7 ms·
Aluminum batteries outlive lithium-ion with a pinch of salt
- moron4hire 2y ago> But before the Al-ion battery is ready for commercial applications, its energy density will need to be improved There it is. No mention of how much. Though they do tell you how much longer it lasts! So apparently we aren't that averse to numbers.
- brohee 2y agoEnergy density is only an issue if you move the battery around, grid storage doesn't care so a bit concerning they don't mention that usage either.
- hedora 2y agoGrid storage can reuse post-consumer batteries. Li-ion capacity fall off is a fixed percentage per year, so when your car hits 80% of original capacity in ten years, its battery pack can just be used for another ten years. It’ll provide > 64% capacity at the end of that (grid workloads are less stressful than driving workloads). So, the alternative battery technology has to cost less than the cost difference between refurbishing and recycling old car batteries. That delta might be negative.
- capitainenemo 2y agoThere's been a few grid storage fires in the news, you'd think refurbishing/recycling would increase the risk. If the aluminium batteries are significantly less explosive, that might tip that balance?
- bArray 2y agoI think grid storage does care: * Size is important, because they need to be stored and maintained somewhere. The larger the energy storage, the more infrastructure required. * Weight typically scales cost (the heavier it is the more it costs). If it really weighs a lot, you need to reinforce the ground too. * Efficiency in charging and discharging. You also need to monitor the state of each cell carefully.
- hamilyon2 2y agoAt some point scaling up you start to compete with giant pile of heated sand. And it is tough capacity/price benchmark.
- _Microft 2y agoThe link to the paper is hidden a few links into the article (what's up with all these 'tags' that they link to?): "A Recyclable Inert Inorganic Framework Assisted Solid-State Electrolyte for Long-Life Aluminum Ion Batteries", https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acscentsci.4c01615 https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acscentsci.4c01615 (Open Access)
- pjc50 2y agoSeems to be fluoro-chemistry; use of AIF3 and Fluoroethylene carbonate. The F ion sets off alarm bells, but I have no idea whether this is significantly more toxic than the corresponding chemistry of regular Li batteries.
- IndrekR 2y agoLithium tetrafluoroborate and hexafluorophosphate are quite common ingredients in lithium battery electrolytes.
- jokoon 2y agoI am too lazy to copy paste the battery check list
- belval 2y agoFor some reason people downvote you, but batteries seem to have this constant flux of N=1 articles explaining why X new chemistry is about to dethrone lithium. When it's not aluminium, it's solid state. This article itself has several red flags: > In contrast, a typical Li-ion battery retains only 80 percent of its charge capacity after 300 to 500 cycles, depending on conditions. LiFePO4 lasts for about 3000 cycles before 80% degradation, not 300-500. > The batteries were also tested at temperatures as high as 200 degrees Celsius Thermal runaway on LFP is 120C, not 200 but still not a temperature you will easily hit. And finally (as always): > before the Al-ion battery is ready for commercial applications, its energy density will need to be improved Which means it's not commercially viable. LiFePO4 is cheap to manufacture, uses lithium, iron, phosphate, all of which are fairly plentiful and lasts for over 3000 cycles (before reaching 80% capacity).
- hedora 2y agoIn defense of them, 99% capacity retention after 10,000 cycles is still much better. I wonder if they are quoting unrealistic 0-100% numbers and you are quoting realistic 20-80%. If so, and you multiply the Li capacity by 0.6, I wonder how far off aluminum's (undisclosed) density is. On an unrelated note, I’m surprised that lithium is only 4x the price of aluminum. They’re both incredibly common elements, but lithium extraction is harder for a lot of reasons.
- silon42 2y ago> 99% capacity retention after 10,000 This would be really useful for plugin hybrids, even if the density is not competitive with LFP for pure EVs.
- tim333 2y agoConsumer gadgets too. I tend to replace the Li-ion batteries in my phones and laptops every 2 or 3 years and it's a pain. I'd pay extra for something that lasted a decade.
- megaman821 2y agoIf these non-lithium battery chemistries had any chance, it would be in grid storage. As time goes on LFPs keep getting cheaper and better, and there will be little market left for alt-chemistries.
- ajross 2y agoLithium is rare enough to always be a cost barrier vs. something like Al/Cl chemistries that are literally made of dirt and brine. It's true that grid storage looks like the biggest market, but there's a lot of space in non-mobile/less-mobile energy storage that would like cheap batteries.
- hedora 2y agoLithium is not rare. It is also extracted from dirt and brine. Compare copper, lithium and nitrogen on this chart (abundance and annual production): https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abundance_of_elements_in_Earth's_crust https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abundance_of_elements_in_Ear... The cost difference (which is only 4x vs aluminum, apparently) is due to a combination of increased demand (not enough production capacity) and probably the amount of energy/environmental impact of the two processes (you have to go through a lot less ore/brine to get the aluminum). Also, aluminum benefits from a robust recycling infrastructure that hasn’t come online for lithium yet.
- zdragnar 2y agoAluminum's recycling infrastructure is based entirely on reusing essentially raw aluminum, and only exists because bauxite is so expensive to smelt without access to dedicated hydroelectric dams. Recycling lithium in the form of extracting from batteries produces a significant amount of chemical waste, meaning that the cost savings of recycling is significantly less when compared with the difference between smelting and recycling aluminum.
- adrian_b 2y agoLithium is enriched in the upper crust of the Earth about 10 times over its average abundance, which makes it appear more abundant. Even so, despite the enrichment it remains about 500 times less abundant than aluminum (in atom numbers, which matter for batteries; in weight the lighter lithium would appear even less abundant). Moreover, the lower concentration of lithium in typical lithium ores means that for mining equal amounts of lithium and aluminum the environmental effects of mining lithium would be much worse, because more rocks are disturbed and more waste is produced. So there is no doubt that replacing lithium with aluminum for large-scale energy storage is a more sustainable option.
- tim333 2y agosee also https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42823063 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42823063
- 01HNNWZ0MV43FF 2y ago[flagged]
- mlhpdx 2y agoAs a boater, I find salt being used to reduce corrosion a bit ironic.
- chris_va 2y agoOr ionic? :) On a boat, Aluminum "corrodes" and forms an oxide layer (also known as sapphire), which then protects it from further corrosion. But, said layer is not electrically conductive (or in this case does not allow Al ions to flow into the electrolyte), so you need something to prevent the protective layer from forming.
- ErigmolCt 2y agoI think there's some hidden life lesson here: the same chemical process can be beneficial in one scenario and a hindrance in another
- anarchonurzox 2y agoIt really feels like progress in battery tech is unlocking the next "wave" of hardware development. Miniaturization leading to better drones, wearables, cameras, etc., and alt-batteries with better cycle efficiency to better usage of "green" technology. I love seeing these kinds of physical and chemical engineering breakthroughs, even if they aren't quite ready for industrial use.
- GuB-42 2y agoBattery tech improvement has stayed mostly quiet because we never really had an impressive breakthrough, instead, we had decades of slightly better and slightly cheaper stuff, and it added up. Now we have drones, electric vehicles, grid scale storage, rechargeable batteries so cheap we put them in disposable products, battery power tools that match corded and gas options. EVs in particular are entirely about batteries. The energy density of fossile fuels is the only thing going for combustion engines. Electric motors are simpler, cheaper, more efficient, more powerful, better for the environment, the only problem is storing the electricity needed to power them. Electric cars actually came before gas cars, that's 19th century tech! The only reason we are only starting to see them back on the roads is because until now, we didn't have good enough batteries. I expect such research to pay off eventually in the same way. No big breakthrough, but maybe in the future, you will look into buying a new car and realize that that $10k electric car you thought would be useless actually has decent range, that the generator section in the hardware store has been mostly taken over by battery packs and that city buses do not sound the same as they did before.
- technothrasher 2y ago> Electric cars actually came before gas cars They essentially both came about at the same time. They were both being actively developed during much of the 19th century, with the first real marketable versions of each coming in the later half of the 1880's.
- ErigmolCt 2y agoAbsolutely! Battery advancements seem to be the bottleneck for so many emerging technologies
- squeedles 2y agoI thought one of the biggest barriers to Al-ion use was large dimensional change with charge state introducing mechanical stresses. No discussion of that, but a viable solid state electrolyte is pretty sweet.
- elihu 2y agoIt's mentioned in the article. They say it doesn't change dimensions all that much when charging/discharging.
- jillesvangurp 2y agoA bit of inaccuracy in the article: > a typical Li-ion battery retains only 80 percent of its charge capacity after 300 to 500 cycles That's off by 10x at least. Typical LFP batteries that are widely used now have thousands of cycles. Over 5K in some cases. Some of the solid state batteries that are coming to production in the next few years might do better. 300 to 500 is more typical of some older chemistries. Even NMC batteries used in e.g. Teslas have cycle life spans of at least 1500 or so cycles. And for reference, if you charge and full de-charge your car that would be 1 cycle. A decade is only 3653 or so cycles (there might be 2 or 3 leap years). Most car vehicle owners don't charge nearly as often or so completely. A typical Tesla that is partially charged maybe once a week or so is not going to need a battery replacement until the 2040s or so. Anyway, the article carefully avoids talking about energy density. Which is of course the key thing here. Together with other things like charging speeds. Operational temperatures, etc. These all matter. This is a university study, not a plan to get this to production. Promising and interesting but probably well over a decade away from any serious applications. By that time we might have all sorts of other battery tech that is sitting a bit higher on the technological readiness scale on the market.
- radlad 2y agoI find it interesting that my 2021 MBP's "health" was down to about 85% after the first year, but has only decreased to 82% after two additional years. I have 653 cycles now. Assuming that's accurate, and batteries spend a majority of their usable lifetime around this capacity, perhaps battery estimates should be based off of the 80% capacity mark.
- peer2pay 2y ago80% SoH is the de-facto industry standard for EoL/replacement. Mostly because after that you will eventually get a "knee-point" in your degradation curve at which operation is risky and largely inefficient. Without knowing specifics, your MBP might have had issues with an individual cell such that initial capacity dropped significantly until the cell was disconnected.
- deleted 2y ago
- readthenotes1 2y agoTldr; another Better Battery Bulletin
- bdamm 2y agoA large number of these sometimes smell like an oil lobby working their contacts to convince people to put off their EV purchase for five years until the amazing and better battery (tm) comes out. I can't tell if this is one of those. It does have many of the hallmarks.
- AngryData 2y agoIf you want a battery that will last a really long time, nickel-iron batteries already do that. They have 50+ year life spans and are incredibly robust. And if you care about recycling, well its just nickel and iron. The nickel you obviously would want back, but the iron is worth almost nothing. Until we can surpass current lithium batteries in energy density, cycle stability, and safety all at once, iron-nickel is more than good enough to be used in any application where current lithium tech struggles, and will outlive you along with being infinitely recyclable and basically as safe as any battery ever could be.
- adrian_b 2y agoNickel-iron batteries self-discharge quickly, so they are not suitable for long-term energy storage.
- tryptophan 2y ago1% per day which is the number I found doesn't seem terrible for solar type systems.
- nine_k 2y agoThis may be an issue for very small draws, like a TV remote. This can be moot in situations of constant recharge and only staying without any recharge for 2-3 days, rarely, like in utility-scale renewable generation (solar, wind). They seem to cost much more per kWh than LiFePO4 batteries though.
- userbinator 2y agoThey have 50+ year life spans Exactly the sort of thing the planned-obsolescence cartel doesn't want.
- ErigmolCt 2y agoThe real challenge is finding a chemistry that balances density, stability and sustainability without major compromises
- pjc50 2y ago
- Melatonic 2y agoSounds like it could potentially be a cheaper (and maybe less fire prone) battery where weight and volume is less of a concern - maybe batteries for residential / commercial buildings or grid storage ? Possible also easier recycling - especially locally close to the battery. Even compared to LFP (much higher cycle longevity than the article quotes) these sound like they retain energy capacity much better