of confusion and other behaviour that is highly undesired (one example going around a roundabout constantly) but that doesn't qualify as a 'crash'.
- ajross 2y ago> Is crash the best indicator of success? Well, yeah? Or rather, if it's not, then I think the burden of proof is on the person making that argument. Even taking your complaints at their maximum impact: would you rather be delayed by a thousand confused robots or run over by one certain human?
- potato3732842 2y ago>Even taking your complaints at their maximum impact: would you rather be delayed by a thousand confused robots or run over by one certain human? Depending on the relative rates and costs of each type of mishap it could go either way. There is a crossover point somewhere. The fact that you're coming right out the gate with a false dichotomy and appeal to emotion on top tells me that deep down you know this.
- mlyle 2y ago> There is a crossover point somewhere. I think his point is explicitly that that crossover point is rather high. And let's not forget that crashes, in addition to their other costs, do cause significant delays themselves.
- indiosmo 2y agoI suppose the argument is that while the robot itself might not have run over anyone, it might have caused someone else on the road to do it. So if we're just measuring how many crashes the robot has been involved in, we can't account for how many crashes the robot indirectly caused.
- dmitrygr 2y agoWaymos drive in a rather different environment. They do not drive in poor weather or on highways. They also drive much more cautiously (read: slower) and slow down others. Net effect on safety is not that easy to measure. Not crashing yourself is not enough. You could accomplish that by driving 10mph always, but you'd be causing accidents all around you.
- _zamorano_ 2y agoIn Europe (or at least in Spain) a very common ocurrence while driving is getting to a crossroad of slow traffic where you have to yield. But traffic is heavy and you have no room to, for example, turn right. So it's common practice to advance, little by little, until you're basically an obstacle and some other driver has no alternative than letting you in. Otherwise, you'll spend much time waiting. To make thigns worse, the drivers behind you won't take this unending wait lightly either, so they'd get nervous and try to overtake you and all things get messsy. How do these systems face this situation?
- Propelloni 2y agoIf the "other driver" is a German they would yell at you and cut you off. If a German driver would like to turn right in this particular situation they would set their indicator and wait until somebody lets them in -- which actually will happen rather quickly. German drivers are full of contradictions (me too), it's quite heartwarming :D
- _zamorano_ 2y agoIf you do it rightly (softly, no brisk movements) in Spain, the other driver knows this is the way. No honking and no yelling
- kelipso 2y agoDo people even believe the numbers anymore after years and years of these statistics based on perfect condition roads with barely any traffic, where they those numbers with human drivers in various weather and traffic conditions? I would look at these numbers with deep deep skepticism.
- asielen 2y agoSan Francisco is perfect conditions without traffic? Sure, no snow but plenty of other human hazards.
- slifin 2y agoThere's a big problem with "car blindness" when it comes to cars, pedestrian crossings, car signs I think we forget how invasive they are. So instead, I want you to imagine the sea or a very large bay, the most wide open space available, then I want you to imagine a ferry that can carry 500 people, big yes but there's still plenty of sea and its reasonably tranquil. Now imagine 500 people on jet skis roaring around, then imagine that the jet skis and ferry are all trying to get somewhere different but that's relatively the same, perhaps commuting between the different sides of the bay. If I was mayor I would put a stop to 500 jet skis and say look you have to use the ferry, people on jet skis keep colliding with each other, the noise is horrendous for people on the beach and makes swimming dangerous, and it's also wildly power inefficient when you step back - that's even if we ignore the pollution! 1000 spots to store a 500 jet skis on both sides of the bay is perhaps even worse! If you can make a sea packed and grid locked with just 500 just imagine what it does to a city with thousands, hundreds of thousands, if you then turned to me and said the jet skis drive themselves! I would still think most people should be taking the ferry and there's a upper limit to sustainable jet ski use.
- ryandrake 2y agoThe ferry is not originating or stopping at every possible destination on the shoreline, so the ferry is only useful if its passengers 1. have a second way to get from their origin to the ferry and a third way to get from the ferry to their destination. And if the ferry does stop at every possible origin and destination along the shoreline, then it's going to take much longer on average than a point-to-point jetski.
- mchusma 2y agoI see many debates on this and other threads about whether a system is truly "full self-driving" if it requires human intervention in extremely rare cases. I think this misses the point. A system that requires human assistance only one in a hundred times is still automating away roughly 99% of the human work. When customer support is 99% automated with the remaining 1% handled by remote humans it is often economically and societally the same as 100% automation. The same applies to self-driving cars. If there's 99% automation and humans can handle the remaining 1% remotely, and if that combined system (including the handoff process) is safer in aggregate than a standard human driver, then you basically don't need drivers anymore. You don't actually need 100% AI-only automation to make dramatic economic and societal difference. You just need 100% coverage through the human-AI combination.
- bufferoverflow 2y agoYeah, but Waymo only drives in few selected environments. Unlike Teslas, they can't just self-drive on any random road.