19 ms·
US will ban cancer-linked Red Dye No. 3 in cereal and other foods
- pavlov 2y ago[flagged]
- hammock 2y agoThe previous administration were the one who started Operation Warp Speed to reduce other regulatory hurdles, so maybe they will.
- billfor 2y agoIf they get cancer they will probably die earlier and save us more money on not having to distribute social security checks.
- gertrunde 2y agoMaybe the FDA will get sued by the health insurance companies due to impacting their profits...
- martin_a 2y agoBetween all the snarkyness (is that a word? I'm not a native speaker :-D) I think there's a point here. With all the regulations the EU has put up, and the bureaucracy that came with them, I'm really happy that we got food and its ingredients pretty tightly under control and locked down. Glad to see that other countries are prioritizing consumer safety, too.
- Funes- 2y agoBut Musk, RFK Jr. and others were precisely the kind of people that were advocating for this kind of regulation to take place. Remember the thing about replacing seed oils (eugh) with beef tallow? I really don't think they are against this kind of regulation--on the contrary.
- throwaway7783 2y agoA quick search shows RFK is in favor of replacing seed oils with beef tallow? Is that supposed to be a good thing? What am I missing?
- Funes- 2y agoJust do some research on what seed oils where used for just some decades ago, and the extreme processes they go through to make them somewhat edible and not too unpalatable. It's just a byproduct of corporations trying to reduce costs at the expense of our health. They'd do it with literal shit if they could find the way.
- throwaway7783 2y agoThere is enough research linking saturated fat (beef tallow has a lot) to heart disease. Not saying seed oils are better. But claiming beef tallow is better doesn't cut it.
- Funes- 2y ago>There is enough research linking saturated fat (beef tallow has a lot) to heart disease Find me one where saturated fat is isolated from every confounding factor. There is none. They are epidemiological studies linking saturated fat from junk food (itself mostly comprised of processed carbs with a myriad of artificial ingredients) to heart disease. That's akin to claiming that dairy protein alone is bad for health because almost every junk dessert has some form of dairy in it as an ingredient.
- throwaway7783 2y agoFind me one where it debunks saturated fat does not contribute, and has not been funded by the relevant industry. No study in history is free of confounding factors, because we are talking about people.
- caseysoftware 2y agoRemoving dyes and healthier food in general is one of RFK's stated goals so they'd call this a win. You need better news sources.
- ceejayoz 2y agoThis is the old "at least Hitler made the trains run on time" thing again. I'm all for removing dyes from food, but if the tradeoff is bringing back polio, no thanks.
- Funes- 2y ago[flagged]
- rconti 2y agoRFK is anti-vaccine. It's a pretty short, straight line. No conspiracies needed, no mental hoops to jump through.
- Funes- 2y ago[flagged]
- ceejayoz 2y agohttps://apnews.com/article/robert-f-kennedy-vaccines-trump-rfkjr-7f8dcb25de76a5a70710d22bbc63f6fa https://apnews.com/article/robert-f-kennedy-vaccines-trump-r... > Kennedy has insisted that he is not anti-vaccine, saying he only wants vaccines to be rigorously tested, but he also has shown opposition to a wide range of immunizations. Kennedy said in a 2023 podcast interview that “There’s no vaccine that is safe and effective” and told Fox News that he still believes in the long-ago debunked idea that vaccines can cause autism. In a 2021 podcast he urged people to “resist” CDC guidelines on when kids should get vaccines. > “I see somebody on a hiking trail carrying a little baby and I say to him, better not get them vaccinated,” Kennedy said. > That same year, in a video promoting an anti-vaccine sticker campaign by his nonprofit, Kennedy appeared onscreen next to one sticker that declared “IF YOU’RE NOT AN ANTI-VAXXER YOU AREN’T PAYING ATTENTION.”
- 9283409232 2y ago[flagged]
- SV_BubbleTime 2y ago[flagged]
- rqtwteye 2y ago[flagged]
- EasyMark 2y agothat is 99% of all politicians though. Her policies were generally much better aligned with the health and well being of the average American vs the average billionaire.
- cycrutchfield 2y agoAnd you think that her political opponent did? His only goals seem to be either enriching himself or his donors.
- rqtwteye 2y agoIs it ok to criticize both candidates? Or do I have to like the other candidate if I don't like a candidate?
- cycrutchfield 2y agoOne was more contemptible than the other, so it’s kind of weird to only criticize one of them.
- EasyMark 2y agoI think that Trump doesn't care one way or another about food coloring or Americans getting cancer, and as such his administration will likely leave such things alone and untouched for the most part unless the food lobby asks him to cancel or defund the FDA for campaign contributions or similar.
- toomuchtodo 2y agohttps://archive.today/O00Tr https://archive.today/O00Tr https://public-inspection.federalregister.gov/2025-00830.pdf https://public-inspection.federalregister.gov/2025-00830.pdf Related: FDA weighing ban on red dye No. 3 - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42542951 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42542951 - Dec 2024 FDA may ban artificial red dye from beverages, candy and other foods - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42382676 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42382676 - Dec 2024 US Food and Drug Administration moves to ban red food dye - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42352983 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42352983 - Dec 2024 The data and puzzling history behind California's new red food dye ban - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37857175 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37857175 - Oct 2023 California becomes first US state to ban 4 potentially harmful chemicals in food - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37838521 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37838521 - Oct 2023
- bryanlarsen 2y agoThe comparison between American and Canadian Froot Loop cereal is illuminating: https://www.reddit.com/r/mildlyinteresting/comments/uc265y/american_froot_loops_are_different_colours_than/ https://www.reddit.com/r/mildlyinteresting/comments/uc265y/a...
- kwanbix 2y agoThose companies ought to be sued. They know that their die is cancer-linked and they still use it in the US even though they don't do it in Canada/EU. We, as humanity, should sue all this big companies (nestle, coca-cola, etc.) for poisoning our lives for profit.
- haliskerbas 2y agoin the US, priority #1 is fiduciary duty to shareholders. if customers are buying, and we make it more expensive to make, then shareholders will be mad!
- parineum 2y agoNot causing cancer falls under fiduciary duty.
- arcticbull 2y agoAzo dyes, in the quantities used in food, do not cause cancer. What causes diabetes and cancer is obesity which you're likely getting from consuming the food -- dyed naturally or artificially. The dye is ancillary. People need to eat less of the Doritos, the azo dyes aren't the problem.
- gonzobonzo 2y agoI looked into it, and from what I can tell the only link to cancer they've found so far is in male rats exposed to high levels of it, but they haven't found evidence that it causes cancer in humans or other animals. What's odd to me is that it's still fine to sell food like bacon, where the link to cancer in humans appears to be much, much stronger.
- tivert 2y agoNow for the important question: which children's cereals will be changing color?
- giancarlostoro 2y agoI assume all the really colorful ones, including froot loops. None / less of the organic ones.
- sgt 2y agoWhy don't all parents just buy the organic ones to start with? Lack of information?
- EasyMark 2y agomore likely lack of money
- giancarlostoro 2y agoDrastically more expensive. This adds up way too high for most people who make average income. I do think its also lack of information. Edit: The only people I've ever heard of whining about cereals having bad ingredients are the people everyone calls conspiracy nuts, this is my issue with calling things "conspiracy theories" and dismissing people, when someone brings forth valid information, you miss out because you're blindly dismissing them based on bias not fact.
- gangstead 2y agoMy kids won't eat the healthy cereal so for me the number one reason is taste. The organic ones also cost more so price conscious people have a second reason.
- beezlebroxxxxxx 2y ago> My kids won't eat the healthy cereal so for me the number one reason is taste. This is one of those things where "taste" is basically sweetness. I used to love cereal. Ate bowls of it all the time. I've been on a basic oatmeal with blueberries kick for the last couple years, though, and whenever I try cereals I used to like again I'm disgusted by how sweet they are. You really can only taste sweetness. Kids love that sweetness, though, and brands are extremely focused on marketing candy to children as "healthy" breakfast staples. Lots of kids think stuff tastes bad because it doesn't taste like candy. The price of "organic" cereals is an issue though.
- hammock 2y agoWhat about Red 40?
- gertrunde 2y agoRelevant news story from a few years ago in the UK, where a bakery was using US sprinkles on cakes, that aren't legal to use in the UK, due to Red #3 : https://www.npr.org/2021/10/15/1046348573/sprinklegate-sinks-a-u-k-bakerys-top-sellers-after-topping-is-found-to-be-illega https://www.npr.org/2021/10/15/1046348573/sprinklegate-sinks...
- do_not_redeem 2y ago"British sprinkles just aren't the same, they're totally s*** and I hate them." "I am extremely passionate about sprinkles." Honestly hilarious. I feel his pain.
- biminb 2y agoA moment's silence for the baker's daughter who couldn't go to Disneyland because of this regulatory overreach: https://x.com/hausofvee/status/1448032811798175747 https://x.com/hausofvee/status/1448032811798175747
- modeless 2y agoGetting it out of the way before RFK can do it, huh?
- EasyMark 2y agoMight as well get some credit for the one or two good ideas he has before the antivaccine rhetoric begins and measles/mumps/whooping cough kills a few tens of thousands of people and the GQP goes "oops" and fires him and puts the old policies back in place.
- fnordian_slip 2y agoA comment by redserk in another thread might be enlightening to you, as someone else made the same uninformed remark: "Incorrect. https://public-inspection.federalregister.gov/2025-00830.pdf https://public-inspection.federalregister.gov/2025-00830.pdf Scroll down to "I. Introduction". > In the Federal Register of February 17, 2023 (88 FR 10245), we announced that we filed a color additive petition (CAP 3C0323) jointly submitted by RFK was not the HHS nominee in February 2023. But it appears this process has been going even earlier than that: November 15, 2022 [0] [0]: https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2023/02/17/2023-03 https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2023/02/17/2023-03..." I remain sceptical about the influence RFK has in this administration anyway, in comparison with corporate interests. Why would this time be any better than the previous Trump administration?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- diob 2y agoPretty wild how far the US is behind in banning these sort of things compared to other countries.
- wnevets 2y agoSource? The last time I checked the FDA bans more food dyes than most other countries.
- joshstrange 2y agoNot sure on food dyes but my understanding is the FDA is leagues behind the EU on regulation when it comes to food. My experience in Italy with foods that normally cause some issues (dairy/cheese) really opened my eyes to that. My sister who doesn’t eat cheese/dairy at all here in the US was able to eat it there without issue because of how they process dairy over there or something.
- rconti 2y agoSo it might not have anything to do with regulation at all?
- thfuran 2y agoPossibly, but dairy processing is heavily regulated.
- estebank 2y agoSimilar thing with my wife and bread. In the US she developed/discovered/exposed a gluten intolerance, to the point that she removed it from her diet entirely, but bread in France is ok for her.
- rsynnott 2y agoIn that case it's not a gluten intolerance; there is gluten in bread in France. Might be a sugar thing? Bread in the US is more likely to contain added sugar and/or HFCS than in most countries.
- newfocogi 2y agoAdmittedly to a fault, I tend to be quick to trust institutions and don't tend to be quick to believe conspiracies (not claiming that this is). With most of the additives to products that people seem to be worried about, I default to thinking it's not the most important thing I need to be concerned with in my daily life. But the FDA making this ruling is validating for my friends who seem to go way out of their way to find product ingredients to be afraid of. I know people have been claiming for years that Red3 being allowed in the US is crazy. I'm genuinely here to listen: how would someone who believes that the US allows far too many dangerous ingredients in consumer goods and believes the consumer needs to actively screen and research what is in their products convince me that I need to be more serious about screening the products I use for dangerous ingredients?
- culopatin 2y agoWe don’t need to convince you of anything. If you care, you’ll look and do your own research about the ingredients. If you think you’re safe, then you’ll eat them,.
- gigatree 2y agoIs it not enough to know that the federal regulatory agencies are captured? Why wouldn’t they poison you if it increases their bottom line and they can get away with it?
- legitster 2y agoFrom the CNN article: > There don’t appear to be any studies establishing links between red dye No. 3 and cancer in humans, and “relevant exposure levels to FD&C Red No. 3 for humans are typically much lower than those that cause the effects shown in male rats,” the FDA said in its constituent update posted Wednesday. “Claims that the use of FD&C Red No. 3 in food and in ingested drugs puts people at risk are not supported by the available scientific information.” > But “it doesn’t matter, because the FDA mandate under the Delaney Clause says that if it shows cancer in animals or humans, they’re supposed to keep it from the food supply,” said Dr. Jennifer Pomeranz, associate professor of public health policy and management at New York University’s School of Global Public Health. Even more confusing - the FDA still doesn't believe there's a cancer link with humans. But they are banning it anyway on a technicality.
- modeless 2y agoThey are banning it now so that the incoming administration can't claim credit for banning it in a few months.
- lowercased 2y agoBut... they will anyway, if public sentiment favors it. If not, they'll blame the predecessor. This seems predestined to be.
- blindriver 2y agoThey never would have banned it if RFK Jr. wasn't the HHS nominee.
- redserk 2y agoIncorrect. https://public-inspection.federalregister.gov/2025-00830.pdf https://public-inspection.federalregister.gov/2025-00830.pdf Scroll down to "I. Introduction". > In the Federal Register of February 17, 2023 (88 FR 10245), we announced that we filed a color additive petition (CAP 3C0323) jointly submitted by RFK was not the HHS nominee in February 2023. But it appears this process has been going even earlier than that: November 15, 2022 [0] [0]: https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2023/02/17/2023-03391/filing-of-color-additive-petition-from-center-for-science-in-the-public-interest-et-al-request-to https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2023/02/17/2023-03...
- bgro 2y agoWhy’s there no avenue for receiving risk appropriate compensation funds for having increased personal risk of death by consuming something a reasonable expert in the industry could consider dangerous? If I skirt the law on technicalities to cause harm to an employer for example, such as knowingly implementing trivial security encryption on critical transactions, I feel I could be liable for damages. Why is this a game of spot the problem and then get off with a warning before going to the next preplanned technicality workaround that usually also causes cancer but will buy them a few years until the process repeats? Shouldn’t mass risk of life be considered a terror level charge? Or rather, instead of saying no to that question because it didn’t appear to meet X criteria, why aren’t we finding ways it could meet that criteria? For example if it needs a political reason, we should ask how this could be a politically motivated decision rather than saying this doesn’t appear to meet any political agenda. That’s how the laws are always completely one sided abused against normal people anyway in a more extreme stretch than my example. I think it’s reasonable to do a reasonable-amount of application back.
- ixtli 2y agoIt would set a precedent that is unpalatable to people who sell this stuff.
- csallen 2y agoBecause the people en masse have not successfully come together to demand this. What makes companies more powerful than the people is not that companies actually have more power. They don't. It's that they concentrate the power they do have into the hands of a small group of decision-makers, which allows it to be deployed effectively. By comparison, the people are divided, disjointed, disorganized, and distracted, and as such typically fail to come together to demand specific changes they agree on.
- nucleogenesis 2y agoIdk I think there is a ton of overlap between industry and the highest levels of government. They wouldn’t want pesky things like human well-being to get in the way of profit so they get their hands on some of the levers of power and mitigate their liability one way or the other. It’d probably take a class action lawsuit in the kind of case you describe to be brought to justice.
- airstrike 2y agoGreat. Hopefully in 50 years we'll have banned most of today's children's cereals.
- Separo 2y agoDo libertarians support this kind of move?
- EasyMark 2y agoNo libertarians feel that people will likely get sick or die from bad products, and will sue the company/quit buying the product; aka let the market and survival of the fittest decide what people put in their bodies.
- h1fra 2y agoaka a system that doesn't work since FDA had to step in and ban this
- zeristor 2y agoCancer is a very wide category, I assume that it may induce a sub-group of all cancers. I believe the article mentions Thyroid cancer specifically.
- legitster 2y agoIt's specifically a type of cancer in rats with no human equivalent. But the FDA rules state they can ban an ingredient if it causes cancer in humans or animals.
- gigatree 2y ago[flagged]
- HeatrayEnjoyer 2y agoYou have some valid points, but this mostly reads as exasperated defeatism that doesn't offer any actionable solutions.
- pc86 2y agoIt'd be great if people stopped just copy-pasting stuff from LLMs and then responding to that instead of other real human people. It's not a foregone conclusion that just because people haven't ingested things before doesn't inherently mean that ingesting them is bad. Saying it is is itself a pretty obvious logical fallacy. Now I'm not saying at all that ingesting oil, even byproducts after multiple rounds of synthesis, is a good idea. But it's not impossible to synthesize something edible out of something inedible, so the fact that oil is inedible doesn't mean that all oil derivatives are as well.
- greenavocado 2y agoFD&C Red 40 (Allura Red AC): Linked to hyperactivity in children in some studies, although evidence is mixed. Theoretical concerns regarding disruption of cell membrane integrity, potentially leading to increased permeability and toxicity. FD&C Yellow 5 (Tartrazine): Some in vitro studies suggest potential neurotoxic effects, though human evidence is lacking. Theoretical concerns regarding modulation of neurotransmitters, potentially leading to behavioral changes. FD&C Yellow 6 (Sunset Yellow FCF): Similar to Yellow 5, some in vitro studies raise concerns, but human evidence is limited. Theoretical concerns regarding binding to DNA, potentially leading to mutagenic effects. FD&C Blue 1 (Brilliant Blue FCF): Theoretical concerns regarding exacerbation of respiratory conditions like asthma. Theoretical concerns regarding increased cell membrane permeability, potentially leading to toxicity. FD&C Blue 2 (Indigo Carmine): Limited human studies, but some animal research suggests potential neurological impacts. Theoretical concerns regarding triggering or exacerbating immunological reactions. Read food labels.
- pigeons 2y ago"according to claude" makes it hard for my mind to give much credence to the post in a way very different from "according to Wikipedia" with a link. I intend this politely, but if I wanted to know what claude would output I would ask it myself, during the phase of the moon when the way I've chosen to word the prompt has the best chance of working.
- paradox242 2y agoThe credibility of the food industry is so low that I think people would support bans on most additives on general principle. We look back at things like putting lead and radium in paint or using asbestos in insulation and say "they should have known better, how could they be so stupid". Well, good additives have a lengthy history of containing harmful additives and I think future generations will say the same about many of these currently in use. What's interesting is that from our current time we can see just how easily it happens, even with the amount of information available to average person.
- rcpt 2y agoLabeling is the big one imo.
- BroodPlatypus 2y agoWhat gets tracked gets improved. I think we need to update the ingredient requirements for food (wtf is seasoning) but also update the fields on Nutritional Facts. Having a drink like Oreo Coca-Cola read 0’s down the board is illustrative of my point. There’s lots of crap in our food but it’s been selected specifically for its ability to not be captured in the dozen or so categories deemed important back when legislation passed on food transparency.
- gigatree 2y agoI realized a long time ago that lack of information isn’t the problem. We’re basically living in a Brave New World now; most people are too distracted to realize they’re being poisoned and would only accept it if the very institutions doing it told them they were doing it. But IMO it’s more of an emotional thing - once you realize it it’s hard to go back to the comfy world of “actually the bureaucrats and shareholders are looking out for my well-being”.
- arp242 2y ago> We look back at things like putting lead and radium in paint or using asbestos in insulation and say "they should have known better, how could they be so stupid" The main thing is: they did know better. They lied to us. They spent a lot of time, money, and effort to lie to us. And this has happened time and time again in many different industries. Just the other day there was a story on the HN front-page about the PFAS industry has been copying the tobacco playbook for in disinformation campaign. Also on other topics. For example canned tuna with "Dolphin friendly" logos. Looks good, right? And then people look into it to see what it means, and turns out it has no value, is something the company simply invented themselves, and has done zero-effort to make anything more "dolphin friendly". The entire thing is a basically just a lie. Many additives are probably entirely safe. Things like vitamin C and caramel are "an E number", and those are fine. But I sure don't trust things, and I don't have the resources to see what is and isn't safe myself, so best to just avoid most of it.
- ipython 2y agoGreat, now ban Red 40 and the other synthetic dyes. You can't avoid them in anything marketed toward children. I have children and I know others who also have children that are highly sensitive to these dyes, causing major behavioral issues that last for 5-7 days after ingesting food/medicine/drinks that contain these dyes.
- parineum 2y agoThat's been proven in double blinded studies, I assume.
- ipython 2y agoNever been asked to participate in one. I am a huge proponent of the scientific method. This argument always interests me, though. (by the way, just a quick search on pubmed: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3441937/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3441937/; https://www.cspinet.org/page/synthetic-food-dyes-health-risks-history-and-policy https://www.cspinet.org/page/synthetic-food-dyes-health-risk...; the EU bans some of these synthetic dyes: https://www.efsa.europa.eu/en/topics/topic/food-colours https://www.efsa.europa.eu/en/topics/topic/food-colours). Also reference the famous "Southampton six" study in 2007 which triggered evaluation of food dyes across Europe: https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(07)61306-3/abstract https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6... As a parent, if I notice a correlation between an action and subsequent behavior, are you saying that my lived experience is irrelevant because... nobody bothered to include me in a specific double blind study? How many things do you do every day that have not been studied through exhaustive scientific research? From my own lived experience, when one of my my kids eats a red velvet cake or a bag of Skittles or M&Ms that he's violent and crazy for a week, but if he has a few Oreos he's fine. If one of my other kids does the same thing, she doesn't have the same reaction. If I knew the exact chemical pathway that made this happen, I'd be thrilled. I am just living my life trying to parent kids in this world, and you know what, stupid bright dyes that do nothing other than make food appear unnaturally incandescent are practically impossible to avoid. So it's just one more thing that's piled on as a parent that you have to deal with. If you ask me, this aggressive "well, you're stupid and you shouldn't trust your own eyes because science" attitude that has triggered the strong anti-authority sentiments globally. It's why objectively crazy people like RFK Jr get huge followings- I vehemently disagree with 99% of his rhetoric, especially his anti-vax viewpoints, but I totally agree with his stance on food additives such as these synthetic dyes. I see the effects with my own eyes. Telling me I'm stupid doesn't help science, it just serves to further diminish the trust in the very institutions we need more now than ever.
- SoftTalker 2y agoI remember the concern about and ban of Red No. 2 when I was a kid. I've always been a little suspicous of colored food since then. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amaranth_(dye) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amaranth_(dye)
- Dig1t 2y agoAccording to Google: >Red 3 dye has been banned in the European Union for food use since 1994 Seems pretty reasonable to me.
- Aloisius 2y agoIt's actually approved in EU for candied cherries and cocktail cherries.
- MuffinFlavored 2y agoWhat other things does the US need to ban to catch up with Europe? Who is "right vs wrong" here? Is Europe wrong for having too many things banned, is US wrong for not having parity with what is banned in Europe? Is Europe being overly cautious, is America being unsafe?
- PHGamer 2y agothis is merely a money grab by moneyd interests to ban dyes that are not patented and to force us onto something that is patented.
- whodev 2y agoMy goodness, for a website full of techincal individuals a lot of you are falling for the appeal to nature fallacy hard. Also, it looks like no one here knows how to defer to experts. I don't know much about food safety standards, chemical compositions, additives, etc. so I've talked with people who are experts instead. And from what I have gotten, most people are freaking out because they lack an understanding of what is really safe or not. People believe that since a certain scary sounding chemical was added that the food is now less safe when that's not the case.
- BytesAndGears 2y agoI think an important note is that regulatory agencies in other countries have cracked down on some of those scary-sounding chemicals, due to them being unnecessary for food with no real benefit for the person eating it, and possible evidence of negative affects. I mentioned this in another comment, but as someone who has lived for multiple years in the US and Europe, it is a drastic difference in food quality between the two. Much easier to eat foods made of whole ingredients where I lived in Europe - even many prepackaged foods that we’d buy at the grocery store. I came across this link yesterday[1] on a health-focused HN thread[2]. The study split a group of overweight people up into low-carb and low-fat diets, to see which produced better weight loss. The group that lost the most weight was actually neither - it was just whoever ended up eating less processed foods and more whole foods. [1] https://www.pbs.org/newshour/amp/health/to-lose-weight-focus-on-what-you-eat-not-how-much-study https://www.pbs.org/newshour/amp/health/to-lose-weight-focus... [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42668123 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42668123
- whodev 2y ago> other countries have cracked down on some of those scary-sounding chemicals, due to them being unnecessary for food with no real benefit for the person eating it, and possible evidence of negative affects Just because another country bans something does not make that thing harmful. Politicians banning food products and additives with no real scientific evidence is not unusual. They bend to public will, they are politicians after all. Also, studies that show "possible evidence of negative affects" in mice ingested at higher dosages then a human would ever eat or drink does not show they are harmful in humans. Humans are not mice after all. > as someone who has lived for multiple years in the US and Europe, it is a drastic difference in food quality between the two This is purely subjective, I've been to Europe and the Middle East, both have great food. But food in America is no worse in quality. The main difference is when I visited those area's I mostly ate out, at nicer restaurants where food would of course feel/taste/look better then the average meal at home or from fast food. But when eating at friends homes, the food quality (vegetables, fruits, meats) was no different than what I could get here in America. > it was just whoever ended up eating less processed foods and more whole foods I'm not arguing that we don't eat more ultra-processed foods. We do eat too many highly refined foods with little nutritional value. My argument is against blaming food additives, dyes, GMOs, HFCS, etc... Eating more whole foods, vegetables, and fruits would make you healthier, but that's due to the nutritional value, fiber, feeling more full for longer leading to reduced caloric intake, etc... Not because you got rid of food dyes.
- hfourm 2y agoMy Doritos will never be the same
- exmadscientist 2y agoFor anyone wondering why it takes so long to actually switch this stuff out, and the available alternatives to Red 3, I thought this piece from a food dyes company (no relation) was fascinating: https://na.sensientfoodcolors.com/confection/replacing-red-3-in-confections/ https://na.sensientfoodcolors.com/confection/replacing-red-3... You have to figure that if these guys had a drop-in replacement, they'd be offering it for sale at a high price, so this probably is the best you can do. The process changes and requalification looks like no fun at all. But it also looks pretty doable for a company in this line of business, so maybe you won't see too many color changes on the shelf with this ban.
- jpk2f2 2y agoThanks, that article was fascinating. I wasn't aware of how complex swapping it out could be, its continued use makes a lot more sense now. I'm very curious on what's going to happen with cocktail cherries - I believe they use Red #3 (it's one of the only permitted uses in the UK).
- VanillaCafe 2y ago> For anyone wondering why it takes so long to actually switch this stuff out One counterpoint is do we really NEED to have brightly colored foods? It's a hard problem if you need a food to be bright red. But, that has to boil down to strictly to improving sales, right? Hypothetically, if all the artificial food dyes were banned, then all food companies would be on the same level playing field.
- dylan604 2y agoColor is definitely something that catches a person's eye, so if you have a "food product" that needs extra to convince someone to buy it, color is a way to do it. You can't taste it before purchasing. You can see and smell it, so they push those levers as much as they can.
- makapuf 2y agoMandate big font "contains carcinogens" label when your food contains this colour. Then let the buyer choose whether s/he finds this shade of bright red attractive or not.
- reverendsteveii 2y agoFun fact - this is how blue raspberry was created as a flavor. Raspberry flavored things were purple, made from a combination of red and blue dye. The red dye (red no 2) was banned. So companies making raspberry flavored stuff just left the red dye out and said "raspberry is blue now" and we all went "shit yeah it is, always has been! why would raspberry be anything other than blue?"
- bagels 2y agoDo raspberries not taste like raspberries? What product has "blue raspberry"? I can only think of one raspberry product I buy, and it doesn't have any dye, and is deep red colored (from the raspberries)
- thebigspacefuck 2y agoJolly rancher
- maerF0x0 2y agoGatorade cool blue used to be blue raspberry
- thatguy0900 2y agoBlue raspberry is a candy only flavor. It doesn't really taste like raspberry. Its pretty common as a flavor in the us at least, it's one of my favorite candy flavors.
- PolygonSheep 2y agoIf you eat a bowl of mixed blueberries and raspberries, it actually does taste like blue raspberry. It's a mixture of the two flavors.
- tuukkah 2y agoAlso known as the flavor of Queen's jam (from Sweden), which looks nicer as instead of blueberries, it uses bilberries (whose flesh is deep red).
- ProofHouse 2y agoFor anyone that pushes back on the government currently elected, well, far from optimal imagine that so many before them allowed a cancerous substance like this to be in so many foods
- Over2Chars 2y agoMeanwhile cigarettes, which are also cancer linked, are legal with a warning and some picture on them. And alcohol, which is also linked to cancer, is legal, with a warning on it. And (non-self driving) automobiles, which kills tens of thousands of Americans yearly, with no warning or pictures, are legal. Activities that reward being sedentary - a known factor in lethal cancers and disease - have no warning labels. When is my PS5 gonna warn me about playing video games? While Americans are dying from a range of cardiovascular disease and cancers it's comforting to know that red M&Ms or red fruit punch won't be one of the causes.
- issafram 2y agoFinally
- sizzle 2y agoNow do Red 40 and the others
- KingOfCoders 2y agoLike in overregulated Europe. Now the US fails!
- interludead 2y ago2027 feels like a generous timeline for something identified as harmful...
- ggm 2y agoToo late to go long on cochineal insect breeding shares?
- thih9 2y agoFor comparison: > The European Food Safety Authority only allows erythrosine in processed cherries and pet foods. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erythrosine https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erythrosine
- kgc 2y agoWhy not just ban every additive that causes cancer?
- gregjw 2y agoThe past was alterable. The past never had been altered. Oceania was at war with Eastasia. Oceania had always been at war with Eastasia.
- jcrben 2y agoTechnically it appears red dye no 3 was banned due to cancer and Delaney clause, however, keep in mind that I think the primary reason it was banned in California last year was all the studies correlating it to deleterious cognitive impacts on children https://www.additudemag.com/red-dye-3-ban-adhd-news/amp/ https://www.additudemag.com/red-dye-3-ban-adhd-news/amp/ https://www.contemporarypediatrics.com/view/potential-impacts-red-dye-no-3-has-on-children https://www.contemporarypediatrics.com/view/potential-impact...
- gregors 2y agoLots of other countries other than the US banned this dye years ago. So what changed in the US? Logically speaking we didn't just come to our collective senses. Did government lobbying budgets dry up? Or did the cost just increase where it wasn't worth paying anymore?
- nikolay 2y agoSo, avoiding crap in my foods for 25+ years starts to pay off... My guiding axiom is: Given enough time, we'll find that everything causes cancer. So, it's best to stick with substances (read "toxins") that we're well-adapted to!